1. Podcasts
  2. The Indicator from Planet Money
  3. Caution: Men NOT at Work
The Indicator from Planet Money

6 Nov 2026 · 9m · 4 chapters

Episode artwork

Caution: Men NOT at Work

In short

Jobs Friday on Planet Money’s The Indicator examines why the labor force participation of men has declined, with a “CAUTION: MEN NOT at WORK” framing. It contrasts recent job gains (165,000 jobs added in October; unemployment 4.1%) with long-term trends: men increasingly opt out of work.

Guests and backgrounds

Laura Ulrich, director of economic research at Indeed; Drew McCaskill, workforce analyst who analyzed job data for LinkedIn.

Key claims

Men’s labor force participation fell from ~87% in the 1940s to ~67% today, while women rose to ~57%. Causes vary by age: manufacturing decline for older men; opioid crisis and the Great Recession for younger men; a Journal of Political Economy study links improved video games to fewer hours. Young men (late teens/early 20s) saw a 13% participation decline since 2000 (SHRM). Disengagement shouldn’t be moralized; it requires constructive institutional responses.

Notable examples

Encouraging apprenticeships/certifications; expanding “men’s work” beyond trades to roles like nurse practitioners (projected >40% demand growth; median pay ~$132k) where only ~10% of nurses are men.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Job Market Overview

Discussion about the recent job numbers and unemployment rate changes.

“Well, in recent months, the job support has been sending caution signs about men who are not at work and honestly not even looking for a job.”
3:13

Historical Context of Workforce

Analysis of historical trends in male and female labor force participation.

“that was a period of rapid change in the labor force and in education for women.”
5:50

Reasons for Male Disengagement

Discussion on various factors contributing to men's disengagement from the labor force.

“And that can put financial stress on households.”
8:06

Changing Perceptions of Men's Work

Exploration of how societal views on men's roles in the workforce need to evolve.

“The point is, there is room to grow the pie.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Indicator from Planet Money, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01NPR.

0:06Carden Hedlund: This is The Indicator from Planet Money. I'm Adrienne Ma. And I'm Wailin Wong. It is Jobs Friday, the day of the month where we check out the latest official jobs report and spotlight trends in the labor market. And the numbers this month were better than expected. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the economy added 165 ,000 jobs in October. The numbers from August and September were revised upwards by 84 ,000 jobs, and the unemployment rate ticked down to 4.1 percent. It was a good month for jobs. But as always, we also like to think about the long-term trends. Today, we're talking about one involving men.

0:43You know when you drive by a construction site and there's a big yellow sign that says, CAUTION! MEN AT WORK! Well, in recent months, the job support has been sending caution signs about men who are not at work and honestly not even looking for a job.

0:59Carden Hedlund: For decades, men held most of the jobs in the U.S. economy. But for the past several months, it's been the reverse. And that's only happened a couple of times before, right after the Great Recession and briefly just before the pandemic. This shift goes hand in hand with a longer term trend we've also been seeing in the labor market, which is an increasing proportion of men opting out of work. Today on the show, what's behind this trend, why it matters, and what we might do about it. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once.

1:36It's even harder to do it efficiently. But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at linkedin.com slash indicator show.

1:53Carden Hedlund: This message comes from Edward Jones, where they believe rich means opening yourself to new possibilities. That's why your dedicated financial advisor meets you where you are, helping you move forward with confidence. Let's find your rich. Edward Jones, member SIPC. This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab with its original podcast on investing. Each week, you'll get thoughtful, in-depth analysis of both the stock and the bond markets. Listen today and subscribe at schwab.com slash oninvesting or wherever you get your podcasts.

2:31Carden Hedlund: In the 1940s, BLS data show around 87 % of men were in the workforce, meaning they had a job or were looking for a job. By contrast, only around 32 % of women were in the workforce. But over the course of several decades, those numbers have moved in opposite directions. Today, about 67 % of men are in the labor force compared with 57 % of women. So what happened there? Well, for women, it was a lot of things. Following World War II, a thriving economy created new demand for so-called pink-collar jobs, like secretaries, nurses, and teachers. And after that, things really got going. Laura Ulrich is director of economic research for the job site Indeed.

3:12Carden Hedlund: Between the 1960s and when I was in college in 96 to 2000, that was a period of rapid change in the labor force and in education for women. This included the movements for civil rights, which resulted in new laws barring sex discrimination in employment. More universities opening up to women. And then in the 1970s, the Supreme Court expanding access to contraception and abortion, which contributed to more women entering the workforce. And on top of all that, the economy was changing such that for many households, it wasn't enough just for the man of the house to bring home the bacon. I'm having like a Homer Simpson moment.

3:51Carden Hedlund: Oh, bacon. Mmm, delicious bacon. Those are all factors in women jumping into the labor pool. But why, over that same stretch of time, have more men been jumping out? This is something Laura has been thinking about a lot. For one thing, she says all three of her children are boys. I love my children very much, but I also want them to have jobs and be out of my house at some point. So I found myself kind of personally invested in this story. And so I do think that this is something that's been brewing for generations now at this point. This is not something that just started happening a few years ago.

4:26Carden Hedlund: So why have an increasing proportion of men basically detached from work? I think the question of why is very complicated. and it's impacting some of those different age groups differently, I think. I think the things that drove it for my generation, the Gen Xers, are slightly different than what drove it for millennials, which is slightly different than what's driving it for Gen Z. For instance, Laura says for an older generation of men, they were particularly hard hit by the decline in manufacturing jobs. For younger men, it was the opioid crisis and the Great Recession, which hit male-dominated sectors like construction.

5:02Carden Hedlund: Laura even mentioned something that may not be on the same scale as those other macroeconomic events. But there was a study in the Journal of Political Economy a few years ago that suggested the increasing quality of video games has contributed to younger men working fewer hours. I think it kind of depends on what's going on, what the cultural trends are of the moment. But I think overall, the thing that stands out to me is whatever the trend has been, whatever the cause has been attributed to, it just seems to hit the male labor force harder than it does female. And even if you aren't a mom to three sons, Laura says this is a concerning trend.

5:37Carden Hedlund: So females on average make lower wages than men. And so if we are to see male employment going down and female employment going up on average, we might see overall wages go down. And that can put financial stress on households. But what if you aren't worried about earning money for your household? It's just you. Maybe you're in your late teens or early 20s. Well, according to a recent analysis by the Society of Human Resource Management, these young men saw a 13 % decline in labor force participation since the year 2000. And that is the steepest drop compared to men in any other age band. And this is particularly concerning for Drew McCaskill.

6:17We can't just say, oh, you guys are really, really lazy, right? Like, you're just hanging out in the basement. I think that we have got to diagnose their disengagement without moralizing it. Drew is a workforce analyst who spent years analyzing job data for LinkedIn. If institutions don't give young men a constructive explanation for why their lives feel harder, somebody else online will. Young men, they aren't helpless, but they need more than lectures about working harder and more than algorithms telling them who to blame.

6:49Carden Hedlund: I'm imagining like what some kind of Manosphere podcaster would say to this headline that men are detaching from the labor force. Maybe they would say like, well, that's because there's so many more women in the labor force. You know, like look at the big trend line. You know, what would you say to that argument? I would say that they should turn that podcast off because the answer is not to put women back. is to bring these men who are disaffected to bring them forward. Women still face workforce barriers. Black and Latino workers still face completely unequal outcomes. Queer workers, workers with disabilities, veterans, caregivers, people with criminal records, they all have distinct obstacles that deserve intentional solutions.

7:29And so caring about those realities doesn't require pretending male labor force disengagement is irrelevant. Workforce strategy isn't a zero-sum sort of empathy contest. And the labor market isn't a zero-sum pool with a fixed number of jobs. Economists call that the lump of labor fallacy.

7:47Carden Hedlund: And economic studies show how, over time, women entering the workforce has actually helped men overall by increasing household incomes and growing the economy. After all, workers aren't just workers. They're also earners. And earners become spenders. And spenders increase demand for products and services, which leads to more jobs. The point is, there is room to grow the pie. And Drew says bringing more young men back into the labor force requires a multi-pronged approach. One would be promoting career paths beyond traditional college. We spent so much time talking to boys about college when we really should talk to them about work instead.

8:25Apprenticeships, community college, certifications, skilled trades, right? The objective is fewer dead ends between school and work. Two, Drew says, our traditional notions of what constitutes men's work need to expand. As a society, we've gotten better about encouraging Tina she can grow up to be a doctor or a lawyer or an engineer. We're less good at telling Timothy he can also be a teacher or a nurse. Those are jobs that we spend a century telling boys that were not necessarily for them.

8:58Carden Hedlund: And why not? If you look at some of the fastest growing jobs, take nurse practitioners, demand is expected to grow for them over 40 percent over the next decade. And currently the median pay is around$132 ,000 a year. It's pretty dang good. And yet only about 10 percent of nurses are men. Drew says these are the sorts of jobs we need to encourage men to look at. The goal is not to restore the labor market of 1948 is to prepare men for the labor market of the 2030s, right? But that means working to change our own cultural biases, something Laura admits can be difficult. Being a female who was going to get my Ph.D., like everybody in economics, everybody was cheering me on, right?

9:38Carden Hedlund: Like, you can do this. Like, go be one of the only women in your class. No problem. But even today, if a male is enrolled in an early childhood education program or other educational programs that are highly female-dominated, culturally, people may not cheer them on in that same way. there are still stigmas attached to that there's stigmas attached to being a male cheerleader too but hey listen the indicator encourages that you want to be a cheerleader a nurse a teacher we said go for it this episode was produced by angel carreras and engineered by travis hagan it was fact checked by leila dos cake and cannon is our editor and the indicators of production of npr Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

10:24This message comes from Open Door with Cash Now More Later. Get cash up front for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now and move on your own timeline. Cash Now More Later, now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash NPR. profits calculated after fees and costs eligibility and offer price may vary

From the publisher
An increasing number of men are dropping out of the workforce.  What’s behind this trend and can anything be done about it?

Fact checking by Leyla Doss.

Your Next Listen 
–What's going on with men's labor force participation?
–Over 2,000 episodes in our archive on the NPR App

Connect with The Indicator from Planet Money
–The Indicator newsletter — a weekly roundup of news, ideas and staff picks.
–Instagram, TikTok and YouTube
–Find the Planet Money book
–Find the Planet Money game, Sell Me A Sasquatch, and other merch at the NPR Shop!

Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

More from The Indicator from Planet Money

All episodes