Gated vs. Ungated Content

0:00Duct tape marketing really helped me shave at least six to eight months off of work that I was dreading. After leaving the corporate world, even before I participated in the agency intensive training, I had already landed my first customer. This, in essence, more than paid for my investment in duct tape marketing. What you just heard was a testimonial from a recent graduate of the duct tape marketing certification intensive program for fractional CMOs, marketing agencies, and consultants. Just like them, you can choose our system to move from vendor to trusted advisor, attract only ideal clients and confidently present your strategies to build monthly recurring revenue.

0:40Visit dtm.world slash scale to book your free advisory call and learn more. It's time to transform your approach. Book your call today, dtm.world slash scale.

1:03Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Chance. My guest today is Jonathan Gandolf. He's the founder and CEO of The Juice, a B2B content platform. On a career path that has wandered through digital marketing, craft beer, and content marketing, he and the team at The Juice are now solving marketers' biggest pain points when it comes to distribution, reach, and audience engagement. So, Jonathan, welcome to the show. John, thanks so much for having me. I'm excited to be here. So I don't always start with this question, but I think in your case, I better start with if somebody came up and you said, so Jonathan, what do you do for a living?

1:40How would you describe what you do or more specifically, maybe what the juice is? Yeah. At our core, we sell marketing to marketers, which is, I always try to tiptoe around the question of what do you do, but maybe a slightly longer explanation. Everything we do as consumers is curated for us, whether you're looking for news, music, movies, home, fashion, traveling. There's a website, right? That connects buyer and seller based on the buyer's information, right? Or what they are interested in, or maybe it connects creator and consumer. I was a B2B marketer and I was just sitting here, man, we create a piece of content, we put it on our website, create a piece of content, put it on our website.

2:22It's like, why are we all fighting each other to send traffic to our own website? Let's get all the content in one place and then let's let software play matchmaker between the creator and consumer, buyer and seller. And so that's what we've built. So long answer, probably a long answer to a short question, but I try to say we're like Spotify for B2B content. Yeah. That's, you've always got to use the, we're like Airbnb, but for. Exactly. Exactly. Very cliche to do that. But yeah, guilty as charged. So if somebody were to ask you, what's the state of content today? I know that's a giant question, but what are we going through?

2:57We had the point where we're like, content was king. No, no, no, contest air. That's what? I mean, so how to, again, when you talk about the biggest pain point solving it. What's the state of content today? We'll have to get into AI and things like that, but just generally speaking, what's the state? Evolving, I would say, would be the one word. I think how I sometimes summarize it up, HubSpot created inbound marketing movement around 2010, 2012, somewhere in there. And it was really novel when it first started to create a piece of content, drive inbound traffic, get information. And it works really well, but it works so well that everybody started doing it.

3:35And it feels like that's ran its course now. And now different channels are emerging. I think different content formats are emerging as well as emerging technologies. So I just think it's all changing very quickly. But I think the punchline is that good content, and I think I define that as content that educates or entertains, still resonates and still works. How you deliver it might be changing, how somebody consumes it might be changing, but good content still works. Yeah. I think unfortunately the message a lot of people here is, oh, I just need more. And I think that sort of goes against what you just stated, isn't it?

4:09I totally agree. I think more for the sake of more. There's a lot of people caught on that content hamster wheel. I call it create just because of the status quo. And I think that's not the right motion to be stuck in. I'm only four minutes into the show and we'll start talking about AI just because it has such impact. It has impact on many areas of business, but it clearly on content as a place that it is impacted. How do you talk about the role of AI in content creation? There are so many different ways you can use it. I view it more as an operational efficiency as opposed to a creator, right?

4:43There are ways you can use it to create SEO content at scale. There are ways you can use it to create blogs at scale, but I view it more as an operational efficiency. I think you might be doing this, taking this podcast recording and turning it into a transcript and then atomizing that transcript into newsletter copy, ad copy, social copy, whatever. That kind of operational efficiency, I think there's a ton of opportunity there. But I almost view that as that's almost like as much a technology as it is a CMO technology. That's a operational activity. The one that I think goes under discussed or isn't being discussed enough is how consumers, how marketing consumers of content are using AI.

5:25I think it's going to have some search implications and we're starting to see some of that come to life. I think the other thing is, and this is something we talk a lot about at The Juice, is if somebody comes across a 20-page ebook, are they going to sit down and read that? Or are they going to drop that link into their favorite GPT and say, hey, give me the five takeaways, give me the key insights from this? And so then it's does the type of content we should be producing that still is human-created change altogether. I think there's still some level setting to happen there on how consumers are using AI in their day-to-day.

5:58Yeah, I think that's a really great point. So maybe the five key points I was going to write about are now on one page, right? Exactly, yeah. Yeah. So let me flip that. I asked about the role of AI. What's the role of humans now? That's a loaded question. I'll share with you what I share with some of our customers. I always say share what you know. So I think your own knowledge, your own wisdom that you've gained over lived experience, I think sometimes we discount that as humans because it can't be put in a spreadsheet. Like we'll say, oh, I made that decision off of gut instinct. It's gut instinct, but it's gut instinct derived from years of experiences and years of similar decisions that you've made.

6:38So I think that should carry just as much weight as sometimes what you can put in a spreadsheet. So I think taking that experience, that wisdom and knowledge and sharing it is always really good. as well as templates. We see on our platform templates outperform any other type of content by a factor of about 3x. So I think a lot of times people are, they want to learn from each other, right? And the ability to share that knowledge is really powerful. And then the last one I'll mention is proprietary data. That's still the one thing that AI can't replicate, at least not yet. If your platform or your product or your service creates this proprietary data set that you can look at and analyze and create unique insights that can't be replicated.

7:18And so we're always trying to coach customers on sharing content that has a data in it like that. Just don't share it with the GPT. It's true, right? Like once that's not going to all get aggregated, it's going to be interesting to see. Yeah. We're all going to learn. So one of the challenges I think for a lot of marketers today is that people are consuming content in their, the way they want to, the journey they want to go on, the format they want to consume it in. And so it really makes, it's almost like you can't produce a piece of content. You have to produce a piece of content that is repackaged into 40 pieces of content or different formats, at least.

7:54What's your take on the most effective way to maybe do that, particularly when it comes to distribution, which is a big part of what you do? I would say great content doesn't convert. If you're creating content to convert, it's become very trendy to say great content converts. And I think if conversion is your goal, with a piece of content, like I think you're going into it with the wrong intent. I say great content educates and entertains. And you're right. So much of what is happening, how buyers buy right now is changing so much. And so much of it happens in that dark funnel or in that dark social or just outside of your periphery that you just have to create quality content and then having an immense amount of trust in your team and your product to convert to them when they are ready to be converted.

8:40I think the days of pushing literally, maybe not literally, but figuratively pushing somebody through a pipeline or through a funnel with content, I think that's an old school way to think about how buyers are interacting with content nowadays. Yeah. I don't think the customer journey is very linear. That's for darn sure. I always say that you talked about the great content converts. What I always say is trust converts. And that's really what great content does. I might be stealing that one. You can go for it. Let's talk about for years, it was so novel to actually make somebody opt in to get a piece of content and we would do it by the millions.

9:18Now people, we see it when we test it that people will turn away from a form today. However, as marketers, there's always that. But if I don't capture the lead, I can't continue to market it to them. So where do you fall on gated versus none? We published a 23 page ebook in the fall about gated versus ungated content. So what's interesting about - Wait, did you have to opt in for it or not? So I'll get, that's the punchline. That's the punchline. I'm going to get there. I will get there. So we, the unique thing about our platform is you sign up for it once and everything's ungated. And we have what, we have resources that were originally gated or ungated on our platform.

9:53So it's a level playing field. It was over 300 ,000 resources. We saw that ungated content actually is 26 % more engaging than gated content. So we as marketers were making this decision to put what we thought was more engaging content behind a form. On a level playing field, it's actually not the more engaging content. It's just content that we have arbitrarily decided to gate, right? And I think what's happened, I mentioned this a little bit earlier, is when gated content was novel, it worked, right? I think it became so ubiquitous that now content consumers know what's happening when they put their data in a form.

10:30They're going to get a call. They're going to get an email. They're going to be in a drip. And I've done it. I've seen it in our own forms. You get things like Daffy Duck, James Bond, Mark Zuckerberg filled out on the form. And then you end up passing that spreadsheet to the sales team. The sales team says, this is low quality. And it actually is, it's diminishing trust between sales and marketing. So we found the content that was ungated was actually more engaging. and I still think there's a time and place to gate content. If you're adding value with that information, so if you're getting something like job function and that allows you to pass along a piece of content to that person that's specific to that job function, compensation reports are a great example of that.

11:12I think that's a way to do it. If it's actually customizing their web experience on your website, so if you're getting something about them that allows the rest of the experience to be custom, I think that's good. But if you're just getting the information and passing it to your sales team, I would not gate content. So we had this interesting, we were really proud of this report. It's something we're still really proud of. And we were like a week and a half out from launching it. And somebody on our team asked, wait, are we gating this? And we all just looked around the room. Wait a second. Are we gating this?

11:40Like we had spent all this time and energy on this report and we hadn't even thought ourselves. And we said, the data says the ungated content's more engaging. So it's an ungated report. And that's where we fall on it. But I was actually really impressed by the nuance of the conversations we had with marketers on it. And I am more of the belief now that there is a time to gate content and a time to un-gate content. For us, we've made the decision to have most of our content un-gated. I don't know if we can call this a bullet point or if this is a whole other topic. Where's this evolving thing called generative search going to lead us?

12:16If I never have to actually visit a piece of content, does it exist? Yeah, what is it? I think it's 67 % of Google searches end without a click now. Not an SEO expert, and I'm not an AI expert. What I have said is that the SEO game is changing. If I had limited resources as a marketer in terms of financial, I would not be increasing my investment in SEO right now. But the behavior of search from our consumers will never go away. They're always going to be searching, right? I don't know where or where the results they're going to be getting or coding to come from three years from now, two years from now, one year from now.

12:52But the behavior of search isn't going away. I would just be cautious about investing in the current model of search. Yeah, yeah. So one of the things that's always been a challenge, it's like if you run an ad, somebody clicks on the ad and buys something, attribution's pretty simple. Content, I went here, then I went here, then I went and got lunch, then I came back and did this. It's like, how do you approach attribution, especially when we are trying to get to that ultimate conversion? I'm going to give a super unsophisticated answer here, but to me, and this wouldn't have been my answer probably two years ago, but we've learned a lot of the juice.

13:28Just ask. I think set up the system so that you can have a good educated guess at where that should be attributed, but whether it's in a form or whether it's in a conversation or in an onboarding call, just ask and let them tell you. And it's still going to be an exact, they might've seen a display ad that they don't remember that led them to LinkedIn, that led them to following somebody on your team, but self-reported attribution, I've become a really big fan of and just taking the time and asking. And with traditional marketers, this is a bit controversial, but I sometimes wonder if we're trying too hard to get attribution when maybe it doesn't matter.

14:10If we're doing all the right things, if we're actually putting ourselves in the path of where we think people are going, Do we actually have to know exactly how they got there? Because I think sometimes just what you said, if the first thing on the drop down menu is a Google ad, most people are going to choose that. And does that actually lead us to making wrong decisions as opposed to saying, let's cover the journey as thoroughly as we can in the best way we think we can, and then hope it converts. I'm biased, but I think that's part of the magic of marketing, right? Is that it is a gray science.

14:43And I think if you try to over-engineer the attribution too much to make it black and white, you're going to end up with really boring results and boring outputs from that. I think you, like you said, you have to have the trust that this blend of everything that you're doing is going to give you the results that your team needs. So I'm a content marketer or an agency. Pitch me on what I would get if I came to the juice and had you help me with my marketing. Absolutely. So the juice is going to sync with where you're already publishing content. We don't host your content. We're just pulling in the metadata and then presenting it to our audience.

15:19We've got almost 100 ,000 sales and marketing leaders on our platform who've come to our platform because they're looking for content, right? But they might not know your brand exists. They might not find it in search. But what we do is we play matchmaker between a high quality engaged audience and brands trying to reach that audience. And we've got insight into both sides. And then we just play matchmaker. and we're going to distribute your content for you that you're already doing without changing your behavior. You're going to get access to an engaged audience and we're going to play matchmaker for you.

15:48Awesome. Jonathan, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. Is there anywhere you'd invite people to find out more or connect with you? Sure. Reach out to me on LinkedIn and then you can visit our platform as a user and start receiving content recommendations. It's free. It's app.thejuicehq.com. Awesome. Again, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by and hopefully we'll run into you one of these days out there on the road. .