1. Podcasts
  2. The News Agents
  3. Burnham's first Budget: 'Is that it?'
The News Agents

28 Oct 2026 · 43m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

Burnham's first Budget: 'Is that it?'

In short

The episode is a round-up of UK politics and economics focused on Andy Burnham’s first budget and what it signals about Labour’s next election. Hosts argue the budget is “hemmed in” by limited fiscal headroom (~£15bn), high debt interest, and global shocks (Ukraine, Iran, and Donald Trump’s tariffs). Key measures discussed: £100 direct energy payment for 20m households (council tax bands A–D), minimum wages up nearly 4%, fuel duty cut extended to July 2027, and dropping a planned cash ISA restriction (keeping £20,000 limit). They claim the budget’s 98 measures change taxation by only ~£6bn overall.

Notable examples

business rates relief for retail/hospitality; “breathing space” for families; and a major political pivot toward EU relationship talks (single market/free movement debate).

Guest

Jonathan Reynolds, UK Business Secretary (Labour), former MP since 2010, who defends the budget’s impact on jobs, entrepreneurs, and growth, and links it to EU summit and Made in Europe/SPS fixes.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:14

Key Measures from the Budget

Exploration of the principal measures in the new budget, including energy bills and wages.

“And as John and Emily were both saying at the start there, This was a budget characterised, I think, more than anything else by a tiny amount of economic space in which the new chancellor could manoeuvre.”
3:18

Economic Challenges Ahead

Discussion on the macroeconomic landscape and its implications for the budget.

“The planned cash ISA restriction is being dropped, preserving the£20 ,000 annual limit.”
6:12

The Impact of Global Events

How global tensions and conflicts, especially involving Trump, affect the UK’s economy.

“What was so interesting for me listening to it was that he signified that there were three things out there in the global economy that are having an effect on what is happening in Britain.”
7:21

Straitjackets of Politics and Economics

Examining the limitations faced by the Chancellor within current political and economic frameworks.

“Leave aside kind of, you know, welfare reform in this country.”
8:39

Future Prospects and Political Maneuvering

Speculation about potential elections and the political landscape following the budget.

“If we were to pay off all our debt, we'd all have to give up all of the money that the country generates in one year to the people to whom we owe it.”
14:00

Analysis of Labour's Political Constraints

Explore the limitations faced by Labour in addressing key political issues.

“he said, look, we're not doing anything about the red lines.”
24:20

Government Budget Response with Jonathan Reynolds

Discussion on the implications of the latest budget with Business Secretary.

“Well, we're joined now by the Business Secretary, Jonathan Reynolds.”
28:00

Budget Implications on Living Standards

Discussion on the budget's impact on living standards and economic pressures.

“OBR forecasts suggest that living standards will fall this year, despite the breathing space promised in the budget.”
29:04

The Economic Context of Government Actions

Exploration of the broader economic context, including past government actions and current challenges.

“Let's just remember, in the midst of all this pressure, that wages rose faster and by a greater degree in the first ten months of this Labour government than the previous ten years.”
30:57

Neoliberalism and Economic Vision

Debate on the Labour Party's vision for the economy and the shift from neoliberal policies.

“for growth to reach every part of the country, for industry where ideas and innovation in the UK are no longer lost overseas and scaled up abroad.”
Show all 14 chapters
33:34

UK-EU Relations and Economic Challenges

Discussion on the implications of UK-EU relations and necessary long-term solutions.

“Things like SPS, which is your food and agricultural rules, you know, sorting this out, removing these frictions between the UK and the EU.”
34:25

Addressing Economic Constraints and Future Prospects

Conversations about the economic constraints facing the government and future electoral prospects.

“These are all things that need addressing.”
39:31

Analysis of Israeli Elections and Political Landscape

In-depth analysis of the recent Israeli elections and future government scenarios.

“So we told you we'd bring you up to date on the Israeli elections.”
42:00

The Political Landscape in Israel

Explore the current state of Israeli politics and Netanyahu's influence.

“And so it looks like you're going to have either a very unstable government, which doesn't have a majority and therefore setting the stage.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The News Agents, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Whether you're building a roster or a business, great talent can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies hire and support employees across 185-plus countries. Pebble believes you don't build a winning team by limiting where you look for talent. That belief is at the heart of their new partnership with Bay FC, and the way Pebble helps companies build their own teams every day. With Pebble, companies can hire in over 185 countries, bringing everything together in a single platform that integrates with the tools teams already use. The result is a global team that's actually set up to succeed with accurate pay, real benefits, and the support they need to thrive wherever they are.

0:36Bottom line, great teams can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies build them. Special offer for podcast listeners. Pebble is normally$399 a month per employee. Already a no-brainer for what you get. But right now, there's a limited-time offer on their site that makes it even easier to get started. Go to hellopebble.com slash sports before it's gone. That's hellopebl.com slash sports. Terms and conditions apply.

1:02Jon Sopel: This is a global production. This will go down as one of the most sweeping, audacious budgets of the modern era. OK, it won't. It was a budget where the chancellor was hemmed in on all sides. And it sort of felt like that. We know who we are. We know where we're going. We can see the Britain we want to be. It's a vision burned into every line of this budget statement Madam Deputy Speaker, breathing space now Fresh hope for the future Delivered to the British people by this Labour government I commend this statement to the House But most people in the country listening to his budget Will be thinking to themselves Is that it?

1:45Really? Is that it? The Prime Minister came in promising to reverse 40 years of neoliberalism liberalism. Instead, we got full pee off gherkins. The Conservatives are clearly underwhelmed. Was there anything more that Healy could have done today? Or is an election now looking inevitable? Welcome to the News Agents.

2:14Jon Sopel: It's John. It's Maitlis. It's Lewis. And as John and Emily were both saying at the start there, This was a budget characterised, I think, more than anything else by a tiny amount of economic space in which the new chancellor could manoeuvre. And it showed just to take you through some of the principal measures of this first budget of the of the Burnham government. The politically saliable bit, the bit that number 10 will be hoping and I'm sure probably will lead most of the bulletins tonight and with which Labour MPs can go back to their constituencies and sell something is on energy bills. So£100 direct payment from the government for 20 million households in council tax bands A to D.

2:57Jon Sopel: So that should be£100 towards your energy bill, enough to put your heating on while you read the letter explaining it. Pay and petrol, minimum wages will rise by nearly 4%. The temporary 5p fuel duty cut, I say temporary, it's been temporary since about 2010, is going to be extended until July 2027. The planned cash ISA restriction is being dropped, preserving the£20 ,000 annual limit. There were some further measures on fiscal devolution, some further measures on pensions, protecting pensions from having to pay income tax. But this was a budget which more than anything else was haunted by a deeply uncertain macroeconomic situation, geopolitical situation.

3:42Jon Sopel: and awareness, I think, from the Chancellor No. 10 that, frankly, if some of the rumours are to be believed about Trump resuming incursions in Iran after the midterms or possibly even before the midterms, then the figures that the OBR have produced will be out of date. The big decision he's basically made is to dig in to the fiscal headroom that Rachel Reeves bequeathed him as Chancellor. It's down now to about£15 billion. That's basically the kind of emergency reserve that he has, that he's able to use to meet potential spending pressures or unexpected events. Of course, once you've dug into that reserve, it's gone.

4:17Jon Sopel: And it is the overall picture, as I say, is of a number 11 and a treasury, which is eyeing the bond markets and the global uncertainty very, very closely. It is not irrelevant that the other story that we're going to bring you today, which is what's happened overnight in the Israeli elections, actually feeds into exactly what the Chancellor was or wasn't able. to say today because the price of oil has absolutely rocketed on the assumption now that maybe Netanyahu will remain as Prime Minister of Israel, that maybe Trump and Israel will resume their incursions into Iran, that maybe the Hormuz Straits will remain closed for longer, etc.

4:56You know the drill already. This is not going to make the global outlook much easier. And that's why I think when you talk about hemmed in, it is extraordinary to be talking about a budget in this country where, frankly, we do not control the one thing that is actually going to have the biggest impact on all of our lives, on all of our pockets. And I was looking, I have to say, borrowed unashamedly from Ed Conway today at the number of measures that there were in this budget, which he calculates at 98. In fact, a huge number of announcements. You know, the Chancellor stood up at 12.30 and spoke pretty much till 1.30.

5:34He had 98 different measures in this budget, which sounds like loads of stuff went on. But when you actually see the difference it made in terms of taxation either way, it resulted in changes of about six billion. Absolutely tiny. So in other words, we had something that was full of sound and fury or not fury, but full of sound, full of a sort of, you know, an attempt to generate excitement and yet calm. and yet here we are understanding you. What has changed hands here? Hardly anything at all. The measures that have been introduced today are absolutely minute compared to the scale of where we actually are.

6:14Jon Sopel: What was so interesting for me listening to it was that he signified that there were three things out there in the global economy that are having an effect on what is happening in Britain. And one of them is the war in Ukraine, the other is the war in Iran And the other is the more hostile trading environment, which he spoke about. What links all three of those is Donald Trump. I mean, the hostile trading environment is tariffs. That's what they're talking about, making it much more difficult for British exporters. That's Donald Trump's policy. The war in Iran. And you look at the figures and the projections for the way the oil and gas price is going to go up next year against what was anticipated back in March when Rachel Reeves was the chancellor.

6:55Jon Sopel: It's massive, massive increase. The downgrading of growth for next year again and the upgrading of inflation all down to the war in Iran. And then you've got the war in Ukraine where Donald Trump has decided that he is going to lift the sanctions against Russia that he signed into law a month ago and also resume diesel imports from Russia to try and help him in the midterms. I thought, my God, the shadow of Donald Trump over this budget is immense. Leave aside kind of, you know, welfare reform in this country. Leave aside the manifesto commitments. It is a very big presence in the present economic outlook for the United Kingdom.

7:36Jon Sopel: Watching the Healy budget, the thing I kept thinking of is here is a man, here is a chancellor, but not just this chancellor, here's a government, you know, in a straitjacket. In fact, if it's possible, he's wearing two straitjackets. One is political and one is economic. The economic one is that he has so little room for manoeuvre. Which one do you arms go into? Well, I think ideally both. Well, hang on. Where are we in the centenary of the death of Harry Houdini? Right. Well, this is in honour of Harry, my Harry Houdini analogy. And I'm not sure that... One goes on backwards and one goes on backwards.

8:07Jon Sopel: I'm not sure John Healy is that dexterous. But the economic one is really significant. I do think, I mean, Kemi Bay not getting up at the end. And of course, she's a leader of the opposition and she's got to sort of critique. The sort of unspoken truth of this budget and every budget we're going to have for quite a long time now is we have got to get used to economically being a country, at least for the short to medium term, with roughly 100 % of debt to GDP, i.e. we owe every single pound that we generate in our entire economy every year. If we were to pay off all our debt, we'd all have to give up all of the money that the country generates in one year to the people to whom we owe it.

8:46Jon Sopel: And that is a big difference of, say, 15 years ago when the financial crisis started, when we were the sort of country with roughly 40%. debt to GDP. What it means is that every move you make is watched by the bond markets. It was fine in the conservative years, or most of the conservative years, because we had a period of ultra low interest rates. We no longer have that. Our national debt is past £3 trillion. Just to illustrate what I mean by this, borrowing was nearly £100 billion in just the first six months of this financial year. Today's forecast puts annual borrowing at 4.2 % of GDP, and debt interest has more than doubled since 2020.

9:24Jon Sopel: If this government had a department of debt interest it would be the third biggest government department in terms of spending. So that's an economic straitjacket. And the political straitjacket is this. This government potentially does have quite a radical programme. We heard it outlined by Andy Burnham at the Labour Party conference. Electro-reform, close relationship with Europe, big changes in terms of fiscal devolution. The problem is there's no mandate for it. There's no political mandate for it. He can't turn to his Labour MPs and say, right, we're going to do this on Brexit or we're going to do this on electoral reform because they'll say, well, we didn't stand on this.

10:00Jon Sopel: So it feels to me that something has got to give. And I think if the polling is right, I think that the logic of what we saw today or the polling sustains, I think that the logic of what we saw today, I think they'll suggest an election sooner rather than later. If this government is going to break out of at least one of those straitjackets, which is a political one. I think that's such an interesting proposition because arguably the most interesting thing that happened in the Commons today, and this is not to denigrate what the Chancellor is trying to do for now. And he did come up with a lot of small measures that will have a massive impact on a few people's lives, like the cuts to business rates and all the rest of it, trying to help entrepreneurs, trying to help those in hospitality.

10:40I mean, we can come on to explain some of those later. But I would say the most interesting conversation that happened was over Prime Minister's questions today when Kemi Badenok basically took it straight to Andy Burnham and said, where are you on Brexit? Are you reopening this question? Are you reopening the debate? Are you even considering freedom of movement? And Andy Burnham, I think, actually went further than we had seen, even in his comments to The Times over the weekend, where he's no longer pretending that this is just an honest conversation. It's an honest conversation that he's pushing from behind to get onto the table.

11:15And he reminded that Kemi Baden-Ock that there are three weeks to go until this summit in Europe. Now, whether or not that slightly undermined what the Chancellor was trying to do today, I would say maybe I think she's right. I think it is a much more interesting conversation. And it's clearly one that Andy Burnham is willing to embrace. So I suppose you're stuck in two positions now. One is like, if that's where the conversation is going and he said there can be no changes to the red lines without a referendum of sorts and that might be an election, then yes, he has to hold an election. In that case, an election has to come next year to allow him to do that.

11:51But the other way of looking at it, Lewis, is that and this was basically where Darren Jones was with us yesterday. They will never have 400 Labour seats again. They will never have that kind of majority to actually effect change with. And so as soon as you go to the polls, you are not only risking another party becoming the government, but you are definitely risking having a really small number, a much smaller number of MPs who hate you forever because, you know, you could have done all this stuff without an election and you didn't.

12:23Jon Sopel: It would be a huge risk. And I think, you know, Joni's absolutely right. I mean, that's clearly the high watermark in terms of seats. But I suppose it depends if Burnham, it depends what he's going to do with those seats. And if you're just going to tread water for three years and he concludes that if we do that, there's a danger that we get to 2029 and people say, what the hell have you done? Then I can see the imperative for Burnham as a risk taker or the attraction for Burnham as a risk taker for doing it. I mean, I completely agree with you. It's a very rare budget day where Prime Minister's questions is more interesting than the budget.

12:53Jon Sopel: But that was what we had today. What struck me about it was not just that Burnham chose not to resile or to sort of back away from some of the things he's been saying. He went further. And you could see the contours of political arguments which he's developing in his mind. I was so struck that not only was he willing to do something Keir Starmer would never have done and never did, which was so directly attack the Johnson Brexit deal. Starmer started to do that towards the end, but not as viscerally as Burnham did. and secondly connect very directly not just the brexit deal with the low growth that basically he knew was about to be announced but with uncontrolled immigration you can see i think in the prime minister's mind the contours of a set of arguments that he thinks that he might be able to make and i suppose as well if you think that there is so little room for maneuver on the economy you can sort of see the political attraction of reanimating some of the brexit wars because it's free and it is something which could potentially bind and gel the progressive coalition, which Burnham so far has started to reassemble.

13:55Jon Sopel: Look, I think that, you know, again, to your point, Lewis, about the timing of the next general election, he said, look, we're not doing anything about the red lines. Those are manifesto commitments. We're not going to do anything until after another election. And we've talked about how limited the room for manoeuvre is because of the manifesto commitments, because of the reluctance of a lot of Labour backbenchers to accept welfare reform. All these other things where you think, God, they're completely hamstrung and there's nothing much that they can do. And as you say, you've got two countervailing forces, haven't you?

14:27Jon Sopel: You've got one, get a fresh mandate and see if you can suddenly start making progress on all these big policy questions like, you know, single market, whether we rejoin the EU, does it need a referendum? And all those things that would kind of really energise an election campaign. And against that, you've got the lesson of Theresa May in 2017, where the British people don't much like an election that is called for opportunistic reasons because you think, oh, this might be a good time to do it. And Theresa May had a huge lead in the polls and it all disappeared. But you are asking something here.

15:02Yeah, you are actually asking a question. The point about Theresa May was it was clearly about, you know, her alpine walk and where am I in the polls. Never go to Snowdonia. Was it Snowdonia? Why do I always think it was in Switzerland? Oh, I thought it was Switzerland. No, no. Well, alpine, I think, covers it. Yeah, it looks alpine. With a fair truity. But I think this time you are, you have got a question. I always go back to that, you know, the simplest question, which is what are you taking to the electorate? Are you taking a question to the electorate? If you haven't got a question to ask them, don't go because they won't come out to the polls with no question.

15:35If they, you know, or they won't come to say, oh, we'd like to raise more taxes. Will you vote for us? No, probably not. If you went back and said we are going to open this whole question of Brexit because we think that that is the single best way of increasing growth for this country. I mean, it's kind of brave.

15:50Jon Sopel: What I'd love to know is inside number 10 Downing Street, is there a plan? Is there a detailed war plan of, right, this is how we start the argument. This is how we reinforce. And you heard it a bit at the end of Andy, at the end of John Healy's speech. You know, I've got the CBR on my side. I've got the Federation of Small Business. We've got all these groups lobbying, business lobby groups who are behind this kind of reshaping of the relationship with Europe. I mean, you know, have they got a plan worked out, the battle plan? This is what we go to on the election. This is how we build the coalition.

16:26Jon Sopel: This is how we win the argument in a way that we did in 2016. The Party of Europe on the 20th of November, which is three weeks away. I mean, the thing, just to go back to Healey and the budget, the thing I was struck with, and it comes back to that whole question of audacity or bravery, whatever you want to call it. He was the man who resigned, you know, as Kemmy Bader not made clear, because the defence spending wasn't up to scratch. And yet the whole build up today was about putting a plan for a plan in place for a future plan, which would then get you to the place. Which would then set up a working party.

17:00And wasn't there something, yeah, there was a working party as well. And you can feel your heart sinking at that point.

17:06Jon Sopel: I love a bit about incubator capital. Bad news for neonatal units everywhere, I think. I think there's a really good line from Kemi Bainov. He has funded the defence investment plan. That is welcome. Yes, there is more support for Ukraine. That is welcome. But he said himself in June, that wasn't enough. What he's done is he's given himself a bit of breathing space, given himself a bit of breathing space until next year. Instead, what we have is a plan to have a plan. I bet Putin's really scared now. The point about being prepared for war is that you can't really signal to your enemies that you will be prepared for war, but not quite yet.

17:45In three and a half years, we're fine.

17:47Jon Sopel: Come back to us then. There was a private eye front cover when the Argentinians invaded the Falkland Islands. And it said a task force will be assembled and we'll launch a surprise attack in three months time. Yeah. You know, that was the kind of although Kemi can wind a neck in a little bit. I mean, you know, you would you would think you would think that, you know, where was defence spending in the Conservatives? And they say all things have changed. Putin invaded Crimea in 2014. You know, and 2020. So, you know, they've got a brass neck. But just on the Brexit stuff, the other thing I thought was so interesting.

18:16Jon Sopel: There was a cabinet readout today and it wasn't about the top of the readout wasn't about the budget. It was about Brexit. Prime Minister opened by setting out how he would shortly write to Cabinet on the UK's relationship with the EU. He said the Brexit deal left by the last government had been bad for the UK and had led to a harder Brexit than had been promised at the referendum. The Prime Minister said the deal had led to low growth and made it harder to control immigration. And it goes on. I mean, when this started, I thought Burnham was just sort of, you know, speaking out loud a little bit, chanting his luck, seeing...

18:44What we call alcoholic football shots.

18:46Jon Sopel: Yeah, and he does that quite a lot. I started to think that he's quite serious. Well, that's what I mean. What is the plan? Is there a plan? Have they worked this all through about how they're going to marshal the argument? And in that case, maybe this budget was the perfect budget for now, which is like, you know, a little bit for retailers, a little bit for dads, a little bit of paternity, a little bit for oil, but wait till you see what we're really doing. And the other thing about an early election, I mean, Brexit or otherwise, which supports that, is, I mean, you know, I mean, you've already alluded to it, Emily.

19:13Jon Sopel: I mean, the spending review penciled in for next year. I mean, Healy basically deferred. I mean, Benny Bader is right about this. I mean, you know, he basically deferred a lot of the tough stuff of that, particularly defence. And given how parlous the fiscal situation is, if he's serious about setting out how to get 3%, that implies really serious departmental cuts in other departments, not good. And that comes on top of Rachel Reeves' other legacy, which is that she did things in quite an unusual way in her early budgets. Normally when chancellors come in, they do the hard stuff in the early part of the parliament and then they leave themselves loads of room as you get close to the election.

19:48Jon Sopel: So you can do giveaways. Reeves did it the other way around. Yes, she raised a lot of tax, but she also did a lot of public spending in those first two budgets. And she partly paid for that on the basis that in the years leading towards the end of the Parliament, there would be serious, quite serious, you know, 2%, 3 % departmental cuts. I mean, if you think that the Labour Party is going to go into an election with 3 % departmental spending cuts in an election year, I mean, I've got a bridge to sell you, right? Like, that is just not going to happen. so I think that the political and economic imperatives certainly to me I mean I think that you know I wouldn't be against I don't know if you'd lose too much money if you put a bet on for a May election of 2027 I think you have already I have I think I'd put one on for April which I now feel is wrong April would definitely be wrong I went long so I think that I've lost that well I still haven't been paid out for the last time my only thing is I don't understand why you can't...

20:49I mean, I'm just pushing this out there. If it was Boris Johnson, I mean, God forbid, but if it was Boris Johnson, Boris Johnson would not be... And he had a majority like that. He would not be stymied into promises he'd formerly kept.

21:02Jon Sopel: Oh, on the lack of mandate? No, but I think... I agree with that, and I'm sure with... Yeah, but I think the problem is with the parliamentary Labour Party, right? If Burnham turned around and said, right, we're going to rejoin the single mark, I just don't... I think the majority would disappear because there'll be enough Labour MPs who said, well, we just can't, you know, I stood on this, Red Wall MPs stood on this, it will be a betrayal and it's absolute catnip for reform and for the Tories. But you're not having an election at that point. You're just saying, we're going to do this and by the time there is growth in the country, I mean, I understand, you know, there's a big question of trust, a big question of political trust, but it's also, I would say, a question of leadership.

21:38If you believe that you are opening the door to making everyone's constituents better off, then you just say, I'm sorry, we're going to get on with it.

21:46Jon Sopel: There's also another intriguing political possibility, right, if they're serious about this Brexit stuff, which is they might not really be thinking so much about reform, but about the possibility of a Conservative revival. Because it is awkward for Bay to knock this, right? Her argument at PMQ's was no-one wants to reanimate this. No-one wants to have this debate. Well, there are a lot of people who want to reanimate the debate, actually. And a lot of them, her entire strategy... In her party as well. Her entire strategy has been basically reorienting the Conservative Party away from the 2019 coalition.

22:12Jon Sopel: She's not doing anything for the Red Wall. She doesn't think they're going to be competitive in those sorts of seats. It's basically reanimating the party in its historic heartlands, wealthier, more affluent parts of the southeast of England, London. That's her entire policy and political pitch. if Brexit re-emerges as a central dividing line that's really awkward for her with that coalition because she's basically ceded the red wall bit that Boris Johnson did very well in in 19 to reform and her just going no one wants to reanimate this debate talking to the voters she's chosen and that's really awkward for her and difficult so you can see some of the political advantages or political possibilities but isn't this interesting that we've basically on the day of the budget and we've all sat through pretty much two hours of Westminster, of John Healy, of John Healy and Kevin Bainock.

23:00And what we've come away with is the question that actually Andy Burnham started the weekend, four days ago.

23:06Jon Sopel: Well, we'll be back in a minute and put some of those questions to the business secretary, Jonathan Reynolds.

23:22anywhere. Pebble helps companies hire and support employees across 185-plus countries. Pebble believes you don't build a winning team by limiting where you look for talent. That belief is at the heart of their new partnership with Bay FC, and the way Pebble helps companies build their own teams every day. With Pebble, companies can hire in over 185 countries, bringing everything together in a single platform that integrates with the tools teams already use. The result is a global team that's actually set up to succeed with accurate pay, real benefits, and the support they need to thrive wherever they are.

23:55Bottom line, great teams can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies build them. Special offer for podcast listeners. Pebble is normally$399 a month per employee. Already a no-brainer for what you get. But right now, there's a limited time offer on their site that makes it even easier to get started. Go to hellopebble.com slash sports before it's gone. That's hellopebl.com slash sports. Terms and conditions apply.

24:26Jon Sopel: Well, we're joined now by the Business Secretary, Jonathan Reynolds. Welcome to you. Look, you came into Parliament in 2010. You've sat through so many budgets on the opposition benches as a member of the government. is this the smallest some might argue the most inconsequential budget that you've seen in that time no no i mean genuinely no to that i mean i am a very happy business that's not a pejorative that's not a pejorative way of putting it what you mean what you what you what you maybe mean is is the scorecard as substantial as you know the big movements of tax and spend so what i'm talking about is will it make a difference to people's lives that that's the measure i think we would use and obviously where we had promised breathing space for families and businesses I think Chancellor has delivered on that particularly on VAT on energy bills and the relief if you're on council tax bands A to D but for my part what I believe is honestly the absolute number one mission of any government this government in particular which is turning around our economic performance and there are some encouraging signs on that but you had a real you know huge statement of support for entrepreneurs with founders relief that is a new thing EMI share options so for people who create businesses and wealth chancellors back them for high streets the changes to small business rates relief threshold you know for retail hospitality and leisure that's your life of your town centre and high street and then on really big strategic stuff you know the announcements on energy should not be underestimated the government moving from essentially an objective simply around clean energy to cheap and clean is absolutely crucial for industry for re-industrialization so So the big strategic things I wanted the Chancellor to deliver upon from my brief, he's absolutely been there on the side of jobs and growth.

26:08And for the bigger picture for families, for breathing space. Again, I think he's delivered on that. So whether you describe that in terms of the scorecard, for me, it's the impact on people's lives.

26:18Jon Sopel: Isn't this a budget that shows a Chancellor totally hemmed in by global headwinds, whether it's the war in Iran, Ukraine, Donald Trump's tariffs policies, Then there's the manifesto commitments, which means you can't do much in terms of, you know, the big items where you can raise and move taxes. Europe, the red lines that we heard about. This is a, you know, you just didn't have any room to move. I think the international situation, particularly the impact on trade from the US-Iran conflict, it had wiped out pretty much half the headroom before it began. So, yes, I think you're right to identify that.

26:56But Donald Trump has got a lot to answer for. It also shows, though, that even within the kind of pressures this Chancellor has been under, he's not powerless, we're not powerless, we've made decisions that will make a difference. So, you know, those set of measures in terms of business, investment, growth, those are very strong. You know, this is also part of a run where we will see the UK EU summit, which will deliver, I believe, real tangible benefits for British business and for families as well, for individuals. We've got the Milburn Review, which is a really substantial piece of work into opportunities for young people and youth employment.

27:29The tenure plan will follow that up. These are major and significant interventions, I would argue, putting the country on the right path. So, yes, the global situation could not be more challenging. I mean, what this Chancellor has had to contend with, no Chancellor's got an easy job, but this was a real set of pressures, external pressures coming in. And I think within that, he has actually performed pretty impressively in terms of delivering against those.

27:52Jon Sopel: Business Secretary, you and the Chancellor and the Prime Minister talk about breathing space. But isn't it the truth that under this government, voters are suffocating? I mean, look at this. OBR forecasts suggest that living standards will fall this year, despite the breathing space promised in the budget. OBR forecasts that living standards will be just 2 % above pre-pandemic levels in 2030. I remember when Keir Starman, when you were in opposition, you constantly berated, rightly, the Tories for having the first parliament in history where living standards was lower than where it began. You're about to oversee another.

28:26Look, the pressure people are under is exactly why this government is right to pursue the course of action that it has. But it's not worth it. If you look at what is forecast to happen because of, in the main, the huge disruption to global trade through the Strait of Hormuz and the US-Iran conflict, the projections for what that means for industrial inputs, for inflation, for different types of inflation, like food inflation, Those are significant. And there's going to be, at this time, real pressure on households that come from that. I would not shy away from that. Will you have let...

28:56Jon Sopel: But, President Secretary, to be clear, Labour is the party, self-described for working people. If we get to the end of this Parliament where people are worse off than at the beginning, will you have let them down? Let's just remember, in the midst of all this pressure, that wages rose faster and by a greater degree in the first ten months of this Labour government than the previous ten years. But that is the context it's happening in. But let's not forget that for the first time in a long time, we are seeing real signs of economic growth that, yes, actually not yet where I would want it to be.

29:26Downgraded. Well, hang on, hang on. Downgraded in the short term because of this international situation. But then actually the fundamentals of where we're at. If you're on your growth, compare the UK to the rest of the G7. I'm not saying it's a job done yet, but it is. We are standing out for our level of performance. Wages rising faster than prices. if the context of this was stronger it would be a genuine level of performance but I'm not shying with that but in the midst of those pressures the resilience of the UK economy I would argue is far stronger than even many people projected Will you be comfortable going back to your constituents

29:59Jon Sopel: at the end of this parliament and saying vote for us we saw yet another parliament of declining living standards I would absolutely have no hesitation in saying vote for us the pressures this country is under are of a level which we recognise Turns out it wasn't just the Tories' fault, though, was it? Turns out that they had a macroeconomic situation to deal with as well. On things like the pandemic, I, of course, am not blaming the Tory party for that. But frankly, if you combine austerity, the uncertainty in the aftermath of Brexit, you know, the difference for the Tories was these were things they had put into the mix.

30:30You know, these were choices they had made. No government can control sometimes the international situation, but I would argue, and I think the evidence shows this, that we are starting to see, for the first time since the global financial crisis, real signs of optimism in the British economy.

30:48Jon Sopel: Or maybe it's because you've got no vision for the economy. I mean, what is Labour's vision of a political economy in this country? What's John Healy's vision of a political economy in this country? John's vision, the Prime Minister's vision. A little bit here, a little bit there. It's for not just wealth, but power to be distributed throughout the country, for growth to reach every part of the country, for industry where ideas and innovation in the UK are no longer lost overseas and scaled up abroad. I mean, this is part of the practical measures brought in today. This is a Prime Minister that at one point people said, look, he's just really good on social media.

31:16Then he does a conference where he says, oh, the agenda is far too radical and bold. I mean, people oscillate between those things. But he has a vision. You cannot argue he has not come to deliver on the big things.

31:25Jon Sopel: Would you say, Business Secretary, that that budget represented the first step of unwinding neoliberalism, as the Prime Minister promised in his conference speech? It is absolutely part of restoring power to all parts of the country. So that's ending neoliberalism? When the Prime Minister talks about the country taking a wrong path 40 years ago, the neoliberalism point, he is talking about the fact that that is the point where the people in London find this easy or not to hear, where many parts of the country felt they lost not just jobs, but power in the country. And I actually think one of the things that is totally underappreciated is the level of not just devolution, but fiscal devolution that this Chancellor built on.

32:03Rachel Reeves actually started this process as well. This is incredibly significant. Real economic revenue raising power, income you can borrow against, power being given not just in a sense of certain responsibilities, but real money and influence to parts of the country. I mean, we haven't seen anything like this.

32:20Jon Sopel: In the political calendar, there is probably no more important day than budget day. And yet I would argue that the most significant thing we heard today was the statement issued from the press office at Downing Street that the cabinet have signed off on a document about the relationship with Europe, that there's going to be a statement. At Prime Minister's questions today, Andy Burnham seemed to go further in embracing the idea of a completely reshaped, rechanged relationship with the EU, possibly rejoining the European Union. And this is a this is kind of eclipsed anything that we heard in the budget.

32:53It just shows the scale of the Prime Minister's ambition to make an impact on the country. So you don't dissent from that view that this is the most significant thing? I could go through the budget line by line and tell you how significant I think it is. There's only so much time this podcast has. I think what is important as well is, first of all, the UK EU summit, I think, is not just going to give us the chance to avoid some real potential harms to the UK. Because people might have heard of the Made in Europe agenda. It's essentially a reaction in Europe to pressures they're under from China, but real consequences for the UK in automotive and aerospace.

33:23And I believe, actually, there's a real lack of appreciation for the key parts, the premise of the EU-UK reset that, again, last government began. Things like SPS, which is your food and agricultural rules, you know, sorting this out, removing these frictions between the UK and the EU. This is one of the reasons, let's be frank, so many businesses in the UK just stopped exporting entirely after Brexit. These will deliver real benefits. So that's the here and now. Now, he has also talked about making sure for the long term, for the 10 year plan, we address some of the problems between ourselves and the EU.

33:57Jon Sopel: Are you looking forward to going back to Staley, Bridge and Hyde and having this argument with your voters who voted for leave, that it's a really good idea for us to rejoin the single market, to have free movement? You're getting ahead of yourself, though. Well, I don't think I am, really, given what the Prime Minister has said. about is if we're looking to the next decade this is his 10-year plan there are no ways we can avoid a conversation about some of the things going on in Europe that impact upon us so made in Europe is one example of that I've got steel tariffs in Europe John that have huge consequences and we need a solution for we've got the rules of origin left over from the original TCA for the automotive sector if we don't fix those by the 1st of January a 10 % tariff under the existing arrangements we We have automotive products transferred between the UK and the EU.

34:43These are all things that need addressing. And we have to appreciate whatever the EU does will have an impact upon us.

34:48Jon Sopel: The Prime Minister, though, is a bit different from his predecessors, isn't he? In his tone on this. I mean, I know you're saying we're getting ahead of ourselves, but I think it was hard to imagine Keir Starmer, certainly at the start of his premiership, talking the way that Andy Burnham did at Prime Minister's question. I think what you'd have to say is that... There's been a shift, right? What you say about Andy in a whole range of areas is he just does not shy away from the big issues. So whether that is the pension system, social care, our relationship with the EU, you know, he addresses those big issues.

35:13And I think people find that authentic, quite rightly, and compelling. And I think actually, you know, politics has got to be about the big issues as well as the retail and the individual. It's got to look at the big things affecting the UK. And I certainly kind of welcome a prime minister who's got that ambition and perspective.

35:28Jon Sopel: Would you be comfortable, just theoretically speaking, do you think you could imagine a situation where the Labour Party did endorse the idea of rejoining the EU? I think that is honestly getting too far ahead of ourselves. The PM has talked about it. What also needs to be considered in this is there are things going on on the EU side, the direction they've gone in since we left. You've got some very strong political currents in the EU. And I don't know what the EU itself will see. But would you like to? The PM has said he'd like to see it happen in his lifetime. For me, it's about solving problems in the main for British industry.

35:59And what is the relationship that is necessary? Do you think British industry would be better off as part of the single market? I think there is no doubt that when we left the European Union, there was an economic price for that. I mean, I don't think that is particularly a controversial thing to say. Some people have voted not on the economy, important to say that they've voted for other reasons around that. But yes, I mean, the figures that are in the public domain are broadly correct for the difficulties Brexit has caused.

36:25Jon Sopel: Just, we've talked about the constraints that the Chancellor is under and the limitation, the limited room for manoeuvre. And part of that is down to manifesto commitments. Part of that is you can't, you know, because of the certain rules and framework that you've got. Would I be mad to put 10 quid on an election next May? Yeah, I think you would be. Totally mad? You've just got to listen to what the Prime Minister says and you can't say it any more times. He has got plans for this country. that is what we're doing. That is the job that we are getting on with. I don't think after the So five quid, okay, ten quid a bit I think we've had so many general elections in this country in a short space of time that I think we'll never stop speculating on them.

37:06But just listen to what the Prime Minister has said on this. But even

37:09Jon Sopel: though you are so constrained in what you can do because of the manifesto commitments, you heard the ambition to confront some of these big issues from the Prime Minister this lunchtime during Prime Minister's questions but having to acknowledge there are red lines because of manifesto commitments. But he is, and we are confronting those big issues. And look, I think, frankly, the speculation partly comes from the fact he clearly has a relationship with the public. I think he is in a very strong position in terms of the endorsement he has from the British public to be the country's prime minister and leader.

37:41And I understand speculation will come from that when you look at the relative position, perhaps, of some other parties. But again, I would just say, listen to what he has to say. Bookies don't agree with your business secretary.

37:50Jon Sopel: You're against British business. Bookies don't get everything right. 15 to 8 you can get for an election next year. You know, some people... A tenner, that would get John an 1875 profit. Some people had something relegated last year and we qualified for Europe. So you've got to be careful sometimes of what the bookies come forward with. You need to back British business business secretary. British bookmakers. On economic forecasts, I would point out as well, we've outperformed those for the last few years as well. So, yeah, you've got to listen to those things, but sometimes the performance is different.

38:20Jon Sopel: Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, thank you very much.

38:49With Pebble, companies can hire in over 185 countries, bringing everything together in a single platform that integrates with the tools teams already use. The result is a global team that's actually set up to succeed with accurate pay, real benefits, and the support they need to thrive wherever they are. Bottom line, great teams can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies build them. Special offer for podcast listeners. Pebble is normally$399 a month per employee. Already a no-brainer for what you get. But right now, there's a limited-time offer on their site that makes it even easier to get started.

39:22Go to hellopebble.com slash sports before it's gone. That's hellopebble.com slash sports. Terms and conditions apply.

39:38So we told you we'd bring you up to date on the Israeli elections. And when I say bring up to date, this could be a rolling story that takes us into about January. But essentially, at eight o 'clock last night, which is 10 p.m. in Israel, the polls closed. And within a moment of them closing, you get a whole load of exit polls. It's not like the one exit poll that you have here. You get about 11 or 12. And they all have varying degrees of difference. but they are trying to predict what they think will be the largest party and how the Knesset, the parliament, will be shaped as a result. What emerged pretty quickly from those polls was that Netanyahu's party, Likud, would have the largest number of seats, but would not have enough for a majority, and that the opposition party would have a smaller number of seats, but potentially a better share of a coalition government.

40:33And since then, we've been looking at the kind of way the seat tally has been changing up and down. And the biggest change of all this election was the number of seats that the Arab parties have won, which looks as if it will be 18 or 19 seats in the Knesset. They form 20 percent of the electorate and the Arab voters came out in their droves yesterday. and it was an extraordinary thing to see the highest turnout, the highest tally for ever, for any Israeli election ever. And I guess what we have now seen is that Israel is, as we thought, entirely split. So what we're trying to work out now is where, who gets the first chance at establishing a government and whether it is, in fact, the person with the largest party, which is once again Netanyahu.

41:27Jon Sopel: Yeah, I mean, 20 seats for the Arab parties in the Knesset, which has a total of 120 seats, means they are a really significant voice and could be the kingmakers. The problem is that would any of the other parties do a deal with the Arab parties to get a majority because of the electoral risk and national security concerns and all the other issues? And they've all said no. And they've all said no. And so you are there with, well, there is one party that can make you the king and make you sit as prime minister. But no one will go near. And so it looks like you're going to have either a very unstable government, which doesn't have a majority and therefore setting the stage.

42:13Jon Sopel: Oh, I think that's the only scenario. I think the only scenario is it's an unstable government and there'll be another general election soon. unless Bibi Netanyahu pulls it off again and somehow conjures an alliance. But the other parties that were part of his coalition did very badly. I mean, they originally had, the coalition had 68 Knesset members. Yeah, he's fallen, I mean, he's fallen popularity considerably. But he's still got enormous grip. And Netanyahu, in part the problem is that he's cannibalised some of their seats, right, within the bloc. You know, Likud itself, his own party has not done that badly.

42:47Jon Sopel: The problem is that the other parties have fallen back. I mean, one of the things that's actually remarkable, right, is that, I mean, I suppose, you know, just taking a step back, in some ways the fact that Netanyahu remained even seriously competitive, given what happened on October the 7th, given the security failures, which he oversaw. Yeah, he was the Prime Minister. He was the Prime Minister and has done extremely well sidestepping. I mean, whatever one thinks of him, he is an extraordinarily quicksilver political figure. I mean, he is, he is, I mean, you know, when one considers that his first election when he was elected in prime minister was in 1996, you know, he has dominated Israeli politics for a substantial proportion of the time that Israel has even been a state.

43:31Jon Sopel: You know, I mean, in so many ways, modern Israel is Netanyahu's Israel. The fact, given that everything that's happened and the security failures and what we've seen in Gaza, that he remains so competitive, I think, tells you much about the tenor of Israeli politics. Yeah, I mean, I think what you have to remember is that this is not an election so much as a marketplace. You know, once the voting is done, they all start coming and haggling. One of the most interesting negotiation thoughts that came to me today was this, that there would be a plan for a very temporary government with the Arab parties to change the laws and prevent Netanyahu running again.

44:09And at that point, they would then dissolve the Knesset and do a unity government with new Likud. Because the irony is that the two bands that can really form a government are the two bands that oppose each other, Likud and Yashar, who is Gaddy Eisencott's opposition party. Without Netanyahu, could you see something that was Likud and Yashar? Maybe. or could Eisencott bring himself to saying, yes, I am going to reach across the aisle. I am going to work with the Arab parties. I mean, you know, one of the, an Israeli I was talking to this morning said, the most sensible thing they could do is make Mahmoud Abbas the foreign secretary.

44:48You know, bring a Palestinian Arab right into the heart of government and just go, that is the sign that we are serious about this government, you know, about security, about peace, about all the rest of it. But is that the end of a political career? That's how they will think.

45:03Jon Sopel: Can I just point out one irony in all of this? And that is that Donald Trump came out twice to vocally support Benjamin Netanyahu and that he should be returned to power as the prime minister. Benjamin Netanyahu did far better than people expected in the polls. And what was the effect of that? The oil price leapt because it suggested that there was much greater likelihood that there would be renewed conflict with Iran. And what does Donald Trump want to do before the midterms? He wants to bring the price of oil down. So Donald Trump, well done. You've pushed the price of oil up with your support for Bibi Netanyahu.

45:37Jon Sopel: Exactly what you didn't want. We'll be back tomorrow. Bye-bye. Bye for now. Whether you're building a roster or a business, great talent can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies hire and support employees across 185 plus countries. Pebble believes you don't build a winning team by limiting where you look for talent. That belief is at the heart of their new partnership with Bay FC. and the way Pebble helps companies build their own teams every day. With Pebble, companies can hire in over 185 countries, bringing everything together in a single platform that integrates with the tools teams already use.

46:11The result is a global team that's actually set up to succeed with accurate pay, real benefits, and the support they need to thrive wherever they are. Bottom line, great teams can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies build them. Special offer for podcast listeners. Pebble is normally$399 a month per employee, Already a no-brainer for what you get. But right now, there's a limited-time offer on their site that makes it even easier to get started. Go to hellopebble.com slash sports before it's gone. That's hellopebble.com slash sports. Terms and conditions apply. This has been a global production.

46:48Whether you're building a roster or a business, great talent can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies hire and support employees across 185-plus countries. Pebble believes you don't build a winning team by limiting where you look for talent. That belief is at the heart of their new partnership with Bay FC, and the way Pebble helps companies build their own teams every day. With Pebble, companies can hire in over 185 countries, bringing everything together in a single platform that integrates with the tools teams already use. The result is a global team that's actually set up to succeed, with accurate pay, real benefits, and the support they need to thrive wherever they are.

47:24Bottom line, great teams can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies build them. Special offer for podcast listeners. Pebble is normally$399 a month per employee. Already a no-brainer for what you get. But right now, there's a limited-time offer on their site that makes it even easier to get started. Go to hellopebble.com slash sports before it's gone. That's hellopebl.com slash sports. Terms and conditions apply.

From the publisher

If the Chancellor wanted to deliver a quiet budget then this was probably it. Even the opposition couldn’t find that many big ticket items to criticise, leaving Kemi Badenoch plaintively asking: "is that it?". Big decisions were delayed through taskforces and spending reviews into next year. Small measures will help small businesses, families with skyrocketing energy bills, the high street, and dads on paternity leave. But broadly this Budget contained tonnes of little things - small measures that won’t make much of a fiscal ripple. Is the Chancellor too hemmed in by Labour's red lines and the reverberations of Trump and Netanyahu's wars to really make a difference? And why is his PM still pushing on the Europe door? We ask Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds.

Later - Israel has voted, so why don't we know whether Netanyahu is finished or not?

The News Agents is a Global Production.

The News Agents is brought to you by HSBC UK - https://www.hsbc.co.uk/

More from The News Agents

All episodes