


A wide-ranging Squawk Pod episode covering (1) U.S. trade policy aimed at global factory overproduction and tariffs ahead of midterms, (2) Iran-related economic pressure and possible U.S. military escalation, (3) the NFL’s Supreme Court brief on regulating prediction markets, (4) a reported F-35 parts shipment mishap involving an email routing error, and (5) a dispute over AI “solving” the Navier-Stokes problem.
Jamison Greer, U.S. Trade Representative; Tristan Buckmaster, NYU mathematics professor.
Greer is the U.S. lead on trade policy and sanctions coordination; Buckmaster is a long-time researcher on Navier-Stokes and related fluid dynamics.
Greer says a 36-country statement targets excess capacity (mainly Asia) and that tariffs and sanctions are reducing deficits and supporting manufacturing jobs; he argues leverage in Iran negotiations will fade as sanctions tighten. Buckmaster claims OpenAI’s GPT-6 Astra result was achieved by using/accelerating work after he revealed his identity, and he alleges pressure and unethical tactics.
NFL argues CFTC lacks resources to prevent manipulation/insider trading on platforms like Polymarket and Calci; China allegedly seized F-35 stealth parts after a UPS email warning was missed; Buckmaster says OpenAI “one-shotted” Navier-Stokes claims were later contradicted and that OpenAI agents reproduced his Euler-to-Navier-Stokes progress quickly.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on global supply levels and economic pressures on Iran.
“When you partner with CDW, you get more from your devices with solutions that take modern work to the next level.”
Discussion on global supply levels and economic pressures on Iran.
“Welcome to Squawk Box right here on CNBC.”
Analysis of the NFL's stance on regulating sports betting markets.
“Now, yesterday's Fed Minutes revealed that central bank, the central bank expects to hike rates for a second time this year, but didn't indicate whether it would be at the October or December meeting.”
Discussion about a shipment incident involving F-35 parts and email miscommunication.
“I mean, he was one of the early ones, wasn't it?”
U.S. Trade Representative discusses tariffs, factory overproduction, and trade relations.
“China managed to obtain parts from a U.S.”
Discussion on the current state of tariffs and trade relationships, particularly with China and Canada.
“So things are in motion and America is at the front of it.”
Exploration of the U.S. sanctions strategy regarding Russia and Iran, and its implications for global trade.
“We have 72000 new manufacturing jobs this year.”
NYU professor Tristan Buckmaster discusses his near-solution of the Navier-Stokes equation and the role of OpenAI in its resolution.
“CNBC Changemakers, spotlighting women who innovate, lead boldly, and are transforming business.”
Discover the intricate negotiations and ethical concerns surrounding AI research and authorship.
“So they said, when I said this was completely unethical what their offer was, and I said, look, I'm going to go public with this, they said, why would you ruin your career?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Squawk Pod, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Hey, Fidelity. What's it cost to invest with the Fidelity app? Start with as little as$1 with no account fees or trade commissions on U.S. stocks and ETFs. Hmm, that's music to my ears. I can only talk. Investing involves risk, including risk of loss. Zero account fees apply to retail brokerage accounts only. Zero dollar commission does not apply to customers designated by Fidelity as a professional equity trader. A limited number of ETFs are subject to a service fee of$100. See details at Fidelity.com slash commissions. Fidelity Brokerage Services, LLC, member NYSE SIPC. When you partner with CDW, you get more from your devices with solutions that take modern work to the next level.
0:38CDW experts are delivering powerful productivity with Lenovo AI PCs, helping users block out distractions, access virtual support anytime, anywhere, and share content seamlessly between devices. Make amazing happen. Learn more at cdw.com slash Lenovo. Bring in show music, please. I'm CNBC producer Ron Anastasio, long-time listener, first-time host. Great to be with you today on Squawk Pod. America's top voice on international commerce, trade representative Jamison Greer on global supply levels and the economic squeeze against Iran. Whatever leverage they have left will go away in due course. Again, I think it's similar.
1:25Anytime you're negotiating with any country on any topic, friend or foe, at some point, leverage catches up. At some point, reality catches up and people want to get to yes. Then check out this story, the NYU math professor who says he was this close to solving an equation that has driven math whizzes for decades crazy when OpenAI announced their models had done it. They went from before they knew my name, they had no progress. After they knew my name, they suddenly started from where we left off. So you find it suspicious? I find this suspicious. Plus, the NFL weighing in on regulating prediction markets.
1:59Oils rise. And remember to check your email. Could you send top secret plane parts to China? Talk to a person if it's that important. It's Thursday, October 8th. Squawk Pod begins right now. Stand back to buy in three, two, one. Cue, please. Good morning, everybody. Welcome to Squawk Box right here on CNBC. We are live from the NASDAQ market site in Times Square. I'm Becky Quick, along with Joe Kernan and Andrew Ross Sorkin. We are here. We're ready to go. It's a Halloween tie before anyone says anything. Crypto? No, no. Has Bitcoin ruined orange ties forever? I've got a lot of them. I can't just not.
2:39That's actually a different shade. Right. But I can't just not wear orange ties. No, it's a fall shade, and I will give you the jack-o'-lantern. Michael Saylor. Michael Saylor. No, and it's Penelope's birthday as well. October 31st. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So I got to wear orange. So I can, your light's on. Your light's on. And if your light's on, your phone's going to get... Your light's on, you're old. That's just the key. That's true, too. Let's take a look at Treasury yields. Yields were higher yesterday for both the 10-year and the 30-year, which were still sitting at those highest levels since 2002.
3:11And they're up once again this morning with the 10-year yielding 534. The 30-year's at 572. And the two-year is sitting at 481. Crude oil prices also rising. President Trump speaking out about the Iran war at a campaign rally in San Antonio, Texas last night. He made this comment about his negotiator, Steve Witkoff. He's working on the Iran deal and doing very well. I think the deal isn't really something that I want to do, but they're willing to offer us anything to stop. NBC News reported yesterday that the president and his national security team have discussed the possibility of resuming large-scale U.S.
3:51military operations in Iran in the coming weeks. Separate reports said that that could include massive bombing of Iran's energy, infrastructure and nuclear targets. Fed Governor Christopher Waller saying more rate hikes needed to cool inflation. Waller speaking earlier this morning at the Istanbul Economic Forum. He said insufficient progress is being made in lowering inflation to the central bank's 2 percent target. However, Waller says he is not concerned that hiking rates would damage economic growth. Now, yesterday's Fed Minutes revealed that central bank, the central bank expects to hike rates for a second time this year, but didn't indicate whether it would be at the October or December meeting.
4:32I don't know if you have a bet on that. I would bet later. I'm betting on later. Yeah. The NFL now weighing in on prediction markets and how they should be regulated. Contessa Brewer joins us with more on that story. Good morning. Good morning, Andrew. Yeah, we can exclusively report this morning that the NFL has filed a brief with the Supreme Court urging justices to issue a speedy decision in the battle between prediction markets and states over who can regulate sports betting on platforms like Polymarket and Calci, with whom CNBC has a commercial relationship. The NFL is arguing the CFTC maybe doesn't have the staff or the resources to protect the integrity of its sport against manipulation and insider trading.
5:17Further, the league says repeatedly it has petitioned the CFTC and the prediction platforms themselves to eliminate event contracts that are vulnerable to insider trading to no avail. And the league wants a 21 and over age limit where prediction betting is available right now to 18 to 20 year olds. Now, according to the draft brief to the Supreme Court obtained by CNBC, the league argues that regulating gambling is among states' sovereign police powers. And it asks, what constitutional power allows Congress to override states' traditional police powers to regulate interstate gambling? We're in Macau to cover the NBA China Games.
5:57And tomorrow, we'll interview NBA Commissioner Adam Silver. He has also taken a cautious approach to prediction markets, though some of the NBA's biggest stars, of course, guys have signed massive contracts with the platforms like LeBron James. Fifteen million dollar reported deal with Polymarket where he's out earning what he makes with the NBA. So we'll talk to the commissioner about that tomorrow and see whether his stance has changed at all on this. Do you expect his? I mean, he was one of the early ones, wasn't it? Wasn't Adam Silver one of the first? On sports betting, he was one of the first to embrace it and see the real possibilities here.
6:33The question has been, though, in this fight, whether there's enough integrity protocols put into place to keep insiders from gambling. And the NFL is saying in its brief, there's just not. And that when they've gone back and pointed out specific event contracts, they particularly find problematic that nothing has been done. You know, we had the head of the CFTC here at the table just just earlier this week, and I suggested to him in this great age of technology, this seems like something that could be fixed insofar as if, for example, you were a player associated in any way with the NFL or associated in any way with the NBA or whatever it was that you could literally limit their trading on anything, therefore, related.
7:20similarly if you were a politician of any sort that they could from a technological perspective do such a thing and for whatever reason he didn't seem to take the bait on that idea well and the technology already exists because the nfl is already using it for instance you may not gamble on sports from nfl facilities and they have it geo-fenced out so that if somebody tries to get onto a sports gambling site from an NFL facility, it pings the NFL and it pings the platforms themselves that it's happening. The technology absolutely does exist. And this technology is supposed to be deployed, for instance, in Nevada, where a federal court has sided with the state of Nevada saying that it can enforce its gaming laws against CalShe.
8:06But I was in Nevada last week in Las Vegas, and I was talking to people who said they're still getting on the platform. Contesta, we look forward to following this story. It's a fascinating one. Appreciate it. A story about the importance of checking your email. China managed to obtain parts from a U.S. F-35 stealth fighter jet after a UPS employee missed an email warning not to route that shipment through Hong Kong. That's according to a Bloomberg report that said that the shipment of the warplane parts was meant to travel to San Francisco through South Korea and then Taiwan. But it was late leaving Australia and was mistakenly routed through Hong Kong in an effort to try and speed up delivery.
8:47China seized the parts in Hong Kong and the Pentagon is, in their words, actively working to retrieve them. The incident prompted investigations by the Pentagon and the State Department, and U.S. lawmakers have demanded a review of the global supply chain for U.S. armaments. Yes, sending them through UPS was not something that I had realized was happening. Second of all, sending something on an email. You know how many emails I miss on a daily basis? If it's important, call. I know. Talk to a person. Well, in the future, your agent will catch it. Rarer and rarer. Your agent will catch it. Talk to a person if it's that important.
9:28Cheese will be next. Coming up on Squawk Pod, U.S. Trade Representative Jamison Greer on combating global factory overproduction, sanctions on Iran, and a state of tariffs ahead of the midterm elections. The president is very comfortable with his trade policy. He's proud of it. It's led to deficit reduction. We have 72 ,000 new manufacturing jobs this year. We have 110 ,000 new factory construction jobs. So for us, the numbers are going the right direction.
9:58Oh, look. You just got added to a meeting about coordinating another meeting to prepare for the pre-meeting ahead of the follow-up meeting, which will, of course, require a recap meeting and then another meeting. Hit your booking point, book with Southwest and enter airplane mode. Hey, Fidelity. How can I remember to invest every month? With the Fidelity app, you can choose a schedule and set up recurring investments in stocks and ETFs. Oh, that sounds easier than I thought. You got this. Yeah, I do. Now, where did I put my keys? You will find them where you left them. Investing involves risk, including risk of loss.
10:50Fidelity Brokerage Services, LLC, member NYSE SIPC. CNBC Changemakers, spotlighting women who innovate, lead boldly, and are transforming business. Do you know someone who is rewriting the future? Nominations for the 2027 list are open now at changemakersnominations.cnbc.com.
11:13Welcome back to Squawk Pod. Here's Joe Kernan. Stand by, Joe. Here's Mike. Here's you. All right. U.S. 14 major economies, including Canada, Japan, and India, have signed a joint deal to crack down on global factory overproduction. Coalition is targeting excess manufacturing, demanding an end to unfair market distorting trade policies. Join us now with the details. U.S. Trade Representative Ambassador Jameson Greer. I mean, I think I know who we're talking about here, Jameson. Anybody other than China come to mind? Well, certainly China, but I think also places like Vietnam and those other places in Asia, too.
11:58We just have a finite amount of demand in the world. It's certainly dynamic and can grow and change over time. But when you have a country like China or Vietnam and they're building factories with an eye to just building them for employment or investment or export growth without an eye to increasing their domestic consumption or going off of market demand, you end up with excess capacity makes impossible for American workers or workers in the European Union or Japan or wherever it is to actually get ahead and fill demand in a market based way. I mean, that's almost part of the business model of China.
12:33I didn't realize Vietnam as well. How does that not come home to roost for Vietnam? I mean, China, I think, has had the ability to stay one step ahead, it seems like, even with, you know, a lot of times there's things built that aren't even used, stadiums and apartment buildings and the like, factory overproduction. They do dumping. The same thing's happening in Vietnam. How do they how do they stay ahead of the game like China? Well, well, it's not a recipe for sustainable growth. I agree with you. I don't know how long it lasts for Vietnam. What I do know is that President Trump is taking action.
13:10You know, we've taken strong tariff measures over the past year and a half. Our trade deficit substantially down with China. It's gone up somewhat with Vietnam. Some of that's electronics. But what's remarkable about about the statement that you talked about? This is American leadership. This was we developed this statement at the G20. You had a couple of folks who didn't want to sign on, like China. And so on the margins of the OECD, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, this week we released it. It's the EU. It's Japan. If you count all the EU countries, it's 36 countries agree with the United States that there's overcapacity largely in Asia.
13:44And it's negatively affecting us. And so we've agreed to get together. We're going to share information. We're going to cooperate. And notably, we've agreed to coordinate action. Now, what that looks like in practice has yet to be seen. But you've already seen the EU this week go to China to ask them to restrain their exports to the EU to deal with China shock 2.0. So things are in motion and America is at the front of it. I mean, the midterms are coming up and we do hear, you know, Republicans in the administration criticized and it's a it's a campaign issue. And that is tariffs, even though I think in certain instances, I think Democrats agree with with some of these tariffs.
14:24But even though it's a hot button issue for the election, we haven't talked about it a lot in terms of of new tariffs or exorbitant tariffs other than maybe just Canada. But, for example, I'm talking about China, really. There's been sort of a lull. It's almost a managed trading situation that we have with China right now. Is it working to both countries benefits, would you say? Well, it's certainly working to America's benefit. The big benefit to China is they get a stable relationship with the United States. Again, they're under pressure. Their growth right now, it's only export-led. Their domestic demand is cratering.
15:06That's why they're shipping vehicles to Europe and not selling as many as they were in their own domestic market. As you know, we've shut those vehicles out of this market to protect our own workers in places like Michigan. but I think what you're seeing is as the U.S. deficit with China goes down as we diversify you know we are paying attention to other countries in the world as well where we tend to get influxes of sometimes it's second hand right you get Chinese inputs or goods to a third country they do a little screwdriver work a little assembly work and they send it to us it technically counts as a good from another country with a preferential duty rate but maybe fundamentally it's Chinese so we're trying to get at all of these things right now.
15:45With China, we have a stable situation. We have our national security measures in place, whether it's export controls, you know, tariffs on sensitive goods. But on a balanced way, we're managing trade and non-sensitive trade with China. As far as our friends in the north, is anyone getting ready to blink? Would you say I saw that the Senate candidate in Michigan, Republican, I think Mike Rogers said that came came out against, I think, some of the tariffs. I saw a debate the other night with Senator Collins, and Maine probably isn't that happy with some of the tariffs with their friends to the north as well.
16:24Any progress being made? Well, first of all, I would say Canada, as I've mentioned before, they've always had the best tariff treatment, even over the past year and a half. The majority of the goods from Canada come in duty-free. Most of what we send to Canada also is duty free. You know, what we have is a situation where Canada has banned wine and spirits from the U.S., banned U.S. companies from participating in procurement. We put tariffs on about five percent of what we import from Canada. So the reality on the ground, it's smaller. But we know there's emotion involved in this. Right. We know Michigan and Maine.
16:58These these states are are close to Canada. You know, there were a couple of things here and there in Maine and Michigan where the tariff posed a problem. So we adjusted that. We modified that. You know, one thing with Canada, they signed on to this statement that we did on excess capacity. They know this is a problem, too. We speak with our Canadian counterparts frequently, including at the highest levels. I think right now people are seeing where things land. They have an election up there. They just had an election for the Quebec premier and it went with the separatists. It didn't go with Prime Minister Carney's office.
17:29So they have some they have a little bit of preoccupation up there, I'd say. I think we're holding fast with the Canadian. Yeah, there's elections in both in both countries that might be impacting. So you think something happens after those elections or. Well, it depends. Again, the president is very comfortable with his trade policy. He's proud of it. It's led to deficit reduction. We have 72000 new manufacturing jobs this year. We have one hundred ten thousand new factory construction jobs. So for us, the numbers are going the right direction. GDP growth past two quarters was revised up for 2.2 percent, 2.5 percent in Q1.
18:02So we like where the numbers are going. We like how the trade policy has helped it, coupled with our energy policy, the tax credits for businesses and households. So we like where we're going. When the Canadians want to get to yes, obviously, we'll be there ready to talk. The sanctions passed on Russia by Congress. Where do you stand on anything changed since earlier this month when you said the administration wouldn't enforce that? Well, that's not what I said. I know there's a headline about that. What I said is the president's going to decide. So we're going through executing Congress's law on that, where they say you have to you have to determine who's buying Russian oil, who's buying Russian gas, who's evading this, what sanctions are available.
18:43Congress also made sure to give the president a waiver authority, which is pretty standard for sanctions, to give him the flexibility to make sure he can negotiate with, obviously, Russia and Ukraine, but also third countries who might be fueling it. I think there's a big eagerness on all sides to get this thing wrapped up. Obviously, it's affecting diesel prices with refinery destruction in Russia. Russia's attacking agricultural infrastructure in Ukraine. Neither of these things are good for those countries. Neither is good for the global economy. So the president's going to use these authorities as appropriate, uses waiver authority as appropriate.
19:18He'll decide how to implement it to make sure we can get to a lasting peace. I mean, as trade rep, you're not I mean, Iran, we're not talking tariffs, but we are talking about a lot of economic measures that Treasury Secretary Besson has announced. Can you update on it? Is it are we getting close to the breaking point? We keep hearing we are. They seem to have an enormous amount of ability to to, you know, to to have whatever pain we're inflicting. And they pass it on to their people. And I don't know if it ever actually has a breaking point. Yeah. I mean, there's certain ideal. They're certainly ideologically driven.
19:55Right. This is why for 50 years we've been stuck with this regime and no one was willing to do anything. The president has been. He set them back on their nuclear program for forever, for a very long time, which is a great outcome for the world and for world peace. Their inflation rates are going up. Secretary Best and the Treasury are ratcheting up sanctions, not just on Iran itself, but on third countries that are aiding and abetting it. The Strait of Hormuz is essentially open. We're getting shipping through the Strait of Hormuz again. And we have we have countries coming together to go around it, to go around straight and for moves, to go around Iran.
20:31So whatever leverage they have left will go away in due course. You know, again, I think it's similar. Anytime you're negotiating with any country on any topic, you know, friend or foe, at some point, leverage catches up. At some point, reality catches up and people want to get to yes. Right. Ambassador Greer, thank you. So, yeah, you talked about some construction jobs. There's a lot of people employed around there, it sounds like. is that the ballroom that we're hearing? I think that I won't look behind me because I'm on TV, but it could be the ballroom. It could be the front portico with some pillars.
21:04We have a lot going on. The president trying to beautify not only the White House, but the whole city. Oh, great. Okay. Thank you, Ambassador. Still to come on Squawk Pod, the puzzle between a mathematician and open AI. NYU professor Tristan Buckmaster was working on solving a legendary math problem called the Navier-Stokes equation. He got close and OpenAI finished it. He's now taking credit for it. I said, look, I'm going to go public with this. They said, why would you ruin your career? Sebastian said, I'm nice to you. Sebastian Bubeck from OpenAI. I've been nice to you. I don't have to be nice.
21:38And at that point, I knew the negotiation was over. We'll be right back.
21:48Oh, look. You just got added to a meeting. about coordinating another meeting to prepare for the pre-meeting ahead of the follow-up meeting, which will, of course, require a recap meeting and then another meeting. Hit your booking point, book with Southwest, and enter airplane mode. Introducing Fidelity Trader Plus. With customizable tools and charts you can access across all your devices. Try our most powerful trading platform yet at Fidelity.com slash Trader Plus. Investing involves risk, including risk of loss. Fidelity Brokerage Services, LLC. Member NYSE SIPC. CNBC Changemakers, spotlighting women who innovate, lead boldly, and are transforming business.
22:36Do you know someone who is rewriting the future? Nominations for the 2027 list are open now at changemakersnominations.cnbc.com.
22:50Welcome back to Squawk Pod. Ever hear of the Navier-Stokes problem? It's something of a white whale for math nerds. Yes, we see you. A set of equations tracking how fluids and gases move. And it's one of a series of problems so complicated that solving it holds the promise of prize money. There's been a$1 million purse offer since the year 2000 for the first person to prove whether math can describe the slippery movement of fluids. Well, our next guest says he was close to solving it. He and a partner were on the verge when artificial intelligence giant OpenAI found out. The company announced in September that its model GPT-6 Astra generated a final form of proof of this tricky problem.
23:28Clearly, they're into math. This week, OpenAI has released hundreds of new mathematics findings on a wide range of topics, including algebra, number theory, and logic. So what happened? We went to the professor to find out. Joining us right now is NYU mathematics professor Tristan Buckmaster. He says that some of the recent advances by him and another researcher may have inspired OpenAI's prompts that led to that solution that he'd been working on for quite a while. Tristan, welcome. Thank you. All right. So let's talk, first of all, what the Navier-Stokes problem is, why it's important, how long you've been working on it.
24:01Yeah, it's one of the most fundamental equations in mathematics and physics, one of the oldest. 100 years. One of the oldest sort of partial differential equations. So it's used to describe fluid and water, blood flow, air, along an air wing. Airplanes. Yeah, it's the most fundamental equation in fluids. And it's been an open problem for hundreds of years of whether the solutions can break down. And you've been working on this for not hundreds of years, but a lot. No, it's sort of been a north star for me for my whole research career. It's so bizarre. Something goes to infinity in a finite amount of time.
24:45Yeah, so... Are you sure? To infinity and beyond? Just to infinity. The velocity goes to infinity. So imagine a fluid particle goes... So the physics breaks. Right, exactly. The equations don't make sense anymore. I immediately thought, would this change anything in how you design an airplane, now that you know this? I mean, it could be used in all sorts of ways, sort of test fluid models and like sort of test fluid models. But it's something that's so rare that it wouldn't fundamentally. But it has been solved now. This has been solved, yeah. You were at the point, you and your partner, Levant Apoge, right?
25:24You were at the point of solving this. And then OpenAI came out and said, hey, lo and behold, we have solved this. What did you think? What happened? That's right. So end of August, we were, I think we thought we were roughly a month away from solving it. From solving it or from publishing it? Solving it. Oh, you know, I don't know. Until we had the result. And that's when a rumor sort of, well, there was a leak from Anthropic to OpenAI that Anthropic was close to solving two Millennium Prize problems. Not this problem, but two other millennials. Well, this problem and the Hodge conjecture, it's another Millennium Prize problem.
26:07So that had spread from OpenAI to the tech world and then on to Twitter. And it had sort of gone a bit crazy. And then, so OpenAI started working on these, started spending all these millions of dollars on compute trying to solve these Millennium Prize problems. For them, it was sort of a life or death situation because, you know, if Anthropic had come out and they resolved a Millennium Prize problem, it shows that, you know, they had their internal models were better. Levant works for Anthropic. That's right. You should back this up. So there would be the association with Anthropic solving this problem because he is an employee there.
26:44So what happened when you heard that they had solved this, when they put this out, you contacted them? So, no, they contacted us before. So first of all, the rumor was spreading. We heard things were getting a bit crazy. So we contacted them and we told them, look, we're using your product as well. This is not a big anthropic project. It's just me and Levent. And we hoped actually we could have worked together. And they said, look, let's not compete. They offered us millions of dollars. They offered you millions of dollars? No, not millions. They offered us millions of tokens to complete the project.
27:30Okay. So this is where you get into the, did they steal this from you? So let's talk about that. And then on Saturday, we got this, we were told that they're about to do something stupid to get on the phone call. And so this is when we had this infamous phone call. Okay, so what does that mean? Yeah, the infamous phone call, what happened? We don't know. We don't know what it was, but it was enough to convince us to get on the phone. And what happened when you got on the phone? Well, they first tried to bribe us. They said, no, they, or bribe me. They said I could publish their paper as sole author as long as Levent wouldn't be part of it because he was an anthropic employee.
28:10They then threatened me. So they said, when I said this was completely unethical what their offer was, and I said, look, I'm going to go public with this, they said, why would you ruin your career? And he said, and Sebastian said, look, I've been nice to you. Sebastian Bubeck from OpenAI. So I've been nice to you. I don't have to be nice. And at that point, I knew the negotiation was over. I don't understand what the negotiation is about. Either you've done the work or they've done the work. So we had solved a different problem, the Euler equation, which is a step below the Navier Stokes problem.
28:49Right. And the negotiation was, they'd realized that they'd done something wrong. But when you say they've realized they did something wrong, let's just go straight at that. Because that's, by the way, that to me is the whole story. Either they did something wrong or they didn't do something wrong. Sure. What are you accusing them of actually doing? We haven't really got to that part of this. Sure. Well, when after I'd revealed my name, it took maybe a day for them to get exactly where we were in our in our research program. So we had duplicated your name. You revealed your name when to them? On the third, I think.
29:24So, Tristan, let's just back this up to say you were using OpenAI for some of your work. Explain that. Yeah, I was using OpenAI to help interpret some of the work and help develop the work that I was receiving from Levent. And so what that meant was that all our work was on OpenAI servers. Okay, but can I ask a very technical question? Do you have an enterprise account? Do you have a personal account? Personal. You have a personal account. You're in a paid personal account. That's right. And you're working using ChatGPT. You're chatting with it. You're using Codex. What are you using? Codex. Using Codex.
30:04And just so we're all on the same page, you have turned on or off their ability to train or use any of your information. That's actually a significant component part of this story. It is and isn't. But there was two accounts, I think, that I'd turned it off. and there was one account that was still on. On, meaning that they... The default is on, they're allowed to turn it on. The default is on. The default is on. That's right. The default is on. So there was one that I hadn't turned off. But, you know, there isn't the walls you believe, you know, from user data in OpenAI. I mean, you know, just recently they had a white hacker who used Claude to hack into their system and gain access to their internals and get access to user data.
30:51I mean, the whole, you know, the whole sandboxes aren't holding up whatsoever. So I don't know what happened. I also don't know. But you have to genuinely believe that somebody on a very individualistic basis saw you, saw exactly what you were doing and decided, let's go collect all the information in this personal guy's account. Well, somebody or something, the agents, if they were doing it, sending agents, is that what you suspect? Exactly. I don't think there was one person that said, like, steal this person's data. I mean, honestly, I don't think they even know whether, you know, the initial statement is they couldn't determine.
31:27Let me say this, that what they now say is that we can say this is open. We can say categorically categorically that it is impossible for Dr. Duckmaster's codex prompts over the last two months to have influenced the system in any way, including training. Now, there is some some room in that it says the last two months, the last two months, would they have needed that to get to the answer? I mean, they wouldn't have needed much. I mean, the issue is that they make these statements and they keep changing it. So when they made that statement to The New York Times, they originally started with it was April, and they shifted it to July.
32:04You know, they've been lying the whole time. When I got onto the phone call, they said they one-shotted Navier Stokes. Basically, what they claimed is they— One-shot is a single prompt. Single prompt. To create the answer. They took the prize problem, they put it into the prompt, and then they press enter and out came the Manning Prize. Now, this evaporated within minutes. They admitted this was not true. You know, they had internal people communicating them on their internal messaging. And it turned out they worked on all these other problems, including the work that we were doing ourselves. And, you know, they used 10 ,000 agents to get what from our result, which is the oil equation to the Navier Stokes.
32:48They used 100 agents and they got to exactly where we were with exactly the same argument and exactly the same methods within a day. I mean, look, I don't have any, you know, I can't say how they did that, but how did they went from, before they knew my name, they had no progress. After they knew my name, they suddenly started from where we left off. So you find it suspicious? I find it suspicious. I think maybe more interesting is what you are describing as kind of hard pressure and threatening you if you would not publish on your own with this. I mean, that may say more about the tactics that were used.
33:33Now, they have denied those tactics, too. What do you say in response to that? Well, actually, they haven't denied any of the tactics. They admitted that they said that they offered me to be sole author. They admitted that they said, why would you end my career? They haven't actually denied. Sebastian has never denied that he said, I'd be nice. I don't need to be nice. They haven't denied actually anything that I've said. So, I mean, let's... Can I just go backwards for a second? How did you get in touch with them originally? How did they get in touch with you and why? So Levent contacted an open AI mathematician.
34:17And we originally got in contact with them just because this rumor was going crazy. I mean, there was betting markets making bets on whether Anthropic would solve the million price. So we just wanted to calm things down. Well, calm down for what reason? Well, first of all, the rumor was false, right? We hadn't solved the Navier Stokes problem. You're saying the rumor was out there that you had solved it? The rumor that we'd solved it was actually false. We'd solved something slightly less. And so we realized that this was, you know, the Navier Stokes problem was, you know, a pet project of the tech companies.
34:53And it was if their rival had solved it, this was, you know. Okay, how much money did they offer you in all of this and why? They didn't offer me money. They offered me to be the sole author of the paper. So I would have got the million dollars. You just suggested. Am I wrong? Didn't you say they were offering millions of dollars? No, they offered millions of tokens. Millions of tokens. They offered me... Why were they offering you millions of tokens? Initially, when I came to them and I said, like, let's talk. Initially, they said, let's not compete. We can offer you compute. So as in to work together.
35:27Right. That wasn't by email. That was before the phone call. Okay. And then they started competing, of course. So do you use OpenAI still and Anthropic still? I still use Anthropic. I still have OpenAI codecs, but I don't put any sort of ideas in there, anything I decide to be original. And what's come of all of this? So you're not going to get the million dollar prize money. Where does that kind of leave things? How are you feeling about it all? I mean, for me, I mean, honestly, it was never my goal to solve the Navier-Stokes problem. So, I mean, like to solve the Euler problem, I'm super happy.
36:04Like, so, I mean, in all of this, like, it was never my goal. I mean, I think the bigger picture is like this recent dump of papers on Tuesday, which destroyed the careers of early mathematicians, early career mathematicians. So we've had whole research programs wiped out on Tuesday by their dump. And you have to understand, they have access to all our research proposals. And the reason they have access, you don't even have to use LLM. So if you submit a research proposal, a panelist will look at that research proposal and they have to write a summary. And often how they write the summary is they put it into the...
36:48So they have a massive conflict of interest, right? They have all, for the next few years, they have all the mathematicians and scientists' research programs in their training data and how they're going to go about it. And your message would be user beware. Yeah. I mean, the fact that they would front run their customers, I mean, it shows their sort of disdain for their customers. I mean, like, why would a company buy their product when, like, if you get an interesting ideas, they can look at your private notes and beat you to market? Yeah. Tristan, thank you very much for joining us today. Thank you.
37:32That's it for Squawk Pod today. Thanks for listening. It's great to be joining you and the team here. Squawk Box is hosted by Joe Kernan, Becky Quick and Andrew Ross Sorkin. Tune in weekday mornings on CNBC at 6 Eastern. We'll get the very best of our morning show directly in your ears in an easy-to-listen-to podcast from Fall Squawk Pod. We're on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube. We'll meet you back here tomorrow. We are clear. Thanks, guys.
38:10outside opinion from independent experts in a single score. And then when you're ready, trade U.S. stocks and ETFs with no commissions. That's right. I am always right. Investing involves risk, including risk of loss. Zero dollar commission does not apply to customers designated by Fidelity as a professional equity trader. A limited number of ETFs are subject to a service fee of$100. See details at Fidelity.com slash commissions. Fidelity Broker Services, LLC member NYSE SIPC.
President Trump has suggested that the U.S. may initiate more attacks on Iran’s energy infrastructure, and tariffs remain on center stage as the midterm elections draw nearer. U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer discusses both from the White House North Lawn. Mathematician and NYU professor Tristan Buckmaster has been working on solving the Navier-Stokes Problem for years; now OpenAI agents have solved it, but Buckmaster believes his work was used in the process. The mathematician discusses his conversations with OpenAI’s leadership and his own concerns about models training on private work. Plus, CNBC’s Contessa Brewer is in Macao for the NBA’s latest push, and a missed email at UPS resulted in China’s receipt of U.S. F-35 parts.
Contessa Brewer - 04:39
Jamieson Greer - 11:34
Tristan Buckmaster - 24:24
In this episode:
Amb. Jamieson Greer, @USTradeRep
Joe Kernen, @JoeSquawk
Becky Quick, @BeckyQuick
Andrew Ross Sorkin, @andrewrsorkin
Contessa Brewer, @contessabrewer
Ryan Anastasio, @Ryan_Anastasio
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.