In short
Podcast Summary: The News Agents - "Will Starmer have the guts to punish Musk for his undressing app?"
Episode Overview In this episode of The News Agents, hosts Emily Maitlis, Jon Sopel, and Lewis Goodall delve into a potential confrontation between the UK government and Elon Musk regarding the controversial AI tool Grok, which has been used to create non-consensual sexualized images. The discussion also touches on London crime statistics, the recent defection of former Conservative Chancellor Nadhim Zahawi to the Reform Party, and the broader implications for UK politics.
Key Topics Discussed
- Elon Musk and the UK Government
- Ofcom Investigation:
- The UK media regulator, Ofcom, has launched an investigation into Musk's platform, X (formerly Twitter), for allowing its Grok chatbot to generate non-consensual sexualized images.
- Potential consequences include fines up to £18 million or a ban on X in the UK if it does not comply with the Online Safety Act.
- Government Stance:
- While the government has asserted that action is up to Ofcom, there is skepticism about whether they will take strong action against Musk, given his connections and influence.
- Officials emphasize that this is a decision for the independent regulator, which raises questions about the government's willingness to confront Musk directly.
- Musk's Reaction:
- Musk has labeled the UK government’s actions as fascist and a form of censorship, complicating the political landscape for Labour leader Keir Starmer.
- Crime Rates in London
- Meeting with Sadiq Khan:
- The episode features an interview with London Mayor Sadiq Khan, who announced that London has reported the lowest homicide rates in over a decade.
- Khan addresses public perception of safety in London, noting that while crime statistics are improving, public sentiment remains influenced by stories disseminated on social media.
- Public Safety Concerns:
- The disparity between actual crime statistics and public perceptions is highlighted, suggesting that misinformation and sensationalist narratives contribute to fears of crime in London.
- Political Dynamics and Defections
- Zahawi's Defection to Reform:
- Nadhim Zahawi, former Chancellor and prominent Conservative figure, has defected to the Reform Party, raising questions about the Conservative Party's future.
- Zahawi's previous commitments to the Conservative Party and his criticisms of Reform are contrasted with his current political maneuvering.
- Political Consequences:
- The discussion reflects on how defections, particularly from high-profile figures, can shift political dynamics and public opinion in the UK.
- The Broader Implications of Political Rhetoric
- Polarization:
- Discussions touch on how political rhetoric surrounding issues like diversity and immigration can polarize public opinion and impact electoral politics.
- The hosts reflect on the responsibility of progressive politicians to articulate their values confidently in the face of rising nativism and populism.
- Impact of Social Media:
- The role of social media in shaping narratives about London and the political landscape is examined, with emphasis on the need for effective regulation to combat misinformation.
Key Takeaways
- The UK government faces a critical test in its willingness to confront powerful figures like Elon Musk, especially regarding issues of consent and online safety.
- Public perception of crime can be misaligned with actual statistics, influenced by narratives on social media.
- The political landscape in the UK is shifting, with notable defections raising questions about party loyalty and future electoral outcomes.
- The challenges posed by misinformation and divisive political rhetoric require a robust response from progressive politicians.
Conclusion This episode of The News Agents illustrates the intertwining of social media regulation, public safety narratives, and evolving political allegiances in the UK. As the government navigates these complex issues, the discourse reflects broader societal tensions and the urgent need for accountability and regulation in the digital age.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOOfcom's Investigation into X
0:46 to 2:35
Discussion about Ofcom's investigation into the Grok chatbot and its implications for X and Elon Musk.
“And these questions about Grok, we're going to address with the mayor of London, Sir Sadiq Khan, in just a moment.”
Government Responses and Regulations
2:36 to 4:32
Exploration of the UK government's response to the investigation and the implications of the Online Safety Act.
“So it's not government censorship as such.”
Elon Musk's Reaction and Political Ramifications
4:33 to 6:45
Analysis of Elon Musk's response to the investigation and the potential political fallout for Keir Starmer.
“But we have seen them repeatedly be pretty toothless as a regulator.”
Sadiq Khan's Views on Crime in London
6:46 to 7:40
Sadiq Khan discusses crime rates in London and the perception of safety among residents.
“since he's been prime minister, has sought to stay on the right side of Donald Trump and America and recognises that Elon Musk is a very powerful voice within that country.”
Perceptions of London and Political Narratives
7:41 to 12:30
Sadiq Khan addresses the political narratives surrounding London and their impact on public perception.
“And by the way, thanks for having me back on News Agents.”
The Role of Accountability in Democracy
14:01 to 15:06
Explore the importance of accountability and the challenges faced by diverse leaders.
“That seems to basically be the inference of it.”
Regulating Social Media: The Case for X
15:07 to 16:53
Discuss the implications of recent changes in social media regulation and the role of Ofcom.
“We've had the whole issue with what has been on X and on Grok, and there's now going to be an Ofcom investigation.”
Free Speech vs. Regulation
16:54 to 18:29
Delve into the complexities of free speech limitations and their implications for society.
“He calls any attempt to regulate his platform fascism.”
Addressing Racism and Political Discourse
18:30 to 20:54
Examine the challenges posed by influential figures in politics and their impact on societal norms.
“That tweet alone about what's going to happen to America without re-emigration has been seen 37 million times.”
Migration and National Identity
20:55 to 23:11
Analyze the debate surrounding migration and its effect on national identity and unity.
“So let's put the far right argument to you, which is that, you know, and you can use the phrase from Donald Trump's national security strategy about Europe facing civilizational erasure.”
Show all 17 chapters
Understanding the Impact of Immigration Control
23:12 to 26:51
Discuss the implications of immigration policies and the importance of integration.
“The ability to be a bus driver, I'm not sure if I've mentioned this, but that was a bus driver.”
Rebutting Myths About London and Diversity
26:52 to 28:00
Learn how evidence-based arguments can counter negative perceptions about diversity in London.
“You're petrified about your nationality being questioned, your loyalty being questioned.”
The Importance of Evidence in Political Arguments
28:00 to 29:01
Discover how evidence plays a crucial role in shaping political discussions around reform.
“is to not just rebut some of these myths and untruths about London, but also to talk up why diversity is a strength, why I talk about the difference it makes to our great city.”
Nadim Zahawi's Defection to Reform
29:21 to 37:54
Analyze the implications of Nadim Zahawi's defection from the Conservative Party to Reform.
“Discover how today's story affects your life.”
The Impact of Political Defectors
37:54 to 41:20
Explore the effects of political defections on party loyalty and public perception.
“I mean, does Nadim Zahawi really think this country is like the Iraq of Saudi?”
Political Pressure on the Federal Reserve
42:00 to 44:25
Exploring the implications of political influence on the Federal Reserve's actions.
“And just have a listen to the way Jerome Powell has had to come out and more or less say, this is a politically motivated witch hunt by Donald Trump because I won't cut interest rates.”
Jay Powell's Stand Against Authoritarianism
44:25 to 45:36
Discussion on Jay Powell's resistance to political pressures and its consequences.
“who published that video across social media channels.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:01Jon Sopel:This is a Global Player original podcast.
0:05Lewis Goodall:It's perhaps been a long time coming, but potentially a showdown between the UK government and Elon Musk may finally be here. As ex-Elon Musk social media platform has now been placed under formal investigation by the UK media regulator Ofcom after its Grok chatbot has enabled users to digitally undress people, including women and underage children. Ofcom could issue a fine.
0:34Jon Sopel:And if X doesn't comply with the fine, there could be a move to shut X down in the UK. Would the government really have the balls to take on the richest man in the world and close friend of Donald Trump? Welcome to The News Agents.
0:56Jon Sopel:The News Agents. It's John. It's Lewis. And we are at City Hall in London. And these questions about Grok, we're going to address with the mayor of London, Sir Sadiq Khan, in just a moment. But as we were coming over here, we heard that Ofcom had announced that it was launching an investigation into X because of what it's been putting out on its AI platform Grok and the possibility that 10 percent of earnings could be a fine levied at Elon Musk, some 18 million pounds potentially. and then the possibility that if he doesn't comply with that, well, there could be a move to shut X down in the UK.
1:35Jon Sopel:And the question of whether the government really has the appetite to do that has to be asked.
1:41Lewis Goodall:Yeah, we talked about this on the show last week. It has become an increasing source of deep unhappiness among Labour MPs, backbencher MPs in particular. This concerns specifically the regulator Ofcom, saying it is responding to, quote, deeply concerning reports of image manipulation, which it said may amount to intimate image abuse or pornography. Sexualised images of children may amount to child sexual abuse material, Ofcom is saying. The action is being launched under the Online Safety Act, which gives Ofcom the power to fine X hundreds of millions of dollars or ban it. And indeed, this follows, we saw Indonesia, the Indonesian government banning the use of Grok in this way over the course of the weekend for precisely the same reason.
2:24Lewis Goodall:The UK government over the course of the last week has been keen to say that this is a decision for Ofcom. We had some criticism on the show last week. In a sense of that, you can kind of see why they would want to make it look like this is something for the regulator rather than the government. So it's not government censorship as such. But nonetheless, really, this is a deeply political decision, which I think probably ought on some level to be taken by ministers. But the response from the UK government so far has been basically to say, Ofcom do want to ban X. If they refuse to comply with the obligations under the Online Safety Act, then they will back them.
2:57Lewis Goodall:This is what Heidi Alexander, the Transport Secretary, said to me about that precise subject on my RBC show yesterday.
3:02Jon Sopel:Well, I think the powers that Ofcom have as the independent regulator
3:05Lewis Goodall:is to apply to a court to, in the most extreme circumstances, perhaps through business disruption activity, take X offline.
3:15Jon Sopel:But that would be a decision for the independent regulator.
3:17Lewis Goodall:But is it something you would support if they felt they had no choice?
3:19Jon Sopel:If Ofcom came to that conclusion that X hadn't taken appropriate action in response to them, then obviously we would support what the independent regulator decides. And you can imagine that Elon Musk has responded in a temperate and moderate way. Happy to talk. Happy to discuss. Has accused Keir Starmer's government of being fascist after ministers stepped up, threats to ban the social media site over those AI generated sexualised images. And he said that this was just another example of any excuse for censorship from the British government. So there you have Elon Musk, who spectacularly fell out with Donald Trump a few months back, but is absolutely right back in there now.
4:09Jon Sopel:He's doing something today where he's appearing with Pete Hegseth, the Secretary of State for War, as he's now called. And so it shows that he's very much back in the White House circle, which again raises the risk level for Keir Starmer if he wants to move against X. and of course that maybe explains why the government is saying nothing to do with us we've got an independent regulator we'll let them get on with the work it's not our decision whether action is taken against x it is down to the regulator not us yes i wouldn't hold your breath
4:42Lewis Goodall:necessarily for some dramatic action from ofcom ofcom have repeatedly showed that they are pretty toothless as a regulator they have showed repeatedly i think they simply do not understand the digital world and the digital media world in which we now live we have this extraordinary set of circumstances in which, you know, everything on traditional broadcast media is highly regulated, everything on digital media, despite the fact that sometimes they're owned by the same companies, is unregulated. Fine. But we have seen them repeatedly be pretty toothless as a regulator. The government is passing the buck to them again.
5:13Lewis Goodall:Fine. But you can see the nightmarish politics that it sets up for Starmer, which is on the one hand, as you say, John, Musk is completely back or largely back in the MAGA fold. We have seen Republican, congresswoman over the course of the weekend say that if the UK government does act against X, then the US government should respond with economic sanctions against the UK. And yet at the same time, you have got a government which has just before the end of last year launched its violence against women and girls strategy. It is one of the top five missions of the government to halve violence against women and girls.
5:50Lewis Goodall:Its MPs rightly, deeply care about the subject. And you have got one of the most powerful men in the world because of his deeply libertarian, I would argue, nihilistic view of how freedom of expression ought to operate, seriously drawing as a line in the sand, saying that basically non-consensual sexualised images of women, girls, children should be OK in the name of freedom of speech. And indeed, X responded to it the other day by saying, well, we're going to limit that to premium users, that particular function, as if it's okay. As long as you're paying for it, then like, you know, what's the problem, lads, right?
6:23Lewis Goodall:That is the kind of philosophy that we're dealing with here. And that is basically the challenge for Keir Starmer. And it is a nightmarish one, but it is a test of his mettle and the government's mettle, as we were saying last week, for seriously how much they care about these sexualised images, non-consensual sexualised images, because if they really do, then they will absorb the bad politics.
6:44Jon Sopel:Yeah, and we know that Keir Starmer, since he's been prime minister, has sought to stay on the right side of Donald Trump and America and recognises that Elon Musk is a very powerful voice within that country. And as you say, Lewis, you know, we have seen the government avoiding confrontation wherever it can. You know, was the lifting of Maduro from Venezuela, breach of international law. Well, that's for Americans to explain. There have been so many examples where they haven't wanted to have that conversation. but over this it looks like they might have to with the chill effect that could have on Anglo-US relations.
7:24Jon Sopel:Now we're going to ask Sadiq Khan all about that in just a moment but we're here in City Hall because the Mayor of London has today announced that homicide rates in the capital are at an all-time low and that some other areas of crime are also falling and you can see that Sadiq Khan after the criticism that he has come in for is on something of a victory lap over that
7:51Jon Sopel:well Sadiq Khan welcome to the news agents good to have you with us I mean obviously the homicide statistics for London are much much better but if you talk to any of our production team they'll all have got anecdotes of anti-social behavior petty crime inconvenience does anything think change the narrative about the fact that a lot of people feel that London is unsafe?
8:15Sadiq Khan:Well, I think it's all linked. And by the way, thanks for having me back on News Agents. Look, I think one homicide is one death too many. I think one violent crime is one victim too many. But what the latest evidence shows is just an example of the progress we've made, which even the most harshest critic will have to accept. We are, unarguably now, the safest city when it comes to homicides in the world, far safer than Paris, Berlin, Brussels, Milan, Rome, Toronto, any state in the USA. But you're right, there's a perception which we've got to address. And the best way to address the perception is by dealing with the reality, which is the crime.
8:53Sadiq Khan:So yes, remarkable progress in relation to reducing homicides. We're also tackling the sorts of crimes which we call high volume crimes. Think about your phone being stolen. It's really distressing. All your photographs are there, your contacts are there, your messages are there, or your watch, or your handbag. Think about if you're a shopkeeper, the impact of shoplifting on you, or when you're using public transport and you're seeing somebody not paying their fares, a sense of unfairness. We're tackling those crimes as well. And the good news, personal robbery down 15%, theft down 25%, more than 1 ,000 additional arrests a month.
9:27Sadiq Khan:And we're making progress on violence against women and girls, a real issue for more than half of Londoners.
9:32Jon Sopel:Let me ask you a slightly different question, which is not about the crime rate. but about why you think it is that London has become politicised by Donald Trump, by Elon Musk, but also in Britain as well on the right, where London is the sort of the source of division. And I've never known that to happen before.
9:51Sadiq Khan:Well, I think objectively, I think we have to accept that politicians and commentators have been spamming social media feeds with an endless stream of what I would call distortion and untruths. A variety of reasons I would give for why I think that's happening. If you are a nativist, if you've got a certain political agenda, then a city that is liberal, that is progressive, that is diverse, that is incredibly successful is a problem for you. That it has a Muslim mayor as well? That's an issue for some people, I suspect. But here's the point. When you look at a number of objective criteria, the number of tourists coming to London, the amount of music we have in London, sports in London, foreign direct investment, international students, homicides.
10:41Sadiq Khan:We are the best city in terms of the lack of homicides, in terms of our success. We are, I would argue, objectively, now the greatest city in the world. That's a problem for those people who have got a certain political agenda. What you're seeing is not just the president of the USA or the vice president of the USA, are politicians and commentators across the globe. You're seeing people in this country, politicians and commentators, jumping on that bandwagon. Is that a problem, though?
11:08Lewis Goodall:I mean, in the sense that are there, I mean, it's very clear, as you say, Makan, that there is this kind of narrative, there is this kind of information ecosystem, which portrays London, portrays your London in particular, as a dystopia, right? Does that have real world consequences? I mean, does it affect kind of how American businesses, say, treat London, invest in London, how British business treats London? Is there actual real world effect or is it just in their heads?
11:31Sadiq Khan:I think it is an issue. Why do I think it's an issue? Because perception matters. Park the evidence for a second. If you're somebody who's not been to London and you're getting your news from a certain social media outlet, or if you're somebody around the world who's not mixed with a Muslim or an ethnic minority or been to London, and you're getting your news from a certain outlet, you may prejudge what this great city of ours is like. Now, the likes of JPMorgan Chase and Apple and Google and I could name a number of others, they ignore the noise because they've got real experience of London. Londoners, vast majority, ignore the noise because they've got a different experience of London.
12:11Sadiq Khan:But I want people from outside London to come to London for a day trip or to study or to work or to invest. I want people across the globe to think actually diversity is not necessarily a weakness. It doesn't make us weaker. It doesn't make us poorer. But the evidence from London is diversity is a strength. It makes us richer, not poorer. It makes us...
12:31Lewis Goodall:That is completely against the ideological wins, though, isn't it?
12:35Sadiq Khan:But you can see why they're pushing this agenda, whether you're Elon Musk or J.D. Vance or President Trump or Nigel Farage, and I could go on. You can understand why they're pushing this agenda. And I think it's unpatriotic. We are the capital city, by the way. We are the capital city. We are arguably the most diverse city in the world. Also, objectively, one of the safest cities in the world, whether it's foreign direct investment, international students, as I said, a number of other criteria. We're doing remarkably well in historical terms, as well as across the globe in relative terms as well.
13:09Sadiq Khan:And I think what I want to see is more of us pushing back. We're now giving you the evidence to push back on. And my worry is this perception clouds the reality.
13:20Lewis Goodall:I think the government should push back harder, national government.
13:22Sadiq Khan:Well, I'm pleased to see the government pushing back in terms of what they're saying. We need more of that. I also recognise our responsibility as the capital city in terms of contribution towards the Treasury when it comes to monies, when it comes to people coming to the country through London as a springboard to go to the next...
13:39Lewis Goodall:Just one other thing on that, though, because, I mean, we've seen that sort of language in particular. It's a very particular rhetoric which is used about your city, and it is directed at you. And we've seen it mirrored as well since Zora Mamdani became mayor of New York. It's a very particular phrase which percolates around social media. It's London or New York has fallen. Now, we all know what that means, right? Because you're both Muslim mayors. That seems to basically be the inference of it. Is that a particular problem? What is your reaction to that?
14:06Sadiq Khan:Well, before I answer that question, can I just make this point? I think it's right and proper that people like you hold me to account. I think I should be challenged with my policies around housing or transport or crime. That is legitimate. And that's the joy of a democracy. I think what's unfair is, and it's wrong, is when people are targeted because of the colour of their skin or the religion they belong to. And we can't run away from the fact that the two most diverse cities in the world, New York being the second greatest city in the world, of course, have mayors who are different to the ideal candidate that President Trump and others may have.
14:39Sadiq Khan:Now, the fact is, actually, both Zohoran and myself love our cities. We're both trying to address the cost of living crisis in our respective cities. We're both examples of, respectively, the New York promise and the London promise. You work hard. You get a helping hand. You can achieve anything. I would suggest that actually, you know, Zohoran Mamdani is a good example of the American dream. And if I was a national politician, I'd be pushing that as an example of the joys of the United States of America.
15:06Jon Sopel:You talk about the misinformation about London and the kind of perception it creates. We've had the whole issue with what has been on X and on Grok, and there's now going to be an Ofcom investigation. Would you support a ban on X if it doesn't change?
15:24Sadiq Khan:I'm not there yet, and I'm generally not in favour of banning social media. I think there needs to be better regulation. Let me tell you why I say that. Because in the recent past, we've seen the safeguards that were in place, as imperfect as Twitter was. There were staff employed to fact check, to take down clear rubbish, and the algorithms were used in a different way. And what we've seen since Elon Musk took over and Twitter became X is the removal of those staff, and the algorithms working differently. I think it is a problem when artificial intelligence is used without guardrails to, for example, have these images of children or women in particular wearing hardly any clothes.
Read the full transcript
16:05Sadiq Khan:And that's why I welcome the regulator looking into what X does. Firstly, I think I'm not sure how practical it is.
16:13Jon Sopel:Do you think the government should be doing more and not kind of saying, oh, this might challenge America. So let's off come deal with this and not Downing Street.
16:20Sadiq Khan:Well, my view is if the regulation, the law is inadequate, the Online Safety Act, we need to change the law. And from what I understand with what Ofcom are saying today is they'll investigate, they'll serve notice of their conclusions to X, X have a chance to respond. And there is a sanction potentially of fines. If that doesn't go far enough and X don't change their behaviour, I think we should look at whether the legislation is fit for purpose. I think the legislation, in my view, should be the floor, not the ceiling.
16:48Lewis Goodall:But it's very clear, isn't it? Mac, are you talking about regulation? Musk isn't interested in regulation. He's not interested. He calls any attempt to regulate his platform fascism. And what we're talking here is quite a low bar, right? We're talking about ensuring that women, the images of women and even children are not manipulated in a sexual fashion, in a non-consensual way. And he calls that fascism. I mean, this is heading for some confrontation, isn't it? Well, actually, when you look at the...
17:16Sadiq Khan:It's really important we address head-on this assertion that limiting free speech is fascism. The right to free speech is not an unlimited right. Look at the jurisprudence coming from the United States of America, the European Convention, or this country. We've got laws around censorship that limits free speech. We've got laws around national security that limits free speech. We've got laws around defamation that limits free speech. We've got laws around incitement that limits free speech. And he calls quite a lot of that fascism. Both in the USA and the UK. And I'd say in a respectful way to great Americans and great Brits remember our history remember our history and remember why it is we love our countries and this idea that we allow an individual to make this sweeping assertion about our country based upon regulation I think is wrong we should respond to it There's been 12 ,000 arrests in relation to infringements of free speech Well I'm not sure about where that figure what I do know is when it comes to laws around free speech a lot of them are civil not criminal there are very limited rules around criminal law and free speech most of them are civil the remedy for defamation is a civil remedy.
18:20Sadiq Khan:The criminal remedies are very limited around incitement and around national security.
18:24Lewis Goodall:But I just wonder what you think in terms of the effects of politics, Mayor Khan. As you say, you talk about diversity, you talk about the importance of progressive politics. How does progressive politics respond to a man who is possibly the most powerful, one of the most powerful, certainly one of the richest men in the world, who controls one of the most influential information platforms in the world, who is regularly, just in the last 24 hours, retweeting and tweeting white supremacist content, suggesting that the United States is going to head the way of post-apartheid South Africa is going without re-emigration, who is routinely posting that sort of content that we would have once considered not only fringe, but the preserve of the far right.
19:02Lewis Goodall:That tweet alone about what's going to happen to America without re-emigration has been seen 37 million times. Is that not a profound threat to exactly the sort of politics that you're saying is a great strength?
19:12Sadiq Khan:Well, but Elon Musk isn't the only person normalising racism, by the way, normalizing these views. And so my starting point is to respond and rebut to views that are wrong. Secondly, to articulate my concern, which is if you're an ethnic minority, if you're a member of a minority, if you're a woman, you want to think twice or thrice about becoming a politician or putting your head above the parapet, because if they think this is what you get for doing this, you mentioned the importance of tackling the lack of regulation around AI and Grok. But the third point I'd make is this. Look, it's really important we remember not just where we are now in terms of the benefits of diversity and the benefits of equality, but also where we've come from and push back.
19:57Sadiq Khan:Because I think in the end, the best way to respond to somebody who's got views that are abhorrent is to respond with debate. And the vast, vast majority of people in this country are decent and they'll reject the views of Musk.
20:08Lewis Goodall:Have a progressive politician been too weak?
20:10Sadiq Khan:I think we've got to have more confidence, more confidence to articulate our values, more confidence to understand, you know, where this is heading. When I see the rise of nativist populists across the globe, whether it's the USA or Hungary or elsewhere, of course, I get nervous. But then I see the response from progressive, whether it's Canada or Australia or UK and France. We've got to be more confident in relation to this issue. We are seeing more polarization. That worries me. We are seeing people trying to sow the seeds of division. That worries me. And one of the reasons why I welcome the election of Zohar Mamdani, as I do indeed my three elections in London, is London has rejected fear and chose hope.
20:51Sadiq Khan:London has rejected division and chose a unity. And I'm confident if we can articulate the benefits of our values, more people will be on our side, whether it's in the UK or the USA as well.
21:01Jon Sopel:So let's put the far right argument to you, which is that, you know, and you can use the phrase from Donald Trump's national security strategy about Europe facing civilizational erasure. And some of the things he's said about you, you only get elected because, you know, so many foreigners have come into this country. I mean, I think in 1961, London was 93 percent white. It's probably less than half now. In 2021, it was 53 percent. that London has changed beyond all recognition. And this is what the far right are talking about when they talk about civilizational erasure.
21:35Sadiq Khan:Well, look, I mean, we're an island. How far back do you go in terms of immigration? The Vikings? Well, I'm talking about 60 years in people's lifetime. That's, you know, quite a profound change. Well, I think there's two issues. One is I'm somebody who speaks from personal experience and is saying I'm born and raised in London. So my grandparents were migrants from India to Pakistan. My parents are migrants from Pakistan to the UK. I can go nowhere. I've got nowhere else to go to. I'm born and raised in South London.
22:01Lewis Goodall:But they say you're not English, Makan. You know that. They say that you're not truly English. Yeah. That's where the debate has moved to.
22:06Sadiq Khan:Yeah, but if we're taking somebody's, you know, nationality based upon where they were born, I mean, Boris Johnson wasn't born in the UK either. I could give a number of examples of Great Britons not born in the country in which they're naturalized or which becomes their country of choice. And I think it's a really dangerous argument to have. You could go to President Trump himself, where his grandparents are originally from as well. But actually, look at the contribution great countries have had from people who are from a different country of origin. I think the flag of your country of origin or the color of the flag of your country of origin or the color of your skin shouldn't be the criteria upon we judge the contribution made by citizens.
22:44Sadiq Khan:And I think it's a really dangerous argument. And we should push back and explain that actually one of the reasons why many of us love America is civil rights movement, is great American politicians, is the contribution made by successive waves of migrants in the USA. And indeed, whether you look at the UK or France or elsewhere, there's a different conversation, by the way, about controlling migration. We've got to control migration. We've got to have strong borders. We've got to make sure that people integrate. I think it's really important to speak the first language. Look, the ability of my dad to go to a parents' evening was made much better because you could speak English.
23:15Sadiq Khan:The ability to be a bus driver, I'm not sure if I've mentioned this, but that was a bus driver. He couldn't do it.
23:21Lewis Goodall:I knew the Prime Minister's dad was a toolmaker. I don't know. It's a vague rumour. I'm sure.
23:25Sadiq Khan:They're different conversations. And there is an issue about, you know, if there's too much migration over a short period of time, the impact it has on public services. Those are different conversations from what you're alluding to, which is the far right asserting you're never really a pucker Brit or a pucker American if the colour of Michigan is different. I mean, Rishi Sunak, I mean, you know, the idea that Rishi, who may be from a different political party, but that Rishi Sunak isn't an Englishman or a Brit is ridiculous.
23:52Lewis Goodall:There is, though, an argument, and we've heard it articulated again today. I don't know if you've seen, but the former Tory Chancellor, Nadim Zahawi, has defected to reform, become the latest Conservative to defect to reform. He's made an argument to say, and he says this, of course, from a Muslim background himself, he is arguing that Britain has an unaddressed problem with Islamic sectarianism. Indeed, he argued that at the next election, he thinks there will be a wave of sectarian Islamist parties or candidates standing in British cities and displacing, in his words, half the cabinets. And that we've ignored the problem of political Islamism in this country for too long.
24:26Sadiq Khan:What would your response to that be? Well, I'm not sure what he's referring to and stuff. And I need to speak a bit more with Nadim to understand what he's talking about and to respond in kind. I'm somebody who works incredibly hard bringing people together, visiting synagogues and mosques and gorodbaras and temples and churches and so forth. Because I think it's really important to get people mixing and mingling. I think it can be quite a problem if you've got people living in silos. I'm not sure what Nadim's referring to, so it'd be for him to explain. But I think using that sort of language is a problem.
25:01Sadiq Khan:Let me tell you why it's a problem.
25:01Lewis Goodall:Well, he's actually compared Britain as it is at the moment to the Iraq of his childhood. That's how sectarian he believes Britain is becoming.
25:07Sadiq Khan:Yeah, but let me tell you the impact of his words on people who may live in parts of the country where they've not got a Muslim neighbor or a Muslim work colleague or somebody who's Muslim. They will assume that every single Muslim is involved in sectarian politics and every single Muslim is somebody who's got an ulterior motive. And that's just not the case. And so I'm not sure what Nadeem is driving at. You know, there may be problems in relation to people's concerns around particular issues and stuff. our job as politicians and as leaders is to address any fears people may have, to respond to concerns they have.
25:44Sadiq Khan:And I think the way, generally speaking, is to offer hope rather than fear.
25:48Lewis Goodall:We talked a lot. I mean, in a way, our conversation, something we talk about on the show a lot is the kind of weird fusion that's taken place, particularly over the last year between US and UK politics. And it feels as if there's almost one conversation going on. And it's not just from us to them. They talk about us a lot. Certainly the right of American politics talk about you a lot. They talk about our city, London a lot. They talk about the UK a lot. There has been, actually, both from the Conservative Party and Reform, a suggestion that what we need is a British ICE, i.e. the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agency, that is being used by President Trump at the moment to deport lots of people, and indeed, sometimes even American citizens.
26:27Lewis Goodall:Reformer actually pledged to create one. So have Kemmy Badenow. What do you make of that? And if you were mayor of the city when that came about, would you cooperate with the British ICE?
26:35Sadiq Khan:Well, can I explain the consequences of ICE to Americans that are talking about the experience of ICE? It means if you're somebody who may have been born in another country but has become naturalized, if you're somebody who's got a skin color that's not white, you're petrified about the tap on your shoulder, or worse. You're petrified about your nationality being questioned, your loyalty being questioned. You're petrified about being deported to a country you've never been to. Now, of course, there's got to be proper controls at our borders. And of course, you need to enforce the laws or people have broken the laws in terms of being here who shouldn't be here.
27:11Sadiq Khan:But the idea that you have a situation where people are looking to ice for inspiration is not something that I subscribe to. But also, I think we should at the same time talk up the benefits of lawful migration, but also talk about the disbenefits. the reason why I'm going to address illegal migration at the same time. I think it's possible to do both. Let me just ask you this.
27:31Jon Sopel:Do you think you're winning the argument? You are there as a sort of symbol of multiculturalism, of a liberal London. You've won three terms in office. But in the rest of the country, it feels like reform is very much on the rise, dominant in the opinion polls. And you are being used as the exemplar by them of all that can go wrong. and they seem to be garnering support as a result almost.
27:57Sadiq Khan:Well, one of the reasons I welcome being asked to be a news agency is to not just rebut some of these myths and untruths about London, but also to talk up why diversity is a strength, why I talk about the difference it makes to our great city. And here's the fact they can't argue with it. My question was, are you winning the argument? The question they can't argue with is the evidence, right? As a former lawyer, I think you win cases with evidence and with strong arguments based upon the evidence. And I can understand, by the way, if people only have, you know, one point of view being presented to them, they might subscribe to the follow through, which is vote reform.
28:33Sadiq Khan:So, for example, if reform are playing in your fears because you can't get decent housing, because you can't get decent health care, because you can't get kids into local school, and they're saying the reason is because of the other, you can understand why there's not a counter view. They may decide to support reform. The response is actually we've not invested enough in the National Health Service. we've not invested enough in local schools, we've not built enough council homes and that's why it's incredibly important to address people's fears and concerns rather than play on them. Thank you very much indeed.
29:02Sadiq Khan:Thank you.
29:21Jon Sopel:Discover how today's story affects your life.
29:24Lewis Goodall:Listen on our free Global Player app or the new LBC app.
29:28Jon Sopel:LBC, leading Britain's conversation.
29:35Jon Sopel:The News Agents.
29:37Lewis Goodall:Something we came to expect in 2025 on Mondays were the regular drumbeat of reform press conferences. Sometimes a bit of a surprise, sometimes much trail, sometimes quite dramatic, sometimes completely humdrum. Well, they've had their first for 2026. And guess what? They've got a new member.
29:57Jon Sopel:I'm here today to tell you all, and of course, the British people, that Britain needs reform. Britain needs Nigel Farage as Prime Minister. I know this may come as a surprise to my old party and to many Westminster watchers, but it really shouldn't. and it certainly won't come as a shock to the tens of millions of hard-working, patriotic, decent people up and down our wonderful United Kingdom. So that very lyrical defection was coming from Nadim Zahawi, former chairman of the Conservative Party, well-known figure in conservative circles and saying what Britain needs now more than anything else is Nigel Farage to be the next Prime Minister.
30:47Jon Sopel:And I guess Nadim Zahawi is a big name, a big defection from the Conservative Party to reform. I mean, there are elements of his career, which maybe we could dwell on a tiny bit, which has shown that he has been an opportunist in the past. But he is now taking his opportunity because he thinks the best chance for the next election of who is going to win will be Farage.
31:12Lewis Goodall:Zahawi is by far, I think, the most senior former Conservative now or person associated with the last Conservative government to defect to reform. Previously, that had been Danny Kruger, I think had only been a junior minister of parliamentary undersecretary of state. Now, Zahawi, as you say, John, had been Tory party chairman. He had been education secretary. He'd been much heralded as the vaccines minister during the Covid period. He was for about 40 seconds chancellor of the Excheca. Yes. In the interregnum between Boris Johnson and Liz Truss. people remember and Sunak resigned as Chancellor.
31:44Lewis Goodall:Zahawi was put in to replace him and about a few days later called on Boris Johnson to go. So he's no stranger to a little bit of political intrigue, well liked within the Conservative Party, well liked actually within Westminster, you know, a Brexiter of very long standing, very closely associated with Boris Johnson. So yeah, clearly a scalp for the Reform Party. Kemi Bader not been on a bit of a roll recently in terms of that slightly diffuse commodity of momentum. She's been doing quite well at Prime Minister's Questions, There's been some evidence of a bit of a polling bounce for her personally, maybe a bit for the Conservative Party reform on the slide a little bit.
32:18Lewis Goodall:So that will dent potentially some of that momentum. The danger, of course, for reform is that this is the latest of a string of former MPs. And you will have noted, John, that they all tend to be rather alike. Where are they all from? They're all from the Conservative Party. And not just the Conservative Party, but a particular wing of the Conservative Party, which is the sort of hardcore, radical right, Brexiter right bit of the Conservative Party, perhaps most associated with Boris Johnson and his trust, those sorts of people. and so it is a potential vulnerability that I know some reform have been grappling with the extent to which they should absorb more defectors from the Conservative Party because of course it burnishes the argument from the Labour Party which will be made again and again and again and again that these are just a bunch of people from Farage down a bunch of Tories in reform clothing.
33:06Jon Sopel:Now the thing about Nidazine Zahawi which will be a plus for Nigel Farage if you think of who is going to be the minister for the morning rounds Who is good televisually? Who is good on the radio? Zahawi is a very effective communicator and does that very well. He's also shown himself to be very prickly when people start investigating his own financial affairs. And he used some pretty, well, he used some pretty dodgy legal mechanisms to issue these slap orders where he threatened anyone with libel actions if they dared to write about any of these subjects. which has a very chill effect on journalists' ability to do investigations.
33:48Jon Sopel:And he was found out in the end and humiliated by that whole process. So, you know, Zahawi has got a past track record as well. But Zahawi is from a very interesting background and very unlike a lot of conservative MPs. I mean, his family fled Iraq and his dad was a very well placed. I think he was the governor of the Bank of Iraq back in the day. and so was from a very well-to-do, wealthy Iraqi background, but came to Britain with little and that to learn the language and all the rest of it. However, one of the more improbable allusions he made for leaving and talking about the state of Britain today was to compare Britain now with Iraq when presumably Saddam Hussein was in charge.
34:35Jon Sopel:I also know a thing or two about growing up in a country that is fundamentally broken. riven by sectarian strife, economic depression and cratering living standards. The sickness is no surprise to anyone. To anyone trying to get a doctor's appointment. To anyone who wants to express an opinion, whether on X or even just down the pub. To anyone who wants their children to be taught facts, not harmful fictions at school. to anyone just trying to earn a living and not get crushed into the dirt by ever-growing taxes. Even if you don't yet realise that Britain needs reform, you know in your heart of hearts that our wonderful country is sick.
35:28Jon Sopel:How many of you at home have thought to yourselves that nothing works today? I know I have and I have a damn sight easier than most people.
35:41Lewis Goodall:So two things about that that strike me about what Zahawi was saying. Number one is it kind of illustrates what I was just trying to say about the dangers of having too many defectors who are very closely associated with the last conservative government, which is what did Zahawi open with there? So, you know, we're living in a country where you can't get a doctor's appointment. Well, whose fault is that? I mean, yes, his government have been in 18 months. Yes, progress on public services clearly isn't as fast as anyone would like, including them. But the reason, I mean, you know, when Labour left office in 2010, you could get a doctor's appointment relatively easily.
36:11Lewis Goodall:You know, public services are in a relatively great state. The reason that you can't get a doctor's appointment is because of 14 years of Conservative government. Now, you know, you can make an argument about all of the structural things that buffeted them along the way. But that is undoubtedly the case. Governments that Zahawi was part of oversaw that decline. That is unarguable. That's a problem for reform because it's an argument that can be placed upon them. And then secondly, you know, again, Zahari, who I think is, you know, I've always known as a reasonably kind of pragmatic conservative kind of figure.
36:40Lewis Goodall:Yes, I think definitely with some ideology on the right of the party, perhaps, but a reasonably kind of sensible, pragmatic kind of figure. There again, basking in the sort of boiling water of the radical right, sounding so fevered in so many ways. I mean, that allusion, as you say, John, to Britain being like a rack of his childhood, the sort of sectarian kind of the sectarian madness of a rack of that time of that sort of collapsing state. You know, this is this is Britain has got profound problems. Of course it has. But we were talking in the first half there exactly with that disconnect. There is the Britain of the fevered imaginations of the radical right, where sometimes there is a kernel of truth to a story, but it is exaggerated and becomes a dystopia with almost no intervening period whatsoever.
37:26Lewis Goodall:And Zahawi is now like, unfortunately, quite a bit of reform. The danger is, is that so much of the right in Britain now seems to be swimming in those seas. and that's bad for politics because it takes politics in frenzied, fevered directions but it's also, I would say, bad for reform and bad for the right of politics because they start to seem and sound eccentric, fringe and weird. So I think Zahawi's trajectory there is one that many on the right of British politics have gone on in recent years and it's sad to see.
37:53Jon Sopel:I think it's terrible when you get people who are just... I mean, does Nadim Zahawi really think this country is like the Iraq of Saudi? A police state. A police state, no. and you're just saying it to get a headline, to get some attention. And you just think it bears no relationship. And because it's the language of that part of politics now. Yeah. It bears no relation to reality. Can I just read you this from Nadeem Zahawi? Nigel Farage, no chance. Been a Conservative all my life and will die a Conservative.
38:24Lewis Goodall:How times have changed. Well, that was a tweet from Nadeem Zahawi, I think, when he was being asked if he would join UKIP. I mean, admittedly, it was 12 years ago, I think, but nonetheless. Another tweet from that time, And again, this is the problem with defections, right? Because you can just, people just dredge this up, particularly in a digital age. Zahawi tweeted in 2015, I'm not British born, Mr. Nigel Farage. I'm as British as you are. Your comments are offensive and racist. I will be frightened to live in a country run by you. And that's not just the change of party. Again, I think that speaks to the change in the centre right of British politics.
38:56Lewis Goodall:I've no doubt Zahawi didn't have much time for Farage's politics back in 2015. But he does in 2026 because Farage has been enormously influential in dragging the right of British politics toward him. And generally speaking, as well, the right of politics in the US, the UK has become far more radical. I'd say just one other thing as well. And you say, you know, we shouldn't forget Zahawi had to resign as Conservative Party chairman, as you say, because of his tax affairs and, you know, serious breach of the ministerial code. So that will come up as well. But although, you know, personally I have quite a bit of time for Zahawi, I said particularly when he was a Conservative minister, I always thought he was one of the decent ones.
39:32Lewis Goodall:I think from whatever party, defectors kind of, I don't know, I haven't got much time for defectors. I feel something for Baden-Ock on this. I can totally understand why she would be mega pissed off. And this would be for a Labour defector or Conservative defector. I think unless you have a very good reason, i.e. you've been driven out of your party in whatever way, you've been subject to particularly appalling treatment, whatever. If you're just leaving because you see which way the wind is blowing and you think you fancy it go at that. And Zahari was doing this thing. We hear Farage do this and others.
40:00Lewis Goodall:They do this whole kind of, I could have a great life in business. I could have this. You can. No one's forcing you to go back into politics. We all know the reason you're going back into politics is you like politics, which is fine, but don't pretend you're being dragged towards it. At the end of the day, the thing with defectors is, unless you are a truly stunning politician, which most of these defectors, if not all, never are, because by definition, or most of the fact that they're defecting, unless you're a stunning politician, The only reason anyone has ever heard of you is because of the party that you were part of.
40:29Lewis Goodall:They give you everything, right? He was Tory party chairman. He was a Stratford MP for, what, 15 years. You know, I always think it's so offensive to the activists who get no glory, get nothing, and they just traipse the streets, pound the pavement, stuff the letterboxes day after day to get you elected because they believe partly in you, but also they believe in the party banner that you're representing. And then you turn around and you go, actually, you know what? screw you, screw you, screw the party I can see that politics is moving in another direction and I'm going to join them you know, no one heard of you no one voted for you, the only reason anyone knows who you are is because of the rosette you wore and I just think it's offensive really.
41:09Lewis Goodall:We'll be back in just a moment
41:20Jon Sopel:The News Agents
41:22Lewis Goodall:Right, before we go, we've got very used to Americans on the MAGA right talking about the UK and talking about what an absolute hellscape the UK has become over the last year. So I think it's only right maybe for us to return the favour a little bit. And just in case you didn't think that the United States had been turning hard towards authoritarianism over the last year, then there's something that's happened over the weekend that just gives an extra little lift to that bit of analysis.
41:48Jon Sopel:It is extraordinary. What is happening is that the Justice Department has launched a criminal investigation to the chairman of the Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, Jay Powell. And it is equivalent to the prime minister saying, I am going to prosecute the governor of the Bank of England, not because of financial mismanagement, but because he didn't like the way the governor was doing an extension to the building of the Bank of England. And just have a listen to the way Jerome Powell has had to come out and more or less say, this is a politically motivated witch hunt by Donald Trump because I won't cut interest rates.
42:31Jon Sopel:Have a listen. On Friday, the Department of Justice served the Federal Reserve with grand jury subpoenas, threatening a criminal indictment related to my testimony before the Senate Banking Committee last June.
42:44Lewis Goodall:That testimony concerned, in part, a multi-year project to renovate historic Federal Reserve office buildings. I have deep respect for the rule of law and for accountability in our democracy. No one, certainly not the chair of the Federal Reserve, is above the law. But this unprecedented action should be seen in the broader context of the administration's threats and ongoing pressure. This new threat is not about my testimony last June or about the renovation of the Federal Reserve buildings. It is not about Congress's oversight role. The Fed, through testimony and other public disclosures, made every effort to keep Congress informed about the renovation project.
43:26Lewis Goodall:Those are pretexts. The threat of criminal charges is a consequence of the Federal Reserve setting interest rates based on our best assessment of what will serve the public, rather than following the preferences of the President. This is about whether the Fed will be able to continue to set interest rates based on evidence and economic conditions or whether instead monetary policy will be directed by political pressure or intimidation. I have served at the Federal Reserve under four administrations, Republicans and Democrats alike. In every case, I have carried out my duties without political fear or favor, focused solely on our mandate of price stability and maximum employment.
44:10Lewis Goodall:Public service sometimes requires standing firm in the face of threats. I will continue to do the job the Senate confirmed me to do with integrity and a commitment to serving the American people. That was an absolutely astounding intervention from Jay Powell, who published that video across social media channels. Chairman of the Federal Reserve does not do stuff like this. They are largely unseen. And just a way to think about this, as John was saying, the pretense here, Trump has claimed that he didn't know anything about it. But the pretense here is this is about, yeah, an extension to the building of the Federal Reserve.
44:42Lewis Goodall:The actual reason for this has got a long history. But basically, even though Jay Powell was appointed by Donald Trump in the first administration as the governor, basically Trump has been highly dissatisfied with Jay Powell and the Federal Reserve not reducing interest rates as rapidly as Trump believes that they should be decreased. As there has been in this country since 1997, there's been an even longer history in the United States of interest rate decisions being taken independently away from the federal government. Powell, to his credit, according to most analysts, you know, has resisted entirely political pressure from the White House.
45:16Lewis Goodall:He served under four different administrations, Republican and Democratic. And he has resisted political pressure and that has generated Trump's fury. And it is clear that this investigation against him is basically as a result of that unhappiness. And I'm sorry, it is textbook authoritarianism, really, is a textbook example of how democratic political institutions should not work and are starting to fail witch hunts. He loves that word witch hunt. This is clearly a witch hunt against someone that he does not like at the highest levels of the US government. As John said, it would be like the prime minister using the metropolitan police to go after the governor of the Bank of England because they didn't like an interest rate hike or the fact that an interest interest rates had not been cut.
45:59Lewis Goodall:It's mad. There will be more from some other health scape tomorrow. We'll see you then. Bye bye. Bye bye.
46:04Jon Sopel:This has been a Global Player original production.
From the publisher
Is the government about to stand up to Elon Musk? That now seems possible. Downing Street said today that they would support action from Ofcom - the media regulator - against his platforms if they deemed it necessary.
Ofcom has announced that it has launched an investigation into Musk's X platform over its AI tool Grok being used to create non-consensual sexualised images of women and children. Ministers have said they expect action within days.
After unveiling the lowest homicide figures in more than a decade, Jon and Lewis speak to Sir Sadiq Khan, the London Mayor - about how to confront the hard right claims that London is a 'hellhole', and what can be done about the misinformation on Musk's platforms.
Later, one-time Tory chancellor Nadhim Zahawi was unveiled today as the latest Reform defector. He's the biggest name to move over to Nigel Farage's party so far but, having pledged he would remain a Conservative for life, why has he done it?
