


Why classic sitcoms (Seinfeld, The Office, How I Met Your Mother) have largely disappeared from streaming-era TV, despite ongoing popularity.
Mike Schur, TV writer/producer known for Parks and Recreation, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, and The Good Place; he’s promoting Dig on NBC’s streaming service Peacock, starring Amy Poehler.
Streaming economics changed what’s profitable: streamers want fewer episodes, reducing syndication-style “long tail” revenue. Fewer episodes raise per-episode costs via amortization. Sitcoms also need time to “gel,” but streaming moves fast. Overseas distribution favors formats that translate more easily, and comedy is culturally specific. Streamers measure minutes watched, making hour-long shows more valuable than half-hour comedies.
Dig’s workplace comedy plus cliffhangers; comparisons to Law & Order/CSI; references to Seinfeld ending in 1998 and The Office ending after Obama’s second-term start.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the decline of sitcoms and their changing nature in television.
“Shows where characters didn't learn or change that much.”
Mike Schur explains how streaming has affected sitcom production and economics.
“Sitcoms are still really popular in America, but there's just one problem.”
Discussion on the challenges and adaptations for sitcoms in the streaming era.
“Traditional networks counted how many households tune into a show.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Indicator from Planet Money, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00N.P.R.
0:07Hey, Ricky! Thanks for inviting me to your party! Hey, Waylon. Ooh, I guess I'm the first one here? Yeah, I think you're the only one coming. What happened? Well, I invited all of my sitcom buddies, but no one seems to be around anymore. My TV friends, the ones I could kick back with for a half hour. They went away. Hey, they're still avid elementary. Sitcoms are still on the air. Yeah, but it seems like the last of a dying breed. You know, TV shows you can just drop into, like Seinfeld, The Office, How I Met Your Mother. Shows where characters didn't learn or change that much. Gosh, well, I wonder what happened.
0:51Is there anyone we can call? I guess. Let's try Mike Schur. He made a few classic sitcoms like Parks and Rec and Brooklyn Nine-Nine. Everything about the way we make TV has changed dramatically in the last 15 years. And one of the casualties of that has been the comedy. This is The Indicator from Planet Money. I'm Waylon Wong. And I'm Ricky Mulvey. Today on the show, Mike's take on how streaming changed TV economics and how creators are adapting. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Edward Jones, where they believe rich means opening yourself to new possibilities.
1:33That's why your dedicated financial advisor meets you where you are, helping you move forward with confidence. Let's find your rich. Edward Jones, member SIPC. This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current, so you can win more deals. Learn more at HubSpot.com. This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab with its original podcast, On Investing. It's hosted by Lizanne Saunders, Schwab's chief investment strategist, and Colin Martin, head of fixed income research and strategy for the Schwab Center for Financial Research.
2:16Each week, Lizanne, Colin, and their guests analyze economic developments and bring context to conversations around stocks, fixed income, the economy, and more. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com slash oninvesting or wherever you get your podcasts.
2:36Sitcoms are still really popular in America, but there's just one problem. Many of them ended their runs over a decade ago. Yeah, close to a quarter of Americans watched at least one Seinfeld episode this year. And the show ended in 1998. I know, I watched the finale when it aired. Last year, NBCUniversal said that half a million accounts watched episodes of The Office daily, a show that ended shortly after Barack Obama was sworn in for his second term. In the 1990s, sitcoms made up about 12 % of new shows. It's less than 2 % in the 2020s. Sitcoms, if they do well, have this long tale of success.
3:14So we wanted to find out why aren't streamers trying to make more of these shows? What happened? Settle in, people. There's a couple things going on here. Mike Schur has a new show coming out on NBC's streaming service Peacock. It's called Dig, starring Amy Poehler. In addition, he produced and wrote on the U.S. version of The Office and created The Good Place. Mike says the economics fundamentally changed. In the old days, many successful sitcoms actually lost money for networks when episodes premiered. Ad revenue on the first airing did not make up for production costs like paying the stars.
3:49But you don't mind because there's a flourishing aftermarket. You are going to package these episodes when you get to 100 episodes. You're going to package them and sell them into syndication. Syndication is when reruns of a show run on other channels. When cable was booming, this allowed less watched channels to fill their content engines and gave the popular networks more cash. But streaming changed everything. Now networks aren't selling to those smaller channels as much. They're selling to streamers. Mike says these deals last a long time and mean less money coming in. That's because when streamers buy a show to begin with, they usually want fewer episodes.
4:26They don't want to pony up for, say, 22 episodes if 10 episodes could bring in the same number of subscribers. This actually raises production costs because of an accounting principle called amortization. And this is when a business spreads out the cost of a big purchase. Fewer episodes means there's less room to spread. You know, if you make a new show and you build a set, in the old days, you would build a set, you would spend$3 million on your set, but you spread that cost out over 22 episodes. Well, it's not that much per episode to have that set. Now you're only spreading it over eight episodes.
5:00So this means that TV studios need to find other ways to make money. One being selling distribution overseas. The world is now almost completely open. And as a result, the studios need, in order to make the amounts of money, the gobs of money they're trying to make, they have to sell their shows everywhere. And comedy is cultural. What is funny in one country is not necessarily funny in another. You know what does travel? Cops chasing bad guys. So when you're trying to sell a show overseas that has to be dubbed into another language or has to translate more easily, people understand cops chasing bad guys.
5:37They understand murder as a dramatic device. They understand the nuts and bolts of like hour long dramas just are better overseas. So that is the baseline answer to why we still have a lot of Law and Order or CSI type shows and not a lot of sitcoms. There's also a comedy physics problem. Sitcoms often need a few episodes to gel, to find momentum, maybe even a season. Actors learn how to work together. Writers learn how to make their characters funny. Mike says that the streaming world system does not give these kinds of comedies the time they need to experiment and find their footing. Audiences move on quickly.
6:15Why should I watch this show versus everything else on Hulu? Or log off and check out Amazon Prime, Netflix, or YouTube? Bottom line, comedies don't have time to do the research and development they often need to succeed. That's the last sort of tragic piece of this, is that this system cuts you off at the knees before you have a chance to have something like The Office really click and take off. On top of all of this, streamers keep score in a different way from the old days. Traditional networks counted how many households tune into a show. That determined how many ads they sold. Streamers count minutes watched.
6:51So all else being equal, a successful hour-long show is twice as valuable as a successful half-hour show. This leads to a challenging combo for the comedy format. They're less valuable overseas, each episode has fewer minutes watched, and they are expensive to make. And that has just meant that these very efficiency-minded tech companies are like, well, this asset is less valuable than this asset, and so we're not going to make that one anymore. We wondered if Mike was an exception. You would think that his track record would make him a pretty good bet for a streamer. Like, hey, I made Brooklyn Nine-Nine.
7:26Give me 10 episodes to figure it out. He says he has the benefit of the doubt, but he still had to adapt. It's far from, like, you know, whatever you want to call it, a get-out-of-jail-free card or a cloak of invisibility or whatever magical power you want to ascribe. Mike has a new show on the streamer Peacock. Dig is made with Amy Poehler. It's a comedy adventure show set at an archaeological dig site. It's the first time Mike has collaborated with Amy since Parks and Rec. And Mike said this combo made him confident the show would get made, a rare feat. And while it has some of the elements that'll feel familiar to Parks and Rec viewers, it's not a rehash.
8:04This show is going to be tailored to the era in which we are living, and that's just basic survival. He knows that the show will be measured on its episode completion rates and minutes watched. So there's a central mystery to propel viewers through episodes. Nothing like this has been found for hundreds of years. Dig has workplace comedy and cliffhangers. But if we dig it up ourselves, you'll get the credit. It would be worse than Watergate. Right. Please tell me you know what Watergate is. Relax. I read it. It's not a book. Mike has his black belt in making hangout shows, boring settings with colorful characters that you want to see week after week.
8:40But the market has changed. I have talked to certain friends who, you know, worked with me on previous shows. Like, do you think it's possible? Could we go into a network and say, we want to do this the old way? We want to do a 22 episode season. We want the show to be a more casual kind of hangout show. Let's spend 30 minutes in a room with these people and hope that, you know, people, the audience falls in love with them. Like, could we could we do that? Would they let us do that? I don't know anyone who's pulled that off.
9:17So Ricky, do you think we'll ever find the killer of the classic sitcom? Kid, you'll never make it in this town trying to figure out who pulled the trigger. It wasn't a person. It was streaming economics. The score changed. The episodes got more expensive. It's the money. And this time, it ain't funny. Wait, but why did you turn this sitcom episode into a show about murder? Oh, that's because we need to sell the international distribution rights. Don't you see? They want crimes, not laughs. Got it. There's an armed robbery on Main Street. Gotta bounce, kid. Turn in your badge and your gun. You're a loose cannon.
9:55I object. What else do I yell?
10:01If you want to hear my full interview with Mike Schur, where we go even deeper on TV economics, make sure you're signed up for NPR+. We're publishing it as a bonus episode in the Planet Money feed next week. It's a great hang. Just go to plus.npr.org to sign up. It's also a great way to support our work. This episode was produced by Angel Carreras and engineered by Anhui Wang. It was fact-checked by Leila Dose. Kate Kincannon is the show's editor, and The Indicator is production of NPR.
10:32Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Mint Mobile. unwrap huge savings this season all plans even unlimited are 15 for new customers go to mint mobile.com slash switch upfront payment of 45 for three month 90 for six month or 180 for 12 month plan required 15 per month equivalent taxes and fees extra initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy capable device required availability speed and coverage varies cment mobile.com