1. Podcasts
  2. Proven Podcast
  3. Increase Your Conversion Rates - Andrew Gottlieb
Proven Podcast

7 May 2024 · 44m · 20 chapters

Episode artwork

Increase Your Conversion Rates - Andrew Gottlieb

In short

Andrew Gottlieb explains how to increase conversion rates by using his “impact with profit” methodology: conscious creatives, rapid experimentation, and tying every campaign to P&L outcomes (not vanity metrics). He argues against “set it and forget it” Facebook ads and stresses that iOS 14 changed what works, making creative and funnel alignment more important.

Guest

Andrew Gottlieb, digital marketing strategist and developer of the “impact with profit” methodology; focuses on media buying and scaling for online education and other performance-driven businesses.

Key claims

(1) Don’t run ads without proper tracking/reporting; (2) Don’t force Facebook as the first channel—choose based on audience and test; (3) Avoid unrealistic CPL/ROI expectations (e.g., webinar CPL under $1 is “ridiculous”; $5–$7 is more realistic). Process: Phase 1 fractional CMO consulting to find bottlenecks and align to go-to-market/P&L; Phase 2 overhaul creatives and nurture funnels; Phase 3 run campaigns and split-test.

Notable examples

slow 1995-looking sites with loud “buy now” buttons and outdated funnels; B2B SaaS targeting senior execs via LinkedIn/email/podcasts instead of Facebook; iPhone selfie video outperforming highly produced video for authenticity; changing titles (“you” phrasing) worked in one context but backfired in white-paper/technical environments; clients plateauing due to too few creative tests and overexposure.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:19

Understanding Digital Marketing Strategy

Discussion on the conscious approach to creating effective digital marketing campaigns.

“So Andrew, walk me through your process.”
0:45

The Impact with Profit Methodology

Andrew explains his unique methodology focusing on conscious creatives and user experience.

“We came up with this a few years ago because we saw some gaps in how marketing agencies, marketing departments were approaching digital marketing.”
2:14

Common Digital Marketing Mistakes

Exploration of frequent mistakes in digital marketing and how to avoid them.

“And then lastly, is connecting marketing to a P &L statement.”
3:40

Tools for Effective Reporting

Andrew shares tools and methods for effective data reporting in marketing.

“So if I don't get around to three, you know, remind me.”
6:01

Choosing the Right Advertising Medium

Discussion on the importance of selecting appropriate advertising platforms based on industry.

“What is another thing that mistakes that people aren't doing other than not getting data and not giving specific reports?”
7:47

Testing and Optimizing Ad Campaigns

Insights on how to test and optimize ad campaigns for better results.

“Let me kind of rapid fire some industries and you can kind of tell, hey, yes, no, yes.”
11:15

Setting Realistic Expectations in Marketing

Andrew discusses the need for realistic expectations in digital marketing campaigns.

“What is the third mistake that you find that people run into just all the time?”
13:29

The Impact with Profit Methodology Explained

Andrew elaborates on his impact with profit methodology and its phases.

14:09

Shifting Business Models Post-iOS 14

Learn how the business adapted its model following significant changes in digital marketing.

“So we made a huge shift in our business model in 2021.”
16:51

The Role of Fractional CMOs

Understand the importance of hiring fractional Chief Marketing Officers for holistic business strategy.

“And a lot of times business owners or marketing departments don't understand their data.”
Show all 20 chapters
21:02

Testing Offers and Product Market Fit

Discover strategies for testing product offers to ensure market fit before scaling.

“So one of them is making sure you have your tracking ecosystem set up correctly.”
24:39

The Importance of Authenticity in Marketing

Learn how authenticity can influence marketing effectiveness through real-world examples.

“There was just too many things based on our design.”
27:38

Continuous Testing and Market Adaptation

Understand the necessity of ongoing testing and adaptation in marketing strategies.

“and felt like you're talking to a friend, that doesn't always work in other environments.”
28:00

The Importance of Testing in Marketing

Learn why constant testing is crucial for effective marketing strategies.

“You have to constantly be talking to someone like an Andrew that's going to help you through that and say, hey, I live and breathe this stuff.”
29:00

Finding Your Product-Market Fit

Discover strategies to validate your product-market fit through targeted testing.

“I'm going to bring it back again to test your offer via your existing social media, you know, fans and community, your email database, find some friends who can do some affiliate mailing.”
30:40

Identifying Bottlenecks in Scaling

Understand common obstacles to scaling and how to overcome them effectively.

“And each one of those, as we talked about before, it's different.”
33:50

The Right Talent for Scaling Marketing

Learn how to identify and utilize the right team members for scaling success.

“You always use the example, the analogy of Tarzan.”
36:50

Preparing for Effective Marketing Campaigns

Get prepared with actionable steps before launching high-budget marketing efforts.

“I love Christine, more than I could possibly tell you, but Christine will tell you, I'm not a Facebook marketer.”
39:20

Effective Strategies for Marketing Success

Explore key strategies for effective marketing and avoiding common pitfalls.

“These are the people that are in my vertical.”
42:01

Discussion on 'Fanatical Prospecting'

Learn about the book 'Fanatical Prospecting' and its impact on sales strategies.

“I was going to go look over here real quick because I have a really good book I want to bring on camera.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Proven Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Welcome to the Proven Podcast, where it does not matter what you think, only what you can prove. Our guest today, Andrew, the digital marketing strategist who developed the impact with profit methodology, as a proven success scaling requires more than just throwing money at Facebook ads. It demands a conscious strategy, relentless testing, and connecting with every campaign to your bottom line. The show starts now. Today, we're going to talk about the idea that there's all these ways to scale with Facebook ads or any of that, but we never talk about being conscious enough about how to create your ads to create your campaigns that are driven on both impact and can create profit.

0:33And that's why Andrew is here. So Andrew, walk me through your process. Welcome to the show. Let's get into it. Hey, Charles. Well, what I like to say is our unique way we approach digital marketing is our impact with profit methodology. We came up with this a few years ago because we saw some gaps in how marketing agencies, marketing departments were approaching digital marketing. And so we like to focus on conscious creatives. So are you creating, you know, copy and design that really puts the individual in the hero spot versus the company is the hero and the guru? That's one element in making sure all the user experiences very up to speed.

1:14I was just auditing a website for my friend's business, one of his competitors. You know, I went on it. It was loading slow. It looked like it was built in 1995. It had about 300 testimonials on it. It had one of those like loud shouting, you know, buy now style buttons. And that's just in fly with digital marketing in 2024. And I see so many, you know, copywriters, funnel builders who had funnels that were successful in 2010. and they keep on trying to rinse and repeat that 14 years down the line of that just not how the world works anymore. So that's the creative element of this rapid prototyping.

1:55So I hate it when people want to just launch, you know, a few creatives, few copy, few targeting and set it and forget it like it's a billboard. The advantage of digital marketing is that you can test so many different elements of your campaign and really figure out the bottleneck of what's stopping conversions from happening for your organization. And then lastly, is connecting marketing to a P &L statement. So how does marketing actually help to grow a business? Because any CEO you talk to is not going to care about your click-through rate, your impressions, reach. Is this actually helping me generate highly qualified leads?

2:31And are those leads becoming customers that buy? I love that you went in and you talked about this stuff about time. Hey, if it worked 10 years ago, that's adorable. We don't live in that world. We always talk about what have you done today? I also love that you talked about getting likes, getting followers and clicks. It's adorable, but how does it affect the bottom line? No one's in here just to create a relationship. We're just going to talk to people and they're going to come to our site. No, that's not the world we live. It's about a bottom line. If you're going to talk about scaling and they're going to do these things in a very effective way, that there's a very specific place.

3:04Can you give me an example of the streaming billboards and funnels that were there, you know, years ago. Good God. That are kind of like the, as soon as you see it, like the top three mistakes, you're like, just don't do this. When it comes to it, these are the three things you see all the time that it'll just save people. Just don't do these three things. And then we can get into very specific when we talk about creating impact and creating profit, going through, you know, kind of the methodology. Like, hey, guys, if you never interact with Andrew ever again, do this. So, you know, first off, what are the three big mistakes that people just, good God, why aren't you doing it?

3:39I'm going to ad lib a few in here. So if I don't get around to three, you know, remind me. So and I'll give some recent examples of what I've seen. So one is a project of ours where they had a prior advertising consultant on it and chatting with the CEO, you know, catching up with them, hearing what's going on. And he was super pissed off because he was not getting reporting from this individual. So getting your data, getting your reporting organized is a must in digital marketing. If you think just sending an email to the CEO saying like your campaign was good or I spent this, you know, this happened.

4:21Sure, they know, you know, money's hopefully coming back in. But we're digital marketers and we need providing much more in-depth reporting to clients or, you know, in-house, whatever that dynamic looks like. What tools are you using for that? Would you have ones that you specifically enjoy better than other ones when it comes to doing that reporting so you can give that report properly to it? Like which ones do you rely on? So we do a lot of Microsoft Excel. We're a lot of hand-to-hand combat with that. So we have all these custom formulas and everything that we built for years, which is how we populate our data into that.

4:55So we not only produce a report for clients, but then we send a weekly breakdown analyzing, you know, everything that we're working on with not only the data, but then our color commentary, like we're Pat McAfee breaking down everything that's that's going on. We also include a loom video explaining that. And we have a weekly call with all of our clients to hash out their campaigns and talk face to face. I think this is one of the things you and I have in common. The combination of whatever you send also connects it to a room video. Looms are so mission critical. You can rapid fire them really fast and it gets over there and it saves so much time.

5:32Also, I get to cheat a little bit here and take a little bit of a break from the podcast and know that you also have an Excel spreadsheet with your missus because you're expecting a little one very soon. So I'm cheating here and saying mazel tov. I'm exceptionally happy for you. I'm glad that she's mapped everything out. Sorry, back to the podcast. I thought that was going to be a sponsorship commercial. I didn't know where he got it. Not at all. I don't understand. You know me. I'm just leaving red spot. All right. So Excel, Loom, those are the things. Getting the things. So that's one example.

6:02What is another thing that mistakes that people aren't doing other than not getting data and not giving specific reports? I would say another big thing is forcing Facebook ads as the first advertising medium. So we've been around since 2012. Back then, Facebook was cool. People loved Mark Zuckerberg. He was a whiz kid. Public perception as Facebook has changed. Yeah, it's swapped on its head. iOS 14 happened, Russia hacking or whatever was going on with that, Cambridge Analytica, there's just been so much going on with Facebook over the years that it's not the, you know, just click a button and results happen, which is what it was feeling like for years from, you know, 13 to 20 or whatever that time horizon looked like.

6:54So we really want to work with a brand and figure out what advertising medium actually makes sense for them. And in some cases, Facebook ads don't make sense. We just started working with a B2B SaaS organization who has an AI product. And Facebook ads does not make sense in this scenario to get in front of senior vice presidents or presidents of organizations, I believe, is our avatar. We're going a much different route to get in touch with them between some LinkedIn outreach initiatives with email. We're advocating to do a podcast, actually, as well for that organization. And we think that's a better way to get in front of presidents of organizations.

7:36We're not talking about like your mom and pop trying to get in front of presidents of like Fortune 500 companies. So we're very much meeting them where they're at and where their avatar is. Let me kind of rapid fire some industries and you can kind of tell, hey, yes, no, yes. Let's see if that kind of fits in. So if you're selling some sort of goods online, you're digital, you're selling some sort of Amazon fulfillment type of thing, where would you kind of say, hey, this is where you kind of want to look versus not here if you're trying to do something like that? Well, I would say in general, Facebook is great in B2C environments.

8:12When you're getting into B2B, that's where the question can arise. And I have to give this caveat. So this is a long-winded way for me to answer your question is that I had a friend who worked at a B2B SaaS company and they'd split tested all the platforms at once. The best results came through Instagram. So at the end of the day, you have to put it out and test and see what happens. And I don't know the specifics of why Instagram was their best advertising medium, but it beat out Facebook, Google, LinkedIn, and YouTube through their split testing. Can you have a platform that you've seen just universally that has the best ROI, or is it just so unique based on the type of industry that you're playing?

8:56B2C Facebook, for sure. everything else is so specific to that organization and what they've gone on. And also, when you think about another platform, there's other things to think about. For instance, keyword volume. Is there even a keyword volume level? And are people actively searching for that? So if you have a coaching product, for instance, that might not be something someone is seeking out via a Google AdWords campaign versus we work with this Italian retreat center. and the keyword volume for like fancy yoga retreat Europe is out of control. So Google does great with them. And that was actually where we started our campaigns.

9:39So it's, it is phenomenally different, but you have to test it and what tools and what are the methodologies that, again, these are people wanting to scale their businesses. They want to get to them excellently. There aren't people just starting the, you know, the people who listen to this are scaling. What are some of the tools or some of the, some of the ways that you have proven that you can test. And I will go back to one more example that don't do, but I want to make sure we don't lose this. If you're testing, what are some of the tools that you're like, this works really well, this doesn't work really well, we've had really good experience with this versus that when it comes to testing your products?

10:12In terms of software that you could use to run the split test, that would be a better question for some of our advertisers of the specific software that we're using let me bring it back to more variations of creatives that would be great so we'll deploy um depending on the ad spend budget which is going to influence uh how many creatives you're to play so let's say it's a first month of split testing you're doing three to five thousand per month we would probably recommend a combination of eight variations of uh copy and then eight variations of design, motion animated, GIFs, video for that campaign.

10:54When you have a much higher ad spend budget, that's when you need to really, you know, increase the number of creators that you're going to be split testing and deploying. By default, you want to start with at least a different variance of that ad copy. In that three to five K per month ad spend budget, that's what a lot of our campaigns look like. Love it. All right. So we've got two mistakes. Let's get back to the third mistake. What is the third mistake that you find that people run into just all the time? Unrealistic expectations.

11:30I was not on this call, but I got a debrief earlier this afternoon of someone on their team. We have brought down their webinar CPL from 15 to 250 in Q1. Uh, he thinks a webinar CPL and a Facebook advertising campaign should be below a dollar. Uh, well, that's what we said, uh, as well. He spoke very enthusiastically about how that's realistic. And I don't know if he worked for Tony Robbins and that what Tony Robbins pulls off, but, uh, completely unrealistic expectation of what's possible, uh, in each type. and I'll break this down more for Facebook. Depending on the type of lead generation campaign you're running, the CPL is going to vary.

12:19So if you're doing a quiz campaign, under a dollar is probably possible. With that, you're going to get a high volume, but people do quizzes all the time and they just take it and leave. A webinar campaign is a much higher call to action for an individual. And it's a much bigger commitment to, you know, put on your calendar, show up for 45 minutes, which is why you're going to have a higher CPL. So we're thinking$5 to$7 for a webinar CPL is pretty solid in 2024. Solid. Under a dollar is completely ridiculous. Never going to happen. It's just, yeah. And I love when people are like, well, Tony Robbins, because I'm like, are you Tony Robbins?

13:00And also, I think it's really important where people are watching that when we're looking at the CPLs. Again, this doesn't matter. It's about impact of profit to your bottom line. That's all that matters. Look at your PNLs, your profit loss statements. how is this actually right are you generating income for this and i think that goes into where you know we've got through the stakes but your focus isn't on hey am i getting am i lowering this to the lowest cost or am i getting the best exposure you're one of the things i love about you is like am i increasing my bottom or how are we helping you earn more money so you can scale your business so now that we know the three things that are just don't do that which the last ones um and shocking there's no business i've ever worked in that they have unreal expectations okay um now that to do that if they want to scale and they want to you know obviously help out their mind online what are some of the things and what is your process that you go through that you found that works just religiously uh the impact with profit methodology or just in general I let me I'm going to address that, but also talk through what our three phases of running a campaign looks like, which ties into the impact with profit methodology.

14:09So we made a huge shift in our business model in 2021. So 2021 was when iOS 14 happened. It's when King Kong and Godzilla, Facebook and Apple started fighting each other. And we were just the fake. Did you like that metaphor? Yeah, I've heard that metaphor, but now it's going to stick. I'm stuck with that now forever. Thank you. It's another one of the things. We were just the Facebook advertising team before iOS 14. So iOS 14 was happening, and we thought we might be out of business in six months. There was about a six-month window of a warning. So we decided to shift the business model to one, hire a team of fractional chief marketing officers to start our client projects and then build up our back end services so we can support clients in a bigger variety of ways within digital marketing.

15:04So the phase one with us is consulting with a fractional chief marketing officer. We did that because I love advertisers. They're our core competency of our business model. They're also not the right person to think holistically about an entire business. They're also usually not the right person to feel the wrath of a CEO who's pissed that you missed your financial numbers. so we want that fractional CMO oh go ahead this is why when people come in all the time my CFO is telling this or my bookkeeper is telling me this I'm like your bookkeeper doesn't make decisions about where we're going with the company it just tells me what's going on but do not let him do that it's kind of like letting your gardener decide what you're going to eat it's not that it's not a good gardener it's a phenomenal gardener love what he does my landscape looks amazing I appreciate you for taking care of everything but you're not going to decide what goes into my body and then vice versa i'm not the guy who makes my meals decide how my lawns go so it's no offense and this is important i know because you gave a little bit of flavor going i love marketers yes it's important when you're scaling or hiring or doing anything to stay in your lane you've got a lane you know your lane stay in your lane double down on your strength outsource your weaknesses it's just a huge thing get ego out of the way i think that's the biggest problem i run into whenever i'm scaling people's companies when I brought in.

16:28It's the owner. They think this is my baby or I know everything. I'm like, yeah, don't. My favorite example, this is Steve Jobs. Steve Jobs says, as long as I'm alive, we're never going to do an iPad mini. We're never selling them. They're never going to take off. He released the iPad mini and now they sell like crazy and people are dying. So sorry, even Steve Jobs. Anyway, just wanted an input on that one because people don't get it. He's not picking on marketers. Just stay in your lane. Hire people who decide to do this. X, don't expect them to do well. And a lot of times business owners or marketing departments don't understand their data.

17:03So it's impossible to scale when you don't understand your numbers. So the fractional CMO in phase one is thinking holistically about really the entire business model and what role marketing has. So doing historical data gathering analysis, understanding the funnel, the Facebook ad campaigns, the messaging, the branding, the avatar, all those things that financial forecast and go to market plans. And then we come up with a new go to market plan for an organization. So within that, we have, you know, the P &L statement. That's part of that. The split testing recommendations are part of that. And then the creatives as well.

17:42and phase two for us is overhauling creatives. This is super important in a post iOS 14 world. Before iOS 14, a lot of advertising success was based upon your targeting and just pixeling and following people around the internet until infinity. That's no longer an option because of iOS 14 and people opting out. So creatives are super important and we don't want to pass that. It's like, have you, what's his, Peter Thiel? We don't want to have the Peter Thiel approach to branding. I don't know if you've ever heard that inside joke. It's probably not appropriate for this, but he doesn't. Yeah, we'll probably get out with that.

18:22We'll do it after recording. We'll do it in the right. We'll be four feet early. So we want to make sure you're having all the right creatives deployed not only in your advertising campaign, the copy, the design, the video, but making sure your backend sales funnel is actually going to nurture those leads up to the point of sale And whether that's, you know, a B2C business, that's a completely, you know, virtual checkout process via Skype, PayPal, whatever, or if they're actually being handed off to a sales rep and making sure that's a smooth process. And then for us, phase three is when we actually start running our marketing campaigns.

18:58And whether that's, you know, advertising on Facebook, you know, YouTube, Google, wherever that is. There are instances with B2B organizations where we'll do LinkedIn outreach or email outreach campaigns. And then from there, yeah, we're aligned on goals. We're running the marketing campaigns and, you know, let's run our split testing and start scaling. I'd like that we've, because you have all these books and I was just going through it. I was boxing up the things and I had all the books that I got from Russell Bronson years and years ago about how they're all these funnel books. I'm like, aw, they're so adorable.

19:32It was kind of like looking at a yearbook that I had when I was in high school. And I was like, aw, okay, that doesn't work anymore. Things are changing so radically and so impressively. I remember I was sitting down at an event and I was getting an argument with somebody. No, but iOS, the iOS dominates the market. That is most iOS, you know, there's more iOS phones than there are Android phones. And I was like, you want to double check your data? Because things have changed. We have this volume where just things aren't the way they used to be. So I love that you've taken this approach of going, hey, there was this way.

20:03And then King Kong and Godzilla showed up and these radically changed. All right. So we understand what mistakes people are doing. We understand that things have started to change and there's a specific three phrase process. And I love that your process doesn't start with, all right, let's just want to put Facebook ads and spray and clay and hope that the pixel and we just pop people and become stalkers, which I know this is a surprise that that's not working anymore. So if you guys are trying to do that, you're trying to scale, stop. So let's talk about what does create a profit. And let's talk about what does affect you.

20:35So walk me through that and say, okay, if people are sitting here right now going, all right, I get it. Andrew knows what he's talking about. I get that I made some of these mistakes, which hopefully you did not make the third one. That's embarrassing. But hopefully you're in a situation where like, okay, what do I need to do? What are things that I can do right now that I can pull over, take notes and say, okay, these are things that I need to do right now that I can do before I move to the next step, be it start stalking you and bothering you and your team. So what are the things I can do now?

21:05I'll just shout out a few. So one of them is making sure you have your tracking ecosystem set up correctly. We had a previous client last year who had, what were they in? They were in like WordPress and then there were ClickFunnels. They were in GoHighLevel. I think they might've had five different CRM tracking ecosystem. It was a complete nightmare. So it was actually impossible for us to run any advertising campaign until they cleaned that up. So when you were doing that and they switched over, what are the things that you took them to? We were like, all right, how are we cleaning this up? What is the process that you do to help them clean that up?

21:45Do you have any recommendations of things that they could do? This was too much for us. So we said, you need to figure this out yourself. No, see, and I love that. Because people understand like, oh, well, he's going to give me this advice. Sometimes the best advice you could do is outsource that. I am the keen of outsourcing. I don't outsource everything because I don't need a full-time CEO. I don't need a full-time CFO. I don't need a full-time CMO. There are times where I just need a fractional person to come in, fix this, and get out of the way. It's just this per diem type of work. We used to do this all the time when I worked at hospice.

22:16You don't always need a full-time nurse. Sometimes you just then that they're per diem, you as need them. So it is what it is. Now, going back to the fact that you're about to have a little one, you do need a full-time nanny, a part-time nanny, a night nanny, a nighttime nanny. So you need everything. I'm just saying, so you got to make a bunch more money. You have a staff of at least 70 ,000 to 80 ,000 people helping you out at all. All right. Back to the next thing. All right. So you're organizing data. So getting the tracking ecosystem all figured out, that's a super important thing. Let me even backtrack a little bit.

22:53And if this is not answering your question, let me know. We think about offer testing in three phases. I've been very much describing a company who's ready to scale. There are some instances of a client who has a completely new product to market. They might be bootstrapped. It's just reinvesting profits back in. Maybe they got some angel money. Maybe it's just a quick loan. So we recommend, one, testing your offer with your email list. if people who know, like, and trust you from your existing audience and social aren't going to buy from you, Facebook ads is not the right thing. And you probably don't even have a product market fit.

23:30So let's make sure that's aligned. Second tier is let's make sure, you know, this is converting via affiliates. This is going to give us another vote of confidence that you have product market fit. And then the third tier is really what I've been emphasizing today, which is more of the, you know scale mode for an organization so we really want to make sure that there's product market fit and you can bypass one and two if you have the capital and just go straight to ads and figure out do you have product market fit but for a lot of companies uh it's going to save them a lot of headache and uh you know pissed off conversations with their marketing team if they don't actually have a product market fit and they don't have anything differentiated yeah don't don't be that guy that thought it was going to be a thousand.

24:14I don't recommend in any shape or form, for me personally, in my experience, even if it's a short window, you're going to want to test it. You want to test it with people who are already KLT. You're going to want to sit there and just interact with them and see what their reactions are. When we started out and we were doing the scale lab and we were creating the lab reports, we created this very detailed, just books, just had walls of information. And we found out that the information was phenomenal, but we overwhelmed in the audience. There was just too many things based on our design. Now, if we had gone to market and pushed this all out and gone nuts, we would have got ego.

24:47I mean, we wouldn't have known why. Wouldn't have known why it wasn't going to convert. But because we gave it to an environment of people who actually we enjoyed talking to, and I exposed it to my mastermind, they're like, oh, love the data. It's too much. You fried my brain. I was like, okay, what do we do? Then I expanded out to four or five more pages. Don't try and jam everything. And we're like, oh, but I wouldn't have gotten that feedback from a Facebook guy. I wouldn't have gotten that. I it doesn't work and i said well it's not okay well i don't have a product market i'm just i'm msol so i think it's really important to go out and reach beyond your friends and family because they're a lie to you you know it's a surprise but go out and reach out say hey this is what i have this is what's going on is it converting it's just going to generate any constraint for me and i think those steps um when you're doing this and you're doing this testing and this is just me kind of finding out do you have copies or ads or things that hey we tried this it didn't work or examples that i might be able to squeeze out of you down the road we can put them into the lab report just saying uh i'm sure they're in a google folder somewhere that i don't know how to operate so they're in our backend system somewhere awesome i'm gonna i'll reach out to your team and we'll get exact examples of like before and after and we'll try and get it into the org to help people out okay you know what's interesting I'll give one example of, yes, some split test of ours that we were wrong about.

26:03So we have some clients who can film very high quality produced video. And we told them, let's split test and just take an iPhone and record something. There are instances where the iPhone selfie video actually does better than the highly produced video as it feels more authentic. And you're talking to a friend. I'm not saying that's you know all cases but we had one who her best ads for the longest time were just her under a tree as it was kind of like a hippie-ish product just like I built a selfie video and it felt like a friend was introducing you to the brand and it felt more personal versus the highly produced you know video and video team and hair and makeup people in our belief just didn't feel as connected to the CEO and their vision so that's a test that didn't work.

26:54for us. Yeah, I love that because it's those little idiosyncrasies that matter. For example, we were doing, I was working with a client and we were trying to get better interaction and get better impressions, get people to spend more time. And we changed the titles. We had you, how you can earn more money or how you, we added you, the power of you. We then took that and we said, okay, but we're going to personalize this in a white paper. We're going to sit there and say, hey, this is what you need to do. Because at the time I was doing tech, we're like, this is how you need to install it. Maybe you have not done this or you haven't done this.

27:24And it just, We got forward feedback. They hated us. We feel like you're attacking us because you don't think we know how to install a printer paper. And we're like, wait, what? So what works over here in the social media world of having how you can make money or making a very personalized message to you, just like your client did with a cell phone and felt like you're talking to a friend, that doesn't always work in other environments. So this is why it's so important. You talked about having about eight tests. It's so important to test and understanding that what might have worked six months ago doesn't work anymore.

27:52You know, a great example of that is COVID. COVID changed the market. It just, it is what it is. Things do not operate in the same world because the environment has changed. So it just isn't. You have to constantly be testing. You have to constantly be talking to someone like an Andrew that's going to help you through that and say, hey, I live and breathe this stuff. This is my world. I love marketing. Bless you guys and scaling and what you guys do. God bless you guys. It's kind of like when I talk to my accountant and new tax levels come out. He gets excited about it and he tells me about it.

28:20I try my best not to fall asleep in the middle of lunch, but it happens. I hear someone smarter than you get out of your way, understand what worked this month isn't going to work next month or a little bit worse. All right. So when we've got that, we're doing these different tests. We're making it personalized. We're trying these different things. You're testing on your own before you spend all the money on Facebook. And we're going to show some examples of what works and doesn't work. Where do we go from there? What is our next step if we're sitting at home and they want to try something? What is the next thing they can do?

28:52I would say, and I'll bring it back to someone who might be more in the, do I have a product market fit? And then I'll get into, you know, you're ready to scale. So do you have product market fit? I'm going to bring it back again to test your offer via your existing social media, you know, fans and community, your email database, find some friends who can do some affiliate mailing. One of our clients, he had awesome success with his docuseries going around to some people in his very specific niche on after-elect communication and trying to get them to host screenings of his film in a donation-based model.

29:30So he did that, you know, rinse and repeat however many times it was and build up enough data that we were able to go to an organization with a 600 ,000 person email database with his exact avatar of a person and say, hey, this is what we've done in all these tests. If you mail for us, you know, with two or three emails, this is a revenue we think could come back to your business with, you know, copy and paste this, mail it out. And you could just be making money like that. I'm oversimplifying this by that. No, it's amazing. No. and then went to the mega affiliate partner who then did the mailing for them.

30:06And I love that it was a stepped approach. They didn't just go to the mega affiliate partner and said, spray and spray. They were like, okay, I know exactly who my audience is. I know exactly how they respond. I know exactly what words I need to use. I have my offer flushed out. I know my offer works, which is a huge problem that some people have. You'll drive the people to the site, to the funnel, to whatever it is, or to the person on the phone, and it just won't convert if you haven't perfected that process. you know overnight success takes over a million years so it just it just it takes time to do these things so i think it's so important it's going to save you time and it's going to save you money when you're scaling this to have this data that has been analyzed with a fine-tooth comb so you know what works you know i know it sounds crazy but when you send messages out matters not only the text not only the content not only the copy but when it's actually been set up morning Saturday, Tuesday, all of these things matter when you're scaling.

30:57And each one of those, as we talked about before, it's different. It's different based on your niche. It's different based on your offer. And it's different based on your product and market, if it just makes sense. There's so many different little things. And since you've done that for so long, are there certain tests that you're like, you know what? These type of tests or these type of things, we know when in doubt, if the person only is going to get one type of swing at this, and they can only do one or very small swings, do these type of tests first versus these other type of tests so that we do create that impact and we do create that profit line.

31:33Let me bring it back to kind of the phase one report is we really want to understand what is the bottleneck to scale. And this can be a lot of different situations and I'll give you some use cases. And I hope this answers your question in a roundabout way. So we just had a recent client who came on board. And as we were analyzing, you know, why can't they scale? They had a live launch in the fall. They really think they could double it. You know, what's the reason? And a big part of that was simply because they had the wrong person in the right seat. Or is that? Yeah, wrong person in the wrong seat.

32:09This person was not right in any scenario. he was a very junior marketer trying to scale a campaign so it was really in that situation you just made a bad hire and if you want to scale you need to bring in these marketers to take this to the next level we had a different use case with a client where they just simply weren't willing to test enough creatives you know the campaign had plateaued out which happens when you're scaling in Facebook world, and it can be a lot of different situations. Their target audience was hit up way too many times with the same creatives. They need to do a lot more testing and stop outsourcing to Asia for$10 an hour because we know it's cheap, but it's equally as crappy.

33:00Yes, exactly. We had another use case of a client from a few years ago where they had an in-house marketer who was the right person in the wrong seat. Different scenarios that first one. So he was great at copy, email marketing, just overall marketing strategy. And he picked up doing Facebook ads for them just because he was a marketer. So he got it to 3K a month in Aspen and could never break through to the next level. So he delegated out to us, seasoned marketers and marketing agency. And we've spent anywhere from 10 to 60 ish per month, depending on, you know, offers and all those things. So they really just needed to get this guy into a zone of genius.

33:48And yeah, he built the campaign to 3k, but he wasn't the right person to go from three to 50k per month in ad sped. You always use the example, the analogy of Tarzan. When you're swinging through the vines, you're holding another one vine and then you grab another other ones, sometimes you got to let go of the one that's really safe and secure and you got to let it go in order to keep that lamenting. And in this case with this marketer, you know, a marketer's not a scaler. Sorry, marketers out there, you're going to try and kill me for that. You're not scalers. And your scalers aren't systems guys.

34:17Sorry. And it's just important to get out of the way and fix these things and to understand that what person who got you here isn't going to get you there. And there's nothing wrong with that. There's nothing wrong with this person. Just as you said and let them sit in their zone of genius when they do these type of things. So this is what it is. One of the things that when you talk about your genius, one of the things that you're like, wow, this is what my agency does better than anybody else. This is our model. This is what really, really, you know, we know the mistakes. We know the things that people are making mistakes for.

34:52When you sit there and say, hey, when we show up and we talk to Andrew, holy crap, this is what they do better than anyone else. and this is the stuff that you know you're getting consistent results with. What are the things that you have found that you're like, this is why we do what we do. These are some of the things that without giving away the special sauce, but the stuff that I did, this is it. We found out that when we put flamingos on babies and make them run around in circles, it took work, whatever that narrative is. I would say for us, what we're most well known for is media buying for online education organizations.

35:30So it's an organization coming to us who wants to grow and scale their, you know, Facebook, Google, YouTube. We don't really like LinkedIn and TikTok, never had great success, but we know how to operate on those platforms. And their product stack tends to be books to courses to events, certification training programs. What am I missing? Maybe there's one more, but that whole product stack, you know, we'll take on clients who won't be in that vertical from time to time, that's really a game time call with us. We worked with a pro soccer team a few years ago as a lifelong soccer player. You know, I wasn't gonna pass that opportunity.

36:06I've mentioned some B2B SaaS organizations we've worked with. That's very because I have a few individuals on my team who have a B2B SaaS background and I know they could come and deliver in that situation. So really the clients come to us because they have that scaling problem with our media buying campaigns and they don't know why they can't go from three to 50 K per month or whatever that looks like in that situation. Or yeah, they're at a big launch and they need to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars. And you're like, how the heck do we do this? And yeah, stop outsourcing to Asia for$10 an hour.

36:41Sometimes a, you know, a premium. There are some people in Asia that are phenomenal, but like my Viennese in the Philippines, and that's kind of that Asian environment. She's phenomenal. I love Christine, more than I could possibly tell you, but Christine will tell you, I'm not a Facebook marketer. This is not what I am. So find the person, not saying that there's not people who can, but find the person again and be willing to pay for it. Because from what I've found is whenever I tried to go cheap, especially with marketing, it always bites me in the air. So what are some things that if you've got someone that's like, all right, you know what, I get it.

37:17I know I'm going to have to drop a couple of bucks to get this done. what are some of the things that I can do now to prepare myself before I get on the call, before I drop XYZ dollars, that I can get my ducks in a row that someone can do before they go, all right, I'm here, what's going on? We already talked about doing some of this testing in your own network with people already that KLTU. We already talked about doing that. But when we're talking about writing copy or we're talking about doing creatives, are there certain places that you're like, you know what? I really like these are the people who are doing creative reading.

37:46video. I don't recommend, take a look at that. Other than just your competition, these are some of the places that have some really great resources that we can kind of give people who are listening to the podcast, like, okay, I get it. I got to get my ducks on the road to save time before I do swap to sell whatever. Yeah. Let me clarify. I have nothing against talent from Asia. That was not a hate pill rant I was going on. That was, I don't know, the horse I was trying to say, don't just take the cheaper route because it's cheap. uh just making that uh disclaimer you know nothing against facebook advertisers nothing against anyone uh we're going to divide your home address and your own phone over and we're going to send it to all of asia and they're going to come find you uh we're going to give them the gate code so that they can get in and yeah you get to talk to them direct i so i would say you know if you're in the um you know coaching oriented space with those product mark uh product stack that i mentioned I always say check out what Tony Robbins is doing.

38:43I think his team is top of the line in just everything that they do, not only from the virtual conferences they put on, their creatives. I think they're very top notch. What you can also do is go to a website called Facebook Ads Library, which allows you to see all ads run by any Facebook page. So if there are people in your vertical that you want to do some competitor analysis on go to facebook ads library and they'll be able to show you you know everything that they're doing exactly what they're doing and then those are the ones you create those kind of eight tests from you know you got to test that okay well this is what i go susan's my competition you know i really think that she's doing great you can actually put that up and start working with your team and then again when you go and you do find someone who clearly is not from asia at this point i'm still sending them your address you can give and say, hey, these are the people that are in my niche.

39:39These are the people that are in my vertical. This is what they're doing. Here, let's talk about it. This is what I've got. And that'll help out. This is what we try to create. And before you start getting in the environment, because again, this is, seriously, when you get to this point and you're paying the five, six figures at ad spending, you're doing these campaigns that are at that level, you want to make sure you're as effective as possible. And that doesn't, for me, happen at the five to six figure level. That happens when you're lower and you're doing these baby tests and you're doing it with people you already know, just like the example I gave earlier.

40:08So I know you've got to wrap it up and we've got to get going here. If there's one thing that you could tell someone, please don't do this, and one thing you could tell, please do do this, do do them. They're going to be used to that very soon. You've got a little one coming, so get used to that. One of the two things, and those two divides, and again, mazel tov, I'm having a little... So, thank you. Don't do this. Absolutely do this. One of those two things.

40:34do this incorporate video into your marketing whether that's in your advertising campaigns and your landing page or email sequences just more video the better I the example I gave earlier of this split test between the selfie video and the highly produced video and just know like you can get by with a lot just on your cell phone so don't do

41:03I'm going to go back I was going to go back to the whole unrealistic expectations. The way we break goals with clients is we reverse engineer back instead of just pulling something out of thin air of$1 CPLEs on a webinar funnel. That makes no sense. That's never going to happen. Or clients who want to have I was just chatting with someone last week who wanted 40 booked sales meetings per week to go from zero to 40. And so I was like, yeah, I was like, okay, that's, that's a look great. Yeah. It's really good to walk things. It doesn't mean it's going to happen. All right. Last question, because I think we got to wrap it up here.

41:49Is there one book? It doesn't even have to be related to what you're doing. One book, this book absolutely changed my life. I highly recommend it. Is there one book you have? Charles's book, which I don't know the name of and I've never read. I'm just kidding. Thank you. Look away for free. That doesn't count. I was going to go look over here real quick because I have a really good book I want to bring on camera. Go for it. By the way, as you guys can tell, completely unprepared for this. I like doing this. I like dropping random questions for those of you guys who follow. Sorry, Andrew was not prepared.

42:23So what do you got? I'm only half of the way through with this. Whoa, you can hear a little audio issues there. So I'm only half the way through with this. It's called Fanatical Prospecting. Because I had such a huge influx of sales meetings, I started to book. I put a pause on it. I was like, I've done so much already. I can see I'm not even halfway through. I'm like an eighth of the way through with this book. This is fantastic. It was recommended to me by a friend who's a fractional VP of sales. and a little fire under my butt of, you know, it was one of those like, oh, I'm a POS. I'm not doing nearly enough of what I need to do.

43:06So that was a great book that I'm in the middle of reading. And so what was the name of the book again? It is Fanatical Prospecting by Jeb. I was going to say Blunt, but Blount. But close enough. All right. Perfect. Thank you so much, Andrew, for jumping on the podcast. We will get all those resources. I will have my team reach out and reach out and get some of those trainings for you. So any last things you want to wrap up before we go away, I just want to say goodbye to the people. I'll just say goodbye and adios. Shabbat shalom. That's it for today's episode. Here's the truth. What worked yesterday won't work for tomorrow.

43:42And what works for someone else might not work for you. Test everything. Measure everything. Never stop adapting. And only implement what's proven.

From the publisher

In this episode, Charles sits down with Andrew Gottlieb of No Typical Moments, a digital marketing expert who shares his unique "impact with profit" methodology for scaling businesses using Facebook ads and other digital marketing strategies.

Andrew reveals the common pitfalls businesses face when attempting to scale their digital marketing efforts, such as relying on outdated tactics, forcing Facebook ads as the first advertising medium, and setting unrealistic expectations. He breaks down the importance of crafting conscious creatives that resonate with your target audience and emphasizes the need for rapid prototyping and testing to identify and address bottlenecks in your marketing funnel.

Throughout the episode, Charles and Andrew dive deep into the three-phase process for scaling your business with digital marketing. Andrew stresses the importance of connecting marketing efforts to your P&L statement and ensuring that your campaigns are generating highly qualified leads that convert into paying customers.

Gain valuable insights into the essential components of a successful digital marketing campaign, from setting up a clean tracking ecosystem to testing your offer with your existing audience before investing heavily in paid advertising. Andrew shares real-world examples of split tests and case studies, demonstrating the impact of authentic, personalized creatives in driving conversions.

Whether you're a seasoned digital marketer or a business owner looking to scale your online presence, this episode is packed with actionable advice and proven strategies for creating marketing campaigns that deliver both impact and profit. Tune in to discover how Andrew's "impact with profit" methodology can help you navigate the ever-changing landscape of digital marketing and achieve sustainable growth for your business.

Key Takeaways:

  • Uncover the three critical blunders in digital marketing that can derail your business growth, and learn how to navigate around them
  • Discover a proven, three-step approach to supercharge your business's expansion while making a positive impact
  • Learn the essential strategy you must implement before investing in any marketing campaign to ensure its success

Head over to https://provenpodcast.com/  to download your exclusive companion guide, designed to guide you step-by-step in implementing the strategies revealed in this episode.

Key Points:

1:10 Impact with Profit Methodology
5:54 Importance of Detailed Reporting
7:29 Finding the Right Advertising Medium
10:14 Importance of Split Testing
12:00 Unrealistic Expectations in Advertising
15:43 Fractional CMO Importance
17:46 Historical Data Analysis
19:29 Running Marketing Campaigns
23:06 Organizing Data
25:01 Importance of Testing
29:28 Product Market Fit Testing
32:10 Understanding Agency's Strengths
37:50 Preparing for Call
41:08 Incorporating Video Marketing

More from Proven Podcast

All episodes