My Property Is Losing Money: Should I Sell or Pivot? (Rookie Reply)

0:00What if the project you spent five months bleeding into is now worth less than the credit card debt that you actually racked up trying to finish it. And you have to decide today whether you are going to sell it or keep it. Or maybe you finally agreed to partner with someone who can fund the deal that you can't buy yourself, but now you're wondering if a handshake 50-50 is going to cost you your friendship and your first paycheck. And once the keys are in your hand and the wire is sent, what do you actually do in those first 30 days before a single tenant walks through the door? Today we're answering three questions from the BiggerPockets forums that hit exactly where rookies hold the most pressure right now.

0:43This is the Real Estate Rookie Podcast. I'm Ashley Kerr. And I'm Tony J. Robinson. And with that, let's get into today's first question. So our first question comes from the BiggerPockets forums. And it says, I have a property that I have remodeled that is ready to hit the market. Unfortunately, after crunching the numbers, I will not be making any profit if I actually sell it. In this market and with interest rates rising, does it make sense to hold onto this property and rent it out instead of selling and walking away with no profit. For the experts out there, what would you suggest? Should I refinance and rent it out?

1:14The hard money loan balance is about$400 ,000 and a possible rent in the area is$3 ,000 to$3 ,500, or should I just sell it and recoup my investment without any profits? Comments would be greatly appreciated. Well, first, I don't think this person is alone, that as the market has shifted, There's been more folks who probably lost money on flips. I've got a flip right now. Actually, I just went under contract in the past week on that flip that I've been trying to sell. And remind me, how long was that flip? Over a year, right? You were trying to sell it? It was over a year that we had it on the market.

1:48Yeah, we're recording this in May of 2026. And we listed that property right at the end of 2024. four. So it was like December, I think, or November, maybe 2024, that we listed the property, it was up for a year, I took it off the market, and I relisted it about a month ago. And now we got some traction, but it's, I don't know, I think 30 grand under asking. So we listed at 399, we're under contract at 370. So I guess I'll like give my just quick story on that, because I feel like it's similar to this, because I, I went through the same mental exercise on this deal. It's like, okay, well, what do we do?

2:26And like the basic math was, I looked at, okay, do we turn this into a short-term rental because the opportunities were there? Or do I cut my losses and sell it at a loss? And what I looked at, the property actually could do from a revenue perspective, could do decently well. It's in a market where the competition is incredibly strong and I'm pretty confident we could go out there and do well. But when I compare the cost of what we would have to spend to both refinance out of my private money note, and then also fully furnish the property, it was a much bigger number than if we just sold at a loss.

3:02So that was the math I looked at. It's like, okay, how much am I going to spend to get into this deal? And then if we just sold, what would that look like? And for me, it financially made more sense to go the route of selling. And because I was working with private money lenders as opposed to hard money lenders, um my i had the the lender who was in the last lean position um he's investing or he he gave me the funds for like a retirement account so he doesn't need the funds today anyway and he was fine refinancing that shortfall into a longer note as well so even though we're losing money on this deal i don't have to write a big check at closing we're just kind of spreading that that loss out i think it was like a 36 month note or something like that so he's getting a slightly higher interest rate he's still getting a return on his capital without having to redeploy it and I'm saving myself from having to write a big check at closing.

3:48So that was a math that I went through. It was like, okay, what's the total cost for refinancing and keeping? What kind of return do I think I'll get there? What's the total cost for me if I just sell this at a loss, and what makes the most sense? So that was my thought process on that specific deal. So I think it has to do a lot with what you are, first of all, the numbers. What did the numbers look like in each scenario? So how much money would you actually be losing if you sell the property, and how much money would you be losing a month if you rent it out, or maybe you'd actually be making money.

4:18So you need to find out how you could refinance it, what your mortgage would be, and kind of break down the numbers from there. That's the first step you have to do is run the numbers in each scenario and say they're both a loss. So with that loss, are you able to maintain that loss and pay that difference that you owe for the mortgage every single month or for the expenses and then wait it out and maybe in a couple of years be able to sell the property? Or do you have cash savings that you could go ahead and dump into the property? Maybe you're taking a lower mortgage on the property. So I think really running the numbers, then also kind of looking at what you are comfortable with doing.

4:58Do you even want to be a landlord? Do you want to have tenants in place? So I think you have a lot of questions to look at for the numbers and then just for yourself personally too is what you actually want to deal with. Maybe you would rather take the loss and sell it because you don't wanna be a landlord and you don't wanna have tenants in the property. Coming up, what happens when your partner brings 100 % of the money and you bring 100 % of the work? Is 50-50 actually fair or are you about to give away your first paycheck? We'll break it down right after this quick word from our show sponsors.

5:33Vacation is expensive. Your empty place doesn't have to be. If you're heading out of town and your home is sitting empty, you could list your space on Airbnb while you're away and turn those unused nights into extra income. And with Airbnb's co-host network, getting started is more straightforward than most people think. You can hire a vetted local co-host with hosting experience who could create your listing, manage reservations, handle guest communications, and even provide on-site support for guests during their stay. So while you're away spending money, your space could be working in the background, bringing in extra cash.

6:09Find a co-host at airbnb.com slash host. Do you ever notice how every passive investment somehow turns into a very active lifestyle? Active spreadsheets, active phone calls, active stress. Here's a better question. What if you could buy brand new construction homes, 10 % below market value in the best markets across the country without making real estate your second job? That's exactly what rent to Retirement does. They're a full-service, turnkey investment company handling everything for you. In some cases, investors get 50 % to 75 % of their down payment back at closing, plus interest rates as low as 3.75%.

6:44They've partnered with BiggerPockets for over a decade, helping thousands invest smarter. If you want to do the same, visit biggerpockets.com slash retirement to learn more. When you buy your first rental property, there's usually a moment right before you pull the trigger where your brain starts spiraling a little. What if I'm making a mistake? What if I can't figure this out? What if this whole thing becomes way more complicated than I expected? Honestly, building any business feels like that at first. And for a lot of investors, that next step is creating a brand, a website, or even a business around what they're building.

7:18And I've learned this myself. Whether it's real estate, building a brand, launching a side business, or creating something online, the hardest part is usually just getting started before you feel fully ready. As a consumer, I use Shopify-powered stores all the time. Chances are you do too. Some of the brands I buy from regularly run on Shopify, and you probably wouldn't even know it because everything just works. The checkout is smooth, the experience is easy, and that's exactly what you want if you're building a business and trying to earn customers' trust. That's why Shopify makes so much sense.

7:52Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10 % of all e-commerce in the US. From brands just getting started to household names, you can build a professional online store with ready-to-use templates that actually look good, even if you're not tech savvy. Shopify also has AI tools that help write product descriptions, page headlines, and even improve product photography. And instead of juggling five different platforms, Shopify puts everything in one place, from payments to inventory to analytics. Plus, Shopify helps you market your business with easy email and social media campaigns so you can actually reach customers.

8:30It's time to turn those what ifs into with Shopify today. Sign up for your$1 per month trial today at shopify.com slash rookie. Go to shopify.com slash rookie. That's shopify.com slash rookie. Okay, welcome back. So today's question, it says, hey guys, I'm getting close to closing on a deal with an equity partner? This will be my first partnership, so I have no frame of reference. What's the best way to split our equity if he's providing the down payment and I'm managing the asset on my own? I want to be fair to both of us. Thanks for your time. Okay, so I think there's one piece of this question that is missing that is not being considered.

9:13You have one person bringing the capital for a down payment, and then you have somebody that's going to be doing the sweat equity and managing the asset. But what about the leverage? What about the mortgage? Whose name is the debt going into? Are you both going to be on the debt? Is just the person providing the capital going to be on the debt? Because that is some, I guess, I don't know how to phrase this. What's the word I'm looking for, Tony, where it's not like it's something you're providing to the deal is the person who's signing on the debt, who has the good credit, the good debt to income, and is taking the risk of the debt on this property too.

9:53So for example, say Tony provides the down payment, Tony's also going and getting the debt in his name and I'm going to manage the property. I have a little, I have less skin in the game, I would say. As in like, if I decide this property is not working out, I don't want any more of it. I walk away. I didn't lose any capital. I don't risk the mortgage payments not being paid. If they don't get paid, oh well, it's not my name on the debt. I just lost the time that I was managing the property. So I do think that's a third element that really needs to be considered in this as to whose name is going on the debt also.

10:28Yeah, it's a great point, Ash. And I think once you have that solidified, like the 50-50, I think is, yeah, it is a fair structure for a lot of deals because even for the person who's carrying the debt and is bringing the capital, the extent of their work is really done once the property closes. And really all they had to do was, you know, obviously that there's some pain in qualifying for the loan and doing all that stuff. But for the most part, their work was signing some documents, right? But for you as a person who's going to continue managing this property, your work will persist for however long you own that property.

11:04So if you own it for five years, 10 years, 30 years, you are the person who's signing up to agree to manage that deal. So there's a lot of work that goes into that. So honestly, I think 50-50 is pretty fair in that scenario. I think one thing I will recommend is that, especially if you're doing this on a first deal, I wouldn't necessarily start an actual business with this person yet. Don't stand up an actual LLC together. Just test the first deal with you guys separately, each owning your ownership. You've got your entity that owns 50%. They've got their entity that owns 50 % and use that as a way to kind of date.

11:38And then if you guys like that experience, So a joint venture agreement. Exactly, right? It's like a JV between your entity and theirs. And then only if you guys enjoy that process, then maybe stand up and see together. But I see some folks who are just like super trigger happy on like setting up all these additional LLCs. And it sounds cool on paper, but it does, I think, add a certain layer of complexity. But on that note, Ash, I think whatever structure you and this other partner decide on, make sure you get it down in writing. ash and i co-authored a book for bigger pockets called real estate partnerships uh so you can read that book to get a better sense of what those you know what those agreements typically have inside of them but uh i think the more clarity you can have on what the structure looks like uh and getting that memorialized in some way the less chance there is for friction moving forward um like just writing things down in general i think helps a lot when you get in some of those situations.

12:33But I think in general, guys, 50-50 is a fine structure. But at the end of the day, there's no right or wrong answer. It's whatever you and that other person both feel is fair. And there's a million different ways you can skin the same cat. We're always talking about Ash's first deal where she gave that person a sweetheart deal. It's like they got whatever, equity percentage, but they also got paid back. It was a great deal for them. So there is no right a wrong answer. It's just making sure you guys are both happy, you're both protected, and you've really thought through all the different scenarios and how you'll handle those before they actually happen.

13:09All right, so we're going to take a quick break before our last question. But while we're going, if you have not yet, be sure to subscribe to the Real Estate Rookie YouTube channel. You can find us at Real Estate Rookie. And if you want to be a guest on the podcast, head over to biggerpockets.com slash guest, and you might just be the next rookie that we interview for the rest of the audience. We'll be right back after this.

13:30If you've been listening to the show for a while, you've heard us talk about Lightstone Direct, the direct-to-investor platform from Lightstone, a$12 billion real estate firm that invests 20 % plus of the equity in each investment right alongside accredited investors. Right now, they're inviting investors into Hidden Lakes, a 384-unit apartment community in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Lightstone is acquiring it at a 12 % discount to comparable sales, and they already own and operate 10 ,000 apartment units in Michigan. So they know the market cold. The deal is targeting a 7.3 % net cash-on-cash return to LPs and a 13 % net IRR and a four-year hold.

14:14Accredited investors only$100 ,000 minimum. All investments involve risk. Visit lightstonedirect.com forward slash BP. Most investors only think about insurance when something goes wrong. A tenant injury, storm damage, loss of rent. Then suddenly, the cheapest policy doesn't feel like the best one anymore. That's why a lot of BiggerPockets investors use steadily for landlord insurance designed specifically for rental properties. Whether you own one property or a growing portfolio, they make it simple to get covered properly. And BiggerPockets Pro members get an extra 5 % off their landlord insurance premiums.

14:51Visit biggerpockets.com slash landlord insurance to get a quote today. New Year, clean slate, and maybe a vacancy that needs to get filled fast? That's where Avail comes in. With Avail, rental listings can be published to 24 top rental sites with one click. Completely free. That includes places renters are already searching, like Realtor.com, Apartments.com, Redfin, and more. No copying and pasting. No juggling multiple platforms. Just one listing that shows up everywhere. If getting rentals organized and filled fast is on the list this year, start with Avail. Sign up for free at avail.co slash biggerpockets.

15:24That's A-V-A-I-L dot C-O slash biggerpockets. Billion-dollar investors don't typically park their cash in high-yield savings accounts. Instead, they often use one of the premier passive income strategies for institutional investors, private credit. Now, the same passive income strategy is available to investors of all sizes, thanks to the Fundrise Income Fund, which is more than$600 million invested and a 7.97 % distribution rate. With traditional savings yields falling, it's no wonder private credit has grown to be a trillion dollar asset class in the last few years. Visit Fundrise.com slash pockets to invest in the Fundrise Income Fund in just minutes.

16:06The fund's total return in 2025 was 8 % and the average annual total return since inception is 7.8%. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Current distribution rate as of 12-31-2025. Carefully consider the investment material before investing, including objectives, risks, charges, and expenses. This and other information can be found in the income funds prospectus at fundrise.com slash income. This is a paid advertisement. All right, guys, welcome back. Our final question comes from the BiggerPockets forums, and it says, I just closed on my first investment property. Congratulations.

16:35On paper, the numbers work. I walked through it with everyone I consider an advisor, but the moment I saw the wire amount on the closing statement, reality finally hit. Now I'm sitting here with the keys and I'm torn. Should I spend the first 30 days setting up systems, getting the LLC, insurance, and bookkeeping dialed in before listing it? Or should I race to find a tenant so the property isn't bleeding money? What do you wish you'd done in those first 30 days that you didn't? So I got, well, first, congratulations. Like I said, like it's always a great thing to, I think, to have the property closed on.

17:08But some of these things I hope you would have gotten done before closing, like insurance. That's typically something you want in place, like during your due diligence period is during your closing period is when you're setting up insurance. Yeah, if you don't have proper insurance on the property, that would be the absolute first thing that I would go tackle is getting the right policy in place. Because even if the property is vacant, you still want to make sure that it's properly insured. So that's the first thing that jumps out at me, Ash. I don't know what your thoughts are on that piece. Yeah, so I'm going to go even further back before you even close on the property, like just making sure that you've switched all the utilities in your name.

17:46And then when you have actually closed, like confirm that you have account numbers, what your account numbers are, I keep a utility sheet for each of my properties. And when I switch the utilities into my name, I'm putting the provider, their contact information, anywhere I'd log in, what the login is, my account number, maybe where the meter is located for the utility service, any information like that. So I can always easily access it. So I think for me, one of the biggest things is going through your property and documenting your property. Because if you own that property for 10 years, like I have a property, I've had the same tenant in there for 10 years that I've owned this property.

18:30I have not been in that unit since I walked to the property 11 years ago before I actually closed on it. I could not tell you where the HVAC is. I could not tell you where the electrical panel is. I could not tell you, you know, what type of flooring is in that unit. Okay. Now, any property that I've bought within the last several years, I can look up all of that stuff because I've documented it and I make myself a sheet and it's just my unit information sheet. So every time I close on a property, I'm going through and writing down as much information about it. And I've actually put it at biggerpockets.com slash resources and you can download it there for free.

19:09But just I'm documenting my property and things that I may need to know in the future. Like if I send a handyman out to a property, I'm able to tell them exactly where the water shutoff is. Or if my tenant calls and says water is shooting all over, I'm telling them where the water shutoff is. So I think that is like a really big thing that a lot of people miss and don't do. And then they kind of scramble when it comes time to actually need that information. Or just like you said, setting up the insurance, Tony, like that should be done before closing on the property. But if you are scrambling to do that, the insurance is going to have questions about the property that you should have some of that information for, such as, you know, when was the roof last updated?

19:51What type of roofing is on there? Is that metal? Is it shingles? Things like that. I think going back to the core part of this question, though, is like, what should they do first, setting up all those things or going after their tenants. I think there's probably a reality where you can do both, right? You know, there's Pareto's principle, right? Like the 80-20 rule, you know, 80 % of your results come for 20 % of your actions. And I think you've got to find that 20 % that's going to move the needle 80 % for you in this situation. And getting your tenants in place is probably one of those things that's going to move the needle.

20:20We don't want you sitting on this property for weeks and, you know, months without generating any revenue. But we also want to make sure that you have, you know, like the right insurance in place and things like that. So I would tackle both of those things simultaneously. So yeah, go, go set up your listing and distributed, you know, whatever, you know, platform you want to go to, like, go find your tenants, Facebook marketplace, you know, whatever tools are out there, but, but go start listing the unit. And then while you're waiting for folks to come in, you can go work on, okay, let me put the lease together.

20:48Let me go sit down with it within with a real estate attorney for my market to put the lease together or go, go grab one of the bigger pocket state specific leases and use that as a starting point. Yeah, double down to make sure that your entity structure is set up correctly, set up your business bank account. But you've really got to, I think, be doing both of those things simultaneously. I don't think it's an either this or that. It's both. Well, thank you guys so much for joining us today on this episode of Rookie Reply. I'm Ashley. He's Tony. And we'll see you guys on the next episode. Hey, rookies.

21:18If you're watching this, we want you to apply to be a guest on the Real Estate Rookie Podcast. That's right. Ashley and I are looking for amazing stories just like yours to be a part of our Real Estate Rookie Podcast. Now look, you don't need to be an expert. You don't need to have done thousands of deals. Even if you've done one deal, your story could help inspire the next listener. As a rookie investor, especially if you just got your first deal, it is all fresh in your minds and you are the best person to tell your story, give your experience on how you got it done to help someone else get their first deal.

21:49So head over to biggerpockets.com slash guests if you want to be a part of our show. Again, that's biggerpockets.com slash guest, and we'd love to have you on. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.