In short
Prof G Markets Podcast Notes
Episode Overview Title: Will Tesla’s Robotaxi Ever Arrive? + Sin Stocks and Zyn Nicotine Pouches Hosts: Scott Galloway and Ed Elson Description: Scott Galloway shares insights on Tesla’s recent earnings report, discusses the overinvestment in the electric vehicle industry, and analyzes the implications for Tesla's stock in light of potential political changes. They also explore the rise of Zyn nicotine pouches among Gen Z and the ethical considerations of investing in "sin stocks."
---
Key Themes
- Tesla’s Earnings and Market Position
- Lackluster Performance:
- Tesla's recent quarterly profits fell 45% year-on-year, marking its second consecutive decline.
- The profit margin has dropped to its lowest levels in five years.
- No new sales target was provided, indicating uncertainty in growth projections.
- Industry Overinvestment:
- Scott compares the current state of the EV market to the streaming industry, highlighting overinvestment leading to price wars.
- EV prices have dropped significantly due to competition, with some electric models now cheaper than their combustion counterparts.
- Future Outlook:
- Concerns over Tesla’s innovation lag as competitors emerge, particularly in autonomous driving technology.
- Speculation about the impact of political factors on stock performance, especially regarding Elon Musk's political affiliations.
- Robotaxi Concept
- Delayed Launch:
- The anticipated unveiling of Tesla’s Robotaxi has been pushed back, reflecting ongoing challenges in self-driving technology development.
- Discussion around whether the current AI advancements could lead to a breakthrough in autonomous vehicles within 2024.
- Comparative Positioning:
- Tesla's self-driving technology still faces formidable competition, raising questions about its long-term viability and market share.
- Sin Stocks and Zyn Nicotine Pouches
- Rise of Zyn:
- Zyn, a nicotine pouch product, has gained immense popularity, particularly among Gen Z, leading to a nationwide shortage.
- Philip Morris International’s acquisition of Zyn has proven lucrative, with a reported 50% increase in sales.
- Investment Ethics:
- Discussion on the complexity of investing in sin stocks (like tobacco and alcohol) and the moral implications.
- Scott emphasizes the importance of financial security over moral judgments in investment choices.
- Market Vitals and Earnings Reports
- Weekly Market Review:
- S&P 500 experienced its worst day since 2022.
- Major companies like Google and LVMH reported mixed earnings, with reflections on market reactions:
- Google: Despite beating expectations, heavy investments in AI and declining YouTube ad sales caused stock volatility.
- LVMH: Sales growth at its lowest since 2009 due to reliance on the Chinese market.
- Spotify: Surged in subscribers and profit, highlighting successful business strategies.
---
Key Takeaways
- Investment Strategies:
- The conversation underscores the necessity of adapting investment strategies in response to market dynamics and consumer trends, particularly in the tech and automotive sectors.
- Cultural Shifts:
- There is a noticeable shift in consumer behavior regarding nicotine and alcohol, particularly among younger demographics, which has significant implications for companies in these sectors.
- Future Predictions:
- There is cautious optimism regarding Tesla's future based on potential AI advancements, but there remains skepticism regarding its current stock valuation.
- Political Influence:
- The intersection of business and politics is highlighted, with Scott noting the potential risks associated with Tesla's alignment with political figures and movements.
---
Notable Quotes
- "Bottom line is, this is classic economics. Overinvestment results in a price war."
- "Zyn is a nicotine pouch that you absorb through your gums, and they're so popular that there's been a nationwide shortage."
- "I think it's easy to be a purist and lecture other people after you're already rich."
---
Next Episode Teaser
- Tune in for the next episode featuring Dan Ives, where they'll delve into more insights about tech stocks and market predictions.
---
This structured summary provides a comprehensive overview of the discussed topics while highlighting the key issues, opinions, and predictions made by the hosts, making it accessible for readers looking to understand the capital markets better.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00This episode is brought to you by On Investing, an original podcast from Charles Schwab. I'm Kathy Jones, Schwab's Chief Fixed Income Strategist. And I'm Lizanne Saunders, Schwab's Chief Investment Strategist. Between us, we have decades of experience studying the indicators that drive the economy and how they can have a direct impact on your investments. We know that investors have a lot of questions about the markets and the economy, and we're here to help. Join us each week as we explore questions like, how do you evaluate corporate bonds? And what sectors of the stock market are outperforming?
0:31So Kathy will analyze what's happening in the bond market and at the Fed, and I'll give you our latest analysis of the equities market and the U.S. economy. And we often interview prominent guests from across the world of investing and business. So download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com slash oninvesting or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:55Support for this show comes from strawberry.me. Be honest. Are you happy with your job or are you stuck in one you've outgrown? or never wanted in the first place? Sure, you can probably list the reasons for staying, but are they actually just excuses for not leaving? Let a career coach from strawberry.me help you get unstuck. Discover the benefits of having a dedicated career coach in your corner. Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer. Today's number,$10. That's the value of the Uber Eats gift card that CrowdStrike offered customers as an apology for its worldwide outage.
1:37Ed, I just can't take much anymore. I'm divorcing my wife. First it was some guy in a drunk party. Then it was her ex-boyfriend, her boss, my best friend, even an Uber driver. I just can't stop sucking other men's cocks, Ed.
2:01That was bad even for me. Here we are, Ed. Prop G. Our producer just went off camera. She's calling her lawyer.
2:14Hello? Hey, Dina. It's Claire again. What's going on, Ed? I'm doing very well. By the way, I saw a nice headline in the news this week, which is that you're donating$12 million to UCLA and UC Berkeley. Oh, that's an interesting segue from me giving random oral sex to men. Yes, I am, Ed. I'm trying to portray you in a better light here. We definitely changed altitudes pretty quickly there. Do you want to stay on sucking dick? You want to remain there for a little bit longer? Let's try and pivot out of that. Even I'm feeling a bit cringed out right now. Even I'm feeling a bit cringed out. All right, back to me and my virtue signaling.
2:51What would you like to know, Ed? You know me, I don't like to talk much about myself. What's on your mind? Well, I think you should just talk about it. I shared it on Twitter, which you're not on, so you didn't see this, but I just sort of gave you a little shout out for putting your money where your mouth is. That's nice. That makes me feel good. And people just loved it. I mean, it's gone, I wouldn't say viral, but semi-viral. I think people are just very, very impressed with that donation. So maybe explain what it's for, what you're doing. I just like when you, yeah, follow through with your ideas, is, and that's what you've done here.
3:26Okay. Well, first of all, thanks for asking. So it's a lot of things. It's a culmination of a lot of things. One, it's an overdue nod to the generosity of California taxpayers that gave me a shot. The reason I'm here with you today is the generosity of California taxpayers and the visions of the Regents of the University of California. I'm not being humble. I'm a remarkably talented person, but without the certification contacts and job opportunities that I got from the University of California, I just wouldn't be here. And the thing about UC back in the 80s was that it was not only affordable, it was accessible.
4:01Yeah, 76 % admissions rate,$1 ,200 per year. And I feel that people who are successful and have gathered some wealth have an obligation, especially UC grads, to try and return it to that level of affordability and accessibility. In addition, I saw an opportunity, and that is we have this incredible infrastructure across the UC campuses. We don't take advantage of the facilities at night or during the summer. And also, our product hasn't evolved. Not everyone should be shoved through a traditional four-year liberal arts degree. And because five people are leaving the trades for every two that are going in over the next 10 years, we've seen a dramatic escalation in the salaries and compensation of plumbers, electricians, cybersecurity professionals, specialty nursing, specialty construction.
4:47So I approached the chancellors at UCLA and Berkeley and said, if I funded a program that was more vocational in nature, that gave maybe young adults and adults a chance to take courses, very specialized courses over the course of a year, that gave them access to this incredible upswell in compensation and job opportunities in the main street economy, would you be interested? And they were interested and they were very generous with me, even though they hate using the term vocational. So we talk about nontraditional students. Why do you think they hate the term? Does it just sound not elite enough or something?
5:19Yeah, I think they see themselves as wanting to, higher education is about giving a kid a chance to explore different disciplines such that it rounds out the kind of the brain as a muscle, whether it's history or philosophy. And that maybe our junior colleges or other trade schools are really for that, that that erodes kind of the mission and somewhat of the elite status of higher ed. So they are very, they have been, that was the hardest part about this gift was getting them to somehow move to the notion that we need to offer an opportunity here over one or two years that would help kids have the skills that foot to the main street economy right now.
5:57And my vision is I want it to be free and I want it, I don't want there to be an admissions process. I want it to be, if you're smart, not even smart, you're a good person who wants to be a part of our economy, wants to be in the middle class, wants to, or higher, wants to pay taxes, but isn't cut out like two-thirds of Americans for a traditional four-year liberal arts degree that you have opportunities. And, you know, free and accessible. Those are my two call signs here. But this is, I'm super excited about it. Both UCLA and Berkeley were really supportive of the idea. and also for me, it's not even philanthropy.
6:33It's consumption. It makes me feel really fucking awesome. I feel like a baller doing it. I think I'd have accomplished another goal, which is that many of the comments I saw on Twitter were, I didn't know Scott had$12 million. I have$12 million and one. It's all gone now. That's what I said. Someone said, how much does he have? I said, more than$12 million. It's super exciting. I'm happy to be, you know, I don't know, dad. It's like you get to a point in your life and what I want to do is I love the difference between an opinion and a principle or a value. And the difference between an opinion of which I vomit out to everybody on this and other podcasts is that, okay, are you really passionate about struggling young men?
7:17I think I am. Well, it's an opinion or is it a value? I'm really passionate about higher ed and making it more affordable and accessible. Well, is that just an opinion or is it a value? And the way you show it's a value is that you sacrifice for it. And so I'm sort of overdue closing the gap between everything I say and everything I do. I need to, you know, I definitely talk the talk. I need to walk the walk more. And this is an attempt to do that. And with that, let's share our opinions on the news. Let's start with a weekly review of Market Vitals.
7:52The S &P 500 had its worst stay since 2022. The dollar was flat, Bitcoin declined, and the yield on 10-year treasuries fell. Shifting to the headlines. Google reported second quarter earnings beating analyst expectations on the top and bottom lines. Operating profit crossed$1 billion for the first time ever. However, the stock still fell 5 % due to concerns over heavy AI spending and slowing YouTube ad sales. Louis Vuitton and Dior owner LVMH reported only a 1 % increase in sales for the second quarter. That is its lowest growth rate since 2009, excluding the pandemic. Sales for fashion and leather goods also only rose 1%, nearly half of what analysts expected.
8:31The stock fell more than 4 % following that news. And finally, Spotify hit 246 million premium subscribers in the second quarter. That's up 12 % from a year earlier. Those subscriber numbers helped deliver a record profit of just under$300 million. Spotify stock rose as much as 16%. Scott, your thoughts, starting with Google earnings. I've been thinking a lot about Alphabet, and I wonder if they're still sort of semi-stuck in the innovator's dilemma. And that is the company's LLM, Gemini, gets about an eighth of the traffic of ChatGPT. When you think about the captive audience they have between Android and search and the fact that a lot of the IP for AI was actually developed at Alphabet, have they really turned the fire hose of their, you know, three billion captive consumer base to Gemini?
9:25Or do they want to have their cake and eat it too? And that is the majority of the AI efforts I have seen from Alphabet have been in the context of a Google search and it has that kind of summary at the top. But I haven't, I don't feel like I've had that much marketing or that much incentive to use Gemini. And I wonder if it's, they're still sort of protecting or not going full force. They don't, they're not, they haven't, in other words, they haven't burned the boats, so to speak. And they're busy sending out$23 billion offers to Wiz and buying back shares and issuing dividends. Yeah. Their capbacks got hit hard this quarter.
9:57And what struck me, I immediately thought of Apple that's so smart not getting into this arms race. They're just going to make sure they own access to the billion wealthiest consumers. And then they're going to charge someone like Alphabet or OpenAI a ridiculous amount of money to be the AI of iOS. But their capbacks hit$13 billion, up 91 % from a year earlier. Their total capbacks this year could be around$50 billion, which would be 84 % higher than when the company has averaged annually over the past five years. I got to think most of that was on AI, which was mentioned, get this, 89 times on the earnings call.
10:32YouTube, you know, ad revenue still climbed 13%. So I think it's pretty striking. The thing we have to remember here is that Alphabet, and this is our big tech stock pick of 2024, so I've been tracking it. Microsoft year-to-date is up 16 % for all of the excitement about that stock. Amazon's up 21%, but Alphabet ad is up 25%. So they're doing really well. And it just strikes me when the analysts zero in on the negatives here, but the company is still doing really well. What are your thoughts? I completely agree with you. I think people are so obsessed with this idea that they're behind on AI, which is probably true when you compare it to Microsoft.
11:13But as with anything, you have to look at the big picture here. And the big picture for Google is extremely compelling. Search revenue is up 14%. People thought that chat GPT and AI would be eating into that revenue. It hasn't hurt it at all. In fact, you know, search is chugging along just fine, better than fine. Cloud revenue up 29%. I think that was expected. And as you mentioned, the YouTube revenue, people didn't like the 13 % jump in YouTube revenue. It's coming off an insanely high base. And I think they're just comparing it to the previous quarters where they were getting 20 plus percent growth, which is already insane.
11:53I just want to point this stat out. YouTube ads, just the ads alone, they are now bringing in on an annualized basis,$35 billion per year, which is higher than Netflix's total revenue last year. And it doesn't even include all the paid subscriptions that they get from YouTube Premium and YouTube TV. So I just think it's remarkable what YouTube has done. We have been saying this for a while. I continue to believe that YouTube is the most underrated media asset in the world. And I think if you just stack all those things up, there's so much reason to be optimistic about Google. Well, the market agrees with you.
12:34And I've always, the thing I've said about Alphabet for a long time is that it has the greatest concentration of IQ since NASA. And the team of the best players wins. And Alphabet consistently finds, attracts, and retains some of the best players. It's an incredible company. I think you have to admire their management and what they built there. As we went to LVMH, thoughts on these earnings that were a disappointment? LVMH is sort of the, quote unquote, bellwether for luxury. And what's ailing them is kind of it's ailing every luxury firm and that is that asia or specifically china is no longer the gift that keeps on giving and if you were overexposed to china it was champagne and cocaine from like 2000 to 2018 and estee lauder went through the roof and you know north face it took north face i think 20 years or 30 years to get to a billion in sales it took them 18 months in china i mean the shit was just selling before it even got offloaded from ships, right?
13:39And last year, it's about one in six purchases globally of luxury happened in China. But the Chinese economy is showing signs of weakness. High net worth families in China reduced their annual spending by 11 % last year. And you want to talk about just an incredible shift in fortunes. Chinese stocks have lost$6 trillion over the past three years. That's twice the GDP of the United Kingdom. The S &P over the last five years has doubled. It's up 100%. India, 65%. Japan, 25%. Europe, 24%. China is down 30%. So if, I don't know what it was, if China was 10 trillion and we were 25 trillion, we went to 50 and they went to seven.
14:20I mean, LVMH gets about a third of its revenues from China. So if that's down 15%, that means overall revenues are going to be down 5%. I wonder if it's a buying opportunity. It's such a well-run company. They have such incredible brands. But this is just simply put, their biggest customer doesn't have as much money as they used to. I'll also add, it's very interesting. I think this is another nice example of these ripple effects that we often talk about in the markets where what started out as basically a real estate crisis in China that began with Evergrande has morphed into a larger issue in China.
14:56It has reverberated throughout the world, and it's now worming its way onto the income statement of a French luxury fashion house, which is LVMH. And so it's a very interesting dynamic going on here. Having said all that, I think your point that it could be a buy is a good one, because this company is not in crisis. I mean, the stock is down this year, you know, down 10 % year to date, coming off some crazy highs where you saw, or no, becoming the wealthiest man in the world. So yeah, I don't think this is an organizational issue with LVMH. This is a regional issue. It's a problem with China. So, but let's just look at the stock.
15:36Over the last five years, the stock's up 66%. I mean, it's just, and then the one that just absolutely flummoxes me is Hermes has a market cap of 213 billion euros, which is about 240 billion. Unbelievable. So I think luxury is going to continue. I think it's ridiculous. This notion that young people aren't as fascinated by luxury as my generation and their ability to command margins once they get to sort of that iconic status. And they also, and I'll wrap up here, they have an incredible moat because the majority of luxury brands have a heritage. You just can't spin up heritage. You can have a brand like supreme that becomes aspirational for a while but these brands you know panerai was initially crafted for italian uh submariners i mean this shit is just louis vuitton trekked into paris on barefoot and said okay it makes no sense that these carriages are carrying suitcases that are rounded at the top and have leather that attracts moisture and mold so he came up, luxury is really rooted in innovation.
16:43I think it was, was it L 'Oreal or was it, I forget who initially, it was a German chemist who went to the fields of the south of France and found a way to crush these flowers and turn them into a fragrance. I mean, this shit, it really is rooted. It was innovation before there was innovation as we saw it in terms of technology was in fact luxury. Anyways, that's my rant on luxury. Coco Chanel defined luxury as the following, luxury is a necessity that begins when necessity ends. I thought that was sort of the perfect encapsulation and a great explanation of why, yes, we will always worship luxury no matter what we say.
17:22We'll find a way to find necessities when necessity ends. Yeah, she also said the opposite of luxury is not poverty, it's vulgarity, which I love. And she also said, I love that Nazi dick. She said that too and she said that too okay is that fair is that fair it's pretty easy to tell i'm no longer working for a company that caters to luxury brands by the way chanel's an amazing company with amazing people sorry about that yeah that's why you're getting sent clothes from nike and not louis vuitton i've used chanel moisturizer i use chanel blue it's what i bought actually when my son was headed back to boarding school i always do a little bit of a shopping ritual for him and I'm like, this shit is gangster.
18:05You got to put a little of this on. And I use Chanel Blue moisturizer. Anyway, it sells lovely. Masculine yet feminine at the same time. It's fascinating. I'm glad everyone's getting to hear this. Let's move on to Spotify, who had a great quarter. Monthly active users up 14%, revenue up 20%, profits up 45%, record profits for the company. Your thoughts on Spotify? If you think about what Spotify has accomplished, it's singular. They've taken an entire medium and distilled it to a single icon on your phone that is searchable and very user-friendly. No one's done that in TV. No one's done that in books.
18:44I think it's a great value. I think they do a fantastic job. In some, I think it's a great company. And they were also pretty bold. They went all in and gave the artists and labels a disproportionate amount of the revenues. They basically lost money. They were more like a collective or cooperative, just taking money and distributing it to the record labels and the artists. But once they got scale and once they kind of not consolidated the industry but had a large enough share where they could start, they had the pricing power to improve or increase prices and their subscribers didn't go down. And basically, essentially what they have figured out is that they have more pricing power than they thought.
19:17And despite increasing prices, they have increased their revenue. So revenue from premium users increased 21%. And premium subscribers accounted for 95 % of Spotify's gross profit over the last 12 months. The thing that doesn't work or the thing I saw in this earnings call or in these numbers is I think both Netflix and Spotify, I think the advertising does not work for them. And I remember being like in 2000, like the early 2000s, I think I was on a date or whatever. I had some people over and I was trying to impress these people and I was at my loft. I know it's horrifying to think of me as single.
19:57and I remember I had music on and you know things were going really well and all of a sudden it dawned on me like some really bad ad for like pets.com or something came on and I'm like oh my god no one's ever gonna have sex with the ad supported Pandora guy and I literally thought having ad supported Pandora was just gonna ruin no matter how many panoramas I had or how I was I was trying. When the pets.com ad comes on on Pandora Radio, it's over. Everyone's like, well, it's getting late. It's getting late. But what I saw in the Netflix earnings call and in this one is that it's just the ad-supported ecosystem is having a really difficult time.
20:42I think it gets in the way of storytelling. And I think this earnings shows just that basically it's subscribers that are, what, 95 % of Spotify's gross profit. One other thing I found really interesting was how the CEO, this guy Daniel Ek, announced these earnings. And that is before the official earnings call, he posted on Twitter and on Instagram what was essentially like a TikTok video. It was like a two-minute selfie video where he just spoke directly at the camera and ran through all of the headline numbers in the earnings report. I think he started doing this around Q4 of last year. This is kind of his comms strategy.
21:22I'd like to get your take. I will just say, I think it's such a good idea because in a weird way, the way most people consume earnings news, it isn't actually from the company earnings calls. It's from media companies. It's from like CNBC or the Wall Street Journal, or even you might get it from listening to this podcast. You're rarely hearing from the CEO, but this strategy is such an obvious one. Just post directly to social media. That sort of fixes it. you know it's a small detail it's a small innovation but i would predict that this is going to become the norm i think you're going to see lots more ceos posting on social media these selfie videos about their earnings in the next few months i think that's really interesting i didn't know that you can see them bypassing kind of the analyst industrial complex or the cnbc industrial complex and doing a video uh kind of timed well choreographed tweets and then maybe doing like Instagram live to do their analyst calls, right?
22:20To say, all right, I'm going live to answer your questions. There's some choreography around SEC and, you know, when you release non-public material information that they got to be careful of. But I think you're right. I think that that might be, because what you want is you want to get more people just as you want to garner more consumers. A consumer brand wants to get new consumers into the franchise, get new customers. The company wants to get new investors. And they also, what never goes out of style is they all want to be known for having an innovative product that's differentiated and that they're good at what they do and they're competent.
22:56But what they really want more than anything is they want some of that innovative pixie dust poured all over them. So communicating your earnings via a video that's posted to YouTube and then spliced up for TikTok or what have you, and then doing some of this live stuff on some of these platforms, that just sort of screams of innovation. Yeah, I can't understand how PR firms or PR teams, I should say, at these public companies haven't gotten on this. It's weird to think this, but I would bet within five years, 10 years max, a key component of your boards deciding whether they make someone CEO is how strong is their following.
23:34Basically, as the CEO, your job is to attract and retain the best talent and set a vision for the company. But as much or more than anything now, it's your ability to tell a story or craft a narrative that results in access to cheaper capital such that you can invest at a greater rate than your competitors and pull away from them. Anyways, I'm 100 % with you. And I would bet you're the next generation of CEOs are ones that come armed with pretty decent followings on social media. We'll be right back after the break with a look at Tesla.
24:37Thank you. There are no hidden fees, no maintenance costs, no minimum balance, and signing up is completely free. With Found, your financial world is streamlined and your time is freed up, so you can put your energy into growing your business. Oh, and by the way, other small businesses are loving Found too. This Found user said, Found is going to save me so much headache. It makes everything so much easier, expenses, income, profits, taxes, invoices even. And Found has 30 ,000 five-star reviews just like this. You can open a Found account for free at F-O-U-N-D dot com. Found is a financial technology company, not a bank.
25:13Banking services are provided by Piermont Bank, member FDIC. Don't put this one off. Join thousands of small business owners who have streamlined their finances with Found. From Pushkin Industries, I'm Jonathan Goldstein, and Heavyweight is back. The new season is bigger than ever. Bigger hopes? I keep waiting for this moment when he says, Mom, I get it. I'm sorry. Bigger dreams. Tom Hanks wants to meet with you. This is a real chance. And bigger heartbreaks. I thought it would be my movie moment. And maybe he would even whisper in my ear, I've always been in love with you. Check out new episodes of Heavyweight on Apple Podcasts.
26:02Support for this show comes from SoFi Small Business Lending. If you run a small business, you need capital to find new opportunities and grow. For that, SoFi's Small Business Lending Marketplace is your new best friend. SoFi's Marketplace is a fast digital solution. In one single simple search, SoFi matches you with vetted providers for your business in just minutes. Discover financing choices that meet your specific needs. For example, need working capital, a line of credit, an SBA loan, equipment financing. SoFi's marketplace can help you find all of the above. And it's already helped thousands of small businesses like yours find the funding they need.
Read the full transcript
26:42And if you like where this is going, SoFi also offers business owners curated tools, vetted business bank accounts, business credit card recommendations, and a ton of resources to help you scale your business like a boss. SoFi, now helping you get your business right. Visit SoFi.com slash box pod and see your options in minutes.
27:10We're back with ProfG Markets. Tesla's second quarter profits fell 45 % year over year, declining for the second quarter in a row. The company also posted its lowest quarterly profit margin in five years and its second consecutive sales decline. Tesla did not offer a fresh sales target for the year, but it did warn that its vehicle volume growth rate would be, quote, notably lower than 2023. The stock fell 12 % after the earnings call. Scott, reaction to Tesla's earnings? I think the analogy here is this market feels very similar in some ways and not in others to the streaming market. And that is Tesla basically had the market to themselves similar to Netflix through the aughts in the 2010s.
27:54And that is, if you were going to buy an EV, you were really going to buy a Tesla. It was kind of like Tesla in the seven door. No one was going to buy a Pontiac Leaf or whatever the heck it was called, right? And so they sort of owned it. And then the stock market just reacted so positively to Tesla and gave them SaaS-like, tech-like multiples that everyone in the auto industry said, okay, okay, we got to get into this. And they announced, you know, Mary Barra announced that half the cars sold from GM were going to be electric within a certain time. Rivian spinned up, you know, Fisker, all these startups kind of spun up.
28:31And there was essentially what happened in the EV race is what happened in streaming. That is, it became overinvested. And the manifestation of that overinvestment is that a year ago, an EV, an electric powered vehicle was$8 ,500 more expensive than its internal combustion equivalent. As of today, it's only$1 ,500 more expensive. And in some instances, it's less expensive. So the F-150 Lightning, that is now$10 ,000. The electric version is$10 ,000 less than its internal combustion brother. And I will say brother, that's a pretty macho fucking car. That shit has real balls, Ed. That shit has balls.
29:11Bottom line is, this is his classic economics. Overinvestment, because of the market giving an above market multiples, that overinvestment results in a price war. And then I think you combine that with Tesla's products feel a little bit dusty right now. They don't feel that. I mean, by the way, I drove in a matte black cyber truck. No way. Yeah, a friend of mine is this total master of the universe baller hedge fund guy. And he invited me out to his house. I went out there last weekend and his house manager picked me up in a matte black Cybertruck. No way. And I'm like, I am literally the douchiest douche in doucheville right now.
29:49How did it feel on the inside? Because I kind of agree with you. I think Teslas feel very cheap on the inside. Did it feel cheap on the inside or did it feel cool? No, it felt modern and very techie. But on the way back, we drove in his Range Rover and I thought that was just much nicer. I think the car, quite frankly, I think the Cybertruck is fucking ridiculous. I think it looks like something Homer Simpson would have designed after watching Battlestar Galactica for 48 hours straight. I think it's just so stupid looking and weird looking. And the inside was very, it felt like you're on a set of a movie about the future, but you would never fucking actually own this car.
30:28Right. And, you know, people were coming up and stopping and talking to us because they were so interested. It looked like, you know, the Batmobile. But I don't, I think the thing is a giant thud. Although I guess the sale, have you heard anything about the sales of this thing? I don't think they've broken out the sales for the Cybertruck yet. But I think the consensus is that orders are underwhelming and they're sort of struggling to keep up. The other thing that strikes me about Tesla is that if you think about pure meme stocks, like the memiest of meme stocks, a meme stock is a stock who's, in my opinion, whose stock is totally disassociated from the underlying fundamentals of the company.
31:08It's like the ketamine of the market, if you will. And the ultimate meme stock is hands down Donald Trump media. It's got a$6 billion market cap even after declining 30 % in the last week on like$7 million in revenues and$300 million. The company makes no fucking sense. It's basically people have decided it's a proxy for your support of or your belief or the probability that Trump is elected president. And it trades on kind of sentiment and emotion. It has nothing to do with the underlying business. Halfway between a stock that trades on its underlying fundamentals like an alphabet or 99 % of stocks and Trump, which is a Trump media, which is a total meme stock.
31:49I think in near meme stocks would be like AMC and GameStop. They're shitty businesses and they trade at much greater multiples than they should because people think there's a chance they'll go crazy again because of, you know, Roaring Kitty or whatever. I think perfectly in the middle of that continuum is Tesla because, to be fair, it's an amazing company. It inspired the EV race. They do have great products. Their energy unit is making money. The idea of a robo-taxi is compelling. We'll come back to that. But Tesla trades at 99 times forward earnings. This is in contrast to Ferrari, an amazing brand that a lot of people want, kind of singular in terms of prestige and self-expressive benefit.
32:31That trades at 50 times. Ford trades at seven times. And GM, get this, Ed, trades at five times forward earnings. So great company, but should it trade at double the multiple of Ferrari and 20 times the multiple of General Motors? So this is sort of a term I would use is it as it relates to meme stocks that Tesla is a hybrid to Prius. Yeah, it's a great company, but it can't really justify the multiple it's at. And then what I'll end up with, and this will come back to our prediction, is that just as Donald J. Trump media became an index for whether or not Trump got reelected. I think these guys, these techno libertarian weirdos really fucked up by coming out so forcefully in favor of Trump.
33:17Because what they've done is they've tied themselves and their businesses to the re-election of Donald Trump. And as the likelihood of Vice President Kamala Harris becomes more likely, and it's become much more likely just in the last five days, I think people are going to go, well, who is this going to hurt? And I think, one, it'll put pressure on Bitcoin prices because they'll say, OK, maybe Bitcoin isn't going to be totally deregulated and become the ultimate stablecoin or whatever. I don't know, whatever the right term would be good for Bitcoin. But also, I think people are going to soon learn or soon figure out if it's a Harris administration, they may not be inclined to put tariffs on BYD.
34:00they may not be as inclined to give subsidies that would include Tesla or give subsidies that might exclude some of the Tesla models. I think people are going to start connecting the dots that when you go all MAGA, Musk, there's some risk there. And I think that risk will start to show up in some pressure on the stock as a little bit of a meme stock tracking Trump's election or lack their rub to the White House. You mentioned the robotaxi, which we should definitely talk about. It was supposed to come out, or the robotaxi model was supposed to be unveiled in August, and then on this earnings call, Elon delayed it to October.
34:42And that's, I think, a big reason why the stock fell. He's been saying that full self-driving is coming next year for literally a decade. So, you know, he's delayed the unveiling again. Supposedly, it's coming out in October now. One sort of tangential point I'd like to get your reaction to in terms of this, when will this robotaxi ever arrive discussion. I was speaking with an AI founder recently, and he actually started his career as an engineer at an autonomous vehicle company, and that episode will be coming out in First Time Founders. And he made a really interesting point, which is that we tend to think of self-driving cars as its own sort of separate, very specific technology.
35:28But in reality, as he pointed out, self-driving cars is just AI. And his point is that, you know, right now is the big AI moment. 2024 is the year of AI. And so, logically speaking, you would think that if we're in the AI moment, we're about to witness the self-driving moment, too. I think it's a strong case for why the Tesla Robotaxi might actually, it actually will arrive this year, despite all of Elon's bullshit. And I'm wondering if you agree. I have no idea. I just know that it's the thing that's supposed to be around the corner, and then you look around the corner and it's not there. And you also have Waymo, you also have a lot of competitors in the space.
36:08In order to really, I'm taking this through, In order to capture incremental margin that results in this type of increase in earnings, you would have to have Teslas that were more AI-enabled or had more automated driving technology than any other car. Is Tesla that far ahead of the other self-driving technology such that they could capture that innovation just for Teslas? There's two things here. When does this happen? And also, what would Tesla's ability be to capture the economics of that innovation versus any other company? Just before we wrap up on this, we spend all this time ragging on Tesla.
36:51Let's try to think a bit more positively. Say you were on the board of Tesla. And let's be clear, the business is struggling. Revenue rose, but it only rose 2%, and profits fell 45%. It's dealing with a lot of issues. You know, its market share in the EV space in America is down to 50%. Four years ago, that number was 80%. So we're not being biased by saying that Tesla as a business is struggling. What would you be focusing on if you were trying to improve this business and you were on the board? Okay, so if we're going to imagine we're on the board, I'm going to imagine that I'm dating Tom Brady and he runs his hands through my share-like thick hair.
37:30I mean, if we're really going to imagine If we're really going to hallucinate, let's go full psilocybin and with a kicker of like nine shots of something. Okay. I'm on the board of Tesla. Oh, that's a good one. Where would I be focused? I think I'd be, I mean, this sounds boring, but I think I would, their energy stuff is pretty cool. Totally. By the way, that business doubled. Yeah. Doing pretty well there. I mean, it sounds really base. I guess I don't have anything creative here. I'd be focused on freshening the model lineup. And then I would probably, I would probably for the robo-taxi stuff, I would probably acquire Lyft and have a built-in base and user base of people who are comfortable with ride hailing.
38:16They should acquire Peloton. Yeah, there you go. That's right. That was my favorite for a while. They're definitely being acquired, says Prop G. We'll be right back after the break with a look at a tobacco company's recent success.
38:37Eczema isn't always obvious, but it's real. And so is the relief from EBCLIS. After an initial dosing phase, about 4 in 10 people taking EBCLIS achieved itch relief and clear or almost clear skin at 16 weeks. And most of those people maintain skin that's still more clear at one year with monthly dosing. EBCLIS, LibriKizumab, LBKZ, a 250 milligram per two milliliter injection is a prescription medicine used to treat adults and children 12 years of age and older who weigh at least 88 pounds or 40 kilograms with moderate to severe eczema. Also called atopic dermatitis that is not well controlled with prescription therapies used on the skin or topicals or who cannot use topical therapies.
39:13EBCLIS can be used with or without topical corticosteroids. Don't use if you're allergic to EBCLIS. Allergic reactions can occur that can be severe. Eye problems can occur. Tell your doctor if you have new or worsening eye problems. You should not receive a live vaccine when treated with EBCLIS. Before starting EBCLIS, tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. Searching for real relief? Ask your doctor about Epglis and visit epglis.lily.com or call 1-800-LILY-RX or 1-800-545-5979. Tuesday on NBC, Jimmy Fallon and Bozema St. John host the highly anticipated new competition show. I hired 10 creatives from all walks of life.
39:47They will be battling it out to see who can impress the world's biggest brands. This is a huge opportunity. This is the battle for the next big idea. This is not play play. We're spending millions of dollars. I'm so excited to embark on this adventure with all of you. Make the best I do win! On brand with Jimmy Fallon. Series premiere Tuesday on NBC. I'm Christian McCaffrey, pro running back, and Abercrombie is an official fashion partner of the NFL. I'm not kidding when I say NFL by Abercrombie broke the internet last year, and I think this season's lineup is even cooler. And so does my wife, who keeps stealing all my hoodies.
40:22Stay fit for the season and Abercrombie's newest arrivals. Shop NFL by Abercrombie in the app, online, and in store.
40:40We're back with ProfG Markets. Shares of Philip Morris International hit their highest level in more than two years after a red-hot product propelled the tobacco company to a better-than-expected earnings report. That product is Zin. Zin is a nicotine pouch that you absorb through your gums, and they're so popular that there's been a nationwide shortage of them this summer. Philip Morris, which acquired Zin in 2022, said sales of the pouches rose 50 % year over year. Overall sales in its smoke-free category rose 24%, and total revenue for the company rose 10%. Scott, what do you make of this new Zin trend that Philip Morris has managed to capture and that is benefiting this company?
41:20I think it's really interesting. I think all the sin guys are trying to figure out a way to go sort of near sin. And that is my understanding of sin is that I want to be clear. This shit is not good for you. Don't pick it up if you don't have an addiction to nicotine. But it's a much less damaging means of delivering nicotine than chewing tobacco. And just full disclosure, I have some background here. I invested in a company being pulled out of bankruptcy called Enjoy, which is an electronic nicotine delivery system, better known as vaping. And I think I did it in 2015 or 16, a long time ago. And one of the reasons I invested was my mother died of a smoking-related illness, and I'd had two friends who'd quit smoking using Enjoy.
42:08And just as combustibles are going away, every year they're down like 5 % or 8%. One in three people who buy a pack of cigarettes, says this is their last pack they're ever going to buy, one in three. It's the largest source of preventable death in the United States, and it's going away. People are getting the memo here. Long story short, we pulled this company out of bankruptcy. I think we bought it for 60 or 70 million, put a bunch of money into it. It was basically a regulatory play. I think we invested another 100 million in it to try and get FDA approval and show that we're good players.
42:45We're acquired for$2.8 billion by Philip Morris. Sorry, was it because there's Altria, which used to be Philip Morris, and then there's Philip Morris International, which is the international segment that was spun out of Altria several years ago. So that's just one little wrinkle in this story. Do you know if it was Altria or Philip Morris International that acquired you? It was Altria. So you're right, it's technically a different group. Because there's different dynamics and I guess they figured they could get more money. Yeah. And they're totally separate companies now, but at one point it was, they were the same.
43:19Yeah. My favorite though, is they changed their name to Altria thinking to people would like them more. They would forget about all the death, disease and disability that they'd spend around the world. You don't think it worked? Um, I don't like name changes when you're trying to escape from something. I don't, I don't, I don't know. I don't think it made any sense anyways. But the thing that really struck me, I think I told you this. I went to summit at sea with all these, you know, young and up and coming vertical farming, you know, it's like, I call it learning man. It was Ted talks during the day.
43:48And then at night, everyone did their drugs with a DJ and pretended they were interesting and thoughtful people because they'd gone to a talk during the day. I'm like AI and fashion. That'll be riveting. Anyway, so, but the thing that struck me was it was on this Virgin cruise ship and I went up and ordered a Makers and Ginger at the bar and he was like, oh my God, finally someone's drinking. And I said, what do you mean? He goes, none of these kids drink. They're all doing drugs. And I noticed that everybody, the drug of choice was mushroom chocolates. And then everyone buys one drink and just nurses it all night.
44:22And that alcohol is really, well, actually, I'll turn this question back to you. You're young. And now for a young person, what is going on with the trend of substance abuse, both tobacco and alcohol and drugs? And I won't ask you to say what you do, but what do your friends do, Ed? Yeah, that's exactly right. Everyone stopped drinking. I mean, here are the statistics. Non-alcoholic beer sales increased 28 % last year. And then two, probably more importantly, Gen Z drinks 20 % less alcohol per capita than millennials did at their age. And I'd love to see the difference between the millennials and the boomers, probably like 100 % less.
45:02but the thing that you know what we should be talking about with this story is this new obsession with zin and yeah it's a nicotine pouch it's it's similar to chewing tobacco but without the tobacco supposedly it doesn't cause cancer but like the vapes we just don't have enough data to say it causes or doesn't cause it but it's extremely popular everywhere zin sales are up 80 % earlier this year. It's now around 50%. An expected 580 million cans will be sold this year. And as I mentioned, there is a Zin shortage in the US. So now Philip Morris is spending$600 million on a manufacturing facility in Colorado just to keep up with demand.
45:44Final anecdotal evidence I will offer. Most of my friends use Zin. Really? Yes. None of the women, all the men, especially the tech bros and especially the bankers. This is sort of a phenomenon in the world of nicotine. So it's massively popular. I think the question is, do you want to get in on it as an investment? I mean, Philip Morris International is trading at 20 times earnings, which is pretty high. It's double Altria's PE ratio at the moment. I think the market is correctly recognizing that Zin is an absolute rocket in the nicotine industry. But, you know, I will throw this back to you.
46:29One, do you like this as an investment? Two, do you have any ethical concerns about investing in a company that sure offers tobacco alternatives, but also sells tobacco? I think it's easy to be a purist and lecture other people after you're already rich. I think people have an obligation to develop economic security for themselves. Like, I used to own Facebook stock, and I got so much shit for it because I'm constantly saying, you know, Mark and Cheryl have done more damage to the world or teens than anyone. I'm like, but you own the stock, so I sold the stock. But I don't have a problem with owning sin stocks.
47:02I don't, my attitude is, you know, if you really have a moral, if you really are against it, then fine, do what you want. But my observation is that the companies that are quote unquote ruining the world generally have the nicest people and are the best run companies. So I did work for fossil fuel companies and my first company, Profit. The people at Chevron, the people at Exxon, so nice, such a well-run company. I've worked with people at gaming companies, you know, casino guys. Incredibly professional, incredibly well-run. Walk into Altria, do work at Altria, and you're going to see some of the most talented, disciplined managers.
47:44They've massively invested in their human capital. I think it's got some of the happiest employees in the world based on surveys. They invest a tremendous amount of money and training. They have great employee profit sharing. These are just really well-run companies. And they're typically, in terms of evaluation, somewhat depressed relative to peers because there's a large segment of the population that won't invest in them. So long term, I'm not going to make a moral argument for or against them. I mean, you know, I'm a capitalist. And, you know, have at it. It's your capital. Do what you want.
48:18But I would invest. I would invest in it. I'm an investor in a – am I an investor in a fossil fuel company? I'm an investor actually in a small fossil fuel company in Switzerland. But let me put this way. I think it's a personal choice, but I don't look down on people who invest in this stuff. I think economic security is really the thing you should be pursuing. And I think we should be voting for people that put in place regulations that think about the well-being of people. Let's take a look at the week ahead. We'll hear the Fed's interest rate decision for July, and we'll also see earnings from Microsoft, Meta, Apple, and Amazon.
48:51Big earnings week. Do you have any predictions, Scott? Well, Tesla is about to become a bit of a meme stock that is an updraft or a downward draft based on Vice President Harris's likelihood or where she is in the polls. And I think these guys a couple of weeks ago, this big list of tech bros, again, seemed like literally the lamest club in San Jose, thought that they were smart to go all in on Trump and that it would pay off for him. they didn't do the math on what's going to happen if all of a sudden a Harris presidency becomes more and more likely that I do think it's going to actually impact the companies they're involved in.
49:30And Musk has turned Tesla red pill. And it appears as if he's gone all in on Trump. He said he was giving$45 million a month. Now he's backtracked on that. Well, he argues that it was made up. I don't think there's any way that we'll know. Well, okay. It was the Wall Street Journal reporting it. So who do you trust more, The Wall Street Journal or Elon Musk? Anyways, this is about to become another, not as much as Donald Trump media, but it's about to become a tracking stock and become inversely correlated to Harris's poll numbers.
50:14Vox Media Podcast Network. Join us on Thursday for our conversation with Dan Ives, only on Profit G Markets.
50:46And the dark flies In love, love, love, love
From the publisher
Scott shares his thoughts on Tesla’s lackluster earnings and explains how the electric vehicle industry has suffered from overinvestment. He also breaks down why Tesla’s stock could suffer if Trump doesn’t get elected. Then, Scott and Ed discuss Zyn’s popularity among Gen Z and the dilemma that comes with investing in sin stocks.
Order "The Algebra of Wealth," out now
Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice
Follow the podcast across socials @profgpod:
Threads
X
Follow Scott on Instagram
Follow Ed on Instagram and X
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices




