In short
Stock Club Podcast Episode #297: What Stocks to Buy During the AI Bubble (w/ Porter Stansberry)
Episode Overview In this episode, host Emmet is joined by financial expert Porter Stansberry, known for his ability to recognize financial risk and educate investors. They discuss the current investment landscape, focusing on the AI bubble, the U.S. economy, corporate spinoffs, and psychological traits of successful investors.
---
Key Discussions
- The Bull and Bear Case for America
- Bull Case:
- The U.S. is the largest market globally and maintains a cohesive culture despite diversity.
- Strong respect for the rule of law and human rights.
- Generally perceived safety for individuals and property.
- Bear Case:
- Concerns over the growth of the welfare state and entitlement spending, which now constitutes 80% of federal spending.
- Warnings about U.S. Treasuries facing potential technical defaults similar to those in 1933 and 1971.
- Rising gold and silver prices indicate market concerns over the U.S. credit situation.
- Navigating the AI Investment Landscape
- Porter stresses the importance of being cautious about investing in AI stocks due to potential market overvaluation.
- Investing Strategy:
- Focus on established companies like Apple and Google that have a strong technological foundation and are well-positioned in the AI space.
- Consider shorting companies likely to be outperformed by AI advancements, but only in moderation (10% of the portfolio).
- The Value of Corporate Spinoffs
- Porter highlights corporate spinoffs as underappreciated investment opportunities that can avoid the hype associated with IPOs.
- Investment Criteria:
- Look for spinoffs with a high-quality core business and a CEO that moves to the spinoff.
- Historical average returns for spinoffs can be around 22%, significantly outperforming the market.
- Psychological Traits of Successful Investors
- Key traits include emotional resilience and the capacity to remain objective under market stress.
- Successful investors buy from pessimists and sell to optimists, maintaining a long-term perspective.
- Investing in Essential Services
- Porter discusses the reliability of businesses in essential services, suggesting that they can serve as stable investments compared to traditional fixed income.
---
Key Takeaways
- Investment Strategy:
- Be wary of AI stock valuations; focus on established companies.
- Consider gold as a hedge against financial instability.
- Explore high-quality corporate spinoffs for potential alpha generation.
- Psychological Factors:
- Strong emotional control is crucial for long-term investment success.
- Understanding market cycles and investor psychology can enhance decision-making.
- Market Conditions:
- Current market valuations are extreme, making it challenging to find good value investments.
---
Quickfire Round
Buy, Hold, or Sell
- Waste Management: Hold
- Tesla: Sell
- Intercontinental Exchange: Pass
- Lockheed Martin: Buy
- Berkshire Hathaway: Sell (with a caveat regarding potential spin-offs)
- Amazon: Wait for better conditions.
---
Desert Island Stocks
- Philip Morris: Porter believes in its long-term potential due to its robust global branding and marketing strategies. The company has adapted to changing consumer behaviors with its innovative tobacco products.
---
Conclusion Porter Stansberry's insights provide a blend of caution and opportunity in today's investing landscape, especially in light of the AI bubble and other economic concerns. His emphasis on psychological resilience and the importance of recognizing undervalued opportunities highlights the nuanced approach needed for effective investing.
For more insights and strategies, listeners are encouraged to explore MyWallSt's content and investing services.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOCurrent Market Conditions
0:30 to 1:09
Porter discusses the current extreme conditions in the market and credit.
“Can you see any extreme value anywhere at the moment?”
Porter's Journey in Finance
2:25 to 4:40
Porter shares his background and key achievements in the financial industry.
“Porter Stansbury, welcome to Stock Club.”
America as a Stock
4:40 to 5:41
Porter analyzes the bull and bear cases for America as if it were a stock.
“and I hope you have that letter framed and over your desk.”
Investment Strategies Amidst Economic Change
6:35 to 12:20
Porter discusses investment strategies related to gold, treasuries, and AI stocks.
“it i think the bull case is very obvious i think to everyone um it's the largest market in the world It is remarkably culturally cohesive considering the diversity that we have.”
Navigating the AI Bubble
12:20 to 14:00
Porter provides insights on investing wisely in the AI sector.
“So for an ordinary everyday investor listening to this, how are you staying involved in something as transformative as AI without getting caught owning great companies at terrible prices?”
Investing in Tech Giants: Apple and Google
14:00 to 17:04
Understand why Porter Stansberry is optimistic about investing in Apple and Google.
“The best example of that is, you know, there wasn't a single newspaper in the world that was profitable 10 years after, because the internet transformed the way that we share and publish information.”
The Power of Corporate Spin-Offs
17:05 to 21:24
Learn about the potential benefits of investing in corporate spin-offs and how to identify them.
“And then all the other downstream things like management usually benefit from a low initial valuation and so on.”
Psychology of Successful Investing
21:55 to 24:53
Explore the emotional traits that differentiate successful investors from the rest.
“You can sign up right there and you'll find it in my recommended portfolio and my product, which is called The Complete Investor, and it's from December.”
Investing in Waste Management and Home Builders
24:54 to 28:04
Gain insights on the reliability of waste management investments and the evolving home building sector.
“And then I saw you mention it recently on X and it is waste management who have just constantly raised their dividend.”
NVR's Unique Business Model
28:04 to 29:16
Learn about NVR's asset-light approach to home building and its industry impact.
“So, what made NVR very different, this is now going back almost 20 years, what made NVR very different at the time was it was the only home builder that did not invest in land.”
Show all 19 chapters
Current Market Conditions and Value
29:16 to 30:14
Explore the challenges in finding value in today's market and the implications of credit creation.
The Risks of Financial Narratives
30:14 to 31:11
Discuss the prevalence of misleading financial narratives that may harm investors.
“So there's virtually no difference in the market today between a corporate credit and a treasury.”
Musical Tastes of an Investor
31:11 to 32:18
Discover Porter Stansberry's favorite musicians as a light-hearted interlude.
“I don't know if you've ever listened to Jason Isbell, but he's just an incredible singer-songwriter.”
Buy, Hold, or Sell: The Game
32:18 to 33:43
Engage in a quickfire round where Porter shares his investment decisions on various companies.
“But here's the thing, you can go buy, hold, sell or pass if you're just it's outside your knowledge at the moment.”
Analyzing Berkshire Hathaway's Investments
33:43 to 36:21
Delve into the performance of Berkshire Hathaway's investments and why they may not be superior to public companies.
“But their operating businesses are a bunch of garbage.”
Desert Island Stocks: Philip Morris
36:21 to 37:38
Learn why Porter believes Philip Morris would be a top investment choice for the long term.
Philip Morris' Business Strategy
37:38 to 42:00
Examine Philip Morris' innovative strategies in branding and product development.
“You know, I kind of, I should have really said Philip Morris, considering our conversation.”
Exploring Philip Morris' New Products
42:00 to 43:51
Learn about the innovative nicotine products from Philip Morris and their market impact.
“it was giant financial fraud underlying all this and he ended up killing himself.”
The Economics of Addiction
43:51 to 45:43
Understand the economic dynamics behind consumer addiction and company profits.
“You think about how many humans that there are in the world.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Porter Stansberry:When you want your spring break to feel like... And your kid's pool day to feel like... And your hotel bed to feel like...
0:12Emmet:Ooh, and room service to feel like... Because at Hilton, hospitality feels like... Your cabana's ready. Would you like fresh towels? It matters where you stay. Book now at Hilton.com. Hilton. For this day. Can you see any extreme value anywhere at the moment?
0:34Porter Stansberry:No, we are at such an extreme in terms of global credit creation. And such an extreme in terms of credit spreads. So there's virtually no difference in the market today between a corporate credit and a treasury. And that just means that the credit spigot is wide open. So there is nowhere in the economy right now is anybody pricing in the risk of default on anything.
1:09Emmet:Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome back to Stock Club. Today, I'm delighted to be joined by someone who has shaped financial publishing and indeed the financial landscape, Porter Stansbury. In 2022, after an incredible career, Porter launched a new financial research firm called Porter & Co. He started with a small team, a tiny amount of capital, and a deliberate rejection of the copy-heavy ads that dominate this industry. Now, less than four years later, it has worked out very well. Porter & Co. serves over 100 ,000 subscribers, including nearly 10 ,000 long-term partners, which is their name for subscribers.
1:54Emmet:Porter believes investing success is about survival, risk control, and compounding. His firm's first audited track record shows market-beating returns with lower volatility, particularly in areas where he spent decades building expertise, such as property and casualty insurance. Previously, Porter built one of the most successful independent research firms in the world and in doing so, once again, helped redefine what it means to serve individual investors. Porter Stansbury, welcome to Stock Club.
2:28Porter Stansberry:Emin, it's great to be here. I really appreciate the invitation and I look forward to visiting you in Dublin in a couple of weeks.
2:35Emmet:Likewise, Porter, very much looking forward to that. Now, I kicked off, I was lowballing your very many achievements. So with your modesty filter turned to zero, would you give me your preferred 60-second autobiography?
2:50Porter Stansberry:I started Stansberry Research in 1999 when I was 26 years old. I started the firm with total capital in of$36 ,000. We never had a capital call. There was no outside investment. I sold that business in 21 to the public markets at a valuation of$3 billion. dollars. And along the way, we reached over a million paying subscribers annually. And I did a whole bunch of things that Stansbury research that I'm still very proud of. I think most notably, writing about General Electric's fraudulent accounting from 2002 until the company collapsed in 2017. I predicted the, a lot of people claimed to have predicted the global financial crisis, but I wrote about it extensively for about three years, and then shorted Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac all into oblivion.
3:43Porter Stansberry:So my portfolio was up for 2008, which I think is a pretty incredible accomplishment. And then finally, I would just say that probably like my personal fondest memory in finances, for about two and a half years, I wrote fake letters from the chairman of General Motors telling the shareholders what they should have been told, which was there was no way for General Motors to avoid bankruptcy because in 19 of the previous 20 years, it hadn't earned enough money to even pay the interest on its debt. And I got a reply from one of those letters from Warren Buffett, which was a tremendous accomplishment for me.
4:25Porter Stansberry:So it's been a long career. And I know that I've done a lot to help individual investors achieve really good results, mainly, as you mentioned, by learning how to recognize and avoid financial risks.
4:40Emmet:Well, that is some autobiography, and I hope you have that letter framed and over your desk.
4:46Porter Stansberry:It's an email, but yes, I certainly kept it.
4:49Emmet:Well, okay, let me start at 40 ,000 feet, as I wear. As you know, I'm Irish, I live in Ireland and consequently I have a front row seat at the play show that is America but I've never really lived there as in paid utility bills. I did a stint there when I was a kid in Maine in 1988 so my understanding of the big picture of the USA today comes from British, Irish and American news sources. You on the other hand are born and raised in the USA, you've been central in your industry and successful in your industry as we both described for decades so if america usa was a stock great brand huge scale and messy operations what would be your bull case and your bear case for america in 2026 this podcast is brought to you by profit the four minute a month stock selection system built for long-term wealth creation.
5:53Emmet:It's as simple as this. On day one, buy an equal amount of the 10 recommended stocks. On the rebalance date, profit tells you what to sell, what to buy, and you repeat the process. It's that easy. The result? Since 2009, profit has delivered an average annual return of just over 19 % with performance spanning multiple market cycles it has outperformed the s &p 500 13 out of 17 years that's 76 of the time which is virtually unheard of sign up today email frank at my wall street.com and if there's a discount going he has
6:35Porter Stansberry:it i think the bull case is very obvious i think to everyone um it's the largest market in the world It is remarkably culturally cohesive considering the diversity that we have. There is a profound respect here for the rule of law and for sort of the basic tenets of human rights. You have genuine free speech here. You have due process here. Generally, wherever you go, United States, you're safe and your property is safe. So I think those things are very easy to understand. What I think is harder to really understand is the insidious growth of the welfare state here, beginning of course with the New Deal of Franklin Delano Roosevelt, and then expanding enormously in the 1960s under what was called the Great Society Programs of the President Lyndon Johnson.
7:34Porter Stansberry:The worst aspect of those things has been the growth and entitlements. Those entitlements now make up 80 % of all federal spending. And that spending alone is in excess of tax revenues. So we've come to the point in socialism where we've run out of other people's money. and we've been living on the printing press and living on enormous amounts of debt. It's true that our economy is very large and it's capable of sustaining a large amount of debt, but that still has limits. And so I think, just my judgment alone, I think that the huge moves you've seen in gold and silver this year are the markets sort of pushing back and saying that America's credit card is finally really tapped out.
8:33Porter Stansberry:And you guys need to make some very important structural reforms, or else there's going to be severe consequences for your borrowing costs. And I think I'm probably way out of consensus here, but I think that it's inevitable that the Treasury will default. And when I say that, what I mean is not necessarily that they won't pay the bills, but that there will be another technical default like there was in 33 and like there was in 1971, where what you're being paid back is in clearly wildly inflated dollars so that it, you know, the promise to repay you becomes meaningless.
9:11Emmet:So the parallel between GE, which looked bulletproof right up until it wasn't, and today's long-term or long-dated US treasuries is very strong. So if you, would you say it's time to start selling treasuries and buying gold uh i have said for
9:30Porter Stansberry:for quite some time now that treasuries are uninvestable yeah um and of course as you know um ever since i wrote my documentary the end of america in 2011 i've been urging people to keep at least 25 of their portfolios into gold yes and uh it was so funny because back then you would not believe how widely mocked I was. Everybody thought that advice was completely bonkers. But of course, gold has dramatically outperformed stocks and just about everything else in that period. When I personally started buying silver in 2006, I wrote a whole newsletter back then, I'd love to send you a copy that explains how America's entitlement spending was entering a doom loop and that default, while not happening anytime soon, would be inevitable.
10:27Porter Stansberry:And so I started buying silver when it was$2 an ounce.
10:31Emmet:Unbelievable. I actually recall you being a bull, a gold bull, when Warren Buffett wrote an op-ed piece for Fortune magazine, which I'm sure you know, which was, I think it was entitled, Why Stocks Beat Gold and Bonds. And he wrote a piece about that if you took every piece of gold known on the earth and melted into one giant big cube, it would fit on a baseball triangle. Is it that's what it's called, a baseball triangle? and he said that the baseball diamond thank you baseball diamond and he said that the economic output of the equivalent value of companies was always going to be greater than the economic output of that square of diamond and i mean of gold and you were calling the opposite and i do recall uh that you nailed that i just want to say i think that i think the thing that buffett never
11:24Porter Stansberry:understood about gold um and i i this is conjecture i've never spoken to him about this but But I think the thing that Buffett misses is similar to what a lot of people don't understand about gold, is that if you do a deep dive into the theory of money and you try to understand what is a perfect money, you actually need something that does not have an other use. So people say, oh, Bitcoin's useless or, oh, gold is useless. You can't do anything with it. Silver is an industrial metal. Well, ironically, that is what actually makes it the most appropriate form of money because, therefore, its supply is very stable.
12:03Porter Stansberry:And that ability to conduct trade globally without an intermediary is incredibly valuable. And that's why I've also been very bullish on Bitcoin. I actually believe that Bitcoin is a better form of money than gold. And so I think it will have a much larger value in time.
12:23Emmet:yeah very good point and i would agree with that and as a stocks only purist i've never really given gold a whole lot of thought like all i know is that about 100 years ago john maynard keane said that gold has one great merit it cannot be increased at will which is your point governments may print paper money but gold remains stubbornly beyond their control um and i think everything you've just said is a is the 100 year later reflection of that insight um last december moving away from gold for a minute you pointed out that time magazine had named the architects of ai zuckerberg musk jensen hang sam altman as its 2025 person or persons of the year then in a subsequent blog you put forward that ai is real it's world changing but the stocks around it may be in a bubble.
13:18Emmet:So for an ordinary everyday investor listening to this, how are you staying involved in something as transformative as AI without getting caught owning great companies at terrible prices?
13:33Porter Stansberry:That's a very important question for everybody right now. And my staff and I have worked furiously on these issues for the last three years, ever since chat GBT came out. And it reminds me very much of when my career began in 1999, when I launched Stansbury Research from my apartment. The internet was transforming industries across the world so quickly, and really small amounts of capital was able to disrupt businesses that had existed for hundreds of years. The best example of that is, you know, there wasn't a single newspaper in the world that was profitable 10 years after, because the internet transformed the way that we share and publish information.
14:18Porter Stansberry:And that was very obvious to me. Among the things that we did was we shorted America's largest newspaper, which was a business called Gannett. And the paper was called the USA Today. But anyways, my point is that what I think investors really sometimes forget is that for every new Google, you know, there's 50 businesses that Google put out of business. And so one thing I think is, again, it seems kind of obvious, but it's, I think it's very important is that I'm long Apple and I'm long Google. I think that Google has the best overall technological suite in the world. And I think that they will win the AI race.
15:03Porter Stansberry:They have the hardware, they have the best software, they have the best engineers, they have the best R &D, and their reach is uniquely broad. So they have AI already into automated cars. They have AI into all of their systems. If you type in Google search, it's AI now. They're really uniquely positioned. And they have a partnership with Apple. And this is very similar to great tech combinations I've seen in the past. So Apple's going to handle the branding, the marketing, the distribution, and they're the best in the world at that. Google's going to do all the hard tech work. And that partnership is going to be way more valuable in 20 years than it is today.
15:47Porter Stansberry:So I think that's a simple thing for investors to get their heads around. Got it. Totally. Yep. And so I don't really need to know more than that to be successful as an investor. And if I am retired and I'm worried about volatility, then I would also say for every dollar that I'm long, Apple and Google, I want to be short 10 cents of things that Apple and Google are going to put out of business. So look around. What is very likely to go the way of the dodo because of AI? and find those things and have a hedged portfolio. Now, I want to be really clear, shorting is not for everybody. And if you decide not to, you'll be fine.
16:38Porter Stansberry:And if you do decide to short, please notice I'm saying, you know, 10 % short versus a dollar, you know, long. So there are some, you know, there's some guardrails. But I think that if you look at my track record from 1999 until today, and my model portfolios, typically, we were short between 10 and 30 percent of the portfolio and that really did reduce our volatility dramatically and provide some some really nice um uncorrelated returns especially during bear markets like you saw in 2020 like you saw in 2009 like you saw in 2001
17:19Emmet:we might swing back to a few big names later on in the podcast but certainly apple and alphabet bet as a twisted pair for the long run is a great way to play the ai mega trend if i change direction just slightly porter you you wrote a great post arguing and i loved this i truly love this article i say to our listeners to go to your website and read it when they get a moment but you wrote a great post arguing that corporate spin-offs are one of the most consistently underappreciated opportunities investing in investing um because you explained that the market really usually misunderstands them and gets them wrong at that moment and you went on to make the point that when a company spun out of a larger parent many shareholders um are either in different sellers uh index funds can't hold it active managers are kind of uninterested it feels like the unwanted child analyst coverage is usually thin etc etc and all of that pressure pushes the price down And then you explained that spinoffs also avoid the hype of IPOs.
18:23Emmet:And then all the other downstream things like management usually benefit from a low initial valuation and so on. But most of all, the point you were making in that blog post was spinoffs often undo value destruction caused by bad mergers. So to get to the question, are there any on your radar today? Are there any corporate spinoffs, breakaways, divestments where you can just smell value where the rest of the world has looked at it and said, I don't know, I think it's dead?
18:59Porter Stansberry:That is a great, great question. For those of you who haven't thought about this very much, watching high quality spinoffs and waiting for them is one of the very few ways of getting alpha for free in the markets. And when these happen, there are really two important things that you need to look for. One is obvious. You want to look for a spinoff that has a very high quality core business, right? You don't want to, you don't want, you know, if a company is ejecting the bad bank, that's not the one to buy. So you need, you need to at least pay attention to whether or not the, it's a core, it's a good, you know, it's a good business.
19:41Porter Stansberry:Is return on equity above 20 %? Do they have consistent revenue growth? Is it a business that you can understand? Is there a moat? Those basic things all need to, you got to check all those boxes like you would with any other investment but the most important tell is number two where did the parent company ceo land oh yeah yeah if he goes with the spinoff that's the one to buy oh that's excellent an insight i never thought of i never thought that one that's the one to buy and the excess returns in those situations are very substantial you know average return is like something like 22 percent so you know, roughly double the market.
20:22Porter Stansberry:And I was for a short while, the chairman and CEO of a public company market wise. And I can tell you when you when you have access to all the company's information, you know who all the players are, you know, all the people, you know, all the products, it is not hard for you to pick out the winners and segregate them. Wow. So that to me, the spinoff where the CEO leaves with it is like the ultimate insider buy strategy. And to answer your question, I'm not currently targeting any spinoffs at the moment. There is a spinoff that we invested in late last year that is at the end of its orphan stage, I believe, where the CEO after the spinoff not only left with the spin code, but he also invested more than$50 million in the open market in the shares.
21:15Porter Stansberry:And that is a new and current recommendation. So I hate to be cheap, but I've got to save something for my subscribers.
21:23Emmet:But yeah, it's an incredible story.
21:26Porter Stansberry:In fact, I wrote this in December of last year, and I said that I believe this opportunity will be the very best investment that I make in my career. It's a very unique story. Where does someone go to find that?
21:39Emmet:So just let's come on to FOMO. We're all twitching now. Tell us, where do we go? Where do we sign up?
21:43Porter Stansberry:Well, you just go to porterandcompanyresearch.com, and that's all spelled out. So, you know, Porter and Company, not Porter and Co., porterandcompanyresearch.com. You can sign up right there and you'll find it in my recommended portfolio and my product, which is called The Complete Investor, and it's from December. I'll give you a little tease about it. It is an irreplaceable business that has over a hundred years of operating history in the United States. And it is the third most profitable business in the history of the U.S. capital markets behind only Philip Morris and Vulcan Materials. It's a very, very good business and no one's ever heard of it because it was recently spun out.
Read the full transcript
22:29Porter Stansberry:And so no one's heard of it. It's not in any index funds yet. It's completely an orphan. It's a really incredible story. Okay.
22:36Emmet:FOMO at 10. you've written extensively about fear and greed and indeed human behavior. In your view, what psychological trait most cleanly separates investors who manage to compound wealth from those who are constantly resetting to zero and losing their nerve, you might say?
23:00Porter Stansberry:That's a very important question and it's very underappreciated. to be a successful investor you have to have an incredible amount of emotional reserve if you're the kind of person who you know who spooks easily or who falls in love with things it won't work very well for you you need to be you need to be um spock-like if you recall the old american television show star trek you need to be you need to disengage from your limbic system And you need to make sure your frontal lobe is in control at all times. The other thing I will tell you is great. This is just an incredible truism that I learned from one of my mentors.
23:42Porter Stansberry:Investors are people who buy from pessimists and sell to optimists.
23:50Emmet:Yeah. Yeah. Oh, yeah. That's what they're going for, for sure.
23:54Porter Stansberry:So, yeah, you have to tilt a little towards the optimism. But it's astounding to me if you look back at the history of the capital markets. You know, the capital markets have survived World War I, World War II. They survived the introduction of nuclear power, including nuclear bombs. They've survived the Cold War. They've survived, you know, Coca-Cola is, in my opinion, far safer to own than a U.S. Treasury bond. And if you ask me, do I want to have a million dollars in Coke stock or a million dollars in gold, I tell you a million dollars in Coke stock all day long. For sure. And it's amazing that even though these things are absolutely abundantly clear and obvious to anyone who even looks at it for 10 seconds, it's still amazing how many people manage to lose money investing.
24:47Porter Stansberry:To me, it's just shocking. It ain't that hard.
24:53Emmet:Well, that's a lovely segue into a stock that a few weeks ago I pitched here on Stock Club podcast. And then I saw you mention it recently on X and it is waste management who have just constantly raised their dividend. I think you said there was, I don't have it from me, but you kind of alluded that there's very few businesses as class as waste management. And is it a business you own in your folio? And would you buy today?
25:26Porter Stansberry:A great question. I can't really speak to it today. I haven't looked at it in detail lately. But I have been an investor in waste management companies for some time. I use them in my portfolio in replacement of bonds. So I don't like investing in fixed income because of the constant inflationary risks. So instead, I invest in things like property and casualty insurance companies, which are big, they're just big portfolios of bonds with an underwriting unit on top. And I invest in things like waste management, auto parts stores, other things that have operations that are so fundamental to the economy that nothing can happen without them.
26:08Porter Stansberry:And so in that regard, their earnings are much more reliable and much more similar to a fixed income coupon than the earnings would be in a lot of other types of businesses.
26:18Emmet:Great, great answer. I understand that in general, you're quite skeptical of home builders, if I'm right, as an investment, because they're very capital intensive and usually debt heavy, cyclical. Is there any home builder you particularly like?
26:34Porter Stansberry:Yeah, you know, what's interesting is that's becoming less true. So for many, many, many years, one of my great investment case studies and the lessons that I would always present to groups of investors to help them understand why capital efficiency is so important. And what I mean by that is a company that can generate a billion dollars on a capital base of$100 million is worth a whole lot more than a company that has a capital base of$10 billion to generate the same billion in profit. And you want to be in the asset light business because more of the earnings will be able to be recycled into share repurchases or dividends instead of having to be invested in the business to continue to grow it.
27:18Porter Stansberry:These things, when you think about them for a second, they're pretty obvious. But when investors price earnings, they mostly ignore capital efficiency. So you might see a capital efficient business trading at 15 times earnings and a heavy capital business trading at 15 times earnings. That doesn't make sense. you're much better off buying the capital light business. And the example that I would always use is the share, the home builder called NVR. And I've been an investor in NVR since 2007. Ironically, I said, look, we're going to have a huge housing crisis. And when NVR trades below$400, which it will, because it's going to get sold off with all the home builders, that's when you should buy it.
27:59Porter Stansberry:That stock today is around$8 ,000. Whoa. So, what made NVR very different, this is now going back almost 20 years, what made NVR very different at the time was it was the only home builder that did not invest in land. And it didn't invest in land because it had gone bankrupt in the early 90s because of its land portfolio. And when it emerged from bankruptcy, the new owners absolutely verboten to own land. And so, it was the first Capital Light home builder. Now, since then, many of the home builders, including the major national home builders, have begun to spin off their property portfolios as a separately traded REIT.
28:41Porter Stansberry:And then they have become much more like NVR in the asset-like category. But even still, NVR is still the leader in that model where 99 % of all the homes they build are on somebody else's lot. and so uh that's that's that's why i i had it wasn't what i think you might have seen in the past was me being critical of the other home builders yes but it wasn't it wasn't it wasn't really about home building per se it was about the business model that the asset heavy model
29:16Emmet:versus the asset light model i took something uh our three core concepts from something you wrote I'd say about a year ago and the first thing you said was asset allocation matters more than picking stocks so like how you spread your money across all the various assets the second thing I took was matching risk to your time horizon and temperament is really important and the third thing which brings me to my question is be patient most of the time but aggressive when value is extreme um on that on that last one can you see any extreme value anywhere at the moment
29:57Porter Stansberry:no unfortunately um we are we are in the we are at a period of time which is you know we are at such an extreme in terms of global credit creation and such an we're at such an extreme in terms of credit spreads. So there's virtually no difference in the market today between a corporate credit and a treasury. And that just means that the credit spigot is wide open. So there is nowhere in the economy right now is anybody pricing in the risk of default on anything. And as a result, all evaluations are extremes. Yeah, it's very, very difficult to find any good value today.
30:46Emmet:And that kind of says to me, Porter, that there must be some dangerous financial narratives being sold to ordinary investors at the moment.
30:55Porter Stansberry:Well, there always is. Yeah, that is true. There's not much better business in the world than selling schlock to investors, unfortunately.
31:10Emmet:That's so true. so um okay let's change gear for one millisecond what's your favorite band and we are and musician am i going to get you this is kind of changing your your frame of mind as we move into the next
31:22Porter Stansberry:phase that is just so tough um i'm so random i love i love music i love all kinds of music i think the best the best songwriter over the last you know whatever a couple decades are are either Post Malone or Chris Isbell. Sorry, Jason Isbell. I don't know if you've ever listened to Jason Isbell, but he's just an incredible singer-songwriter.
31:49Emmet:He was at the Grammys last night. I saw him in the audience.
31:52Porter Stansberry:Oh, yeah, yeah. He's an incredible talent. But yeah, I love all kinds of music, and I think it's interesting that Post Malone's music can both be rap or can be folk country.
32:08Emmet:It's fascinating. Okay, well, that's the gear in your mind changed. And I'm that's getting you warmed up, if you like, for a game called, it's the easiest game in the world, buy, hold or sell. But here's the thing, you can go buy, hold, sell or pass if you're just it's outside your knowledge at the moment. So I'm going to name a company with zero research and preparation, and just your intuition, you go buy, sell or pass.
32:34Porter Stansberry:Waste management. Okay, so hold on though.
32:36Emmet:Okay, let's put the parameters in place.
32:39Porter Stansberry:Well, when you say buy, what's your...
32:43Emmet:Okay, let me, let me, on a long portfolio, would you buy shares in a long folio if they were locked away for 10 years?
32:51Porter Stansberry:Okay, so this is a 10-year long-term buy. Okay, that makes it a lot easier because then I don't really have to worry about valuation.
32:58Emmet:Yeah, exactly. So you kind of, we're speaking to the business model management team, the stuff you've absorbed. Okay.
33:04Porter Stansberry:Waste management.
33:06Emmet:Sure, absolutely.
33:08Porter Stansberry:One of the highest quality businesses in the world.
33:11Emmet:Tesla. No.
33:14Porter Stansberry:Sell.
33:16Emmet:Sell. Interesting. Intercontinental exchange. Pass. Lockheed Martin. Buy. Berkshire Hathaway. Sell. Amazon.
33:34Porter Stansberry:on the Berkshire. If, or I should say when they spin off their property and casualty insurance company, then buy. But their operating businesses are a bunch of garbage.
33:46Emmet:Really? That's a podcast unto itself. And I don't want to drag you into a grand that you don't want to talk about, but is there any more you can give us?
33:55Porter Stansberry:Oh, yeah. If you go back and you look, and I've done all this research and I have an essay about it that I'm happy to send you. If you go back and look at every single one of Berkshire's large take private deals. So, for example, the purchase of Mid-America Energy. So they've put roughly$100 billion into Mid-America Energy and other regulated utilities since 2000. Their return on invested capital today is about minus 40%. Right. Disastrous investment. And no one realizes it because it's private. it. So it's hidden in the conglomerate, but you can see the facts. If instead you had simply bought, what's the biggest, most credible, largest energy company that's publicly traded in the world as of 2000?
34:46Porter Stansberry:It's X-Mobile. Yeah.
34:47Emmet:Oh yeah. X-Mobile, of course.
34:48Porter Stansberry:Right. So in other words, I'm not, I'm not trying to like be a rear looking trader. I'm just telling you if, if you, if your choice was buy the largest publicly traded thing or buy what Buffett's buying. In every case, he gets blown away by the public analog. So think about this. He sold shares of McDonald's to buy Dairy Queen, to take Dairy Queen private. Would you rather own McDonald's or Dairy Queen? Today, McDonald's, of course. Of course. So what I'm saying is, what's the largest publicly traded analog? He's buying a quick serve restaurant business. Well, the largest publicly traded analog is McDonald's.
35:26Porter Stansberry:He's buying an energy company. What's the largest publicly traded analog? It's ExxonMobil. If you go back and you do that analysis for every single one of his take private transactions, if they had done the public analog instead of the take private deal, then Berkshire Hathaway would be a$6 trillion business or something like that. It'd be massively larger. Another case in point, he spent$55 million buying that crappy Nebraska furniture mart remember how he loves to brag about mrs b and how sweet she is she's 100 years old okay well what was the largest publicly traded analog to nebraska furniture mart in 1985 take
36:04Emmet:a guess hooker furniture home depot home depot and home depot has made 26 a year since 1985
36:13Porter Stansberry:for investors so we should rather have mrs b or home depot
36:21Porter Stansberry:okay the reason the reason why warren buffett is the world's greatest investor is not because he was a very good investor he was an average investor he's the world's best investor because he was investing billions of other people's money he had this enormous pile of float year and a 70 year runway yeah so he basically he had the equivalent of 6x leverage in his portfolio and that is what explains all the outperformance the his average annualized return without the
36:50Emmet:leverage is about 12 which is very average yeah that's s &p stuff so okay well i'm not gonna ask anymore because that's a great way to finish the quickfire round i'm gonna conclude porter by asking you about desert island stocks so without divulging anything that's privy to your paying members if you to own just two or three businesses for the next 20 years just a reminder that profit lets you benefit from successful stock investing without having to constantly think about it every four weeks it tells you exactly what to sell from your 10 stock portfolio and what to buy with the proceeds stick with the process through good markets and bad and 17 years of rigorous testing suggest you'll be very glad you did sign up today i'd start by emailing frank at my wall street.com if there's a discount going he has it okay on with the show what would you buy and hold today philip morris oh i knew you'd say that i knew you'd say that yeah is that's it that is it philip
37:59Porter Stansberry:morris would you would you buy a second philip morris uh is gonna outperform everything else
38:06Emmet:well that is one heck of an insight give us more tell us more why well do you know how much if you
38:14Porter Stansberry:put a dollar into philip morris and 1919 when it first sold securities to the public do you know how much money you'd have now from that one dollar this is probably like the rice and the chessboard
38:27Emmet:thing uh where you double it on every square i do not know i'm not going to divulge my mathematical ignorance with that kind of exponential mathematics about 4 million right right so
38:40Porter Stansberry:16 16 16 a year annualized return for more than 100 years so nothing nothing in the history of capitalism has made more money than philip morris nothing else comes close so just as i put you on
38:58Emmet:the spot by hitting you with names that i didn't prime you with uh it's coming right back at me because my hot take which is based on nothing except you know osmosis is that philip morris's business is going into decline i must be wrong yeah i think you're wrong i think most people
39:17Porter Stansberry:just don't understand what an incredible business philip morris is do you know do you know who invented the light beer?
39:27Emmet:Constellation brands, maybe?
39:30Porter Stansberry:Philip Morris.
39:31Emmet:You know, I kind of, I should have really said Philip Morris, considering our conversation.
39:36Porter Stansberry:So Philip Morris bought a brewer from Chicago out of bankruptcy in 1971. Forgive me if my dates are not exact. But they bought this brewery out of bankruptcy because it had a formula for light beer and they relaunched that beer as light l-i-t-e in 1972 and within three years of the launch of that product it was the best-selling
40:06Emmet:beer in the world and what was the name of what was the brand miller miller yeah okay um that is Miller Lite. Miller Lite, of course.
40:17Porter Stansberry:So people really don't understand what Philip Morris is, is the world's very best global branding and marketing business. And it's the best it's ever been. They created Marlboro. And they were very savvy about this. In America, the Marlboro man was a cowboy. But in Europe, he was an F1 driver.
40:38Emmet:Oh, yeah. It's the aspiration. Yeah. It's just so brilliant understanding the different cultures and the different ideas of masculinity in the different places.
40:47Porter Stansberry:They're absolutely brilliant. And the death of a cigarette is vastly overrated or whatever, overstated. Yeah, there's a quote in there. Cigarette volumes are increasing globally, not decreasing.
41:02Emmet:I never would have guessed.
41:03Porter Stansberry:And watch content. If you watch Netflix, how many people were smoking cigarettes on Peaky Blinders?
41:10Emmet:Probably plenty. I haven't seen the show, but probably plenty. Right, right.
41:15Porter Stansberry:All of them. So it's just the ways that they find to get their marketing out are still very savvy, very sophisticated. And they're just the best in the world at doing M &A around great consumer products. So what is it now? Four years ago, I believe, they bought a business called Swedish Match. and the whole history of the Swedish Match Company is really interesting. If you want to read a good book, go read the history of Swedish Match. It's extraordinary. It was started by a corrupt fellow selling or buying match monopolies all around the world. And I can't remember his name right now. It escapes me.
41:58Porter Stansberry:But he ended up, he ended up, it was giant financial fraud underlying all this and he ended up killing himself. But Swedish Match continued and Philip Morris bought it about four years ago because they had this new kind of nicotine product called Zen. And Zen is a cornstarch infused with nicotine that you put on your gum in a little package. And so it allows people...
42:24Emmet:Very Swedish.
42:25Porter Stansberry:It allows people to enjoy their nicotine addiction without carcinogens.
42:31Emmet:And you go off to Sweden, They always wear these little nicotine patches inside their gum. You could be talking to someone in Stockholm and you're thinking, what's wrong? Are they a boxer? No, they're wearing these little nicotine patches inside their gum.
42:45Porter Stansberry:Yeah, we call them lip pillows.
42:47Emmet:Lip pillows.
42:49Porter Stansberry:Anyways, that part of Philip Morris' business is growing dramatically. And they control about 75 % of the total global market for those kinds of nicotine pouches. They also have this incredible new heated tobacco product called Icos, I-C-O-S. And it's the thing to have if you want to smoke in Japan. And it's an electronic cigarette, but it actually warms up a Tabasco. a tobacco stick. And so it gives you the exact sensation of smoking, but it does so without lighting it. And so therefore it doesn't have the same amount of carcinogens. It's much safer. It's much easier on your lungs, et cetera.
43:38Porter Stansberry:And that product, Icos, is only now launching in the United States. In 10 years, that product alone will be another$10 billion business for them in the US.
43:49Emmet:That is fascinating. I'm so glad we dived into that thank you for that porter so that's my desert iron that's my desert desert island stock wonderful choice i never thought you'd change my mind in such a short period of time on a business that i'd somewhat put into the vice bucket in decline not relevant makes you sick and even all those different diverse or sorry related diversifications are just absolutely on point
44:14Porter Stansberry:can i say one more thing about philip morris please do and this this will make a lot of people very upset. But look, I'm a realist. I didn't create this. I didn't make the rules. I'm just describing them.
44:28Emmet:Okay.
44:28Porter Stansberry:You think about how many humans that there are in the world. And think about how many of them are capable of producing anything or compounding capital in any way. Not many. Lots of people are good at consuming. Very few people are good at producing. Very few, remarkably few. There's a reason why 1 % of the people own half the world. It's because they're that much smarter and faster and better. They just are. The reason why Philip Morris will always be the highest profits in all of capitalism is because they figured out a way to make billions of worthless people miniature compounding machines. people who cannot save a dime in their lives will find five dollars for a pack of cigarettes every goddamn day you want you want to see a mode want to see a motivated human being go talk to a crack addict they find a way and so if you went into ireland in 1970s everybody well most people
45:30Emmet:were poor like they lived within their means they couldn't go much further than their needs but everybody smoked everybody always had a cigarette so that that is the that is the secret
45:42Porter Stansberry:mad genius of what they do and it is an unstoppable economic force that's an absolutely perfect ending
45:50Emmet:uh porter as you said at the top of the show i'm really looking forward to seeing you meeting you in person in a few weeks time at the tail end of march here in dublin we'll tell our listeners more about that uh as we get closer to the date in the meantime all that remains is for me to thank you sincerely for joining me on Stock Club today and happy investing.
46:10Porter Stansberry:Thanks, Emma. It was a great pleasure to be here. I look forward to seeing you in a couple of weeks.
From the publisher
This week, Emmet is joined by a legend in financial publishing, Porter Stansberry. Porter is a master at recognizing and managing financial risk—and educating the public along the way. He even delivered positive returns during the 2008 financial crisis.
Porter shares his bull and bear case for America, weighing freedom of opportunity against excessive borrowing. He’s wary of U.S. Treasuries and worries the country could face a technical default similar to those in 1933 and 1971. He also outlines his views on the A.I. bubble, drawing lessons from the Dot-Com era.
Tune in to hear why Porter believes corporate spinoffs are underappreciated investments, the role of gold in your portfolio, and which psychological traits differentiate successful investors.
We wrap up with Buy, Hold, or Sell and an edition of Desert Island Stocks.
Prophet, MyWallSt's latest investing service, is focused on delivering market-beating in less than 5 minutes a month.
Click here to join now or email frank@mywallst.com for a deal.
Become a successful investor by checking out all the content MyWallSt has to offer:
📩 Email us: pod@mywallst.com
📚 Learn the fundamentals of investing by downloading our free Learn app: https://bit.ly/3DXPOz7
💻 Keep updated on stock market news by visiting our blog: https://mywallst.com/blog/
🎧 Tune in to our podcast Stock Club to stay updated on weekly news: https://mywallst.com/stock-investment-podcast/
🎉 Follow MyWallSt on social:
❌ X: @MyWallStHQ
💃 TikTok: @MyWallSt
📸 Instagram: @MyWallSt
🖥️ Facebook: @MyWallSt
👔 LinkedIn: MyWallSt
00:00 Intro
04:56 The Bull and Bear Case for America12:23 Navigating the AI Investment Landscape17:00 The Value of Corporate Spinoffs22:08 Psychological Traits of Successful Investors24:23 Investing in Essential Services31:39 Quickfire Round: Buy, Hold, or Sell36:30 Desert Island Stocks
