1. Podcasts
  2. The Interview
  3. U2, rock band: Dysfunction pushes us
The Interview

6 Nov 2026 · 23m · 7 chapters

Episode artwork

U2, rock band: Dysfunction pushes us

In short

U2’s 50th anniversary and their 16th studio album Carnival de Luz, framed by the band’s “dysfunction” as a creative engine, plus themes of freedom, face-to-face connection, and political speech at concerts.

Guests

Bono (vocalist; co-wrote/produced songs emphasizing joy and freedom), The Edge (guitarist; says early dysfunction helped them avoid predictability), Adam Clayton (bassist; discusses songwriting duality and joy vs melancholy), Larry Mullen Jr. (drummer; started the band by posting a school notice).

Key claims

Their dysfunction and studio difficulty “push us” toward special breakthroughs; joy is hard to write but central to Carnival de Luz; concerts reset people out of online “algorithm bubbles”; venues shouldn’t censor artists.

Notable examples

U2 formed at Mount Temple Comprehensive School (1976); early gigs at McGonagall’s; “Torn” duet with Dolly Parton (and her last vocal); defending politically active lineups (Public Enemy; Chile under Pinochet; Sunday Bloody Sunday/Pride in the Name of Love in contentious places).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

3:53

Dysfunction as a Driving Force

U2 discusses the challenges of dysfunction within the band and its impact on their creative process.

“Larry, you are the instigator of this whole enterprise.”
6:28

The Journey of Songwriting

U2 reflects on their songwriting experience and the duality of joy and struggle in their music.

“just Larry at the front of the stage with a power hose getting rid of the front row yeah It was an act of kindness and love because it was a hot day.”
14:20

A Trip Down Memory Lane with U2

Reflecting on U2's early days and their evolution in the music industry.

“I met you two back in Dublin as they celebrated their 50th birthday.”
15:10

The Importance of Connection

Exploring the value of personal connections amidst a digital world.

“One of the threads on the album is just the idea of connection in person with other people being a solution to living remotely online and believing everything you see.”
17:25

Collaborative Creativity in U2

Discussing the dynamics of collaboration and creativity within the band.

“It was something that's been talked about between us for a while.”
20:04

Dolly Parton Duet: Torn

Insights into the collaboration with Dolly Parton on the track 'Torn'.

“It's a wild thing and very upsetting for family.”
22:37

Artistic Freedom and Responsibility

U2's stance on artistic expression and the importance of free speech.

“I think they were sticking up for a narcissist's right to free speech.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Interview, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Mark Savage: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30all in one place, so you can invest your way. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Fall and comfort foods go hand in hand. Grandma's mac and cheese, soup and grilled cheese. But how do you create those cozy moments while still maintaining your health goals? Hero Bread can help. Hero Bread's soft, fluffy, flavorful sliced breads, bagels, tortillas, and Hero Noodles have only 0 to 5 grams net carbs and up to 19 grams of protein per serving. So go ahead, enjoy some cheesy mac and cheese. Enjoy that stacked sandwich with Hero Bread for lunch. Or start your day with a fully loaded bagel. Because with Hero Bread, there's none of the stiff baked goods you expect from Better For You brands.

1:16And right now, Hero Bread is offering 10 % off your order. Go to hero.co and use code IHEART at checkout. That's H-E-R-O dot C-O code IHEART. All figures per serving of Hero Bread. See Nutrition Facts on Hero.co for sodium and sugar content.

1:38Mark Savage: Hello, I'm Mark Savage, the BBC's music correspondent, and this is the interview from the BBC World Service. The best conversations coming out of the BBC. People shaping our world from all over the world. I want to get freedom. I like that freedom. A gender equal world would be a better world for men too. We need this is fire. We need healing. We need trust. These companies don't really, they don't care what governments do. This is a war. The first thing that we want is a war to end. For this interview, I met the legendary Irish rock band U2 at McGonagall's, a small club in Dublin where they first played in the 1970s.

2:21Mark Savage: The group was formed as a six-piece at the Mount Temple Comprehensive School in Dublin back in 1976. Within two years, they'd settled on the current line-up of vocalist Bono, guitarist The Edge, bassist Adam Clayton and drummer Larry Mullen Jr. During the decade that followed, they quickly grew from a local post-punk band into one of the world's biggest rock acts. They enjoyed a string of global hits such as Pride in the Name of Love, With or Without You and I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For and lined up alongside the likes of Elton John, Queen and David Bowie to perform at Live Aid in 1985.

2:59Mark Savage: Now, as they mark their 50th anniversary with the release of their 16th studio album Carnival de Luz, U2 are recognised as one of the biggest selling musical acts of all time with some estimates placing record sales north of 170 million copies. But despite enjoying global success across those five decades, finding the magic doesn't always come easy. The most frustrating thing for us sometimes is the dysfunction. It's the things we can't do, but as it turns out, it is the thing that pushes us. We've never found it easy. It's always been a challenge for us. And that's what makes those moments when it does go off so special.

3:43And that's why you keep on chasing it. and to why you stay in a band.

3:49Mark Savage: Welcome to the interview from the BBC World Service with U2. 50 years of U2. Larry, you are the instigator of this whole enterprise. Talk me through what went through your mind when you were going to put that sign up in the school. I'd been playing on my own in my house. My dad was pretty frustrated. I wasn't very good at many things. Playing the drums was included in that. So I think he, out of frustration, said I should try and play with other people. So I wrote a note and put it up on the notice board in the school, hoping that someone would respond, and they did. Unfortunately. Oh, yeah. You've got the three of us.

4:36Yeah, and I ended up with these guys.

4:38Mark Savage: You turned up to Larry's house wanting to play the guitar, but you didn't bring a guitar. Yeah, not good with gear. Carrying it, unpacking it, that kind of thing. Yeah, I was thinking about it. I owe my place in this four-piece, not just to Larry, but also just to friendship in general, because my mate, Reggie Manuel, the Cocker Spaniel, he talked me into coming. And I didn't think I should do it, you know, because, I mean, you were, what, third year? Oh, second year. Second years. I wouldn't be hanging out with second years. And particularly really good looking ones. I was not going there. But Reggie said, no, I should do it.

5:19Reggie Manuel. What a man. And he drove me there on his Yammy 100. Wow. So I did arrive on a bike and I can tell myself it was a Harley Dixon, but it was a Yamaha 100.

5:33Mark Savage: And that first rehearsal, Adam, I heard even then there were screaming girls climbing over the wall of Larry's parents' house. He already had a fan club. And we thought, well, if he's got a fan club, that looks pretty good to us. Maybe if we hang out with this guy, it might stretch a little further. As I recall, Larry Mullen took a hose to the fans. Now, maybe I'm not... This is probably not... It's definitely not the way to treat your fans. But I think it was playful. It was playful. Yes, it was playful. It was playful. they were sitting on the garden wall I don't know what was actually I did I did get the garden house they enjoyed it I believe it was a hot day it's been the story of our life ever since it's like we just saw Barry Mullen but he doesn't even want to have fans we'd really like them I would like to see that on the next tour just Larry at the front of the stage with a power hose getting rid of the front row yeah It was an act of kindness and love because it was a hot day.

6:39Mark Savage: I see. Nice one. The Edge, I read you say that in the beginning of the band you were very dysfunctional as a quartet. How ugly did it get on these stages that you played at the beginning? Well, that dysfunction is both a challenge but a strength because it's made us have to find unique ways to utilise our instruments and work together. So it's sort of been a guiding light in some ways, the limitations of the band. But we therefore are in this place where musically we don't know what is about to happen. It can fall apart or it could become something extraordinary. And in turn, and that's the beauty of U2, is the lack of orthodoxy and formality and predictability.

7:29And that's carried through right to this album. You know, the early sessions of playing the new songs that we came up with were at times super inspiring and then like really not that good at all. So I hope that never changes because I think that is really a big part of what makes us unique.

7:49Mark Savage: I've always wondered, because you talk a lot about how you can come unstuck in the studio in the search of greatness. Larry, when you hear other artists saying Oh I recorded a song in an afternoon Or we did a whole album in a fortnight Do you just think, you liars? Yeah, look, it is the most frustrating thing for us Sometimes is the dysfunction It's the things we can't do But as it turns out, it is the thing that pushes us But even when we're in the studio this time Working and working things out I am always reminded of how incapable I am of doing all those things that other people find so easy.

8:33We've never found it easy. It's always been a challenge for us. And that's what makes those moments when it does go off so special. And that's why you keep on chasing it. That's why you stay in a band. Some songs come easy. I mean, I think there's one or two over 50 years. No, but there is. There's one or two probably an album, right? Yeah, it varies. But to get to the thing that will happen just naturally like that, you've sort of got to stick with it. And it's the stick-with-it-ness, I think, is part of the thing that you have to have. And we definitely have that.

9:07Mark Savage: Well, you've stuck with it for 50 years. Relentless. Absolutely relentless. It's a grudge match. Even now, this feels like our first album. and, you know, we really want to know that people will hear about it. We put out two EPs this year. It'll be 24 songs in a year, which we've never done since we started. But the first two EPs, we just put them out without telling anyone. And so management, label, all like, you can't do that. And we said, we can. And we did. And they said, people won't notice. And we said, we don't mind. And they didn't. I mean, really, it was beautiful. The people who we wanted to notice, noticed.

9:53And it's okay not to have a big hype behind everything. This, hopefully, we will get a bit of hype going.

10:02Mark Savage: Is that something, like five decades into your career, you have the luxury of that. You can sneak a record out, and it doesn't matter if it's a big radio hit or a big chart hit. It's about the art. Whereas, I guess, in the early days, you've got to be hungry to find the audience. I think there's some truth to that. And it is a privilege and a luxury to be at this point where we don't actually have to prove anything to anybody. We are making music that we want to make. And we always put ourselves in the audience when we work on a song. Like, what would we want to hear if we were in the pit and the band were on stage in front of us?

10:43So in some ways, it's very much for our own satisfaction, not thinking about an audience per se, but we're still fans. You know, that's basically the way we approach it.

10:56Mark Savage: The phrase that I wrote down when I listened to the album for the first time was defiantly joyful. And it feels to me like there is a fight in the songs to find light in a time of pessimism and doom mongering. I wondered, is that an idea that had crystallised for you, Adam, during the recording? I think, you know, the best songwriting always has a duality and a tension. But I think with Carnival de Luz as a body of work, we didn't want to be dragged down by the dark clouds or the melancholy. We wanted to make the point that we didn't want our joy robbed. And joy is a very hard thing to write about or to produce in music.

11:38But that was what we wanted to follow down. And we also, we realized that freedom was something that we had thought was going to be around forever. You know, our journey from the mid 70s was about expanding freedom and opportunity for everyone. It was like, make your own rules, pull down what wasn't useful or whatever. But now we seem to be in a period where that's under threat and under attack. but we wanted to enshrine it on the record and say that's what we hold dear. And carnival is an expression of freedom so that duality is in there with the songs.

12:19Mark Savage: I'm sorry I interrupted you. No, just complimenting. I'm sitting beside a man I've sat beside for a long time but I'm still amazed at his wisdom. Very philosophical.

12:32Mark Savage: You're listening to The Interview from the BBC World Service. Fall and comfort foods go hand in hand. Grandma's mac and cheese, soup and grilled cheese. But how do you create those cozy moments while still maintaining your health goals? Hero Bread can help. Hero Bread's soft, fluffy, flavorful sliced breads, bagels, tortillas, and Hero Noodles have only 0 to 5 grams net carbs and up to 19 grams of protein per serving. So go ahead, enjoy some cheesy mac and cheese. Enjoy that stacked sandwich with Hero Bread for lunch. Or start your day with a fully loaded bagel. Because with Hero Bread, there's none of the stiff baked goods you expect from Better For You brands.

13:19And right now, Hero Bread is offering 10 % off your order. Go to hero.co and use code IHEART at checkout. That's H-E-R-O dot C-O, code IHEART. All figures per serving of Hero Bread. See Nutrition Facts on Hero.co for sodium and sugar content.

14:03No bouncing between tabs. And best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

14:20Mark Savage: I met you two back in Dublin as they celebrated their 50th birthday. We went with them to the school where they formed in 1976. And there they put on an impromptu show in the playground. for some of the school's current pupils. And later on, we went back to a bar in Dublin that hosted some of their first gigs. It's a little underground, small venue called McGonagall's that these days actually acts as a bingo hall. But it was a fascinating place to meet this band who are used to playing stadium shows to hundreds of thousands of people because it put them back in the mindset of that post-punk group who grew up with no real idea how to make it in the music industry, and they were able to reflect on the journey that's taken them to those stadiums that they play today.

15:09Mark Savage: OK, let's return to my conversation with you two. One of the threads on the album is just the idea of connection in person with other people being a solution to living remotely online and believing everything you see. There's something of value in face-to-face connection, right? Absolutely. And that ties back to your anniversary because there's a line, your friendship is a prize on midnight sunrise. Is that the secret that you value this friendship above anything else? I think we check each other. I mean, there's a great leveling that occurs when you're working with equals in this kind of collaborative situation.

15:49And your ego has to be put in check. and you have to always keep an open mind because someone else might have a better idea than you and not to feel like just because this is how you think today that it will be exactly how you think tomorrow. So much right now seems to be belief has turned into personal identity and that's a dangerous situation. So yeah, I agree. Interconnectedness in the band has been hugely important, I think, between the band and the audience. And when you go to a rock and roll gig, You're seeing that interconnectedness in action. And I think there's a dearth of that right now.

16:28I think concerts and these ritual gatherings are a great opportunity to reset, as you say, and just kind of check yourself and get out of your bubble. Because I think people are. They're in their sort of online algorithm bubble and not really thinking straight in a lot of cases. What is it? If the world is at war, we better not be. That's, I think, what you're getting at, isn't it? I mean, it applies to the band, applies to families, applies to your mates. As you go, you know, it's like this is the time to stick together. No such thing as rock and roll. We just needed it to be. I was standing in a schoolyard waiting for you to happen to me.

17:08I could say that to my bandmates now, as I said it then.

17:15Mark Savage: You talk about that divisiveness between families on the final track, Torn, which is a co-write and a duet with Dolly Parton. Larry, tell me how that came about. It was something that's been talked about between us for a while. We worked with Johnny Cash, worked with Bob Dylan. We've always toyed with the idea of duets. And during that period of time, during the sphere and this record, Bono and Edge had started to work with lots of different people, just trying out an idea of maybe doing a passenger's tube. And during that period of time, I know Bono was in touch with Dolly Parton and Parton with the song, and she had a better idea.

18:03And take it from there. She did. I mean, it's some kind of folk songs we were playing, and one with Ed Sheeran and Johnny McDade, and there was one called Lifelong. And I remember her saying, you know that's a little too Irish for me and that's but you're from the Appalachians you've got to be Scots Irish right she said no I'm talking about where it hits my voice and you realize I don't think this way but I probably should I remember this Roy Orbison and he said I want to do a song that only I can sing kind of thing so she had started something and she says look I've started a song called Torn.

18:44You can take it where you want, take it somewhere else, and I might like where you take it. And she did. And we took her to a pretty sci-fi country place. I mean, it's, there is a little bit of Daniel Lamois playing pedal steel. There's a little bit of most of the time Bob Dylan on there, that rolling thing that you were doing on the drums, Adam. So yeah, I was we were really surprised that she loved it. We had no idea. We knew she was ill when she took on the vocal, but we had no idea that would be her last vocal. That was a real shock. And shock for us because we've been working with her, but shock for anyone who loved music.

19:21Probably the only thing that people can agree on in the entire world right now is Dolly Parton. Whether you're gay or straight or conservative or, you know, liberal, whatever your political colour, she was ready for you to fly it at her show. It's interesting. and yeah I remember it was with Michael Stipe in a car going out somewhere and the news came in and Michael Stipe the singer from R.E.M perhaps one of the greatest singers who's ever lived himself he actually fell down he just couldn't he just started sobbing he just could not believe it because he knew as a great singer the greatness of Dolly Parton.

20:08We just, yeah, I don't know. It's a wild thing and very upsetting for family. Her manager couldn't have been more kind. I mean, these are old school people. And always funny, always funny. In an interview, you know, she'd say, I think the great line was, ask me any question you want and I'll tell you what I want you to hear me reply. Now I'll tell you what I want to hear me reply.

20:35Mark Savage: I interviewed Dolly a couple of times. She was always good value. Oh my God. She was great. And I guess in the US, you're going to be playing some of the same stadiums that Ed Sheeran's playing. Ed, given what's happened on his tour, where the owners of the stadiums have said they do not like some of the statements his support acts were making on stage, as a band who uses their platform, how would you feel if that was to happen to you too? Well, we've been faced on occasions in the past where it would have probably been smarter or better for us to have not said things. And we've just gone straight ahead and said them.

21:12So we totally support Macklemore's right as an artist to say what he wanted to say. And we could never accept a venue owner telling us what to say. We had Public Enemy on our tour in the southern states of America at a time when they had part of their show where they were lynching a Ku Klux Klan effigy in kind of a symbolic way. And people in our circle were freaking out. And we said, look, that's their thing. We kept them on the tour. We managed to do it by kind of not telling any of the venue owners who was on the road with us. But we did so basically in order to protect them and allow them to do what they wanted to do.

22:01And we ourselves have on occasions been in situations where it would have been way smarter and better for us to shut up. On one occasion we were in Chile during Pinochet's reign, reign, administration. And we had the mothers of the disappeared come on stage. with photographs of their children, because we'd supported the mothers of the disability, written a song about them. It was artistically necessary. And we just said, we can't not do this. But I don't think Ed should be vilified. He's in a very difficult situation. But I commend, I think, the young artists who decided to leave the tour. I think they were sticking up for a narcissist's right to free speech.

22:43And I think that's the issue above anything else. We might disagree with some of the members of the pro-Palestine movement, but we absolutely agree with the fundamentals. We absolutely agree that what's going on there is unconscionable and that a child's life is equally valuable no matter what their background. These are fundamental principles that we hold to. So we agree with Macklemore mostly. And then we totally get why he felt so passionate. I mean, we wouldn't get to play, we were saying this the other day, we couldn't have played Sunday Bloody Sunday in some places you might be familiar with.

23:26We couldn't have played Pride in the Name of Love in Arizona when we were campaigning for Martin Luther King Day. And the governor at the time, Governor Meacham, I wasn't having any of it. We went ahead and played.

23:39Mark Savage: I remember you playing Please in Ormo Park in Belfast. Yeah. So, you know, and our audience knows that. And actually, though in Chile there was booing when we spoke to, it's the maddest thing because it was live. And so I said, General Pinochet, we are not your judge. God will be your judge. but tell these women where the bodies of their children, where the bones of their children are buried. And things went a little different. And the crowd, some started to boo because they were for the Pinochet and not the regime that had been displaced by him. and there is, I think, a thing we should encourage, which is it is okay for your audience to disagree with you.

24:44I mean, people said that must have been, you know, that must have been shocking. Your audience, you know, turned on you. No, that's the kind of audience we have and we encourage people to be at our shows and not agree with us. I think you just, you want everyone at the show. You want all, people should feel safe at shows and safe to be who they want to be. I think artists have a right to choose whether they want to be politically active or not. It is a human right. But we, as a band, will fight for the right to speak your mind as long as it doesn't incite violence. And even if we disagree with it or don't like it, nobody has the right.

25:40No billionaire, no promoter, no owner has the right to censor anybody. But they will definitely not be censoring us ever.

25:55Mark Savage: Thank you for listening to The Interview. If you enjoyed this conversation, you can find many more episodes of The Interview wherever you get your BBC podcasts, including ones with other music icons, including Paul McCartney, Stevie Wonder and Shaka Khan. Until the next time, goodbye for now.

26:25but it also comes with risk. As technology and AI evolve, AXA XL is facing into risk. As a leading global insurer, we constantly push the boundaries to protect your data and network from cyber risks. AXA XL, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation, nor a description of any products or services of AXA XL. balance your trading strategy by adding futures cme group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes visit your online broker and get started see what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made this is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service.

From the publisher

“Dysfunction is a challenge but a strength as well, because it's made us have to find unique ways to utilise our instruments and work together. So it's sort of been a guiding light in some ways, the limitations of the band, but we are in this place where musically where we don't know what is about to happen. It can fall apart or it could become something extraordinary. And that's the beauty of U2 - the lack of orthodoxy and formality and predictability.”

Mark Savage meets legendary Irish rock band U2.

The group was formed at Mount Temple Comprehensive in Dublin back in 1976, with the current line-up of vocalist Bono, guitarist The Edge, bassist Adam Clayton and drummer Larry Mullen Jr., coming together just two years later.

Within a decade, they had gone from local post-punk band to one of the world’s biggest rock acts. They enjoyed a string of global hits such as "Pride (In the Name of Love)", "With or Without You", and "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For", and lined up alongside the likes of Elton John, Queen and David Bowie to perform at Live Aid in 1985.

Now, as they mark their 50th anniversary with the release of their 16th studio album, Carnaval de Luz, U2 are recognised as one of the biggest-selling musical acts of all time, with estimated record sales north of 170 million.

But despite enjoying global success across five decades, getting it right doesn’t always come easy. The Interview brings you conversations with people shaping our world, from all over the world. The best interviews from the BBC, including episodes with other music icons such as Paul McCartney, Stevie Wonder and Chaka Khan. You can listen on the BBC World Service on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays at 0800 GMT. Or you can listen to The Interview as a podcast, out three times a week on BBC Sounds or wherever you get your podcasts.

Presenter: Mark Savage Producers: Ben Cooper, Anisa Sudebar and Jonathan Sumberg Editors: Farhana Haider and Damon Rose

Get in touch with us on email [email protected] and use the hashtag #TheInterviewBBC on social media.

(Image: U2. Credit: Getty)

More from The Interview

All episodes