

The Opportunist episode “Mitchell Gaff: The Gum Gambit” follows how Everett, Washington investigators solved decades-old murders by combining early forensic foresight, later DNA technology (CODIS, STRmix), and a 2024 undercover “gum ruse” to collect DNA from Mitchell Gaff (later legally Sam Wise Price).
No guests appear as interview subjects in the transcript. Named voices are Detective Susan Logothetti (Everett Police Department cold cases) and CNN reporter Nina Giraldo.
Judy Weaver’s 1984 murder was linked to Gaff via preserved evidence (including vaginal swabs) and later STRmix/CODIS hits; gum provided the confirmatory DNA sample for arrest. Gaff was also tied to Susan Vasey (1980) and earlier attacks including Jacqueline O’Brien (1979) and two teenage sisters (1984).
Judy Weaver’s unlocked-door attack; sisters’ 1984 assault with a matching M.O.; Jacqueline O’Brien’s 1979 lawn attack; gum-based DNA collection in January 2024; Gaff pled guilty in April 2026 and received 50 years to life.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploration of Judy Weaver's murder and the initial investigation.
“In this episode, we examine the story of Mitchell Gaff, a killer whose crimes were unearthed from the cold cases by a creative detective and a stick of gum.”
Overview of the cold case period and the challenges faced by detectives.
“And while DNA evidence was not a powerful forensic tool at the time, they still had the foresight to collect vaginal swaps.”
Details of the brutal attack on two teenage sisters by the same assailant.
“In August of 1984, Everett police were called to the scene of a brutal attack on two teenage girls.”
Background on Mitchell Gaff and his previous crimes against women.
“Five years earlier, Jacqueline, who was a Washington State parole officer, was mowing her lawn when she had the misfortune of encountering Gaff.”
Explanation of how CODIS helped link Gaff to previous crimes.
“In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Mitchell Gaff was on a rampage.”
Learn about the advancements in DNA technology that solved cold cases.
“Samples are rarely whole, or without contamination, or in large quantities.”
Follow the investigation that led to Mitchell Gaff's arrest for two murders.
“DNA evidence that had been collected in 1984 is now opening up leads for a cold case in 2020.”
Learn about the shocking discovery that linked Mitchell Gaff to multiple murders.
“And, and we had, we had developed a good report.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Opportunist, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00The best holiday finds aren't always the ones you went looking for. At Ross, discover unexpected gifts, fashion, decor, and plenty of reasons to keep looking. Ross. Expect the unexpected.
0:19It was around midnight after the Fisherman's Festival in Everett, Washington in June of 1984. A man walked down the street of a residential neighborhood and stopped dead in his tracks. Was that smoke? A thick, dark cloud billowed from an apartment's bedroom window. He ran across the street to a neighbor's house to call 911. With the fire trucks on their way, the two of them raced back to the burning building, banging on doors to wake the residents and warn them of the fire. No one stirred in the burning room. When firefighters entered the building apartment through an unlocked back door, they encountered black smoke so thick they couldn't see more than a foot in front of them.
1:01They crawled through the kitchen, then the living room, and finally, the bedroom. There, they found a mattress lit on fire. As they were crawling, the first one in found Judy on the ground and said, I think we have a body. Judy Weaver was 42 when she was murdered in her home. Her assailant came in through an unlocked back door, attacked Judy in her bedroom, and tied her up with objects found in her apartment, including her telephone cord. To cover up his crime, the assailant disabled her smoke detector and set her mattress on fire before fleeing the scene. There were no obvious suspects. Judy Weaver had no enemies.
1:50How would she ever get justice? It would take more than 20 years, major advances in forensic science, and one detective willing to turn an unlikely lead into an opportunity. A wad of chewing gum helped break over the case, and today a convicted killer who brutally raped his victims was sentenced for his crimes.
2:19This is The Opportunist, an original podcast from Podcast One. You're listening to a story told in one episode called Mitchell Gaff, The Gum Gambit. I'm Sarah James McLaughlin. In this episode, we examine the story of Mitchell Gaff, a killer whose crimes were unearthed from the cold cases by a creative detective and a stick of gum.
3:02Detectives did everything they could in 1984 to catch Judy Weaver's killer. They collected evidence from the crime scene, including the ligatures used in her attack. And while DNA evidence was not a powerful forensic tool at the time, they still had the foresight to collect vaginal swaps. Here is Detective Susan Logothetti from the Everett Police Department. I think that there was one detective, he had the foresight, he had just been to a training. Even in 1984, he remembered a forensic scientist saying, When you come across a victim that you think was raped, you should do a vaginal swab. That really wasn't a thing at that point.
3:55He was in the sex crimes unit and had just had this training. And they were pretty positive that Judy had been raped. Even with the ligatures in hand and DNA evidence collected at the scene, technology wasn't advanced enough to identify the killer. For 20 years, Judy's case went cold. But the final piece of evidence needed to identify her killer would be unknowingly collected by the Everett Police Department just two months later. The dots just needed to be connected. In August of 1984, Everett police were called to the scene of a brutal attack on two teenage girls. Two months after killing Judy Weaver, the killer was back out stalking the streets of Everett, trying unlocked doors.
4:46He saw the youngest sister sleeping on the couch in the living room through the window, and she had fallen asleep watching Johnny Carson. and when I interviewed him, he told me that the way he would open a door, if you're sitting in the house, he took his time and would move the doorknob so slowly that if you were sitting in the room and looked at the doorknob, you would never see it move. While the younger sister slept on the couch, the rest of the family was asleep in their rooms, the elder sister in her upstairs bedroom, and their mother in her basement bedroom. So when he came inside, he liked to wander around.
5:29That was part of his thing. He would go through things. He grabbed a knife from their kitchen, and he gathered things to tie them up with. Like he always does, he likes to use things from people's houses. He got the phone cord and maybe some other things and went and got the younger sister on the couch first, put a knife to her throat, told her he was going to kill her, all of these menacing things, and gagged her, taped her mouth, put a pillowcase over her head, tied her up, hog tie. And then he went back and found the older sister in her bedroom and did the same thing to her. Over the next four hours, their attacker repeatedly assaulted the two sisters, threatening to kill them.
6:19And he nearly did. After strangling the younger sister with a hairdryer cord, he turned his attention to her older sister. And while he was strangling her, the younger sister regained consciousness and managed to escape. She just ran, ran right outside, ran across the street to the neighbor's house, and started banging on the door. she's trying to scream and she couldn't and that's when she realized that the cord from the hair dryer was still tied around her neck and it was tied so tightly that she couldn't scream so she started just beating the door with the hair blow dryer as hard as she could until her neighbors woke up and came down the neighbor who answered the door said when she opened the door she saw her she was just saying she's killing her she's killing her By the time the concerned neighbor had grabbed a weapon and ran outside to investigate, he saw the assailant running out of the house and down the street.
7:21Police arrived at the scene shortly after, but the intruder was nowhere to be found. The one thing detectives had to go on was a very specific M.O. In fact, it was an M.O. they had seen before. This is CNN reporter Nina Giraldo. It's actually interesting because the reason that he was able to be identified in the case with the sisters was because after he attacked O 'Brien, the same police officer that helped O 'Brien find him, he pulled him in having worked on O 'Brien's case and had the sisters identify him. So that was something that Detective Susan Logothetti told me, that it was actually because of O 'Brien's attack that they were able to identify him in the rapes of the two sisters, because he had fled the scene.
8:22Distinct similarities between the sisters' case and an attack against a woman named Jacqueline O 'Brien in 1979 inspired detectives to consider a new suspect, a man named Mitchell Gaff. They pulled up a photo of O 'Brien's attacker and included it in a lineup that was presented to the two sisters. The sisters both identified Mitchell Gaff as the person that had assaulted them in August. When Gaff attacked the two sisters, he was on probation for his crimes against Jacqueline. Five years earlier, Jacqueline, who was a Washington State parole officer, was mowing her lawn when she had the misfortune of encountering Gaff.
9:03He did all kinds of deviant things. He would stalk them sometimes, follow them, make a note of where they lived. He would sometimes just find a woman he found attractive and watch them. Jackie was in 1979. She still is a beautiful woman, but she was, she was very beautiful. She's out there mowing her lawn, very independent. And she caught Gaff in her grass clipping shed that she had. And he was changing clothes, or at least he was acting like he was. He said he was on his way to his kung fu class. So she told him to get out, get out of there. And he wound up when she was putting her lawnmower away, attacking her, beating her in the head with the butt of a gun and had brought a rape kit with him.
10:13Jacqueline fought back hard against Gaff when she realized the gun he had was a fake. She threw her body weight against him, fended off his knife with her hands, and hit him until she was able to escape into a nearby alley. She found help and called the police. Jacqueline was able to ID Gaff, and he was sentenced to five years of probation and one year of work release for attempted rape. While all of Gaff's crimes were random acts of opportunity against women, he was starting to leave a clear trail of evidence. His M.O. from O 'Brien's case led to his arrest in the Sisters case, where he was sentenced in 1985 to 11 and a half years in prison.
10:56While Gaff is serving his time, CODIS was launched. It allowed law enforcement agencies across the country to compare DNA profiles from crime scenes with those of convicted offenders, helping investigators identify suspects and connect previously unsolved cases. Because Gaff was a convicted sex offender, his DNA profile was added into the new system. 20 years later, this injury would come back to haunt him.
11:30To be perfectly honest, the holidays really aren't my thing. But even when you're not into the season, it can still mess with your gut. Your routines just go out the window. there's sugar everywhere, and the stress alone can leave you feeling bloated and just off. That's where Cachava's new 3-in-1 Digestive Boost comes in. It's targeted support for your gut, prebiotic fiber that feeds the good bacteria, probiotics that add more beneficial bacteria, and clinically studied postbiotics that support your gut barrier function. He makes it right into your cachava shake or any cold drink. Cachava shakes are clean nutrition that actually tastes delicious with no fillers and no nonsense.
12:14Try Cachava's new 3-in-1 digestive boost at cachava.com and use code opportunist for 15 % off your first order. That's cachava, k-a-c-h-a-v-a dot com, code opportunist.
12:34In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Mitchell Gaff was on a rampage. From 1979 to 1984, he was involved in at least three separate violent crimes against women, all with a similar M.O. In addition to prison time, Gaff paid for his crimes when his DNA was loaded into a database called CODIS. CODIS stands for Combined DNA Index System, and refers to the FBI's database that houses DNA samples gathered from convicted federal offenders in crime scenes. When law enforcement collects DNA samples, they can run those samples through CODIS. If they get a hit, it means that the DNA from the new crime scene matches that of a person already convicted for another crime.
13:20This database is an effective way of tracking down serial offenders, connecting seemingly unrelated crimes and sharing evidence across states and bureaucracies. CODIS had not launched by 1984 when Gaff's DNA was collected from both Judy Weaver's and the sisters' crime scenes. The DNA Identification Act officially launched CODIS as an FBI tool in 1994, but investigators quickly realized that having access to DNA was one thing, but being able to accurately analyze it was another. Interpreting DNA evidence from a crime scene can be an incredibly complex process. Samples are rarely whole, or without contamination, or in large quantities.
14:09In Gaff's case, his DNA evidence was unable to be tested until the invention of STRmix, a software system that was capable of interpreting DNA profiles that had before been impossible to decipher. Here's Nina Giraldo from CNN. So in the last few years, the most significant improvement is the development of this new software called StarMix, which they used to solve this case, and that's S-T-R-M-I-X. and with StarMix they were able to pull out that small ratio of DNA that was on one of the ligatures on Weaver's body and they were able to identify this very small amount of DNA with this software and that was very recent only in the last few years.
15:02We're able to solve cases now that we never could happen. Like it just scientifically was not possible before. And we're able to solve those today. And really sometimes all it takes is some prompting, a little nudge from a family member or from law enforcement to get police to revisit these cases that might be, yeah, sitting right under them and they haven't solved yet. And they maybe could if they just went back to it with the technology we now have. STRMix launched in 2012, but it would take 10 more years for Judy Weaver's case to come back across Everett Police Department's cold case desk. Detective Susan Logothetti had been with the Everett Police Department since 2012 and took over cold cases from a detective retiring from the major crimes unit in 2020.
15:53This is Detective Susan Logothetti. As the previous detective was retiring, he told me about the Judy Weaver case, which is the 1984 case. And he had told me that it was basically closed and he had met with the family and everything. And he thought it was her fiance, Bill Richards, who was the suspect. Just to confirm it, before he left, he sent in part of Judy's ligature for testing to the Washington State Patrol Crime Lab. and he said eventually you'll get the report back and and hopefully it confirms that it's it was Bill Richards I don't remember how long it was after he left but I got the crime lab report back like you said I would and um it was not Bill Richards uh it was a totally unknown name I had read the file front to back.
16:49And the name on the paper was from a CODIS hit from DNA found on the literature. And it came back to a man named Mitchell Gaff. No one was expecting Gaff's name to pop up in relation to Judy Weaver. But after looking into Gaff's record, the puzzle pieces started to fall into place. He is alive. and so I thought okay I need to learn more this is promising I got all of his documents from the Department of Corrections in Washington because he had been convicted of two rapes in 1984 and an attempted rape in 1979 so I wanted to get all those documents and take a look and see what those crimes were all about.
17:40When I got that all back and read through everything, it was really shocking how similar the crimes were. And I knew, I was sure that Mitchell Gaff was the suspect. This was the first promising evidence in Judy Weaver's case in 20 years. But law enforcement cannot make an arrest based on a CODIS hit alone. Legally, CODIS evidence is strictly investigatory and won't stand up in trial. In order to connect Gaff to Judy, Detective Logothetti would need to obtain another DNA sample from him. But how? Well, sometimes it's not just criminals who see and seize an opportunity.
18:39There's nothing quite like having pieces in your closet that you love and know you can count on for any occasion. Except maybe giving someone else that same feeling. This holiday season, Quince is where I'm finding those pieces. Quince makes elevated everyday essentials with premium materials like Mongolian cashmere and organic cotton. Their 100 % Mongolian cashmere sweaters start at just$50, and their 14 karat gold earrings and bracelets make thoughtful gifts for anyone in your life. And it's all priced 50 to 80 % less than similar brands. The cardigan I have from Quince is one of those pieces I'd happily give someone else because I know how much wear I've gotten out of mine.
19:20I use it constantly and I know friends who would too. Give the gift a quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, let it know it was the opportunist. It's the best way to support the show.
19:59DNA evidence that had been collected in 1984 is now opening up leads for a cold case in 2020. Mitchell Gaff's trail of crimes, from Jacqueline O 'Brien to Judy Weaver, was finally reaching its end. With a CODIS hit matching GAF in one hand, the only thing left for Detective Lugathetti was to obtain a confirmation DNA sample. But first, she had to do some research on GAF. This is Detective Lugathetti. He was a free man. His only obligation was to register as a sex offender. but he had managed to legally change his name from Mitchell Gaff to Sam Wise Price. He had gotten married to a man, an older man, and was living in his house.
20:53I was basically taking care of him. Yeah, he was just free. His neighbor's neighborhood, I don't think they ever had a clue who he was or that he was the predator that he is. Gaff had no idea that he was being investigated again, and Detective Logothetti wanted to keep it that way. Everett Police Department set up cameras aimed at Gaff's home and performed round-the-clock surveillance waiting for him to come out. Typically, law enforcement will collect surreptitious DNA from a sample that the suspect leaves behind in their daily life, like from a cigarette butt or a coffee cup. But Gaff never seemed to leave his house.
21:36Time was ticking, and that's when a detective on Logothetti's team came up with an out-of-the-box idea. I had another detective reach out to me and say, why don't we try this, you know, gum ruse? And he said we could make flyers and t-shirts and pretend like we're launching this gum and ask if he wants to participate in like a sort of a taste test scenario and we're going door to door or whatever. And I thought, oh God, like this isn't going to work. I also worked for the Department of Corrections for eight years as a community corrections officer in Washington. And I worked with felons coming out of prison and I thought most felons are, you know, they're not going to fall for something like that.
22:31They're pretty suspicious of, I would be suspicious even, you know, like of someone coming to my door and asking me to chew gum. But I was like, I'll try anything at this point. So the gum ruse was initiated. Detective Logothetti and her team went all in on making their door-to-door gum survey seem like the real deal. They created t-shirts and flyers, and procured generic unbranded gum to give to GAF. They even bought Safeway gift cards to reinforce the idea that participants of this fake scheme were rewarded for their time. Once all the details had been locked down, all that was left to do was execute the plan.
23:17In January of 2024, Detective Logothetti and two detectives went undercover as gum salesmen and knocked on Gaff's door. I remember knocking on the door and he came to the door. He was in like leisurely comfy clothes. It was a drizzly day. When he came to the door, he's kind of cracking it. He didn't want his cat to escape. He didn't want to give us his cold. And we gave him our pitch. And we had the gift cards. And I think that's what kind of sold him on it. He was like, oh, yeah, I shop at Safeway. There's one right next door to him, basically. And he's like, all right, because we're just kind of cold and it was raining and everything, like he invited us in.
24:08And one of the first things that the sergeant of this operation said was, try not to go in the house. But we did. We didn't want to be weird, you know. Once inside, the detectives got Gaff chatting. He warmed up to them quickly, and soon it was time to get the DNA sample they had come for. The undercover detectives handed Gaff one stick of gum after the other. and when it was time for the next flavor, had him spit the previous piece into a ramekin. And just like that, Detective Logothetti had the DNA sample that would officially connect Mitchell Gaff to the murder of Judy Weaver. Once Detective Logothetti confirmed the new sample against CODIS and the original crime scene evidence, Gaff was immediately arrested.
25:00While Judy Weaver's case was coming to a close, another lucky coincidence connected Gaff to a second cold case. Message was forwarded to me. And when I heard it, it was a name I didn't recognize. It was, he said his name was Ken Vesey. And it was a little bit grouchy. Not too bad. I've heard worse. But he said something similar of my name's Ken Vesey calling about my wife's murder and not that you guys have ever done anything, but one of your main suspects just died and I thought you might wanna know. And then he left his phone number. And I was curious because I didn't know the name and clearly it was a cold case because it was forwarded to me.
25:57So I immediately called him back. He started to tell me how his brother who had been a suspect in the case had passed away and didn't know who to call anymore. There's been, there have been many detectives throughout the years and thought someone might want to know. And I said, what year was your wife killed? And he said, 1980. And when I looked at 1980, the only cold case I saw from that year was a male. And so I just asked him to start telling me about the case. When he started giving me details, all I could think about was Judy Weaver. Susan Vasey was 21 in 1980 when she was murdered in her bedroom with her 15-week-old baby next to her.
26:45Gaff would later confess that he had been trying random doors in the neighborhood when finding Susan's home was unlocked. Susan was alone with her two young children when Gaff beat, raped, and strangled her, just as he had done to Judy Weaver. Susan's husband found her body on the bedroom floor. Their two children were nearby unharmed. The similarities between the attacks on Jacqueline O 'Brien and the two sisters had led investigators to gaffe. Now, the similarities between the murders of Judy Weaver and Susan Vasey raised the possibility that he was responsible for both. Detective Logathetti knew it was a long shot, but she needed to rule him out as a suspect in Susan's murder.
27:31Fortunately, Everett police had plenty of DNA evidence from chewing gum to work with. We had a ton of DNA because the gum. So I sent up the ligature, Susan B.C.'s ligature, to be tested and compared with Mitchell Gaff's DNA. It felt like it took forever at that time. Ken BC was, he would call me like at least once a week and just for any updates, what's going on. And, and we had, we had developed a good report. and finally I get the crime lab report I see it in my email and I open it and what I saw was that there was a 1.7 septillion uh something like that that this DNA on Susan B.C.'s ligature was Mitchell Gaff.
28:35And I don't even know, I think I just was stunned. Due to some good detective work, a well-timed phone call from a family member, and a wad of gum, Susan Vasey's murder was solved after over 20 years as a cold case. On April 16, 2026, Mitchell Gaff pled guilty to the murders of both Judy Weaver and Susan Vasey. In May, he was sentenced to a minimum of 50 years and a maximum of life in prison. Gaff attacked Jacqueline O 'Brien, the two sisters, Susan Vasey and Judy Weaver, all in the span of five years. Gaff is not an active suspect in any cases currently, But it is likely there are many more victims of his waiting for justice.
29:28This is Nina Geraldo. There's no, like, one crime that they can connect him to outside of these murders, necessarily. But something the detective told me was it was something that was really on her mind. Because she said, I really doubt that Mitchell Gaff was dormant between 1980 and 1984. before, there's a very real possibility that there were other victims that we just don't know about or haven't been connected to him because it's been so long. And often it is a family member like Ken Vesey or law enforcement that will prompt another look into one of these cold cases that we now can solve with modern DNA technology.
30:14For years, Mitchell Gaff had moved through the neighborhood looking for just one unlocked door with an unsuspecting woman on the other side, about to be face-to-face with a killer. In the end, Gaff was brought to justice by the very thing he had used against his victims, the ability to recognize an opportunity.
30:41Thank you for tuning in to The Opportunist. This episode was written by Kaylee McHale, and executive produced by Connor Powell. We'll be back in two weeks with new stories about people seeing an opportunity to get ahead and taking it. Until next time.
31:25I don't know what I'm doing. Need a break. Forget it, I quit. Escape to Pluto TV. This is objectively fantastic. Relax into the movies and shows you already know and love, all for free. Shwing! Even our news is uplifting. You stay classy, San Diego. Watch Tommy Boy, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Anchorman, The Legend of Ron Burgundy, The X-Files, Wayne's World, and so much more. We're not worthy! The best things on TV really are free. You just have to know where to look. Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now. Pay never.
When an Everett detective knocked on Mitchell Gaff’s door in 2024, she asked him to try a new chewing gum. He thought it was a taste test. She needed a DNA sample. For the families of Judy Weaver and Susan Vesey, two women murdered four years apart in the same Washington city, that visit would help answer questions they had lived with for decades.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.