How Business Storytelling Builds Trust and Drives Results

10 Sep 2026 · 22 min · 11 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

How business storytelling builds trust and drives results, using Don Yeager’s framework from his book The Business of Storytelling: Inspire Action, Build Trust, and Drive Results Through Story.

Guest

Don Yeager—national speaker; Hall of Fame inductee; 13-time New York Times bestselling author; longtime associate editor at Sports Illustrated.

Key claims

Credentials/data don’t guarantee persuasion; better storytelling does. AI can’t tell your story for you because it lacks “heart.” Great stories are human, and the “story behind the story” (why/how/who) matters. Stories can turn value (eBay tchotchkes: $193.50 to $8,000 in four days). Businesses should tell origin, customer, and employee stories.

Notable examples

Yearbook research to connect with a CEO; Google reviews focused on personal service; Harry & David pears sent after a life-insurance call; Deion Sanders/Walter Payton referenced as storytelling benchmarks.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

The Power of Storytelling

0:00 to 0:28

Learn why storytelling is crucial for effective communication.

“So some people walk into a room with more credentials, more data, more experience maybe than anyone else there and still get ignored.”

Exploring the Business of Storytelling

0:45 to 1:50

Discussing Don Yeager's book on storytelling and its importance.

“I can go on and on about all books about some of our famous sports stars.”

Translating Storytelling for Everyone

1:50 to 3:25

Strategies for individuals to tell their authentic stories.

“Now, you, occupational hazard, let's call it that, have interviewed thousands of people.”

Techniques to Uncover Authentic Stories

3:25 to 4:55

Methods for pulling true stories from interviewees.

“And certainly I have people that have a story they need to tell, particularly thinking about the person that needs to pull a story.”

Researching Unique Stories

4:55 to 6:50

How to find and utilize personal stories in interviews.

“Are you going to try to get me to cry, Don?”

The Effectiveness of Storytelling

6:50 to 8:35

Understanding why storytelling connects us on a human level.

“So the idea of actually finding their unique websites out there, almost any one of these CEOs is on a charity board.”

Mastering Storytelling Across Contexts

8:35 to 10:27

Benefits of storytelling in various aspects of life.

“I mean, you know, obviously storytelling in the boardroom, storytelling, you know, on a, you know, reporting, you know, call of the numbers and whatnot, but just even like making a connection in a sales call.”

Universal Truths of Storytelling

10:27 to 14:00

Exploring the four universal truths that underpin effective storytelling.

“So let's get to, we kind of flirted with them a little bit, but maybe you could unpack.”

The Power of Personal Stories in Business

14:00 to 17:08

Learn why personal and human stories enhance connection and trust in business.

“I kept the key because it meant something to me.”

Essential Stories Every Business Needs

17:08 to 19:16

Discover the key stories every business should have to share effectively.

“I would say, number one, you know, we all would agree, the origin story.”
Show all 11 chapters

Overcoming Discomfort in Storytelling

19:16 to 20:54

Get advice on how to create impactful stories even if storytelling feels uncomfortable.

“And in fact, let me show you the posters which explain all of our core values, all 28 of our core values, right?”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00John Jantsch:So some people walk into a room with more credentials, more data, more experience maybe than anyone else there and still get ignored. Somebody else with less of all three changes minds instead and the difference always comes down to who knew how to tell a better story.

0:27John Jantsch:Hello and welcome to the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantz and my guest today is Don Yeager, a repeat guest, national speaker, Hall of Fame inductee, 13-time New York Times bestselling author and longtime associate editor at Sports Illustrated. I can go on and on about all books about some of our famous sports stars. But for the purpose of this show, we're going to talk about his latest book, The Business of Storytelling, Inspire Action, Build Trust, and Drive Results Through Story. So welcome back, Don.

1:02Don Yaeger:Hey, thanks, John. I always appreciate the opportunity to spend a little time with you.

1:06John Jantsch:Well, so let's dive right into the book. You have some universal truths in this book. It's kind of based around that or structured around that. And this is the one that I wanted to test. It says no formula governs a great story, but then you give us like 10 elements to build a great story. So how do you square those two things? Ten elements are not a formula.

1:29Don Yaeger:The formula is plus, you know, insert hero here, insert challenge there, and out comes transformation.

1:36John Jantsch:Right, right, right.

1:37Don Yaeger:These are elements that allow a great story to come together. And I just know these elements to be true. And you cannot really tell a great story without covering that waterfront.

1:50John Jantsch:Now, you, occupational hazard, let's call it that, have interviewed thousands of people. You've heard thousands of stories and some of the people that you've chronicled books are amazing storytellers. So how do you translate that to the person that maybe certainly doesn't have that background, but maybe doesn't have a communications team, is really just kind of trying to be more authentic in a world of AI? I mean, how do you translate that to them?

2:21Don Yaeger:Well, first off, thanks for saying those words, because I think that's a real driver in all of it, right? I mean, I think there are so many people that think I'm going to see that. I'm going to I'm going to ask AI to tell my story for me. And the one thing I will promise you is that the one is that AI cannot tell your story for you. In fact, if you lean into it, you may or may not have any control about what your story shows up to be when you're when you're suddenly introduced. AI, as we know, likes to make things up. But on top of that, it also has weaknesses that remain and will probably always remain.

2:56Don Yaeger:The one thing AI can't do is bring heart to the equation, right? Obviously, it's not very insightful of me to say that a computer can't bring heart to the equation. But that's what a great story does, right? A great story takes statistics and numbers and everything else, and it wraps them in a heart. and that ability to kind of humanize a good story belongs to us.

3:22John Jantsch:So, you know, I think there are two ends of this because I have listeners that need to pull a story out of somebody. And certainly I have people that have a story they need to tell, particularly thinking about the person that needs to pull a story. When you start interviewing somebody, I'm guessing there are some people that just get right to the heart of it. I'm sure there are also some people that put up a mask and it's like, here's the story. Here's the story I want you to hear. I mean, how do you actually get to the real story when you, or do you just realize, hey, they're not going to tell me anything.

3:56John Jantsch:I'm done.

3:56Don Yaeger:So I don't give up on it. One thing I, one thing, you know, if you do the right prep work, right, you're listening to somebody or you're reading stories with someone's interview involved. One thing that happens is you become really clear. like these are the stories they're just used to telling, right? These are the ones that it's like, you know, they pull a little cord and then, you know, it just spews out. And at the end of the day, what I'm always trying to do is be aware of those stories so that if they start going there, I can immediately kind of start to shift it in another direction. I do not want the story everybody else gets when they're in conversation with John Jatch, right?

4:34Don Yaeger:I'm looking for something that I can pull from you that you may not have wanted to say when this conversation began. I have lots of experience doing that, but I think the real key is you have to know what you don't want in order to really start beginning to drive people to where you hope to get. And so research is an enormous part of what I do when I'm trying to pull a good story from someone.

5:03John Jantsch:Are you going to try to get me to cry, Don? Is that the goal?

5:05Don Yaeger:It will not be long, brother. I'm going to make that happen. So get ready, get your tissues out.

5:11John Jantsch:So let me push back just a moment because, I mean, you're interviewing, you know, Deion Sanders, Walter Payton. There's a lot out there about them. I mean, you can find all the stuff, but what about the CEO of a small, you know, private company? There's not a lot maybe out there? How do you do that research and prepare when there's not much to know?

5:33Don Yaeger:So first off, I would disagree with you that in today's day and age, you know what they ate for lunch, right? In today's day and age, there are so many places you can go. I did an interview this morning, or I was on with someone this morning in which I actually, I shared with her, hey, you know, I saw in Classmates, and you may not even know it, Classmates actually shows you the yearbooks of people, you know, dating back 100 years. And I said, hey, I was looking at Georgia Christian High School where you graduated in 2005. I saw the yearbook and I noticed that you were not just a three-sport athlete.

6:10Don Yaeger:You were also a homecoming queen. And like, she was blown away. But it was a simple website. It's not a difficult one to get to, not a difficult one to track. It wasn't stalking. It's a yearbook. The yearbooks are available in libraries. And so she just understood that I had taken time to learn something about her. She wasn't even aware other people might know. And it gave me an opportunity to talk about being a three-sport athlete myself. And, you know, I was not homecoming queen, but I, you know. And then between that, suddenly we go from, I know something about her. I've now connected to her because we both have something in common.

6:49Don Yaeger:And then it allows me to go into different places in the interview process. So the idea of actually finding their unique websites out there, almost any one of these CEOs is on a charity board.

7:02John Jantsch:Yeah.

7:02Don Yaeger:There's amazing things you'll find about them in the charity board website.

7:06John Jantsch:Yeah, they put personal details down there sometimes, right? Yeah.

7:10Don Yaeger:Right. And about the things that they've done for the charity that might be really inspirational. And if I can know that, again, it's very public knowledge. I'm not finding stuff that isn't available to everyone else. I'm just doing it well enough that at the end of the day, they realize I've cared for them by learning about them.

7:30John Jantsch:So let's get back to the book, but one more stop. Let's unpack a little bit in your mind why storytelling is so effective. You know, the neuroscience actually even, you know, behind it, not just as a tool, but really as a, you know, I mean, just part of our human nature.

7:48Don Yaeger:Yeah, absolutely. Well, I mean, think about it. It is the one thing that's been true over the history of mankind is that we relay knowledge through story. We relay history through story. We build relationship through story. And, I mean, you go to the caves, you walk into the crypts, and you see things that will blow your mind because you'll understand that this was the way history was recorded. It's just as true today. The way that I want you to understand me is through story. The way I hope I can relate to you is through story. And some people might argue that they don't need to know how to do this, that it's just a nice to have.

8:32Don Yaeger:I argue that it's an imperative. In today's day and age, revenue changes hands, money changes hands over storytelling.

8:41John Jantsch:Well, and just the human connection. I mean, you know, obviously storytelling in the boardroom, storytelling, you know, on a, you know, reporting, you know, call of the numbers and whatnot, but just even like making a connection in a sales call. You know, and my dad, you know, was an old kind of bag carrying salesperson. He'd walk in the office. First thing he did is like, here's Walter Payton's jersey. You got three kids. You got, you know, there's Muhammad Ali. It's like, I know how to connect with you now because I find that common thing. And, you know, it's corny as it and contrived maybe as it can sound.

9:16John Jantsch:You know, it just it speeds up the process of connection so much.

9:20Don Yaeger:Absolutely. And what happens? So, you know, sometimes we love to say people like to buy from people, you know, like them. Sure. People like them, right?

9:30John Jantsch:Yeah.

9:31Don Yaeger:So how do you make sure that they know that you're like them? You understand who they are and you try to draw that point of connection. So it's not just, again, this, it's funny. I started several years ago as I was really, I had been working for years to become known as a good storyteller, great storyteller. I've been fortunate, the likes of Simon Sinek, the likes of John Maxwell, people that I value greatly refer to me in that way. And that's awesome. But one of the things I started asking people is, would you be better as a salesperson if you could tell better stories? Would you be a better leader if you could tell better stories?

10:08Would you be a better parent if you could tell

10:11Don Yaeger:better stories? And the truth is, there almost is, there's not a question I could ask you where you would say no.

10:18John Jantsch:Yeah.

10:18Don Yaeger:There is, this is a skill that if mastered makes you better across the board.

10:27John Jantsch:So let's get to, we kind of flirted with them a little bit, but maybe you could unpack. You don't have to do them all, but just the book is based on these universal truths. So maybe kind of cover the range of those and maybe you can pick. I always like to ask authors to pick their favorite.

10:46Don Yaeger:Well, the universal truths, there are four of them and there are 10 elements, but for the four universal truths, the first one's extraordinary. I mean, it's just first one we would have to agree on between each other because I know it. I know you know it to be true. That's the best stories are always human. I could tell you a story about our productivity. I could tell you a story about how many more widgets we are producing today than we've ever produced before. But if I tell you how those widgets are changing lives for one family or for a user of our product or how producing more widgets is making more of our employees wealthy enough to be able to pull themselves out of poverty.

11:28Don Yaeger:If I can use, if I can build the story around people, it always remains more memorable.

11:36John Jantsch:Well, just go look at a dozen Google reviews of, say, like a, I don't know, a furnace company or something. And I will tell you that none of the five-star reviews will say this is the best company. They will say Rusty fixed our boiler. And he was, you know, he closed the door. He was so kind to my children. I mean, that proves your point, doesn't it? I mean, that's what people connected with.

Read the full transcript

12:00Don Yaeger:And it is. It's the every great story is human, right? So that's first and foremost. The second of the universal truths is that it is the story behind the story that is the story. You know, many people think I can, I'm going to tell you my story about my life. And often it's very linear, but it's the things that made that happen that absolutely, that's the real story. The story is what is, what's behind the curtain. And so you have to start asking you the questions, you know, why, how, who was involved in the, in the, And as you're telling the story and you start bringing some of those questions to the fore, you start finding the deeper story about why what you're doing matters and who it matters to.

12:45Don Yaeger:The third of the universal truth is that we argue all the time that there's money in storytelling.

12:51John Jantsch:Yes, yes.

12:52Don Yaeger:That is not. And there's, and we use a number of examples, but one that I love is a couple of journalists, a couple of researchers several years ago decided to take on a project and they took, they bought a hundred items off eBay, right? A hundred tchotchkes, little things worth nothing. I never paid more than, never paid more than$3 for a single item. Then they distributed those hundred items to guys like you and me, right? Storytellers. And, but they picked some really great ones. And in the distribution, they asked each person to take their tchotchke and create a story about its significance to them as the seller.

13:32Don Yaeger:And then they put them back on eBay. And while they spent$193.50 to start, they put them back on eBay. And the second go-round, they earned$8 ,000. $193 turned into$8 ,000 in four days because stories suddenly made this no longer was it a car key. It was the key to the most amazing vehicle I've ever owned in my life. And I had to sell the vehicle. I kept the key because it meant something to me. Now it's at a place in my life where I'd love, if you happen to be a fan of Maserati, I'd love for you to own this key so that you too. Anyway, you get it, right?

14:16John Jantsch:Well, wait a minute, though. That made me, the first bubble, thought bubble that went off in my head is, did the stories have to be true?

14:22Don Yaeger:No, in this particular case, they actually note in each story, this story was created for this item by author Doug Dorris or, you know, whoever it is. But they make it clear. Now, I argue that the good stories we want to tell have to be true. Well, of course. Now, could there occasionally be some embellishment for the terms, for the value of speeding something along? Yes. But, you know, we're not, we're in the process of developing true stories.

14:55John Jantsch:So, I'm not sure we got through all four truths, but I want to circle back to one thing. All the best stories, like you said, are human, but also they're probably personal for some people. And some people are, it's hard for them to tell them. They don't think anybody wants to know that part. They're afraid it'll make them look bad. But my guess is sort of the deeper or the more deeply personal, the more probably engagement.

15:22Don Yaeger:Without question, because, well, a couple of things happen. Number one, there's probably as you're telling the story, there's some piece of it that they have lived to. Right. So in some way, they are on the journey with you as you're telling your story. But secondly, they get a chance to know, they know something about you that they didn't know when the conversation began. And in the process, a connection is built. Right. And we've already discussed it a couple of different times. Commerce occurs when connection is built. Right. Yeah. And so if we can make sure that we are, we're finding ways to become in relationship.

15:57Don Yaeger:and sometimes my ability to share my cancer journey, especially if I know that you've been on, if you've had dealt with cancer, right? It will allow the two of us to, we have that moment together. And yes, every great story has to have you in it in some way.

16:14John Jantsch:Yeah, and I think from a business standpoint too, you know, a lot of times when somebody encounters a business, all they see is, wow, this is a great business. But the story behind it is the struggle that actually made it. So I think has real value, doesn't it?

16:28Don Yaeger:Absolutely. It's never, you know, there are a lot of people like to look at you, me, people and say, wow, what, how incredible that success is. But that grinding that occurred 20 years ago when we were struggling to try to figure out how we were going to pay that week's, that week's grocery bill. That's, that's, it's lost on most because we're so busy assuming that everything has always been that way for John Jantz or Don Yeager, right?

16:55John Jantsch:So for, particularly for a small business, do you, and I know you don't necessarily consult on, you know, with small business owners in that way, but certainly the book covers information for them. Do you, are there like three or four core stories that every business needs to have and be able to tell kind of at the drop of a hat?

17:15Don Yaeger:Completely. I would say, number one, you know, we all would agree, the origin story. You came together to solve, to patch a hole in the universe. What was the hole? And what made you understand the hole? Like what was, so when I say the story behind the story, don't tell me what you came along to solve. Tell me why you came along to solve it. What was it that made that happen? Number one. Number two, there's always a great story about some customer whose life changed by doing really well at what you do. Tell me the story about one of your customers. Number three, tell me the story about one of your employees.

17:57Don Yaeger:So many of these stories, they don't have to be about you, the owner. They're often more effective if they're about the people that have been part of the journey with you. And if you could tell me the story about one of your employees and how one of the things, I mean, I did some work the other day for a company that regularly they do call centers. They're working with people in life insurance. And they were so taken by trying to deal with a man who was struggling with the loss of his wife. And he was just trying to figure out what the policy looked like. The person on the phone just realized, you know what, I want to send something extra to this guy.

18:33Don Yaeger:And so I went online to Harry and David, sent some pairs to the man. the man writes a note to the CEO of the insurance company and says, there's no way she could have known this, but pears were my wife's favorite fruit. And that your employee was able to do something like that. That's a story the CEO now gets to tell.

18:52John Jantsch:Yes.

18:53Don Yaeger:And what it says is this is how we care for the people that we consider our policyholders, right? The people that are our stakeholders. And this is the freedom I give my employees to care for them.

19:04John Jantsch:Yeah.

19:04Don Yaeger:There's so much in that story that will make you attracted to his company more so than one of the others that it gives him a competitive advantage when he tells it well.

19:15John Jantsch:Well, and certainly goes way beyond any kind of words on a website, you know, of we care. We're the caring company, right?

19:23Don Yaeger:We're the caring company. Let me give you our slogan. And in fact, let me show you the posters which explain all of our core values, all 28 of our core values, right? none of which your employees can recite.

19:36John Jantsch:Yeah. So a lot of small business owners, and I wonder if we could wrap this up with you just kind of giving them advice. Don't like to talk about themselves. Don't think they have a story. So how does, if you were going to advise somebody whose job it was to create those core stories that the company should have, what do you think is the best way for them to get at that when there's really not any ready access to it?

20:01Don Yaeger:So one of the things you might want to do is just literally, there are lots of, right now, there are lots of unemployed writers in the world, right? There are a lot of writers looking for jobs because newspapers are closing, magazines are closing. There are a lot of people who understand how to take stories and help them. So there's plenty probably of access to talent. You can go to Fiverr and you can find all kinds of people. But more importantly, understand, the story doesn't have to be about you. If that's your place of discomfort, make the story about your customers. Make that story about your employees.

20:31Don Yaeger:As I said, make that story about the moment that it became apparent that this company needed to exist. And yes, you might be included in the story, but it's not about you. And if that's a point of discomfort for you, there are plenty of ways to let the world know how special you are without pumping yourself up.

20:54John Jantsch:Well, Don, I appreciate you taking a few moments to stop by. Is there someplace you'd invite people to find out more about your work and certainly pick up a copy of the Business of Storytelling?

21:02Don Yaeger:Well, Business of Storytelling is, as I love to say, available anywhere that good books are sold. If you go there and it's not there, it's not a good bookstore. But yeah, Amazon is a big part of our strategy. But they can also, I'd love if they're a friend of yours, reach out to me. I'm at donyeager.com and I own all spellings of my last name. So you can butcher it and you will probably still end up at my website. But it's donyeager.com.

21:32John Jantsch:Probably a lot of E's before the A.

21:34Don Yaeger:There is a lot of that.

21:36John Jantsch:Certainly. And I own that site. I own that site too, by the way. Just like I own D-U-C-K marketing as well. Because a lot of people still use that erroneously. So it directs to the right place. And I would also encourage, especially if you're a fan of good sports writing, certainly Don's entire catalog of books would have something for you there, too. So, well, Don, it was great for you taking a moment to stop by and hopefully we'll run into you again soon out there on the road.

22:05Don Yaeger:Always. Thanks, John.

From the publisher

Business storytelling helps leaders build trust, strengthen connection, and turn ideas into action when facts alone aren’t enough. Don Yaeger, author of The Business of Storytelling, explains why the most memorable stories are human, how to find the deeper story behind what your business does, and why storytelling can create a real competitive advantage. He shares the core stories every business should be able to tell—from its origin to the customers and employees who bring its values to life. For business owners, marketers, salespeople, and leaders, better storytelling can make it easier to connect with people, communicate what matters, and drive results.

00:00 Introduction

01:07 What Makes a Great Story in the Age of AI

03:21 How to Get the Real Story From Anyone

05:11 How to Research Anyone Before an Interview

07:30 Why Storytelling Is a Business Superpower

10:26 The Universal Truths of Great Storytelling

14:55 Why Personal Stories Build Stronger Connections

16:55 3 Stories Every Business Needs to Tell

19:36 How to Tell Your Business Story Without Bragging

Rate, Review, & Follow

If you liked this episode, please rate and review the show. Let us know what you loved most about the episode.

Struggling with strategy? Unlock your free AI-powered prompts now and start building a winning strategy today!

👉 Get Your Free Prompts: https://dtm.world/freeprompts

More from The Duct Tape Marketing Podcast

All 360 episodes
How Business Storytelling Builds Trust and Drives ResultsThe Duct Tape Marketing Podcast · 22 min
Listen in VO