

Conversation with writer/director Andrew Stanton (Pixar) about story craft, sequels, and Pixar’s storytelling principles, using Toy Story 5 and the Toy Story franchise as the main case study; also covers writing process, “spine”/character motivation, and a few nerdy side segments (shot counts, cool media picks).
Andrew Stanton, writer/director known for Finding Nemo, WALL-E, Monsters, Inc., and Toy Story; plus hosts John August and Craig Mazin (Script Notes).
Sequels are hard but can work if you find a “way through” and let time change the world (especially Toy Story’s time-passing advantage). Pixar avoids classic villains; it prefers antagonism. The core job is making audiences care, and hiding craft (“two plus two” means don’t over-explain). Pixar’s tone comes from rigorous, audience-accountable storytelling.
Toy Story 2’s “economic necessity” origin; Toy Story 4’s opening problem solved by focusing on mundane toy life (rain, drawers, play sheds); Toy Story 5 starting from a single Buzz shipwreck image; “50 Buzz Lightyears” marooned premise; Pixar’s “spotlight” technique for guiding attention.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hosts introduce Andrew Stanton and discuss his contributions to Pixar.
“Today on the show, we are going to be talking to the writer and director of that film, Craig, whose credits also include Monsters, Inc., Finding Nemo, WALL-E, and the Toy Story franchise.”
Andrew Stanton discusses the challenges and decisions behind creating Toy Story sequels.
“I want to talk about what lessons we can take from animation to other things and what lessons don't transfer as well.”
Exploration of what makes Toy Story unique in its storytelling and character development.
“But in my mind, it's day two from whatever day one was.”
Andrew Stanton reveals the initial ideas and creative process for Toy Story 5.
“That's the other thing that I'm always trying to learn or figure out or remind myself, whether I'm helping somebody else on a movie or not.”
Learn how to align story elements to enhance character development.
“So how can I possibly set it up to be aligned so that they start going on offshoots and branches from the trunk of the tree in ways that I think it should evolve?”
Explore how technology impacts character arcs and narratives in Toy Story 5.
“But no, what I did was I was reluctant to say yes to committing to animation again because of the time it takes.”
Discuss the thematic evolution of the Toy Story series and audience expectations.
“That was another, there was three worlds that I felt or scenarios that I felt had not been covered for all the movies, Toy Story movies that pre-existed.”
Understand the deeper stakes in Toy Story 5 regarding friendships and childhood connections.
“But what we're really do spend time thinking about is, should this be an animation?”
Discover the unique Pixar tone and its influence on storytelling across generations.
“And you realize it was the personification.”
Explore how Pixar has refined sentimentality in storytelling over time.
“And Pixar started with a level of sentimentality.”
Discuss the importance of constraints and how they shape creative decisions.
“Like I just don't, I just got to do my thing in my headspace.”
Learn about the deep understanding required for effective character development.
“Basically, there's a spine that stories go back to and an itch that characters can't scratch that drives the behavior.”
Insights into the collaborative writing process and the importance of partnership.
“And so I kind of was the lucky one that discovered the recipe and then got called in to do it very fast on two and then sort of lay the groundwork on three and then call back on four.”
Discuss audience behavior and the unspoken rules of etiquette in theaters.
“I'm not going to say you have to do it, but like you send them back to me.”
Discussion on the social contract of movie theaters and personal anecdotes related to disruptive behavior.
“I love that people are going to the movies, but they shouldn't be going to the movies with their laptops.”
Exploration of shot counts in films over decades and how they reflect filmmaking trends.
“All right, I have a happier one cool thing for us to get into now.”
Discussion about the Criterion complete Kubrick box set and its extensive content for filmmakers.
“I was an early recipient of the complete Kubrick box set from Criterion.”
Craig shares impressions of the documentary by Nathan Fielder, focusing on its cinematography and storytelling.
“Craig, you don't realize that you could have met Lance Al, but he's actually been on the show.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Scriptnotes Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00John August: Hey, this is John. Standard warning for people who are in the car with their kids, there's some swearing in this episode. Hello and welcome. My name is John August. My name is Craig Mazin. And this is episode 757 of Script Notes. It's a podcast about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters. Craig, is it safe to say that you are a fan of a movie called Finding Nemo? Finding Nemo. Nemo. It was a Pixar film. It involves a fish, several fish. Yes. It's a little familiar. You had it a whole episode, episode 403. Yes, that's right. I can't shut up about it. Yeah. Yeah, I've been talking about this movie since I saw it.
0:46It's a long time.
0:47John August: It's a long time. Today on the show, we are going to be talking to the writer and director of that film, Craig, whose credits also include Monsters, Inc., Finding Nemo, WALL-E, and the Toy Story franchise. outside of Pixar. He's also directed live action features and a lot of television. Welcome to Script Notes, finally, Andrew Stanton. Hello, it's truly a pleasure to be here. We're so excited to be talking with you. We did it. John, what episode number is this? This is 757. Can we stop now? Yeah. Is this it? No, it's not it, Craig, but it's a milestone. It's certainly a milestone. This is a milestone.
1:20This is a milestone. It's a big one. I'm honored. I hope I can live up to any expectations. Don't see how you can.
1:27John August: So, Andrew, I want to talk through this most recent Toy Story, the Fitz and Stalman, the Toy Story franchise, but I also really want to talk about story overall. I want to kind of nerd out on story because your approach to story and the Pixar approach to story is specific and unusual and has been a big influence on screenwriting overall. I want to talk about what lessons we can take from animation to other things and what lessons don't transfer as well. And then in our bonus thing for premium members, you also direct other people's things, things that you didn't write yourself. And I want to talk about that as a thing as well.
2:00John August: Okay. Let's start by talking about this most recent Toy Story. So I really enjoyed this most recent Toy Story. Good. I loved the entire franchise. But talk to us about the decision to make another Toy Story. From the start, was the idea of like, well, let's have another adventure for these characters? Or is there always an issue of what is compelling? What do we need to talk about this time? It's a bit of both. People sometimes forget that our third movie was Toy Story 2. and it was born out of pure economic necessity. And it was originally going to be a direct-to-DVD, which was considered a B-level way to approach it.
2:35And sequels were considered lesser than. And once we saw that it wasn't working while we were busy making our second movie, A Bug's Life, we realized that we didn't want to put out anything lesser than what we had done and were doing with the first two movies. I remember the conversation. We're like, what are other great sequels? And we said, Godfather 2 and Empire Strikes Back. And I think maybe we said Aliens at the time, but it was a short anemic list. And we said, we want to be on that list. And the truth was, all that meant was it's got to be as great or greater than what we've originally done.
3:16And we've done so many sequels of other sorts since. I've come to realize that the advantage of doing a sequel or a prequel is that you already know the basis of the existing world and the characters. And that gains you about six months. And then you're back to square one like every other story of trying to figure it out. And if anything, it feels harder because you've already tried things and you feel robbed of the vast canvas you had on the original.
3:47John August: So you were there from the very beginning of Pixar. You had to figure out how to make a computer animated film. And then you had to figure out how to do it again and again. There were certain things that were easier because you'd figured out the technology and other things, but you had to figure out how to create the Pixar way of doing things. And part of that is figuring out how to make a sequel. What is a sequel? What are the central tent poles of what a Pixar film is like? Can you talk to us about those early decisions? We were learning as we went. None of us had made a feature before when we made Toy Stories.
4:19I remember the end of that run of the first one going, how did we do that? And the only thing I walked away with was trusting my instincts. But then I remember going, they're going to ask us to do this again. And I don't feel any smarter than I did when I started on this. But now I know that I have instincts I can trust when we're in a hole again. And then all I remember is the next 10 years for never stopping. Like there's just one train track in front of another. We were always working on two films at the same time in some levels. There was always two patients on the operating table. And the problems just never stopped, even if it wasn't on your own watch.
4:59And then you suddenly looked up and 10 years went by. And then I feel like right around then, it's right around 2005, right around Nemo's release. I remember I was like, okay, I feel like I can talk about what we do at Pixar. Okay. My memory is just that. It's like the longest film school run. And then, okay, I think I can put words to it. But I was the guy in the group that was always hating that we were putting rules to things. I was very superstitious about it. And I always, I remember saying like, wouldn't it be great if you, the only thing that you knew about a Pixar movie was that it was going to be worth your time, but it was never the way you thought.
5:38Like I was always, always being like super loud and obnoxious about that. And that's, that's kind of happened over time. But there's also the truism of like, people want the satisfaction of the flavor they just had of ice cream, but, but in a different way. And they just can't express it to you. I remember Steve Jobs saying to us, like, it's up to us to know what people want before they do. And that's very true. But all that was, was us going, what do I want to see? You know, and I never want to see the same thing twice, but I'd be happy to go back to some of my favorite movies and see another movie.
6:10I just, I have the same trepidation that a sequel is going to suck as everybody else, both internally and externally as an audience and as a filmmaker. But then there's part of me was like, yes, but how would you thread that needle? How would you, you know, how would you make that work? And that's the mindset that we've always had with sequels. It's just, okay, I get the list of why we shouldn't and can't, but what's the way through? And if we didn't think of it today, then there's always tomorrow. But we never have promised a sequel before we had the idea that we think there's a sequel there.
6:42And that's why you see so many years go by between the sequels. It's not that we tried a bunch of things and five years went by and we just couldn't stick the landing. So we didn't do it. We didn't follow through with it. But the thing that I've found is the advantage, particularly and only uniquely to the Toy Story world, is time is our friend. The fact that time passes and kids grow up and life moves on and toys, some stay, some don't, some evolve to whether they're cherished or whether they're put on a shelf. Like that is unique to that world and that's what makes it interesting. And so it's always been our advantage to let a lot of time pass in the real world because we come back with such a different perspective.
7:25It is always profoundly moving to me. And I've seen it now for quite a while where parents, their first movie was Toy Story and they brought their kids to experience hopefully the same fulfillment. But I've never thought of that when I'm making that. I'm always like to me, maybe it's like a television series. Maybe it took us three years or four years before the last season to bring out the second season. But in my mind, it's day two from whatever day one was. And I'm not thinking about an audience that spent two years waiting. All I'm thinking is someday somebody's going to binge this and it's got to all hold.
8:02Yeah. Right. When I really look at it now, I realize, oh, I've always looked at the Toy Story movies, not like a franchise. I always hate that they have a number behind them. I think they're more like a prestige series where like this was season one and we can end it here if we had to. But the world's going to keep moving on whether or not we go back to it. And there's things that I'm so fascinated. I use the Game of Thrones analogy all the time, like the opening with the map. And I'm always like, what's over there that we just cruised past in the opening credits? But what's over there? What happens if you go across the street from Andy's house?
8:41That, to me, is the potential of a promise fulfilled on every new Toy Story movie. It's time passing and the margins grow. One thing that I think you guys, sometimes, the decisions we don't make are as important as the ones we do. So obviously there are a million decisions that go into what is a sequel going to be. And in the case of Toy Story 2, one of the great sequels of all time, I'm obsessed with that movie.
9:05John August: Yeah, the Godfather reference is appropriate. Yeah, I mean, I love, I love, I like Toy Story 2 more than I like Toy Story 1. I just think there's something incredible about that movie. I could go on. I won't. However, here's what I will say. Typically, and John and I have both dealt with this in live action space and in films for families. When studios approach sequels, their general point of view is, okay, this is a sequel. all we know is it should be bigger and stupider that's generally that that's the the deal and what you guys knew to not do was get bigger and stupider even put stupider aside yeah even just not bigger in a way like yeah there are some big set pieces in toy story 2 sure but it's still toys.
10:02Exactly. Mostly talking to each other. Yeah. And the thing I didn't realize until I went back into five was like, oh, you have to remind yourself and anybody else that like, we used to be fascinated with Toy Story because toys were a lie. But now that's so normalized. Nobody's wowed by that at all. Like you get nothing for making that your starting point. So the gift you get is, I don't have to teach people how this world works anymore. But what sequels steal from you is the joy of discovery and surprise. But the thing that we've always known is the secret ingredient that's unique to it that we've had to teach other people making the movies is the mundanity and the perspective shift of being a toy.
10:45And do not overlook that. A perfect example is I came in to help fix Toy Story 4 and they never could nail their opening. And I said, guys, how many years have these toys been with Andy? And they said, we were probably about nine. And how much screen time have we been in Andy's house? It's like, well, if you take the actual scenes, it's maybe about 30 minutes. Like that's a lot of mundane time of being a toy and existing in life in that house that we have never covered that you could make 10 movies from. So what's a simple thing that has never been seen from a human perspective or thought about from like just a toy that's left out in the rain?
11:26and everybody got brought inside. That would have been a whole adventurous set piece in the first movie. Do not forget that. We do not have to land a Boeing 747 at the end of everything to make this work. We just have to go, oh my God, I've always gotten my toys two days later after it's rained. But for them, that's life. And you don't get that in other movies. That's the other thing that I'm always trying to learn or figure out or remind myself, whether I'm helping somebody else on a movie or not. It's like, what can you only do in this story that you can't do anywhere else? What's that list?
12:01Have you exhausted that list before you've tried to do other things? Because I always feel like, oh, we may never get another shot at this story. We may never get a shot at this movie. And you want to feel like if you're going to only cross the ocean once, did you cross it correctly? Did you get what you really wanted out of it? I mean, not to jump the shark like a bad term, but to jump to Nemo. like Nemo started out with just a list, just a list of shit I'd like to see in the ocean. Like, and what it would be like to adventure and with no plot. And on the other side was like a father fish losing his son.
12:36And like, literally you had the whole ocean of the world and you're like, where do you start? And so I just, and I've learned that's not a bad thing to think like sometimes is the grocery listing of what can you only do in this world, you know? And what does that inform story-wise? Yeah.
12:53John August: So Andrew, for Toy Story 5, as I've read about the behind the scenes of it, you started with exactly one scene, which was the Buzz Lightyear's, the shipwreck and the Buzz Lightyear's all washing up on a beach on an island. And so that was the initial scene. Yeah. You didn't know what the rest of the movie was. You just had this image, this idea, this one thing on a checklist. I didn't announce this because there are certain things you say out loud with executives and it will just cause anxiety and a lot of debating and you just watch time get pissed away. And so I just learned to keep my mouth shut.
13:28So like I knew all along from the minute I asked them to put Woody to put the badge on Jesse at the end of Toy Story 4, which was a request of mine, that whoever was the sucker that had to do five the day it came would have to address that Jesse's the new... She's the sheriff. Because I knew she was fertile territory. And I felt really strongly privately that like Woody's had enough. Woody deserves a break. And if I know the world of commerce in show business as well as I think I do, these movies are going to keep getting made whether I ever want them to or not. So how can I possibly set it up to be aligned so that they start going on offshoots and branches from the trunk of the tree in ways that I think it should evolve?
14:11And I felt Jesse was a perfect bridge to start getting used to paying attention to somebody else for these movies. So that was always there. But I didn't know what to do with that outside of I had that and electronics like I had that. But just to sit down and start writing, I needed to just be interested in the same way an audience is going to come in. So I just wrote free associated what would crack me up. Wasn't sure that was going to stay, but I loved the promise of that. 50 Buzz Lightyears that just thought they were marooned on another planet and didn't know any better. And where would that go?
14:48And the minute we came up with a sort of a horse girl room with a horse collection, I said, can there be 50 horses? because now I see it. Now I see how you put them on the horses and they save. And for them to come to the aid of Jesse at her story would be the ultimate support in the present of that storyline. But I've learned to just jazz it in the early days and just see where it leads me for a while. Because I just know I'm going to write really badly for a while. So I got to at least enjoy myself.
15:22John August: So does it seem like you wrote out and shared with people? Yeah. Or is that something you kept for yourself? Okay, so you shared that sequence with people. I didn't share it as a sequence. I'm sure you guys have this. There's always at least one sequence you wrote that never kind of changed. Like no matter how much has happened over the course of it and how many drafts or how many years, like that one scene just always stayed. And that's the one, surprisingly. And that was the first thing I wrote. So I always find that funny. But no, what I did was I was reluctant to say yes to committing to animation again because of the time it takes.
15:59I'm in my 60s now and four years gets shorter the older you get. And I didn't want to spend four years on anything the same. I wanted to do four things in one year, not one thing in four years. And that's kind of what I had been doing for the last 10. But I love the idea of like, if it was done right, where this storyline could go. So let me just write a bad first draft. That's basically why I pitched it. Because I have strong opinions about where I think this world should go. And that will decide it because you'll either see right away, like, oh, we don't want to do what you want to do and we'll part ways mutually, or you'll agree.
16:34And so they saw that buzz scene in the context of a whole first draft.
16:39John August: Okay, great. And so within that first draft, you're establishing Jessie as like the central protagonist. She's doing sort of the woody function of like the character who has a clear vision for how things are supposed to go. And then there's disruptions, the disruption being the lily pad, which is the new technology, who seems like a villain. But we know enough about Pixar movies now that they generally don't have real villains. They don't have villains in the classic sense. I'm not a fan of villains. Yeah. I'm a fan of antagonism, but I'm not a fan of villains. Yes. And then ultimately, it's going to be about this journey of accepting that technology will be a part of these kids' lives because it's impossible to take that out of there and introduce toys that would have existed in the meantime between the initial Toy Story and today.
17:26John August: So these things that were bridge things, so smarty pants and the GPS tracker and things like that, which are just absurd things shoved in a drawer and that forgotten generation of toys. We all have that drawer. We all know that drawer. That was another, there was three worlds that I felt or scenarios that I felt had not been covered for all the movies, Toy Story movies that pre-existed. and one was that drawer that everything's shoved in that never gets opened that has all the spare batteries and wires. That play school shed that's been left out for too long, years after your kids are too old for it.
17:59And then it's the vines have grown over it and all the outdoor toys that have been there. And the horse collection. Yeah. And so we ticked them all off. So I don't know what anybody's going to do about six, but I felt lucky that I found new territory.
18:12John August: So the other thing I noticed about Toy Story 5, it has many more human characters who are doing important things in it than ever before. And so the young girls have their own storylines and motivations that don't have a toy directly in them. Their parents also have more in there. To what degree was that recognizing that these are kind of movies more for parents than they are for kids? Is that an aspect of it? And also you can just do humans much better than you could back in Toy Story 1 days. Those are all true. Well, no, the parent, you can do it easier now. True. I take Umbridge with - Please.
18:45For its kids and for parents. I've never thought about that. I get it all my life. Like, oh, my kids like your movies and I like them too. Like, that's a bonus. And I'm like, well, and I always have said since 95, like I wrote them for you, not for your kids. We're just immature enough and are stuck in Peter Pan mode, most of us that write these things, that we're just writing what we would want to see. I always equate it to music. If I found out that somebody had audience tested why I think I'd like that artist's painting, I'd be really off-put. I'm usually looking at an artist or a musician to see where to go, where are they headed, and I want to follow them.
19:28And I'm fascinated to see where they explore. And so I try to give the same respect to the fictitious audience by sort of not worrying about them and worrying about the audience member and myself. And I was lucky that I didn't do this in isolation. I did it with a gang that found each other like a garage band for the first movie and then for the next 10, 15 years. And so we just lived like a band. We were like, if we like it, then fuck the rest of the world. And the Pixar tone is just our tastes, unadulterated and for lack of a better term, and ignoring anything other than I just want it worth your time when you're sitting in the theater and the lights go down.
20:07And we don't want to exclude kids because we know that they'll come. But what we're really do spend time thinking about is, should this be an animation? What is it about this medium that's helping us tell this story better than live action? Or, but so we take each film, or I certainly do like my last shot at making a movie in general. And so I want it to be worth somebody's time. And I want it to feel like, yeah, that's the only way I should have seen it is the way you executed it. Can't say you can control that as much as you'd like, but that's always the intent. The thing that I think is a reflection of how evolved we've become with the Toy Story movies and as writers and as sophisticated moviegoers, even for younger audience, because of all the stuff that's out there, was that we could make What was at stake in Toy Story 5 was the child's development versus would the toys not make it home?
21:08Would the toys not have a safe haven? Would the toys be forgotten? It stopped being, the focus is now like, will this kid move forward in a much more direct, they've always been surrogate parents, the toys, but this one was more like, will a friendship be made? And it wasn't until I was talking out loud. I've used this before in other podcasts, so I'm sorry, but it's the best analogy. Like when I grew up on my street, there was only four or five other kids. And when we all got together, because I'm out of boredom, everybody wanted to kick a ball and I didn't have any interest. And I would do it just because it was the only excuse to hang out.
21:46But then these two girls moved across the street and invited my GI Joe to get his hair cut at their Barbie salon. And I was like, I found my tribe. And I suddenly realized that like that vulnerability you have as a kid, when you make friends, when you show your true self, especially when you're young and you're playing, it's like you're dating or you're courting. You're not really showing your fault. Like, can I be the weird way I think? And it can affect a kid for the rest of their life. But when you find that other kid, it can be for life that you have somebody that just gets you to your core just because of the way you played with each other.
22:22And it wasn't until we were saying out loud, I'm like, I said, I think this might be the most high stakes thing that the toys have ever battled for in any of the movies. And you can feel it in the audience at the end of that when the friendship is or isn't going to happen. And you realize it was the personification. The toys have been saying it for all the other four movies. We're here for Andy. We're here for Bonnie. And we're like, but what does that mean? And this was, this is what that means. I want to come back around to something you mentioned earlier as you were leading into this point, which was the Pixar tone and how you and this group, this group of CalArts folks and wherever you all came from, through trial and error or Inspired Genius or a combination of both, you came up with something that everybody recognizes is Pixar.
23:20It is. There is a tone. There's something identifiable. And you were talking about how now these movies are being watched by the children of the people who watched the first movie as children. And it struck me that the early Pixar films weren't just raising another generation of parents. It was also raising a generation of writers. I think John and I are among them.
23:46John August: I agree. Writers that came of writing age in the 90s all had the benefit of Pixar. And I'm curious if you have, as you've absorbed culture around you over the years, if you and your cohorts at Pixar have felt it echoing back a bit, felt the influence of the Pixar tone in the culture around you. I've never thought about that. I don't have the, for as much as I like the sound of my own voice and wanted to make a difference, I don't know if I would recognize it. I think that's for you guys to recognize. It's like I don't know what I really sound like. Yeah. I recognize it everywhere. I recognize it when I do.
24:35I recognize it when other people do. I sometimes watch movies that have nothing to do with family entertainment, and I see it there.
24:42John August: And I went back to your 2012 TED Talk where you talk about sort of the Pixar way of storytelling. And I was just taking notes on it. It's like, oh, this feels familiar. This feels like the kinds of things that were specific and different. And so one of the things you describe is two plus two. Yeah. Do you remember your description of two plus two? Tell us what that's like. It just means that don't say four. Don't, it's not just simply be expository. Don't be expository and say four. Like audiences love to solve stuff. They love to think that they're putting something together. They don't want to know that they're working for their meal.
25:16They don't want to know that they're doing math. Our job, we're manipulating all the time as storytellers. We just have to hide it. But I'm always telling other people that are working on their stories, like if you do it right, you have a spotlight. It's like a spotlight in a dark theater, and you can make everybody pay attention here and then follow the spotlight here. And if you shape it right, and that's on you for like, what did you want them thinking here? Because I'm always finding like, why do you guys think this scene or this line works? And they say, well, because they've gone here to here and I'm like, oh, you haven't walked through it the way the audience is taking this in.
25:56That's very different than what you're putting on the paper or what you're saying. Like the fact that you buried that word two sentences in, nobody's listening to. And so they didn't catch the first clue. So they're already off the path here. And so now what's the next thing? Well, we did a scene where we pay attention to everything that was about that word. Nobody knows what the fuck's going on because they didn't hear that word in the first one. And now you've got your audience bifurcated because some people think it's about love. Some people think it's about death. I do the hard, annoying work of walking them through the wrong steps and show them like, it's like a family circus where you see where the kid wandered through the house until they got on it.
26:40And I build them that path. I go, you need to own what you're doing. It's like you're in the communication business. You need to own how you're communicating and not what you want to communicate. That's fine. But what did you do? What did you actually do? And sometimes it doesn't take a screening or a read-through to do that. Sometimes it just takes a pause and just like, let's just talk about it for a minute. You've got the audience for about 10, 15 seconds at all times. And then you've got to, you've got to like, do you still have them? And do you have them where you want them? And then you go, okay, you've kind of got to check it at those baby steps sometimes to sleuth out or to ferret out, you know, where did we go wrong on these subtler problems?
27:25That process is, I mean, that rigorous process of being accountable to an audience and making sure every step along the way is intentional and therefore designed to achieve the very purpose you want to achieve. That is a great description of process. What I've noticed as a kind of almost revolutionary thing that Pixar has given us all is a goal. And the goal is a kind of very sophisticated sentimentality. Because I think for the longest time, sentimentality was something that was a bit broad or dull. And Pixar started with a level of sentimentality. And then with every passing movie seemed to sharpen it more and more and more until you start to get to movies where in a meta way, it's even about what sentiment is.
28:19Now you're an inside out. Now you're talking about what the nature of feelings are. And I think that what you guys have given everybody is not just a rigor of storytelling, but also you rescued sentimentality, I think, from where we had abandoned it, I think, particularly in family entertainment, which had, again, become very loud and stupid. Yeah. And now, and also since, I think since I've been working in this business, the word that would constantly come up is heart, which was...
28:52John August: The heart is a little icky. It's icky. It doesn't achieve what you guys have done, which is a significant and sophisticated... Yes. Yeah. The crucial thing is you make us care. You make us care about the heroes that we're following and also their opponents and everybody else involved who's on screen. You make us care about them. And that's one of the most challenging things to do with live action characters or animated characters is make us believe they are real creatures that we want to see succeed. And that we're worried that they're not going to succeed. And so the little girl's emotional stakes of will the little girl make a friend can seem really inconsequential.
29:29John August: It's not world ending, but you've made us care about her. And you've made us believe that all the other characters in this movie care about this happening. Thank you. That's the greatest compliment. and on behalf of the rest of us, I will accept it. Accept it. And pass it on. I don't think you're wrong. I think that the make me care, which I also have been saying since the beginning, is really the doorway through because I'm so superstitious about their becoming rules or patterns, even if there are, I almost don't want to know them because we found our voice not having self-awareness of rules and patterns.
30:15And so it's almost like a superstitious batter coming up to bat. Like I just don't, I just got to do my thing in my headspace. Do not listen to the thing I said about Finding Nemo.
30:28John August: Do not listen to it. It will ruin you. It will ruin you. Andrew, from the start though, you did have a list of, I saw five things, which you did not want to do as you were making a toy story. You said no songs. Yeah, no I want moment. Yep, no happy village, no love story, no villain. No villain. And so those are constraints you're putting on yourself. And constraints, as we've always said on the podcast, can be your best friends. Because when you say these are things you're not going to do, then you have to decide, like, how am I going to make this movie work without these things? Yeah. And that's a godsend.
30:58Yeah, no. But that list, from just a story writing, storytelling standpoint, is going to be different every time. Yeah. But it's good to give yourself a challenge, put yourself in a box and see if you can get out of it. I mean, I think so much of what you've been describing about our identity came from a place of frustration and feeling marginalized. Because we've always felt, I came from animation, all of us did. And we felt like second-class citizens in the filmmaking world. and we kept saying like, I feel like I'm being treated like I'm a utilitarian job that you can just swap out like an electrician or a plumber or something like that, which I don't mean to offend electricians and plumbers, but people approach it like you can just get anybody.
31:44And we, having grown up in film school with other animators and had animators that we revered and we knew like almost like sports who were great, who were okay at it, who weren't, who brought certain things to the table, just like your other favorite filmmakers or actors or stuff. So we just felt like there was so much possibility of what you could do with the medium in the 80s and going into the 90s, only to see it wonderfully on one side become so successful. But then the success of Disney, everything was a musical and everything had an I Want song and then everybody that was getting into the business was thinking that's what makes them work.
32:26And we were like, that? No, we knew full well that you could make an animation be anything. And so we had been bitching about it for so long. We felt like it's, we got to put up or shut up and just show something completely different. And so our drive on Toy Story wasn't to make the first CG animated film. I remember the meeting where we said, there's going to be another house. There was some other company somewhere that was for a while looking like they were going to come out with it first. And we said, by then we really knew we were onto something special with the story we were telling. And we said, are we a content company or are we a tech company?
33:03And we said, no, we're a content company. And so we've always used the CG technology advancement as a wolf in sheep's clothing to just tell stories that nobody would let us tell otherwise. So we've been in very pointedly in the storytelling business from the get go, or at least that was our goal in the beginning. and then we achieved it and then it's been how to maintain it and how to evolve it.
33:27John August: One of the things you also talk about in the 2020-12 TED Talk was the spine. Basically, there's a spine that stories go back to and an itch that characters can't scratch that drives the behavior. Craig talks a lot about this with Marlon and Finding Nemo is that he wants to protect his kid and so he will make good decisions to protect his kid and bad decisions to make his kid but it's all coming out of the same root cause. Is that something that's still relevant to your thinking as you're working on like Toy Story 5 and the characters in there? Absolutely. But it's more, I'm much more, like I said before, jazz about it.
34:02Like I want them to tell, I want to find out who they are. I don't like planning who they are. I like discovering what is it I'm saying, you know, and so I'm always auditioning what the premise might be, but then I'm not going to hold to it. I just sort of play it. And then I go, what do I, what do I think is the spine driving this character? I'm not confused about who they are and what they're doing. I don't go on the couch with them because I'm a little nervous. I'm a little superstitious about losing the mojo. But when I'm having trouble guiding them or it seems like there's too many random choices about what their character would do, then I put them on the couch a bit.
34:42I mean, I just think like an actor would. Like, what's the commonality that makes me play any scene? I was so inspired. What got me onto that? I don't know if you guys ever saw, it's online. You can get it. I got it 20 years ago. It was a copy of Frank Pearson's Cool Hand Luke. It's great. And the first two pages of it was just one paragraph or less description behind every character that's in the story. And it was like an actor's dream. It was just like, oh, you could take any of the descriptions that he put for each of the characters and apply it to, as an actor, you'd go like, oh, now I know how to buy milk.
35:22Now I know how to like rob a bank. Like there's their spine. And it was so, I didn't know that word then, but I always made that my goal to be able to understand the character that well. That I could, it's like, you know your family that well.
35:38John August: Yeah, I certainly have that with Big Fish because I've written a thousand versions of Big Fish. So I know those characters so well that they had to go to space. They could go to space. Craig's gotten a chance to use his characters again and again on The Last of Us. Yeah. He could have them do anything because you just have the chance. They really are, you know how to make them do the things that they want to do. I mean, that's been the... But they change. Yeah. That's why I kept getting pulled back into the Toy Story movies, because I found the voice of Woody. It was a combination of getting to work with Hanks early on and finding what capitalized on him, plus my cynical nature, which was a veneer over, I had a very romantic side, or soft sides.
36:19And so I kind of was the lucky one that discovered the recipe and then got called in to do it very fast on two and then sort of lay the groundwork on three and then call back on four. And so I've shared that evolution, that speech he gives Forky and four walking down the highway is just literally how I felt at the time after my kids were long gone and had their own lives going post-college. but being a little protective of my vulnerability by being sarcastic about it. And so it's been fun to share that ride with that one character all the way. People always ask me my favorite characters and I always say it's him because of that.
37:00I've spent so much time alone in a room making him talk.
37:03John August: Speed round questions for you because Craig and I have never worked at Pixar. You say you wrote a script for Toy Story 5, but my perception is that it's so iterative and there's so many, there's storyboards and all these things. Is there always actually a script, script that you could like at any point, like read a whole script or is it just a thousand pieces everywhere? What does it look like? It can be both. This is the, Pixar doesn't have one specific methodology. It includes boarding and writing. On my shows, there's always going to be a script that you can refer to, but it's, we're moving so fast with getting board artists to represent what's been written and we promote that it evolves and changes.
37:41It's just like blocking a scene or having your actors come in. And now you see what else it can be. And that's why you board it. So it's a constant catch up for the script to be updated sometimes to match it. So it goes in fits and starts. And, but there's some shows where they feel more comfortable being in boards all the time. And the script ends up just being a list of the dialogue, which was somewhat what Toy Story was for a while. So it can be dependent on the way the show is run. But all in all, there's junctures at about every six. The pattern is write a draft, board it, it changes. We put it up, edit it, watch it, have notes, write a new draft, and then do that again.
38:24And so depending on where you are in that process, the script may be reflective or may be out of date.
38:29John August: So when writer Kenna Harris comes on to the script, where was the project? What was new being learned? Like, what is it like to share some control there or have a different writer come in? For me personally, I love it. I'm always looking to have somebody to throw the ball back and forth. I don't like being alone. I like being alone in a room to untie a knot sometimes or to think straight. But I very quickly want to, I just learned talking in a room with a bunch of people. And so I have a very writer's room method of working. But I don't like having to defend my stuff all the time. I just like to have somebody that can just, I can just share the thought and keep tossing the ball back and forth.
39:11And I don't trust that I will get to the greatness on my own, even if I'm in a moment where I say, give it to me. So, but I do need to know what is it I'm even trying to do sometimes without it being shared with anybody for a moment. So I would do this on any show, even not knowing what it is. I would write the first draft myself because I just need to know unadulterated weaknesses and all what's in me. What am I trying to, what do I think I'm trying to do. And then I'd pull somebody in to be hopefully my writing partner to share the journey with. And that's what I did with Kenna. And then I'm very honest with them up front.
39:46I say, look, I'm going to be the editor. I'm like, you're going to write pages. I'm not going to tell you what to do. I'm not going to say you have to do it, but like you send them back to me. And I'm, but I'm going to see the minute I read them, I'm, I'm, I know I'm going to have an opinion about not critiquing your writing, but like where the scene should go. And as long as we understand the hierarchy that like, I will not abuse the rank of director and head writer, but I will have to use it sometimes just to keep us moving forward and to pick a direction and to like, just, and I will pivot.
40:18And if you end up writing 90 % of it, and I only ended up with 10%, I don't care. I just want to navigate us to the answers. So that's, that's ideally how I've always written with a partner.
40:29John August: We're going to transition to some one cool things, but before we get to that, Meredith, I would love for Meredith, our producer, to share one disastrously stupid thing, an event that happened to her this last week. I think Craig and Andrew will both, we'll all take umbrage, but then we'll maybe figure out solutions for it. Meredith, can you talk to us about, like, you went to see Sense and Sensibility. Yes, yeah. So I went to see Sense and Sensibility two days ago in theaters, and I saw something that I'd never seen in theaters before, which was somebody with their full laptop out and headphones on in the movie.
41:04And I will admit, I snitched. I went out of the theater and I said, there's somebody in there with their laptop out and headphones on. And the attendant said, oh, that's weird. She went back in. I saw that she asked him to close the laptop. And after about a minute, he opened it back up. And it was so bizarre. But I guess after about 30 minutes in, maybe they left the theater entirely. And so I was talking about it with John. I'm like, are they just trolling around the AMC? Because I watched them later come out of another theater. So I think they just do work in there. I can't make heads or tails.
41:40Do they have free Wi-Fi? Yeah. I don't think so, but it's something to test. That was their coffee house, right? They could just keep roaming from theater to theater. That's so rude. I guess, and I guess sense and sensibility, maybe they thought that's no explosions.
41:56John August: Yeah. Wow. So part of a bigger discussion of just like, I think it's fantastic that our theaters are making a giant comeback. I love that people are going to the movies, but they shouldn't be going to the movies with their laptops. That is a mistake. And there is a social contract for movie theaters. And yes, we can talk about like, oh, ordering on your phone at the Alamo. I'll take that over someone with a freaking laptop open at a theater. I forgot to mention too, front row. It was the front. Well, at first they were in the middle and then they were in somebody else's seat. I saw them ask to move and then they were in the front row so everyone could see the laptop the whole time.
42:33And no one else said anything? As far as I know, I was the only snitch. I have a memory of my father that stays with me to this day. I was very little and he took me and my sister to a movie. I do not remember what it was, but we were little, like maybe seven. And this was the 1970s. It was utter chaos, Meredith, chaos in the streets. Yeah. And at some point in the movie, somebody set off a firecracker. Oh my God. In the theater. And my dad, and I was like, what? And everyone was like, oh, and my dad, who was a public school teacher, but also in addition to his teaching duties was the dean of discipline at the school he taught, stood up and said, try it again.
43:29Just like that in his dad voice. And the entire theater got quiet. And I was like, now you know. Now you know how it is in my house all the time. But they didn't try it again. But what I remember is there was no hesitation, no fear. It was just like, no. If you give that person one minute, then you have seeded the Sudetenland. Do you understand? Like you have to like everybody has to just go. It's not snitching. No. Sorry. Would it be snitching if like if you called a waiter and you're like, sorry, there's somebody taking a dump on that table over there. It's not snitching. No. Yeah. No. That is so true.
44:23Outrageous. Absolutely agree.
44:25John August: Absolutely agree. Wow. So we don't have like a clear solution to this problem, but I think that if you see something, say something is the right answer here. And this dude, like, listen, I can respect like, oh, it's air conditioned place, but like go to an empty theater. Don't go to, don't be in a place where there's actually a movie showing on a screen. John, they were also wearing a trench coat. Oh, that's creepy. Come on, come on. Okay, all right. Or like a large coat. So I was like, I don't think. We're dealing with the whole situation now. I thought about the air conditioning thing too. And then I was like, then why would he be wearing a coat?
44:59But also, no, no. No. You can't. I don't even care if the theater is empty. No, they shouldn't let you walk in with a laptop. No. All right.
45:12John August: All right, I have a happier one cool thing for us to get into now. This is a blog post by a data scientist named Stephen Follows. He's been on the podcast before. In this blog post, he's trying to answer a question. How many shots are in the average movie today? Has the number of shots in a film increased or decreased over the decades? And so what he did is he looked at shot counts of 8 ,770 feature films released between 1930 and 2025. And he found that a typical film released between 2017 and 2025 has 1 ,535 shots, with a shot being a continuous run of frames between two different edits there.
45:50John August: So Craig and Andrew, what is your instinct? Do you think that like, have films become cuttier or less cutty over the years? My knee-jerk response would be if they've more shots now than back then. Yeah, I would say so, although maybe not as dramatically more as people might guess. Yeah, and both of you are correct because the number has inch up, but not as much as you might think. But also the range, the variation has grown tremendously. So between the Cuddiest and the Leigh's Cuddiy. And if you take out all the Indian films, which tend to be much more Cuddi, there's even less of a growth. If you look at shots per minute, because films have also gotten longer, if you look at shots per minute, Michael Bay averages 20 shots per minute.
46:33John August: Woody Allen averages 3.9. So there's a... You can see what that would feel like. 20 shots per minute every three seconds. Oh, geez. So, and there's a very predictable bell curve showing sort of like where most movies fall, which is sort of in the statistical meaning of it all. But it's sort of good to know because intuitively you would expect that movies have gotten cuttier and they have, but not to the degree you might expect, which is also kind of nice. So I'll put a link in the show notes to the blog post, which has a lot more about method and sort of the sort of weird outliers, which is kind of fun.
47:13John August: So I just like that someone is doing the nerdy math on all of this. Andrew, do you have one cool thing for us? I do. I was an early recipient of the complete Kubrick box set from Criterion. And it is a thing of beauty that I wish you could give to every filmmaker, but if it has to be one right now, that's gotten the thorough treatment, like there's not a stone left unturned. It's a thing of beauty. It is a deep dive. You could spend probably every inch of the holidays, which I probably will, just going through and learning even more about Kubrick than I knew and seeing things at a quality. Some movies that I never got, Full Metal Jacket is finally released on there in 2001 and Lolita.
47:58And it's a piece of art itself, just the box set. And so I can't get enough of it in my spare time right now.
48:06John August: Well, that sounds great. And so beyond the films themselves, what are the other materials in there? Are there like behind the scenes documentaries? Like what stuff are you learning? Not only, I mean, it's got all his movies from 1951 to 1999. And every one of them comes with, like, for example, The Shining has the European cut that nobody's ever seen before, as well as the American cut. So there's almost some of these movies, there's two versions. And every one of them has documentaries, behind the scenes footage, commentaries. Some of them are resurrected from versions that you just couldn't get anymore.
48:42But it is thorough. Everything I've known that was existing documentary-wise outside of the Kubrick films is in this. So it is literally the complete Kubrick. Anything you'd want to know about him, read about him, beyond just watching the movies. It's fascinating. That sounds amazing. Great. Craig, how about for you? Well, let's combine all of your cool things slash disastrous things, good directors, the theatrical experience, and shots were not a lot of shots per minute. Last night. You got to see the movie. I saw You Can See Everything. Wow. Wow. I got to say. So I met Nathan Fielder once a number of years ago at an event.
49:30And he told me that he listens to this show. Now, the thing about Nathan Fielder is even in that moment, I was like, or is this a bit? Because it's hard to tell. But I'm going to take him at his word that he does. I don't know if he still does. If he still does, I hope he does. Then he's going to hear me say this. So he and Lance Oppenheim directed this documentary about Elizabeth Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans, a man you're going to be hearing a lot about in the next, I don't know, rest of your life. And it's just gorgeous. It's gorgeous. It is provocative. And of course, it's about somebody that is fascinating to us.
50:15So on that level, it's interesting. And naturally, because it's Nathan Fielder, there's some interesting meta things that occur that take it beyond just merely documentary. And when those things occur, you're like, oh, whoa. But beyond those things, it's also just beautifully made. Such a fascinating choice of angles, lenses, natural lighting. It is a tough thing to have people sit for three hours. Wow. without an intermission to watch anything. It is three hours long. I could have done another hour. Wow. I was just amazed by it. And it is, it's just quite an achievement. And I can't say enough.
51:03I'm so impressed with what they did. And, hey, you know what? I do not like Billy Evans.
51:11John August: New. Bold choices. I'm going to try to see it this week. Craig, you don't realize that you could have met Lance Al, but he's actually been on the show. He was episode 503. You were gone that week, but he's a guest on the show. Man, I mean, I'm a guest on the show. Let's face it. But it's fun. And I've heard that Nathan Fielder does listen to the show. So maybe we'll be able to get them to come back on at some point. It would be great to talk to them about it. I have loads of questions, but... But don't you worry that at the end, somehow they would have taken over the show and we would just be set aside.
51:44John August: Yeah, sure. fine. I have no problem with that. I mean, and just to be clear, I am not a fan of Elizabeth Holmes either. And there will be plenty of debate and it's just like the ultimate, you know, after movie chit chat doc. I mean, people can, I'm sure we'll go on and on about this with each other because that's the point. I'm not a big fan of either one of them, but I am a fan of what they did here. And Nathan Fielder is unique, which in today's day and age is the rarest of things. I got to see it before it gets spoiled because I know everybody's going to be talking about it. Exactly. So I'm racing to see it as soon as I can.
52:29I honestly, it's not spoilable as far as I'm concerned. It is the experience is the experience. There's, yeah, there are some things that I suppose if I had known going in, maybe would have hit with a little, but only, there's some momentary whoa, and then you just price it into the experience, but now it's the whole of it. It's just gorgeously done.
52:49John August: Gorgeous. Great. That is our show for this week. Script News is produced by Meredith Stedman with help from Lauren Loisberg. It's edited by Matthew Cilelli. Our outro this week is by Nick Moore. If you have an outro, you can send us a link to ask at johnoggins.com. It's also a place where you can send questions like the ones we answered today. You'll find transcripts at johnoggins.com. Reminders of the Script Notes book is available wherever you buy books. Script Notes merch is available at Cotton Bureau. If you'd like to see us, not just listen to us, follow us on YouTube and Instagram. If you'd like to read us, please subscribe to our weekly newsletter called Interesting, which has lots of links to things about writing.
53:22John August: Most of all, thank you to our premium subscribers. You can sign up to becomeone at scriptnotes.net where you get all the backup episodes and bonus segments, like the one we're about to record on all the things you direct that you don't write. But Andrew Sten, what an incredible pleasure to finally have you on Script Notes. It has been such a pleasure to finally meet you guys and talk shop with you guys. Likewise. Likewise.
John and Craig welcome a long-awaited guest: Andrew Stanton, writer-director behind many beloved Pixar films including Finding Nemo, Monsters, Inc., WALL-E, and the Toy Story franchise.
They talk about making sequels, Andrew's approach to storytelling, and the ways that Pixar shook up the typical Disney formula. (For example, Pixar's take on villains.)
In our bonus segment for premium subscribers, the three discuss directing other people's writing, as well as working in TV versus features.
Links:
Download the episode here!
Get your copy of The Scriptnotes Book and become a Scriptnotes Premium member today! For more content on the craft of writing check out Inneresting our weekly-ish newsletter about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters.
Scriptnotes is produced by Meredith Stedman and edited by Matthew Chilelli. Our coordinator is Lauren Loesberg.
Outro by Nick Moore (send us yours!)
Email us at [email protected]