

Script Notes episode 760 argues for reviving “bit parts” (small, memorable roles) in live-action, explains why they’ve declined, and answers questions on naming minor characters and pitching with talent in the room.
No guest hosts; it’s John August and Craig Mazin. They discuss their own production/casting experience (including TV guest actors and directing/writing constraints).
Bit parts/cameos elevate scenes without being story-essential; they’re often cut because writers/notes demand every scene “push the plot,” but audiences still enjoy brief, high-impact moments. Production realities (casting risk, cost/time) lead to fewer small speaking roles, so writers should “create fertile soil” for standout bit parts.
Bronson Pinchot in Beverly Hills Cop; Bill Murray in Zombieland; Melissa McCarthy in Go; “Mean Girls” “she doesn’t even go here”; Harry Met Sally (“I’ll have what she’s having”); No Country for Old Men (Gene Jones gas station owner); Barbie; Pirates of the Caribbean soldiers; Drew Barrymore in Scream.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the decline of bit parts in films and their significance.
“Craig, you may be aware that we just had an election here in the US.”
Hosts share insights on modern filming practices and production challenges.
“But then, of course, there's all the going around Chicago stuff.”
Exploration of what constitutes a bit part and examples from popular films.
“you try to do something too fancy, too clever.”
A look into how writers approach casting for bit parts versus main characters.
“upgrade and get more money because now they're featured or whatever, which I don't care about.”
Explore how bit parts can enhance narratives and engage audiences.
“A lot of times what I will do is as I'm writing, I start to combine a little bit.”
Discuss the challenges and considerations in casting minor characters.
“And that is, okay, when there are characters who don't speak, are they background or do we cast them?”
Learn strategies for justifying and defending unconventional scenes in scripts.
“and how you try to defend spending the story time to do these moments because it's time on screen, but it's also time to shoot these things.”
Learn how naming minor characters impacts audience expectations and production.
“Because what happens is when you go to IMDb, if you see a bunch of things like cop number one, that diminishes them, right?”
Understanding how to describe characters without overcomplicating scripts.
“So to me, at least in terms of a script, whether it's a sequential thing of like cop one, cop two, cop three, because sometimes it's like car pulls up, cops run out, hands up, get down, get down.”
Explore strategies for effectively pitching projects with actors present.
“How do you handle pitching with talent in the room, like actors or directors?”
Advice on how to respond when a similar project outshines your work.
“who is the most important person on the call or in the room about this?”
Discussing interesting topics and personal insights in the 'one cool thing' segment.
“We forget sometimes how many people don't vote.”
Explore reflections on historical changes and societal impacts post-Civil War.
“But yeah, I mean, that's not correct, you know?”
A heartfelt discussion about the closure of a beloved restaurant and its significance.
“First off is a restaurant that is closing on large month, which was a go-to for years for me.”
Analyzing a blog post about the realities and lessons from failed short films.
“a deep dive on the economics of what's happening that all these places are closing.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Scriptnotes Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01John August: Hello and welcome. My name is John August.
0:04Craig Mazin: My name is Steve Kronacki. Taking a look at Monmouth County, what we see here are pretty good votes for Craig Mazin.
0:09John August: I think so. This is a podcast about screenwriting called Script Notes. It is a podcast about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters. I got you there. Voters across the country are excited to have another episode with me and Craig on Zoom talking through things.
0:25Craig Mazin: Yes.
0:25John August: Today, I'll show Craig whatever happened to bit parts, those roles in which a character shows up for one memorable scene. I want to discuss why they seem to have vanished, particularly in live action, and make the case for bringing them back. Then let's answer some listener questions about naming characters and pitching with talent in the room. And in our bonus effort for premier members, Craig, you may be aware that we just had an election here in the US. What? Now, you and I are not political experts, but I think you and I have a strong sense of story. So I want to talk about what narratives we might look forward to in this next season of United States Democracy.
0:58Craig Mazin: I am looking forward to this next season. I tuned out a little bit. I think we all tuned out a little bit.
1:04John August: Yeah, didn't love them, man. I just like that we have a reboot. We have some new plot lines coming in. Yeah, it feels good. Some old ones, some plot lines to figure out how we're going to get rid of them. So it'll be exciting times. This season feels cool.
1:14Craig Mazin: I'm into this season.
1:15John August: It feels better, but eventful. So we'll talk through what that might be. Craig, we missed you in Austin. I'm so sorry. So we were sorry not to have you up on stage. We had a really good live show. We had a good three-page challenge. Phil and Pamela did a great job filling in for you, but it's always fun to have you there.
1:29Craig Mazin: I was sad that I couldn't make it. It was sort of a last-minute thing, but because of some weather issues and some scheduling issues, we were running three different units across Friday, which was the day I was supposed to travel, and Saturday. And so I just, I was told. You were told? I was told.
1:46John August: I was at a birthday party yesterday, and I was talking to a guy who's on a more classic procedural show, a network show, and they shoot eight days, you know, patterns for their shows. And they actually shoot like an episode at a time, which just seems crazy. Do you remember like that TV worked?
2:03Craig Mazin: I mean, we kind of do the same thing. You kind of do? Okay. It's just that the, what happens is we've got some things that are big second unit action things that take place at night. So we'll do daytime work and then we've got second unit out there at night. But, you know, I can sort of look at what they're doing at least for a while before I go to bed. And then we have a splinter unit sometimes that's handling a specific thing that maybe I go and direct. But we actually generally, we've only done block shooting twice. We're in one now where we're shooting two episodes together because it makes sense.
2:35Craig Mazin: But mostly we do one episode at a time, but not for eight days, it's only that much.
2:39John August: I remember talking with Lisa and Jonah about Westworld. And there was one day in which they had four different episodes shooting on the same day with four different directors who all had to share certain cast members. It's just, it's wild how we make things these days.
2:52Craig Mazin: It's been mayhem. Well, you know, our friend Derek, who created and ran Chicago Fire for all those years. Chicago Fire, by the way, hitting its 300th episode. Just incredible.
3:01John August: Crazy, yeah.
3:02Craig Mazin: So most of what they shot was here in LA on stages. But then, of course, there's all the going around Chicago stuff. So there was just a few weeks where all the directors would go and shoot all their Chicago stuff together. And it sounded like it was a bit mayhem like that.
3:19John August: Now, Craig, I want to push back on one thing. The Chicago show is largely shot in Chicago, though.
3:23Craig Mazin: Oh, on stage in Chicago? Yeah.
3:26John August: Oh. I thought that was the whole deal with Chicago. Oh, I thought it was here. Oh. But they definitely had, obviously, there were units, but they had to do crazy stuff.
3:33Craig Mazin: Yeah, okay. So maybe it was that they... They got to burn things. The outside stuff. They just were like, okay, we're going to pack all this action in. And so, yeah, you're probably right. That's probably what it was.
3:41John August: But I mean, a show like Yarr, going back all the way back in time, that was a show that shot on stages at Warner's. And then they would go occasionally to travel to do exteriors, but like they were largely here.
3:53Craig Mazin: John, can I, I'm going to push back on your use of pushback. Pushback, please. I think it's okay to just say to somebody, no, you're wrong. You know what I mean? Like pushback is sort of like, okay, hold on. I have a different point of view. But what you were saying correctly is, Craig, you're factually incorrect. I think, I think it's okay to just say to somebody, no, you're wrong. That's wrong. You're wrong. I mean, you don't have to call me an idiot or anything, but you could definitely. I mean, in that circumstance, you probably would have been more. I got your permission to. It could be like, yeah, fine, you're an idiot.
4:22Craig Mazin: Very nice. Yeah.
4:24John August: A little bit of a follow-up here. Writer Emergency Pack Character Creator Kit. That's a thing that you and I played with a little bit a few weeks ago. That's on Kickstarter. It's almost done. So if you're listening to this episode as it drops on Tuesday, you have two days left to get it and in your hands. This turned out great. So we have over 2 ,000 backers. The first decks are shipping before Christmas. People asked about international people because like the Kickstarter is only for the US. Sometime after the new year, we'll have it through the normal channels for people overseas. It's just kind of impossible to do it through Kickstarter in a way that works.
4:54John August: So not to get it out in time for Christmas. So after the new year. Do you localize the languages or it's just English? It's just English. The reason why international is challenging is because of tariffs and... Oh, well, you know, way to beat.
5:08Craig Mazin: Way to beat, way to beat.
5:10John August: I got a feeling, I got a feeling. Things could be easier. Tariffs and shipping, international stuff. Also just like shipping things to certain countries, stuff gets lost in the mail in weird ways. So if we go through other channels, we can do things much more easily. So we're waiting until after the new year for that. But Character Creator Kit turned out great. We have some more new videos out for that. So check us out on Kickstarter. We also have a new version of Highland Pro. We finally added cards to it, index cards, which we'd never had in the app before. I was always kind of resistant to it because I didn't like how any of their apps were doing it.
5:42John August: But I think we did a really good job of it. Instead of being a separate whole thing, It is actually just your script and you can move around scenes or beats in the card view. And then as you switch back to your script, it actually moved those things around. So it's been fun to experiment with that and have a whole new view for your thing.
5:58Craig Mazin: I've never used those modes.
5:59John August: You used to use physical cards. I remember you had like a board. I did. Are you still doing that anymore?
6:04Craig Mazin: Not really. I think if I were to write a movie, I would probably do it.
6:07John August: Yeah.
6:08Craig Mazin: But I don't really do it for TV. It would be too many goddamn cards. Too many cards. Too many cards. Too many cards.
6:13John August: A thing you probably do have to do though is find and replace. and where you have to, you're going through and looking for a thing, you've named a character, different stuff, you have to do that. The other new feature in 3.4 is an advanced find and replace. NEMA just knocked it out of the park with this, which is, Meredith is nodding here. It can change everything all at once. And so it shows you a list, like these are all the things that are going to change and you hit click and it does all those things. But you can also undo it all at once too. So if you make a mistake, you try to do something too fancy, too clever.
6:42John August: But it can also, particularly for like if you're renaming a character, You want to make sure it's matching sort of where it's uppercase, where it's not uppercase, where there's a possessive on it. It does just a very smart job of that. So try it out. So we've been advanced. Find and replace. Okay, cool. Let's talk about bit parts. So Craig, I'm currently working on the feature adaptation of Wolf's Belly, which has a bunch of characters who are doing different stuff. And like the graphic novel, there are those characters who just kind of have one or two scenes who are very funny and they exist to be funny in that moment.
7:16John August: I think Chub Detectives also has that situation where you have a bunch of things where there are characters who, they're there for that joke, but you don't have expectation that they're going to be doing a lot else in the movie. And that's become kind of rare these days. It got me thinking about how you don't see that as much. And then, because that was queued up in my mind, I saw a video by Shane Anderson, that I'll put a link into in the show notes, where he talks through this idea of whatever happened to the bit part, Whatever happened to those character actors who appear just to do a thing, and it's fine that they're in that movie, and you don't expect them to come back.
7:50John August: So I want to talk about bit parts, extras, day players, maybe even start by defining our terms. What do you think of when you think of a bit part?
7:57Craig Mazin: Well, a bit part to me is really similar to a cameo, or if the person isn't particularly famous. Like the one that always leaps to my mind is Bronson Pinchot in Beverly Hills Cop. He wasn't particularly famous at the time, But he played a guy who works at this art gallery. I think he was in two scenes, possibly one, and captivated everybody. So a bit part is somebody that has a small amount of screen time, but if it's done well, has a very outsized impact on the viewing experience.
8:30John August: Absolutely. And so I would distinguish that between a supporting character who comes back repeatedly and actually has, maybe not a huge arc, but has a significant role that progresses things forward. The other thing that's different about a bit part role is that they tend not to be story essential. Like you could cut them, you could do them in a different way and it wouldn't matter. You could also just replace them with someone who was just purely functional and things would kind of work. It's just that their presence in the scene elevates it to a specific moment. Sometimes they're often interacting with the hero, but sometimes they're not interacting at all.
9:02John August: The thing this video points out is in Pirates of the Caribbean, there are these two soldiers who the movie just cuts back to having conversations that aren't connected to anything, but they're providing bits of context exposition in a way that's really fun.
9:16Craig Mazin: Yeah, and it's a great opportunity for us. I mean, when we're writing to get out of the rut of your main character, your protagonist, your antagonist, the allies and the enemies, all of whom really are in service of the plot, it's a chance to just step away and provide some sort of outside perspective. Sometimes it's wonderful to just have somebody wander into the movie and go, what are you all doing? What is this? Or sometimes in the case of a cameo, it's great to just give the movie shot in the arm. Like when Bill Murray shows up in Zombieland, it's a bit part for Bill Murray. It's a great cameo and it's exciting and it happens and it's over.
9:55Craig Mazin: And you could tell that he had a great day or two shooting.
9:58John August: Well, let's try to distinguish between a cameo and a bit part. Is it a cameo just is a bit part with a famous person? Yeah. Or you recognize the person?
10:04Craig Mazin: Yeah, totally. I mean, it's a person who normally has played lead roles, but is having fun with a bit part. That's a cameo to me. Yeah.
10:14John August: Now you're making a show right now. So you obviously have people who are coming in for specific things and longer things. Talk to us about specific terms you might be using as you're talking to your casting director or to your team. Help us distinguish between extras, day players, under five, featured. What do those terms mean for you? What do they mean for the production?
10:33Craig Mazin: Well, we don't say extras anymore. We say background performers. And background performers are all the people in the scene that don't have lines. They don't really have characters. They're in a group character. So if you have a scene in a restaurant, all the other people eating food in the restaurant are background. Day players are actors who have either a line or sometimes for our show, they don't have a line, but they are important. Like they need to interact in the scene in a way that matters. And so we'll cast that person. And so they're a day player. Sometimes day players act more than one day, but the general idea is you're there for a scene or two.
11:11Craig Mazin: And then there's this notion of like featured background, which, so when, when you're making things, when you're directing, they put this, the fear of God in you to like, if you start to direct a particular person in background, they're going to go ask for an upgrade and get more money because now they're featured or whatever, which I don't care about. never stops me. But featured means, okay, you're a background person, but you are the person who, you know, gets some soda dumped on you or something. Or, you know, you're standing there with your jaw dropped because you're in, the director had to, you know, guide you.
11:46John August: Let's think about that because you could be someone who is like, you're the waiter who's doing a thing. And if, so if the waiter is taking a person's order, they're going to have some lines. And so just by having some lines, they're no longer just background. Oh yeah, no, now you're an,
11:59Craig Mazin: yeah, you're an actor. If you speak, the rule is you can speak as background if you were speaking in unison as a group or cheering or something. So if the director is like, okay, everybody in the crowd say. Non-specific, yeah. Yes, oh, yes. Hell no, we won't go. That's not dialogue. But if you're a waiter and you're like, here you go, welcome to SAG.
12:19John August: Well, let's talk about then the writer's choice there in terms of like, do you mean for that character to attract any attention to be meaningful or are they just there purely for function? And so if the waiter could essentially be off screen and we never actually kind of really see them or they're just barely on screen for it, that is reasonable. And it's going to keep our attention on whatever the conversation that's happening at the dinner table. But there might be an opportunity for that waiter as actually attracting attention and doing something that we're going to actually be paying attention to them.
12:48John August: So an example would be in my first movie Go, there's a scene in the third section where Melissa McCarthy is the roommate of the guy that they're trying to look for. And so Melissa McCarthy opens the door and she takes over the scene. She just controls the moment. She's like, that is a bit part. That she was not a star when we cast her in that. And she completely owns that moment. And yet we don't expect her to ever show up again. Right. We know that she's just there to do that function and be incredibly funny in that function and move us forward. Bronson Pinchot. That is a bit part.
13:18Craig Mazin: Yeah. Yeah, that absolutely is. Once you start going through a lot of production, you don't want to limit yourself when you're writing. You don't want to feel constrained by the rules. But you begin to get some muscle memory. And you start to ask yourself a question. It's not even about money. It's sort of like, okay, if this person says, yes, sir, I got to cast them. Now we have to go. We have to get auditions. We have to watch 12 people say, yes, sir.
13:43John August: They could potentially kind of mess it up on the day, which it seems impossible. But like, I know that for my TV show, I'm like, good Lord.
13:49Craig Mazin: It can happen. Sir, yes. It's a burden on the production anytime you have to cast somebody, right? So you want to feel like, all right, if I'm asking for an actor and I'm asking for the audition process to happen and casting people to do their jobs and actors to come in and care, there has to be maybe something there or a real reason why I need somebody to say yes, sir. A lot of times what I will do is as I'm writing, I start to combine a little bit. So if you do have a classic Soldier 1, Soldier 2, Soldier 3 scene, you want to ask yourself, could we give all the dialogue to Soldier 1? just to begin to narrow it down a little bit.
14:29Yeah.
14:29Craig Mazin: Because, you know, in general, the production loves it when you can minimize that sort of thing because it costs money.
14:37John August: It costs money, but also it could potentially cost time. And it's also just another risk, another variable in there. Like, oh, the one who's playing Soldier 2, it just tanks it. And then you're cutting around that or you're burning an extra 30 minutes trying to get this thing salvageable.
14:51Craig Mazin: Oh, yeah. And, you know, sometimes that does happen. And that's part of the sweet misery of making things. But I do love writing a good bit part. I do love writing somebody that kind of appears and does a thing. And we have a pretty good track record on our show with guest actors. So, you know, that's a whole category in television. Like, okay, guest actor, somebody that shows up, they're not going to be in more than one episode, generally. I think the limit is two. And it's pretty narrow. So like, you know, the late, great Catherine O 'Hara, that was in its own way a bit part, but it was so important.
15:26Craig Mazin: And she was rightfully nominated for an Emmy.
15:28John August: Well, let's talk about some other just great bit parts. So I talked about Melissa McCarthy in Go. She also appears in Charlie's Angels. She's great in her scene there. In Mean Girls, there's the, she doesn't even go here, but the girl who doesn't even go here, that's a bit part. And that's so funny. And you could cut it, but it's just so great. Like you try it. And so it's fantastic. When Harry Met Sally, I'll have what she's having, which is Rob Reiner's mom.
15:53Craig Mazin: Who is that? That is Rob Reiner's mother.
15:54John August: Yeah. And so it's a great example. Like sometimes you give the joke to someone who's not in the scene because the punchline is someone who's not part of the scene, which is just terrific.
16:05Craig Mazin: Yeah. That's, you know, one of the all-time greats.
16:07John August: Barbie is full of bit parts. Barbie is arguably some of the most supporting characters because you see them report repeatedly, but like they're just there to deliver the funny moment. Yeah. It's not just comedy though. So the video points out No Country for Old Men, Gene Jones is the gas station owner. Yeah. Come on. Great. Awesome. And there you needed to cast somebody who can play opposite the Anton Sugar character who's just so absurd. And if we see this gas station owner immediately, we understand what he's like. He's only got the one scene, but it's a little one-act play that's happening there.
16:38Craig Mazin: It's great. And the world of what we call character actors. Yes. And that's a whole other thing, you know, character actors. What are character actors? I mean, basically they're actors that work all the time. They generally are not the antagonist or a key part, but they are a lawyer who shows up or they're a gas station owner. They're great day players. And I love working with those actors. Those actors are like ready to go. What do I do? Tell me where to stand. I got this. And you know what you're getting from me and I'm going to do it. And it's wonderful working with those actors. And also I feel like those actors may know more about filmmaking than anyone because they probably appear, I don't know, maybe they work on 15 sets a year, you know?
17:23Craig Mazin: Think of all the directors they've gone through and all the makeup departments and everything. They know exactly who they are and what to do.
17:29John August: And your casting director will have a very good sense of who are those people who can just show up and deliver. And yes, you're going to pay more money for them, but they're going to deliver something that's great.
17:39Craig Mazin: And that is also a challenge that we face when we're making things. And that is, okay, when there are characters who don't speak, are they background or do we cast them? And a lot of times I want to cast them because I can't necessarily hand this off to a background person. So for instance, let's say there's a scene where a mother and a father are bringing their child to school. It's her first day of school. Well, that requires some acting. Yeah. And a lot of times, you know, if it's a short thing where they're just like, they're walking her to school and then the teacher comes and takes her and it's all about this little girl, but the parents have to have some feeling.
18:16Craig Mazin: A lot of times they give that to background. And I think cast it.
18:21John August: Well, I would say like if this were a commercial, you would obviously cast those people. And so you shouldn't have lower standards for your TV episode or your feature film than you would for a commercial.
18:30Craig Mazin: Well, the budget for commercials is quite a bit higher per second than for anything else.
18:35John August: you know the last example i would sort of give is that horror movies tend to have bit parts and especially like the first kills in horror movies like this is a person who has to command your attention for this whole first sequence and we have to believe that they are in this world they're setting up everything about them and and then something terrible generally happens to them or sometimes in the middle paul walter hauser's character in the new resident evil great and that's obviously a fantastic character actor who's agreeing to do a smaller part in a thing because it's terrific.
19:05Craig Mazin: Because he loves it. Yeah, I mean, the ultimate horror example is Drew Barrymore at the beginning of Scream, which you could sort of call a cameo, but I don't I think it really is a bit part. I think it's it's this great opening. It's a long scene.
19:19John August: Yeah.
19:19Craig Mazin: Gosh, you're so good in that.
19:21John August: So, general things about bit parts, they are disposable as an audience. We don't expect to see those people again. They make a brief encounter with a strong impression. They disappear. And also, I like that they feel like they are the main character of another movie where they're not going to see. I think they give a bigger context to the story we're watching because you're like, oh, there are actually other things out there that exist. And that's where I want to segue back into why I think we've not seen them so much and degree to which it's kind of our fault. It's because I think we are responding to notes that say every scene has to be on point.
19:55John August: Every scene has to be delivering a story and pushing the story forward. Scenes need to be driven by your protagonist, by your hero. And as you look at a lot of these great scenes we're talking about, they aren't that. They are very good for the movie as a whole. But you could argue that like, you could cut the scene and the story would progress fine. Absolutely. And so often on this podcast over the last 759 episodes, we've talked about like, if a scene could be cut, it will be cut. And therefore, you need to always be thinking about that. And here I want to make sure that we are creating space for the opposite of that, which is sometimes your movie just needs to enjoy the moment that it can create and give that sense of excitement and surprise.
20:38Craig Mazin: Well, as writers, we have to earn it. So if you are writing and you feel yourself beginning to write stuff for Clerk, then just ask, does the Clerk deserve this? Have I put enough thought into Clerk? And is this exchange doing anything? So even in Beverly Hills Cop, you could absolutely, they could have completely lifted that Bronson Pinchot thing. It did nothing story-wise. Zero plot impact, zero character impact. But it was in service of the whole concept of fish out of water. Yeah. And Axel Foley trying to wrap his mind around how Beverly Hills functions.
21:21John August: I think that's the crucial thing is that you say like, oh, you could omit the Bronson Pinchot character. except that it gave, by putting Axel Foley on his heels a little bit and not having him drive the scene, it made him more relatable to us. Because like, oh, I can imagine myself in this situation where as opposed to most of the time, Axel Foley is driving things and he's just so different than us.
21:41Craig Mazin: Yes, and it also was really smart because it gave the movie a chance to play the fish out of water thing without any racial undertones because a lot of what was going on in the movies, here's a black man from Detroit who arrives in lily white Beverly Hills and there is a lot of racism and all. You could tell that Victor, the bad guy, clearly doesn't like black people. But Bronson Pinchot's character, he talks to Axel Foley like he's anybody. Do you want to espresso, twist of Lyman? I make myself. He's just weird. And he's expressing this kind of... And it's fun to see that Axel Foley, the guy who's in complete control of everything and puts bananas and tailpipes and...
22:24Craig Mazin: is totally on his heels here trying to figure out what this guy. And that's what you kind of just have to feel like you earned it. And in all these movies, especially comedies, nobody wants to be there all day putting up lights and sweating and doing all this stuff for something that they don't think has bought its way in.
22:46John August: Exactly. So let's talk about how you defend and protect a scene like that, or I guess two scenes like that through the development process because I find that a lot of times those weird moments get shaved off in the development process because people say like, oh, but it's kind of weird because like an actor will say like, well, I'm not the funny person in this. I'm not driving this forward. Or see like the director's like, I don't know if it's really worth the time here. It's that the studio executive saying like, I just don't know that this actually makes sense for us to do this. It's not on plot.
23:18John August: and how you try to defend spending the story time to do these moments because it's time on screen, but it's also time to shoot these things. You just don't know if they're going to work. The Judd Apatow school of just like shooting a whole bunch is fantastic, but it's harder, I think, to defend that amount of time and freedom how we're making movies these days. Well, I agree with you.
23:43Craig Mazin: It is harder. Everything does feel a bit more disciplined. I think what often did happen was there was a character who had three lines. That person came, didn't audition, Rift. Yeah. I think Bronson Pinchot improv most of that scene with Eddie Murphy. Yeah. And so what happens is the director has a sense of like, I'm going to open up a little space here because the truth is, I always say this like page count is, you and I have talked about this is such a bad way of thinking about things because I'm like, once I say action and they start talking, If they go on one more minute and I do 20 takes, I've just spent 20 minutes in the day, that's nothing.
24:23Craig Mazin: Yeah. That's nothing. Like, why not? Let's just see where this goes. And if you, so I think a lot of times it's just about everybody's sort of going, let's see if we can get something. And if we get something, great. And if you write something that's really, really good, do we get somebody good to do it? I think that's, you know, somebody that feels like they're fulfilling the goal.
24:42John August: But the challenge, of course, is you don't have the Axel Foley, Watson Pinchot scene unless you've actually created the space there for that to exist. And so you have to have a scene that can do that and then be thinking, okay, who is the person who on the day can get you to that moment and to that space? Going back to Williamson McCarthy, like that scene was necessary. Like it was a connecting piece to get us to the party at the end and sort of how things, you probably couldn't drop that scene. But I can also imagine the scene where it didn't have that level of energy. Like she says the lines that are in the script, but she just delivers them in a way that is so remarkable that the scene actually has energy to it.
25:19John August: We could have gotten by with something that was less than that. But if you have the version that's less than that, it just gets closer and closer to the chopping block.
25:27Craig Mazin: It gets cut. And look, stuff will get cut. It happens. Not everything works. We must always be mindful as writers that what we see is the result of a thousand edits. So sometimes I worry that I write a little too close to the bone because I don't want to shoot something I don't have to shoot. I do want everything to have a purpose and a meaning, but you know, sometimes you want to give a little bit of, you know, but if you create fertile soil for a good bit part, sometimes, I don't know, it's like the shot in the arm that a movie needs to just suddenly it sparkles. The characters of somebody new to talk to almost always the person who's doing the big part is controlling the scene around them in some way or another.
26:11Otherwise, they're just, you know, a victim.
26:15Craig Mazin: And it's fun to watch your heroes suddenly be like, wait, what's happened? Who is this?
26:19John August: So I think my challenge to listeners is to go through your scripts and find one speaking part that is purely functional. Could be like a nurse, a cashier, a prison guard. And then ask like, what happens if the scene was told from their point of view or imagine they entered the scene with a specific point of view. And just to, most cases you shouldn't do it. Most cases you shouldn't try to write the big surprising twist out of a thing. But I think it's worth it to ask, like what would happen if? Because especially if you have scenes that feel just like functional and lifeless, maybe it's because you're not letting there be an obstacle in the scene.
26:55John August: And the obstacle could be just a fascinating version of that functional character.
26:59Craig Mazin: Agreed. Cool.
27:01John August: We actually have a very related question. This comes from Lauren Loesberg, our coordinator here. She was asking, how do you decide when to give a minor character a name versus just calling them something like girl number one, soldier number two? Should these minor characters be fleshed out when or when not?
27:16Craig Mazin: I deal with this all the time.
27:19John August: So what are you thinking about when that comes up? If we were to look through your scripts for Last of Us, are there function number two?
27:26Craig Mazin: Yes. Yes. It's not common, but yes. When you're dealing with large groups of people and there's a moment where three of them have to do a thing and it's very transitory and in service of sequence. Yes. Now, what often happens is that actors will ask for a name, even if it's not like a number sign. Like, for instance, in Chernobyl, there was an actor whose job was to do the remote control of a rover. And I think I'd just written like remote operator. And the actor was like, could I have a name? And I understand why. Because what happens is when you go to IMDb, if you see a bunch of things like cop number one, that diminishes them, right?
28:07John August: Or guy pissing at your urinal.
28:09Craig Mazin: I mean, classic. And so I understand that, you know, but when you start to write a name into the script, it is creating an expectation that there's going to be more there.
28:22John August: Yes.
28:23Craig Mazin: And that's what actually why I kind of like girl number one and girl number two. if the expectation is simply that girl number one goes, oh my God, and girl number two is like gross and we never see them again.
28:33John August: Yeah. You know? So the middle ground I often find is that I will give, this is going back to Go, but many other scripts too, is rather than girl number one, girl number two, I will give like a specific description of that girl, which becomes their name. And so it's like in the Go script, there's the kids who are in the van who are smoking pot. And so it's like one of the kids is named Spider Marine because he's wearing camouflage. that there is like, you know, 17-year-old girl. It's a little something more that you can hang on. It's the difference between reading a script and seeing a movie. It's like in an actual feature film, we have faces that we can look at.
29:07John August: In a script, if you give a character a name, your brain does that thing where it's like, I have to remember this name and you don't want them to remember that name. You don't.
29:14Craig Mazin: And the worst situation is they begin to confuse that name with another character.
29:19John August: Exactly.
29:19Craig Mazin: And now you're really messed up. So to me, at least in terms of a script, whether it's a sequential thing of like cop one, cop two, cop three, because sometimes it's like car pulls up, cops run out, hands up, get down, get down. Okay, those two people, it's cop one and cop two, because even if you start to get into specifics about them, now the casting people are like, well, you said tall cop and short cop. You're just like, I actually just want two people that say hands up and get down really well. it just helps the production. It's really about thinking about the production and how much weight you want people to give to that character.
29:57John August: Exactly. So I would say it's worth taking an audit through your script and making sure like if you have a lot of number ones and number twos, especially if a numbered character has multiple lines, then it gets to be an application where it's like, it's kind of weird that they're just a number and they're not actually doing a thing. But that doesn't mean that they actually have to have their first and a last name. it can be descriptive and functional so that the reader understands who this person is in the scene and doesn't put any more weight on it because again this is essentially it's like a bit part you're just you're just saying like enjoy this character while we're seeing it but don't expect
30:31Craig Mazin: this character to come back sometimes it's even better if the function of this person is entirely within say their age like let's say you have a scene where there's a kid and there's like it's a bank robbery and there are people holding people hostage and a guy who points a gun at a kid and says, I'll do it. I'll kill you. And kid or child or little girl, please don't. As opposed to Vanessa, please don't. Like who's Vanessa? Do you know what I mean? The whole point is that a little girl is saying, please don't. That is a stronger move actually.
31:03John August: Yeah. And if it's a parent, don't give a name, like girl's mother.
31:08Craig Mazin: Right. Exactly. Girl's mother.
31:09John August: We understand what that
31:10Craig Mazin: That's the important part. Yeah, not Brenda. Yeah. I'd say Vanessa and Brenda.
31:16John August: We have a question from a writing team. This came in from an email, but I asked them and they said it was okay for us to share this on the podcast. Meredith, can you read this for us?
31:23Craig Mazin: How do you handle pitching with talent in the room, like actors or directors? Do you carve out space for the actors to talk about their characters and what drew them to the material? Or do you let that happen more organically?
31:35John August: That's a good question. So there's context around this, which I will be vague about, but it's writers who are going out with a project and they're lucky to have actors attached and they're trying to figure out, how do you deal with the actors in the room? Because do you try to script them? Do you try to plan in advance? Who's going to say what? I've had experiences as both. I've had actors who just went off in weird directions in the room and it was tough. Craig, what have been your experiences with actors in the room as you're pitching things?
32:04Craig Mazin: I don't do it. I don't do it. I don't do it.
32:07John August: So tell me about that conversation and you're talking with them about not having them there, what happens?
32:12Craig Mazin: If the only reason I would do it is if the whole point of it was this actor doing this thing, at which point I don't have a lot to pitch, right? Like if I walk into a room with Tom Hanks and we're talking about doing, I don't know, a sequel to Big, right? It's actually a great idea. Yeah, like there should absolutely be one.
32:33John August: Why has there not been a sequel to Big? That feels like a very obvious idea.
32:36Craig Mazin: There's something going on there. Yeah, I mean, you go reverse. He goes reverse and he's like a little boy again. We're going to make the movie small. Exactly. You want the star to shine and to glitter. And then you want to say, look, here's roughly what the story is about. And you want to, based on that, you want to narrow it to the character. His character, this happens, this happens. And it's all about Tom's character doing this and this and this. And let them ask questions and you can kind of, well, we have this great set piece or we have this interesting. But you don't need to like do a very structured, because it's really just about this actor.
33:09Craig Mazin: Otherwise, if it's not like that, I just find that ultimately what happens is you're going to end up having to pitch it anyway without them because no one's going to buy it unless they know, you know what I mean? Like they're going to need to know. And if the actor's just rambling the whole time, how does that help?
33:24John August: So a fairly recent example I had was a big property that had an actor producer attached to it. And so he kind of needed to be in the pitch. Well, arguably needed to be in the pitch and he wasn't especially helpful kind of in the room. Basically, I pitched the whole thing and he just said, yeah, I'm really excited to do this. And it felt a little weird that like the most famous person on the Zoom was just sitting in a corner, not talking for the whole thing. Yeah, that is weird. And that becomes a challenge. There's also a case where you have a director attached to a thing where I am the writer pitching the thing, but the director who's going to be directing this project is also in the Zoom.
33:58John August: And we tend to do a handoff where the director talks about why they're excited to do this thing and what their vision is. then I talk through the things and then we can both have a conversation there at the end with the executive or whoever's potentially buying it. That's worked better, but it still becomes a question of like, who is the most important person on the call or in the room about this?
34:19Craig Mazin: The most important person is the person that they insist is the least important person. The most important person is the writer. That's why it's a pitch of the story. But I completely agree with you that you can get value pitching with a director, particularly a filmmaker of note, because you absolutely can integrate a pitch where you talk about story and then they talk about imagery, vision, casting ideas, costume, scope, all the wonderful things that directors are going to be dealing with. And then you go back and you kind of do your thing. And this way, it also helps sell a writer and director as a team, which is a very comforting thing for buyers to see.
35:02John August: So another project that I may be going out with soon, we'll have actors attached. And so actors can be attached, but we all know that actors can be attached, but you don't really know, have they even read it? Are they even sort of involved in a thing? It means literally nothing. So it could be helpful to have that person express how excited they are on the Zoom, but it can also be helpful for them to like call afterwards or do the thing or have their agents call, the executive and say like, no, seriously, they very much want to do this and they're desperate to it. And that may be more helpful than having them actually on the pitch itself.
35:35Craig Mazin: If somebody doesn't have a role to play in the room, they shouldn't be there. So it doesn't help if you have, it actually hurts to have an actor of notes sitting there silently. It communicates lack of interest or lack of connection. It's weird. I would say that to the, because I think you're absolutely right. What I'd say to the actors, if you want to help, here's how you help. This is what, this is what'll do it. unless they too have a way to integrate themselves. And if it makes sense, then that's great. Then that's wonderful. You know, I mean, I love actors and it's just not something they do often.
36:12Craig Mazin: They're not in rooms pitching stories the way we do. So as long as they're integrated, then I would say absolutely.
36:21John August: All right, let's ask a third question here. This is about a better version of your script.
36:26Craig Mazin: Andrew asks, I've been writing a script and I feel pretty good about it, but I had a pretty sobering experience recently. My film is about surveillance and illicit dark web stuff in the psychological thriller genre. I just watched a film that's being released this year that is in the same genre and similar space to mine, but is just clearly a better execution than any of my ideas. So my question is, should I examine the ways I think this film is better and rethink my scenes, or should I put this film entirely out of my head and stay the course with what I've originally planned and written and hope that my voice is enough for it.
37:02John August: I have a strong take, but I'm curious what your take is, Craig. I would reframe the question as like, should you finish writing this thing you no longer like slash love? And the answer to that is no. If you have fallen out of love with this idea, forcing yourself to finish it is not probably going to be a good outcome. Different pitch?
37:22Craig Mazin: No, I agree with you. And I think actually you've been given a gift, Andrew. and the gift is somebody did it better. That's what you're saying. You looked at it. And by the way, great sign that you can admit that. Yeah. The humility here is excellent. So now you have a gift. Now you can actually sit and think about where you didn't do as well as they did and why and what did they do that was better and take from those lessons and roll those lessons into the next thing you write. Because no matter what you do here, you by your own admission will be creating something that is a lesser than version of something that already exists.
37:56Craig Mazin: I don't think you'll be the only one who notices that. So I would say, yeah, good news. You learned early, not late. So cut bait, start something new.
38:08John August: So I'm reading this question to say that Andrew somehow saw this movie ahead of time before it's come out in theaters. What I would caution listeners from trying to generalize too broadly from this is that you see a trailer for something that kind of feels like your thing. From my own personal experience, there have been so many times where it's like, oh my gosh, this is exactly the same movie I'm trying to write. And then you see the actual movie, it's like, oh my God, there's nothing like it. The trailer was giving me the wrong impression. There's always that aspect of the thing that's actually made looks better than your thing that's on the page.
38:36John August: And so I would say don't use this as an excuse to bail on your thing. But if this is giving you doubts about the actual quality of the thing that you're doing and recognizing there's a better version of this, then yeah, I think it's time to stop and think stuff around. Again, over the course of 759 episodes, often I think we have said, no, you need to actually finish one thing. And I would stick with that. You need to actually learn how to finish a script because if you're always bailing on anything and never get anything finished, that's not good. And so maybe if you're kind of close and just want to learn what it's like to actually finish and deliver a script, that's great.
39:14John August: But in general, if you're feeling these qualms now, there's a reason why.
39:19Craig Mazin: This is a case where I think we can waive the finish your script rule. It just because he knows like, ah, okay, got it. And by the way, you're absolutely right. You don't want to judge things off of trailers or anything that you want to watch the thing. Look, similar things can exist, but they have to feel like they are different sides of the same die. You know, they can't just be the same thing and they have to be done just as well as each other, ideally, to get out there. So I feel like, yeah, hopefully, Andrew, you're getting a sense that we are giving you permission to take the lessons you've learned and move on to something else.
39:53Yeah.
39:53John August: I really like all three of the questions we answered today. So keep sending in your questions. We love great questions from our listeners. It is time for our one cool things. Craig, what's your one cool thing?
40:04Craig Mazin: Voters. Voters. Voters. Voters. We forget sometimes how many people don't vote. Our elections are in weird ways controlled by dark matter, anti-matter, non-vote, because every non-vote is a big deal. And voters showed up and showed up in places that they have traditionally not showed up. And I don't think I've made any mystery of my general political view about the current state of things in our country. So yes, I was pleased with the outcome, but I'm particularly pleased with the civic engagement. And the more people vote, the more they vote. So I do see some pretty promising signs with this new generation of voters, the people who turned 18 and are 18, 19, 20 as they're voting in this election.
40:57Craig Mazin: They're voting. They want to vote. And that's exciting.
41:00John August: They're going to see movies in theaters and they're voting. And they're voting. Both very encouraging signs.
41:05Craig Mazin: We're bringing the 70s back.
41:06John August: Craig, I would say that leading into these midterms, I felt like I saw much less voter activation, much less sort of campaigns. Like, you got to get out and vote and all this stuff. And I don't know if your voter drives. Because you live in California. I think there's such a general momentum. Like, you know, do you like what's happening out there?
41:22Craig Mazin: Yeah, we don't experience it where we live. But the door knocking that was going on in Texas was crazy. The door knocking that was going on in Mississippi was incredible. I mean, there was just Georgia. By the way, John, I don't know if we talked about this, the all 13 originally U.S. colonies voted Democratic. It's a remarkable thing. But there's in states where there's been traditionally, like Mississippi, the population is 40 % black. And they have not had a black senator in, I don't know.
41:54John August: Since the Reconstruction. Yeah. The last black senator was born a slave. Yes.
41:58Craig Mazin: And he was senator briefly. And it was like right after the Civil War. Yeah. But yeah, I mean, that's not correct, you know? I mean, so it just doesn't feel quite right. And it looks like we're finally getting a bit of a change because they got the vote out. Yeah.
42:17John August: So in our bonus segment, we'll talk about what changes we think might happen over the next couple of years. I have two one cool things. First off is a restaurant that is closing on large month, which was a go-to for years for me. Louisa's. Louisa's Latouria. The last Luiz's. Yeah, so for folks who didn't, you know, spend much time in Los Angeles, Luiz's was a chain that was throughout Los Angeles. There was one near my old house off of Melrose, but there's also an institution on Larchmont was Luiz's Trattoria. It's an Italian place. It's not like the best Italian in the world, but it's like very comfort food Italian, a little neighborhood place where you can see a George Takai at the next booth over.
42:56Craig Mazin: Oh my.
42:57John August: It is where our incredibly picky daughter would actually be willing to eat. Okay. So she'd get her steamed broccoli and her kids' pasta with chicken, which is still her go-to order, which we'll order tonight.
43:11Craig Mazin: Steamed broccoli?
43:13John August: Steamed broccoli.
43:13Craig Mazin: Steamed broccoli is basically like if you took farts and you made them solid. That's what steamed broccoli is.
43:21John August: Steamed broccoli is delicious, especially at Louisa's because I think they cook it over the pasta water, so it has a lot of gluten in it just from that. Yes. Just delicious.
43:29Craig Mazin: You know when someone's steaming broccoli in your house.
43:33John August: You know. You're like a... We've tried to duplicate the effect of Louise's steaming broccoli. So anyway, it's closing. And I'm so frustrated that it's closing because it's one of a slew of great restaurants and institutions that have been closing. I don't... Somebody, LA Material or somebody needs to do a deep dive on the economics of what's happening that all these places are closing. Sycamore Kitchen also closed.
43:55Craig Mazin: Which one closed?
43:56John August: Sycamore Kitchen on La Brea, which is a great lunch place. Sure. It was a go-to for writer's rooms for years.
44:02Craig Mazin: Probably rent. I think it probably is rent.
44:05John August: Largemont is clearly rent. And the families that control Largemont are trying to bring in national chains, which is antithesis of what Largemont should be.
44:14Craig Mazin: And yet the one national chain we had, which was Rite Aid, they lost. So we have no pharmacy there. So Louise's, when it was multiple restaurants, was kind of garbagey. And so I didn't have any interest really going to Louise's on Large Mop. But Melissa was like, no, no, no, this one's like the last one and it's kind of its own thing. It's not, it's like an actual restaurant. Like it's separate.
44:38John August: Their chicken parm was delicious. That's right. It was really good. They had their chopped salad.
44:41Craig Mazin: Yeah, it was a great place and also easy to get into, which I said, well, I'm partly why I'm close. Because for some reason, not to disparage any other restaurants on that street, but there's another restaurant very close to Louise's that is always packed and I am mystified as to who I am. I won't say which one, but I do love across the street there's a there's a good Italian restaurant there but our beloved but our beloved village pizzeria closed so like when we played D &D you know I would order pizza from village pizzeria it was like
45:10John August: because you try to support
45:11Craig Mazin: the local place yeah and then now they're closed yeah what are we going to do it's frustrating
45:16John August: it's because we needed like three more coffee places on large bond or fancy ice creams
45:21Craig Mazin: all of our listeners in Poland are like I'm so bored yes
45:26John August: well here's a useful thing for all of our listeners which is Drew Marquardt our very own former producer wrote a blog post called my short film flopped so yours won't have to which is a postmortem on his short film which we talked about on this podcast before Drew went off and shot a short he did a fantastic job he got into basically no major festivals with it and sort of talks about what happened and why and what he learned from it and useful, good things. We coach them not to be so self-flagellating about it, but also just to, what are the actual takeaways to pull from this? And it's great because we are often encouraging people to make short films.
46:08John August: And sometimes those films just don't flourish in the world. And this is what happens when a film does not flourish in the world. Yeah. So my short film flopped, so yours won't have to, by our very own Drew Marquardt. We'll link at the show notes to that.
46:22Craig Mazin: That is also a rare and beautiful thing, which is humility. This is how we learn, by embracing our mistakes and learning from our mistakes. It's fantastic.
46:34John August: That is our show for this week. Scriptnance is produced by Meredith Stedman with help from Lauren Loesberg. It is edited by Matthew Cilelli. Outro this week is by Brian Keffer. If you have an outro, you can send us a link to ask at johnaugust.com. That's also a place where you can send questions like the ones we answered today. You will find transcripts at johnaugust.com. along with a sign-up for our weekly newsletter called Interesting, which has lots of links to things about writing. The Script Notes book is available wherever you buy books, a perfect Christmas gift. Or honestly, put it on your list so people buy the book for you.
47:04John August: That's the secret, because everyone wants to know, like, what should I get you for Christmas? Get the Script Notes book. We have Script Notes merch available at Cotton Bureau. If you'd like to see us, not just listen to us, follow us on YouTube and Instagram. If you'd like to read us, please subscribe to our weekly newsletter called Interesting, which has lots of links to things about writing. Most of all, thank you to our premium subscribers. You can sign up to become one at scriptnotes.net where you get all the back episodes and bonus segments like the one we're about to record on the next two to four years in American democracy.
47:34John August: Craig, Meredith, thanks so much. Thank you, John.
47:50Thank you.
Whatever happened to bit parts — the roles in which a character shows up only for one memorable scene? John and Craig discuss why these roles seem to have vanished, particularly in live action, and make a case for bringing them back.
They also cover listener questions, such as when to name your minor character, how to pitch with talent in the room, and what to do when you find out someone has already made your movie… and maybe done it better.
In our bonus segment for premium subscribers, we analyze the current political landscape but with a narrative spin. As midterms come to an end, it seems we're in for a very different storyline this season. John and Craig make predictions for what's to come.
Links:
Download the episode here!
Get your copy of The Scriptnotes Book and become a Scriptnotes Premium member today! For more content on the craft of writing check out Inneresting our weekly-ish newsletter about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters.
Scriptnotes is produced by Meredith Stedman and edited by Matthew Chilelli. Our coordinator is Lauren Loesberg.
Outro by Brian Keffer (send us yours!)
Email us at [email protected]