Confronting Evil with Bill O’Reilly

7 Oct 2025 · 40 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Notes on The James Altucher Show: Confronting Evil with Bill O’Reilly

Episode Overview

  • Title: Confronting Evil with Bill O’Reilly
  • Guest: Bill O’Reilly, journalist and author of *Confronting Evil: Assessing the Worst of the Worst*
  • Release Date: September 9, 2023
  • Main Themes: Exploration of historical and modern evildoers, the psychology of evil, and the implications for society today.

Key Concepts and Discussions

Introduction to the Episode

  • James Altucher introduces O'Reilly and the themes of his new book.
  • Focuses on historical figures of evil (Hitler, Stalin, Mao, etc.) and the relevance of their actions in contemporary society.

Understanding Evil

  • Types of Evil:
  • Personal Evil: Examples include figures like Ted Bundy.
  • Collective Evil: Leaders like Hitler and Mao who orchestrate mass atrocities.
  • Bill O'Reilly's Perspective:
  • Discusses how evil reappears when society becomes complacent and stops paying attention.
  • The importance of recognizing small evils to prevent larger ones from taking hold.

Historical Context

  • O’Reilly emphasizes the parallels between past and present regarding violence and moral decay.
  • References recent events, such as the war in Ukraine and mass shootings, as signs of rising evil today.

The Role of Technology

  • Echo Chambers and Radicalization:
  • The internet allows for amplification of hatred and the formation of "clubs for evil."
  • Mental illness and radicalization are exacerbated by online communities encouraging violent behavior.

Justice and Accountability

  • Mercy for the Guilty:
  • O’Reilly quotes Thomas Sowell: “Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent.”
  • Discussion on how leniency in the justice system can lead to increased violence and crime.

Polarization and Apathy

  • Modern Activism and Ignorance:
  • O'Reilly critiques various activist groups and their apparent contradictions.
  • Examines how ignorance and apathy can lead to societal delusions and acceptance of evil.

The Hopeful Perspective

  • Both Altucher and O’Reilly conclude on a note of optimism, noting that good still outweighs evil.
  • Emphasizes the responsibility of individuals to confront and recognize evil in society.

Important Quotes

  • “Evil mutates, reappears, and spreads when we stop paying attention.” - Bill O'Reilly
  • “Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent.” - Thomas Sowell

Timestamped Highlights

  • [02:00] Introduction to *Confronting Evil* and its relevance.
  • [05:51] Motivation behind writing the book amidst current events.
  • [12:24] Discussion on the irredeemable nature of certain historical figures.
  • [15:36] The internet's influence on radicalization and hate speech.
  • [36:54] Call to action: mobilizing the majority against evil.

Key Takeaways

  • Cyclic Nature of Evil: O'Reilly suggests that societal conditions can lead to the resurgence of evil.
  • Need for Vigilance: Emphasizes the importance of recognizing and addressing both personal and collective forms of evil actively.
  • Hope for Change: Concludes that despite rising concerns, the majority of society remains good and can be mobilized to counteract evil.

Additional Resources

  • Bill O’Reilly’s Book: [Confronting Evil: Assessing the Worst of the Worst](https://www.amazon.com/Confronting-Evil-Assessing-Worst/dp/1250374049/?utm_source=chatgpt.com)
  • Official Website: [BillOReilly.com](http://www.billoreilly.com)

---

This structured overview captures the essence of the podcast episode while highlighting key discussions and insights that emerged during the conversation with Bill O'Reilly.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Being an entrepreneur is a 24-7 job. And when you're hiring, you need a partner that works as hard as you do. That hiring partner is LinkedIn Jobs. When you clock out, LinkedIn clocks in. LinkedIn makes it easy to post your job for free, share with your network, get qualified candidates that you can manage all in one place. For one thing, you can post a job. LinkedIn's new feature can help you write job descriptions and then quickly get your job in front of the right people. You get qualified candidates. At the end of the day, the most important thing to your business is the quality of the candidates.

0:30And with LinkedIn, of course, you can feel confident that you're getting the best. Based on LinkedIn data, 72 % of small and medium businesses say using LinkedIn helps them find high-quality candidates. Find out why more than 2.5 million small businesses use LinkedIn for hiring today. Find your next great hire on LinkedIn. Post your job for free at linkedin.com slash altature. That's linkedin.com slash altature to post your job for free. Terms and conditions apply. This isn't your average business podcast, and he's not your average host. This is the James Altucher Show.

1:18Confronting Evil. This is the latest book by Bill O 'Reilly, and he tells basically the stories of everybody from Stalin, Hitler, Mao, to Genghis Khan and Caligula, all the way up to the modern drug cartels and Vladimir Putin and a bunch of others. And he basically tells their stories. I learned a lot. It's almost like a modern history book. But also, why does he write this book? He writes it because now we're seeing incredible evil. We're seeing the war in Ukraine. We're seeing all the stuff going on, you know, with October 7th and Israel and everything that's happened all around that. And we're seeing the shootings in the U S and not only the mass shootings, but then you have things like Charlie Kirk or the, the girl from Ukraine who was throat was slit in the subway and it's disturbing and it's scary.

2:10And the question is, is this new or is this part of this historical trend that's happening now? If things are going to get better, how do things get better? And Bill and I discuss this and we do end on a note of optimism, but a lot of people, I know what a lot of people are thinking too, which is like, well, Bill O 'Reilly's a Republican or he's this or he's that. And you know, you can't, you know, Democrats might not like hearing what he has to say. And I think this sort of partisanship, obviously, you know, anybody who's totally just partisan is probably not very smart. Like people on both sides of the aisle have great things to say.

2:51Most of the country actually is, is centrist. I think we all know this. And, And Bill O 'Reilly is somebody who has covered evil for decades as a journalist and a news anchor and so on. And I think, and we've discussed this in other episodes as well, we just have to start listening instead of fighting. You kind of have to say whenever you're angry that what really is happening internally, you know, anger is often just fear clothed, right? So we're afraid of what will happen if another Hitler rises. So we knee jerk react to whatever everybody around us is saying, or we're afraid what happens if certain people get elected or certain people have a say in what's going on.

3:35But think to what you're personally anxious about. How do you deal with it? How do you have conversations about it? How do you learn from the past? All of these things are really important right now. If we're going to survive this period where there's greater mass shootings than ever, war is happening around the world. I don't know. It is very upsetting and disturbing, but I'm glad I had a chance to talk with someone like Bill O 'Reilly about it, and here it is.

4:09Now, you've obviously been covering evil for decades. You've been, you know, as a journalist, as an observer of geopolitics, you've seen evil everywhere you've turned. Again, you've covered it. You've interviewed it. You've interacted with it. What personal experiences inspired you to write this particular book? It's a little different than your other books. It's not like one story. You really dive into all these stories of Mao and Putin and Genghis Khan and Khomeini and so on. Yeah, there are 15 miscreants that we profile and the confronting banner. I switched over from killing books to confronting, with our last one, confronting the presidents.

4:56And it takes a year to research and write these books. So when we finished presidents, I had another book to deliver to the publisher. And I said, you know, I'm seeing a rise of evil in the United States and around the world. And I think people are looking away from it. So let me shock them. We'll write a book about the worst evil people have ever lived. And maybe they'll get back and say, you know, we got to do stuff about this. Now, here is the ultimate ironing. Book comes out September 9th. I get up September 10th, and Putin is lobbing missiles into Poland. Putin's on the cover along with Mao, Hitler, and the Ayatollah Khomeini.

5:39And then a few hours later, Charlie Kirk gets assassinated. so one interviewer said to me that's so eerie that your book would come out and all this stuff would happen and it is um and there's no reason or rationality attached to it other than coincidence but we are seeing uh evil envelop the world i think at a quicker rate than any time except the 1930s and the rise of the totalitarian regimes. And people got to pay attention to this, James. You know, and I agree. It seems, obviously, it is very scary. But then you look at overall statistics, like death by violence per capita has gone down century over century for forever.

6:35What's different about this evil now? More personal evil. and when you had a world where there were not civility, you had a bunch of countries that were just totally chaotic, then of course you couldn't have a higher level of violence. But in our modern age, we're supposed to be people of civilization. We're supposed to have protections. We're supposed to be acting in a humane way. And most of us do. But the 15%, that's the number I put on it, of evildoers are causing an enormous amount of problems. You can see that with the mass shootings in the USA. Almost every two or three weeks now, we got some idiot, some mentally ill person walks in and mows down people who are completely innocent of anything.

7:31and we have to, as a society, A, recognize the problem and then B, deal with it on a level that's effective. I learned so much from this book, as always with your books. I didn't know that much about Genghis Khan. I didn't know that much about Caligula. Even details of October 7th and the Iranian Revolution, a lot of these details that you've researched, I did not know, even though I've read a lot of things about this. So it's fascinating as a history, but I am really just curious on a personal level, your experiences with evil. In your years as a journalist, who would you say you've talked to or confronted personally that you felt was the most evil person you've ever dealt with?

8:18Boy, I don't know if I can put a capper on that. Ted Bundy. What was that like? I chased him across the country, and I didn't get him, but I was very close when he got arrested in Lake City, Florida. And we talked to his mother, and we had a correspondence with him. That's about it. It's hardcore evil. Two types of evil, James. There's a personal evil. That's Bundy. And then there's a collective evil. That's Hitler. The Ayatollah, those people who just mass murderers. They'll mow you down. Genghis Khan, one of those guys. But in my career, I covered four wars. You know, I was in El Salvador. I was down in Argentina, Falkland's War.

9:06Northern Ireland, Middle East. And you see horrible, horrible things take place every day. Like what? The justification is, well, I was in Belfast, and I actually took my son there last summer to show him where I was in a place called Davis Flats housing project. And it was a clash between the British Army and the IRA people. And they grabbed a 12-year-old boy who was a messenger for the Irish. And they took all the shoes and socks and made them walk across broken glass. These are the soldiers, the British soldiers did that. I mean, that's the kind of stuff. In El Salvador, they shot nuns dead.

9:49But I mean, it's one after the other, after the other, after the other. And so they all justify it by whatever crazy stuff they can come up with. But it's a constant. I mean, look at Putin. Putin's just murdering people every day. He likes them. He enjoys it. He's a psychopath. Blowing up towns, blowing up hospitals, blowing up schools. They don't have to do that. That's not war. All right. He's just lobbing missiles and drones in there to kill civilians. He knows he's doing it. Russian people put up with it, which is incredible. But, you know, I've seen a lot of evil in my life. That's for sure.

10:26So, like, let's take an example of, like, just the guy who's considered the most evil in modern days or maybe of all time, Hitler. Let's say you were to talk to Hitler personally in, I don't know, 1935, 1936. he's still evil and he's always evil, but it was before all the real atrocities. What could you say to him that might have an effect or an impact? Nothing. These are all mentally ill people. So Hitler wrote a book in the late 1920s, Mein Kampf. We kind of laid out the master race theory that the German people were Aryans and they could do whatever they wanted to the lesser races. So everybody knew.

11:13German people knew. This guy, if you give him power, he's going to start to wipe out Jews and gypsies and communists and whoever else he didn't like. Okay? But because the German people were suffering from economic hardship because they resented the Treaty of Asai in World War I, a whole bunch of reasons. They said, ah, yeah, he's not that bad. We'll give him the power. He'll get us back on track. And then boom. The same thing in China with Mao. Mao's the worst mass murder on earth, 20 million of his own people. He starved them to death because he wanted a different type of society. But you can't talk to these people because they're not, it's not like you and me talking right now.

11:55They're not real people. They're damaged in a sense that they don't live in our world. They live in a world of self-gratification and violence. And there's a lot of them. and now there's a trend in the United States not to punish those people, not to isolate them. Let them do 15 or 20 crimes. Look at a guy on a bus in Charlotte, slit that poor woman's throat. Never should have been out on the street in a million years. Judge let him out. For what? For what? Why did you let him out? Judge doesn't answer any questions. There's a Thomas Sowell quote that says, mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent.

12:37Well, that's a good quote. He's a brilliant man. But it's now in the system. And the system and the progressive left says, we're an unjust society. We're a racist justice system. So, yeah, you can't really punish people harshly. It's not really their fault. They're going out mugging some old lady and breaking her arm. I mean, it's totally insane. And we've seen this for our history. What's particularly worrisome too is people now can see this is the, the evil is being televised. Uh, you know, like the, the, the situation you just said, the girl who was her, her throat was slit on the subway, that video, we've all watched it.

13:18Charlie Kirk being shot was maybe the most shocking video I've ever seen. Just the brutality of it. And of course the, the videos coming out of October 7th in Israel. So we all see this now. Do you think this is giving society this collective PTSD? No, I don't, I don't agree that society, uh, is tilted by exposure, but here is a key. The allegation of Mr. Kirk, his family knew that he was going down and his father, who was a sheriff's deputy in Utah, told the authorities, look, we saw that he was on the internet in these evil, dark sites, absorbing this kind of information. We saw his deterioration mentally.

14:14Okay, that happens with more frequency than ever before because we didn't have the internet before. So somebody who's mentally ill but may not act upon their illness, they now have a club on the internet where people are saying, yeah, do it, do it, do it, do it, do it. And some of them get pushed over the edge. So my question for the father, and I do this with all due respect, I think he's a good man, was why didn't you intervene? If you saw your son acting in an a rational way and you knew what he where he was uh you you had to step in there but you know that that is what society needs to come to grips with we have to intervene and but i wonder though how difficult it is in the sense that these echo chambers of violence and evil are being normalized Look, you have guys like Nick Fuentes, popular guy.

15:12You stumble on any of his videos. He's just ranting about black people and Jews. And he gets tens of thousands of likes. Like these echo chambers of evil have millions and millions of people in it. It's now become a normal conversation to say the most racist, anti-Semitic things. And people don't judge you for that. It's remarkable compared to when... And it's remarkable to me even compared with like 10 years ago. Well, I think a lot of people do judge. But if you have 15 % who are evil to the core, we live in a country where you've got 340 million people. So do the math on that. That's a lot of folks.

15:54And now they have a clubhouse, the Internet, where they all get together and spout this garbage. Now our freedoms work against us here. Because you just can't sanction people and shut them down because they may have violent thoughts. You threaten somebody individually, you can't. But collectively, you can't. And so in a totalitarian society like Singapore, for example, you don't have this. Because the inkling of evil is enough to bring the authorities in to isolate you. they don't have any real rights over there. The government tells them what they can and can't do. Same thing in China. When I was in China in May, it's the biggest police state in the history of the world.

16:43But in a free society, this is allowed. And I don't see a solution to that problem.

16:52Take a quick break. If you like this episode, I'd really, really appreciate it. It means so much to me. Please share it with your friends and subscribe to the podcast. email me at alcatra at gmail.com and tell me why you subscribed. Thanks.

17:13In today's world, you have to be super careful with your data, whether it's your passwords, your bank info, your private emails or messages. There is nonstop attempts to get your data. And some of it's like legit corporations stealing your data. And some of it's from hacking and some of it's from, you know, viruses you have on your computer. By the way, everybody probably has some sort of virus on their computer. But here's the thing. You wouldn't take out your wallet in a shady part of town and start flashing your money around, right? Because you're worried that it would get stolen. Well, that's what you do every time you use public Wi-Fi.

17:50Public Wi-Fi is the shady part of town. Every time you connect to an unencrypted network, like let's say you're in the airport and you use the public Wi-Fi in the airport, your online data is not secure. Any hacker on the same network, it's not easy, but they can do it. They can gain access to and steal your personal data. Again, passwords, bank logins, credit card details, on and on. It doesn't take much technical knowledge to hack someone. Some cheap hardware is needed. A smart 12-year-old is hacking you when you log into the airport Wi-Fi. Your data is valuable. The statistics show hackers can make up to$1 ,000 per person selling personal info on the dark web.

18:33ExpressVPN stops hackers from stealing your data by creating a secure encrypted tunnel between your device and the internet. It would take a hacker with a supercomputer over a billion years to get past ExpressVPN's encryption. It's easy to use. You just fire up the app and click one button and you're protected. It works on all devices, phones, laptops, tablets, everything. Optional, dedicated IP service engineered with an innovative zero-knowledge design, not even ExpressVPN can trace an IP address back to the user. Select plans include Identity Defender, a new suite of tools to get your data removed from data brokers, alert you when your data appears on the dark web, and even ensure you against data theft for up to$1 million.

19:13It's rated number one by top tech reviewers like CNET and The Verge. So for me, it's personally important to use ExpressVPN. I don't know how my data is gonna be used. I don't want people to even know where I'm at. I don't want people obviously to know my passwords. I probably use the same password for everything. So use that info how you must. But look, secure your online data today by visiting expressvpn.com slash altature. And the altature is all in caps, A-L-T-U-C-H-E-R. That's expressvpn, E-X-P-R-E-S-S, vpn.com slash altature to find out how you can get up to four extra months. expressvpn.com slash Altature.

20:01So things have gotten really busy for me lately and I've asked for it. Like I'm doing all things I love doing and wanting to do, but I'm very busy and I have to be focused on every single thing. And some of these things that I do during the day, like, Like basically, I'm helping run three different businesses. Plus, I'm doing three podcasts a week. And I have to read and prepare for each podcast. I'm writing a book. Those are just like my professional career things. And then I'm doing all sorts of other things. And I often have to switch from meeting to meeting to meeting. And my brain has to stay focused.

20:39And I don't want to take any stimulants that's going to get me like overhyped or overstimulated and not. I really want to function optimally. I don't think this is going to last forever. Well, I hope it doesn't last more than a month like this. But basically, I had to figure out what to do. And I really can't highly recommend enough Huel, H-U-E-L, and their black addition powder. It's like a complete meal. So you feel full, focused, and I feel more ready for the day. Like it actually works. So at less than$3 per meal, it's packed with 40 grams of plant-based protein and 27 essential vitamins and minerals, no added sugar, gluten-free, tastes great with flavors like salted caramel and chocolate.

21:27Plus it keeps me full for hours. That's key. I don't want to be like hungry during all these meetings. And it's perfect for breakfast, lunch, or post-workout. And just when you thought Huel had everything covered, they just dropped a first of its kind, super greens drink in a can. And it's called the Huel Daily Greens Ready to Drink. So you forget powders, forget those pills. This is your daily greens. No mixing, no mess, quick and convenient without compromising nutrients. Don't go for those compromising nutrients. It's sparkling and comes in flavors like blueberry, apple, peach, 42 vitamins, minerals, and superfoods, only 25 calories, four grams of fiber, one gram of sugar, made by dieticians.

22:13So try Huel with 15 % off for new customers today using my code Altature at Huel.com slash Altature. Fuel your best performance with Huel today.

22:32Being an entrepreneur is a 24-7 job. And when you're hiring, you need a partner that works as hard as you do. That hiring partner is LinkedIn Jobs. When you clock out, LinkedIn clocks in. LinkedIn makes it easy to post your job for free, share with your network, get qualified candidates that you can manage all in one place. For one thing there, you can post a job. LinkedIn's new feature can help you write job descriptions and then quickly get your job in front of the right people. You get qualified candidates at the end of the day. The most important thing to your business is the quality of the candidates.

23:04And with LinkedIn, of course, you can feel confident that you're getting the best. Based on LinkedIn data, 72 % of small, medium businesses say using LinkedIn helps them find high quality candidates. Find out why more than 2.5 million small businesses use LinkedIn for hiring today. Find your next great hire on LinkedIn. Post your job for free at linkedin.com slash altature. That's linkedin.com slash altature to post your job for free. Terms and conditions apply. We all learn about these things in school and we read about them and then everybody starts misusing like calling this person hitler that person hitler but you you this was a real documenting of all these different acts of evil and i really found it eye-opening and it didn't make me think of modern times like you say in a free society it's not possible to basically police this evil and yet we have to or or are you saying we're just doomed as a world.

24:03We're not doomed, but we're going to be suffering as we always have. That's the state of the world. You're not doomed. You still survive because there are more good people than evil people, but the suffering is not going to stop. And anybody who's been the victim of a crime or lost people like on 9-11, I opened Confronting evil with uh october 7th in uh israel and the hamas raid and i did that to show people contemporaneously it's happened now it happened in our lifetime what these hamas terrorists actually did to babies and grandmothers and no reason no reason they weren't going to get any benefit from doing this, pure hatred, all right?

24:54And I said, I wanted to shock the reader into, this is real. What's the solution to this? There is no solution to it, but you can contain it to some extent. But now in the United States, that containment measure is starting to decline with the progressive left saying, oh, no, don't punish him. No, no, no, no. We'll have a discussion. We'll send a social worker in. You can't do that. But it's happening. At what point does it become also like an, almost like an IQ issue? Like you have all these groups, like let's say Queers for Palestine, when people in Hamas or people who support Hamas clearly state, hey, we'll kill you if you're gay and you go over to Gaza.

25:49And at what point are these people just stupid who are defending the people who would kill them? A lot, there are a lot of stupid people. Constitution gives you a right to be a moron. That should be written in there. There are a lot of dumb people. And the people that fit into that category are apathetic. They don't care. They don't seek information. They live in a bubble. they create their own world, their own world is limited, or they're lazy. And the school, public schools in America, you said they teach you, they don't teach you, they don't. You go into any junior class in any public high school in this country and you ask them about the 15 miscreants I write about in Confronting Evil, they don't know anything about them.

26:40But you know, every one of those men, and I couldn't find any women to even come close to what these guys did, they all relate to today. The evil deeds that they did relate to our lives now. Even Caligula, the Roman emperor, Rome fell. The whole thing shattered because of him and the subsequent people who came after him, but he set the tone. If Rome could collapse, certainly the United States could. And that's why I included these people in the book. You know why, like you say, a lot of these people are, or all of these people are mentally ill, but they also justify their behavior in very, you know, twisted, dark ways.

27:30And that's how they get the population kind of on their side or supporting them. Like you mentioned how Hitler kind of played into Germany's economic collapse and then used that to sort of take power and start doing what he was doing. But, you know, look at Rome as a great example where you have a guy like Augustus, you know, one of the first emperors, you know, the first emperor after Julius Caesar, and they kind of call his reign a reign of peace. It was the most peaceful time during Rome. And yet in order to get there, he basically first killed everyone who opposed him. So when would you say someone like that was evil as well, but then kind of used that initial evil to establish a good period?

28:17These are sort of the confusing periods for me. Well, there's not a lot of data to support what was in Augustus's mind. We know him because he was reigning when they nailed Jesus to the cross. So he certainly wasn't a benign leader ever. There have been times in history where what they call strong men have taken over and then they impose order. That's what they do. They impose order on a certain population. um i deal with the people who uh rain led to disorder so world war ii 100 million dead i mean my god uh so yeah i mean it's not a straight line always and there are evil people who've accomplished some good yeah and so you know you you have the hitlers the stalin's the Mao's between between the three of them like you say maybe it's 100 million maybe it's even more when you throw in Mao's uh deaths in the in the 60s all the people who died from starvation from Mao's policies did they ever turn around like does Mao ever think to himself maybe I did something wrong you know none of these people showed any remorse at all then that's one of the classifications to make the book.

Read the full transcript

29:48None of them showed any remorse whatsoever to anyone at any time. They went down, they died in their evilness. So they're probably in a very warm place right now. Let's hope so. And again, when you say, okay, some of these countries have a strong man who establishes order, and you mentioned how Singapore is practically a police state, China's practically a police state, but this is where they're able to deal with crime and evil, maybe in ways that are appropriate now. And you also mentioned, you know, the Constitution allows for stupid people, which is, you know, of course. But at the same time, we all revere the Constitution.

30:33We all revere not having an authoritarian police state. And do you think sometimes it needs to cycle in that way? Is that your belief? No, the Constitution was set up for the benefit of all, but that doesn't mean all are going to take benefit from it. So if you read the Constitution, it gave the people of the United States the power to elect other people to represent them. And hopefully, they were going to represent good people. They're going to vote for good people. But that doesn't always happen. The founding fathers knew that. just a clash between Jefferson and Aaron Burr that was going on right in the beginning of this country, they knew.

31:20But what was the other alternative? They didn't want the king telling them what they do. They didn't want some crazy dictator like Genghis Khan ordering a population to slaughter all the Canadians and Mexicans, which is what Genghis would have done if he had been born in 1750. So they came up with the best solution. We'll give everybody a chance at freedom and hopefully there'll be more responsible people and irresponsible and that'll endure, which it has. It has, and yet, like you say, we're experiencing more of this evil than ever. The shootings are going up. Look, you're seeing this, like there are some questions that seem very obvious, the answers, but then they become political.

32:10Like, let's just take what's going on now. Federal buildings in Portland are being attacked. So why shouldn't it be okay for the president to put federal police to protect federal buildings? And yet this is a huge deal. Like judges are arguing against it. And local police are not protecting these buildings. So I'm not saying this is an example of evil, but this is kind of the divisiveness now that it seems like we can't pull out of. We're sort of going faster and faster into this divisiveness, which almost doesn't make sense on any issue at all. Well, the Supreme Court will sort all that out. And they'll rule the right way that the president of the United States has the authority to protect federal workers and federal structures.

32:58That'll happen. And that's another example of how the Constitution works. so you're always going to have the two uh or three or four dissenters coming at it but then we have a body nine judges that are supposedly just sorted out and i think that's what will happen in this case but what if it doesn't like it just so happens that five out of the nine judges are were appointed by republicans so they vote that you know they tend to vote that way not always but But, you know, what if you just didn't have that? Then the country descends into anarchy. That's what happens. So, so far, we've had one period of anarchy, the Civil War.

33:39And the Civil War was a 20-year experience, all told. And then another 30 or 40 where the South refused to honor the rights of black Americans. So that was a pretty significant thing that you saw the Constitution totter, but ultimately right itself after a lot of pain. We could enter into another era like that if the progressive left wins, but I don't believe they will. I think most Americans know the danger on the far left at this point. do you think that or are you also in an echo chamber because i look at some you know social media sites and it's just all one way or the other and the echo chambers are just ridiculous what people are saying about you know let's say jews blacks republicans or democrats you know just people are like it is 15 or just either mentally ill or evil and i'm not even picking a side here it's just on it's on every side and like who you know using your political analysis and you did this for decades who do you think will be the the democratic candidate for president or who who's the most likely there'll be a whole slew of governors running and uh there'll be some far left uh aoc types running but it's impossible to tell because the country would be much different three years from now than it is now but let me address your point about the internet.

35:08It's just a very small sliver of the population. I'm a data guy, and I see the data from all polling, not the polling that you see, but the internal polling taken by both parties. And overwhelmingly, extremists are rejected. Overwhelmingly. Now, if that number begins to soften, I certainly will report it to my viewers and listeners, millions of them all over the world now, but it hasn't. so I'm not as pessimistic as you. I don't live in that internet world. I know the danger of it, and I stay away from it. I'm more of a data guy, and I know who the people are that compile the information from the American public.

35:56Most of them are not good, but there are a few that are, and those are the ones that I rely upon. and you know would you say that people like mal hitler stalin putin obviously they're mentally ill but is there a particular are they just all psychopaths is there some way you know a lot of mental illness involves some damage to the brain would you i wonder if there's ever any way to kind of detect and this is almost like a stupid question because the answer is probably no but I wonder if there's any way to detect, you know, someone who could potentially be a Hitler. There will be with AI, but it isn't there now.

36:39But just because a person's mentally ill doesn't mean they don't know what they're doing. They know. The guy on the Charlotte bus who killed that woman from Ukraine, he knew what he was doing, but he was mentally ill because you wouldn't do that if you're a normal person. So you can't say, oh, the guy's mentally ill, so we got to let him off. No. They know what they're doing. But for whatever reason, they don't care. They don't feel any human emotion like Putin. Putin's the best example of a psychopath there is. I mean, this guy, you watch him, there he is. He functions. He's running a country of 150 million people, and he's killing people every day.

37:22And for fun, for sport. so you go whoa but the russian people allow them to do it and then that is the danger right because then there's the second order or the second derivative of this evil like like for instance people who applaud whether you're a democrat or republican doesn't shouldn't matter people who are applauding the death of charlie kirk or even the Ukrainian girl or the Israelis on October 7th, regardless of past events or future events from that, October 7th was horrible. And yet so many people just sort of either justifying it or claiming it didn't happen, given even though there's so much evidence, videos, video evidence that the Palestinians took themselves.

38:12And I'm not being one way or the other. It's just there's factual evidence here. Like, what is this second order of people who applaud the evil? Emotionally disturbed, sociopaths, narcissists. I mean, you just go bring a psychiatrist and they can list all the disorders, but it's not rational behavior. And I just walk away from it myself. I I don't engage people like that. And they don't do that around me anyway, James, because I'm six foot four, 200 pounds, and I don't look like I'm going to say it's okay if you think Charlie Kirk's assassination was justified. So they don't do it around me. But I know it exists.

38:57And my advice to people is just walk away. Have a nice day. See you later. And never talk to the person again because you're not going to convince them. Anybody that far out there, Let them live in their own delusionary world. Don't have anything to do with them because they'll turn on you. Yeah, very true. Is there any leader you left out of this that you would have liked to put in? I was thinking someone like a Paul Pott. Yeah, but they were regional. Again, the 15 who made the cut, everything they did influences us today. So Saddam Hussein, he was Iraq, caused trouble, but not at the scale of these others.

39:40Like the drug cartels killing millions of people all over the world. I think that's staggering what the damage and evil they are doing. And when I see people objecting to Trump, designate him as terrorists and trying to blow him out of the water, I just go, you know, people have no idea what's going on. And that I'll leave you with because I got to run here. That is a key that there are just a lot of people who will not accept reality, James. They just won't. And you can just all day long, bring them the facts, show them what's going on. They can see the video. But people believe what they want to believe.

40:23And if they want to believe that Charlie Kirk was some kind of demon who deserved to die, that's what they're going to believe until they get hurt. like Kimmel. Now, once they get hurt, then they draw back in the self-protective realm. But there are not that many of them. 15 % is 15%. 85 % of people don't believe that. So that's what we have to latch on to and mobilize those people in confrontation against evil. well i like ending on a note of hope and optimism i hope you're right i sort of believe you're right but recent events have thrown me off a little bit myself and uh i get i get worried but but bill o'reilly thanks so much again coming on the show confronting evil assessing the worst of the quickly what's the next book you're always on something confronting america what has to change all right good stuff thanks once again bill all right james thanks for having me

41:40this october fear is free on pluto tv with horror movie collections from paranormal activity You will die in seven days. Scream. And from dusk till dawn. This is my kind of place. And don't miss the man-made nightmares in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. Or the world-ending chaos in 28 Days Later. There's something in the blood. All the scares. All for free. Pluto TV. Stream now. Pay never.

From the publisher

A Note from James:

Bill O’Reilly’s new book, Confronting Evil, is both a history lesson and a warning. It’s a study of the most destructive figures in human history—from Hitler, Stalin, and Mao to Genghis Khan, Caligula, and even modern evildoers like Putin and the cartels.

When I first picked it up, I thought it would be about the past. But after reading it, I realized it’s really about right now—about how evil mutates, reappears, and spreads when we stop paying attention.

We talked about the psychology of evil, how it manifests differently in modern life, and why we all need to look inward at how we process fear and anger. The episode ends on a note of hope—but only if we’re willing to face what’s real.


Episode Description:

In this episode, James sits down with legendary journalist and author Bill O’Reilly to discuss his new book, Confronting Evil: Assessing the Worst of the Worst. Together, they explore how history’s darkest figures—Hitler, Mao, Stalin, Putin, and others—reflect modern patterns of violence, polarization, and moral decay.

O’Reilly draws from decades of reporting and war correspondence to explain the difference between “personal evil” and “collective evil,” and why societies collapse when good people stop paying attention.

The conversation also looks at free speech, mental illness, the internet’s role in radicalization, and why mercy for the guilty so often becomes cruelty to the innocent.


What You’ll Learn:

  • The 15 most destructive figures in world history—and why their patterns are repeating today.
  • The two types of evil: personal vs. collective.
  • How technology and echo chambers amplify hatred.
  • Why ignoring small evils allows larger ones to grow.
  • How to recognize and contain evil in a free society.


Timestamped Chapters:

  • [02:00] A Note from James: Introducing Confronting Evil
  • [02:39] Are we living in a new age of violence or just a repeating cycle?
  • [03:39] On partisanship, anger, and how fear disguises itself
  • [04:57] Bill joins: marketing a book in the age of distraction
  • [05:51] Why O’Reilly wrote Confronting Evil and how it differs from his “Killing” series
  • [07:16] Putin, October 7th, and the eerie timing of the book’s release
  • [08:20] Why today’s evil feels more personal than historic evil
  • [09:39] Personal encounters with evil: chasing Ted Bundy
  • [11:01] Witnessing atrocities: from El Salvador to Belfast
  • [12:24] Could Hitler have been reasoned with? The psychology of the irredeemable
  • [14:27] “Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent” — justice and accountability
  • [15:36] The internet’s role in radicalization and digital “clubs for evil”
  • [17:00] Echo chambers, hate speech, and how the free world handles extremism
  • [19:02] Why confronting evil matters in a “free” but apathetic society
  • [20:00] The October 7th attacks and why O’Reilly opens his book there
  • [21:22] “Queers for Palestine” and the IQ of modern activism
  • [22:00] How ignorance and apathy breed delusion
  • [23:00] When does “necessary evil” cross the line into tyranny? Augustus and strongmen
  • [25:10] The psychology of dictators: no remorse, no redemption
  • [26:11] The Constitution as an anti-authoritarian framework
  • [27:50] Polarization, Portland, and the fight over federal authority
  • [29:00] How democracies correct themselves—eventually
  • [31:31] Data over ideology: why extremists are still a minority
  • [32:04] Can AI detect future Hitlers?
  • [33:28] Why people cheer for evil—and how to walk away
  • [34:46] The 15 who made the cut: why some evildoers were left out
  • [35:36] The drug cartels as modern-day mass murderers
  • [36:29] O’Reilly’s warning: mobilize the 85% before it’s too late
  • [36:54] Ending on hope—why good still outnumbers evil


Additional Resources


See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

More from The James Altucher Show

All 301 episodes
Confronting Evil with Bill O’ReillyThe James Altucher Show · 40 min
Listen in VO