1. Podcasts
  2. The Daily Stoic
  3. The Ancient Ideas That Built America
The Daily Stoic

4 Jul 2026 · 28m · 12 chapters

Episode artwork

The Ancient Ideas That Built America | Thomas Ricks

In short

How America’s founders drew “first principles” from ancient Greek and Roman thinkers—especially Stoicism and Roman republican history—and how those ideas shaped U.S. institutions, norms, and moral debates, including slavery and modern hero-worship.

Guest

Thomas Ricks, author of First Principles: What America’s Founders Learned from the Greeks and Romans and How That Shaped Our Country; historian/journalist background implied through his work on classical influence and political history.

Key claims

Founders were steeped in classical models (Cato, Cicero, Seneca, etc.) and embedded them in politics; modern Americans miss the “why” behind norms. Washington best approximated the ideals (including freeing slaves). Cicero and John Adams understood ideas but often failed to live them. Jefferson is framed as Epicurean and hypocritical regarding liberty vs. slavery.

Notable examples

Addison’s play Cato (popular at the time; Washington allegedly had it performed at Valley Forge); Adams as “America’s Cicero”; FDR violating a Washington-era norm; Confederate monument debates; ancient slavery used to rationalize harsher American slavery; Madison’s role in designing the Constitution (two senators per state).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

Creating a Comfortable Space

Learn how personal spaces should reflect individual preferences.

“Look, you should be able to be comfortable anywhere, but you should also be comfortable inside your own house.”
4:26

Ancient Inspiration for America

Explore how ancient philosophies influenced America's founders.

“And to a degree that I think we don't recognize, we're not even equipped as a society generally to recognize, they took their inspiration to a surprising degree from the ancient world.”
6:10

The Role of Classical Ideals

Understand how classical ideals shaped American governance.

“There were a tiny number of colleges in America, six or seven or eight at various times during the pre-revolutionary period.”
7:34

Cato and Its Impact

Delve into the significance of Cato in revolutionary America.

“And if you called someone a Catiline or a Cato, they wouldn't understand whether that's an insult or a compliment and what the implications of those accusations would even be.”
8:21

Cicero and the Flaws of Leadership

Analyze the complexities of Cicero's character and influence.

“in the revolutionary era, not realizing they were quoting, it's the equivalent these days of quoting Casablanca or Ghostbusters.”
10:58

Adams, Washington, and Their Models

Investigate how Adams and Washington embodied classical ideals.

“Unlike the Stoics, he constantly wears his feelings on his sleeve.”
14:00

Epicurean vs. Stoic Philosophy in Founding Figures

Explore the contrasting philosophies of Epicureanism and Stoicism as reflected in the lives of America's founders.

“He's into the avoidance of pain, the pursuit of happiness, and he's constantly pursuing married women through his life.”
16:40

The Influence of Cato on American Leadership

Discuss how George Washington and other founders embodied the characteristics of Cato, shaping the presidency.

“We expect our presidents to be dignified, reserved, prudent, and to respect the dignity of the office.”
20:44

Debate on Confederate Monuments

Examine the ongoing debate around Confederate monuments and what values they should reflect.

“I'm fascinated with Confederate monuments and the sort of argument about, do you leave them up?”
23:12

Complexity of Founding Fathers' Legacies

Delve into the moral complexities of the founding fathers, particularly regarding slavery and their legacies.

“Well, that was actually one of the things I wrote down that I wanted to talk to you about in your book.”
Show all 12 chapters
26:11

Ancient Slavery vs. American Slavery

Contrast ancient slavery with modern American practices and discuss the justifications used by the founders.

“I just wrote an email for the Daily Stoic List about this.”
28:00

The Philosophical Foundations of American Founders

Explore how the American founders embodied philosophical ideals in their actions.

“To go to this point of wrestling with it, though, I think, you know, where Washington shines greater than the other founders is that he seemed to come closer to realizing the ideals than any of the others.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Daily Stoic, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Ryan Holiday: Look, you should be able to be comfortable anywhere, but you should also be comfortable inside your own house. Like your space should feel like you should look the way you want it to look. You should have the stuff that you want to have. And that's where today's sponsor Wayfair comes in, because a budget doesn't need to get in the way of having all of those things. With plenty of options for every style you can imagine, you will definitely find something you like on Wayfair and at a price you can't beat. Got a new rug for the living room on Wayfair. Normally rugs are just like crazy expensive.

0:34Ryan Holiday: And then you're like, do I like this rug? Do I not like this rug? But look, we know we got kids, we got a dog. We don't want to spend a ton of money, but we want something that looks good. We want something that lasts. And on Wayfair, we got the best of both worlds. A rug that matches our style, doesn't cost too much. The dog tracks mud, clean it, you know, whatever. We want it to look nice. We want to be comfortable with it. We don't want to have to stress about it. Delivery was super easy. wayfair also has installation and assembly stuff so i could spend my time writing instead of getting angry at some frustrating instructions ordering online is easy it's all delivered right to your door wayfair products have over 20 million verified five-star reviews to help you make the right call and i recommend shopping with wayfair verified your shortcut to the good stuff their team of product specialists vet everything by hand using a 10-point quality inspection so you know you're getting a great piece no matter your budget.

1:28Ryan Holiday: Are you ready to upgrade your home for way less? Well, head over to Wayfair.com right now to shop all things home and get your space ready for less. That's W-A-Y-F-A-I-R.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. It all comes down to hiring. You got to find the right people for your team and you got to bring them on board and you to onboard them quickly, you know, just throwing up a job posting and hoping you get lucky. I've just found, well, you don't get lucky enough. If you want to find quality hires, well, you should check out Indeed right now. People are finding quality hires on Indeed right now.

2:08Ryan Holiday: In just the 30 or so seconds we've already been talking, people have made dozens of hires on Indeed, according to Indeed data worldwide. Their sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 95 % more likely to report a hire than a non-sponsored job. So join more than 3.3 million employers worldwide that use Indeed to connect with quality talent that fits their needs. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less time, less stress, more results. When you need the right person to cut through the chaos, this is a job for Indeed-sponsored jobs.

2:43Ryan Holiday: And listeners of this show Get a$75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at Indeed.com. That's Indeed.com right now. And support the show by saying you heard about it on this podcast. Indeed.com. Terms and conditions apply. Welcome to the Daily Stoic Podcast. Designed to help bring those four key Stoic virtues, courage, discipline, justice, and wisdom into the real world.

3:16Ryan Holiday: Hey, it's Ryan. Welcome to another episode of the Daily Stoic Podcast. There has never been a better time for people to read the book of today's guest and to listen to this conversation. As soon as I read it, I reached out to have Tom Ricks on the podcast because this is exactly connected to what we talk about here at Daily Stoic. The book is First Principles, What America's Founders Learned from the Greeks and Romans and How That Shaped Our Country. It's really about the Greek and Roman philosophy, Stoicism, Epicureanism, what ancient Rome taught Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin and George Washington and John Adams.

3:55Ryan Holiday: What it taught them, the good lessons they took from it, the flaws inherent in some parts of the system. This is a conversation I was so excited to have. I'll just give you General James Mattis' blurb of the book. Thomas Ricks knocks it out of the park with this jewel of a book. On every page, I learned something new. Read it every night if you want to restore your faith in this country. So please listen to this conversation with the great Tom Ricks, but read first principles, what America's founders learned from the Greeks and Romans and how that shaped our country. We talk about stoicism. We talk about America.

4:30Ryan Holiday: We talk about right and wrong. We talk about justice. We talk about power. Talk about a lot of great things. Be safe, everyone. Be smart. And do the right thing. So you titled the book First Principles, and I think it's a great title because essentially, correct me if I'm wrong, but the premise of the book is what did the people who created this country believe and where did they get those beliefs from? Absolutely. And to a degree that I think we don't recognize, we're not even equipped as a society generally to recognize, they took their inspiration to a surprising degree from the ancient world.

5:09For them, remember, they didn't have rock stars, they didn't have movie stars, they didn't have sports athletes. Their idols and their role models were the great philosophers and political figures of ancient Greece and Rome, especially Rome, and especially the decline of the Roman Republic, the people who tried to stop the decline. So Cato, Cicero, a few other people around them, and then some of the philosophers, some generals.

5:37Ryan Holiday: It's interesting, too, because I've got to imagine that for a good chunk of American history, that set of shared first principles would have almost been so obvious as to not be noticeable because everyone shared that sort of classical understanding. And then today, it's hard to notice because people don't have the familiarity with these ancient teachers to notice a lot of the allusions and the nods, the subtle quotations and the influences, that you would even have to write your book is almost a bit of a commentary in and of itself. They would find it surprising. But remember, it wasn't everybody then.

6:14It was elites. There were a tiny number of colleges in America, six or seven or eight at various times during the pre-revolutionary period. And there were a tiny number of people who had graduated from high school, let alone graduated from college. Most people who got an education were white. Most people who got more than a year of education were white males, and even then, typically, they got one or two years. So they really didn't know the classical world, but at the same time, they didn't have much of a political voice. But the people who led the revolution, the people who designed the country after the revolution, were indeed steeped in this ancient world.

6:53To them, ancient Roman history especially had the urgency of front-page news, because as they designed the country, they didn't have a lot of examples. They were trying to design a country that wasn't going to be a monarchy. And they didn't have a lot of historical examples. But you're right, we're left with a country nowadays where if you take the dollar bill out of your pocket, there's Latin on both sides. If you look at the center of our political universe, the U.S. Capitol is named for a hill in Rome, the Capitoline Hill. The Democratic Party comes from a Greek word. the Republican Party comes from a Latin word.

7:29So it is all around us, but we don't even see what is in front of our eyes.

7:34Ryan Holiday: And if you called someone a Catiline or a Cato, they wouldn't understand whether that's an insult or a compliment and what the implications of those accusations would even be. And that's right. In the 18th century, by contrast, one of the most popular plays of the century was the play Cato by Joseph Addison, a favorite of George Washington, and who was not steeped in the classics yet really absorbed it from the culture around him. Two lines in that play are really striking. At one point, one character regrets that they have only one life to give to Rome. And another character says, give me liberty or give me death.

8:14And so when politicians quoted those, people knew what they were referring to. These days, we think they're just hot quotes in the revolutionary era, not realizing they were quoting, it's the equivalent these days of quoting Casablanca or Ghostbusters.

8:28Ryan Holiday: I've joked on the podcast a few times that Cato was the Hamilton of its day. That's a very good way of putting it. It hadn't occurred to me, yeah. I mean, so popular that Washington puts it on, allegedly, at Valley Forge. Like, the depths of the America... It's even just difficult to wrap your head around a play being that important, that at the depths of the darkest moment of the American Revolution, Washington is having his men act out a play about ancient Rome to cheer them up. It sounds like a Monty Python scene. We're in Valley Forge. What are we going to do? Let's put on a musical. Right.

9:04Ryan Holiday: But it is interesting, too. Stoicism appears in the book, you know, a few times. I would have argued that maybe that Stoicism was closer to the first principles than maybe you do. But it is interesting in the book, the different paths that the founders take to their classical knowledge, right? So someone like Washington sort of gets it through pop culture and maybe a few books here or there. And then Jefferson is reading Seneca in the original Latin. And certainly Washington wasn't doing that. One of my favorite moments in the book is when his vice president, John Adams, was having an argument with Timothy Pickering, who soon was to become postmaster general.

9:46And they were arguing about whether Washington was illiterate. And Adams says, no, he wasn't illiterate. I got some very good letters when I was at Congress during the war written by him. And Pickering says, written by that young Alexander Hamilton boy. He's a good writer. Washington was very conscious of his lack of education, though, and brought in people like Hamilton to perform skills that he was conscious of being deficient in. Tato very much is Washington's model. Washington has the misfortune to constantly have these models foisted on him. Do you consider Cicero a genuine Stoic?

10:22Ryan Holiday: So I have him in that book as actually somewhat similar to the way you portray Adams in the book, which is a person who understood these things brilliantly, but could sort of utterly fail to actually live up to them. So Cicero is fascinating in that he's responsible for rescuing much of Stoicism from the sort of dustbin of history. And he translates it and he illustrates it and tells these stories. But then when you actually look at his life, he failed to actually put into practice much of what he purported to believe. Yeah, like John Adams turns out to be kind of the Woody Allen of the American Revolution.

11:02He's a big whiner. Unlike the Stoics, he constantly wears his feelings on his sleeve. There's a great line that the novelist and historian Charlotte had about Cicero, which applies to Adams as well, which is that he loved to talk about his country and he loved to talk about himself. Unfortunately, he did both things equally as much. Yes.

11:19Ryan Holiday: And I was fascinated with Cicero because it's like Cicero seemed to be play acting through most of his life, all these ideas. And even up through the Catalan conspiracy, which was real, as I talk about in Lives of the Stokes, it's real. But you can't help maybe feeling that Cicero might have exaggerated a little bit for his own good. And then, ironically, Rome does face a real sort of constitutional crisis, a moment of truth. And Cicero is basically nowhere to be found. And in the real moment of destiny, he fails. I have a feeling that, yeah, Cicero was very happy to see the conspiracy come down the pike.

11:59It's a little bit like the glee, which with Madison greets Shade's rebellion after the revolution during the Articles of Confederation era. It's exactly what Madison needed to show that the current system isn't working, to blow the whistle and start beating the drum for the constitutional convention. But Cicero very much is Adams' model. And while I have some problems with Adams, I think his reputation has been inflated a lot lately. It is amazing to me that young John Adams decides to become America's Cicero and succeeds.

12:35Ryan Holiday: Yes, which is interesting too, because Cicero basically decided to become Cicero. And, you know, there's a self-madeness to both of them that you can't help but admire. There is. And, you know, John Adams is the only one of our first four presidents who never owned a slave. He graduates from college. His parents don't have the money to support him. He can't sit down and read Greek and Roman history like Madison does for several years to prepare for the Constitution. Adams has to go get a job, but he winds up a schoolteacher in a backwater in Massachusetts. Doesn't even have a post office. He hates teaching.

13:09He totally is unprepared to be a teacher emotionally. Eventually decides to become a lawyer. But it's striking to me that Adams never has a mentor. I think he's such a prickly figure. He is unable to find a mentor. Whereas George Washington had a mentor, whereas Thomas Jefferson had a couple, and Jefferson becomes mentor to Madison. John Adams almost has to mentor himself. You read his diaries, and he's constantly berating himself. Pay less attention to girls and hunting. Pay more attention to books. Because nobody else is guiding him, even the guy in whose law office he works. sent him off to Boston without a letter of recommendation or introduction to anybody.

13:52Now, this may have been, I think, because Adams was making eyes at the guy's wife, which is a constant problem in this era. Thomas Jefferson is so striking to me. He's an Epicurean. Clearly, he is an anti-Stoic. He's into the avoidance of pain, the pursuit of happiness, and he's constantly pursuing married women through his life. And I think it's the classic Epicurean recipe. It's all the rewards of romance without any of the risk of a permanent entanglement.

14:23Ryan Holiday: Well, in one of Seneca's letters, he talks about, he says, you must choose yourself a Cato. He says, sort of pick your model. And that could be a model you actually know, or it could be a sort of an ideal. But I think it's fascinating. Your book illustrates this so well. It's like John Adams picks Cicero and becomes much like Cicero, but with the flaws sort of being very well pronounced. And Washington seems to pick Cato to some degree, as you said, is also a little foisted on him, but then embodies the genius of Cato and some of the flaws. It seems like each founder kind of had a model that they were shaping their life against.

15:05Ryan Holiday: And I found it remarkable how much they ended up being like the influence that they chose. Well, because they succeeded. You know, we're looking at people who made it to the presidency, who successfully designed the country. There are other people who, in many ways, were spectacular failures. I would say Patrick Henry is a spectacular failure. Alexander Hamilton succeeds. He's basically Washington's prime minister. But pretty soon after that, considers himself a failure. By the end of the 1790s, Alexander Hamilton says to a friend, there is no place in this country for me. It's a terrible thought.

15:42I mean, here he has come to this country. He's helped design the country. He has served well in the revolution and in politics. And he constantly is using different pseudonyms, all of people who were virtuous yet disrespected by their peers.

15:58Ryan Holiday: Yeah, and I mean, they did become successful. So there's some survivorship bias there. I guess what I mean is it's that they came to take on the traits of the person that they spent so much time studying and learning about, which is also kind of a model that I think we struggle with today. Sort of who are your heroes, right? And I think as a society, we've struggled to decide who our heroes are. Yeah, and our heroes are not particularly people you want to emulate. Some of these rock stars and sports stars and so on. and people who we thought of as statesmen, you know, in our world today, we find out are greatly flawed.

16:36You actually just made me think of something I hadn't thought before. I think it's true that George Washington, as president, puts kind of the mold of Cato on the American presidency. We expect our presidents to be dignified, reserved, prudent, and to respect the dignity of the office. and he very much brings that to the presidency as he tries to kind of put the flesh of norms on the bones of the constitution and he establishes a lot of norms about how the president is supposed to behave and then he steps down after two terms and turns over power gracefully to his successor and i think that's one reason i think that donald trump has shocked people so much he is so much outside that cato mold yes which is really a stoical mode for the presidency i think so and

17:22Ryan Holiday: And that point about heroes, I think what Donald Trump has, and I think you can say this without actually getting into the politics in it, what Donald Trump sort of revealed is that we had all these norms. We had all these systems, these processes, these rituals that were based on really hard won wisdom from the ancient world, from the first principles you're talking about. But over the last 200 years, the why of them got lost. Even FDR, when FDR runs for reelection for a third term, he's violating a Cato-esque norm put in place by Washington. And I think people thought the population would be much more upset about it than they were.

18:05Ryan Holiday: But the reality is not knowing so much about why that norm had been set in the first place, it caused less of an uproar. I think what Donald Trump revealed is how much our education and our understanding of the first principles has atrophied. And so when the elites in the media get really upset about this norm or that norm, they expect that people are just going to intuitively understand why this is so important. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. I don't think stoicism is about being emotionless, but it is about thinking about those strong emotions. We have questioning them, getting to the bottom of them, asking if they're healthy or productive or not, asking if they're based on anything real or not.

18:45Ryan Holiday: And these are all questions I've been over with my therapists over the years. I said plural because I've switched at different times in my life based on where I lived, what I need. One thing that's been consistent, though, is I always do remote therapy. I want to find the best person, which means I don't really care where they live. Also, I don't want to drive across town. I don't want to wait in traffic. I don't want to do any of that. That's where today's sponsor comes in. If you've been considering therapy, check out today's sponsor, BetterHelp. BetterHelp makes finding a therapist super easy.

19:13Ryan Holiday: BetterHelp does the initial matching work for you. You can switch at any time. And with over 30 ,000 therapists, BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform, and they serve more than 6 million people globally. Don't let stigma stand in the way of support. Start therapy with BetterHelp. Sign up and get 10 % off at betterhelp.com slash dailystoicpod. That's betterhelp.com slash dailystoicpod. This year is going to be the 10-year anniversary, not just of the Daily Stoic book, but dailystoic.com. The email, the podcast, all that stuff. And I don't think we would be standing here 10 years later if it weren't for Shopify.

19:48Ryan Holiday: Shopify has been the back end of so many things we've done, from the New Year New You challenges to the medallions to posters. Even right now, if you're going to buy a signed book from me, you're going to be checking out through Shopify at dailystoic.com. or if you're buying something from Daily Dad there, or if you come to the Painted Porch, we even use Shopify at point of sale in the store. And if you've been sitting on a business idea, Shopify makes it easy to make that happen. You've got everything you need to start selling and Shopify handles the setup and the checkout and you can focus on growing the business and they've got all the tools to help you with what you need, which is why Shopify powers millions of businesses worldwide from household names like Mattel and Gymshark to small businesses just getting started like Daily Stoic was not that long ago.

20:31Ryan Holiday: With Shopify, nothing stands between your idea and real business. So go make it one. Start your free trial at shopify.com slash stoic. That's shopify.com slash stoic to start your free trial. I've had a number of people on. I'm fascinated with Confederate monuments and the sort of argument about, do you leave them up? Do you take them down? And I think one of the interesting things is like, I think for the most part, we're coming around to the idea that, hey, they should come down. But what we struggle with is like, well, who should we celebrate? If you were putting up a monument today, let's say you put the Confederate statues aside, who should we put a monument up?

21:07Ryan Holiday: And, you know, the fact that it took like 60 years to put up an Eisenhower memorial in Washington, D.C., sort of shows us our struggle with who are our heroes and how do we honor them. The question on Confederate monuments also is asked, who put them up? When do they put them up? And what did they think they were doing when they put them up? Certainly. Certainly. And a lot of them are really celebrations of segregation and Jim Crow and the destruction of Reconstruction. I was thinking about this a year ago. My wife and I just almost by accident happened to be in Belfast in Northern Ireland and took a walking tour of the Troubles, the fighting in Northern Ireland over the last 40 years.

21:49And one of the subjects of this tour, and it speaks exactly to this Confederate memorial issue, was the guy was talking about the difficulty of memorializing. He said, here was a bombing that killed 16 people. It was one of the first three bombings. There is no sign. Why? Because even now we can't agree on what to say. Were they people victims or were they participants? Was it a murder? Was it a political act? And he said, and then why are you putting up one here when you don't put up one for the Catholic down the street who was shot by the police? and you have this constant battle over what to actually memorialize.

22:27But I think it's an important discussion to have because it does point to, what are you going to memorialize? How are you going to memorialize it? Why? My daughter happens to be a public historian and she's involved in a project in Baltimore. There was an African-American cemetery in downtown Baltimore. It was paved over. Now that happens all the time. African-American cemeteries, we're totally disrespected. This is a special case because several hundred of the African-Americans were Civil War soldiers, colored troops. So you're mixing in this, well, you're dissing the military here too. Sure.

23:05Well, they didn't care in the 1950s when they ran a highway over it. So it's fascinating, the whole issue of memorialization.

23:12Ryan Holiday: Well, that was actually one of the things I wrote down that I wanted to talk to you about in your book. And I think it goes to where we struggle as a society right now, which is that, okay, So because the Confederate monument thing is complicated, people go, oh, should you pull down your monument of Washington or Jefferson? They own slaves. And on the one hand, or then some people say you should pull them down because they did own slaves. But what I think what we're not doing, what we should be doing, I'd be curious your take, which is that the founders did own slaves. And it wasn't a horrendous moral contradiction and a shameful act.

23:49Ryan Holiday: I don't necessarily know if we need to come to a conclusion about it, but we do have to wrestle with it. And I think what you do well in the book that we're struggling to do as a society, it's not as simple as the founders' own slaves. It's how do we wrestle with how they worked themselves into this moral complication so we can wrestle with our own moral complications today. Yeah, and we can be instructed by their failures as well as by their successes. My wife happens to be a historian of the 19th century, wrote a terrific book called Escape on the Pearl about the biggest attempted slave escape in American history when a bunch of middle-class slaves, wine stewards, you know, violin teachers in Washington, D.C., chartered a boat to take them to freedom in Philadelphia.

24:37And the boat was captured by a steamboat, and they were taken back, and it became a big, big thing in the 1840s. her rule of thumb is what was the person best known for? Robert E. Lee is best known for fighting a war to defend slavery. Monument comes down. Thomas Jefferson was best known for the Declaration of Independence. Monument stays up. And I think it's a helpful indicator or tool. But since we're getting into the ancient world of slavery, I want to mention another issue here that really surprised me is the founders stood on ancient slavery as a justification. Yes. Yet, ancient slavery generally was very different than modern American race-based slavery.

25:29Foremost, it was not race-based. Anybody could be a slave. In fact, the word slave comes from the Slavs, who are clearly, we would call, Caucasian. And with the exception of a few places like Sparta, slavery tended not to be as harsh as American race-based slavery. Slaves had some rights, the right to petition the emperor over abuse, and their offspring, if a slave was freed, his offspring could hold public office, which was not the case in America. And so I think the founders kind of gave themselves a free ride using the justification of slavery in the ancient world while presiding over a much harsher system of slavery.

26:10Ryan Holiday: I'll forward it to you. I just wrote an email for the Daily Stoic List about this. Jefferson wrote about this in notes from Virginia or whatever the book was called. He was talking about, he said, you know, in the ancient world, you know, the Romans, they had Epictetus, they had Terence, they had Cyrus, they had these brilliant slaves. And he said, that's why the Romans weren't as strict on their slaves is that their slaves were smarter. And he said, but look at us, we don't have any of those. And the irony is, I mean, first off, Phyllis Wheatley was a brilliant slave, But the difference is the Romans allowed the slaves to read and write.

26:45Ryan Holiday: That was punishable by death in a good chunk of the South at this time. And so, yeah, it's fascinating that the founders basically took their love of classicalism and twisted it and contorted it almost like the Nazis did into this perverse ideology that allowed them to rationalize a heinous, heinous act. Yeah. And then they don't allow slavery just to stain the American fabric. They weave it into the American fabric, in the Constitution, the fundamental law of the land. They endorse slavery. And as a result, 250 years later, we are still pulling out these strands. And people don't recognize that white supremacism was written into the Constitution.

27:27And they avoided the word race. They, in fact, avoid the word slavery. But they know what they're talking about when they say people in bondage are to be counted as three-fifths of a person.

27:37Ryan Holiday: When you had a pretty powerful sentence in the book that struck me where you said something like, and throughout the rest of American history, white supremacists would choose one of the parties. Different times, sometimes the Republicans, sometimes the Democrats. But that's always been a voting bloc in the United States, as much as we'd like that not to be true. It still is. And it's dependable, especially for people with declining bases. But you can always play that card. To go to this point of wrestling with it, though, I think, you know, where Washington shines greater than the other founders is that he seemed to come closer to realizing the ideals than any of the others.

28:20Ryan Holiday: He does free his slaves, you know what I mean? At considerable cost to himself. I mean, what's interesting is that Washington, as we're talking about it, an uneducated man is better at learning from experience. He's better at seeing what's in front of his eyes. Like I think a lot of very intelligent people who are not well-educated, he actually reflects on experience and draws lessons from it. In a way, I would say Jefferson doesn't. And that's why Jefferson is just a big old hypocrite. Spends his whole life writing about liberty and philosophy, yet does it living off the sweat of captive humans.

28:59Whereas Washington, after he steps down from the presidency, does get interested in the abolition of slavery and starts reading pamphlets about it. He really did seem to have a different approach. I would say don't diss Madison here, though. Madison, I think, is underappreciated and I think stands right after Washington. I think Madison's the second most important founder. Washington wins the revolution. I don't think another general might have. So Washington gives this to the country. Madison designs the country. And he's constantly in the background. I think he gets dissed a little bit because he is not a memorable writer.

29:37There's no phrases that really jump out from him. He's small, 5 '5", 110 pounds, sickly, suffers from some form of epilepsy throughout his life. He doesn't have a good speaking voice, and he's not really a good orator. Nonetheless, and he's not very social, by the way, which is unusual for a politician. Yet, you know, here's the guy who during the 1780s, the Articles of Confederation period, starts beating the drum for a constitutional convention. He gets a constitutional convention arranged. He's the first guy to show up in Philadelphia. Having spent four years preparing for it, researching ancient Greek city-states, he has all these things at his fingertips.

30:19And that's why we wind up with big states and small states, each having two senators. And he said, well, that's the way that league worked in ancient Greece. the city-states. This is sort of the ancient version of kind of a NATO or the EU. Big city states and small city states, he's got two. So then he leaves the ratification campaign with Hamilton to get the Constitution ratified. And then in the 1790s, Madison and Jefferson invent American politics, sort of the first version of it. Then he goes on and has a kind of mediocre presidency. But Madison really does so much in the background. Daniel Allen, who wrote a terrific book on the Declaration of Independence called Our Declaration, sort of a meditation on equality.

31:02Daniel Allen says that a lot of early American history is Madison talking to himself. So he drafts a letter from Congress to Washington, then he drafts Washington's response, and then he drafts Congress' response to Washington.

31:16Ryan Holiday: It's fascinating. And I think maybe this is a good place to wrap up, but I think what's so brilliant about, you know, Seneca talks about, he says, the purpose of philosophy, studying philosophy is you turn the words into works, right? And Marcus Aurelius talks about, you know, he said, I always had this horror of pen and ink philosophers, just the thinkers. What I think the American founders really were, and why I think they matter, even if you don't live in America, or even particularly like America, is that they were true philosophers in the sense that they took their love of classical wisdom, their inspiration from the ancient world, these principles, and they made something.

31:56Ryan Holiday: They made them real. And they helped millions of people get closer to realizing those ideals, which is, you know, I think the Stoic idea that the Epicurean, ironically for Thomas Jefferson, the Epicurean is like, I'm going to retreat to my garden. I'm going to live in this little fantasy world. And the Stoic says, I'm going to get involved in politics. I'm going to lead a country. I'm going to fight in a war. I'm going to do something in the real world. And I think that's what I found so fascinating about your book and why I think there's so much to learn from the founders. And in that sense, the United States of America is the greatest single product of the Enlightenment.

32:30Ryan Holiday: Yes. I mean, look, Napoleon is also a product of the Enlightenment. And look what he did with those principles. Yeah. You know, killed a lot of people, basically. Yeah. Tom, I love the book. It was so good to nerd out with you about this. I think everyone should read it. And I think if we want to make America great again, which I I believe it should be. What we really have to do is understand these principles that made it great in the first place and then try to get ourselves a little bit closer to realizing them.

33:09Music, food, art. These things define and unite us. And they come in colors that breathe culture. colors that connect us with their variety and richness you'll find that same variety in valspar ultra paints great coverage and durability starting at 29.98 per gallon enjoy everyday protection against scuffs and wear with a smooth washable finish we're made of colors and with valspar ultra you can reflect that pride of culture you have inside on every wall of your home available at lowes

From the publisher

For the Fourth of July, we’re revisiting Ryan’s conversation with Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Thomas Ricks about America’s founding, the ancient ideas that shaped it, and the first principles the founders were trying to build into the country.

In this episode, Ryan and Thomas talk about First Principles: What America's Founders Learned From the Greeks and Romans and How That Shaped Our Country, and why figures like Washington, Adams, Jefferson, and Madison looked to the ancient world for models of courage, discipline, justice, and wisdom.


📚 Pick up a copy: First Principles: What America's Founders Learned from the Greeks and Romans and How That Shaped Our Country by Thomas Ricks


🎟️ DAILY STOIC LIVE | Ryan Holiday is coming to a city near you! Grab tickets here |  https://www.dailystoiclive.com/


🎙️ AD-FREE | Support the podcast and go deeper into Stoicism by subscribing to The Daily Stoic Premium - unlock ad-free listening, early access, and bonus content: https://dailystoic.supercast.com/


🎥 VIDEO EPISODES| Watch the video episodes on The Daily Stoic YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@DailyStoic/videos


✉️ FREE STOIC WISDOM | Want Stoic wisdom delivered to your inbox daily? Sign up for the FREE Daily Stoic email at https://dailystoic.com/dailyemail

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

More from The Daily Stoic

All episodes