

The hosts discuss capitalism’s future under AI and winner-take-all dynamics, then pivot to criticism of Donald Trump’s foreign policy—especially his meetings with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin—and related U.S. priorities.
None.
Sarah Longwell (publisher of The Bulwark) and JVL (host; not described beyond being a co-host).
AI and digital economies can reduce the need for educated workers, severing civic ties and worsening upward mobility; wealth concentration should be analyzed through antitrust/anti-monopoly. On Ukraine, Russia is the aggressor and should be treated as the moral/strategic starting point; Trump is portrayed as siding with “bad guys” (autocrats) and undermining NATO/Europe.
Anthropic’s IPO valuing employees/founders above the bottom third of U.S. households; Trump calling into the Berlin “Coalition of the Willing” while meeting Putin; Elbridge Colby urging Europe to buy American weapons and criticizing Ukraine striking Russian interior; Jimmy Lai’s imprisonment in solitary confinement in China; U.S. detention of people for relatives’ political actions; House Democrats avoiding a shutdown fight over Iran-war funding via a continuing resolution.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hosts discuss an upcoming event for founders and best friends.
“Uh, and we sort of just lay out roadmap for where we are, what we're doing.”
Hosts talk about an article related to them in the Bulwark.
“It's another one of those amazing things about the bulwark where a guy writing about us doesn't even know that there is.”
JVL shares details about a pinball machine he is working on.
“We're going to be a pinball family, too, because JBL can't have an obsession that I don't participate in.”
Discussion on capitalism, regulation, and income inequality.
“Capitalism is a better system than all the others.”
Exploration of how AI affects job markets and wealth distribution.
“Like they're directly related to each other.”
Hosts analyze Trump’s recent meetings with dictators and their implications.
“OK, Donald Trump went to China, met with his two favorite dictators.”
Discussion on moral and strategic considerations regarding the Ukraine conflict.
“I think we all understand how preposterous and absurd this is.”
Understanding the dynamics of disputes, particularly in the context of Russia and Ukraine.
“And if it doesn't, you're missing the fundamental shift that is happening in America right now and why this president is so dangerous and why it's sort of not close between the two sides.”
Examining the implications of aggression in international conflicts and the moral responsibilities involved.
“So not only is that wrong, I think, as a strategic matter, but as a moral matter, Russia started it.”
Discussing the story of Jimmy Lai and the implications of his imprisonment in Hong Kong.
“Well, I was at an event this week, a democracy event.”
Analyzing Trump's alliances with authoritarian leaders and the impact on democracy.
“Trump has decided to ally with people who commit.”
A look at the upcoming government shutdown and its implications, particularly regarding the Iran war funding.
“So you're in a detention camp now in the United States.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Next Level, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Sarah Long: Hello, everyone. This is JVL here with my best friend, Sarah Longwell, publisher of The Bulwark. Sarah, my guy, Friday.
0:09JVL: Happy Friday to you.
0:12Sarah Long: So what a week. What a week. We kind of got a big show. We got a lot to talk about. A quick heads up housekeeping. We are doing an event for our founders and best friends. It's on Wednesday, December 9th. It's going to be in the evening in the East. That's, that's the couple of times a year we get together with just the founders and best friends, people who are the ones who decide they want to pay extra so that we can give away all the free subscriptions we give to people who can, who can't swing them. Um, we love those, those folks. They're the best. Uh, and we sort of just lay out roadmap for where we are, what we're doing.
0:50Sarah Long: Um, what's coming next. We'll email you guys details about this. Sit tight. Just wanted Just put it on your radar. Maybe put a little note on your calendar, December 9th. And if you want to become a founder, if you'd like to help us, help everybody else so that nobody gets left behind, we'd love to have you. We'd love to have you. Okay. Also, we're going to talk about the puck piece about you and the bulwark. I don't exist in the bulwark. It's another one of those amazing things about the bulwark where a guy writing about us doesn't even know that there is. What's a JVL?
1:27JVL: That's not true that he doesn't know who you are.
1:30Sarah Long: 100 % true. No. He doesn't know who I am.
1:34JVL: What do you care? That was a profoundly dumb, why won't Sarah Longwell sell the bulwark? It's like a preposterous premise.
1:43Sarah Long: Exactly. What do I care? I don't care. Whatever you do, don't put in the paper that I was mad. I would like to take a brief moment before we get going for two things, both pertaining to you. The first is I'm going to shift my camera to show people what's that. That is the Deadpool premium pinball machine, which is going to your house quite soon, I think.
2:11JVL: It's coming my way. We're going to be a pinball family, too, because JBL can't have an obsession that I don't participate in.
2:17Sarah Long: the play field is up and removed because i am doing a bunch of maintenance on it to get it absolutely perfectly dialed in i'm installing flipper fans for you i have replaced the flipper rebuilds i've done that i've always wanted flipper fans uh well you know there's a reason why you would need flipper fans i will not bore you guys with that in this podcast and i'm also cleaning and waxing the playfield so that it is silky smooth and buttery to play. I mean, it's going to be great.
2:51JVL: Sounds incredible.
2:52Sarah Long: I'm so excited for this. Okay, that's the first thing. The second thing is I want in my continuing quest to make you grapple with capitalism. Again, one and a half cheers for capitalism as far as I'm concerned. Capitalism is a better system than all the others. I just think we need to fence it in a little bit and regulate it a little bit to try to avoid some of the excesses of capitalism.
3:21JVL: Well, we could also just prosecute people who are nakedly corrupt and doing crony capitalism and some form of corporate socialism.
3:29Sarah Long: That's a little different than what I was going to talk about. So the Anthropic IPO was yesterday. And this from Steve Ratner this morning, as we were taping on Friday morning. Anthropik's 5 ,300 founders and employees are now worth more than the bottom third of U.S. households, 45 million families. I mean, I guess that's fine.
3:49JVL: No, you know, it doesn't seem fine to me, though. It is not fine. And one of the things that I've talked about a lot during some of this discourse, right, where people are like, how can you know discourse talk? No, no, no. But just just really quickly. I am a capitalist, but I'm also an anti monopolist. And I'm also because I don't think that monopolies are good for capitalism. I believe competition is good for capitalism. That is sort of part of its essence. The thing that talking to voters I think has changed in me is how focused I am on income inequality. And and not I and I used to sort of be like income inequality, like there's always going to be income inequality.
4:39JVL: But like many, it's one thing for it's not that I'm saying everyone needs to have equal income. It is that the extent to which it has gotten out of whack to the point where the people who are getting all of the money are doing it actively at the expense of whether or not people on the lower part of the income scale can even have jobs. Like they're directly related to each other. it used to be, or I think that the way that I would think about capitalism in a lot of ways is I don't mind there being corporate or titans of industry when that industry is there to then support an enormous number of workers, right?
5:19JVL: That is the good capitalism. And it also creates an environment in which those titans of industry want to have a good public education. They want to have good roads. They want to have all these good things that help them then have good employees for their corporations to grow and thrive. The internet started to change that. A lot of winner-take-all stuff when you move to a digital economy. That's right. The digital economy changed it then, and especially now in terms of AI. It's not just that the people who are at the very top are going to get rich, extraordinarily rich beyond all imagination, while the ability for people to have upward mobility who are not in that very elite class becomes harder and harder.
6:04JVL: But also their interest in having an educated population that can come do the work becomes increasingly unnecessary. Right. They don't they don't need a an enormous workforce that is highly educated. That's right. Because they got the robots. And so I'm not sure this is as much a question of capitalism qua capitalism as it is a massive question around what an economy looks like when an enormous number of jobs, simply the need for them evaporates. And also the need from the people at the very top, they no longer require people at the bottom, which sort of severs the civic connection between the two.
6:53Sarah Long: No, I think all that is well said. And there is also a part of the wealth inequality conversation is the concentration of wealth with a smaller and smaller slice at the very top and the scale of the wealth. Again, Elon Musk on some days is worth a trillion dollars. In the same way the government has an interest in not letting any one company get too big because it becomes anti-competitive and it has the ability to then do anti-competitive behavior. I think the government has an interest in not letting any one individual amass so much economic power because it gives them the ability to do anti-competitive stuff.
7:38Sarah Long: So, again, I like to think of the wealth inequality stuff really through the lens of antitrust. And that's just me. OK, Donald Trump went to China, met with his two favorite dictators. Do you want to talk first about this? Because I am I feel like this is a new low for America. and I want to just give you two things that happened and then let you cook. On the flight home, so he meets with Xi and Putin, he gets on the plane and there were two sets of meetings happening elsewhere this week in Europe. There was the Coalition of the Willing meeting. It's about 34 nations who are all supporting Ukraine in Berlin.
8:29Sarah Long: And then there were a series of NATO meetings in Brussels. on the ride home from the air, Trump decides he's going to call into a meeting at the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin, like it's Fox and Friends, you know, and I'll just read to you from Politico. In a call from Air Force One on his way home from meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin, Trump lamented what he characterized as the waste of billions to provide Ukraine with weapons and cash for a conflict that is killing so many people, according to three of the European officials who were granted anonymity to describe a private meeting.
9:09Sarah Long: Hours after concluding his encounters with the Russian leader and Chinese president Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, Trump had one message for the leaders gathered in Berlin. Putin is serious about negotiating a peace deal with Ukraine. So the president meets with the guy who invaded his neighbor and has been targeting civilians on a daily basis, who has kidnapped upwards of 20 ,000 Ukrainian children. And the president of the United States doesn't tell Putin, stop your war. He listens to Putin's framing, and then he calls the Europeans and the Ukrainians and says, stop your war.
9:49JVL: Yes.
9:50Sarah Long: So that is thing one. Thing two is that at the NATO meetings this week in Brussels, we sent Elbridge Colby, who's a real human being. That's a real name of a real person. And he. At one of the meetings, which was supposed to be a classified briefing from the Ukrainian defense minister. But you know how these things are. Like everybody gives their own prepared statements first and then the media. Anyway, Elbridge Colby started out by telling the Europeans that it is unacceptable that they are trying to freeze out American defense contractors as they rearm and that they need to be buying American weapons.
10:36Sarah Long: He's like, we're not going to defend you fuckers anymore. And so the Europeans start their own defense industrial complex. And he's like, hey, wait a minute. We want your money, though. So make sure you buy American. He then, at this meeting, made a statement in which he said that it was bad that Ukraine was striking Russian assets in the Russian interior and that they should stop it. Sure. And after his statement, he got up and left the meeting. He didn't stay to listen to what anybody else had to say. He didn't stay to. So. Again, I think this is very, very, very bad and maybe a new low in American history.
11:22Sarah Long: You know, we're on the side of Russia.
11:24JVL: Yeah. And I've got a couple of things to say. I don't need to cook too long. You've set it up well. I think we all understand how preposterous and absurd this is. But one of them is from a body language standpoint, I watched Trump walk in and greet Putin. He puts this big, cheesy smile on his face like he is meeting his favorite baseball star from when he was a kid. And he says, look, it's my friend. And he walks in and just gives Putin. Putin, he poisons people and has them thrown out of windows. He oppresses free speech. He rigs elections. And he's a murderer, right? I mean, horribly corrupt, pays off all of his, the people at the top and suppresses people at the bottom.
12:21JVL: And Trump adores him. And again, I just sort of go back to the idea of something that is important, not in the like when you tease it all out or whatever, like big picture important is who are the bad guys? What makes somebody a bad guy?
12:44Sarah Long: We know who the bad guys are.
12:45JVL: We know who the bad guys are. The bad guys are the ones who don't hold free and fair elections. You know, Garry Kasparov wrote a very nice piece saying that a little discourse dispute. He was taking my side in it. And part of it was because he talked about how important it was when you had autocrats that you build a coalition of left, right and center. And that's what they did in Hungary to defeat Orban. They've done in Brazil. That's what they did to fight Putin. um navalny when he rose up to fight putin he did a lot of it uh was really focused on the corruption around putin this is trump's favorite guy and um and i think that that is that posture his emotional support for putin the way that he is likes him that way respects him that way That's the part that just sucks the soul out of what America is, who we are, who we're supposed to be, what we're founded in.
13:46JVL: And that's always an important point of why we rejected Trump in the first place and why there's not really a balls and strikes side of this. There is a, hey, we've got an American president siding with the bad guys. And so your analysis sort of has to start there. And if it doesn't, you're missing the fundamental shift that is happening in America right now and why this president is so dangerous and why it's sort of not close between the two sides. So that's part one. The other part is in any dispute. One should always take into account who started the dispute. And when you're thinking about Russia and Ukraine as one dispute, you don't get to have the moral authority or the strategic authority.
14:39JVL: Like Trump is sort of saying, like, well, you know, you got to side with Russia because Ukraine can't win. So not only is that wrong, I think, as a strategic matter, but as a moral matter, Russia started it. Russia invaded Ukraine. Ukraine was minding its business being a burgeoning democracy, trying to get better at being a democracy. And Vladimir Putin said, I don't like that Ukraine is out there as an independent democracy. We're going to go start taking their country. the aggressor is the bad guy.
15:20Sarah Long: They could just leave.
15:22JVL: They could stop this right now.
15:24Sarah Long: If you want a deal. They could stop. They can unilaterally make a deal by leaving.
15:29JVL: So again, I say in any conflict, when somebody is more or less just doing their thing and minding their business and you come for them, the response doesn't get to be criticized as though, because the response is what happens when the person agitates the conflict in the first place. And there's a lot of people out there in a lot of different contexts who might want to criticize people for responding when somebody else is beginning the conflict.
16:00Sarah Long: It's really something. I mean, I think this is worse than Helsinki. And Helsinki in 2018, at least that was just Trump taking the side against like the American intelligence community. Like he was taking sides against a branch of his own government or a division of his own government, not a branch. And this, he's taking sides against NATO, who we have a formal alliance with, the European Union, who are our trading partners. And he's just on, he goes to meet Putin and listen to what Putin says. And then he just acts as the go-between where he's on Putin's side.
16:44JVL: Can I, sorry, I've got one last thing here, which is I was at something.
16:47Sarah Long: Because I'm kind of broken by this. I don't even have like insights.
16:51JVL: Well, I was at an event this week, a democracy event. And do you know the story of Jimmy Lai? Mm-hmm. Okay, so his son was there and his son spoke on behalf of his father. So Jimmy Lai was a - He's still in jail, right? He's still imprisoned in Hong Kong.
17:14Sarah Long: Apple News.
17:15JVL: Apple News. So he was he was a guy who made a bunch of money in the private sector, but he got to come to Hong Kong, made a life for himself, made a lot of money and then started a newspaper to push for a pro-democracy movement in China. over time his pro-democracy movement got so big that the chinese government took him and put him in solitary confinement he has spent six years in solitary confinement in a chinese prison where he is not they and they the son was telling the story of they even took the people who were in the cell above him to the sides of him and below him away so he can't hear anything he can't see light.
18:03JVL: He gets he gets 30 minutes by himself in the yard and they've got the yard covered. So he can't see sunlight for the time that he's getting his exercise. That is what China does to people who push for pro-democracy. OK, he is still in jail. His son's not allowed to go back and visit him in Hong Kong because his son is wanted by the Chinese government for being his son and speaking out on his father's behalf. That is who Xi is. Trump has decided to ally with people who commit. And I mean, Jimmy Lai is just trying to be a leader in the pro-democracy movement because he's pushing back against Xi's authoritarian regime, which, by the way, continues to subjugate people, put them in work camps, concentration camps.
18:58JVL: And America's not supposed to ignore this stuff. We're supposed to be on the side of the democracy people. Now, one thing I will just say, because he said this, that Trump has said, you know, hey, you should let Jimmy lie out to Xi. Do you know what Xi's done? Jack squat. You know why? Because Trump's not actually a particularly good advocate for the pro-democracy side of things. No one actually has to pay attention to him. So I just want to say Trump, and this is where I do get a little like, the conservative movement wants to have discourse about me being like, I'm a lib, you know, making kind of a crack on stage.
19:39JVL: That's what they really want to devote themselves to instead of, and it's because there's this like narcissistic focus that they have on their own, like chin stroking, you know, factionalism versus the clearest example yet that Donald Trump has put America in league with the worst dictators in the world. To me, again, this is about people not having their priorities straight.
20:07Sarah Long: We also now are a country that imprisons people for who they're related to. This is one of the immigration cases that Tim has been on is, I'm sorry, Secret Pod Rules. I don't remember the names, but it's the person whose grandmother was like part of the Iranian revolution. And so they were like, well, you know, your grandmother was part of the Iranian revolution against the Shah. So you're in a detention camp now in the United States.
20:34JVL: Or and like, obviously, obviously, we're not so far gone as China, but we do do things like Maureen Comey. gets fired from her job because they keep trying to politically prosecute her father. Like, that's the country we are right now. That's the thing to get exercised about. That's the thing we should be focused on. You guys want to have some stupid internecine conversation about conservatism? How about you go prove that you care about any of this stuff and take it seriously and focus on that?
21:02Sarah Long: OK, the other stuff happening. This is great. So we had a report from Axios that the Democrats in the House, because we have a funding, a government funding shutdown fight coming first week of December, I think, maybe second week of December. Again, secret pod rules. It's early in the morning, guys. And House Democrats want no part of having a shutdown fight over funding for the Iran war. So the Trump administration is going to put funding for the Iran war into this bill. the continuing resolution. And the House Democrats are like, fuck, we're just going to vote for it. We're going to talk about that on the other side.
21:46Sarah Long: And I'm sure it'll be a really happy, productive conversation. And we'll really get into the nuances of this and try to understand where their heads are at. And, you know, and maybe there's a long game. And maybe there's real strategery happening there. But you'll have to be on the other side. I think there probably is. All right. Come. Join Bulwark Plus.
22:07JVL: Join Bulwark Plus. We know who the bad guys are. We'll be clear-eyed about things. We'll tell you the truth about stuff. You should come rock with us.
Full episodes of the Secret Podcast are available exclusively for paid members of The Bulwark. You can join on Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and Substack.
---
Sarah and JVL talk pinball, income inequality, Trump’s three-way with Putin and Xi, House Democrats’ reluctance to fight funding for the Iran war, Elon Musk pretending he doesn’t know what MAGA means, and Thanksgiving traditions.
And the big one: Why The Bulwark isn’t for sale.