What Trevor Lawrence's rise can teach us about NFL quarterbacks

0:00With the Discover Cash Back Card, it's payback time when you earn cash back on everyday purchases. Activate and earn 5 % cash back at different categories each quarter on up to$1 ,500 in purchases. That's 5 % cash back at different places each quarter, like grocery stores, on gas, and at restaurants. It pays to Discover. Terms apply. See discover.com slash 5 for details. Apartheid. White supremacy. Are Israelis indigenous? Are Palestinians? These are the conversations most people are too afraid to have. I'm Yuram Yahu, and my new show Borderlines with That Semite walks straight through that minefield.

0:37Every episode, I hit the street to ask regular people what they really think, then sit down with an expert who often sees it completely differently than I do. No slogans, no point scoring, just two people trying to understand. Search Borderlines with That Semite wherever you get your podcasts. From Unpacked. This is Hannah Berner from Giggly Squad. Opil is the first over-the-counter daily birth control pill available in the U.S. Let's be real. Getting a birth control prescription is not always easy, and it's so much admin. In fact, about a third of women face barriers to access prescription birth control.

1:11Between scheduling appointments, missing work, class, or just trying to exist, it's a lot. But now Opil is putting birth control in our control. Opil is a daily birth control that's FDA-approved, full prescription strength, and estrogen-free, and 98 % effective when used as directed. Grab it online or at most major retailers, no prescription or doctor's appointment needed. So if you're thinking about birth control, check out Opill to see if it's right for you. Use code Giggly for 25 % off your first month of Opill at O-P-I-L-L dot com. That's code Giggly at O-P-I-L-L dot com. Birth control in your control.

1:46We love to see it.

1:50Robert Mays: Welcome to The Athletic Football Show, brought to you by the U.S. Bank Smartly Visa Signature Card. I'm Robert Mays. Typically on these Thursday midweek shows, we like to have an outside guest on, but the conversation that we're having today, I couldn't have it with anybody that is not Derek Klassen. We're going to talk about Trevor Lawrence today, but we're going to talk about Trevor Lawrence and the broader scope of the NFL. We're going to talk about what Trevor Lawrence's rise this year, and even going back into the second half of last year, can teach us about quarterbacks, can teach us about how sensitive they are to their surroundings, can teach us about why we should be patient with some of these guys, can teach us why it's worth hanging on to certain priors you might have, even if in the moment it sounds crazy to do so.

2:31Robert Mays: There is a lot that I think Trevor points to in how we talk about, think about, and consider quarterbacks in the NFL in 2026. And so that's what me and Derek did today. We used Trevor to have a very wide-ranging discussion about the quarterback position in the modern NFL. Let's get to that conversation right now.

2:58Robert Mays: After we had Bill Barnwell on for the midweek show last week, I declared myself retired from quarterback discourse for 2026. And then I willingly decided we were going to have more of it today because I do think there's a really compelling conversation to be had about what we've seen from some guys at the position this year. And more importantly, how we can use that as a jumping off point to talk about the position more broadly. And so I'm excited to dig into this. And I'm specifically excited to dig into this with you because I think you're a notable person to be on the other end of this conversation for a few different reasons.

3:38There's no running from quarterback discourse. You've done this long enough that there's no getting away from it. Even if you want to, like you said, something in the back of your mind creeps up and you're like, but what if I did talk about the quarterbacks? And so, yeah, I think when you pitched this to me, I was really excited about it. And so I think this is going to be a really good one.

3:55Robert Mays: I did my video about this, the replay brew social videos that we're doing. If you guys have not seen them, they're on our Instagram account. They're on our Twitter account. Scott, our social media producer, meets me for coffee in the mornings. And then we just walk back to the studio and I just kind of spout off about whatever's on my mind that week. and it's about a three minute video. But when I finished that three minute video, I was like, there's so many more things we could talk about with this subject specifically. And so I just decided, whatever, it's my show. We're doing a full podcast about it because I think there's so much other stuff that we can hit that you just don't have time to explore in a short video like that.

4:30Robert Mays: And the crux of it is this. I think that Trevor Lawrence is the perfect entry point into this conversation. And the conversation being, we know more, We know less about quarterbacks than we like to admit, and quarterbacks are more sensitive to their surroundings than we like to admit. Trevor Lawrence looks like an MVP candidate this year. Trevor Lawrence is playing at an incredible clip. He looks so good, so confident. We've hit on that in a bunch of different shows. I want to read to you a couple quotes about Trevor Lawrence from NFL coaches and executives from the 2025 Mike Sando quarterback tiers.

5:10Robert Mays: I always thought Lawrence was a unique talent from a body type perspective. So athletic for a guy that tall. And the way he played at Clemson was outstanding, another head coach said. But when I watched him this year, 2024, the instinct wasn't as high there. He looked hesitant. He had some ugly tape. Here's another one from a former GM. He hasn't proved that he can take the team up a level or make the team play better than they are. I definitely think Liam Cohen can help him there if he is able to be helped. this idea of we see some flashes from a really talented player but there's just something missing it comes up so often when we have these big talented guys that fall short in terms of their own production or team success for one reason or another these are the same quotes that you hear about Justin Herbert right now these are some of the same quotes I want to go back and read this one because I think this one is also particularly telling this is from the 2015 15 quarterback tiers.

6:06Robert Mays: Okay. No doubt he's a tier two and I love him, but something is missing. Stafford could be like Aaron Rogers if he had the burning passion. And if he had Mike McCarthy from day one, because he's talented like that and quick with the ball. But you look at the look on Stafford's face before the game. And then you look at the look on Rogers face or big Ben's or Lux or especially drew breezes. Holy shit. You look at Matthew Stafford's eyes and it's like a gym class. It's like, I hope we win. I think we're pretty good as opposed to I'm going to rip your throat out. That is the most like you can ascribe whatever you want to a quarterback when they're winning or when they're losing.

6:48Doing the like, not like Rodgers didn't have passion at the time or whatever, that Mike McCarthy wasn't good at the time. But like that is really funny looking at where all of those pieces and players are now. Like it's just it's kind of ridiculous.

7:01Robert Mays: And I read these because I think it's a good place to start when it comes to how we used to talk about certain quarterbacks that we no longer talk about that way. In that quarterback tiers article that I quoted from about Trevor Lawrence, which came out last summer, okay, last July, July 2025. In that exercise, Trevor Lawrence was quarterback 18 in that ranking. He was behind Tua at quarterback 17. Baker was at quarterback 11. insane. And I don't, I'm not even saying this to shit on the people that are doing that exercise and the people that Mike is talking to. I just think we have really short memories when it comes to how much this stuff vacillates for most of the quarterbacks in the NFL.

7:50Robert Mays: I think there are guys who are immune from this to a degree. If you look at the numbers over the last five to seven years, Mahomes and Josh Allen, even if the circumstances have never really been bad for them. They've been different. The circumstances have changed over a six-year period, whether those are structural within the offense like they are for Josh Allen, whether it's the talent they're surrounded with like it is with Patrick Mahomes. And every single year, those guys are at like 0.08, 0.10 EPA per drop back or better, really high success rates. They are still good no matter what. I would kind of include Joe Burrow in this conversation, which is a slightly different hallway that we can go down if we want to, But those three guys kind of sit alone.

8:33Robert Mays: Even Lamar. Lamar's numbers year after year, he has taken some dips. So you look at Mahomes, Allen, and kind of Burrow. After that, everyone else is liable to have these sort of vacillations from year to year based on the circumstances we're playing with or they're playing in. And I think there's just so much to consider there with how we talk about guys, how certainly we talk about guys, how much grace we give guys, all of that. But as I kind of lay out the broad strokes of what I want to dig into here and use Trevor as a jumping off point, what about this specifically do you find most interesting?

9:12I actually think that there are a couple of different ways that we can go about it. I do think one of them, and I think this actually we can stick on Trevor, and I think this is maybe a particular point that is less like general, but more specific to a handful of guys. I do think with some guys like Trevor Lawrence, And I think that this was absolutely true, Caleb. There is like a weird people wanting to be anti-hype of when we have these unbelievable talents. The guys who are first overall picks have been the first overall pick for years coming into it. And actually, even young Stafford actually falls into this.

9:43People knew he was going to be the first round pick for a long time because the time was...

9:46Robert Mays: Oh my God, he was like 17. Yes, like it was a prophecy. And for all those guys where it feels like it was just always going to be from day one, Andrew Luck is a little bit of this. there's kind of this like until they show that they are truly the best in the league there's always this like the expectations for them are just they get warped and like I think that was absolutely true of Trevor Lawrence obviously Caleb as a rookie and I think that that always extends especially to their rookie seasons where if these guys are not immediately the savior it's like oh well then what was the point this guy doesn't have it it's never going to come along and that's always exacerbated by if anybody else in the class looks good obviously for Caleb Williams like Jaden Daniels looks good that year for Trevor Lawrence Mac Jones looks good that year but and I think what you said actually about the quote about Trevor Lawrence where the GM or coach or whoever it was was like man he played this way at Clemson yada yada yada we we allow ourselves to forget the talent of some of these players because the circumstances wear down on them for a year or two and it's like oh they've got a couple of bad habits now and we forget that what they were in college, you know, sometimes that can be weird circumstances.

10:56You're playing with super talented people, but that talent is there. Like those guys are the first overall pick for a reason or top five picks or whatever for a reason. And you can get to places where offensive line gets better. They find a coach that they love. They go through some of the ups and downs and learning different styles, which that I want to talk about too. Like quarterbacks having to learn different styles of winning. It finally comes along and you're like, oh yeah this guy was always this talented and was just not put in very good circumstances for the first you know in Trevor Lawrence's case the first four years of his career five years

11:29Robert Mays: the circumstances point and we can dig into Trevor specifically in a second I think I want to sit with that before we can dig into the rest of the conversation I think you can draw some lines even if those lines move a little bit from year to year between the top top guys and the rest of them. If you use quarterback tiers as an example, for the most part, there are four to five guys in tier one every single year. Mahomes, Allen, Burrow are pretty much always in there. And then you have a couple guys that sneak in and out for whatever reason, right? We just talked about Lamar. Stafford's been in there a little bit.

12:01Robert Mays: Roger's at the end of his career. After that, so that tier is anywhere from three to five guys in a given year. Tier two is usually from like quarterback six to quarterback 15. And that feels right. Right. And so I think that feels correct. What I want to say to that, and actually this is maybe like a really dumb guy take, but all of those, the elite quarterbacks that you just listed, Joe Burrows, Lamar Jackson's, the guys at the tippy top, Matthew Stafford, I think can fall into this category. A lot of the times the quarterbacks where we are putting them on a pedestal as truly elite and not that they aren't sensitive to their surroundings on some level, but those guys always inarguably feel like the best or second best player on their offense.

12:45Like Joe Burrow, obviously Jamar Chase is on that on that offense as well. But then I think you get into the tier two guys where it's like they are clearly good and helping the offense, but there are just a lot of other really good pieces around them. I think Jared Goff is this Dak Prescott, I think to a degree is this like, I think in my opinion, like Tyler Smith is probably the best player on that offense. Dak, Seedy and Pickens are all like kind of in the same category but again that doesn't make it clear that Dak Prescott is like that level of guy and so I think like that actually does go to your point of like that's why 6 to 15 can kind of feel like it vacillates because depending on who those other pieces are that would normally be like in the same tier as the quarterback or above them or slightly below them that's why stuff feels like it changes all the time for those guys and I think when you see

13:33Robert Mays: all of the movement in that group from six to let's even call it like 18 if you're going to throw Trevor Lawrence in there as quarterback 18 from last year's version of this exercise I think those are that that there is so much movement among that group and there is so much uncertainty and confusion and almost dissonance when we talk about and think about those quarterbacks because that group is just so much more sensitive to everything that's happening around them So in each given year, based on the coaching injuries, the support system in terms of the personnel around them, you can go from being quarterback 18 to quarterback eight back down to quarterback 15.

14:13Robert Mays: And it seems completely crazy and it seems like we don't really know anything. But that's partially because we don't. But it's also just because I think this group of quarterbacks is just particularly volatile based on what's going on around them. And I think part of that, I was trying to think about this as to why it seems like guys are more sensitive to their surroundings than they might have been in previous eras of the NFL. Because it does kind of feel that way, right? Like, based on who your coach is, it can just swing so wildly. Baker Mayfield, on the other side of the Trevor Lawrence thing, is a perfect example of this.

14:50Robert Mays: Like, when Baker Mayfield had Liam Cohen, he was quarterback 11. What does Baker Mayfield look like now? It's not quarterback 11. It might be double that. You might have said double that number. And I think part of the reason for that is that the offenses right now, because of how hard it is to play against modern defenses, have to do so much of the heavy lifting for pretty much every single quarterback that's not one of those guys. That if there are changes in the quality of that support system, you're going to notice it. Like you're just going to see the huge swings because the support system is so important for pretty much every single quarterback.

15:31Robert Mays: And honestly, it's not even pretty much every single quarterback anymore. Think about what the Chiefs are doing right now. The Chiefs came into this season and acknowledged in what their plans have looked like that even we with Patrick Mahomes cannot play the way we used to, which was the most quarterback. The Chiefs and the Bengals played the most quarterback-centric offenses in football. And the Chiefs came to a conclusion after last season saying, even with Patrick Mahomes, we can no longer play this way. So if the Chiefs are thinking that way, how important is the infrastructure and support system to all of the other quarterbacks in the NFL that aren't Patrick Mahomes?

16:12Robert Mays: I would say incredibly important. It's incredibly important. I'm glad you bring up the defense's thing. I do think just with some of the too high stuff and how good teams have gotten with blitzes and some of their simulated pressures and creepers and all that stuff. I do just think that quarterback in a lot of ways feels harder to play now than it did as recently as like five years ago. And I think you have that coupled with like, oh, there are a lot of starters in the league and a lot of these guys that we're talking about where it feels like there's some vacillations to year to year that are like under 30 years old, where it's like you don't I don't think you fully crystallize mentally a lot of the time until you hit around 30.

16:47and a lot of these guys where it feels like you can have these ups and downs or they are sensitive to stuff like a Trevor Lawrence who I think is like 27 years old yeah like those guys are probably going to be a little bit more sensitive to that guys like Drake May Caleb Williams these younger players they're going to be more sensitive to that because I do think another thing that I wanted to talk about is that save for rare cases and it's actually funny you bring up Mahomes because even he has had to do it. Save for rare cases, guys need to go through multiple iterations of themselves before they feel like immovable and unstoppable.

17:22Like most of these guys have to do that. Stafford early in his career was a chuck it, it sort of quarterback. And then he has the Jim Bob Cruder era where it's like, it's all check downs and they put the Ferrari in the garage. It was the worst. I hated it. I hated it so much. Even as someone who was like, I was not like super high on Stafford on the time. I'm not going to lie about that. But even when I was like, the style of quarterback he is just didn't make sense that they were doing that. But I do think like in the long term, it probably served him in some way learning how to live that way.

17:51And then he gets the Daryl Bevel and Sean McVay years where it's a little bit more under center. It's like kind of controlled. It's some blend of the two. Lamar Jackson obviously comes onto the scene and he's incredible as an MVP, but that was so specific. And then he really needs to get into the Todd Monken offense and become something new where it's like, okay, now he does feel a little bit less sensitive to this stuff. He's unstoppable. Jared Goff being kind of Sean McVay's puppet early on in Los Angeles. And then he gets to Detroit and it's like, if he doesn't take more ownership of the offense, he's not going to be a good enough quarterback.

18:23And so he has to go through that. The last one I'll bring up, Josh Allen being a, when he got into the league, he was just kind of a wild horse. And then his second year, he really did learn to throw the one to 10 yard area pretty well. But it was still for that year. and then the handful of years after that was Stefan Diggs, high volume passing offense, we're dropping back, we're throwing it all over the yard. And then the last two or three years, it's been like, we need to slow down the heartbeat of the offense, we're going to run the ball, we're going to throw it down the field, we're going to protect things.

18:52And now I think he's at the point where he can kind of weaponize both of those different worlds of quarterbacking. And again, all of these guys really didn't get to that point until they were 28, 29, 30, 31 years old. And so I think going through multiple iterations learning how to beat everything that's why like Peyton Manning and Tom Brady year to year when they were in their 30s were always able to just like do whatever they needed to do to win a game

19:16Robert Mays: yeah and that's not everyone has till they're till they're 30 that's a long time to wait and it kind of gets into something I want to talk about with how long should we wait and when do we know because I do think there's something to point out there but you talking about that I think the Josh Allen thing is it's worth circling back to even Josh Allen there are vacillations in the type of Josh Allen we get the quality was always at a certain level because of how special of a player Josh Allen was essentially from year three to right now there's been the quality has remained at a certain level but it's felt more volatile he's turned the ball over more his individual play has swung a little bit based on what he was being asked to do within the offense so if Josh Allen's play is going to swing a little bit based on what he's asking to do.

20:03Robert Mays: What do you think is going to happen with quarterbacks who are one or two steps down from Josh Allen, which can still allow you to be a really, really good quarterback in the NFL? It's going to swing even more, even if you're the seventh best quarterback in the league. It's going to swing all the time. And again, that's why guys like Dak Prescott and Jared Goff and all these guys can be and are very good quarterbacks, but it is dependent on things kind of breaking the right way for you or you land in a perfect situation. I mean, like the fact that I think a perfect example for this, Matt Ryan having what is one of the best quarterback seasons ever, basically, where for the majority of his career up to that was a very good quarterback, but he was in that like seven to 10 range, like always like kind of flirting with Pro Bowls, pretty good, had some really high highs, but was never felt like dominant and then you get two years in the Shanahan system you have a hall of fame wide receiver and a couple of other like really nice skill pieces to like put around that and all of a sudden like everything clicks into place where they're getting him to do some stuff that he wasn't comfortable with before with all the boot stuff and marrying that with some downfield passing element that like not every Shanahan style of quarterback has always had and so you just get this beautiful marriage of that which this is kind of why I talked about Trevor Lawrence and their offense feeling like the 2016 falcons potentially is like they are marrying a lot of those things where you're getting the value of the liam cohen under center can you just throw this dig route sort of offense we're going to scheme some stuff open on top of like you can four and five man concept just like drop back and trevor will find people he will throw outbreakers that other quarterbacks can't get and you get this blend of like finding the stuff that he was always good at and then giving him six freebies a game that just like unlocks everything and takes the load off of the quarterback a little bit.

21:53Robert Mays: I'm kind of fast forwarding to this part of the conversation. I thought we might wrap up here, but you mentioning Matt Ryan, I think this is as good a place of any to do it. Before we dig into what I want to talk about, though, let's take our first quick break. Football season has arrived and with the U.S. Bank's Smartly Visa signature card, you earn an unlimited 2 % cash back on every purchase, including at the stadium or at home watching on a brand new TV. Score big with unlimited 2 % cash back on every purchase. Visit usbank.com slash smartlycard to learn more. The creditor and issuer of this card is U.S.

22:23Robert Mays: Bank National Association, pursuant to a license from Visa USA, Inc. Some restrictions may apply. Everyone is looking for something when they go to buy a new car. That something is going to differ from person to person, but there are a few obvious buckets that we're all going to check off in one way or another. For me and my wife, we have two kids. So when we went shopping for our last car, obviously safety, reliability, and something that we knew could be our car for the long haul were at the top of our list. Whatever your priorities when buying a new car might be, CarGurus can help you zero in on them and find the right car for you.

22:55With CarGurus, you can describe what you're looking for in your own words. Simply type what you want, and Guru instantly shows you real available listings that match your exact needs. Dealership mode on the CarGurus app puts you in control. You can compare cars side by side, check pricing, and estimate your final cost so you can navigate the dealership with confidence. With more than 4 million listings, CarGurus has the biggest selection of cars, so it's easier than ever to find the right car in the right deal. CarGurus helps you shop with more transparent pricing, allowing you to see when dealer fees are included so you can compare listings with greater confidence.

23:26It's no wonder CarGurus is the number one most visited car shopping site, according to SimilarWeb's estimated traffic data. Buy or sell your next car today with CarGurus at CarGurus.com. Go to cargurus.com to make sure your big deal is the best deal. That's C-A-R-G-U-R-U-S dot com. cargurus.com

23:49Your call has been forwarded to an automatic voice message system. A missed call doesn't feel like anything. No red flag. No notifications screaming at you. It just disappears into your call log. And nine times out of ten, that was someone ready to hand you money. That's why today's episode is brought to you by Quo, spelled Q-U-O, the business phone system built so you never miss a call. Here's what I like about it. All your calls, texts, and voicemails live in one place, so anyone on your team can pick up a conversation, see the full history, and respond fast. No more, wait, who talked to this customer last?

24:25And if you're worried about after-hours leads slipping through, Quo's optional built-in AI agent can answer questions and even book appointments while your team's offline. It's the number one rated business phone system on G2, and over 90 ,000 businesses already trust it to stay reachable. Money is on the line. Always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free. Plus, get 20 % off your first six months when you go to Quo.com slash tech. That's Q-U-O dot com slash tech.

24:58Robert Mays: All right, so the financial part of this is interesting to me. because I think that it warrants a conversation, right? Because if we can acknowledge that there is a gap between the top three four-ish guys and the rest of the quarterbacks in terms of resilience, how steadfast they are, independent of the circumstances and just overall quality, there's not a huge gap in how they're paid, okay? And so most of those guys are 55 million. They're bumping up against each other. Mahomes obviously got the most recent new deal, but they're still mostly clustered together. And this is where I, this is kind of where I've landed with this thought.

25:38Robert Mays: There are currently 13 NFL quarterbacks that are making$50 million a year. When you're asking as part of this process, if you're having to pay Trevor Lawrence, you're having to pay Jordan Love, and you're not sure that there's been some inconsistency. It's like, man, is this guy worth pay? I think the question that you have to ask yourself and the answer that matters most, could this player in the right circumstances be the MVP of the league or at least like put themselves in like position where you have that season where like Dak Prescott in 2023 I think actually like that's a perfect example too where like he didn't win it but you've seen him a player like that where quarterback 7 to 12 however you want to put it can reach those highs in the right scenarios I mean shit this year the offense might be good enough where he can put up those sorts of numbers and so like he in a lot of ways like feels like the cutoff in some ways like for around what that tier is i want to list off the guys that are making 55 million dollars a year there are currently 13 of them mahomes has multiple mvps allen has an mvp lamar has an mvp stafford has an mvp joe burrow yes he's been up there number of times yes no no question okay dak like you just said 2023 mvp runner-up jaylen hertz even if you're frustrated by jaylen hertz 2022 mvp runner-up He absolutely could be the MVP if you put him in the right circumstances.

27:00Robert Mays: Jordan Love and Justin Herbert. I think the answer for both of them is yes. When you look at what they have done, the level that they have played at, even if it's been frustrating at times and it can be a little bit volatile, I think the answer is definitively yes for both of those players. I mean, Justin Herbert's second year, he threw 5 ,000 yards. The answer for each of those guys is yes. Jared Goff. I think the answer is yes. Like if you look at some of the statistical seasons Jared Goff has had, he's thrown for like 4 ,500 yards and 35 plus touchdowns. In an era where we have the aliens that are doing that plus some of the rushing, it's going to be hard to do.

27:35Robert Mays: But historically, Jared Goff being the quarterback of a top five offense with this sort of passing numbers, yes. Like if the Lions were to win 14, 15 games, there's absolutely a world where Jared Goff would be able to win the MVP. He's the most specific case probably. Yes, agreed. Like the window for how it would have to happen. But like, there's absolutely a world where the offense goes a certain way and he throws 44 touchdowns in a season. And it's like, sure, if they win 13 games, yeah. Two more. Trevor could be the MVP of the league this year based on the way that he's playing, the way that offense looks.

28:09Robert Mays: And the other one, that same deal, Brock Purdy. So those are 12 of the guys. The only one who's making$50 million that I think it would be hard to say this about is probably Baker. and even Baker in 2024, if that team wins a shitload of games, he had the numbers to potentially get you there. But I do think he's kind of the outlier among this group. And I think of all of these guys, that's the only contract where I look at it and say, I think that's a bad contract. All the other guys, I think I would give it to them in a heartbeat. And so when I was trying to do this and I was like, all right, well, if they're not as good, is it worth paying them$55 million a year?

28:45Robert Mays: And I think the answer is yes, because if you have one of them and you can find the Liam Cohen, then the value of having a player like this, you're still not overpaying when you're giving them$55 million a year if they have the potential to have this sort of season. I totally agree with that because I think it's easy to look at the top three or four guys, whoever it's going to be, and then comparing them to what Trevor is making, what Brock Purdy is making, what Jared Goff is making or whatever, and being like, well, it's not that big of a difference. Do you really want to pay those other quarterbacks that?

29:16But in my mind, it's more just like, I think the guys like Lamar Jackson and Patrick Mahomes are just always going to be underpaid. Like, it's just the way that the league works, like the value that they give you, you are just getting a D like a discount on it because those guys are so damn good. And realistically, I do think that, like you're saying, if you can have one of those dozen quarterbacks in the NFL at a given time that can have an MVP season. sure you need more things to go right for those guys than Patrick Mahomes Josh Allen the Hall of Famers whatever not everybody's going to work with the Hall of Famer at a time there's only like five of them in a league at a given time and so if you don't have one of them but you think that they can have those highs and we're seeing it like you said with half of these guys Dak Prescott Trevor and Brock and maybe Jared Goff like might do it this year like all might be in the running and so like I do think that those guys are all like really good cases for what we're laying out

30:06Robert Mays: I also think we don't just talk a lot about this because it's not totally relevant, but I think it's it's worth mentioning. I also think that's why the middle class reclamation quarterback contract over the last few years is so valuable because you're paying 60 percent of this premium. But I think you can make an argument that Sam Darnold is closer to this group than this group is to Patrick Mahomes. yes yeah yeah Patrick the three or four guys at the top are like such an untouchable fix everything all the time that it's you're just not going to get that whereas like with Sam Darnold when you can allocate some other resources to pay for DeMarcus Lawrence on defense and stuff like that you can get them to like the thing Sam Darnold I don't think is ever going to be able to lead an offense that is top three in offensive DVOA or whatever and they're the best in the league and he's going for MVPs but I think that you can get him to the point where they are a top eight offense and you can have a wide receiver who is winning offensive player of the year and that I think is for the money that you're paying like probably better what you're getting than what on a year-to-year basis you're even getting for that like other middle tier but there's none none of those those don't happen I mean they have to luck into those guys yes yes you have to luck into them like the Bucks getting Baker Mayfield initially like I mean they signed him for like a one year whatever million dollars four million bucks yeah it's like you stumble into that working out for you and then even even in the case of baker mayfield because he was a little bit older smaller gets banged up i think a little bit more sensitive to some of that stuff um did not last i think as long as they were hoping whereas like i do think that because sam darnold is such a good athlete he's a little bit younger the arm is unbelievable like i could actually see him having like a longer runway um obviously maybe if he gets paid at a certain point that the number will jump up but like he at least has a longer runway in my opinion for this like continuing to work out for him yeah and i also think that these those contracts just don't come along very often it's a reminder that it's worth taking a chance on those sorts of players the way that the vikings did with the sam darnold the way that the bucks did with baker mayfield if we're admitting that we know less about the quarterbacks than we think and the quarterbacks are more sensitive with their surroundings than we think betting consistently on quarterbacks that were in poor surroundings and hoping you can get more out of them, that is a good bet.

32:23Robert Mays: Unfortunately, the market is going to correct with that. Justin Fields signed a two-year$40 million contract with the Jets last offseason because the Jets were trying to make that exact sort of bet. I don't think it was the wrong process for exactly the reasons that we're talking about. But I think it's just a reminder that the chances to do this are very rare, and they're going to dry up as the market corrects because of how valuable those contracts potentially are. Yeah, that's going to be the thing is everybody's going to try to do it. And then if you're signing, if you're signing all of these guys for 20 % more than whatever the contract you were getting for beforehand, it's like, well, then that's probably enough money to not sign guys like DeMarcus Lawrence on defense anymore.

33:02And so it's like, then it's like, what's the point now? If you're only saving 10%, 15, I'm just throwing out numbers, but if you're only like saving 10 to 15 % on this mid tier quarterback, based on whatever you're paying Trevor Lawrence, Jordan Love, Brock Purdy, it's like, well, shit, sure. it's a little bit more expensive, but I'd way rather just have that guy at a certain point and hope that he's going to solve some stuff for me. Because even having one of those guys that can win

33:24Robert Mays: the MVP is immensely valuable. Yes. And even if those guys, the Dak Prescott's this, that 7 to 13 range, whatever we're calling it, even if they are more sensitive to their surroundings than the top guys like Patrick Mahomes and stuff, they are much less sensitive than guys like Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold. And like, I do think that there still are levels to it, even if those guys ultimately are more sensitive to that stuff. So if the lesson with Trevor is patience and I think a little bit of humility and a little bit of let's wait and see, I want to go through what that process looked like for you specifically, because you never wavered in your belief that in the right circumstances, Trevor Lawrence could be, again, an MVP caliber quarterback, that he could reach that level.

34:10Robert Mays: So I just want to ask you, as you were going through the 2023, back after the 2023 season, and most importantly, the 2024 season before he got hurt. As you were watching Trevor and a lot of people were jumping ship, what kept you in a place where you were like, nah, this guy is still good? I think a big one for me, and I think some people sometimes get frustrated with like holding onto draft priors and stuff like that. We're going to talk about that. Yeah. But I think the draft prior stuff is, like this sounds ridiculous, but like it's valid. Those guys go that high in the draft because they are really talented.

34:47And I do think that that's where it started for me with Trevor is like, he's a really good athlete. He is like 6 '5", like 215 pounds. He's a really explosive, not just mover, but thrower. Like the ball flies out of his hands. And I think just when you see, and the other thing with him, this always stood out at Clemson. It stood out in the NFL. There is, you can kind of really tap into who are the elite athletes at quarterback based on how well they throw when they're rolling to their left. Because to get your body around, to be able to throw that well, to be able to move like that, it's really difficult.

35:18And Trevor has always been one of the best in the NFL at it. And so to me, there was always just this level of talent that was really, really hard for me to move on from. And then I think that there were always just a couple of things that from his best moments, I was willing to cling on to. Like when he had any degree of offensive line help, his pocket presence is phenomenal. the way that he moved around and there were low moments where offensive line cratered a little bit and he starts to feel pressure that's not there and all that stuff but that happens to a lot of quarterbacks but in my mind when he had his highs and he had help the pocket movement and the feel was incredible and the other thing with him to me is he was never afraid to make the most difficult throws on the field whether it's you know those dig routes you'll throw deep outbreakers like he was always willing to make to me the throws that when these guys crystallize by the time they're 30 all of the best quarterbacks in the NFL are making these throws consistently.

36:14And you can get away with offenses on a year-to-year basis that don't necessarily do a lot of that. But over the long term, these quarterbacks have to make a lot of those throws. And I thought that he was always willing to do that. And then the last thing that I would say, and this always sounded like Cope in the moment, and it probably was, but a big part of Trevor's thing is that he is going to throw the football. he he knows what the open throw is supposed to be he can read the coverages he is going to throw it whether or not you are open or can catch the football is your problem and for a long time for a long time they just didn't have receivers who were comfortable over the middle of field or snapping off their routes at the right depth and it was like the quarterback looks like an asshole because he looks like he's throwing to a covered receiver or it's another drop or it's another tipped interception.

37:02And I think I was just willing to believe that with the right players and the right talent, that skill set and style of offense can work. And now we're seeing it. They trade for Jacoby Myers. Parker Washington has really come into his own as that style of player. And even Josh Cameron this year as more of a big body guys, like they have the right kinds of receivers to play the way that Trevor has always wanted to play. And I think I was just willing to believe that eventually we would get to a spot where the team would have that sort of

37:31Robert Mays: talent the receiving talent is part of it but to me the most important thing is Liam Cohen is one of the difference-making guys and that too like when you have one of them one day he would get one of them and I even in the moment when I was watching it I was like and it's so funny because I think people get annoyed by this too where we'll just put them in one of those offenses like just put them in one of like the under center Shanahan McVay offenses and it's like they did it and then it worked you know like it's it sounds stupid to keep saying that over and over and over again but then for the most part outside of herbert with mcdaniel right now which is a different conversation a lot of these types of offenses do make it easier on the quarterback they are a positive multiplier for whatever the quarterback is you mentioning the some of the the he's gonna throw it no matter what things i i want to talk about that because i think that's interesting my personal journey with trevor specifically i was firmly in the trevor camp like all the way through the 2023 season right even when it was a little bit more frustrating In 2022, in the back half of the season, he was great.

38:29Robert Mays: And I think that's important. And I think that will bring me to another point I want to hit here in a second. But even in 2023, the game I firmly remember where it felt like a fork in the road moment where you had to choose one direction or the other is when they played the Ravens on Sunday Night Football in 2023. He had that game where he turned the ball over a couple of times. He had a couple of fumbles. And I remember going back and watching that game and coming on whatever next show it was that we were doing and being like, I actually think he played pretty well. And I understand, and this is kind of what I want to dig into next.

39:04I understand if you are a listener,

39:08Robert Mays: if you are a general NFL fan, having some asshole come on the show after you just watched a guy turn the ball over multiple times in primetime and tell you that he read some sacred text by going back and watching the tape that shows this guy actually played well would be maddening. I completely understand that. And there is a very interesting tension here. Okay? You're watching the people that are on the outside that do not have the time or get paid to go back and rewatch every single one of these games and understand exactly the context, every detail about why a play happened the way that it did.

39:47Robert Mays: They're seeing a guy make mistakes. they're seeing a guy finish look like an also ran quarterback the way that Justin Herbert has at times over the last couple of years, the way that Jordan love can in certain moments, the way that Trevor Lawrence did for long stretches. And they're being like, well, if it's the money ball thing, well, if he's a good quarterback, why isn't he playing good? And I get why there's frustration in what you're seeing. And then some people kind of sitting there and being steadfast and being like, no, I promise you that this guy is going to be okay. And I think as a product of that tension, there have been times where I've kind of thrown my hands up and been like, I'm willing to play devil's advocate here.

40:25Robert Mays: It happened with Trevor in the middle of last year. We had the conversation about it. He was struggling and it was just really hard as you heard this chorus of people being like, you guys are being stubborn, right? Like you guys are being unwilling to move off of things that you should move off. And I was understanding of that viewpoint. And so I think that tension makes it really difficult for somebody like you, somebody like the people that are watching these games to really sit and hunker down in what they believe. Because there are people who are going to accuse you of just being stubborn and cling to your priors.

41:01Robert Mays: When in reality, if you did that with Trevor Lawrence, you would be correct. Like that would have been the right way to treat the situation. And so I'm really understanding of where people are coming from with this. Because the last, I want to be generous. I don't want to be like, well, you just have to watch the f***ing games. Like, that's unfair. It's unfair to people who don't even have the ability to do that, let alone the freedom and time to do that. And so I get why that tension exists. I think we could be a little bit better in how we handle some of that tension. I think that's probably fair.

41:36At least the way I see it in terms of being willing to hold on to my priors, in some cases too long. I'll admit I am very stubborn. I think in the same way that the league is a very week-to-week league, it is a very year-to-year league. And I think that some things are just going to vacillate all the time, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the player is that much better or worse. It can just be all of these circumstantial things. And I think that kind of leads me to another thing that I wanted to talk about where I think a lot of people, we all say that context matters. But then when it actually comes to applying it, it becomes very difficult.

42:10And we just default to like, well, if he's playing bad, then he's just not very good. And I think that sometimes that can happen. Like, obviously, like, you know, Trevor at certain points, I think it's been like, well, he's not playing well. It's like, well, I think that there have been reasons for why that is. And like, I even think Trevor is a good example, too, because he got saved, quote unquote, in 2022. by Doug Peterson and the offense. And then with that same staff, it all falls apart for him. And so it's like, well, why isn't it working? It's like, well, what you're looking at on paper, on the roster, on the coaching staff, if it is materially not helping him on the field, I don't give a shit what it says on the paper.

42:46This happened with, you're very familiar with this, Caleb Williams rookie year. We all looked at what that could be on paper. And we were like, man, this could be so cool. Like, well, they can get by with the offensive line, but they'll be able to run the ball. Waldron can bring the offense and like they've got some of these pass catchers. And then it was completely dog shit. And it was like, I think there was this tension of we thought it was going to be good. And now the quarterback's playing bad in it. So he must be bad. But it's like in reality, he's not playing great, but everything else was not nearly as good as we thought it was supposed to be.

43:17Robert Mays: That is exactly what is happening with Justin Herbert right now. Yes, I have that in my notes too, 100%. None of the promise of the offense is coming through right now. That's exactly what's happening with him. And I just think if you're listening, if you're again, if you're one of these people that is frustrated by this type of conversation, I get it. It's going to go back to the why. Well, why is it never his fault? Why is it never their faults? Why is it never Jordan Love's fault? Why is it never Justin Herbert's fault? Why is it? Why was it never Trevor Lawrence's fault? And I think part of it is that it is their fault, but it also isn't like I think part of this like steadfast belief that it doesn't lay all at the quarterback's feet is that doesn't it make more sense when we have seen these guys play at super super high levels before that what's changed more materially is the circumstances not how good of a quarterback these guys are like a hundred percent like Justin do we think Justin Herbert is a notably worse player than he was in 2022 I doubt it I highly I probably doubt it And do we think Drake May is a notably worse player right now than he was last year?

44:25That's another perfect example where we came into this year being like, they've got A.J. Brown, they signed Romeo Dobbs, and they're going to be able to run the ball better and all this stuff. The offensive line is not any better. Morgan Moses, they had to replace midweek three. They cannot run the ball. A.J. Brown is hurt. And Romeo Dobbs, they either don't know what to do with him and he's not playing very well. And so if anything, their pass catching core is worse because they don't have Stephon Diggs or Kayshaun Booty, who were like not elite receivers last year, but better than what they are currently working with.

44:55So you add that on top of some of the schedule changes and it's like all of a sudden Drake May looks horrible. And it's like in reality, he's actually working with a worse set of circumstances than last year when we already said last year he was kind of getting by and making do with what he had.

45:11Robert Mays: The last thing I want to say about that tension before we get down to how long we should be waiting for these guys and like what becomes, We can't just say we have to wait forever, right? There's got to be a cutoff. Because that's unreasonable too. And I want to explore that. Part of this tension is also when you're in our positions and you're having to talk about these guys, and not even people in our positions, when you're not afforded 90-minute podcasts where you can try to explore every ounce of nuance, I get in a content creation world why sitting there and being like, well, it's just not good enough around him.

45:48Robert Mays: He's still a good quarterback. Sorry. And having that be the end of the conversation, that's not interesting. Like, that's not compelling. That's not compelling in the same way that trying to put it on the quarterback and living laying into the drama. All of that is compelling. I get why this is how most of the conversations unfold, because it does make for good content. It does make for good television. And if you're not somebody that's going back and rewatching all of this shit, it's easy to see. if the quarterback's not playing well and the offense isn't good it's very easy to be like well the quarterback is the problem right I get why that happens and so I think that also plays into this is that it getting to a place where you're just like adding stuff around him isn't good enough and just going back to that over and over and over again in conversation doesn't make for compelling conversation and at a certain point even we have to get to a place where I think we're trying to have more compelling conversations than that.

46:46Yeah. And I think the last thing that I would say on this, which I think actually does kind of transition us into the next thing is like, I think a big thing for me and why I was willing to hang on to Trevor, for example, is that I think oftentimes when I'm trying to defend some of these quarterbacks or we're trying to defend them, whatever, it's not that they are blameless. Justin Herbert is not playing well right now. But the difference to me is that, is he at fault or is he the problem? To me, he is at fault for some of their issues. He is not the problem with the offense. And that was like with Trevor Lawrence, for example, what I believed for a long time was that he is not the problem with what they're having.

47:22He had some bad plays. He's throwing interceptions he shouldn't. He's got a bonehead play every now and then. But that he was at fault but not the problem. And I do think that where a quarterback falls on that scale kind of depends on how much of a leash you can give them for two years, three years, whatever it's going to be.

47:39Robert Mays: The last part I wanted to hit with the Herbert thing specifically is that I get why the treatment of him has been more frustrating to people than it might be for other quarterbacks. And it's because of what people tried to do with him very quickly. I am very guilty of that. You and me both. After that 2021 season, I absolutely was like, he's one of the guys, right? He is up there with everybody else. He is right there and will be with the Mahomeses, the Allens, all of that. That did not happen. I think because the aesthetics of the way that he plays are so exciting, we tried to elevate him into a place that he did not deserve to be quicker than we should have done that.

48:27Robert Mays: And I get why I think that still plays into the frustration that some people have in the way that we talk about Justin Herbert. It's one of those, well, five years ago, you told me that he was the third best quarterback in the league. Why now does he get treated the same way as these guys from 6 to 18 that you're talking about? I get that. That's a fair thing to criticize. And I think that was wrong, right? He probably is in this group and closer to the Dax and the Purdy's and all of those guys than we made him out to be probably too often. I am fully willing to admit that. I think that is important too because I think with almost all quarterbacks and I think this extends to whether they have really high highs or really low lows early really low lows I think are a little bit more concerning but even the really high highs I think can be misleading I don't think we always know what a quarterback's true like level is until four or five years into it because some of these guys really early on can have insane highs like I even think Drake May last year is a good example I want to save this for a second because I want to end with this let's take one more quick break and dig into this because I agree with you, but I also don't.

49:37Robert Mays: Oh, okay.

49:41With the Discover Cash Back card, it's payback time when you earn cash back on everyday purchases. Activate and earn 5 % cash back at different categories each quarter on up to$1 ,500 in purchases. That's 5 % cash back at different places each quarter, like grocery stores, on gas, and at restaurants. It pays to Discover. Terms apply. See discover.com slash five for details. Hey, I'm running out to drop off a stack of letters and packages. Need anything shipped while I'm gone? Save the gas. Stamps.com lets you print postage and schedule pickups right from your desk. Sync your contacts into the address book, get detailed accounting insights, and get notified the moment your certified mail is delivered.

50:23All from my desk? All from your desk. Join the 4 million businesses using Stamps.com right now with code podcast and get your free welcome gift. Stamps.com code podcast. Taxes and fees apply. Press 1 to wait. Press 2 to hear that song again. Press 3 to wonder why customer service still works like this. Or don't. Parlo as AI agents talk with customers right when they need help. No waiting for someone to pick up. Just natural conversations that get them somewhere. Because the goal isn't getting customers off the phone. It's giving them a reason to stay. Parloa, AI agents, real conversations. Unhold your customers at Parloa.

51:01That's P-A-R-L-O-A dot com.

51:09Robert Mays: All right, so keep going with that point. The idea that you think that some of these early spikes can be a little bit misleading because I think they can be, but I also think there's enough signal on them that they're important. they are important insofar as I think if a guy like that proves himself to have insane highs within the first two years chances are he will be a at minimum top half of the league quarterback in this range that we're talking about where you get paid the 50 million dollars and it's fine and I think that part is not misleading at all I think sometimes though when a guy has Jaden Daniels's rookie year Justin Herbert's second year Drake Mays MVP last year where we are immediately like that guy's quarterback for.

51:48And it's like that probably I think is just sometimes of like a really talented player hits a spike and then defenses start to catch on to what they're going to do. Defenses change regardless of whatever that quarterback is like. Things just happen where I think that quarterback is realistically probably not going to sustain that high all the time. You get rare cases. You get Patrick Mahomes where he immediately steps in in his quarterback one and maintains that forever. And that's going to happen every now and then. More realistically, It's going to take four or five years of ebbs and flows, seeing what they look like in different circumstances, playing different schedules, playing different kinds of defenses.

52:25How do they adapt to the league changing? And kind of what I talked about earlier of like most of the time, these guys have to learn to win different ways before they become something that is immovable. And I think that's why some of these really early spike seasons you get and it looks like this guy is going to be the next guy knocking on that door of elite. and maybe they can get there eventually, but it's not always as immediate as you want it to be.

52:50Robert Mays: I'm 100 % with you on this. I think the way that you framed it, I agree with. And I'll say this, and I've talked about this. I'm guilty of it. I get excited by the things that are new. And it's like, man, what if this guy can crack this group of players? And I probably do it a little bit too fast consistently because it's fun to buy into these guys. More good quarterbacks is fun. Yes. Yeah, it makes the league better. Come on. But I think what you're saying is right. And if you, because I think the next logical question here is with some of the other young players in the NFL, how long should we wait?

53:22Robert Mays: How long is it reasonable to hold on and believe these guys might turn into quality quarterbacks? Because I do think if you look back at most of the guys that we're talking about, they all had a spike year in year like two and sometimes into year three, depending on circumstances. Okay. Lamar won the MVP in year two. talked about how Herbert's year two was insane. Lawrence, 2024 was a frustrating year for Lawrence, but he was banged up that year. 2023 that he turned the ball over a decent amount, but I think still was playing really well or still was playing pretty well. In 2022, Trevor Lawrence was awesome.

53:59Robert Mays: Trevor Lawrence had a really good year in 2022. So even if there was a little bit of a valley after that, relatively, we still saw by year two, Trevor Lawrence have one of those spikes. Drake May almost won the MVP last year. Jordan Love in year one as a starter had 4 ,100 yards and 32 touchdowns. Stafford starts 14 through 30 because he got hurt in year two is the year where he had 5 ,000 yards and 40 touchdown passes. Almost all of the guys in this tier have one of those spikes in year two into year three. Like Caleb in the back half of last year probably gives you enough in terms of that spike to be like, okay.

54:34Robert Mays: And from that spike, Like, it doesn't have to be linear. It's often not linear. But if you have that moment, I think it's worth riding the waves in the subsequent seasons because that moment in year two, if you can play for an extended stretch that way, is probably enough of a signal that you will come out on the other side of this as one of the players that we're talking about. Now, that I 100 % agree with. If you reach the mountaintop, even when you fall in certain years, more realistically, you're falling to producing like quarterback eight, nine, 10, whatever it's going to be. And you are still feel like a very good quarterback, even if it's very rare that a guy truly does break into that elite tier.

55:14I mean, that's why those guys are who they are. But yeah, I think we're actually, I think we actually arrived kind of at the same place here with what we're saying. We're like, if you have one of those spikes, you're going to get a very long runway to prove that you can get back there again. And you should. Like Trevor Lawrence is the perfect example. It took us three years to get all the way back there where we could find those spikes again. But once you get to them again and you get the right circumstances, you get the right coach, you have an offense that like might run the table. Like it really is.

55:43I think when you have those moments, you do have to hold on to them.

55:46Robert Mays: And I think it's a good reminder with the young quarterbacks. It's been rough for Cam Ward. It's been rough. And if he doesn't have one of those spikes by the end of this year, maybe you start to get a little bit worried. But he's one of those players like I think we need to show a little bit more patience. We are 19 starts into his career, 20 starts into his career. Michael Penix has started 13 games. 13 games. I think we should be open to the idea of what somebody who is as talented of a thrower as Michael Penix is might turn into. The most interesting case here, probably Bryce Young. Do we have enough time with Bryce Young that even if you, shockingly, and me are acknowledging that we are seeing the best version of Bryce Young we've ever seen this year, do we have enough time with Bryce Young for it to probably be unrealistic that he can become one of these players?

56:44Robert Mays: That's the one where there's probably the most, I don't know what to do with this among the group of young guys that we're talking about. He is a fascinating case because it goes back to what I talked about with Trevor Lawrence earlier and why I'm willing to hang on to him and some other players. Trevor Lawrence is exceptionally talented. There are only so many people in the world who are built the way that he is, who can throw the way he is, who can move the way that he does. Bryce Young, I think, is a good athlete and he has very good spatial awareness, but the physical tools are just not particularly special.

57:13And I think that's why it's a little bit harder for me to see him holding on to top 10 top 12 quarterback status. But he is interesting in the fact that I think outside of these guys who spike really early, a lot of these quarterbacks, it takes until game 24, 26, 27 for it to start to come along. Caleb Williams, great example. It took a year and a half until he was able to be like, oh, he looks like one of those dudes. And I think that that is a more realistic and common path for the young quarterback. And Bryce Young is a perfect example. For the first 20-ish starts of his career he was unplayable and the situation was bad obviously don't get me wrong very bad looked he looked like not an NFL quarterback and they tried to bench him for Andy Dalton until Andy Dalton got in a car accident and then Bryce Young had to come back but then over the last year and a half or so they've improved the offensive line a little bit obviously they're banged up like right this moment today as we're recording but in general they've been better um and then you bring in guys like Terrell McMillan Jalen Coker this year they bring in Darren Waller, like better receivers to give him a chance to look like an NFL quarterback that on top of reps.

58:18And I think them honing in what they want to be on offense. He looks like totally functional and they look like they can be a solid NFL offense. I think to me, the difference is what we're talking about. Is this the spike? Like, is the spike being 11th in quarterback, you know, EPA per play? Because if that's the spike, that's not good enough. The spike has to be like top four top five for me to be like man that's something I really want to hold on to and it brings me back to the conversation from earlier if you have to decide whether you pay Bryce Young

58:48Robert Mays: 55 million dollars a year I think the question you have to ask yourself do we think in the right circumstances Bryce Young could be the MVP of the league even if you think he is a viable starter based based on the way that he is playing right now I think that feels like a tall order I did not mean to do that. It works though. I did not mean to do that. I'm in the same boat though. I, I do think that I've gotten to a place where I think that there's a world where he can hold on to being a top 20 quarterback status and he can be a totally solid NFL starter. I just think that that is a player that if we're talking about paying like one of the top 10 guys and when he signs his deal, he's, he's fifth or fourth on spot track or whatever, or over the cap or whatever it's going to be, I'm still pretty hesitant about that because I just don't know if the ceiling and the spikes are really worth what it's going to cost to get there.

59:43Robert Mays: The last thing I want to talk about in this conversation, because it's the only thing I had in my notes that I do think is worth bringing up that we did not hit. And the jumping off point for it was that Trevor game against the Ravens in 2023. As part of these discussions, we care about turnovers too much. like whether or not a guy, I 100 % agree. I 100 % agree we care about them too much. They are influencing these conversations too much. They're the most visible place. They are so easy to fixate on. And I'm not saying turnovers don't matter. For an individual game, whether you win or lose that individual game, turnovers are the most important thing.

1:00:27Robert Mays: Turnovers are the reason Josh Allen and the Bills lost to the Broncos last year. Turnovers are the reason that Trevor Lawrence and that team lost to the Ravens in 2023. It's really the only reason Josh Allen ever loses games. Yes. But that to me, I think we fixate on them too much when we're trying to decide how good quarterbacks are. In an individual moment, in an individual game, it can be what sinks you. And maybe for Josh Allen, that's what's keeping him from all-time greatness, right? And that's fine because the wins in those games are the biggest thing for Josh Allen right now. But for most of these guys, when we're trying to figure out where they sit in these conversations, we talk and think about turnovers too much.

1:01:10Robert Mays: It's like, oh, man, Justin or Jordan Love threw two picks in this game. Jordan Love sucks. It's like, well, probably not. Like that probably isn't the most important long term determining factor of quarterback quality. The number that jumped out to me, I just very randomly, I was on the 2023 season looking at some stats and sorted all 32 quarterbacks by EPA lost on interceptions. Purdy and Mahomes in 2023 were both bottom eight in the EPA they lost on interceptions in that year. Bottom eight. Like they lost more than almost every other quarterback? Yes, they were bottom eight. In 2023, the Niners were like an unstoppable offense.

1:01:53Robert Mays: unstoppable offense those teams played in the super bowl that year so that's the only other part of this that like i don't think i've ever said explicitly i just think that and this is the other thing and i'll say this now it's far enough removed i firmly believe this and it all worked out in the end because i think he probably shouldn't have won in 2024 josh allen should have been the mvp of the league in 2023 i'm a lamar guy and i'm still never going to give up that trophy but Josh Allen should have been the MVP league in 2023 and Lamar should have been the MVP in the league in 2024 if we can we come out even in the wash I'm fine with that oh yes absolutely because honestly Lamar probably doesn't win it in 2024 only because he won it in 23 and Josh Allen didn't win it in 23 I I really do and I wish this is one of those things that I wish I had more courage in the moment I because Josh Allen turned the ball over so many times that year that's why he didn't get it Josh Allen should have been the MVP of the league in 2023 and Lamar should have won it in 2024.

1:02:49But I think this is important. And because what Josh Allen had to do, given that it was not a perfect team that year, the most of the quarterbacks in my mind who can play top 10 football and have those MVP highs, they are. It's like I said earlier, it's like Trevor. They're willing to make the throws that are really, really hard and willing to make plays and willing to make mistakes. Well, if your team ain't good and you're still willing to make mistakes, you're going to make them. You're going to get strip sacked. You're going to throw picks. you're going to take sacks you shouldn't take like that's going to happen and I think like to to bring him up again Drake May is a perfect example of this he is a quarterback who will press he will make mistakes he will try to find the big plays when it's running hot and it's working and he has enough help he will make them when the situation deteriorates he's not going to take the foot off the pedal he's going to keep going and some quarterbacks will and by virtue of that when the team is bad the quarterback doesn't look as individually terrible like I I think Derek Carr is a great example of this.

1:03:47It's a great example. He had stretches where the team was not good, the offense was not performing, but individually you look at box scores and you watch him play and you're like, I guess he wasn't that bad, but it's like he wasn't doing enough things to really put himself in position to have the mistakes that you would need for those plays to happen. And so, again, I do think it sounds weird, but the guys who are the best quarterbacks are the ones who are willing to make the worst plays sometimes.

1:04:14Robert Mays: And I think that explains part of the gap and part of the fixation with people like us really hyping up and talking about the talented, aesthetically pleasing quarterbacks, because even the lows are going to be low when the circumstances get a little bit worse. But because the highs have a chance of being so high because of the way that they play, I think it's worth believing and betting on those quarterbacks in the long term. And so it just, again, speaks to a lot of the tension that can exist as we're having these conversations about these sort of guys. All right. I'm sure no one will be mad or annoyed about anything that we just said over the last hour.

1:04:52Robert Mays: But I'm glad we had that discussion because as I watched Trevor and as I kind of thought about him in the broader context of the position and the league and just what we can learn from it, I thought it was worth having this sort of conversation about. Yeah, this was a blast. This was to be able to finally come back after five years of Trevor Lawrence being the guy I had to scream about he was good to be able to do a show of like he is good. We're in a happy place for me. All right. That is all we've got for today. We'll be back tomorrow with the week four preview. Until then, talk to you guys very soon.

1:05:28Robert Mays: Thanks for tuning in. Make sure to hit that subscribe or follow button so you never miss an episode. If you enjoyed what you heard, please like, comment and leave a rating. We'll see you next time.

1:06:04We'll see you next time. dot com slash five for details. When you're running a growing business, the right systems can unlock your full sales potential and make fulfilling every order effortless. Switch to ShipStation before peak season so you're prepped and ready before the rush hits. ShipStation connects Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and over 200 more marketplaces with one platform that does it all. You can manage orders, sync inventory, track returns, all automatically. Everything your operation needs, all in one place. Upgrade your shipping operations to stress-proof your biggest sales days and capture every bit of potential revenue.

1:06:34Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO and get 30 days free. Wouldn't it be great if life's little upgrades didn't feel like a splurge? Like getting the aisle seat with extra leg room for a one-hour flight, ordering extra guac with zero hesitation, or paying for assembly on that swing set because you'd rather spend your Saturday doing literally anything else. It's called living filthy comfortable. And whatever filthy comfortable looks like to you, Schwab can help you find it with investing, trading, education, and human help, all in one place. Learn more at Schwab.com. Investing involves risk, including loss of principle.