1. Podcasts
  2. Scriptnotes Podcast
  3. 759 - What It's About? Moving Beyond Loglines
Scriptnotes Podcast

3 Nov 2026 · 52m · 20 chapters

Episode artwork

759 - What It's About? Moving Beyond Loglines

In short

How to pitch “what your project is about” beyond a logline (using emotion, theme, vibe, and audience-specific framing), plus practical guidance on budgeting and raising money to get from script to film. It also includes a Halloween game guessing non-horror movies from misleadingly scary loglines.

Guests

Pamela Ribon (writer/filmmaker; animation work including Moana, Nimona, Ralph Breaks the Internet; Oscar-short My Year of Dicks; making first feature documentary). Phil Hay (writer; co-wrote The Invitation, Destroyer; TV: Mysterious Benedict Society; studio films including Ride Along and Clash of the Titans; Austin Film Festival finalist/semi-finalist).

Key claims

A pitch should answer “what is this,” “why is it interesting,” and especially “why should you care.” Also, “why does this have to exist?” and “how do I want people to feel?” Loglines can mislead; the real “what it’s about” is discovered during writing. For funding, start with realistic budget scale (under $1M for first films; ~$3M is a common threshold), build a team (director/producer), and use comps, pitch decks, reels, and early footage.

Notable examples

Pamela’s documentary One Act (Texas high school one-act play competition). Phil’s “Crazy Beautiful” pitch as a tragic teen romance “love story” for teenagers. “Go” as a vibe-first pitch. Game examples: Finding Nemo, A Christmas Story, The Parent Trap, While You Were Sleeping, Paddington, The Princess Bride, Toy Story, Shrek, Silver Linings Playbook.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Craig's Absence and Humor

The hosts humorously discuss Craig's absence and speculate on his situation.

“Bill and Pamela, you've both been guests before.”
3:28

Introducing The Hosts

Each host introduces themselves and shares their background in screenwriting.

“I'm a semi-retired baseball coach, mainly.”
6:28

Live Show Agenda

John outlines the main topics to be discussed during the live show, including loglines and funding.

“It changed my life, and it's about to turn 100 years old.”
7:20

Pam's Documentary Overview

Pam discusses her documentary about a theatrical competition in Texas.

“You talked about, you gave us a sense of scale.”
8:31

Logline and Emotional Pitching

The hosts analyze the importance of loglines and emotional connections in pitching films.

“Talk to us about how you go from this is the pitch to this is what's really underneath there.”
9:51

Understanding Audience Engagement

Phil discusses how to engage audiences by focusing on the emotional core of a project.

“And that movie was an unabashed, tragic romance that really went for it.”
14:00

The Essence of a Movie: Feeling and Spirit

Learn how to convey the essence and vibe of a film beyond just its plot.

“How do I make this thing happen in the world?”
16:54

Techniques for Effective Pitching

Discover techniques for pitching films, including the 'blank meets blank' approach.

“There's so many of you, it's easier to tell you something.”
20:16

Navigating Collaborative Conversations

Understand the dynamics of discussing and defining a film's vision with collaborators.

“And I'm not trying to redecorate your room.”
24:25

Introducing the Game: Misleading Loglines

Get ready for a fun game identifying non-horror movies based on misleading loglines.

“This is very relevant to this discussion.”
Show all 20 chapters
26:14

Game Show: Guess the Movie

Participate in a lively game where contestants identify movies from loglines.

“We are going to be reading you log lines and you're going to raise your hand if you know what the movie is.”
28:00

Game of Movie Loglines

The hosts engage in a fun guessing game based on movie loglines.

“A charismatic Peruvian stowaway uses politeness to attach themselves to a kind family, but their feral nature and insatiable hunger cannot be contained.”
31:00

Transitioning from Ideas to Fundraising

Discussion on the challenges of moving from a movie idea to actual funding.

“Would you like the three-page challenge or the character creator hit?”
31:58

Budgeting for Film Projects

Insights on how to estimate and work within a film budget effectively.

“We've made movies inside the studio system.”
35:08

Finding Your Team in Filmmaking

Advice on assembling a team of directors and producers for independent films.

“So I'll try not to repeat myself too much, but some of it's the same, which is there are people out there whose job is to find funding for independent movies.”
38:49

Navigating Independent Film Financing

Discussion on the importance of networking and connections in film financing.

“and they know how to pinch the pennies yet actually deliver the value.”
40:05

Pitching Your Film Idea

Exploring effective methods to pitch film ideas and gather support.

“because nobody was going to give me any money and I had to get started if I wanted to catch the season and I had these people that were great and willing to do it.”
42:00

The Journey of a Documentary

Explore the challenges and insights involved in documentary filmmaking.

“And then I just was taking their own footage of them at award ceremonies and putting together the history of this contest and how it feels that it is sports.”
44:20

Finding Unique Funding Opportunities

Learn about unexpected sources of funding for films and documentaries.

“We've only made one documentary and helped out on another documentary.”
46:04

One Cool Thing: Useful Apps

Discover helpful apps that enhance your everyday life.

“It's finding what is specific and unique about your story that can get someone to write a check is often a good starting place.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Scriptnotes Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:11John August: Hello and welcome. My name is John August. Pam, Pam Ribon. I'm Phil Hay. And this is Script Notes. It's a podcast about screenwriting and things that are... Interstate Screenwriters. So well, so, so, so well done. I'm so proud of you all. Thank you all for being with us here in Austin, Texas. Welcome, everyone, to Austin, Texas. Man!

0:44John August: This is the 12th time that we've done a live show here in Austin, Texas. It's fantastic. Bill and Pamela, you've both been guests before. Now you're elevated to actual co-hosts this time. They are not guests. Big moment. They are co-hosts. Huge moment. And this would have happened even if Craig had been here, but Craig for some reason is not here. We're not entirely clear. I'm going to be honest with you here. So Craig is shooting a show called The Last of Us. Alaska. In Vancouver. And if you listen to the episode this week, he was like, okay, I have to fly to Denver and then fly to here. But he didn't make it.

1:16John August: So we need to figure out why. And so there's a couple of stories. We'll figure out what different people heard. What I heard is he got stopped at the border. And you know, they have those dogs who sniff your luggage. They sniffed his luggage, pulled him aside. They opened it up. What did they find? It was full to the brim with umbrage. He was trying to smuggle umbrage into Texas. Unforgivable. I was like, where did he get that in Canada? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, tariffs and all, I guess it's cheaper up there or whatever. But you heard something else? No, well, he kind of let me know that he wasn't coming because he had heard that he was just very worried about being replaced and that he was being replaced by you and me.

1:55And so he was like, will you biff it? Like, Pam, please just biff it. Take the L? Now, Phil, what did you hear? Well, it's interesting. I heard something related, but this is going to be, I think, very bad news for Craig. All right. But great news for all of you. I've orchestrated a coup. All right. So you did this. You did this. I did this. You sent the dogs. I put the pieces in motion.

2:20John August: Yeah. I'm the puppet master. It's my time to shine. So far, bloodless coup. So far. That's really what's happening. It's a 15-year plan, Phil A. It's had to take over Script Notes. And so I feel like I made it here, but these two may replace me as well. John, John, I have bad news for you. But we can get to it after the show. I want you to do your very best tonight. All right. So for folks, I think I realized about live shows is that we assume that everybody here has listened to Script Notes, but you might not. So my name is John August. I'm mostly a screenwriter I've also done some television.

2:57John August: I did Charlie's Angels. I did Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. I did Big Fish. I love to write animation. I'm doing a TV show right now. We're going to talk about those things, but I want these two to actually introduce themselves, like how you would introduce yourself. Pamela Ribbon, talk to us about who you are. Sure. Hi, I'm Pamela Ribbon. I'm a writer, filmmaker. I also wrote books. I work a lot in animation. I worked on movies like Moana and Nimona and Ralph Breaks the Internet. I had a short that went to the Oscars a couple years ago called My Year of Dicks. I've worked in TV. and I'm making my first feature in a documentary.

3:28Phil Hay, talk to us about who you are. How do you introduce yourself? I am Phil Hay. I'm a semi-retired baseball coach, mainly. I also am a writer and I have written a lot of movies. I work a lot with my wife, Karin Kusama, and my writing partner, Matt McFreddy. And so we made a movie called The Invitation and a movie called Destroyer. Thank you. Right on. we did those all together and we did a TV show called the Mysterious Benedict Society that used to be visible on Disney Plus and now is visible on bootleg servers in Serbia and Croatia it's actually on Amazon now it got back into the world of the living and then Matt and I have written a bunch of studio movies like the Ride Along movies and Clash of the Titans and some others so excited to see all you guys I went to UT I'm from Austin and so I love coming back I was a I was a finalist and a semi-finalist here at the Austin Film Festival, and it helped launch my career.

4:26John August: Yeah, all right, that's right. Tonight on this show, two main things I want to talk to you guys about, both of which are extremely applicable to pretty much everyone in this room. First is, how do you answer that question, what is your project about? So we'll discuss log lines, themes, framing, marketing messages. Basically, how do you answer what your film is about to different audiences? And second, I want to talk about how you find money to make your film. So either in the studio system or outside the studio system, and basically how you get from, like, I have a script to I have a movie, which is really the goal of writing any script.

5:03John August: We'll also play a game, because we have to play a game at the live show. It's an institution at Script Notes Live Shows that we play some sort of game that goes awry, and then we'll answer some listener questions at the end. And so a thing that Craig would normally stress is that a question is a thing that can be answered. It is not a statement with a question mark at the end. So think about a question you want to ask, ideally relevant to the three people who are on the stage. That would be fantastic. Yeah, it's the old way of doing things, John. Yeah. So tell us all the new script notes. Here's what we're looking for.

5:3845 second to five minute statements of intent. Just play it that way.

5:44John August: Yeah, some sort of statement would be like, am I wrong? Yeah, that's a good way. But let's start with what it's about. What is your thing about? And a perfect example is a documentary that Pam has made that is fantastic. I got to see the most recent cut of it just this afternoon. Pam, what is your documentary about? What do you say? What's your thing about? It's about the largest theatrical competition in the world. It's set here in Texas throughout every public high school in the state of Texas every spring. Friday Night Lights turns into theater. Following the football divisions, each high school enters a play between 18 to 40 minutes.

6:20You have seven minutes to set up, 40 minutes to perform, and seven minutes to strike, or you're disqualified. We followed eight to 10 schools around the state of Texas for one competitive season. I did this program in high school. It changed my life, and it's about to turn 100 years old. It is about the power of teachers and the gift of young people and young artists emerging throughout a state that is fighting to keep its independence and freedom.

6:44John August: Yes. Oh, wait. It's called One Act. It's called One Act. I was going to stress. That's an important thing. Damn it. Oneactfilm.com. Phil, let's see when I discuss how incredible it was how she just described that. That was flawless. You talked about her personal connection to it. I like you being the new head. That's right. Okay. Sorry. Yeah. God, remember when Craig used to be around and made everybody feel sad about themselves? We don't do that. The maize and sigh. Yeah. No. So let's talk about what was so great about that. There was a personal connection. This is a thing you actually did. It was relevant to this audience here in Texas.

7:22John August: You talked about, you gave us a sense of scale. This was the largest theater competition in the world. It encompasses this entire state that is 100 years old. All these things are so relevant every sentence piqued our curiosity which is a great part of a log line but is that really what it's about when you're in it so because that's the thing so that is a great pitch that what she did was so smart and remember when you first described this to me so we were at a writers guild animation mixer and free your writers tag let them be writers guild writers so we were at a mixer for the writers guild about animation and i said hey what are you working on She said, she told me that.

8:00John August: And I'm like, well, I have to help you. I feel a calling to help you. And that is a power of a great idea, very well expressed. And now a fantastic movie. Congratulations on. And he's my executive producer. And now I'm an executive producer. It is.

8:18John August: That was the log line, the elevator pitch. It had all those things. And yet, Phil, that's how you sell the movie, but it's not ultimately the movie you actually end up writing or end up doing. And so thematically underneath, well, the movie is really about this. Talk to us about how you go from this is the pitch to this is what's really underneath there. Yeah. Well, I would say to start with what Pam said is if you're trying to get your movie across in a short amount of time, there's three things that you would ideally do. One is, what is this? And two is, why is this interesting? And three, which is by far the most important thing, is why should you care?

8:58And sometimes people a little bit forget about the why should you care part, right? Like it's just like I have a clever premise and I'm going to get you that premise. So to me, my experience of doing this for a long time, the constant has been trying to let people understand why they should care about this, why it matters. And so it also goes to in writing the script. I mentor the Sundance Lab a lot. And over many years, what I sort of figured out is the two things that I ask every single person about their script and then about how they put it in the world is the two things you really ought to know are why does this have to exist?

9:32Not why do I want it to exist? Why does this have to exist? And number two is how do I want people to feel? Specifically, how do I want people to feel at the end? And so trying to think of like when you're pitching these things of like, and it's true, like different audience, like we talked before, it's like depending on who you're talking to, you're going to frame it differently, but you're never going to be able to like convey the complexities of an amazing plot you've created in that amount of time but you can convey what is different and special about it and why it matters and like when i listened to you speak i was like i get it why that matters that that makes my heart open i feel i want to see that you know so i would say sometimes we over focus on the thing and you know everybody gives you a formula and believe me the all the pros the same thing you see in a submission letter it's like when blank you know an archaeologist finally encounters blank all hell breaks loose because of blank you know like and there is a use to that right that's a utility but if it stops there that special part of like what's so individual about it can get lost so when i talk about something that we're doing i try to talk about i mean i'll go back to a really old example we had made a movie called crazy beautiful a long time ago and when we pitched it you know to the studio which is a weird thing like it's long enough ago that you would pitch a romantic drama to a studio and somehow sell it but what we said was like there used to be how many people know the movie love story okay good i'm not that seeming that out of touch it's that movie my parents watched yeah yeah yeah but we said you know there used to be movies like love story and there hasn't been one for a long time.

11:16And that movie was an unabashed, tragic romance that really went for it. And we want to do that for teenagers, because when you're a teenager, love is really life and death. It really does mean everything. And that was our pitch, basically. And then we obviously pitched what we were trying to do with it. But leading with the emotion or reaching back to a type of movie that you love, that is viable, but maybe there's people that was, that's kind of like why it needs to exist. We think people want to see these movies and they don't exist right now. That's one approach that I would say.

11:49John August: I used to work as a reader at TriStar. My job as a reader was I would read 10 scripts a week and write up the coverage on them. Part of the coverage was on that title page, you would have a log line. It was my responsibility to boil down this 120-page script into two sentences that accurately, hopefully, described it. It was always so tough. My job as a reader was just to give honestly what it was. I wasn't selling it hard. I was like, this is what actually literally happens in it. That's not useful for you as people who are going out there trying to make your movie because that log line, that two sentences that you described to somebody else, it's probably not your reason for why you're writing this movie, for why you want this movie to exist.

12:30John August: And so I would just urge you to be thinking about like, what is it about this that is so uniquely yours that you must see this movie in the world? Because too often I see these projects or people are describing their projects and it just feels It's like, well, that's maybe minimum viable movie, but it doesn't feel like your passion. It doesn't feel like the thing you actually most want to write in your life. And that's part of, when I ask, what is your movie about? What is it about to you? And what is it about to me? That's the emotional core there. I will say, that's the first time I've said that like that, in that order.

13:06So you asked me that question, I looked at this room, and then I started talking to you. and when we were standing next to each other at the mixer it actually started because you said you're always doing something interesting what are you working on right now this guy likes interesting things and that so i was answering that question so i said it in a different order i started with what would be interesting to you yeah she was describing the same project but she

13:29John August: was describing in a way that or where it was a nascent project at that point you kind of probably didn't know all the things no i think i just started filming yeah yeah but it was so clear They're like, oh, this is a great idea and you are exactly the person to deliver that great idea. I have to see this in the world and therefore how can I help you get to that next step? And that's when you're pitching to somebody, that is what it kind of needs to feel like. The right partners will be the ones who say like, I get what you're trying to do and I know that I couldn't do it, but I see that you can do it.

14:01John August: I want this thing to happen. How do I make this thing happen in the world? There's a project that I'm also executive producing this year, which will hopefully debut at festivals soon. And from reading the script, I'm like, well, this is not a movie I've seen in the world. It desperately needs to exist in the world. How can I help you do this? But even just this last week, the filmmaker came to me. It's like, we have to submit the log line for these festivals. And we're struggling because how do we make this movie feel like the thing that it is? And some movies are hard to distill that way, but it comes down to what is the vibe you're trying to get out of there?

14:35John August: Hopefully reading those two sentences gets a sense of what it feels like and what the voice of the film is. It's tough, but that is the editing of trying to get that distilled idea down. Yeah, and I would also add to that that really focusing on the feeling, the vibe, the spirit. This has a spirit. This has a really punk spirit. This has a spirit of kind of like a formal investigation that goes completely wild in the end. or thinking about feelings versus stuff. And like, I was just thinking when you're speaking, like one, like, maybe this is like a really specific technique thing that may help is one of the very common ways of pitching something is blank meets blank, right?

15:17And I, for so many years, fought that so hard. I was like, I will never do that. I don't do that, right? And eventually you realize you can do that. Like sometimes it really does help. And it's especially if it's, we just started a thing where I'm like, it really is. like the shining on a spaceship like that's what it is and that sounds good and that's great you know but what i'd encourage you guys to do the the twist on it the special sauce like is to pick an element of the things that you're talking about so to say it's the intense and weird lens on modern relationships that's in the invite and it's a little bit of the subversive conspiracy psychosis of the parallax view and it's like so you're not just saying it's parallax view and it's invite and it's another thing you're kind of picking out an element and thus you're making it specific for people and then the last bit of advice i'd say on that is you can't do the off the rack one at the moment so like no matter how hard you want to you can't be like well it's like obsession and like you just can't pick the two most successful things and put them together because people see through that even if it's legitimate so there's an art to if you're going to do it that way.

16:29Choosing, like, you also don't want to refer to things that no one's ever heard of or that weren't successful or whatever. But if you go a little further back into history, sometimes that's a little more compelling than everything within the last five years. Another thing that's hard about it, I find when I'm talking to people and we're just having a conversation and suddenly it's like, what are you, they'll tell me about it. I noticed that I just sort of look down and go it's um and I'm working so hard to keep eye contact and just answer that question without feeling like your pitch brain's starting and so what is it where is the first sentence I'm a person who's like let me tell you all of the thing at the same time with every word that has ever existed and then I'll be like oh I should have said one act but uh could have just started there um yeah so it's practice it's also practice in different proximities and uh rooms and stuff, for me, the further away you are, the easier it is for me to tell you what I'm talking about.

17:26There's so many of you, it's easier to tell you something.

17:30John August: I think what you're describing, Phil, in terms of blank meets blank, is that can be useful for framing. Because what we're really looking at is, how do I create an image in your mind of what space this story occupies? But you cannot stop there. That has to be early in the discussion so they get a sense of where the space is. And then it has to be specific to your movie and your vision, what your project is and why they need to see it and why you are the person who is so perfect for telling it. My first movie was called Go. And I love Go. Impossible to pitch. And I think because I kept trying to pitch this story, when really Go is about the feeling of being in your early 20s when you can just do the craziest shit over the course of one night and then you pick yourself up and go to work the next day.

18:13John August: Where it's not like that isn't the night that everything changed. No, it was just another night. It was just a crazy night. But then you move on. And that is the vibe. That is the experience that you're trying to convey. So yes, there's a lot of plot in that, but I cannot tell you the plot in a two-sentence pitch. I can just tell you what it feels like. And that's really, most crucially, what you're trying to do. It can be helpful to imagine, what would the trailer for your movie feel like? What music would you be playing? You're not going to describe that in the pitch, but you need to have that sense in you as you're talking about it.

18:46John August: Bill, you just set up a new project. It was just announced. Tell us about how you described it when you were telling people about it. Well, it's a project called Mouthwashing. It's based on a very beloved in a cult fashion video game from Sweden. And it's a very, you know, mouthwashing. They're wonderful people. All right, so one ticket sold. All right, exactly, we got it. Yeah, basically, I think we haven't really pitched it out to people yet, but when we talked about it, when we first came in to talk to them about it, We tried to reflect the values that we saw in the thing back to the team that made it and that we're going to adapt to this game.

19:26And it's tricky and it's a very complex moral landscape that the game's on. And that's what we went right to. We're like, we're not going to shy away from that. This is really about betrayal of trust. And this is about like male weakness. And this is about people who are forced to be together, that the proximity starts driving them crazy. and and so that movie was really important because i'm like it's also in a way the shining on a spaceship but specifically the intent we're trying to portray the intent and it helps that we made the invitation which is a psychological thriller about people in one space that can't trust each other at some point so we were able to say that like look this is a lot of what we care about and are interested in is to dig into you know those relationships falling apart and what happens when you watch people who literally can't leave because there's freaking void out there what they have to do to get along with each other or to survive each other but you know if i'm casually saying something like look it's got elements of alien it's got elements of the shining it's got elements of an entirely different thing that this game is it's very non-linear and it's very um philosophically particular so anyway it's like that audience was more like look i want you to understand and i want to reassure you that I'm walking into your room and I love the room that you have.

20:43And I'm not trying to redecorate your room. I'm trying to find all the other rooms that are right around it, you know, but it's interesting with something like that movie that is pretty complex to relate out how we will all eventually do that.

20:57John August: Well, I think what's crucial about what you're saying is that part of describing what it's about, it's not to some sort of external third party, but like two other collaborators, like this is what it's about to me. And you're all sort of showing your cards, this is what I think it is, and does that actually work for you? When I first met with Daniel Wallace, who wrote the book version of Big Fish, I had to say, this is what the movie is to me. This is what it is to me. Tell us what it is to you. Let's make sure we actually agree on how these things fit together. I warned him, I'm going to take your characters and dress them up in funny clothes.

21:29John August: You won't recognize some things, but I think you'll recognize the overall spirit of where we're getting to. Working in animation, it's a lot of describing this is my vision for where we're at let's all have a conversation and see what the the shared vision of this is or working even with a director one-on-one it's like where is the shared understanding of what this material can be i suppose the hardest part is your it's often not your vision it's a vision you're trying to reach of a thing that doesn't exist but we're all supposed to see it and you're still trying to keep your point of view because that's your job is to know how to write your voice.

22:06That's why you've been brought in. But it's to their sometimes studio brand of every single person in the whole wide world. So, you know, they're like, don't get weird. But then they want weird. They want a weird they didn't know they loved. And so how do you keep being you until they get used to the sound of you? When I first started on one of the movies, everybody had worked together for decades on The Simpsons. and I was new in the room. And so they had shorthand. Like, they had baked in, like, Simpsons already did it shorthand. And I was pitching, and they weren't quite hearing me. And one of the senior guys said, well, Pam just said, and I said, if you don't mind, I'm just going to say it again because they need to get used to the sound of my voice so that they know that I'm part of this.

22:55And I think when I was a younger writer, I'd have been like, thanks, Jim. But I needed, you know, when I was a younger writer, I definitely needed that guy to be like, Pam just said something funny. but I don't need it now. I need them to get used to a part of this.

23:07John August: So again, what it's about, it can be the very distilled elevator pitch version of your story. And maybe that's a starting place. Maybe that's some idea, some image that got you excited about the idea and it got you thinking about it and got you excited to write it. Finding out how to communicate that same excitement and passion to everyone else who you're going to talk to about the project in a language and in a way that they're going to understand. And so that's why it's different as you're talking to each different person, because some people will need that framing and they'll need to understand like, this is how you could market this movie.

23:41John August: This is because this other movie worked this last summer. That's a good reference for you. So I'm going to say it, even though it doesn't really apply to my movie. That is fair game. But that shouldn't impact what the movie actually means to you. And don't let that warp your perspective on what it is you're actually writing and what is it about to you. because that's the process that you will probably start with an inspiration and it will change over the course of writing. All the projects we've written and that we're known for change because we wrote them. What it's about, you're discovered in the process of writing and that's also a crucial thing.

24:16John August: To allow yourself to be open to realizing it wasn't really about what I thought it was, but I'm happy where I ended up. It is time for us to play a game. This is very relevant to this discussion. I gotta put the beer back down to do this There was a beer sitting here and I'm from Ohio so if the beer is sitting there I have to pick it up Mine is so far away Oh thank you We're opening our beers Alright I'm working here I can't do that sorry I don't want you guys crying for Craig because I drank too much beer Alright Now we have established that what your movie is about and log lines can be an important framing device and can help set expectations.

25:01John August: But sometimes those expectations can be incorrect. On this special Halloween edition of the game, we need you to identify these non-horror movies based on misleadingly scary log lines. We have two contestants who have volunteered to do this. Do we have Brian Sanchez in the room? Brian Sanchez, stand up. Brian Sanchez, stand up and move to the aisle if you would. Meredith will meet you there. Do we have Juliet Polier. Juliet, are you in the room? Juliet, also meet us here in the room. Producer Meredith Stedman here. Yeah. So the prizes, the stakes could not be higher for the two of you. I want you to know this.

25:47John August: So there are going to be two prizes. One prize is a guaranteed three-page challenge. So basically you will move to the top of the pile, and no matter what, we will cover your three-page challenge. That can be a choice. Or character creator kit, which is the thing we have on Kickstarter right now. One of the only existing decks in the world Meredith has. And so if you win this game, you could choose that as your thing. If you're not playing this game, you can also back the Kickstarter right now for character creator kit, which has turned out great. We are going to be reading you log lines and you're going to raise your hand if you know what the movie is.

26:20John August: And so fast hands, and then Meredith will call on you and then we'll say if you're actually right or not. These are not horror movies. So let's start this off here. When his child is kidnapped and detained in Australia, a father faces incredible danger in pursuit of his rescue. Is that Finding Nemo? It is Finding Nemo! Brian's got it! Yeah. Pamela, would you read the next slide? Okay. A young boy fixated on guns makes devious plans to attain the weaponry he craves. All right. Send out the audience. Throw it to the audience. Yeah. It is a Christmas story. All right. Amazing. The next one? Next one.

27:05Okay. All right, everybody. An outsider commits manslaughter before assembling a team to rob and ultimately murder the victim's sister. Brian or Juliet? Brian. Is it the Wizard of Oz? It's the Wizard of Oz! that is. Double homicide.

27:27John August: All right. Next up, child impersonators plot to disrupt the lives of an estranged couple. Child impersonators plot to disrupt the lives of an estranged couple. Hands in the audience. You right here. It's the parent trap. Yeah, parent trap. All right. next log line after claiming to rescue an unsuspecting man from certain death a loner weasels their way into his family under false pretenses Brian or Juliet alright we see a hand right here while you were sleeping wow while you were sleeping yes that's impressive I wasn't going to get that it was a heart change Sandra Bullock a monster in that movie alright alright Phil Hay you got this one alright This is a good one.

28:22A charismatic Peruvian stowaway uses politeness to attach themselves to a kind family, but their feral nature and insatiable hunger cannot be contained. Is that Paddington? It's Paddington. That's Paddington. Yeah.

28:39All right, Brian.

28:41John August: Brian, scoop in here. All right. This is it, Juliet. You got this one. A headstrong farm girl is pursued and endangered by both her controlling fiancé and her deceitful ex-boyfriend. Headstrong Farm Girl is pursued and endangered by both her controlling fiancé and her deceitful ex-boyfriend. Not ringing a bell. One of my favorite movies. In front of there, it's right there. The Princess Bride!

29:13John August: Everything's dark when you really think about it. Yes. A tale as old as time. Obsessed with their owner, a talking doll aims to eliminate the competition for attention. All right, Juliet. Well, is it Toy Story? It's Toy Story. Hands on the board.

29:34We're on a roll. We're on a roll. Let's see if we can't stop that roll right now. This complex item. I believe in you guys. A beautiful woman desperately conceals her horrific physical transformation. but after getting

29:48John August: oh I see Juliet has a hand up wow the little mermaid no I know so Brian I've got more to read what is happening go for it is it is it Shrek yeah it's Shrek that's Shrek was the wait but was the horrific physical transformation do I get to read the rest of this later let's read the whole thing that's what people know somebody worked really hard on this go ahead probably Meredith said that Meredith worked hard on this. Not me, but did she? The rest of it was, but after getting wrapped up in a complicated land deal, she eventually turns, becoming grotesque for good. Alright. Alright. This is our last one.

30:29John August: So, a mentally unstable man uses dance and deception while attempting to override a restraining order. And a mentally unstable man uses dance and deception while attempting to override a restraining order. Hysterical. Yeah. Architessants don't know. Juliet, Brian. All right. I see a hand over here. Silverlighting playbook. Oh, wow. All right. That is our game. Brian, you're the winner. Thank you so much. Yeah. Hey, Brian. Would you like the three-page challenge or the character creator hit? The three-page challenge. All right. Brian's got a three-page challenge. Do you like it? There's your creative pit.

31:16There we go.

31:17John August: Fantastic. Thank you both very much for playing. Yay. All right. I'm so excited for them. So excited. That's good. It actually went well. Like, this is always a disaster. It's always like last year, we picked contestants by like having a sticky note under people's chairs, and no one could find the sticky notes. The chairs were destroyed. So this worked much better. John got it built for like$7 ,000 from notes. Oh, my God. It's so much. All right, so you have now found out what your movie's about. You've actually convinced people that, oh, that seems like an idea. Now you have to raise the money to go from an idea to actually making a movie.

31:56John August: You're in the middle of raising money right now for your documentary. OneActFilm.com. Absolutely. OneActFilm.com. We've made movies inside the studio system. We've all made independent films. We've done myriad things. Let's talk about the first conversations in terms of raising money, which is really figuring out how much money do you need. So Phil, you've done this a bunch. How do you figure out, what is the first part of figuring out a budget for a film and what scale of film is possible to make? I was actually speaking to someone on one of the roundtables this morning about this and it starts with just an estimate that you can use, like looking at other movies and looking at the scale of them.

32:36And there's always... This is where comps are actually genuinely helpful. Yeah, there's something, and they all have some secret thing that made them cheaper or more expensive, but you can kind of get a ballpark. And, you know, if I'm going to assume, let's just say we're talking about a first film or a, you know, a very small independent, like your first thing you're trying to get going. And the first thing I'd say is in the writing and conception of it, if you can figure out how to make it legitimately for under a million dollars, that's the first point. Like that's, and I'm leaving out the sort of like micro budget stuff, like 250 grand or whatever, which, you know, I just don't have an experience with that you might be able to crowdfund or that sort of thing.

33:13I'm talking about if you have to go to a financing entity or an individual or an equity person. So the first thing is, how can I legitimately imagine this for under a million dollars? And that's a limit on locations. That's a limit on shooting days. That's imagining that you're probably shooting 20 days or less. You're not paying an actor a lot of money. And then the next stage is about$3 million. And once you start getting above that, everyone's asking questions all the time, but that becomes exponentially more difficult for a first-timer. So the first thing would be trying to learn what costs money in a movie is difficult.

33:50Like a lot of us who have made, I've made 10 movies, and sometimes it's a total mystery to me. We're working on a script and we're trying to cut the budget and we cut four pages out and a location and the line producer's like, great, you saved$20 ,000. And I'm like, I don't understand, but it's because the lighting package has already been rented and whatever. you know so trying to figure out the world you're in and then practically the first thing i'd say is you need help you need to find some help and like let's say you have a script you're a writer and you're not a director you want to try to find a director and you want to try to find someone who is as excited about you as you are about making this movie because the next thing you're going to need to do in a certain kind of movie is get cast and you're not going to be able to get cast without your director.

34:37So ideally, a great situation, you've seen I Play Rocky recently, is you want to direct your script and you feel capable of it and you can convince people that you can do it. Then you've got the director piece taken care of. Basically, my advice would be you want to find a director and you want to find a producer who is going to be your intermediary to the rest of the world so that the burden is not completely on you. And they're then going to go try to find you with sales agent at one of the agencies. I talked a little bit about some of the stuff the last time it was on Script No. So I'll try not to repeat myself too much, but some of it's the same, which is there are people out there whose job is to find funding for independent movies.

35:18And if your script is great and you can get it to them and convince them, then you've done the most you can do. Because if you have it in the hands of somebody at an agency whose job it is, then they're going to go out and try to dig up financing for you. And for a really small movie, it's probably going to be equity financing, which is a company or a person who can write a check. When you hear about foreign financing and stuff, that's where you're going to have to have actors that are this weird list that doesn't really make sense of who's worth a lot of money and who's not worth so much money and go to Berlin market or AFM or one of the markets and you're trying to get money for your movie based on the names alone that are going to be in it.

35:57But for the real basic thing, my basic advice is like you need a team you need help you need someone who has some experience in hustling out there to try to put together money to be helping you and that doesn't have to be a famous producer it probably won't be it could be someone you went to film school with that their thing is they're going to be a producer and you trust them and you believe in them and they're going to you're giving them their shot as much as you're they're giving you your shot so but i found that just important like the the ally that's out there to help you hustle is invaluable what we talked in the first

36:29John August: segment about what's it about. When you talk to these people, what's it about? It's about a million dollars. There are patterns and there are templates for how to make these kind of things. And so we had Curry Barker on the show and he talked about Obsession. And Obsession was great. It was so well done. And it was made with a specific formula and a pattern that made sense to people. So whether Obsession was the greatest movie of all time or not, those people could make their money back or at least not lose a lot of money because they knew what that template was like. It was inexpensive, it was limited locations.

37:01John August: There's ways to do that movie that made sense, and they just did the best version of that movie. And the lower the budget is, the less you're reliant on cast, which is the most difficult thing to do, even when you're established. But when you're not established, it's really difficult. And so if you get under a certain number, and it's under a million generally, the focus is more on the thing, and is there an idea here that is saleable? Is it in a genre that is saleable? Then who's in it? because then you have the flexibility to actually go out and get great actors who you're casting versus if you're casting your movie, it's much better than when you're trying to get people to attach to your movie because you're asking them to be part of the speculative unit to get this movie made.

37:42So again, that's just our argument. For the lower budget you have, the casting falls out the window because you simply can't pay. They can't ask you to cast Kate Winslet because you can't pay Kate Winslet. So we talk about a director.

37:55John August: If you found the right director for it, you've written a script and you're not going to direct it yourself, you're looking to find the right director, where would you find this director? A great place is honestly films you love, films that have customals that you love, films that they made something great and they're not a writer-director themselves, and tracking them down and figuring out what are they doing next, how can you get this thing to them? You'd be surprised at the people who are actually looking for the next thing and you could be the next thing if you were the right match there. Also, we talked about the importance of producers.

38:26John August: Look for who produced the films like your film that were good. And those are people who know what they're doing. Do some due diligence. Some of them are just idiots. But some of them are actually really good. And they're the people who are actually going to do it. Which ones? Or which, John? Phil and I have both worked a lot at the Sundance Film Institute. And that lab, they know who the producers are who can actually make the movies that get into these festivals, who can do these things. And they're so good at it. and they know how to pinch the pennies yet actually deliver the value. And that's so hard.

38:58John August: How did you find people who were going to help you out on your documentary? Well, you know, as a writer in animation, your job is to not think about budget. And so I've been on a real learning curve with a script that I had before, which was an adaptation of a graphic novel of mine called My Boyfriend is a Bear. And people being like, well, you got to guess about a girl who dates a bear. He's a real bear. He lives in LA. Comes down because of the fires. They fall in love. He's really good at cuddling. and they don't know if their love will survive hibernation and then also the Silver Lake mommies down the street are like, there's a bear that lives near the nursery, but it's about like, whose land is this and what is love?

39:31But in any event, they were like, this costs too much and so you'd have to sort of figure out, I'm going to get to your question in a second, but it's, so I'm learning like, oh, if the bear gets wet, if the bear goes in the ocean, why do they go to Comic-Con and just cutting these things down to this budget that they can understand. But to me, these numbers don't mean anything. So this was the first time in an independent space where I had to understand what these numbers meant and how to get them low. How did I get people involved? First of all, everybody was like, don't spend your own money.

40:04So I've already broken rule number one because nobody was going to give me any money and I had to get started if I wanted to catch the season and I had these people that were great and willing to do it. So I've been thinking a lot about this story from this old folktale called Stone Soup. you know stone soup so that's how you do it right you're like i have this i'm making stone soup i've got this rock and they're like it's delicious like i'd love some what can i you know you can have some i could use some carrots like i have carrots and so then the onion guy comes and the carrots and you're like i need celery and everybody makes this great soup together and you know i got other producers who knew things that i didn't know who had different talents and what i needed and it's all connections and just trying to get the band together and being someone who said, oh, I'm a producer now.

40:56And the producing part is the hardest part because you're only asking for money or asking what's wrong. Do you have money for me? What can I do to make you feel better today? Every day, it's just problems.

41:12John August: So I think you did really well on one act. It's putting together a site and a pitch deck that actually really sold what the vision of it was. And that was an early part of the process once you had some footage. Can we talk about rip reels, pitch decks, how you are selling the vision of your movie beyond a script if there's a script? So what did you do for your site? Well, I first started looking for just, because I have student filmmakers embedded throughout the production because I was like, well, that's different. You have a student filmmaker here in the audience. I do have a student filmmaker, Reese Wright, stand up.

41:42Yeah. Currently studying film at Baylor now that she's done with high school, but very talented. Already had won at UIL before I got to her. But I was like, what's different is these students are telling their own stories through their cameras. And so I started looking for their footage online at YouTube, which is how I found Mr. Groves because he was introducing the place. And then I just was taking their own footage of them at award ceremonies and putting together the history of this contest and how it feels that it is sports. This is a coming of age tale through sports, but the sport is theater.

42:13and then you get some Friday Night Lights soundtrack and you hit them in the feels with that, you know, kids trying no matter what people have told them they are. And I just knew that, like, you're hitting that sweet spot of, like, the first teacher who told you you were worth something and then the friend that you did it with. And that was sort of the guide. And then everybody cried and I was like, I think we did it. Did you ever, in this movie, were there any grants or fellowships or anything that you could have explored or did? I have applied for absolutely every single grant or fellowship, including a Guggenheim.

42:51I did not get any of them. Not one. Yet. No. Because I was going to say, if you are, specifically I'm thinking of, I worked with a mentee at Sundance Lab who's from Oregon and was making her film in Oregon. and she got like$200 ,000 from the state of Oregon from a program that they had specifically. So wherever you live, if you don't live in LA or New York, or I'm not sure what they have here, if you live in another state, sometimes the state will actually have a hidden program that can help you start that first bit. Because the rule of thumb too is if you can get any money, the rest of the money is infinitely easier to get.

43:34You need that first legitimate chunk of money. and then that first person that jumps in the pool, then it's much easier to get other people. So there may be unexpected sources like that. And it's not everywhere, but occasionally those do exist. And I've been relying on, before I started this, I met with any documentary person who would talk to me and I would pitch them this and I'd say, talk me out of it, talk me out of this. Please tell me not to do this. And none of them would. And they said things like, this will be fine and here's why, you just got to get to this, you got to get to this. and we got to the part where I was like, no grants, no labs, nothing.

44:10And they were like, do you have enough money to get through edit? Will you have a good cut? And so I was like, I'm going to get to the good cut. Then people saw it and then we could do fundraisers. Totally. And then what I was going to say is exactly your experience. We've only made one documentary and helped out on another documentary. But the one we made called The Dungeon Masters was, it takes forever to make a documentary sometimes. And sometimes you don't know when it's going to end. And so it's a more rolling process than making a feature film is, where you try to get to a certain point, and then you can show people what you have, and then if they can see the path, then maybe that's when your second round of funding comes in.

44:49Well, and also the what's it all about is changing. With 600 hours of footage, you're like, well, it could be about anything. It's moving in a way where you can't always answer some of those questions that they need for you to get the money. but also and then you know all the grants went away too i was just in a that's the other thing we're in a really impacted environment right now for the arts that that has a very specific impact on people doing it worried the film would be too political conceptually yeah so i don't think

45:17John August: i would stress is there's people you can ask for money who like no one asks them for money for any of the stuff before it's new to them and that can also be an opportunity there's a member of our extended script notes family who is um working to raise money for a film they want to shoot and it's in a very specific part of the US and nothing has ever, ever shot there. And so there's people with some money there who's like, yeah, you could shoot at my place and yeah, I want to be part of this. And there's ways to find, especially if you're working on a very low budget, to find ways to do a thing that seems impossible because no one's asking them to do it.

45:49John August: A lot of stuff shoots in Austin, but not a lot of stuff is shooting at random places in Arizona or Canadian border towns. If your story is specific to a place that no one else has ever shot before. There may be people who are the rich people of that place who want to see that thing happen. So that's another opportunity. It's finding what is specific and unique about your story that can get someone to write a check is often a good starting place. As tradition goes, we end the show talking about our One Cool Things. It's like something unrelated that we want to talk and share with our audience, both here in the room and at home.

46:25John August: My One Cool Thing is, it's a website that is an app you can download. called whatcable.uk. And USB-C, I think, is a really good format. But God help you, what kind of cable is this? Is it the Thunderbolt cable? Can it generate power? Can it not generate power? Is it just for connecting things? So it's an app that you can download at whatcable.uk that runs on your Mac. You plug in a cable, and it'll tell you exactly what that cable can do. Which is just like, when we got to this place, so I would just recommend it, because literally there are cables I've been carrying around for years. I realized, oh, it doesn't actually do that thing I thought it did.

47:03John August: And so if you're frustrated by things, whatcable.uk will help you out. And then you can make a little sticker or write with a Sharpie and figure out what this cable actually is. John, I thought that was going to be unbelievably niche and it turned out to be stirring. Thank you. I can't wait to get over there on that website. All these cables, a box full of cables and you'll now know what they can actually do. Pamela Ribbon. I guess I'll just keep crying. And thank you. So I gave a commencement speech to the College of Fine Arts here a few years ago. It was one of the best days of my life. But to prepare for it, I listened to commencement speeches.

47:43I highly recommend doing this in the morning when you're getting ready. And NPR has a website called The Best Commencement Speeches Ever. I'm not going to lie and say I had a goal when I wrote mine. but there's over 350 speeches on here. They're by name, school, date, or theme. And there's everyone on here from Phil Rosenthal. Oh, thank you for your$36 donation that just came in. Anthony Corbin. We're doing a telephone right now. I've been doing it. Guys, we're not leaving this ballroom until Pammy's got 10 grand. Who's got 5 grand? Come on. Let's go. One Act Film. You got all night.

48:22John August: Come on. OneActFilm.com. Anyway, it is so cool to listen to a commencement speech from Conan O 'Brien or Mindy Kaling or whoever it is that you're just like, what did they have to say? Chances are they've given a speech that is about their lowest points and their biggest dreams. And they're standing at a place that made them who they are. Looking at it's talking to people who are in a room of graduates. It is the best audience. Everybody is proud of everybody in the room. And they're so ready to hear what you have to say. So listening to someone pitch winners really teaches you a lot about, like, what do you want to hear at this moment that is going to, like, I mean, they won't remember you, but maybe they'll remember you forever if you say the right thing.

49:08So it really helped me be vulnerable.

49:12John August: Remind us the website. Oh, because I just Googled NPR commencement speeches. Because I don't think it's, like, apps.npr.org slash commencement. Just Google NPR commencement speeches. All right, fantastic. Phil. Yeah, I've got something that I love, and it's for all of my movie-loving people, of which I assume I'm in a room full of them, people who like to go out to see the movies in a movie theater as God intended, which I think is really important on so many levels. And so there is an app that is called Paradiso. Have any of you heard of this? All right. Like, it's a very simple, wonderful app.

49:52It's made by, like, a guy. It's not a corporate thing. It's like, and his thing is, and I checked, and this is wonderful, for several cities, including Austin, Texas, Los Angeles, New York, Paris, and they're adding them all the time, it is a very simple way to see what is playing that night in your town. And every theater, it's an attractive image. page it's a little detail about the plot it's you can link right to the site to buy the tickets right off of paradiso so like cinema paradiso paradiso it's all i do now it's like you scroll down and it shows you the revivals that are going on it's like oh yeah they're playing you know paddington over across town i'm gonna go see it right so anyway i recommend it and it really can use your support it's like a kind of a new thing and like you can like email this guy and be like like, hey, can you do my town?

50:45And he'll be like, yes, of course. Paradiso.com. Paradiso. It's an app on the App Store. An app. Do you want to know how much it is?

50:54John August: Tell us. $1 ,300. Yeah. Let's go. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you very much. So visit oneactfilm.com. Not only can you give her some money to help do color prevention, and all the other things that need to be done, but also you can see trailers for what this amazing project is that you've made. Yeah, this money will also go towards screenings and getting high schools to be able to see the show and see the movie. Thank you. Thank you all for being here tonight. Thank you. Thank you to everyone at AFF. Emily Loft, Daniela Farfan, On A.V., Ryan and Kyle, thank you so much. Meredith Stedman is our producer.

51:38John August: Meredith Stedman. I also really want to thank all the staff and volunteers of AFF. You guys are superstars and champions. Thank you, thank you, thank you so much. Remember to subscribe to Script Notes wherever you listen to podcasts. The Script Notes book is available wherever you buy books. Thank you all so much. This was so fun.

52:13Thank you.

From the publisher

How do you answer the question, "What is your project about?"

Recorded live at the Austin Film Festival, John is joined by Scriptnotes all-stars Pamela Ribon and Phil Hay to talk about loglines, framing, and communicating the deeper message behind your project.

They also discuss working outside of the traditional studio system, including ways to find money for your film. Plus, we play a game with the audience.

Links:

Download the episode here!

Get your copy of The Scriptnotes Book and become a Scriptnotes Premium member today! For more content on the craft of writing check out Inneresting our weekly-ish newsletter about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters.

Scriptnotes is produced by Meredith Stedman and edited by Matthew Chilelli. Our coordinator is Lauren Loesberg.

Intro & Outro by Matthew Chilelli (send us yours!)

Email us at [email protected]

More from Scriptnotes Podcast

All episodes