1. Podcasts
  2. Operators
  3. Our Ecommerce Marketing Strategy vs. Real Data: Operators Build (E8)
Operators

12 Oct 2026 · 57m · 19 chapters

Episode artwork

Our Ecommerce Marketing Strategy vs. Real Data: Operators Build (E8)

In short

Operators Build E8 is a six-week “marketing strategy vs real data” update for their DTC subscription brand Winks, focused on Meta ads, creative/messaging iteration, and building trust/social proof for a health product.

Guests

Curtis and Cody (Operators Build hosts). They discuss their backgrounds as “marketing operators” and DTC operators; they reference prior durable-goods brands they’ve built (e.g., Hexclad, Ridge, Simple Modern, Pila) and their audience reach (Cody has many Twitter followers; they note few moms listen).

Key claims

Their original persona (moms/kids, “four and above”) was wrong in practice: by week six, buyers are ~60/40 male/female, and they still get men from ads despite women-focused branding. They believe marketing is perception-driven, so they adjusted messaging around safety/science without over-claiming for kids. CPMs started extremely high (up to ~$800) and dropped to ~$55 after trust signals like business manager verification; creative/social proof and whitelisting are major levers. They’re testing offers/landers/messaging and investing in creator content (Tribe/Discord).

Notable examples

Versioned website (v7 in six weeks), shifting from heavy AI to more creator/whitelisting, seeding ~50 products for ~10 reviews at launch, doctor credibility plans (science advisory council/CME-style roles), and budget changes on Meta (about $1k/day down to ~$600, then ~$250).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Initial Marketing Strategy and Audience Insights

Discussion on the initial marketing strategy, targeted demographics, and surprising audience insights.

“So maybe to start us off, Curtis, remind everybody who we made the product for.”
8:52

Creative Strategy and Development

Exploration of the creative approach, including AI usage, content creation, and the evolution of their marketing assets.

“Yeah, I think it's a very raw way to launch.”
14:01

Building Initial Content and Social Proof

Learn about the early challenges faced in creating content and establishing social proof for a new product.

“But day one, it wasn't a half a million dollar launch.”
16:41

Leveraging Doctor Credibility and Branding

Discover the importance of doctor endorsements and effective branding strategies for health products.

“You know, originally we were marketing to, as mentioned, marketing to women and kids.”
19:26

Adjusting Marketing Strategies for Growth

Explore marketing adaptations made after launch, focusing on customer acquisition costs and optimization.

“So going forward, I think you should say, I think we can say you should expect to see a heavier lean towards the science behind the product.”
22:25

Testing and Iteration for Market Fit

Understand the ongoing testing and iteration process for achieving product-market fit in a new brand.

“And so there's not going to be a lot of signal.”
28:01

Improving Content Through Creator Partnerships

Learn how investing in creators and product seeding can enhance brand performance.

“a lot of time with like our tribe creators.”
29:31

Layering Credibility with Influencers

Discover the importance of integrating credible voices and a scientific advisory council in marketing.

“Like when you think just go to market marketing, what's biggest focus?”
31:20

Navigating Marketing Strategies and Equity

Understand the balance of spending on marketing while maintaining equity for creators.

“I'm sure we'll give you like more of that in the future on where we land with some of these deals.”
36:33

Building a Business with Intentional Growth

Learn the significance of gradual growth and understanding customer feedback in business.

“can navigate we didn't waste a lot of money also guys like i think i've said this to you guys many times but one half of this equation is how do we acquire customers at a at a number and a rate and Is it scalable?”
Show all 19 chapters
37:56

Building a Business with Intentional Growth

Learn the significance of gradual growth and understanding customer feedback in business.

“Their AI builds your support team for you and everything it needs.”
38:19

Learning Through Experience in E-commerce

Explore the lessons learned from starting a brand and the evolving skill sets involved.

“Okay, Cody, any predictions for the next six weeks with CPMs and CAC?”
42:01

The Shift in Marketing Approaches

Learn how starting a new venture changes marketing strategies and skills needed.

“But it's a completely different skill set.”
44:13

Utilizing AI in Ad Management

Discover how AI tools streamline advertising processes and improve efficiency.

“I kind of wanted to suffer a bit, and I wanted to see what it was like to start again.”
45:29

Navigating Feedback and Criticism

Understand the importance of feedback in marketing and how to handle criticism.

“So it's actually been good for me because I definitely don't have the thickest skin and like sometimes I'd send you something that people said and you'd like laugh it off and I'm like, I need a little bit more.”
47:06

The Importance of Clear Communication

Explore how effective communication impacts customer experience and retention.

“I'm like, oh my God, we have to like do a much better, more clear job of telling people how to use the thing that we're selling them.”
48:20

Launching a New Brand: Key Takeaways

Learn essential strategies for launching a new brand effectively and affordably.

“Like there's no customers to retain, right?”
53:45

Reflections on Early Brand Building

Gain insights on the lessons learned from building a brand in real-time.

“I would have like, you know, put, put a bit of cash, a little equity on the table.”
56:00

Discussing Marketing Strategies and Future Directions

The hosts reflect on their current marketing performance and future strategies.

A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Operators, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Matt Bertulli: All right, welcome back to Operators Build episode eight. Today I got Curtis, I got Cody. We're going to be talking about all things marketing, growth, whatever the hell we're calling it, these days in DTC. We're going to walk you, listener, watcher, whatever you are, through our original sort of plan and thesis around how we thought we would go to market with the brand. We're about six weeks in when we're recording this episode, so you're going to get like the current six-week update. What have we learned? Where were we right? Where were we wrong? What have we adjusted? And we're going to try to give you as much detail as possible today so that you can kind of see how we've been changing.

0:37Matt Bertulli: Like, I think for the first three weeks, we were probably changing almost every day based on real time feedback, data, everything. Cody and I were just like publishing every day. So maybe to start us off, Curtis, remind everybody who we made the product for. Maybe just like bring us back, catch people up. We made this product for which customer segment? Who are we targeting? Yeah, I mean, our original thesis was that we were going to target towards moms and kids. Like mom is the buyer in the household. We felt like she controlled obviously the kids routine. We got a little furry bedtime bestie on the packaging.

1:14And we just thought, you know, if the mom's making the decision and she's the one that's more health oriented in the family and we could provide and create a high quality formula for the family for evening hygiene. that she would be the right person to market and target. We created a formula that's actually healthy for everyone, but we can't market to that. And so you can't, you know, you can't market to, you know, a two-year-old. So we said four and above.

1:42Matt Bertulli: We, obviously we have a profile. People know who we are. Operators podcast, marketing operators. Cody's got a lot of followers on Twitter. So when we announced the brand, we did not get moms. Cody does not have a lot of moms that follow him or Sean or myself. We tend to not have moms listening to this podcast. I don't know if you knew this, but what happened, Cody? Who started buying Winks? Yeah, obviously. So Matt sent an email to his newsletter. I sent an email to my newsletter. So there's a lot of Econ bros. A lot of DTC bros. A lot of Econ bros. And that was obviously first day, but what's been really interesting at six weeks is like, we're 60-40, male versus female, which was like, nobody would have guessed that at all, right?

2:29We thought we'd probably be like 90, 10 the other way. And so I think it'll be very interesting for us and we're talking about it now. It's like, does that hold? Was that just our initial audience? Also, like, did we screw up our Pixel? Like Sean and Connor - Dude, that's such a good question. Yeah, because like Sean and Connor didn't launch their brand publicly because I think partly they were worried about the Pixel stuff and I don't know, maybe. So that's been a huge, just like unknown that we didn't expect to happen.

2:55Matt Bertulli: Yeah, it's funny. I was a little worried. I had a moment of like, dude, I have this like productive paranoia. I just sort of scenario map out everything that can go wrong. And I was a little worried that our audience was going to screw us up a bit. Not the pixel, but what I was worried about is we would listen to the DTC bros too much. You know, it's sort of like the classic, you should listen to your customers' problems, but never their solutions. And obviously when you build in public, you're going to get a lot of people saying, you should do this, you should not do this. And there was, there's no shortage of that.

3:27Matt Bertulli: We've posted videos about that. Everybody likes to think they're freaking genius from behind the screen. And what you said is actually, I think is a valid question. I don't know if it's bearing true, right? Because like, I don't know if there's enough volume, but the surprising thing to me guys was it's still holding true that like we are getting dudes by the product from our ads and our ads don't ever really speak to a dude. Like outside of, I think, maybe founder ads that I'm in. It's all women. Like the site is all women. The language, the Landers are all about perimenopause. And like it's about 3 a.m.

4:08Matt Bertulli: wake up. And like everything has been written for women. I mean, look at the colors too. Yeah. Yeah, man. Like the brand was built for women and we're still getting guys. I don't know what this says. of the three people in the household, mom, kid, dad, we were wrong on two. We were essentially, we picked the two that it wasn't. And then it wasn't. So yeah, we got feedback again, pretty, pretty public feedback. And, you know, it was good feedback day one. You know, you shouldn't be giving these ingredients to kids was essentially a nice way of saying it, you know? And I think we decided like, all right, cool.

4:47Like we can stand by it. We can push back. Like we clearly, you guys, you know, vetted it.

4:52Matt Bertulli: Oh yeah, the science says we can, but like, I think enough smart people around us are like, it's iffy. I just think as soon as you get like smart, we had really smart people around us basically say like, yeah, you're, it's probably fine. But like, there are people who would believe that you shouldn't. And as good marketers, we should be more concerned with perception than reality. Like, that's kind of how I look at it. I don't know if you guys disagree with that. But like, whatever is actually factually true in the world tends to not matter to marketing. Yeah. Everything is perception. What we know about the formula is that it's actually safe for anybody, but there's not extensive clinical studies for kids.

5:33So whether or not, if someone has an opinion, I think what you were going to say, Matt, is that if someone has an opinion and that's their perception, then we have to listen to that. No matter what the facts say, no matter what clinical studies say. I mean, this is doctor formulated. Like, you know, we have someone that has actually formulated, you know, hundreds of products and we know that, you know, from an efficacy perspective, it's high quality and it is safe. We just don't, you know, we don't want to play that gray area.

6:01Matt Bertulli: Well, I guess also, Cody, something else that we got feedback on, which I think is really good feedback, is just focus on one customer. like build around one persona one avatar like have a thesis focus on that thesis which is what we've been doing and yes we i disagree that we got them all wrong i think we are we are mostly getting women by the product like mostly but every now and again i see a freaking dude like this morning i'm like oh there's a jonathan i'm like not a woman um came in from an ad right uh so it's still, it is still happening. I don't know why. I don't actually know if I care.

6:42Matt Bertulli: That might be another thing. Like I don't right now, I don't know if I care right now. It's like, we're still at this stage where we're trying to drive acquisition costs down. Um, so maybe let's do this, Cody, uh, let's go right back to, we're six weeks into launch, go back to like launch when we started, which channels did we start with? Just so people know, have context on like, How did we launch the brand, go to market? Where are we focusing our time and money? So I'll say outside of like our operators, our networks, which we did launch and it did obviously bring in initial customers, it's been primarily paid acquisition meta focus.

7:23So we are not on Amazon currently. We're not on TikTok shop, although we are planning to get on there. I mean, we have an Instagram, but it's just, we haven't really even prioritized that. You know, so it's really meta. It's really that. And I think our pick is A, like if we had more time and maybe resources, maybe we have them, but time, like we probably would have gone and I would have wanted to do a little more of like an organic focus, a creator seating focus. But we launched just directly on Meta pretty much.

7:53Matt Bertulli: This episode is brought to you by our friends at Aftersell. Let me start by saying there is something that all of the best operators have figured out. And that is a new customer is expensive as hell to acquire. so every extra dollar you can get out of that new customer, well, that's just basically free money. Ridge uses AfterSell, Simple Modern uses AfterSell, Jones Road uses AfterSell, Pila uses it, upsells, downsells in the cart, checkout after purchase, plus rocked, so at the moments, right after someone buys, make you money instead of doing nothing. Same traffic, more revenue, sounds kind of obvious.

8:24Matt Bertulli: We're building winks right now, that's why you're listening to this show, and AfterSell went into the stack on day one, not a bolt-on for later when we decided we wanted to finally get smarter. Look, Black Friday is coming. You know it, I know it. Your traffic's gonna go up. Your ad costs go up even more. Every single visit is worth more than it was last month. You do it right. So don't just spend more to buy more customers. Make every visitor worth more. That's why we partnered with Aftersell. Yeah, I think it's a very raw way to launch. It's also how a lot of people do things. So I think it's pretty relatable, right?

8:59Matt Bertulli: Is like, you've got this great ad platform out there. all we we don't shut up about it on our own shows what i have found fun is is trying to like just do a paid like a paid focus for a period of time right when it comes to paid cody what did we start with for creative and then where are we at today yeah when we started so even on our site it was it was very heavy ai we're like we're gonna lean on ai as much as possible you know ai images and stuff i got quick quickly got feedback like you're lacking trust signals you know so which is we're probably on we're on six weeks we're probably on like v7 of our website and i think it's getting better and better um with creative with messaging copy etc everything um but we we were heavy ai you know we were working with an agency at the time now we're not but it was very heavy ai um we didn't have any we just didn't have time to get any creator content in our account we didn't have any founder videos so it wasn't even that many videos so it was you know on x i rated us a D minus, I think.

10:01And that's like feedback for myself. That's not for like anybody else. And now we've obviously, we're heavily creator content on Tribe. We have whitelisting ads. So I think in hindsight, like if we want to do this, like what did we do and what did we want to do in the future? Like I probably would have loved to get some of this other stuff from the beginning. Like we should have launched with founder ads. We should have launched with whitelisting. It was just a time thing. But definitely we're going in that direction and we're still doing AI stuff, but it's different. We were doing some animated stuff.

10:29We were doing a lot of AI statics.

10:32Matt Bertulli: Yeah, Sean made us a weird cracked out looking owl. Whatever that thing was. You remember that one, Curtis? I was like, what are you doing, Sean? You're here to scare people is what we are. Yeah, I think I would agree. I think where we are today feels a little more like how you'd probably want to come out to the world. Now, I think if we're being honest, it is hard to start there though. Like in our case, we could have because we had cash, right? And like creators, tribe, all this stuff costs money, right? So we had cash. We could have started there. I like that we started more raw and a little more basic.

11:17Matt Bertulli: Again, because I think most people start there. Like that is true. the founder ad thing uh just to like riff on that a bit one of the reasons that i don't think we did that at the beginning was because of who we thought the customer was yeah right like i experienced this with uh with pila not so much lomi with lomi i was very much like founder ad heavy and that's kind of what carried the business for the first two years um with pila it's like i sell the 22 two-year-old girls. Founder ads were terrible for that brand. If I'm going to go after women and moms, then I'm probably not the best face for this.

11:56Matt Bertulli: And maybe Curtis isn't either. Although I think now that we're learning, like, no, you can totally do it. It's like, just tell your story and do the founder ad thing. Can you just give us a timescale, Cody? How quickly did we start layering in real human faces, real human creators, like all that stuff? So we started out pretty raw, pretty AI. How fast did you get that going? We should just clear this up for the listeners. I think we wanted to challenge ourselves. I know we've said publicly that we're putting in 500K into this. We did not, for people listening, by any means put in 500K into launch.

12:27We obviously, yeah, I think we put 75K into inventory. That's the biggest one. We did the website ourselves. We might've had a designer do the brand and stuff. We did ads ourselves. We're very much trying to bootstrap it and see what we can do. I just want to make that very clear.

12:45Matt Bertulli: You have been listening to us talk for years about building nine-figure durable goods brands, Hexclad, Ridge, Simple Modern, Pila. When we sat down to build Winks, there was never a question it had to be a subscription brand. And being the veterans we are, we could work with anyone, but we decided to work with Skio to build Winks. Working with the team over at Skio has been awesome. We get to see all of the stuff that the fastest growing CPG brands are actually doing to acquire more subscribers and keep them longer. My favorite example of this has been incentivizing new customers to go from a monthly subscription to a quarterly subscription right after their first purchase, but before they get their first order.

13:24Matt Bertulli: The team at Skio has been sharing insights on how much in-portal flexibility to give subscribers, when to change frequency, when to offer product swaps, when to do gifting, what rewards should look like, what is cancel flow optimization. The list is freaking endless and they have shared it all. They have been incredible to work with. They are bringing so much value to this partnership. It almost feels a little unfair. If you run a subscription brand, you should be talking with the team over at Skio. They know their stuff. Yeah, the$500 ,000 was like, this is the budget we're giving ourselves to find product market fit over some period of time.

13:58Matt Bertulli: So that's the commitment we have to invest in the company. But day one, it wasn't a half a million dollar launch. Give me a break. We would have looked a lot better people if it was that like come on you know we started with i think i had like two to three creators so kind of your typical like ugc creators um because we did want some real content um you know i think the content was okay like not amazing right it wasn't the best brief like we like we're starting from zero so we didn't have a pool and a network of creators we hadn't gotten our our tribe community launched at the time um so we got okay content you know we also my thought was like let's get an asset bank so we did a shoot we did a soon a shoot and then we did one other agency but i think the thought process was let's get just an initial asset bank like let's start building an asset library that of stuff that we can use modulally in ads emails you know um there and so we have you know some images of people holding the product smiling and stuff like that so like we do have a little bit we're still using a lot of ai stuff and i think Like we, and a lot more of the mascots.

15:01And as we were getting feedback, we kind of quickly pivoted. We're still in need of more of real assets. Like that's the goal now. Just like social proof is like such a big, important one. And like, it's so hard to build. Well, yeah, we're selling something

15:14Matt Bertulli: that people like literally take, like they put it in themselves. So I think trust is massive. And if you look at the brands that are doing well, right? Like you look like a Marsman or something like that, just like a primal queen, just like stacks and stacks of social proof. hundreds of thousands of reviews. You have before and afters. You have written testimonials. So we did. I think we seeded like 50 products and got in probably like 10 reviews at launch. But it's just like more and more of that. And it's hard to do from the beginning. I don't know how other people are launching with it. So I'd say like at launch, we probably had like two UGC creators.

15:50I think it immediately became the big focus within like the first two weeks of launch. And so it takes time to obviously find the creators see products, you know, give them brief. So I'd say we probably didn't have a lot coming in until like four weeks, maybe three weeks. And now it has just hit it. We're like, we probably have too much content relative to how much we're spending right now. Like, I think I have 60, you know, I've been a little sick, but I think I have like 60 tribe videos to go through right now. Dude, I was looking at them last night.

16:16Matt Bertulli: I'm like, there are so many. Curtis, maybe on the social proof thing, can you, just for listeners, unpack our thinking around the science side. So like doctors, health and wellness creators, like what is going to be our approach there? Because I think that is like both where we're at today, six weeks in, and kind of a bit of a prediction and a forecasting forward. You know, originally we were marketing to, as mentioned, marketing to women and kids. We had this friendly brand with our bedtime bestie, but it was important for us to have something, you know, suggesting that it was doctor formulated, you know, that we had people in the back that could create, you know, strong, a strong formula that had strong efficacy with ingredients that were actually trademarked and had, you know, some, some really good, you know, clinical studies behind it.

17:10And what we realized, I think quickly, you know, I think Matt and Cody, you guys would agree that we launched a brand for women with five dudes with no doctor face, you know, and really no strong credibility. And so, you know, doctor formulated on the packaging is not enough. I'll just say that, you know, and I think also what we saw is that we didn't lean into the quality of our ingredients, like our landing pages, our website, we have all these, we spent money finding and curating and paying for trademarked ingredients that had extensive clinical studies that were premium ingredients, yet our branding is friendly.

17:55And we have doctor formulated and there's not the doctors, any doctor that comes across our formula are impressed by it. And they love the taste. The credibility is good. The ingredients are great, but we don't have a voice around that. We do have Dr. Todd Bourne, you know, been phenomenal, but he's not known. When we launched, we didn't have even videos from Todd. Like, you know, so when we don't have videos from any of our doctors or anybody that actually, you know, put time, energy or approved the formula that we created, then what we did is we launched with, you know, a friendly brand with premium ingredients to moms from five dudes.

18:37I'm getting back into the weeds. One of the things I'm probably the rustiest on is email. I'm super excited to be using OmniSend. They're using them on Winx. We're AI-pilled. We are using it to do everything. I'm running most of our email program from Claude and Codex using the MCP, and it's awesome. We also have email, SMS, and pop-ups all in one place. We have all of our flows, welcome series. It's all talking to each other. I love the platform. The analytics are really good. I highly recommend it, especially if you're in the position that Winx is in. new brand starting out. But if you're on a different platform and you're paying too much and you want to switch, they will do the migration completely for you.

19:12No lost data, no lost list. It takes only five days start to finish. And they are giving our listeners 30 % off the first three months. Go to omnisend.com slash nine operators to try it out for yourself. Right.

19:26Matt Bertulli: So going forward, I think you should say, I think we can say you should expect to see a heavier lean towards the science behind the product. including a science advisory council, probably a chief science, chief medical officer, all of these things that like we know the product supports, right? Because we have actually done the work, but we didn't put in front of the brand yet. But I think that it's safe to say that that is coming. And I would say that, you know, doctors, well-known doctors and physicians in the space. And we're talking about, you know, some of the faces of other brands have tried our product and, and not only love the taste of it, but also like 100 % in line with actually the formula that's been created.

20:16But we just don't. Yeah.

20:16Matt Bertulli: That's actually been fun. That's been fun to get feedback from all these like really high profile, uh, doctors and be like, yeah, the product's great guys. Oh, well that's good.

20:28Matt Bertulli: that's reassuring. Cody, why don't you like put effort into like, I don't know, SEO, AEO, like at the start, is that just a waste of time? Like, I mean, I had somebody ask me this the other day, you guys don't run any Google ads. I'm like, nope, sure don't. Why? So in the Google ad side, yeah, I mean, we talked about it, right? It would only be like demand, you know, capture resources, which is either time or money. You do all of it. I think you just have to pick trade-offs and at the stage of the game, we're, you know, it's you and I, right? And so it's just like, there's only so much, and this is also not our full-time thing.

21:04So there's just only so much that you can do. I don't know the first thing about SEO or AEO, you know? So yeah, it's probably worth investing in and, you know, maybe have an errand do a little bit for us if you're listening. But I think that, you know, we'll pull some strings there. if like I think we should you know I don't think that it would be worth spending a ton of money on but like I think so like you know I also want to get us you know like I'm not the biggest PR fan normally but like I actually think it's worth you know getting featured in some publications for logos and some credibility it's just are we going to spend 20 grand a month on a PR firm like no that doesn't make sense so yeah I think it's a resources thing and as we have either more money or more time as the business grows like we'll use some of that cash to invest in these other things I think it's just like minimum viable.

21:53Matt Bertulli: I'm a big believer that we should just pick a channel and get very good at that channel. Totally agree. With the brand that we have. So like there's lots of ways to go to market. You know, like we know that a lot of people are crushing it on TikTok shops. We know that. There are a lot of our friends. Like we talk to them. It's like, we get it. That's a great play. Like that's a great play. But that's not what we're native great at. We know how to run ads. This is a playbook. There's a series of playbooks that we know very, very well. so that's just where we went right wrong or indifferent like i don't i don't care it's just focus so i'm with you there um let's talk about uh six weeks in what have we seen from uh let's let's talk about like the cpm and cac journey cody where did we start maybe go through that first week because i think i was laughing my ass off at how expensive cpms were so sean got that part right yeah he was like cpms are going to be hilariously high um and then how you don't need to give the exact uh acquisition cost but like how far how far down have you gotten them yeah so sean thought we'd be at like an 800 cac after month one you know sean was like he had just done this with his brand right like he had just been through it i probably should have listened more i was like super arrogant and naive and i was like no we'll be at like a hundred dollars by end of month one you know um you know and so we ended up somewhere there i'll say closer to my end closer to far closer to you than we are sean yeah um but yeah our cpms were probably like 300 bucks when we launched and then you know we got them down 250 whatever and everyone just says like you just have to spend through it so my my my theory you know talking to people talking about it like there's just a tax you pay for you know you're you're losing the auction a like you're not going to have purchases, you're not going to have good purchases.

23:44And so there's not going to be a lot of signal. And, you know, meta is making a probabilistic bet anytime it's going to, you know, show an ad in the auction. And it's not going to bet on somebody that doesn't have any, you know, proof, credibility, any, any signal, right. And so that's the theory. And, you know, based on how, how the algorithm works. One thing that I think helped the most is one day we woke up and our CPMs were just like a third of what they were. The only thing we did differently is we verified our business manager, which is like the simplest thing in the world.

24:12Matt Bertulli: Which is freaking crazy that that happened. Yeah, and that we didn't do it. And that like, that was the only thing. Again, it's just a trust signal to Meta. Because like 30 % of Meta revenue, I don't know if you guys have heard this, is fraud, right? Like, so yeah, it's like a ridiculous amount. And I heard Jamie Dimon talk one time and he was like giving them crap. Like it's a ridiculous amount, and especially with AI. So I think they're just like very, they're like, hey, prove to us you're a real business. proved to us that, you know, we can trust you. So like, A, doing things like, there's so many like tinfoil theories.

24:44Like, I know somebody said we should like lower our credit card threshold. That way we have more successful payments go through. Like all of these things. Oh yeah, I remember that. Yep. So again, I don't know all of them. It's interesting. The only people I have talked to that have not had CPM issues were, or like if you guys know Bar from Booscoos, he's got like a brand that's gone pretty well from. He was taking organic social very seriously from the beginning. And so I believe that that is a huge one that we haven't done yet. And now we're starting to. We're working with Isaac and going to start getting video in.

25:19But I think just like proving to Meta you're a real brand, I think influencer seeding would be really helpful to get people tagging our Instagram accounts. And now we're starting to do that. Whitelisting is probably one of the bigger ones that people have said. And that makes sense because you're getting signal from the other creators. So again, I probably would have started with that. I know Jordan Menard said we probably should have. But I think just trying to do all these things. So six weeks later, we're probably at like a$55 CPM. For people just listening, it did go as high as$800.

25:50Matt Bertulli: Like in the first four or five days, we saw it. It started off at like$150. And I think by day four, it was at like$800. Like it just, it went in the very wrong direction. Yeah. Somebody else, so Brian from, you know, formerly a true classic had the theory that like, we're getting penalized for like supplement claims and so he had the idea to to move any mention of winks in the product to like the third or fourth page in the funnel um right so it did that i don't know work did that combine with like native ads and that brought cpm really low because that was like 10 click through rate like 50 cent clicks i don't know what impact that had on the rest of the account but that those campaigns were at least really cheap because like jones we were probably like$35 CPMs is probably our average.

26:36I forget. It's been a minute.

26:37Matt Bertulli: Yeah, dude, it's category specific, right? Like I think PILA was around 15 bucks, 20 bucks, but click-through rates are really low. I've seen. CPG supplements, like these tend to be higher CPM categories. They're very competitive. You know, it just is what it is. Like I run, I've got ad accounts guys that are in SaaS and CPMs are like in the hundreds for SaaS. So it really is category dependent. And I'm sure that that's not true for all SaaS. So that's actually a good overview, Cody. So maybe for people listening, Curtis, for both you and Cody, the next six weeks, what are we most focused on with the brand when it comes to like marketing, growth marketing, like how we're going to market?

27:23Let's say we're somewhere like 150. Like I want to get down to 100, you know, it's where we need to be. I think it's it's continued testing right of offers so we probably had two to three offers and we'll continue to test offers obviously landers I think we could put more focus there and then creative is the big one and it's just messaging but I think we need to make sure we're just like testing the messaging as much as possible and figuring out what works we're still in that phase of we'll call it pre-product market fit where we just like don't know what our winning angles are yet we have some directional signals, but we just have to continue to test, you know, into them.

28:00We've been spending a lot of time with like our tribe creators. We have them in a discord where, you know, doing a weekly call and we're definitely seeing the content get better and better. So I just think investing in, you know, in that and coaching them more partnership as, and just, I think that's it until we just see signs of life and continue to just iterate and tweak on what we're finding. Because we still just don't know, is it, is it perimenopause? Is it anti-melatonin? Is it, what fat loss like there's a bunch of different ways we can take it we just we just need one for

28:30Matt Bertulli: now yeah agreed and i think the you mentioned the product seeding piece i'm actually a big fan of that uh like that was actually a meaningful improvement um i'll call it strategy that we did at pila like maybe a couple years ago and roman kind of told us this he's like you guys just need to do way more seeding so we started doing like thousands a month right like just like gift out thousands of products a month. And magically our ad account just got better and better and better, right? Like it just, I think what you're hitting on for people listening is just, it's like digital surface area and signal surface area.

29:06Matt Bertulli: So like you just need to have the brand in more places that these AI algorithmic platforms like Meta and Google and whatever, they all, they look at everything, right? I think the more surface area you have, the better the brand is going to perform. Um, so I think that's like, like a just broad bucket. Everything that we're talking about is like create more trust surface area. Curtis, for you, where are you spending your time now for the next six weeks? Like when you think just go to market marketing, what's biggest focus? Yeah. You know, I think the big thing that we need to do is, is layer on credible voices, you know, and known names within the, within the space, you know, and, and there's some, it's not just having an MD behind your name, you know, but Ashley, good quality whitelisters, you know, people with following, people that have credibility in the space and a voice.

29:59So a lot of our time and energy is going to be focused on how do we layer that in just, you know, outside of just basic creators, you know, and, and, you know, we are, we're looking at building a more scientific advisory council. Let's call it a chief medical officer title, experienced, qualified, you know, and certified physicians, doctors, and voices to just round out the credibility of the product.

30:25Matt Bertulli: Subscription brands, I am talking to you. You obsess over churn, but you only know your subscribers by skew, by cadence, and the real cancellation risk, it lies in the actual humans behind that data. Outer signal enriches your existing customer data, the existing Shopify list, and it turns it into real identifiable people and personas. We are talking demographics, lifestyle, who's a VIP, who's a creator, who is buying for a business. All of these persona attributes then get pushed into your favorite email platform so that your retention and win back flows can speak to a segment, a specific small group of people instead of everybody on a 30-day plan.

31:03Matt Bertulli: There's a native Shopify install. It's set up in minutes. Get your free persona report on your customer data. When you sign up, go to outerSignal.com slash operators. Tell them we sent you. I promise it'll help. yeah i think it's worthwhile too and for people listening the way that we're thinking of this is like we are prepared to use equity and cash uh as needed to like secure the right partnerships like my view is uh when you're small nothing company equity don't don't be like stingy with equity like if you can get really high credible creators influencers in our case like looking at doctors who have credibility, that's worth some equity, right?

31:45Matt Bertulli: How much? Massively debated topic. I'm sure we'll give you like more of that in the future on where we land with some of these deals. But, you know, some of the biggest brands in the world that you know, all gave up equity to get the right faces in front of their companies. So it's pretty common. It's just not talked about as much. So I wanted to at least mention that. Okay, Cody, how much money did we start out spending on Facebook? Like day one, what was our budget? And what have you done since then with budget? Knowing that we spent it all on Facebook. We were spending about a thousand a day.

32:23Yep. You know, from the beginning, six weeks later, we're probably spending like 600 a day right now. We brought it down to 250 one day. I think we just had the thought that we're like, hey, I think we're telling Meta that we are willing to spend more per customer than we really are. And let's pull that down. and performance significantly improved when we did that.

32:44Matt Bertulli: It was actually hilarious. Like when you cut the budget that day, I was like, it's like the next day, it's more purchases at lower CPAs. Yeah. You know, it dude, I don't know. I'm having so much fun going from like zero. Like all we do is eat every day. It's definitely the hardest part. It's so hard, but it's fun to see like the process again of like getting going and going from zero. like the last time I was like from zero was probably Pila. Like that was nine years ago, eight years ago, you know? And things have changed. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Clicks were 15 cents in 2017. Oh my God. Well, that's the thing is it's so different.

33:28It's so different, right? I've never ran a tribe community before or stuff like that. So it's like, it's not just about meta. Like we know how to structure a meta ad account or some would say we do, but it's like that doesn't really matter that much. and it's all of these other variables. So yeah, it's definitely fun and like learning it and like coaching creators, briefing them, things like that. Like definitely having fun with like creative strategy.

33:50Matt Bertulli: Yeah, I would say like, I think that that's the, the thing that we have to get better at right now is just the creative strategy piece. I would say from a, like how are we allocating capital? That's about the place, like that's probably the place that I am most willing to spend money is just quality human, creators and faces and then better creative strategy. If anything that's in that wheelhouse of activity is where we're allocating all of our dollars. That's the reason that we're doing our own website work. We use all of our freaking AI tools and trinkets to build emails and just do everything.

34:35Matt Bertulli: Rich panel for customer service. We're trying to clear all of our time and all of our money to go into marketing. And marketing right now is like straight up creative strategy. It's message, customer, format, landers, all that good stuff. So I think that is like for people listening, that's kind of all it is at the beginning. You don't have much else. I don't even give a shit about financials right now. I just don't. It's easy to watch the cash coming in and out. That's basically how you start a business, just cash accounting. I think it's also important to note that when we had this idea to build out loud, we didn't want to, you know, have this massive launch and do everything and anything.

35:18Like that's not achievable for most people that wanted to, you know, start a brand or, you know, seed a product. Like there's no wrong or right way to do it. Like we could look back, you can connect the dots looking back and you could say, hey, we wish we had more, you know, credible people, whitelisters, you know, have a stronger launch, you name it. But the way we've done it is that we accelerated a lot of our learnings because of the audiences that we all had. Number one, that's to our advantage. But number two, we also didn't want to go and spend 500 grand, you know, day one, you know, A, we think it would probably be a waste of money.

35:54But B, you know, it wouldn't be achievable for, you know, anybody, any audience that want to launch their own brand. So it'd be like the least relatable thing we could do. You know, when we're talking about that, we're, you know, reducing our spend, you know, significantly on meta. I mean, those are achievable numbers for a lot of people. There are a lot of it's it's relatable when you launch a brand. And so, you know, the advantage that, you know, looking back, I think we could all say, yeah, we wish we did X, Y and Z. but on the flip side we didn't do a b and c like we we didn't do everything you know and we got we've got a lot of learnings in the first six weeks because we did less up front um and we can navigate we didn't waste a lot of money also guys like i think i've said this to you guys many

36:38Matt Bertulli: times but one half of this equation is how do we acquire customers at a at a number and a rate and Is it scalable? Like all those things. Like that is one half of the equation. The other reason we're not going gangbusters and trying to like do big splashy anything is we need to see how cohorts mature. We need to see how people like the product. We need to know if we need to iterate on the product. Like that's the other half of the business, right? Is like, we know we have a quality product, but do we have a product that people like and will they use it? And what's that feedback piece? So before we start scaling up and spending more money and going for the big headlines and the big screenshots and all that that all the kids love and egos love.

37:23Matt Bertulli: Let's make sure we actually have a good business, right? So like, let's do the prudent thing and like just build more slowly and more intentionally. Most AI tools right now are all promise and no delivery. You know exactly what I am talking about. Super fancy launch videos. This is why I'm loving what Rich Panel is doing. They have AI and support smashed together, made it practical, made it useful. made it valuable to brands today, not on some future promise. And instead of asking you to spend weeks writing prompts and uploading help docs and babysitting, they flipped the whole script. Their AI builds your support team for you and everything it needs.

37:59Matt Bertulli: I've watched it. It works. It's freaking amazing. Richpanel even guarantees 50 % of your support volume will be automated by AI within 30 days or your money back. I call that a no-brainer offer. If you are interested, go to richpanel.com slash demo, not for some generic demo, but to actually book a call and watch them build your actual support team. Okay, Cody, any predictions for the next six weeks with CPMs and CAC? Do you have a target? Let me ask you that. Do you have a one-day new customer ROAS that you're going for? You know, we got to get down to 100. Like, I think ideally... We're close.

38:40Yeah, we got to get down to 100. I think ideally we settle at 75, but like we can start spending more at 100. My thought process, we kind of lowered prices, more aggressive offer to get more volume. Once we get down to 100, then it's like, all right, how do we do some financial engineering? Let's really focus on some post-purchase upsells. Let's focus on some offers. Like how do we get that AOV up where now we can actually hit our target? You know, I mean, listen, if we could ever get to a one, that would be great. I don't know that we will. Like, is this a business? Oh, I think we will. Okay.

39:15I'll make that prediction.

39:16Matt Bertulli: I think we get to a one day and zero ass of one. I don't think we stay there for long though. Like, I think that scale whittles that away. Fair. Right. That's fair. I think that's the goal. Yeah. Let's get to a one. Let's get to like a$75 cap. We can get AOV to that. I think it's like at one, I would be like, all right, Cody, gloves off. Like, let's go. Let's see how far we can push it and how quickly. like there's just for people listening like there's a lot there's a reason why i just believe that consumer operators are the best operators in the world it's like there's so many freaking little things that we have to worry about in these businesses and we have no competitive advantages like margins suck in consumer you got real supply chains we have actual cogs all that stuff has to be managed for growth can i ask you guys cody this is maybe more for you because curtis you you're not getting as much crap as cody does on twitter uh has there been a advice or feedback that you got that we tried that turned out to be really bad?

40:16Matt Bertulli: Or has there been advice or feedback you're like, that is awful. We're not doing that. I actually think it's been really good feedback. It's just, it's just been mean, but it's been good.

40:30Like, like, like Barry hot being like, I'm disappointed. I'm like, dude, like trying like i forgot about that and i'm like i'm like we're doing our but maybe not our best but i'm like i'm trying but like you don't want to say you're disappointed that we didn't get these science pages up like yeah i know it's just like we also forgot some things which again it's we're

40:50Matt Bertulli: doing a lot brands hard companies to start physical goods software there is a weird amount of activity like the amount of stuff that you have to do to get these things going again this is the thing i'm really enjoying is like how much stuff we actually have to do just to like make the business work and things just get dropped and forgotten. Like there was a bunch of things in email I forgot. Yeah. Last night we had a CX and, you know, Skiyo integration issue. Like there's just things like that that happen all the time. I also think people are like coming at us or me with the perspective of like, oh, these guys think they know it all.

41:29Like these guys, like I've seen some people quote we were like oh this is supposed to be like the like the e-com experts and i'm like like we're actually doing this with humility like no like we're not saying like oh we're the best look at us we're actually like hey like let's we're gonna show you how hard this is like we're we're gonna try our best and it's also such a different skill set a five years ago was different i've never been involved with like a pre-product market fit company and and be like you know when you're like i was ceo last three years like you're not doing any marketing even at cmo often you're not really doing a lot of marketing.

42:02Your leadership, your managing, it's such a different skill set of running a mortality test, deciding budgets, deciding a few strategic things, building your team is just incredibly different from standing up an ad account and a brand for the first time. That's why we're doing it. It's fun, right? But it's a completely different skill set. It's funny because I was looking at the Jones Road website last night. I have a new perspective. I'm like, I actually think I've learned more about marketing and creative in the last six weeks that I have in like the last two years.

42:31Matt Bertulli: That statement right there is so true. When you're at scale, right? And you're mature, your rate of learning slows down quite a bit because the machine is just slower to turn. It's, it takes time to do things when you're starting. Like you, you said at the beginning of this episode, we are on version seven of our site in six weeks. Like if you're listening, that means that we have updated it more than once a week, like major updates, major moves in content. And like, yeah, AI helps with that. But you got to think like, that's the focus right now. So like, are we going to miss a bunch of basic things?

43:10Matt Bertulli: For sure. But we are maniacally focused on like one part of the company at the moment. And the other parts, it's not that they don't matter. It's that they don't matter as much. So like right now, it's like increased speed of learning on the one thing, the one biggest lever in the business that we need to be true in order to continue to build the business. And when you're running a big company, like you were Cody and I was, you just don't do that anymore. Like you do incrementality tests and you do these big split tests and you roll out large features and you do product launches. And like we have millions of customers, like that is a very different machine to operate.

43:53Matt Bertulli: and starting at zero, our skills there are probably a zero. We're starting at zero, right? What we talk about on the main shows is how you run a large company, all the things that we learn. This is a different thing. Guys, this is why we did the show. The reason we're doing this in public is like, I don't know, I kind of wanted to suffer a bit, and I wanted to see what it was like to start again. I wasted two hours over the weekend trying to upload ads and I said I've never got to do that again so I had Runneth do it looked at every ad picked the right landing page it named all the ads wrote the headline and copied to match from options I gave it set the naming conventions set UTMs all of it and push it to ads manager for me all I had to do is go into ads manager QA it hit live it was done Runneth is an agent with its own virtual computer so it never shuts off.

44:47It's always on. The whole team can talk to it. The same runneth in Slack. It remembers everything. It has pre-built skills based on some amazing stuff that the motion team has built. Here's one example of how I'm using it. Last night, I hooked up Tribe, our creator sourcing tool. And anytime a creator video comes in, it gets QA'd against my feedback that I gave in it before. We get notified of any new video. I can have it add captions. It watches the video, figures out what it's about, adds naming conventions, edit hooks. I've been doing a lot, building a lot of static ads with Runneth as well.

45:18It's pretty awesome and it all comes out of the box. We've been using our Winx as our main creative strategist, using it to build tons of ads for us. Winx is using it. Ridge is using Runneth. HexCloud is using it as well. Go to runneth.com. They're giving listeners 500 million free tokens for your first month. So it's actually been good for me because I definitely don't have the thickest skin and like sometimes I'd send you something that people said and you'd like laugh it off and I'm like, I need a little bit more.

45:41Matt Bertulli: I literally have said, Cody, just tell that person to fuck off. i will i just like i think that if you've got nothing nice to say you should just shut your face hole uh like the world is better when we're all cool to each other you know and we're all helpful like most people and most people in consumer i will say this like very supportive so like so many people have actually helped us so like let's also say that because like man we have had some awesome like awesome feedback i've had people dm me like dude you should try this on your on your offer box like hey try writing it this way so much good stuff comes out of the consumer community too there's just some people that like every now and again they find a soapbox and they feel like they got to stand on the damn thing i don't know i don't get it oh for sure this is what i've told like people i told my wife i'm like i feel like we got like 98 good pieces of feedback this is awesome you guys did a good job with this and then i just remember the two and that's like how my brain is wired i just remember the two negative ones but that's a you're a good marketer man good marketers like we tend to uh every good market i've encountered is like very obsessive over the details and i think that that just comes with it you know like you and i spend a weird amount of time on small lots of small little things it's like rearrange like the words like i spend so much time on just the words um because i think they matter right and i would say that for like people listening you should obsess over your copy that actually matters a lot like what you say how you say it when you say it the sequence of the things you say all of that stuff matters like um you know even after launch one of the things i did was if you start to like to again getting feedback from people getting the product went in and completely redid all of the copy in our welcome sequence right so it's like a post purchase it's like great you just bought we gotta rewrite all that crap we need to set better expectations of what people should expect with the product, how to use it, when to take it, how much water, what to expect, how's it going to feel today, tonight, tomorrow morning, like all that stuff.

47:48Matt Bertulli: I'm like, oh my God, we have to like do a much better, more clear job of telling people how to use the thing that we're selling them. Like, so spend time there. That is actually meaningful. And I think it has a impact. Talking about focus. Like I was, this is a, has been another lesson for me, right? Just like, because I was so excited to get into subscription, get into retention. Like prior to launch, we built out a lot of stuff in HQ. Like I spent a lot of time trying to learn this stuff. And it matters, but it doesn't matter at all right now. Like there's no customers to retain, right? And so like, I have like, I have not looked, I was like, oh, I can't wait to set up our cancellation flow and stuff like that.

48:29Like, yes, it's extremely important to running a subscription business. It's just off the, you know, So like Skio has been great and they've been able to handle some of it for now. But even like email, like we're not sending campaigns like we, you know, it just it just doesn't really matter right now. We will in the future. We even brought on an agency to do retention homes that's going to help out with our setting up flows and stuff. Just so Matt and I can be focused on acquisition. Because like right now, like nothing else matters. So I think just that that prioritization, you know, lesson like, you know, Alex Ramosi says like you need to be reminded more than you need to be taught.

49:01but like there's been a lot of really good reminders and just like just being laser focused

49:06Matt Bertulli: yes crazy i was actually thinking of this the other day because i was i logged into omni said i'm like man we're getting into the thousands of like people on our list uh but we're not doing anything with it yeah and it kind of made me itchy i was like oh god we're not doing anything with this but focus i think i gotta i think you're right it's just like gotta be reminded that the we have one job right now. All right. So guys, I want to finish on this. If you were going to give advice to another new brand, Cody, let's start with you. Walk through what you think would be the appropriate sequence of activities and what they should do.

49:43Matt Bertulli: Like, how would you start and launch again? You can't invest a ton. Like, I do think it makes sense to go lean, not spend all the money because you don't know and you're going to have to pivot. So, so go lean with the finances and, but you do have to do enough. Right. And so I wouldn't sign gigantic creators or maybe even without the doctors, I wouldn't go and do billboards from the beginning or do fancy launch videos, like do the website yourself, like do that. Like you can polish up your branding and stuff like that. But I think find that, that minimum viable product and do enough. And so I would do a little bit more than we did.

50:20I would, I would spend more time earlier getting our creators going. I would do more organic seating. I would have as much of that as possible, a little bit more kind of organic stuff as possible, just to get that, that zero to one, that jumpstart phase a little bit better. Curtis, what would you, what would you do? Yeah. Organic seating was one of the things that I thought about, you know, we, we all have massive lists, uh, big audiences and we don't have to, we didn't have to go into the digital realm even before we even see the product with, you know, our communities. Like we could have just emailed people.

50:53We could have emailed people. We could have taken our lists, emailed people. They could have signed up. They could have, you know, bought the product. We could have got feedback directly, not spent any money on ads. We didn't do that. I don't think as much as we should have. And it wouldn't have cost us anything, you know, and at the end of the day, like when you launch a product, the co-man is only going to give you so many free samples, right? Like they're just, they're only going to give you so many free samples. So then you have to put a minimum order in and you're sitting on, you know, 5 ,000 units.

51:21It's like, well, between all of us, we could have actually, before even a website was launched, we could have even seeded product and got feedback. You know, in opinions and perspectives, both on the product, on the branding, you name it. So I think that's one of the biggest learnings that we could have done a little bit better. You can only connect the dots looking back. And, you know, people are asking us why we haven't done X, Y, and Z. It's like, well, we haven't spent a ton of money on gifting packages, like packaging and a gift box and a launch strategy, PR, items like that. We actually have done this in a very accessible, achievable way, like relatable way for a lot of people that want to start brands.

52:03When we launched Lomi,

52:05Matt Bertulli: because we did a crowdfund. So we actually had a start date for the campaign with that product. the thing that I liked that we did was that we actually did a lot of one-on-one reach out to our network. And we sent out calendar invites to people. So like we basically said like, hey, this is the day we're launching. Can I add it to your calendar so I can get you to email and post about it on the day that we're launching? And Curtis, you're a hundred percent right. Like each of us actually has pretty good network. We could have easily, and I think a lot of people listening, you know more people than you think you do.

52:44Matt Bertulli: Like even just think of like a LinkedIn list and whoever else you have, like that's what we did when we launched Loamy. I literally hit up everybody on my LinkedIn, everybody on Twitter, everybody on Instagram, everybody on my email. And I was just sending one-on-one messages and I did that and my business partners did that. And we just built up enough people that were willing to post to their own channels. And no massive influencers, by the way. Like nobody in that list of people was huge. It was just like friends, family, whoever was willing to like also support the launch. And I think that doing that again for this, I would do that again.

53:21Matt Bertulli: If I was starting a new brand today, I would do that simply because it gets you a bit of the thing that Cody's talking about, which is that organic jumpstart. A little more signal on launch day than just cold starting. As relatable as cold starting is, I think I would have done all that like grunt work up front. You know, the other thing I would do, I'd, I'd launch it with like a partner, creator, doctor, something like that. Right away. Yeah. Yeah. A hundred percent. I would have like, you know, put, put a bit of cash, a little equity on the table. And I know several people have done that and absolutely would have done that.

53:57You know, my, my curiosity on that though, like I'm going to push back. you know, I think the most credible people, a lot of times these guys don't want to take risk around their credibility early on. They, like, so we don't, we, you don't remember the stories. Like, you know, there's brands that are associated with some of the highest profile celebrities or athletes in the world, and they don't come on from day one. Like they've, we think they do, but there's been so much work behind the scenes. There's so much pre-launch stuff there's so much you know um launched before the brand is even known i think you're right

54:31Matt Bertulli: curtis i would say if we were not going to try to like build in public and do it from a relatable way i would agree with cody because uh i would absolutely reach out to some of these large creators because we all have track record like right cody myself like we could easily just hit them up and be like hey this is who we are yes um we have they would probably do that but for the average person, maybe not. I think that's why we didn't. Yeah, we just, exactly. Cause like, we're trying to do this in a more like, what would a normal, like what would a regular everyday person do to get a bread off the ground?

55:04And I, I think we're in a, you know, you talk about the next six weeks. I think we're in a completely different position in a better way right now. Like, Hey, this is, this is what we've learned. This is what our product is. This is what we need. this is who we are you know and it's real and so you know selling or you know bringing this to a high profile creator slash you know doctor you name it they can touch feel and also they get to learn they get to hear all our learnings they get to understand what we need and we get what we need

55:35Matt Bertulli: every day is like regular order volume tax like cpa is coming down we're getting re like rebills like all of it is pretty positive uh you know are we where we want to be no but we're also setting pretty aggressive goals we'd like to do a lot better it's just who we are we're driven we're ambitious um but we're six weeks in and like not bad guys you know like pretty good um so yeah i i'm i'm very curious to see curtis where we land six weeks from now this is going to be uh cody now the pressure i think is really on it's like we've got traction it's like how far can we push it you know at first it was like jesus can we do this now it's like oh i wonder i wonder you know how low is low with uh cpa all right boys i think that's the pod this has been a fun one this is like all things marketing today um if you've stayed this far in the episode we're gonna do a future episode just on creator and we're gonna do an episode coming up just on offer because i I think that is like a big one when it comes to, well, any product, but like subscription specifically.

56:43Matt Bertulli: So that's coming up. Boys, that's the pod.

From the publisher

“We know how to run ads. This is a playbook.” 

How should you market a new DTC brand in its first six weeks? 

Matt Bertulli (Founder, Pela Case & Lomi), Cody Plofker (Advisor & fmr. CEO, Jones Road Beauty), and Curtis Christopherson (Chief Growth Officer, Ammortal) hold the Winks marketing plan up against the results since launch. 

They built the brand for moms, yet men keep showing up to buy. Meta CPMs hit $800 until a free account fix and a smaller budget turned them around. Now creators and credible doctors have to bring CAC down to $100 before they scale. 

Powered By 

Aftersell 

https://9ops.co/aftersell 

Skio 

https://9ops.co/skio-9operators 

Omnisend 

https://9ops.co/omnisend 

OuterSignal 

https://9ops.co/outersignal 

Richpanel 

https://9ops.co/richpanel 

Runneth 

https://9ops.co/motion-runneth 

Operators Portal 

https://portal.9operators.com/dashboard 

Operators Newsletter 

https://9operators.com/ 

More from Operators

All episodes