

Roundtable on pre–Election Day 2024 Senate races, focusing on (1) why Michigan Democratic Rep. Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers over Democrat Abdul El-Sayed three days before the election, (2) Alaska’s Senate fight involving Mary Peltola vs. Dan Sullivan and claims Democrats recruited a second “Dan Sullivan” to confuse voters, and (3) predictions and polling/strategy implications for Senate control.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on Haley Stevens endorsing Mike Rogers and its political implications.
“This was an eventful pre-midterms weekend with a number of stories.”
Exploration of the significance of endorsements in political campaigns.
“There is some substance behind it, but the explanations that Haley Stevens has given for why she did this.”
Discussing Haley Stevens' principled stance against endorsing a controversial candidate.
“reelected, we should still clap for those people.”
Analyzing the influence of personal slights and campaign handling on Stevens' actions.
“for maybe longer, but it was these petty slights and mishandling by the Al-Sayed campaign that actually got her to do that.”
Examining the controversies surrounding Abdul El-Sayed's campaign statements and their implications.
“We're spending our money on wars to support Israel rather than on, you know, feeding Michiganders or whatever.”
Discussing strategic choices made by candidates to align with party ideologies.
“or safe harbors to those kinds of people.”
Assessing the ramifications of Stevens' endorsement on pro-Israel Democrats.
“There's a lot of anti-Semitic conspiracy theory and stuff.”
Exploring the complexities of standing against party lines and the effectiveness of such actions.
“maybe are feeling, and so she's a voice for them.”
Discussion on Haley Stevens' endorsement of Mike Rogers and the motivations behind it.
“long-term principled stand that she's been thinking about for six months, I would have thought she could, and that's all that it was.”
Examining the impact of polling on the election and the significance of endorsements.
“on the idea that it doesn't matter, that it won't matter.”
Analyzing the symbolic nature of endorsements and their representation of party dynamics.
“Isn't it possible that that's, that it could have some effect, even if you believe generally that endorsements don't matter, Sarah?”
A critical look at partisan behavior and the implications of endorsements leading up to the election.
“abdul al-sayed a jihadist uh all these all these things uh there as i said earlier there are many reasons to object to Abdul El-Sayed.”
Explore the influence of partisan politics on election narratives and candidate perceptions.
“big deal, not big deal stuff, just to suit the moment is infuriating to me.”
Discuss the implications of the Democratic Party's strategy in the Peltola campaign.
“But for Donald Trump and Mike Johnson to say this is such a threat because this guy had family members that were once tied to the Muslim Brotherhood when they're flying around on the Muslim Brotherhood donated plane.”
Analyze the potential legal issues arising from candidate recruitment tactics.
“There's a District Court of Appeal of Florida Third District case on point where the candidate was disqualified for trying to mirror the name of an existing and well-known incumbent candidate.”
Examine the challenges of election result clarity and the public's trust in the process.
“So, yeah, I think there are legal problems here.”
The discussion covers recent election predictions and the potential issues with mail-in voting and ranked choice ballots.
“people to vote in person because mail ballots weren't delivered or weren't delivered in a timely manner.”
Hosts share their predictions for the House and Senate elections, including specific races and outcomes.
“And then what are your predictions on numbers in the Senate?”
Learn about key predictions for the election and the importance of voter turnout.
“Hinson losing, Al-Sayed winning, Sherrod Brown winning, and the other ones tracking with Mike.”
Find out about the Dispatch live stream event and how to participate.
“You can come to, well, I'll tell you where to go later when I read this thing after I know where to send you.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Dispatch Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Fox 1 has your front row seats on live NFL action. The biggest rivalries, the biggest hits. America's Game of the Week. Streaming live on Fox 1 all season long. Download the app today.
0:17Still wearing those old cargo shorts? If your wardrobe's due for an upgrade, but you don't know where to start, you need Stitch Fix. Your stylist learns your size, your style, and your budget, then sends a box pick just for you. They always nail the fit. No store, no hassle, no subscription required. Get started today at stitchfix.com. That's stitchfix.com.
0:52Jonah Goldberg: Welcome to the Dispatch Podcast. I'm your host, Steve Hayes. On today's roundtable, we discuss Democratic Congresswoman Haley Stevens' decision to endorse Republican candidate Mike Rogers in Michigan over fellow Democrat Abdul El-Sayed, only three days out from Election Day. Will this affect tomorrow night's results? What pushed Stevens to endorse Rogers? And then we look at the Alaska Senate race between Mary Paltola and Republican Senator Dan Sullivan and discuss the Democrats' scheme to put another Dan Sullivan on the Alaska ballot to confuse voters and the Trump administration's legal challenge against him.
1:28Jonah Goldberg: Finally, for not worth your time, some predictions about tomorrow night's results. I'm joined today by Dispatch Editor-in-Chief Jonah Goldberg, Dispatch Politics Editor Mike Warren, and advisory opinions host and SCOTUS blog editor Sarah Isker. Let's dive right in.
1:56Welcome, everybody.
1:58Jonah Goldberg: This was an eventful pre-midterms weekend with a number of stories. I mean, I feel like we could go down the top 10 stories of the weekend, the long weekend, and the 10th story is crazy. But we're going to focus on two primarily that could have some effect on the control of the United States Senate. Mike Warren, I will start with you. There was drama in the Michigan Senate race this weekend. can you give us can you give us I don't try to summarize the whole thing because that would take up our entire hour but give us a general summary of what happened and where things stand right now I feel like if I really gave you the full summary it would be like explaining several seasons of reality show drama to somebody who has never seen whatever TV show the Kardashians or whatever, and it would just make somebody's head spin.
3:08But bottom line is, in Michigan, we have this competitive Senate seat, right? Mike Rogers, a Republican. Abdul El-Sayed is the Democratic nominee. And it may come down to the wire here. It may be very, very close. Abdul El-Sayed won very narrowly, more narrowly than he or a lot of people expected. the Democratic primary earlier this year against Congresswoman Haley Stevens, who is not running. Obviously, she was running for Senate, not running for House re-election, a four-termer, I believe. And it was close. It was tight. It was maybe a little bitter. But Haley Stevens had endorsed Abdul El-Sayed after the fact, and then had kind of gone away, had not really done anything more for Syed's campaign as the election season went on.
4:04But every time she did speak about the race, she would say things cryptically like, I support the Democratic ticket in Michigan, or I'm going to be supporting our Democratic candidate. It's never actually saying Abdullah Syed's name. And so there was kind of a lot of talk about whether or not she was really as supportive or doing as much as she could. Yada, yada, yada. A lot of things are happening. We've talked, it's been talked about on this podcast about the ad that was run by a super PAC supporting Abdul El-Sayed, not Abdul El-Sayed's campaign himself or itself. That was depicting a couple talking about the high price of groceries and basically blaming American financial support for the state of Israel for those high gas prices and Blimey Mike Rogers and all the rest.
4:59This is just the latest entry in sort of these questions about Abdul Al-Sayed's comments and the people he associates with engaging in anti-Semitism, certainly anti-Israel, anti-Zionist, whatever you want to call it. And there were questions about whether Haley Stevens was going to do all she could in the final days. There was a question about whether she was going to show up at a rally. this weekend for Abdul Al-Sayed, after she basically was like, you need to condemn this ad, Abdul Al-Sayed, and also you need to do some other things that distance yourself from these people and these comments that you have said that people, voters in Michigan, think is anti-Semitic.
5:45There was back and forth. Abdul Al-Sayed issued a statement basically saying that he condemned the ads, kind of, sort of, but that Haley Stevens was being kind of annoying about this. Back and forth, back and forth. Anyway, it all ended on Sunday when, surprise, surprise, nobody knew this was going to happen. Haley Stevens, longtime Democrat, four-term Democratic House member, shows up on Sunday morning at a church, I believe a primarily black church in Michigan with the Republican nominee, Mike Rogers. It was all, and then a couple hours later after the church service, she had formally endorsed him.
6:25And everybody lost the damn minds over it. And so here we are, she's endorsed him. Mike Rogers, Abdullah Syed is basically saying it doesn't matter. Every national Democrat, and certainly every Michigan Democrat is pulling their hair out over this and saying she's not a Democrat anymore, all this stuff. So that's the drama. There is some substance behind it, but the explanations that Haley Stevens has given for why she did this. She was telling people up to like hours before she did this that she was going to stay and support and rally for Syed. And so I think there are some questions about, and we can talk about it, about how sincere she was in those statements, how sincere she has been in her approach to this.
7:10But at the end of the day, she has said, and she is continuing to say in interviews, that Abdul El-Sayed does not satisfy her as a Democrat on issues like Israel, and so she cannot support him, and she supported Mike Rogers as a result. That was probably too much information, but it's a lot of buildup to this craziness, this drama on Sunday.
7:33Jonah Goldberg: Yeah, no, that was very well done. Sarah, first on the substantive questions, you know, certainly the Democratic primary campaign was roiled by claims of anti-Semitism and sort of Jewish Democrats in Michigan on ease with Abdul El-Sayed. Abdul El-Sayed, of course, campaigning with Hassan Piker, who has said many, many offensive and anti-Semitic things over the years. And then shortly after the Democratic primary ended, Abdul El-Sayed sort of took umbrage in anybody who would ask him about his association with Hassan Piker. How dare you ask me about this streamer from California? That's not what Michigan voters want to talk about.
8:26Jonah Goldberg: But of course, in juicing his enthusiasm for his candidacy in Michigan before the primary, he was happy to campaign with Hassan Piker. Looking at everything that Mike has said and what Haley Stevens, the statement she put out, which specifically got into charges of anti-Semitism, his association, al-Sayed's association with radicals. How much of this, from what you can tell, from what we've observed publicly, is really a substantive dispute that she just happens to be sharing with voters 72 hours before the final contest?
9:12Sarah Isgur: Yeah, there's a lot going on here. First of all, I also think it's relevant that the Hassan Piker part of this, The ad in question is by that guy's uncle. So like this is literally all in the family.
9:26Jonah Goldberg: Young Turks, yes. Okay.
9:29Sarah Isgur: Let's back up to whether endorsements matter. Like endorsements is a general matter, by which I mean like a newspaper, a local newspaper endorsing or, you know, a local celebrity or a sports star, whatever else, endorsing a candidate. They do seem to matter in low information, like low name ID races, but the higher up you get, like to president, the less any endorsement is going to matter. Like you don't actually care who George Clooney is voting for. Not really. Unless the endorsement comes with information, which it rarely does. Normally it's just like, I like this person, I vouch for them and, you know, their policies align with mine.
10:09Sarah Isgur: Well, thanks. What makes this situation different is when we're talking about it, we're not really talking about it as an endorsement, because that's not what she did. Or at least we need two different words. An endorsement is something that is long planned, is rolled out, is part of a campaign operation. This was clearly not that. There is no world in which she always intended to endorse Mike Rogers 72 hours before Election Day. So we need some other word for what this is, which is, I would argue, a probably not all that consequential screw-up by al-Sayed's campaign, which is to allow her, like, to piss off someone so much in your own coalition and to give nothing over and over and over again that they do something like this because they don't feel like they have a choice.
11:09Sarah Isgur: There's lots, there's always bad blood in primaries. That's what primaries are. In this case, basically, she was like, happy to show up to this event with you. I need this one thing. That is also incredibly normal after a primary. I mean, I can't imagine a primary where that doesn't happen if you want the other person to endorse you.
11:28Jonah Goldberg: And the one thing in this case was to denounce this ad. To denounce this outside ad. And then She said and also, you know, clarify his positions. Right. Right. And there was probably even a way to not do what she wanted and still make her feel that this was a candidate in a campaign that she was still a part of and et cetera.
11:51Sarah Isgur: They failed to do that. So this was a failure on their part, not some win by the Rogers campaign, in my view. Also, we have seen repeatedly, well, maybe not repeatedly enough, but we have seen several examples of Republicans knowingly lighting their careers on fire because they reach a point where they can no longer look themselves in the mirror, principles, whatever, that they're willing to give up on their careers that they've built rather than stand by. Donald Trump obviously facilitated that But we've seen Democrats over and over again say this would never happen in the Democratic Party The Democrats would always stand up would always be willing to torch their careers It doesn't matter whether you've been working for 20 years and this cycle I think Proved the thing that Republicans had been saying all along which is simply no You will be shocked by how few people Actually are willing to have their principles cost them something This cost her.
12:56Sarah Isgur: It cost her any future in what she had been doing within the Democratic Party. It probably cost her where she sleeps for the next few weeks, depending on how this race turns out. There's no way she's sleeping at her house right now because of death threats and everything else that are coming her way. And we saw this play out or not play out, as it were, with Graham Plattner's campaign in Maine, where it would have been so easy for Democrats to simply say, no, he has to drop out. I will not support this candidate. And instead, we did hear some of it, but we heard a lot more, oh, it's for the Senate majority, so I have to, which makes the whole Trump thing seem very reasonable.
13:37Sarah Isgur: Well, it was for the presidency. The Senate doesn't even do anything. So that's all to say, calling this an endorsement probably isn't the correct political description. Will it make a difference? I don't actually think so. Same as all of the people who stood up to Trump, and it cost them their careers to do so, and it didn't make a difference, and Trump still got reelected, we should still clap for those people. Whether you agree with them or not, on either side, whether you agree with what Haley Stevens said, and I don't just mean like that she should have on it. I mean that he's an anti-Semite, even if you don't agree with that.
14:12Sarah Isgur: She clearly believes that her principles did not allow her to recommend this guy to Michigan voters. And she said so out loud, even though it cost her a lot. That should mean something to all of us.
14:26Jonah Goldberg: Yeah. Sarah, it sounds like, if I don't want to put words in your mouth, sounds like you think that it was a combination of both sort of petty slights that got her to do this final thing that she seemed sort of to be on the verge of doing or holding in the back of her mind for maybe longer, but it was these petty slights and mishandling by the Al-Sayed campaign that actually got her to do that. But that also, she had real substantive principled disagreements with Al-Sayed and objections to some of the things he said.
14:56Sarah Isgur: Oh, no, I think the two work in tandem, right? Like, to quote Oprah, like, when people show you who they are, believe them. the petty slights feed into the other thing, right? If you're the type of person who believes that Jews are they, them, who won't disavow this ad, then you're the type of person who is going to have these petty slights, who isn't thoughtful about other people, who isn't welcoming. David French said this on MS Now. If you nominate a candidate who says they're going to narrow the tent, don't be surprised when the tent gets smaller. Yeah.
15:28Jonah Goldberg: Jonah, if you go back and review the things that, Abdul El-Sayed has said over the course of his campaign during the primary in the general election. And then again, things that he has refused to say. I mean, he did not actually come out and denounce this ad. It was a horribly anti-Semitic ad and he couldn't do it. He couldn't do the thing in part because he has been making arguments that at least have echoes of the main argument that is in this ad. We're spending our money on wars to support Israel rather than on, you know, feeding Michiganders or whatever. He wouldn't denounce the Iran Revolutionary Guard Corps killed tens of thousands of persons when he was asked directly and repeatedly to do this.
16:19Jonah Goldberg: He said at one point that he didn't want to put out a statement about the death of Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei because some people in Michigan were sad about his demise. There are some pretty significant substantive reasons not to want to support Abdul El-Sayed if you're certainly if you're a Republican, but if you're a fellow Democrat, too. Yeah. So I'm going to start off by saying where I disagree with Sarah a little bit. I don't think this was a screw-up by Syed. I think this was on purpose. For the reasons that you're sort of referring to here, Steve. I think that he wants the Democratic Party to simply be an anti-Israel party.
17:10I'm not saying an anti-Semitic party. but an anti-Israel party is going to be more comfortable with anti-Semites than not. And he doesn't want to give his detractors, the people he wants to purge, you know, as David says, make the 10 smaller, the people he wants out of the party, he wants to signal that he will not dance. He will not bend. He will not compromise. He will not give rhetorical comfort. or safe harbors to those kinds of people. He will not concede the premise of the question ever when it comes to anything that has to do with the Muslim Brotherhood, Iran, Israel, Palestine, Egypt, Middle East.
17:59Sometimes I actually think he says things that are probably, I would not be surprised if he actually goes further to be an obnoxious prick about this stuff than he actually is. But, you know, it's like the Trumpologists who always like to say the cruelty is the point. The obdurateness is the point. He's trying to make it sort of like, I don't know, like you just can't be pro-gun control in the Republican Party. It used to be you just couldn't be pro-choice in the Republican Party. You couldn't just be pro-life and be left-wing on everything else in the Democratic Party. He wants this to be a litmus test, cultural divide.
18:40You know, what do they call them? You know, the deadline where the word actually comes from means like if you go past it, you get shot in a Civil War POW camp. He wants there to be a deadline around the Israel question. And you have to be hostile to it. And so him being arrogant and nasty and obnoxious whenever pressed on any of these things, sure, some of it has to do with his ego. But I think there's an actual strategy to it in the same way that there is with a lot of the Trump stuff. The humiliation for Trump is a feature, right? He thinks it's important for him to portray total strength. If you – I mean, like, why crap on people like John Cornyn, right?
19:25why, you know, these people, it is precisely to show that you can. And that's what Syed is trying to do with the anti-Zionist, anti-Israel crowd, is be seen as the guy who's always going to stand up to anybody who tries to use anti-Semitism or the Holocaust or terrorism or any of these things as cudgels to discipline his philosophical point of view. And that's where I agree entirely with Sarah on the comparison to Trump. He is the most Trumpy figure in American politics today outside of Trump himself. In the sort of the way he is demanding, you know, like we are now in a place where if you follow the social media attacks on Stevens, the gist of it, I mean, there's a lot of sexism.
20:13There's a lot of anti-Semitic conspiracy theory and stuff. But the through line is essentially to say that she's crazy, that she has Syed derangement syndrome, right? And that was a very effective rhetorical tool. I think profoundly stupid and in bad faith. And I still get, you know, like there's still people today who think they can explain all of my positions through Trump derangement syndrome. I have, you know, whenever people use it, I have, I drop my respect for them considerably because I think it's so stupid, but it works, right? It's effective publicly. It says it's a way to anathematize critics and to say they're just weird.
20:51They're stupid. They've lost their mind. How could you possibly think that ad was anti-Semitic? How can you possibly have a problem with what Syed is saying? She's clearly lost it. She's irrational. Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Syed's smart enough. He's smart enough to listen to the people around him who said, you know, what you should do is offer an olive branch. You should make a phone call. Let's campaign together. He knew that was smart politics. He didn't think he had to because I think, first of all, he thought he was going to win no matter what. And if he's going to win, he wanted to win by sending the message that the pro-Israel Democrats have got to go and they get nothing from me.
21:25But even if he lost, he got to blame the pro-Israel crowd for his loss. And so, like, it's sort of like the Jon Stewart clown knows on, clown knows off thing. Like, he gets to be sort of anti-Israel guy whenever he loses anything and say, oh, it's the Jews, it's the Zionists, it's AIPAC. And when he wins, he says, we crushed the Jews, the Zionists, AIPAC, and all that. And he's happy in both regards, right? He's in a win-win place. That's sort of how Trump came to power in 2016, is he couldn't lose by his own standards. That's how, reportedly, Roger Ailes talked him into running. It was like, look, either you boost your name ID, you have a lot of fun, you make a bunch of money out of this, you'll become an even bigger star, or you'll win the presidency.
22:09And for Trump, that was great. It was like, what's the downside? And, you know, for a while there, he was trying to find an exit ramp because he was like, oh, my God, I might actually win. Syed is a much more serious person, but I think he has the same attitude towards this.
22:24Jonah Goldberg: Let me push back on that. I mean, I think it's hard for people to imagine that he, given that this is the race is in its last three days, that he would want to do anything to jeopardize his likely victory, if you believe the polls. But he did. By having this big fight with Haley Stevens. I mean, I think it's probably hard for people to imagine that he would not want to be doing everything he could be doing right now to win the race, even if it's at the expense of. I just disagree with that. There are 500 answers he could have given on all of these Muslim Brotherhood questions, all of these different things over the last six months that would have been politically smart.
23:12And he didn't do them. It's not because he's dumb.
23:15Sarah Isgur: Also, he raised$1.2 million after she endorsed his opponent because of everything Jonah just said. It fits his narrative perfectly. And by the way, he doesn't think he's going to lose. And he doesn't think that anything Haley Stevens says is going to affect his potential to win or lose. And that brings to— I think he's probably right. Yeah, me too. I don't know if I'm a voice of dissent here or not. But I just I would caution us against valorizing Haley Stevens actions over the last couple of days too much, just because she has made a decision that puts her sort of against her party and and puts, I think, her decision and her actions reflect maybe what a lot of other Democrats, pro-Israel Democrats in Michigan, maybe are feeling, and so she's a voice for them.
24:12I do think the way she's been acting over these last few days is kind of weird. Not answering questions very consistently or coherently when she was talking with Anderson Cooper. This was on Sunday night after this endorsement. Sort of unable to explain, answer a basic question about when she made the decision. She was apparently talking to members of Congress, Democratic members of Congress, and saying one thing and then made the decision at some point in a 12-hour period to do the opposite. Instead of going to the Syed rally, she was going to go and endorse Mike Rogers. And maybe none of this matters.
24:55And I actually think none of it matters in a big sense. And I agree that Syed agrees that it doesn't matter. I find her decision to insert herself into the story plays into Syed's hands in ways that I think are going to be damaging long term to the pro-Israel viewpoint within the Democratic coalition. In a way, she has sort of played into Syed's hands. And I don't think, I think there are pro-Israel voices who look at what she has done and say, good for you. You finally, you stood up to your party on this issue. And she did. I just think she went about it in an odd way, in a way that was not helpful for her cause.
25:42You guys ripped me apart on that. But I just, I don't like it.
25:46Sarah Isgur: But the problem is, Mike, the Republican side, we actually have people who have done every version of this, right? People who have stood up to Trump in every hypothetical way that people came up with, which was the, quote, correct way to say no to Trump. And every single version of it has failed. Cassidy Hutchison has failed all the way to Bill Barr. So there is no right way to stand on principle. If you do it one way. Failed to do what? Sorry, failed what? In what way? in that in the end they're told the way you did it wasn't effective you should have done it some other way or you should have been a different person or you weren't the right messenger or you look disorganized oh you look too organized like at the end of the day there is no right way to say here I stand I can do no other you look like you were plotting nope you look like you were you know you've lost your mind I just have strong doubts that anybody in these closing days really was thinking about or cared what Haley Stevens thought about this race and whether it was sort of media questions.
26:51But, you know, I'd have to do like a dissection or a forensic analysis of like how we got here, because I seem to remember her showing up on CNN and some other networks sort of talking about this. And, you know, was she actively trying to kind of engage on this issue? I don't know. Look, I could be wrong about this. I just find this to be like a lot of silly drama over something that ends up playing into Syed's goal, which I agree with Jonah about that, which he wants to basically say, if you have problems with me on this, I don't want you in my party and you don't belong here. And I just think Stevens is not.
27:31Sarah Isgur: And like Trump, he's going to get exactly what he wants. He is going to win and she is going to be of the Democratic Party. That is what Trump so effectively did to Republicans for the last 10 years. Yeah.
27:43Jonah Goldberg: Well, let's put Mike to your point. I mean, it's entirely possible that she did the right thing and made an admirable decision and did take a principled stand, but did it awkwardly. And I mean, I don't, she certainly, if it were a deeply held long-term principled stand that she's been thinking about for six months, I would have thought she could, and that's all that it was. It seems to me she would have been able to articulate that view in a 15-minute interview with Anderson Cooper. Yes. She didn't, and she refused to answer a bunch of questions. I'm not saying that it wasn't, you know, that somewhere in there there wasn't a principled stand, but it seems to me the most likely explanation is there was a principled stand.
28:26Jonah Goldberg: She held this view. She's genuinely concerned about it. There are good reasons to be genuinely concerned about Abdul El-Sayed, as we've discussed here. but that at the end, what tipped her over may not have been a principled objection that she could have made a week ago or three weeks ago or whatever, but instead are the petty slights that Sarah mentioned when we first started discussing this, that he didn't reach out, that he didn't take care of her, that he didn't bring her in, that he didn't welcome her to the event with Jim Clyburn. I mean, all of these things, it seems to me, may have combined.
28:57Jonah Goldberg: Let me, before we move on, I want to push back on the idea that it doesn't matter, that it won't matter. It may be the case that Abdul El-Sayed, certainly if you believe the polling right now, he is winning, he's doing well. The New York Times poll was out this weekend, has him over Mike Rogers, Abdul El-Sayed, over Mike Rogers, 53-42, a double-digit lead. All of the caveats about polling stipulated, and we're going to talk a little bit about polling here in a moment. So it may be the case that he is just too far ahead for this to even matter. But at the same time, if the race were closer than that, she won or she lost the Democratic primary with 49 percent of the vote.
29:48Jonah Goldberg: Basically, they split it in two. And she is, I mean, she's actually, she's not really articulating the principal decision, as I just mentioned, but she's taken a stand that you have heard from many other Michigan Democrats who are uncomfortable with the kinds of things that Abdul El-Sayed has said or has refused to say over the course of this time. Couldn't you make an argument that given the fact that she won half of the party's primary voters and that she's doing so for her stated reason of the kinds of things that have bothered that this might matter, that if you're not paying attention to every single thing that Abdul El-Sayed has said, but you know he said some stuff that rubs you the wrong way, you look at her and you say, gosh, if she can't vote for him, a sitting Democratic congresswoman, I'm certainly not going to vote for him.
30:40Jonah Goldberg: Isn't it possible that that's, that it could have some effect, even if you believe generally that endorsements don't matter, Sarah?
30:51Sarah Isgur: No, not really. We're too close to election day. This is not a low name ID race. People have heard a lot about these candidates. I don't, as you said, I don't think anyone's learning anything a lot more about El Sayed because of what she has said, other than that he didn't want to hold on to her in his tent. So, yeah, I guess I don't see this moving a lot of voters. Will it move 1 ,000 voters? Sure, but this race isn't going to come down to this. Either it's the biggest polling whiff of the last ever, or he's going to win.
31:34Jonah Goldberg: There's a pretty big polling whiff in the primary in Michigan.
31:37Sarah Isgur: Primary polling is much harder because there are so few people who vote in primaries. We have a pretty good sense of who our general election voters are. I'm not saying there aren't polling whiffs, but they tend to be two-point polling whiffs, not five, six, seven, nine point, 11 point polling whiffs.
31:54Jonah Goldberg: I mean, there were some of those in 2024, right? I mean, the undercounted Republicans. Before we go down the polling rabbit hole, I think it's worth just making one quick point. It will be symbolic. It'll be representative in our memories. it will be like, maybe it's not going to be as big of a, I mean, like it is more than almost 30 years later. And we, most people who follow politics seriously instantaneously know what you mean when you say sister soldier moment, even though like how much that actually affected votes, moves, whatever. It was an intra-party elite signaling moment. It was a shibboleth kind of moment.
32:36And for people who know what this internal fight in the Democratic Party is, you know, like, if you listen to the way John Podoretz is in a fetal position just about the Michigan race, does not seem to care a whit about the rest of the election, just this race he cares about passionately, the pro-Israel people care about passionately because of what it'll represent.
33:00Sarah Isgur: And also, like the Trump side, by the way, it will teach all of the other Democrats, Don't be Haley Stevens. Right. So, like, I think as a symbolic thing, as a representative of a dynamic in the party, it will be an avatar for that. And so in that sense, I think it's very important. But I think Sarah's right. It ain't going to have a big impact on an election.
33:25Jonah Goldberg: Before we take an ad break and announcement about election night, please join us tomorrow for our election night live stream. We'll bring you the regular dispatch cast of characters, including Sarah Isker, Kevin Williamson, Mike Warren, John McCormick, David French, Megan McCardle, Mark Sawyer, Stephen Richer, and we'll have drop-ins from dispatch friends around the country. We'll start at 9 p.m. Eastern on Tuesday, November 3rd. Go to youtube.com slash at the dispatch pods or just Google the dispatch podcast on YouTube. If you subscribe there, you can make sure you don't miss any of our episodes.
34:00Jonah Goldberg: One other way to make sure that you're on top of all dispatch editorial offerings, become a member of the dispatch. You'll unlock access to bonus podcast episodes and all of our exclusive newsletters and articles. You can sign up at thedispatch.com slash join. And if you use the promo code roundtable, you'll get a month for free. Speaking of ads, if they aren't your thing, you can upgrade to a premium membership. No ads, early access to all episodes, two free gift memberships to give away, exclusive live town halls with the founders, and much, much more. Okay, we'll be right back. Some of the pictures worth keeping aren't the ones taken at big celebrations.
34:38Jonah Goldberg: They're the ordinary moments. AuraFrames makes it easier to bring those pictures out of a crowded camera roll and into everyday life. An example, for years my kids have stolen my phone and loaded up my camera roll with silly pictures of themselves just meant to troll me. I upload these photos to my parents' AuraFrame and they not only get to see our carefully posed family photos and shots from honor roll celebrations or sports victories, they get a glimpse of the insanity of our everyday life. Aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families, and their Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year.
35:14Jonah Goldberg: For a limited time, visit AuraFrames.com and get up to$50 off select frames, plus an additional$5 off your order with the promo code DISPATCH. That's A-U-R-A frames dot com promo code DISPATCH. Support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply. There's something satisfying about a well-made object. Not a gadget that gets replaced every two years, but the kind of thing you could hand down to your kid. That's getting harder to find. Today's sponsor is one of the exceptions. VAR, that's V-A-E-R, is a Los Angeles watch company whose goal is pretty straightforward. Bring American watchmaking back.
35:55Jonah Goldberg: They now assemble watches across California, Arizona, Rhode Island, and Alabama with leather straps made in Illinois and Florida. And these aren't fashion accessories. They're proper tool watches. Sapphire crystals, premium materials, and full waterproof warranties, meaning you can actually swim or dive with them on. I've been wearing one recently, and what stands out is how solid and understated it feels. The kind of watch that seems designed to last for decades. It's not flashy or ostentatious, and yet since I've been wearing it, I've gotten one compliment after another. Vare has already earned over 10 ,000 five-star reviews, and it's become one of the largest independent watch assemblers in the United States.
36:36Jonah Goldberg: If you like the idea of owning something rugged, timeless, and thoughtfully made, give them a look. Go to varewatches.com slash dispatch. That's v-a-e-r watches.com slash dispatch. There's a simple way I think about a mattress now. When the alarm goes off, you know whether you actually rested or just spent the night in bed. I wake up and feel restored. I can tell that I've slept well. And when I roll over and check my sleep score, I see the difference. I feel like my bed was made for me. That's one reason I appreciate Brooklyn Bedding's approach. They don't assume everybody sleeps the same way.
37:14Jonah Goldberg: With more than 15 mattress models, there are choices for different kinds of sleepers instead of a single answer for everyone. And the 365-night comfort trial means you get time to decide whether your mattress is actually a good fit. So go to brooklynbedding.com and use my promo code dispatch at checkout to get 30 % off site wide during the Black Friday sale. Exclusive with my code. That's brooklynbedding.com and promo code dispatch for 30 % off site wide. Let them know we sent you in the survey after checkout. brooklynbetting.com promo code dispatch welcome back let's return to our discussion before we go uh i do want to just make one comment about donald trump who's been campaigning and calling abdul al-sayed a jihadist uh all these all these things uh there as i said earlier there are many reasons to object to Abdul El-Sayed.
38:13Jonah Goldberg: I can't imagine some of our friends, former conservatives, former Republicans who are making an impassioned case that you absolutely have to vote for this guy, Abdul El-Sayed, because it's the only way to block Donald Trump. Some of the same people made the case. You absolutely had to support Graham Plattner. They're no longer really pro-democracy so much as they're just pro-democrat. Fair enough, they can make their own decisions, but I think it's a difficult argument to make. Can I say real quick on that point? In that way, this has been a very important bit of drama because I think it's been revealing in an embarrassing way how far people are willing to go in that direction and are willing to get behind somebody for basically party over any kind of moral objection.
39:09Sorry. On this point, I wasn't going to do this, but I spent the last week in CNN green rooms emailing with people, talking to people who just rolled their eyes and yawned at the Mary Patola, Alaska Battle of the Dan Sullivans thing. It's not that big a deal. oh, this happens in politics. I don't like it. I would never do it. But, you know, norms, schmorms. It's just not that big a deal. You guys are getting too worked up over this. You know, it doesn't matter. Ranked choice voting, the other Dan Sullivan was going to disappear. You know, like just rationalizing it away as kind of a nothing burger thing, which I'm fine with if you want to make that argument.
39:55except you've had Democrats for 11 years now talk about how they are the only vessel of democracy. They're the only one who cares about norms. They're the only, you know, our democracy, all this kind of stuff. And then these shenanigans, and then there are shenanigans, they just yawn at. Okay, all right, fine, there's that hypocrisy. And I think there's an arrogance to that that is going to bother some people, but I don't think it's going to matter very much either. And then a week later, you have this thing where Haley Stevens endorses a Republican and you have people losing their frigging minds about how this is going to radicalize a generation, how this is the greatest betrayal, you know, I know as I joked on Twitter since I don't know the first defenestration of Prague because we all know there are many defenestrations of Prague.
40:44Like you can go to like Benedict Arnold can't hold a candle to Haley Stevens. And like, isn't this also just politics, right? I mean, this is like a thing that happens. You had, you know, Democrats endorsed George W. Bush at the Republican convention. It is not, you know, you had, you know, Joe Lieberman, you know, I mean, like, like the Zell Miller, it just shows you how unbelievably elastic these external standards are when you are in full tribal mode. And I'm not saying they're the exact parallel thing, but neither are illegal. You know, there's nothing illegal that Ailey Stevens did. And there's apparently nothing illegal that Mary Patola did or her campaign did or Democrats did.
41:28It's all about norms. It's all about trying to, you know, do the right thing, have some integrity, all this kind of stuff. And I don't think there's any argument that you can make that what Stevens did is like just an absolute stain on her character. I think it's kind of a screw-up. There's no... I think Mike's right. She couldn't have planned this if her entire staff resigned when they found out about it, you know? But just the arrogance on, arrogance off, big deal, not big deal stuff, just to suit the moment is infuriating to me. And I only welcome it because it's been infuriating to me among pro-Trump people for 11 years.
42:11And when you have a chance that both sides it leftward, I'm going to grab it with both hands.
42:18Jonah Goldberg: Well, I mean, this isn't isn't this I mean, this is, again, something we talk a lot about a fair amount on this podcast. This is sort of partisan brain rot at its worst. And you would expect to see this kind of partisan brain rot in the days before an election. But it is, I think, clarifying in so many ways. The point I was going to make is you have Donald Trump talking about Abdul El-Sayed as this, you know, his family ties to the Muslim Brotherhood. He's this radical Islamic extremist. As Donald Trump is flying around the country on an Air Force One airplane donated by the Qatari government that is the largest funder of the Muslim Brotherhood.
42:58Jonah Goldberg: I mean, if Donald Trump were really worried about the Muslim Brotherhood, he would not have given security guarantees to the government of Qatar when they gave him a$400 million plane. I'm worried about the stuff that Abdul El-Sayed says. I'm worried that he doesn't find it easy to denounce an anti-Semitic ad that's obviously anti-Semitic. It bothers me that he seems to have some feeling or give the benefit of the doubt to the Iranian regime in certain moments when he's asked questions about it. But for Donald Trump and Mike Johnson to say this is such a threat because this guy had family members that were once tied to the Muslim Brotherhood when they're flying around on the Muslim Brotherhood donated plane.
43:45Jonah Goldberg: Color me skeptical that they really mean it. Sarah I want to pick up on something that Jonah said and go to you on this because you and I talked before we were recording about this and I'm very interested in your thoughts Jonah talking about the Mary Peltola arrangement shall we say the fact that there were apparently the worst Robert Ludlum novel ever
44:14Jonah Goldberg: the Mary Peltola arrangement Weird, I just saw that at the airport when I was walking by, yeah.
44:25Jonah Goldberg: Democratic national staffers, along with people on the Peltola campaign and others, outsiders, taught to recruit other Dan Sullivan to put him on the ballot, to run, to confuse voters. The New York Times had this huge expose. I think the reporting was very solid. And I think it's awfully damning as it relates to the National Democrats, Democratic Party, for people who have claimed for a long time that they just really want to give voters an accurate, fair and accurate choice and that they're the good guys here. They sure don't look like the good guys in this thing. We have heard, as Jonah points out, from either Democratic partisans or never Trump types who have become Democratic partisans that this is all it's all fair and in love and politics and people should get over it and stop complaining about it.
45:17Jonah Goldberg: Um, Jonah said it doesn't appear to have been illegal what she was doing. And this is one of the arguments that you hear from her defenders that this is, it may be unseemly. We might not like it. Maybe we wish we didn't, she didn't do it, but there are really no legal implications here. And the Alaska Supreme court, um, looked at these questions before the New York times reporting came out, and it's much ado about maybe not nothing, but very little. Is that your understanding of this, Sarah?
45:53Sarah Isgur: No. I cannot sitting here today tell you that any given person definitely committed a crime. What I can tell you is that a lot of the people in that story should probably go get a criminal defense attorney, though. Okay, let's start with the it's just icky but not illegal. It is certainly nothing new to recruit third-party candidates to run, right? Both parties do this all the time. Republicans recruit Green Party candidates, Democrats recruit Libertarian candidates in the hopes that it will siphon off just a few votes from one of the main parties, tale as old as time. It is also not unheard of to recruit candidates who have similar names.
46:37Sarah Isgur: The problem is it doesn't work very well in a normal way that we usually run elections with a primary and then a general election runoff between two candidates. Because like what, you're gonna run them in the primary? Like what's the point? They don't win, huh? Nevertheless, we actually do have examples of candidates doing this. There's a District Court of Appeal of Florida Third District case on point where the candidate was disqualified for trying to mirror the name of an existing and well-known incumbent candidate. But the argument from the court was basically like, you'd never gone by this name before.
47:19Sarah Isgur: You've never conducted official business or personal business under this name before. So we can disqualify you as not a good faith or honest purpose candidate. There was another one that's a little bit closer. the incumbent guy's name is, sorry, the incumbent guy's name is Fred H. Johnson, and someone tries to run whose name is Arthur Fred Johnson, and he wants to go by Fred Johnson. Then they're like, no, your name is Arthur F. Johnson or A. Fred Johnson at best. Okay, so this isn't unheard of, and it is icky, but like you said, lots of things in politics are icky, I guess. Although, can we maybe just say that when one side does something icky, maybe don't vote for that side.
48:04Sarah Isgur: I don't know. Whether it's Paxton getting impeached or Mary Peltola's campaign, like senior operatives and the Democratic Party operatives that were supporting her from the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee. I don't know. That's pretty high up. This wasn't some random doing it. Don't vote for those candidates. Okay. On the legal side, what they represented what uh daniel sullivan's legal team represented at the alaska election division and then to the alaska state courts that they went through was that he in fact was simply um he chose to run as a republican because of his conservative views that's why he changed his party affiliation while he has not been registered with the republican party prior to filing his candidacy, that timing does not prove that Mr.
48:56Sarah Isgur: Sullivan falsely represented his political beliefs or lacked the legal ability to request a Republican designation. He claims that he believes in conservative principles and Republican viewpoints. So first off, perjury. They have emails and texts, because these people are morons, that seem to say that he very much understood why he was running for office, and it was to cause voter confusion to help Mary Peltola, who he supported in the general election. That is a problem for them.
49:29Jonah Goldberg: And has supported before.
49:31Sarah Isgur: Yep, yep. But like, you're allowed to change your mind. The Alaska Supreme Court's right. There was no evidence that he hadn't just changed his mind and decided to run against her. But now there is. Okay, perjury, number one. Number two, fraud. The guy who was recruiting appears to have been paid by fairly, like maybe by the DSCC at various points. He went around Alaska using a false name to try to recruit these candidates. This would be an Alaska state law fraud issue, maybe. Three campaign finance violations. This is really easy to screw up. How were they giving the money and how were they reporting the money that they were giving?
50:08Sarah Isgur: So I'd wanna look at that too. But the last one is the big one. And this is 18 U.S.C. 241, Conspiracy Against Rights. This is a federal charge where you try to oppress any person in the free exercise or enjoyment of any right or privilege secured to them by the Constitution, in this case, voting. This is the charge that DOJ brought against Donald Trump about January 6th. Then it went to the Supreme Court. And if you remember, this is the Trump immunity case where they said, well, he would have immunity for official acts, but not for unofficial acts. And DOJ charged him once again under 18 U.S.C.
50:47Sarah Isgur: 241, arguing that all of this was unofficially done as a candidate to try to prevent people's votes from counting. 241 is an expansive statute. again i am not saying that they did violate this statute i'm saying that i would hire a lawyer because there are certainly federal prosecutors and by the way this isn't a trump department of justice thing in any administration with any department of justice federal prosecutors would look into exactly what these people were saying to each other and whether that was their purpose was to oppress people's votes and the text messages that they have going back and forth about the focus group, where they're basically giggling about how their effort to confuse voters is working, is not great for them on this 241 charge.
51:38So, yeah,
51:40Sarah Isgur: I think there are legal problems here.
51:42Jonah Goldberg: There's at least, it sounds like you believe there's at least a case for a serious investigation. Unfortunately, the serious investigation would come from the Trump Justice Department, correct? And Alaska state officials.
51:57Sarah Isgur: They will, all of the fraud stuff that I talked about.
51:59Jonah Goldberg: Everybody will look at.
52:00Sarah Isgur: And perjury. That was perjury to a state court. Yeah.
52:04Jonah Goldberg: Okay. I mean, it is problematic if there were a crime of some kind to have been committed that the Trump Justice Department would look into this because. Well, this is why you don't torture credibility over dumb, dumb stuff. Right. But they have and it's problematic. And it's not a good way to go into the final voting, which takes place tomorrow. Well, also bear in mind, we don't have that many examples of this.
52:35Sarah Isgur: But just because someone is indicted does not mean that it undoes the election. Now, sometimes it does in 2018, where it was shown that votes had actually been not cast or changed, etc. They did redo that election in 2018. In North Carolina, yeah. Yeah, yeah, the 2018 North Carolina congressional race. In this case, I think if Mary Peltola won, there would not be a lot to redo that election.
53:05Jonah Goldberg: Mike, according to this latest batch of New York Times polls, this is nearly a dead heat. The Times has Mary Peltola up two points. Dan Sullivan, she's at 48. Dan Sullivan at 46. if this, if it's a tight race, if it's a race that tight, virtual guarantee that there will be a huge fight about this race, both because of, for the reasons that Sarah suggests, also because even before this was known and reported, the Trump administration was challenging some of this because of the present, the mere presence of two Dan Sullivan's in the Trump Justice Department seemed to think that it could foretell the will of the voters in that context.
53:53Jonah Goldberg: But we're almost certain to have a big fight over this thing and it could determine or help determine who controls the U.S. Senate. Is this, are we just, I mean, we're sitting here, it's late afternoon on Monday, November 2nd. Is this just, are we just now on the front end of just a long slog looking at Alaska, these kinds of issues, and probably a bunch of others too, because California house districts aren't going to be able to call their races. Donald Trump is almost certain to step in and point to the non-citizen voter things that he's been raising now for months. Is this, I mean, election day is tomorrow.
54:31Jonah Goldberg: It'd be nice to think that we could have some understanding of what happened in the early vote and on election day tomorrow, you know, by Thursday. Is that likely possible? Not happening? I mean, my inclination is to say whatever the worst possible scenario you can think of, it's what we're going to be living through. For the sins of us and our fathers and our grandfathers, we're all suffering through this for that reason. Look, I think there is a likelihood that the margins in terms of control of the Senate will be close. And the races that will determine, you know, what those margins are, you know, will Democrats have the majority or Republicans keep it?
55:22Those races will also be close. That's Alaska, it's Michigan, it could be Kansas as well, Texas. So I just think we're in for a long period of not quite knowing what the results are. And some of that is going to be is going to be legitimate. But there are a lot of problems and questions as well with regard to mail-in voting that I think the USPS, there has been some talking down in Florida, frustration in Broward County. Remember Broward County and elections where they're encouraging people to vote in person because mail ballots weren't delivered or weren't delivered in a timely manner. And so I just think it's going to be, I would say to listeners, strap in, get ready to have a sort of a long period.
56:19And I will love to be proven wrong on this. I would love for everything to be wrapped up on Thursday. And we know who's going to be in control. The margins are going to be wide enough that there's really not going to be much of a debate, but I just think things have closed quite a bit in these last final days. And these real unforced errors on the part of Democrats, particularly Mary Poltola, I can't think of a dumber move by just about anybody in recent years in politics than this effort and putting it all in writing. And it's going to cast doubt on the results there. And so we've got bad actors in places like the Justice Department and in the White House.
57:05And so we're going to suffer the consequences of all these bad actors and stupid people.
57:10Sarah Isgur: Also, it's worth noting that because this is ranked choice voting, I think people have sort of said that maybe this doesn't matter because anyone who votes for Daniel Sullivan will rank number two for Dan Sullivan. I have no idea why anyone thinks that would be the case. If you are moving quickly, you could very easily rank Daniel Sullivan first and then Mary Peltola second. if you're trying to vote for Dan Sullivan. You could also be voting for Daniel Sullivan, intending, like, as a protest vote, because you're a Democrat, and vote for Mary Peltola second. So the ballots will look identical, and we will have no idea what the voter intent was, which, again, is going to lead to the worst-case scenario, Steve, that you are talking about, which is control for the Senate falls to Alaska.
57:54Sarah Isgur: Mary Peltola is the winner by the vote count. And people do not accept that because there's a lot of reason to think that she committed crimes or her team committed crimes to do so.
58:08Jonah Goldberg: Jonah, do you expect that we will know who controls, which party controls the Senate by Thanksgiving and the House of Representatives by Thanksgiving? Yes. You do? Yeah. Boy, you're such an optimist. Look at you. I am so happy to be wrong, but you're just basically asking me. That's a glass half full guy. No, I'm just, you're asking me basically, do I think the Democrats are going to win decisively enough that it doesn't boil down to Piltola, which I think is probably the case, and that they win decisively enough that we're not counting ballots in Kansas or Michigan forever. And I honestly think given just the, I mean, it's the vibes to be sure, because I don't trust all these last minute polls and gambling on, you know, early voting totals.
59:06That way lies madness. but it feels, if you just look at, there's not a set of data out there that doesn't suggest that basically every demographic that wants to vote Democratic is performing it at or above 2024 levels. And the demographic that Trump relies upon most is at or below conventional midterm levels. That makes me feel like it's a wave and a lot of, you know, races that are going to surprise us are going to tip towards the Democrats. And if that happens, I don't think we will have to wait till Thanksgiving.
59:49Jonah Goldberg: But I could be wrong. Trump built his coalition on low propensity voters. Fair to assume that low propensity voters might not show up, even as he's told them to imagine that he's on the ballot. All right, we're going to take a quick break, but we'll be back soon with more from the Dispatch podcast. Fox 1 has your front row seats on live NFL action. The biggest rivalries, the biggest hits. America's game of the week. From the opening kickoff to the final drive. Catch every game-changing play as it happens. Go beyond the box score with highlights, interviews, and expert analysis you won't find anywhere else.
1:00:27At home or on the go, live or on demand. The NFL on Fox is streaming live on Fox 1. Download the app today.
1:00:36Jonah Goldberg: When bad weather is coming, there's a familiar ritual. Find the flashlights, charge a backup battery, and make sure there's coffee. We're good at preparing for an inconvenience we can picture, but what about a disruption we can't? If people depend on your income, life insurance is one way to think ahead about their financial future. Ethos makes exploring life insurance a lot less intimidating. You can get a quote in seconds, apply in minutes, and potentially get coverage the same day. There's no medical exam, you just answer a few health questions online. Depending on your need, coverage can reach$3 million, and some policies start as low as$30 a month.
1:01:11Jonah Goldberg: A flashlight might get you through a dark evening. Life insurance can help provide financial security if the people you love ever face something much, much bigger. Take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through Ethos. Get your free quote at ethos.com slash dispatch. That's E-T-H-O-S dot com slash dispatch. application times may vary rates may vary and we're back you're listening to the dispatch podcast let's jump in okay finally for not worth your time this is a gift to sarah we are going to do a substantive election related news driven not worth your time i'm not going to ask you about food
1:01:57Jonah Goldberg: predictions i think this is genuinely not worth our time we don't do a lot of this stuff but let's do it. What are your predictions on the House? Give me a number. Give me a ballpark. What are your predictions? I mean, I would control. And then what are your predictions on numbers in the Senate? Sarah, you start.
1:02:16Sarah Isgur: My real prediction is that I think Democrats will have a very good night and they will control the House and the Senate. But I will make a just an important prediction for my own mental health, which is that 2026, if you're a person who was looking at American politics and thought, yeah, I want to run for public office this cycle, that's not great. I don't trust you, probably. And so just, again, because we can't have nice things, because it is 2026, my personal protection prediction is that both El-Sayed and Paxton win, which is the worst case scenario for America, like politics and rewarding good behavior and not rewarding bad behavior as people are thinking about running in 28 or 30.
1:03:09If if Paxton and El-Sayed win, that's then the roadmap for how to win public office
1:03:17Sarah Isgur: in America.
1:03:18Jonah Goldberg: OK, Jonah, I'm going to you next because you were just so upbeat and optimistic a moment ago. Do you have anything more to give us to move us beyond Sarah's abject cynicism? Oh, no. I mean, look, if we want to have a cynicism off, I'm ready. I mean, I was just saying that the one potential scenario of why everything is going to go to hell wasn't the most likely one in my mind. Which made me optimistic. I was glad to hear. Yeah. Well, like, yeah. I mean, I think the, you know, I don't know what the final number will be, but I think the House number is going to be much larger than basically everything that we've been talking about for the last six months.
1:04:08You know, people have been saying 12 to 18 because of the gerrymandered this and the polarization that and yada, yada, yada. And I think it is going to beat the historical average, which is like 22 or 24, depending upon where you start from. So I think it's going to be closer to the high, like a 28 seat, maybe a 30, maybe even north of that. Um, and on the Senate side, Mike, uh, I know the polling says Susan Collins loses. And I, if I were, I would not bet a lot of money that she wins, but I kind of feel like she still might. And so I think, but I think it's going to be basically 52 Senate seats for the Democrats.
1:04:54I could be, I can see scenarios where like if some of this Louisiana and Mississippi stuff is remotely real, you know, you could see it going to 54, 55. I don't think that's going to happen, but I think 52 is very possible.
1:05:10Jonah Goldberg: I mean, there's actual polling suggesting that South Carolina could be. up. Hard as that. I mean, one of the good things about, I mean, just because you want to do this nightmare scenario stuff about not counting votes and stuff, it's going to be really hard to make the argument that South Carolina election officials or Texas election officials rigged the election for the Democrats. I mean, like these states that have not been, not had a Democrat in statewide office for 20, 30, 40 years, somehow, you know, Kansas, which is not elected as a Democratic senator since for a century. You're going to tell me that like, oh, the deep state got in there and this time around, I mean, I mean, it'll be easy to make the argument.
1:05:56Jonah Goldberg: Trump will make it, but he made it in 2020. Yeah. You know, states that Republicans won. He said he lost. I mean, there doesn't have to be a logic applied to Donald Trump's thinking on these matters. I know. I just think the effectiveness of it is, they've passed the point of diminishing returns. It'll feel like shtick, like so much of his other stuff feels like, like tired shtick now. Um, if he tries to go full election denier at Italian satellites and yada, yada, yada, um, I just think it'll blow up in his face. Jonah, you're making me more optimistic. I love it. We should talk more often. Um, Mike, neither Jonah nor Sarah gave us a number.
1:06:37Jonah Goldberg: Jonah gave us a number. Jonah gave us a number. Jonah gave you something. Number. Just now, I mean. Don't blow my cover. Children. We're in sixth grade.
1:06:50Sarah Isgur: My six-year-old says it means shut up when someone shows you that finger.
1:06:58Jonah Goldberg: Mike, do you have numbers for us? What's your guess? So in the House, 25-seat majority for the Democrats is my prediction. And I find it easier to go through the competitive Senate races and tell you how I think they're going to go. And, of course, all with the caveat that I will likely be completely wrong on some, if not all of them. But my predictions, Maine, Collins wins that seat. Let's see. North Carolina, that goes to the Democrats. Cooper, Georgia, Ossoff wins re-election. South Carolina, Graham wins, but it's very, very, very, very close. In Florida, the governor's race is going to be a lot closer than people think.
1:07:47I think Donald's wins, but it's going to be like really nail-bitingly close. Let's see. Let me go through. Ohio, I believe Vivek Ramaswamy loses that race to Amy Acton. and Sherrod Brown wins by a hair. Let's see, Syed wins in Michigan. In Kansas, Adam Hamilton beats Roger Marshall. In Nebraska, Pete Ricketts, the Republican incumbent, beats Dan Osborne, the independent but Democratic-leading candidate there. Texas, Tallarico wins, but Abbott, the governor, narrowly wins as well. So there's some split ticket voters there. Things are close as in Mississippi and Louisiana, but not as not close enough to actually help Democrats win in those races.
1:08:35A bit of a mirage there. Let's see, Alaska. I think Sullivan actually pulls it out. And all of this discussion on what happened in Alaska will sort of be, I mean, legally or not, I don't know, but it will politically sort of be for naught. It will be very close in Minnesota. But the Democrat Flanagan will win in that Senate race. And I think that's about it. Did you say Hinson wins in Iowa? Oh, I forgot Iowa. Of course. Okay. So Hinson wins the Senate race. Happens all the time. Yeah, yeah. I know. But I've been talking about it all year, so I should have remembered it. Hinson wins, but Rob Sand, the Democratic candidate for governor, wins as well.
1:09:15So that's another split, like in Texas, another split ticket election there. And there we go.
1:09:21Jonah Goldberg: And so on the Senate, I think I've got you 51-49. Yeah. And then Fetterman switches parties and we have a Republican majority. And then Murkowski switches and then we have another.
1:09:31Sarah Isgur: I think Mike, I think Collins' luck runs out. That's the only one that I really disagree with Mike on is that Jackson beat Collins in Maine. Yeah, and by the way, that one and the Alaska race are the two that I could see going the other way and I'd be perfectly fine with. I think you're right on Alaska. It feels like Sullivan's going to win that one, but we'll see.
1:09:54Jonah Goldberg: I've got... 53-47 Dems with Collins hanging on in Maine, Sullivan losing, Hinson losing, Al-Sayed winning, Sherrod Brown winning, and the other ones tracking with Mike. And then on the house, I think it's 240, 240 plus total, which I think could be a big deal. we'll see how many fights there are over the districts in California, which I think that is where Trump is going to make his stand. They bring it on themselves by their inability or unwillingness to count votes in an efficient way.
1:10:38Sarah Isgur: Such a good way to phrase it.
1:10:39Jonah Goldberg: But you can imagine what Donald Trump is going to say. I mean, Alaska has an excuse. Right, right. You know, Alaska, it's got grizzly bears. it's got, you know, puddle jumping planes and remote wilderness and whatever.
1:10:54Sarah Isgur: Don't sleep on the moose. They kill people too. Moose kill people too. It's true. Here's one last prediction. At the end of the day, I do think the most important poll will be the one on election day. So you can take that one to the bank.
1:11:07Jonah Goldberg: That's good. It's going to come down to turnout. I have this theory it comes down to turnout. It's going to come down to turnout. We're going to get in. What about the day of Waukesha County? Just because of hand gestures. Turd out. Wow. Write that one down. That's what the premium members are paying for. The other prediction I will make, I'll make a final prediction. We are going to be doing an election night live stream from 9 until 11, at least 11. Sarah and I are going to co-host it. Jonah is going to join when he's freed from his CNN duties. Mike will be there. We have a good cast of characters from Dispatch World and the greater Dispatch universe.
1:11:46Jonah Goldberg: And I think in spite of some grim thoughts here, we'll have a good time doing it. So if you are clicking around, join us tomorrow night, Dispatch live stream. You can come to, well, I'll tell you where to go later when I read this thing after I know where to send you. Or I know where to send you.
1:12:13Jonah Goldberg: Finally, if you want to support what we're doing here, you can rate, review, and subscribe to the show on your podcast player of choice to help new listeners find us. And for those of you who want to watch the show, check us out on YouTube. Head over to youtube.com slash atthedispatchpods or just Google us, The Dispatch Podcast on YouTube. As always, if you've got questions, comments, concerns, or corrections, you can email us at roundtable at thedispatch.com. We read everything, even emails from people far more cynical than Jonah Goldberg. That's going to do it for today's show. Thanks so much for tuning in.
1:12:47Jonah Goldberg: And thank you to the folks behind the scenes who made this episode possible, Noah Hickey and Peter Bonaventure. Thanks again for listening. Please join us next time.
1:13:31I'll see you next time.
1:13:37I never do. So buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply. See our seven-day return policy at Carvana.com. Big news. Wayfair's Black Friday sale is here. Right now, get up to 80 % off everything you need for the season ahead. Save on kitchen and dining, bedroom furniture and mattresses, seasonal decor, and way more. All at Wayfair. These are Wayfair's best deals of the year. From seasonal finds to favorites you'll use all year long. Plus, enjoy fast and free shipping with delivery in time for the holidays. Save up to 80 % off during Wayfair's Black Friday sale now at wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home.
Steve Hayes is joined by Jonah Goldberg, Sarah Isgur, and Mike Warren to discuss Haley Stevens’ endorsement of Mike Rogers and whether this will affect the race for a Michigan Senate seat for Tuesday’s midterm elections.
The Agenda:
—Endorsing Mike Rogers
—Will this change election results?
—What Abdul El-Sayed did wrong
—Mary Peltola’s ballot scheme
—When will we know results?
—NWYT: Predictions
Show notes:
—Latest New York Times poll
—Join us for an election night livestream!
The Dispatch Podcast is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a nonpartisan perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including audio versions of all our articles and newsletters—click here. If you’d like to remove all ads from your podcast experience, consider becoming a premium Dispatch member by clicking here.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices