1. Podcasts
  2. SmartLess
  3. "Colman Domingo"
SmartLess

19 Oct 2026 · 1h 5m · 19 chapters

In short

Smartless cold open and interview with actor/playwright Colman Domingo, centered on embarrassment and scams, how critics vs audiences shape film success, and Domingo’s acting process and career path.

Key claims

Domingo says audience response (including social media) can outweigh critics; he argues art is subjective and should be polarizing; he frames his work as research to find a character’s humanity; he says publicly traded studios often prioritize shareholder-driven business over riskier art.

Guest backgrounds

Colman Domingo is a West Philadelphia–born actor, playwright, and multi-hyphenate (writer/director). He studied journalism at Temple University and began acting after a pivotal acting teacher. He has major screen/TV/stage credits including Birth of a Nation and Michael (as Joe Jackson), plus theater work and writing (e.g., co-writing the Donna Summer musical). Hosts Sean Hayes, Jason Bateman, and Will Arnett discuss scams, documentaries, and film reviews.

Notable examples

“Pardon, Sir” gay chat line story; scam calls and phishing emails; debate over Rotten Tomatoes and the film Birth (Jonathan Glazer, Nicole Kidman); Michael Jackson biopic success (Domingo cites over $1B and highest-grossing biopic); Joe Jackson prep via research and family interviews (including Jermaine Jackson’s son Jafar).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:22

Embarrassing Stories

The hosts share embarrassing moments from their past, including a gay chat line.

“Wait, there was something that I wanted to talk about.”
5:04

Documentaries and Film Criticism

Discussion on documentaries, criticism, and audience reception of films.

“Yeah, I mean, he, these scammers, JB, I mean, they don't, they keep their eye on the prize.”
9:15

Introducing Colman Domingo

The hosts introduce guest Colman Domingo and discuss his career.

“You know, Rotten Tomatoes in Canada is called Rotten Tomatoes.”
14:00

Navigating Public Feedback and Performance

Learn how public reception can impact artists and their work.

“But you have to be careful what you get, right?”
28:34

Colman Domingo's Journey to Broadway

Colman discusses his transition from bartending to a successful theater career.

“What was the first gig where you were able to give up that day job like that, or that gap job of, whether it was bartending or whatever?”
30:28

The Art of Acting and Its Service

Colman shares insights on what acting means to him and its impact on humanity.

“because I've always been a multi-hyphenate.”
32:14

Exploring Dark Characters

Colman discusses the complexity of portraying villains and their humanity.

“Mine's going to be, do you have any funny theater stories?”
34:14

Theater vs. Film: A Creative Journey

Colman contrasts the creative processes of theater and film acting.

“You know, I don't think that people, and that's kind of the beauty of life is, right?”
36:58

Navigating Career Challenges

Colman reflects on his struggles in the film industry and thoughts on leaving.

“I'm going to fuck up the lines for the next like three takes, but I'm going to get there.”
42:01

From Heartbreak to Headshots: A Career Turning Point

Learn about Colman Domingo's journey from considering leaving the industry to finding success through strategic networking.

“So I was doing a lot of work and getting some minimal traction.”
Show all 19 chapters
45:15

The Evolution of Directing: Embracing New Roles

Discover how Colman transitioned from acting to directing, including insights on his experiences and mentor relationships.

“Oh, yeah, because also this new agent, her name was Elizabeth Wiedersheim, and she said, oh, I have an audition for you for something.”
46:50

The Desire to Contribute: A Multi-Hyphenate Mindset

Explore Colman's thoughts on the desire to contribute creatively beyond acting and his approach to collaboration in filmmaking.

“And now you have to guide the audience's perspective and all that stuff and lenses and lighting and all that stuff.”
54:35

Adjusting to Fame: Life After Recognition

Colman reflects on how fame and recognition have impacted his personal life and interactions with others.

“And I think even in the last few years, I've had to make some new agreements in a way.”
56:00

Navigating Fame and Privacy

Colman Domingo discusses the balance between fame and personal privacy.

“And he said, you'll notice that things change and you'll need a little less access.”
58:28

Aging and Letting Go

The hosts and Colman reflect on aging, changes in perspective, and personal growth.

“She's not smart and talented and funny at all.”
1:01:11

The Art of Saying No

They discuss the importance of setting boundaries and learning to say no as one ages.

“For some reason, criticism kind of became kind of this.”
1:02:55

Theater Mishaps and Lessons

Colman shares a humorous story about theater mishaps and the lessons learned from them.

“But when they come over, they could be there for five hours.”
1:05:28

Connecting Through Energy

The conversation shifts to the vibe and energy that influences connections between people.

“But they're like, yeah, what are you going to do?”
1:10:03

Silent Communication and Connections

Explore the nuances of silent communication and personal connections between individuals.

“like immediately just like but it's not they're not giving any any signal or any words beforehand like is there some sort of a silent communication that exists between two beings at times that are match or not match?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On SmartLess, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Everyone knows those red Target bags, but what's inside? That's a different story for everybody. Maybe it's something new you didn't know you needed. Something that makes life a little easier. Or turns an ordinary Tuesday into something to look forward to. Because a Target bag isn't just full of things. It's full of what you need, what you love, and even what you'll love next. This fall, all that's new and uniquely you, it's in the bag. Only at Target. The Hulu Original Series, Phony, is coming to Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus October 20th.

0:34Will Arnett: My name is Sunny Cook. Ever since the accident, my mom looks different.

0:38Sean Hayes: You think your mom has been swapped out with a different woman? I know something, okay? Something's wrong. I don't know what's going on with you, but I know that I'm your mother. If that's not your mom, do you think she is? I don't know, but I need to find her. Watch the Hulu Original Series, Phony, on October 20th. Streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Can we talk about something embarrassing besides the sound of my voice? Imagine you're at lunch. The server brings a Coca-Cola Zero Sugar while the food is still on the way. You think, just a sip while I wait for my chili dog.

1:13So you take that sip, but suddenly you can't stop drinking that delicious ice-cold Coke Zero. The food arrives and you're just sitting there emotionally unprepared, waiting for a life-saving refill. Real Coca-Cola taste with zero sugar? It's hard to resist. Coca-Cola Zero Sugar, too good to wait. Enjoy the delicious taste of Coca-Cola Zero Sugar today.

1:43Hey, guys.

1:44Will Arnett: Welcome to another fresh cold open on Smartless. Oh, is this a fresh one? I'm happy to have you two here, guest starring in a cold open. I'm excited to be here and see you guys. This is really incredible. I've been wanting to get you guys in a cold open for a while. You look just like your pictures, yeah. So what do you guys understand a cold open to be? Do you think it is as— We just want to blast into it and get into the show. Yeah, I know what it is. It's probably short. You don't think it has anything to do with temperature or anything like that? No, I think we're ready to go.

2:14Sean Hayes: No, and I don't think we belabor it in the way that you are. Okay, but anyway.

2:17Will Arnett: All right, so you just want to get into the show then.

2:18Sean Hayes: Yeah, I just want to say, hey, welcome. Welcome to Smartless.

2:21Will Arnett: Oh, okay. Welcome. It's all new Smartless.

2:40Sean Hayes: Wait, there was something that I wanted to talk about.

2:43Will Arnett: What were we talking about the other night at dinner? You wanted to talk about your love for me and for Sean. And go ahead. We're ready to listen. No. No, there's two things. Yeah. You want to talk about the gay chat line. Oh, the gay chat line. And you want to talk about... What was it called? It was Manhole. I looked it up. I looked it up. I thought it was called Manhole. It was called Pardon, Sir. Pardon, Pardon, Sir. Yeah. That's like you're on a crowded subway. So, Sean, tell the story.

3:08Sean Hayes: So, you... It was a crowded subway. Pardon, Sir. Your mom came to you one day. How old were you? You were like 17, maybe. Yeah, 17 or 18 or somewhere around 17, 19. and I would go downstairs to the phone in the basement and I would call like a gay chat line, like a party line, like, hey, what's going on? And I didn't know that it was like, I don't know, back then it was like two bucks a minute or five bucks a minute, I don't know, some crazy kind of money. And I'd talk and talk and talk and my mom came to me with the bill. She's like, are you calling? Now it's called pardon, sir, or whatever it is.

3:38Because she called it and found out what it was. And I was like, oh, I was so embarrassed. I was like, oh, that's just a joke. You weren't out yet. No, uh-uh. I was like, that's just a joke. We were just joking around. Isn't that funny? Oh, no. What's funny about it? Isn't that funny? There's nothing funny about it. Right? Isn't that funny?

3:58Will Arnett: Okay, so that's pardon, sir, Shawnee. Now, what about this manhole? Yeah, exactly. Totally. And I was like, my only comeback was at least I have two eyes. No, I didn't say that. I didn't say that. Oh, no. No, but she was really, and then I, anyway, who cares? It was really embarrassing. I care. I care deeply. And then the other day, like a week ago, Will FaceTimed me. And while I was on my laptop FaceTiming with him, my phone rings. And it's one of those people from another country that asked for, told me like I had a - That sounds racist. What are you talking about? Told me I had like a bill.

4:40Like a phone bank, like a scam. Yeah. Like I had a, I don't know, like an overdue bill or something, they need my information. And so Will, I put on speaker, and Will says, I can see you. I can see you. God is in you. God is in you.

4:57Sean Hayes: And the guy's like, oh, and by the way, the guy was undeterred. He's like, okay, there's no problem. Well, if you can see me, you can see your bill. So let's get to the thing. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, he, these scammers, JB, I mean, they don't, they keep their eye on the prize. It's amazing. I said so much gibberish to him.

5:13Will Arnett: What was the, when you got the, when you looked at your phone of the incoming call, Did it say unknown caller? No, it said the number, and then the curiosity always wins. I was like, who is that? So I always answer it. See, what a count on guys like you.

5:25Sean Hayes: You heard about the cat, right? You heard about the cat with the curiosity? No, what happened? Yeah, it ended up killing him.

5:30Will Arnett: It ended up killing him. What about all the emails? Do you guys get 1 ,000 emails a day that are just phishing with a link? You know, like it looks like an Apple bill or an Amazon bill or something. Yeah, always. Oh, yeah. Do you always hit?

5:44Sean Hayes: Your Amazon bill is just, you know, you click here and adjust it.

5:48Will Arnett: I know, and then your life's over. If you click on that thing, you're hacked. I'm very good about just deleting anything that looks a little sideways. Are you bad at that, Shani? I do that too, but I always make sure I say something funny so they know it's me. Like if I forward it to my tax guy or whatever, I'll be like, hey, this is. I'll say like, you know, I'll do a joke so he knows I'm not forwarding. Did you say you're tax evasion guy? Tax evasion guy.

6:17Sean Hayes: You didn't say tax evasion guy. Tax evasion guy, yeah. Why is he based in the Caymans? Why is he in the Caymans? That's where he lives. I just wanted to have a quick, I said, why is that? What, I was saying documentaries, this is a new thing. Do you guys have, there's so many what they call documentaries out now about people. and then it feels like a lot of them are endorsed by the person and they're part of it. Yes, yes, yes. And half of them feel like just... Puff pieces. Yeah, puff pieces. Like they're glazing themselves like it's to sell them and their brand. Does that feel accurate? So I have people go like, oh, did you see the such and such documentary?

6:57I'm like, I don't know.

6:58Sean Hayes: The term documentary is a bit of a stretch here. It feels like a reel, like a self-promotional reel. Right, yeah. That's interesting. Are you working on that?

7:07Will Arnett: There are some of those. Yeah, but man, the ones that aren't, I'm such a documentary fan. No, there's so many good ones. Yeah, of course. Speaking of films that I love, I saw a film last night that is not a new film, so I'm late to this as it goes. God, this is fun when he does this. Superman? Is it Superman? The film is called Birth, and it's directed by Jonathan Glazer. Oh, my God, yeah, Jonathan Glazer. Oh, it's so good. Nicole Kidman film. Good Lord, is this film good. Really? When did it come out? It's so good. 2004 or something like that. Oh, I got to see that.

7:37Sean Hayes: It was the movie he did right after Sexy Beast. Yeah.

7:40Will Arnett: I mean, I think it moves slowly, but I love stuff like that. Mamma mia, is it good. He is some kind of director. And I looked it up online, didn't make any money, got terrible reviews. And I'm like, well, then my taste is in my ass. In other words, I try to make stuff. And if I turned that in, I would think, oh, my God. You have just like here. You did it. Here comes the rest of your career, pal. Nice work. And then you just get no money, no reviews, no nothing. It doesn't do well at all. What are you supposed to do if you've got taste like that? I guess I'm doing something wrong. No. I don't know.

8:24There's no rhyme or reason to it, I don't think. I really don't. I think the Rotten Tomatoes thing is wild, too. Now, something will get 90 % or 100 % of Rotten Tomatoes, and then I'll see it and be like, I don't think it's that great. or vice versa.

8:36Will Arnett: But at least with that, it's an aggregator. So you're seeing a consensus

8:40Sean Hayes: and this film had a consensus. if it's over 60%. Yeah, but what I'm saying is the critics sometimes kind of get seduced by certain things. I agree. I agree. There were a couple films in the last couple of years where everybody was like bandwagon. They jumped like lemmings. TV shows and films and they all jump on it and it's the water cooler effect, I think.

9:03Will Arnett: I did look at a couple of my favorite critics, though, gave it rave reviews. Like a guy in the New York Times and the New Yorker, like they loved it. And I guess it was just maybe just so many people reviewed it, it brought it down. I don't know. But man, is it good.

9:15Sean Hayes: I think film reviews are pretty tough to, I don't know. I know. You know, Rotten Tomatoes in Canada is called Rotten Tomatoes. Did you guys know that? Is that right? So, is that right, eh? So, speaking of critically acclaimed, that's what our guest today is. Oh, they can answer some questions. They got it right for us. He's accumulated 146 nominations, 46 wins. What? Nominated for two Academy Awards for Best Actor, BAFTAs, Critics' Choice has won an Emmy, got nominated for a bunch of other ones, Golden Globes, Olivier Awards, Screen Actors Guild Awards, you name it. He has an incredible list of screen and television and stage credits, Shawnee, that you're going to get a theater story out of this guy.

10:05Sean Hayes: He's a playwright. He's a performer. You know him from Birth of a Nation. You know him from, he was incredible as Joseph, Joe Jackson in Michael. You know him from Disclosure Day. You know him from the four seasons. Guys, it's Coleman Dunn. Oh, Coleman Dunn. Wait a minute. This is crazy. I was just, oh my God. I was just watching you like on some, oh, I just watched Michael again last night. Oh, sweet. And I was like, I would kill to meet Coleman. I've never met, and here you are. This is crazy. Good to finally move. We passed each other at events and stuff like that, but I've never been up because I get kind of weird in shots.

10:41Sean never stops. He never stops. He's moving. He never stops. You're like, I'm in seat 3A. I got to get to my seat. Right. I'm such a huge, huge fan. I'm a fan of all of you. I am as well. I'm so excited you're here.

10:53Sean Hayes: It's such a thrill to have you here at Colvin. Thank you, guys. Thank you. I also just watched Michael this summer and I was blown away by your performance. Thank you. Thank you, guys. So good. Thank you, guys. I appreciate it.

11:05Will Arnett: I mean, talk about something that does well. I mean, that did incredibly well. I mean, millions and millions of people watch that still today. As you were talking about the Rotten Tomatoes, I was thinking that we got like panned with Rotten Tomatoes. Michael was? Yeah, Michael was panned with Rotten Tomatoes. Oh, no, no. No way. Yet audiences. Because I don't know. I feel like, you know, again, I think people jumped on the bandwagon or they wanted a certain story about Michael Jackson. and so they weren't able to look through the lens of what we were creating. But then the audiences swung the other way.

11:37Yeah, didn't it? Did huge box office, didn't it? Huge. We made over a billion dollars, yeah. No way. Wow. It's the highest grossing biopic ever made and the highest grossing one for Lionsgate. Yeah. That's amazing. And you guys said, hey, screw you critics. We're going to make a sequel. Dude, exactly. That's exactly the... You're like, you know, but also what's beautiful because I feel, listen, all right, I just think that at some point, I think I naturally, maybe I just feel this way because I feel like criticism, you know, especially when it comes to the lens of like people, they want something.

12:12And if you're not delivering that, they're not able to see it through the lens. But in audience, I'd rather just follow someone's, you know, opinion of someone that I respect. You know what I mean? Somebody even on like on Twitter or IG or something like that. Oh, great. I'll go see it because these people liked it and they're talking about it in the comments.

12:27Will Arnett: I think that's the way it's going more and more, right? That sort of social media kind of crowdsourcing opinion, I think, is driving a lot of box office.

12:35Sean Hayes: Yeah, I think it's easy. I mean, I don't want to be the guy who, you know, takes apart critics just because he's been on the short end of bad reviews. As have we all. We all have. Yeah, for sure. But I do think it's really difficult now when I watch. Sometimes I'll see a review or whatever, and then I'll look at the guy and be like, I don't want to watch anything that this guy likes like he and I don't have the same and it kind of goes to what you say Coleman it's more about aligning yourself with people who Jason talk about birth right like you go into these things and you go well yeah there are certain people who aren't going to like it but those aren't the kind of people that you would want to go and do something creative

13:16Will Arnett: with exactly yeah yeah do you read do you read all your stuff Coleman I don't read all of it I like sometimes I feel like I sort of like put myself in a little bubble for a minute but then at some point i want to sort of like pull back the blind and see see what people how they're responding to it you know but i really don't want it to take over the what the feeling i had about making it you know i mean i'm not going to look at it the day after we premiere or something and suddenly like you know yeah but it is sort of like it is it's i've always felt that since we we we we have a public job and we we our product is for the masses uh hopefully it does stand to reason that you would then look at what the public is saying about it.

13:55Will Arnett: How is it being received for the audience you are trying to please? I guess. It's true. It's true. But you have to be careful what you get, right? Because I remember recently I guest hosted Jimmy Kimmel. And I never guest hosted a show like that. So I wanted to know. So I went behind the blinds of Twitter. and I went on there to just see how people were responding to it. And it was overwhelmingly beautiful. But then I got like fixated on this one chick who was like, you know, you're doing too much. You know, just like, calm down. Too much exuberance. And I was like, what do you mean? So I'm sorry, I was mad at her.

14:30But of course, I turned it into part of the monologue the next day. I was like, you know what? Because I'm human. And I wanted to know like how people were responding to it.

14:37Will Arnett: You got to right size it, right? I mean, it's like one person's opinion. It's not indicative of the whole thing. And even if it is everybody's opinion, and how did you feel about what you did and what size should that be in your calculus as to whether it was a positive experience or not? Yeah, but also I feel like art is so subjective as well. I feel like some people should fucking hate it. If you're making some really good art, hopefully it's polarizing in some way and people are like, I'm not sure about what people want. Like even let's say the Michael Jackson film, I wanted to make sure I gave some humanity to Joe Jackson and really made him a bit more complex than I think what anyone would want, what assumed Joe Jackson to be.

15:15And I thought that was my job. But I feel like some people were like, no, I want more of the monster. Or like, oh, why'd you do that? So I'm like, you know, I can't please everybody. All I can do is try to do my best. You're pleasing everybody. You're doing something wrong.

15:25Sean Hayes: Dude, exactly. I loved your portrayal of Joe Jackson. I thought it was so layered. Even those moments where you thought he was going to blow up at Michael, and then he kind of went like, okay. And I thought that was really cool. It was really nuanced. But getting to the, sorry, I just wanted to go back to that idea. If you think, and it just occurs to me, and it was not a new idea, so forgive me. And believe me, I used to read the critics of this podcast early on, and I was reminded how unoriginal my ideas are. But, you know, the idea that back in the day when there used to be, especially when we went through these great periods in show business, in the sort of the 70s, et cetera, in TV and film, where we had a lot of groundbreaking stuff, and there was stuff that just we never heard of and went away.

16:10Sean Hayes: a lot of those things were driven by art, were driven by just trying to do the really cool, interesting, breakthrough, you know, groundbreaking material. And it wasn't driven by marketing and box office and looking at... You would never have a Robert Altman film. You'd never, no, you'd never have any of those films because, you know, now they look at it and they go, the first thing they do is if they're making films, they go to their sales department, their marketing department, they go, can we sell this movie? And then they go to the awards department, exactly. And then they go to the awards department as opposed to, is this movie good?

16:43Sean Hayes: Is this something that, you know, we like? And people, producers, directors, actors, studio chiefs would take a chance on something because everybody agreed that this is something that could be great. Why do you think right now that people are so, I know it's money, but I feel like you can't have a parasite. Or like, you know, what was that? Everything, everywhere, all at once. So like, imagine reading that. It doesn't sound like that movie would make any money or make any sense. It would scare the hell out of you if you were writing the check. But it takes people to say, we're going to take a chance on this because we believe in this good art.

17:13And then it succeeds.

17:14Sean Hayes: It is money. It is money, Coleman. I think that also a lot of these big companies that make the decisions that lend them money or give them money to create these projects, films, TV, whatever, these companies are now big publicly traded companies that have to and their CEO and chairman have to answer to their shareholders. So they're like, hey, I have a fiscal obligation to our shareholders and this doesn't fit that criteria. and it's just... Straight business.

17:41Will Arnett: It doesn't really necessarily work with art. No. Yeah. Speaking of art, speaking of selling something, just real quickly, Willie, I saw the Behemoth trailer two days ago. I think it was two days ago or one day ago. I want to see that. It looks freaking great. I mean, and you actually start the trailer and finish the trailer and it's so exciting to see you up there. Oh, that's so cool. But that movie looks fantastic. Pedro Pascal, Tony Gilroy. Yeah.

18:08Sean Hayes: Pedro's amazing in it. I'll just say, Pedro Pascal is amazing in it. God, he's the best. And Tony, you know, the great Tony Gilroy and Olivia Wilde and Eva Victor are some great people. That's a beautiful cast. I can't wait to see it. Coleman, can I just ask you a couple questions about Joe Jackson? I know you're so sick of talking about it. One question. Just one caller. No problem. Yes, Sean. Sorry. Sorry, Coleman. We're really sorry about Sean. Okay, go ahead. I was just such a huge fan of Michael Jackson growing up. Just massive fan. And what was it like? Like, did you talk to the family? Did you talk?

18:40What was the prep like? Like, and were you petrified? Because he is such a well-known person. I wasn't petrified. He ran the family. You know, the moment I got the offer, I was like, let me see how he lives in me. And then I started to do some research. Because I'm like, I think I know who Joe Jackson was. But he just seemed like a typical villain because his eyebrows were up high and all that stuff. Light blue eyes and crazy looking, dirty girl. And I was like, let me get beyond that and see, do some research. And I really looked at him as sort of, you know, I really looked at him just being a man who was born pre-civil rights and, you know, very modest and really had limited education, limited access, but he had these kids who have talent.

19:20And they really relied on him to, like, push them to become the best. And I thought, well, he gave everything he had. I mean, so let me look through the lens of a father. I'm not going to look at the lens that everyone else sees him as. How does Joe see himself? And then there was one interview that I thought was very interesting. It was one interview and Joe's sitting there and they're like, you know, Michael's talked about his abuse and how he was beat. Or what did he say? And he would vomit whenever you came into the room. And Joe Jackson literally sat back there with a little smile. He said, he said that?

19:50Really? Oh, okay. He said, well, I beat him, but I beat him all the way to the bank. And I was like, oh. Wow. And I thought that was interesting because he said, because, you know, child rearing was different back then. He was like, it was rigor, it was discipline, and I made sure you were the best you could be so you can get out of your circumstance. So for me, that's how I framed Jill Jackson. And then I went to some conversations with, the beautiful thing is Jafar Jackson, who's Jermaine Jackson's son, played Michael. So I had him at such a resource of like, hey, tell me, you know, how was your relationship with your grandpop?

20:23And he said, oh, pop, pop. And there was so much love that, you know, whether he or I talked to Marlon Jackson, a few others, and they always said, they were like, oh, he's a complicated man, but you know, he loved me, and I love my dad. Yeah. And so I wanted to lean into that about what the family, what's behind the closed doors. You know, I saw a video of Joe Jackson Day because they were Jehovah Witnesses, so they didn't have, you know, birthdays or anything, but they had Joe Jackson Day. And it's just a simple video I saw with them sitting around, he and Catherine, and the kids, and the grandkids, and I'm like, oh, they're just a typical family like anybody else.

20:55And I'm sure they have problems like anybody else, and it's a big-ass family. But they're the most successful family, and there would be, honestly, there would be no Michael Jackson or Jackson clan if it wasn't for Joe Jackson. So I feel like I wanted to look at it through Joe's lens, so that's what I did. Yeah, fascinating family.

21:14Will Arnett: Willie, start us at the top. Tell us about Coleman. Where did Coleman come from? Yeah, where are you from? Take us through your research, Will.

21:23Sean Hayes: So Coleman, you're from West Philly. Yes. Born and raised. Is that right? Yeah. Born and raised. One of five kids, is that right? No, four. Four kids? Yeah. Four kids. Sorry. One of four kids, one off. Youngest? Middle boy. I was the youngest for a long time, so they call it the knee baby. So I was like 12 years old before my younger brother was born. So I was the baby. Wait, wait, what's the knee baby? The knee baby is like you got one on the knee and then you have another one. That's hilarious. I never heard that. Yeah. Uh-huh. And you had, you had, you didn't come from a family of performers.

22:01Sean Hayes: Your parents weren't performers. Nothing like that. But you had a, am I right in saying that you had a teacher who encouraged you to pursue acting? There was like a pivotal teacher in your life. Is that true? Yeah. Tell me a little bit about that. I was, I mean, it's probably hard for many people to believe this. But I was very shy. And I had a lot of, you know, whether I had a lisp, I was not cool. I was, you know, from, you know, lower middle class family. I was wearing my older brother and older sister's hand-me-down clothes. So by the time I go to college, I just wanted to be something else.

22:27So I actually took an acting class as an elective. And because my mother said, take something and get you outside of yourself. You know, I know she knew me to be a bit more funnier and have a bit more personality, but I didn't show it outside. So I took this one class. I was teacher Chris. It was just acting 101 at Temple University when I was studying journalism. Another career where I thought, like, I was just going to be a newspaper writer and stay behind the scenes.

22:51Sean Hayes: You just be on your own and you can be quiet. Be in a dark room, exactly, and nobody bother me. But then I took this class and he said, he put me aside one day. He said, hey, have you ever thought about acting as a profession? And I said, I don't even know what you're talking about. Like, what is that? What is acting as a profession? As the first kid in my family to go to college, I was supposed to go out and get a job and a job with benefits. You know what I mean? It was no like the idea of me being an artist didn't even make sense. So he said, I'd be very curious if you did. Because he said, I think you have a gift.

23:23And I said, oh. He said, I think you have a gift. And I'd be very curious if you pursued that gift. Oh, yeah. So it was like a mic drop. And I was like, and I didn't know until some friends of mine told me I'm at, what, Enneagram 8, which is the challenger. You know, I like to be, I like a challenge. So that was like a challenge. Like, I'd be curious. I'm like, I like that challenge. So I started taking some theater classes off campus from Temple University because I sort of kept it as my little secret. I would take acting classes, like breathing exercises and laying on the floor, filling myself up with orange juice and shit like that.

23:56All this wonderful stuff, and I loved being in the theater. I was like, wow, this is what I want to do. I want to be in the theater. So I was a theater rat for most of my career, you know? And that was very fulfilling, you know?

24:05Sean Hayes: And you, yeah, and you were like, is it true that I read somewhere that you were working in the theater, but you also had other jobs going on. I always had hustles, yeah. You talked about taking your final bow and 15 minutes later, you were serving drinks. Oh, yeah. I worked at Manhattan Class Company in New York City, a beautiful off-Broadway theater. I literally would bow. I did this show with John Randall called Bright Ideas. I'll never forget it. It was one of my first off-Broadway shows. And I took a bow, got up, and I had it timed. I would get up, rip off my costumes, which I'm sure cost thousands of dollars, you know, call a cab, get over to the 55 bar in the West Village.

24:47And suddenly within 15 minutes, because I was like, I have to be late for my shift by 15 minutes because the show started at 730. We were done at like 859, got over there. Next thing you know, I was like, hi, what can I get you? I literally walked in the door and went straight to the bar because I needed the hustle. So I was, off-Broadway, I was getting paid like$350 a week. And then like I needed to live in New York. I was like, I had to have that job. Sure. We'll be right back. Looking for a new mattress? You know where we're going to go with this. With over 20 mattress models to choose from, Helix is the perfect upgrade.

25:25Helix custom builds your mattress based on your sleep needs. Just take the two-minute Helix sleep quiz to find your best fit. Plus, Helix delivers your mattress right to your door with free shipping in the U.S. Rest easy with seamless returns and exchanges and a 365-night sleep trial. And you're in good hands knowing Helix mattresses have been tested and reviewed by experts like Forbes and Wired. You know I've been talking about it for years. My Dusk Lux, it's awesome. Might be hard to say, but it's not hard to sleep on. Go to helixsleep.com slash smartlist for 20 % off-site wide. That's helixsleep.com slash smartless for 20 % off-site wide.

26:07helixsleep.com slash smartless.

26:13Let's talk about the Idaho effect. It's a feeling you get hiking the Sawtooth Mountains at sunrise or mountain biking on hero dirt at Silver Mountain Resort, leaving you craving more. It's a feeling where the freedom to roam is real. And it's found in Idaho. Idaho might just be the last authentic place in the West. Once you have this feeling, one that stays with you long after returning home, that's the Idaho effect. Plan your Idaho vacation at visitidaho.org.

26:53Sonos is a sound system engineered to make you feel. You know how you can walk into a room and it just has a certain mood? the right music can completely change that. You put on a song, everyone knows, and suddenly people are hanging out, singing along, maybe dancing around a little bit. It just changes the energy. And with Sonos throughout the house, you can keep that going from room to room. The music basically moves through the house with you. I've had Sonos for years and years and years, and I pump it through the house when I'm getting ready to go out, when we're having people over for dinner, and it's really, really terrific.

27:28And when I want to, I just lift it up off the bass and take it outside. You can actually move it outside. And it's so cool. It makes outside just as great listening as inside. So whether you're trying to wind down, get some energy going, have people over, whatever it is, Sonos helps set the mood. Love the sound. Feel the system. Visit Sonos.com to build your system.

27:53Can we talk about something embarrassing besides the sound of my voice? Imagine you're at lunch. The server brings a Coca-Cola Zero Sugar while the food is still on the way. You think, just a sip while I wait for my chili dog. So you take that sip, but suddenly you can't stop drinking that delicious ice-cold Coke Zero. The food arrives and you're just sitting there emotionally unprepared, waiting for a life-saving refill. Real Coca-Cola taste with Zero Sugar? It's hard to resist. Coca-Cola Zero Sugar. Too good to wait. Enjoy the delicious taste of Coca-Cola Zero Sugar today.

28:34Will Arnett: And now, back to the show.

28:37Sean Hayes: What was the first gig where you were able to give up that day job like that, or that gap job of, whether it was bartending or whatever? Do you remember? For a long time, when I tell you, for a long time, because I think I was always afraid of being broke, I always kept a bartending job. Even when I was on Broadway, I would still have like, oh, no way. Dude, I was on Broadway and passing Strange and still like, you know, on a Monday night, I'm like, I'll pick up for that shift. Because I was afraid it wasn't going to last. I was always, it was that roller coaster. And, you know, like, let me just ride this out.

29:11But it was for a long, I would say from like 20 years of my career. And I've been doing this now for what, 35, 36 years. And I think I just stopped having a side job. I think

29:22Sean Hayes: but I mean but like but you mentioned that Passing Strange you're like right after this podcast I gotta go pick up a shift you guys I don't know if it's gonna last but Passing Strange it's funny you mentioned Passing Strange that was filmed by Spike Lee am I right about that? yeah absolutely yeah but literally when that show closed I went back to bartending that's amazing wow my career was always these highs has been these highs and lows where I was always doing these shows that were in my theater career I was doing these shows that had no intention of going to Broadway. Like I did, Sean, I did a show called Scottsboro Boys at the Vineyard Theater with Susan Stroman, the final collaboration between Kander and Ev.

30:01That started out, you know, we went to Off-Broadway at the Vineyard Theater, we went to the Guthrie. It really is these really weird pieces of theater that somehow end up in the commercial space. So then I kept, really, I was just going to be an avant-garde actor and then like get a rent-stabilized apartment, and that was fine for me. And then my career started to do other things. But you were doing it, and you're going all over the place.

30:22Sean Hayes: You were in Australia, you were in the UK. You were really, really doing it in the theater. Yeah, and also, I mean, that's the thing too, because I've always been a multi-hyphenate. I've always been a writer, a playwright. I write musicals, I write plays, I direct. Didn't you write? I co-wrote the Donna Summer musical. The Donna Summer musical. Yeah, I co-wrote the Donna Summer musical in Broadway. Yeah, that's crazy. I co-wrote a show about Nat King Cole that was at the New York Theatre Workshop last year. So it's like, people always know that even still, you can knock on my trailer door and people are like, what are you doing?

30:54I'm like, oh, writing a play or a screenplay. It's just like, I feel like those are my hobbies. Jason, you know what Jason's doing?

31:00Sean Hayes: He's watching TV. What's Jason doing? Jason, what are you doing? He's watching TV.

31:04Will Arnett: No, my brain, I was telling you that, no, that's too, that's a shitty question. No, that's a shitty question. So I'm just going to ask. Ask the shittiest question, though. I know. Start there. Let's lean in. I'm just so taken with your talent, Coleman. I always have been. Me too. And that's why I was so curious as to how it got started in you. And I'm always interested in this because I started before I even knew who I was. I started when I was such a young kid. This whole notion of pretending to be somebody different was a different thing for me. And to hear that you started at such an older age when you knew who you were, what is it about acting that you really like?

31:49Will Arnett: I mean, can you tap into like where you go when you pretend to be somebody else? Is it about exploring different sides of yourself and people just get to watch that? Or are you conscious of the audience that is receiving this show and you're performing for them? Does that make sense?

32:09Sean Hayes: Yeah. By the way, that's a really good question. That's a great question. It's not a shitty question at all. Yeah. But you know what? To try to answer that. Mine's going to be, do you have any funny theater stories? We know, we know. Sean, we know. Anything with Tyne Daily. We're trying to hold that off. Anything with Tyne Daily, Coleman? Anything? Oh, my God. I'd give anything for a Tyne Daily story. Sean was waiting for the question. But you know, I think that, honestly, I feel like, listen, and I don't want to get too sort of erudite about it, but I do think that acting is a bit of a service job.

32:42It is. But yet it's incredibly wonderful to feel like I'm very curious about other people. And I think it's also going back to my journalistic roots of like me wanting to be a journalist. I'm like, I want to find out why people do what they do. And if I can actually now embody it and become that person and do research. Like I've played horrible people. And, you know, I'm sure we all have. I've played Mist in the Color Purple or, you know, Pimp in Zola. Somebody who sex traffics women. I'm like, that's totally the opposite of me. and being such a feminist. But for me, if I find something in them and I'm like, I want to find their humanity in there.

33:17Will Arnett: Right. And it almost makes you feel closer to people, I guess, maybe. It makes me feel like, I'll be very honest, I feel like there's nothing that, I'm not somebody who truly believes in cancel culture because I always feel like there's a path and if we look into the humanity and we really find our commonalities in some way, I feel like it's something about trying to become more human and kinder. I mean, also, when you play dark characters like that, or villains or whatever you want to call them, they don't think they're villains or horrible people. No, not at all. They feel justified. Absolutely.

33:52Will Arnett: And it's really interesting finding that part of the character that showed the audience that, oh my God, look at that look in their eyes. They think they're not doing anything wrong. Absolutely. That's a fascinating discovery of the audience. Isn't it? I like to lean into people who are so different than my own experience. and I feel like that brings me some joy in some way. If I can tap into that, I think that's a win.

34:13Sean Hayes: Well, you're talking about, like, you're also talking about nuance too. Like it's sort of like a joy of nuance. There's such a loss of nuance now. You know, I don't think that people, and that's kind of the beauty of life is, right? It's like, what are the things that make us there? Like, why are, you could, like, as you said with Joe Jacks, like you could look at him in a binary way. You could go, he did X, Y, and Z and then he was, but no, but why? There was a thing and he had, in his mind, he believed it. That's kind of interesting. Exactly. You don't have to agree with it, but it's interesting.

34:41Because I love all the questions around it because I feel like I think, listen, I can say it to you guys. I respect you guys so much and I've seen all of your work. And I feel like part of this work that I love so much is the research and the detailing and finding the nuances and finding out what makes them tick and where they live in your body, you know, where they live in your soul in some way, shape, or form. I think that's, it's incredibly selfish in a way too. I feel like that's for me. I want to unpack all that good stuff, you know?

35:05Will Arnett: The difference between your process and doing a character on stage over a period of months versus doing a film or a series or something like that where you're doing that one scene that day and you'll never do it again affects sort of your ability to kind of like dig down and play different parts of that character. Do you enjoy the theater process more just because you get more time with that character in those situations? You know what's interesting to me? I like the idea, because I'm still such a theater actor, that the moment I'm cast, I go into research and development. Really. Sean, you probably agree with this too.

35:45Literally, I can take myself through a 40-hour rehearsal week for myself before I get to set. If I know the work that I have to get done, I'm like, let me get into the gym and work this stuff out, put on my headphones, whatever. So when I'm on set, I'm loose. I can go anywhere with it. For me, that's what I enjoy. I don't like showing up and just say, thinking that this is going to be the moment. I'm like, no, I've already played it. Do you memorize the whole thing before day one? I memorize at least 90%. For me, that's a trick for me to feel like it's always still very new. But also, I'm a person like, even when we go to set to rehearse the scene, I have the script in my hand.

36:22People who don't have the script in their hand, I'm like, I feel like I need it to still feel like it's... It makes me nervous when they don't have their script. It makes me nervous. Because it feels like they already have a way they're going to do it. and for me I'm still trying to figure this shit out I don't know what Sean or Jason or Will's going to say or do I don't know how I'm going to do it until I see what you're doing exactly, I'm going to respond but I've done my work so I've been in the gym working it out so now I can be available and so for me that's what feels good and I like the idea of not being it's funny I had to talk about this with a colleague of mine a couple weeks ago I think work should be imperfect I strive for the imperfections in my work and so I feel like maybe that's why I feel like when I go to set and the thing that annoys me the most is when like you're walking through the scene and then suddenly the script supervisor, like she's like, oh, you know, the line is, you know, it's fine.

37:14I'm going to fuck up the lines for the next like three takes, but I'm going to get there. It's going to be different on the next take too. But I'm going to get there. I'm going to get there because I have an esteem for my work, but I feel like I need to be raw and loose and I'm trying to figure out how this prop works or whatever. So my brain is going all over the place. So you said perfection in your work. Does that spill over in your personal life? Oh, yeah. Imperfection? Yes, absolutely. But also, it was funny because I think, listen, I literally, I don't know, why am I telling you guys this?

37:41But I guess I— It's just us. You made me have a show. It's just us. We're going to record in a minute. Thousands of people, exactly. But, you know, it's funny because I think that I realized that I had something dental possibly happen to my teeth because I was wearing some fake fronts when I played by Rustin in Rustin. And I think it sort of like made my tooth a little go in. And every time I see it now, because I'm like, I don't remember that. Has it gotten like that now? Like, what the fuck? So I look in movies and TV and I'm like, what the fuck is going on with my tooth? And now I'm just like, but then I'm just like, maybe that's all right.

38:13I'm like, should I get it fixed? But then I'm like, no, it's okay. My face is supposed to change, I think.

38:18Sean Hayes: Right. You know what, Coleman, it's so funny you say that. I went to my dentist a couple years ago and he goes, you know what? Your bottom tooth is kind of in a little bit and I'm going to get you in the Invisalign. and I kind of like let him, I was in the chair, I'm just doing a cleaning and I was like, okay. And I said, yeah, and they did the thing and I got the Invisalign, I started doing it after a couple days and then I realized and then I go, I call him up, I go, I'm done, I'm not doing it. He goes, well, you're going to fit and I go, I don't care. I'm not a tooth model. Yeah, right. I don't give a shit.

38:45Yeah, and maybe that's the thing too because I think everybody feels like everyone should be perfect and I feel like, maybe that's, you know, I feel like,

38:58Sean Hayes: Lots of lines in my face. Jason, no comment.

39:02Will Arnett: I always say it's a privilege to get older. You want to be the most wrinkled person in the world because that means you've lived a long time. The only way to avoid getting older is to die. So anyone complaining about getting old is like, I mean, talk about a binary choice. You're either getting older or you die. Like, which do you want? Right, right, right. And we can get older in the best way. We can take care of ourselves and what we have and all that shit. But I feel like the idea of vanity, I feel like I don't want to have the vanity that's outside of myself. Distracting. Yeah, exactly. I look at myself, I'm like, not too bad for 56.

39:41I'm doing all right. There you go. Yeah, same. I'm 56 as well. Don't you feel?

39:45Sean Hayes: Yeah, and you know what I realized the other day? I was like, these are laugh lines. This means that I laugh a lot. Man, am I lucky. I get to live my life laughing around. Jason, Jason, Jason. Jason's looking at plastic surgery for you right now as we speak. No, but just like a light laser. I just did a light laser. Just a light laser. Just get that. Right, a real light. Hey, you know, Coleman, I wanted to ask you about, it's funny. So you did all this stuff. I mean, you've done so many, your credits are insane. And, you know, all this theater and film and television. And then there was that period you did Selma and you did The Butler.

40:24Sean Hayes: And I read somewhere that you said after that that for a minute you felt like there wasn't as much work coming your way in film and TV that you wanted. And you almost thought of like giving up on film and TV. Is that true? Yeah. And then you went right into The Fear of the Walking Dead. Is that right about that timeline? Well, the wild thing is I was booking a lot of these sort of like, you know, small roles in big films. like whether with Steven Spielberg or Lee Daniels or Ava DuVernay or Steven Soderbergh, you name it. But they were looking at me from being a theater actor in New York. I was booking this stuff when I would go in and sign in.

40:57You know, to go and sign in, I had the most boutique agent that no one ever knew about up against CAA and WME and all that other stuff. And so I felt like I was rare. I was getting in there because of my theater work. And so I would go and get these smaller roles and everything. And it was fulfilling enough. But then after I was, when I was entering my mid-40s, I was about 44 years old. And I went to London on the West End and did Scottsboro Boys, came back. And I was getting these auditions, like, you know, under five. And I was like, this doesn't make any sense. And I was, like, living in Manhattan Plaza in New York City, you know, rent-stabilized apartment.

41:33Oh, classic. And I was like, you know, I was making it as an artist. But I just thought, like, man, I think, you know, I have friends who are doctors and lawyers and they have 401Ks and shit. And I was like, I'm still living like a teenager. I'm like, maybe I need to do something else. And then I had a succession of auditions that felt like they were going nowhere. And they were breaking me, breaking me, breaking me. And then, of course, that was back when they had a pilot season. So, of course, there's months where they say, you're not supposed to go anywhere. I would just defy that shit. I'm like, I'm going to go fucking Australia and do my solo show.

42:00Fuck that. So I would go into these meetings. So I was doing a lot of work and getting some minimal traction. And then I just tried to make a stronger decision. But this decision was because after some heartbreak too. I think I was just, I felt after a while I was getting disrespected from the auditions that I was, the things that I was being offered or being part of or not be a part of. And I was like, I just want to get off of it. And I feel like I just wanted to stop before I was brokenhearted about the thing that I love the most. And you would have gone just primarily exclusively to theater.

42:37No, I was actually going to leave the industry, period. You were? I had a side hustle as a headshot photographer Really? I was making money I was doing everybody's headshots

42:49Will Arnett: Wait a second, are people still getting headshots taken? Maybe, I don't know Probably not the four of us But yeah, dude, I would do headshots I would make like 300 bucks here 300 bucks here I was doing everybody's headshots in New York So you'd show up with your camera and a tripod and a roll of seamless? Yeah, absolutely or they would come with you. Wait, what's scene? The backdrop. The backdrop. Yeah, exactly. Dude, I would set it up in my apartment and people would come over and I would do their headshots. I fucking love it. Dude, and so I was going to have a headshot business and just like stay with that because it was lucrative.

43:24I felt artistically fulfilled. It's a great way to meet people. Yeah, and also I felt like, again, I didn't want to be so downhearted about this industry because I loved it so much. So I was ready to leave it. So glad we didn't lose you.

43:35Will Arnett: Oh, thanks. But then like you're saying, But then, like, I had to do some strategic things. Like, as I was leaving this industry, one of my dearest friends, Daniel Breaker, he said, hey, you know, my managers have been wanting to meet with you for a long time. And I was like, nah, I'm good. I just let go of my manager. I'm letting go of my agent next week. He said, just meet with them. And I went in there, and I was not my most effervescent self. I really sat there, arms folded, and just like, they were like, oh, so tell us about you. I'm like, well, this is what I do. I do this, this, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

44:05But it was a bad, bad meeting for me. And they were like, well, we'd love to take you on. I said, all right, let's see. Let's see if we can give it six months and see what happens. And literally, they said, first thing we have to do, we have to change your agent. And so I was, my literary agent was at Gersh. And then eventually they moved me over to Gersh. And I went for my first couple auditions because I knew, this is what I knew. I knew that my auditions weren't being seen. I knew I really knew how to do a good self-tape. but I had no access or agency. So literally within a month, I booked Fear the Walking Dead and Baz Luhrmann's The Get Down.

44:44So two series leads. I had to choose. I had to make a Sophie's Choice and I chose the thing that was the weirdest thing because that's me. I chose Fear the Walking Dead. I'm like, what is that? I didn't know about The Walking Dead or anything but I was like, I feel like I want to go on that road to figure out this character. The character was written, he was written like Richard III, his first monologue and I was like, oh, this is interesting. And then I went on to do that show for eight seasons and I was the longest running character on there.

45:11Sean Hayes: And directing too, JC. Oh, then I directed it and produced it, yeah.

45:14Will Arnett: The new agent pushed those auditions through and got them seen. Oh, yeah, because also this new agent, her name was Elizabeth Wiedersheim, and she said, oh, I have an audition for you for something. It's a Walking Dead franchise. And I was like, I don't even know what that is. Again, I was a bit more, a bit of a snob, to be honest, when it comes to television work because I didn't think at the time they were writing, at least for this face, very complex roles, you know, forward and forward. So I usually, I mean, my experience with television up to then was being, you know, auditioning for every episode of like Nash Bridges or something playing a character called Too Cool Whipped Tyrell.

45:48Sure. You know what I mean? So I just like, I gave up on that. I'm like, nah, they're not writing for me. I think I can do better work in the theater, you know? Right, I get it. So then you started directing Fear of the Walking Dead, yeah? Is that what you said? I started directing and producing. That's amazing. But listen, you know why? Because I'm someone like, because I think maybe it's the way I was built. It's like I walk into a room, I can't just be an actor. I've got to figure out how we're doing this whole thing. How are we making it? And so that came from Gayle Ann Hurd. She came and saw, on a hiatus, I was directing a production of Robert O 'Hara's Barbecue at the Geffen Playhouse.

46:23And I invited my executive producer, Gayle Ann Hurd, to come and see it. And she says, have you ever thought about directing TV? And I was like, no, not really. And she says, I think you, again, someone else says it to me. I think you may have a skill set for that. And so I was curious about it. So I started shadowing on my own show for the next year. And then they gave me my first episodes to direct. And how did you like it? Was it comfortable? I loved it. I think you love it too, don't you? Because you're a beautiful director, man. I love it so much.

46:49Will Arnett: So you'd been directing in the theater, but now you've got a camera. Yeah. And now you have to guide the audience's perspective and all that stuff and lenses and lighting and all that stuff. Did you have a good partner? I did. Cinematically? Cinematically, I did. Andrew Bernstein, who's a beautiful television director. Oh, my God, I love Andrew. Isn't Andrew wonderful? He really was my mentor in many ways. Isn't he a sweet man? He's a sweetheart and so talented. And so I was just working with these guys who were willing to give me any amount of information. Talk about lenses, talk about lighting, talk about you name it.

47:21How to tell the story, how to prep. And I just soaked it all in, man. And then it just felt right and natural. But also what I love about, maybe this is what I love because I direct on my show now on Four Seasons. What I love is being sort of the cheerleader for all these smart people. And coming up with a vision and saying we're going to get behind this. I like the idea of trying to make a day. I love being up again. You're back against the wall. You know what I mean? But I love the enthusiasm and the encouragement to make something open. Have you ever wanted to develop or create something for yourself or have you?

47:53And I just don't know. I have. I have. I've been, yes. And it's funny, we're developing something now for Netflix, a show called Headlands House. And so that's for me. Okay, good. Are you going to direct that too? Probably. It's funny. They asked me about that, but I feel like it's a central character. And I feel like I like the idea of sometimes laying back, letting another creative come in here. I don't want to do everything at times, you know, unless I really feel it. I didn't really. I don't know if I have a handle on this.

48:20Sean Hayes: Yeah, Jason, he doesn't feel the need to control everybody all the time, Jason. God. But what would you say about directing yourself?

48:31Will Arnett: Do you find it complicated or do you find the opposite? Do you find that it's efficient in that that actor's kind of reading your mind? It's efficient. Yeah, it's efficient. And I also know how to, I feel like, you probably know this as well too, because I feel like I really know how to prep well. And then also I'm okay with also, you know, I will have my handheld monitor, take a look at that. I can judge my own performance, but also I don't mind listening to my EPs and just like anything else you need and the writers, whatever. So I'm collaborative in that way. And I know how to, if something even happened in the scene, I can be fully present in the scene and then suddenly, okay, we're going to do a pickup and like, hey, try this here, blah, blah, blah, whatever.

49:04I'm going to do this, boom. And then we go again. You know? Yeah. No. I love it. That's great. That's it. But don't you do the same thing, Jason? How do you feel about it? Oh, I can't.

49:11Will Arnett: I cannot get enough of it. Yeah. It's just. It's a high. Yeah. And I don't know. I mean, yeah. But like, thank God, you know, that, you know, speak for the four of us here that we're at a point in our careers. thank God, that our ambition is matched with our access. You were speaking earlier about all the talented friends that you have and maybe are without access like you were at one point. My heart breaks for those people. There's so many people that are incredibly talented, far more talented than some that are enjoying success, that just simply can't get in the door. They can't get their tape seen.

49:49Sean Hayes: Well, think about it. Yeah. Think about Coleman, how long You just described how long it took. You were in your 40s. You were doing, you built all this. I was thinking about, you built this incredible career. You have this incredible CV of all these different roles and various things in film and TV and stage. And then you do Euphoria. And for whatever reason, because that show is just such a part of the sort of culturally part of the fabric right now. That show is so popular. And it feels like that was the show was like kind of you're coming out to a broader audience and everybody's like, Coleman Domingo's amazing and you win the Emmy and all this sort of stuff and you're like, hey man, I've been building this shit for 25 years.

50:30Exactly. Right, a little bit? Overnight success, yeah. It kind of feels that way, but also it took like, for me it took people like Sam Levinson, and I wonder if you guys agree here, it took someone who wrote, he wrote the triple axel for me. He wrote something where he thought, oh, Coleman can deliver this. not something that like oh like he wrote it for me which is beautiful so he knew the things I could do and he also knew the things that probably scared me and I wondered if I could do but he believes in me that's what feels good and I feel like the things that I started to get more recognition for I've really been under the hood with whether it's the film Rustin or something like that I've actually been able to do the thing that I knew I'd do best I've never been I would always say this and I wonder if you guys agree for yourselves because you're all multi-hyphenates.

51:20I never thought that, like, I'm not that great to just be the actor that's hired to just, like, come hit the marks and leave. I'm like, I want to know how are we making it. You want to contribute. Yeah, I want to contribute. How are we making this? You want to leave. Exactly. I show up to, you know, sometimes I'll show up to set and just I want to see how things are made. I want to watch how we're doing that scene. I want to know how my engine will work with that as well. But also I'm just curious about the whole process, you know?

51:44Will Arnett: Yeah, which makes you a better soldier, right? Right? I mean, if you know what's going on in all the departments, yeah, you can figure out how to maybe fill in the margins a little bit when appropriate. Absolutely. Absolutely. That feels good. We'll be right back. Learning to invest is kind of like learning to drive. Putting your teen's hands on the wheel is the best way for them to learn. With a Fidelity Youth account, your teen can make their own trades while you supervise as needed. It's the only brokerage account a teen can own independently, and investing 101 lessons are built into the app.

52:23Will Arnett: Learn more at fidelity.com slash youth. Investing involves risk, including risk of loss. Fidelity Brokerage Services, LLC, member NYSE SIPC.

52:38Being safer on the road starts with the person behind the wheel. That's Mazda's philosophy when designing every vehicle. Their proactive safety features help keep you more aware, connected, and engaged during every drive, which means your car does more than help protect you. It helps make you a safer driver, which helps protect everyone. That's why Mazda has been named Consumer Reports' safest new car brand. To learn more, visit mazdausa.com. Consumer Reports does not endorse products or services.

53:20This is a paid ad by BetterHelp. Guys, mental health awareness initiatives are really important, like World Mental Health Day. But you shouldn't wait to focus on your mental health until a certain date on the calendar, right? So for some people, therapy can be one way to support their mental well-being. Remember, therapy isn't just for the big life choices either. It can be a place to talk about relationship problems, work issues, or simply the sense that something feels off. With over 30 ,000 therapists worldwide, BetterHelp is one of the leading online therapy platforms, having served millions of people globally.

53:56BetterHelp therapists have at least three years and a thousand hours of hands-on experience. Plus, BetterHelp makes it easy to fit therapy into your routine with flexible ways to connect that work for different schedules and lifestyles. Your mental health doesn't need a special occasion or anyone else's permission to matter. BetterHelp can connect you with a therapist who gets you so you can make space for what matters to you. Visit BetterHelp.com slash SmartList to explore your payment options. That's BetterHelp.com slash SmartList.

54:33And back to the show.

54:36Will Arnett: it sounds you know you're saying before you you spent so long living like a teenager when um when stuff really started to change for you how did you were you comfortable with the integration of a different a different rhythm of life both both in in time and also in in luxury and in travel and in um and and and and and privacy and and all those things how is how How is success wearing on you? That's a great question. And I think even in the last few years, I've had to make some new agreements in a way. Yeah. One was, even where I live now, I live in this gated community in Malibu, and I didn't know I needed it.

55:20I went to actually Denzel Washington's house. He was renting a house out in Malibu, and it was after I was nominated for Rustin. And he said, hey, so we were hanging out for like three hours. And he says, I said, well, I got to get back to, I was living in Downey, this little suburban town. Yeah. And lovely. Far away. Yeah, exactly. Southeast LA. And I loved it. And I lived there for like eight years while I've been on shows and stuff like that. Yeah. And I said, oh, I'm heading back home. He said, where do you live? I said, I live in Downey. He said, what's that? I said, oh, it's a little southeast suburb.

55:51He's like, hmm. You been there for a while? I was like, yeah. He said, you have a gate? I was like, yeah, I have a gate. He says, you know you're going to have to move, right? And I said, why? And he said, you'll notice that things change and you'll need a little less access. And you have to figure, you have to navigate that for yourself, how you have access. And he was right because things started to change where I realized I needed more privacy to just be. And for me, where I live now, I really just get to be and just be a person and not be an actor or anything. The question that I still navigate whenever I see somebody out in the world, they're like, hey, what are you up to?

56:29I'm like, oh, I'm just going for a walk here, but they want to know your CV, what you're up to. I'm like, no, that's actually not me all day long. You know what I mean? Right, right, right. And I feel like it is, I've learned because I think because it's happened later for me. First of all, I'm extremely grateful and I'm so happy that when people see me, I know I get something that a lot of people don't. People want to hug me all the time. People want to, oh my God, could I have a hug? And really, my colleagues are like, wow, people want to hug you. Whatever that is that I give off, I feel like I'm very grateful for that, that people want to connect like that.

57:07Well, you're not an asshole. No, no. No, no. You know, I try every day to be a good person, you know what I mean?

57:13Sean Hayes: And your characters, you've had such a run of enormously emotionally demanding performances that you've delivered just with aplomb, shall I say. and yeah and and i think that that probably translate i think that that probably speaks to i'm asking more uh are these the kind of things that you look for now that you because it seems to me talking to you that you're a person who is looking for that kind of emotional connection constantly i i am i think that's maybe that's it that all makes sense to me i feel like i can even you know we we start getting to these ages where sometimes you get like sort of retrospective of your work that you're supposed to talk about and you're like oh my god i can now see the thread that i'm interested in being deeply human and being connecting with other people and i feel like that that's in everything that i do i feel like the blessing is i was able to now doing the show four seasons that makes me feel like there's a bit more of a light-hearted humor and i don't have to sort of carry the weight because i know that i'm sure we all we go deep when we go like into a deeper expression of human pain or anxiety.

58:21And I feel like I've been doing that for so long that I need to just wear a cute sweater and give witty banter. Yeah.

58:28Sean Hayes: But then you've got Tina Fey. You've got Tina Fey. You're awful, but Tina. Isn't she horrible? She's horrible. Tina Fey. She's not smart and talented and funny at all. Will Forge. And Will Forge. Don't even say that. All these people are just...

58:46Will Arnett: What about that original Four Seasons, the film, is one of my favorite, favorite movies. I love that. Okay, you and I, okay, you, me, you, all of us, Tina Fey, we were like, what, 10 watching that movie? Yeah, watched it a lot. Why were we watching that movie when we were that age? Because I think Cable had just kind of gotten started, and it was one of those films that was in a rotation. It was a prison or something. Uh-huh, okay. Yeah, and I just, and then all the, you know, the Vivaldi all the way through it, obviously. I was just like mesmerized. But we were kids watching, I guess, watching a show about like our parents or something?

59:16There's a lot of those, like Ordinary People we watched. Yeah, I watched that all the time.

59:21Will Arnett: Alan Alda and Jack, was it Jack Weston, right? Jack Weston, exactly. Yeah, and I just love that. Rita Moreno. Coleman.

59:30Sean Hayes: Go ahead, Sean, I was going to say go ahead, but do you mind if I just ask this? It occurs to me as you sort of talk about this and being of a certain age, we're all of a certain age here in our mid to late 50s, shall we say. All of us could play late 40s, by the way. Oh, without a doubt. Max. With good lighting? You see, I was adjusting this. With good lighting? In the beginning, I was adjusting this like crazy. I was like, let me get this. With a bounce? With a bounce card under here, you know? And I might have, Jason, you might have to Hollywood it underneath. Oh, yeah, you just fly it in there, sure.

1:00:03Sean Hayes: But is there anything, like, in your life? Like, I've been going through this thing being now, being 56. There's so many just kind of things that I've laid down that I've just stopped, that I've sort of, like it's taken me a long time to kind of get there. And I was wondering, have you guys been noticing that, that you're just like... Stripping stuff away? Letting go of things. Shit that you don't do anymore. Yeah, for sure. Like I'm way less judgmental than I was two years ago. I'll go for it. Way less judgmental than I was two years ago. And I see it so much and I'll be in a conversation with somebody, I'll go, does it need to be said?

1:00:37Sean Hayes: Does it need to be said right now? how does it need to be said by me? Like, I just kind of let it go. Yeah. Because you don't have to comment on everything either. You're just like, okay, cool. Is that the way you feel? Yeah. Cool, great. Do you guys feel that way? Yes.

1:00:48Will Arnett: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I do find, Willie, building on yours, I found that I'm trying to be less judgmental in a way of just, it's sort of a lazy crutch for conversation. You know, like, I rarely, I'm really sincere about my judgment, and it's more about like, oh, well, let's just bond, kind of like fucking dragging this person and talking shit about this film or this. For some reason, criticism kind of became kind of this.

1:01:18Sean Hayes: The great igniter, yeah. Or gossip, like gossip.

1:01:21Will Arnett: Yeah, exactly, another term for it, exactly. Just as like, well, you feel like you're getting closer with that other person or you're signaling to that other person, hey, it's just between you and me or we're getting closer. And it's kind of a, you know, it's lazy. to be honest.

1:01:38Sean Hayes: And you feel shitty. Yeah, yeah.

1:01:41Will Arnett: When you don't even believe it and you don't mean it, it's just like, well, instead of coming up with something that could bond you that's a little bit more positive on a different subject, I'm now reaching for that. Let me tell you guys something. A few years ago, I was walking around with this older woman and she said, well, how old are you? I said, at the time I was like 52 or something. She says, oh, okay, you're in your storytelling season. I said, what's next? She says, right now it's important for you to tell a story, tell a story about yourself that last year until you're 50s and so when you hit your mid 50s to early 60s you move into your truth telling season I was like what's that she says if you don't want to do something you just say no I said wait just no I said no qualifier she says you just say no because you're not responsible for the way other people feel about something I love that isn't that dope for sure so I sort of jettisoned right to that season I was like I'm going to move right there

1:02:33Sean Hayes: that feels good yeah I've told enough stories i'd like to get into the truth exactly yeah no is a fine yeah no is a fine answer as

1:02:41Will Arnett: long as you as you say it in a kind way and you just take a just take a second to just message it the right way and and then it gets received the way you intend yeah now you know i i quit like um i've kind of if people come over for dinner like i have friends that i haven't seen or people in the business and they have a dinner at my house i used to be like oh shoot how do you get to how do you get them out of your house because it's different than going to a restaurant because in restaurant, the check is the end of the night. But when they come over, they could be there for five hours. They could be an hour.

1:03:09Like, you don't know. So now I'm at the age, I just go, guys, I'm going to bed. Thank you. I mean, that's it. I've literally watched people. I've got to go to bed. You guys know Chris Hardwick? I've been to his, literally, I've watched him one day. He, we were sitting around outside. It was wonderful and lovely. He goes up, he comes down like in pajamas and he starts, he starts turning the lights. That's my move. You do that? It's to go upstairs

1:03:31Will Arnett: there's a change and come back down. So, Sean delights. Like, what? What?

1:03:37Sean Hayes: Sean, you'd love, Sean, by the way, Coleman, I always say that Sean is, he always wants to be only like in the place that he's not in now. He always wants to be somewhere else. But, I will say this, Sean, I found this restaurant I have a lot of anxiety. I have a lot of anxiety. On Long Island with the kids. Sure, anxiety. And, I went to this restaurant and I found it and they had on the table a QR code. So, you could eat your dinner and then they were like, oh, and I hit the QR code and you can just self-check out, do the tip, do everything right there. You don't have to have the waiter come over.

1:04:07Sean Hayes: That's the best. And it became my favorite place to go this summer because I'd go with the kids. We'd eat and I'd be like, boom, we're out. That's fantastic. No more nice and please. No more asking for the check. Nowhere waiting. Then they go, they bring it back and the thing. They need that in Europe. For real. They need that in Europe because you can never get a check. I know. That's exactly right. When I was in London last year, how many trips back and forth are we doing until I pay the thing? It's endless. Wait, Coleman, do you have any horrible gone wrong theater stories? Yeah, we need one before we let you go.

1:04:36Just like one, like something where the set collapsed or somebody vomited or somebody passed or anything like that. A real funny one. A real hilarious one. Somebody had a stroke in the middle of a scene? No, no. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, well, no. That's okay. How about going up on a line? No, buddy. I won't say this, but I had, okay, in London, listen, people do things a little differently on stage. Like they will go in between shows. If you're an old school actor, you'll go to the pub and come back completely pissed doing the show. And I look at my fellow actor, I'm like, his face is beet red. I'm like, this dude is drunk.

1:05:16Will Arnett: You can smell it. Yeah, and he would go up on his lines. My lines were always after his. I'm like, this motherfucker. I was constantly saving the scene. I'm like, oh my God. But really, but it was okay with him because he's a legendary actor and he just was a little drunk. But they're like, wow. But they're like, yeah, what are you going to do? But they were all cool about it. They're like, he went to the pub. I'm like, wait, that's not that thing. Did I hear you say you've got a one-man show that you do sometimes? Do you ever fear going up on your lines when you've got no one out there to help you?

1:05:43Oh, I did go up on my lines. I went up on my lines at the Vineyard Theater and it devastated me. I was mortified. But I went up twice because I went up on the same thing. I had to restart the show and then I went up again. But I realized, okay, this is not to bring the mood down. I realized it was the anniversary of my parents passing and the show that I was doing was all about my family and then I thought I was performing the show beautifully but suddenly something clicked and was like oh no you have to feel the show and I kept going up and then I was racing through the show to get to the end because I was on adrenaline I can't go up on lines so I was performing probably like a fucking maniac for like 90 minutes I left that show and I was just like oh my god, oh my god I felt like crazy because I had never gone up on a show but then I realized I had my own psychotherapy that I was like, oh, I'm not actually dealing with this event that I don't have my parents anymore.

1:06:32Yeah, right. And the next night you were okay? Yeah, and the next night I was okay. But to be honest, there was a breakthrough because I realized, and the beautiful thing is sometimes you have these breakthroughs as we do as performers. You're like, oh, I was performing it. I wasn't really living it. So now I have to live it. And that was a joy. Suddenly I had a breakthrough

1:06:50Will Arnett: and it changed me as a performer as well. It was like - You'll have a better chance of remembering all your lines if you're living it as opposed to performing it. Absolutely. Absolutely.

1:06:58Sean Hayes: Yeah, because you have no choice because everything makes sense that you're saying. Yeah. Got it. You're not trying to like, right? You're not trying to just. I was doing it more for, it was more outside in instead of inside out. And so I feel like. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But also I think that those mishaps, any mishaps we have in our work, I really try to look at it. It's that magic. It's that thing that like you'll never get back. But if we lean into it, it's something that can transform you, you know? Yeah, for sure. Yeah, well, it goes back. Yeah, the imperfection, the thing where it's not corporate, you're not trying to hit something.

1:07:30Sean Hayes: It's just like it's the beauty of the thing. And the most beautiful things are imperfect in that way. Yeah, Coleman, I said this story before, but the one-man show I just did, you know, you're playing 10 different people. And the line was, I buzz the door and Larry answers, right, is one of my lines. And then I go into Larry, a different person. and I was actually, it was like show 60, 70, whatever. And I was actually waiting for whoever was playing Larry to talk. And I was like, and I, because my mind, I just checked, I checked out, you know what I mean? I was like, I buzzed the door, Larry answers.

1:08:06And I was just waiting for, I go, oh shit, I'm Larry too. Oh, it's me.

1:08:10Sean Hayes: Oh, it's me. Oh, I'm Larry. It was crazy. Oh my God. I'm Larry. Anyway. I think solo shows are the most terrifying things though, to be honest. Of course. Like standard comedy as well. Oh God. Yeah. I mean, I feel like we could talk to you forever. What a delight to get to know you, man. You guys, too. Honestly, you've just been such a fan for such a long time, so it's just really a thrill to have you. Well, I left at this because I really admire and, like, adore you guys so much. I like to hang out with them and, like, you know, hopefully become friends, you know? Well, we'll do it in person, man.

1:08:41When I see you, I'm going to hug you. Please hug me. Yeah, me too. I'm going to hug you, too.

1:08:45Sean Hayes: It'll be a huddle. By the way, we're looking for more friends. We're looking for more friends. You better meet it.

1:08:50Will Arnett: I'm in. Yeah, I'm in. great thank you guys thank you for coming on thank you Colman you guys are wonderful alright pal have a great day bye bye bye see you later bye how great is he well yeah I'm so glad you brought him on yeah the energy I love his energy he's just

1:09:08Sean Hayes: he's just got so much I mean he's just like that guy is that guy's an artist man yeah that dude's an artist

1:09:16Will Arnett: do you guys believe in like and I'm you know here we go looking at a computer here that I was still feeling like, I don't mean to sound all, you know, unicorns and rainbows, but like that there was a vibe. Do you guys feel like that you get a vibe from somebody and then like that person's a match for you? Yes. Like I would get along with that person. You know, when it happens in person, you just end up always getting on with that person. It's not because of anything they particular said or it's just a vibe. and like do you think that that's like a real thing or is it i'm not am i just a ding no i mean that's that's why you that's why you create a relationship with somebody but like is it animal you know like because i feel like you know without communication i feel like animals do that you ever see like like dogs when they just like stare at each other and they'll like they'll start like like immediately just like but it's not they're not giving any any signal or any words beforehand like is there some sort of a silent communication that exists between two beings at times that are match or not match?

1:10:19Will Arnett: I think so. Yeah. Yeah.

1:10:21Sean Hayes: I think so, man. Hey, dude, are you going through something right now? I don't know.

1:10:27Sean Hayes: If you guys could just call me after this. By the way, what if you're like, yeah, I feel that, and then you got his number, and you're like, hey, call me, man. I feel like we should hang out. And he's like, yeah, just sorry, man. I'm not feeling that. Fuck you, David. You're so crazy. You know what's so funny? By the way, I didn't even realize we were both in The Running Man. the Edgar Wright movie, right? Oh, yeah. And when Edgar said, I forgot to bring it up, but when Edgar called me, he was like, do you want to play the game show host? I was like, oh my God, yeah. That's such a great part. And then I got the script and it was just the opening game show host and Coleman played the game show host.

1:11:03The actual part. Edgar should have been more specific. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But he was fantastic in that too. He always is. Anyway. Never terrible. But you know, he's very famous. Oh boy. By the way, God, God.

1:11:15Will Arnett: You got to get better about that. It's so embarrassing for you. It's always the same.

1:11:19Sean Hayes: I know it is. But because he goes like this. And you see him and he goes, but, you know.

1:11:26Will Arnett: Yeah, and then he looks on his computer where he's sort of halfway written it out. Go ahead. Right. So, you know, he's in The Walking Dead or Fear the Walking Dead, you know. Yeah. And he's in a very famous episode called Days Gone. Bye.

1:11:44Sean Hayes: God, you had to dig deep for that one. Bye. Smart Less.

1:11:54Smart Less.

1:11:58Sean Hayes: Smart Less is 100 % organic and artisanally handcrafted by Rob Armjarf, Bennett Barbaco, and Michael Grand Terry.

1:12:11Smart Less. The place you call home is important to you. So it's important to Allstate. Because home is where you make all your memories. Like forcing your grown siblings to wear matching PJs in front of the fireplace for your annual photo. It might not be a memory they cherish, but it's one you'll never forget. If it's important to you, it's important to Allstate. Switch to Allstate and you could save hundreds on home insurance today. Not available in every state. Potential savings vary subject to terms and qualifications. Allstate North American Insurance Company and affiliates, Northbrook, Illinois.

From the publisher

Pardon sir, it’s Colman Domingo. On this week’s episode of “How to Be a Better Soldier,” we’ve got: Broadway, Bartending, living like a teenager, truth-telling season, and a Sophie’s Choice. I’m Larry / it’s an all-new SmartLess.

Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ to listen to new episodes of SmartLess ad-free and a whole week early.
Start a free trial now on Apple Podcasts or by visiting siriusxm.com/podcastsplus.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from SmartLess

All episodes