1. Podcasts
  2. Scratch: CMO Interviews
  3. The 2026 Rival 50: Seven Moves Challenger Brands Are Using to Win
Scratch: CMO Interviews

16 Nov 2026 · 47m · 19 chapters

Episode artwork

The 2026 Rival 50: Seven Moves Challenger Brands Are Using to Win

In short

The podcast explains how Rival’s 2026 Rival 50 Challenger Brand Index was built (methodology, scoring, ranking) and shares seven “moves” challenger brands use to win, with actionable takeaways for marketers.

Guests (backgrounds)

  • Lance (Chief Strategy Officer, U.S.): leads strategy for Rival; discusses challenger principles and trend implications.
  • Dakota (Lead researcher and writer, Cape Town): research/writing lead for the Rival 50 report; emphasizes analytical methodology and category convention analysis.
  • Advisors mentioned: Sadira Furlow (ex-CMO, Tony’s Chocolonely), Tom Denford (CEO, IDcoms), Marcella (Global CMO, Dove), Paul Coxhill (COO, Informa), Dagmara (ANA), plus Rajash (Imperial College marketing professor).

Key claims

  • Challenger brands win by punching above budget via innovation; differentiation, relevance, talkability are scored against category conventions; momentum (growth, share of voice/talkability, revenue) determines inclusion.
  • Seven trends: flip category emotional code; start in microcultures; run like a franchise; marketing moves into product brief; ship unfinished (participation/personalization); sell what you take away (subtraction); design for disagreement.

Notable examples (top 10)

1 Hoka; 2 Awala; 3 Liquid Death; 4 Dr. Bronner’s; 5 Who Gives a Crap; 6 Fenty Beauty; 7 Sidemen; 8 Slate Auto; 9 Tony’s Chocolonely; 10 Crocs.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Understanding Challenger Brands

An overview of what challenger brands are and their significance in marketing.

“You know, see the sun come up behind me as we go on this journey.”
2:18

Methodology of the Rival 50

Discussion on the methodology used to create the Rival 50 Index and the principles evaluated.

“Well, there's quite a bit of rigor here.”
3:38

Scoring and Evaluation Process

Explanation of the scoring process, including human scoring and advisor input.

“And so we basically created from our nominations lookalikes and used a very calculated way to leverage rival intelligence to cast a wider net.”
4:55

Unveiling the Rival 50 List

Detailed reveal of the top brands in the Rival 50 along with commentary on significant inclusions.

“And we felt pretty good about the list that we're going to share with you.”
8:50

Analyzing Trends from the Rival 50

Introduction to the seven major trends identified from the Rival 50 research.

“I'm going to see if I can share my screen for people watching on YouTube.”
14:00

Introduction to Trends and Last Year's Winner

Discussion about the previous year's winner and introduction to current trends.

“and, you know, the labels all connote some aspect of Italy, it feels like, or certainly the Mediterranean.”
14:28

Overview of the Seven Trends

Overview of the seven biggest trends from this year's Rival 50 research.

“So, Lance, I'm going to kind of let you drive here.”
15:25

Trend 1: Flip the Category's Emotional Code

Exploring the importance of flipping the emotional code of categories for branding.

“as we were evaluating the trends, we probably had a list of, I don't know, 14 trends and then, and we decided on these, these seven.”
19:15

Trend 2: Start Inside a Microculture

Discussion on leveraging microcultures for brand relevance and engagement.

“Number two, start inside a microculture and then let it carry you out.”
22:09

Trend 3: Run Your Brand Like a Franchise

Insights on treating a brand as a franchise to create a lasting emotional connection.

“And we talk about this all the time, right?”
Show all 19 chapters
24:45

Trend 4: Marketing Moves into the Product Brief

Discussion on the shift of marketing principles into product development.

“I mean, last year we talked about challenger brands were thinking like media companies, right?”
28:00

Trend Three: Think Like a Showrunner

Learn how adopting a media company mindset can enhance your brand's storytelling.

“and they recognize that this is a world that so many readers love and so many consumers love.”
28:50

Trend Four: Marketing Moves to Product Brief

Discover how successful brands integrate marketing insights into product development.

“Lance, you touched on this briefly with Slate, but give us the overview.”
31:00

Trend Five: Shipping the Brand Unfinished

Explore the IKEA effect and how brands invite consumer participation.

“You think about the four P's of marketing, product is in there.”
34:10

Trend Six: Embracing a Reductionist Mindset

Understand how brands can thrive by simplifying their offerings and appealing to consumer desires for less.

“Lance, tell us about trend six, what you take away.”
37:00

Trend Seven: Designing for Disagreement

Learn how brands can create memorable marketing by embracing controversy.

“They're ahead of the curve where actually less can be such a key selling point.”
42:04

Key Takeaways for CMOs

Learn actionable strategies CMOs can use to innovate in their categories.

“And just knowing, and often, like you said, Lance, you can see the sea of sameness.”
43:33

Encouraging Innovation and Boldness

Discover the importance of exploring beyond current brand conventions to foster change.

“And pick the top three that you think can have the biggest impact, but also the ones that are going to be most actionable.”
45:43

Rival 50 and Future Engagement

Find out about the Rival 50 report and ways to engage further with the findings.

“A lot of work went into it again, over 2000 brands.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Scratch: CMO Interviews, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00All right, welcome to a very special edition of Scratch. Lance is already bobbing his head. Today, we are going to talk publicly, actually for the first time, about the 2026 Rival 50 Challenger Brand Index. So we are going to go through how we developed it. It's been, what, a four-month labor of love for a very big team, very big part of the team here. We're going to go through the methodology, the approach. Of course, we're going to talk about the list, the brands that made it, the brands that didn't make it, some surprises on both sides. And we're going to get into the seven biggest insights and trends and part of the report that I love this year, what you can steal as a marketer for your own business.

0:43So with me today, we have Lance, our chief strategy officer. Lance, how you doing? Cheers. Good morning. You know, see the sun come up behind me as we go on this journey. So by the end of this, it'll be bright and it will be time to end. Very metaphorical. Lance is joining us from the U.S. And joining us from Cape Town is Dakota, who is our lead researcher and writer for this report. How are you doing, Dakota? It's sunny in Cape Town at least, so yeah. Rub it in going into summer down there. All right, well, no time to waste. Let's get into it. So as I hope you all know at this point, the mission of Rival is to document the playbook of successful challenger brands.

1:27We think of challenger brands as the future of marketing that's here but just not evenly distributed yet. The Davids that are taking on Goliaths, they are forced to punch above their weight in how they think about and how they go to market with marketing because they don't have the budget and resource to compete. And those constraints force innovation. That's why we are so fascinated and driven by challenger brands. and the Rival 50 is, to be honest, the culmination of the thinking and research and observations that we do over the course of the year. It is the biggest thing that we do every year in partnership with Imperial College here in London to analyze the observable universe, as we like to call it, of challenger brands and to quantify the impact that they are driving with their marketing.

2:12So there's an actual ranking and an algorithm and a methodology that we will get into. And we get down to the top 50 and release that every year. Well, there's quite a bit of rigor here. Like, I think it's last year was impressively rigorous. I feel like this year it's to the nth degree. Took a step up for sure. So, but we start backwards, you know, building on what you said about the challenger principles. the thing that we want to get to is an understanding of how these brands are really breaking from the conventions of their category. You know, that's obviously something that's critical to understand with the challenger orientation.

2:50But importantly, we want to know how they perform on the principles that we believe are foundational to challengers. Differentiation, relevance, talkability. We believe that those are not just challenger principles, but there's a commercial orientation to those things. So the methodology this year was we did what we did last year. We opened and invited anyone who has an opinion, has a challenger brand that they think is worthy for consideration, please nominate. We got a very robust, healthy set of nominations like we did last year. But we really wanted to make sure that we cast a wide net. We wanted to make sure that we go beyond the usual suspects.

3:26I think that, you know, there's a few brands that are on repeat as anybody in the world talks about challenger brands, and we love that, and that's great. But can we extend beyond that to learn some new things? And so we basically created from our nominations lookalikes and used a very calculated way to leverage rival intelligence to cast a wider net. and our total base got up to what Dakota like 2200 20 over 2000 we'll leave it at 2000. 2000 and 79 brands. 2039 brands which is an impressive list the only thing that mattered other than looking like some of the nominations so having the qualities seemingly of a challenger brand but in that moment all that mattered was momentum are these brands that are growing is there evidence that they are growing share of voice share of talkability are they seeing revenue growth.

4:22We needed some proxy for confidence that these brands had a trajectory that was worth considering. And then we went into the rigor of scoring against the principles. Again, differentiation, relevance, talkability. I feel like you're going to hear that a million times over the next 40 minutes or whatnot. We had rival intelligence score them. We get into the data in a very significant way to make sure that there's kind of deep rationale behind it. And then we did human scoring. And we did that twice. And then we sent it to advisors to give us their opinion. So the rigor behind this is pretty intense.

4:57And we felt pretty good about the list that we're going to share with you. We're excited. I think importantly, it's really not about who's really number one or two. It's really about the spirit behind each of these brands and the things that they're doing. So, you know, sorry, number one and number two, I think it's great that you're number one or two. But for me, it's as interesting to look at somebody who's in the 30th position because they're all worthy of, I think, some congratulations because you're doing interesting things. Yeah, and I will, I just want to give a quick shout out to our advisors because we had an amazing panel this year.

5:30We had Sadira Furlow, who's the ex-CMO of Tony's Chuck Lonely, Tom Denford, who's the CEO of IDcoms, Marcella, who is the global CMO of Dove. We had Paul Coxhill, who's the COO over at Informa, Dagmara from the ANA. So some real heavy hitters, but also a really good mix of challenger brand CMOs, incumbent CMOs, and then real senior people with different perspectives on the industry from the brand side, from the agency side. And of course, Rajash, the marketing professor at Imperial College. So bringing that kind of academic perspective to the table as well. Lance, I want to ask you a question that I get all the time when I'm talking to people about the Rival 50.

6:10They say, well, how do you quantify differentiation relevance and talkability? So maybe you could just talk a little bit about the methodology that we developed and how we actually come with a number to say this brand is more or less differentiated. Yeah, and Dakota, feel free to chime in because she, I think, was probably monitoring this more closely than anybody else. I mean, importantly, in order to understand if you are pushing off of the category, we have to understand the category. So we go deep in each category. Like once we have the nominations, everybody falls into the appropriate category, automotive, CPG, what have you.

6:44And then we chronicle, what, 15, 20 brands within the category to really identify the conventions and understand what the conventions of the category are. So that that is what we're scoring against. Like how differentiated from the category is this brand in their design, in their brand positioning, in kind of how they market and how they move into the world. From a relevance perspective, we want to understand, are they doing things that are meaningful to consumers and for consumers? We want to understand, are they creating relationships with consumers or are they kind of old school on their approach where they're just scaling and kind of talking at consumers?

7:21Talkability, of course, is are they doing things that are so meaningful to their consumers that the consumers want to talk about it, want to talk about the brands and the moves that they make? And so, you know, to the best of our ability, this is not a perfect science, but, you know, we basically benchmark and we say, OK, this is what standout in this category means. And it gives us confidence that these brands are doing things that are interesting. So Dakota, you have lived, breathed, and as we were talking about before we pressed record, dreamed about this list for the last four months. Anything to add on kind of the methodology and the approach and maybe anything about how it was different for you this year?

8:01Because of course, you know, you were relatively new to the company, but you were heavily involved in the process last year as well. You are now Rival 50. That's your new name. That is my name now. I think this year we had an even more analytical approach. I mean, last year, yes, the methodology was rigorous, but this year we actually taking the time to look at the categories and look at what are the current category conventions before deciding, okay, they're actually challenging it. that really set things apart. I mean, looking at who are the big incumbents, who are the heavy hitters to compare against, I think it really did make the list stand out in an even bigger way and make this even more meaningful.

8:47Shall we get to the list? Let's go do it. All right. I'm going to see if I can share my screen for people watching on YouTube. Has somebody got a Dremel effect or something? We'll see if producer Tobias can work that in. um so hopefully you can see my screen if you're watching if not go to youtube or of course go download the report the rival 50 it is here i will read off the top 10 and then dakota would love your commentary on any surprises in terms of what's included what who wasn't included um or or kind of the rankings and then lance same from you number actually i gotta go number i gotta go 10 up don't i okay number 10 of course a uh a family favorite over here particularly for me is Crocs.

9:30Number nine, Tony's Chaka Lonely. Number eight, one of my favorites from the list this year, Slate Auto. Number seven, Sidemen. Number six, Fenty Beauty. Number five, Who Gives a Crap. Number four, Dr. Bronner's. Number three, another fan favorite, Liquid Death. Number two, Awala. And number one, Hoka. Dakota, reactions from you as this list came together and as you see it now? I mean, we obviously have to address the fact that Oala and Liquid Death, as well as Crocs, were on our top 10 last year. The fact that Liquid Death literally held its own, it was number three last year, it's still number three, is pretty impressive.

10:14But I think the main thing that we need to highlight is the fact that Tony's Chocolonely and Fenty Beauty were both on the Rival 50 last year but were much lower down the fact that they moved into the top 10 alone was a pretty big thing um the biggest shock that most people will probably have and i know lance and i have had this conversation is sidemen no one thinks of like sidemen and thinks a brand they think content creators so i think that's one that's gonna be a little bit of a shock for people if they know that i mean maybe you can just take a second to explain who they are because i actually hadn't heard of them before but maybe that's just me i think that lance has an even better explanation because i had to go do my research i'm not a youtube girl but lance it's seven guys who who started creating content like that's the you know the basis of it um and we talked about i mean first of all yes their brand like in every like by every definition of the word the um the thing you know as we talked about do they belong on those lists we're like how are how is netflix how would Netflix be appropriate to be in this list but they wouldn't be appropriate to be in this list and so we really went deep on like yes they are creating content but they are a brand in their own right and yes they create quite a bit of content go check them out in the interest of time in the interest of time Lance any other reactions for you yeah the ones you know I've always loved Tony's Chuckle just from you know day one when you first had that product and you open it, you know, the product itself conveys the brand's position and purpose.

11:54You know what I mean? The inequity is in the product itself. Love that. Have always loved that. I think that they continue to scale. I'm starting to see them in places in the United States, which honestly surprised me. So love that they are taking that position and seeing such great growth. I think that Slate Auto is an interesting one. I maybe was not as interested in that brand when it launched, but watching what they're doing and how they are launching the brand is interesting. And that's in our write-up. But the other thing that, as we wrote this, that became very clear is one of the trends that they are kind of at the top of the list of in terms of reductionism.

12:33So they're interesting to me from that. I love Who Gives a Crap. Dr. Bronner's new, very interesting, with the shift that they made, kind of pushing off the category that um because they didn't believe there was an authenticity anymore so some of the moves that they made and the reasons they did it so really really interesting list when you get to the top 20 it gets even more interesting we've got a feld or field a dating app uh bandit running really born of microcultures vacation um and a really awesome sunscreen kind of you know probably reduced it to something too small, but created an interesting universe with a product that is a category that's so well-trodden that it's no longer interesting.

13:18They breathe new life in it. Love, Wallabach, am I saying that correctly? Yeah, me too. I tried to look it up to see if there was some guidance on pronunciation. You know, their position is we don't design clothes for the next season, we design for like the next century. I'm butchering it, but the premise is they are not following the tropes of the fashion category and delivering something completely unique. Love their founder. So really interesting list. And I got to point out Graza. Graza, of course, has been so disruptive to the olive oil category. When's the last time there was innovation in olive oil?

13:54It's really interesting to see a brand always move in to a very storied kind of category that is rich with green bottles. and, you know, the labels all connote some aspect of Italy, it feels like, or certainly the Mediterranean. So love seeing that brand continue to push into new places. The only other one I'm going to call out is our winner from last year was Boldak. They did make the top 50, but they dropped down to 23. And actually, I just got connected with their North American CMO. So we're going to have him on the podcast. We'll dig into why that happens. All right. Shall we get on to the trends?

14:30So, Lance, I'm going to kind of let you drive here. Why don't we first, you know, tell people we're going to tell them and then tell it to them and then tell them what we told them. What are the seven biggest trends from the Rival 50 research this year? Okay, so we'll go through them very quickly and then we'll go back and spend a little more time on them. Yes. Yeah. So the overview on the seven and then we'll dig into each one. Trend one, flip the category's emotional code. Trend two, start inside a microculture and then let it carry you out. Trend three, run your brand like a franchise, not a campaign.

15:09Trend four, marketing moves into the product brief. Trend five, ship the brand unfinished. Trend six, sell what you take away. trend seven, design for disagreement. I want to just start as we dig into these by saying, as we were evaluating the trends, we probably had a list of, I don't know, 14 trends and then, and we decided on these, these seven. I will say that some of these don't feel abundantly new. Some of them are like really kind of fresh, but some of them feel like moves that we have seen brands make for a long, long time. And we talked a lot about how interesting it is that challengers are so effective at taking the playbook of the category leaders or the incumbent playbooks and flipping it, or in the case of a few of these trends, just grabbing something.

16:05And it's something that the category maybe hasn't paid attention to for a while and started to take it and turn it into an advantage for them. I think that at the top of the list is trend one, which is, I gotta go back to my list, flip the emotional code. This is one, as we were writing this, I thought a lot about, and I went back to my days at a Chicago mega agency. And I'm not gonna name any names, but there was, the organization had a lead researcher. She was a statistician. maybe one of the smartest people I've ever met in my life, like impressively thought-provoking and was really able to like dissect with data things that marketers should pay attention to.

16:50One of those things was the emotional code of every category. And interestingly, you know, like in CPG specifically, the emotional code or the emotion that generally most are anchored in is some version of joy. And to that degree, most marketers are like, well, what's my version of joy? What is our articulation of joy? How do we, you know, stand out in the category that owns joy? And she created, she did a study. There's actually 96 different forms of joy. Like the joy that you get from having a baby is very different than the joy of getting your first job, is very different than the joy of buying your first house.

17:26And she very successfully articulated and argued that, you know, joy needs to be more specific for a brand to really be able to leverage it. What I love about, while that's all true and that's good, this trend says, don't try to find your space in the category. Go the other direction. Flip the code. Just adopt a completely different emotion. And so, you know, you think about brands like, I made some notes here. You think about Liquid Death, right? That's a category that is completely about calm, pure, refreshing. We can all think of, you know, the ads we've seen for, you know, water. Um, they're even, you know, connoting relaxation.

18:05Liquid death comes in with bold, if not loud moves that are emotionally charged. I think that in a category that sells, you know, aspiration, Fenty offers affirmation. Um, I think in a category built on anxiety, Nix is really owning self-acceptance and empowerment. Um, in a dating category that sells hope, Field is offering belonging and freedom. and so I think that there is a really rich exercise to ask yourself you know what is the what is the emotion of the category and is that the emotion that we want to own or try to arrest or is there an opportunity for us to flip the script and take on a different approach a very very simple play but you know if if those who love liquid death and liquid death I think is the most cited brand that we that we hear people talk about when they talk about challengers just think about that like the decision to not be like fiji water you know what i mean and waterfalls etc and to go into a space that they've got what looks like heavy metal on the can and in the ethos um and obviously it arrests and it is powerful like so that's number one any builds thoughts on the emotional code all right then we're going to go to number two number two Number two, start inside a microculture and then let it carry you out.

19:29This is one that we've been talking about for a long time at Rival, microcultures. Microcultures, you probably have heard us say, are communities of like-minded people connected by identity, identifying interests and passions. They are, we also talk about, they are the replacement for monoculture. monoculture is you know on its last gasp if not completely dead and what has the influence of monoculture has transferred to microcultures and so these communities of people are very powerful in terms of the interests and the things that they get excited about surface up in culture we all take notes we get excited we even join the microcultures and then the next microculture bubbles up but the thing that we see in brands on the rival 50 this year is that previously and I think still for a lot of brands, they go to, you know, a microculture and they decide how can we advertise to them?

20:24How can we leverage them to do something interesting if not stunty by way of activation or maybe there's a collab or something that, you know, is the heart of what we do. And so they tend to find microcultures that give them, you know, the fodder insight to be able to do that. These brands are actually starting inside the microcultures. Sideman emerged from, you know, the world of UK YouTube, gaming and football. Lomography is built from the society around analog photography. Cactus Plant Flea Market is somewhere between toy collecting and streetwear. Liquid Death borrows from, you know, Kids of Metals we talked about.

21:01Bandit was born of the run club scene. So these brands are now looking for ways to leverage microcultures. The microcultures are the actual fuel for these brands and their movement and what they've been able to accomplish. And I think it's really important here because they understand the assignment with microcultures is, you know, to understand that, yes, mainstream exists, but find the orbits that people are already in, the places that they already live, and earn a piece of attention or relevancy within that, right? so these brands are not just you know moving in and making claims and doing things that are interesting for talkability purposes they're actually anchoring and belonging which is what we think is so important for brands to understand about microcultures anyway so love love that we're seeing microcultures continue to be a theme um any thoughts on microcultures builds observations I'll jump in and then I'll let Dakota build as well.

22:08But I think, you know, the steal this at the bottom, I think this is one of the most applicable, actionable insights. And we talk about this all the time, right? Like we do a lot of this microculture work with our clients. The idea of, you know, it says here, stop asking which demographic to target, ask which community you could genuinely serve. I don't know that it necessarily needs to be a stop. I think this can be like a yes. And, you know, I was actually on a call earlier today with Cecilia, who leads our microcultures work with the CMO of a very household name brand here in the UK. And he was saying, we spent all this money on this audience segmentation work.

22:42You know, you need that to a certain extent. But then you come in and you do the microculture segmentation so that you know the who, but you also know the way to make your communication and ideally your product more relevant to them. And that's really the core of the microculture research that we've been doing since you joined Lance over two years ago is that we see challenger brands prioritizing relevance over reach because reach is no longer enough in the crowded and competitive world, not just from a competitive set in terms of other brands that are trying to sell the same product, but from an attention set as well in terms of how many demands there are on people's attention and how crowded people's feeds are.

23:25Dakota, anything else that you'd add on this one before we move on? Honestly, I'm also happy to see that more bigger mainstream brands are also realizing and waking up to the fact that they should be tapping into microcultures. I mean, Selena Gomez's Rare Beauty brand a couple of months ago in the wake of a very big like book talk moment named their first ambassador, celebrity ambassador. She is the actress from off campus and it went everywhere and it was right after the series launch. So you're seeing more and more mainstream, bigger, not necessarily always challenger brands tapping into microcultures as well.

24:06Yep. And again, back to what I said at the beginning of the future of marketing that's here, but just not evenly distributed is what we always see. Right. The forced innovation of these challenger brands eventually gets adopted by the incumbent brands because it all comes down to outsize impact. How do you do more with less? Everybody wants to do more with less. But then what's new becomes standard and you have to challenge what's standard. You have to challenge the convention in order to do more with less, in order to engineer outsize impact. And so, as you said, Lance, the principles remain the same, but the practices of how you apply them are changing constantly.

24:44And that's why this research is so fascinating and so important. Yeah. Should we move on to number three? We should. Run your brand like a franchise. When you're brand like a franchise. I mean, last year we talked about challenger brands were thinking like media companies, right? In terms of how they think about publishing content, learning attention. You know, what we're witnessing is brands, you know, that are small. These are not brands that have massive budgets that can go create worlds. These are brands that are small, but very inventive with how they think more like franchises. They're not just making content.

25:18They own the characters. They're creating a world of IP that they can leverage. You know, in the write-up, we talked about kind of the science behind this is the, you know, salience and mental availability. They're creating hooks, right, which has always been important for brands to, you know, to be remembered, to be successful. So we love that we're seeing brands like an entire fictional 1980s company, which became Vacation Inc., right? Love that Liquid Death, you know, has an identity that's built around murder, your thirst. and a platform that they continuously invest in. Duolingo obviously has been a standout here with their Almas dot and the way that they continue to build fandom around that.

26:01I think that cactus plant flea market is going to be interesting for people to see on this list. But I think that this notion of them building a world is a real critical reason why they're showing up on this list. But the thing that is so critical is that there's kind of a holistic orientation around how these brands think, right? They're thinking about things bigger than just what my 30-second video asset is going to look like. Like, they're really imagining, like, what is the world that they can create? How do people participate in it? How do people engage? In terms of the investment that they make in this world and the things that they create, how does, you know,$5 actually equal$20?

26:43so there's a rigor and a willingness to think beyond a single tactic which i think is for a lot of marketers it's tough because i need something in this period and i need a 30 second video spot that's going to do this thing for me and these brands are certainly recognizing that consumers will engage with something if they find it interesting and relevant to them you know yes we have terrible attention spans but in a world where we will binge watch the latest whatever were interested on Netflix, just these brands recognize that creating a franchise that has the same pole is a very powerful, powerful lever.

27:21Dakota, anything to add? I mean, we discussed this last year, obviously, with our one trend where we were thinking beyond like commercial brands about what is a challenger brand when someone nominated Dochi as a challenger brand during the initial process. And I think we're seeing a lot more consumers want to belong in a world There's a lot of escapism. And I mean, one of the collaborations that I loved this year, which was actually one of our top 15, Nick's, they recently in wake of the release of Sarah J. Moss's latest installment of the Court of Thorn and Roses series, did a collaboration. Now, we see a lot of brands doing collaborations with like movies and TV series, but books like people want to belong in a world.

28:07and they recognize that this is a world that so many readers love and so many consumers love. So they tapped into it. And I mean, that limited edition run, it went everywhere. So I think there is a really massive surge in consumers just wanting to belong in other worlds now. Amen. All right. So the steal this for trend three, how to apply this for your own business. Think like a showrunner, not a campaign planner. Define your world's rules and characters and then commit for the long term. So it is the think like a media company that we talked about last year, but it's taking it further. It's thinking like a show producer.

28:41Who are the characters? What are the storylines? And how do you bring those to life over the long term, not in traditional campaign cycles? Trend number four, marketing moves into the product brief. Lance, you touched on this briefly with Slate, but give us the overview. Yeah, I mean, look at Tony's Chocolonial, look at Graza. I do want to give a shout out to a brand that I worked on that's not a challenger, it's not on this list, but understands this to its very core, and that is Oreo cookie. Oreo is a black and white sandwich cookie, and it is the brand as much as the product, right? The twist, look, dunk, the whole brand experience is based on the product truth, the embossment of the cookie, etc.

29:20et cetera. I love, it was something that, you know, really always respected Mondelez for staying close to that in terms of how that brand moves into the world and operates. These brands are all are doing the same thing. They are making the product the brief and it is the core part of the brand experience. And so I just love that. Honestly, before any ad was ever created, these brands are thinking about how the product can be differentiated, how it can be part of the narrative. I think one of the things that we wrote in this write-up, keep me honest, Dakota, is, you know, they're imagining not only how it's going to look on shelf, they're imagining how it's going to show up on Instagram.

29:59They're really thinking about, like, how this product can be visually arresting and a big part of the narrative. talked about Tony's Chocoloni Graza obviously belongs in the system because as I said earlier this you know you walk into the olive oil aisle and it is a sea of same if you will not different than who gives a crap you know what I mean a while that an aisle in the any market that's white these brands have gone in and said let's make the product a big part of the narrative and I think more brands could do that I think Slade Auto is doing it in terms of what they're allowing people to do with the brand so So move the product itself, you know, give it more attention and time and ask yourself, are there things that we could be doing to make the actual product a bigger part of the narrative?

30:44And I love that as like, you know, most marketing teams don't have ownership, but hopefully most have some influence on the product development. So just thinking more broadly and again, back to this is really about the fundamentals in a way, but how do you apply it in a modern world? You think about the four P's of marketing, product is in there. And so if you are only thinking about Marcoms, take a step back, broaden your perspective. And I love this in the steal this section. Add one question to every product review. What will this look like on someone's phone? And I think that that's a really tangible and specific thing to take away and try to apply within your own business.

31:24Number five is kind of somewhat related, but comes from a very different. and I think much more unique insight, really, shipping the brand unfinished. Lance, you want to tell us about this one? Yeah, so this is one that is very new and really interesting. And kind of the science behind it is really provocative. As we got into studying Slate and Crocs and Duolingo and others, we went back and said, what is happening with these brands that makes this interesting? And what we leaned into or discovered was basically the IKEA effect. And it's this notion that people value products more when they've helped make them and they feel greater liking, ownership and connection, you know, to their own identity.

32:12That's not a surprise. We love to, you know, we live in a world that loves to curate everything. We love to curate our homes. We love to curate how we look, you know, music lists, et cetera. So any brand that allows us to basically curate, you know, is a brand that we love and generally plays an important role in our lives. These brands have taken that to the nth degree. Crocs is not new. The gibbets and the ability for people to customize and make that brand their own is a real important part of how they've been successful, especially with, you know, younger consumers. But to watch Slate basically offer a car as a blank canvas and offer it at a price point that allows you to paint it any way you want to with over 100 accessories or fits, etc., is such a provocative move, right?

33:00Right. In a world, you know, automotive specifically where you can get, you know, what low, the normal package, which nobody wants the middle package, which everybody gets the premium package, which everybody aspires to. This is brand is saying, like, this is your art. Make it any way you want to. And we think that that's super provocative. And I suspect that we're going to see more brands start to do this and find ways to not just have the marketing being finished. And I mean, Duolingo is so good about saying, help us finish the narrative. You know, whatever you, however you participate is going to help us decide the outcome.

33:35These brands are actually baking in like the product into the narrative that allows consumers to finish the story. Dakota, any additional builds from your perspective? I mean, honestly, what Slate Auto has done is brilliant. But I think we're also just living in a world right now where consumers want personalization. They don't just want a product anymore. They want to say in how the product is. They want to show up differently in the world. Nobody wants to just fit in anymore. So I think this is something that is becoming increasingly more apparent across brands. So true. Trend six, second to last.

34:14Lance, tell us about trend six, what you take away. Think about the world that we live in, right? We are absolutely in a place where people want less. They want to be inundated less by things on their phones. We wish the world would slow down. We want to make time for more things. Like people are in a reductionist mindset. And even with that, what we are seeing most brands do is continue the trajectory that they've been on for the past 20 years, which is a race to the new, a race to more. Like I've got to find the latest, you know, shiny object to add to my product or to my marketing. And that's going to be how I'm going to be successful.

34:56Innovation has been the lifeblood of brands finding ways to be relevant and talkability, right? Certainly, you know, that is going to continue to be important to think about. But what these brands are doing is saying, actually, we're going to go the other way. We're going to take things off the table. We're going to reflect a culture that wants less, that wants more time, that wants less anxiety, however you want to package it. These brands are recognizing that there is a reductionist mindset that's on the move and they're really anchoring in it. So again, you know, Slate is showing up here with, you know, there's no touchscreen, there's no paint, there's manual windows.

35:35Light Phone sells a phone designed to be used as little as possible, right? Volaback has removed seasonal collections, logos, lifestyle from everything that it does. Molabad takes the same kind of approach to privacy. Lomography sells imperfection. Havanachi sells paper. Like, when's the last time he wrote anything down? I don't even think I'm capable of writing anymore. But these brands just are saying, there is a movement and insight for us to leverage in terms of, rather than add more, let's actually take things away and make that the narrative. That's the story. and I do think that it is something that every brand has permission you know in the steal this section where you say why don't you do what do we call it a subtraction audit you know I mean list every feature and ask yourselves is there a benefit to consumers to taking it off the table and celebrating it yeah and again to the conversation about product and marketing you know if you're in an earlier stage business typically there's closer integration if not more control between those two disciplines.

36:40But however your business is structured, just asking that question of what do we currently offer that actually people would be more interested in if we took it away? And that could be actually a unique selling proposition. It kind of like flips things on its head because to your point, Lance, so much of modern marketing is more, more, more. But we're seeing this trend that challenger brands, again, are leading. They're ahead of the curve where actually less can be such a key selling point. I mean, and, you know, it's important to note that, you know, major brands that are famous for their annual announcements or their product, their latest products, et cetera, are falling victims to this reality because there's what I call disappointment.

37:20Like every year we're like, what's it going to be? And then we're like, that's it. so you know like this notion of reductionist is actually you know something even those brands should consider because you know of that disappointment and the moves aren't landing the way that i think that um that the brands want them to so last trend design for disagreement which is my favorite anybody who knows me knows that i am a contrarian by nature you are designed for disagreement i was designed for disagreement this is a lance trend so um as a strategist i I have my entire life tried to help brands be bold and to really think about, you know, any trade-off that they're going to make when it comes to understanding consumers' perceptions.

38:03Because we live in a world where marketing is built to avoid rejection. You know what I mean? Like, we don't want to be in the center of any controversy because controversy is risk and it's bad. and to that end when you know people create advertising or agencies create advertising marketers create advertising there's a pursuit to make sure that the edges are as sanded down as you possibly can to make sure that there's no edge to it and you know in many ways that creates advertising that is you know not memorable like in the simplest of terms so what i love about this trend is that these brands, it's not that they're polarizing.

38:48They're not trying to be divisive. They're not trying to move in a world where they're just like creating talk value for talk value, but they are absolutely, you know, willing to, um, to, you know, basically put, to make strong reactions, their goal, like rather than, you know, orient around something that is sanded down there, their orientation is how can we make sure that this gets noticed and creates a strong reaction went over the direction. So, you know, Crocs has been the one that I think lots of people have talked about in this capacity for a while. I think that they were apologetic about their shoe design when they launched.

39:25And, you know, maybe not apologetic, but certainly were, like, aware that the products were not necessarily high fashion. And now they're celebrating the fact that, yes, we don't look like everybody else. You know, we are, and consumers love that for love that about us um i think that there's brands that are um like liquid death just finding interesting ways to move into the world and be themselves and some people find it polarizing and ridiculous and some people don't i think cactus plant flea market volabock are brands that are creating controversy just be by by being themselves which is confusing to some people you know i mean so like not needing to make sure that everything is crystal clear is also something what these brands do, right?

40:09They let kind of the brand ethos be a part of what can be, you know, perhaps discouraging or there can be some disagreement about. But I think the thing that more brands could just, you know, steal here is, you know, a discussion about what you're willing to lose. Like, is there more to be gained from that, you know, sanding the edges off as we talk about in this trend? Dakota, what else did you see as you were identifying this trend, seeing the brands that were doing it well? I mean, I think there's something to be said in trying to be something for everyone just means you mean nothing to everyone.

40:47These brands, they understand exactly who they're for and they're OK with not being something to other people. When you're when you're set in like who you are, your ethos, you will attract the right people. Liquid Death's been doing it for so long. And I mean, yes, there are a lot of their ads and a lot of their marketing tactics that a lot of people find shocking, but their audience loves it. They thrive on it. I mean, their limited edition drops sellouts in seconds. So I also think that there are a lot of brands within the top 50 that are doing it, maybe not in such extreme lengths, but even just Crocs.

41:28I mean, they understand that there are people who find their shoes ugly, but they know that there are people who love it as well. It may not be as aggressive, but they stick to their ethos. Yeah, it's a fun trend. So those are the seven trends. So again, for everybody listening, but hopefully you go read the report. Flip the emotional code. Start inside a microculture. Run your brand like a franchise. Marketing moves into the product brief. Ship the brand unfinished. we've got sell what you take away and lastly design for disagreement and then i'll read these key takeaways for cmos so again we want this to be as actionable as possible we talked through how you can steal each of these trends and apply it but if we sum it up and then lance and dakota i'm going to give you the last word i always like to ask at the end of every podcast what is the one thing if you had to pick one thing for people to do differently after this conversation and the last four months of of research that you all have done what would it be but the key takeaway is that we have summed up, audit your category's convention.

42:30What is everybody else doing? And just knowing, and often, like you said, Lance, you can see the sea of sameness. You know, we literally, when we start a project, we put it up on a wall or put it up on a mirror board. You can see how similar the language is, the visual identity is. You need to know where everybody else is, the center of gravity in your category so that you can challenge it and find a white space. Number two, find the emotion that your category forgot. Is there a different way in to create emotional connection with consumers in your category that again would be different from what everybody else is doing.

43:03Number three, map the communities around your brand. Again, we have a whole white paper on this and a methodology in our product with Rival Intelligence to help do this. Number four, bring marketing into the product review. Number five, run a subtraction audit. Number six, design for participation. And number seven, check your stack, which is, I know this is a little bit cheeky, but this is my takeaway. Obviously, go read the report and set 30 minutes on your calendar with your team to have an honest conversation. Take these seven trends and say one to 10, where are we against these? And pick the top three that you think can have the biggest impact, but also the ones that are going to be most actionable.

43:43You know, maybe you're not in a position where you can really influence the product and try to subtract something from the offering, but maybe you can map the category convention or identify microculture. So set a 30-minute meeting to discuss the findings of this report and the seven trends with your team. That is my one thing. Dakota, what is your one thing people should do differently? I would say, and it's easier said than done, but I would say stop being afraid to look too closely. I think a lot of people, a lot of marketers, a lot of brands, they kind of just accept that this is the brand and let's make a way forward with what it is instead of investigating a little too closely and thinking what actually could we change what actually could we do differently and i think you need to move past that fear and actually just have the conversation of okay this isn't working what can we change i love that i love that because there are people behind all of these brands making these decisions you know i mean this isn't like a robot making the decisions like they're people um and they are i think um explorers you know i mean if not dreamers who are just imagining different ways and i think that what you just said about looking closely and then covering is um you know is ultimately what makes them successful my one thing is actually a page in the report which is i think that often we look at like what's the trend what's the thing that I want to go grab.

45:11What we notice with these brands, especially that I'm just going to read this to you, brands in our top 20 use an average of 2.8 of these seven moves against 1.65 for brands ranked 31st to 50th. Like there's a dynamism to be had in terms of doing a few of these things and recognizing that it's not any one thing that any brand does. it's the willingness to you know be bold on a few different fronts um and i would say you know the way that we end this document is to really um challenge the brief like when you are asking people to think about the brand and think about the work and develop things like really leverage this to really think about what am i asking people to do what is the actual brief that is going to get me to success and i think that's a role for these trends within that so and if you need help of that, obviously call us.

46:03So there you have it. That is the Rival 50 for 2026. A lot of work went into it again, over 2000 brands. So kudos to Lance and Dakota for leading a very large and integrated team here at Rival and putting it together. The report is now live. We are Rival.com slash Rival 50. Read it, download it. Would love your feedback. And of course, if you'd like to discuss it more with us. We're also doing lunch and learn sessions for client teams and partner teams. So if that's something that's of interest to you, get in touch on the website. Thank you so much for listening. And thank you so much to the folks that nominated brands for the list this year.

46:40And the sun is up behind me, which is obviously the richest metaphor we could provide. There you go. All right. Hope you enjoy.

From the publisher

More than 2,000 brands went into the pool. Only 50 came out the other side.

In this episode of Scratch, Eric Fulwiler sits down with Rival Chief Strategy Officer Lance Koenig and Rival Media Content Strategist Dakota Steyn to unveil the 2026 Rival 50 Challenger Brand Index - and the top 10 that made the cut.

They walk through how the list got built: nominations widened into a pool of 2,039 brands, then scored on momentum, differentiation, relevance and talkability through a mix of data, human judgment and advisor review. Then they get into what actually separates the brands at the top from everyone else.

We get into:

→ How 2,039 brands got narrowed to 50, and why momentum was the first filter

→ The 2026 top 10, from Hoka and Owala to Liquid Death, Fenty Beauty and Crocs

→ Why Sidemen counts as a brand, and what that says about where attention lives now

→ Seven challenger-brand trends, from flipping a category's emotional code to designing for disagreement

→ Why brands in the top 20 used nearly double the moves of brands ranked 31-50

→ Practical ways to apply the findings, from auditing category conventions to running a subtraction audit

The key takeaways:

The only thing that mattered first was momentum - Before anything else got scored, the pool was filtered for brands that were actually moving: against competitors, against their category, against expectation.

Differentiation, relevance, talkability - The three pillars behind every score. Standing apart, connecting with real audiences, and earning conversation without paying for it.

Stop asking which demographic to target. Ask which community you could genuinely serve - The shift from broad targeting to microcultures shows up again and again in this year's list.

Think like a showrunner, not a campaign planner - The brands building franchises, not campaigns, are the ones compounding attention over time.

Add one question to every product review: what will this look like on someone's phone - Marketing doesn't start after the product is built. It starts in the brief.

Run a subtraction audit - List every feature, then ask if there's a benefit to taking one away and celebrating that instead.

Trying to be something for everyone just means you mean nothing to everyone - Why the sharpest brands on the list chose a side.

Brands in the top 20 used an average of 2.8 of the seven moves, against 1.65 for brands ranked 31st to 50th - The gap between the two halves of the list isn't talent. It's how many of these moves a brand is willing to make.

Watch this episode:

▶️ YouTube: https://youtu.be/ddF8eh2ut_Q 

Scratch is a production of Rival, a marketing innovation consultancy. Hosted by Eric Fulwiler, featuring Lance Koenig and Dakota Steyn of Rival.

Find Rival: wearerival.com | LinkedIn

Find Eric: LinkedIn

Find Lance: LinkedIn

Find Dakota: LinkedIn

Say hi: [email protected]

Rival is a marketing consultancy for brands that want to challenge convention in their category. We’re on a mission to understand what challenger brands do differently to grow in categories that are being disrupted, and use a challenger playbook to deliver outsized impact through an integrated, tech-enabled approach. Past guests include CMOs from Mastercard, GE, Shell, Hyperloop, Adobe, PepsiCo, and Papa Johns.

More from Scratch: CMO Interviews

All episodes