1. Podcasts
  2. The Dispatch Podcast
  3. Why the Nvidia Scandal Is Everyone’s Problem
The Dispatch Podcast

17 Nov 2026 · 1h 16m · 28 chapters

Episode artwork

Why the Nvidia Scandal Is Everyone’s Problem

In short

The growing NVIDIA scandal and how it may affect AI, U.S.-China policy, national security, and markets/retirement investments; plus cabinet-level disputes and upcoming congressional scrutiny.

Guests (backgrounds)

Steve Hayes (host). Jonah Goldberg (Dispatch Editor-in-Chief). Kevin Williamson (Dispatch National Correspondent). Megan McArdle (Dispatch contributor; Washington Post columnist).

Key claims

  • NVIDIA became central to AI because Jensen Huang’s GPUs (made by TSMC) became the scarce “kingmaker” hardware during the ChatGPT/Claude boom; export controls on advanced chips to China are a major flashpoint.
  • The U.S. stance softened from Gina Raimondo’s “no way” position under Biden to more permissive enforcement under Trump, partly due to Trump’s stock-market focus and personal closeness to Huang, plus influence from technologists/investors tied to NVIDIA.
  • Financially, NVIDIA’s off-balance-sheet liabilities and founder-led risk-taking could cause “unexpected perturbations” in AI/data-center investment, though not “Lehman-sized” systemic risk.
  • Politically, Howard Lutnick (incoming Commerce Secretary) is portrayed as enabling carve-outs; Marco Rubio is portrayed as warning early about Alice Wong’s alleged China-linked espionage/corruption, with entity-list action blocked (“commerce holds the pen”).

Notable examples

Blackwell-class chips and export bans; China “end runs” via renting access to AI facilities; Enron/Raptors analogy; data-center ballot initiatives and potential Democratic politics around data centers.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:55

Understanding the NVIDIA Scandal

Discussion on how the NVIDIA scandal impacts finance and personal investments.

“I want to spend some more time today on this rapidly unfolding NVIDIA scandal.”
2:50

The Rise of NVIDIA and Its Importance

Exploration of NVIDIA's history and its role in the AI industry.

“if you have a retirement account, this is probably affecting you because it's affecting NVIDIA and it's affecting NVIDIA's stock.”
4:28

Jensen Wang: Visionary Leader

Discussion on Jensen Wang's impact on NVIDIA and the AI market.

“Then comes 2022 and 2023, the release of the first useful chat GPT models followed by Anthropic launching Claude.”
6:31

U.S. Policy on AI and China

Analysis of U.S. policies regarding NVIDIA's business with China.

“I don't play them, but they look like you're in the middle of something real.”
8:35

NVIDIA's Financial Strategies and Risks

Examination of NVIDIA's financing methods and associated risks.

“Well, I think that this is probably a case of the well-known phenomenon of Trump being completely informed by the last person he talked to.”
11:15

The Future of NVIDIA and Its Impact

Discussion on the potential implications if NVIDIA becomes a normal company.

“Didn't mean to put you on the point with the Raptor quiz.”
14:00

The Performance of Founders and Companies

Discussion on the performance dynamics of company founders and their eventual decline.

“Those guys, when they're in their prime, their companies overperform.”
14:55

Systemic Financial Risks in AI and Private Credit

Exploration of the systemic risks surrounding AI growth and private credit funding.

“Enron was a bit of a systemic financial risk.”
17:40

Howard Lutnick's Role in NVIDIA's Controversy

Analysis of Howard Lutnick's influence and controversies related to NVIDIA and national security.

“Anyway, one of the Jays who has all of these is wildly over levered.”
21:44

The Integrity and Oversight Issues in Government

Discussion about the lack of integrity and oversight in the current administration regarding NVIDIA.

“Yeah, I mean, so going back to that memo that Rubio wrote, it was a good reminder that he's actually also the national security advisor.”
Show all 28 chapters
24:20

Cabinet Conflicts and Accountability

Examination of the conflicts within the cabinet regarding Howard Lutnick's decisions and their implications.

“and he dove deep into the numbers and the legalities and stuff and figured things out.”
28:00

The Consequences of Not Acting on Megaspeed

Discussion on the oversight regarding Megaspeed and its implications.

“government from doing more business, would have flagged that Megaspeed was bad.”
30:00

Understanding Alice Wong's Role

Exploration of Alice Wong's background and her relation to Chinese intelligence.

“There's a lot more to learn about that as well as a lot of the other things we're talking about today.”
31:35

The Nature of Espionage

Discussion on how espionage works and the misconceptions surrounding spies.

“But she does have a tiny camera that she can take pictures of stuff with.”
36:25

Marco Rubio's Actions and Motivations

Analysis of Marco Rubio's involvement and perspectives on national security issues.

“So, Kevin, let me get back to Marco Rubio.”
42:00

Trump's Role in the Nvidia Scandal

Explore the implications of Trump’s actions regarding Nvidia and China.

“advanced chips to China or chips, chips to China in one way or another.”
44:10

The Debate on Chip Export Policies

Discuss the divided opinions within the administration on chip exports and AI dominance.

“And there are people who really are on the Wong side.”
46:50

Democrats and the Data Center Debate

Analyze the political risks and strategies Democrats face regarding data centers.

“I asked Yuval Levin during the first Trump administration if it was possible that, like, the people around Trump could just kind of run things while he fluttered around, you know, yelling about tariffs.”
49:50

Public Sentiment on Data Centers

Examine public opposition to data centers and its implications for political strategy.

“And so there's a kind of domestic risk to that.”
52:30

The Complexity of Environmental Concerns

Discuss the intersection of environmental issues and data center construction.

“At the very least, they are articulating the position that you just did, which is, hey, let's slow this down.”
56:00

Political Implications of Recent Elections

Discusses the unexpected outcomes of recent elections and their impact on political dynamics.

“Because Trump was in office and Republicans ran everything.”
1:00:30

Transition to the Next Segment

Brief transition before moving to the next topic of discussion.

“All right, we're going to take a quick break.”
1:00:40

FAA Ground Stop Incident Explained

Analyzes the FAA's first nationwide ground stop and government responses to it.

“You're listening to the Dispatch podcast.”
1:01:49

Personal Experience: Sausage Jail

Megan shares a humorous experience about being detained for bringing sausage back from France.

“Duffy from a press conference that he held in Washington Reagan Airport about a year ago on this podcast for not worth your time.”
1:08:00

Sausage No-Fly List and Travel Insights

Continues the discussion on customs regulations and travel experiences related to banned items.

“Did you ever get an explanation as to why they sell it at duty free, but you can't bring it in?”
1:10:00

Travel Troubles and International Regulations

Learn about the complications of international travel and new regulations for entering the U.S.

“There was a guy, there was a guy complaining on Twitter about how he'd had trouble entering the United States because he had been to Afghanistan and he was getting trouble about having been in Afghanistan.”
1:11:32

The Viral Meat Ad and Its Impact

Discover the story behind a viral advertisement related to meat and its cultural significance.

“Is that a Congolese sausage in your pocket or are you just happy to see it?”
1:13:11

Customs Confusion with Unique Items

Hear a lighthearted tale about confusion at customs involving an unusual purchase.

“way attempting to cast a disparagement upon our many fine American sausages.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Dispatch Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Jonah Goldberg: This podcast is presented by UnitedHealthcare. The America in the World Consortium is accepting applications from Ph.D. students and early career scholars for its pre-doctoral and post-doctoral fellowship program. The AWC is a partnership program at Duke University, Johns Hopkins University-SICE, and the University of Texas at Austin, creating a more vibrant debate among policy-interested scholars about America's role in the world. The AWC prioritizes an interdisciplinary research community and welcomes applicants from all disciplines with research focused on American grand strategy. Preference will be given to applicants in history, political science, public policy, classics, and political philosophy whose research is policy relevant.

0:47Jonah Goldberg: Fellows will spend most of their time working on their own research and writing projects while taking advantage of the many academic resources available at their host institution. The fellowship offers a competitive stipend, access to campus facilities, and a wide range of resources on campus. Learn more at www.awconsortium.org slash opportunities and apply today.

1:21Jonah Goldberg: Welcome to the Dispatch Podcast. I'm your host, Steve Hayes. On today's roundtable, we'll go deep on the growing NVIDIA scandal and its implications for finance, AI, the U.S. relationship with China, our national security more broadly, the Trump administration, and potentially your retirement account and other investments. And then for not worth your time, Travel Hell Sausage Edition. I'm joined today by Dispatch Editor-in-Chief Jonah Goldberg, Dispatch National Correspondent Kevin Williamson, and Dispatch contributor and Washington Post columnist Megan McArdle. Let's dive right in.

2:09Jonah Goldberg: Welcome, everybody. I want to spend some more time today on this rapidly unfolding NVIDIA scandal. Do we call it an NVIDIA scandal now? It's a scandal of the personal variety, of the governmental variety, potentially financial variety. And it is affecting already virtually every aspect of our lives. We had a very good explainer this morning by Jack Kubinek, who is a staff writer at The Dispatch. We're recording this Monday morning. And Jack walked through in great detail how this is affecting you, even if you don't think it's affecting you. If you have index funds, if you own stock of any kind, if you make any kind of investments, if you have a retirement account, this is probably affecting you because it's affecting NVIDIA and it's affecting NVIDIA's stock.

3:02Jonah Goldberg: I want to start though, Megan, with a sort of a bigger picture question. And I'm hoping because you're a lot smarter than I am, you know all this stuff much better than I do. Why is it, maybe you can explain this to me. how did NVIDIA find itself at the center of everything? Why is NVIDIA so important to AI, which is driving the global economy, which is driving the U.S. economy? How did NVIDIA get here?

3:30Steve Hayes: It is a great story. So Jensen Wang founds NVIDIA to make graphics processors. There are multiple points at which the company nearly goes out of business. He saves it with his... He's just a crazy obsessive, is basically. And so he has a nice little business going. He's valued in 2022. Companies valued lower than Intel. But it's in some ways a better business because Intel is like a failing giant. And NVIDIA is just a nice little engine of money making. And then the AI boom happens. Now, this actually starts back in the 2010s. but it's not a general purpose technology, right? They're selling these cards to AI businesses but the AI businesses are just not that big part of the market and most people know them as being the best maker of chips for video gaming.

4:30Steve Hayes: Then comes 2022 and 2023, the release of the first useful chat GPT models followed by Anthropic launching Claude. And suddenly, I mean, the company's market capitalization vaults like 10x in the space of a few years. And so Wang oversees this. You can argue that it's kind of an accident of history, right? He did not set out to dominate the AI industry. But he was a guy who was able to steer the company through that serendipitous moment. He, you know, managed to make these chips. They don't actually make the chips. They design the chips and then TSMC makes them, which is the big semiconductor fab in Taiwan.

5:16Steve Hayes: And he becomes kind of like the kingmaker in the industry, right? Because these chips are so hard to get, especially the best chips, the Blackwell class chips, the ones we have an export ban on to China. They're so in demand that like he can basically say, you get the chips or you get the chips. He's making VC investments in a bunch of AI firms and sort of becomes like the hub of the market. And also, while he's doing that, is apparently dating a Chinese woman who may or may not be a spy and also some people at his company and making a kind of mess of his personal life at the same time as he is like making a great thing out of the AI market.

6:03Jonah Goldberg: So he was a visionary. I mean, a visionary sort of on a number of levels, right? I mean, there's a reason that when people talk about how damaging it could be potentially to have Jensen Wong no longer as the CEO of NVIDIA. He has resigned since this scandal was first revealed. There's now reporting that he and others are attempting to mount a comeback that would sort of put it back into the CEO chair at NVIDIA. But he is, by all accounts, a true visionary. As you say, Megan, he's an obsessive. He saw, you know, when he founded this company in 1993, famously at a table at a Denny's with a couple other people, what they were trying to do was take the really bad graphics of, you know, the kind of video games that we all used to play, Pitfall and Donkey Kong back in the old days and made made it feel like these are real like your real life.

7:01Jonah Goldberg: I mean, now the video games are crazy. I don't play them, but they look like you're in the middle of something real. And that was the original goal. And then he figured out that this was going to be in demand for AI companies. He made pitches. He was early and aggressive and won a ton of that business. He has also been a very strong and outspoken advocate of selling these chips to China, despite the fact that the United States, certainly under the Biden administration and maybe at least initially in the Trump administration, had great concerns about selling chips of this class to China because doing so would enable China to potentially, the argument of sort of national security experts, allow China to catch us in this AI race that so many people see as crucial to America's future.

7:59Jonah Goldberg: Kevin, there came a time when U.S. posture seems to have changed. And I'll ask this in the broadest possible way. There was a moment where former Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo, under the Biden administration, in effect said, absolutely not. We are not selling these chips to China. in a no way, no how, period, end of story. It's not happened. That position softened under the Trump administration in the last two years. Can you explain to us why that position softened, how that position softened?

8:36Megan McArdle: Well, I think that this is probably a case of the well-known phenomenon of Trump being completely informed by the last person he talked to. And he became personally close with Jensen Wong. He's also advised by people like David Sachs, who is a technologist who has himself large investments that are highly correlated with NVIDIA in AI infrastructure and things like that.

9:01Jonah Goldberg: David Sachs chaired the president's AI technology council. soul.

9:07Megan McArdle: And one of the things I think is maybe worth thinking about is Trump, as with COVID, thinks of the NVIDIA story as a stock market story. So he was facing a tough election. He didn't want the stock market to go down. He knew NVIDIA was keeping the market up. And even though these right-wing populists like to emphasize that there's a difference between the stock market and the real economy, they do take that, or Trump anyway, takes that as being an important barometer. And he didn't want to go into the election with the market way down and making it thus complicated for him to say about how great the economy is doing under his enormously subtle and intelligent leadership.

9:40Megan McArdle: The interesting thing to me about this, and I'd like to get Megan's view on this, is that the AI world is so small and so very tightly interconnected. When I was reading about how NVIDIA is the primary provider of financing for companies that consume its products, building these AI centers around the world, which allow China to 80 % make an end run around the export ban anyway because they can just rent access to these facilities that have the ships that they can't buy. But what I kept thinking, so, you know, NVIDIA used its gigantic growth inequity to finance consumption of its own products. What I kept thinking of, it's not exactly the same, but I kept thinking of the Raptors at Enron, where Enron had these enormous expensive hedges against various kinds of business developers, but the hedges weren't funded with cash or anything.

10:25Megan McArdle: They were funded with Enron stock. So at the very moment when Enron needed those hedges, the underlying asset, funding those hedges started to collapse because it was Enron shares. And I think you've got the potential for a similar kind of thing with NVIDIA, where it's very dependent on growth for its business position, but it's also the firm that is funding their growth and financing their growth. And without NVIDIA's financing, it's not entirely clear whether we'd be seeing the same kind of growth in AI infrastructure, data centers, and the rest of it. And that's a huge part of where our economy is right now.

11:02Megan McArdle: Like we're in a construction recession. If you take away data centers, we're in a down market. If you take away the AI stuff, I think Megan probably knows a little bit more about that internal financing stuff than I do. And I would love to hear from her about it. Didn't mean to put you on the point with the Raptor quiz. I, uh, I did review Enron the musical. So that was, that was kind of my, uh,

11:23Jonah Goldberg: it was a pretty good musical too. And change your title to national economics correspondent.

11:28Steve Hayes: I feel like Obi-Wan Kenobi here because, you know, like I got my start as a blogger writing about Enron and MCI Worldcom. And so now I'm like, Enron, there's a name I have not heard in a very long time. I was looking at the NVIDIA off-balance sheet liabilities a little bit, and they're huge. They're like hundreds of billions of dollars. Now, look, the company had$70 billion in free cash flow. They had a lot of free cash flow in the first half of the year. So I'm not that worried. They are genuinely making money. There is cash coming into the company. It is not some sort of just advanced Ponzi scheme.

12:12Steve Hayes: But those off-balance sheet liabilities are large. And one issue is that the incoming CFO, the Wall Street Journal wrote this morning, The incoming CFO has been skeptical of the amount of risk that Wang is taking on these deals and is probably going to trim them back. I don't think that matters so much for the frontier companies, right? Like Elon Musk can get money. He's not really a frontier company, but like he can get money if he needs it. Anthropic and OpenAI can get money. Google can certainly get money. They're basically just sitting on a giant money tree in their backyard. which is search.

12:54Steve Hayes: And so I'm less worried about those guys. And I'm not that worried about someone asked me this weekend, is this a systemic financial risk, right? Where you've got all these weird off balance sheet liabilities running through one company if NVIDIA collapses or if it just turns into like a normal company, because this is something what I wrote my column about last week is founder CEOs, they really are different. The rich are different from you and me and founder CEOs are really different. They're weirdos. They're obsessives. They're visionary risk takers.

13:26Jonah Goldberg: You're talking about Jonah here. Steve Hayes.

13:28Steve Hayes: Yes. Yes. Well, I'm talking about Jonah and Steve.

13:31Jonah Goldberg: Yeah. Sort of me. I'm sitting here going, obsessives, risk takers.

13:36Kevin Williamson: As you know,

13:37Steve Hayes: we have two visionary risk taking founding CEOs on the podcast. But these guys, they tend to their companies overperform when they're in their prime. And look, there's some selection bias there, right? Like founders who are bad at leading a large company, they exit pretty early and then either someone takes over or their company goes down. But founders who really like have the whole, the cold package, right? Those guys, when they're in their prime, their companies overperform. They tend to underperform when they're elderly. So there is a point at which because founders hang on longer than normal CEOs, right?

14:13Steve Hayes: They're not going to let their baby go and the market changes or they just get old and start making bad decisions and they won't let go. And so you can get a kind of like you claw back some of that value at their late stages. But when they're in their prime, they tend to overperform. And so when you get a successor firm, I think you've seen this at Apple with Steve Jobs' untimely death. It's not that Apple has died as a company, but it's become kind of a normal company, right? It's not releasing transformational products constantly. It's releasing very good products on a normal production cycle.

14:46Steve Hayes: So what happens if NVIDIA becomes a normal company at the moment when you have this very abnormal growth that Wang has been central to? I don't know the answer. There are definitely reverberations. Is it a systemic financial risk? Enron was a bit of a systemic financial risk. I don't think so. Just because ultimately, the circular funding is enabled by outside banks. maybe, and outside investors, maybe they're all stupid. But there is quite a lot of money sloshing in from customers of these labs. And there's also quite a bit of money sloshing in from investors. And also for all the talk about private credit, I was like getting really worried about private credit, which has funded a lot of the data center construction.

15:33Steve Hayes: And, you know, there were a lot of people this summer and last spring saying, this is a bubble, it's another Lehman. And so I asked a guy who is not himself in private credit, but does a lot of investment in private credit funds. And he said, look, these guys are levered like 2x or 3x. They're not levered, you know, 30x the way it is.

15:52Jonah Goldberg: What does that mean?

15:53Steve Hayes: Okay, so think about it. When you take out your mortgage, you put down a 20 % down payment, and then you have 80 % of it as a mortgage. You are levered 4x on that house. You have 20 % equity and then four times that in debt. And so the problem with Lehman was their leverage was incredible, right? And so it had a very thin slice of equity. Now, their equity was not a down payment. It was, you know, the assets they owned. But they have a very thin slice of equity and huge borrowing on top of that. And they're running money constantly through the bank to make that work. And the private credit funds, first of all, they've got lockup periods.

16:30Steve Hayes: Their investors can't run the way that you have a run on a bank. And second of all, their leverage ratios are much lower. than the old investment banks. The old investment bank leverage ratios are also lower, by the way, because we did a lot of regulation after the financial crisis. And also, I think they would have fallen anyway because a lot of people got scared. So I'm not sure it's a systemic risk, but I do think that you could see a lot of really unexpected perturbations in the AI marketplace. And certainly, I think one thing you think you will see is fewer data centers in Asia, as it's become clear that a lot of these are cutouts for allowing Chinese companies to access the export banned chips.

17:11Steve Hayes: But so I've been trying to work through all of the ways this could go. And I'm sorry, that was like a bunch of words because I still don't know what to think about it. I'm still kind of trying to model in my mind what happens next. And the answer is, I don't know. There is some risk there. I don't think it's Lehman size risk. Or who is the guy who caused the collapse in the 1870s, the railroad collapse? The Panic of 1873. Jay something. I always get my Jays confused. Was it Jay Gould or Jay Fisk? Anyway, one of the Jays who has all of these is wildly over levered. And there's a big financial panic in 1873 that he played a big role in.

17:53Steve Hayes: I don't think we're at that level, but I, boy, I hope I don't have to eat those words.

17:59Jonah Goldberg: Yeah, we don't want to be playing this back at you in six months.

18:02Steve Hayes: You are invited. Like, if I get it wrong, you may play it back at me and chide me.

18:08Megan McArdle: Yeah. I loved your choice of analogies, by the way, with the 20 % down payment, because there are a lot of people over what was left of Lehman's going, if only 20 % down payments, that would have solved this whole problem.

18:18Steve Hayes: Well, I mean, but like, that's actually why, you know, someone who was like, is this a Lehman thing? It was like, it wasn't just that Lehman was over levered. It was all those homeowners were also over levered, right? Like everyone has way too much debt riding on way too little underlying asset. And that cascaded in a way that I don't think this would cascade. But could something happen that touches off a recession? Because as you say, Kevin, this is like driving a huge amount of construction and other economic associated growth. I definitely wouldn't rule that out.

18:49Jonah Goldberg: So, Jonah, back to the beginning of the second Trump administration. Jensen Wong says he got a call from Howard Lutnick at the very beginning, as I think it became clear. Donald Trump has sort of famously and repeatedly said, yeah, what's NVIDIA? I don't even know what NVIDIA was. What is NVIDIA? But by the beginning of the second Trump administration, it's obvious to everybody what NVIDIA is. And Howard Lutnick, Trump's incoming commerce secretary, Trump sees Jensen Wong at the White House, I think, on day 11 of the second term. Howard Lutnick, his incoming commerce secretary, calls Jensen Wong.

19:25Jonah Goldberg: This is according to Jensen Wong in an interview that he gave, I think, earlier this fall to Joe Rogan and says, in effect, Jensen, I'm your man in the Trump administration. Whatever you need, you call me. Now, on the one hand, he's the commerce secretary. This is, by this point, an unmistakably significant, important piece of the U.S. economy. It's significant for all the reasons Megan and Kevin have suggested. It's not that call itself wouldn't raise alarms. Having said that, now looking back on everything that's been reported about Howard Lutnick and his role in essentially being the Sherpa to Jensen Wong and to doing everything he can to open doors for Jensen Wong.

20:16Jonah Goldberg: this guy who oversees the export controls that should have, in theory, kept NVIDIA in check from selling chips that the U.S. government has decided we don't want to sell. It seems like the reporting suggests he's not done that. And in fact, in many cases, has done precisely the opposite. And this has caused tremendous tension in the Trump cabinet. You've had other people, I think, including and especially Marco Rubio, kind of sounding the alarms behind the scenes on what they saw happening, including the understanding many, many months ago that this Alice Wong, no relation, the woman that worked for - Well, lots of relations, but no relation.

21:02Jonah Goldberg: Fair, fair. The woman that he had this extramarital affair, one of the women he had an extramarital affair with, who's thought to be a Chinese spy. This was known a long time ago, but Rubio's cautions went unheeded by Howard Lutnick and others. What do you make of all of the reporting about Howard Lutnick, about his role here, about his potential own financial complications, shall we say? His son now runs his old firm, Cantor Fitzgerald, making a lot of money on NVIDIA. What's your big takeaway assessment of Howard Lutnick and his role in all of this?

21:44Kevin Williamson: Yeah, I mean, so going back to that memo that Rubio wrote, it was a good reminder that he's actually also the national security advisor.

21:50Jonah Goldberg: Yep.

21:51Kevin Williamson: Which is something like a lot of people were like, why would Secretary of State write that memo? It's like Secretary of State didn't really. It was the national security advisor. I also think if you watch Todd Blanche's press conference, I guess, last week, he was asked if he was approached or had any concerns or knew about any of this. And he basically was just sort of like, this is not a DOJ thing. But he also said, look, to the reporter, look, you said she's a spy. I don't know that. We don't know that. And it's very weird. But you can't actually find someone to say even authoritatively on background that she's a spy.

22:27Kevin Williamson: It's just that she might be a spy. I suspect that, you know, there's a difference between being an asset and a spy. It is entirely possible that she just wanted to make a ton of money by illegally selling chips to China. and the Chinese were happy to help her do that, but she was less of a spy and more of a corrupt businesswoman. I don't know that, but I just think it's important to clarify because the whole honeypot narrative is just so Hollywood that everyone just sort of leaps to the spy thing where it could be more of an issue of corruption, which brings me to Howard Lutnick. I don't think Howard Lutnick should have been hired.

23:08Kevin Williamson: The best day to fire him was the day after he was hired. He certainly should have been fired. I saw, I think it was Tom Tillis say, look, I lost confidence in that guy after Liberation Day. And so I think that Lutnick is a particularly grubby dude who clearly has, much like Witkoff, they're both men of sort of, Witkoff who is a non-confirmed, but apparently special envoy of, he's basically doing foreign policy for the president outside of the constitutional order, which is another one of these things that we should never forget, how accustomed to the abnormality of these times. But people like Kushner and Witkoff and Lutnik, they basically have dual portfolios.

23:57Kevin Williamson: They're doing business in the government and they're doing the business of the government at the same time. And so I have, you know, zero trust that he was lobbying for these carve-outs for selling NVIDIA chips to China or to work around sanction regimes for third-party sales and all that kind of stuff purely because he put on his green eyeshade and he dove deep into the numbers and the legalities and stuff and figured things out. When Scott Bessent has to sort of, both publicly and privately, call you to the carpet for not putting this Alice Wong's company on the sanction list and for doing these kinds of work runs.

24:44Kevin Williamson: When Marco Rubio feels it's necessary, whether he thinks he's doing it for national security purposes or to insulate himself from what he sees as a looming political scandal, that he feels he has to put it on paper. These concerns about how Alice Wong is a sign that Lutnick is just not paying attention to national security concerns. and the problem in this administration is if you don't have integrity, if you don't have these patriotic, you know, circuit breakers yourself, you can run a long way before somebody else's will kick in and call you out for it, right? It's like if you just want to make a buck on your own in the administration or if you just want to like bend the rules, people are so siloed in their lanes, to mix a metaphor, that you really have to go far out.

25:37Kevin Williamson: You have to color way outside of the lines before somebody else is like, whoa, whoa, whoa, this is bad for the country. This is bad for the administration. Don't do this. And so I suspect that Howard Lucknick has done an enormous number of things like this. And in part because I hate to say this, but I think he's dumber than Trump. And he's so politically unsophisticated in the way he explains things that I suspect that reflects who he actually is. And he's one of these guys who I just think doesn't understand. He doesn't know what he doesn't know. And he doesn't understand that his son's getting rich off of his insider information and his access to corridors of power is a bad look.

26:23Kevin Williamson: I just don't think he can see it. And if you can't see that that's a bad look, like going to Epstein's Island might be a bad look after you said you had nothing to do with the guy, right? Saying that you never had a meeting with him after he had this realization he was a horrible guy, except for that yacht trip to his island. This is a guy who's not good at this stuff, and it's going to become apparent once the investigations really get going.

26:45Jonah Goldberg: And he is, as you point out, a demonstrated, proven liar. I mean, this is somebody who's been caught repeatedly in public lies. Let me go back. I want to get back to the internal back and forth in the cabinet. We're going to learn a lot more about that in the coming weeks. Because, you know, Jonah, as you point out, it's common to have sort of behind the scenes interagency disputes. In so many ways, that's what the interagency process is about, these kinds of fights and, you know, making compromises between state and defense. You don't often see it. I mean, you sometimes see it in to burst out into public.

27:24Jonah Goldberg: You saw this, the State Department view on the Iraq war versus the Pentagon view on the Iraq war was sort of an obvious example. You do sometimes see these things spill out into public view, but this has been extraordinary. What we have seen in the past week has been extraordinary with on the record finger pointing. Scott Besant was interviewed, I believe it was Friday on CNBC, and he was asked about these disputes about putting Megaspeed, which is Alice Wong's company, on an entity list, which would have prevented the U.S. government from doing more business, would have flagged that Megaspeed was bad.

28:06Jonah Goldberg: This is where the NVIDIA chips, some of them were going. This was what Alice Wong was, we think, doing. And he said, commerce holds the pen. That's a paraphrase, not a direct quote. Basically said, this is on Lutnick. He also said, Treasury War, USTR, which is the United States Trade Representative, and state were in favor of putting Megaspeed on the entity list for months. And he said to the interviewer, if you want to know why this really important step didn't happen, you need to ask Howard Lutnick. And then he did the same thing. Besant was on, I believe, Fox yesterday, Sunday. And he did basically the same thing.

28:50Megan McArdle: There was one little detail of that conversation that kind of stuck in my head for some reason, where he said that the discussion had been happening at the deputies level, which I know that's not nothing. But if you really think that this enormously consequential company is wrapped up in a Chinese espionage problem, maybe you pick up the phone yourself. I mean, this is what we have cabinet secretaries to do to make a point of this. Now, I suspect that he was emphasizing that it was a deputy conversation so that he doesn't have to personally take blame for the fact that they weren't persuasive and didn't prevail in their view and that nothing actually happened.

29:23Megan McArdle: But I thought that was an odd little detail that he seemed intent on emphasizing.

29:27Jonah Goldberg: This is who seemed intent on emphasizing that.

29:31Megan McArdle: Besson, yeah.

29:32Jonah Goldberg: The way that a lot of these debates unfold, the deputies meetings are, they're basically cabinet level, cabinet meetings with the number two at each of the, sometimes the number three, if the number two is unavailable. And then for the really important things, as Kevin suggests, this is kicked up to the principals meetings of cabinet secretaries. And so by saying it was the deputies, maybe he's suggesting this wasn't sort of a tier one issue for a lot of us until it became one. This memo, Kevin, let me ask you about this, this memo that Marco Rubio wrote. There's a lot more to learn about that as well as a lot of the other things we're talking about today.

30:12Jonah Goldberg: But Marco Rubio, as National Security Advisor, as Jonah points out, that is an important detail because he's not going to be doing this as Secretary of State. had these concerns raised to him by the intelligence community about Alice Wong and who she might be. And we should, to Jonah, briefly before I ask Kevin this question, we should point out that our friend Josh Rogan, Washington Post columnist or former Washington Post columnist, I guess he's still doing the intelligence thing. He's a good national security reporter, focuses a lot on China and Asia more broadly. He's written a terrific book, writes, Chinese spy here is shorthand.

30:48Jonah Goldberg: It's unlikely Alice Wong was a full-time, fully trained intelligence officer. That's not the only type of spy. It looks like she was more of a shady businesswoman who reported to and therefore worked for Chinese intelligence. And this is, it is the case that the Chinese Communist Party requires you to, in effect, work as a de facto spy, even if you are not a spy by training and report back to the government if you are doing these deals and there's some advantage for China. So she may not have been a spy in the way that we think of spies like, you know, the Mata Hari. Yes, exactly.

31:24Megan McArdle: She went to James Bond spy school and got her spy diploma and then her spy masters and then she had her spy license. Yeah, that's how almost none of espionage really practically works, as I understand it. I'm far from an expert in the field. But she does have a tiny camera that she can take pictures of stuff with.

31:41Kevin Williamson: But then again, so does everybody now.

31:44Steve Hayes: I'm becoming sort of wistful listening to all of this, that I have never been approached by the CIA, that I've never been important enough for like...

31:53Megan McArdle: That was the moment we learned that Megan was a spy. Sure, yeah. I believed you until...

31:58Kevin Williamson: I assumed that until you said it. Wait till the shoe drops on Suderman.

32:06Steve Hayes: In college, I think, at one point I was like, I would like to be a spy. And someone looked at me and was like, Like, how are you going to conceal yourself, six foot two woman? Like, there is nowhere that you can go in the entire world that you would not be instantly recognizable as you. And I was like, yes, that is correct. And then I learned more about spying. And they're not all undercover, right? You have, like, diplomatic cover and, you know, lots of them are. People basically know that they're spies, but no one says it.

32:35Kevin Williamson: If you work for the agricultural section of any embassy in the world, the presumption is you're a spy. are.

32:41Megan McArdle: You run the U.S. Center Library, you know, in some place like Delhi. Yeah.

32:49Jonah Goldberg: Before we take an ad break, please consider becoming a member of the Dispatch. If you think things have been chaotic in our national politics over the past decade, buckle up for what will be a hugely consequential time in Washington and beyond. By becoming a Dispatch member, you can enlist the Dispatch and our talented group of journalists to be your guide to the crazy. Jonah Goldberg, Kevin Williamson, Nick Catozio, Sarah Isker, Megan McArdle, and many, many others. And you'll get Mike Warren's Next Right newsletter, the most authoritative reporting and analysis on the emerging post-Trump political reality.

33:23Jonah Goldberg: You can sign up at thedispatch.com slash join. And if you're already a member but want more dispatch, you can upgrade to a premium membership. No ads, early access to all episodes, two free gift memberships to give away exclusive live town halls with the founders and much, much more. Okay, we'll be right back. Everyone wants healthcare to be simpler and easier. That's why UnitedHealthcare is fast-tracking more than 60 % of children's procedures that used to need pre-approval so more kids get the care they need when they need it, and speeding up procedure approvals and payments for more than 1 ,500 rural hospitals so they can focus on caring for their communities.

34:03Jonah Goldberg: And that's just the start. There's something satisfying about a well-made object. Not a gadget that gets replaced every two years, but the kind of thing you could hand down to your kid. That's getting harder to find. Today's sponsor is one of the exceptions. VAR, that's V-A-E-R, is a Los Angeles watch company whose goal is pretty straightforward. Bring American watchmaking back. They now assemble watches across California, Arizona, Rhode Island, and Alabama with leather straps made in Illinois and Florida. And these aren't fashion accessories, they're proper tool watches. Sapphire crystals, premium materials, and full waterproof warranties, meaning you can actually swim or dive with them on.

34:45Jonah Goldberg: I've been wearing one recently, and what stands out is how solid and understated it feels. The kind of watch that seems designed to last for decades. It's not flashy or ostentatious, and yet since I've been wearing it, I've gotten one compliment after another. Vare has already earned over 10 ,000 five-star reviews, and it's become one of the largest independent watch assemblers in the United States. If you like the idea of owning something rugged, timeless, and thoughtfully made, give them a look. Go to varewatches.com slash dispatch. That's v-a-e-r watches.com slash dispatch. There's a simple way I think about a mattress now.

35:26Jonah Goldberg: When the alarm goes off, you know whether you actually rested or just spent the night in bed. I wake up and feel restored. I can tell that I've slept well. And when I roll over and check my sleep score, I see the difference. I feel like my bed was made for me. That's one reason I appreciate Brooklyn Bedding's approach. They don't assume everybody sleeps the same way. With more than 15 mattress models, there are choices for different kinds of sleepers instead of a single answer for everyone. And the 365-night comfort trial means you get time to decide whether your mattress is actually a good fit.

36:00Jonah Goldberg: So go to brooklynbedding.com and use my promo code DISPATCH at checkout to get 30 % off site-wide during the Black Friday sale. Exclusive with my code. That's brooklynbedding.com and promo code DISPATCH for 30 % off site-wide. Let them know we sent you in the survey after checkout. BrooklynBetting.com. Promo code DISPATCH. Welcome back. Let's return to our discussion. So, Kevin, let me get back to Marco Rubio. My favorite subject. What I think, you know, read a ton of this over the past couple of weeks, the story that emerges about Marco Rubio is this is somebody who's inside the administration and is alarmed early about Alice Wong and what she's up to and seems to buy the assessments of the U.S.

36:48Jonah Goldberg: intelligence community broadly that at least there's concern about her activities. And yes, she may be a full-blown spy. And Rubio starts trying to sound the alarm. And he sends, at one point, I think before he sends this memo that's been reported on, he's talking to people, he's trying to get people to pay serious attention to this. Then he sends this memo by, I think, most accounts designed to sort of grab people by the lapels and say, hey, everybody, listen to this. This is a big deal. It seems to me that Marco Rubio was intent on stopping what was going on, at least internally, and may not be unhappy that this has spilled out into the public these days.

37:35Jonah Goldberg: He was sufficiently alarmed that he wanted to stop this. Where do you see his role? Is this Marco Rubio? I mean, I think one of the, you know, the DC parlor games these days is what does Marco Rubio actually believe these days? He was a one time China hawk. He was a one time Russia hawk. He was, you know, he made arguments that had people lump him in as a neocon when he ran for president in 2016, but he's now super mega. He gives these, you know, mini patriotic speeches now and again that are sure to get clipped on social media because he's definitely not running for president, but he might be running for president.

38:09Jonah Goldberg: But he's concerned about this stuff. Is this Marco Rubio in trying to bring a stop to what was happening, a flash of the old Marco Rubio from the earlier days? Or is this just him doing his job in the context of the Trump administration?

38:26Megan McArdle: Yeah, I think, you know how everybody always writes a book when they're getting ready to run for president. And Rubio's is going to be called, I tried to tell these dumb bastards, but they wouldn't listen to me. And chapter one, I'd like everyone to remember that JD was the guy on Iran, not me. You know, chapter two, wasn't my fault. And chapter four, I turned the archives around. Chapter five, I never met Epstein. And yeah, it's Rubio seems to have been sufficiently unmoored from whoever it was he was before by the experience of, you know, being in Trump world and serving the Trump administration and trying to both sublimate his ambitions to that while keeping them alive in some way that I think that it's hard to tell what he actually thinks or believes about anything anymore.

39:11Megan McArdle: Although an interesting thing about Rubio is compared to some of these other, you know, guys in the cabinet is that this situation is a reminder that we don't have really good ethics rules for billionaires who go into government. So, you know, if you're Marco Rubio and you've got maybe a couple million bucks in an IRA and some savings accounts and, you know, your Morgan Stanley brokerage account or whatever, you can put stuff into a blind trust. You know, you can comply with these rules pretty easily. You can't put Cantor Fitzgerald into a blind trust and just have it sort of, you know, managed that way.

39:41Megan McArdle: And at some point, we're going to have to answer the question about... This is Howard Lutnick's company that Howard Lutnick ran and his sons. His sons currently run. You know, and if you're someone who is that kind of figure at a company where they're still going to be looking for your advice and input on stuff, there's no way for you to really completely step away from it in a way that is responsible and fair to other people who have financial interests in that company as well. And so we're either going to have to come up with a set of ethics rules that can accommodate that, or we're going to have to come to a kind of social norm that says, okay, you can go be, you know, a big shot at a company like that.

40:16Megan McArdle: You can be a big private equity, venture capital guy, whatever, and have a whole lot of fingers and a whole lot of pies. And if you want to be in public service, you know, eventually we'll welcome you to that, but you've got to unwind yourself from that stuff first. You know, this is something, you can go be secretary of treasury at the end of your career once you're out of this stuff, instead of playing golf. If you want to be in the cabinet, that'd be fine. But you can't really have a foot in both of those worlds at the same time and perform both roles adequately. And I think that Rubio, in addition to whatever sort of moral or political principles he has left, which I don't suspect is very much, is one of the people in the administration who, because of his abject poverty, at least compared to some of the people he's around, is more at liberty to pursue these things without having to think about, well, hey, my kids are in charge of this company now that has a whole bunch of money at stake, including my money on these, you know, infrastructure deals and things like that.

41:12Megan McArdle: And you can kind of imagine how Rubio will tell that story when he's running for president about, you know, how he was the voice of, you know, patriotism over self-interest and all that. And he's obviously kind of fitting up, as everyone seems to be, Lutnick for the role of rat bastard in all this, which, of course, I mean, just Lutnick sort of invites that because he just sort of seems like a rat bastard because he is one. But he's not the only bad player in this. And Trump's actions in this are certainly going to be of great interest to the Democratic majority that's going to be sworn in in January, as they should be.

41:45Jonah Goldberg: Yeah. I mean, this is, I mean, there's been a lot of focus on Howard Lutnick and I think a lot of well-deserved focus on Howard Lutnick and what he was doing behind the scenes to sort of open doors and to move this, move these deals along and to allow, in effect, NVIDIA to sell these advanced chips to China or chips, chips to China in one way or another. But Donald Trump bears some responsibility here. He is, after all, the president. And this is a president who, as we know, was fixated on the U.S. economy continuing to grow. He cares a ton about the stock market. NVIDIA was driving a lot of these gains that we've seen over the past calendar year.

42:24And even after Jensen Wang's, after all of this was revealed, Donald Trump came out several times and said, he's an honorable man.

42:35Jonah Goldberg: He's a good man. He's going to be just fine. Trump has asked about the FBI. He's going to be just fine. This is also the president who, when Jenshwin Wong was taken off of the trip, off of the manifest for his summit in China, Trump reportedly intervened to put him back on the manifest and allow him to go to China on Air Force One with Trump. Wong flew to Alaska to meet the plane in sort of an emergency step to get him to go to the summit. President Trump had Wong at the state dinner with Xi Jinping not long ago, despite the fact that Rubio's memo had been circulated in the government a long time ago.

43:22Jonah Goldberg: How much of this should we be looking at as a Howard Lutnik problem? How much of this is a Donald Trump problem? And to Kevin's final point, Elizabeth Warren is going to have the gavel of the Senate Banking Committee starting in January. You've seen Republicans on the Banking Committee, Tim Scott, current chair, say, hey, we want to talk to these people. We're going to call you up to the Hill. And at first, the first blush, that's sort of, oh, this is good that these Republicans are getting serious about getting accountability here. Second thought, they might want to hurry these hearings along because Elizabeth Warren is coming in January.

43:58Jonah Goldberg: How much of this scrutiny should be on Donald Trump over Howard Lutnick? And where does this go once Democrats have the gavels?

44:06Steve Hayes: These are all fascinating questions. So I'll start by saying, like, look, let's let's lay out the most charitable case for the administration, which is that this is there is a divide in the administration and it is sincere over whether the best way to cement American dominance is to hold on to the chip player by selling to China and undercutting Huawei, which is the leading domestic maker of semiconductors, or whether the best way to win the AI race is to dominate the software, we'll call it the software layer, although software, the model layer. And there are people who really are on the Wong side.

44:49Steve Hayes: The argument is, look, export controls don't work. And to the extent they do work, They're just like boosting the growth of Huawei. I don't find this argument, to be clear, very convincing. And Wang has been a really terrible advocate for it. He keeps going on podcasts and making these vehement, angry, he yells at anyone who disagrees with him. And yet his argument is just not that plausible for two reasons. One is that if you think that this thing is self-accelerating, an early lead matters more than what happens later. And so even if it only delays Chinese advancement by a few years, that matters.

45:30Steve Hayes: But the other reason is that I don't think there's any world in which China decides not to make a run at the semiconductor layer.

45:40Jonah Goldberg: It's going to happen anyway. Yes.

45:42Steve Hayes: It's going to happen anyway. I mean, you can see this. Electric cars is a good example of this, right? They've got all of these. They're dominating markets outside the U.S. in electric cars right now. But that's because they're selling the cars at a loss. They have subsidized so much electric car production that no one's making any money. They're all just like, you can sell a great vehicle for less than you make it for. And like, they're gonna, and this is obviously to them, they're very strategically interested in this. They're going to do the same thing in semiconductors no matter what the United States does.

46:18Steve Hayes: But that's the most charitable, that there's a real divide in the administration And there are people who buy the Jensen Wang argument that we should we should not be actually enforcing that because Biden was the administration that really slapped the export controls on hard and that they they don't want to formally repeal it. There would be all sorts of political blowback to that, but they just don't want to enforce it very strongly because they think that that is actually strategically correct. And then, you know, like, so part of the question is, should we blame Trump? In some way, yes, because, like, it's clear he has not decided what the policy is.

46:56Right.

46:56Steve Hayes: I asked Yuval Levin during the first Trump administration if it was possible that, like, the people around Trump could just kind of run things while he fluttered around, you know, yelling about tariffs. And Yuval said, no, you have to have a decider in that position. If you don't, it's chaos. I think we saw that in the first Trump administration, but this is an issue where Trump may just not have decided. And then he's letting his people, you know, go to war with each other. And so the anti-China faction led by Marco Rubio is going now as taking the war public with the pro-China faction or with the pro-selling to China faction, let us say.

47:31Steve Hayes: And that itself is dereliction, but it's a different kind of dereliction than like being bribed by China to export them chips, right? It is just not doing the job of president, which is to be the guy who decides what the policy is going to be and then everyone else is going to have to go along with it. And sorry if you don't like it, but that's what I've decided. I'm really interested in what Democrats are going to do. I think it doesn't matter if you get, you get all these guys up to the hill, they're all coming back. As soon as Elizabeth Warren has the gavel, she knows this is powerful, right?

47:58Steve Hayes: Howard Lutnick is going to have to either take the fifth, refuse the subpoena, or explain what the hell he was thinking. But one reason I'm interested in this is that the politics are complicated for Democrats, right? So there were over 40 anti-data center ballot initiatives on various ballots this year, and they did really well. And it is very clear, and Democrats have been moving to capitalize on this grassroots opposition to data centers, or maybe if you are of a conspiratorial mind, non-grassroots opposition to data centers that has been seeded by China, because there is a theory floating around that they're actually promoting a lot of this.

48:42Steve Hayes: And it's on environmental grounds, it's on existential risk, it's on fears about jobs, and it's just about the fact that no one wants anything built near them. And so Democrats have been obviously moving to capitalize on that. You had Bernie Sanders calling for a data center ban, et cetera, et cetera. And there's a risk here to that strategy. Because if you make this into a national security thing, if you make it clear that like America is in a geostrategic competition with China over AI and that we are in danger of losing it, on the one hand, if you as a Democrat want to make the argument that this competition is incredibly important to our security future, but also our economic future, and that the Trump administration has endangered that by allowing these chips to leave the United States, and that China is relentlessly attempting to achieve dominance, and that Howard Lutnick's arguments about how they're going to get it anyway are ridiculous.

49:42Steve Hayes: You want to make that argument, right? But the moment you make that argument, you may change people's mindset around whether we should allow data centers to be built. And so there's a kind of domestic risk to that. And I don't know how they're going to negotiate that. And they might just try and like all of the above arguing these two incompatible things on one side on, you know, like on one hand, on the other hand, and just not letting those arguments, trying not to let those arguments talk to each other. But I don't think that will work. I think there's a real danger for Democrats that they shift the politics on this in a way that I think would be good, actually.

50:15Steve Hayes: I think America's Americans should be thinking about both the economic and the national security implications of losing our current frontier position in AI. But I think that that will then complicate a lot of the domestic policy stuff that they want to do.

50:30Megan McArdle: It'll be great to see these Trump administration officials dragged up to Capitol Hill to explain why being soft on China is the right policy. You know, a guy who's a guy who's made, you know, signophobia just sort of the central part of his politics at so many points.

50:44Steve Hayes: And he was the guy. This is the crazy thing, right? Like he was the guy who changed the conversation about China. Yeah.

50:53Megan McArdle: Yeah. And this is where I think where the Democrats are able to maybe simplify the politics a little bit, you know, is you put them on their back feet by making this about them being soft on China. And then the second part of the one, two is that they're doing it for reasons of personal corruption and personal financial interest. And that's a big enough emotional wallop that maybe you don't get people asking, so what does that mean about our desire to build a data center in rural Nebraska 20 years from now? Because, you know, when people start talking about that, they're going to say, what they always say is, well, we're not anti-data centers.

51:23Megan McArdle: We want to make sure they get built in the right way at the right time and that local stakeholders are properly consulted and that the environmental things are taken care of and that there's a proper union contracts and all the rest of it. They don't have to be like wildly bright line in the sand. There shall be no data centers. you can strike out this other position that means there's no data centers. And it's a way of communicating to the people who care deeply about that, that you're not going to let it happen without making yourselves look entirely like jackasses.

51:51Jonah Goldberg: But I think, Kevin, what you've just articulated has become sort of the de facto, very strong pro data center position because we've seen such a shift over the past two years. And as Megan points out, I mean, it was the case that in this most recent midterm election, whatever, two weeks ago, 40 of 41 local referenda on data centers went down, lost. This took place in 10 states. I think like almost half of them were in Ohio in one way or another. But if you use that as a gauge on where people are, the concerns people have about data center building, it's not a very popular position. And I do think you have Democrats embracing this.

52:32Jonah Goldberg: At the very least, they are articulating the position that you just did, which is, hey, let's slow this down. We need to look at this. We need all of the environmental concerns, all these things that matters. But I do think you have a good number of people in the Democratic Party, including some in the Republican Party, whose position is more or less like, no, no data centers. We got like full stop moratorium. We don't want to do this right now. And that worries, you know, people, I think, who are looking at our frontier position and where we are in this race against China on this stuff.

53:06Megan McArdle: That'll really change when the AI porn runs out and they can't make any new ones because they don't have enough data centers to do it. And there will be, you know, there will be an upswing in the populist world to get that fixed.

53:17Steve Hayes: And there is, I mean, there really is a strong anti-AI faction in the Democratic Party.

53:23Jonah Goldberg: Yes. Right? And in the Republican Party. It's most of them.

53:26Steve Hayes: Yeah, I think those are actually different. They're different, though. The anti-data center faction is much more prominent, educated, closer to power. There's like a local Republican opposition to it. And there are some of the kind of like Matt Walsh figures who are like, no, I want to go back to the 1950s, not forward to the 2050s. Stop. But in general, like the people in the Democratic Party have a much more articulated position. They are against data centers. You have the environmentalists who think that they consume too much electricity and water. You have the labor people who don't want it to undercut any jobs.

54:08Steve Hayes: And so I think that the factions against this in the Democratic Party are much more powerful, much better organized on the issue. And that you're going to have to do some battle with the groups. if you take the position that you just laid out, which I agree is like the correct position, especially because some of these groups, like labor, labor will let you talk out of both sides of your mouth, right? Labor will let you take a strategic position and then in practice not allow you to build data centers. But labor is actually complicated on this right now because the construction unions want it, right?

54:41Steve Hayes: Because it's like, sure, the graduate student union might be upset about it, but the construction workers, there are a lot more of them. And so, like, and the environmentalists just don't want it. And they're also really bad at being strategic and taking half a loaf. And you can see this with a permitting reform that's going through Congress right now, right? A lot of the environmental groups did not want it. And the minute Democrats retook Congress, they're basically now like, no, let's kill this thing. We'll do a better bill later that will not be permitting reform, right? That will only be permitting for solar panels, which is, like, would be political suicide, bad all around.

55:15Steve Hayes: But they're organizing to stop it, and it looks like they're going to succeed.

55:19Kevin Williamson: So, I mean, I agree with all of that. I do think it's worth remembering. It's sort of like, remember how when Dobbs came down? There were just an enormous number of politicians on the left and the right who for years just flatly said, I am all in pro-choice or I'm all in pro-life because it was a free position to take. Right? And then all of a sudden there's like, oh, no, your position on abortion actually matters. And they were like, hamana, hamana, hamana, hamana. Because it turns out like you can be forgiven for a lack of nuance when it doesn't matter. And I think there are a lot of Democrats who took, staked out all sorts of positions on various aspects of this kind of stuff without getting too deep in the weeds on it.

56:08Kevin Williamson: Because Trump was in office and Republicans ran everything. and they kind of had just a free pass to sort of be oppositionalists, to be in favor of all the good things and all of that. And I suspect given how, this is one of the really weird things about this moment. We're not doing a post midterm thing, but like the fact that the democratic win was so big and their coalition is so big that even though more lefties were elected, you know, there's a net gain in lefties. There's also a net gain in righties and centrists and whatnot. And And now their positions matter. So in effect, this election has moved the Democratic Party to the center in ways that I don't think a lot of people foresaw.

56:49Kevin Williamson: And I just think that that is going to, having to be held accountable for your positions may create some surprising epiphanies in some places. But I may be wrong. I mean, I just think it's going to be a lot more robust kind of situation, zesty, I should say, in terms of the political debates about it. I did want to make one quick point about Trump, the point that you've all made to Megan about how you need someone who decides. It occurred to me, the comparison hadn't occurred to me until I heard Megan say it, that Trump and Jensen Wang have something in common. In that they both, Trump runs the White House, much like Wang ran NVIDIA.

57:34Kevin Williamson: He has all these direct reports. He's basically the company's own press secretary. and, you know, Trump, people talk about, you know, Stephen Miller as chief of staff. The chief of staff role is just different under Trump than it is under any president of our lifetime. And similarly, press secretary is a different role than any president of our life because presidents before Trump didn't post, you know, 50 times a night sometimes on true social, right? They weren't in charge of their own messaging the way Trump is. And that flat organization of the White House is very much like the flat organization of NVIDIA.

58:13Kevin Williamson: The difference is that Wong was hyper obsessed with detail and extremely competent. I don't think he can level those charges at Trump. But you get the same result, which is that Trump likes to pit different sectors against each other and all of that kind of stuff. And I think the other complicating thing about all this is that everybody, everybody now knows how to talk to Trump.

58:38Jonah Goldberg: Yeah.

58:38Kevin Williamson: In the first term, there were certain Trump whisperers who knew it. Everyone's like, it's like, it's like become public domain how to talk to Trump now. Everybody has access to it, friends, foes, allies. And that actually has the result of making policy setting more chaotic rather than less because he literally finds everybody he talks to persuasive because they all kiss his ass. And that's just gonna make it a lot harder.

59:05Jonah Goldberg: When you saw Kim Jong-un have success with Trump by flattering him and the president of the United States saying that he's writing love letters with Kim Jong-un, I think everybody else thought, if Kim Jong-un can do this, I too might be able to flatter the president to get what I want. I want to end this with some questions that Brett McGurk laid out. Brett McGurk was a senior official in the National Security Council under Obama, under Bush. He has served four presidents. And he lays out these three sort of key questions, which I think allow us to put this in context and think about what comes next.

59:43Jonah Goldberg: The first question was, did Jensen Wong and other NVIDIA executives know whether Megaspeed, which was Alice Wong's company, was diverting advanced chips to China in violation of U.S. export controls? Two, did Commerce Secretary Lutnick responsible for overseeing those export controls know? And why did he resist action against Megaspeed? And three, did Donald Trump know? And when did he know it? I think those are the key questions. Those are the things that we're likely to see the Banking Committee, maybe first under Republicans and then under Elizabeth Warren, but certainly under Democrats, trying to get answers to as this scandal unfolds further.

1:00:20Jonah Goldberg: It is worth noting that Donald Trump heads to China on Tuesday, which will make what was already going to be a very interesting trip even more interesting. All right, we're going to take a quick break. We'll be back soon with more from the Dispatch podcast.

1:00:39Jonah Goldberg: And we're back. You're listening to the Dispatch podcast. Let's jump in. We need to move to not worth your time now. There was on Friday, as I think probably everybody listening to this podcast knows, the first ground stop issued by the FAA across the United States on Friday. The Transportation Secretary, Sean Duffy, had a difficult time explaining what had happened. DHS Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen also struggled to explain. They later came to this conclusion that it was sort of routine, that it's not likely to happen again, but it could happen again. It's both problematic, but nothing to really worry about.

1:01:22Jonah Goldberg: Sean Duffy went on all five Sunday shows over the weekend to offer further explanation. He said, I mean, there's a wide variety of answers that he gave. But in effect, he said, it's really all about funding. We just don't have the money. We had originally requested$30 billion. Now we're requesting$50 billion. And that should solve the problem. I just want to point out before we get to actual not worth your time, which might end up being more worth your time than this part of not worth your time, that we played Secretary Duffy from a press conference that he held in Washington Reagan Airport about a year ago on this podcast for not worth your time.

1:02:04Jonah Goldberg: Because Secretary Duffy held a pull-up competition with Housing Health and Human Services Secretary RFK Jr. at Reagan Airport so that they could announce$1 billion in spending to make travel more pleasant for families. This was an actual announcement. It included things like, quote, creating more children's play areas and exercise areas, creative terminal projects that focus on enhancing the family travel journey. So what you had from the secretary of transportation is an announcement of a billion dollars in spending to create kiddie gyms in airports and other things that might make the travel more pleasant.

1:02:52Jonah Goldberg: But apparently we didn't have the money to do these kinds of essential things that would have kept us from having to do a ground stop. Having said all that as a preface, I want to talk about a real problem. And that was your problem, Megan, trying to get back to the United States from France with sausage.

1:03:12Steve Hayes: Yeah.

1:03:13Jonah Goldberg: Can you tell us what happened?

1:03:15Steve Hayes: I went to this conference in Nice, and then I was supposed to fly back through Lisbon, but Lisbon had a giant storm. And so instead, I got routed through Frankfurt. Now, I had duty-free shopping plans for Lisbon that were obviously disrupted by this. And so I did hasty duty-free shopping in Nice. I usually go to duty-free with a plan. You need a strategy. You need to know what you're after. And so I bought my husband not the Portuguese cherry liqueur that I had been planning and I bought him some stuff. But I was like, I don't know whether this is going to be anything he likes. I should get him something else.

1:03:52Steve Hayes: I got, you know, cookies for my office. And I thought, ooh, there's a thing of sausage here and like three little, and Peter loves charcuterie. And so I thought I will bring the sausage. Now I should, I guess, have known better, but I did not. I'm just going to put this up front. Seasoned travelers were like, you didn't. So I show up and being the honest person that I am, I get to the customs guy and I say, yeah, I bought some sausage in France. Whereupon they take my passport, put it in a plastic box so I can't get it out. And they send me off to sausage jail. And I'm like, could I just throw it out?

1:04:33Steve Hayes: And they're like, no, it has to be assessed by the agricultural officer. And I said, why? And they said, because you can't just throw it out anywhere. It could contaminate the landfill or something. I was like, right, but don't you just have a bin where I could be like, you know what? This is not worth it. I am tossing it in your secure disposal bin. No. So I had to sit there. I think I was there for about an hour. I didn't check. and it's like the most demoralizing and mystifying experience. And it made me understand in somewhat the way I once got locked in a holding cell for 10 minutes when I was covering a courthouse and the deputies asked me if I wanted to be locked into a holding cell for 10 minutes while I was waiting for court to restart.

1:05:14Steve Hayes: And I was like, sure. And it was really like, I felt like I, in that moment, got a little bit of insight into what it's like to be going through the criminal justice system. Although, of course, they unlocked it at the end of 10 minutes and I could leave.

1:05:28Megan McArdle: I can give you more insight sometime if you like. Then they asked you, Kevin, can you fill us in, please?

1:05:34Kevin Williamson: Sausage jail takes on a whole other meaning.

1:05:37Steve Hayes: I had just been in a courtroom where I'd been in a courtroom where I watched a guy tell off the judge who was trying to send him to rehab. And he was like, I don't need rehab. And the guy was like, if I don't send you to rehab on probation, you're going to prison. You understand that, right? And he was like, I'm not an addict now. And then the judge sent him to prison.

1:05:55Megan McArdle: And I was like, the number one way, you know, that you need rehab is if you're in court yelling at the judge about how you don't need rehab.

1:06:01Steve Hayes: Yeah. And I was sitting in this holding cell meditating on that guy because that holding cell was like the worst place I've ever been. And I would have been on my knees to that judge being like, how do I not go back there? Help me help you. I will do anything. But so anyway, like I but I'd never been actually detained where I was not allowed to leave. Like, no, it was not like a prison. It's just a waiting room. But, you know, they don't tell you anything. No one explains what's going on. No one. And you're just stuck there. It's 10 o 'clock at night. I'm hugely jet lagged. Or 9 o 'clock at night.

1:06:34Steve Hayes: I'm hugely jet lagged and miserable. And all I want to do is get home. And I have to sit in sausage jail for an hour, waiting for the agricultural officer to be like, indeed, this has to be thrown out. And I was like, you could have told me that an hour ago. I would have just thrown it out. I did not have any personal attachment to the damn sausage. It was a totally innocent mistake. I've also been warned that this means I may get flagged again, even though I declared it. It's not like the dogs caught me. Like an idiot, I walked up to the guy and was like, I have sausage. It was obviously an innocent mistake.

1:07:10Kevin Williamson: Sausage watch list is another thing that you just don't want to be on, regardless of connotation.

1:07:16Megan McArdle: Name a Jonah's memoir.

1:07:17Jonah Goldberg: Did you think that they thought you had links to organized sausage crime?

1:07:23Steve Hayes: Very possibly. I mean, the thing you really don't want to be on is the sausage no-fly list. So I'm hoping, if you were listening to this Customs and Border Control, I have a couple of things I would like to say. And one of them is, please just explain to people what's happening. It would go a long way towards easing their psychological distress. But also, I swear to you, on my life. I will never again try to bring sausage into this country. I had no idea it was verboten. It was at the duty free. I stupidly assumed things at the duty free can be brought into America. I'm really sorry. And I'll never do it again.

1:08:00Steve Hayes: Yeah.

1:08:00Jonah Goldberg: Why is that? Did you ever get an explanation as to why they sell it at duty free, but you can't bring it in? Like, that seems illogical.

1:08:07Steve Hayes: I mean, like, look, there are probably other places you can bring it, but it is a little weird because there's not that many, you know, like I would think that American tourists are a prime market and that you cannot bring the sausages back. And another thing, if you run a duty free store, how about some flags about stuff you cannot bring into the country? It may actually be that they had such flags, but I didn't see them. I was I was already a little tired.

1:08:32Kevin Williamson: But Megan, also, as a devoted news consumer, I'm just amazed you missed that when Trump was campaigning in 2024, he called for a total and complete shutdown of sausages coming into this country until we can figure out what the hell is going on. And you just missed it entirely.

1:08:47Megan McArdle: I'm pretty sure that verboten sausage was the name of that ska band that Jonah was in when he was in high school.

1:08:53Jonah Goldberg: Verboten sausage would be German sausage, not French. Well, there was a

1:08:58Kevin Williamson: time when all the sausages in France became German. Anyway, that's another story.

1:09:02Megan McArdle: I mean, fair enough. Yeah, we spent we spent days resisting Wong jokes. I know. And and then Megan says, let's start talking about sausage. How about the no fly sausage?

1:09:12Steve Hayes: I'm sorry, guys.

1:09:14Jonah Goldberg: Let the record show I brought it up because of the meat and not because of whatever innuendo you children might inject into this conversation. I was, as I think I've mentioned here, I don't think I've ever told the story and it will have to wait for another time because we are out of time. I was on the actual no-fly list, the terror watch list back in the day. I made a lot of jokes about it at the time.

1:09:36Steve Hayes: You terrify me, Steve. It is true.

1:09:38Jonah Goldberg: It's the beard. I was. I really was on the terror watch list. And I should have seen it as the beginning of the conspiracy culture because immediately I was put on it. I mentioned it in public. And the next thing I know, there were conspiracies from the right that Obama had put me on it because I was too tough reporting on Benghazi and other. I was too tough on the Obama administration, which was never true.

1:10:00Megan McArdle: There was a guy, there was a guy complaining on Twitter about how he'd had trouble entering the United States because he had been to Afghanistan and he was getting trouble about having been in Afghanistan. And someone responded to him on Twitter. What kind of legitimate business did you have in Afghanistan anyway? And you say, well, I was there in my professional capacity as the prime minister of Norway.

1:10:20Steve Hayes: Wait, I actually have, like, along with the public service announcement for international travelers about not attempting to bring sausage into this country. except from Iceland, apparently, the agricultural officer told me. You can bring it in from Iceland because they don't have whatever disease they're worried about. The other thing that is new is that you have to fill out a declaration that you've not been to the Congo because of Ebola.

1:10:42Kevin Williamson: It just started.

1:10:43Steve Hayes: But because Air Portugal had shifted me over, they'd had to buy me a flight because their hub is Lisbon and the entire thing was shut down. They had bought me a flight on Lufthansa. And I didn't have a confirmation number or anything, so I just check in at the airport. Well, I go to the airport and it turns out you need this declaration which they didn't have the form for. You're supposed to fill it out online because I hadn't checked in online because I couldn't. There was a kerfuffle. But so anyway, the long story short is if you are in this situation and unable to check in online, you need to download and print the PDF of the Congo declaration or you are going to have like five people running around the airport trying to find you a copy of the form, which they eventually did and I got on, but everyone has to fill this out before they come to the United States now.

1:11:31Steve Hayes: So fair warning if you were planning international travel.

1:11:34Megan McArdle: Is that a Congolese sausage in your pocket or are you just happy to see it?

1:11:36Jonah Goldberg: Oh man, and there we go. We tried our best to resist. I should point out in closing, speaking of meat, after our conversation about now Senator, recently elected Scott Colombe's fantastic ad in the Mississippi Senate race, Pick Another Protein that has gone viral and people are talking about it. And the kid who made it is famous. And the guy who starred in it, it turns out he was once a homeless veteran. It's just, it's a great story about a great ad about meat. And after our last discussion on the podcast about the ad and about Pick Another Protein and about doing another dinner at Megan McArdle's house where she would make us braised short ribs and oxtail, we got a terrific note on Twitter from Sarah Little over at the Meat Institute.

1:12:32Jonah Goldberg: Love their work. Who wrote, listened to the pod, Julianna Potts and the Meat Institute would love to host a post-election protein dinner to celebrate all of the animal proteins ready to nourish the 120th Congress. So we don't have more details yet, but we're looking forward to those details. And we are looking forward to our big meat dinner with the Meat Institute. Maybe we can see if Scott Cologne and Ryan Sales, I think is the young man who made the ad, can be there to help us pick many, many proteins.

1:13:09Steve Hayes: And let me be clear that I have, by attempting to bring French sausage here, I was in no way attempting to cast a disparagement upon our many fine American sausages. I just thought it would be like, you know, variety.

1:13:23Jonah Goldberg: But I mean, look, you were just trying to pick another protein, as it were.

1:13:28Steve Hayes: Yes, indeed. I was picking the wrong protein, the very, very, very wrong protein. I am very sorry, Customs. I will never do it again.

1:13:37Kevin Williamson: So I know we got to go. But just so you know, I had this whole story because we bought a footstool that looks like a little long-haired sheep in Scotland that 10 years ago. And they give you a cute little, like a cat box carrier with air holes in it. And the people at customs at Dulles were looked inside, thought it was real in some way and made us wait in footstool jail for an hour and a half. So there you go. An hour and a half because of your, you did not have an actual animal. It was like an upholstered footstool that looked like a sheep. That's a weird thing to buy. Did you say it's not real?

1:14:14Steve Hayes: Did you try to like show it? We tried.

1:14:16Kevin Williamson: We tried. There's like those guards, as you experienced, their whole point is just... Go away. Once they make a decision, I don't want to talk to you about it anymore. It's somebody else's decision. And like my wife was not inclined to be civil. I'd be pretty frustrated. For the next hour. Yeah. It was a long night.

1:14:34Jonah Goldberg: Well, now we really have to go. Thank you all. Appreciate the time. See you next time.

1:14:42Jonah Goldberg: Finally, if you want to support what we're doing here, you can rate, review, and subscribe to the show on your podcast player of choice to help new listeners find us. And for those of you who want to watch the show, check us out on YouTube. Head over to youtube.com slash at the dispatch pods or just Google YouTube and the dispatch podcast. As always, if you've got questions, comments, concerns, or corrections, You can email us at roundtable at thedispatch.com. We read everything, even emails from Alice Wong. That's going to do it for today's show. Thanks so much for tuning in. And thank you to the folks behind the scenes who made this episode possible, Noah Hickey and Peter Bonaventure.

1:15:20Jonah Goldberg: Thanks again for listening. Please join us next time. And a thank you to our sponsor, UnitedHealthcare.

1:15:40Now pictures memories and proportions There are peopleSoap There probably sins

From the publisher

Steve Hayes is joined by Jonah Goldberg, Kevin Williamson, and Megan McArdle to discuss the widening Nvidia scandal, the Trump administration’s infighting over chip exports to China, and what Democrats will do with their new subpoena power.

The Agenda

 —The history of Nvidia’s rise

 —Softening policy on China

 —Nvidia’s off-balance-sheet liabilities

 —Howard Lutnick’s role and Marco Rubio’s memo

 —Lutnick’s problem or Trump’s problem?

 —Ethics rules for billionaires in government

 —The Democrats’ data center dilemma

 —NWYT: Sean Duffy and the FAA ground stop

Show Notes

—Jack Kubinec’s Dispatch explainer on Nvidia

—Megan McArdle’s column on founder CEOs

—Wall Street Journal reporting on Nvidia’s incoming CFO

—Reporting on Marco Rubio’s memo

The Dispatch Podcast is a production of ⁠The Dispatch⁠, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a nonpartisan perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including audio versions of all our articles and newsletters—⁠click here⁠. If you’d like to remove all ads from your podcast experience, consider becoming a premium Dispatch member ⁠by clicking here⁠.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from The Dispatch Podcast

All episodes