

A Dispatch roundtable analyzing why Democrats made major gains in statehouses/governorships and what it means for the future of the Republican Party, Trump’s influence, and the “civil war” on the right. Guests argue the election was a repudiation of Trump and MAGA, driven by corruption, cost-of-living anger, and dissatisfaction with how wars (especially Iran) were handled, plus the effects of online/right-wing culture.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the midterm elections and their implications.
“Jonah, it's been a minute, as the kids say, since the election.”
Exploring the consequences for the Republican Party after the elections.
“What we saw was, look, it's a positive way to talk about it.”
Analyzing why voters are dissatisfied with Trump and his policies.
“I mean, a lot of voters who voted for Trump three times voted against Republicans to punish him because he said he was on the ballot and they don't like what he's doing.”
Discussing the various factors that influenced voters in the election.
“or trying to put this in broader context or downplay what a rebuke of the president this was, will say, eh, this is basically what happens in midterms.”
Examining how perceptions of corruption impact voter behavior.
“But the upside is that I live in a representative democracy, so I live with it.”
Explore how feelings of precarity influence voter behavior and support.
“If I am doing fine, if my income is going up, if there's peace and prosperity, it's going to take more for me to rock this boat.”
Discuss the detrimental effects of Stephen Miller's policies on the GOP.
“Politically, it is very difficult to think of somebody who has single-handedly done more damage, put Trump aside, than Stephen Miller.”
Examine the primary concerns of voters affecting their decisions in the election.
“And 56 % of those voters voted for Democrats this time around.”
Analyze how cultural perceptions and behaviors surrounding MAGA are evolving.
“And then the final one, just on Iran real quickly, as we've talked about on this podcast many times, he didn't really make a case for the war in Iran.”
Explores how MAGA's values and imagery have negatively influenced young men's political alignment.
“It is this, to become a part of MAGA means to be like Trump and to act like Trump.”
Discussion on J.D. Vance's views and their disconnect with mainstream concerns.
“Jonah, I want to ask you about a couple of things that David mentioned.”
Examines how online discussions drive political narratives and decisions.
“talking about the Rachel Campos-Duffy controversy, because that's really vital.”
Discussion on Vance's claims regarding the reasons for MAGA's electoral losses, including the influence of the Iran war.
“knows more about this than anybody thing is Vance's version of that.”
Exploration of how being in the White House can create a narrow worldview, affecting policy understanding amidst public sentiment.
“hardcore, the way he can replicate the Trump model is Trump only had at the beginning in 2015 and 2016, about 25 % of the party that was his.”
Introduces a metaphor for understanding online outrage and corporate reactions to it, contrasting it with real public engagement.
“And you saw this in the Biden White House, too.”
Analyzes how politicians misinterpret rally attendance as widespread support, referring to historical and recent examples.
“thousands of people shouting about something.”
Discussion on how Trump's rally crowd reactions influenced political nominations.
“This crowd at a Trump rally react to Matt Gaetz as Attorney General and said, this guy needs to be Attorney General.”
Analysis of polling results and implications for the Democratic Party's direction.
“And we have what I think is a fun, not worth your time to get to as well.”
Exploration of new faces in the Democratic Party and their potential impact.
“David, is there any likelihood that that will happen given the volume that we get from DSA types?”
Discussion on the complexities facing Democrats in governance and voter expectations.
“I mean, you've got Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries.”
Assessment of Trump's ongoing influence in the Republican Party and future elections.
“So like there's going to be, there are so many countervailing forces pushing back and forth right now that it is hard for me to say.”
The hosts discuss the influence of political spending and the discrepancies in voter performance among different Democratic candidates.
“Like there's a stat going around that I need to fact check.”
The hosts analyze James Tallarico's campaign strategies, including his vegan approach and its impact on his election results.
“You're listening to the Dispatch Podcast.”
Discussion on how ads influence candidate perception and the overall election environment, with a focus on Tallarico's success.
“and you can point to just too many things that were variables, but in the Mississippi race, I think it is obvious that but for that ad, he doesn't win, because it was so close, right?”
Discussion on candidate viability and performance during tough political climates.
“And a lot of people that we didn't realize were bad candidates are exposed in that environment.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Dispatch Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile with a story about deception. Beautiful little tin. You open it, expecting delicious butter cookies. Instead, 40 years of loose buttons. Mint wouldn't do that to you. What you see is what you get. All plans, even unlimited, are$15 a month. Unlike this blue box of lies. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three months,$90 for six months, or$180 for 12 month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. See terms.
0:30Hey y 'all, Kelly Clarkson here with Wayfair. You know my favorite compliment during the holidays? Your house feels so cozy. That's when I know everyone's comfortable enough to kick off their shoes, grab more dessert, and stay a little longer. Wayfair makes it easy, with everything from dining furniture to festive guest room essentials, all in one place. So whether you're hosting for an afternoon or all weekend, everyone feels right at home. Get holiday guests ready at Wayfair.com or on the Wayfair app today. Wayfair, every style, every home.
1:07Jonah Goldberg: Welcome to the Dispatch Podcast. I'm your host, Steve Hayes. On today's roundtable, everything turning blue. We'll discuss the massive win for Democrats in state houses and governor's mansions in the House of Representatives, in the Senate. Big wins in deep red states, including Kansas, South Carolina, Texas, and maybe even Mississippi. What just happened and what does it all mean? And then what will the Democrats do with this new power? And what should we expect in the coming civil war on the right? How much influence will Donald Trump continue to have over the Republican Party? And finally, for not worth your time, we're going back to meet one more time.
1:45Jonah Goldberg: I'm joined today by Dispatch Editor-in-Chief Jonah Goldberg and Dispatch contributors David French of the New York Times and Megan Cardell of the Washington Post. Let's dive right in.
2:08Jonah Goldberg: Jonah, it's been a minute, as the kids say, since the election. What the hell just happened? I kind of want to say that nature is healing, but I feel like we ran through the tape on nature healing and went quite a ways further than that. What we saw was, look, it's a positive way to talk about it. There's a very positive way to talk about it. And then there's a more troubling way to talk about it. The very positive thing is that American politics proved yet again that there are no permanent coalitions. That having voted for a Republican is not like being left-handed or gay or tall or short. It doesn't mean that you have to do it for the rest of your life.
2:54It is not a form of identity politics. That the consequences of bad leadership is punishment from voters. Like, there's nobody on this podcast, and there are probably very few people listening to this podcast, that aren't familiar with our refrains about, you know, the lessons we've learned over the last quarter century of parties overreading their mandates, of the necessity to take responsibility for the possible downsides of your policy choices, that pandering to your base is a problem, whatever. What we've seen in this midterm is that lesson be taught good and hard, right? And so in many ways, for the foreseeable future, the Republican Party has been mortally wounded.
3:44That doesn't mean it's permanent. That's one of the lessons here is that nothing is permanent, right? But it is very difficult. Like, I don't think Texas is now just indistinguishable politically from Massachusetts or something like that. But for presidential Republican candidates to win in the future, they can't count on Texas. They have to spend money in Texas. They have to spend money in a bunch of places that normally they wouldn't have to spend money in, in part because we now have a majority of states, a majority of Americans will now live under Democratic governors. And I don't know about Democratic legislators, but it's going to be at least close to that.
4:25And that has consequences for policy, it has consequences for politics going forward. And it's too soon to tell if Democrats learn the right lessons or the wrong lessons from all of this. but I am very reassured that, you know, corruption and self-dealing, irresponsible leadership gets punished by voters, including voters who voted for Trump. I mean, a lot of voters who voted for Trump three times voted against Republicans to punish him because he said he was on the ballot and they don't like what he's doing. I don't think, I mean, I'll leave it to the other guys to give their own responses, but I just think that there's the rush to say this happened because of X or this happened because of Y, the war, Israel, gas, whatever, all of those things have truth to them because this is one of the most overdetermined elections in American history, I think.
5:16But the one through line of it all is that it was a repudiation of Trump. And I just don't know anybody. There's only one person in America who disagrees with that as far as I can tell, sincerely. And that's Donald Trump. I don't know anybody else who's with a straight face or persuasively thinks otherwise. But you can't come up with these monocausal theories of anything beyond that, because any theory about demographic shifts doesn't explain Mississippi, right? Any theory about Hispanics doesn't explain Maine. You know, Any theory about gas prices can't explain, you know, Florida to a certain extent.
5:57I mean, like, it's just a lot of stuff going on here, and it's going to take us a while to digest it. Sorry, I'm still sleep-deprived and rambly, but that's my first stab at it.
6:06Jonah Goldberg: Megan, one of the partial explanations, and you are hearing this from people who are defending the administration or trying to put this in broader context or downplay what a rebuke of the president this was, will say, eh, this is basically what happens in midterms. We all know that this is what happens in midterms. This happened to Barack Obama in his midterm. And while this is the second midterm, and usually there's not quite the repudiation of the sitting president in a second midterm, because Trump had, his terms were interrupted by the Biden presidency. This counts effectively as a first midterm all over again, and people shouldn't freak out.
6:45Jonah Goldberg: This is just what happens. You buy that?
6:48Steve Hayes: No. No. No, I do not buy that. Not even a little bit. You should not buy it either. You should take that back to the store and be like, no, I am returning this bad argument. Exchange it for a good argument, please. Get the salad spinner. What argument would you exchange it for? That look, the thing that I said on Twitter yesterday, not to the general approbation of Trump fans, was that this is what Trump supporters voted for. It's not what they wanted, but it is what they voted for. I get you wanted less immigration. You wanted like a reformation in the United States economy. You wanted a culture shift.
7:31Steve Hayes: Great. But to try to get those things, you elected a chaos Muppet who has no interest in policy, who is a rapacious narcissist, who, number one, remaking the party in his own image, testing politicians for loyalty rather than electability or competence, who pursued his whims both incompetently, right? They were not well executed from a legal perspective. I think David can talk more about that. But he got rebuffed by the courts in a bunch of ways. But the things that he did do had really large short-term political costs, notably the tariffs. If people are mad about affordability, let's slap a tax on middle-class consumers that makes everything more expensive.
8:19Steve Hayes: This was not going to be popular, even if you think this is a good policy. You have to understand there are real political constraints and that normal politicians who understand how politics and policy work, they work within those constraints. You know, Matt Iglesias once said about Medicare for All that what the Democrats should have done is just like, you raise Medicaid to like 150 % of the poverty line. And then you come back and you raise it to 175. And you just keep ratcheting up, and that's the way to get durable policy victories. And I think looking at the kind of wreckage of Obamacare, that analysis was correct.
8:53Steve Hayes: And the same thing, I don't personally think tariffs are a good policy, but if you think they are, you put a little tariff on and then you come back and you do it more and you just keep ratcheting it because that's how you do it without triggering a political backlash that is going to undo your whole program. Well, it's also just a point on that. It's also the more effective way to do tariffs. I mean, I mean, as economic policies, you give businesses a lot of time to plan, reshore, you know, all that kind of stuff. They didn't want to do that either. And visibility. I was talking to manufacturers who were just like, you know what?
9:26Steve Hayes: Give me a 15 % tariff. Just tell me what it is. Because I can't order anything without knowing what the cost of that thing is going to be. I need to plan my supply chains. And the fact that like here today, gone tomorrow, now you see it, now you don't. Tariffs were making it impossible for them to like invest in their firms and build for the future. And so this was predictable from who Donald Trump is. It was indeed predicted by the tariff people, by the anti-tariff people, that this was going to raise costs and be really unpopular and bad for the economy. And then you get the Iran war. Years ago, people would say to me, well, he's against wars.
10:11Steve Hayes: I was like, he's not against wars. He's against wars you lose, which is functionally what he'd said about Iraq. And of course, that's only clear in hindsight. So the chaos Muppet is like, you know, Venezuela went well, going back to the buffet for Iran, piling my plate high, and his eyes were bigger than his stomach. He had no plan for the most predictable thing, which is the Straits of Hormuz were going to be closed. Everyone who has wargamed this scenario, it's the first thing you do if you're playing Iran. Everyone knew this was going to happen. But Donald Trump has no ability to plan. no interest in long-term planning, no respect for experts who tell him, do not do this thing.
10:54Steve Hayes: And that's how we ended up where we are. And that was what you voted for, because that was the guy you had on the ticket. And I understand that you have desires for various things, and no one was offering them to you. Look, as a libertarian, I can't tell you how much I sympathize. But as a libertarian, I also, and I fight with other libertarians about this, like I vote for one of the two major parties. Why do I do this? because they're giving me exactly what I want? No. I'm choosing between the actual available options in this great messy democracy of ours. And you have to do that with an eye to can what I want be done politically feasibly?
11:33Steve Hayes: Like, look, I had all sorts of interesting ideas for like reforming taxes and Social Security and Medicare and all the rest of it. And I think there are good plans, but I also understand that there's not a snowball's chance that they will happen because I live in a representative democracy and my neighbors would freak out. And, you know, like, it's not ideal. It makes me sad sometimes. But the upside is that I live in a representative democracy, so I live with it.
11:58Jonah Goldberg: David, I want to ask you why some of these things that both Jonah and Megan mentioned broke through this time. I mean, many of the things that we're saying here were true of Donald Trump in 2018. They're true of Donald Trump when he was reelected in 2024. Why is it that these things seem to matter now in a way that they didn't before? Yeah, that's a great question. I think there's a couple of changes, a couple of differences. And not long ago, I was talking to somebody about this very topic, like if it does break through, why would it break through? And what I found interesting is if you look at the exits with all of your caveats about exits.
12:42They're not precise, et cetera. But I'm struck by one trend. Like the number one thing I keep seeing, the number one voter concern wasn't cost of living. That was two. The number one was corruption. And if I look at it and you think about it, it makes a ton of sense. Because one thing that I didn't appreciate fully when I was a much younger person in 1998 and in 1996, and Bob Dole was, you remember Bob Dole, where is the outrage in America? Because we knew by 96, I mean, it seemed like the Clinton campaign was selling access to the White House. You know, there was Chinese money get involved in the election.
13:20Think about how many of these sort of scandals are resonant today. But what was the difference? 96, the 98 with Monica Lewinsky is all taking place. The economy is booming. There's this thing called a surplus actually happening, which we hadn't had a surplus in forever. And I remember thinking, but it's not worth it if the president has terrible character. This president is corrupt. This president exploits women. But I think a lot of voters sort of have this, they strike a deal with their politicians. And the deal is this, your freedom of action as a corrupt Lothario is directly dependent on your ability to deliver for me.
14:03If I am doing fine, if my income is going up, if there's peace and prosperity, it's going to take more for me to rock this boat. But if things feel like they're not going fine and if things feel like I feel precarious, whether it's I feel precarious because of the geopolitical situation or I feel precarious because of inflation, I feel precarious because I'm of Hispanic heritage and I'm terrified to get behind the wheel of my car, if I feel precarious because I work at an institution that's free speech rights are being shut down, I mean, you name it. If I feel precarious or if I feel in distress and I look at you and you're living it up, it gets French revolutionary really fast.
14:48And that's what I felt like happened was in essence, if you took it and you look at all of these different fronts to the voters who voted for him because they wanted peace in the Middle East, he gave them a war without congressional approval. To voters who voted for him saying, I need relief from prices, my family is struggling, he gave them nonsense tariffs imposed punitively and seemingly at random and also a war. To people who, Hispanic people in Southwest Texas who were new Republican voters and who wanted a border under control, but decency and order and humanity inside the country found that their nephews, uncles, aunts, sisters were getting pulled over and sometimes brutalized because of their accent or the color of their skin.
15:32For anti-wokers who said, I'm so tired of stifling amounts of intolerance and stifling punishment for free speech. He gave us the worst free speech president literally since Woodrow Wilson and an online world of MAGA that is every bit of swarmy, shamey, mocky, threatening, as the most far left gang that migrated to Blue Sky. And so you look at thing after thing after thing after thing, and he's not delivering what was promised. He's a chaos agent into people's lives. The economy, their wages are not matching inflation, even though inflation is not at historical high levels. What people really care about is, is my paycheck keeping up?
16:15It wasn't. And so in a weird way, the only thing that really kind of should surprise us from that outcome is that we were surprised by that outcome when you put it all together. But at the same time, to go back to Jonah's point, a lot of us who've been critical of Trump have been feeling this chaos for year after year after year. And now it's just radiated throughout the country. And one last quick thing, I spent years and years and years in laboring in the trenches of religious sobriety and free speech, talking about how extreme a lot of college campuses were. It's extreme. It's extreme. It's extreme.
16:54And people are like, oh, that's bad. But it was very low on the totem pole. But then when the thing that I encountered, say, when suing, you know, say University of Wisconsin ends up on the HR training of the local tire shop. In other words, it's not on campus anymore. It's right in front of my face. Right. People change. change and that's very similar like i think with the hispanic vote in large parts of this country i don't know when republicans will have an ability to grab it for a generation because of what you did to people's families how you imposed a sense of pervasive fear and anxiety on entire communities and so in hindsight i'm surprised that i wasn't surprised but i know why i wasn't surprised it's funny like we don't you know you know how in the covid leak lab leak theory basically there's one dude whose name we don't know who's probably dead but there's one dude who got some vials confused or like kept something you know that stuck to his shoe and he got out of a lap he made some mistake that cost millions of lies and trillions of dollars and like biggest screw up of the millennium kind of thing, right?
18:12Politically, it is very difficult to think of somebody who has single-handedly done more damage, put Trump aside, than Stephen Miller. Oh. Right? Stephen Miller is the lab leak of the golden age, right? Like, they had this working-class, multiracial working-class party theory. You know, Rubio said it, Vance said it, they all said it, They all thought that was the lesson of 2024, that the GOP had broken the back of the FDR coalition and that now, you know, the GOP was going to be this new thing. And Stephen Miller, because he wants to live in a more white country. And that's not my ad hominem. There was like reporting that, you know, about conversations he's had with Trump, where Trump has said, look, if you had your way, everything would look like the 1950s.
19:02And Miller's like, yes, that's correct, Mr. President. And that kind of thing. He has a theory of the case. He thought the cruelty would be the point. It would cause mass self-deportation. And he pushed this in a way that even Trump thought was too heavy-handed. And at times, at least according to some reporting. And he's destroyed the ability of the Republican Party to break out of the constraints it's spent a generation trying to get out of. And the policy wasn't successful, right? I mean, it's still a multiracial country. and I just don't, he's not getting the dirty looks and finger pointing from within the tent.
19:41From outside the tent, I would want a food taster if I was him and there's a reason why and it's kind of outrageous that he has to live on a military base. But like inside the rooms, in the bunker, in the downfall video, they should be turning on Stephen Miller something fierce and they're just, it doesn't seem like that's happening.
19:59Jonah Goldberg: So I think David's case is very persuasive And a similar case, our Nick Catojo made the case yesterday in his newsletter. We'll post that in the show notes that they were willing to sort of give Trump all of this leeway as long as things were good. He had run on the economy several years in a row. The economy was good. He couldn't say that this time. But I wonder if there's also something more going on. And David, you mentioned corruption as the top issue. If you look at the top three issues when voters were asked about their concerns, the top three issues, I'm just calling these up here, the percentage of voters who ranked these issues, crucial or major factor in deciding their votes.
20:42Jonah Goldberg: The number one, as you said, David, was corruption with 90 percent of voters citing corruption. Ninety. That was a factor. Nine zero. Yes. Now, part of that, it must be said, this goes both ways, right? Because Democrats were voted about Donald Trump's corruption. Republicans are concerned about Democrats' corruption. But 90 % is a huge thing. And 56 % of those voters voted for Democrats this time around. The second issue was cost of living. 89 % were concerned, said it was a crucial or major factor in their votes. And 58 % of those voted for Democrats. And then the third was the Iran war. 74 % said it was a crucial or major factor.
21:20Jonah Goldberg: And 63 % of those voters voted for Democrats. But I wonder if you look at each of those issues, I wonder if it's not also that they revealed something more about Donald Trump. And you all have heard my theory about the corruption case. I think people had this sort of general sense that Donald Trump was corrupt. He didn't seem to care about corruption. But I do think that this really important point came when he himself tried to bribe American voters. In September, he repeated the offer throughout the last two months of the campaign. He put out a video at 4 p.m. the day before the election saying, if you keep my party in power, I will give you$5 ,000.
22:01Jonah Goldberg: And my theory, Jonas heard this probably too many times, is that if you're an average voter and you're living in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin or Peoria or Wichita, and you read these stories about crypto investments and planes from the UAE and you don't know what to make of that. And then the president of the United States in public says, I'm giving you$5 ,000 if you keep me in power. All of a sudden, all of these other things that you don't know how to understand make sense. And you think, if he's willing to bribe me in public on this thing so that he can stay in power, maybe there's some truth to all of this other stuff.
22:38Jonah Goldberg: And they learned something there about Donald Trump. I would say the same thing is on the cost of living. I think you're right. The easiest and most accurate, probably for the most number of voters, gas prices were too high. They're sick of gas prices being too high. This is not what he said he would deliver, and he delivered the opposite. But also, he's lying about it. He lied about it throughout the entire election. He said he would bring gas prices down. He didn't. And then he told people, things are better than you think they are. Trust me, I'm Donald Trump. And he brought along so many people who voted for Republicans and voted for Trump over the course of his time in public office.
23:15Jonah Goldberg: who could sort of suspend disbelief because Trump is telling them he's the authoritative source for information these days. They don't believe the media. They don't believe this other stuff. Maybe the election in 2020 was actually stolen because Donald Trump is saying it, even though all these other people, but for them, this was unfalsifiable. They had no way to know. But on cost of living, when he's telling them, literally it was the morning before the election, he gave an interview on Fox and Friends and he said inflation is solved. In effect, there is no cost of living problem. And I think voters heard him say that, and probably not a lot of those people were watching Fox and Friends, but in his speeches, they read the headlines and they said, this guy is totally full of shit in a way that I maybe didn't recognize a little bit earlier.
24:01Jonah Goldberg: And then the final one, just on Iran real quickly, as we've talked about on this podcast many times, he didn't really make a case for the war in Iran. Ever. At all. Or a plan. A plan, a case, anything. He would change his reason from moment to moment. It was, you know, Iran's nukes. It was the regime was bad. It was any of a number of things. And he never really made the case. And I think at a certain sort of very basic level, you've got Trump sort of living in the Oval Office, doing his crazy stuff, giving his crazy speeches, might be mildly entertaining for people. But war and peace is a very serious thing.
24:39Jonah Goldberg: And I think ultimately people wanted to see that this commander in chief, however much he might be an unserious guy in so many other ways on this one thing where people are going to die, actually took it seriously. And he gave evidence every single day with every single thing he said that he never took it seriously. David, I'll go back to you on this. Am I just over reading it because I want more specific direct blame for Trump and his character stuff rather than just voters wanted cheap prices? Okay, let's, this is the wildest election to analyze since I've been in this business, because normally what you do is you get election results and you go, okay, this issue really resonated with voters or this messaging really worked.
25:27Or and you're looking at it like, you know, the Sarah analogy of curling of where you have the the rock is sort of the moment of the race. And then the strategists and all of this, they're the sweepers who are barely moving the rock this way or that way. And in our very closely polarized world for the last 25 years in most elections, like those small movements of the rock are enough to be the difference between winning and losing sometimes. And you could say, well, it was this ad. Look at the response to this ad. Or, hey, let's tie this to a particular inflation rate or a crime rate or where you can parse this thing.
26:04Not this time. This is so big. This is post-Watergate big. We have not seen anything like this. As Jonah said at the beginning, it could be an extinction level event, at least for this iteration of the Republican Party. And so I think, Steve, I could imagine a voter sitting here and going, you're about one third of the way through that litany of things you just went through. or maybe I get about one third of the way through the litany of things I went through. And they're just like, no, what actually happened is I just decided you're horrible. Be gone. Go away. And I think that it's all of these things at once.
26:42At some point, you reach a point. And then, you know, and Ezra, my colleague Ezra Klein said something really interesting. He said, whoever wins Twitter loses American politics in about three or four years. So whoever like gets a hold of Twitter, whoever makes that their domain, they lose politics. They lose American politics for about three or four years. And when you look at the culture of the right that grew up online and then it's they spilled just like the, you know, as I just said before, like the H.R. Briefing all of a sudden has critical race theory or whatever. All of this just began to spill all over America.
27:20It just spilled all over America. And when I was down in Texas and was reporting on the Tallarico Paxton race, the thing that I was struck by was that the pro or the anti-Paxton Republicans were seething with rage. It wasn't just like, I'm upset with Ken Paxton. I don't like him. He's not a good guy. It was this person is horrible. The people around him are horrible. and you couldn't go more than three seconds without not just hearing about the candidate, but the universe around the candidate. And that universe around the candidate was MAGA. It is this, to become a part of MAGA means to be like Trump and to act like Trump.
28:11And this began to just metastasize throughout our culture. And I think the most striking statistic of all, the biggest swing, the biggest swing was in young men. They sprinted left, sprinted left. And I started to rant about this at the end of our dispatch live. It's not a mystery. Why? What happened is this right-wing Trumpist Manosphere basically took Biff Tannen from Back to the Future and said, behold, the model man. And it's disgusting. Okay. It's disgusting. The vision they put forward of manhood is the bully in a Christmas story. It's the, I mean, like it's every villain you have ever seen in every movie about coming of age.
29:04Right. And that became what the ideal Republican man was. And it repulsed young men. It repulsed people. Look at what happened to the youth vote. And then the reason we were told not to purge Groeperism from conservatism was because you're going to lose Gen Z. Well, congratulations, guys. Congratulations. You just lost Gen Z. And so, yeah, to me, it was, this is such a different election because it is not. Well, you know, if they changed the messaging in Texas, Steve, with a little bit of higher ad buy in the Southwest. No, it was like, you're making me sick. Be a get away, be gone was sort of the, the, just the national sense of revulsion.
29:49It's, it's astonishing.
29:51Jonah Goldberg: Before we take an ad break, I've got a big announcement for a limited time. The dispatch is offering annual memberships at 50 % off our normal rate. That's just$50 for a year of full unrestricted access to all of our editorial offerings. If you've been listening to us or been part of our internal conversations at the company, you know I hate discounts. But we think this is a big moment and we are eager to bring more people into the Dispatch family. If you join, you'll unlock access to bonus podcast episodes and every one of our exclusive newsletters and articles. If you think things have been chaotic in our national politics over the past decade, buckle up for what will be a hugely consequential time in Washington and beyond.
30:38Jonah Goldberg: Allow the dispatch to be your guide. Jonah Goldberg, Kevin Williamson, Nick Catozio, Sarah Isker, Megan McArdle, and many others. And you'll get Mike Warren's Next Right newsletter, which will be the most authoritative reporting and analysis on the emerging post-Trump reality you can find anywhere. Please sign up at thedispatch.com slash join for our 50 % off special sale. The 50 % sale also applies to premium memberships. No ads, early access to all episodes, two free gift memberships to give away, exclusive live taun hauls with the founders, and much, much more premium memberships include upgrades from existing members, and they are also 50 % off for a very limited time.
31:26Jonah Goldberg: So make the leap. Okay, we'll be right back. Some of the pictures worth keeping aren't the ones taken at big celebrations. They're the ordinary moments. Aura Frames makes it easier to bring those pictures out of a crowded camera roll and into everyday life. An example, for years, my kids have stolen my phone and loaded up my camera roll with silly pictures of themselves just meant to troll me. I upload these photos to my parents' Aura Frame, and they not only get to see our carefully posed family photos and shots from honor roll celebrations or sports victories, they get a glimpse of the insanity of our everyday life.
32:04Jonah Goldberg: Aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families, and their Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year. For a limited time, visit AuraFrames.com and get up to$50 off select frames, plus an additional$5 off your order with the promo code DISPATCH. That's A-U-R-A frames dot com promo code DISPATCH. Support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply. Picture a neighborhood print shop on a Thursday afternoon. A school needs posters for a fundraiser. A local band wants flyers by tomorrow and somebody has just brought in a rush order. The customers see the finished work.
32:43Jonah Goldberg: They don't see the owner juggling a new employee's onboarding, next week's payroll, and questions about benefits. Getting it right matters just as much as getting the colors right on the page. And that's where Gusto can help. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use, so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. Gusto helps simplify payroll with automatic tax filing and unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price without hidden fees or surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash dispatch and get three months free when you run your first payroll.
33:21Jonah Goldberg: That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash dispatch. One more time, gusto.com slash dispatch. There's a simple way I think about a mattress now. When the alarm goes off, you know whether you actually rested or just spent the night in bed. I wake up and feel restored. I can tell that I've slept well. And when I roll over and check my sleep score, I see the difference. I feel like my bed was made for me. That's one reason I appreciate Brooklyn Bedding's approach. They don't assume everybody sleeps the same way. With more than 15 mattress models, there are choices for different kinds of sleepers instead of a single answer for everyone.
34:01Jonah Goldberg: And the 365-night comfort trial means you get time to decide whether your mattress is actually a good fit. So go to brooklynbedding.com and use my promo code DISPATCH at checkout to get 30 % off site-wide during the Black Friday sale. exclusive with my code. That's brooklynbetting.com and promo code dispatch for 30 % off site-wide. Let them know we sent you in the survey after checkout. brooklynbetting.com, promo code dispatch. Welcome back. Let's return to our discussion. Jonah, I want to ask you about a couple of things that David mentioned. Looking back, we spent a little bit of our time here at the start looking back and coming up with an explanation for this, But I also want to turn and look forward a little bit.
34:47Jonah Goldberg: I think the way to do that is to look at this post that J.D. Vance made on X on Twitter. Long, detailed post. He had talked to some experts. He had talked to some pollsters. He loves all of them. Anonymous. And he walked through and he gave all sorts of reasons. Here's why. And he basically said, really, the real reason is the war. So I want to get your thoughts on both his substantive explanation for what happened, But also, to David's point, there was something that struck me in particular about his long explanation. And it wasn't any of the substance. It wasn't anything that he said about this is why, and I heard this from these pollsters and everything else.
35:28Jonah Goldberg: He had a line in this long post, which reads as follows. Many spent Monday attacking Rachel Campos Duffy for calling a diplomatic resolution to the conflict. He's talking here about Iran. It turns out her political advice was sound. She's also a great person. And I read that line and I thought, in what universe, in what bubble are quote unquote many people talking about Rachel Campos Duffy? And I was, I'm in New York City right now. I was at a dinner last night with about 15, 20 people who I think pay attention to this stuff, but they're not in it, right? They're certainly not online in the way that J.D.
36:16Jonah Goldberg: Vance is online. And I asked for a show of hands. How many people have heard of Rachel Campos Duffy, much less are outraged about how she was attacked on Monday for this thing that literally nobody in the room had heard of Rachel Campos Duffy. I had to explain that she is a co-host on Fox and Friends and she must have. I didn't know that she was attacked. I didn't know that this co-host on Fox and Friends had offered a solution to the Iran impasse. And J.D. Vance has this aside where he thinks that in his world, this really mattered. Many of the people, many people, many of the people that he listens to or cares about, were talking about this moment.
37:04Jonah Goldberg: And my thought was, whatever he says in the rest of his explanation, and please feel free to engage on that, this is the most important thing. This is a guy who thinks that the world are these online people sniping about the day before the midterms, sniping with one another about what some Fox and Friends host says about the Iran war. Nobody cares about that. Nobody knows who she is. And he's making decisions about our lives, thinking this. It's a distorted reality, in my view. What did you think about the substance? And what does it tell us about where J.D. Vance sees himself, this guy who has been the conventional wisdom?
37:46Jonah Goldberg: We have not agreed about this. The conventional wisdom's frontrunner for the nomination in 2028. First of all, I think we should spend the next half hour talking about the Rachel Campos-Duffy controversy, because that's really vital. shocking outrageous how did we miss it how did we miss it hiding in plain sight you know so like i i actually gave a speech on this last year and i keep meaning to write it up that i think one of the things most in one of the most important things that nobody talks about really i mean there have been some news articles about it but is the role that these large group chat yes whatsapp chats whatever play in our society i'm so glad you're bringing this up right it's like There's a reason why in the revolutions of Europe, 1830, 1848, 1870, the powers that be were freaked out about dinner parties in salons.
38:42Because what would happen is people would get together and they would work themselves up into a lather and then sort of like it couldn't contain all of the revolutionary spirit. and it would spill out and it made the association, the right association became seen as a threat to the established order. You now have a similar dynamic in virtual space where people all across the country combine. And some of these group checks, particularly in the Silicon Valley world, are massive, right? And Vance is a central player in a lot of those things. You know, and I don't want to like, you know, all the tech bro ones he's sort of in or around, at least on the very right-wing ones, you know, in the Teal universe and the Andreessen universe and all that kind of stuff.
39:26And so it's a little similar to what happened at the New York Times before David got there, when during the whole Tom Cotton controversy, where they had one massive Slack channel where everybody was allowed to sort of work up their revolutionary zeal until it kind of spilled out into public in the pages of the New York Times. I think that there's a lot of that kind of thing going on. And then you have to compound it with, like, I was talking to a friend, he wasn't telling me this on the record, so I have to be a little careful. But like, I know people who go to the NED, which is this private club at MAGA Central, and it is bunker mentality as far as the eye can see with people, you know, like, you know, Besant and other people holding court there and that kind of thing.
40:13And a lot of those people actually believe the stuff that like that quote from Kevin Hassett that we heard a couple, you know, 10 days ago about how it's a myth that affordability is a problem. Inflation has been solved. Like they believe that these people I talk to sincerely say they believe it over there. And so, you know, on election night, the former White House press secretary is now a Fox News contributor. Carolyn Levitt. Carolyn Levitt. Yeah. She flat out said, I mean, we can play the clip. I'll get it for you. Like, she flat out said, I think a big part of this is that the American people have been duped by the left-wing media into actually not understanding that they have more money in their pocket than they think they have.
40:59And again, you cannot lie to people about the money they have in their own pockets. Right. And the thing is, I don't think she's lying. I think she's ensorcelled about all this. So very quickly on the Vance thing, because I feel like I'm triggering Megan. I think the Vance statement was outrageous and profoundly dishonest. If you look at his list of reasons, it's basically three synonyms for Israel and something else, right? He doesn't mention corruption, right? He has this list of reasons that concern the voters. He does this thing. I joked about it on Twitter. Like, you know how there are always pretty like blue sky liberals who will say, my five-year-old this morning asked me why it is we can't have Medicare for all, right?
41:42Or my six-year-old on the drive to school asked me about Reinhold Niebuhr and climate change, you know? And it's just total fictional nonsense.
41:49Jonah Goldberg: You're just saying that because your kid has grown up, Jonah. I mean, my little kids still say this stuff. And so, uh, the, my personal data guy or the data guy who knows more about this than anybody thing is Vance's version of that. And he quotes all these people saying that these are the reasons. He wants to make it sound like this is science, right? And this is just known and super reasonable. And it's amazing how all the hardcore MAGA people, including, I got in trouble a little bit on CNN yesterday because the White House correspondent said into the camera, and Vance's tweet has just been endorsed by Donald Trump Jr., who said, all of this, 100 % emoji, 100 % emoji, 100 % emoji.
42:35And I just started laughing on camera about it. Like, oh my, three 100 % emojis from Donald Trump Jr.? It must be right, you know? And what Vance does in that, among other things, is he says, okay, the reason why we lost is because of the Iran war, which he's always wanted a separate lane on. And that's fine. I mean, it's not fine. It's kind of unprecedented, but like, we know that. The thing is, and he says, as the president has said, it was because of the Iran war. The president didn't say that. The president said that it was because of high gas prices, which were a result of the Iran war. Nothing in Vance's thing says anything about affordability.
43:10It says it's the war. He wants to make it that the Tucker Carlson critique of the war is the reason why voters did this. And I got to say, look, I think that's BS. I think most voters, to the extent they care about the Iran war, they don't like that it was done glibly. and they really hate high gas prices. If you didn't have the high gas prices or if it had been successful, successful in some sense, I don't think it'd be a major issue at all. It is symbolic of the affordability stuff and the lack of trust in Trump stuff, but it's not because it's in the Middle East and that is triggering to Qatari paylords for Tucker Carlson or something.
43:48And I think he's got a theory that he can get 25 % of bought-in, hardcore, the way he can replicate the Trump model is Trump only had at the beginning in 2015 and 2016, about 25 % of the party that was his. And he let the rest of the candidates eat each other alive. And he was the last one standing. And then everyone said, well, you have no choice. You got to back the nominee. I think he wants that strategy. I don't think it'll work because I think he's a crappy politician. I think people see through it. And I think that the 25 % he wants is different than the 25 % Trump had. Trump was a limousine liberal from New York City.
44:24He was not coded the way, you know, MAGA didn't mean then what it means now. And the 25 % that Vance wants to lock in are, as David was alluding to, quite simply the worst people in America. Amazingly bad. They're horrible people. You know, they're racist. They lean into their racism. They spent the day yesterday trying to construct a narrative that Ribbon has lost Texas because of the Indian American H-1B visa vote.
44:52Jonah Goldberg: Yeah. You know, these are people who want racist narratives. They're nasty. They're trolls. They're very online. I don't think they actually make up 25 % of the electorate for primaries, but he's got this theory that that's the tip of the spear he can use. And I think it's going to blow up in his face. Because he's so online. This is part of it. This is his world. It's unbelievably so online. Megan, to you, one of the other things, it just has to be said before you respond to Jonah, two of the four things, arguably three, at least two of the four things, to Jonah's point, had something to do with Israel, right?
45:29Jonah Goldberg: One is end the war, you know, people in this world that Jonah's describing, the United States was dragged into the war by Benjamin Netanyahu, this is Israel's war, et cetera, et cetera. And the fourth was people want to, Republicans want to change our relationship to Israel. I think Vance overstates that and there's exit polling that actually contradicts what he said there. But your response to what Jonah said and to the Vance argument more broadly.
45:56Steve Hayes: Yeah, look, what I was going to say to Jonah is that it's not just the Washington bubble and it's not just the group chat bubble. It's the White House bubble. And you saw this in the Biden White House, too. Right? You're in the White House and you have no access to, you're working so many hours. All of these guys, whatever else you think of them, they are all working like 16 hours a day, seven days a week, right? And so you are totally consumed by policy fights. You are totally consumed by the palace intrigue and all the rest of it. And you're totally consumed by just literally the amount of work that you're putting in, the meetings, the trips, etc.
46:32Steve Hayes: And so your worldview narrows a lot. You don't have interaction with normal America almost at all. And so with Biden, with the inflation, right, what you actually saw quite a bit of the same thing is like they're looking at numbers and you can kind of squint at the charts and be like, well, you know, wages rose too and one of those things should offset the other, right? Okay, yeah, prices went up 4%, wages went up 4.6%. Why are people mad? And there are a lot of answers to that, including the fact that like, it's not like an even little frosting on everyone's income. Some people are fine. Other people's incomes do not go up as much as the average real wage, and their prices still do go up by the amount of the average inflation.
47:23Steve Hayes: It takes time to, like, yeah, sure, maybe you're going to negotiate pay increases to offset the inflation, but you're not going to do that, like, a day after milk went up 50 cents at the Piggly Wiggly. You're going to do that in six months. And so the Biden administration made the same arguments, And they too had their weird conspiracy theories about how like it was collusion in the meatpacking industry. That was no, that's not what's going on here. And then there's also the problem that like while they have not tamed inflation, the parts that are policy amenable are really hard. Right. Like they have they often feel like they have done everything they could.
48:03Steve Hayes: It's just that the things that they would have to do, like you could ask the Fed to raise interest rates up to recessionary levels. People wouldn't like that. You could cut the budget deficit, which is helping to drive inflation by quite a bit, and also raising the cost of money, raising the cost of car loans and mortgages and so forth. People wouldn't like that. That would also be recessionary. They don't have a, like, you, even if we declared war, ended the war against Iran tomorrow, it would take a bit for gas prices to come down. And then there's the tariffs, which are technically not inflation, even though they look, they like, it's like a little kid dressed up as inflation for Halloween, right?
48:43Steve Hayes: It's a one-time increase in the price level. It is not technically, like, but. It is the dorkiest debate among economists, I have to say. Yes, it is really. I enjoy tweaking economists. But I love it. Yeah. Jonah, that is not true. The dorkiest debate among economists is whether you are technically, we should treat you for tax purposes as if you were paying yourself rent on your home and tax your imaginary rental income. Literal debate among economists. Hilarious. I like it. Good times are had by all. And so, like, I think these guys are just wrapped in the White House bubble. And because they're wrapped in the White House bubble, they do hunger for reality.
49:23Steve Hayes: They wish to know the world beyond their cap. But they don't have time to leave the White House. So what do they do? They go online. And that is how these guys get Twitter brain. Yeah. Now, like, Twitter brain afflicts us all. And I'm sorry if listeners have heard this before, but I love this metaphor so much that I'm going to drag it out yet again. Guys, have we talked about the Texas high school football stadium fallacy? so like years ago when companies keep these online mobs will spin up and companies are like you're fired you're fired you're fired cancel that product like our entire we're putting our entire store will now be like swabbed in rainbows like 365 days a year with little christmas rainbows for christmas there'll be red white and green rainbows for christmas but otherwise rainbows And I said, I was trying to get companies to like have some proportion about this.
50:18Steve Hayes: And I said, like, look, in the state of Texas, there are 87 high school football stadiums that seat more than 10 ,000 people. And 10 ,000 people is a pretty good online mob. And now for a Texas high school football stadium, moreover, those people, they have to get up. They got to shower, put clothes on. They got to drive. It's very hot in Texas during the beginning of football stadium. And they got to sit there in the heat, drinking their water, trying not to sweat too much. It takes a lot more effort than hitting retweet. So if someone demands you do something, I want you to ask yourself, if the Katy Tigers fan squad was demanding that I do this immediately, would I change my corporate policy?
50:55Steve Hayes: And if I would not be like, oh my God, you know, the Overland, Texas team is ripping us. We got to do something immediately. Then you should not react to an online mob either. And because it creates, like, our evolutionary lizard brains are just not equipped to filter thousands of people shouting about something. And it feels like a huge number of people because we're involved to live in groups of between 25 and 150 people. So thousands is like, oh my God, literally the entire world is angry at me. That is what your lizard brain is saying. But in fact, it's a teeny tiny number of people who are not making a whole lot of effort, who are hitting retweet because they're bored, or to show off to their friends, or for some reason, most of them don't care, and nothing will happen if you ignore them.
51:42Steve Hayes: And that is, the problem is that as they're looking out, they look out online, and they try to, like, get a sense of what people are doing, but they are filtering on, I agree, it's not 25 % of the base is, like, super concerned there are too many Indian immigrants at University of Texas football games. But those people are really loud, and if there's a few thousand of them, which is 0.00001 % of the United States population, it still feels like a lot. And I think that that cognitive bias explains not just a lot of what's gone wrong in the Trump presidency, but some of what went wrong in the Biden presidency as well.
52:19So two quick data points on that. One, if we're doing Greatest Hits, one of my favorite stories is from Richard Nixon when he was asked whether he, as sitting president, he was asked whether he believed in like the Paul Ehrlich overpopulation thesis and whether overpopulation was a problem. And Nixon allegedly said, oh yeah, overpopulation's obviously a huge problem. I mean, look, everywhere I go, I see huge crowds. And it's like, maybe that's because you're president of the United States. And I think Trump has that bias, right? He's sort of like Romney in 2012 in that last Pennsylvania rally.
52:56Trump sees packed rallies. And he's also inclined to think the crowds are always bigger than they actually are. We know that about him. But he goes to these rallies, which have to be organized. There are a lot of people saying, look, you got to look, like, look where he's going. This means the Republicans are in trouble, which in retrospect is definitely a plausible argument because he was in trouble everywhere. But there's also a reason to believe that he was going to do rallies in places like Mississippi and Alabama and whatnot, because that was the one, those were the places where they could make sure that he had big enough crowds to see who he could go.
53:30Yeah. And so my only point is they could put those online, right?
53:34Jonah Goldberg: And I think to bring these both two things together, they could film it, they could show the long lines, and then they could put it online. But in his mind, I mean, it's very similar. Like, it's amazing to me, and it bothers me that no one else thinks it's as interesting as I do as an insight into Trump. I now collect examples. He says it all the time. Harry Enton, good guy, colleague at CNN, right? He says he had this video clip of him saying that Trump has 99, it was actually 98, 98 % support among self-identified MAGA voters. Well, the thing is, if you self-identify as a MAGA voter to a pollster, you are saying you support Trump.
54:14So it's like saying I have 100 % support among people who support me.
54:19Steve Hayes: G-File readers. Yes. Yeah, right. It's like, you know, it's it's of the people who say they love me. A hundred percent of them love me. Right. It's just it's it's a it's a tautology nonsense. Right. But he he says he cites this all the time. And like he said to Brett Baer the other night on election night, he says, look, you saw the CNN said I have ninety nine percent support from MAGA. Well, I think MAGA is the Republican Party. So I have 100 % support from the Republican Party. And he's, you know, he's always believed that the Republican Party is the American electorate. He doesn't care about anybody else.
54:58He actually had this great line in 2016 where he says, look, the important thing is to unify the people because the other people don't matter. And that's his sort of mindset. And so when he sees that all these people show up as a rally, he thinks, see, the people love me.
55:11Jonah Goldberg: Totally right. That's totally right. rather than like the subset of people who love me who want to show up at a rally or showing up.
55:18Steve Hayes: I would also like to shout out Harry Enten as a proud graduate of the Riverdale Country School, where I also graduated from. So huge. Always a soft spot in my heart for... So much intellect.
55:27Jonah Goldberg: So much intellect coming from there. Also, Neil Sadaka's nephew. Huh? Okay. Anybody else? Mic drop.
55:38Steve Hayes: Richard Engel, who was the journalist who was imprisoned. He was the year below me.
55:45Jonah Goldberg: This is the kind of stuff, like, we always say we don't do clickbait. This is the kind of stuff, if we take this as a short and put it out on Instagram, like, we're going to be overwhelmed with the number of new listeners we get. I will say just as a coda on that, I had a U.S. senator who had spoken directly with Donald Trump about this, who said that the reason that Matt Gaetz was nominated or was going to be nominated to be Attorney General of the United States was because Donald Trump gave a speech and mentioned that possibility and saw the crowd react. This crowd at a Trump rally react to Matt Gaetz as Attorney General and said, this guy needs to be Attorney General.
56:26Jonah Goldberg: The people love him. We need to move on because I want to get to a couple other things. But like, you saw this early and often in sort of MAGA rhetoric where there was this pretense that they spoke for the entire country. We the people want X, Y, and Z. And it, you know, it's been clear for a long time that that wasn't true, but I think it's never been clearer than it is today, two days after the election. I want to go, we don't really do lightning rounds, but can we do semi-lightning rounds? Because I want to get to two things before we quit. And we have what I think is a fun, not worth your time to get to as well.
56:57Jonah Goldberg: I want to talk about the Democrats and I want to talk about Trump's influence on the future of the Republican Party. On the Democrats, One of the things that we can say pretty definitively if we're looking at polling is that whatever this was, this was not a resounding endorsement or a show of enthusiasm for the Democratic Party, right? There was a poll by the New York Times shortly before the election, late October, that asked people for their views of or their satisfaction with the Democratic Party, and it was like 26%. Donald Trump, and I believe it was the same exact poll, came in at 38 % approval.
57:32Jonah Goldberg: So they might not love Donald Trump. They don't love the Democratic Party. But now the Democratic Party has a lot of power and will be able to shape these events. Two interesting things. Somewhere, we don't know the exact number yet, but there were somewhere between, I think, five and nine DSA-affiliated or DSA-adjacent or DSA, Democratic Socialists of America, endorsed candidates coming to the House of Representatives. We've talked about it before. This has been a big—this has gotten a lot of coverage in the media. And they'll no doubt be influential, and Hakeem Jeffries will have to deal with them.
58:06Jonah Goldberg: At the same time, and we've made this point before too, there are a number of new centrist Democrats who won in Trump plus five, Trump plus 10, Trump plus, in some cases, 15, 20 districts. And those numbers are greater, actually, than the DSA-aligned people. You have moderates in the Senate who are coming in. Andy Andrews from South Carolina. Adam Hamilton who campaigned as a moderate. in Kansas, Roy Cooper in North Carolina. You could make an argument just on sheer numbers. The message that Democrats should take from this election is, by God, be normal. Like, look at these normal centrist people.
58:46Jonah Goldberg: Govern, do what they want to do. David, is there any likelihood that that will happen given the volume that we get from DSA types? I always I'm always interested to look at sort of who emerges as the star. So you had after the 2018 midterms, you had, you know, a very strong showing in the House for Democrats. You did not have the strong showing in the Senate. So it was that mixed result. Republicans took something from it. Democrats took something from it. And what did they take? They had the squad. Remember it? It was Nancy Pelosi. And what was it? Rolling Stone Vanity Fair had the cover shot of Nancy Pelosi.
59:25AOC, Ilhan Omar, and the squad. And in hindsight, what a colossal mistake. What a colossal mistake by Democrats to really put forward, you know, three or four people who really proved to be the left fringe of the House. I mean, they were sort of like what you would call backbenchers in Parliament. They didn't have committee. They weren't running committees. They weren't leading the House. They were this alleged new wave in sort of the woke one era of the triumph of young, woke activists. Who are the stars this time? To the extent that there are stars, it's Ossoff, it's Tyler Rico, it's Adam Hamilton.
1:00:05It's this whole discussion about, wait a minute, is there now a new religious left? It is the progress that Democrats made with Catholic voters, with mainline Christian voters. So what I'm seeing, to the extent that anybody is sort of emerging as the star, as sort of the face of victory, which is very hard for any one person to emerge as the face of victory because of just the scope of it, just the sweep of it. But you're seeing Tallarico is really sort of a main face of victory. You're seeing Adam Hamilton. People are talking about Ossoff and everyone but the left online is looking at the Shapiro blowout in Pennsylvania, just an absolute wipeout where Shapiro stomped on.
1:00:49I'll borrow a phrase that I saw Jonah use. He stomped on Republicans like Godzilla stomps on Bambi. Like, I love that phrase, Jonah. And so in that sense, I'm at least somewhat hopeful, cautious. I don't know. I might eat these words immediately, but that some of the takeaway here wait a minute, our most impressive victories were all those Southern states. I mean, they marched like Sherman from Austin to Charleston. And who did they do it behind? A bunch of moderate Democrats. And so, but I don't think Chevalier in Brooklyn or wherever is going to be the face of this victory. It's going to be more Tallarico or Ossoff or Hamilton.
1:01:35Jonah Goldberg: I mean, I think you could make the case that AOC will use Chevalier to bolster her case and say, look, I've been saying this for several years. Now I have sort of reinforcements. And you could make the argument that one of the main stars on the Democratic side, arguably the main star coming out of this, is Abdul El-Sayed, who, while he disclaims any association with Democratic Socialists of America, an awfully progressive dude, and I would say fairly radical in his own way. Megan, what's your sense of how Democrats are likely to govern right now? I mean, you've got Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries.
1:02:14Jonah Goldberg: They've got stuff to do here, and they need to please the people who sent them to Washington. They've got work, and they want to set themselves up for a 2028 victory. What do expect to see from them?
1:02:28Steve Hayes: Yep. So I think this is a really complicated question in part because post-election dynamics are always a little weird and hard to predict. Like you can say this is the rational thing to do and you can often be right, but that doesn't mean that will be the thing that happens. And I go back to, you know, after Clinton wins the midterms in 98 within the House, which is getting ready to impeach him or like working its way up, working itself up to impeach him. There's a sense of like everyone's saying, oh, well, I guess we're not doing that now. And then six weeks later, they impeach him. Because no one wants to be the guy who goes to the voters and is like, remember all that stuff I said about impeachment?
1:03:08Steve Hayes: Not so much anymore. Right? No one wants to go to their base and explain why they're not doing the thing, which was supposed to be a big principled stand. You have the additional complication that Chuck Schumer is a New Yorker And so, like, he is afraid of the people who elected Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Dario Elisa Chevalier, even if people in Michigan are not. Although, also in Michigan, you have Abdul El-Sayed. So, like, I don't know how the dynamics shake up. I think there are a few things. One is that Democrats really are sick of Trump. They're excited. They're happy. And they really don't want to screw it up in 2028, right?
1:03:52Steve Hayes: Like, that's the people that I know, or at least the people I talk to. But those people tend to be, like, in journalism, not in politics. They don't have to win elections, right? And so that's one thing pushing towards being more moderate. But another thing, and another thing pushing towards being more moderate is that they have big margins. So, like, the problem that the Republican House has had is, like, you lose three votes and you can't pass anything.
1:04:17Jonah Goldberg: Yeah.
1:04:17Steve Hayes: And so you have to cater to, like, everyone. Every little faction has to get its taste. And if they don't like something, they can shut it down. Democrats are going to have a lot more room to maneuver in the House than Republicans have had. They could lose 30, 40 votes. Yeah. Which means that the left is not going to be able to hold them hostage. It also means, though, that the conservatives are not going to be in a great— like, their more moderate members are not going to be in a great negotiating position. And the broad swath of the party, I don't think it's Abdul El-Sayed. I think it's more like Heather Cox Richardson.
1:04:52Steve Hayes: It's resistance libs. That's the core.
1:04:55Jonah Goldberg: She's a very popular political sub-stack author.
1:04:59Steve Hayes: Makes millions of dollars, history professor. But those people are super angry. And they want retribution. They do. They really, really, really want retribution. They are going to demand that, like, they are going to be doing proctological examinations of every single Republican in the Trump administration if they can find the time. And I think some of that will be salutary. I think corruption investigations are definitely warranted. But I think that that can get out of hand in the way that the prosecutions got out of hand, right? There were good cases against Donald Trump on election stuff, but Democrats weren't content with those good cases.
1:05:40Steve Hayes: And instead, you get all these cases in New York. The weaker cases are going first, which is bad. And it ends up in the minds of voters being rolled into like, oh, this is just a broad package of retribution against Donald Trump. And they'll just hang him on anything. So I don't necessarily have to trust any of the charges that they bring. And I worry that you're going to see that kind of overreach again. It's going to be endless investigations. You're already seeing the progressive groups trying to kill permitting reform because they want to wait until they have the trifecta and then do something much more aggressive, which doesn't like do anything for oil and gas, which would be a disaster on a number of levels, I think including politically for Democrats because it would raise prices and people, as we've seen, really don't like that.
1:06:23Steve Hayes: So like there's going to be, there are so many countervailing forces pushing back and forth right now that it is hard for me to say. I think what leadership would like to do, strike a pragmatic tone, do investigations where you're going to get the goods and where it's narrowly focused. But then you get the Warren camp that wants to investigate every CEO who has done anything. It might be good politics for them. I think it's bad economics and it's not going to like do anything for the country at large, but it will make Elizabeth Warren and her faction of the anti-corporatists happy. And the more they're trying to pay off all of these factions in order to get, you know, like energy and reward and hold the coalition together and not say no to anyone, the less likely they are to govern successfully, is what I would say.
1:07:09Jonah Goldberg: Jonah, I know you would like to weigh in on salutary proctological exams, but please resist. And I'm going to give you the only shot at answering this question that's sort of top of mind for me and certainly top of mind for our listeners and viewers. We addressed it in the editorial that we posted at the dispatch yesterday. How influential is Donald Trump going to be in the Republican Party in the next two years in terms of both what he wants to do as an agenda. He hasn't shown much interest in having an agenda, but also in the 2028 elections from presidential, Senate, House. Are people still going to listen to this guy?
1:07:49Yeah, I mean, for the same reason they listen, I mean, Obama pen and phone statement stuff applies to Trump as well. We should not sleep on the fact that Trump could make, you know, like when you see him and Chuck Schumer talk, it looks like two dudes eating pastrami at the Carnegie Deli. They've known each other for a very long time. They could work out a deal on all sorts of things to avoid problems. Like, if Schumer were the brilliant master of the Senate that no one thinks he is, he would give him, like, the arch and the ballroom and get Medicare for all out of it. You know, like, and anyway.
1:08:24But, so, like, he has the ability to do some stuff. Also, like, before when I was saying Vance has... a theory about how he needs just like a slice of the GOP electorate to like get the nomination. Trump controls a bigger slice still, right? There are still people who love Trump. And there are a lot of Republicans who are in office that don't have a lot of power, but like he can still screw them for their primaries. They're still afraid of him. Just a quick stab on the point that Megan was making. If Jeffries and Schumer were smart, like they can do a base only, you know, a Democrat only legislative, you know, free for all.
1:09:01and they have the votes to do it. But, like, they can replace the DSA votes with probably some Republicans who see that it's probably in their interest to play along
1:09:13Jonah Goldberg: and be moderates in a way that actually gives a functional, even larger coalition of votes to draw from. Just one other last point, because I haven't been able to make it in two and a half days of punditry. And I saw that Abdul Syed is his first, one of his, I've seen him say a bunch of different things about what his first goal is, but one of the things he said is he wants to get money out of politics. I'm sorry. The lesson of this midterm is that money isn't nearly as important as people think it is. I'm not saying it's not important. You need some money, right? You need a necessary amount of money.
1:09:52But once you have it, the difference between necessary and sufficient, you know, it just goes away. It's like the Republicans, particularly in Texas, outspent Democrats. Like there's a stat going around that I need to fact check. I find it superficially plausible that Elon Musk has spent more this election cycle on politics than George Soros has spent in his career. Yeah. And think about how much we talk about George Soros's influence on politics. Right. And he got nothing for it. He like, Like Texas went blue, right? And there's this idea out there that money, that the system is corrupt. I was, for reasons having to do with original sin, I was in Tallarico's Victory Party speech.
1:10:35And, you know, he's talking about how money drives it. He won with less money, by far less money. And I just think that, like, the narrative that Democrats want to believe about how our politics work versus the reality is where they could either repeat the mistakes that each party has made over the last 25 years of going with the reality they want to believe is true or actually like saying, look where our voters are. I mean, Nate Cohen of the New York Times makes a fascinating point. The people who most underperformed in this election, I mean, other than Republicans who lost, but the people on the Democrats who most underperformed were the DSA, very progressive ones.
1:11:17The ones who most overperformed were the normie moderate blue dog types. Again and again and again. Like Syed underperformed where he should have been in Michigan. If Syed is winning Michigan by less than Tallarico is winning Texas. Exactly. Right. Angie Nixon in Florida underperformed. Everyone's talking about how close she came. Yeah, well, she came close because in a bunch of red states, Democrats won by 20 points. So like, you know, and Florida has was an R plus 13 in 2024. Texas was an R plus 14. Democrats swept in Texas because they wanted to they wanted to come across as moderate. She joined the DSA weeks before announcing her candidacy.
1:12:06If she had been more like a Dave Jolly type, it is entirely possible she would have won. And if Democrats can learn that, right, and not do the same thing Republicans did, which said, oh, well, look at all of these Tea Party, you know, Freedom Caucus guys who won their races, this is the future. If they actually think about the median voter, like, they could fix a lot of this. It would make me sad because, like, it means we could have a majority party that I disagree with for a very long time. But, like, it would still be a healthy fix for a lot of our problems with our politics.
1:12:40Jonah Goldberg: Yeah, if they were normal. I mean, this was Kevin's point in his terrific piece from Texas. If Democrats could just be normal for a while, it could do them a heck of a lot of good. And it seems to have done that. And I think it's super important also when we talk about the size of the Democratic majority in the House, in the Senate, what's super important is where did they get their majority from? Right. They got it from the South, including the Deep South. And so you're going to have a bunch of Deep South Democrats who know that they're in a precarious perch who are going to be constantly telling Schumer and the West Coast and Northeast Democrats, OK, you could go ahead and do that if you want me to be a one term senator, if you want to lose this majority that we just got.
1:13:24And so I do think having a Cooper, an Ossoff, you know, gosh, Tallarica, I mean, a Hamilton, all of these red state, deep south, southern, southern Midwest kinds of senators, I think, are going to make a difference just sort of sitting there saying, what are you doing? If you go too far, we're out. But I love that I just saw this number. We are just getting numbers and numbers and numbers that show how crazy much of a white annihilation this was. Roy Cooper received 1 ,728 ,000 votes from early voting.
1:14:04Michael So Cooper would have won if no one showed up on election day to vote for him. On election day. That is amazing. In North Carolina.
1:14:14Jonah Goldberg: All right, we're going to take a quick break, but we'll be back soon with more from the Dispatch podcast. Hey, y 'all. Kelly Clarkson here with Wayfair. You know my favorite compliment during the holidays? Your house feels so cozy. That's when I know everyone's comfortable enough to kick off their shoes, grab more dessert, and stay a little longer. Wayfair makes it easy, with everything from dining furniture to festive guest room essentials, all in one place. So whether you're hosting for an afternoon or all weekend, everyone feels right at home. Get holiday guests ready at Wayfair.com or on the Wayfair app today.
1:14:48Wayfair, every style, every home. We just moved into our new house, and I didn't realize just how close we were to the neighbors. That's when my friend told me about Blinds.com. Blinds.com isn't a medication, but it can improve how you feel about your home. Customers who shop at Blinds.com experience excellent customer service, from consultation to installation. Side effects include increased privacy and better sleep. Talk to your partner today and see if Blinds.com is right for you. Shop Black Friday all month long at Blinds.com. Don't miss huge deals dropping every week.
1:15:22Jonah Goldberg: And we're back. You're listening to the Dispatch Podcast. Let's jump in. We need to wrap up here. And I want to, speaking of obstacles that James Tallarico overcame, It wasn't just financial disparity. We have spoken here before about James Tallarico in this video showing him from 2022, a speech that he gave in campaign mode, showing him calling for his campaign to be a vegan campaign. We've talked about it before. I genuinely thought that this was going to be problematic or could be problematic for him. And Republicans did everything they possibly could to make it problematic for him. Donald Trump talked about it.
1:16:03Jonah Goldberg: Ted Cruz talked about it. There were online videos, everything else. Let's just play briefly, if we can, a clip from that video because I need to offer some self-criticism on the other side of it. We have, I think, heard more and more issues of animal welfare. I think not just because it's the right thing to do and the moral thing to do, but also it's, as all of you know, necessary to fight climate change. It is now existential that we try to reduce our meat consumption and that we try to respect animals in all aspects of society. And so I am proud to say that our campaign has officially become a non-meat campaign.
1:16:41So we are only buying vegan products from our local vegan businesses. Some of you may know Big Nonas. They were little Nonas, and then they opened up Brick and Mortar, some of the Big Nonas. But we just got our pizza from there. today. And so the point is that I think all of us, not just policymakers, but everyone has to take personal responsibility in this effort.
1:17:06Jonah Goldberg: So I thought that was going to be a big deal. As I said, Republicans tried to make it a big deal. It ended up, he ended up winning by 12. Nobody really cared about what James Tallarico thought about Meade. Meade ended up being maybe a factor in another race in Mississippi. I don't know if you've seen this ad, but there is this fantastic ad. I think it's one of my favorite ads in the last 20 years from Scott Colum picking up on a point that his opponent made in an interview that she gave on local television about the price of ground beef and people having to forego ground beef. Can we play the ad?
1:17:42Jonah Goldberg: The price of beef continuing to go up.
1:17:45Steve Hayes: You know, you have so many proteins to choose from. Pick another protein? Shit, I'd rather pick another senator instead. Pick another protein. She done lost her damn mind. I'd rather pick another senator. Pick another protein? What the? Pick another senator instead.
1:18:09Jonah Goldberg: I mean, such a fun ad. I did not think that it would be Republicans necessarily who would be on the receiving end of this beef thing. David, thoughts on that ad? And was I just wrong all along to think that meat mattered? Well, I mean, it obviously, you know, Tallarico was very clever in diffusing meat gate early on in the campaign by just like always being photographed eating brisket. Like when was the man not eating brisket? Even continues it after the campaign. Where does he have his like meeting with the new Democratic that this new the summit, the public summit with the new Democratic governor in a Whataburger?
1:18:45So like the guy was just basically campaigning with a Big Mac in either hand to try to defuse this. So then you have Mississippi, the Republican Party gets on the wrong side of the red meat divide in the deep south. What? How do you do that?
1:19:01Steve Hayes: Not a good place to be. How do you possibly? And if anything could show you like the power of the Trump cult is that it would pull someone, a Republican, onto the wrong side of the red meat divide to rationalize Donald Trump's policies. Perfect symbol. Perfect symbol.
1:19:17Jonah Goldberg: Megan, I have an idea. Among the best meat I've eaten in the last year was these oxtails and short ribs at your house. Do you think we could do sort of an off-the-record session with James Tallarico?
1:19:29Steve Hayes: Yeah.
1:19:30Jonah Goldberg: And you could make that for us again? Bring James Tallarico and let them eat meat?
1:19:36Steve Hayes: Absolutely. I think we need to investigate how much meat this dude eats. and I am in a position to oversee... Okay, that did not... Just roll with it. Just keep going. Yeah, just rolling. Just rolling. No, like, look, I think, can this guy pack away, like, two pounds of short ribs? Or is he just waving that brisket around, like, kind of nibbling at the bun and then, you know... Campaign prop.
1:20:02Jonah Goldberg: It may well have been.
1:20:03Steve Hayes: Yeah, it's just a campaign prop. So, yeah, if the folks at the dispatch can arrange that, I will absolutely cater that dinner. I will even offer a vegan option.
1:20:12Jonah Goldberg: We will send an invitation.
1:20:13Steve Hayes: Some vegan science. I used to be a vegan.
1:20:16Jonah Goldberg: Well, I mean, actually, it would be a good way to test the proposition, right? If he comes.
1:20:19Steve Hayes: I mean, look, cornbread, you can make good vegan core bread.
1:20:23Jonah Goldberg: Vegan core bread? No, you need...
1:20:24Steve Hayes: Good vegan beans and rice. Butter needs to be in there somewhere.
1:20:29Jonah Goldberg: Jonah, will you write this letter to James Tallarico? I'm sorry? I think we should invite him. Will you write the letter to James Tallarico? From Jonah Goldberg to James Tallarico, come and dine on Short Ribbon. Dear Senator-elect, you may have seen me at your victory rally. Yeah. Yes, exactly. I will say, like, you know, part of the problem with the Democratic margin of victory is that, and you can point to just too many things that were variables, but in the Mississippi race, I think it is obvious that but for that ad, he doesn't win, because it was so close, right? I mean, I think it's, maybe there are a thousand votes left, But like last time I looked, it was like he was winning by 28 votes with like a thousand votes left to count, something like that.
1:21:15That ad went super viral. It made him likable and approachable. And it's very rare that an ad and one of the things that's nice about it is, yeah, it was technically an attack ad, I guess, but it was done in good cheer. Yeah. And he took the edge off of it. And he was, you know, he was on the right, the right side of the issue. which is like, it's ridiculous to tell people. Pick another protein. Pick another protein, but don't have meat. Yeah, especially when everyone knows it's due to your policies. Like, you know, hey, we've implemented these tariffs and you don't want, you can't afford steak anymore, but here's some catfish next to it.
1:21:58Like, no, no.
1:22:00Steve Hayes: In fairness, I'm not sure beef prices specifically are a Trump administration policy thing. I think like, because they've gone up more than other stuff. Like, I think there's just normal agricultural market stuff happening there. And the same way that eggs were going up under Biden. Yeah, yeah. Not because they had crappy egg policy, but because we had avian flu. Yeah, right, fair. But like, yeah, the problem with all of these things is that when things are going badly, there isn't that much that like the Senate can do about beef prices. right and I think she just kind of like you know blanked and was like well well I don't know you know fried chicken's delicious too and that was she's not a great candidate pick another protein pick another protein was not a great that was not this is so good but we should also say like I mean like Tallarico ran a much better campaign than any of us thought he would I mean I don't want to speak for everybody but like when he first rolled out it seemed like oh yeah and and people say he would have, you know, I've been saying all along that they'd only pick Cornyn.
1:23:06I'm not sure Cornyn would have won in this environment. A state that did this probably would have thrown Cornyn out, too. It would have been much closer, to be sure. And I don't think it's a down-ballot wipeout either. Right. Yeah, I think Cornyn would have won.
1:23:18Jonah Goldberg: I think Cornyn would still prevail. All I'm saying is that's a more contestable proposition now. Right. But this is the way waves work. I actually don't think, I think that the meat thing could have really hurt Tallarico in a normal environment. Yeah. against a normal Republican. But you look at the perfect storm of stuff and the fact that Tallarico was given a minute to, once he got the nomination, they didn't throw the money, Republicans didn't start attacking him yet. So he got to define himself before Paxton could. You know, there are lots of woulda, coulda, shoulda things. But like in a wave, bad candidates win when they shouldn't and good candidates lose when they shouldn't because the environment is so bad.
1:24:02And a lot of people that we didn't realize were bad candidates are exposed in that environment. Like, no one knew that Marshall in Kansas was that bad a candidate because he was always surfing. He was always sailing with the wind at his back. And he just looked like a normal Republican. But then it turns out when the environment goes south, he was just not up to the job of defending that seat. And I think another better candidate could have. but Hamilton was really good and the environment was just brutal for Republicans.
1:24:34Jonah Goldberg: Well, we did not get to three quarters of the questions that I was hoping to have us entertain today because there's a lot to talk about. We had lots to say, Steve. There's a lot to talk about and the good news is we'll be doing this again in just a couple of days. So thanks for listening. Thank you all for joining and we will see you next time.
1:24:54Jonah Goldberg: Finally, if you want to support what we're doing here, you can rate, review, and subscribe to the show on your podcast player of choice to help new listeners find us. And for those of you who want to watch the show, check us out on YouTube. Head over to youtube.com slash atthedispatchpods, or you can just Google The Dispatch on YouTube. As always, if you've got questions, comments, concerns, or corrections, you can email us at roundtable at thedispatch.com. We read everything, even emails from people who don't want to pick a new protein. That's going to do it for today's show. Thanks so much for tuning in, and thank you to the folks behind the scenes who made this episode possible.
1:25:28Jonah Goldberg: Noah Hickey and Peter Bonaventure. Thanks again for listening. Please join us next time.
1:25:59Traditional home security only alerts you after a break-in, and that's too late. SimpliSafe is changing that. Stop. This is SimpliSafe. Police are on the way. We don't just alert. We help stop crime before it starts. Plan starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 70 % off your new system with professional monitoring at SimpliSafe.com slash Spotify. SimpliSafe. Ahead of crime in real time.
1:26:23Steve Hayes: Outdoor deterrence plans start at$49.99 a month. Visit SimpliSafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information. Black Friday, well, shop, Wayfair now, month-long, big deals, yeah, these are steals, 80 % less money spent. You kick a run, check out the song, flash just go for, Black Friday scores, your most is too, more than a few. Grab a big bed, two layer head, mattresses, two sheets that are used, save that Wayfair, save on these chairs, find just your style, it makes you smile. Here's a quick plug, area roast, free shipping while Wayfair is how. Win the season, win the, win the season Win there, win there, win there, win there, win there
Steve Hayes is joined by Jonah Goldberg, Megan McArdle, and David French to discuss the results of the midterm elections, J.D. Vance’s postmortem on X, and whether Democrats can resist the pull of their own base.
The Agenda
—Is nature healing?
—Corruption as voters’ top concern
—It’s all Stephen Miller’s fault
—Trump’s $5,000 bribe
—J.D. Vance’s explanation for the GOP loss
—How the White House distorts reality
—Whether Democrats follow the moderates or the DSA
—How much influence Trump retains over the GOP
—NWYT: “Pick another protein"
Show Notes
—Nick Catoggio on the midterm results
—The Dispatch editorial
—Kevin Williamson’s latest
—J.D. Vance’s postmortem on the midterms
—Scott Colom’s beef ad
The Dispatch Podcast is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a nonpartisan perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including audio versions of all our articles and newsletters—click here. If you’d like to remove all ads from your podcast experience, consider becoming a premium Dispatch member by clicking here.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices