In short
Podcast Episode Notes: The Journal - Investment Accounts for Babies Are Coming. Wall Street Can’t Wait.
Episode Overview
- Hosts: Ryan Knutson and Jessica Mendoza
- Featured Guest: Alexander Saeedy
- Release Date: December 10, 2023
- Main Topic: Introduction of investment accounts for babies, termed "Trump accounts," which provide a $1,000 grant funded by the government for children born between 2025 and 2028, sparking significant interest from Wall Street and philanthropists.
Key Highlights
Introduction of Trump Accounts
- What are Trump Accounts?
- A tax-advantaged investment account for U.S. citizens born between January 1, 2025, and December 31, 2028.
- Each eligible child receives a one-time grant of $1,000, aimed at promoting early investment in diversified, low-cost U.S. stock index funds.
Philanthropic Support
- Michael Dell's Donation:
- Dell and his wife announced a $6.25 billion donation to the program, targeting 25 million American children aged 10 and under.
- Their contribution aims to expand the initiative and is considered one of the largest private donations in U.S. history focused on children.
Structure and Functionality of Accounts
- Investment Mechanics:
- Funds must be invested in ETFs or mutual funds tracking the U.S. stock market, with fees being very low or potentially free.
- Once a child turns 18, the account converts into an IRA, subject to standard IRA rules.
- Contributions:
- Families can contribute up to $5,000 annually starting from July 4, 2026.
Motivations Behind the Program
- Financial Literacy:
- The initiative aims to teach children the value of saving and investing from a young age.
- The government projects that with optimal contributions, families could grow the initial investment to significant amounts (theoretically up to $2 million).
- Encouraging Family Formation:
- The program also seeks to counter declining birth rates by providing a financial incentive for families to have children.
Wall Street's Interest
- Corporate Participation:
- Major financial institutions, including JPMorgan Chase, Charles Schwab, and Robinhood, are eager to participate, viewing the program as an opportunity to build long-term customer relationships.
- Marketing and Cross-Selling Opportunities:
- Banks can use the Trump account as a gateway to offer additional products and services to young families, enhancing their business models.
Criticism and Concerns
- Affordability and Accessibility:
- Critics point out that the program may disproportionately benefit families who can afford to contribute additional funds into the accounts, raising concerns about equity.
- Political Ties:
- The program's branding and the connections to the Trump administration could influence public perception, with some viewing it as a way for corporations to align with political power while contributing to charity.
Conclusion
- The Trump accounts represent a unique intersection of philanthropy, corporate interests, and government policy aimed at improving financial literacy among children and potentially revitalizing family formation rates in the U.S. The success of the initiative will depend on family participation and the extent of contributions made over time.
Further Listening Recommendations
- Related Episodes:
- Closing the Wealth Gap With a Trust Fund for Babies
- The Nvidia CEO’s Quest to Sell Chips in China
- Inside Intel's Deal With the U.S. Government
Additional Resources
- Merchandise: [The Journal Show Merch](https://wsjshop.com/collections/clothing)
- Newsletter: Sign up for WSJ’s free What’s News newsletter.
---
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:05Last week, Michael Dell, the CEO of Dell Technologies, made a big announcement. Thank you, Mr. President. It's a great honor to be with you here in the White House. Dell and his wife Susan revealed that they would be donating more than$6 billion towards a new government program. Susan and I are super excited to announce our$6.25 billion gift to 25 million American children, 10 and under. The contribution would dramatically expand a new tax-advantaged account for minors, known as Trump accounts. Trump accounts. Trump accounts. Trump accounts. The families that opt in will receive a one-time payment of$1 ,000.
0:50They must invest in diversified, low-cost U.S. stock index funds. I talked to our colleague Alexander Saidi about this. What is a Trump account? It's an IRA for babies through a very small seed investment of$1 ,000 for any child born between the beginning of 2025 and the end of 2028. Babies who are U.S. citizens born between 2025 and 2028 are eligible for a$1 ,000 grant from the federal government to be invested in a tax-advantaged account for their future.
1:28The program was signed into law last summer as part of Trump's big, beautiful bill, and it's set to launch in early 2026. Alex says that from the jump, corporate America wanted to be a part of it. Not just philanthropist billionaires like Michael Dell, but also banks and brokerages that see a major opportunity in participating in the program. The idea is to have multiple private institutions offering Trump account rollovers. so you can keep your money with the financial institution of your choosing. And so with the Trump account, the business world is excited about, specifically on Wall Street, about being a part of it.
2:06Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business, and power. I'm Jessica Mendoza. It's Wednesday, December 10th.
2:20Coming up on the show, why Wall Street is all in on Trump accounts.
2:41The idea to create better investment tools for young people has been around for a while. But one venture capitalist has taken it up as his mission. His name is Brad Gerstner, and he's been working on the idea since at least 2021. and he'd gotten support from some Democrats. But he was having trouble getting it off the ground.
3:02He wanted to get President Joe Biden to buy in on the idea, but just, like, couldn't successfully get an audience with him. Then, last year, a friend of Gerstner's happened to be playing a late-night poker game at the Bellagio Hotel in Las Vegas. And he was near Senator Ted Cruz. and he told Cruz that Gerstner wanted to bring stock investment accounts to young Americans through an outfit he has called Invest America. And days later, he was in Senator Cruz's office talking about how can we make this a reality for young Americans. By June, Gerstner was at the White House for a roundtable event on the initiative.
3:46With him was President Trump, along with Michael Dell, Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon, Robin Hood's Vlad Tenev, and other big names in finance. At the event, Trump called the idea, which by then had been named Trump Accounts, one of the most exciting parts of the tax bill he would sign into law in July. I also want to thank you for being here as we discuss one of the most exciting parts of the one big, beautiful bill. It is indeed a big, beautiful bill, and it's doing very well. The Trump Accounts, as they call it.
4:21Can you just walk me through how a Trump account would work? This is all like being worked up in real time. There's still a lot of details that aren't fully fleshed out. But more or less what we know is that families will be able to sign up for the accounts and get access to$1 ,000 with the Treasury Department. But what they'll allow you to do is to roll it over into a financial institution of your choosing. That$1 ,000 becomes a kind of seed fund for eligible children. Once the account is open, parents, relatives, friends, really anyone, can contribute up to$5 ,000 a year. Contributions can be made starting on July 4, 2026.
5:01So how does this investment work? What happens to this money? You're very limited in what you can invest in. You have to essentially invest any money in a Trump account into an ETF or mutual fund that tracks the broader U.S. stock market. We'll see what is defined as eligible or not. It's designed that the fees on the fund you invest in are very low, potentially free. They don't want you investing in like, you know, a private equity fund. It's really meant to be like the 401k that you don't touch. When the child turns 18, the Trump account automatically converts into an IRA. And then the money is essentially yours to use, as you see fit, subject to regular IRA rules.
5:58Trump accounts have two big advantages. Some get seed money from the government, and they're allowed to grow tax-free. But they're also less flexible. Because the Trump account works like an IRA, it means beneficiaries, for the most part, can't withdraw the money till they're 59 and a half without paying hefty penalties. And why is the Trump administration doing this? What is the problem it is trying to solve? So I think it's trying to do many things at once. The administration is really focused on the, I would say, financial literacy angle the most. This is an affordable way to teach people at a very young age about the value of saving money and investing money through a very small seed investment.
6:48And, you know, in theory, the administration is saying if you take full advantage of the program, you could grow that initial 1 ,000 seed into as much as$2 million. And there's obviously a really big asterisk on that because that means you need to do the maximum amount of private donations year over year. But I think the idea is let's find a way to, like, teach kids the value of money, and it could change people's lives. But financial literacy is just one piece of it. Fertility rates in the U.S. are lower than ever. And one reason is that people are delaying having kids because they're concerned about the cost of living.
7:30The Trump accounts come at a time when many on the right are trying to motivate young people to start families. This is essentially a type of incentive to have a child. If you have a baby, you get$1 ,000. You know? Why not? That's literally it. And this is a very relevant thing because we've reported at length on how one thing that seems to be holding up family formation in the United States, or certainly, you know, the choice to have kids or get married, is affordability and the perception that I'm not going to be able to afford to have kids. So even though this is small and just like a seed, this in a way sort of is like, look, like, you know, we, the government, will help you out.
8:19When it announced the program, the White House didn't address declining birth rates, instead focusing on helping children achieve economic stability as adults. President Trump said the accounts would give children, quote, a shot at the American dream. Still, the policy supporters say the accounts could shift the thinking around starting families.
8:42Some of the most visible proponents of the Trump accounts come from Wall Street. That's because participating families can roll that initial$1 ,000 seed money into banks and brokerages. Financial institutions see that as a huge opportunity, both to build relationships with customers and to show support for Trump's policies. That's after the break.
9:16The Trump accounts are projected to cost the government around$15 billion through 2034. If parents actually apply for and take the$1 ,000, that means all that money will get invested into the American financial system. That's good news for Wall Street because it means tons of new investors and tons of money flowing to invest in American companies. And it's specifically good news for financial institutions. Everyone from banks like JPMorgan Chase to brokerages like Charles Schwab and Robinhood Markets are vying for a role in the program. What is the benefit for these financial institutions, you know, to participate in Trump accounts?
9:54Just the work of administering the program or offering the Trump accounts in the lifetime of the account probably won't actually make them money in and of itself. So the kind of investment management fees you'll get off of a Trump account is going to be very low, probably zero. What banks get, though, is a relationship with a child and their family. and you could in a way like structure the Trump account into a broader package that you offer young families that include like mortgage, maybe an auto loan, basic financial planning, checking accounts, credit cards. A bundle. Exactly. And the Trump account is like the seed that gets you in the door and then they start to cross-sell you on all these other products that do actually make them money.
10:52And then when the child turns 18, their account will be rolled over into another investment account at this same shop. According to people familiar with the matter, many of the largest banks, brokers, and asset managers say they plan to make pitches to the Treasury Department. Robinhood CEO Vladimir Tenev even created a mock-up of what the Trump accounts might look like and posted it on X. adding that the platform was, quote, ready to go. Besides the administration and Wall Street, there's another group of people hyped about this program, big donors like Michael Dell. The Michael and Susan Dell gift is meant to be the biggest example of and a catalyst for more outside money to come in and help finance it.
11:41So that gift, it's a huge philanthropic donation. probably the biggest private gift that's going directly to kids in American history. It's$6.25 billion, which is just a staggering amount of money by any stretch of the imagination. Because the seed money is only for babies born from 2025 to 2028, the Dells wanted to expand the pool of children who could receive some kind of funding. Their donation will provide$250 for kids age 10 or under who were born before January 1st, 2025. And it'll target children in zip codes with a median income of$150 ,000 or less. The Dell's donation to the Trump accounts could be the first of many.
12:27Dell said that he spoke with other philanthropists ahead of his announcement last week, and he's expecting others to make gifts as well. And Alex says this is part of a broader move that has been on the rise in the second Trump administration. Philanthropists and executives trying to cultivate a good relationship with the president. What we're seeing here is like just another iteration of, you know, wealthy corporate executives continuing to like try and, you know, do things that are aligned with the administration. donating to various Trump causes has been a big theme of the year. I think what's been a very common scene is business executives gathering, you know, in the White House to, like, talk about a business initiative that they're working on that also aligns with the administration's own strategic priorities.
13:21Over the last year, companies from NVIDIA to Intel to U.S. Steel have been working to build closer ties with Trump. And that's a bigger story that's been playing out this year is the sort of proximity of business executives to the White House and the kind of game of influence they have to play to, you know, protect their own interests and stay on the good side of the White House, which has shown a willingness to go against, you know, business leaders they don't like or thought leaders that they don't like. Some of these efforts to get close to the administration have drawn criticism. In letters to corporate executives, Democratic lawmakers pointed to the$250 million ballroom under construction at the White House, noting that many of the donors supporting the project have active business before the federal government.
14:10Alex says helping to fund the Trump account initiative could be an easy way to signal support for the administration while also being charitable. This at least is a form of clear philanthropy. Like this is direct giving to, you know, children, right? But at the same time, you get to like put your seal of approval on it alongside the Trump administration. This program is called the Trump Accounts. So any donation to it is sort of therefore linked with the president. So all of these things are kind of playing together at once. And for the Trump accounts specifically, how helpful could these donations be?
14:52So if we see more and more of these types of donations, then what looks like a$1 ,200 roughly seed, could that grow into$2 ,000,$3 ,000? And that, you know, like the compounding effects of that get more and more powerful. So we really have to see how much more the sort of top 1 % and, you know, even the upper echelons of that group pitch into this because that will give it even more firepower. So this is all very much like still in progress. What are you looking for to know whether or not these Trump accounts work? That's going to take a long time. It's going to take a long time to know. And I think you need to see like how many families at least contribute something.
15:38Right? I think, you know, on the macro level, it will have a modest impact. You know, but it's at the micro level where it's like, what does each individual family choose to do with it that will make a difference? Also, I mean, I think it's fair to say that because this is a blanket target, right, there's no income basis for how the Trump administration is giving out the funds. The people who are going to benefit from it the most are the ones who have the most to contribute.
16:29Thank you.
16:38Thank you.
From the publisher
Starting next year, babies born from 2025 to 2028 can receive $1,000 to start investment accounts. The initiative has gotten corporate America excited, with financial institutions vying for a role in the program, and philanthropists like Dell Technologies CEO Michael Dell pledging billions of dollars in donations. WSJ’s Alexander Saeedy unpacks how the accounts work and why Wall Street is buzzing about them. Jessica Mendoza hosts.
Further Listening:
- Closing the Wealth Gap With a Trust Fund for Babies
- The Nvidia CEO’s Quest to Sell Chips in China
- Inside Intel's Deal With the U.S. Government
Sign up for WSJ’s free What’s News newsletter.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
