

19 Oct 2026 · 1h 35m · 31 chapters

How to build a “winning offer” for consumer subscription brands, using Winx as the example. The episode defines offers as perceived value vs perceived risk/effort, then lays out 10 elements to test. It also includes two guest segments: Jordan Minard on subscription offer structure, pricing, and unit economics; Lina Faizal on messaging to women (especially moms) and CRO.
Offers aren’t discounts; they’re perceived outcomes with low risk/effort. Address objections, answer “why now,” fit product experience, pick the right customer, set up orders 2–5 (subscription + cancel flows), and ensure the business can afford the offer (cohort-based contribution, not day-1 profit).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the definition and perception of an offer in consumer markets.
“See, most people think offer means discount.”
A detailed breakdown of the ten critical components for crafting effective offers.
“Okay, now that we have a bit of a framework on what an offer is, let's get into the actual 10 things that we're using to figure out offers on Wix.”
Insights from guest Jordan Minard on subscription offers and pricing strategies.
“Now we're going to get into the guest segments.”
Learn effective pricing strategies and discount structures for subscription services.
“And I would say that's like a little too much.”
Explore how gamification can enhance customer engagement in product selection.
“So like you're saying go less discount to subscribe as like your evergreen?”
Understand key metrics for optimizing customer retention in subscription models.
“There's a difference between how much am I buying and what's my frequency of subscription.”
Learn how whitelisting can enhance brand trust and advertising efficiency during launch.
“I remember you had a decent amount of whitelisting from the beginning with some larger creators.”
Explore the importance of whitelisting and budgeting for influencer partnerships.
“I would have, you know, sold two and three boxes earlier.”
Discuss the allocation of budgets towards different tiers of influencers.
“So we, we break it out into three different tiers.”
Meet Lina Faizal, the Chief Overy Officer, and her unique approach to marketing.
“Why don't we start with who you are, what you do, and then I think that'll give people context for why you're here on this episode with us.”
Learn effective marketing strategies aimed at female consumers.
“Because a lot of times what I see when men try to sell to women, they make them feel like to get them to buy a product.”
Explore the nuances in women's purchasing decisions and their motivations.
“Women buy parasocially is how I would frame it.”
Learn how to effectively communicate permission and benefits in marketing to women.
“It watches the video, figures out what it's about, adds naming conventions, edit hooks.”
Learn how to effectively communicate permission and benefits in marketing to women.
“For all the dudes watching this, I don't mean literal permission.”
Understand the shift in marketing strategy from highlighting problems to showcasing positive outcomes.
“And being the veterans we are, we could work with anyone, but we decided to work with Skio to build Winks.”
Learn how to connect advertising messages to specific audience identities, particularly women.
“You just want to show them like something realistic, right?”
Discover the importance of testing various identity statements in advertising for better audience engagement.
“Like something more specific where it's like you immediately can identify, like the viewer of the ad can immediately identify with that person.”
Understand why specificity in ads targeting women can significantly impact response rates and effectiveness.
“So I think there's a lot of specificity that can be done to themselves, like who you're talking to, in my opinion, at first glance.”
Learn how to effectively connect advertising messages and landing pages to satisfy audience curiosity.
“So these are the things that you're experiencing.”
Learn about the connection between perimenopause and sleep disturbances.
“And so we don't want to let that happen.”
Discover how educating women on perimenopause can impact marketing strategies.
“So what I've written down here is like these landers for our target woman.”
Explore the importance of understanding customer awareness and how to research it.
“And I think that explaining how perimenopause affects their sleep and them staying asleep makes a huge difference.”
Learn about effective research strategies for understanding target markets.
“Like, I feel like research will tell you the actual like mechanism behind it and stuff, but not people's like awareness of it.”
Understand how to identify customer pain points and their journey to solutions.
“So for example, me, you, Matt, maybe we have, I don't know, a hair loss problem.”
Discuss the importance of market segmentation for women experiencing perimenopause.
“I'm actually curious if I may, I would love to ask like for you guys, how did you end up, you know, with perimenopause and sleep and stuff like that?”
Learn how to craft marketing messages that resonate with women.
“And also the main thing that I know that a lot of people talk about as well is falling asleep.”
Explore how reassurance in marketing can enhance customer trust and reduce churn.
“And so I love that you guys have that on your PDP and some of your landing pages.”
Learn about the differences between tour-driven and away-driven customer motivations.
“is very important as well is knowing whether your customer is you know are they are they tour-driven or are they away-driven?”
Discover key differences in marketing strategies for men and women, including their motivations and responses.
“Or do they want to go toward like the end state?”
Explore how offer strategies differ for men and women and the importance of traffic source.
“And so for me, it's just like, there's a better way to do it.”
Get insights on testing and adapting marketing strategies to better connect with audiences.
“Yes, to a certain extent, but they need to try the product for it to experience what it's done.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Operators, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Jordan Menard: Welcome back to Operators Build Episode 9. Have you ever wondered what makes a great offer? See, there's a lot of content online about offers for B2B businesses, for info businesses. There's even a big bearded guy that loves to talk about all those kinds of companies. But what about consumer? I couldn't really find much on consumer. So we decided to make an entire episode on offer. And we're going to use our new brand, Winx, to talk about offers in depth. We even have two different guest segments today to help us think it through. But before we get to those segments, which are awesome and you should stick around for, I want to break down some of the bigger points on offers and the 10 elements that we used to figure out our offer with Winks and actually that we continue to use because I still don't think we have figured out our offer for Winks.
0:47Jordan Menard: First, what is an offer? See, most people think offer means discount. It doesn't. Everything is about perception. This is the perceived result your customer wants. This is how much she believes you're going to deliver it. Then there is perceived risk. So there's perceived value. Then there's perceived risk. How long is it going to take to get the actual value? How much is it going to cost her? Effort, money. Your goal with offers is to make your customer feel like they are going to get all of the perceived value and it will take little to no perceived risk and effort. But if you do this part well, price matters less and less.
1:23Jordan Menard: So unlike info and B2B, we just have less things to play with. This is why you see brands focus so much on trust and social proof and those signals, especially when it comes to anything a person might consume. See, a great offer makes the customer feel stupid for saying no. And it leaves your unit economics better after order one, not worse. Okay, now that we have a bit of a framework on what an offer is, let's get into the actual 10 things that we're using to figure out offers on Wix. Number one, offer is not just about price and discounts. Offer is product and price and positioning and terms and proof.
1:58Jordan Menard: A discount gives away margin once and then the customer leaves. Everything else on this list is about keeping the list price where it is and giving your customers reasons to come back. I happen to be one of those people that believes that the reason that people repeat purchase is because the experience was great at every step of the journey. It's not just some SMS or email thing that you send out after. Number two, this is the second thing. It fits how the product needs to be experienced. This one's big. Everybody on this show came from durable goods, Cody being the exception, he comes out of beauty.
2:30Jordan Menard: And how our offer is constructed for a consumable, so we are selling it as a subscription. And we're going to have to do everything we can to make sure that the offer and how the product is experienced line up with one another. This was very different when I was running Pila. We're very different when I was running Glomi. Or how Sean runs Ridge or Mike runs Simple Modern. This is where things like sampling come in for some brands. If you have a product that people love after they try it, you create an offer that lets them try it. The offer is a product decision. It is not just a marketing one.
2:59Jordan Menard: Number three, your offer needs to be built for one customer and one problem for that customer. In our case, she should say, this is for me. The ad, the landing page, the cart, the checkout, everything should sell the same story. You've heard a lot of people talk about funnel congruency, especially on this podcast. It is real and it matters. You can have a winning ad angle and still pull the wrong customer if the page and the gifts and everything else sells something different than the ad. Number four, it adds value before it cuts price. This is why I think you see in a lot of subscription brands, consumables, supplements, whatever, they do a lot of gifting, a lot of bundling.
3:38Jordan Menard: Some companies give out credit, access perks afterwards. This is all about stacking value that isn't a discount. Discounts take away from value. And if I'm being honest, we have not cracked this part of the Winx offer stack yet. We've still got so many things we're going to try. This is a big area of focus for us. The trick with a gift is you want something that is low cost and high perceived value to the customer. So in our case, like a nice sleep mask might cost us a few bucks, but it might have really high perceived value, especially when she gets it and tries it. So your customer actually has to want the free gifts.
4:11Jordan Menard: It can't just be a free gift that nobody wants. We've probably made this mistake when we launched Winx. We included things that maybe people don't know or don't care about. Number five, your offer needs to speak directly to your customer's objections. Too expensive, which is the number one reason people always give for I don't, this is why I'm not buying it. Too expensive just means I don't believe it. And in sleep, as many of you have told us, this is going to be a massive hurdle for us to overcome. We're going to have to focus on proof and terms and guarantees, like all things that help fix doubt.
4:42Jordan Menard: And I think this is an easy exercise to go through. Or maybe it's a simple one. It's not easy. How you get to all of the reasons people don't buy, all of their objections. If you have no data, you kind of have to just make a big list of the things that you think are gonna be objections. And if you have data, which you should be getting if you have customers, you should always post-purchase ask, what is the thing that almost made you not buy from us today? Some version of that question. So if you have that kind of data and you list them all out, you will quickly see where your offer needs to address the objections.
5:15Jordan Menard: And in our case, when we get to the guest segments today, you're gonna hear a little more about language from Lena because this is where she specializes. Number six, and this is my favorite, your offer needs to answer the why now question. I think this is massively underappreciated part of marketing. We can all find all the reasons in the world that a customer wants something, but if we do not answer why they should buy it right now, we're stuck using discounts to incentivize the purchase. So on Pila, we did this with design drops. That was our why now. Every week, exclusive design drop. This is why you should buy it.
5:49Jordan Menard: On Winx, we're going to have to use our words and other moments to drive a stronger why now. See, Jordan's going to kind of hit on this in his segment. At least this is what I took away from it. Gifts with purchase and drops and collabs and customization windows. Like there's so many things that you can do on a calendar to create all of those reasons for why now. And no, fake timers are not the way that you do this. That stuff just burns trust. Use them very, very carefully, please. Number seven, your price makes sense in the market it competes in. This is important. If your customer can side-by-side compare you to someone else, then the market is very much going to set the price.
6:28Jordan Menard: You've got to find ways to be different. If you want to hold a premium standard, you need something that your customer can't really compare to. It could be design, formulas, format, story, imagery. There's lots of ways to be different in the market. We did an entire operator's podcast just on positioning and being different. You should go listen to that. How you are positioned in your market is a big driver on what is allowing you to test your pricing, okay? Most founders, they test price spans five bucks up or down. Don't do that. Test entirely new price spans before you start making these micro adjustments.
7:03Jordan Menard: It'll work better, I promise. Number eight, your offer has to pick the right customer. Now, this isn't talking about serving one customer. This is about an offer that chooses high quality customers. So in our case, your first order offer is effectively a customer selection algorithm. You're going for quality repeat customers, not just one timers, at least we're not. So this first order offer actually matters. If you angle towards discount buyers, so if you just use a discount as the main reason you're going to try something, you're going to get discount buyers. Remember, modern day ad platforms, algorithms, social media platforms, they are the very best targeting machines we have ever had as marketers.
7:42Jordan Menard: And your offer is a big part of how they're going to be doing that targeting. Number nine, it sets up order two, three, four, five. Your offer is not just the first order. Store credit, second order deals, another gift at order three or four on their subscription. You can do a lot with subscription products to ensure your customer continues to feel loved. And yes, this is actually part of your offer. I think people think the offer is just that first touch point. It's not. That's just the first part of your offer. Hell, even giving somebody the option to subscribe is a part of the offer. So they know that they're getting on a subscription.
8:18Jordan Menard: When we spoke with Aiden from Skio, he really pushed our thinking on cancel flows with SMS and email and making sure that we were taking great care of our customers, which this kind of runs counter to a lot of the hardcore DR people who make it super hard to cancel a subscription. In our case, we want to build a real brand. So we want to love our customers and make it easy on them to do these things. And that we think that this is part of the overall brand offer. Number 10, this is very important when it comes to an offer. Your business has to be able to afford it. So it needs to make money. Judge your offer just as much on everything customer as you do on contribution dollars.
8:53Jordan Menard: And contribution dollars in subscription, in our case in consumable, might not be day one contribution. We're probably going to lose money on day one. It's likely going to be at day 60, at day 180, 90, whatever. Not just day one. The offer that wins today could very much lose you money in six months if you don't design things properly. So we're going to be very focused on cohorts and the kinds of people we're acquiring with our offers and with the things that we're testing. In summary, there's a lot of ways to think about offer and those are the 10 vectors that we're using. And if you think these are going to help with your brand, please steal them.
9:27Jordan Menard: And again, in recap, number one, offer is not just price and discounts. Number two, it fits how the product needs to be experienced. Number three, it's built for one customer and one problem. Four, adds value before it cuts price. Five, it addresses the objections. Six, it answers the why now problem. Please don't skip that one. Seven, the price makes sense against the market that you're competing in. Yes, we all compete. Eight, it picks the right customer. go for quality, not quantity and crappy. Number nine, it sets up orders to three, four. Think about the LTV, please. Number 10, the business can afford it.
10:04Jordan Menard: Your offer needs to generate profit, guys. That's it. Those are the 10. Take them, use them, hope they're valuable. Every CPG founder thinks they know their margin until the Amazon fees, the chargebacks, the cogs fluctuations in the month and the ad spend and every other little fee you never see quietly eats into it. And then the real number, well, it shows up a month later when your accounting team finally closes the books and maybe has the bravery to tell you. Iris Finance connects your Shopify, your Amazon, your QuickBooks, and your ad accounts all in one click. And it gives you a live P &L by channel, by SKU, not a spreadsheet from last quarter.
10:40Jordan Menard: Brands like Jones Road, Caden Lane, Jolie, Stars and Honey, and now Winks use it to catch margin leaks in real time before they turn into a real, real problem. If you're running a CPG brand and you're past 5 million in revenue, go to irisfinance.co slash operators for a free demo and see your real numbers. Now we're going to get into the guest segments. And first off, we sit down with Jordan Minard. He's one of the drivers of instant hydration. Anybody who is in subscription, anybody, is likely using some of Jordan's playbooks. He's just a great guy to talk to when it comes to scaling up these kinds of companies.
11:17Jordan Menard: We have him tear apart our buy box, our pricing structure, talks to us about calendars. There's just a lot of things that we get out of Jordan. And I hope that this is valuable to you. So Jordan, I think the idea here is we want to learn as much as we can about sort of subscription offers. And since all roads seem to lead back to Jordan for everybody I talk to, we just get you on for a bit too um and just get your thoughts on on some of this right now would it help if we showed you kind of what we're currently thinking that's what yeah let's start there i i can riff off the top on kind of like the general state of subscription if you want um or let's just let's show you yeah yeah cody you want to share screen yeah yeah i'll share and then yeah i would love to hear that too here's what we're doing here's what we're planning obviously trying to go heavy subscription so one time right here will be 96 so you know brought that up upcharged it trying to downsell it so 96 main offer we're thinking will be you know every four weeks so 28 in each of them um 62 so it's about 35 off kind of going grun style where it's more aggressive discount on the first one so it'll be 62 and then it'll drop down to 67 ongoing going uh obviously you can pick quantity with so let's go let's go back a second it it goes so it's like 10 off basically 35 off in 96 right you never sell at 96 or is that the one-time purchase the one time is the one time okay so just anchoring to that yeah so okay um so higher price point.
13:03Jordan Menard: Can I see the ingredients? Matt can tell you way more about them than I can. We're branded on three and clinical dosage on three. And lithium. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Super small amount. I know our doctor insisted on it. Really interesting. And this is, this is really interesting. Okay. Cool. So there's a lot of angles that can come from this product that are not sleep directly that I would really go hard on. I would really go hard on cortisol if I were you. Yes, you're you're, you know, you can do some really cool stuff because you have saffron at the literal perfect dosage, which will allow you to make mood claims.
13:47Jordan Menard: Understood. The pricing seems a bit high to me for 96 at one time. I kind of get the vibe there that you guys basically priced it off. Like, what do we want to sell the subscription for? And then reverse engineer there. And I would say that's like a little too much. I think that you're going to have, you're going to run into issues with that. I would just structure it a little bit differently. I would do it, you know, bring your one-time purchase to a reasonable amount, right? And, but still high, right? So like whatever the market is, do like 10 % more than the premium option, right? Set that for your one-time purchase and then do a 10 % discount on the subscription.
14:30Jordan Menard: But then during times like Labor Day, you can run like a 30 % discount on top of the subscription discount, which can allow you to run different offers and tests. And that's what Grunz did. They ran a bunch of different tests, different landers to kind of figure out what the perfect arbitrage of percent off acquisition MER CAC, right? Because when everything goes into Meta's black box, the algo is going to give you different outputs based off the inputs. This four sleepers in the house thing, walk me through that. Well, the brand is very built around like family sleep health. right so it's like kind of mom first hence why it's like cutesy and very family friendly and you know mascot um so it's like our ideal jordan is like you get mom and you get sort of like multiple family members all taking this do you have uh any different uh flavors not yet so single flavor for now but we're gonna add multiple flavors okay um let me share this page real quick.
15:44Jordan Menard: This page actually when we ran it, it beat the control in both conversion rate and AOV at the same time, which is rare. And so it's not a ton, but I would do this because Matt, this still accomplishes what you're trying to do. But what happens if I'm just like a very budget conscious single sleeper in the house who likes to buy in bulk to get a lower price per unit? I'm going to leave on one sleeper even though. And so I just don't see that bet paying out right. I don't like those odds, that EV if you will. But I like this. So the way that we do it here, notice how when I it's gamified 22%, 17, 12, I get more free gifts.
16:43Jordan Menard: It shows me what I'm getting. And let's say I pick three. Then this is like a two step flavor selector funnel does so well. I've seen this work a bunch of times. Same thing. Instant is running. And so I would test that as a PDP. and then I would also test this as a PDP this is probably where I would go first but these like super minimal PDPs brush where you have like a slider at the top with all your and then you just have like a little blurb right here real coffee you know just tells you exactly what it is um you know four sentences and then you can choose like whatever um super clean and minimal converts very well rise does something similar let me stop there and kind of go back to you guys what questions what do you want to double click on on that one specifically the number of sleepers i got everything else we were saying are you saying it's show the quantity just like don't call it for who it's for but just like make it more general one two three bags two bags three bags yes exactly exactly that's easy um and just one two three and then increase the discount at the more boxes they add so the more boxes they add they get a bigger percentage off i call this shop yeah we have that i got a few things jordan first is just expanding on the sort of like one-time purchase price versus the subscription.
18:15Jordan Menard: So like you're saying go less discount to subscribe as like your evergreen? Yeah, I'm saying, I mean, try this, test this, see how it goes. Okay. For sure. And then, but if it's not doing well, you know, I would test pricing for sure. Yeah. Oh yeah, we're very open to that too. That's kind of why I'm asking is like, you know, your gut was that, okay, the one time's a little high. Yeah, but that could be fine. Right. Yeah, we don't know yet, right? We don't know yet. And so think of it as a question of arbitrage, right? There's some perfect, happy medium, right? You'll find out what your natural CAC is if you're running ads hard in the first five months, right?
19:01Jordan Menard: By month five, you'll probably have that number. And so now you're presented with different options, right? The reason I use the term arbitrage is because if you can now sell a two-pack, a three-pack and add an upsell, when that goes into Facebook's algorithm, they're going to charge you a higher CAC, but how much? Is the acquisition MER trade-off worth it? Did CAC go up, but are advertising is actually getting more efficient? Well, in that case, I want to lean in there. But the big thing is what's the LTV? Because everything has to be made around, all the decisions have to be made around that.
19:43Jordan Menard: So you guys don't, you haven't launched yet, right? No, not yet. No, you can see too, like we're trying to push people to quarterly, like the every 12 weeks. And Cody, if you click on that, you'll see Jordan, we're stacking in all the free gifts there. Yeah, I would, I would do something that shows they're not getting the free gifts when they're not on this right like that's the i don't think we're gonna push it super yeah we're not gonna push it super hard like you know how ima it's like it's like open and like defaulted i think we'll start here just to get volume but like that will definitely be one test that i think we should run yeah that that's fine i think like just illustrate that they're not getting the free gifts because like free gifts work i see what you mean and and and like if if that's your bread and butter then you should have like a free gift on the first month it's gonna convert better what kind of gifts like does it matter or is it anything free it matters but you guys have so much you can do look at the everyday dose starter kit frother mug all of that stuff yeah we can include frother or we could right now what are we doing now, Cody?
20:53Jordan Menard: We're more like digital. We have like one month of this app. We have our ebook just because we don't have the inventory right now. Those gifts typically don't work well in terms of like it's physical gifts that really get like customers excited. And then you also use that as a retention tool, right? Like you hit certain points in the subscription and you unlock X free gift and then you gamify and make that experience congruent across all your correspondence, your retention portal, your CRM, everything. Yeah, it's cool. Yeah, definitely planning on getting there. I'm getting back into the weeds.
21:31Jordan Menard: One of the things I'm probably the rustiest on is email. I'm super excited to be using OmniSend. They're using them on Winx. We're AI-pilled. We are using it to do everything. I'm running most of our email program from Claude and Codex using the MCP, and it's awesome. We also have email, SMS, and pop-ups all in one place. We have all of our flows, welcome series. It's all talking to each other. I love the platform. The analytics are really good. I highly recommend it, especially if you're in the position the Wings is in. New brand starting out. But if you're on a different platform and you're paying too much and you want to switch, they will do the migration completely for you.
22:03Jordan Menard: No lost data, no lost list. It takes only five days start to finish. And they are giving our listeners 30 % off the first three months. Go to omnisend.com slash nine operators to try it out for yourself. okay so we want to call out like the somehow in that in the four week uh cody is like we want to call out there is no free gifts here so like somehow draw more attention to that yeah so if you like that that everyday dose page that i showed you see how like if you just build something like this if you go away from the how many sleepers thing and if you just do one bag two bag three bags and then you have the gifts that are unlocked here then i guess that's true you lose the toggle between four weeks and 12 weeks too yeah but but you don't need it because they can select three bags right here and so and i think this format's going to be better for you guys um where you have the free gifts that like see how they they like go they gray out something like that would be a cool way to do it.
23:14Jordan Menard: Yeah, I love that gamification. That's cool. Like one bag, 12 weeks? I guess that's my question. There's a difference between how much am I buying and what's my frequency of subscription. You can do the same thing though, right? It doesn't have to be one, two, three. It could be, you know, whatever weeks, right? Four weeks, eight weeks. Yeah, four weeks, 12 weeks. Yeah, that's a good one. It's like a bigger, because it's like a format and offer. Matt, on Grooms, I noticed they do it pretty well. They call out because they're trying to incentivize that. No free shipping, discount for sure only.
23:43Jordan Menard: Yeah, I think that's a good call out. Jordan, what else are you sort of seeing right now in land of subscription supplement? Anything that stands out to you that you're seeing people try, that's working? You called out the UI on Everyday Dose. Is there stuff like that that you're paying attention to? So with subscriptions, like are you guys like really locked on your numbers we're pretty good like even like margin math and unit economics like you know your cact ltb and everything like that we know what we would like we don't know what it's real yet because we haven't launched but but do you know like your worst case scenario i think that depends on cac now yeah but there's a number that you can afford do you know what that number is can you explain what you mean by there's a number you can afford Like, give me the bounds and I can tell you if we've got it.
24:35Jordan Menard: I've got, like, a lot of data, a lot of models. Yeah, so it's like, whatever, what's the number that, the highest CAC that you think you can afford with a reasonable retention cohort? Have you looked at anything like that? I haven't looked at it through that lens, no. I've just looked at, like, you know, at certain levels of CAC, you're, like, you need either better retention to pay for it, right? Yeah, but there's a part where it doesn't work straight up. And I would presume an industry standard retention cohort and then understand that you're going to have to re-forecast monthly. But I would get really, really serious about that number because you need to understand all of those things.
25:22Jordan Menard: And you need to understand, okay, if our first rebuild cohort, which doesn't actually come until your second month, by the way, because month one is all your diehards. that's going to put your numbers. When you get your second rebuild cohort, that will tell you, like, do we have a problem? Are we on plan based on this model? Because you know what percent needs to rebuild in order for that lifetime shipped margin number, which is the most important, right? And it's all a baseline of are you tracking to that? So lifetime ship margin is like CAC to lifetime shipped profit for like a ROAS number, right?
26:05Jordan Menard: Like what's the multiple? If you guys have a$60 CAC, how much shipped margin does that produce in three years, right? And your big strategics want at least a two to one, at least. And so I would, Matt, start there. Reverse engineer from that with your COGS. what numbers would it what would be required and then every month you can see if you're hitting baseline or not really beef up your cancel flow really figure out why people are canceling beef up your treatments um you know really understand exactly you know how to minimize that as much as possible um and i think like high level that's you guys have questions you want to dig into anything Yeah, I mean, slightly tangent, but I feel like watching Instant, you hit it pretty hard.
26:59Jordan Menard: I remember you had a decent amount of whitelisting from the beginning with some larger creators. What do you think worked really well? Because I know that you took off really quick. And what would you do differently when you launched for a new brand? Solid question. I think definitely go heavy on whitelisters on launch, right? I think for a million different reasons that you get that borrowed authority and trust. But I think a big one is to like, um, it's a good signal to Facebook that you're like a reliable, high quality advertiser because that first, like when you first start launching ads, the CPMs are crazy.
27:34Jordan Menard: You'll see them like 200 bucks and like, they will come down, right? It's just a, uh, something that you have to get through. But I think whitelisting can help with that. I would go really big on that. Um, I think I would have done like more of a, we're live offer and messaging and, um, Um, yeah. And, um, I would have, you know, a lot of the stuff that I'm telling you, I learned as we went, you know, some of the stuff, you know, we were just focused on selling one box up front for a long time. I would have, you know, sold two and three boxes earlier. Whitelisting. What do you, when you say you would go bigger there, um, can you give me a size, like a size, like how many whitelisted partners would you launch with?
28:16Jordan Menard: yeah it's not i mean i the the hard number is it it's more like budget right like you know yeah it's like how long is a piece of string i get that yeah i i would say like you know 50 to 100 for the first month is is where i wouldn't go lower than 50 um when we do you know we do whitelisting as a service for some um of our select agency partners and you know we always tell them like don't go less than 50 it's just like 50 000 yeah a month um you're just the chances of you finding one that will the whitelisters are a lot like a vc portfolio right like most of them are going to lose but the minority that wins can win so big they can cover all the losses and provide all the profits and so below 50k i found the bet becomes asymmetric in an unfavorable way, right?
29:16Jordan Menard: Like you just restrict yourself. Yeah, your hit rate has to be too high. Yeah, exactly. Subscription brands, I am talking to you. You obsess over churn, but you only know your subscribers by skew, by cadence, and the real cancellation risk, it lies in the actual humans behind that data. Outer signal enriches your existing customer data, the existing Shopify list, and it turns it into real identifiable people and personas. We are talking demographics, lifestyle, who's a VIP, who's a creator, who is buying for a business. All of these persona attributes then get pushed into your favorite email platform so that your retention and win back flows can speak to a segment, a specific small group of people instead of everybody on a 30-day plan.
30:01Jordan Menard: There's a native Shopify install. It's set up in minutes. Get your free persona report on your customer data. When you sign up, go to outerSignal.com slash operators. Tell them we sent you. I promise it'll help. And for 50 ,000, how many would, would you go after a few big ones or would you try for like 10, a combination? Yeah. Combination. So we, we break it out into three different tiers. Like we have our marquee influencers who are like 25 grand a video for 30 days of usage, sometimes more. Um, and then you have like the working middle, which is like, you know, seven to 15 K, you know, you get bangers there and then you have your high volume, needle in a haystack, which is the 1 to 5K influencers.
30:43Jordan Menard: And we like to spread it out. It's the caviar potato chip, if you will. I like that. Cody, did you run similar at Jones Road? Is that kind of how you looked at things? Because Jordan taught me what to do. Jordan's whitelisting is the most dialed thing I've seen. So I've learned just from one hour, tremendous amount. So yeah. But yeah, I agree. I mean, it took off when he taught us and everything. And I absolutely agree. I think that's the hard part from the beginning. Even with the inventory we have, 50 might not just make sense for us to do from the beginning. But yeah, you have to. Any channel in the past that I've launched and dabbled in, it's hard.
31:23Jordan Menard: I remember we launched podcasts. Actually, podcasts we did a big, but YouTube. It's like, yeah, we're going to spend 50 grand. You do one big test, and that's like 40 % of your budget. That's not enough. what will happen like the magic of the game is when you like we this just happened we got like a 7k influencer just a banger right i think like we're now spending like you know 20k a day on our ad well as soon as i saw those numbers were like really amazing in north beam like we went back and renegotiated that ad an extension for the next 90 days right and so before all the notifications start flooding in, right?
32:03Jordan Menard: And I think stuff like that sounds small, but to Cody's point, like the influencer department has such a major effect on everything at scale. It should be about 50 % of your ad account, if not 60. And Cody, I would push back, bro, like start with it, off jump. Like it's gonna help, like don't, I would not launch without it because you're gonna get all that borrowed authority and that initial learning window of meta if you signal you're a really high advertiser, I think you're going to have a better long-term game. That's your call, Matt. You're the budget guy. I'm so okay with it, dude. I really am.
32:39Jordan Menard: We have some budget. I want to take high-quality shots on goal. That's the best one. Yeah, I also have my list from Jones Road. It's not the exact demo, but it's pretty close. We need moms. We need 35 - to 50-year-old moms. And yeah, to Jordan's point, like we probably i don't know how we didn't take any giant ones but we probably went like 40k a month was like our biggest one and like the big ones pretty work but like we also had some critters that were like 2k a month that we probably spent like not seven figures but like close to on like you get some of them that just carry the whole exactly and there are diamonds in the rough it's real but like you have to understand the hit rate's way lower and so you know you need to just make sure that everything works together jordan do you in your experience with whitelisting do you find that the ones that hit can pretty much hit on any brand because they're just so good at it or is it brand by brand creator by creator it just you never know you never know but but cody's right in the sense like look at proven people that are great at making content that's what you're looking for some influencers like are followed because of just who they are some are followed because of the content that they make i always want to find the content creators the people that are actually making content yeah where in your stack of like you said you have like three tiers of whitelisting where you stick the the new crop of like affiliate creator where they're like just crazy volume of video production you know it's the like what's coming out of tiktok shops now where you get people who are like no i'll make you a hundred videos a month because i get paid on spend or a commission on like where is that is that like a fourth tier now of like how you think about create a relationship i i think of more that is more like an affiliate play um for create when i'm talking about like partnerships it's like whitelisting specifically um i think affiliate has a massive massive role i think but i think i would group that under like affiliate because they're still whitelisting those people but you that you would put that whitelisting into like, this is an affiliate bucket.
34:48Jordan Menard: I don't really do that whitelisting, to be honest. It's not worth it. It never is. That's like a participation trophy whitelisting. It's like, I'm doing it because I heard on Twitter I need to do whitelisting. That's not what I'm interested in. It's the same reason we test creative in ABO. I don't do it because I like it. I do it because it works. We negotiate with influencers manually. It's the only way to do it, unfortunately. I like this, dude. That was, like, coming in hot. Yeah, I definitely needed the push on the... I'm cheap as everyone knows, so I definitely needed the push on going bigger on whitelisting.
35:23Jordan Menard: Yeah, Cody, let's hit up some of the ones that you know are good, and let's just... Let's go there. No, I like the offer stuff. I think for us, like, we're going to test it all. It's just figuring out what to test, but I like that, you know, that buy box, that's a bigger one. Definitely hear you on the one time. I think the offer stuff is great, and we just have to test right through it. Love what you were saying about the calendar stuff. Like, brilliant, super smart, so... I think that's great. And we have a few moments to hit. Super key. And, you know, Liberty will be big. Get those free gifts included.
35:51Jordan Menard: And, you know, you guys could really hit the ground running. Yep. It's good timing for lunch, too. Because, like, we're turning it on and we're going to start testing ads like this week. Awesome. Jordan, super appreciated, dude. Okay, we're done with Jordan. A few weeks later, we bring in Lina Fahizul. I hope I said your name right, Lina. Sorry if I didn't. also known as the chief ovary officer who basically roasts men selling to women. We thought this was a good idea. Ultimately, she's like here to help you get better results if you are a guy selling to women. So she looked at our ads, our landing pages, our messaging.
36:26Jordan Menard: She found things that we would have never caught ourselves. And lovely, lovely Lena did not hold back. Let's dive in. Lena Fajizo. Welcome to the pod. This is Operators Build. Why don't we start with who you are, what you do, and then I think that'll give people context for why you're here on this episode with us.
36:52Lina Fahizul: Yeah, thanks for having me. I'm so excited. My name is Lina Faizal, aka Chief Overy Officer is what I'm known for, because a lot of times I roast men that sell to women. And what I do is my work is kind of like in the intersection of direct response marketing, female biopsychology, which is my expertise, and CRO. So that's what I do. And I help men sell to women better.
37:18Jordan Menard: Most AI tools right now are all promise and no delivery. You know exactly what I am talking about. Super fancy launch videos. This is why I'm loving what Rich Panel is doing. They have AI and support smashed together, made it practical, made it useful, made it valuable to brands today, not on some future promise. And instead of asking you to spend weeks writing prompts and uploading help docs and babysitting, they flipped the whole script. Their AI builds your support team for you and everything it needs. I've watched it. It works. It's freaking amazing. RichPanel even guarantees 50 % of your support volume will be automated by AI within 30 days or your money back.
37:55Jordan Menard: I call that a no-brainer offer. If you are interested, go to richpanel.com slash demo, not for some generic demo, but to actually book a call and watch them build your actual support team. Okay, so can you explain that work to me a little bit? Like, is it mostly, is it therapizing men or is it like actually showing us how to write better copy?
38:15Lina Fahizul: It can be both, but pretty much showing them how to write better copy and how to talk to women in a different way. Because a lot of times what I see when men try to sell to women, they make them feel like to get them to buy a product. And I'm essentially saying there's a better way to do that without making women feel like crap just to get them to buy a product.
38:38Jordan Menard: Okay. So why don't you start with like, can you maybe walk us through high level with some of the common things you see are like that? Like that's a great lesson for people. It's like, you don't always have to make women feel like to get them to buy. So maybe start high level for us. And then we can then get into like a wink specific things.
38:56Lina Fahizul: Absolutely. And then also
38:57Jordan Menard: So like, what do you have to get them to feel to get them to buy? Oh, yeah. That's a good point. Yeah. Yeah. Tell us what to do also.
39:05Lina Fahizul: All right. I'm excited. I'm excited because I feel like the difference between men and women buying are not talked about enough. And this is essentially all I yap about. And so I'm going to start with the common things that I see that I can tell instantly if the founder or the owner of the brand is male. And so one of the things that I mentioned earlier was making women feel like crap. And so a lot of times what they can look like is pain, agitation. You know, the usual formulas that a lot of...
39:36Jordan Menard: Like Ada. Yeah.
39:38Lina Fahizul: And I'm not saying it can't work. I'm saying there's a time and place for it. So number one is that, right? Making women feel like crap, pain, agitation, driving in the pain and all those things. Number two is operating under the assumption that men and women buy the same way. Men buy or they tend to buy most of the time very linearly. For example, you, Matt and Cody, you want to buy a shirt or you want to buy shampoo and you're just like, OK, sweet. I'm going to go see what's around. What's the best deal? Boom, buy. Right. And then that's it. For women, it's not the same, but a lot of men who sell to women make that same assumption.
40:21Lina Fahizul: So how I look at it is women buy more circularly. They have a problem. They go out to find a solution. But they're not just looking for the best offer. A lot of the times they're screenshotting, they're sending to their friends and saying like, hey, have you heard of this brand? You know, what do you think about them? Do you know anyone who's used this brand before? Once they get that social validation, they'll go back to your brand and then take a look at the comments. What are people saying about it? Having a look to see, okay, is there anything off? Are you being sussed about anything? And then they'll make the decision to buy.
41:01Lina Fahizul: And so there's so many more layers to it before they make the purchasing decision for women. So I think that's two, right?
41:09Jordan Menard: Can you expand on the share with friends for me? So knowing that, do you advise brands to make things more easy to share?
41:20Lina Fahizul: A hundred percent. For one of my clients who sell skincare to Gen Z specifically, who loves to screenshot products, we made it in such a way where the product page on mobile is done in such a way where the person can screenshot it and all the key information is just there that they can share with their friends. And so that can look differently for who you're selling to or for who Cody is selling to. But just keeping that in mind that these women, we have a group chat where we're asking our friends, have you heard of this brand? Did you try it? Was it easy to get a refund or return? Women don't buy.
42:02Lina Fahizul: Women buy parasocially is how I would frame it. And so that's something you have to keep in mind as well.
42:07Jordan Menard: Oh, that's so interesting. Okay, so keep going.
42:10Lina Fahizul: Okay, so those things. And also the other thing that boils my blood is when men say, yeah, we're selling to women. what kind of woman? Who are we talking about? You know, what's her age? Like, you know, like there's women is not just like a monolith. There's like, there's so many different types of women. There's Gen Z, there's boomers, you know, there are moms, there are working moms, single moms. There's so many different types of women. And so making the assumption that just selling to women or having one product solve one problem for just women in general. So not knowing who they're selling to and assuming that all women have the same problem.
42:57Lina Fahizul: So that's another thing as well, is that they just assume all women are the same and that there's no nuances or layers to women. That's another one. And then the other thing that I can think of as well is just making the assumption that you as a brand, you're competing with other brands. That's one part true. But when you sell to women, you're not just competing with other brands, you're competing with her mental space, you're competing with other people in her lives. For example, Winks, you're selling to women over 40 or what I assume are moms, or it could be not just women over 40, let's say moms.
43:40Lina Fahizul: When you're selling to moms, you're not just competing with other brands. You're competing with her thinking about, okay, maybe I could use this money to buy something for my kid or for my husband or for the household or for these things. And so when you're positioning your product, you have to think about that as well, that you're competing with all the other things in her lives. And so that's why I talk a lot about permission and giving women permission to buy a product, especially if she's a mom. And when I say that, I see some people just take my tweets and they rip off and they literally say, hey, you have permission to buy this.
44:19Lina Fahizul: It's not a literal permission that you need to give them. It's such a male thing.
44:25Jordan Menard: It's like, wait a minute. Let me check the box.
44:27Lina Fahizul: No, I see some of y 'all take my tweet and you just put it in chat.jpg and I read it and I'm like, hmm.
44:36Jordan Menard: That's so good.
44:38Lina Fahizul: Like, not literal permission.
44:41Jordan Menard: Yeah, we have to give permission, but don't say that.
44:45Lina Fahizul: Yes. So for the guys watching this, can I riff a little bit more on what I mean by permission, by the way?
44:51Jordan Menard: Yes, please. Because I think, Cody, I don't know about you, I would like expansion here. I don't. I'm one of those like, well, she said it literally, so she must mean it literally. So tell us what you ask. Can you just like go deeper on it, please?
45:05Lina Fahizul: Okay, perfect. Yeah. up.
45:08Jordan Menard: I wasted two hours over the weekend trying to upload ads. And I said, I've never got to do that again. So I had runneth do it. It looked at every ad, picked the right landing page. It named all the ads, wrote the headline and copied to match from options I gave it, set the naming conventions, set UTMs, all of it, and push it to ads manager for me. All I had to do is go into ads manager, QA it, hit live. It was done. Runneth is an agent with its own virtual computer. So it never shuts off. It's always on. The whole team can talk to it. The same runneth in Slack. It remembers everything. It has pre-built skills based on some amazing stuff that the motion team has built.
45:42Jordan Menard: Here's one example of how I'm using it. Last night, I hooked up Tribe, our creator sourcing tool. And anytime a creator video comes in, it gets QA'd against my feedback that I gave in it before. We get notified of any new video. I can have it add captions. It watches the video, figures out what it's about, adds naming conventions, edit hooks. I've been doing a lot, building a lot of static ads with Runneth as well. It's pretty awesome and it all comes out of the box. We've been using our Winx as our main creative strategist, using it to build tons of ads for us. Winx is using it. Ridge is using Runneth.
46:12Jordan Menard: HexCloud is using it as well. Go to Runneth.com. They're giving listeners 500 million free tokens for your first month.
46:19Lina Fahizul: For all the dudes watching this, I don't mean literal permission. When I say give permission, it says something like, you know, why not give your chance to fall asleep and stay asleep? You know, why not let yourself have a restful night's sleep so that you can be more present for your family and stuff like that. Because a lot of times when they're making a purchasing decision from a lot of the moms that I interview when they're buying products and stuff like that that I've spoken to, they're always debating on whether or not this money could be used for something for their kids. And that's just a normal thing, right?
46:51Lina Fahizul: When you're a mom, because your priority is your kid. And so giving them permission to want it reduces the guilt for them to actually make the purchase.
47:01Jordan Menard: How would you, okay, so could you maybe, I don't know if you're, if you can do this like live, but how would you advise us to do that? Because the idea of like a big part of the positioning of the product is sort of like just my own, my own wife and like watching her struggle with sleep. She's 45. She's perimenopausal. We have 11 year old daughter, like all the things. And what you're describing like that, I've never quite thought of it that way. I'll be honest. like the we're competing with everything else in her head, which is really terrifying to me because I watch how much she goes through in a day, uh, like how much stuff is like kind of rolling around.
47:37Jordan Menard: And I don't quite know how to do that language wise, right? Like think of like a landing page or even just as a brand. Um, like I, I get the, like the average mom doesn't sleep eight hours. That's so obviously, especially with young kids, like Cody, you, Cody's got very young kids. He knows this. So like maybe Lena, could you go, could you give us like examples of how we might do that as a brand?
48:04Lina Fahizul: Yeah, I think it really very, I'm trying to make this as tactical to everyone listening. I think it really goes back to the fundamentals, which is knowing who you're talking to and what they're struggling with and really getting deep into their psyche and knowing what they go through on a day to day and what they're actually looking for and wording it that way so for example it can be something like when it comes to wings i think just wording it in such a way of saying it like why not give yourself the chance or you know finally get the make three hours sleep or why not give yourself the chance to make three hours sleep feel like eight hours or something like that or why not give yourself the chance to be more present with your family stuff like that so centered around the things that she wants in the after state or like the desired outcome of the product that you're selling her oh that's that's good actually
49:02Jordan Menard: i like that because as a guy when i think of like the the benefits of sleep like the outcomes so like sleep is so foundational to health like broad health right uh mood all those things but it's actually like it's the classic like um i don't know if you remember the whole like why do you buy a drill it's like it's not to put a hole in the wall it's not to hang the picture it's literally like uh to stop your wife from nagging you to hang the picture like you actually have to go like really deep into why did you buy the drill and in this case it's like sleep isn't just about mood sleep is about uh it's like mood yes but it's so that you're more present or more calm with your kids so like you're less agitated so in the morning you're like you don't snap as quick, something like that.
49:49Jordan Menard: That's what I'm hearing, right? It's like, just follow it through to like sort of the desired psychological state.
49:56Lina Fahizul: Exactly. Because eight hours of sleep is not something, yes, she wants eight hours of sleep, but what is the byproduct of eight hours of sleep? It's if a mom who is a single mom, who is also working while taking care of the kids, it's being mentally sharp at work while also being present with your kids and not snapping at them, you know, first thing in the morning, or when they're not being, when they're not listening to you. It's all those things. And I guess when you flip it over to men, you know, men, I guess you can pair it with sleep and testosterone. So why do they care about testosterone?
50:32Lina Fahizul: Like those things, you know, the byproduct of having, I guess, high testosterone levels.
50:36Jordan Menard: Yeah, for men, it's like, it's performance. It'll be like productivity, energy, like performance. For women, it might be energy so I can play with my, like for a mom, Like my wife would be like energy so I can go and go play baseball with my kid or go out for a hike or mood for her is very much like I just don't want to be as short with my daughter. Right. I don't have short temper or stuff like that. Yeah.
51:01Lina Fahizul: And that goes back to like my whole point of selling to women. It's not you. You're not just selling to them. because if you listen to what you just mentioned earlier about your wife, all these things that she's doing, it's not inherently for her, it's for those people around her and the type of woman that she can be, right? And so that's the main thing that I always want to drive home when I talk to men who are selling to women is that these are the important nuances that you have to pick up on and you can only know these things when you really get to know who you're selling to and the type of woman that you're selling to and essentially what she's going through as well.
51:34Jordan Menard: That is so good. But so for that, I guess, is it better to help reduce the guilt to do stuff for herself? Or is it better to sell by saying, here's how this will help you show up for other people?
51:46Lina Fahizul: I think it depends who you're selling to. Like one of the things is definitely reduce the guilt. And then the other thing is just painting the after state of what her life could look like. Because a lot of the ads that I was looking at for Wings in particular, a lot of the messaging and angling I noticed is just talking about her current state in her current problem, but I haven't seen any ads or have yet to see any ads that talk about what her life could look like after she's had the product or after she's consumed the product. What kind of woman is she? How's her life different after she consumes, you know, the supplement?
52:20Lina Fahizul: It's a lot of times just kind of like talking about her current problem and it works to a certain extent, but what I've seen worked better for women is showing her what kind of life she could have what kind of mother can she be how um how much well rested is she going to feel and how that's going to affect her life and so going back to your earlier question cody about you know what kind of messaging or how should you approach talking to women is a lot of times what i've seen worked well with clients who are selling to women is painting the after state of what their life would look like after they've consumed their product that's great actually that's such a uh
52:59Jordan Menard: there's nuance there because i think a lot of direct response marketing is very like pain first agitation so it's like let me start with like my current state and what you're saying is we should focus more on the like here's how i feel after i got a good night's sleep yeah or here's how i feel after 30 days like actually sleeping better you have been listening to us talk for years about building nine-figure durable goods brands, Hexclad, Ridge, Simple Modern, Pila, when we sat down to build Winks, there was never a question it had to be a subscription brand. And being the veterans we are, we could work with anyone, but we decided to work with Skio to build Winks.
53:43Jordan Menard: Working with the team over at Skio has been awesome. We get to see all of the stuff that the fastest growing CPG brands are actually doing to acquire more subscribers and keep them longer. My favorite example of this has been incentivizing new customers to go from a monthly subscription to a quarterly subscription right after their first purchase but before they get their first order the team at skio has been sharing insights on how much in portal flexibility to give subscribers when to change frequency when to offer product swaps when to do gifting what rewards should look like what is cancel flow optimization the list is freaking endless and they have shared it all they have been incredible to work with they are bringing so much value to this partnership.
54:19Jordan Menard: It almost feels a little unfair. If you run a subscription brand, you should be talking with the team over at Skio. They know their stuff.
54:28Lina Fahizul: I always sell this to my clients as well. Like test it out and see what works. But most of the time, the ladder always works because when you use pain, agitation, and all these things, when you sell to women, they end up not making the best clients or they don't stay for very long or they churn a lot faster as opposed to the women who, when we sell the after state, because then the kind of customers that you're attracting as well, the kind of customers that are going to stay long enough to see through or to see the end result through.
54:59Jordan Menard: That's fantastic. Okay, what else do you got? Jeez. Now, like we have all these creators. I'm like, this actually tells us like what we can advise even Cody. I'm thinking we go back to like all of our tribe creators, right? And it's like, instead of just focusing entirely on like the bad. It's let's go after this end state thing. Yeah.
55:19Lina Fahizul: And even the type of creators that you engage in as well, I think something that's overlooked with this is that they get creators that just do not look like the customers that they're selling to. One time I had a client who was selling to moms and, you know, the kind of moms that they were selling to are, you know, moms that don't have time to take care of themselves. They look like an average person, not someone too athletic, not someone to, you know, just average, but the kind of creators that they were engaging were like these super fit, hot yoga moms. And I'm like, I mean, it works to a certain extent.
55:53Lina Fahizul: I see the logic, but I think men take the extreme of like, you know, show the customer what they could be to an extreme. You just want to show them like something realistic, right? Who are these people that are like her? You know, what kind of women are like her? Because a lot of times when women buy, They don't just want to buy from your brand if it works. I mean, yes, if the product is good and stuff like that, but they're also looking at other women like me specifically that it's worked on. You know, I'm a working mom. Would it work on someone like me who's a working mom, a single mom, stuff like that?
56:27Lina Fahizul: And so I think this can be something that's taken into consideration with the creators that you work with as well. As, you know, are these moms that you're selling to going to be able to relate to them?
56:38Jordan Menard: Lina, can I ask you a question on this? when you, so just from an ads perspective, right? Because like so much of our, everybody's P &L goes into ads. Do you like it when, or would you recommend that we actually like have creators start with like an identity statement like that? Like I'm a single mom of a eight year old of two kids, five and eight. Like something more specific where it's like you immediately can identify, like the viewer of the ad can immediately identify with that person. Or are you more of a, Thank you. And then, start with the after state. Like, here's how I'm feeling right now, and this is not where I started.
57:18Lina Fahizul: Kirsten, I like to test it for all different clients. So, what you mentioned is what I test. So, for example, one will do like a very specific, like, I'm a single mom, and, you know, my mornings are super busy, and so therefore I don't have time to X, Y, and Z, and this product helps me X, Y, and Z. and then something else where we don't say it specifically or literally but you put yourself in an environment or we ask them to shoot an environment where you know people are very visual and they can pick up on things so for example uh with one creator we ask them you know to shoot in their kids like playroom where everything's messy and you know they look a bit disheveled and they're like you know i'm a mom and you know how moms are blah blah blah or she doesn't even have to mention that she's a mom and she's like you know it just showcases that the the everyday life or the reality that she's going through so it doesn't have to be very literal as well you can also use visual cues to your um your advantage that makes sense okay um
58:18Jordan Menard: and if you were looking i guess like we can talk specifically about winks but if you're looking at us it's like the first thing you said is like we talk a lot about we start with like the pain or the problem. So we're not hitting on like the after state in the ad, which is great because like I would have, my default is like the ad's job is to get the click and like get them to the site. Right. So like I would actually default to starting with pain. I think Cody, you'd probably agree with that. Um, but I haven't thought of like, if you start with the after state that actually might also get there.
58:51Jordan Menard: So like, what else would you advise us to start looking at?
58:54Lina Fahizul: Yeah, I think I I just want to touch a little bit more on that as well. I think a lot of the ads, what I see is like just a woman lying awake at night. And then if I had to, if I had to summarize it, it's like a woman sleeping or lying awake at night and then get wings. But there's no like women either, you know, sleeping through the night and then like an afterstate of her, you know, playing with her kids and then try wings. You know, it's a lot of just a woman laying awake at night. That's number one. And then number two is that I'm just saying all the things that come to my head right now because they're sitting fresh with me.
59:28Lina Fahizul: But I think I don't know who you're talking to because I just see, you know, your sleep has changed after 40. Or, you know, you talk about circadian rhythm and cortisol and stress and all these things. And so I think the messaging is a bit muddy because I'm just like, okay, what kind of woman are you talking to? And I think I'm not sure if maybe you guys are not sure if you're going after perimenopause women because it seems like it's tiptoeing around perimenopause. But on a lot of the landing pages, I think at the bottom is when I see, oh, okay, it is talking to someone with perimenopause, if that makes sense.
1:00:08Lina Fahizul: So I think there's a lot of specificity that can be done to themselves, like who you're talking to, in my opinion, at first glance.
1:00:19Jordan Menard: So if you look at the landing page that you shared with us, it's like 10 reasons women over 40 wake at 3 a.m. and what you can do about it. would you actually just straight up say like 10 reasons women going through perimenopause like would you actually just be like that like this is for you so i think one of the ads that
1:00:38Lina Fahizul: that to this as i recall because i was looking at the landing page concurrency as well it was a static ad saying something like your um your sleep has changed um at 40 or something like that right and so before I like to do this thing but I like to guess the landing page before I open it and so what I guess I was going to land at was a landing page telling me or explaining why my sleep has changed now that I'm 40 but I and I I thought okay when I saw the the headline saying 10 reasons women over 40 wake at 3am and what you can do about it I'm like okay great maybe we'll get into it. So if we're going to skim through right now, we're looking at all these things.
1:01:24Lina Fahizul: And I'm not just going to roast you guys. I want to tell you what I like as well. I love the specificity of the things that you mentioned, you know, like stuff like, you know, the exact time, not roughly, these things. These things I talk about a lot because when you get into specifics when you're selling to women, it makes you feel like you know them, right? And you're not just saying something generic. And so I like that you guys are very specific with how you work certain things. But then where it gets a bit muddy for me, it's like, okay, nobody warned you and every product on the, okay, these things are great.
1:01:57Lina Fahizul: Something I want to highlight that I think you guys do a great job at is externalizing the blame. And so I talk about this a lot as well as that when it comes to women, you don't want to blame them and say like, you know, you're not sleeping well because you take melatonin. No, you want to say you're not sleeping well because nobody told you that melatonin you know helps you fall asleep but doesn't help you stay asleep so you want to externalize the blame when when you sell to women and so that's something i think you guys do a really good job at okay i i didn't even know
1:02:27Jordan Menard: that that was a thing but externalize the blame i'm doing yes but yeah i think where it gets
1:02:31Lina Fahizul: muddy it's like okay now i'm looking at the problems i'm like okay this is fine and then like this one it's just like something about somewhere in your 40s your body stops being reliable about temperature overnight blah blah blah fix it but it doesn't tell me that why why has my body become warmer because yes in perimenopause in women who go through perimenopause they get hot flashes and stuff like that but in nowhere does this acknowledge that right it just talks about okay it just tells you what to do it doesn't tell you why you're going through something so it doesn't acknowledge in any of the copy here okay the back half of your night got lighter Your deepest sleep happens early.
1:03:11The second half is lighter and it gets lighter with age. So a noise, a warm patch, a stray through, blah, blah, blah.
1:03:18Lina Fahizul: Nothing about you is broken. Here's how to fix it. Again, it doesn't tell me why. So I'm in no way assuming that, you know.
1:03:25Jordan Menard: Can you explain why that matters? It's the why part. So like, is that a, this is for women? Women want to understand why? Is that what I'm hearing?
1:03:33Lina Fahizul: I think it's also the messaging in your ad. because, for example, you just say that your sleep has changed around 40. There's nowhere in the ad that mentioned anything to do with perimenopause. And so when you open that loop of my sleep has changed now that I'm 40, I want to know why it has changed, you know, because there are some women who are not even aware that they're going through, that their sleep is affected by perimenopause. And so when an ad tells me something about myself, I want to know why it is. And so if I open this page and it explains how perimenopause affects my sleep and why, then that makes more sense than what you're telling me to do.
1:04:13Lina Fahizul: Because what you're telling me to do doesn't explain why I need to do it in the first place, if that makes sense. And so that's where I see the disconnect. Oh, this one's my favorite. when I went through this, I literally wrote in my notes, girl, no woman has this in her drawer. Like, she's not going to have batteries. And I know it's something my favorite. That's hilarious. But like, visuals are so important when it comes to landing page. Because this is a man's drawer. No woman is going to have this in her drawer.
1:04:49Jordan Menard: Yeah, that's right. And obviously, we should have caught that. It's just like AI slop, just like putting images in. But yeah, of course, it's hilarious to look at. That's such a good one. We know. We would agree with you on this one.
1:05:02Lina Fahizul: I saw this and it cracked me out because yeah, for me, landing pages are kind of like similar to the ads. They tell a story. And so like what I do when I'm creating landing pages as well as I make sure the visual goes along with the copy. So even so much so that even the person that I'm using and the images, they're the same person throughout the landing page. But yeah, that's something as well. And so then we go into the ingredient part.
1:05:34Lina Fahizul: Then we go into the ingredient part as well. And it just goes straight into the ingredient. But for me, I'm left still not knowing why my sleep is affected. And then we go straight into the ingredient. And so I think there's a disconnect there because I need to know why I have this problem. and then what is the solution and how Wings differs from all the other solutions outside there. And so essentially what I'm trying to say is that I need to understand why I have the problem and then have the belief bridge be closed. So I know now I have a problem with sleeping at 40. So I need to know why and then I need to know what can help with that.
1:06:18Lina Fahizul: And then that closes the loop. And so that's how I imagine the landing page to be. Because if you're not going to tap into her emotional side first, it's going to be hard to get her to buy into these things. Because unlike men who buy logically, women tend to buy emotionally first and then justify with logic later on. And so if you tap into that emotional part of it, it's going to be a lot easier or it's going to be a lot smoother when you then insert your product and it makes more sense. That's kind of how I see the landing page. I just feel like it's telling me what to do, but it's not telling me why I have the problem in the first place.
1:06:55Lina Fahizul: Does that make sense?
1:06:58Jordan Menard: Yeah. So can you maybe just like this, you keep saying close the loop, open the loop.
1:07:02Lina Fahizul: Yeah.
1:07:04Jordan Menard: I think I get it, but I'd love for you just, especially for people listening, like what you mean by that. Like is it an ad that opens the loop and then you're expecting the lander to close the loop? Or on the lander, are you like creating loops with each reason?
1:07:19Lina Fahizul: I think it's both. So I'm going to show you guys right now what I imagine the landing page would have looked like if I landed on it. Obviously, this... Oh, I love the let's talk about why.
1:07:30Jordan Menard: Right away.
1:07:33Lina Fahizul: It's not the best copy-wise because it's one-shotted, but... No, it's great. I love that line.
1:07:39Jordan Menard: It's awesome.
1:07:40Lina Fahizul: Perfect. Yeah, because... So going back to your question earlier, it's like, what do I mean by close the loop? So the ad opens the loop, right? It asks the question or it made a statement of your sleep has changed around 40, but it doesn't answer why. And so I imagine the ad sparks a question or a statement and then the landing page would then follow up on that and continue the conversation of why their sleep has changed. And so this is essentially the landing page that I thought I was going to land on. If your ad tells me that my sleep has changed at 40. So let's talk about why. And so then you can go in here, unlike the first page that we were going through that has no mention of perimenopause.
1:08:27Lina Fahizul: This one tells you, you know, your sleep has changed around 40. Now let's talk about why and how perimenopause affects your sleep. And so the first point to hear is explaining how perimenopause affects your sleep. And, you know, there's even like a little timeline here that explains how like, you know, it's the years before menopause that you get all these different hormonal changes, not just the moment your period stops. And then it can go to pointer two. Okay, like what that can look like at night. So what are you experiencing at night? So these are the things that you're experiencing. So for the woman reading this, it explains why her sleep is changing.
1:09:08Lina Fahizul: It explains how, you know, the things that she's experiencing. And now she has an answer as to, okay, this is why I'm not able to stay asleep. So it connects the dots. It starts connecting the dots. Because the other thing as well with women is that when you don't fill in the blanks for them or when you leave things to the assumption, a lot of times, psychologically, we tend to fill in the gaps with the worst case scenario. And I tell this all the time to the men that I work with. It's like, think about your friends who are girls, women, or your wife or your partner, whatever. You know, when they try to call you and you don't answer and they're like, oh my God, I thought you died or I thought you were in a car crash.
1:09:54Lina Fahizul: Like, it's funny, yes, but that's the whole point of what I'm trying to say is that women tend to fill in the blanks with worst case assumptions. And so we don't want to let that happen. And so we want to fill in the blanks as much as possible and empower them with as much information as possible. But going back to the point here is explaining again, okay, these are the reasons why and connecting the dots for them. And then this is why, now that we've explained perimenopause and why they can't sleep, then we go into, okay, now that you know that, It helps empower you, helps you change what you do next.
1:10:34Lina Fahizul: And then you can go into talking about start with the cause, not another guess. So then when you go about it this way, inserting the product here is a lot more natural and it makes sense. And so to me, the way I look at it is that I want to explain the reason why and then explain what they can do about it and then explain the solution if that makes sense. going back to what I was talking about earlier. And so now this becomes a lot of a smoother process. And then now they're open to understanding how these ingredients work with all the things that they're experiencing currently with perimenopause and not being able to stay asleep.
1:11:19Lina Fahizul: So everything ties together as if to tell a story. That's kind of how I would imagine the landing page to be.
1:11:27Jordan Menard: Great. Right. So what I've written down here is like these landers for our target woman. So if we're just like saying that the perimenopausal woman or my wife, we want to start with education first. Right. And like really just teach is the main thing. Yeah, because from the research that I've done when I was looking through women who are going through perimenopause or the women that I've spoken to,
1:11:55Lina Fahizul: Not a lot of them actually tie back their sleeping problems with perimenopause. And I think that explaining how perimenopause affects their sleep and them staying asleep makes a huge difference. But I think that goes back to, again, who you're talking to as well. Because I think there's a lot of different sub-avatars that I know that you guys are talking to, right? Because I see cortisol being used. I see circadian rhythm. I see melatonin as the supplement that you're positioning against. And so cortisol, a woman who has high cortisol that can't stay asleep, is going to be different from a woman who's going through perimenopause.
1:12:46And so there's just different, I guess, different sub-avatars.
1:12:50Lina Fahizul: And so the messaging would just have to make sure that it's aligned with who you're talking to, if that makes sense.
1:12:55Jordan Menard: Yeah, it's like add to lander congruency. We think we all we would agree. Like we think that's very important.
1:13:02Lina Fahizul: Yeah, 100%.
1:13:03Jordan Menard: Can you talk about your your research process? So say somebody's listening to this and like trying to identify those avatars or understand, you know, what you're saying about each time? Like, what's your process? Where do you like to look? And I think probably more importantly than that, like, what are you looking for? Like, what helps you? What are you looking for to help understand what their state is? what those questions that they're asking are or what, you know, what they're experiencing so you can write about it. Every marketer has to like develop a process for this. And I'd just be curious to hear yours.
1:13:31Jordan Menard: Like, and if it, if, and I'm curious because I want to know if it's, is it any different from mine? Because, because all you think about is like, how do I sell to women?
1:13:39Lina Fahizul: Yeah, I think like when it comes to wings specifically, when I realized that you guys were selling to, you know, women who are in their forties who are going through perimenopause, Then I take a look at, okay, what is the amount of women or what is the percentage of women who connect that their sleep is affected by perimenopause? Is it a high percentage or low percentage? Then I realized that it was a very low percentage of women who realize or who connect the dots that their sleep is affected.
1:14:12Jordan Menard: So how do you know that? How do you know, like, what tells you that it's a low percentage? where are you seeing that what are you what are you looking for okay i actually do like a
1:14:24Lina Fahizul: google research and then i look into like um published findings done or research done external research done and so i take a look and then i actually go through everything and i look at what they're saying um what studies have been done and stuff like that and so that's what i look at in order for me to figure out the type of messaging that i want to put out right and so it can just be any published findings done if obviously you can also look at reddit and stuff like that but i like to first take a look at like anything that's been done by like universities or anything like that so i guess more like uh established um established research so that's where i start so how is this might be a dumb question but yeah how is research
1:15:09Jordan Menard: how is research going to tell you like what you know percentage of people know that they have this problem. Like, I feel like research will tell you the actual like mechanism behind it and stuff, but not people's like awareness of it.
1:15:21Lina Fahizul: If there's a certain percentage of women that are not connecting the dots, then that's where I'm going to start. So once I start there, then I'm going to comb through Reddit. I'm going to comb through like TikTok, all the other usual places that I think every marketer takes a look at. Once I've kind of confirmed, okay, what is the angle that I want to go with? And that's when I go with. Because a lot of times as well, is all the other women that I speak to, they are not, obviously it can't just be based on the women that I speak to as well, even though I speak to a lot of women on this. It also has to do with like research, what people say, what people have found and all these things and all these different things.
1:15:57Lina Fahizul: And that's not to say that perimenopause affects like women in this bracket differently as well, because for example, with POCs or people of different ethnicities, it might affect them differently as well. That's kind of essentially how I do my research amongst many other things. Because once I start, I kind of like block out a time, for example, maybe two hours, three hours, and I just let myself go down the rabbit hole. I'm not a very organized person. So I'll have a doc, research dump doc, and I'll just put every single thing that I find and I look at repeating patterns. And then what I also like to look at is what is the tipping point for someone to find your product or to get to the solution.
1:16:42Lina Fahizul: So for example, me, you, Matt, maybe we have, I don't know, a hair loss problem. And then what is the, I put myself in the position of the customer and think, okay, what are the things that I've done or what are the emotions that I feel that has led me up to finally the breaking point of actually rectifying the problem? And so those are the things that I also put myself in when I think about the customers that'll help me find random keywords and random things to look at as well. I don't know if it makes sense, but I'm actually not organized at all when it comes to research. And so there are just certain things that as more like muscle memory and stuff like that that I do.
1:17:22Jordan Menard: Yeah, yeah. No, that makes sense.
1:17:24Lina Fahizul: I'm actually curious if I may, I would love to ask like for you guys, how did you end up, you know, with perimenopause and sleep and stuff like that? How did you kind of come up with that avatar?
1:17:40Jordan Menard: Oh, perimenopause, like 100 % my wife and all of her friends. Now, I will say, Lena, that what's interesting to me is the when I think about that group of people that I'm close with, right? This is like, let's call it like 10 women. They're all very health conscious. So like these are regular supplement takers. They hire coaches. They've got like multiple doctors. like they're very educated customers and all very aware that like perimenopause has a huge, can have pretty significant impact on sleep just because of hormonal changes and all that stuff. Like literally one of my wife's best friends is a perimenopause creator.
1:18:22Jordan Menard: It's like what she does. She just like, she's a doctor who talks about women in perimenopause. And I think that that, like listening to you, this actually might've been a blind spot of mine in that, like the percentage of women that realize that this is a major impact on sleep and why i never really thought of it that way because all of the women in my life are all hyper aware of this uh so now i'm thinking like oh geez like this this actually might change a little bit in how we market to this segment of like women over 40 who don't even realize that like this we have to connect the dots for them we have to actually like educate a little bit right they know they're sleeping like that's easy uh but why you know and it's not obvious it's probably it's not your kids yeah i think because even when you look at the sentiments
1:19:10Lina Fahizul: i think a lot of people correlate i mean we know cortisol this so there's been a lot of talks about cortisol lately circadian rhythm and all these things and how it affects your sleep but never really like perimenopause never really entered the chat right unless you're unless you're surrounded by women such as yourself, which is the 10 women that you mentioned. And also the main thing that I know that a lot of people talk about as well is falling asleep. And so I think what's really interesting, one of the things that I thought was interesting with the angle that you guys are taking is that you're not talking about falling asleep, you're talking about staying asleep.
1:19:45Lina Fahizul: And so the amount of people that probably would correlate staying asleep to perimenopause is probably even more little. So I think it's a really interesting angle to take as well.
1:19:55Jordan Menard: Yeah, this is super helpful. It's it also just I don't know, Cody, like to me, it just screams. This is like a lesson that I think marketers just continue. We need to learn. It's like you don't just have one customer. You've probably got like a thousand like little sub personas and ICPs and that you have to be making ads and funnels for like each one. that speak and I think Lena what I'm taking away from this is like the specificity part like you have to be specific so that your woman like really can see herself or like oh that's me right um yeah I think that's a really good takeaway here and just to add on to what you
1:20:36Lina Fahizul: said earlier as well Matt about like the different types of like people as well it's because I feel like when I was reading the the messaging or the themes I think you know staying asleep or wings in itself could also be beneficial to just as different I guess pockets of sub avatars there is and so high functioning women who can't switch off their mind or you know moms who just like constantly get disrupted sleep because their kids are waking them up and so it's something like you know your kids are asleep but what about you and so it's always the mom that's that's getting their sleep affected so there's just different ways that i'll put the messaging or different sub avatars that um that could that could be spoken to things that i love that you guys do and i think that something to be considered for other male founders who are looking to sell to women is having a timeline and i love that you guys have this on your pdp and some of your landing pages and what I mean by timeline is that say you're selling skincare, beauty supplements, anything of the sort that people won't feel the change immediately after they use it.
1:21:47Lina Fahizul: Painting a picture of what they're going to experiencing, like for example, week one, week two, week three, helps make a huge difference in managing expectations, in answering the questions that they already have in their head and also reducing churn. And so I love that you guys have that on your PDP and some of your landing pages. And as much as whatever I'm saying right now seems like such an obvious thing, you'd be surprised how, number one, it's not talked about enough, I feel. And number two, I don't see it on a lot of brands that have products that you can't feel immediately when you consume it or when you apply it on your skin.
1:22:23So that's one.
1:22:26Lina Fahizul: Number two is when it comes to selling to women is reassurance. I'm not telling you to write copy like it's okay baby I'm gonna take care of you. None of that. I mean like how can you help reduce all the things that she's worried about for example when it comes to risk risk reversal you know when it comes to her getting her refunds and stuff like that. So just making sure that at every step of the way you're telling them okay you it's a money-back guarantee, no questions asked, all these things. So just making sure that everything's as easy as possible for them to, in any case, if they want to return the product or the product doesn't work, and then validating how they feel.
1:23:11Lina Fahizul: Something that I see that you guys do in your copy as well, which I love, and I would love to see more brands that sell to women do. And that's, for example, in the case of Wings, saying something like, it's not your fault, not that, sorry. It's saying something like, you're up at 3 a.m. again and it's not your fault, stuff like that, you know? It's okay to go through X, Y, and Z, stuff like that, just validating how they feel, you know? Not invalidating them, externalizing the blame and just painting the after state of where your customer wants to be. And so just, I guess, if I had to distill it into like as simple as possible is just thinking how you can make the copy honest and positive and not make them and not have to make them no fear mongering without making them feel like crap and stuff like that and those are the things i think about and something else that i think that is very important as well is knowing whether your customer is you know are they are they tour-driven or are they away-driven?
1:24:21Lina Fahizul: So tour-driven is, are they more, do they resonate more with messaging that gets them towards the end product of where they want to be? Or are they more away-driven? Meaning, are they more, do they respond more or do they resonate more with copy that takes their pain away? So stop waking up at night or stop waking up moody and stuff like that. And so those are the things that I would consider.
1:24:49Jordan Menard: If you guys know, like this guy, Carl, I forget his name, but he does like IMA, it's like funnels and stuff. He posted a tweet that he said they had a pretty big win. And they're like, understand, do research, find out if your customer is. And like, that's not something I would probably be able to go to do research. I haven't done it with this mindset and been like, OK, this is it. Like, what would you be looking for specifically if you're doing this research? What would tell you if they're towards or away?
1:25:14Lina Fahizul: Okay, first things first, I do want to, I want to credit my mentor, Alan Soltanich for this, because this was something that he taught me that opened my mind. And I was just like, this is insane because in the overall spectrum, there are people who actually either resonate to towards or away. And so for me personally, I'm pretty sure like everyone has different ways of testing this if they're aware of this. But what I like to do is I like to start with a headline. And so for example, with one of my clients, what we did was we tested the landing page with away-driven and tour-driven headlines for all the funnels, across all the funnels.
1:25:53Lina Fahizul: And so, for example, let's say one of the funnels for the landing page, they resonate with tour. So we do like an A-B test. One is the control, the normal headline, and the other one is like tour, and then the other one is like away, right? Depending on which one wins, I'm then going to expand the messaging of either away or toward on that particular landing page. And then I'm going to see how it performs again. So then from that, then I can test it out on my ads as well. And so for me, that's how I kind of test what kind of messaging your customer resonates with. Like, do they want to stop the pain?
1:26:31Lina Fahizul: Do they want to move away from it? Or do they want to go toward like the end state? All right.
1:26:38Jordan Menard: I have one other question. Everything that you're saying is great. Matt and I both have pages and pages of notes. Everything you're saying is great. It's also just general, really good marketing DR advice. Like, is there any reason any of this can't be applied to men as well?
1:26:57Lina Fahizul: I think it's mainly because also what men resonate with. You can test it and see if it resonates with men. But generally what I find with men, they're more attracted to like status. and so and they also are more motivated with pain and so generally that's why you see when men break up you know like they get hotter they have a glow up and stuff like that they use that pain as fuel to become better and so like with men when we say like you know if you want to get like I think the best example because I get this a lot as well it's like I don't know if a lot of econ bros would know this but like Andrew Tate and Shelby Sapp prime example of the differences in how you market to
1:27:43Jordan Menard: men versus women that's a good I follow Shelby I don't follow Andrew Tate because he he he bothers me Shelby does a lot of like this is how you could change your life yeah she does a lot of that like future pacing foreshadowing that's a good point Andrew Tate is like um I don't know if I'm allowed
1:27:58Lina Fahizul: to curse but he's a lot like you know escape the matrix like um women stuff like that like not stuff that I personally resonate with, but if you look at the numbers it tracks, look at how many men he's gotten to get into Hustler University. It's all about status driven.
1:28:21Jordan Menard: That's fair. Okay, fine. That's a good answer and 100 % right. I think there's some stuff that can be. Less about that framing, but a lot of the here's what you can expect. A lot of the the notes that I've taken where you're like, hey, you have to very clearly close the loop. You have to explain to them why this works compared to what they've said. I think there's a lot of really good nuggets that still do apply that I'll take even to mail funnels as well.
1:28:49Lina Fahizul: I always tell my clients as well, anyone who consumes my content, don't just take my word for it. Test it out. See what works. But what helps you know what to test or what to do and see what works is understanding the nuances of marketing to men and women. I think my gripe is this, that there's so many male founders who just market to women in the same way that they market to men. And it's always the same things that I see over and over again. And so for me, it's just like, there's a better way to do it. And I think women deserves to be marketed to better.
1:29:23Jordan Menard: Any other final points, Cody, Lina, that we want to hit on before we can let you go, Lina?
1:29:28Lina Fahizul: I didn't do any research on competitors, but to be honest, I think that a lot of what I say can be applied. I think the whole mode of like, oh, how you can differentiate yourself from your competitors is just knowing who you're talking to, to like such a deep level that you know his psyche, you know exactly what she's experiencing, you know what her life looks like, what her day-to-day looks like, why she wants eight hours of sleep. And, you know, hint, hint, it's not because of the sleep itself, it's who she is when she gets eight hours of sleep. And so all these things will help, is what's going to help you stand out for your competitors.
1:30:05Lina Fahizul: Because you'd be so surprised to see how much generic messaging there is out there. That if you get so detailed on who you're talking to and really know who your avatar is, that's going to put you way ahead of all your competitors, in my opinion. And so for me, it's like competitor research is second. I want to know who I'm talking to first. Because chances are, sometimes when I look at the competitors, they're not actually going to deep, deep detail or really take the time to get to know their customers. What makes you a great marketer and what I strive to be as a marketer is have empathy. Because when you have empathy, you can really put yourself in your customers' shoes and really understand how they feel and why they want to change the current situation that they're in.
1:30:53Lina Fahizul: So if you have empathy when it comes to marketing, I think that puts you way ahead of any and all of your competitors besides other things, of course. I've got so much.
1:31:03Jordan Menard: I feel like you got to do a mic drop now, but that's been awesome. Yeah, it's super helpful. Like, Lena, what's great is like some of this is just a good review of like good marketing, right? Good copywriting. And then some of it is just like this nuance into women in how we think about like messaging to them. And there's just so much nuance. And I mean, anybody listening is like, obviously men and women are different. I get it, but it's hard to write copy for both. So this is really, really helpful for me. Ooh, I do have one more question. Shoot. Do offers change between men and women? Like, is there a different psychology of the offer that you think that we should try or would be successful?
1:31:48Jordan Menard: like are women less or more likely to take subscription versus not because it helps with their you know their business and their their responsibility or is there anything that you think is important to think about there yeah i think that in terms of like offers it doesn't
1:32:05Lina Fahizul: switch between men and women i think it's more of like the traffic that you're sending to the offer so i'll elaborate on that a little bit when it comes to subscription something that i have seen is that when it comes to men, they're most likely to charge back because they don't want to deal with the hassle. Whereas with women, they would actually write to you and they would explain why they want to cancel the subscription and stuff like that. Something that we've taken away is just making it as easy as possible to cancel the subscription. And when it comes to women as well, what we notice that makes them stay or retain them is when you give them a reason to and when you make their experience more personalized.
1:32:42Lina Fahizul: If you know who you're talking to, what she's feeling and what's going to lead up to the next subscription and just making sure the messaging and stuff like that resonates. That's one thing I wanted to point out. The other thing is that not so much men versus women when it comes to offers. I see so many people try to force subscriptions when it just doesn't make sense. Or even when they feel like it makes sense, for example, supplements, people might think like, okay, subscription makes sense. Yes, to a certain extent, but they need to try the product for it to experience what it's done. And so something that, you know, I'm doing for one of my clients is that we have the landing page where like, you know, people from Meta are coming from via buy one, get one free.
1:33:25Lina Fahizul: And then once they've tried the product and they experience the product, the offer on the website, which is where, you know, people who are Googling it has a higher intent, right? So they're going to subscribe. So you buy one, get one free, try the product. It's a lower commitment. It's better for cold traffic. They take it. They experience the product, go on the website, and then they subscribe. And so having different offers for different traffic is something that I would consider. Yeah, we're testing everything at this point.
1:33:58Jordan Menard: Now, Lena, this is great. Truly, this is awesome. I just like so much to do now. This is great. People are going to love this.
1:34:07Lina Fahizul: Awesome. I'm glad it resonated and it helped. And I'm going to keep an eye out on the brand and see how the messaging is going to change and stuff like that.
1:34:16Jordan Menard: I got a lot of questions in terms of the answer. I've been kind of thinking, trying to create a framework for how you think about it and just kind of open a research doc and just block two hours out. Thanks so much for jumping on. This has been awesome.
1:34:31Lina Fahizul: No worries. Thank you guys for having me.
1:34:36Jordan Menard: 10 vectors to think about offer two experts two very different lenses to think of the same problem as you can see offers are not just pricing they're not just buy boxes they are messaging they are journeys they are everything right jordan came in and reframed how we think about the math behind the offer we're still figuring that out lena reframed how we think about the women we are selling to and how we talk to them so helpful your real offer is not your price it is not your buy box. It is the story that a complete stranger is going to tell themselves in the eight seconds before they scroll past you forever.
1:35:09Jordan Menard: You get it wrong. None of the math matters, guys. That is a wrap for this episode. I hope you enjoyed it. The next one is going to be an absolute banger. Stick around for that one.
“A great offer makes the customer feel stupid for saying no.”
How do you know your offer is wrong before the market tells you?
Jordan Menard (Co-Founder, Instant Hydration) and Lina Fahizul (Chief Ovary Officer, Freelance) join this episode to put Winks’ pricing, promotion, and pitch on trial. The payoff is a 10-element offer playbook any DTC brand can steal.
1. Not just price or discounts
2. Fits how the product is used
3. One customer + one problem
4. Adds value before discounts
5. Tackles your top objections
6. Gives a reason to buy “now”
7. Priced right for your market
8. Your most-valuable customer
9. Built for orders 2, 3, 4, etc.
10. Profitable unit economonics
It starts from a simple claim: Your discount gives away margin once. Jordan catches the founders without an answer for the CAC they can afford. Lina shows why making moms feel bad wins the click and loses the customer. Today's “winning” offer could lose money for months.
Powered By
Iris
https://www.irisfinance.co/operators
Omnisend
OuterSignal
Richpanel
Runneth
https://9ops.co/motion-runneth
Skio
https://9ops.co/skio-9operators
Operators Portal
https://portal.9operators.com/dashboard
Operators Newsletter



