1. Podcasts
  2. Strict Scrutiny
  3. We Need to Talk About Ethics Reform
Strict Scrutiny

1 Oct 2026 · 47m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

We Need to Talk About Ethics Reform

In short

Supreme Court ethics reform and church-state backlash in Texas public schools; argues SCOTUS lacks meaningful accountability and should follow enforceable ethics rules like gift limits, disclosures, and recusal standards.

Guests and backgrounds

Gabe Roth, founder/executive director of Fix the Court (since 2014), focused on making the Supreme Court democratically accountable. Also cited: Ted Lowe, Texas parent in a lawsuit; interfaith family (Ted Jewish, Rebecca Christian) with kids in Texas public schools.

Key claims

SCOTUS is “most powerful, least accountable” because impeachment/removal is virtually impossible. Justices claim Congress can’t bind them, but they file annual financial disclosures created by Congress. The 2023 Supreme Court code is voluntary/unenforceable and enforcement infrastructure is missing (no ethics counsel/inspector general).

Notable examples

Texas law requiring Ten Commandments displays; families suing to Supreme Court. Gift examples: Fix the Court cites hundreds of accepted gifts over 20 years, including lavish private-plane and yacht trips. Alito’s Wall Street Journal remarks about Congress lacking authority. Recusal example: AFPF vs. Bonta (Barrett/Kavanaugh confirmation donations; no recusal).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:04

Identifying the Ethics Problem

Discuss the issues surrounding Supreme Court ethics and accountability.

“And this year, 5 million children across Texas are going to be greeted by, wait for it, the Ten Commandments in their classrooms.”
2:04

Identifying the Ethics Problem

Discuss the issues surrounding Supreme Court ethics and accountability.

“And I say that with admiration and appreciation on reforming the Supreme Court and making it more democratically accountable.”
3:16

The Need for Stronger Ethics Rules

Examine the necessity of implementing stronger ethics rules for the Supreme Court.

“And I think that's even more so now than it was when we started in 2014.”
5:26

Justice Perspectives on Accountability

Explore how justices perceive their accountability and ethics compliance.

“And they right now are subject to no meaningful accountability mechanisms short of impeachment, which under the Constitution is virtually impossible.”
8:00

The Impact of Recent Revelations

Analyze recent reports highlighting the ethical concerns among justices.

“The lower courts, I think, have stopped contesting that they can be bound and required to file annual financial disclosure reports.”
10:00

Potential Legislative Solutions

Discuss proposed legislative measures to enforce ethics rules in the Supreme Court.

“And that, I think, evinces a fundamental misunderstanding of these core separation of powers principles, which is that every branch is subject to checks from other branches.”
12:24

Future of Supreme Court Ethics

Speculate on the future of ethics regulations and the interaction with Congress.

“And I have a whole host of them that, you know, we can we can talk about.”
14:00

The Debate on Supreme Court Ethics

Explore the complexities of ethics reform for the Supreme Court justices.

“The Supreme Court now has, I mean, back then it was like$100 million.”
21:55

Proposals for Legislative Changes

Discuss the potential legislative package to improve ethics in the judiciary.

“Again, I know there's some bills out there, but our listeners are not going to be as steeped in the specifics as you are.”
28:00

Understanding Gift Bans and Recusal

Learn about the challenges of enforcing gift bans for justices and the recusal process.

“When you're a public official and you talk to groups and you visit locations, people do give you pens and plaques and T-shirts.”
Show all 14 chapters
29:50

Expanding Recusal Rules

Explore proposals to enhance recusal laws for justices and their implications.

“But I guess sort of would this potential inspector general or other kind of enforcement authority also advise on or issue kind of, you know, binding guidance to the justices on recusal or just how would recusal work?”
33:10

The Case for Nonpartisan Ethics Reform

Discover why ethics reform for the Supreme Court should be a bipartisan issue.

“And his language was the justices shall write a code of conduct that is at least as strict as that which applies to the lower courts.”
36:10

The Argument for Term Limits

Discuss the merits of implementing term limits for Supreme Court justices.

“And I think, yeah, I mean, maybe for very different – it's like the Supreme Court's sort of very low approval ratings right now.”
42:05

The Case for Supreme Court Term Limits

Discussion about the necessity and implications of term limits for Supreme Court justices.

“So, you know, it's not going to be a perfect nine justice, 18 year rotation for maybe a decade or two.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Strict Scrutiny, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Strict Scrutiny is brought to you by Americans United for Separation of Church and State. Guess what, folks? It's back to school season. And this year, 5 million children across Texas are going to be greeted by, wait for it, the Ten Commandments in their classrooms. Texas politicians passed a law requiring the Ten Commandments to be displayed in every public school classroom, forcing their religion on every kid in those schools. 28 families in Texas, supported by Americans United for Separation of Church and State, are taking the fight to the Supreme Court, and we need you to amplify their voices before the Supreme Court gets its hands on this case.

0:35They're going to go up, but we're going to fight to get them taken down. That was Texas public school parent Ted Lowe. Ted and Rebecca Lowe are an interfaith couple. Ted is Jewish and Rebecca is Christian, and their kids are in Texas public schools. The story that they tell in this video is moving, and we hope that everyone hears it and shares it, because there is a human cost to Christian nationalist policies like these Ten Commandments laws and the decisions that the Supreme Court hands down. You can visit au.org forward slash 10c to learn more about this case and how you can help join the fight to protect church-state separation.

1:16Mr. Chief Justice, may it please the court. It's an old joke, but when a man argues against two beautiful ladies like this, they're going to have the last word. She spoke, not elegantly, but with unmistakable clarity. She said, I ask no favor for my sex. All I ask of our brethren is that they take their feet off our necks.

1:59Hello, and welcome back to Strict Scrutiny, your podcast about the Supreme Court and the legal culture that surrounds it. I'm Kate Shaw, your lone host for this edition of our special bonus series, Hot Supreme Court Reform September. And for this installment of our series, I'm delighted to be joined by returning guest Gabe Roth, who is the founder and executive director of Fix the Court, which for over a decade has been focused monomaniacally, you might even say. And I say that with admiration and appreciation on reforming the Supreme Court and making it more democratically accountable. Gabe, welcome back to Strict Scrutiny.

2:31Thanks so much for having me back, Kate. So as you know, Gabe, and listeners by now should know, we are spending September and just a sliver of October doing weekly deep dives on various SCOTUS reform proposals. We've talked about term limits and court expansion and jurisdictions tripping. And if you haven't listened to those episodes, please make sure to go back and do that. They're great conversations. But for today, I want to focus on Supreme Court ethics, although maybe at the end of the conversation we'll sort of broaden things out a bit. So, Gabe, Supreme Court ethics are something very much in your wheelhouse.

3:02This has been something that you've focused on for quite some time. And maybe before we talk about reform proposals, let's take a couple minutes and just identify the problem. So how would you describe the problem with the Supreme Court when it comes to ethics? I think if you just broaden it out, Fix the Court has, since we launched in 2014, has called the Supreme Court the most powerful, least accountable part of our federal government. And I think that's even more so now than it was when we started in 2014. And so I think the problem is that if we see something wrong, if we see some ethical malfeasance, there's really no way to fix it because there is no impeachment and removal.

3:44That's just never going to happen. And the Supreme Court, as has been articulated by some of the justices, believes, I think inaccurately, that it is above some of the laws that Congress passes. So, you know, if a justice, just to give an example, is accepting lavish gifts and going on all these free trips paid for by someone who clearly has a view on how the Supreme Court should be ruling in cases, there's at least currently little that we, the public and the public through its representatives in Congress, could do to sort of tamp that down. So I think there just needs to be stronger rules of the road, maybe some different personalities of the court down the line as well.

4:23But I think just as a sort of basic level, the way I like to think about it is if you're going to have a court that has arrogated to itself so much power, right? You and I were in college when Bushy Gore came out. And so the idea that the Supreme Court decides an election, I mean, the Supreme Court came down with a major election case just last night. We're recording this on the 15th. So on the 14th, they came out with a major election ruling. They're deciding many aspects of all our elections. The Supreme Court is going to have this much power to decide life or death and health care and voting and gerrymandering and elections and health care access and so much more.

4:57They should follow some of the same rules that other branches of government and even the lower court judges have to follow. So that's sort of like the big picture is like, you know, there's definitely a problem. And then I think given all the power the justices have, they should be looking elsewhere in government and following some of those rules. Yeah. So this is an institution with enormous power that it has asserted for itself over everything from elections, immigration, abortion and bodily integrity, public health, the environment. I mean, the list goes on. And they right now are subject to no meaningful accountability mechanisms short of impeachment, which under the Constitution is virtually impossible.

5:36in a highly polarized moment where you need supermajorities in the Senate to actually remove someone for office pursuant to the impeachment provisions of the Constitution. So enormous public power, enormous public power for life, and very little accountability. And so it's not only important that I think that the Supreme Court, like other government officials, be subject to some kind of ethics rules. In some ways, it's the most important branch to subject to binding ethics rules because they don't stand for regular election and they're not hauled before Congress for regular oversight like members of the executive branch, right?

6:10There just aren't the same kind of checks and accountability mechanisms. And so it seems really important that they be subject to binding ethics rules. And you alluded to this a little bit, but Gabe, will you say a little bit more? And I think this is very much part of the problem about what some of the justices seem to think about the applicability of the ethics rules that constrain all other members of public office to them. Like, how do they communicate their positions on whether whether they're bound at all by the laws that do exist? I mean, I think you're teeing me up for for the Justice Alito interview in The Wall Street Journal three years ago, and I'm happy to elaborate on that.

6:48But basically, he told the Wall Street Journal editorial board that Congress can't make laws that bind the justices for any sort of reason, which is super ironic because Justice Alito, the entire 36 years he served in the federal judiciary, has filed and submitted an annual financial disclosure report, which is required under 5 U.S.C. 13101 and following that he file. The justices actually did it voluntarily after the Fortis scandal in the late 60s, early 70s. But then after Watergate in 78, Congress passed the Ethics in Government Act requiring these disclosures. That went into effect in 81. Lower court judges actually sued so they wouldn't have to file annual financial disclosures because they were thought to be too invasive.

7:33They lost in the court below. SCOTUS denied cert in, I think, January of 1981. And then since then, the justices, all nine of them, every single year, have filed an annual financial disclosure report. That is 100 percent a creation of Congress, the fact that they do it every year. And same thing with the 2 ,400 lower court judges. So this idea that they can't be, you know, the Congress can't bind them to do anything is kind of ridiculous and disproven by their own annual activities with the filing of the disclosures. OK, yes. So absolutely. They have appeared to acquiesce. The lower courts, I think, have stopped contesting that they can be bound and required to file annual financial disclosure reports.

8:14The SCOTUS members as well filed these annual reports, although we can talk a little bit about the sometimes – Oh, they omit things. Oh, yeah. That's a problem. Yeah, sort of spotty practice. But at least they do, I think, through their conduct, seem to be acquiescing in the applicability of these mandatory filing requirements to them. And yet there are, I think, not. So Alito told The Wall Street Journal that basically Congress doesn't have any authority to regulate justices of the Supreme Court. But it's also the case, I think, that they have suggested that they are deciding to file these annual financial disclosure reports, but maybe just as a matter of grace and discretion as opposed to compliance with some binding directive that Congress has the authority to subject them to.

9:04So in 2023, following this wave of, I think, really blockbuster pieces, largely by ProPublica, revealing the degree to which several justices have been the beneficiaries of this largesse from kind of billionaire friends and benefactors, the justices announced for the first time that they were setting forth a code of conduct for the justices of the Supreme Court, which they said basically just formalized and announced to the public the practices that justices of the Supreme Court. already followed. And the filing of the annual financial disclosure reports are sort of on the list. But it almost sort of suggests that the willingness to file these annual reports is something that the justices are deciding to abide by, but only, again, because they have decided to do so rather than because Congress has enforced upon them this binding obligation.

9:58And so I kind of think that the filing of the annual financial disclosure reports is important, but the things they have said and communicated about why they are filing in some ways only underscores the problem, which is that they have announced that they are the kind of ultimate arbiters of the ethics rules that they are going to follow. And that, I think, evinces a fundamental misunderstanding of these core separation of powers principles, which is that every branch is subject to checks from other branches. That's pretty central to the design of the Constitution. And yet this Supreme Court seems to believe that it alone sort of stands outside of meaningful checks.

10:37And maybe it's going to decide to do some things that will promote a modicum of transparency, but, you know, it could decide differently tomorrow if it wanted to. So do you basically agree with that assessment? Yeah. So, yeah, that harkens back to a William Rehnquist authored memo in 1991 when the Ethics Reform Act was coming into effect. And that talked about, OK, there are these new gift rules that Congress is putting on itself and on the judiciary. We make no statement on the constitutionality of these new gift rules, but because we're nice guys and gals, we're going to follow them. So that was this memo.

11:10I'll link to it on fixthecourt.com. I'm sure we have it there. But yeah, it was the justice saying, okay, we have these new gift rules. We have these disclosure rules. We're going to follow them. I mean, the thing is that if they don't file a disclosure, if they lie in the disclosure. The attorney general can bring a civil action against the individual. But typically, it has to go through the judicial conference. And the judicial conference, which is the policymaking body of the judiciary, is run by Chief Justice Roberts and as a body runs interference on ethics issues. There's a judge in Georgia that had sex in her chambers and lied about it, and she should be impeached in the judicial conference.

11:48Their Committee on Judicial Misconduct could have done something and they didn't. The Judicial Council there didn't do anything. So the infrastructure of the judiciary itself, it's not just the court, it sort of insulates the justices from accountability. And I think what you were implying is that it might come to a head, right? If we have an enforceable ethics mechanism that is passed by a future Congress, if we have a gift ban rule, if we have certain rules about prediction markets or amicus filings or lobbying at the court, what have you, that might end up being decided by a Supreme Court. And what is the Supreme Court going to do?

12:24It doesn't mean I don't think we should try to get convinced a member of Congress to pass new ethics rules for the court. And I have a whole host of them that, you know, we can we can talk about. But, you know, I do think that that is an important point that and it but it's a similar I think it's similar to the conversation you had with Alicia on the on the term limits context, like the Supreme Court might say term limits are unconstitutional, but we still have to try. I mean, we still have to say, like, this is what we want the Supreme Court to look like from a length of tenure perspective or an ethics perspective.

12:52And if the Supreme Court ultimately turns down that law, I mean, look, in 2022, we got a bipartisan law passed that requires all the justices to post their disclosures online and to post their stock transactions online. It's an extension of the Stock Act that was passed for members of Congress 10 years earlier. Alito's posting his stocks. Roberts is posting his stocks. The justices, when they get, you know, they're following this law. So I think, you know, I'm sort of of the mind that when it comes to brass tacks, I'm going to be hopeful. And if it ends up coming to a constitutional head and the Supreme Court says, oh, these ethics laws are unconstitutional, then sure, let's ramp up.

13:31But I think we at least have to try to pass something stronger via legislation rather than acquiesce to this sort of, you know, Rehnquist, Alito-Thomas view that they can't do anything about us. Right. They would like, they are through these statements trying to communicate basically back off Congress because maybe anything that you try, we are going to assert the authority to invalidate. But that's, of course, not a reason to move forward because fundamentally they're wrong. Congress does have the authority to regulate them. And if not, we can take away their budget. I mean, this is something that we at Fix the Court have started years ago.

14:02I think it's catching on now. The Supreme Court now has, I mean, back then it was like$100 million. Now it's closer to$200 or$225. Half of that is for security. I think that's sacrosanct. The justices need to be safe. Like, that's no debate there. But the rest of the money. Exactly. We can take away the money for their law clerks. We can take the money for their printing and their judicial assistance and their lunches and their electricity or what have you. I'm okay with them keeping electricity. I think security electricity. You know what, Kate? They get electricity. They get those things. That's fine.

14:32But they don't get, yeah. Yeah, I think that the kind of the cudgel of the budget is really important. OK, so we jumped a little bit ahead to sort of like, right, what how a showdown might look if Congress actually did pass binding ethics rules with teeth that applied to the justices. I want to give you a caveat there, though, because I think it's important, because when we're talking about binding ethics rules, too, I think it's also important to remember, like, the goal of the binding ethics rules are not to make it so Clarence Thomas and Sam Alito no longer hear cases. Like, I just don't think a world exists where that is possible.

15:07I don't think there are 67 senators to impeach and remove. I don't think there's enough cases where recusals could be put into play. I mean, I'm sorry to disappoint that progressives who listen to this podcast, but I don't think that Thomas and Alito are going to leave other than when they decide to step down in 2027 or 2028. But the ethics, you know, but the ethics with the with enforceable ethics, you know, it's just it's having, you know, what I want to sort of put out there is like the fact that there is no inbox to file a complaint against a justice. The fact that there is no one within the court, right, personnel is policy.

15:43They haven't hired any ethics experts since the 2023 code came out, that there's nobody in the court and there should be an inspector general and ethics counsel and ethics investigation counsel and their bills that would do all of this within the court reviewing the justice's behavior to ensure that it's compliant. you know the fact that there there is no one doing that i mean i think that you know that might not be satisfactory for those of us and look i'm you know pissed off at the conservative six as much as anybody but you know to have somebody there that's reviewing this so the public understands what these justices are up to and what their foibles and their ethical malfeasance is i mean you know the fourth estate does a great job but we need somebody inside the building reviewing these these possible complaints but we currently don't even have that So I think it just it is when we talk about ethics, enforceable ethics, it's both sort of very high bar because no one's getting impeached and removed on the one hand.

16:34But on the other hand, it's a very low bar because it's like, let's at least have somebody in there and some sort of process. So the public feels that we know the ethical framework through which the justices are operating.

16:49Strict Scrutiny is brought to you by Quince. You know, those pieces in your closet you find yourself wearing on repeat. that sweater that goes with everything, the perfect pair of pants, or the furry blanket that your dog likes to lie on all the time. Those are the pieces that make your life easy, and that's what Quince does best. Quince focuses on high-quality wardrobe staples made with premium materials like 100 % Mongolian cashmere, organic cotton, and merino wool. Their styles are timeless, versatile, and designed to become the dependable pieces you reach for day after day. Their 100 % Mongolian cashmere sweaters are my personal faves, and they start at just$60, giving you the softness and quality that you would expect from a luxury brand, but without the luxury price tag.

17:36And everything at Quince is priced 50 % to 80 % less than similar brands. They work directly with ethical factories, and they cut out the middleman, so you're paying for high quality, not a brand markup. I love it. And it's not just clothing or furry blankets. Quince brings that same approach to every single thing they make, from hotel quality bedding, their linen sheets are A +, and bath and kitchen essentials, and thoughtfully designed furniture. All of it is fantastic because Quince makes well-designed pieces for everyday living. So head over to Quince.com and find your next fall favorites.

18:13You can download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to Quince.com slash strict. You get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. And here's the best part for you folks across the pond and to the north. Quinn's is now available in Canada and the UK. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E dot com slash strict. Strict Student is brought to you by Jones Road Beauty. Here's the thing about aging, folks. Like, it's not just about finding a skincare routine that works for you. It's also about finding a makeup routine that works as well. Because as you get older, you develop fine lines and wrinkles, makeup can actually be a challenge, maybe even a problem as it seeps into those fine lines, making you look less fresh.

18:56That is why I love Jones Road Beauty. It's so refreshing when you have a product that actually enhances your skin instead of just caking on layers of makeup. The Jones Road Miracle Balm is just that. It's an absolute miracle that allows you to get a glowy look in under a minute, and it has earned a permanent spot in my everyday makeup routine. I can just dab a little bit on my cheeks, look a little bit more alive than I did before, and keep it moving. So if you've already simplified your routine with Miracle Bomb, Jones Road just launched another product that's going to fit right into your streamlined makeup routine.

19:33Their new Minimalist Defining Mascara is all about enhancing your natural lashes, not covering them up. The flexible silicone wand separates every lash for a soft, feathery look that makes it easy to coat every single lash, even those tiny lashes in the inside corners. Jones Road, modern day makeup that's clean, strategic, and multifunctional for effortless routines. And for a limited time, our listeners are getting a free full-size mascara on their first purchase when they use the code STRICT at checkout. Just head to jonesroadbeauty.com, use code STRICT at checkout, and after your purchase, they're going to ask you where you heard about them.

20:09Please tell them that you heard about Jones Road from the effortlessly glowing ladies of Strict Scrutiny with their miracle bombs. Thank you. Strict Scrutiny is brought to you by Cook Unity. Guess what, folks? I hate cooking. This is not a secret, but you know what? I do love eating. That means I have a disjunction. And Cook Unity is what enables me to fill the gap. Cook Unity is the first chef-led meal delivery service that makes your meals in small batches inside local micro kitchens all across the United States, not in factories. So every dish arrives at the kind of freshness you would get at a restaurant itself.

20:46And the meals are from Michelin starred chefs, James Beard winners, and Food Network stars. So head over to cookunity.com for a short strict or use code strict before checkout for 50 % off your first week. I just finalized my meals for my next orders, and I cannot wait to try the smoked chicken chili with Greek yogurt. Yum. And here's my new favorite, the chicken and dumplings. Old school comfort, but without old school slaving over the stove. Every CookUnity meal is handcrafted by chefs in local micro kitchens, not mass produced in large facilities. So they're fresh, never frozen, and they can be refrigerated for up to seven days.

21:23CookUnity uses real culinary talent, cooking in real kitchens. It's not a brand just slapping a chef's name on some factory product. And there are hundreds of dishes to choose from. And the menu is updated constantly. So taste what happens when real award-winning chefs make fresh, small-batch meals just for you. Go to cookunity.com forward slash strict or enter code strict before checkout to get 50 % off your first order. That's 50 % off your first order by using code strict or going to cookunity.com slash strict. Get on it. Get eating.

22:04Okay, so why don't you give me a few bullets, which are you've mentioned gift ban and prediction markets, and just maybe give me like four or five, six bullets of what an ideal legislative package in terms of the substance would look like. Again, I know there's some bills out there, but our listeners are not going to be as steeped in the specifics as you are. So talk about some of the specifics and then maybe to say a little bit more whether an ethics counsel, an inspector general, both sort of what it would look like to have some independent or quasi independent actors inside the judicial branch and maybe inside the Supreme Court specifically that actually enforce these new rules were they to go into effect.

22:42Sure. So I think that's foot in the door. Just get in there. Talk a little bit about what we need to do to fix things. That, to me, is the gift ban bill. Currently, there's a bill introduced by Congressman Raskin in the House and Senator Lujan Raskin from Maryland, Lujan from New Mexico in the Senate, that would effectively place upon not only the Supreme Court justices, but all 2 ,400 federal judges, the same gift acceptance rules that members of the other two branches have to follow. And it's a little bit different branch to branch. I mean, the executive branch, it's usually$20, but obviously, like, there are a million emoluments right now.

23:18So what does that even mean? Congress, it's$50. The reason it's not$0 is you don't want to get in trouble if you, like, take a pen away from a constituent event or, like, get a free Starbucks coffee when someone's passing it down in line or whatever. So it would be a$50 limit for gifts for a single gift and then$100 for the year. So to me, that is sort of like the very basic, we should be able to get a bipartisan consensus on this. And to be clear, there is not such a ban in place when it comes to federal judges at the moment. That is really striking. Yeah. And we've, Fixed the Court has identified something like more than, I think it was 515 gifts that the justices have accepted over the last 20 years.

23:57And that's ridiculous. I mean, some of them are, you know, Justice Sotomayor got a pin from the University of Vermont that's, you know, five bucks or whatever. Justice Gorsuch got a silver julep cup from one of the schools in Kentucky because they're all about their mint juleps there that was like worth 50 bucks. But some of these are flights on a private plane across the world worth tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars or free yacht trips around the world worth tens of hundreds of thousands of dollars. The justices all make$300 ,000 a year. None of them are poor. They can all afford their vacations.

24:31They can all afford a julep cup if they want one. And so to me, just requiring the justices have the same rules as members of Congress on the gift makes a ton of sense. And so that's sort of that's sort of number one. And I think number two would be creating sort of an enforceable ethics framework that is very similar to what we have in the lower courts. Right. So I filed a complaint against Judge Emile Bovee on the Third Circuit. He attended a Trump rally. I couldn't find any history of sitting federal judges attending a political rally. I filed a complaint against him. That's being reviewed currently.

25:05Can't really talk much more about it because there's confidentiality rules around it. But I know that is being reviewed by a panel of judges somewhere in America. OK. Right. So you can do that. So Bove sits on the Third Circuit. It turns out you as a concerned member of the public, you know, a watchdog or even just a citizen who is interested. I live in Virginia. I've never met the guy. But there's a mechanism for doing that, for initiating a complaint when you think that some improper conduct has occurred. There is just no such process when it comes to the Supreme Court justices. Exactly. So that would be number two.

25:32So we just be creating some sort of mechanism, whether it's reviewed by an inspector general or some sort of internal ethics office. The Office of Legal Counsel, you know, kind of as useful as maybe the DOJ OLC at the moment, for those of you who know, you know, but they have an OLC. I'll say, actually, it's very good lawyers in that office, and they just have a remit or mandate that does not encompass the kinds of sort of ethics enforcement. Ethan, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to diss you. No, it's just, it is a small office, and it has kind of a time-honored function, but that does not encompass, at least, you know, when I was familiar with it, this kind of evaluation of the ethical propriety of certain courses of conduct that justices might want to take or gifts they might want to receive or things like that.

26:17And I think that it would be difficult to expand their mandate to include this kind of work. I think much more realistic would be creating something new, a new entity and populated with new people. Yeah, exactly. So I think that's sort of number two is figuring out what that is. I think there's room for both an internal ethics office at the court and then sort of a branch-wide judiciary inspector general chuck grassley had a bill to do that for about a dozen years um he's no longer on it now it's uh dick blumenthal so it was a republican bill now it's a democratic bill it's like 99 the same bill but over the last two decades republicans and democrats alike have seen the value of having an inspector general in the judiciary there's an inspector general in all the agencies and the executive branch and then Congress has its own internal, there's no inspector general per se, but they have internal ethics bodies, the Senate Ethics Committee, the House Ethics Committee, and other ombudsmen.

27:12So something like that in the judiciary, that would be, you know, we'd be funded through the judiciary, it'd be Article III. I think you have to appoint it by, I think you have to have Chief Justice Roberts appointed. I don't think you could have a president appointing an inspector general for the judiciary. That'd get a little fishy from separation of powers issues. But have Roberts in point, you know, I don't know, Tom Griffith, Mike McConnell, Greg Costa, Paul Watford, you know, a former judge who's hanging out, doing their thing. Yeah, it's hard to see what constitutional objection you could possibly formulate to Congress creating an office.

27:45I mean, Congress creates, you know, the all aspects of the lower federal courts and has passed a lot of laws regulating different aspects of the Supreme Court, even though the Supreme Court itself is created by the Constitution. The specifics, like the details, are filled in by Congress. And so this would be that. And then giving the chief justice the authority to appoint, say, the inspector general, I think, would sidestep any possible constitutional objection. And then so in terms of what such an office would do, so we have potentially enforcing this gift ban, advising on whatever, wherever the line is, because I think it's right that it's pretty customary to say certain kinds of de minimis value items that are exchanged all the time.

28:25When you're a public official and you talk to groups and you visit locations, people do give you pens and plaques and T-shirts. And there's nothing really objectionable about that. And so you figure out where the line is. Yeah, but above that, there's no conceivable public-facing reason to give the justices the authority to take high-value items and all kinds of reasons to prohibit it. And so figuring out how to enforce that would be one piece of it. What about – we haven't really talked about recusals, and that's something that I'd be curious to hear a little bit about. So under the plain terms, I think, of 20 at USC section 455, federal judges and justices are required to recuse themselves or disqualify themselves, quote, in any proceeding in which their impartiality might reasonably be questioned.

29:08I also think the commentary to the 2023 code suggests that there might be some question about whether that statute clearly applies to the justices. There's like this language in the commentary that's attached to the code about how sometimes the duty to sit or the rule of necessity, like you need to have a quorum of Supreme Court justices. And so this kind of disqualification directive in the statute has to be understood in light of this kind of other principle that the Supreme Court is unique because you need the justices all to sit. Now, you actually only need six to make a quorum, but that disqualification is problematic on the Supreme Court in a way that it's not in the lower federal courts, at least in the view of, I think, this current Supreme Court.

29:49Anyway, so sorry, that's kind of a long windup. But I guess sort of would this potential inspector general or other kind of enforcement authority also advise on or issue kind of, you know, binding guidance to the justices on recusal or just how would recusal work? Yeah, I think I think binding guidance would be tough. I think the justices, the best that we've come up with, those of us who have thought about it in terms of legislative language, is if you are a litigant and you want a justice to recuse one of the nine, you can file a recusal motion. And then the eight other justices would decide the merits of that recusal motion.

30:24And then that justice should follow the recommendation of the eight other justices. The problem is that we, all of us, all humans, are terrible at understanding the levels of our own bias. And so the idea that if I file a recusal motion against Justice Gorsuch to recuse in some case, I don't even know what, you know, he's currently, and I'm a litigant, he's the only person who can decide that motion. And that is completely ridiculous. So like I said, you know, the best is take the one, pass it off to the other eight. Are the other eight going to run interference for that one? maybe but i think it's worth having the other justices say okay this is why i think that you know justice corps such in this case should or should not participate in that case and so i think and there are ways to expand the recusal rules and i think you're right if you look at the code of conduct and you look at some supreme court precedent it's it's you know the federal law says impartiality reasonably questioned you have to recuse shall you have to recuse then you look at the supreme court the jurisprudence the common law it's like well actually if it's an unbiased person who knows all the facts of the case, who understands the law.

31:29It's like they're adding all these stipulations that are not part of federal law. So I think, you know, A, getting rid of stipulation is theoretically possible in statute, number one. Number two, expanding the recusal law to say, okay, you know, if you're a litigant and you've donated money for the confirmation, right? There was a case AFPF versus Bonta and AFP, which is the sister organization of AFPF donated a million dollars to get Barrett and Kavanaugh on the court. And they didn't recuse an AFPF versus Bonta. And I thought that was kind of ridiculous. You know, a million dollars is not like, you know, here's three dollars to support somebody, you know, whatever.

32:05Like it's that was a that was a huge amount of money to get those two justices confirmed. And then when their sister organization had this big case, First Amendment case before SCOTUS, all nine justices heard that case. So I thought that was a little ridiculous. And there's also ways to include... And lo and behold, I think ruled for the organization with it was challenging on First Of course they did. The regulation that they didn't like. So I think there's ways to expand it. Spousal jobs. I think that there's a lot of concern about Chief Justice Roberts' wife's job because she's a legal recruiter.

32:34I think that's overblown. But I think there is definitely concern about what Ginny Thomas was doing in January 6th. And if she had sort of a financial motivation to try to stop the certification of the 2020 election, we need to know about it. And Justice Thomas should recuse. So there's ways to, you know, sort of at the margins, expand the recusal law. If you've given a gift to the justice in the path, you should be required to recuse up to a certain point in time. So I definitely think there's ways to improve it and make it clear. But I think the larger and this is actually just to mention Senator Murphy just put out a bill.

33:05It's called the Supreme Court Ethics Act. He's put out a version of this every Congress since 2011. So, you know, he's not he's been on this for a while. And his language was the justices shall write a code of conduct that is at least as strict as that which applies to the lower courts. So the fact that the justices in their 2023 code wrote something that was not only not enforceable, but not even as strict as their lower court compadres was kind of ridiculous. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I find myself nervous about a lot of these legislative proposals that seem so cautious about doing anything that appears too direct to vis-a-vis the justices and just hands them the authority to do everything.

33:44And I sort of worry a little bit, but I understand wanting to respect and be mindful of constitutional lines. But I think the over deterrence that I think we are seeing that the Supreme Court has sort of saber rattled. And so everyone says, well, we're going to be really careful not to overregulate because you might strike down what we do is also a real problem. But certainly, whatever the source, whether it's Congress legislating directly or Congress telling the justices to promulgate something, it is crazy that this incredibly powerful body shouldn't be subject to ethics rules that are at least as strict as those that are applicable to the lower federal courts.

34:14Like, it's really wild. So let me ask you to follow up on something that you said a couple of minutes ago. So you mentioned that Grassley, of course, is a Republican senator from Iowa, for many years introduced a version of the bill that would have created an inspector general that is now kind of a Democratic priority. But I think the sort of deeper point is that for a long time, and you think correctly, this has been a sort of nonpartisan and non-ideological issue, injecting some degree of ethics rules into the Supreme Court. And so can you talk a little bit about this? I've heard you talk about this before, but can you just like make the case that Supreme Court reform and ethics reform in particular should be a nonpartisan and non-ideological issue?

34:55Sure. So first I'm going to make the shitty case and then I'll make the real case. So the shitty case is conservatives, you're winning at the court. You should want a court that is above board ethically, that people aren't doubting their ethical forbearance and their decision to come out this way because there is a sense in the public that they are acting unethical. So the justices should be doing as much as they can ethically to propel. And, you know, you still have a 6-3 court at the end of the day, right? If you have all these ethical rules, the math is the math. I mean, there are other groups that want to, you know, I'm happy to talk about jurisdiction stripping or expansion or whatever, but that's not really what I do.

35:31I do mostly ethics and about half, it's actually half lower court, half SCOTUS. But, you know, the point is that, you know, if you're a conservative, you should want the court to be looking better than it is now and putting upon themselves ethical frameworks because you are winning. Right. People are doubting why you are winning because they think that you're doing it via underhanded unethical means. So that's sort of a. I would disparage it. That is a case if you're trying to build like a really big tent. And I think you're right. It's harder to build like a really broad constituency for some of these other kinds of reforms.

36:03But ethics, I think, is the one that has the most realistic chance of actually attracting sort of broad support. And I think, yeah, I mean, maybe for very different – it's like the Supreme Court's sort of very low approval ratings right now. And I talked to Jamel Bowie about this. You know, a lot of it is liberals were really unhappy, and I think rightly so, with the court. But then there's also this conservative contingent that is mad the court hasn't been more MAGA. And so anyway, that's – together, you get like a 33 percent approval rating. Anyway, so I actually do think there is a world you can imagine where Supreme Court ethics reform actually gets across a legislative finish line because there are people who have very different reasons to be unhappy with SCOTUS.

36:41So anyway, but so the conservative case is that you want a court that actually is not going to be dogged by these accusations or suspicions that it's acting for improper motives, that it's doing all these conservative things and people sort of have to accept those. So you like the court, you should support ethics reform. What's the other case? The other case is that the Supreme Court is not different from any other government institution. Just because it's mentioned in Article 3 of the Constitution, and we have this reverence for it, and we even have reverence for individual justices, which is so weird.

37:18I mean, there's no such thing as the Scalia seat or the Ginsburg seat or anyone's seat. It's just people who are supposedly doing, supposed to be doing a job and then getting out and, you know, riding circuit after they retire like Justice O 'Connor did and even Justice Breyer is doing as well. But anytime you have an institution with that much power, you want them to sort of, you know, follow the same rules as everyone else. And I think we've sort of, you know, people, I guess. OK, so I'll say it this way. People think, oh, the Supreme Court is different. They're not political. They're above us all.

37:54We have to have a Supreme Court because they decide if, you know, two different circuits or whatever disagree or if there's a tough question of politics or constitutional law. Yes, but at the same time, to me, it's the substance, right? It's what they are deciding and how much power they have that requires them to have this strong ethical framework. Having Congress pass laws that make ethics happen doesn't make the court political. If anything, it tamps down the politicization of the court. They've already decided that gerrymandering isn't a thing, that the Voting Rights Act isn't a thing, that they're going to stick their noses in basically every federal election that we ever have.

38:37um and so because of that they there is sort of a floor after upon which they should be operating and they are not currently doing that and and that to me is a big opportunity no matter who you support no matter you know left right center and so you know in the end um you know it should be something that that that the left and right can agree on i have an op-ed in scotus blog about why that is and you can read that or whatever if you're interested. But overall, and historically, because it hasn't been a partisan issue, you know, I'm hoping that, you know, maybe after Thomas and Alito retire, it can become a little bit more bipartisan because there are such lightning rods these days.

39:19But in the long run, you know, my hope in creating a nonpartisan nonprofit is that we can sort of return to first principles, which is all three government branches should be equally ethical all the time. I worry a little bit about having to wait for Alito and Thomas to exit the stage to do something. I mean, this feels like... I think they'll be gone in the next 18 months, but you know. That's fascinating. Okay. Well, and then I suppose the legislative agenda sort of would kind of align in terms of timing, but I guess, you know, I'll have to have you back in 18 months and see where things stand.

39:51Maybe just one or two more questions. So you've said You mostly do focus on ethics reform, but if you were going to sort of think more broadly than just ethics reform, are there things that you think should be done to change SCOTUS beyond the stuff that we've been talking about? You're going to make me talk about term limits, aren't you? Okay, here we go. So, look, I think I – at first – so when FISTACourt started in 2014, term limits wasn't one of the fixes because it was so entrenched within the conservative movement. and I was trying to create a nonpartisan nonprofit. So if I had term limits, everyone's gonna be like, oh, you're conservative.

40:29Then as sort of we moved into 2015, I started talking about term limits and all my liberal friends were like, why are you trying to reduce the 10 years of Hillary's justices? And I'm like, okay, well, and you obviously everyone knows how 2016 turned out. So regardless, we decided in 2015 to add term limits. I think that having justices, I was really sort of convinced by this law review article by David Garrow, who's an Obama biographer and Pulitzer Prize winning historian, basically showing that in every generation, a justice has lost their mental acuity before they retired. So even someone, you know, everyone knows the William O.

41:07Douglas example, but even Brennan and Marshall, they were examples of them sort of slipping towards the end. Ginsburg and Scalia were definitely not as sharp towards the end as they were earlier in their careers. So I think the idea that you have justices who serve for a time and not for all time, which in this case is 30 or 35 years, is something that we need to institute. I think the only way to do it, however, is to have them be prospective. So in other words, you'd add a new justice, that justice would be serving for 18 years for life on the federal judiciary, 18 years of which would be on the Supreme Court, and then they'd rotate off and serve on, you know, the regional court in Boston, Chicago, New Orleans, Cincinnati, wherever, or retire or whatever.

41:47They can do whatever they want to do. I don't think you can reduce the tenure of the current justices. So what this means in practice is that if there's a Democratic president in 2029 and term limits is instituted, that justice might be the 10th justice for a time if the nine who are sitting in 2029 don't want to leave. So, you know, it's not going to be a perfect nine justice, 18 year rotation for maybe a decade or two. So there might be 10 justices, 11 justices. I'm fine with that. And I polled Republicans, Democrats and independents about this a few years ago, I think 2021, and they were, they were all fine with that better than the current system of 40 year, you know, we're getting close to 35, 40 year 10 years.

42:24So, you know, I don't think you can reduce the 10 years of the current nine. But I think that if you have justices who have prospective term limits, you would, you know, in a little and, you know, take a little while, but you'd have that perfect nine justice, 18 year term limit rotation. And there's a bill in Congress, it's HR 1074 that would do that. and, you know, hoping it'll continue to be introduced in every Congress until one day it's enacted into law. Yeah. I really like it. I had sort of a similar conversation with Alicia Bannon about coming to the place of supporting term limits. I think that we different people have had different trajectories around them.

42:57And mine was a little bit different. It sounds like yours and Alicia's. But but it is interesting that people with very different kind of priors have over the years, like with enough thought and also given the trajectory that the court has been on, come sometimes sort of unwillingly, but come to believe that actually some version of term limits and, yeah, maybe paired with either deliberate or just kind of functional court expansion as part of the implementation of the term limits actually is really, really important and actually kind of goes in some ways hand in glove with this question of ethics reform.

43:34Right now, enormous power, service for life, few meaningful constraints, and also like, you know, an unamendable constitution. This is a truly intolerable state of affairs. And it's, I think, going to require a multi-prong and multi-front and maybe multi-year effort to actually address it. But all of it, I think, is necessary to get to a place of a healthy, functioning Supreme Court consistent with our constitutional design because we are very, very far from that right now. Okay, Gabe, if people want to learn more about ethics reform and want to hear more from you and about Fix the Court, where should they go to do that?

44:09Sure. We're at FixTheCourt.com, at FixTheCourt on your favorite or least favorite social media platform of choice. I'm Gabe at FixTheCourt.com, and we have staff monitoring the info at FixTheCourt and every other combination and permutation thereof. But yeah, I would love to hear from you. I mean, I think that people talk about the big tent in politics, this and that. I think there really needs to be a big tent in court reform. And if you're just a regular person or congressional staff or, you know, a member of the judiciary and you have a question, like, I've probably thought about it and I may not support it.

44:46I may have, you know, we may, we may not. But I think it's worth having that conversation with people who have sort of been thinking about this issue for a long time. And then, you know, we can go from there and see what makes the most sense to try to push legislatively. But, you know, a lot of these proposals, especially when you talk about Congress, they're going to need to pass by wide margins, right? I don't think that, you know, future Congresses are going to spend three weeks debating a Supreme Court ethics regime. It's going to have to pass with, you know, 60 votes, 70 votes, 100 votes, because that's just the way Congress works nowadays.

45:18And so, you know, I think the way that we get to consensus is sort of, you know, taking down the temperature about individual justices or even individual rulings. I think there's definitely a place for that outside the ethics conversation and figuring out ways that, you know, we can expand the tent and expand the view of what smart Supreme Court ethics reform looks like and how we're doing it not to necessarily hurt or help one party or one political view or another, but how we can make and create a Supreme Court that we all feel proud of and that we all trust that their hearts and minds and ethical mores are in the right place.

45:54All right. Well, this sounds like sort of a fantasy land right now, but I do think it feels like a place that we just have to sort of start to try to figure out how to move toward. Thank you so much, Gabe Roth from Fix the Court, for joining me today. Really appreciate the time and your relentless focus on this issue. Thank you.

46:23with the Writers Guild of America East.

46:41As someone tuned into politics, you've probably seen the constant bickering about who belongs in the pro-democracy movement. Well, we think it's best to have these conversations in person, and hopefully it will also be more productive. Crooked Con is right after the midterms, and it is going to be the first time we come together to hash it out in person and kick off the 2028 debate. We just posted a ton more info about what to expect from the big event on Saturday, so check it out at crookedcon.com and get your tickets now. See you in DC.

From the publisher

In the fifth and final installment of our Hot Supreme Court Reform series, Kate speaks with Gabe Roth, executive director of Fix the Court. What would a meaningful and enforceable set of ethics rules look like for the Supreme Court justices? Why isn’t there an Inspector General for the judiciary? How are there no real rules around recusals? Roth makes the case for these nonpartisan reforms and more.

Take the Strict Scrutiny survey.

New Strict merch available here.

You can now listen to Strict Scrutiny for CLE credits in California, New York, Texas, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, Washington, and Oregon! More info at crooked.com/strict_cle

Get tickets for STRICT SCRUTINY LIVE on November 6th in Washington, DC: Crookedcon.com

Buy Melissa’s book, The U.S. Constitution: A Comprehensive and Annotated Guide for the Modern Reader

Buy Leah’s book, Lawless, now out in paperback

Follow us on Instagram, Threads, and Bluesky

For a transcript of an episode of Strict Scrutiny please email [email protected]

More from Strict Scrutiny

All episodes