The Next Billion-Dollar Bitcoin Idea: Inscriptions and Ordinals

12 Apr 2024 · 59 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Summary: The James Altucher Show - Episode: The Next Billion-Dollar Bitcoin Idea: Inscriptions and Ordinals

Overview In this episode of *The James Altucher Show*, James Altucher delves into the emerging trends of inscriptions and ordinals on the Bitcoin blockchain. Joined by experts Timothy Collins and Benjamin Republic, they explore how these innovations are reshaping collectible markets, offering historical significance and potential value appreciation, akin to NFTs but on the more stable Bitcoin network.

Key Themes and Concepts

  1. Introduction to Inscriptions and Ordinals
  2. Definition: Inscriptions and ordinals represent a new class of collectibles on the Bitcoin blockchain, creating a market for unique digital items.
  3. Comparison with NFTs: Unlike NFTs on Ethereum, which can often seem like mere JPEGs, Bitcoin inscriptions promise greater permanence and historical significance.
  1. Historical Significance of Bitcoin Transactions
  2. Satoshis: Each Satoshi (the smallest unit of Bitcoin) is assigned a unique ordinal number, making certain Satoshis collectible based on their historical transactions.
  3. Example: The infamous pizza transaction in 2010, where 10,000 Bitcoins were used to purchase pizzas, highlighted as a milestone.
  1. The Value of Satoshis
  2. Rarity and Value: Some Satoshis are more valuable due to historical significance, such as the first mined Satoshi in each block or those from the first transactions made by Satoshi Nakamoto.
  3. Market Impact: The discussion on how these unique Satoshis influence market dynamics and create opportunities for collectors.
  1. The Mechanics of Inscriptions
  2. Inscriptions: The process of attaching data (like images or code) to Bitcoin transactions, utilizing the witness data in Taproot wallets.
  3. Use Cases: Potential applications include digital art, certificates, and even books stored on the blockchain permanently.
  1. The Community and Marketplace
  2. Growing Community: The episode discusses how the community of creators and collectors is crucial for the success of inscriptions.
  3. Marketplaces: Platforms like SatScribe, Magic Eden, and Magisat are highlighted as venues where collectors can buy, sell, or create inscriptions.
  1. Future Opportunities
  2. Speculative Nature: The episode emphasizes the speculative opportunities in this new market, especially with the upcoming Bitcoin halving event expected to affect the dynamics.
  3. Potential for Growth: There's a sense of optimism that as awareness grows, the market for ordinals and inscriptions could expand significantly beyond its current niche audience.

Key Takeaways

  • Satoshis as Collectibles: The uniqueness and historical context of certain Satoshis create a valuable collectible market.
  • Inscriptions vs. NFTs: Inscriptions on Bitcoin offer a more permanent and secure alternative to Ethereum's NFTs, possibly appealing to a broader audience.
  • Community Importance: The support and engagement of the community are vital for the growth and sustainability of the inscriptions market.
  • Technological Advancements: With evolving protocols such as Casey Rodemore’s ordinal theory and the upcoming Runes project, new opportunities for creativity and investment are emerging.

Conclusion This episode highlights a pivotal moment in the Bitcoin ecosystem, where inscriptions and ordinals could redefine digital ownership and collectibles. As the community grows and technological advancements unfold, opportunities for everyday users to engage with this space are likely to expand, potentially leading to significant market shifts in the future.

Listeners interested in entering this space are encouraged to explore various platforms and engage with the community to understand the evolving landscape of Bitcoin collectibles.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Look, as a manager of people, as an employer, as an entrepreneur, and as an investor in startups, I can tell you the most important thing for your business is the quality of the quality of people. you hire. The best part is that great candidates are already on LinkedIn. Employees hired through LinkedIn are 30 % more likely to stick around for at least a year compared to those hired through the leading competitor. And I will tell you that the great thing about LinkedIn is that you're not just looking at random people. You're able to see the people who your friends and trusted peers and colleagues who they trust and who they've hired in the past and who they recommend.

0:42And hiring doesn't have to be complicated. Realistically, when you have a business to run, you don't want to spend hours on hiring. You want to hire the right person as quickly as possible. That's why LinkedIn Jobs AI Assistant suggests immediately 25 great big candidates daily so you can invite them to apply and keep things moving. Hire right the first time. Post your job for free at linkedin.com slash altature. then promote it to use LinkedIn Jobs' new AI assistant, making it easier and faster to find the top candidates. That's LinkedIn.com slash Altucher. Post your job for free. Terms and conditions apply.

1:19This isn't your average business podcast and he's not your average host. This is the James Altucher Show.

1:36A few weeks ago, I was talking to Tim Collins, who has been on this podcast before. He's talked about NFTs and crypto and so on in this podcast before. I was talking to Tim Collins, and I never was really that into NFTs, but Tim got me super excited about the potential for, and I guess they'll describe the differences, but something called inscriptions and ordinals, which is like what NFTs are to Ethereum. Inscriptions and ordinals seem to be an improved version, but on Bitcoin, but much more interesting. And I'm going to let Tim and Ben Hoenig from Sats Republic describe, but how are you guys doing?

2:21Hey, James. It's good to be back. I got super excited, Tim, when we were talking. Oh, I know. We were driving around Austin in a car. And by the way, how good was that food? oh my god it was excellent but i i was i had so many questions about these inscriptions i barely remember the food i was getting well i was gonna say on that whole cart ride over i don't think i got out half an answer before you were asking the next question and you are correct uh the ordinal uh the ordinal movement on bitcoin or the discovery of bit in bitcoin is is a big deal um And when you think about the comparison to NFTs and everything that NFTs lacked, which a lot of times just, you know, we're talking about PNGs or JPEGs in their house, in the cloud, as opposed to being actual data.

3:10You know, Bitcoin, it's funny, we always say Bitcoin fixes this. But in that case, it's actually true where this becomes something permanent and something that stays there. It's going to outlive us all. but but like nfts created a market of millions and tens of millions of dollars and it's still i don't want to say it's thriving but it still exists but this inscriptions and ordinals seems like a real thing that people could get like nfts just always had a bullshit flavor to me and maybe it is maybe it isn't but this seems like really real and maybe you could like maybe you guys could describe a little more what it is and then how one can make one and why one would make one and so on well let me do this we'll we'll start i'm going to turn it over to ben here and introduce ben ben i met through the pizza artifacts uh ordinal collection which um it was actually the second thing i ever inscribed and it was the first collection that was ever done on the exotic pizza sets.

4:13If you think back to, gosh, when was that, Ben? The first pizza that was purchased. 2010? So this is when 10 ,000 Bitcoins were used to buy one slice of pizza or one pizza pie. The world's most expensive pizza. Who was that guy? Who was that guy? Laszlo Hanyas was his name. I hope he ultimately made some money on Bitcoin. Me too. Me too. $700 million fade's a bad one. Yeah. I mean, do you think he kills himself? No. I think I've seen some interviews about him, and he sits here and he's like, listen, if I didn't do it, Bitcoin wouldn't be what it is today. So if anything, you're welcome. I don't know about that.

4:56You're not taking a lot of credit. But he did demonstrate. It was the first ever transaction. Yep. Real world purchase. But so Ben, I met Ben through that and that got me turned on to the whole idea of sats. Before it was, you know, I have a very low. A sat is a satoshi, which is one billionth of a Bitcoin. One hundredth millionth. One hundred millionth of a Bitcoin. So the same way that there's a hundred pennies and one dollar, there's a hundred million satoshis in one Bitcoin. Imagine asking for that change. So, so, right. So I have a couple of questions. you made an inscription relating to these pizza coins, the Bitcoins actually used in the transaction for the pizza.

5:44It's as if I had like a dollar that Barack Obama used to ride the subway on his way to voting or something. So it's as if I had that actual dollar. Sure, sure. And so you took a Satoshi from one of these 10 ,000, Bitcoins that were used to buy in the very first Bitcoin transaction. And you inscribed like a picture of a pizza on it. So what is the meaning of that? What's the value of that? Why'd you do that? What is this? What's an inscription? Yeah, for sure. Maybe you could answer. And did you start the pizza project that Tim got excited about? Yes, yes, I did. And I know a mutual friend of ours through the Bored Ape community just from being a part of that previously.

6:30Still am. And you have a Bored Ape NFT hanging right behind you. I do. It's the Rolling Stone magazine. There's a few other from the different Ape Fests over here. I got to do something with all the memorabilia. Now, do you have an original, speaking of NFTs, do you have an original Bored Ape NFT? Yeah, of course. I actually, I think right now, last I looked, the floor is at like 14, which is obviously, you know, down from all-time highs, big time. But I was fortunate. It's still, yeah, I was about to say ETH is still up. It's still not cheap. That being said, you know, a lot of Ethereum projects are losing a lot of steam, including CryptoPunks right now because of, you know, the big craze in Ordinals right now.

7:13That being said, you know, I think CryptoPunks have staying power. I think that, you know, Bored Apes are still, you know, Yuga is still the most well-capitalized, you know, NFT company in the world. and uh you know i think that there's hope i think that you know obviously you know every company goes through their bumps but i think what's interesting is that board apes are still always talked about they're still like the strongest ip play when it comes to web3 and there's you know pudgy penguins are definitely giving them a run for their money but everyone knows what a board ape is still so i think they're still culturally relevant i always thought there wasn't anything truly artistic about nfts or or like okay there may be some value some utility like maybe they could be used as tickets or you know i was trying to think of use cases for nfts this is another topic we we've we've talked about nfts but there's something that seems intrinsically interesting about inscriptions and ordinals to me and also by the way for bitcoin miners this is very interesting it's it's a way a new revenue source now that they're the having is going to cut their revenues in half.

8:16So maybe describe what this pizza inscription is, and then we can start from that. For sure. So what I'll actually start with initially is what are ordinals and how does this all work? So essentially, there is a Bitcoin dev named Casey Rodemore who invented something called ordinal theory. And what ordinal theory does is it's a lens into Bitcoin, meaning it's built on top of Bitcoin's pre-existing protocol. And what he's done is he's created a protocol on top of that, that assigns numbers to each individual Satoshi, starting from the first one to the last one. So, you know, you have the Genesis block that Satoshi Nakamoto mined, and every single Satoshi in each Bitcoin is assigned an individual number, 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, you know, and so on and so forth.

9:00Up to 21 million. Yes. Well, remember, 21 million times 100 million. Is the number of Satoshis. Correct. And they're numbered. Correct. And so these exotic pizza sats, for instance, are, you know, as you do the numbering and you see when the transaction happened of those 10 ,000 Bitcoin for the two pies of pizza, you're able to say, oh, those are these specific sats because you can see when that transaction happened on chain. You can take a look at the blocks or go to May 22, 2010, and you can very clearly see, you know, a transaction for 10 ,000 Bitcoin. Okay, so step one is, and this is interesting to me, you have to look, like, let's say I'm hypothetically interested in some historical occasion on the Bitcoin blockchain, a transaction that occurred.

9:52Like the very first transaction, 10 ,000 Bitcoins for one pizza pie. And first step is I have to find those 10 ,000 coins. Correct. Correct. Now, obviously, with there being 10 ,000 Bitcoin in that transaction, that's a lot of Satoshis. So pizza artifacts, like pizza sats, pizza artifacts are different, but pizza sats are exotic. They're not rare. There's a ton of them and they're pretty inexpensive to acquire because they're part of 10 ,000 Bitcoin. But they have a great story. But how would I even find those Satoshis from those 10 ,000 Bitcoin? For sure. So when you send Bitcoin from one person to another, for instance, if you have one Bitcoin and you send me one Bitcoin, but maybe you have 10 Bitcoin in your wallet, I'm getting one Bitcoin from you.

10:44But the underlying Satoshis that make up that UTXO that you're sending are totally different. So what people do is they'll sat hunt. So, for instance, I'll take 10 Bitcoin and send it to Coinbase and then I'll withdraw it back. Now, while I might still be sending 10 Bitcoin to Coinbase and receiving 10 Bitcoin in return, the underlying Satoshis that I'm getting are different. So what I'm able to do is imagine you have like 10 decks of cards and you're shuffling them all around and you're trying to find all the ace of spades. That's what's happening over here. You're sifting through different Bitcoin and extracting individual sats.

11:15And the way you do that is you're able to go and manipulate the different UTXOs and take out the individual Satoshis. So I'm just, I know this is getting probably a little technical for listeners. So let's say first, I just want to find one of the 10 ,000 Bitcoins that were used in the pizza transaction. How would I go about finding that Bitcoin? Well, nowadays, I mean, like you could go to the Block Explorer. You could, you know, like mempool.space or Block Explorer, you know, any Block Explorer. He doesn't want to give away all his secrets, though. Imagine. But you just literally go scroll back or if you're writing some code, you can query the indexers and find that exact date and find the transactions that happened on that.

12:00And what if someone owns that Bitcoin right now? What if that's buried in some wallet somewhere? For sure. So there's really cool tools that you can go to like satting.io that allows you to copy and paste a wallet address and it'll tell you the Satoshi's in that wallet. Another great place to go is a rare sat marketplace called Magisat, Magisat.io. and you can put your wallet address in there and it'll show you the actual rare and exotic Satoshis in your wallet. And these can be pizzas or for instance, a really popular one are the Block 9 sats or the Block 9 450Xs, which are the first transaction to ever happen on Bitcoin, period.

12:37This is when Satoshi sent money to how many? He sent 50 Bitcoin. So you can have a Block 9. Two times 100 million Satoshis exist from that very first transaction. For sure. And Tim, you just said you own some of those Satoshis. Yeah. I know Ben does as well. But I finally broke down and went and bought a bunch of the exotics. And basically kind of like a diverse portfolio of exotics between palindromes and JPEGs and vintage. Where did you buy them? Did you find them? Actually, Magisat. No, Magisat. I went through Magisat. That is - What's the odds if I have like 10 Bitcoin? what's the odds if I look at my wallet, there's one of those Satoshis?

13:19Not high. That's the thing. A block nine is incredibly difficult to find because those are so early. Those are mostly on dead wallets that just haven't moved in years. So to actually get one in circulation, it's not easy right now. It's obviously, you know, the fact that palindrome or an alpha. For sure. For sure. And uncommons are a little bit easier also. So a palindrome being not. Remember, each Satoshi is numbered. So that number is just a palindrome. Same as it forward as it is backwards. So the Satoshi number is the same forward as it is backwards. So every Bitcoin, all 21 million Bitcoins have palindromes, have repeating numbers and the whole thing.

14:02They're given a sat number and that sat number could be a palindrome or it could be an alphanumeric palindrome. But specifically, though, this block nine Satoshis are Satoshis that were in one of those first 50 Bitcoins. How do you extract the Satoshi from the Bitcoin? So Satting and Magistat both have really easy to use tools now where you can just connect your wallet. And it'll automatically, with a very busy user interface, you can literally just click on the Sat type, click isolate, and it's done. Yeah, you can either isolate or not. What's going on? Yeah, exactly. And obviously, you know, it might get a little too technical for the audience of what's going on behind the hood.

14:42But what's happening is essentially you're rearranging different sats and splitting up different UTXOs to reorganize these and kind of move the position of each sat within a UTXO. And for people that don't know, a UTXO is an unspent transaction output, which is money that you have yet to actually spend from your wallet. So there's two things interesting. One is this underlines the difference between Bitcoins and a dollar. Like I can't take a US dollar and give you the exact pennies that come from that dollar. It just so happens a penny is worth one hundredth of a dollar, but a dollar isn't made up of a hundred pennies that I could then pull out and spend individually.

15:23Like a Bitcoin, you could actually take it apart and pull the pennies out of a Bitcoin. So that's interesting. But the other interesting thing, like take this block nine thing or the pizza transactions. and this is a big difference between inscriptions and nfts it seems like there's what makes something valuable like what makes a specific satoshi valuable is almost its historical significance on the blockchain on it like like satoshis that came out of that first transaction it's almost like they satoshi touched them and so he did it's like it's a real collectible yeah for sure i mean he did yeah that's why that's why they are collectible because he did Those were in his wallet.

16:04Yeah. So like I can see, like the same way people collect baseball cards, I could see how someone could want to collect. If someone loves the history of Bitcoin and everything about Bitcoin, there's value there. There's real, you know. And not only is there value there, but if you think about, you know, the average Bitcoin holder, average Bitcoin holder never really had anything to do with their Bitcoin, right? They had to just hold it. And there are obviously a lot of people that definitely got those through not the most legal terms and really can't spend them without getting flagged. And now, all of a sudden, there's this whole market that is giving people that are traditionally Bitcoin whales just holding Bitcoin an opportunity to actually put that Bitcoin to work.

16:46Because some of these collections that people are buying and selling similarly to the NFT boom of 2021 are skyrocketing. You know, for instance, somebody who just wants to hold on to their Bitcoins forever can say, hey, I'll trade you some of these exotic or rare Satoshis for regular for some amount of money that you give me for a thousand regular Satoshis. Exactly. It's like if you were buying, you know, a penny that George Washington held. A penny is a penny. It's one cent. But because it was George Washington's, maybe you're paying a million dollars for one penny. So it's interesting, right, where you're paying X amount of sats for an individual's satoshi.

17:23Like, remember the wheat pennies? I remember growing up as a kid, you'd always try to collect the wheat pennies. Hey, these are worth more. Or the Indian head nickels. So immediately, I understand, as opposed to NFTs, I understand. Like, NFTs gain value in large part because of the community that was created around a particular group, like the Bored Apes or CryptoPunks or whatever. but this is, so that didn't quite make sense to me. But this, here you're saying there are specific Satoshis and coins out there that have value because of their historical significance. I buy into that because that's like every collectible market.

18:01That's a real collectible market.

18:15me at Alcantra at gmail.com and tell me why you subscribed. Thanks.

18:27Look, as a manager of people, as an employer, as an entrepreneur, and as even an investor in startups, I can tell you the most important thing for your business is the quality of the people you hire. The best part is that great candidates are already on LinkedIn. Employees hired through LinkedIn are 30 % more likely to stick around for at least a year compared to those hired through the leading competitor. And I will tell you that the great thing about LinkedIn is that you're not just looking at random people. You're able to see the people who your friends and trusted peers and colleagues who they trust and who they've hired in the past and who they recommend.

19:10And hiring doesn't have to be complicated. Realistically, when you have a business to run, you don't want to spend hours on hiring. You want to hire the right person as quickly as possible. That's why LinkedIn Jobs AI Assistant suggests immediately 25 great big candidates daily so you can invite them to apply and keep things moving. Hire right the first time. Post your job for free at linkedin.com slash altature. then promote it to use LinkedIn Jobs' new AI assistant, making it easier and faster to find the top candidates. That's LinkedIn.com slash Altachirk. Post your job for free. Terms and conditions apply.

19:46What can 160 years of experience teach you about the future? When it comes to protecting what matters, Pacific Life provides life insurance, retirement income, and employee benefits for people and businesses, building a more confident tomorrow. Strategies rooted in strength and backed by experience. Ask a financial professional how Pacific Life can help you today. Pacific Life Insurance Company, Omaha, Nebraska, and in New York. Pacific Life and Annuity, Phoenix, Arizona. Now, what does it mean now to then inscribe, and why are some Satoshis worth more than others, and so on? For sure. Sure. So when Casey created the protocol, he actually defined Satoshi rarity into the protocol itself.

20:33And these are based on different mining activities. So for instance, the most accessible type of rare sat is a uncommon sat, which is the first sat that is mined in every single block. And that happens about every 10 minutes. So what you're able to do is those are, you know, when those first started being bought and sold or rather traded, you know, before they were P2P marketplace. places and it was all OTC and discords like spreadsheet days, which was very much a thing back in January, February, up until March. People are paying upwards of$1 ,500 just for one uncommon sat just because they were so hard to get at the time.

21:12Now they trade for around 200 bucks, but the prices are usually very volatile. And as you inscribe on them, the supply of them is deflationary. Because once you inscribe on a SAT, you can't uninscribe it. So it kind of takes it out of circulation. So you can modify the inscription though, right? You can re-inscribe a SAT. You can't modify the pre-existing one. It's fully immutable. So like, for instance, what I could do is I could have an inscription, like a PFP that evolves, right? Like I could have, you know, for instance, Pizza Ninjas is a really neat project where what they do is, you know, They have hit this thing called the sat endpoint, which allows you to take your current pizza, inscribe new art on top of it, and then it can display the latest index of what's inscribed.

21:56So the most recent thing gets displayed to the public as opposed to the first thing. um so so okay so so backing up a second so in the this guy casey's uh ordinal theory he basically said certain satoshis and bitcoins are worth more than others for instance the first satoshi that is mined in a particular block is more valuable than the third one she's yeah correct and and i I didn't know this, I guess, but Satoshi's, when miners are validating a transaction, they mine it one Satoshi at a time? They're mining a block at a time. And a block, you're given a reward, for instance. Right now, you're given 6.25 Bitcoin as a reward for mining a block.

22:46And then after the halving, obviously, that's going to be 3.125. So that's another interesting point, actually, is that at this current halving, there is what's called an EpicSat that's going to be mined, which is the first sat mined at each halving block. And currently there's only three in circulation right now. So they're incredibly rare because there's only been three halvings. Now there's a fourth. And not only is there a fourth, but KC is launching a new protocol called RUNES, which is essentially enabling for shit coins or meme coins on Bitcoin. The whole idea is to make the world's grandest casino.

23:21And it gives people the opportunity to deploy their own tokens onto Bitcoin. And that's also happening at the halving. They can take a block and they could say every Satoshi on this block is JamesCoin. Well, it's a little bit more technical about what happens there. What he actually does is you store this data in what's called an op return. And then you actually store things in the transaction output, but that's getting way too technical. But that's humming out at the halving along with an EpicSat being mined at the halving. And this EpicSat is likely going to trade for anywhere between, you know, two and a half upwards to$10 million.

23:59There's only four that exist. To give you an idea, you know, some other very expensive ones that have previously sold. There's what's called a rare sat, which is the first sat that is mined in each difficulty adjustment period. SatRepublic actually brought the first rare sat to auction at Sotheby's, where, you know, the auction house actually recognized rare sats. And we sold that for 2.7 Bitcoin. But what's also really cool is that what's called a black sat, which is someone pretty much took the narrative and said, well, why does it have to be an uncommon sat if it's the first sat that's mined in each block?

24:33What about the last sat? And those are called black sats. And they've caught, you know, a pretty crazy narrative. And the community is kind of like really bought into it. And Casey Rodemore gave them his blessing of it being cool. And as a result, they're very much a thing. And the first ever black rare sat from 2009 actually sold for like four Bitcoin in that sub-abuse auction. So people are paying real money for this. So you're talking about things that are going for a quarter million dollars that are one one millionth of a Bitcoin. One one hundred millionth. Or one one hundredth million. I always miss that up.

25:07So and we're not even we're not even at the inscriptions yet. We're just talking about valuable Satoshis that are valuable for historical reasons. yep and so what's the point then so so okay so there's a market for that the the community plus this guy casey has sort of decided which satoshis are more valuable than others and it sounds like it makes some common sense like the first one the last one palindromes maybe other unique numbers i don't know um what's what are inscriptions then on top of this yeah so inscriptions is essentially, you know, this whole idea that Ordinal is really enabled, which is taking advantage of the witness data in a taproot wallet and allowing you to essentially store data within transactions.

25:58So if you're a miner, you can store up to a four megabyte file on a specific SAT. And then if you just do like relay issues on the network or relay, I wouldn't say issues, but just like relay permissions on the network, you can only do up to 400 kilobytes as like a regular person who's not a miner, but you're able to store arbitrary data on an actual SAT. So for instance, if I take an image and I take like a regular JPEG and I have it under 400 kilobytes, I can store that as a whole string of text, a base 64 image is what it's called. And you put that on a SAT and then through any web browser, you're able to display that.

26:42just like you could anywhere. And that's the place, but not just images. Yeah, so sorry to interrupt. I just want to make an analogy so everybody kind of understands. So if I Venmo you a dollar, I have to say what that dollar's for. Like, oh, I Venmo'd Ben because I bought a pizza from him. I have to put that in the Venmo transaction. That's like the metadata of this transaction. And an inscription is sort of like the metadata. I'll give you a better analogy. Sorry to cut you off now. I'll give you a better analogy. Please cut me off. Don't be sorry. Don't be sorry. Don't ever apologize for that.

Read the full transcript

27:19So the best way that I have found to describe this to people is imagine I gave you a penny. And traditionally, you have Abraham Lincoln on the front and you have the monument on the back. Now, let's say I give you this pen and the penny is, you know, let's say it's rare. It's from 1776 or whatever, right? Let's say that same penny doesn't have Abraham Lincoln on the front and it doesn't have the monument. You just have this copper coin from 1776. That's the rare sat. You can view the rare sat as a canvas, right? It adds to the narrative of what you're putting on it. You then are taking a chisel and you're etching, you know, Abraham Lincoln on the top of that penny and you're putting the monument on the back.

27:55And that's what an inscription is. You're putting data onto the sat or, and does that make sense? Why does a, a, why do we need inscriptions? Like why isn't just the market for rare or exotic sats interesting by itself? Because there's a lot of things that you can do once you're able to store data on the network, and especially not just the network, but the Bitcoin, the most decentralized, most secure network in the entire world. Like that's the whole value add here is that you're actually storing data on chain on Bitcoin as opposed to, for instance, like a board ape is stored on IPFS. And what's IPFS?

28:31It's a bunch of Amazon servers. Same thing with R. If they go down, it's gone. Or Filecoin. It's all just distributed servers. This isn't Bitcoin. It's actually stored on every single person who's running an ordinal's indexer. It is being stored on their node. So it's fully on-chain. And that's the value add here. And what's neat is that this doesn't apply to just images. I can store code. I can store JavaScript. I can store HTML, CSS, any language that I want. And I can have them all interact with one another within this sandbox of the Bitcoin network. So create on-chain programs. You could do a book like that and it can never go, it will never go away.

29:12Unlike if you were to put a book onto an NFT that was stored at Pinata or IPFS. If those companies go out of business, your book is gone. Yeah, like a file coin disappears as a coin for whatever reason. Millions of NFTs are gone. I mean, those are, I think, stored on IPFS also. Like they're stored somewhere, right? They're on some sort of like an Amazon server. But in script, like those aren't stored on the coin itself. Like it would be on like if Ethereum disappeared one day and you weren't able to access the smart contracts and you weren't able to see the if you ever take a look at like the board ape contract, you see that each board ape has what's called a token URI.

29:57And that's a token URL. And that is just referencing an IPFS address that is pulling in an image or pulling in the JSON of the metadata. but like if i wrote a book and inscribed it on one satoshi uh then or let's say let's say i took 10 consecutive satoshis and made a book like that's a book or and then i could i guess i could use 100 million satoshis to print like you know uh a million books then yeah 10 million books and so i can make a whole publishing company where books are just uh stored on satoshis sure i mean what Yeah, I mean, you could do that. You could obviously, yeah, I mean, like, listen, you could probably get a book down to like 400 kilobytes for sure.

30:42But if you can't, what you could do, which is also interesting, is you could inscribe each page of a book, and then do what's called a recursive inscription, right? So what I can do is I can, let's say, I inscribe 1 ,000 pages of a book. And then I have another inscription that says, okay, reference all 1 ,000 of these inscriptions and make me, with JavaScript, a fun animating flipbook. And I can just take those images in. And then fully on-chain, you have an animated book that's pulling in to previous pages. And what's cool also is that people can own a page of the book, right? So it's like if you wanted to like – it might be an interesting idea in case you wanted to sell a book.

31:21Instead of people buying a copy of the book, you mint it out. People can own an individual page. You can actually own the page of the book. And then you're actually distributed this other inscription, which allows you to render the entire book. That's just an idea I came up with off the top of my head. But like it's something you could do. I haven't seen anyone do it. Let's say Warren Buffett was going to – not that he was interested in Satoshis or Bitcoins at all, but let's say Warren Buffett was going to put a stock pick on a Satoshi and auction it off. That's potentially something that could be valuable, for instance.

31:54Sure. And it's something that's on the blockchain forever. I mean if Warren Buffett says this is it, yeah. I mean if – listen, if Warren Buffett actually came out and said something positive about crypto, that would be one thing. if he actually came out and said that, you know, he inscribed his pick on a sat. Yeah, I mean, like that's provenance right there. I'm just thinking, what's the use case? Like right now, I see there's artistic use case. Like, okay, we're going to get this historical Satoshis from these historical Bitcoin transactions. We're going to make some image on it to give it a little bit more artistic value.

32:29And now we're going to sell it. What are some other things that can happen with? Honestly, when we looked at NFTs, like with birth certificates, college graduations, high school diplomas work much better on a SAT because they're all unchained and you don't have to deal with Amazon web server going down and all of a sudden I don't have access to my data anymore. Right. And it seems like it's less friction to find. I mean, it could be in your Bitcoin wallet. Yep. Very simple. Sorry, I didn't need to catch you off, Ben. I know you had some other ideas too. What I would say is it's a more true form of an NFT because of its immutable provenance on the Bitcoin network.

33:14And the truth of the matter is, is Ethereum going to be around forever? Probably. You know, like Ethereum is obviously an incredible, you know, smart contract platform. That being said, there's Base, there's Arbitrum, there's Optimism, there's all these L2s, there's Solana, there's Sui, you know, whatever the hell there is. And I have no idea what the hell is going to last in the next 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 years. But I definitely can assure you that Bitcoin will be here. And that's why it just makes most sense. If you're going to store something on chain, it might as well be on the most decentralized, most secure network in the world, which is the king of all cryptocurrencies.

33:49What's neat in terms of like an everyday use case and more than just, you know, inscribing images is, you know, back to things you can do with code, for instance. long form generative art has been really having an interesting moment as well, because what you're able to do is that people have inscribed, for instance, the P5JS framework on an individual Satoshi. What you're able to do is as an artist, you're able to code your generative art and have it reference that P5JS inscription. The same way if you are writing code on your computer and importing P5.js from a library, you're importing it the same exact way, but it's all on the Bitcoin network, right?

34:26So it's not hitting any external sources. And you can do really neat things like you can reveal the art or have the seed to that generative art be a specific block, right? And have a delayed reveal, for instance. So like, let's say we're maintaining at block 840 ,000, which is the halving, I can make it so maybe I have a collection of 100. One is going to reveal at 840 ,001, 840 ,002, and a fully on-chain delayed reveal with the block itself being, you know the seed which is like i think really really cool there's other use cases as well people are making you know like midi systems so you can generate music on chain i mean like at the tip of the iceberg right now you know like this has only been around a year and so like what what do you see like let's say someone's listening to this doesn't quite understand everything you're saying um how can they think about this in terms of like i want to get involved early in this because i didn't with nfts and what's something creative they could do what's what are what are creative how are you making money right now with this you know other than your company yeah for sure yeah for sure you know obviously like we definitely generated revenue you know building satscribe which was the uh first inscription platform for rare and exotic sats you know obviously there's tons now but this was back in june when we launched it um you know Obviously, pizza artifacts do well, and we have this new platform that we're rolling out.

35:52So with the pizza one, you took rare sats, like the first sat from one of the 10 ,000 bitcoins. Exotic sats. They're considered exotic sats. Okay, you took exotic sats from the 10 ,000 bitcoins. You inscribed something that made whoever sees this inscription aware that, hey, this is a Satoshi. This is an exotic set from one of the Bitcoins from the very first pizza transaction. And what are one of those Satoshis worth right now? So yeah, so a pizza artifact, they've actually done very well. So when we launched those in June, those was June 2023, we launched those for 0.01 Bitcoin. And at the time, Bitcoin was$25 ,000.

36:40So it's like 250 bucks. And now Bitcoin is$70 ,000 and they're trading actively for 0.135 Bitcoin. So around$10 ,000 US, 9 ,500. So they've gone up in value and Bitcoin's gone up in value. And there's only 222. Yeah, there's only 222 of them as well. Why 222? Why did you pick that number? Sorry. That is a very good question. um it had to do so it's it's really interesting so it was partially like we wanted like a fun number like 222 and like the 21 million is obviously a significant number when it comes to bitcoin but like having you know like 210 felt weird um but the truth of the matter is a lot of it was like how do we have a big enough community that also feels kind of tightly knit that we can curate the specific holders that we'd like to be on for this journey with us but at the same time, just so you understand, like it is not cheap to do these inscriptions on Bitcoin.

37:41So when we first launched this, it was like a massive risk where it was like, if we don't sell out right now, we just spent 0.35 Bitcoin inscribing this, which is a lot of money for, you know, a founder to just put up and potentially lose, you know, it's like$20 ,000 at the time. So, or a little bit like 0.35, what was that? Like 12 ,000, 15 ,000, whatever. a substantial amount of money to put up, you know, a substantial amount of money to put up to, you know, maybe not mint out. You know, obviously we did mint out pretty quickly. It only took a couple of hours because, you know, obviously launching out in tandem with Satscribe.

38:20But, you know, there's a lot of risk. Like if you're doing a project and there's, you know, 5 ,000 unique inscriptions on here, I mean, now with recursive inscriptions, there are different ways to try to bring that cost down, but you're spending a lot of money. For instance, Leonidas, who's a big Ordinals influencer, launched this thing called Runestone, which is the largest, fairest community airdrop within the Ordinals world. I think 113 ,000 people were airdropped these. And the way that it happened was that he took a snapshot of any wallet that had up to three inscriptions that weren't text files at a certain block height.

38:57And those were considered OGs within the space. And then he partnered up with a miner, he partnered up with Ordinal Spot, and he partnered up with a bunch of different people in the community that donated up to eight Bitcoin, I believe it was, to do all this, you know, so to inscribe 113 ,000 things costing eight, that's a lot of money, you know. So it's like a big risk right now, if you're well, it's a big risk as a founder. But the nice thing is, because, you know, there, that now there's some platforms that allow you to do pay as you go kind of mints. But like for the most part, like if you want to be on like the Magic Eden launchpad, you need to inscribe it yourself, which means that you as a founder need to put your own money where your mouth is, which kind of filters out the grifters and the people that aren't serious about, you know, actually building out what they're building out.

39:43You know, for me to like put up, me and my co-founders put up like$15 ,000 to like maybe it turned into nothing. It's like a big, it's a big gamble, you know? Well, how do you build a community to support that, you know, will kind of buy out your project? That is a very, that's a very good question. So a lot of it has been like, just like years of being my co-founder being in the space and just like, you know, being like everyone else, like we've been degenerates, you know, in our non-web three lives, you know, we're builders, you know, like I'm a software engineer for 15 years. My co-founder was a former software engineer also built like early DeFi analytics software.

40:24And both of us were kind of just sitting here and like you become friends with a lot of people in the communities that you're trading with all the time. I'm in a ton of different group chats. We're all on Twitter spaces all the time. It's hilarious. It's like this whole community of people that like I literally speak to more than I speak to my everyday IRL friends, but I speak to them all day, every day on Twitter, you know? And it's like, you almost feel like you know these people. and you just sit on these Twitter spaces long enough and all of a sudden you have a following and you're like, like I said, you're trading together and it's like, listen, I'm building something and everyone's kind of just like down to support because, you know, I've posted pretty good calls that, you know, we've made money.

41:03I've obviously posted some that haven't, but like, you know, like everyone's kind of feeding off of each other and everyone's just down to support one another. And also, I don't know, I've been here since January, like the gen, like literally since these were a thing And there's a very small community of founders that came from that time period. And we all know each other and we're all like pretty good friends with each other at this point. So it's like we're all down to support and help one another out. Like it's a very that's the very interesting thing about this community is that everyone here is really down to support one another.

41:36You know, like if I like pretty much I could tell you any founder that I've interacted with in the past, they tell me something's minting, I'm minting it. you know, like anything to support them because they've done the same. And because I've seen them here for a full year grinding.

42:05And so there are some, again, there's tons of Satoshis or not tons, but there are these exotic satoshis that have, let's call it some intrinsic value, regardless of who's selling it. Then there's inscriptions on rare satoshis or exotic satoshis of, you know, various Bitcoins. And it's the art plus the historical transaction aspect that give it extra value. Plus the community. yeah the community around the founder of it and then what do you think is the next generation that like again how's the everyday person going to get involved how's this going to break out of the close-knit community it's a great question also and this is one that i think a lot of people are spending a lot of time solving it's something that i think about often um i think that the way that you do it is you need to have products that are seamless to use for this is the test that i use if my mother can use it i know it's good for the public to use it you know my mom's like 64 years old she probably would hate me saying that on a podcast right now no no i agree with you completely i think i think that's the litmus test for crypto in general by the way it's 64 year old which no one listens to right but it's better now i'll tell you we're having this conversation in like let's say 2017 or 2016 i felt the bitcoin community didn't want 64 year olds to use it like everybody was quote-unquote hodling they had their own language and if you didn't speak it's like it's like internet users in 1993 when aol opened up internet news groups to their members everybody all the academics on the internet were very upset and i feel crypto has morphed now into people understand that you need wide use of a currency in order for it to be used.

44:02It needs to be simple to use. Well, I think that this is one of those aha moments where a lot of builders like myself are having where it's like, okay, this is finally another opportunity to really start over again, really bring Bitcoin to the masses. How do we do it? Oh, no one really understood buying and holding. But now if I tell you there is really serious collecting of art that you can be doing on here and not just art, but like so many other use cases, you know, membership to clubs, you know, like Tim was saying, you know, like different certificates and things like that. Now that there is actually a use case, an opportunity to actually put your Bitcoin to work, you know, you have these moments where it's like, okay, well, how are we going to make it super easy to do that?

44:46So, you know, for instance, like I said, I've been building mobile apps for the past 15 years. That's kind of like my bread and butter. Make the kind of dumbing down hard to understand concepts and making them a little bit more palatable. And that's what I'm focusing on right now is building very strictly mobile first infrastructure. Everyone goes to the web and everyone likes to do like a Google Chrome extension or a website. The truth of the matter is everyone's on their phone. And even most 64 year olds know how to use an iPhone these days because you can't even park your damn car without scanning a QR code from an iPhone app.

45:18You know, apps are everywhere. So you might as well have a very easy to use app that allows you to very quickly, for instance, trade your runes, collect your rare sats, see what your portfolio is worth. The same exact way that you could download Fidelity and do it there. So that's what my focus is on right now is how do I make it super easy for the everyday collector to get involved. And the big argument against NFTs was just that, hey, this is just a JPEG. how come I can't just cut and paste this into a file and print it up and put it on my wall? But this solves that problem because these are Satoshis that are verifiably part of some important historical thing, like the first Satoshi mind after that halving or whatever.

46:06Listen, the truth of the matter is you could still right-click, save an image, right? You could still right-click and save the image. Yeah. But like at the end of the day, you know, like you right click saving an image and not having the wallet or not owning the private key to that wallet. You don't own it. It's the same kind of idea as NFT. So I don't think it's much different in that regard where like right click save movement is still a thing. But I think that like if you take a look at where the world's going right now, you see like the Quest 3, you have the Vision Pro, you see a full world where we're going to be living in this like AR, VR kind of mixed reality.

46:39and eventually that's going to gravitate to like a Google Glass, which was a little bit premature for its time where you're able to actually, you know, see, I could walk down the street and see digital ads on a building the same way if I'm watching like a hockey game, I can see the digital ads around the boards, you know, like we're about to be living. And especially with Neuralink, like all these things sound crazy, except for the fact that it's, you know, you're seeing a guy with cerebral palsy is playing, you know, chess with his mind, you know, from Neuralink's latest video. And then you realize very quickly, oh shit, I don't know if I'm allowed to say that on this, but like, this is where we're going.

47:15We are going to a digital first world and, you know, owning something in the digital, like if you ask a kid right now, what would you rather do? Would you rather like own something in the physical world or buy something in Roblox? They'd rather buy something in Roblox, you know? Right, but the difference with the NFTs and the inscriptions is that literally the canvas you own it on, an inscription on, has value. Because that canvas is a very particular Satoshi in each case. Whereas the NFTs... That's true. I mean, that's the fun thing. They're never going to zero. As Bitcoin goes up, the value of a sat goes up, right?

47:56You know, that's just the way that it works. So technically, unless Bitcoin goes to zero, they're not going to zero. And the value of these rare sats go up more. Right. Right. So I'm just wondering, what's the range of creativity? I bet you there's going to be an opportunity where some artist or somebody who's creative in some other way is going to come up with an idea of inscribing that's going to have value outside of the crypto Twitter community where everybody knows each other. I feel like there's going to be a growth point here that didn't happen with NFTs. It's so early that it's much more possible.

48:34Also, you have the learning curve from the NFTs. You can see where a lot of projects went wrong, where some projects went right. The other thing in order to support some of these early movers is we're seeing a lot of airdrops in order to reward early adopters of ordinals, the upcoming runes, exotic sats, rare sats, uncommon sats. So we are seeing like the early project founders saying, look, if you've supported me or if you just supported the community, I'm going to reward you just to keep the community growing. We saw that a little bit in NFTs, but not very much. It was very much this community is closed and this community is closed and this community is closed and you got to buy this in order to be part of our club.

49:28With ordinals, we haven't seen that, especially with runes coming up. We haven't seen that. If you're a here, here, here, here, here, we're going to reward you. Runestone, which there were guys in some of my communities that got dropped runestone. And we weren't super active in ordinals, but we did inscribe some ordinals very, very early, sub 445 ,000 inscriptions. Now we're at like 70 million. So it was very early. Those guys got an airdrop. That airdrop now is worth like$7 ,000 or$8 ,000. What is it? They're trading for like 0.09 Bitcoin right now. Per Satoshi? That's Runestad. And that was just for doing three inscriptions.

50:12And I think they spent$90 to do three inscriptions. And now they have an asset that's valued at over$7 ,000,$6 ,000. Obviously, the values change. and they're in line to receive some upcoming additional airdrops, it looks like. So this community is very supportive, very different than NFTs. I went on this site, OrtaScan, and it says basically there's like 68 million inscriptions. Who are these 68 million people? Not people, obviously, people are doing more than one inscription. But like who? Actually, I'm looking at one of these. subscriptions uh i don't know it could if you're looking we are defined like as an actual collection if you search pizza artifacts on order scan on magic it's p-i-z-a or like that or double oh no no this is pizza artifacts p-i-z-z-a we we spelled pizza the right way um these people are trying to just make money off you maybe that's that's basically what it what it is is you have some of these uh providence is a big deal in bitcoin lore and bitcoin history and so like what drew me to pizza artifacts is it was the first organized product that project that minted on pizza sats and so now you know i own one of the pieces that is a genesis collection on pizza sats any other ones coming on pizza sats are going to be second third and on down the line And we know from everything that goes on in collectibles and in history, being first matters.

51:54And being first has a value. To give you an idea, like the first portals collection period, which is sub-1 ,000 inscriptions. Again, we're at 70 million now, sub-1 ,000. We have a floor of like two and a half Bitcoin and actively going for like two and a half to like five Bitcoin. And so who is buying and selling? Is it just crypto people? Or has it, again, you mentioned Sotheby's has been auctioning off some of these rare sats. How does the growth look to you? I think that we are in such a bubble right now where everyone is so bullish within this little Bitcoin bubble and it hasn't even had the opportunity to like explode into like what it's going to be.

52:45Like we are very much in an echo chamber where everyone is like all bullish altogether right now. But it is such a small community right now, like compared to what we saw with NFTs, compared to like the entire world of people that were Bitcoin maxis and, you know, never gave Ethereum or any other network beside the time of day. You know, you're seeing like the most OG builders, you know, builds on Bitcoin, like on Ordinals right now. Like the Taproot Wizards is a very notable project where you have Udi Wertheimer and you have people like Jameson Lopp, you know, like Hal Finney, who, you know, literally received those first 50 Bitcoin from Satoshi Nakamoto.

53:21Doesn't follow many people. Jameson is one of them. Like this is like some of the most OG people in this debate are finally super excited to be building on Bitcoin again. So if someone wanted to view like Satoshi's and maybe buy some, where can they look? Like listeners are probably just still curious, like what's going on here? Where can they look to see some Satoshis, learn some more about it, maybe, maybe buy some. And when you buy some, again, it's, you just put it in your Bitcoin wallet with your Bitcoins. Yeah, exactly. So, I mean, there's a bunch of tools now that make it super easy. You know, obviously we built SatScribe that allows you to just click what type of rare Satoshi you want.

54:00You can either buy them individually or you can scribe on them. Another great marketplace where you can kind of do like a P2P trading, kind of like an OpenSea from NFTs. But for RareSats, Magisat is a great one. MagicEden is another great one. Luminex is a great platform for doing parent-child provenance, which is something we didn't even get a chance to talk about. But long story short, you know a BoredApe is a BoredApe because it's attached to the BoredApe contract. What you're able to do on Bitcoin is if you're an artist or a founder or whatever, you can inscribe what's called a parent inscription.

54:31and then have children inscriptions that on-chain connect to the parents. So you can actually see the whole family tree on-chain, which is as true of provenance as it gets. Yeah, there's, I would say those four places, Satscribe, MagSat, Magic Eden, RuneX. Ordiscan is a great place. Ord.io is a great explorer as well. Xverse Wallet is probably the most popular wallet right now to use. They support RareSats. Magic Eden Wallet is a really good one, too, that they've rolled out. Those are like the main two that I would say are really dominating the market right now. There are other ones like Leather Wallet, Unisat.

55:13OKEx has a wallet, too. But I would say my recommendation, if you want to get your hands dirty very quickly without having any issues, because Exxer supports RareSats. Not all wallets do. So does Magic Eden. They support subscriptions. They support separating your wallet into Bitcoin, like an actual payment address versus a ordinals or runes or a rare SAT address. Xverse, I would say, is the way to go, or Magic Eden. I think that answers my next question, which is how do you know when you have some Satoshis in your wallet and you're spending some money? You're not just spending one of these incredibly valuable Satoshis.

55:50You want that wallet that splits it for you. Exactly. Xverse and Magic Eden do that. Yep, exactly. So right now I could basically go to some marketplace, buy a rare Satoshi, spend a little bit of money inscribing it, and then saying, hey, I have this inscribed Satoshi that I made. Does anyone want to buy it? I could put it on some marketplace and see if there's a market for it. Yes. Yes. Or you could just buy the rare set or exotic set, not inscribe it, and just hold it. and let other and let other people just hold it exactly because they're deflationary right so the more people that inscribe them the more sequestered or rather the more inscribed they are the less there are in circulation um you know so you like one of the places that i've made is i have a like i have a bag of uninscribed uncommon sats i have a bag of uninscribed block 9 450 x's which maybe i'll do something with them in the future but for right now i'm just holding them as virgin sats, so to speak.

56:54So like a bucket of, let's say a year ago, you bought a bucket of rare sats or, or exotic sats or whatever. Uh, what would, how much has it gone up, uh, percentage wise in the past year? Like just rare sats. It depends. It depends. I, yeah, no, it depends for sure. It depends on when you bought them, obviously, cause it's insanely volatile. Um, I would say, you know, if you bought them at around 75 to 130 bucks right now, you're, you know, even give or take the day. But there is a time period where commoners, which was the first ever collection inscribed on uncommon stats, took 10 ,000 uncommons out of circulation, and the price ran up from $130 to$800 in about an hour, you know, so like, there are different, different catalysts that I would say change the volatility of that right now.

57:45It's also, like I was saying in the beginning of the podcast that it was significantly harder to acquire them, which when they were more expensive versus now where we have peer-to-peer marketplaces like Magusat and Magic Eden, where you can very easily buy and sell these and the free market has dictated the price. So if you bought at the top, you're definitely down right now. But this is very much like a long-term play. But also, again, the average person even involved in crypto doesn't know anything about this, even though it might be common in your community, I can tell you like I'm involved in crypto every day and I don't really know that much about the whole ordinal world.

58:25And so if this becomes a thing, which it is already, I mean, there's 70 million of these inscribed, but if this becomes a thing where people know it the way they know NFTs, then these rare stats that are worthy of inscription will go up in value. I mean, that's my bet. Nothing is obviously guaranteed. Right. And that's my bet. What projects are you working on now with these inscriptions? What's the type of project you're working on? Yeah, so the most recent one, we actually have it launching on April 15th on the Magic Eden launchpad. It is called Runivo, which is a pre-runes ordinals collection.

59:06So what you'll be able to do is pizza artifacts are getting an allocation to this and people are able to mint them and they're able to collect this as an ordinal before the halving. And then holding that, we're rolling out two massive mobile first infrastructure platforms that can't talk about just yet only because we're launching them at the halving, which is give or take April 18th or the 20th. We'll see. But what I can say is that Pizza Artifacts and Runevo owning those will have a lot of utility within using those platforms. You'll be able to generate a lot of points for doing transactions.

59:45Is it related to the having? Yeah, it's very important. Yeah, it is. So Runez, the protocol that enables this whole casino of meme tokens and utility tokens on Bitcoin, is going live at block 840 ,000, which is the having block. and Casey Rottermore inscribe or pre-mined the first ever runes, which is going to be called Uncommon.Goods. And it'll be interesting to see, you know, who ends up getting the first having block because that'll dictate, you know, like the first 1 ,000 names and what they are aside from, you know, Uncommon.Goods. But everything happens at the having. The epic sack gets mined at the having.

1:00:21Runes goes live at the having. So that's kind of like why the date is the date. And is it just some lucky miner who's going to end up with the epic set at the halving? It is a lucky miner for sure. And there is definitely a lot of people that are competing to become said lucky miner right now. And there are a lot of people bribing miners right now to be included in that block and actually get the first 1 ,000 runes. And I can tell you, I'm talking like bribes of 20 Bitcoin, you know, like real bribes. But even with that bribe, there's still only like a 15 % chance that you get it, which isn't bad.

1:01:01There's a chance. Obviously, the odds aren't in your favor, but they're not bad, you know, 15%. But that's very much what's happening right now. Well, it seems like there's an expected value there, though, much higher than 15 Bitcoin if you're talking about millions of dollars for an Epic set. Yeah. Also, I am five minutes over. I have a five o 'clock that I'm late to. So I don't know how we're supposed to do this abruptly if you want to do like an end. No, no, I'm going to keep talking to Tim here. So Ben, thank you so much. All right. Help yourself out. Good luck on your projects. I'm going to maybe buy some.

1:01:36I don't know. Thanks so much, man. Thanks for answering my questions. I know I asked a ton of dumb questions, so I appreciate you answering.

1:01:56Thank you.

From the publisher

Episode Description:Today's episode features part one of a 3-part detailed discussion on the emerging trends of inscriptions and ordinals in the Bitcoin blockchain, positioning them as exciting new forms of collectibles with real historical significance and potential for value appreciation. James is joined by financial advisors Timothy Collins and Benjamin Republic (Co-Founder & CEO at SatRepublic), who bring their expertise on the subject matter, explaining the technical aspects, comparisons to NFTs on Ethereum, and the intrinsic value of certain Satoshi's due to historical transactions or rarities defined by ordinal theory.The episode covers the potential use cases, like digital art and collectibles with immutable provenance, leveraging the security and permanence of Bitcoin's blockchain, far beyond traditional NFTs stored on more volatile platforms. They delve into how ordinals create a new market for Bitcoin enthusiasts to engage actively with their holdings through creative inscriptions and the anticipation around the Bitcoin halving event that could significantly impact this emerging space. Listeners are guided on how to participate, buy, and potentially create their inscriptions, underscoring the novelty and speculative opportunity ordinals represent in the broader context of cryptocurrency innovations.Ben Honig:https://twitter.com/nftsupplyhttps://twitter.com/SatScribeXYZhttps://twitter.com/SatRepublic Episode Summary:00:00 Diving Into the World of NFTs, Inscriptions, and Ordinals00:37 Introducing the Experts: A Deep Dive into Bitcoin's New Frontier02:21 The Historical Significance of Bitcoin Transactions06:54 Exploring the Rarity and Value of Satoshis21:51 The Fascinating World of Inscriptions on Bitcoin26:54 Exploring Recursive Inscriptions and Digital Ownership27:51 Warren Buffett and the Value of Inscribed Picks28:42 Artistic and Practical Uses of Satoshi Inscriptions29:02 The Evolution of NFTs and Blockchain Certifications30:14 The Future of Digital Collectibles and Community Support36:27 Building a Community and the Importance of Early Support44:17 The Potential of Inscriptions Beyond the Crypto Community52:36 Navigating the Marketplace: Buying, Selling, and Holding Rare Sats
------------What do YOU think of the show? Head to JamesAltucherShow.com/listeners and fill out a short survey that will help us better tailor the podcast to our audience!Are you interested in getting direct answers from James about your question on a podcast? Go to JamesAltucherShow.com/AskAltucher and send in your questions to be answered on the air!------------Visit Notepd.com to read our idea lists & sign up to create your own!My new book, Skip the Line, is out! Make sure you get a copy wherever books are sold!Join the You Should Run for President 2.0 Facebook Group, where we discuss why you should run for President.I write about all my podcasts! Check out the full post and learn what I learned at jamesaltuchershow.com------------Thank you so much for listening! If you like this episode, please rate, review, and subscribe to "The James Altucher Show" wherever you get your podcasts: Apple PodcastsiHeart RadioSpotifyFollow me on social media:YouTubeTwitterFacebookLinkedIn

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

More from The James Altucher Show

All 301 episodes
The Next Billion-Dollar Bitcoin Idea: Inscriptions and OrdinalsThe James Altucher Show · 59 min
Listen in VO