1. Podcasts
  2. ReThinking
  3. The craft of storytelling with Ann Patchett
ReThinking

7 Jul 2026 · 46m · 22 chapters

Episode artwork

The craft of storytelling with Ann Patchett

In short

Adam Grant interviews novelist Ann Patchett about “the power of stories,” including how she writes (practice, revision, throwing drafts away), why reading matters, and themes from her novel Whistler (enduring love, resistance to “toxic positivity,” the role of randomness, and how people can’t be who they aren’t).

Guest backgrounds

Ann Patchett is a bestselling, award-winning author of 10 novels, including Bel Canto, The Dutch House, and Tom Lake. She owns Parnassus Books in Nashville, opened in 2011, and is known for advocating indie bookstores.

Key claims

Every book is a “gateway drug” to reading; writing is more about loving the craft and showing up than talent/muse; practice and revision are central; “write what you’re interested in,” not just what you know; positivity can be sincere, and “darkness” isn’t automatically more credible.

Notable examples

Her father’s LAPD history (interviewing Manson; picking up Sirhan after Bobby Kennedy’s shooting); her mother’s push to write; a friend’s private essay she refused to publish; a birthday phone call returning her high-school night table papers; Whistler inspired by friend Jim Fox’s death; randomness illustrated by a stranger advising her to attend Sarah Lawrence.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:12

Growing Up with a Police Captain Father

Discussion on Ann Patchett's upbringing and her father's career.

“I don't want to live in a city that doesn't have a bookstore.”
3:08

The Impact of Divorce and Moving

How her parents' divorce influenced her life and writing.

“Well, my father had just about every job in the LAPD.”
4:19

Encouraging Her Mother's Writing

Ann discusses how she encouraged her mother to write a book.

“Well, my parents got divorced when I was four or five, and my mother moved me and my sister from Los Angeles to Tennessee.”
6:05

The Journey to Becoming a Writer

Ann reflects on her lifelong aspiration to be a writer.

“about that, that she brought you into the world and you were able to bring her into your world.”
8:06

The Importance of Practicing Storytelling

Discussion on the practice of writing and how to improve skills.

“And I became very loyal to the skill set.”
10:40

Writing for the Sake of Writing

The philosophy of writing for enjoyment rather than publication.

“The idea that I think so many people have is I'm going to work on this story and polish it and polish it.”
13:30

Writing as an Essential Part of Life

Ann shares her deep connection to writing and storytelling.

“And when I'm finished writing it, then I'll decide where it may or may not go in the world.”
14:03

The Creative Process of Writing

Explore the intricate relationship between passion for writing and the act itself.

“And that's how you feel about writing today?”
19:16

Fiction vs. Nonfiction: A Writer's Perspective

Delve into the differences between writing fiction and nonfiction, and the joys of each.

“And I have to play journalist for a bunch of weeks and it just feels like a big diversion.”
24:04

The Role of a Bookstore Owner

Learn about the motivations and experiences of owning a bookstore as a writer.

“and I actually read it about half as quickly as I would normally read a book of similar length because I didn't want to miss a sentence.”
Show all 22 chapters
28:00

The Joy of Author Interviews

Learn about the transformative experiences that come from interviewing authors.

“But as I was going home that night, I thought, if I didn't own this store and Douglas Stewart was coming to, say, Vanderbilt to do an event, would I have gone?”
28:50

The Power of Connection Through Books

Discover how reading fosters community and connection among people.

“Well, I think it's safe to say that you love people much more than the stereotypical writer does.”
30:10

Critique of Toxic Positivity

Explore the author's views on toxic positivity and its cultural implications.

“and they want to talk about my book, but they want to talk about reading.”
31:10

The Nature of Kindness

Discuss the author's perspective on kindness and the societal focus on negativity.

“And there were two, I thought, hilarious lines that came out of one of the books that he was well known for.”
32:50

Embracing Randomness in Life

Examine the role of chance encounters in shaping our lives and futures.

“If I'm in the airport, if I'm in a restaurant, I just see people by and large being really kind to one another.”
36:30

Exploring Change and Relationships

Delve into the complexities of love, change, and acceptance in relationships.

“And that I think would be a great travesty.”
40:50

Writing Tips and Advice

Gain insights into effective writing practices and physical well-being.

“So you can pause in between, of course, if you wish.”
42:00

Writing Tips and Posture Importance

Learn about the significance of physical posture for writers and creative processes.

“What's your favorite writing tip that you don't hear given often?”
44:35

Rethinking Book Tours

Discover how changing your mindset can transform your experience of book tours.

“I've twice cracked my head on the wall in the middle of the night when I've gotten up to find the bathroom.”
47:25

Managing Growth in Bookstores

Explore strategies to manage growth in a bookstore without expanding too quickly.

“of more being something that gets people in trouble.”
49:51

Balancing Expansion and Focus

Understand the paradox of managing growth while focusing on writing.

“But every time something stands in the way and I say, yes, it goes to that whole heart open.”
52:16

Managing Growth in Bookstores

Explore strategies to manage growth in a bookstore without expanding too quickly.

“That's where ServiceNow's AI specialists come in.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On ReThinking, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00With no fees or minimums on checking accounts, it's no wonder the Capital One bank guy is so passionate about banking with Capital One. If he were here, he wouldn't just tell you about no fees or minimums. He'd also talk about how most Capital One cafes are open seven days a week to assist with your banking needs. Yep, even on weekends, it's pretty much all he talks about. In a good way. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N.A. Member FDIC.

0:32This episode is brought to you by ServiceNow. I get to spend my days studying how people think and what it actually takes to change our minds. It's work I find deeply meaningful. But even in meaningful work, there's still busy work. The admin, the repetitive processes, the invisible load that pulls attention away from what really matters. That's where ServiceNow's AI specialists come in. They don't just tell you what you should do about your busy work. They actually do it. Start to finish. Cases closed. Requests handled. No extra work for you. To learn how to put AI to work for people, visit servicenow.com.

1:07I think every book is a gateway drug. If you can get people to read and you get them comfortable in a bookstore, then they're going to read other books. If you read nothing, you're always going to read nothing. Hey everyone, it's Adam Grant. Welcome back to Rethinking, my podcast with Ted on the science of what makes us tick. I'm an organizational psychologist, and I'm taking you inside the minds of fascinating people to explore new thoughts and new ways of thinking.

1:40Ian Patchett is a bestselling author and award-winning novelist. Along with acclaimed nonfiction works, Anne has written 10 novels, including The Dutch House, Tom Lake, and Bel Canto. But Anne's relationship with literature goes far beyond the page. In case you haven't seen her passionate videos online advocating for indie bookstores, you should know that she actually owns one in Nashville, Tennessee, called Parnassus Books, which she opened with a partner in 2011. Before that, Nashville hardly had any indie bookstores. For me, it felt like a civic duty. I don't want to live in a city that doesn't have a bookstore.

2:15Therefore, I guess I am the person who is going to open a bookstore. Anne is a firm believer in the power of stories. and she's one of the most powerful storytellers of our time. Her fiction is so emotionally honest that people have been asking if her latest novel, Whistler, is autobiographical. Whistler is a moving book about the enduring love of two people who've been separated for decades. I ended up reading it about three times slower than I normally read, just to savor each line. I'm always curious about how authors draw inspiration from their own lives, so I wanted to start at the beginning with Anne.

2:54I have to start by asking you about your upbringing, because not many of us grew up with a father who was a police captain arresting serial killers. And I have to know what that was like and how it shaped who you are. Well, my father had just about every job in the LAPD. He was involved in some high-profile cases, but I don't think those cases defined his career. He was one of the first people to interview Manson before they brought him in. And he also was the guy who picked up Sirhan the night he shot Bobby Kennedy and drove him in. And that didn't affect my life, I will say, because I was a kid.

3:40And those were names. And that's what my father did. But I was very young. And my father wasn't somebody who sat around and talked about murderers either. He would not have been interested in that at all. That actually maybe answers the next question I was going to ask you, which is, it's so clear throughout both your work, your writing, and the reputation you have that you see the goodness in people. And I often worry that when kids are raised in an environment where you're just acutely aware of the fact that there are bad people in the world, does that skew your worldview? And it sounds like you were shielded from that.

4:19Well, my parents got divorced when I was four or five, and my mother moved me and my sister from Los Angeles to Tennessee. So I didn't grow up with my father. I saw my father a week a year, which was a great sadness. The two things that have gotten cheaper over the course of my lifetime, plane travel and long distance phone calls, which are now free, but were huge defining deal when I was growing up. So it wasn't like my father was coming home at night with blood on his hands. You know, I didn't live in that world. We loved to go to the police academy when we went out to visit. But I just thought of my father as a very popular guy.

5:04Everybody came over to the table to pay their respects. I had an uncle who was a career firefighter in Los Angeles and another uncle who was a prosecutor in the DA's office. So, you know, we were a very civil servant family. Okay, let's talk about your mother. She was a nurse before becoming a novelist, which is also my wife Allison's trajectory. My mother was 60. She wanted to retire. She didn't have enough money. And I kept saying, write a book, write a book, write a book. You know, I'll help you. I made her do it because I saw it as the best road to retirement. and she was somebody who used to write and I think wanted to be a writer when she was young, didn't have the self-confidence.

5:54But by the time I was a writer and I was, you know, moderately successful, I could really set a course for her and push her through. There's something very poetic about that, that she brought you into the world and you were able to bring her into your world. Yes, absolutely. And, you know, so much of it is just discipline and having somebody to say, I want to see chapter four by the end of the week. You know, mom, get on it. I'm not taking no for an answer. Okay, now I want to see chapter five. And that's really what she needed. She just needed somebody to keep her on track. So when did you know that you wanted to be a writer?

6:36I never knew that I wanted to be anything else. If you were interviewing me when I was seven, I would say, I want to be a writer. And I don't know what that's about, but it's always been where I've landed. If you go back to when you were seven, how much of that was you loved words, you loved books, you loved stories? What do you trace it to originally? I trace it to the fact that I didn't go to school very often. There was a lot of upheaval in my family. My parents had gotten divorced. We had moved across country. We left in November when I was in first grade. And so I was very nominally going to school with some kids we were staying with.

7:24And the idea was we were going to go back to Los Angeles. It was just all very sloppy. We moved a lot. I really didn't learn how to read until I was in the third grade. Wow. Because we just didn't really go to school regularly. I couldn't read or write with any fluency, but I could tell a story. And that became the thing that got me through at the bottom of the class, but I would probably still be in second grade were it not for the fact that I figured out that telling a story was a good skill set to have. And I became very loyal to the skill set. What was it as a second grader that made you a good storyteller?

8:14I wasn't a ham. I was a quiet kid, but I could put together little poems. I could make rhymes. I had a good sense of language. I had a good ear. And now, what do you think are the most crucial skills of storytelling? The ability to work. The ability to keep showing up when you have sat in a chair all day long and come up with nothing, to be willing to go back and do it the next day and the next day and the next day. I feel so far away from talent and muse and creativity and those words that seemed so important when I was young. And now I think it's the people who make it are the people who just keep showing up.

9:07It's much, much more like learning to play the cello. You're going to put in the hours a day of practice. People don't tend to think about writing in terms of practice because we can all write. We can all tell a story. And so then if we sit down and we can't write, we can't get the story in our head onto the paper, we say we're blocked. We're not blocked. We just need to spend more time practicing. What does that practice look like for you? because when I hear practice, I start to think about the psychology of deliberate practice and deliberate play where there's a skill development component and you have a cycle of, I do a rep, I get some feedback, I make an adjustment, I repeat and I'm constantly trying to improve.

9:54And I think that's a place where people get stuck writing because it's hard to gauge objectively whether you're getting better. You can gauge whether a story has gotten better or whether a sentence has gotten clearer, but did I learn anything from that? Have my skills grown? I don't know. So I don't really know how to practice, I think is the feeling many people have. You do. Tell us how. Well, the willingness to work on a story, revise it, get a friend to read it, figure out how it can be better, revise it, do it again and again. And then when you get to a place where you think it's great, throw it away and take what you've learned and put it into the next story and work on it and revise it and revise it and throw it away and go again to a new story.

10:43The idea that I think so many people have is I'm going to work on this story and polish it and polish it. And when I finished, I'm going to send it to the New Yorker. And that's the end game. The end game is not publication. The end game is becoming a better writer? The idea of writing a whole draft, refining it, and then throwing it away to start over, I think is foreign to a lot of people. I think it's smart in two ways, at least. One is, I think it overcomes what in psychology we would think about as anchoring and escalation of commitment biases, where you get stuck in the way that you've done it before and you don't adjust enough.

11:25And two, it's also a chance then to really experience your growth and progress so that you can take, as you said, all the learning that came from revising the previous draft and start over fresh. At the same time, it's really hard for me to imagine just abandoning all the work that I put in. Does that ever bother you? Well, it doesn't happen very often anymore, although it does happen. The ability to be honest with yourself, the ability to see your own work clearly, which if we're serious about writing, we should have. You can read something and, or I can read something of my own and I know if it's any good or not.

12:08And I often write things that are bad and I marvel in a sense, like, wow, I didn't know that I could be 62 years old and at this point in my career and still write something that bad. But also bedrock to all of it is love. I'm doing this because I love to do it, because it's who I am, because it's how I see the world and experience and figure things out. I can think of a couple of great stories. One, years and years ago, So my friend Elizabeth Gilbert gave me an essay that she had written, and it was just the best thing I had ever read. It was spectacular. And I said, where are you going to publish this?

13:02And she said, no, no, no. I wrote this for myself. This is private, and I'm showing it to you. I'm not showing this to anybody else. I said, no, no, no. This is astonishing. You have to. She said, no, this is a private thing. This is a true private story, and I'm not going to publish it. But I needed to write it because that's what I do. That was a huge lesson for me. So just going into something and saying, I am writing this for the sake of writing it always. And when I'm finished writing it, then I'll decide where it may or may not go in the world. And that is the place that you have to come at writing from.

13:51I do this because I love it. I play the cello not because I'm going to be Yo-Yo Ma in Carnegie Hall, but because I can't imagine a whole day without playing the cello. And that's how you feel about writing today? That's how I feel. Yeah. I mean, heaven knows I can go for long periods of time without writing, although I think about writing all the time. And that's, for me, a very similar state. I fall asleep every night thinking about a novel, a story, an idea in my head, the story I tell myself. What's that Joan Didion quote? We tell ourselves stories in order to live. And that is definitely true for me.

14:35So, yes, but also it's luck and privilege. And if somebody said, you know what, it's over, you're never going to write another book, I would say I've had such a great run and I've been so lucky. I wouldn't die. It's not air, but it's great. That seems like a healthy attitude toward it. I'm reminded of some research suggesting that for people to stay motivated writing, they have to be as interested in the process as they are in the content. Absolutely. And I think that's what a lot of people miss about writing is you can be fascinated by the topic, but if you don't love the craft of formulating sentences and shaping paragraphs and trying to make ideas and stories and characters come to life, then you probably shouldn't be a writer.

15:29So years and years, decades ago, I used to teach in a summer program at the Fine Arts Work Center in Provincetown. And I would teach with my friend Lucy Greeley. And she taught nonfiction and I taught fiction. And we shared a little apartment together. And at night we would look at the homework that came in. And my students were so much better than her students. And I said, why is this? Why are my students better? She said, because your students want to write. My students have had something horrible happen to them and they want to figure out a way how to sell it. They're not primarily interested in writing at all.

16:13But boy, a lot of people don't understand that. They want to be a writer, but they don't want to write. Yeah, it's really unfortunate. I think, you know, it makes me think that we should, we should be careful not to define ourselves by nouns and make sure that the verb of the activity actually resonates with us and is something we would want to do, not just be. Yes, exactly. Well said. This episode is brought to you by Quince. The start of your day, you don't want to be overthinking what outfit to put on. Lately, I've been reaching for the same few Quince pieces on repeat, and honestly, it's freeing.

16:53I grab their quarters at Pullover, and it's a perfect go-to for cool summer nights. It's one of those pieces I reach for without thinking. That's what I love about Quince. Their 100 % European linen shirts and pants are the summer upgrade your rotation needs, starting at just$34. Their tees are soft enough to live in all day, and the lightweight cotton sweaters are exactly what you want when summer nights cool down. Everything is priced 50-80 % less than similar brands because they work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen. Make your summer wardrobe easier. Go to quince.com slash rethinking for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns.

17:31Now available in Canada too. That's quince.com slash rethinking for free shipping and 365-day returns. quince.com slash rethinking. This episode is powered by AT &T Business. There's something we often don't question until it fails. The invisible systems that support our work. When you're building something, whether it's a business, a team, or an idea, you're constantly making trade-offs about where to invest your time and energy. Imagine being hunched over a laptop in a quiet corner of the office, finally hitting your stride, only to have a spinning loading icon bring everything to a halt. It's that split second where the momentum just breaks, and you're forced to stop what you're doing to troubleshoot a connection that should have just worked.

18:14When you're already navigating uncertainty, complexity, and competing priorities, reliability isn't a luxury. It's a foundation. That's what makes AT &T Business a strong provider for small business owners. It's built to work so you can spend less time troubleshooting and more time focusing on the work that actually matters. Powered by AT &T Business. Built to work. Get today at business.att.com.

18:40with no fees or minimums on checking accounts it's no wonder the capital one bank guy is so passionate about banking with capital one if he were here he wouldn't just tell you about no fees or minimums he'd also talk about how most capital one cafes are open seven days a week to assist with your banking needs yep even on weekends it's pretty much all he talks about in a good way what's in your wallet terms apply see CapitalOne.com slash bank Capital One N-A member FDIC

19:15so I'm really curious about your experiences with fiction versus non-fiction as a non-fiction writer there are moments when I say to my wife who represents more of the fiction side of our house it would be really nice one day to wake up in the morning and be able to invent a story because, you know, oftentimes I'm trying to unpack an idea or explain a study and I know the narrative arc that I'm looking for, for the story that I want to illustrate it. And I can't quite find it. And I have to play journalist for a bunch of weeks and it just feels like a big diversion. Like it would be, it would be so fun to just be able to have total freedom.

19:54And I'm so curious because you do both about whether you feel that too and how you would compare and contrast the joys of fiction writing versus nonfiction writing. What does your wife say? Allison said, yes, it's great to have freedom. And it's also terrible to have freedom because you could take the story anywhere. And she said, at least you have constraints. I agree with Allison. So when I am a fiction writer and I am first and foremost, a fiction writer. To be a fiction writer is to be God. You have to make the people, the trees, the leaves. You decide when the day starts, when the day stops, who lives, who dies, who falls in love, who goes on the hero's journey, all of it.

20:39And it's a massive undertaking. When I write nonfiction, I don't go looking for nonfiction. Nonfiction finds me. Sometimes something happens, and I just think, wow, you know, the universe has just handed me a perfect essay. Several years ago on my birthday, phone rings, rings, rings. Normally, I don't just pick up the phone without checking caller ID, but it was my birthday, and I picked up the phone, And it was a guy whose grandmother had bought a night table in an antique mall. And it turns out that this night table had been my night table in high school. And a bunch of my papers from high school had fallen down the back of the drawers.

21:35poems, photographs of my friends, notes, and an award. This is why the guy tracked me down. It was like an award that I had won from Rotary about an essay I had written on the Pledge of Allegiance. And I'm thinking, this is just like someone is saying, okay, here you go. Here's an essay. And where does the essay begin? It begins when the phone starts ringing. Where does the essay stop. It stops when this guy comes to my bookstore with his wife and his baby and he brings me these papers. And in the middle, I'm thinking about the journey of this piece of furniture and how things can come back to you.

22:16That, it sounds like a piece of fiction, but it's a completely shaped essay about our relationship to our past and to things and how what means so much to one person means nothing to another person was a great essay. And I imagine though you have experiences in fiction that are like that, where something happens in your life and it becomes a jumping off point for a story or you meet somebody and you think, you know what, I could base a character on them. Yes, that's true. It doesn't happen as often. I'm kind of clawing around in the dark or squinting. That's what putting a novel together always feels like to me, squinting.

23:00And really, Whistler was very different because that was the case in which a friend of mine died. Jim Fox died on his 85th birthday. And I was writing a piece for The New Yorker about a glowworm cave in New Zealand. And there was a little piece in that essay about Jim's death. And I thought, oh, wow, I can really write Jim. And I thought, what if I wrote a novel in which I took all of the love that Jim had for me and all of the love I had for Jim, and I made up a story, and I put the real love onto made-up people in a made-up story. and it was a very easy and joyful book to write because I had such a sensation of being with my friend.

24:01Well, you did it beautifully. Thank you. I could feel the love in the book and I actually read it about half as quickly as I would normally read a book of similar length because I didn't want to miss a sentence. Thank you. That's a lovely thing to say. No, thank you. It was a delightful experience And it's not my typical genre as somebody who normally turns to fiction for sci-fi, thriller, mystery. And I enjoyed it, I think, all the more because of it. That's really fascinating. I was doing an interview recently, and the topic of conversation is, how do you get men to read literary fiction? And somebody was saying, oh, literary fiction, it's really been taken over by women.

24:45And I was like, well, you know, it's not like the writing's been taken over. It's that more women read literary fiction and more men read nonfiction. I own this bookstore and the nonfiction when you walk in the door is to the right and the fiction is to the left. And it's not 100 % true, but the men tend to go to the right and the women tend to go to the left. How do you think about changing that? Because I think we all need to read fiction and nonfiction. You know, I don't think about changing it. I'm happy that people read. Anytime somebody is reading, I think it's a bonus. And I think if you read always in the same genre, someday you might trip over into another genre.

25:33So I would never say, well, I just want to make sure that kid grows up and reads literary fiction. I just want to make sure that kid grows up and reads. Spot on. And we have to talk about your decision to run a bookstore because when I think about what would compel any writer to own a bookstore, the first thing I think of is discovery. I have such fond memories of being a kid and walking into the library and walking into several bookstores and not knowing what I was going to find. And that does not happen on the internet for the most part. I get recommendations that are similar to what I've already read.

26:15Right. And so how does that relate to your motivation for doing this? You're absolutely right. It's completely true. And it doesn't relate at all to my motivation. So my motivation was the bookstores in Nashville closed. This was 15 years ago. And I waited around. I've never wanted to own a bookstore. That was never my dream. I waited for someone else to do it. No one did it. I met a woman who was a retired sales rep from Random House. She wanted to run a bookstore. We decided to go into business together, total strangers. So, you know, we just started this thing from nothing because the city has to have a bookstore.

27:00You know, you just have to do it. Well, some would say also you could easily hand it off and not have such a central role in it. What has kept you so involved? Well, to a large extent, I have handed it off. I hire people I really love and trust, and they run it. And the main thing I do in that bookstore is we have a first editions club, which I like to say is like fruit of the month club that doesn't rot. So I'm always picking a book six months, five months out. It absolutely destroys my life because this is what I'm doing constantly. I'm just on the hamster wheel. People are sending me galleys night and day because they want me to pick their book.

27:53and yet even as it drives me out of my mind I have read so many fabulous books that I would never have found otherwise and that's been great the other thing I do I interview authors who come to visit for the store so that's an amazing opportunity I just interviewed Douglas Stewart about his new book John of John which is one of the best books of the year he wrote Shuggy Bain and won the Booker several years ago. But as I was going home that night, I thought, if I didn't own this store and Douglas Stewart was coming to, say, Vanderbilt to do an event, would I have gone? I don't know. It was like one of the greatest nights of my life to meet this guy and sit there and be in conversation with him.

28:43It was holy. It was absolutely amazing for everyone in the room. And I could have missed it had I not been the person who was interviewing the author. Well, I think it's safe to say that you love people much more than the stereotypical writer does. Well, if you had interviewed me before I opened a bookstore, I think I would have seemed much more like the stereotypical writer because I was always protecting my privacy. My idea of myself is I am a shy, quiet introvert who wants to stay home and write fiction. But for 15 years, I've owned a bookstore, and now I am the national spokesperson for all things independent books, authors, and constantly being pushed out of my comfort zone has made me a happier and more productive person.

29:43person. It does track with the evidence that even we introverts get energy from interacting with other people. Yes. You spoke to this in your recent TED Talk when you said reading. That solitary endeavor has proven to be a means of connection. Yes. And that's what I see in the bookstore. And that's what I see when I go out on book tour and a thousand people come in a city and they want to talk about my book, but they want to talk about reading. They want to talk about everything they're reading. They want recommendations. They want to meet each other in the signing line who's sitting next to me in the audience and talk about books.

30:25It's like a tent revival for reading. And so when people say to me, reading's dead, books are dying, this is all over, I'm like, maybe it is in your world, but every morning when we unlock the doors at Parnassus, there are lines of people who want to come in and buy a book and talk about books. So my evidence is different. We need more of that in the world, I think. Yes, absolutely. So let's talk a little bit about Whistler. I don't want to spoil any plot points, but there were a few themes that jumped out at me that I thought would be interesting to ask you to riff on. You are not particularly kind to a self-help author who's peddling positivity in this book.

31:14And there were two, I thought, hilarious lines that came out of one of the books that he was well known for. Bounce on your toes while brushing your teeth. Feel the positivity radiating up from your ankles. I want to know, why were you so eager to poke fun at that. Have you been bothered by toxic positivity in the world and the Pollyanna sense that people are pressured to be upbeat and optimistic at all times? What's behind this? I like the idea of a really grumpy guy pushing positivity as a unit of sales. This is how he has figured out how he is going to make his money. So also I will say, and I hadn't thought about this before, I, throughout the course of my career and in my life, I get a lot of grief from people because I am a positive person.

32:14and people call me a Pollyanna and unrealistic. And I always say, you know, why would it be more realistic if I wrote books about serial killers? You don't know any serial killers. I don't know any serial killers. I know plenty of nice people. You know plenty of nice people. Why do we take the darkest parts of our nature to be somehow more credible and true? And I don't believe that. I believe in what I see and what I see in my life, in my bookstore, my house, my neighborhood, the people that I interact with. If I'm in the airport, if I'm in a restaurant, I just see people by and large being really kind to one another.

33:02Now, granted, these are the eyes that I have in my head, and I looked at the world through my eyes, and I am, by my nature, a positive, cheerful person, and I have been ever since I was a child. No virtue in that whatsoever. I was born this way. And if you have a cheerful, sunny affect, people tend to meet you in a cheerful, sunny way. Yeah, I don't think anyone who's ever interacted with you would doubt it for a second. Um, so another thing that, that I was so curious to hear your reaction to is you have a line about randomness, a paragraph about randomness. I'll just read you a bet. You say there's so much randomness to youth.

33:45The person assigned to share your room becomes your friend. The girl you pass on your way out the door becomes your wife. And from these random encounters, our entire lives are built. There are 10 grandchildren now, 10 new people who in part owe their lives on earth to a series essentially of random events. How do you feel about that? Does it delight you? Does it bother you? I believe it. I would say it neither delights me nor bothers me, but I think it's true. When I was looking at colleges, I had gone to a Catholic girls' school for 12 years, and we did not have a guidance counselor, and my parents weren't particularly interested in my going to college.

34:32I mean, they wanted me to go to college, but it was not a group activity. It was just something that I was going to figure out, and I didn't know what I was doing. And the schools that I applied to were just wildly random because I didn't have any idea what I was doing. And one of the schools I applied to was Alfred in New York. I went up to interview at Alfred, and as I was walking around the art department, there was one girl there painting. She said, what do you want to do? And I said, I want to write, but I'm also interested in painting. She said, oh, if you want to write, you should go to Sarah Lawrence.

35:10And I did. That was the sum total of collegiate advice I received. A stranger said, that's where the writers go. Oh, okay. Thanks very much. At Sarah Lawrence, I studied for a year each with Alan Gerganis, Russell Banks, and Grace Paley. You couldn't go to Harvard and get that lineup. In classes where there were 12 students in the class, you stayed with that teacher all year and you met with them individually once a week. There could not have been a better, more life-shaping education for me. and a stranger in Alfred, New York, was the person who told me to go there. Couldn't be more random and yet my entire life was built off of that encounter.

36:10I mean, it's such a great example of what bothers me about the randomness or used to bother me, which is I wonder how many of those moments we miss. Oh, sure. Because, you know, what if you had arrived a minute later or a minute earlier, right? That chance encounter might never have occurred. We might not get to read you. It's possible, right? And that I think would be a great travesty. On the other hand, I think, okay, we have to also then be extra grateful for all the random connections that do get made. And at some level, it's not the fact that the random event occurred, right? It's the fact that then you took the initiative to take that advice to heart, to follow it and then to make the most of the experience you had at Sarah Lawrence.

36:57And so I think, I guess that tells me there's still a role for human agency and proactivity in the process. Yes. You know, this relates to another moment in Whistler that I wanted to ask you about, which is, it's toward the end. You wrote, it had been one possible scenario, Eddie and Abigail, which could have worked had every single thing about them been different. Yeah. It was such a striking line for me because if every single thing about them had been different, they wouldn't have been who they were. And yet - You know what I meant. You're inviting the reader to consider the possibility that they could change much more dramatically than we normally assume.

37:39And I wanted to hear you talk about that. They couldn't have changed. It could not have worked. But they still loved each other. And it took them their whole life maybe to be able to get to a place where they could look back and see, oh, that would never have worked because we are who we are. But there's a sweetness in just acknowledging that. I love you. It can't work. But I see you and I know you and I love you and I let you go. This episode is brought to you by LinkedIn. Running a small business means every hire matters. A bad hire can cost you time, money, and momentum. A good hire, they can change everything.

38:27But finding great talent isn't easy, especially when you don't have the time or resources to sift through piles of resumes and find the right fit. That's why LinkedIn built HiringPro. It's your new hiring partner that screens candidates for you. Instead of sorting through applications, you can spend your time talking to candidates and finding your next great hire. With Hiring Pro, you can hire with confidence, knowing you're getting the best talent for your business. In fact, LinkedIn found that its users are 24 % less likely to need to reopen a role within 12 months compared to the leading competitor.

38:58Join the 2.7 million small businesses using LinkedIn to hire. Get started by posting your job for free at www.linkedin.com slash adamgrand. Terms and conditions apply. This episode is sponsored by Kohler Smart Toilets. The objects we interact with most are often the ones we notice least. Kohler's Smart Toilet challenges that assumption. What if the most overlooked space in your home could become the most considered? Their Veil Smart Toilet is a sculptural silhouette that isn't just intentional, it's a philosophy that design changes everything. The Kohler Veil Smart Toilet is sleek, with a rounded shape that's more like architecture than just plumbing.

39:37And it goes beyond looks. The touchscreen controls and customizable cleansing features offer a level of comfort and cleanliness that exceed expectations. It's all about elevating those ordinary daily rituals into something extraordinary through thoughtful design. Kohler has been pushing these boundaries for over 150 years, mastering that balance of stunning form and high-performance function. That's a long time to get it right, and it shows in every detail. Experience the difference of Kohler Smart Toilets. Find out more at Kohler.com.

40:09Hi there, it's Adam Grant from Ted's Rethinking Podcast, and this episode is brought to you by ServiceNow. I get to spend my days studying how people think and what it actually takes to change our minds. It's work I find deeply meaningful. But even in meaningful work, there's still busy work. The admin, the repetitive processes, the invisible load that pulls attention away from what really matters. That's where ServiceNow's AI specialists come in. They don't just tell you what you should do about your busy work. They actually do it. Start to finish. Case is closed. Requests handled. No extra work for you.

40:41To learn how to put AI to work for people, visit servicenow.com.

40:52Okay, time for a lightning round. Oh boy. All right. So you can pause in between, of course, if you wish. If I'm not fast enough for the lightning round. No one is, it turns out. Okay. So let me ask you first, what is the worst writing advice that you hear people give regularly? Write what you know. And you hate that because? Well, I mean, I don't hate it, but there are all sorts of things that I don't know anything about that I write about. I write what I'm interested in. The very best part of writing is that it means that I get to do research. I wrote a book about ichthyology. I went to the Harvard Museum of Comparative Zoology and hung out with all of those dead fish.

41:37That was not writing about what I know. That was writing about what was interesting to me and how lucky that I got to hang out there. If you write what you know, you're writing about your mother all the time. Yeah, I think writing about your curiosity is much more compelling than writing about just your experience or your knowledge. All right. What's your favorite writing tip that you don't hear given often? Uh, posture is everything. There is no one truth for writing except that you have to take care of your body. And there is nothing in the world that I like more than sitting cross-legged on a sofa with a sofa cushion in my lap and my laptop on the sofa cushion and writing.

42:30And guess what? That isn't going to work. I had a friend who wrote a whole book that way and had two hips replaced at the end. So you have to figure out how you can keep your body in a good place. And if that means you stop every 25 minutes and jump around, I have a treadmill desk. I have written my last two books on a treadmill desk because it helps me stay physically pain-free and in the game. And leads to more creative ideas, according to a series of experiments. I absolutely have found that to be true. Normally, this is a dinner party question, but I'm going to modify it and make it a bookstore.

43:16question for you. Okay. You get to host at Parnassus any writers you want living or dead for a conversation about anything you choose. Who are you inviting and what are they talking about? Okay. So first off, I would invite my friend Lucy Greeley, who was my best friend from college and graduate school who died when we were 39. I would invite my friend Dorothea Benton-Frank, who died before COVID. I would just want to see people that I love and use writing as an excuse. You know, I don't need to call up Shakespeare and Dickens. I would just like to see the people who I haven't seen in a while.

44:01Grace Paley. Let's invite Grace Paley, too. Oh, I loved her. And she was such a wonderful teacher. And what would we talk about at that dinner party? I imagine we would talk about how beautiful it was to be alive for the course of the evening and how happy we were to be together. Wow. That is unlike any answer I've heard to this question. Tell me something you've rethought lately. Okay. Book tour. So I have spent the majority of my career hating book tour. and I have dug deeply into my hatred. I don't get any food. I don't sleep well. I've twice cracked my head on the wall in the middle of the night when I've gotten up to find the bathroom.

44:50I don't like the airports, the travel, and I have bitched and complained about going on book tour enough. And several years ago, before Tom Lake, which was my last book, I did an experiment. I decided to pursue right speech. I stopped swearing and I decided that if I dropped a glass, I was not going to say, you idiot. I was going to say, nice glass. That was a great glass. It so changed my life to make those adjustments in my speech and thought that I thought, I'm going to do this for book tour. And when people say, how do you feel about book tour? I'm going to say, I'm really excited. I'm looking forward to meeting the readers.

45:33I'm looking forward to seeing my friends who work in those bookstores that I go and visit. I feel really lucky that I get to go on book tour. I did not believe it, but I kept saying it and I kept saying it and it became true. And I changed completely my mind about book tour and I'm going on book tour and I am feeling good about it. I'm delighted to hear that. And many of your readers, I'm sure, are thrilled too that you've changed your stance. Okay, office hours time. This is the point where I turn over the mic to you. Do you have a question for me? So the question is about my bookstore. Every year we've been in business, we have topped the previous year.

46:21It is booming, this bookstore. The thing is, we don't want to grow. And I understand that there is no such thing as stasis. but everybody's always saying, oh, open another location here or there, this building, that building. I'm like, no, no, no, no. We want to do this one thing really well, but it keeps getting bigger. What do we do? Well, that's such a great problem to have. Yes, isn't it? Yeah. I think, I mean, normally growth is not something you have to fight. Normally you're trying everything you can to make it happen. I was actually thinking earlier about Hemingway and how he wrote that every writer needs a built-in shockproof shit detector.

47:11And what I took away from that was just being ruthless about projecting bad material and bad ideas. And I think that running a business is the same thing, right? I think Jim Collins would describe it as the undisciplined pursuit of more being something that gets people in trouble. And I see this happen in companies all the time. I think in a thriving bookstore, I think that the answer to how not to grow is to default to no. And to only say yes, if you have something that is irresistible, that you've already tried to refuse multiple times and you keep coming back to it. But then to have a simple math rule, which is if we're going to add something, we also have to subtract.

47:55And I've had to learn to do this with my calendar. Why do I keep getting over committed? If I'm going to take on a new project, I need to finish or end an old project. And I think that running an organization is the exact same way. So no addition unless you subtract. How's that? Well, okay. So we turn down over 800 event requests a year. Wow. And we do well over 350 events a year offsite and in-store. So we're good at saying no. Well, I guess then maybe an interesting solution for you if you haven't already tried it is, okay, so you're going to have this temptation to grow because of all the demand you've created and all the energy there.

48:39Every time something new comes and you do it, can it then be spun off to be its own entity? Give me an example. An example would be, so let's say, for example, you wanted to do another hundred events, but you can't. Can you then spin off an events business that kind of runs on its own? No, no, no, no. Because then that's just massive growth and more businesses. You know, what I think of is romance. When we started, we had no romance. Nobody cared about romance. Romance is huge now. It takes up a big chunk of store. And everybody's like, we should open a romance bookstore. Let the romance and the fantasy and the romanticy and the dragons and the princesses go to another building.

49:23but no because then it's just another store it's bigger it's bigger it's bigger i just want this one store i guess i was thinking about a slightly different model kind of like a startup incubator where you know founders are allowed to come in for a period of time and then they build something and they go off and grow it themselves you don't want that no i'm 62 and i want to write novels well then that's what you should do and there's your answer don't say yes to anything that would stand in the way of your writing. Oh, everything stands in the way of my writing. But every time something stands in the way and I say, yes, it goes to that whole heart open.

50:00It makes you a bigger, better, happier person and more expansive, which makes you a better writer. La la la. This is the best problem to have. You know what? Esther Perel would remind me at this point that this is not a problem to solve. It's a paradox to manage. Okay. I love that. I'm just going to have to grow up and deal with it. That's what the answer is. I think you can handle it. And my dog has come home. I can hear him now scratching on the door. Well, Anne, thank you. I have to tell you, sometimes I approach meeting writers I admire and adore with a little bit of trepidation, because it's almost impossible to like them as much as I like their stories and their characters.

50:42and you're the opposite of a never meet your heroes person. Everything that's on the page when I read you just leaps out of you as a person and that is a real, real rare gift. Thank you. That is incredibly kind. I've loved this conversation. So thank you. Rethinking is hosted by me, Adam Grant. The show is produced by TED with Cosmic Standard. Our producer is Jessica Glazer. Our editor is Alejandra Salazar. Our engineer is Asia Pilar Simpson. Our technical director is Jacob Winnick. And our fact checker is Paul Durbin. Our team includes Eliza Smith, Roxanne Hilash, Van Ben Chang, Julia Dickerson, Tansika Sung Manivong, and Whitney Pennington Rogers.

51:26Original music by Hans Dale Su and Alison Leighton Brown.

51:33Score! Adam Grant said I could have a dinner party and invite my dead friends. Guys, come back. Quick, quick.

51:47with no fees or minimums on checking accounts it's no wonder the capital one bank guy is so passionate about banking with capital one if he were here he wouldn't just tell you about no fees or minimums he'd also talk about how most capital one cafes are open seven days a week to assist with your banking needs yep even on weekends it's pretty much all he talks about in a good way What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N.A. member FDIC.

52:39That's where ServiceNow's AI specialists come in. They don't just tell you what you should do about your busy work. They actually do it. Start to finish. Cases closed. Requests handled. No extra work for you. To learn how to put AI to work for people, visit servicenow.com. We've all heard that social media is taking away kids' childhoods, giving them social anxiety, and increasing rates of teen depression. Social media has been labeled the culprit. But what if it's not? What has been really shocking to me as I've stood here and kind of watched this debate unfold and seeing how things are translated to the broader public is that there's just this massive gap between what evidence has been generated to date and rigorous studies have found and expert panels have concluded, which is essentially that there's very tiny correlations between social media and mental health.

53:32That was developmental psychologist Candice Ogers, who joined us for a special interview to unearth the research that debunks social media as the cause of the mental health decline for our teens. What else is causing it and what are the solutions for a path forward? Find out in the full episode of TED Talks Daily wherever you listen to podcasts.

From the publisher

Ann Patchett is a bestselling author and award-winning novelist—she also owns an independent bookstore in Nashville, Tennessee called Parnassus Books. In this episode, Adam and Ann reflect on writing as a craft and whether all written work should be seen by the outside world. Ann also shares the real-life relationship that inspired her latest novel, “Whistler,” and how she rethought her position on book tours.


Featured guest




Connect with the team



ReThinking is produced by Cosmic Standard. Our Senior Producer is Jessica Glazer, our Engineer is Aja Simpson, our Technical Director is Jacob Winik, and our Executive Producer is Eliza Smith.


For the full text transcript, visit ted.com/podcasts/rethinking-with-adam-grant-transcripts

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from ReThinking

All episodes