1. Podcasts
  2. The Next Level
  3. 1135: Secret: So Much Winning
The Next Level

13 Nov 2026 · 20m · 9 chapters

Episode artwork

1135: Secret: So Much Winning

In short

Post-election analysis of polling errors and Democratic wins (especially Scott Colom in Mississippi), plus political news (Delray Beach canceling St. Patrick’s and Pride parades under Florida’s DEI restrictions; Trump pulling J.D. Vance from Iran negotiations) and upcoming segments on Van Hollen vs. Schumer and an NVIDIA/Jensen Huang “honeypot” spy story.

Guests/backgrounds

Sarah Longwell, publisher of The Bulwark; hosts JVL and Longwell discuss forecasting/pundit accountability with references to Nate Silver and Cook Political Report.

Key claims

Polls missed due to fast-changing conditions, late-breaking developments, and model assumptions; Democrats won via turnout shifts (new voters, young voters, Black and Hispanic voters) and Republican rural turnout collapse. Mississippi was underestimated because polling was mixed and candidate-quality gap mattered.

Notable examples

Scott Colom winning Mississippi; Delray Beach canceling St. Patrick’s Day and Pride parades; Trump removing Vance from Iran talks.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:30

Conference Vibes in Denver

Discussion on the atmosphere and key figures at a Democratic conference.

“This is JVL here with my best friend, Sarah Longwell, publisher of The Bulwark.”
1:20

Scott Colum's Win in Mississippi

Hosts celebrate Scott Colum's victory and discuss its significance.

“And so I feel very comfortable calling myself a lib.”
2:20

Polling Errors and Forecasting

Exploration of polling inaccuracies and their implications for forecasts.

“And they want to make this distinction about how it's gotten so impossible to find reliable polling that there's now like a lot more.”
4:40

Understanding Voter Turnout Dynamics

Analysis of voter turnout trends and their effect on election outcomes.

“But they have noted that it was difficult for them to raise money because their rating kept them like they are.”
6:40

Diverse Candidate Strategies

Discussion on the need for varied candidate approaches to win elections.

“Um, the reason I was bullish on Mississippi was because, uh, the polling was so mixed that nobody had any idea there.”
9:20

Delray Beach Parade Controversy

Hosts discuss the cancellation of the St. Patrick's Day parade due to new laws.

“Like, they ran pretty conservative campaigns in their states.”
14:01

Florida's DEI Law Controversy

Discussion on the implications of Florida's DEI law and its cancellation of events.

“Doesn't the mayor of Del Rey know that the DEI law is only supposed to apply to black people and gays?”
15:07

Trump's Influence on J.D. Vance

Exploration of J.D. Vance's recent political maneuvers and Trump's reactions.

“Vance has been pulled off of the Iran negotiations by Donald Trump.”
18:55

Upcoming Topics and Personal News

Teasing future discussions about Chuck Schumer and NVIDIA while sharing personal updates.

“I think he has changed his mind about J.D.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Next Level, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00All right, all right, turn it up. This next track by Crown Royal, it's got a way of getting everybody together. So grab your people, grab a glass, and play this one loud. You got gold. So bring it, bring it, bring it. I said you got gold. So just bring it, bring it, bring it in. Give me more, baby. This track is brought to you by Crown Royal. Please drink responsibly. I said you got gold. So just bring it, bring it in. Hello, everyone. This is JVL here with my best friend, Sarah Longwell, publisher of The Bulwark. Sarah, happy Friday. You are coming to us from a few time zones away in lovely, sunny Denver, the Sunshine State.

0:45Sarah Longwell: I'm in Denver for this, you know, majority Dems big conference. It's actually huge, you know. Vibes are good. A lot of the 2028ers are here. I'm seeing some of my faves, so it's good. I did I gave a speech yesterday where I said that my haters in my book. No, my haters are using against me. No, because I said I was like, I'm a lib now. And, you know, this is like where the base angry baseball man or whatever. So see, see their libs. But, you know, little do they know that I've always been somebody who believes in liberal democracy. And I'm a classical liberal. And so I feel very comfortable calling myself a lib.

1:28Whatever. Those fucking people. Okay. We have a tight show. We're going to rock through. We have some very good stuff. I want to begin with Scott Colum. Colum? Colum? Colum? Like cologne.

1:44Sarah Longwell: I saw him do a really cute video with his dad where they teach you to pronounce his name. Okay. Well, the thing is, I used to say that until somebody did a, like, here's the phonetic pronunciation. and having been told that they're like, I need to remember a phonetic pronunciation of it has gotten into my head. And so every time I want to say Cologne, I think, oh no, that's wrong. I, eh. Anyway. I don't know. I just watched it yesterday. Cologne as in Cologne. He is the winner in Mississippi. Hell yeah. And I got to tell you, I get as much patriotic joy out of that as I did anything else. Yeah.

2:24uh just a black guy becoming a senator from the state of mississippi

2:29Sarah Longwell: fuck yeah have you seen the the the as the results were coming in they're like scott colomb has won jefferson davis county yeah it's like wait well what and like forest right there's the mate there's the nathan bedford forest county you know the guy anyway it's a it's just it's a great moment for america i'm glad that that filled you with patriotism because we've been hard it's been hard to get you you know really into your like i'm happy about all this phase i do think we haven't talked about and we should um it's a it's been kind of in the air here and i talked about it somewhat with nate silver but the fact that they the the polling was really wrong have you not to not to give myself away but have you written anything yet about the big polling this uh no i haven't we uh we had a piece on the bulwark.com about that from laksha laksha jane oh laksha he's here and he told me he just wrote something for us but i haven't seen it again i'm on the road rules here but part of what's interesting is that the polls really did miss in the democrats direction and one of the things that um in a lot of these polling conversations that i'm hearing is people are saying like yeah i'm not really a post pollster anymore.

3:48Sarah Longwell: I'm a forecaster. And they want to make this distinction about how it's gotten so impossible to find reliable polling that there's now like a lot more. I'm making these assumptions and these assumptions. And then, of course, people are then aggregating, you know, polls and forecasts into other forecasts. And you're trying to come up with something. Yeah, that's right. There's a lot of modeling and this is what Nate Silver does. And you do end up like – and then the Cook Political Report, right? And then the other people then who do the ratings, sort of everybody lives in the same ecosystem. And so they sort of all miss together a little bit.

4:31Sarah Longwell: People are less mad at this time because it went in the Democrats' direction, I think. But the people who are upset are people like Scott Cologne and Annie Andrews, although I don't know about – I shouldn't say upset. I don't want to speak for them. But they have noted that it was difficult for them to raise money because their rating kept them like they are. And people like us then who sort of look at this world, too, like we started paying attention to the Mississippi race and you were you were potentially there on it. Like you I think you thought for whatever reason and maybe you can even explain why you thought this because you said, well, I just trusted the polling.

5:16Sarah Longwell: But even the polling wasn't as bullish as you and Bill. Yes. So, OK, I mean, there's a lot to unpack here. I'm going to try to move through quickly on the polling error. I think you have to understand that just by definition, the bigger a swing there is from one election to the next, the bigger the error is going to have to be. Right. I mean, because all of every set of polls is built on an assumption, assumptions made about the way the world worked two years ago. right or four years ago and when the world is shifting really fast like the models are gonna you know the models which by which i mean like the way the upholsters decide they're gonna wait for groups and understand what turnout is gonna be and stuff like it when it becomes hard you know like from 2000 to 2000 uh or from 1998 to 2000 right like there's just not a lot happening in the world.

6:22Things are basically the same from every two years to the next. This was a big, this was a big change. Um, also it does seem to me that a lot of stuff was breaking late. And so the polls are just behind by like a week, you know, like if, if the, if polls had another seven days to capture the result, I think they probably would have gotten there. Um, the reason I was bullish on Mississippi was because, uh, the polling was so mixed that nobody had any idea there. There was also polling showing, uh, Louisiana, very, very close. The candidate quality difference in Mississippi was obvious and enormous.

7:06And my thesis was we have a big wave happening. It's happening everywhere. It's especially happening with African-American voters. And the polls are just behind here by like a week. And so that's why I thought Mississippi was better than a coin toss.

7:26Sarah Longwell: Yeah. I mean, part of what was interesting to me is that it's funny when you sort of do the, OK, let's do our pundit accountability. What were we saying the whole time? What turned out to be true is that my thesis held up great. Like there was a massive drop off in rural voters and then big and also some swing, maybe more swing than I thought, too. Like there was actually Democrats just did better. But it was a collapse in turnout among Republicans sort of across the board because depressed voters, which is what we heard in these focus groups all the time, lead to depressed turnout. But for I mean, I just I guess The only reason I'm going into all this is I want people to understand how hard I think it was for people to see something like Mississippi coming or South Carolina, because it had to defy so many of the fundamentals that people are working on in the forecasting.

8:24Sarah Longwell: And it did like the total drop off, plus the big break among independents, plus the like level of persuasion among Republicans, and then the massive turnout from Democrats of new voters, young voters, black voters, Hispanic voters. Like that's what did the trick all over the place. and I do think Democrats too it's funny they're sort of just waking they're very excited about Scott Cologne winning but they're also being like his race was like totally unknown to them so they're all looking at him saying oh he's not he's sort of a like he's just like in Kansas you've got candidates who are personally pro-life and they They speak with warmth about trans, you know, people's humanity and, you know, but they also, they didn't, they were sort of, they were against the sports issue.

9:26Sarah Longwell: Like, they ran pretty conservative campaigns in their states. And so I... Because they fit their states. Because they fit their states. But this is I do think as we as we as people process the victory, they're going to sort of retroactively look back and be like, whoa, we put up some really different candidates than Democrats done a long time. And so sometimes this like debate about like more moderate, more progressive, it really does fall apart in the wake of saying, if you're going to win in Kansas, you're going to win in Mississippi, you're going to win in South Carolina, which is funny because Annie Andrews ran a campaign that was sort of different than who she is online.

10:09Sarah Longwell: Like the Republicans are just now discovering what an intense poster she is. And she's like a really funny, like resist kind of person. But like for Democrats to win everywhere and expand the map, they had to do like a ton of different things. And it's actually really lovely to look back at now and examine what everybody did. Yeah. And I want to ask you this, and I don't want to dwell too much on it, but I'm curious what your thoughts are. My tentative view is that if the Mississippi race had gotten a ton of attention. 10 weeks out, Republicans would have panicked and thrown money into it. And he only won by, what, 3 ,000 votes?

10:50Sarah Longwell: Yeah. I mean, he was probably helped by relying on the pure candidate skills gap and not having money become a more determinative factor in the race. All right, all right, turn it up. This next track by Crown Royal, it's got a way of getting everybody together. So grab your people, grab a glass and play this one loud.

11:26This track is brought to you by Crown Royal. Please drink responsibly.

11:35Sarah Longwell: Yeah, or even, you know, they weren't like sending, you know, their big surrogates out there. She was totally unseen. And I said this on TNL. I was like, I know that they're right now. Some of these candidates are saying, like, it was frustrating to not be able to raise money because of the Cook ratings and where the polls sat. And I was like, I think that's probably best case scenario is that nobody was on to you guys until it was too late for them to do a whole lot about it. They were Misunderestimated Okay I want to Just bring a news item to you That I love I saw today This morning actually Delray Beach, Florida The city has announced That it is canceling Its annual St.

12:24Patrick's Day Parade Why? You ask? Because of an anti-DEA law Signed by Ron DeSantis Which takes place On January 1st, 2020 I'm going to read from the city of Del Rey's website. DEA? The new state law. DEI. Oh, DEI. That's okay. DEI. Yeah. The new state law, which impacts all Florida cities and takes effect January 1st, 2027, establishes restrictions on municipal funding, sponsorship, promotion, and official actions involving activities defined under the legislation as diversity, equity, and inclusion. The law includes restrictions on certain programming activities designed or implemented with reference to race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, or gender identity.

13:11It also voids existing local ordinances. The city is determined that it is legally prohibited from organizing, funding, sponsoring, promoting, or marketing the St. Patrick's Day Parade. And they emphasize this is not a budgetary decision. and they say, look, the Florida law has exemptions for federal holidays, but St. Patrick's Day is not a federal holiday. I'm sorry. And also the law in Florida makes this. This is great. Any county or municipal official who violates the law while acting in an official capacity may be subject to allegations of malfeasance and face potential civil and other legal penalties.

13:55So they're like, basically, I ain't going to go to law for your St. Patrick's Day parade. I'm sorry. And the people of Florida are outraged, Sarah. Doesn't the mayor of Del Rey know that the DEI law is only supposed to apply to black people and gays? It's not supposed to apply to Irish.

14:18Sarah Longwell: I have a question. Is this them making a point? like are they what is i i because i don't know the story is are they are they trying to make a broader point or are they genuinely canceling it because it falls under dei rules no they they the announcement is they've canceled both this and the pride parade so del rey has historically had like a big i a bigst patrick's day parade a big pride parade and they're just saying right now like look we just finished legal review and we can't do this oh my god get sued because i'm the you know, the town manager, I mean, I, you know, open myself up to this.

14:56Screw it.

14:56Sarah Longwell: But I wonder if they're the only ones or if other people will do it, too. Fingers crossed. OK, J.D. Vance has been pulled off of the Iran negotiations by Donald Trump. Oh, this I did see. This is delicious. What do you think? So is that good for J.D. or bad for J.D.? I mean, I read this as they are fraying. Their relationship on this is fraying somewhat. And I thought it was Trump putting him in the penalty box. He was like, because J.D. Vance is going to root out corruption in our blue cities because Democrats have corruption in their blood. And I was like, this is oh, oh, OK, we're going to change the narrative from you being corrupt to Democrats being corrupt.

15:52Sarah Longwell: OK, good try. And then he was and it was actually a weird tweet because then he immediately was like, and we're we're not negotiating with Iran. We don't even need a deal with Iran. We don't need a deal. This is let me make a bigger point, because the specifics of this trying to actually analyze this is for crazy people. Like, I don't know what's going on here. As a broader matter, Trump really is even like the context of that tweet seemed like two separate tweets stuck together accidentally. He is not doing great mentally. If you've seen him in things, he is super scattered. I think that the election has genuinely rattled him.

16:38Sarah Longwell: I do think people who are doing analysis, including you, right, we're sort of trying to decide, OK, OK, does he correct his behavior in light of this wipeout or does he double down on it? And I know that the putting Miller in there and some of his other moves sort of seem to signal that he is going to double down on things. But then he's like weirdly conciliatory in other places. I saw him out there doing a big like kind of love up of Scott Cologne, kind of giving him that Mom Donnie treatment. And I just I don't think it's clear which way he'll go because he is increasingly just an old man doing old man erratic stuff.

17:26Sarah Longwell: This thing about and it's this is where the scary part is. The scary part to me about Trump is no longer is he going to try and stay in 2028? Like, how is he going to try to, you know, impact the 2028 elections? and much more around a guy who is increasingly losing his marbles is not tethered by anybody like Susie Wiles leaving Susie Wiles was a corrupt craven horrible individual she was also one of the most normal people in that administration and so like Stephen Miller we are looking at kind of wheels off and how much Trump like if you're Stephen Miller what are you doing with Trump you're probably being like here sir would you like to focus on your ballroom we're gonna get Get your arch going like they will treat him like a toddler.

18:11Sarah Longwell: And Stephen Miller could basically be doing what he wants. Anyway, that's my overall read on Trump. But my also I just think J.D. Vance did a disloyal thing. Trump kind of rolled with it and now seems to be like increasingly annoyed by it and trying to and maybe people are in his ear saying J.D.'s coming for you. Like maybe he read your triad about the Tucker Don Jr. And so Trump's starting to feel like people are coming for him and getting uneasy. And so how he lashes out under these new pressures with his, I think, diminishing brain remains to be seen. But it read to me like penalty box. What did you think?

18:55Hard to say. I mean, he certainly has. I think he has changed his mind about J.D. and I think it is meant to be penalty box, but maybe it's good for JD, right? I mean, if the answer is he's trying to prove his bona fides to the real America voice, you know, America firsters, having Trump be mad at him for saying the truth out loud might help. I don't know.

19:24Sarah Longwell: I could see it. I could see him saying to himself, and also I could see him saying to Trump, you don't want me to do the Iran stuff. Like, I don't agree with you. I won't be helpful to you. Like, put me somewhere I can be helpful, like on the corruption. Maybe. Okay. We are going to talk about the Chris Van Hollen versus Chuck Schumer throwdown, which is like the saddest little throwdown ever. And we're going to talk about NVIDIA and the Jensen Wong honeypot sex trap spy story. I have so many thoughts on this, and I want to talk about them all with you. Okay, I can't wait. But on the other side.

20:07Also, I have life news. I have life news to share with you, but we're going to do it on the other side. Okay. Guys, come and join. Become members. Join Bulwark Plus. We want to have you. Right? We do.

20:20Sarah Longwell: Tell the people. Come protect liberal democracy with us. Be a lib with us. And we're going to have a good time. There's a lot that's going to happen in the next two years. And you're going to want to be with us through it all. And you know what? Some of it will be good. I'm now convinced that some of the things that happen over the next two years will be good. Maybe not most of it, but some of it.

From the publisher

Full episodes of The Secret Podcast are available exclusively to paid members of the Bulwark on YouTube, Substack and Apple Podcasts.

Full episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/L6efft3OFNc

Full episode on Substack: https://www.thebulwark.com/p/so-much-winning

---

Sarah and JVL talk about:

- Scott Colom’s inspiring victory.
- Did the polling miss hurt, or help, Democrats?
- An anti-DEI law in Florida targets the wrong people.
- Chuck Schumer vs. Chris Van Hollen
- JD Vance has Iran taken away from him.
- Is Nutlick licked?

Plus, JVL has a very special announcement . . .

More from The Next Level

All episodes