What makes a good special teams coordinator?

0:00Derrik Klassen: This is Kat and Nat from Kat and Nat Unfiltered and this episode is sponsored by Michael's, your destination for all things birthday parties. If you've ever planned a birthday celebration, you know it goes from cute idea to full-on chaos real fast. The party shop at Michael's makes life easier with over 4 ,500 party supplies in 60-plus themes like Bluey, Rodeo, Soccer, Rainbow, and more. starting at just 99 cents. You can shop same day delivery or order online for pickup in-store and they even do free helium inflation on SelectBloonStyles. Michael's, everything to celebrate anything. Visit Michael's in-store or shop online now.

0:41Dave Helman: Hello, this is Catherine from the Tennis Podcast. Now, AI was supposed to take over the parts of the job you hate. Turns out it made your job even harder. Instead of doing the work, it gave you homework. ServiceNow's AI specialists get work done from start to finish. Cases get resolved, loops get closed, no extra work for you. With ServiceNow, you can do the parts of the job you're best at and delegate the rest. To put AI to work for people, visit servicenow.com. What if fragrance could do more than fill a room? The Sense of Calm Collection from the Pura Calm Partnership is designed to help you unwind, recenter, and find stillness right where you are.

1:26Dave Helman: Explore three new fragrances, each paired with Calm's most loved audio experiences. Try Sleep Story, a lavender drift into deep rest. Or there's Breathe Bubble, a mindful reset wrapped in white tea and cashmere. And finally, Soundscape, a fresh, clearing rush that restores your energy. Ground your space, quiet your mind, and explore the Sense of Calm collection at pura.com slash calm.

1:51Derrik Klassen: Welcome to The Athletic Football Show. I'm Dave Hellman. Robert Mays is out this week, but never fear. Derek Klassen and I have another full mailbag for y 'all. As usual, just an amazing batch of questions. Like every week, I wind up feeling bad about the ones we didn't get to because the questions are so good. they're bound to inspire 10-minute arguments about various esoteric things. Another just great mailbag. There's no telling where it's going to lead you. We talked about our favorite teams that finished with losing records. We talked about backup quarterbacks that are too bad to be starters, but too good to be backups.

2:31Derrik Klassen: We talked about whether we'd rather have the best team of all time with a terrible quarterback or an all-time great quarterback with a mid-roster around him. my gosh, did we talk about special teams? All my special teams sickos get ready for that in the midpoint of the show. We covered a lot of ground, suffice to say. So let's get right to it. Derek and myself answering all your questions right up next.

3:05All right.

3:05Derrik Klassen: As I said, no Robert today, but the format remains unchanged. And that means we've got Michael Beller here. The dulcet tones of Michael Beller reading the questions for the mailbag. Beller, let's get this thing going. Let's get right into it.

3:20Dave Helman: Derek, I can't wait to hear your answer for this one. Behind the curtain, you guys, when I gave Derek and Dave the questions for this, this very first question from Dave, Derek was like, hell yeah, first one's a banger. I had an answer in 0.46 seconds. So I can't wait to hear what it is. Dave's question, what are your favorite teams in a particular year? So for example, the 2010 Seahawks of all time that had a losing record. Why or what made them uniquely stand out despite their record? Derek, what is it? 2017 Jets, they went five and 11, but they had an offense led by 38 year old Josh McCown, who was just chucking balls all over the field to Robbie Anderson, Robbie chosen now, but Robbie Anderson at the time and Jermaine Kearse.

4:06Dave Helman: And funny enough, actually bringing back a 2025 character, John Morton was their offensive coordinator. And they were a very like air raid inspired, just like chuck it all over the field offense. And were they good? No, but watching a 38 year old Josh McCown, who had, you know, it had been a while since he'd been a starting quarterback in the league at that point, just kind of throwing passes all over the yard, firing him in. Like I thought it was a really fun offense to watch. They were definitely a an oddity in that year. And they really weren't a threat. But every time I turn them on, they were one of my like weird when I have extra time on a Wednesday afternoon watching film.

4:41Dave Helman: I was like, I want to see what the Jets offense is doing.

4:43Derrik Klassen: You're a sick, sick man, dude. Dude, go back and watch Josh McCown just ripping it all over the field. It was such a fun offense. I just love that in. I got the message on Slack, too. Like you said in less than a second, you knew which team you were going to choose. And that team was a Todd Bowles Jets team.

5:04Dave Helman: They were. Listen, listen, I just I even I actually saw I went back earlier this week on my just like personal little sub stack. I wrote about some of the rookie linebackers. And I forgot that the picture I put for that website is 2017 Josh McCown because I love that season so much.

5:23Derrik Klassen: God, dude, looking through the pro football reference for the 2017 jets. First of all, we're fresh off of Hall of very good. This was toward the end of Matt Forte's career. Matt Forte, the New York jet. Jermaine curse led that team in receiving Austin safarian Jenkins. That's a name I have not thought about in quite some time. This is, this is a poll. My guy, I think like Bilal Powell was like one of their lead running.

5:50Dave Helman: Well, like it's a weird team, man.

5:52Derrik Klassen: It's a weird team and it was not a good one, but I enjoyed them. I can always count on you to go into the weeds because really like if we're talking about a team with a losing record, it's got to be for me a team that made a little bit more of an impact on the league at large, especially like when you when you cover the entire league. It can be hard to maintain a connection or a sense of fondness for a team that wins like five or six games. I had two, and I think there's, for me, there's two types of teams that fit this category. One is a bad team that went surprisingly far, like the 2010 Seahawks, and had that cool moment in the playoffs.

6:32Derrik Klassen: Or a team that was bad, but you could see the flashes of great things to come. So a team that's worth shouting out for me is the 2018 Bills, just because you had... That's a good one. You had baby deer Josh Allen running around like just like a baby deer let loose in somebody's kitchen, just breaking all the China running around, scored 18 touchdowns for a six win Bills team. That was like the end of LaShawn McCoy's career. Just a fun, bad team. And my vivid memory from the 2018 Bills was week three, they beat the Vikings and the Vikings were coming off of that trip to the NFC title game in 2017.

7:17Derrik Klassen: So it was, you know, it was supposed to be an easy Vikings win. And it was, it's the most memorable survivor, survivor pool bloodbath I can ever think of where like everybody was on the Vikings to win this game. And the Bills just went up to Minnesota and beat them up. and Josh Allen did Josh Allen things. That was the game where he had like the crazy, I think it was like a third and long run where he was like diving at the sticks. And yeah, you got a very early look at what Josh Allen was going to be about.

7:46Dave Helman: Yeah, that's a good one for what is to come. Like of Josh Allen just doing shit like that.

7:51Derrik Klassen: My other answer that I wanted to shout out is similar to the 2010 Seahawks, a team that won a bad division. What a saga the 2020 Washington football team was. Yeah, dude, that team was that that defense was actually kind of cool. And some of that front was actually really cool. I mean, Chase Young won defensive rookie of the year, which feels like it happened a lifetime ago. You had John Allen and Deron Payne doing their thing. The front was a lot of fun. Obviously, quarterback was a saga. Alex Smith comes back from that horrific injury. That was the that was the first year he played after the injury.

8:28Derrik Klassen: I think he took 2019 off. He went five and one as their starter, but he got banged up. They couldn't lean on him. I think they ultimately they tried to play Dwayne Haskins. It didn't really work out. Kyle Allen was part of it. And obviously, Taylor Heineke winds up starting a playoff game and scaring the bejesus out of the Tom Brady Bucks. Just and obviously won the Super Bowl. COVID is obviously the backdrop to all of this. Just a bizarre season. I went back and I was watching highlights from that wildcard game. Empty FedEx field, just nobody there because of all the COVID regulations. Just a weird dream of a season.

9:10Derrik Klassen: And the other thing I wanted to shout out that I will remember forever was the season finale that got Washington into the playoffs was the game where Doug Peterson pulled Jalen Hurts and played Nate Sudfeld through the end of the game. And Philly just basically gave up on it. and backed Washington into the playoffs by not trying to win the game. And Doug Peterson winds up leaving the Eagles like a week or two after that. Just a strange moment in time. I mean, that's not even the team's name anymore. They were the Washington football teams. Just a weird, a weird team and a weird time capsule. That is, I just, I will fondly remember that time.

9:50Dave Helman: A question like this leading us to a Nate Sudfeld pull is what it's all about. That's a good one. It really is what it's all about. I do have one more team that actually is more like this helped go where the league was going. The 2014 Browns, when Kyle Shanahan was their offensive coordinator, they went seven and nine, but actually had a winning record with Brian Hoyer in his 13 starts. And then they lost the other three with backups. It was like one game of Johnny Manziel and two with like Connor Shaw or something ridiculous. Like it's somebody who was not like ever really stuck around in the league for that long.

10:20Dave Helman: But that offense, that was obviously Shanahan had like called plays before and like been a part of bigger offenses. But I remember 2014. This was right when I kind of started doing the football stuff seriously. And I was watching the 2014 rounds and I was like, holy shit, this this Kyle Shanahan guy, it feels like he's got something here.

10:37Derrik Klassen: A dumb fun thing that I love about revisiting old teams is like if it's a team where maybe the starter got injured or maybe you don't have a established quarterback. but over the course of a year, you could have as many as three or four starting quarterbacks. And it's so morbidly fun to go try to piece it back together. Like, Oh yeah. Like why did that guy have to start three games? Why, why did they go to Manziel here? Just it's, it's very fun reliving all of that. It's like CSI. All right, Beller. What's our next one.

11:09Dave Helman: Okay. Spoon Fiesta says my buddy and I have always talked about some backup quarterbacks in a tier where they're too good to be a backup, but too bad to be a starter the guy that got this going Kyle Orton I was wondering if you all see any quarterbacks in that tier right now Dave what do you think on this one I'm curious for Derek's

11:28Derrik Klassen: take on this because Derek is a I was you could say he's meaner than me but he's just he's he's no but like that's not even true he's just he has a higher standard than I do I'm I'm more forgiving Derek what do you think if I say to you like I think an obvious place you could go here is Mac Jones right but like I think Mac Jones I think he's I think he deserves another shot to be a long-term starter like I think when when this contract is done in San Francisco I would be in favor of somebody giving him a shot not saying throw the the Brinks truck at him but somebody giving him a shot to be a starting quarterback like I think I'm not ready to close the book on Mac Jones potentially being good enough to be a full season starter do you agree or disagree

12:16Dave Helman: so I had three names and I think Mac Jones is the toughest one because he he does feel like he's if if this is like a range of like you know too good to be a backup but too bad to be a starter he's he feels closer to like the high end of the range where it's like he's probably too bad to be a guy you for sure want to be starting every year like you know you want to pay him outright but he's he probably is too good to stick around as a backup for as long as he's going like it doesn't make sense for him to be a backup for the next three four years that's how i feel like mac jones

12:46Derrik Klassen: might not ever be better than high like low 20s as a starting quarterback but i do think i do think he's better than too bad to be a starter or you know maybe maybe spending a year in the Shanahan system is just coloring my perception there. But we've seen guys benefit from getting to hang out in San Francisco for a little while before. So, yeah, I thought it was a little harsh to say Mac Jones. So after Mac Jones, the answer for me, like if the phrasing is too good to be a backup but too bad to be a starter, I landed on Jameis Winston pretty easily right after Mac Jones.

13:24Dave Helman: I think there are two guys who have kind of been this tier for a long time. Jameis Winston is one of them I think for the last like three or four years Tyrod Taylor has also been like that that tier of player where like earlier in his career he actually was good enough to be a starter obviously with the bills and then he had like stretches with like the Chargers and Texans where he was like an okay starter but I would say the last like three or so years Tyrod Taylor has kind of been in that tier of like at this point he's probably too old to be like considered like I would want to go start him but like I think he has been that guy

13:54Derrik Klassen: for a while yeah I think I think that's fair and I think my and I know Terod Taylor started four games last year but I just I think back to like 2023 Terod Taylor stepped in and did some good stuff for the Giants like that that Bills game I think it was on Sunday Night Football where they scared the hell out of the Bills but like that's two three years ago at this point so I think that's fair. I think Terod Taylor is in the same class as Jameis Winston. Jameis Winston's just the most chaotic quarterback in the NFL. Like over the last two years, 7 % of his throws have been big time throws per PFF, but also per PFF, another 7 % of his plays have been turnover worthy plays.

14:45Dave Helman: With those two, that's the funny thing. You probably end up at like the same net. like like net neutral spot but you just get there in about as different ways as you possibly could

14:54Derrik Klassen: which if that's the case sign me up for Jameis because like over his last nine games he's averaging 290 passing yards his last nine starts I should say 290 passing yards when he gets into the game 14 passing touchdowns but also 14 interceptions like that's that's just the that's the Jameis ride it always has been but if Jameis Winston was the backup on my team particularly if it was a pretty good team i'd be like okay if shit hits the fan james can step in and have like a 300 yard night and just wow us for two and a half hours but that's like a that is the high-end result and b we can't be leaning on this for more than like one afternoon or it's gonna go wonky and so like i i feel like james is a very good answer to this question

15:43Dave Helman: i do have one more and the the problem is it feels weird because he actually is going to be a starting quarterback this year. Jacoby Brissett is absolutely this tier of player. It's just the Cardinals have kind of backed themselves into having no other option for this particular season. Themselves into or opted for that path? Yeah, you know, I'm trying to give them options, you know, maybe they'll get into Carson Beck by the time they get to week 10 or whatever.

16:06Derrik Klassen: I think that is, Jacoby is a really good point because we've seen him step in over several times over the years and perform really admirably, but then fairly early in the season, like what week? Yeah, it was early November. It was right at the midpoint of the season when the Cardinals made that switch from Kyler to Jacoby, and he looked good against the Cowboys. Most people did, and then it was just never really good again after that. I think he went 1-11 as the starter for Arizona. Like, it never materialized into the consistency that you might hope for for how much we liked our glimpses of Jacoby Brissett over the years.

16:47Dave Helman: All right, Baller, what is our next question? Dennis Ahn has the next question, and Dennis says, last week's Mailbag episode had a discussion about certain positions being undervalued, and you guys mentioned how a star edge rusher gets paid nearly twice as much as a comparable quality offensive tackle. That got me wondering, what is a non-QB position group that benefits the most from adding a star, and what's a position group that benefits the most from plugging a weakness? Perhaps the edge room benefits more from adding a$50 million star player than upgrading your third edge rusher, but for an offensive line, it's more important to not have the glaring weak link than to pay a star tackle that kind of money.

17:24Dave Helman: Is this an appropriate way to think about positional value? What say you, Derek? I think kind of. I actually think offensive line is a little bit of a tricky one. I think in terms of fixing weak links, the interior is the interior offensive line is kind of how I think about that like paying you know 12 million bucks for like an okay guard who can get by I actually do think tackle being able to add a star does have like a huge bonus effect because like with interior players you can't just leave them on an island like in pass protection like that's not really how that works just by way of where they are aligned but a tackle if you have a star there if you trade for a let's just say a Laramie Tunsil, you can just leave him alone because he's a top five pass protecting offensive lineman and you can just kind of let him be.

18:10Dave Helman: And I do think that that has like a huge cascade effect for the other players around them. Edge is obviously another one we're adding a star just by virtue of like guys who can affect the quarterback like that. I think that goes a long way. Wide receiver and running back. I think when you get guys who are like true game changers, because of how often they touch the ball, I think being able to add at those positions does a lot. and then the positions where I felt like more like fixing a weak link made more sense interior offensive on like I said safety like I think it's cool to have some of the safeties who can just do a million things like you know a Kyle Hamilton and all that stuff but that is I mean it's in the name safety the job is to like you are the last line of defense please don't f this up when the other guys are uh you know kind of let things happen so I think fixing weak links there is always good and then tight end to me is like a glue position and so being able to have stars there again is really cool but that to me is more like a hey if that guy is not a huge problem for our offense that allows us to like do some of the other stuff that we want to do not surprisingly I

19:10Derrik Klassen: would throw in corner as one of those positions that can elevate everything where I mean if you I'm thinking about Denver off the top of my head where if Pat Sertan is just a guy that you never ever have to worry about and you can just pick up the slack in a variety of different ways across to the rest of the secondary. I mean, we joke about it all the time. Is Riley Moss a bad player or does Riley Moss just get targeted all the freaking time because nobody's messing with Pat Sertan? But he has an exposure problem. But like for how often he has to deal with that, I would argue he's a pretty good player.

19:46Derrik Klassen: Like, I mean, if you got a few DPIs on your record because that's the only part of the, the only time the opponent's willing to try the field deep, like I think that makes perfect sense. But yeah, I think when I was thinking about this, you know, I'm trying to be as smart and introspective as possible, but I'm like, yeah, I think the positions that you would highlight as the premium game tilting positions where the guys make the highest salary, I think those are the ones that have the greatest impact. And that's why, and the filling a weakness is very similar where, yeah, like guard, interior, offensive line safety.

20:25Derrik Klassen: These are spots where you're trying to protect yourself from just being a glaring weakness and just like an unplayable level of football. The one thing that I think makes that interesting and it can be so hard to find is for instance, like linebacker where a Fred Warner is absolutely worth the money that he makes. but finding Fred Warner is one of the most difficult things to do in football. So determining who's worth paying and, and whether they play up to that contract, it's fascinating to me because if you find that guy, a linebacker of that caliber can be a difference maker like that. Even if we don't talk about linebacker, the same way we talk about edge or corner or receiver, but help, help me find that guy, please.

21:16Derrik Klassen: I'm begging you because it's very hard to do it.

21:18Dave Helman: Because that I think too is like, that's 100 % it. Like I think having, adding a star at linebacker does go such a long way. If you like a Fred Warner or just like guys who they just allow you to play with different box counts or you can do different stuff and coverage because they can do all this stuff. And that because they're in the literal middle of the defense allows you to have this huge cascade effect. The problem is, like you said, there are only like three guys at a time who are like truly that kind of a force. Whereas like there are seven, eight corners right now in the league that I would say like you can just leave them on an island and they're fine.

21:54Dave Helman: They're not all as good at it as Pat Sertan, but there are seven or eight of those guys where I'm like, if we need to do that for a game, we are so good.

22:02Derrik Klassen: Well, and that goes back to when we did our under 25 and under draft. It's it's not to shit on Puka Nakua or Jackson Smith and Jigba at all. and receiver is so incredibly important, but there's a shitload of those guys, dude. There are so many receivers that you would say you feel that way about. Like, I feel so confident about being able to find a math-changing receiver, even if they still are, in the grand scheme of the NFL, rare. But you can get up toward, like, 20 guys, in my opinion, who could be that guy for you. Linebacker, completely different conversation. If you could guarantee me their production, like you come to me ahead of time and say this is fred warner linebacker would be so so high on who i would prioritize paying but because we don't know it makes me really nervous and that's what makes you reluctant to do it it's it's fascinating that's the other thing too because even for like the great coverage linebackers right like you could be the best coverage linebacker in the

23:04Dave Helman: league and you get one interception a year maybe whereas like if you are the best receiver in a league you're like up for triple crowns every other year just based on like how good the quarterback is playing like the production like you said is a guarantee whereas like at linebacker you can obviously feel their effect when you watch how the defense plays but it's not necessarily a guarantee that they're like getting hands on the ball

23:23Derrik Klassen: don't you worry this is not the last time we will be talking about the linebacker position on this mailbag that's what they call a tease though we'll get to that and more questions right

23:32Dave Helman: after our first break what if fragrance could do more than fill a room the sense of calm collection from the Pura Calm Partnership is designed to help you unwind, recenter, and find stillness right where you are. Explore three new fragrances, each paired with Calm's most loved audio experiences. Try Sleep Story, a lavender drift into deep rest. Or there's Breathe Bubble, a mindful reset wrapped in white tea and cashmere. And finally, Soundscape, a fresh clearing rush that restores your energy. Ground your space, quiet your mind, and explore the Sense of Calm Collection at pura.com slash com. Hey, this is Knox from the podcast.

24:13Dave Helman: The youth mental health crisis is growing and social media is a major driver. Kids are spending up to nine hours a day on screens, often unsupervised. And studies show a direct link to anxiety, depression, and even suicidal thoughts. That's where Gab comes in. Gab offers safer phones and watches for kids with no social media tailored to every age, offering the right tech at the right time or tech in steps. From GPS tracking enabled watches for younger kids to phones with parent-enabled apps for teens. Each device allows kids to more safely grow their independence. Visit gab.com slash getgab and use code getgab for an exclusive offer.

24:49Dave Helman: That's gab, G-A-B-B dot com forward slash getgab. Gab, tech and steps. Independence for them, peace of mind for parents. Parles-tu français? Hablas espagnol? Parli italiano? If you've used Babbel, you would. Babbel's conversation-based technique teaches you useful words and phrases to get you speaking quickly about the things you actually talk about in the real world. With lessons handcrafted by over 200 language experts and voiced by real native speakers, Babbel is like having a private tutor in your pocket. Start speaking with Babbel today. Get up to 55 % off your Babbel subscription right now at babbel.com slash acast.

25:29Dave Helman: spelled B-A-B-B-E-O dot com slash ACAST. Rules and restrictions may apply.

25:42Dave Helman: All right, Valor, what's our next one? All right, Kevin Levine wants to put you guys in Roger Goodell's job. He says, for one day, you have all the powers of the commissioner of the NFL. Nobody knows this, so anything you do is completely anonymous and you don't have to answer any questions about it. In a weird quirk, you are also allowed to make one change to the way the NFL works that doesn't need approval of league owners. Everything's in play. You can reimagine the salary cap or abolish it entirely, rework the draft to try to fix teams' tanking, redefine what it catches, redesign the playoffs, the schedule, how many points a touchdown is worth, how long or wide the field is.

26:14Dave Helman: The entire league rulebook is your oyster. What one change would you make to make the league better, and what change would you make just for your own personal enjoyment? Dave, why don't you take this one first? All right.

26:27Derrik Klassen: I'm going to take the exact wording of the question and run with it because Kevin very clearly said, I can do this without the approval of NFL ownership. And that is crucial to what I'm about to say because never in a million years would they sign off on this. But the number one thing I would do, and I've got another one that's more about the play on the field and like actual football. But the number one thing I would do is invent some checks and balances for NFL ownership. I would invent some way to keep NFL fan bases from being held completely at the whim of these 30 some odd business men and women who may or may not be good at their jobs or may or may not care about running a good football team.

27:17Derrik Klassen: whether that's I mean one easy way to do it I would force NFL teams to disclose earnings and expenditures coaches salaries how much they're spending on facilities stadium how much they're paying in rent how much profit they're making all that good shit I would force them to disclose it the same way the Green Bay Packers have to do because they are a publicly owned company and then I would have to really sit down and like get into the nitty gritty of this, but I would set some sort of way to have oversight on NFL decision making, whether that's like a board of trustees, you know, like a panel of people that can sit and weigh like, how are we running this?

28:03Derrik Klassen: How are we spending the money? Are we making a good faith effort to be competitive? Because I think these franchises are far too valuable and far too important to the communities that they represent to just congratulations. You own an NFL team for one reason or another. And and that's all there is to it. I think like the NFL has gotten so big, so profitable and so important that I just I don't think that's fair. And I think like one of the greatest imbalances in this whole thing is that fans just have to hope that the person that owns their team gives a shit. So I would, thanks to not having to get the owner's consent, I would put checks and balances on the owners in place.

28:48Derrik Klassen: First, first hour of my first day.

28:51Dave Helman: I love that you went like as big picture as possible because mine are so specific. And like the minor, like so like down to the line. We'll cover the gamut.

29:00Derrik Klassen: We'll cover the gamut, baby. It's okay.

29:02Dave Helman: Yeah, so mine, in terms of like what would I change that I actually feel like would make the game better, revert how defensive pass interference is called. Like I let DBs play, like I've been saying this for basically the entire time that I've been doing this job. I think obviously it's like, yeah, you're going to have some moments where the DB is completely mugging the receiver and it looks bad. But like offense should be hard. Throwing the ball should be hard. It's a really hard thing to do. And so that's kind of my guiding light there. I also just think it like when you live in that world, it makes the quarterbacks who are really good stand out even more because it's like, wow, this is as hard as it could possibly be.

29:42Dave Helman: And this guy's electric. And so that's kind of where I would go with that. My other small one that is like a personal change, all passes behind the line of scrimmage to players in motion should count as runs. We should stop counting those as passes like the little jet touch passes. Those count as runs on the score sheet.

30:00Derrik Klassen: Man, that makes it so much harder to stat pad on video games, though. Good.

30:09I'm trying.

30:10Derrik Klassen: Yeah, like, I didn't think about actual rules and regulations. I'm trying to think of, like, the things that piss me off the most. Like, okay, DPI is fine, but, like, defensive holding should not be an automatic first down. Like, especially if it's, like, a long... down like if it's a long distance like if it's third and 12 and you get a defensive holding like whatever third and eight and try again you know like i it's too many automatic first downs when this stuff is already skewed toward the the offense in the first place that's a that's a good one

30:45Dave Helman: because again if the if like the starting field position is going to change and then on your first third and 11 you just get this automatic first down because of a holding call that happened like six yards down the field it's like man what do we do you're already in field goal range basically

30:58Derrik Klassen: Like, what are we doing? The other one that I wanted to shout out, which it's something Derek, you and I complain about all the time. But so I thought about I'll be I will be transparent. I thought about just axing the 17th game and going back down to 16, which I would be fine with. But. The games make money and the games are a big part of the reason why the salary cap continues to jump. And I think that's more fun and more fair for everybody. So I don't know if it's a good idea to ax the 17th game. I think what I would do, I would add an 18th game. I would get rid of the third preseason game.

31:40Derrik Klassen: So two preseason, 18 regular season. We would add a second bye week. And most importantly, for our purposes, we would cap the schedule at Sundays, Mondays, and Thursdays. Amen. Absolutely. No more of these other games. and and we would impose a no more than one thursday night game a year rule like we don't need to be doing the double thursday bullshit we don't need to be having teams play on thursday four times because they're popular you get one thursday game we play on sunday and there's one monday night game the way the good lord intended this is actually the best change you're the

32:18Dave Helman: commissioner now like we need to go back to where the football schedule is a ritual sunday monday

32:23Derrik Klassen: thursday don't change shit i'll just do i'll do all the 30 000 foot stuff and you fix the actual dynamics of what's happening on the field i think this is a good strategy guys i want to get on in

32:34Dave Helman: this too especially since you brought out the 18th game here dave um i'm gonna i'm gonna get in i'm gonna use this to future proof something we're going to 18 games i think we all kind of assume that's going to happen eventually if and when that happens i say get rid of nfc afc regular season games you play your teams in your division twice that is six games you play every other team in your conference once that is 12 more games for 18 games and we get the we can have these fun like what if like for their entire careers or at least their entire rookie contracts and we'll see what happens after that we knew that Jaden Daniels and Caleb Williams were playing each other you get these fun little mini era based rivalries that would happen I would love to see that and I love the symmetry of it too and like i don't want to hear anything about like oh but then this fan base would never get to see nfc teams will never get to see lamar jackson nfc teams will never get to see josh allen afc teams will never get to see bijon robinson they see them once every eight years as it stands right now so like that doesn't happen anyway that is not an actual argument

33:39Derrik Klassen: a i i disagree beller because now that we've added i mean it's kind of stupid but now like now that the 17th game is cross conference, that's one more opportunity to see that player. So you have a statistically better shot. And I don't know, something doesn't sit right with me about the idea that like, if, if you're, if you love the Ravens and you live in Phoenix, Lamar Jackson's just never coming to town. You just write that off. It's coming once every eight years as it is. It's better than, it's better than knowing from the jump that it's never going to happen ever. and you have to like travel to see Lamar Jackson play.

34:19Derrik Klassen: I don't know. I don't like that. Something about that doesn't sit right with me.

34:22Dave Helman: I don't know if I do or don't like it, but I do think it would make, because I feel like AFC versus NFC in terms of like how a lot of the teams are organized and like where the power structure is. Obviously AFC for a long time has been like quarterback dominant. NFC has always felt like it's a little bit more team oriented, like just like overall team quality. I wonder if that would feel more different. Like would that even get more disparate if that's how this was going like i don't know i do think that the clash by the time we get to like the super bowl would kind of make for even more interesting matchups i don't know if that's good or bad but i think that's where my head's at for the purposes of building a playoff field it is as balanced as a schedule as you can have also where you're playing everyone who you are actually directly directly competing for playoff spots with you get to play them and you

35:06Derrik Klassen: all play the same schedule save for your division matchups can you even imagine the effect that it would have because think about the way the current schedule formatting works so drastically influences the playoffs because somebody in the nfc has to play the afc west and somebody else in the nfc gets to play a weaker division i don't want to say someone and piss someone in the afc

35:32Dave Helman: north some of the afc is playing the nfc north this year and someone's playing the nfc south

35:37Derrik Klassen: yeah which four of those exactly and we're gonna we're gonna look up in october and be like holy shit all these teams are above 500 in november and it's like well they all got to play the nfc south so i think you're right it would be more balanced but i don't know i can't i can't get all the way there i it bothers me to think that that you would just never play a team from across the conference unless you made the super bowl unfortunately for all of us we're not going to see any of our sweet

36:04Dave Helman: changes implemented because that's not how this works but how this show works is that we move on to another question from helena fothergill helena says would you rather have an offense with a top four quarterback and the 10 other starters net out to league average or a bottom four quarterback but anyone you want at the other 10 spots so like josh allen and average dudes around him or i don't know shader sanders and the first team all pros around him what do you got here derek i think putting shader sanders on it specifically it feels like it's gonna take bottom four I was just trying to illustrate this bottom four.

36:37Dave Helman: I think the answer is clearly bottom four quarterback with the other 10 guys. If you're telling me the rest of my roster is Jamar Chase, Puka Nakua, like Penesul, Tristan Wurst, Creed Humphreys, B. John Robinson, Brock Bowers. Like, yes, we're going to crush everybody. Like, what are we talking about?

36:59Derrik Klassen: you you know who finished bottom four in like epa per drop back this past season right give me last

37:05Dave Helman: year's like geno smith or give me jacoby brissette like i don't care i can't like we were the bottom

37:10Derrik Klassen: four day jj mccarthy shader sanders cam ward and geno smith i believe cam ward wins the super bowl with that team no question i don't i don't think i agree with this i think davis mills wins the Super Bowl with that team. My answer specifically was the phrase bottom four is what scares me off because like if you even bumped it up to like 15th or 18th best quarterback, a middle of the pack quarterback would probably be too easy because like Trevor Lawrence was 16th in EPA per play last year. So give me Trevor Lawrence with the super team and I'm taking that all day. But like, yeah, cam ward geno smith oh i forgot to mention uh joe flacco as well like i don't i don't joe flacco wins the super bowl with that team like this joe flacco having if i have the best player

38:08Dave Helman: at every other position i think we're underrating how powerful that is i'm just terrified of it being

38:18Derrik Klassen: like the third quarter of a game and jamar chase is just throwing up his hands in frustration because he's open all the time and the ball's not getting to him i don't know i like i've seen some bad bad quarterback play and it is a good point i don't know how much i've ever watched a terrible quarterback on the best team ever assembled but the guys gotta see it and gotta have the confidence to rip it and and be going in the right direction on a consistent basis. I don't know. It just scares me, man.

38:52Dave Helman: I think doing it with like the young quarterbacks who are that bad does make it a little bit trickier. But again, I think if you give me one of these bottom four bets, like again, like if you give me like Davis Mills with 10 all pros around him, I think you win the Super Bowl.

39:06Derrik Klassen: I always think that's too much talent around him. It would be pretty fun to see Joe Flacco on a team like that where he's seen just an ungodly amount of football like you can't really throw anything new at a guy like that and he's just got an amazing offensive line yeah okay I could I could talk myself into into Joe Flacco doing this hey just for the record Davis Mills

39:29Dave Helman: led one of the craziest comebacks last year that effectively won the Texans the division against the Jaguars the Jags game yes yeah what a stupid game by the way I can't believe the

39:39Derrik Klassen: Jaguars lost that game.

39:41Dave Helman: Davis Mills, two Russian touchdowns in that game.

39:44Derrik Klassen: We're talking about like one game sample sizes, by the way, you got to win. You got to win like 18 or 19 games to win the Super Bowl, maybe 20.

39:53Dave Helman: He did that with the 30th best offensive line, as opposed to like what would literally be the best offensive line of all time. I'm just I don't know. I think it would be easier than where a magic is. It's like, obviously, quarterback is the most important position, but it's the most important position in part because you can never assemble 10 all pros around them.

40:12Derrik Klassen: I'm really surprised. I would have bet my life that Derek would be like, don't make me watch the bad quarterback. I'll take the good one no matter who he's playing with. But I see your logic. I don't know. It just it scares me to think about wasting all that talent if the quarterback's not good enough. Whereas and by the way, I mean, we we've seen Patrick Mahomes drag two really forgettable offenses to Super Bowls in recent memory. So I know that that is a thing you can do if you have that guy at QB.

40:44Dave Helman: So I think that's what makes it tricky, because like this, that part of the hypothetical like is real. And we've seen that, right? Like Josh Allen being as good as he has been for a long time. I know their offensive line is good, but given the pass catchers, that probably amounts closer to average. Obviously, what the Chiefs have done in that time, Brady had some teams, obviously, where they were probably pretty average around him, and he elevated them to being what they were. And so we've seen that, whereas the other side of the hypothetical, we'll never see.

41:14Derrik Klassen: We're never going to see a team where it's 10 all pros around a bad quarterback. Maybe I just want to be safe with what I've seen before. like like I said the thought of wasting all of that potential scares the shit out of me but I I it is a good point that like you can't underestimate how much talent that is but I still think I lean on the good quarterback all right Beller what's up next Esquire Rhapsody

41:42Dave Helman: writes in there's a lot of context to this but I'm just going to boil it down straight to the question save us I don't know 15 seconds of runtime you're welcome Katie uh what makes a great special teams coordinator. Dave, you got to take this one first.

41:56Derrik Klassen: Obviously, I love this question. And my answer is enthusiasm, people skills, and just a ridiculous attention to detail. And so to add some context to the question, you know, the the Squire Rhapsody asked, you know, that there's only so many ways to punt or defend a kickoff. You're working with back of the roster players. It's not like you can foster competition at kicker and on and on and on. I think that's fair, but that is why every special teams coordinator I have ever spent time around is a maniacal madman. And that comes across as either like, you know, we talk about offensive coordinators as guys that sit in dark rooms and scheme up ways to draw plays.

42:48Derrik Klassen: special team coordinators do that as well. Like when you're working in the, with the margins and special teams, you're talking about the difference between, oh, well, you know, we've noticed that this guy, you know, he lines up one foot wide of the hash. And when he does that, he gives up some leverage on his inside shoulder. And we think that can give us a shot at a punt block when they're in the right look, or, you know, this guy overruns his target on kick return. And we think like, if we create a block here, It can open a seam for us. They are doing that shit to an insane degree. And then on top of that, like I said, enthusiasm and people skills, because I do think it is a good point.

43:28Derrik Klassen: You are working with a lot of back of roster players. I think it is an underrated skill to get 20 plus guys who are used to being the best guy on their football team to buy in and want to work their ass off at special teams to say, hey, you were the best corner on your team, but right now you're fourth on the depth chart, and you've got to play like a demon 15 snaps a game and hope that it leads somewhere better. I think the very best special teams coordinators are really good at fostering that sense of ownership and enthusiasm to go do shit that you would rather not be doing. And so I have more to say, but I want to hear what Derek says.

44:12Derrik Klassen: But yeah, like that's where it starts for me.

44:14Dave Helman: I mean I don't have as much to say to me it is a lot of the people skills for a lot of the reasons you're saying because like nobody necessarily wants to do special teams you play football to go catch passes to rush after the passer like whatever it's going to be and so being able being forced being forced to do this stuff I do think is something that not everybody necessarily wants to do so like being able to foster that give a shit factor is huge and then like further to that point for guys on the offense you know year over year you might have eight of the 11 same starters like year over year eight or nine and so there's a lot of like consistency in terms of like who you're coaching if you're the offensive or defensive coordinator or whatever the turnover on special teams is massive year to year because it's all back of the roster guys it's like you know you might have had a fifth round pick and you caught him after a year and now you've got two two different day three like it's always you're shuffling in guys in and out of the roster constantly.

45:06Dave Helman: And so I do think it's always having to be flexible with like what body types you're using, how you're using them and just like how your team actually looks in terms of the construction. Because again, I think those guys filter in and out at such a high rate.

45:20Derrik Klassen: It's true. I will say this, though. I think it's it's misleading to say that special teams is purely back of the roster, guys, because the average NFL team has at least one, if not as many as three or four like a special teamers that carry over from year to year like Matthew Slater's the most famous one but every single team in the league has a guy like this who keeps making the team because he can play four special teams he's a he's a demon on kick return he'll get in there on field goal block and covering a team for as long as I did it was always funny to see the influence the special teams coordinator had because every year these veterans who had proven that they weren't really up to snuff on offense or defense kept making the team and you're like holy shit can we get some new blood in here like can we like can we keep the young draft pick instead of the year five guy who's gonna ace special teams but that is the priority that NFL teams put on this stuff like they they view it as very important and in a lot of cases they will give leeway to the special teams coordinator to keep the guys that he trusts

46:35Dave Helman: that also is a good point though about not it not always being back of the roster guys like especially on like kick block team like that that is actually a lot of your starters especially like along the d-line like jordan davis blocked a number of kicks last year and he is obviously like a key starter for the Eagles defense.

46:51Derrik Klassen: Quick story that I want to tell, which illustrates my point a little bit. It clearly stuck with me. We all remember Joe Judge, his career as Giants head coach didn't go that well, didn't go well at all. Who am I kidding? But he's a special teams coordinator, longtime special teams guy. I remember after a Cowboys Giants game, you know, the head coaches typically do some sort of show where they answer questions about how the game went and Joe Judge gave this awesome lesson on like Giants media where the game was played in Dallas you know the Cowboys have these the big windows and like all the time the sun sets and it's this big fiasco where the sun is in everybody's eyes it happens like six times a year Joe Judge like gave this lesson after the fact where he was like, yeah, well, we knew it was the three 30 game.

47:46Derrik Klassen: We knew the sun was going to be coming through the windows. There are sunspots here in this part of the end zone, this part of the end zone and this part of the end zone. And we asked our guy, I think it was Graham Gano to angle his kicks for the sunspots so that Tony Pollard would be standing and looking into the sun every single time. And like best case scenario, he's going to drop one. But even if he doesn't, you have to pause and hold up and fight the sun to catch a ball that is coming through the sunlight, as opposed to if you've got a clear beat on it and you're just running up on it and nothing's impeding you, you can get a running start.

48:23Derrik Klassen: You can get that much better of a kick return. Whereas if you've got to fight the sun, stand still and then go, you're going to be slower. You're going to be less decisive and it won't be as good. And lo and behold, the Giants lost that game, but they were animals on kick return. And I watched that video and I was like, holy shit, these guys are thinking of stuff that would have never even occurred to me. And that's just like, that's just the beginning. That is insane to me.

48:49Dave Helman: That makes sense, especially for that stadium. That makes a lot of sense. But that is completely insane.

48:53Derrik Klassen: I would say that is a really obvious one by special teams coordinators standards. But I mean, they are thinking of the wildest shit. All right. I'm almost done. But whatever. Robert's not here to rein me in. the question did ask like who are the better or the best special teams coordinators in the NFL right now. I would absolutely shout out Jay Harbaugh after what he did for the Seahawks last year. Their special teams were fantastic on the way to the Superbowl. Chris Banjo for the jets, who was a longtime special teamer in his own right. The jets had a phenomenal first year under him where I think they led.

49:30Derrik Klassen: Yeah. They led the league in special teams DVOA. they were right behind seattle in um special teams scored hey you gotta you gotta be happy about something right um john fossil is with the titans guy he was he's a guy that i covered for a long time in dallas um and when when i talk about like a maniacal enthusiasm for this shit john fossil is like the dictionary definition of that um and then frank ross in houston and darren rizzi has been Sean Payton's special teams coordinator forever. Those are, there are plenty of other ones, but that's like the short list of guys I would shout out if you want to know about some special teams coordinators.

50:11Derrik Klassen: Okay, Beller, I'm done. I think I went more than long enough on special teams.

50:17Dave Helman: All right, let's take our last break and then we'll come back and answer a few more questions. What if fragrance could do more than fill a room? The Sense of Calm collection from the Pura Calm Partnership is designed to help you unwind, recenter, and find stillness right where you are. Explore three new fragrances, each paired with Calm's most loved audio experiences. Try Sleep Story, a lavender drift into deep rest. Or there's Breathe Bubble, a mindful reset wrapped in white tea and cashmere. And finally, Soundscape, a fresh clearing rush that restores your energy. Ground your space, quiet your mind, and explore the Sense of Calm collection at pura.com slash calm.

51:20Dave Helman: www.schwab.com

51:24Derrik Klassen: Still waiting in line?

51:27Dave Helman: Again?

51:28Derrik Klassen: That's time you'll never get back. Save time and money with Stamps.com. Over 4 million businesses have skipped the line with Stamps.com. Join them to save up to 90 % off carrier rates from your computer or phone right now. Print postage for certified mail, registered mail, and packages in seconds. Then schedule a pickup right from your home or office. For a limited time, go to Stamps.com and use code PODCAST for a free welcome gift. Taxes and fees apply.

52:01Dave Helman: okay ramsey abdul rahim has our next question ramsey says in a recent mailbag robert and derrick discussed the optimal ages for each position and agreed that the younger the running back the better how much of this consensus is based on calendar age versus accumulated wear and tear a few running backs of yesteryear had career peaks after their age 27 seasons tiki Barber averaged 2 ,000 yards from scrimmage after age 27. Thomas Jones averaged 1 ,200 yards rushing between ages 27 and 31, Bear down, and Warwick Dunn had his best season at age 30. Each of these players spent the first half of their careers as a backup or complimentary piece and were, quote, fresher than their age might have indicated.

52:38Dave Helman: Has the nature of the position changed, or should teams seek out low-cost second contract guys in committee situations to be bigger parts of their offense despite their age, thinking along the lines of Jalen Warren, Kenneth Gainwell, Tyler algier etc derek why don't you take this one first so i think it feels like what we're trying to pick at here with the guys who are maybe potentially committee players and then signing them to second year contracts or second contracts and then giving them the job the the problem is that a lot of the guys who like are committee players now are not big enough to be like full-time workhorses in the way that like we see the other guys in the league so like last year for example 10 running backs took at least 250 carries nine of them were drafted in the first two rounds the exception is Kyron Williams nine of them are 205 pounds or heavier the exception is James Cook um 2024 was a little bit different in terms of where they were drafted because you had Chuba Hubbard came out of nowhere Aaron Jones was on a second contract for Minnesota and so every now and then you get some of these guys, but the guys who are good committee players and then go on to be decent lead backs for their team are the guys who have the size.

53:50So in this example, like Jalen Warren's a weird one because

53:54Dave Helman: he's heavy, but he's 5 '8". So he's kind of a tricky one to get a handle on. But like Kenny Gainwell, for example, he is generously 200 pounds. He's always been a role player. Like he's always been a guy who like is good as a committee player, probably not someone who is built to be like a full-time player. I think if you're trying to look around the league now and find the guys who are committee guys for one reason or another and could have good second contracts, Tyler Algier I did think was that guy until obviously his same team drafted Jeremiah Love, who obviously that's going to be a committee now.

54:27Dave Helman: Braylon Allen for the Jets in a couple of years, I think is a guy who could be that because he's a little bit bigger, has that bell cow size. And then you've seen a couple of other examples before of guys who were kind of saved on committees and then had good second contracts. Aaron Jones, who I mentioned earlier, like the Packers kind of split a lot of time with him and Jamal Williams early on. And so he was able to sustain into a second contract for the Packers and be good. Tony Pollard was this, like obviously him and Zeke split time. And so, but even again, Aaron Jones and Tony Pollard, they were like 205 plus and they were built like full-time backs.

54:59Dave Helman: They just weren't getting that opportunity. And so I think that to me is where a lot of it comes down to, is the size.

55:05Derrik Klassen: The other thing I would bring up is the league, The business of the league has just changed a little bit in the time since the running backs mentioned in the questions. Tiki Barber was pick 36 in his respective draft. Thomas Jones was pick seven and Warwick Dunn was pick 12. And some of it was injury related, but like these guys weren't bell cow do everything backs right off the jump in their careers. And I just don't think that's how the NFL works anymore. Like if you I mean, certainly if you draft a player top 12, you're drafting him to be the guy and carry a lot of the load for your offense right away.

55:49Derrik Klassen: And even up to like pick 36, pick 50. I mean, Kenneth Walker was pick 41 in the 2022 draft. And if you compare his stats to Tiki Barber at this point in their respective careers, like when Tiki Barber was done with his fourth season, he had a half as many rushing attempts as Kenneth Walker. Like, I think if you're drafting a running back highly, it is to maximize that rookie contract, get as much as you can out of him. And if he's good enough and durable enough that you want to pay him, by all means, do it. But NFL teams, the goal, it sounds callous, but the goal is to get as much as you can out of them while they're still fresh and worry about that later.

56:30Derrik Klassen: Whereas I don't think NFL teams, whether it's a trust factor, whether it's because the contract situations are different, but NFL teams just weren't as. I don't want, I don't know if the, if it's willing, but they just weren't as focused on getting that much out of running backs that quickly. And you, I mean, you look across the spectrum, Bajon Robinson's the same way where his usage usage compared to guys drafted, you know, like Thomas Jones, it's just not even close. And so I think to Derek's point, if you're going to get to your second contract and still be really fresh, you're probably a day three guy.

57:09Derrik Klassen: And if you're a day three guy, why is that? Is it because you're a little bit undersized? Is it because teams don't really want you running between the tackles and you kind of have to prove that you can do that? Is it because you're more of a receiving back or whatever? I think guys that are going to get to a second contract with a relatively low amount of mileage on their legs are going to be guys that have to prove themselves as day three picks. That's not a blanket statement, but in general, I think that's probably true.

57:39Dave Helman: A hundred percent agree. And I think the other thing here that like is especially true now in the in the world that we live in with the way that defenses are operating so much of being a good running back right now, I think is being able to generate explosives. That's harder to do when you're a little bit older. Like last year, the only runners who had at least one explosive run a game, which I was using a 12 yards in a game. So at least one 12 yard carry per game. The only guys who were 28 and older to do that last year were Derek Henry, who was like a timeless wonder in a top 40 pick. Saquon Barkley, who was the second overall pick in his draft.

58:14Dave Helman: And Christian McCaffrey, who was also a first round pick in his draft. And all these guys are like pretty big. And so I think, again, it does come down to like there is a pretty clear profile for what is a lead back in the NFL and which guys can sustain. And to me, I think it is the guys who are big enough and like clearly special athletes. And I just don't think a lot of those guys hang around as committee players for very long in this current NFL.

58:41Derrik Klassen: Having said that, I mean, we say it all the time. I would have liked to see Tyler Algier in a more advantageous situation. And I am really excited about what could be in front of Kenny Gainwell for the record. Like, I think those are great examples, but I think it's those those situations are few and far between at this point when you're talking about big time running backs that have a chance to be successful into their late 20s and early 30s.

59:12Dave Helman: All right, guys, here we go. Last question of the episode. This one comes to us from Jason. Jason asks, what do you think drives teams not to look at retread defensive coordinators, Jim Schwartz, Steve Spagnuolo, Vic Fangio, as head coaches? Even in a weak coaching class, this class of coaches, this group of the DCs, didn't even receive a look despite clearly still having their fastball. Is it just the offensive first nature of the league or something specific to the individuals involved? Dave, get us started on this last question.

59:39Derrik Klassen: I have one slight pushback to the question, which is just that even with all the factors working against defensive coaches and retread defensive coaches. Dan Quinn got a shot very recently, and Robert Sala got a second shot in this hiring cycle. So I would argue teams are still willing to do it, probably less willing to do it. And I think Jason hit on a couple of the reasons. I mean, I think all things being equal, I think NFL teams would rather hire an offensive coach, um a because the the way the rules are skewed because of the continuity that you get if you hit on an offensive coach all the stuff that we talk about week after week i think that's all true for the most part and i think we talked about it in the lead up to the super bowl because we you know we looked at the splits of the super bowl 10 years ago versus this year and nfl coach uh head coaching ages are just trending downwards teams are looking for the younger hot shot commodity.

1:00:47Derrik Klassen: I mean, everybody is obviously everybody's looking for McVay, but even on the defensive side of the ball, teams are now looking for Mike McDonald or, you know, like you're hoping Jesse mentor can be the Mike McDonald archetype in Baltimore. And so I think the longer you've been around the league, the more you've had an opportunity to put bad tape out there or prove that maybe you're not the personality for the amount of forward-facing stuff that a head coach has to do. I think teams are looking for reasons to not do that. But like I said, I think at the end of the day, I still think there's a willingness to do it because we've had two defensive retread hires in the last couple of years alone.

1:01:27Dave Helman: Right. And I think a lot of the defensive coordinators that do get like retread higher jobs, like a Robert Sala, they're just a little bit younger. Like Vic Fangio is 67 years old Steve Spagnuolo is 66 years old even Jim Schwartz is 60 which I don't think it like that is probably right around the line of like what is too old to like really be hired in this in this category and I know there were some other older coaches hired in this cycle but those three defensive coordinators those three defensive minds you would want them on your staff because they could call plays for you whereas the other older guys in the cycle John Harbaugh obviously being hired by the Giants.

1:02:05Dave Helman: He's not like a play caller. That is a CEO, like look over the entire building thing. Mike McCarthy is a little bit of a tricky one. Like, you know, you're kind of hiring him to be the offensive mind, but I think you're also hiring him to like, to just be a steadying hand, which I don't think is the reason that you would hire a Vic Fangio or a Jim Schwartz. You would hire them because they kick ass calling defenses. And then the other one that I think you could maybe make the argument for is Todd Monken. You know, obviously being the offensive coordinator for the Ravens for a long time, he's going to have a big part in the Browns offense but the Browns offense was not like the Browns team was not a necessarily desirable job so I don't that to me is not even one that I'm like really necessarily picking on them for not having gone a defensive one like I think that was kind of just like a this was probably Monken's last shot to get a head coaching job and he took what he could get and so that's kind of where I landed with that so I still think that retread defensive coordinator hires can happen like Raheem Morris happened not that long ago obviously that didn't turn out well but you mentioned Dan Quinn.

1:03:02Dave Helman: That was another one that had happened not that long ago. And so I think they do happen. If there's any in this cycle that you have some questions about, it's kind of like, you know, Vance Joseph and the Denver Broncos defense was really good. Maybe why didn't he get more looks? I think that's potentially one. I think Brian Flores, given the legal disputes with the league, I think we know why that one hasn't happened. But like, that's another guy that you could maybe pin. So there are some guys, but like, for the most part, these are pretty explainable,

1:03:29Derrik Klassen: I think Vance Joseph is a, is a good one to note. He's only 53 years old and I'd be surprised like the Broncos defense is going to be great or at least solid for the foreseeable future. And so I'd be pretty surprised if he doesn't eventually get a look because like he's, he's more than young enough and he's going to keep coaching a fantastic unit. Like it would surprise me if he doesn't get a shot, but yeah. Fangio, 67. He's also, he's from Philly. Like everything about Fangio's situation to me kind of suggests that he's okay just calling a really talented defense until he's ready to retire. Spagnuolo is definitely weird to me because, I mean, it would be easy to say, oh, he's happy coaching defense for a dynasty.

1:04:16Derrik Klassen: And I'm sure he is, but Steve Spagnuolo has made it pretty clear through various channels over the last three or four years that he would love another shot. and he didn't he did it never materialized and maybe he still could or maybe it's too late but that is one where i'm like it's a little strange that you were the the architect of a defense that had a lot to do with all of those super bowls and it never really materialized for you so that is that is always one that i've thought was really curious but for the most part i agree with you that a lot of these are pretty explainable.

1:04:51Dave Helman: And I actually do have one more to keep an eye on as far as like retread defensive coordinator hires that will probably happen. If the Saints defense is good again, Brandon Staley will get some looks again. Like obviously the Chargers stint did not go very well for him, but I think that he would probably get another look if things go well.

1:05:08Derrik Klassen: That's an interesting one because he was such a flashpoint. Like not necessarily fair, but he was billed as, I mean, he was, people thought he was Mike McDonald. Like what Mike McDonald has done in Seattle, everybody thought that was Brandon Staley. And it obviously did not work out remotely that well. And so I don't know. I feel like there's and this is this is just like I'm not talking about anybody that makes decisions in the NFL. But like the just the opinion of him from the public at large is it's almost like a pariah. Like, oh, Brandon Staley. And so like I feel like I think I think you're right.

1:05:48Derrik Klassen: But I feel like the fan base that ultimately hires Brandon Staley for a second shot, whether it's fair or not, is going to have a lot to say about it.

1:05:57Dave Helman: It might take a few more years because of what you're saying. Like, we might need to be a little bit more removed from how the Chargers run defense looked for a Brandon Staley hire to feel good for whoever it's going to be. I will say, though, like, I think part of even the concern going into the Brandon Staley hire with the Chargers was like, man, this is a really young coach, even as far as not just like actual age, but like NFL years. Like he had not been in and around the NFL for very long. Now we're like so much further into his like being in NFL buildings, you know, knowing how to manage that sort of thing.

1:06:27Dave Helman: Part of his career that I am at least interested for him to get another shot within the next handful of years.

1:06:34Derrik Klassen: It reminds me of Parks and Rec where Adam Scott's character, Ben Wyatt, was like a teen mayor. And it went like terribly. and 15 years later he's like a normal adult who's good at his job but all anybody wants to talk about is when he was a teen mayor so hopefully Brandon Staley gets a chance to correct that course of events but yeah I mean he's 43 years old I would imagine if he keeps doing what he's doing he'll have his opportunities if there's one thing you can count on this show for other than just the nerdiest level of football discourse we're gonna get like a mid 2000s to early 20 teens sitcom reference off.

1:07:18Derrik Klassen: That's what we're going to do here. But for now, that is all we got. Thank you all so much for listening. I I'll echo what Mays always says. I love doing these shows. The questions are incredible. They like it. It's I look forward to having my brain challenged by these questions every week. So we love doing them. Please keep sending them in and we will be back with plenty more. We'll talk to you all next time. thanks for tuning in make sure to hit that subscribe or follow button so you never miss an episode if you enjoyed what you heard please like, comment, and leave a rating we'll see you next time

1:07:58Dave Helman: what if fragrance could do more than fill a room? the Sense of Calm collection from the Pura Calm partnership is designed to help you unwind, re-center, and find stillness right where you are explore three new fragrances each paired with Calm's most loved audio experiences. Try Sleep Story, a lavender drift into deep rest. Or there's Breathe Bubble, a mindful reset wrapped in white tea and cashmere. And finally, Soundscape, a fresh clearing rush that restores your energy. Ground your space, quiet your mind, and explore the Sense of Calm collection at pura.com slash calm.

1:08:36Dave Helman: Hey, Pablo Torre here. As a sports journalist, I've covered global sports for many years now. And there is one thing that I can promise you.

1:08:44Derrik Klassen: Nothing compares to the World Cup.

1:08:46Dave Helman: And this time, it is even better thanks to McDonald's. You have the chance to take home one of nine legendary cups when you order the FIFA World Cup meal. The cups feature some of the biggest legends in football, like David Beckham, Thierry Henry, and Ronaldinho, Christian Pulisic, Lamin Amal, and Alfonso Davies. Right now, get one of nine legendary cups when you order the FIFA World Cup meal only at McDonald's. At participating McDonald's, only for a limited time, while supplies last. All rights reserved. Copyright 2026. McDonald's at the FIFA World Cup 2026. Your team just added its 67th AI tool and also your 67th security blind spot.

1:09:24Dave Helman: The good news? The Vanta agent works like a GRC engineer in the background, finding every app your team uses, scoring the risk, and drafting fixes for you. Vanta is the platform used by over 16 ,000 fast-moving companies like Ramp, Cursor, and Harvey, who are shaping the future with AI and staying ahead of AI risk. Get started at Vanta.com.