

4 Nov 2026 · 44m · 15 chapters

Jason Mantzoukas and Rishikesh Hirway discuss Hirway’s album In the Last Hour of Light—especially how it was made live with session musicians—and how collaboration and process lessons from Song Exploder shaped his songwriting.
Rishikesh Hirway is the Song Exploder host and a musician; he previously worked on TV/film scores and took a long break from writing personal songs. Jason Mantzoukas is a comedian/actor/improviser and podcast host (How Did This Get Made?), known from The Good Place, Parks and Rec, The League, Big Mouth, and John Wick.
Hirway’s producer Phil Weinrobe told him to start over with no use of demos and to record everything live; he says “perfect is the enemy of good” helped him finish. He credits prompts from Sam Beam (Iron & Wine) for jumpstarting songwriting (Stray Dogs). He argues small “friction” and imperfections can be the best parts.
Sam Beam’s prompt (“describe a street you grew up on from a stray dog’s POV”); Beam later sings on “Stray Dogs.” “Home Movies” uses real VHS audio from Lindsay’s father, triggered live during recording.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Rishikesh introduces Jason and discusses his new album 'In the Last Hour of Light'.
“You might've seen him in John Wick or The Good Place or Parks and Rec or The League, or you might know his voice from Big Mouth, or you might know his podcast, How Did This Get Made?”
Jason shares the transformative process of recording his album live with musicians.
“You know to be given truly a challenge Yeah.”
The conversation delves into songwriting techniques, including prompts received from Sam Beam.
“And he said, okay, well, we can get somebody to play your guitar parts.”
Learn about the transition from solo creation to embracing collaboration in music.
“Like, are you texting him like two days later to be like, yeah, man, I need you to sing on the song that is now called Stray Dogs that you basically gave me.”
Discover how insights from interviews helped unlock creativity and overcome writer's block.
“You know, and like when I talk to people about acting, I'm like, wait, that's what you do?”
Explore key lessons learned from other artists' processes and their impact on creativity.
“So 2014, it took a long time before I could actually try and apply that.”
Examine how music serves as a vessel for memories and the struggle to document experiences.
“So there are songs on the album where it's not the only song that I ended up writing about that thing.”
The guests discuss their struggles with memory and the importance of documentation in preserving moments.
“from my 30s forward and all of the nonsense that I've done.”
Jason shares a poignant story about his relationship with Lindsay's father and how it inspired his songwriting.
“And then there's a photo that I took of my wife, Lindsay, on our third date.”
The conversation shifts to how Jason integrated Lindsay's home videos into his song, enhancing emotional depth.
“that is so much more impactful, so much more, I don't know, like hearing that person, especially someone you've never heard but have populated so much in your mind, hearing that is exceptional.”
Jason describes a powerful moment in the studio when Lindsay's father's voice was played during recording, changing the atmosphere.
“and all the people who were working on the song, suddenly they hear the voice of Lindsay and her father right as we're about to go into the next part and it completely changed everything.”
The guests discuss artists and songs that inspire them, focusing on the emotional resonance of melancholy in music.
“One of the other things that you sent me was a bunch of songs that you felt like were either inspiring to you or artists.”
They explore how Jason’s work on Song Exploder influences his own music creation and the challenges of writer's block.
“it's the feeling that I want when I'm making music.”
Jason shares insights on recording live music and the beauty of embracing imperfections in the process.
“Working with Phil, I had an allergic reaction to the idea when he described it.”
Learn about the unpredictable nature of improv and the importance of listening in collaborative art.
“where you're intentionally trying to make something that nobody could have predicted.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Song Exploder, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00You're listening to Song Exploder, where musicians take apart their songs and piece by piece tell the story of how they were made. I'm Rishikesh Hirway. You might have heard me say that Song Exploder is part of Radiotopia from PRX, and I wanted to explain what that means and how it connects to you. PRX is a public media nonprofit, so they're focused on supporting work that serves the public interest. and they started Radiotopia as a way to empower independent podcast makers like me. Here on Song Exploder, we try to book artists from a really wide range of music and backgrounds and ideas, and we spend a long time editing together each episode.
0:39I think that's what makes the show special, but it's not a great formula if you're trying to maximize profit. But I've been able to keep this show going despite that because of the support of Radiotopia and listeners like you. Radiotopia sells ads for the show, but those come and go, and nothing is as reliable as the listeners who believe in what we're doing. So if you care about this show, and if you care about supporting independent media, please visit radiotopia.fm slash donate. You can chip in any amount that works for you. It all makes a difference. Again, it's radiotopia.fm slash donate.
1:15Thank you so much. Thanks to Steele for sponsoring Song Exploder. I took a trip to Iceland this summer, and because it was the summer, I didn't really think about dressing for the cold. Even though I was hiking and I was planning on seeing some glaciers, I thought, it's August. But then I got there, and I realized I made a huge mistake. Now, though, I have a Stio hometown hooded jacket, and I just wish I'd gotten it before my trip. All of Stio's clothes are designed and tested in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, by locals who live, work, and ski in below freezing temperatures. I'm headed back out into the cold this winter, but now I'll have my insulated, hooded Stio jacket.
1:57Ski season's almost here, so gear up now, the way the locals do. Go to stio.com slash songexploder for 20 % off your order. That's stio.com slash songexploder. stio.com slash songexploder. Steele, designed and tested in Jackson Hole. This show is supported by Odoo. When you buy business software from lots of vendors, the costs add up and it gets complicated and confusing. Odoo solves this. It's a single company that sells a suite of enterprise apps that handles everything from accounting to inventory to sales. Odoo is all connected on a single platform in a simple and affordable way. You can save money without missing out on the features you need.
2:42Check out Odoo at O-D-O-O dot com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.
3:12if you don't already know Jason Mantzoukas, he is a comedian and actor and improviser and writer and podcast host. You might've seen him in John Wick or The Good Place or Parks and Rec or The League, or you might know his voice from Big Mouth, or you might know his podcast, How Did This Get Made? I love talking to Jason about music and film and TV, and our conversation kind of touched on all of those things. But principally, it's about this album that I made called In the Last Hour of Light, which is my fifth full length, but my first one in 15 years, since before I started making Song Exploder.
3:49If you want to listen to the album, there's a link in the show notes. So thanks for listening to this, and thanks to Dropbox for supporting the event. Here it is. How we doing, everybody? We are here to talk about, I mean, you're going to play music. It's going to be great. We're here to talk about your new record and how it was made, How Did This Get Made? is the name of my podcast, which I just love to get. I'm doing plugs at the beginning. So we've been friends for years, and we get together and we talk about stuff. First of all, how are you enjoying season 21 of Taskmaster? It's really good.
4:27Episode three, I think I told you so far, was my favorite. That one was an all-timer. Taskmaster fans? See, these are the kind of things we talk about when we hang out. Taskmaster. the fact that we're middle-aged men who watch anime. Because I feel like we are always talking about stuff we're listening to, stuff we're watching, stuff we're processing. But then when you told me you had new music, that was very exciting to me. And then when you played me new music, that was even more exciting because the reality that you were making a band record was deeply exciting. because I feel like that's newish, you know?
5:11I'm going to ask a lot of process questions. How did the record come to be? How did it go? But I think what was so interesting to me, especially in that first tranche of songs that I heard, was like, this is a band record. And then talking to you about like making it together in a room and how different that was for you. Can you talk a little bit about like how this record came just differently? Yeah. I mean, it wasn't my plan to do it that way. I recorded with a producer named Phil Weinrobe And I went to him thinking that maybe I was going to make A mostly solo-ish kind of record I had recorded a bunch of stuff Where I was playing all the parts And I really loved this record that he had done with Adrian Lenker Songs and Instrumentals Beautiful, incredible record Incredible, one of my all-time favorites And that album is her She's layering some guitar parts and some vocals But that was sort of my idea.
6:05That was a big inspiration for me. And so I went to the person who co-produced it to say, can you help me make my... Did you have demos at that point? Yeah, I had demos, some of which were very fleshed out, some of which I thought might make it onto the record. As is, even. Not as is, but close to it. I was open to the idea that he might say, take this part out or add this part. I hadn't closed the book on those demos, but I felt like I'd written parts and arrangements and figured out tempos, things like that. And then he said, okay, great. We're not going to use any of this. And I love that. We're going to just start over.
6:43I love thinking you're someplace and then someone stripping it to zero. Yeah. I feel like that is a impactful moment to be like, wait, I'm doing this all wrong and you want me to change it completely? Here we go. I was looking back the other day And it turns out that that conversation Where he told me that was It was the first time we'd ever spoken It was my birthday Oh wow And you know I didn't realize at the time The impact that it would have Now I can look back and be like wow That was such a crazy process that began on that day And it feels great that it was my birthday Was he and yeah What a great gift in a lot of ways You know to be given truly a challenge Yeah.
7:25You know, and so at that point, was he like, no, I want to do this live, like recording everybody in the same room? Because now you've shown me pictures that I'm certain people can find, if you've already put them out there, of all of you crammed into a room together recording this record. And it's awesome. Yeah, he knew right away that he was like, we're going to do this with session musicians. And there are people who I trust. And I said, and when do I send them the demos? And he was like, you're never going to send them the demos. They're going to learn the songs on the day that we record them.
7:59And you'll just play them for all of us. He's like, I'm never going to listen to your demos again, by the way. Oh, my God. Oh, that's incredible. How much time between that conversation and you being in that room in Brooklyn? Four months. Okay. During which once a month I would call him and be like, can we please do this a different way? Wow. Because I don't feel like I'm constitutionally up for recording in that way. Which you'd never done. I'd never done. Like previous to this, you'd mostly played the instruments on your, you'd done it all yourself in a lot of ways. So this was not just different.
8:34This was foundationally different. Yeah. I'd never worked with a producer like this. I'd always been the producer. That was something I wanted to do and was excited about. But I really wanted to let somebody else have a vision for the thing. I just didn't realize how drastically different his vision would be from what I was comfortable with. so you arrive and forgive me if this is like drilling down too much into it but like this is the kind of stuff that i'm fascinated by you arrive you get there are you meeting the musicians for the first time when you are recording almost all of them yeah wow that's incredible there was only one person who i knew beforehand we had put together a band with the idea that i was going to be playing guitar and singing and then when he really wouldn't budge on this idea that we would do everything live, I said, I don't know if I feel comfortable playing guitar and singing and having to get both of those right at those standards that I want to have for the album.
9:31And he said, okay, well, we can get somebody to play your guitar parts. You know, they can just do what you would do. And so I said, well, what if we asked my friend Ken Pomeroy to come do those parts? Incredible. Because we had written a couple of songs together. What if you still lives in me? Native tongue, crooked teeth. Skies the two of us had seen. Slipping from me while I sleep. I'd only met her like six months earlier, but we'd become friends. And I thought at least having one familiar face might help a little bit. And she's all over the record in such an incredible way. And her presence is essential.
10:23It's really impactful. It's wonderful. Okay, so as you get into it, there's a way in which process-wise, I was absolutely dumbstruck by some of the stuff that you were talking about. You were saying that there was a moment where you were going to a writer's retreat and you were like, oh, I'm nervous. I'm stressed. I don't know that this is going to be successful or work out or how am I going to, I'm nervous I'm going to, this time will have been wasted or something. And you ask Iron and Wine, aka Sam Beam, for a prompt, which this blew my mind. I've never, I love this. So can you tell us like what was his prompt and what then happens?
11:04Just that moment of like asking someone to just give me something that I can just jump from. I asked a few friends for prompts because I really... I did not get asked. I just want to say I was not asked. Well, I didn't want to have to explain prompts to you. Yes. So true. Yeah. Sometimes you get a suggestion from outside of yourself and then you have to do something with it. I think what I love about it is it is an improv scene, which is like my whole thing. Yeah. Does anybody have a scene where they would like me to answer this question from? Yes, if we could just get a non-geographic location for this answer to be set in.
11:50I heard proctologist's office. So, doctor, I was worried about squandering this week. You know, for the first time I was turning everything else off in my life and just working on songwriting as opposed to squeezing it into the sort of nooks and crannies that I had been doing for the last few years. Yeah, your whole thing is English muffins. You know, it's all about the nooks and crannies. Thomas is English muffins. Yeah, and finally, I was going to be just writing the songs. And I knew that sometimes, you know, you set the scene to write a song or to work on music and just nothing comes. And so what would I do if I'm in the middle of this week or even at the beginning of this week and suddenly I can't write or nothing's working out.
12:37So I thought, let me fill up some pages with ideas that I can turn to, even if they don't end up being songs, just like as a way to loosen my mind or something. So I reached out to a few friends and yeah, Sam was one of them. And he gave me three prompts, but the first one was kind of all I needed. He said, describe a street that you grew up on from the point of view of a stray dog. I love that. It was so successful and so inspiring that you finished the song before you went to the writers. retreat. Yeah. So what it was supposed to give you, you just were like, no, I guess I did it already. Yeah.
13:11I mean, it was so great to get a song out of it, but then I used it already by the time I got to Texas. That is incredible. And so from then, that's the first song on the album is called Stray Dogs. Yeah. I can't believe the joy that poured out of us when we were 19. Now we don't speak It's harder to call Every year in between But we used to be Bad free Sam sings on that song with you. And was that how soon after he gives you the... Because it sounds like that turnaround was very quick. Yeah. Like, are you texting him like two days later to be like, yeah, man, I need you to sing on the song that is now called Stray Dogs that you basically gave me.
14:10I didn't ask him until after we were done recording. The original idea was that we would do any kind of overdubs or anything like that, that it would really be all live. But there were some ideas, daydreams that I had, and one of them was the idea that since the song owed such a debt to Sam Beam to begin with, wouldn't it be cool to have him sing or just do something on it to have his presence captured in that way that like codified his involvement. And he's great. It's great. It's so, let's just talk about collaboration. You are a generous and prolific collaborator. And that is not just in terms of these songs and this record.
14:48You are collaborative in your podcast work. You are also someone who is curious about collaborations. You've done a podcast about people collaborating on things. You know, Song Exploder is about understanding process and how people are doing it. When you are collaborating, because you're collaborating not just with the same, but with all different people, how much are you adjusting to what they're giving you versus your driving? You know what I mean? Like, how do you suss that kind of collaborative dynamic, I guess, because you are so good at remaining yourself in all of these things, but you're collaborating wildly with all these different people.
15:27And that to me is fascinating. I think that's something that I learned in a later part of my life. My 20s, when I was really entirely focused on music, I was focused on music in a way that was kind of the opposite of collaboration, where I was trying to do everything myself, where I was like, oh, I need to write all the parts. I need to record all of them. I mean, there were other people who played with me and people who would contribute and there were people who play instruments. And certainly there were other people whose creative input was very important. But if I can do it myself, let me try and do it myself.
16:00I thought that was important artistically that I do it all myself, that it be as pure of an expression of who I am in order for it to be, I don't know, for me to feel proud of it or something like that. Or it needed to just be like this really undiluted version of who I am. I think you and I both struggle with needing or wanting to be in control. Yes. This is the, I feel like the ocean is very much about this. All my life I've been holding on too tight Can't slip up, darling But things are never gonna turn out right
16:46I ended up getting writer's block and starting to do other things. And I started doing podcasts for the first time. And I opened things up a little bit. I think that era of my life changed because suddenly it is, at least the podcast that I was making, they really did rely on other people. With Song Exploder, I'm telling other people's stories. And with West Wing Weekly, I was like, I needed Josh, his perspective. And with Home Cooking, it's a conduit for Samin's knowledge, Samin Nasrat's knowledge. So that was like a whole new way of making work for me. And so when it came time to make this record, it felt natural in a way, but it was new to do it in music.
17:27Inside of Song Exploder, you're talking week to week about how people do the thing that you also do. You know, and like when I talk to people about acting, I'm like, wait, that's what you do? Are you serious? Because I'm not doing that at all. Boy, this is crazy, you know? Like, I did a show with Merit Weaver, and I was like, I don't even know what you're doing. It's so incredible. I'm over here being an absolute joker, and you are transcendent. How much of getting and gaining insight into other people's process, how much did that help unlock that writer's block? Or was it a matter of broadening your horizon to be like, oh, I need to incorporate other people or I need my process to be different.
18:12For a long time, when I was making Song Exploder, I was not making music. Oh, really? Not at all? I mean, I was making music for other people's projects. I was doing... TV and film scores, yeah. But I wasn't writing my own songs. I wasn't making personal work. And I felt like I was collecting these stories and wisdom from all these artists and disseminating it. But even though I found it fascinating, it was kind of academic because I wasn't making music and I didn't actually even know if I would ever make music again. I didn't know if I still had it left in me. And so it didn't really, I wasn't like, oh, and I'll use this and I'll use this because I was just like, I don't know.
18:52It's just like - You didn't have that feeling like, oh, you can do it that way. I mean, I did. I was like, that's really cool. For someone who makes music, that's really cool. But I just, I felt so detached from me. Interesting. And then when I finally did get back to making music, it was like a decade of lessons that had been stored up suddenly now hit me all at once where I was like, oh, I can think about this. And I can think about working with a producer and I can think about all these different ways that people work and apply it to myself. But it took 10 years for those lessons to reach me.
19:25That's an incredibly long time. So are there any like specific things that you feel like moments or practices or tips or tricks or anything that you feel like you even remember now that someone said? Like, for example, and I'll give an example for me from one of your podcasts, which is West Wing Weekly, where you guys were talking about Allison Janney's method to memorize lines. Yeah. Which I'm just going to very briefly tell you because it's absolutely batshit bananas. is she memorizes lines by memorizing the first letter of each word in a sentence so she only is remembering a letter and the letter reminds her of the word think about that for a second it's and now think about like how wordy west wing is like it is crazy but that so and i remember you guys were talking about it and then at some point you had her on and she talked about it.
20:26Yeah. And then I was doing some job at one point and I had some speech to give that was full of like jargon that I could, like technical jargon that I couldn't remember and I tried the Alice and Janney thing and it worked. Wow. It worked because I was like E-D-N-F-B and I was like, that's all I have to say. I just need to remember because it just felt so technical. It wasn't emotional. Yeah. I found that so inspiring because I was like, oh, I'm being given access to someone else's way of doing a thing. And they are elite level. Yeah. And Song Exploder is you talking to people who are elite level songwriters and musicians.
21:04So were there any things that stuck out to you or that you then have carried through now back into music making? Yeah, there are so many things. In one of the earliest episodes, I interviewed my friend Alex, who makes music under the name Seawolf. We were label mates. And he said something about how perfect is the enemy of good, of saying, but I had never heard it before. And it really hit me. Oh, yeah. My therapist said something very similar to me. And it, like, rocked me. Yeah. I sent myself a note. I sent myself an email with that in it. And I was like, I got to remind myself of this all the time.
21:43Yeah. I think, and I'm still trying to wrap my head around it. Oh, yeah. But I think if I hadn't heard that, I don't know that I would have been able to make this record. It was like the fourth episode of the podcast. So 2014, it took a long time before I could actually try and apply that. Then another one that I really loved was I did an episode with the electronic artist John Hopkins. He had made an entire track. It's like a really cool sounding John Hopkins track. And he was like, but I didn't like it. And so then he basically takes the entire thing and puts it through this meat grinder of sound processing and makes this crazy sludge out of it and then chops that up.
22:25And then that entire thing that was a whole song becomes this one little sonic layer that he then builds a song around. Wow. And it was a lack of preciousness about a thing that he had made that he was like, oh, yeah, I did this. But actually, this thing's purpose was not to be a song in itself. And rather than continue making it a thing, I can use that. I can cannibalize an idea and turn it into another idea. And I thought that was really fascinating, too. Because I think a lot of times my inclination is to bang my head against the wall until I can get this thing right. Oh, yeah. instead of just saying like, I can smush this up and see where it goes.
23:05I feel like similarly, I feel like it took me a long time to get comfortable with things being messy and shaggy, even though you would think my appearance would tell you that I love that. No, like I also am constantly striving for in the scripts I write or the things I do, perfection or whatever. And there's a great story about them making Full Metal Jacket and Stanley Kubrick doing take after take after take. And Matthew Modine, it's his scene. And he's going, I need another one. I need another one. And Stanley Kubrick is like, I've got it. Don't worry. And he's like, no, I need another one. And Modine gets one.
23:41He goes, okay, that's it. That's the one. That one felt real. And Stanley Kubrick goes, I'm not going to use that one. I'm going to use the one I like because interesting is better than real, which I love. Wow. And his pursuit of reality was in direct opposition to the interesting movie that Kubrick was making. Love it. Mustafa the Poet from Toronto, he had a song that I just absolutely loved, a heartbreaking song called Air Forces, and I did an episode with him. And this was another thing that I really loved, a lesson that I got, where we were talking about it, and then just sort of offhandedly, he was saying that he had been writing and he had this collection of five songs besides the one that we were talking about.
24:22And I was like, oh, what were the other, what else was on your mind? What were the other songs about? And he was like, oh, this. Like, they were all about the same thing. Wow. And I was like, oh, you could keep writing about this? He's like, yeah, because you don't know which one is going to be the better expression of this idea. That's fascinating. Yeah, because if you're trying to unlock or figure out a thing, come at it from every angle. Yeah. And at some point, and it's almost like the John Hopkins thing, like at some point, maybe they all collapse into one song or something. Yeah. Oh, that's great.
24:57I love that. So there are songs on the album where it's not the only song that I ended up writing about that thing. I love that. The song Swimming Pool, you were talking about how as you get older, your relationship to time is becoming very difficult. I now feel like one year, to me, feels like it goes by in about six months. Yeah. Truly. Like, I feel like time is speeding up in a way that is terrifying. How do you feel? And you had a great line in something you wrote to me, which was basically like, I'm nervous that the moments that I'm experiencing right now in the present tense, I will forget in the near future.
25:36And that I have also like a real kinship with, a feeling like, boy, do I wish I remembered more things. Do you feel like these songs are helping you remember? I don't know if they're going to help me remember, but at least I feel like they were like little pots that I could put that feeling into. I remember getting into a fight with my dad. We were on a trip and he was just like videotaping everything on his phone. And I was like, dad, it's just five of us here talking. Can you just be a part of the conversation? And, you know, whatever. This idea of like living through your phone, documenting the thing instead of experiencing it.
26:14I feel like I'm so often on the side of like, put down your phone. I love that voice. I will say as your voiceover mentor. Jason is my voiceover mentor. Yes, he's gotten parts on Bob's Burgers. It's happening. It's real. I mean, come on. That was just, you guys just got a taste of this guy's voice work. This is a voice that I'm doing. That one. That's the real guy. That's the guy I know. This guy. Oh, podcast, Rashid? It's like when you realize that Stringer Bell, Idris Elba, was British. Yeah. Little do you know that off mic, like Cockney accent. It's just one of the many ways I'm just like Idris Elba.
27:01So, so much. You also are now saying you will not play James Bond. Yeah. So part of my life, I'm always like, put down the phone, let's experience this thing. And then an increasing part of me is saying like, I understand my dad wanting to film that moment and take a picture of every single thing. because I'm worried that if I don't have the picture, it will be like it never happened, no matter how important it was in the moment. We're drowning in pictures of, like, the most mundane elements of our life and focusing so little on a singular picture from that whole trip. Yeah. You know, like when an entire trip just had 36 pictures because that's the number of pictures on a roll of film or whatever, you know, everything felt so much more meaningful because even if it was a bad picture or whatever, it's one of the only, like, the reality of, like, I have so few pictures of myself until I'm in my 30s, and then I have all of the pictures of myself from my 30s forward and all of the nonsense that I've done.
28:06Yeah. You know, but prior to that, it really is, like, I can barely remember those years because I have nothing to jog it with. I have nothing, so I feel like I got to document this so that later I can remember it, but that's not working. My phone is full of just garbage. There are a couple of documents or lack of documents that were a big part of this. One is that my mom started losing her voice when she, I guess in 2011, 2012, the symptoms started to come. And then as I was getting an iPhone for the first time and all of this access to recording all the time, my mom kind of became a diminished version of herself.
28:46So there wasn't as much to document. and the condition that she had also, like one of the symptoms is like she could not necessarily focus her eye contact. So, you know, trying to take a picture became difficult. Just be like, look at the camera. She couldn't do it. So I feel like I have these kind of side-long glances of her at best in the last decade of her life. And I have no videos or recordings or anything like that. And so that was a big part of it, of realizing how much this relationship to time was kind of heartbreaking for me. And then there's a photo that I took of my wife, Lindsay, on our third date.
29:25It's like her in her apartment. Did you take it on a phone or on a camera? With a proper camera. With a camera. And I can look at that, and I remember exactly how I felt in that moment because that was like the thunderbolt. Like we'd had a couple of nice dates, and then that day I was like, oh, I'm done for. Yeah. I have a picture of that. Like I have the moment that I felt that. And I was like, man, I wish I had something like that to remember all of these big moments. And I do feel like a lot of these songs are excavating those moments. You know, like I feel like you're talking about your mom losing her voice.
30:03And there is like in home movies, there is, for Lindsay, there is her father's voice. And I think if you can tell that story briefly, I think that is an incredibly beautiful story, not just about the home movies and getting to see and hear him, but then how that gets inserted into the song incredibly beautifully, but also how you ended up doing it in the studio, I thought was super interesting. So there's a song on the album called Home Movies. It's the last song on the album. And, you know, so many of the songs are about a relationship that I have. And this was a song about my relationship with Lindsay's father, who I never met.
30:45He passed away a couple weeks before Lindsay and I had our first date. We have a life together, and he was such a big part of her life. So naturally, he sort of casts a shadow over my life, but it's like seeing the shadow without ever having seen the thing that casts the shadow. And I wanted to write about that idea of someone who could have such a big presence who I'd never met. And around the same time, Lindsay's family had uncovered these VHS camcorder recordings from her childhood with, and it's mostly videos of Lindsay and her brother, Brian. And so I got to see them for the first time. And it's just great to be able to see them as little kids.
31:24But it's also like, I'm hearing the actual voice of this person who I had kind of only understood as this nebulous idea. I've seen photos and stuff like that, but there was just - But voices are, there's something about voices that is so much more impactful, so much more, I don't know, like hearing that person, especially someone you've never heard but have populated so much in your mind, hearing that is exceptional. And in a lot of the videos, he's the one filming. And so you can hear him sort of like directing Brian or Lindsay to like do something. And I realized watching that that that felt a lot like what my experience of him was.
32:04You don't see him on the screen, but his presence is clearly there. You hear his voice. You hear this sort of expression of him without like seeing the direct thing. And so I wrote this song. And then when I was demoing it, I asked Lindsay if it would be okay to use some of the audio from one of the actual home movies. And she said yes. And so this was one of the demos that was like quite produced. I thought like I had written all this stuff for it and actually like put in these things. So that one was feeling pretty done. and then we tore it all back, started over when I was in the studio with Phil and all of these musicians who had never, didn't know anything about this, had never met me before.
32:45Sure. But you sat them down, you made them watch all of Lindsay's home videos. Yeah. You're like, you guys gotta watch all of this. Yeah. I know we're on hour five, but I played them the song, we started playing it. I was like, actually, let me tell you about this song. Let me tell you what it's about, who it's about. And then I said, oh, also, I have this idea that I think I would like to do after we're done. I want to incorporate these moments from the actual video. Like these snippets of Lindsay's dad saying something. Yeah, Lindsay and her dad talking to each other. Yeah. And I feel like you talked about the song wasn't quite clicking as you were doing it.
33:22Yeah, exactly. Everybody was playing competently. They're all really good, but it just hadn't landed yet. And then I mentioned this idea, but we can't do this because everything has to be live. and Phil said, do you have those pieces of audio? And I was like, well, I have the demo audio of it. And he's like, okay, so give me those. And he, because everything is supposed to happen live, when it came time for those moments, he just like hit play on those clips and played them through a guitar amp in the room. So we're in the middle of recording this song and we get to this first chorus and all the people who were working on the song, suddenly they hear the voice of Lindsay and her father right as we're about to go into the next part and it completely changed everything.
34:09I put new strings on your dusty mandolin I'm surrounded by what's left of the person you had been all day
34:31Hotel Hotel
34:45It's one of my favorite takes of the whole album because I could see how they responded right then and there. Oh, and it is like that moment, those moments in that song give you chills. It is so incredible to get a peek into that story, into that little bit of just those little bits of dialogue and the way it ends on him and them. And it's really, it's absolutely beautiful. In a home movie, I keep watching on repeat. Watching on repeat Watching on repeat Watching on repeat Watching on repeat
35:37One, two, three Hey, I need to show you I'm okay Okay More from my conversation with Jason Mantzoukas after this Song Exploder is sponsored by Tin Can, the landline reinvented for kids. And I just got one for my niece, who's 11. Tin Can is the new school way for kids to talk with their friends. It's a secure landline that lets them call all their favorite people, but with parental controls to keep them protected. No screens, no algorithms, no texting. Just a phone being a phone. So I called my niece on her new Tin Can. Hello. Hi, what do you think? I love it. What are you going to talk about with your friends?
36:20Star Trek. You're going to talk about Star Trek? Yeah, because that's what we're into. Amazing. So go to tincan.com slash songexploder to get$10 off your first order. It's exclusive for Song Exploder listeners. That's tincan.com slash songexploder for$10 off. And when you use that link, you're supporting the show. Again, it's tincan.com slash songexploder. Talk to you soon. Love you. Love you too. Bye.
36:53One of the other things that you sent me was a bunch of songs that you felt like were either inspiring to you or artists. You mentioned Adrian Lenker earlier from Big Thief. There was Arthur Russell was in there. But boy, was I happy to see The Innocence Mission in there. Karen Paris, one of the true, like wonderful, unique voices in music. there's a feeling in her voice and in their songs it's not just the sound of her voice it is this place that like hovers between hope and melancholy yes and i feel like you write about melancholy and loneliness and certain elements that i feel like overlap and for me are always summed up in the joni mitchell lyric there is comfort and melancholy There's something.
37:40Oh, there's a baby here? Oh, that's awesome. The baby, huge fan. Because Arthur Russell, too, very melancholy. Like, there's stuff to that. Yeah. So when I stumble across music that lives in that kind of in-between, it's the feeling that I want when I'm making music. And so to run across an artist like that or songs by them, it's incredibly inspiring to know that this emotion has been captured you know it's like here is that feeling it is possible to capture it and so that gave me something to aim for i'm curious when you okay because you have this big you know break where you're not making music but you're obviously like just so ensconced in music with song exploder you've got all of these people telling you how they do music and then you start doing your thing again does it butt heads at all?
38:33Do you have to change what you're listening to? Or do you have to change how you're listening? Or does it change your relationship to doing Song Exploder because you're now making your own music and don't want to be either too influenced by this? Or is it the opposite? I'm so wide open that doing the show and listening to music is inspiring everything I'm doing. Does that make sense? Yeah. For a long time, I felt like Song Exploder was kind of deepening my writer's block because I was talking to such successful musicians about their work that I felt like, well, what's the point of me making music?
39:06It's never going to be as good as this. So much of the stuff on the show is there are these huge hits. Oh, yeah. A lot of these people are massive artists who have been also around for quite a long time, some of them. Yeah. And I felt like it actually was getting in the way of writing things that felt real and good. Yeah, because you can't be working on something with the intention being, and it will then be huge. Yeah. because that is almost going to guarantee it will never be. Right. You know, I think. I think that so often on the show, a lot of times people are like, I never thought that song would take off.
39:40I was shocked when people liked that song. You know, that's my song, you know? And that I feel like is, you know, you doing it for you, you know? And that's what I feel like this record feels like it is for you, you know? Beautifully so. Do you feel like in making this and getting back to making music, you've had like a reframing of how you approach making music. So recording the album live and then releasing what was recorded live has done such a number on my brain. Working with Phil, I had an allergic reaction to the idea when he described it. And then even as we were doing it, I was just like, oh, you know, because I know that I'm going to hear the flaws.
40:23Because there's a part of me that really believes in what he said, which is think about some of your favorite records and think about some of your favorite moments on those records. I bet there are so many records that you have where things aren't perfectly in tune or perfectly played or like perfectly in tempo. And I bet that you don't love them less because of that. And in fact, I bet that those are some of your favorite moments when the weird thing happens. That little bit of friction, that little bit of dissonance, that something that is off. Yeah. I was like, yes, I can appreciate that. I hear what you're talking about.
40:57And in Song Exploder, I'm often trying to push people to talk about the mistakes or the weird things that are in the recording because it's so cool that those things exist. But to be able to turn that kind of perspective on something I made felt impossible and felt like I was just exposing all the ways in which I'm a fraud if I ended up publishing that stuff. Like, for example, would you ever release demos? Or would you now, but maybe before you wouldn't have? I think I could release a demo if it was like, but here's the perfect thing. Isn't it cute? It's like a beautiful person being like, look how awkward I was as a teenager.
41:34Yeah. You're like, I think I live with a level of cringe at myself all the time. Even right now, as I'm saying this, I'm like, how could I have done this better if I can go, I'm going to go back and edit this. That's where we're different. I am crushing it. Well, you live in a world where, I mean, like, improv is all about the moment. The moment. It is so much more like this live band recording thing where you're intentionally trying to make something that nobody could have predicted. Yes. And will never happen. And truly, the most significant and important thing that you can bring to it is listening.
42:13Is, that's it. Yeah. It's just the ability to listen and comprehend everything other people are doing. Not, I'm here saying this. Me, me, me, me. It really is. You are really being informed by the people in the group with you or in the scene with you or whatever. Yeah. There's like a collision. And the best outcome is this unpredictable accident that suddenly spontaneously occurs. Well, because, boy, when you start an improv scene, you're going to end up someplace nobody could have predicted. versus if you wrote a sketch, you know exactly where we're going to end, you know? And there's something really fun about being like, when we started that job interview, I did not think we'd both end up dead.
42:53You know? Yeah, yeah. And as a huge fan of yours and the improv stuff that you do... Oh, really?
43:04I love all of that stuff. I love going to improv shows and I love seeing how the thing slowly gets built and there's something so special about that. And yet it's been really, really hard for me to give any version of that permission to myself. And for a long time, I would do live performance because I was like, well, this is part of the job. And I love meeting people and talking to people and I love traveling. I love everything except for the part where I'm actually on stage playing the songs and not doing the best job I possibly could. There's a version of this where it's like, I got a perfect score.
43:40and I never get the perfect score. And so it's always a little bit disappointing. And I feel like I live in the disappointment part of it as opposed to all the awesome stuff. And so I'm really trying right now to reframe my brain. It's expectation. It's all expectation because you, I feel like you have in your mind an understanding of how you think it should go, sound, feel. Yeah. And if it doesn't for any number of legitimate reasons, because you're playing, yes, the same songs, but in different rooms, in different circumstances, every night, different crowds, different everything, then you can't help but judge it against each other iteration versus I get on stage every night and I'm like, who knows what's going to fucking happen?
44:21And it happened tonight with you guys and now we did it and here we get it. And it was the best version of this we did, you know? And we'll never do it again. I mean, unless you ask me to do it again, in which case we will do it again, but it will be completely different. Thank you, Jason. Thank you so much. Thank you, Rishi. Thank you, everybody.
44:40thanks so much for listening to this episode and if you feel like listening to my album again it's called in the last hour of light it's out under my name and if you go to song exploder.net slash album it'll redirect you to the different streaming platforms or you can go to the website for the record label keeled scales where you can get it on vinyl or cd and all this stuff is on my own website which is rishikesh.co i'm gonna go on tour again and you can find the tour dates on there you You can also find a brand new song that I just put out called Never Going Anywhere.
45:16After my tour ended, I went back to record some more new music with Philip Weinrobe in the same way as the album, with everything live. And this new song is sort of a coda to the album. Also, thank you so much to Dropbox for their support for this event and my tour. On Dropbox, you can find a special archive that I made that has a lot of the material that Jason mentioned in our conversation. It has my demos and voice memos, studio photos, and some things that inspired me as I made the album. It's the sort of things that I ask people to share on Song Exploder. I shared this archive via Dropbox with everyone who came to the shows.
45:52And you can find a link to it yourself at rishikesh.co slash albumarchive. There's a link to that in the show notes as well. Learn more about how you can share your work with Dropbox at dropbox.com. Tiger Biscop helped me put this episode together and Song Exploder is a proud member of Radiotopia from PRX a network of independent, listener-supported, artist-owned podcasts You can find out more about our shows at radiotopia.fm My name is Rishi K. Shirwe Thanks for listening
46:34But known by many names
46:41I hear the water rushing
46:47Through a shape that doesn't change Never going anywhere
46:58Never going anywhere
47:04Never going anywhere.
47:11Never going anywhere.
47:18Radiotopia. From PRX.
Listen to 'In the Last Hour of Light' here – lnk.to/inthelasthouroflight
Listen to "Never Going Anywhere" here — lnk.to/nevergoinganywhere
Dropbox archive of demos, photos, and more – hrishikesh.co/albumarchive
I wanted to share this conversation that I had with my friend Jason Mantzoukas earlier this year. It was on stage, here in Los Angeles, at my album release show on May 14, 2026. Before playing my songs, I had this in-depth conversation with Jason about music and creativity, and my own creative process. And if you don’t already know Jason Mantzoukas, he is a comedian and actor and improviser and writer and podcast host—you might have seen him in John Wick, or The Good Place or Parks and Rec, or The League, or you might know his voice from Big Mouth—or you might know his podcast How Did This Get Made?
I love talking to Jason about music and film and TV, and our conversation kind of touched on all of those things. But principally, it’s about this album that I made called In the Last Hour of Light, which is my fifth full-length, but my first one in 15 years, since before I started making Song Exploder.
For more info, visit songexploder.net/jason-and-hrishikesh.