1. Podcasts
  2. Operators
  3. 6 CPG Funnels: How We Study Ads, Landers & Offers
Operators

2 Nov 2026 · 1h 8m · 27 chapters

Episode artwork

6 CPG Funnels: How We Study Ads, Landers & Offers

In short

How to study CPG/DTC ad funnels by analyzing competitors’ ad accounts, landing pages, pricing/offer structures, and social proof—while warning against “AI scraping/copying” that leads to temporary arbitrage instead of durable value.

Guests

Cody and the host (Cody and “I”; no other guest names). No external guests are interviewed; the episode is a behind-the-scenes walkthrough by the two hosts.

Guest/brand examples studied (3 each)

  1. Nutrition Geeks (UK supplements): ~860 ads since late Sept; varied creatives (static/video/UGC). Funnel: ad → PDP-style landers (ingredient-focused bundles like magnesium/creatine/apple cider vinegar). Key claims: real Trustpilot placement, “no forced subscription” (one-time vs subscribe toggle not used to trap). Notable examples: Trustpilot section; buy-quantity bundles (1/2/4 and 1/3/6 patterns).
  2. Norse Organics (UK tallow/skin): Gen Z DR; ads target acne sufferers via moms/kids. Key claims: “confidence back in nine days,” risk-free, heavy layered social proof (screenshots, doctors/authority, before/after). Notable examples: “emotional sandwich” layout; 60-day guarantee; subscription toggle shown transparently.
  3. Elevate (UK collagen): ~2,500 ads; partnership-heavy. Funnel: long-form clinically framed collagen pages with expectation management. Key claims: “start my transformation” timelines, subscribe-and-save vs one-time (no trickery), loss-aversion cues. Notable examples: ingredients far down the page; FAQ depth; Facebook-comment screenshots.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Understanding Industry Trends

Discussing the prevalence of copycat advertising and the importance of originality.

“That is not the way to build enduring enterprise value.”
2:03

Researching Brands and Funnels

Sharing insights on the selected brands for analysis and their uniqueness.

“And then the other thing I would say is we tried our best to pick them brands that are not the most talked about ones just to make it more interesting.”
4:06

Deep Dive into Nutrition Geeks

Examining the brand Nutrition Geeks and its advertising strategies.

“So I was looking for like, who do I think is spending a lot?”
7:29

Analyzing Magnesium Products

Exploring the product detail pages and marketing strategies for magnesium supplements.

“So this thing is a PDP lander, like classic PDP.”
11:48

Critical Marketing Insights

Discussing the effectiveness of the marketing strategies and product positioning.

“I didn't find any top of funnel landers.”
14:00

Introduction to TikTok Shop Strategy

Learn about the importance of TikTok shop for D2C brands.

“to like what should your buy box sort of like hero box on the PDPB, like this would be how I think everybody should approach.”
14:42

Analyzing Offer Sizes and Discounts

Explore how different sizes and subtle design elements impact perceived value.

“I also like how on their offers, they get larger.”
15:41

Testing New Offers for Winx

Discussion on testing non-subscription offers and initial performance insights.

“Anything that you think we should look at for Winx?”
16:22

Norse Organics: A Case Study

Insights into Norse Organics' effective direct response marketing strategies.

17:03

Visuals and Messaging in Ads

Evaluate how visuals and messaging resonate with target audiences in ads.

“So I think that they're doing a really great job.”
Show all 27 chapters
18:46

Targeting Multiple Customer Segments

Discuss strategies for targeting various customer segments with clear messaging.

“You know, you never know, but like they're clearly showing people acting.”
19:59

Effective Landing Pages and Offers

How to create effective landing pages and compelling offers for products.

“Most AI tools right now are all promise and no delivery.”
21:43

Crafting Effective Offers

Understand how to create offers that clearly convey value to consumers.

“Yeah, like what's the rest of the funnel look like?”
28:00

Introducing Runneth for Ad and Landing Page Management

Learn how Runneth optimizes video and landing page creation for advertising.

“uploads them, analyzes them, does all of it.”
28:43

Discussing Subscription Offers and Discounts

Explore the impact of subscription offers like discounts and loss aversion.

“Okay, so like it's sort of like very visual, 46%.”
29:30

The Effectiveness of Long Landing Pages

Understand why long landing pages can lead to better conversion rates.

“I feel it's obviously like a little gray hatty maybe, but they're being very general about it.”
30:55

Analyzing Successful Landing Pages

Learn what makes a landing page effective through examples of successful brands.

“they got the clinician's choice, you know.”
33:10

Elevate Brand Insights and Customer Engagement

Discover how Elevate uses clear messaging and social proof in their marketing.

“No, it's a, I think it's a masterclass, but that's a good point.”
36:28

Effective Design and Messaging in Direct Response

Examine how effective design can enhance direct response marketing strategies.

“My favorite example of this has been incentivizing new customers to go from a monthly subscription to a quarterly subscription right after their first purchase, but before they get their first order.”
39:34

Marsman Brand Analysis and Ad Strategies

Analyze Marsman's advertising strategies and their effectiveness in the market.

“So like you can kind of see as I click around here, like what am I getting or not getting even all the way up to nine bags.”
42:00

Analyzing Advertising Techniques and Strategies

Learn about effective ad strategies and the importance of clear messaging.

“He's essentially talking like a caveman.”
45:08

Exploring Mars Marketing Tactics

Delve into Mars' innovative marketing tactics and customer engagement.

“So this is like a mid-funnel, you know, natural, by the way, natural, you know, approach to testosterone.”
52:30

The Unique Approach of Spoiled Child

Examine the unique quiz funnel approach of the brand Spoiled Child.

“And I just thought it was different from everybody else.”
56:00

Gamification and Learning in Ads

Discussion on the effectiveness of gamification and quizzes in advertising and learning.

“But it just goes to show you, I don't know if it's gamification.”
56:55

Success Story: Buskus and Organic Growth

Highlighting Buskus's success with organic marketing strategies and effective ads.

“He used to work for, I think he worked for No Commerce.”
58:08

Analyzing Boost Coos and Brand Messaging

In-depth analysis of Boost Coos's advertising strategy and potential improvements.

“So it's not just, like, tribe creator style.”
1:02:18

Lessons from Whisperflow's Marketing Tactics

Exploring Whisperflow's marketing strategies and their implications for other brands.

“Yeah, I could almost see a world, Cody, where like see how each of these is like kosher, gluten-free, glyphosate-free, fiber protein.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Operators, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Matt Bertulli: Welcome back to Operators Build. This is episode 11. Today is just Cody and I. We're going to do a little switch up for everybody. Instead of just showing you our stuff, we want to take you behind the scenes of how we work. One of the things that I like to do, I know Cody likes to do, is we look to other brands to see what's working, how are they approaching certain problems, what are they're accurate, like basically study their funnels. I want to caveat that with one thing. I think the industry right now is rampant with like everything. Everybody's basically building giant digital copiers and copy machines.

0:34Matt Bertulli: This is an AI thing. It's like it's very easy to scrape an ad library, pull out concepts, and then literally just duplicate the ad. That's just a race to the bottom. It feels very arbitrage-y and temporary. That is not the way to build enduring enterprise value. You might find quick, cheap wins by doing that. What we're going to do today and what I hope you take away from this episode is how to study people in the industry. I've got three brands. Cody's got three brands. We're going to show you why we picked these brands. They're not going to be super obvious. And we tried to get some variety, right?

1:08Matt Bertulli: Like we're building a supplement brand. So we wanted consumable oriented brands and why we liked them. We're going to show you the ad account, the landers, pricing offer. Cody, anything to add to that like approach and just like research, I guess? Yeah, no, I agree with that. You got to know everyone is running the same playbook like i feel like i first saw like hollow socks like the 10 reasons why right like very specific kind of hybrid listicle advertorial like everyone's running the same playbook and you should like you should but don't just copy like get inspo and understand what's working but like don't look at you shouldn't like i shouldn't be able to tell from your lander like oh this is an exact grunt's replica this is an exact hollow replica you know like have some originality to it.

1:53But I think what we're going to try to do is show the principles. And we're going to talk about it. And like, hey, here's what we could learn from these guys. And here's what we could learn from these guys. So we're not just ripping one. And then the other thing I would say is we tried our best to pick them brands that are not the most talked about ones just to make it more interesting. So we're not talking about IMA.

2:11Matt Bertulli: We're not talking about Resilience Day. I think I have one brand who's very popular and talked about, but I want to highlight them because I think they do such a great job. But yeah, otherwise, we try to pick some sleeper hits. I know everybody right now is like Rise, Resilia, Javi, Groons, IMA. There's just like the top list that everybody just rips off. And these are our friends. We're in chat groups with all these guys. And they always laugh at how many people just copy their stuff without even knowing the numbers behind each ad. I think that's the interesting thing. When I was looking at some of these brands, and I'll show mine in a second here.

2:49Matt Bertulli: um to me when i look at a brand it's less interesting if i look at like well what is their top spender it's it's a data point right but i think the thing that's missing is like i don't know the cohorts behind that ad i don't know if it's like which stage of awareness or five i can take a guess by looking at the ad but i don't know the purpose of that ad in the business so to just like straight up rip it off i'm not doing that equipped with the full information of what purpose that thing is going to serve. So like just taking an ad and copying it for my own company, like, I don't know, it feels foolish.

3:26Matt Bertulli: Like I wouldn't copy anybody's anything, right? I'm here to learn and try to infer. And then we, you and I talk and we build what we think works for our brand. So I think that's like a full context of it all. So dude, why don't I, I'll share screen first and I will show you my first brand and let me know if you've ever heard of these guys. So I did a little different. I actually went out of the US for the first one and I wanted to find, and I found, I believe. Surprised you didn't get three Canadian brands. I didn't. I'm like not Canadian and not American. And I went to the UK and my first one is Nutrition Geese.

4:07Matt Bertulli: So I was looking for like, who do I think is spending a lot? I have no idea if they're spending a lot of money. I think they are. Like there's 860 ads in this account. And there's pretty good variety, like statics, visual, like video, there's UGC. And this is sorted by impressions. So like this is clearly spending a decent amount. Hasn't been running that long, like since September 29th. But it's obviously getting a lot of impressions. I just thought their statics were really good. And I thought the variety of faces and visuals and angles also really good. Headlines are good. Like these are very basic ads.

4:45Matt Bertulli: you know that it was actually really encouraging i'm like these are not fancy these like shot it on an iphone it is like a guy just like waving his hands right can't hear that but it's all it is is like and then it's a straight offer what i also thought that you'll see this with all three of uh the brands they all have very different funnels uh nutrition geeks was like very i want to say like classic funnel so when you click on any one of these ads and you go through to the lander, the landers, that's their homepage, that's their brand. But the landers are basically PDPs. Okay, and I'll show you kind of what I did, how I got to all these.

5:28Matt Bertulli: But these are their most popular landers. I have a, I'm sure everybody does at this point, but I have an ad scraping quad code project that basically like uses Appify. So Nutrition Geeks, right? You guys just saw the ad library. i'll show you the lander in a second but these are their top like 247 206 like here's the landers and here's what's in each one it's it's like straight up pdps um and they are like almost what i liked about them versus the other guys i showed is like these ones i think are like very like single ingredient like you are buying a magnesium you're buying an apple cider vinegar creatine like um and then they have like different bundles and things so i thought that was actually really cool, like their product catalog.

6:14Matt Bertulli: So this is what my scrape looks like. I just use Appify and Cloud Code and it just rips through the thing and pulls out the landing pages grouped by how many ads have them. And that to me is like usually an indication of like, okay, they clearly sell a lot of magnesium, like, and a lot of creatine. Like that's, these are big focused areas for them. This episode is brought to you by our friends at Aftersell. Let me start by saying there is something that all of the best operators have figured out, and that is a new customer is expensive as hell to acquire. So every extra dollar you can get out of that new customer, well, that's just basically free money.

6:48Matt Bertulli: Ridge uses AfterSell, Simple Modern uses AfterSell, Jones Road uses AfterSell, Pila uses it, upsells, downsells in the cart, checkout after purchase, plus rocked. So at the moments, right after someone buys, make you money instead of doing nothing. Same traffic, more revenue, sounds kind of obvious. We're building winks right now. That's why you're listening to this show. And AfterSell went into the stack on day one, not a bolt-on for later when we decided we wanted to finally get smarter. Look, Black Friday is coming. You know it. I know it. Your traffic's going to go up. Your ad costs go up even more.

7:18Matt Bertulli: Every single visit is worth more than it was last month if you do it right. So don't just spend more to buy more customers. Make every visitor worth more. That's why we partnered with Aftersell. This is just fascinating. So let's go to their magnesium. So this thing is a PDP lander, like classic PDP. You buy one pack, two pack, four pack. I don't think this is a subscription. Was that preselected? Yeah. Was that third one preselected or you had to select that? No, no. Like when you land on this page, the first one is preselected. Okay. that's an interesting thing one two what's a free gift yeah and then like free turmeric free vitamin D so it looks like they just like they bundle in their other SKUs as their free gifts one two four is not that common I feel like one three six is much more common or now like buy buy two get like we're doing though buy one buy two get one buy three get two like I see that more often I don't see the one two four but maybe it makes sense for them with the quantity or something like that.

8:34Matt Bertulli: I actually thought this was interesting, like putting your, like Trustpilot, I hate Trustpilot. I think they're just like extortionists on the internet. But like these guys clearly lean into it and that most consumers will encounter a Trustpilot review at some point. So like to have them kind of on page is interesting to me. Yeah, well, I think like social proof, that can't be faked. And I'll, as I, when I share some of mine, I'll share some examples. I think I would guess, right, like we should try to like sum this up into like what all these brands will do well. They probably all have really good offers.

9:07They probably all go very heavy on social proof. But social proof that can't be faked because like anyone can, you know, just put a testimony on. But most brands aren't going to rip like fake trust pilot or, you know, you get like real photos. So I like that a lot, actually.

9:23Matt Bertulli: Yeah, I think I mean, yes, there's a lot of I've encountered a lot of supplement brands, especially when I was researching. I'm like, these are just clearly fake. Like, it's so obvious. Like you're four months old, you don't have 150 ,000 customers. Like it's like so obvious. Whereas these guys, I'm like, everything looks pretty legit. Um, so I like this section, the like wire customer switching, right? So like us versus others, they don't name their actual like other, it's just sort of like a, you know, generic. Um, and there's reviews. It's like, this is not a complicated lander. and maybe it's because they are big like maybe maybe they don't have to do a ton of work here i liked the whole flow like this is actually like pretty easy um and then what i also like is i'm and i'm pretty certain dude that this is not a forced subscription no because it would have to show in checkout so yeah they're going no sub was there even a sub offer on that page i didn't even see an up a sub offer no like this is another one apple cider vinegar like it's just one pack, three pack, six pack.

10:23Matt Bertulli: This is what, um, the Calvin from knobs was like, he's, he's, he was sort of taking this position that like, you know, tricking and forcing people into subscription is just like generally not a great direction. If you're trying to build a real brand, you know, that you should, if you have a good product, you should just stand by the good product. So maybe that is their approach here is that like, they probably have great cohorts and great LTV and they just don't need to force the, force the subscription. I mean, these are also like pretty common products. Like if you look at their site, they are selling ingredients that are very popular.

10:54Matt Bertulli: Like all of these are super, super popular. Um, each of them has their own tam. So they, they, they basically run like product funnels from ads. So it's like high volume of ads, whitelisting, lots of creative variety, creative diversity, and then just like dedicated funnels by product and then you know um because it's supplement nutrition most of their ads in the account are like extremely problem solution so it's like struggling with energy um you know calms my mind like there's just these are classic ads like very simple that was really good yeah yeah clear versus clever yeah right um there's not a lot i didn't like about what i saw here like i I mean, whoever's running this company, like, man, hats off.

11:42Like, you're, I just love it.

11:44Matt Bertulli: I think it's really great. And they're in the UK. Yeah, what would you do if you were to say, like, one thing that they could do? I didn't find any top of funnel landers. Again, not knowing the size of this company, I'm assuming decent. I'm surprised that I don't see more, like, well, what is turmeric? You know, like, I'm going right from add to, like, apple cider vinegar, support your metabolism, blood sugar. Like I would have expected to see like advertorials and long form landers, especially to like from ads that feel a little more like I'm unaware stage of customer awareness. And like, and I want to learn a little bit.

12:26Maybe they just don't have to. Same thing, 100%. That's where I met with like the straightforward. It's like the ad is a very good ad going to a, you know, a good offer page. But usually you'll see some type of a listicle, a little bit more DR yapper story base, something like that, higher funnel.

12:43Matt Bertulli: Yeah, it's like higher funnel, upper funnel activity. You know, like the ads, I feel like there's definitely ads that feel that way. But my other thought there was maybe they don't have to just because like these ingredients, like apple cider vinegar is just so well known. Ashwagandha is so well-known. Like everybody and their dog is taking collagen. These are all just really, really well-known things that there's a ton of education in the market and maybe they're just like using meta for what it's good at, which is just scooping in market demand and they don't really have to worry too much about education.

13:16They're just like, now let somebody else do that. Because even ads, like most of the ads I'm seeing are like stop overpaying for creatine. You know, here are the results I got from this, this week only. Like they're very middle bottom funnel ads as well. I'm sure they have some, you know, upper funnel ads, like some sore knees as this works. But yeah, I agree. Much less than the conventional wisdom would probably be.

13:38Matt Bertulli: Yeah, I love the, by the way, I will shout them out on this too. I really like their image carousel on the PDP. Like every image is doing a job. Like it's selling, it's adding value props, it's like comparison, social proof. like it's very Amazon-y, which I think is just like, if you're going to have a default to like what should your buy box sort of like hero box on the PDPB, like this would be how I think everybody should approach. If you're a D2C brand not taking TikTok shop seriously yet, then you need to be. That's where T-Bar Partners comes in. They're the actual operators behind some of the biggest TikTok shop brands right now.

14:19Ridge, Hexclad, Groons, most importantly, us at Winx and more. T-Bar built the system behind all of them. Creator sourcing, sampling strategy, Discord management. They help building a real loyal TikTok shop community. And a huge bonus is they give brands a ton of high-performing UGC content that crushes it on meta.

14:37Matt Bertulli: So if you're looking to scale up TikTok shop, visit tbarpartners.com. I also like how on their offers, they get larger. So the one, two, and four, the box that they're in are actually slightly larger on each one. I think there's like a subtle - design element to that just to show value. Yeah, like see this one's 136. This is what you were calling it earlier. Like the collagen glow up powder, like 136, six months supply, two free gifts. I mean, these are not aggressive. Like you have to give them that too. Like these discounts are not crazy. I wonder how much of this is this going to be an ignorant comment is like UK, like just maybe less competition, less saturated.

15:19Matt Bertulli: I don't know. But like, look at this, right? It's like you're saving. I mean, it's not a huge discount. Whereas like I, a lot of sort of supplement funnels I encounter are like 50, 60, 70 % off kind of claims. And this is just not doing that at all. Like this is a much simpler sort of funnel and flow. I think it's great. That's mine. Any other comments on nutrition geeks? That's my first. No, no, no. Good, good find. Anything that you think we should look at for Winx? You know, so we are testing right now just not on live site but on like a paid funnel like a no sub offer just a bundle offer. I was actually very bullish on it.

16:01It was like, hey, you know maybe it's a CPM thing. Maybe it's just a new brand. I expected better conversion rate, better performance. It's been pretty slow to start. It's starting to take off in the account. I can share some numbers later but it's starting to take off but less obvious than I would have thought so I mean yeah but I I do agree with that general thing is everyone has gone so hard into subscription especially for a new brand

16:26Matt Bertulli: like test it I don't know if you saw this but like here you have a toggle between one time and subscribe and save okay yeah on their collagen yes you got a few it's like very upfront you know like one time subscribe and save like there is no sneaky here all right i'm gonna go number one first brand i have norse organics you familiar with them at all uh a little bit so i don't know too much about them um i i am extremely impressed i i definitely see them get talked about um i think they're just putting on a but they're not you know they're not like a resilia or something like that I think they're just putting on a DR masterclass and offer creation landers and ads as well.

17:10So I think that they're doing a really great job. You know, people talk about Primal Queen a lot. Like, they're great. I almost put them. Oh, they're awesome.

17:17Matt Bertulli: Yeah. I think these guys are similar. You know, similar space where I feel like this, like, right, this, like, tallow, healthy, neutral, like, you know, primal thing is like definitely having a moment. And so here's what I like. So if we look at, you know, ads, they obviously show the visuals very well, right? They're very, you know, iPhone native. Right away, like male, female. That jumps out to me. Interesting. Yeah. Yeah, you're right. Yeah. You know, very, very obviously just problem aware, problem focused, you know. It's great. They got some founder stuff. I haven't really seen that. but they just show the visuals super well.

18:02Right?

18:03Matt Bertulli: Yeah, I know. It's like so striking. Yeah. Like, look at the background on that one static, dude. Holy technical. Yeah. By the way, and these guys are not precious about the brand at all. That's one of the things I love. No, clearly. I'll show you. Even on their like main site, right? Where most brands have like, this is the name of the product. They just like name the offer bundle, like fix acne thing. Like they're very just DR through, which like you got to respect it. Um, but yeah, they show very strong transformation. So highly recommend their ad library. They're definitely like Gen Z. Like you can even see some of the ads, like they're showing the mom and selling to the kids.

18:42Oh, isn't that interesting? Yeah. So some very strong visual before and afters that I can only imagine are real. You know, you never know, but like they're clearly showing people acting. So like very thumb stopping from a visual perspective. product is very well situated. Oh, look at this.

19:02Matt Bertulli: Objection busters. It's so pricey. No 10-step routines. These are all great objection busters. These guys will... I think DR people know this, but they will break when we look at Lander, it's like break a lot of the myths people have of like, oh, you got to have skimmable or very copy heavy. Very DR playbook applied to DTC, it feels like. Yeah. It breaks my heart. Oh, that's good. It breaks my heart watching my son struggle with severe acne every single day. Oh, God. Sell him to the mom. Yeah. Go, mom. Yeah. I love that. Kill acne. This is the thing. So, right away, the variety in the ad account and the number of different people.

19:48Matt Bertulli: It's like there's one problem, but they've taken the one problem and the one product, and they're basically finding lots of paths to lots of different customers, which it's very clear exactly yeah very different formats and visuals it's also just it's very clear right like it's very clear what they're doing who they're going after oh yeah like we know they're going after kids with acne we know they're telling to kids and moms it's just it's very clear I think as we get through the library you probably see more of like the emotion behind it and there's very strong deeper emotional reasons that acne sucks and so they do a good job of that they go full funnel right um like that native ad feeling like they're really all over the place man bravo guys yeah very very very good visuals um right talked about the suffering so like if you know if you watch the ads they they get into a lot of the different one the different you know emotions behind having bad acne as a teenager which is like very very clear um and then let's go to some of the funnel.

20:57Matt Bertulli: Most AI tools right now are all promise and no delivery. You know exactly what I am talking about. Super fancy launch videos. This is why I'm loving what RichPanel is doing. They have AI and support smashed together, made it practical, made it useful, made it valuable to brands today, not on some future promise. And instead of asking you to spend weeks writing prompts and uploading help docs and babysitting, they flipped the whole script. Their AI builds your support team for you and everything it needs. I've watched it. It works. It's freaking amazing. RichPanel even guarantees 50 % of your support volume will be automated by AI within 30 days or your money back.

21:34Matt Bertulli: I call that a no-brainer offer. If you are interested, go to richpanel.com slash demo, not for some generic demo, but to actually book a call and watch them build your actual support team. What are the landers? Yeah, like what's the rest of the funnel look like? Does every, are they like fully congruent? You know, so like each question. so they have a few right um they do a lot of the the pdp style ones but they also have kind of regular landers so if we go this one here oh yeah look at that really good lander and a fit headline get their confidence back in nine days very specific wrist free nine days very good design visual hierarchy of that yeah these guys have and primal queen does well tons of social proof like so many different ways that they've done it.

22:21So, I mean, tons of volume here. And it's not just 750 ,000. By the way, it's also a little DR hack. Don't say 750 ,000. Say a very specific number. But they don't just say customers. They say acne suffers cured. Everything is very intentional with problem solution. Nothing is about brand ingredients.

22:48Matt Bertulli: I mean, super emotional too. Like, look at that, dude. Like, look at the sandwich that's happening between the headline and the bar. So it's like, get their confidence back in nine days. And then like the bar. My son in tears the morning after using this for stubborn act. Like, it's just like emotion. It's like an emotional sandwich. It is an emotional sandwich. And then like try it at risk-free in the middle of the sandwich. And it's almost all about the user, the consumer, right? It's not, you know, it's not 750 ,000 people love our product. Like everything is about what it is. It's nothing about them.

23:17Matt Bertulli: Yeah, which is great. Obviously, clear offer, right? Try it risk-free, right? It's a big one, risk-free. Obviously, they got some of the DR stuff, like high demand, stock is limited.

23:31Lots of social proof. So good. Speaking of the social proof that you can't fake, images, right? And then also what looks like Facebook screenshots. So it's not beautifully designed things. It's very real, very raw. you know walls of social proof but that can't be faked it's like very convincing yeah yep this is really good objection think yours is too severe to clear

24:04Matt Bertulli: risk reversal i love their guarantee their return policy like it's like 60 days guaranteed need oh yeah more social proof there's press there's doctors oh doctors and mothers oh yeah just like there it is again social proof you got like i know social proof which i think in this space you kind of need like the whole like acne space is one of those things where it's very clear if it works or doesn't work it's not like a typical supplement brand where it's like you really don't know if it's working or not um acne is like no it's still here it's not so So I think the social proof is like got to do double duty in acne as a category because you are overcoming a lot of like, I have tried everything.

24:46Matt Bertulli: There's so much. Oh, it's a super, right, take like breakthrough advertising term, like sophisticated market, right? Yes. And you have the Accutane and all that other stuff. And so not only do you need social proof a lot, but I also think the product with the mechanism works super well. Like people, because like the Accutane or, you know, I think that's what Proactiv is. Like it's very damaging to your skin and whatever. And like this is like a very different mechanism. That's like a very natural thing. Yeah. Parents want to put, would prefer to put that on their kids. So like they have a lot of that.

25:18But also I think like the social, all the different formats of it is also really interesting. So they have some actresses. They have, I guess they have doctors. I don't really see them in here. But yeah, they have a few doctors, right? So that's authority. They have authority here. And then they have results. Social proof too.

25:37Matt Bertulli: So good. Let's go down more. More, more, more. They just layer it in, man. And lots of before, after, which is pretty crazy. I've noticed, yeah, they've done this twice and talked about timing, which I would be surprised by because I would imagine with such a sophisticated market, they would be more skeptical to a timing thing. of like fixing it quickly, but maybe that's important to them. So I know before they say 90s. I think she kind of highlighted that when it comes to language, if you're selling to women, like expectation management is important. And this page to me feels very built for mom.

26:15Yeah, but I would have thought like it would have been longer term and that like promising results. Yeah, a week feels unbelievable kind of thing. Yeah, that's what I would have thought.

26:23Matt Bertulli: But clearly they do it there in nine days. How do they sell it? What's the offer? Like, is it a subscription? Let's go to that. So here's, I think they do a wonderful job, offers. I mean, just an offer masterclass, right? Yeah. The name of the bundle, the offer, right? So talking about like offer creation, which just for everybody who's new to it, an offer is what you're selling, the price, discounts, terms, GIFO purchases, all of that stuff. Everything. Plus also the promise as well. And so I just think they've packaged it so well. They're not saying this is, you know, like this is the night balm or this is the night plus day balm.

27:05It's the complete system for acne prone skin. Like it's so clear what it is, what, who it's for. Like I don't even really know. And maybe this would be feedback and it's like probably I'm wrong about it. Like it's actually not super clear to tell what's in it.

27:19Matt Bertulli: Like you can't really read that super well. There's no bullets here. Like this is all benefit driven. But it's like what are you actually getting? Yeah, what are you telling me to put on my skin kind of thing? Yeah. Well, like, what are these three products? I'm sure that's somewhere on the page. It just feels like they're not going to miss that. Every brand I talk to has the same problem right now. You need way more ads and you need better ads. We have agencies, creators, and AI that all help with the volume. But then there can be a week of back and forth. There's a lot of logistics and a lot of people in the way before any of it is even ready to launch.

27:52At Winx, we skip all of that. We have Runneth that's helping with everything. Runneth makes almost all of our statics directly in Slack. They come out launched pretty much one-shotted, uploads them, analyzes them, does all of it. Runneth also helps with our tribe. We're getting so many videos, but we want to make sure that they are appropriate and hitting the right things. Runneth has been trained on all of the feedback and comments that I've given to tribe creators. So it is briefing them, it is QAing all of them, and it's messaging them feedback based on what's working in our ad account. Runneth has started building all of our landing pages for us.

28:22A lot of people are talking about having ad and landing page compliance together. Runneth has made that possible by allowing us to ship really good landing pages very quickly. Runneth has the homework. It has all of the context of Winx and our performance. If you want to check it out, go to runneth.com and start your 14-day trial. Tell them Cody sent you so they can hook you up.

28:42Matt Bertulli: So what is it? What's the, so it's 76. Okay, so like it's sort of like very visual, 46%. I'm assuming that's a subscription. Yeah, say 46 % off with our flexible plan. flexible plan no contracts cancel with the ease that's kind of funny i mean it's a subscription warning low stock notice okay so you toggle if you toggle you it's uh even taking away so like i love that that's the whole like nobody like 30 off as a bundle or 46 off as a subscription yeah Yeah, yeah, yeah. Congrats, you're saving. I love that. You get some like, what do you call that where it's like loss aversion? Like when it's like, you're almost already committed.

29:28Matt Bertulli: The takeaway is the loss aversion part. And then like the congrats, you're saving. It's like, oh, it's back. So if you toggle, does that go away? Like if you toggle the thing? Yeah. Oh no, it's still doing it. Okay. Okay. Warning, low stock notice. I feel it's obviously like a little gray hatty maybe, but they're being very general about it. they're not like only 100 left so like who's to say it's not low stock I guess we are not on eBay watch out for fakes oh that's interesting yeah I wonder if that's like a real one or if that's just a DR thing to get them to buy it there that is super interesting I've not seen that very often also Trustpilot there you go another one leaning into Trustpilot by the way yeah and so super long page lots of stuff I think people get super skimmable though, right?

30:23They do a really good job with their design visual hierarchy, so yes it's a long page, you can get and I'm really big into design because I think it's so important and design doesn't have to be pretty or whatever you can get the message by skimming you know what the offer is, you know what the benefit is you know who it's for you know it works for people just by skimming. That's, I think, what is so great about this page. Like,

30:51Matt Bertulli: you have walls and walls of social proof, you know. Obviously, they got the clinician's choice, you know. So, they got some of that sharing ingredients, what's in them, which is definitely important. But get the pretty long form, big section, so very similar to Primal Queen there. Yeah. Yeah, so they get more into the ingredients here. Yeah, there it is. I was going to be surprised if they missed it. But yeah, no, that's really awesome. And then. Dude, very impressive. And what's cool. So like I'm just on a landing page now. But if you go to homepage and you go to, you know, like even on their homepage, it's very similar to landing page.

31:33It's very DR. If you go to products, right, like that's their main offer is, you know, just product page. So like their whole site is kind of very funneled.

31:42Matt Bertulli: A common mistake too for people when they see long landing pages is they'll look at analytics of long landing pages and they'll say, you know, a lot of people don't get to the bottom. So why are they so long? Like make something shorter. And I think what is also common is that that is true. It's just that the people that do get to the bottom are likely to buy. So like scroll depth and purchase likelihood tend to be pretty tightly correlated. um yeah i've always struggled to explain it but you're like yeah it's not going to work on that many people like the like the length but of the people like the people that aren't going to get there weren't going to buy anyways yeah but the people that get there clearly have desire they clearly are looking for something and more information is usually better to convince them than less information yeah and i think in a product like this where like it is a super sophisticated market, lots of competition, uh, that longer form where you just like, you put everything that a person could possibly need in one place.

32:46Matt Bertulli: You are also making it easier on them to make a decision. So like, this is a highly researched, highly considered purchase. Uh, it makes sense to me that they would run longer form landers. Whereas like the one I showed, you know, I'm buying collagen. Like, I don't know how highly researched I need to be about collagen. Like it's kind of, it's like buying creatine, like the kind of all the same. Um, yeah, you're right about that. I like that one a lot, dude. That's yeah. Yeah. No, it's a, I think it's a masterclass, but that's a good point. It definitely depends on your awareness and set and, you know, sophistication.

33:19Really good point.

33:20Matt Bertulli: My next brand is Elevate. L-A-vate. Uh, again, British company, I believe. Lots and lots. Like when you look at this ad library, um, first thing I noticed, like it's like number one, there's 2 ,500 ads in this account, right? Lots of partnership ads though. Like these guys are everywhere. And you'll see like not as much visual variety in the faces. Like I just see a bunch of women that are all roughly the same age. This is a collagen brand. Like they are really focused on collagen. Collagen is a big tam, lots of like lots of room, but you start to see some variation in the faces. Like they get older, younger.

34:02Matt Bertulli: That always stands out to me. I think their copy is really good. Like Say Goodbye to Sagging Skin.

34:11Matt Bertulli: You know, here's a review one, like a partnership ad review. I just think they've done a really good job. Like clearly also not too precious about brand. Yeah, yeah. The problem aware funnels that we were talking about the first one could have. like it's just like a lot of customer language i guess is how i would describe their ad library like it's video white like partnership ad video with like here's the language of the customer but what i really like what you just showed if you sort of like skip into their um let me just again show you my little landing page thing here unlike nutrition geeks where everything nutrition Geeks was like largely PDPs and some, like you can see, like they had some pages.

34:57Matt Bertulli: It looks like these are all product landers, but when you actually go into the landers, what you're going to notice, they are actually like quite long form. So like clinically studied collagen super blend for women. So again, I think it's like with acne, it's, you know, with Norse it's different, right? Like collagen, very well understood. Huge ham. So like the way that they structured this page, like start my transformation, great call to action. Now I need the results guaranteed. Lots of that language that we were being told by Lina to say, like you've got to really focus on like expectations, right?

35:39Matt Bertulli: So everything is about what you should expect to notice as you take the product. It's like benefits, lots of social proof. Again, start my transformation, social proof. Very clear who they're going after. Yeah, exactly. Super clear. Like, look at this. Like, tell me who they're going after. You have been listening to us talk for years about building nine-figure durable goods brands. Hexclad, Ridge, Simple Modern, Pila. When we sat down to build Winks, there was never a question it had to be a subscription brand. And being the veterans we are, we could work with anyone, but we decided to work with Skio to build Winks.

36:23Matt Bertulli: Working with the team over at Skio has been awesome. We get to see all of the stuff that the fastest growing CPG brands are actually doing to acquire more subscribers and keep them longer. My favorite example of this has been incentivizing new customers to go from a monthly subscription to a quarterly subscription right after their first purchase, but before they get their first order. The team at Skio has been sharing insights on how much in-portal flexibility to give subscribers, when to change frequency, when to offer product swaps, when to do gifting, what rewards should look like, what is cancel flow optimization.

36:52Matt Bertulli: The list is freaking endless, and they have shared it all. They have been incredible to work with. They are bringing so much value to this partnership. It almost feels a little unfair. If you run a subscription brand, you should be talking with the team over at Skio. They know their stuff. Probably the best customer to go after. yo totally great customer to go after start your transformation but here's what i love this this is kind of why i picked this brand is like what should i expect from consistent use of elevate collagen and it's like one week one like look at that it's just so good it's so clear it's simple the page hierarchy is great you know uh look at this like just this old like it's just so good again you're like that whole ancestors thing you know that like ancestral like let's do it the old way i i have a feeling that like ai is causing a lot of this like people are sort of looking into the past and have like a nostalgia for like slower and simpler and that brands like this and norse like they're leaning into it primal queen well look at these guys they're positioning it against you know botox and totally so it's very it's very natural you know holistic angle which is yes having a moment yeah yeah like look at this right like the the getting a needle i don't know like look how long this page is too like it is just they got those facebook comments so like that was something i originally picked up on like zach's tux podcast but like yep just like screenshot your facebook comments i know especially by the way for a facebook funnel for yeah for a facebook fun it's like duh uh it oh because it's like a visual pattern that people have right so like they'll see facebook comments like i just came from facebook that makes sense And when you're a brand targeting older women, there's a good chance.

38:40Matt Bertulli: I bet you without seeing their ad account that like a lot of their traffic comes from Facebook and not just heavy Instagram. But like, again, look at this. So like every image has a purpose, has a job. This is the buy box. Very clear subscribe and save versus one time. Love this. No trickery. Like it looks like it's very well designed. Yeah, so I was just thinking about it. Like that's what I actually really appreciate about them. is they're doing a lot of the DR stuff well, but in a very non-tricky way. They're not like, hey, if you have parasites. They're doing a good job building a brand at the same time.

39:20And I don't mean it's the most beautiful or whatever, but it just means they're getting conversions by helping people fit it in their lives, see how it's going to work, good offers, stuff like that. But they're not deceiving or scamming. So it's like a great white hat. DR. Yeah.

39:38Matt Bertulli: Yeah. It's like it's hitting loss aversion. So like you can kind of see as I click around here, like what am I getting or not getting even all the way up to nine bags. It's like I get a free 15 minute consultation. That's cool. Uh, although I don't know much about it. I love the add to cart like this, just that little visual treatment. I just love it. Yeah. That's funny. I think this is like a very, very, and then like, look at the FAQ, by the way yeah look how long you saw that it's freaking crazy man like look at the like the again just like know your customer and then their ingredients are way way down here at the bottom which i thought was interesting because like we with winks we went like very like here are the ingredients first uh so it's a little more about the product and a little like these guys are clearly like very no what about the customer and what about the expectation of using the product like look how far down this page is the freaking ingredients where they they get to shine a little bit and not the only one right uh north was the same yep so i think that's something that we can look at is like maybe we need to have it but the person who cares about the ingredients might also be the person who scrolls super deep in the page so that we can just like do way more social proof way more benefit benefit emotion emotion and then like drop some of the like about us about the product about the ingredients lower in the page and then they sort of sandwich the ingredients between again more social proof right it's like what do our customers think faq even the images used for the ingredients like again because most people are going to skin like they they got that natural feel it's like oh this is not total beef natural cows like yeah i love the marine collagen is like freaking sushi.

41:24Matt Bertulli: It's awesome. Anyway, give us your next one. That was mine. I'm going to go little, it feels a little cop out, but I think they're incredible. So I'm going to go Marsman. I'm going to go ZXX brand Marsman. Obviously gets talked about a lot. Very familiar. People are very familiar with it. But, you know, there's a lot to learn from them, I think. Look at their ad library. Okay. This ad, I highly recommend people watch. This is the one I sent you last week. It's like their top ad right now. It's just like a guy who it's very, I would say gray-headed. Like, I don't think it's a doctor, but he's wearing a coat.

42:02He's essentially talking like a caveman. And he's just essentially starting with a problem, just going very unique mechanism. Like, I'm sure a lot of people will start ripping off this ad. It's just like a yapper, but like, it's just like super, super simple. But with some authority. Yeah, with a little authority. And then it's like as simple as possible. He's not even talking false sentences. Just, you know, wow. Interesting. They have a lot of offer bottom funnel statics that they run. But you can tell they have, you know, good diversity. I would say mid funnel ingredients. I love their statics.

42:39I think they do a great job on statics. Very clear, very skimmable. That orange works really well for them. You know, to get attention. I like these. obviously they go a lot of high cortisol they do a really good job with like mechanisms they they do that you know I like that they have women in there like this was a really good hook exposing side effects for my 52 year old husband like really good hook in there yeah obviously they'll have you know all the the AI animated stuff man boobs gone or your money back like super clear and easy you know super super clear um you know they do these kind of like pov style long form so pretty

43:22Matt Bertulli: good diversity in their ad account yeah you know what i appreciate about uh about mars and why i think they're a good one to show is i do feel like mars uh cracks formats more often like they don't i don't feel like mars is copying everybody like they they've really like zach runs a great machine around looking for new concepts and like concept development um i one of the groups i'm in zach was in there and he kind of ran through like his creative process and it's very intentional like they are they're just a dialed machine dude i think they're they're talked about a lot but i think for good reason um and it's not just like hacky kludgy like they actually spend a lot of time cracking formats i'm getting back into the weeds one of the things i'm probably the rustiest on is email.

44:08I'm super excited to be using OmniSend. They're using them on Winx. We're AI Pilled. We are using it to do everything. I'm running most of our email program from Claude and Codex using the MCP and it's awesome. We also have email, SMS, and pop-ups all in one place. We have all of our flows, welcome series. It's all talking to each other. I love the platform. The analytics are really good. I highly recommend it, especially if you're in the position that Winx is in. New brand starting out. But if you're on a different platform and you're paying too much and you want to switch, they will do the migration completely for you.

44:38No lost data, no lost list. It takes only five days start to finish. And they are giving our listeners 30 % off the first three months. Go to omnisend.com slash nine operators to try it out for yourself. Yeah, and I know Zach keeps his ear to the ground. He's super humble and curious, but he's not like, let me rip that. He's like, let me see what's working. Let me see how we can, you know, he's doing it from like a learning perspective. Yeah. you know they got so they have some and also but Mars is like I mean again they're El Catterton now they're like becoming more of a brand and so it's it's very like I amate style right but they're not like just like gray hat black hatty so they're not doing stuff like that they got James Harrison like NFL you know alumni in there doing doing stuff like he's got you know they've got UFC partnerships like they do a good job of that I thought that I thought I saw some GLP one but maybe they're going after TRT.

45:32So this is like a mid-funnel, you know, natural, by the way, natural, you know, approach to testosterone. So I think there's that other natural thing that's coming out again. Interesting. So here's exposing the side effects for my 35-year-old husband, right? Yep. If you go up here, and I think it's ranked by, you know, impression or ad rank here. So they're just like, all right, this worked well. Let's go, let's go, go. and I always try to do this at Jones Road, not with like full effectiveness, but like, all right, it works for 50s. Yeah, let's just scale this to 25. Let's scale this to 35.

46:08Matt Bertulli: Yeah, you know what? Actually, like, let's call that out. So the way that, one of the things I like that Mars does is he has like a very, like they clearly have a testing sort of like supply chain that they follow. So like when they find a new concept, crack it, then they find ways to go deep into the concept so like variety of faces variety of formats shoot styles ai animations not like they just go very very deep once they crack one but if you look at their account what i notice is they're just they're trying lots of different angles like they're always trying to crack another concept i agree it's very very different i think it's it's definitely one of the best libraries right oh yeah there's their ai animations remember those ones.

46:54Those are hilarious. Yeah. So yeah, I think great. We'll look at Landers now. Good use of AI statics. Definitely one. And I think it's one of the larger brands now that you could still learn from it. It's not like they're like a whatever. It's like a ritual or a seed or even IMA. There's still a lot to learn from this. Yeah, they're running a very good tactical

47:19Matt Bertulli: setup. All right, if we go Landers. Let's have a look. I'm curious now because I haven't looked in a little bit, but they were like heavy quiz. I'm curious what it looks like. I think they've a little bit more diversified. So, all right, this is actually really cool and interesting. I mean, there's, you know, multiple landers with very different. And I know a lot of people talk about that, like landing page diversity. They have some that are very different. So here's the first one we'll look at. So this is like a, you know, I'll call it a lander. It's not It's not advertorial, just good, good, you know, pre-sale sales page lander offer plus emergency.

47:57Matt Bertulli: You know, I don't know how I feel about the countdown because I don't know that it's going away. I never liked them as a, but it's like, I don't like them because of marketing. Well, I actually don't know that that's legal. Oh. To advertise a discount that's going away when it's not. You might be right. It might, like, I mean, I think the FTC has rules on that. So maybe, maybe, I don't know. Maybe it goes away in 44 minutes. Yeah. Yeah. They have tons of social proof is what I like. So they have a ton of that. They go a little bit more into ingredients than some of the others earlier on. You know, so it's pretty skimmable.

48:37Matt Bertulli: It's very try. Like language, I love that. Like try with the money back guarantee. Like that combo of language is really good. Yeah, focus big on the guarantee. yep um you know still obviously lots of benefits and stuff lots of social proof you know authorities so they have you know doctors as well as athletes um i like going i like how they go with the you know former athletes kind of trying to get their their tee back yeah reclaiming their edge i find really strong messaging they do a great job with like visual social proof so here they got actual labs. Yep. I got screenshots of labs plus screenshots of reviews.

49:19That's interesting. Screenshots of reviews on other places. I haven't seen that. Like, that's an Amazon review. I've not seen that yet. That's cool. That plus labs. Yeah, they're like pulling an Amazon review. That's hilarious. It's really funny. It's really interesting. And like, look at that,

49:34Matt Bertulli: your history, like screenshots of people's testosterone tests. Oh my God. Yeah, that's what I mean by the labs. Very interesting. Cool. Obviously, tons of before, after, like this feels like I don't know you're probably familiar like some of the like 90s 2000s like infomercials like P90X like that's kind of what this feels like here it totally does it's got the same vibe yeah everybody's in GM it's like also like Mara's like very clear who their customer is like I gotta call that out absolutely like so so obvious very very very clear yeah yeah great great job of that super clear I think that's again that's for us to learn from as well like I think that's one of those principles that we can definitely work on yep agreed totally agree And again, just think about how many different forms of social proof they have.

50:16Just stacks and stacks. It's all super skimmable. It's just like, boom.

50:21Matt Bertulli: I think that's something that we have to do on Winx is we have enough customers now that we should be doing more social proof harvesting. And I bet you they go out and they actually really incentivize to get this kind of content. No, I agree. But it's something that's hard in the beginning. And like you said, we don't want to make it up, right? Especially because we're building this publicly. We can't be like 300 ,000 reviews. So it's like, no, no, no. We have to do the hard thing. Yeah. But I agree. We can go more and then more different formats of it. Like we got to figure out what is our version of this before after?

50:53Like, is it the scale? Is it the labs? Is it the sleep score?

50:58Matt Bertulli: Like what is our before after that we can show like this? I mean, we should absolutely do sleep score. Like even Dr. Born will drop stuff in Slack for us, right? Because he has clinical patients that he consults with for sleep. And he's like, the Winx product works. like you got he gets reviews from people it's like this is actually a great product and scores improve and energy improves all that stuff so like we just we can learn a lot from these guys and like lean into that social proof yeah yeah it's like make it front and center I agree I agree just like building a system to get it you know yeah all the time love it again just tons of that gotta love Mars man like they just crush and then one thing on the offer um and so they go I believe you can only subscribe i don't right they don't do it one time yeah and they're clear about it they're not saying subscription here but they're obviously it's it's it's clear it's you know refills like they put it here and they put it here very legal and it's 50 off for life like their language is definitely leaning to like this is subscription but i think that they disarm that with like try it now and a guarantee so they're giving you that like one two punch as a consumer i agree the guarantee to try it now, the tons of social proof.

52:11It's cool to show different ways to do it. They got some gifts in there as well. And I've talked to Zach about this, like a lot of their gifts, like ladder is like a strength that like, it's just habit formation. How can we do everything we can to help these people be successful and actually improve their tea? And so I really like,

52:25Matt Bertulli: because if they're successful, then it's like, they'll, I bet you their retention is better. This is a great one. All right. Let me, uh, let me tee up my last one. I chose this one because of Funnel. And I just thought it was different from everybody else. So some people might know this one and it is Spoiled Child. And you pointed this out. This is an oddity brand. Yep. Yep. So Il Makiage is like their first one. And then, yeah, this was the second one that they started. But it's been what it seems like is ripping. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, look, 780 ads. Their top ads are all like these things, like new to collagen.

52:59Matt Bertulli: But dude, actually, you know what the reason I really chose it is because like lots of ads in Spanish which I thought was very interesting and then tons of partnership ads like partnership ads just statics videos like yep lots and lots of variety uh which I yeah I know like partnership ad static I'm like don't see that very often um but you can kind of see like this Tia Maori like they're clearly leaning into her, but good variety, good like variety of faces. Um, but the Spanish thing kind of threw me for a loop, especially like this is sort of by impressions, which me like these are getting spent like for sure they are with a grain of salt.

53:43Matt Bertulli: Um, but the real reason is they are basically fully quiz funneled. Like every single ad, every single ad that all the top ads all run to this style of page so like how does your skin feel most days uh and then look at this one different one does any of the below apply to you so like i don't know how this stuff works for them um but you can kind of see like you go through this thing i'm gonna have to like just click stuff for people really quick let's have a look cody i should have I had one already done. Il Makiage was the same way where everything was quiz funnel. They were. They were very quiz funnel.

54:27Yeah.

54:27Matt Bertulli: Help, it's serious. Right? Like, ooh, and look, I'm doing work. So like, this is just a classic quiz funnel and then you got to put in your email and your phone and then it'll take you to thereby. But I thought interesting that at this scale, they only run to a quiz funnel. Yeah, I think that would be, and I didn't get to, I don't want to spend too much on Mars, but that would be probably my like, if I had any feedback for them, like versus Mars, like they have quiz funnel, they had 10 reasons, they have standard. And it was like, I do think that is a very important diversity mechanism. Yeah. So like you can just sort of see like everything in here is a version of the same thing.

55:07Matt Bertulli: And like, this is a pretty significant spread. Like 169 ads are just going to this quiz funnel. How does your skin feel most days? Which I thought like just so interesting to not see any variety in the style of Lander that they do. But I think their ad variety is great. I think the copy is good. I love the Spanish-English thing. Even the landing page, by the way, they have a Spanish version of that quiz funnel. So they are congruent in the language. So you're going from a Spanish ad to a Spanish Lander. I thought that was actually pretty cool. But yeah, that was my third. Have we tried quiz on Winx?

55:43Matt Bertulli: I think we did, didn't we? I built one. Because you're a fan of the quiz funnel. Yeah, I built one. Because it actually wasn't going to. I was like, oh, it's not really, we have only one skew. And Zach was like, no, you should. And if you notice, because for me, quiz is like, all right, beauty, coming from beauty, help people get their shade. And he helped you decide. Right. When you have one skew, it's like... But it just goes to show you, I don't know if it's gamification. I don't know if it's like, quizzes can be a good way to help people learn, understand things. Because the framing of Mars is not, will help you find your, they had one skew at the time.

56:16but it's like a diagnostic funnel kind of, you know? Right. And so I like it for that. So yeah, we've tested. I just, you know, I think we're testing again. But that would be my feedback on these guys is just like I do think they're a little bit stuck in an older playbook a little bit, like especially with El Makiage, like very like tube science-y style, like iterative. Yep. And I think like there's a slightly different playbook that they're slightly later on. Yeah, that's good feedback.

56:49Matt Bertulli: That's interesting. Landing page diversity is part of that. Totally agree. Cool. All right, what's your third and final? Who you got, man? I'm going to go with Buskus. Know him as Barr. He started this. He used to work for, I think he worked for No Commerce. I forget. Awesome guy. Lives in Denver. A friend of Conor Rowling. I believe Bootstrap, Don't quote me on it. Has this protein couscous brand that he started. And we're going to shout out because there's a lot he's doing actually really well. Just brought on somebody to lead growth. Is doing really well growing. And so excited to kind of look and shout him out.

57:30One thing I know about what he did initially. He started organic first. And saw him creating content. He started this while he was still working full time. and when he launched ads, I can tell you his CPMs were very reasonable. And so I don't know if it's because it's not supplement, maybe, but I do think going hard on organic to start helped him here. And then I know his top ads for a while were founder ads.

57:56Matt Bertulli: Oh, yeah. Well, obviously, right? Because that was his organic play. Yeah. So I think he learned. But I think he learned. I think he probably did cut 30. I believe he did. And he learned content from that. So I respect that a ton and I think that's a great way to do it. dude i just signed up for cut 30 nice i'm gonna learn it's awesome uh so yeah i mean good amount i know that you noticed this right away but like good amount of content yeah i was so surprised because like i think what's nice about highlighting this too is like boost coos is a newer company probably not at the scale of uh mars like they're definitely not at the scale of mars and elevate and like you could tell like there's 60 ads in this account not 600 right or 6 000 yeah i mean look apparently it's a really good product and i think i just i love to see the variety that he's got in the account um yeah i'd love this stage like it's like he's doing all the right things is there any partnership ads like did you see some whitelisting stuff or is that mostly i don't think i would see it there's some i don't know how much yeah oh there we go There's definitely some.

59:03Matt Bertulli: Like, that's, like, yep. Yeah. So it's not just, like, tribe creator style. So he's got some. And you could, yeah, with tribe, you can get whitelisting. So he's got some, which is great. Well, that's true. Yeah. Looks like he's going pretty big in the gluten-free. So, like, I would think about, and I think he's probably got enough customers' orders, but Barr, if you're listening, of, like, tips, right, like, to do. I would think about messaging and just, like, building several funnels around it, which would be how I would try to scale this. So, like, if I was to look in reviews and all that stuff, I'd imagine, like, gluten-free is probably one big angle.

59:33protein is probably another one. So that's another one. If you compare this, and I was consulting with an investor who was talking about a$20 million brand yesterday, the feedback I gave them and they were struggling to grow was like, everything is about the brand. It's just very precious about the brand. Everything but the ad is this percent off or it's like, this is the product. And I think maybe this here slightly more is about the product. and just go with the people and who they are. Struggling to hit your protein on a GLP-1, boom. That's probably going to be a funnel I would go with. Gluten-free, go to who the consumer is and not...

1:00:19That would be my thought. What do you think?

1:00:22Matt Bertulli: I would agree. I would agree. I think, though, to be fair to Barr, it's probably age and stage of company. you know like my guess is that like this ad account is growing his business is growing and that he will get there like he will absolutely like layer those things in because it is it's it's great advice for sure um i mean these consumable companies like these supply chains are hard to scale up like these for sure so i could see like how you sort of like you have to step these all businesses up you got to step up with supply chain and stage of business but i just think like the visual variety i love it it's like he's all over the place i do like this branding a lot yeah i do like oh yeah branding yeah yeah swap your rice not your cravings yeah no that would just be my my suggestions for like unlocking next phase of growth yep totally is there's probably a lot of like more problem focused angles i think more upper funnel problem focused angles um but yeah i mean i like these statics so they look ai generated but not in like a bad way at all like there's nope there's clear you know um no no honestly like Everything's going to be AI generated.

1:01:30Matt Bertulli: Yeah. But they're solid. So yeah, just with the messaging and understanding insights and then building landers. So it's all going to homepage right now. Oh, yeah. Let's look at that real quick. It's obviously a place to go test. Yeah. I believe it is. His homepage is very like... I mean, most great homepages are great landing pages. Right? Yeah. Yeah. It's solid. You know, you got clear what it is, showing what it is, you know, social proof, really good reviews. So like product seems great. Super skimmable, you know. So I think it's great. But yeah, I would just build some like listicles and just test different messaging around them.

1:02:08Yeah, no, it's very good. It's very good. Your execution can definitely be, my guess is a seven figure can definitely be a figure brand just with, you know, continuing to do what he's doing and just kind of getting that.

1:02:20Matt Bertulli: Yeah, I could almost see a world, Cody, where like see how each of these is like kosher, gluten-free, glyphosate-free, fiber protein. Each of these could be its own ad funnel, ad to Lander Gruent funnel, like vegan. Ads just for the vegans. That should be in here. This page is kind of taking care of all of them in one big bucket, but I would absolutely be testing, I'm going to build dedicated funnels and full funnel marketing for each of those benefits because they all speak to a different, not different customer, but like a different motivating reason to buy. Like if I'm vegan, that's like, that could be very strong reason for a vegan to buy this product.

1:03:01Yeah, my guess, if I was just spitball, so I'm sorry, I'd go with those. I'd go vegan, I'd go gluten-free, maybe kosher, I don't know. I'd go GLP and I would try kids. Oh yeah. Struggling to get your kids eating 14.

1:03:12Matt Bertulli: Those would probably be the top five I'd do. And I would just try to build some listicles and then, you know, UGC partnership around those. Awesome, man. Very cool. All right, dude. Did you have one more? Do you have a surprise one? You told me you had something that you wanted to show that was a little off the wall. We'll do one more. So let's do Whisperflow. So I wanted to share one. I was just like, hey, it would be cool if we shared one. It's not even consumer. That was not consumer. Well, because so and the reason why is, you know, the Hector for Whisperflow went viral having his like UGC playbook.

1:03:43Oh, yeah. And it was great. It was amazing. But a lot of people were like, hey, the, you know, these guys are very behind e-com, you know? And I don't know if I think so. I think there's a lot that we could learn from SaaS as well. But I think it's cool to show what they're doing well and what they maybe could improve upon. And everyone's going to say, oh, well, they have VC money and stuff like that.

1:04:05Matt Bertulli: The principles are still the same. Yeah, exactly. I was going to say, good marketing is good marketing. Who cares how it's funded? 1 ,900 ads for a freaking... Tons of ads. Wow. And they are going much heavier on meta than most, you know, like for their go-to-market compared to most SaaS. So they're going very heavy on that. Tons of content. So like tons of whitelisting, whether using Tribe or SideShift or something like that. Wow. The volume is mental, man. Like look at that. Tons of volume. And I want to see like the ads stuff. I think the thing that's important in any vertical is just like what are your messaging funnels?

1:04:46You know? Yes, you need your formats, but like what are your messaging funnels? And don't talk about the product, but figure out who are the avatars, you know? And like what are the funnels behind that? But yeah, good amount of partnership ads. I like that they even comment.

1:05:00Matt Bertulli: They got like comment funnels. So like comment this. Let's put like a mini chat flow. Interesting. Oh yeah. Yeah, because I would imagine in their conversion event as an app install would be my guess. Yep. Yep. I think this is the thing to call out, right? Is like, if you're in consumer, don't just study like brands in your space. So I find even that happens a lot. It's like, hey, I'm in supplements. I'm going to just study supplements and supplement funnels and flow. Like, no, like go look at how all, you should be studying all marketing. It doesn't matter what they're selling. Like if they're selling to an individual, which I mean, we're all selling individuals, even if the business is the buyer.

1:05:42Matt Bertulli: It's worth just studying those funnels because you're going to learn a ton from the breadth. Yeah, I completely agree. So I would say my biggest feedback is I want to get a little tighter with what are the funnels and messaging. You know how we were talking even on the Bootscoost page and we're like, oh, these could be the different ones? And you could see it on some of the other ones we're looking at. It's hard to tell. And I think you should be able to tell, and obviously Winx could do a way better job of this. I think you should be able to tell what is the messaging just by looking at like a quick static or looking at like, you know?

1:06:12And so you can't really tell. It's a little too much about the product. And then I think it's all going to like homepage. Maybe it's because it's going to like app install.

1:06:21Matt Bertulli: Yeah. Interesting one. Like I'd love to see like a listicle be done for SaaS. Like I never see that. No, you're right. That's sort of where like the end consumer, we have to pull all these damn levers because we have no margins. Maybe these guys can just do whatever the hell they want. I don't know. That's cool. I like the surprise, dude. Uh, very cool. All right. Let's, let's wrap it up. Um, I think that's the pod. I think if you've enjoyed this, you like the deep dives, you're that much of a nerd, uh, you know, like, and subscribe, we're going to try to do more of this on the build series, which is what you're listening to or watching right now.

1:06:56Matt Bertulli: And just like go behind the scenes of what it is to like build companies. Like that is Cody, like for me, that is just how I do it. I just look at ad libraries and I go go through and I click through and I'm just like kind of studying not for any other reason I'm just trying to pick up all the nuance those little details and that was like six pretty good brands with one surprise lots to learn from all six I think anything you want to wrap on before we uh we finish yeah that was a fun one for me yeah that was good I like the nerdy stuff all right that's the pot let's get out of here

From the publisher

“It’s very easy to scrape an ad library, pull out concepts and then literally just duplicate the ad. That’s just a race to the bottom.” 

How do you learn from other brands without copying them? 

Matt Bertulli (Founder, Pela Case & Lomi) and Cody Plofker (Advisor & fmr. CEO, Jones Road Beauty) share their screens to walk through six consumables brands they’re learning from while building Winks. Each picked three, plus one bonus from outside DTC. 

1. Nutrition Geeks: UK single-ingredient 

2. Norse Organics: Natural acne care 

3. Elavate: UK collagen for women 

4. MarsMen: Testosterone support 

5. Spoiled Child: Oddity’s brand 

6. Boostcous: Gluten-free couscous 

(Bonus) Wispr Flow: AI voice app 

Matt and Cody trace each brand’s ads, landers and offers, including why long pages still convert. Some brands force subscriptions, others offer a choice, and a few lead with one-time bundles. Meanwhile, Winks is testing a no-subscription bundle of its own. 

Powered By 

Aftersell 

https://9ops.co/aftersell-operators 

TBAR Partners 

https://9ops.co/tbarpartners 

Richpanel 

https://9ops.co/richpanel 

Motion 

https://9ops.co/motion-runneth 

Skio 

https://9ops.co/skio-9operators 

Omnisend 

https://9ops.co/omnisend 

Operators Portal 

https://portal.9operators.com/dashboard 

Operators Newsletter 

https://9operators.com/ 

More from Operators

All episodes