In short
Podcast Summary: The Beat with Ari Melber - "Lawmakers Say New DOJ Filing Suggests Epstein 'Cover-Up'"
Episode Overview
- Date: February 16, 2026
- Host: Ari Melber
- Guests: Andrew Weissmann (former FBI General Counsel), Michelle Goldberg (New York Times columnist), Brian Tyler Cohen (progressive host)
- Main Topics:
- Trump DOJ's handling of Epstein files and transparency concerns
- Criticism from bipartisan lawmakers regarding the DOJ
- Barack Obama's recent interview with Brian Tyler Cohen
---
Key Discussions
- Trump's DOJ Under Scrutiny
- Context: The DOJ's handling of Epstein files comes under fire for perceived transparency issues.
- Key Points:
- Lawmakers express frustration over the DOJ's compliance with the Epstein Transparency Act.
- A six-page letter from the DOJ cites controversial redactions, including names that raise questions about their relevance (e.g., deceased celebrities like Marilyn Monroe).
- Criticism of Attorney General Pam Bondi for lack of accountability and transparency.
- Accountability and Criticism
- Bipartisan Concerns: Both Democrats and Republicans question the DOJ's actions and the perceived cover-up.
- Calls for Action:
- Resignation vs. Impeachment: Discussions on whether Bondi should resign or face impeachment for her handling of the Epstein files.
- Contrasts drawn between accountability for figures associated with Epstein abroad versus the U.S. administration's lack of action.
- Expert Insights
- Andrew Weissmann:
- Emphasizes the DOJ’s flawed compliance with laws requiring transparency.
- Raises concerns over withheld documents, questioning the legitimacy of claimed legal privileges.
- Michelle Goldberg:
- Discusses the difference in accountability between independent institutions abroad and the current U.S. government.
- Critiques the Trump administration's handling of Epstein-related matters as reflective of a broader lack of decorum and morality in politics.
- Barack Obama's Interview Insights
- Context: Brian Tyler Cohen interviews Obama, discussing Trump's conduct and its implications for the Democratic Party.
- Key Remarks by Obama:
- Criticizes the current political climate as a "clown show" and highlights the need for decency.
- Calls for the Democratic Party to engage young voters and adapt to contemporary issues and concerns.
- Emphasizes the importance of coalition-building over purity politics within the party.
- Political Landscape
- Democrats’ Strategy:
- Discussion on how the Democratic Party can capitalize on Trump's controversial actions in upcoming midterms.
- Importance of presenting a united front and addressing internal conflicts to maintain voter support.
- Closing Reflections
- The episode concludes with acknowledgments of the political climate surrounding ICE and the actions of local governments to restrict ICE's enforcement capabilities.
- Obama encourages activism and community engagement as a counter to perceived authoritarianism in current U.S. governance.
---
Key Takeaways
- Transparency and Accountability: The DOJ's handling of the Epstein files raises significant concerns about transparency and accountability in government.
- Bipartisan Criticism: Lawmakers from both parties are unified in their criticism of the DOJ's actions, highlighting a rare moment of bipartisanship in response to perceived governmental failures.
- Need for Adaptation: Barack Obama’s insights emphasize the need for the Democratic Party to engage with younger voters and adapt to current cultural and political challenges.
- Community Engagement: The importance of community organizing and activism is underscored as a vital response to current political issues.
---
This episode illustrates the complex interplay of law, politics, and accountability, set against the backdrop of ongoing societal issues related to governance and civil rights.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VODOJ Under Fire for Epstein Files
1:43 to 4:28
Discussion on the DOJ's handling of the Epstein files and the implications of redactions.
“Lawmakers, including some in both parties, criticizing the DOJ for the next step, also late in its compliance with the Epstein transparency law.”
Comparing Accountability Across Governments
4:28 to 7:20
Analyzing the discrepancies in accountability between Trump and other international figures linked to Epstein.
“As for what we're learning in the files, well, there was one Trump confidant, Tom Barrack, who is the U.S.”
Media Influence and Public Perception
7:20 to 13:20
Exploration of how figures like Joe Rogan affect public perception of Trump's connections to Epstein.
“And so obviously, he has a not just vested interest, but really an existential interest in avoiding accountability for Epstein relationships.”
Congress and the DOJ: Tensions Rising
13:20 to 14:02
Discussion about Congress's potential actions against the DOJ regarding the Epstein files.
“And, Andrew, I've just about a minute left.”
Congress and the Epstein Transparency Act
14:02 to 15:08
Learn about Congress's power dynamics and the Epstein Transparency Act.
“So remember that Congress does have the power of the purse.”
Democrats' Strategy on ICE and Government Shutdown
16:49 to 21:05
Analyze the Democratic approach to ICE and the implications of a government shutdown.
“If you follow all of these shutdown politics, we start the week here on a holiday with DHS employees working without pay.”
Nancy Pelosi and Concerns Over Election Integrity
21:07 to 22:50
Discuss Nancy Pelosi's stance on election surveillance and integrity.
“She is widely seen as one of the Democrats' tough, more effective leaders during her tenure.”
Historical Views on Mount Rushmore
22:51 to 25:15
Reflect on discussions surrounding presidential legacies and Mount Rushmore.
“So we will end with a little more historical view.”
Obama's Insights on Decency and Political Discourse
25:19 to 28:00
Hear Obama's thoughts on decency in politics and the current state of discourse.
“Now, speaking of presidents, Barack Obama was the popular president at the All-Star Game, even catching the ball.”
Obama's Response to Political Decorum
28:00 to 28:30
Discussion on how American public perceives political decency and decorum.
Show all 21 chapters
The Role of ICE in Communities
28:30 to 29:30
Exploring the implications of ICE's actions under the Trump administration.
“propriety and respect for the office, right?”
Obama's Perspective on Generational Politics
29:30 to 30:20
Obama addresses the disconnect between older politicians and younger voters.
“All the stuff that we saw, tear gassing crowds simply who were standing there not breaking any laws.”
The Importance of Youth Engagement in Politics
30:20 to 32:30
Discussion on how to tap into the potential of young voters for the future.
“So the rogue behavior of agents of the federal government is deeply concerning and dangerous.”
Obama on Trump's Impact on Midterms
32:50 to 34:30
Analyzing Obama's thoughts on how Trump's actions may influence Democratic strategy in midterms.
“He would have stood up and went right to the three and drained.”
Coalition Building vs. Purity Politics
34:30 to 36:20
Discussion on the need for coalitions in politics rather than strict adherence to litmus tests.
“Those aren't just going to fix themselves in a vacuum.”
Hopeful Politics: Lessons from Campaigns
36:20 to 40:30
Insights on the importance of hope and community in political campaigns from Obama to recent candidates.
“And if you want to create an environment that is welcoming and makes people feel, okay, there's room for me here.”
Obama's Relatability and Impact
40:30 to 42:02
Discussion on Obama's unique ability to connect with people across different topics.
“trap of protecting institutions and processes and norms, that those institutions are not the end.”
The Complexity of Authenticity in Politics
42:02 to 42:40
Discussing the unique relatability of Barack Obama in politics.
“And this dude is the ultimate, like he is the ultimate guy and, uh, and he can, he can do everything.”
Local Resistance to ICE Tactics
42:40 to 43:47
Exploring community efforts to push back against ICE actions in various states.
“Americans continue to find ways to push back against Trump's ICE tactics.”
Personal Accounts of Government Violence
43:47 to 44:04
Individuals share their harrowing experiences with government actions.
“Barack Obama making news on President's Day, as we mentioned.”
Obama's Call for Peaceful Activism
44:04 to 45:06
Barack Obama emphasizes the importance of peaceful protests and community organizing.
“And here's a little bit more from that interview we hadn't aired yet about activism.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Ari Melber:On Deck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, On Deck's loans up to$400 ,000 make it happen fast. Rated A-plus by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star Trustpilot reviews, On Deck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by On Deck or Celtic Bank. On Deck does not lend in North Dakota all loans and amounts subject to lender approval. Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start?
0:31Ari Melber:Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
0:48Andrew Weissmann:Welcome to The Beat, everyone. I'm Ari Melber. Coming to you live on this President's Day, which is, of course, a day to still reflect on all the U.S. presidents and the great ones who come throughout history. There's a classic Rushmore. Hello to you. I can tell you in the same theme that one of the most beloved presidents alive, Barack Obama, is driving new headlines from an interview, his first public comment since Trump posted that terribly racist video. He comments on the Minnesota protests. You may have seen some highlights. Well, we have the podcaster who conducted that interview joining us later tonight and also some of the highlights from it.
1:26Andrew Weissmann:So that's one way we're happening to mark President's Day, given the news. He was also spotted at the All-Star Game this weekend for a little fun. Yes, we still have fun around here. There he was catching the ball unplanned. We're going to get into all of that tonight on this President's Day. But we begin with our top story, which is Donald Trump's DOJ under fire for more errors, bungling or outright malfeasance in the Epstein files. Lawmakers, including some in both parties, criticizing the DOJ for the next step, also late in its compliance with the Epstein transparency law. The DOJ sent a six-page letter to Congress.
2:05Andrew Weissmann:This is required by that law. And it discusses the very controversial redactions and purports to list all the government officials and politically exposed persons that are named in the files. That's one of the law's requirements. But the list doesn't really pass muster. With very little context, it includes some names that are exposed, including President Trump, Steve Bannon, Les Wexner, a billionaire tied to Epstein, and then others like Janis Joplin and Marilyn Monroe, which is hard to understand because it's not understandable. Those individuals, long deceased, do not fit in the congressional definition.
2:44Andrew Weissmann:So it raises the question, one, why are they on this list? And two, did the DOJ even proofread and correct this list? Does it care about even seeming like it's accurate and on the level? Heat continues on Attorney General Bondi. Even some conservative commentators have suggested that her time is up, that she should resign after a bonkers and combative congressional hearing, where she really made it a point not to answer questions, despite being under oath and that being part of the job of showing up for an oversight hearing. Lawmakers continuing to call her out.
3:18Ari Melber:This is a massive cover-up being led by the White House and the DOJ.
3:22Brian Tyler Cohen:Do you still have confidence in Pam Bondi as attorney general?
3:28Andrew Weissmann:I don't think Pam Bondi has confidence in Pam Bondi. The actual files that have been out in the public or that we've seen, they're overly redacted. Ultimately, it's her who is responsible for the document production. The last voice you heard is a Republican member of Congress discussing the obvious. Despite all of the lower standards or rank... incompetence that has been on display in the administration recently, the attorney general is responsible for this. And the letter is not accurate. And they already broke the law by being this late. And Pondy's been caught making several misstatements or lies about the Epstein files.
4:08Andrew Weissmann:So in a healthy, normal democracy, you would have accountability for that. The person might resign trying to show the president they get it, or they might be removed by the president. or if the malfeasance is proven, Congress might ultimately consider impeaching Bondi out of her role, something that former Trump lawyer Ty Cobb talked to us about making some headlines. That was just last week. As for what we're learning in the files, well, there was one Trump confidant, Tom Barrack, who is the U.S. ambassador to Turkey and has been a special envoy, who had contact with Epstein for years. Commerce Secretary Lutnik only admitted that he visited at Epstein's Island after the new files showed that he'd been lying about that in public.
4:47Andrew Weissmann:Other powerful individuals outside of the Trump cabinet and administration have faced far more accountability than people working for Trump. There was a story we reported on when it first broke that Casey Wasserman, who's really a powerhouse figure behind the scenes in L.A., not maybe a name that everybody knows, but you know all his clients. He's one of these super agents. And so many of his clients have basically protested his link to Maxwell in the files, saying they would or will leave if he doesn't do something, that he's actually selling his entire agency, his entire empire, because he doesn't have clients who will stand by him.
5:26Andrew Weissmann:Or Obama vet and prominent business people ousted. International figures have been held to account. We have continued to see this contrast between accountability in independent institutions and abroad, while President Trump, who once claimed he wanted to get to the bottom of these files, won't even remove a single employee of their role, despite really audacious links to Epstein. The discrepancy in the accountability is glaring. So as we begin the week, I want to bring in two people who have done a lot of work on this, covering it, discussing it. Andrew Weissman is a former FBI general counsel, former prosecutor, New York Times columnist Michelle Goldberg.
6:06Andrew Weissmann:Welcome to both of you. Michelle, I mentioned that contrast is something you raised on this program and others have, that abroad there are governments taking this more seriously in corrective action. Everybody knows what's done, sometimes sadly is done, but action. And Donald Trump, who rode a wave of Epstein outrage in 24, won't so much as relieve a single, you know, a single employee entangled up with Epstein. What do you see there in that contrast tonight?
6:35Ari Melber:Well, I mean, I think the difference in democratic accountability is a big part of it. This government has worked to insulate itself from any of the mechanisms of accountability. There's also just different interests at play. I don't think that, you know, I don't think that the government of England or of France, where a diplomat is in trouble over his Epstein ties, the governments themselves are not fundamentally invested in minimizing Epstein and his crimes the way that this government is, because the head of this government is one of the people that you would think would be held accountable if you start going down that road, right?
7:11Ari Melber:I mean, it's the head of the head of the head of the United States, members of his cabinet, people who were intimately involved in his campaign. This is his circle. And so obviously, he has a not just vested interest, but really an existential interest in avoiding accountability for Epstein relationships. Yeah.
7:37Andrew Weissmann:And Andrew, I mentioned the letter. There were many people skeptical of this DOJ under Bondi who thought, would you ever get any documents? Would you ever get anything that wasn't totally blacked out? And so in my job as a journalist, I think it's important that we reflect that there was a lot of new material released. And some of it made Trump figures look bad for the reasons we just discussed. Some of them made Steve Bannon and others look bad. We don't know, perhaps, whether other really hot material around the president, et cetera, was still not given up. But I'm wondering how you view that level of compliance.
8:15Andrew Weissmann:The DOJ apparently did not want to just completely break the law, obviously. And now their partial compliance with the letter, which matters because that's where they document under the law what they gave over. But names like Marilyn Monroe and Joplin kind of, at a minimum, make a joke of it. How do we look at this with nuance, with balance for what's happening, Andrew? Sure.
8:40Ari Melber:Well, let's start with the fact that there are documents that were released, but it's hard to say that you should give credit to the Department of Justice for partially complying with the law. Remember, they weren't doing any of this until Congress passed a law that said you have to. And so I just can't stomach the idea that I'm going to be saying, oh, well, attorney general deserves credit for complying in part with the law. That's her job. That is what the Department of Justice is supposed to do. But let's now focus on the in part. in the letter that was just released to Congress, they actually say that they are withholding documents.
9:23Ari Melber:They don't say how many, but it could be in the millions because we know that there's a huge tranche they turned over, but there's a huge tranche they're keeping. And they say they're withholding it based on privileges. They say it's attorney-client. They say it's work product. It's deliberative process. That means all of the documents that we'd be very interested in, which is government reports, government assessments, all of that could be withheld under those claimed privileges. Why is that a problem? It's a problem because the law itself does not permit that. The law actually says these are the grounds you can assert and these are the grounds you cannot assert.
10:10Ari Melber:And so the department is not in compliance with the law. So that's another reason that I think it's fair to say about the department that they are completely flouting their legal responsibilities. And if you think there's damning material in what's been released, you do have to ask yourself what's in the remaining parts.
10:33Andrew Weissmann:Yeah, exactly Michelle, Joe Rogan rode this way with Trump in 24 But unlike, say, most of the Republican members of Congress or Fox News He has a type of independent audience and voice Where he is calling out what he sees is wrong with it Which is obviously quite different than some of the other folks who rode along with Trump in 24 Here he was speaking recently about how the Epstein release is going
11:04Ari Melber:Why would your name be redacted if you're not a victim? Like, this is what's crazy about all this. Like, how come you redact some people and you don't redact other people? Like, what is this? This is not good. None of this is good for this administration. It looks terrible. It looks terrible. It looks terrible for Trump when he was saying that none of this was real. This is all a hoax. This is not a hoax. Like, did you not know?
11:33Andrew Weissmann:Michelle, where does that fit into this as a very widely discussed story that has some people refereeing it saying no to what Rogan has called Trump's gaslighting and lies?
11:46Ari Melber:Look, I'm certainly glad that Joe Rogan and kind of other Manosphere influencers are coming around to seeing what many other people have seen in Donald Trump for a long time, because it's not as if Donald Trump's very close relationship with Epstein was a secret before any of this, you know, before his reelection, before his first election, frankly. You know, at the time when he when he hired Alex Acosta into his government the first time around. That said, I think that because the way that they're handling it, the the ever changing stories that are irreconcilable on their face from, you know, I have all these documents on my desk to the documents don't exist with Pam Bondi.
12:30Ari Melber:You know, to that embarrassing display before Congress where, you know, we should be talking about the fact that the stock market is at 50 ,000. It's so it maybe works if you are entirely encased within the bubble of Donald Trump's alternative reality. But if you have even, you know, a finger or a toe in the real world, you can see how that it just doesn't add up. Right. It's so obvious that they are not being honest and not being frank. And then you have these documents, both the way that they were released, the weird redactions, the fact that they weren't released in total just feeds kind of the the sense of of of mystery and conspiratorial thinking.
13:19Ari Melber:And in this case, the sense that there are the legitimate sense that there are real conspiracies out there that that feeds that feeds discourse and that feeds podcasts.
13:31Andrew Weissmann:Yeah. And, Andrew, I've just about a minute left. We mentioned, of course, some of these individuals, they weren't accused of criminal wrongdoing. There's a DOJ process for this that's been running a long time. When you look, though, at the fact checking or the question of if there are materials being held back that should not be under the law, is this the end of the line? What else does Congress do? Are they just taking the DOJ's word for it?
13:56Ari Melber:Well, that's not really a question for me. There's lots of levers they could pull. So remember that Congress does have the power of the purse. They also do have the ability to hold on nominations. So they do actually have a lot of power. Remember, they did manage to get a consensus to pass the Epstein Transparency Act. So now it really is a question of are they going to take action, given that the department is now an open defiance of them in terms of what it is that Congress said they wanted. So, you know, obviously we've seen Congress, you know, back down and not assert its will. That's not how the Constitution was envisaged.
14:41Ari Melber:It was envisaged that it would be ambition against ambition. And it remains to be seen if they will do that here.
14:49Andrew Weissmann:Yeah, understood. Andrew Weissman and Michelle Goldberg, thanks to both of you. Happy President's Day. Coming up, we'll look at how Democrats are using their powers to try to get control of ICE and that new Obama interview we have. But next, we look at Kristi Noem's election problems. Gene Robinson is here in 90 seconds.
15:12Ari Melber:Need to restock inventory, cover seasonal dips, or manage payroll? OnDeck's small business line of credit provides immediate access to funds, up to$200 ,000, exactly when your business needs it. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and full control over repayment, you can tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. Apply today at OnDeck.com, and funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. On Deck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval. Why have we asked our contractor we found on Angie.com to be our kid's legal guardian?
15:49Ari Melber:Because he took such good care when redoing our basement that we knew we could trust him to care for our kids, all eight of them, should something happen to us. Are you my dad now?
16:00Michelle Goldberg:Uh, no, sorry, I do basements. Connecting homeowners with skilled pros for over 30 years. Angie, the one you trust to find the ones you trust. Find pros for all your home projects at Angie.com.
16:15Ari Melber:At DSW, we ask the important questions, like, what shoes are you going to wear? Whether you're prepping for wedding season, festival season, or just planning the ultimate vacay, the right shoes can make or break an RSVP. So own the moment. You've got big plans, and we've got just the shoes. At the perfect price, of course. Get ready to get ready with Designer Shoe Warehouse. Head to your DSW store or DSW.com today and let us surprise you.
16:47Andrew Weissmann:Democrats are playing hardball. If you follow all of these shutdown politics, we start the week here on a holiday with DHS employees working without pay. Democrats say there are restrictions they demand on ICE to reopen the government. making them follow these warrant rules that's in the Constitution itself, showing ID, body cams, and getting rid of these masks. Here's Trump border czar Tom Homan.
17:13Michelle Goldberg:As far as the masks, look, you know, I don't like the masks either. But because threats against ICE officers are up over 1 ,500 percent, actual assaults and threats are up over 8 ,000 percent, these men wouldn't have to protect themselves. I'll let the White House and members of Congress fight that out. But I think some of the asks are just, I think they're unreasonable.
17:38Andrew Weissmann:The White House thinks the asks are basically unreasonable. The Democrats have the wind at their backs. As for what's reasonable, well, a majority of the country is against Trump's ICE tactics as having gone too far. and the very disturbing and terrible reality of two Americans slain in the streets has not exactly made people think that the ICE approach is very reasonable. Politico has an assessment of Trump's second year in office thus far, the first year of the second term, discussing a kind of whiplash, a series of self-inflicted wounds, the about face on everything from immigration and tariffs to all that time spent on threatening Greenland.
18:18Andrew Weissmann:Politico says it's painfully obvious there's no strategy. And the Times looks at how Trump has tried to take President's Day and make himself the focus of everything. They liken that more to what dictators do, a spree of self-aggrandizement that goes beyond mere vanity. Mr. Trump, the Times writes, is making himself an inescapable force in American life. And yet it is not making him any more popular. Seeing Trump everywhere is apparently reminding people of what Trump's government is doing, And he's crashed to his lowest polling point overall, including on issues he once did better on, like immigration and economics.
18:56Andrew Weissmann:We are joined by Eugene Robinson, Pulitzer private and columnist and MSNOW analyst. Your thoughts on all of that, including a second shutdown. We all know that the more you experience something, the more you get used to it. I'm old enough So I bet you're probably old enough to remember That 20 years ago A shutdown was like a big deal Now we have a second one There's a lot of other important stuff going on What does it tell you though that Democrats Think they can hold the line here again That they want to use what few minority powers They have to try to trim ice Well
19:33Ari Melber:Number one yes I am old enough To remember when a shutdown was a big deal Now this is just a partial shutdown It's DHS shutdown, but that's a lot of stuff. Look, I don't think Democrats have a choice. Democrats have to answer to their voters, and their voters will not stand for Democrats quickly caving on this. So that's number one. I mean, I think it's kind of a matter of political survival for Democrats at this point. And second, what they're protesting and what they're asking for, rather, is is just plain common sense. It's so normal that, again, I don't see how they could do otherwise. Don't wear masks.
Read the full transcript
20:24Ari Melber:OK, we this is not an American thing for a policing agency to to be running around the streets with masks, with no ID, with no warrants, just grabbing people. You know, I remember that elderly man who was taken out of his house in his shorts and bathrobe with no warrant by masked men. That's not supposed to be America. And I think you have to simply take a stand. If you don't take a stand here, where do you take a stand? Yeah.
21:06Andrew Weissmann:Nancy Pelosi was speaking out. She is widely seen as one of the Democrats' tough, more effective leaders during her tenure. And she was drawing this line on the concern about Trump's effort to undercut or steal elections in the future. Take a look.
21:23Ari Melber:I hear that all over the United States, not just in Europe, that there is concern about the election. Let me just say that surveillance by the intelligence operation of our country, surveillance in our own country is something that is absolutely not to be allowed. I know if there's some particular reason, there's one thing. But for them, for Tassie Gobert to be looking into elections is really not right. It's not lawful. Gene? No, I would agree. And look, add to that what Kristi Noem had to say about elections. And Kristi Noem said, essentially, we're going to make sure, referring to the midterm, we're going to make sure that the right people get to the polls to elect the right people, right?
22:18Ari Melber:The right voters get to elect the right people. Well, that's pretty ominous sounding because it sounds as if she's saying we're going to decide who the right people are and act accordingly. And so it's not paranoia to be really concerned about the coming election and to guard against any sort of shenanigans that this administration might pull. Yeah.
22:51Andrew Weissmann:Yeah, it is President's Day. So we will end with a little more historical view. These are two historians talking about their Mount Rushmore. This is on Ari Emanuel's podcast who stopped by here recently. Take a listen to their picks.
23:08Ari Melber:I'm going to keep Washington. I'm going to keep Lincoln. I'm going to keep Teddy. But I'm going to replace Jefferson with FDR. Each one of those other four were at presidents at a moment when democracy was in peril. And I think that's a topic that's so critical right now. I don't think an evening with George Washington would be a lot of fun. So I'm taking Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln, FDR and Reagan.
23:37Andrew Weissmann:That's their Rushmore picks. Do you have anyone you would put on Mount Rushmore or or a favorite president to share with us this holiday?
23:46Ari Melber:You know, I'm going classic on this. I think I'm keeping the form we got there, right? I'm not getting rid of Jefferson. Jefferson was a problematic character, but he wrote the Declaration of Independence. I mean, and the Declaration of Independence, even though the nation has taken a long time to really live up to its stirring words, it is an amazing, stirring document. So I'm leaving him up there. I'm certainly Washington. Read about the Revolutionary War. We don't have a country. We don't have Washington. Lincoln, obviously, in my opinion, our greatest president. And then, you know, the one I guess you could argue whether or not we have the right Roosevelt on Mount Rushmore.
24:44Ari Melber:You know, Teddy was, you know, was it was it was an important figure. I guess I might argue that that FDR, Teddy's Teddy's district cousin, was was a more consequential president because of the Depression and World War Two.
25:02Andrew Weissmann:Yeah, and he got the extra terms. Very consequential. Teddy was an iconoclast, and he wasn't afraid of the powerful and the powers that be, which is also good quality to president. We thought this would be fun here to mark the holiday for a second with Eugene. Thank you so much.
25:21Ari Melber:Okay, thank you.
25:22Andrew Weissmann:Happy President. Happy President's Day. Yes, sir. Now, speaking of presidents, Barack Obama was the popular president at the All-Star Game, even catching the ball. Look at that. Extraordinary. We're going to show you what he's saying about Trump, politics, ice and racism. He paired that that special fun visit with a serious new interview on politics. We're going to show you that with the podcaster who who got the big exclusive next.
26:17Ari Melber:You just knocked it through. and amounts subject to lender approval. Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today. You know that thing where you get an amazing pair of shoes at a really great price and want to tell everyone about it? Yeah, so do we.
26:48Ari Melber:Here at Designer Shoe Warehouse, we'll give you something to brag about. Like the latest styles from brands you love. Or the trends everyone's obsessing over. Or shoes that make you feel like, well, you. So go ahead, show off a little. Find shoes that get you, and prices that get your budget. Head to your DSW store or DSW.com today. DSW, let us surprise you.
27:15Andrew Weissmann:It is President's Day and all eyes have been on a particular former president, Barack Obama. He's been in the news for a couple reasons. One, he sat down for a lengthy interview with a hit liberal podcaster, Brian Tyler Cohen. You may have seen his face or have heard of him. This is what we're seeing different politicians do more and more of. Obviously, anyone on any channel would kill for an Obama interview right now. Well, Cohen got it. And this is a rarity because the former president doesn't do a lot of long interviews these days, doesn't get pulled into every Trump debate. And so he was asked about and made his first public comments about Donald Trump's viciously racist online post about the Obamas, which was later taken down.
28:00Andrew Weissmann:Here was the response.
28:04Michelle Goldberg:as i'm traveling around the country as as you're traveling around the country you meet people they still believe in decency courtesy kindness and there's this sort of clown show that's happening in social media and on television uh and what is true is that there doesn't seem to be any shame about this among people who used to feel like you had to have some sort of decorum and a sense of propriety and respect for the office, right? So that's been lost. But the reason I point out that I don't think the majority of the American people approve of this is because ultimately the answer going to come from the American people.
29:01Andrew Weissmann:Classic Obama, a classy response to an ugly kind of gutter ball attack, and Obama quick to position this as a compliment to the public. Of course, the majority of the public in America doesn't want Trump's racism. And he went on to try to discuss in depth what maybe America would want. He wasn't sparing, though, the fact that he disagrees with many of the things Trump's administration is doing, including the ICE power grab and the rule of law.
29:36It is important for us to recognize the unprecedented nature of what ICE was doing in Minneapolis, the way that federal agents, ICE agents, were being deployed without any clear guidelines, training,
30:03Michelle Goldberg:pulling people out of their homes, using five-year-olds to try to... Bait their parents. Bait their parents. All the stuff that we saw, tear gassing crowds simply who were standing there not breaking any laws. So the rogue behavior of agents of the federal government is deeply concerning and dangerous.
30:36Andrew Weissmann:When he first came into office, Obama was one of the younger modern presidents on par with Clinton or Kennedy rather than Trump or Biden. And he discussed how elder Democrats need to be open to the younger generation.
30:53Michelle Goldberg:I'm pretty healthy, 64. Feel great. Yeah. But the truth is half of the references that my daughters make about social media, TikTok, et cetera, I don't know who they're talking about. Yeah. There is a element of at some point you age out. You're not connected directly to the immediate struggles that folks are going through. I'm not making a hard and fast rule here, but I do think that Democrats do well when we have candidates who are plugged into the moment, to the zeitgeist, to the times, and the particular struggles that folks are thinking about as they look towards the future rather than look backward toward the past.
31:47Michelle Goldberg:That spirit, that energy, it's out there. And you can feel it, but it's bottled up. We haven't given enough outlets for young people to figure out how do I become a part of that. And that's this enormous untapped power that we have to get back to.
32:07Andrew Weissmann:ever respectful obama saying the party's got to look to the younger candidates who are plugged in and he wasn't just saying that in some new york times op-ed respect or some 60 minutes conversation like politicians have been doing for 50 years respect depending on the sunday or the episode he was saying it walking the walk in a new format that he and his team had clearly picked over television. They went to a hit liberal podcaster, Brian Tyler Cohen, who got the big interview and is our guest about the Obama interview next.
32:47Andrew Weissmann:No, actually, I think exactly what he said was, that's what I do. I got it.
32:51Ari Melber:That's what I do.
32:52Andrew Weissmann:Would have been better. He would have stood up and went right to the three and drained. Or he could do a mellow and puffing. get right. No, actually, I think Barack Obama's everywhere. Courtside can catch the ball. Little memories of that's what I do. And he just sat down for a lengthy, substantive interview. The podcaster, Brian Tyler Cohen, who hosts No Lie and just sat down with the former president. Congrats on the big get.
33:17Brian Tyler Cohen:Thanks, Ari. I appreciate it.
33:20Andrew Weissmann:Yeah, really interesting. I would encourage all viewers to go check out the full 40 plus minutes on YouTube. But we've got the highlights, So don't do it yet. If people are watching right now, let's start with what he said about how he thinks Trump's conduct will help Dems in the midterms.
33:39Michelle Goldberg:The current White House, this administration and their enablers, they're behaving so badly. They're doing such crazy stuff that it shouldn't be hard for our side to coalesce around the areas where we agree on and focus on that. And I think that, you know, that is going to happen if we are effective in winning the midterms.
34:12Andrew Weissmann:What did you see him emphasizing there?
34:16Brian Tyler Cohen:Look, I think he's saying what a lot of people already recognize, which is in terms of the midterms, that's going to be largely a referendum off of Trump. But we have a long path forward. You know, Democrats do have a poor approval rating. We have brand problems that need to be fixed. Those aren't just going to fix themselves in a vacuum. I hope that people don't see success in the midterms as some indication that, you know, we've solved everything because we haven't. But, you know, he talked about that a little bit. And I'm not sure if you're going to show a subsequent clip where he does discuss a little bit of the infighting.
34:47Brian Tyler Cohen:But, you know, I think that's going to be it. He has a very particular focus on coalition building as opposed to purity politics. And I think, you know, in an era where everybody has a voice, everybody has a platform online, making sure that we can still remember that the goal of politics is actually to build a coalition, to cobble together a big enough coalition to win, to be able to do something is first and foremost.
35:13Andrew Weissmann:Well, let's turn to that because he discussed it with you at length. He referenced things that people are familiar with, the kind of mood of certain people being a scold, trying to dictate to others what their political morality should be, or this term virtue signaling. And this, I thought, was an interesting exchange. So we cut it at some length. Let's take a look.
35:40Michelle Goldberg:I think there was a certain way of talking about issues for Democrats where we sounded like scolds. There was a virtue signaling that made it seem as if ordinary folks, if they did not say things in exactly the right way or meet this litmus test, that they were being chastised, pushed away. And the truth is, most of us, all of us are complicated and we have blind spots and sometimes we say dumb stuff. And if you want to create an environment that is welcoming and makes people feel, okay, there's room for me here. then the message and the story we tell has to be all right none of us are perfect all of us count we all have good in us that we can tap into we can all learn from each other and and i think that is something we need to recover
36:57Andrew Weissmann:What did you see him hitting there?
37:00Brian Tyler Cohen:I mean, you know, similar to what I was saying before, I think that, you know, at its core, again, politics is about getting enough votes to actually win. And this stuff really does. It's personal for a lot of people. They hold it really, you know, they wear it on their shirt sleeve. And so it's not a surprise that when it comes to these political matters that people will take it personally and they will want to impose litmus tests. and they'll do what they do online these days. But I think it's important to get these reminders from somebody who doesn't have any skin in the game, but he has a lot of cachet.
37:34Brian Tyler Cohen:And so he has the freedom to be able to come out and say this kind of stuff to reroute the party, I think, into a smarter direction as we head toward 2028. Even if it's just planting a little bug in our heads to say like, we are, you know, I'm sure you've heard people say politics is a bus. You're not necessarily going right to your front door. You are taking the bus to the closest destination to where you live. And that's how we have to think of it. We can't let perfect be the enemy of good. And you're going to have people within the coalition who disagree with each other. But it's going to be important to make sure to remember that it is a coalition at the end of the day.
38:13Andrew Weissmann:It's interesting coming from him as well because he's won these campaigns, doesn't have more to run. So even for people who are skeptical and don't like the message, it's different than some other old school Democrat saying, hey, I don't like this. He's speaking about it from the kind of good faith position within his party of how to win. You guys also touched on the Mondani energy. Take a look.
38:37Michelle Goldberg:What happened in our campaign and what you recently saw in Mondani's campaign in New York. Yeah. When there's that sense of joy and engagement and involvement, then people feel like, all right, this is not just some transactional grind. This is me becoming part of a community.
39:07Andrew Weissmann:isn't it funny because i don't know about you but like we use this word culture in different ways but there is a there is a culture of politics and the idea that what was once the liberal street protests counterculture energy say of the 70s um lost sight of that that how did liberals even sometimes young liberals get perhaps unfairly caricatured as as no fun or hall monitors. And then Mamdani came along and reminded everyone or you could be like this.
39:41Brian Tyler Cohen:And look, you know, between Mamdani now in 2026 and Obama in 2008, those are parallel campaigns. Those are people whose campaigns actually did inspire hope as opposed to feeling like, you know, So, I mean, you know, as opposed to feeling like it's the lesser of two evils or whatever it may be, but politics needs to be hopeful. I mean, it is, you are building a culture. I mean, to your exact point, you're building a culture and a community and people don't want to join a community that, you know, is overwhelmingly negative, especially on this side. And so we have like winning formulas right in front of us.
40:13Brian Tyler Cohen:I don't know how many times we need to be hit over the head with this idea that if you can have a hopeful, inclusive campaign a la Barack Obama in 2008 or Zoran Mamdani in 2026, that the formula is there. We just need people who are willing to pick up that mantle and not fall into the D.C. trap of protecting institutions and processes and norms, that those institutions are not the end. They are a means to an end, but the end has to be people. It has to be people-focused. And that's what Barack Obama's campaign was. 20 years ago almost, and it's what Zoramamdani's campaign was just this past year.
40:53Andrew Weissmann:And real quick, here were some of the quick light moments you guys had.
41:00Michelle Goldberg:Wasn't political. Bad Bunny's halftime show. It was demonstrating and displaying. This is what a community is. Are aliens real? They're real, but I haven't seen them. Is Tupac alive? he's alive on my playlist if you're going to pull off a prank it's got to be on somebody who can prank you back and wasn't nobody going to prank me
41:25Andrew Weissmann:did you find him to be the same old fun Obama or now he's in his elder statesman role
41:31Brian Tyler Cohen:no look this dude knows how to hang and I think that is such an under understated value like if you can get a guy who can just you know without cursing, who can just like hang on a podcast, who can go the next day to the NBA all-star game and throw down about sports and who can talk politics better than anybody else. I think like that there is, there is so much power in something like that because we've, you know, look, we're in the TikTok era. There is so much focus on authenticity and relatability. And this dude is the ultimate, like he is the ultimate guy and, uh, and he can, he can do everything.
42:10Brian Tyler Cohen:He doesn't just fit neatly into like one bucket where the only thing you can talk about is politics. And there's a lot of virtue in that. And that's why Barack Obama is Barack Obama. And it's so difficult for other people to replicate that.
42:22Andrew Weissmann:That's fair. And as you say, hanging on a pod where it's no more free form can be a bit back like retail politics, like when you go to Iowa and some people could get along with folks. And that matters in ways that we're seeing in any era. Brian, again, congrats on the interview. Thanks for coming. We will be right back.
42:50Andrew Weissmann:Americans continue to find ways to push back against Trump's ICE tactics. In California, Michigan, and New York, local officials are pushing what they call ICE-free zones, restricting the way agents may be able to get near government-owned spaces. some communities successfully blocking ICE attempts to convert warehouses into new additional detention facilities. There's also evidence of ICE raids that expose agents sometimes making false claims. In Chicago, a Border Patrol agent who shot an American citizen five times is under investigation. Prosecutors had charged the woman with using her car to assault agents.
43:25Andrew Weissmann:And yet body cam video shows an agent at the wheel swerving over into her car, then exiting and firing what appear to be five shots.
43:35Ari Melber:The mental scars will always be there as a reminder of the time my own government attempted to execute me. And when they fell, they chose to vilify me. I am Renee Good. I am Alex Preddy. I am Silberio Villega Gonzalez. I am Keith Porter. They should all be here today.
44:03Andrew Weissmann:Barack Obama making news on President's Day, as we mentioned. And here's a little bit more from that interview we hadn't aired yet about activism. We should take a moment to appreciate the extraordinary outpouring of organizing, community building, decency, citizens saying
44:27Michelle Goldberg:this is not the America we believe in. And we're going to fight back and we're going to push back with the truth and with cameras and with peaceful protests and shining a light on the sort of behavior that in the past we've seen in authoritarian countries and we've seen in dictatorships, but we have not seen in America.
44:56Andrew Weissmann:A practical call to do what you can, when you can, how you can, peacefully and lawfully by a former president on this holiday. We close with that tonight.
45:24Ari Melber:obstructive sleep apnea, OSA, and obesity to improve their OSA. Z-Bound should be used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity. Z-Bound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15 milligram injection. Z-Bound contains terzepatide and should not be used with other terzepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if Z-Bound is safe and effective for use in children. Do not share needles or pens or reuse needles. Don't take Z-Bound if allergic to it, or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer or multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2.
45:57Ari Melber:Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop ZEPBound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes, depression, or suicidal thoughts before scheduled procedures with anesthesia. If you're nursing, pregnant, planned to be, or taking birth control pills, taking ZEPBound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and and worsen kidney problems.
46:24Ari Melber:Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979 or visit zetbound.lily.com. Zetbound and its delivery device base in QuickPen are registered trademarks owned or licensed by Eli Lilly and Company, its subsidiaries or affiliates.
From the publisher
February 16, 2026; 6pm; MSNOW’s Ari Melber reports on the Trump DOJ’s handling of the Epstein files, as lawmakers criticize the department over a lack of transparency. Former FBI General Counsel Andrew Weissmann and The New York Times' Michelle Goldberg join. Plus, Melber is joined by progressive host Brian Tyler Cohen to discuss his recent interview with former President Barack Obama.
To listen to this show and other MS podcasts without ads, sign up for MS NOW Premium on Apple Podcasts.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
