1. Podcasts
  2. The Playbook Podcast
  3. Schumer’s challenger
The Playbook Podcast

16 Nov 2026 · 23m · 12 chapters

Episode artwork

Schumer’s challenger

In short

The episode covers three main stories: (1) a Democratic Senate leadership challenge, (2) the Murdochs’ efforts to reshape Democratic politics and media, and (3) the FAA “ground stop” caused by an upgrade to aging communications infrastructure.

Guests/backgrounds

Jordan Carney (senior congressional reporter) discusses the Chris Van Hollen vs. Chuck Schumer leadership fight. Megan Messerly and Adam Wren host. Adam also references coverage with Pete Buttigieg at a Denver conference.

Key claims

Van Hollen argues Schumer’s team may try to move the caucus leadership election earlier than the December 1 rule, which he says would “short circuit” a fair process. The Murdochs (James and Catherine) are building a rival centrist media/political network, aiming to counter their family’s polarization legacy. The FAA meltdown stemmed from an Arkansas telecom upgrade disrupting controller communications/tracking; Congress already approved $12.5B for modernization, but more funding may be needed.

Notable examples

Van Hollen’s “don’t rush a coronation” argument; John Fetterman’s threat to leave the Democratic Party if Van Hollen leads; Murdoch donations (e.g., ~$2M to Majority Democrats; ~$500k to Josh Shapiro); Denver flight cancellations/ground stop; Buttigieg offering help rebooking flights.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:20

Chris Van Hollen Challenges Schumer

Discussion on Chris Van Hollen's challenge to Chuck Schumer for majority leader.

“So there's been talk for a while now about, you know, appetite for change within Democratic Party leadership.”
2:14

Desire for Change Within the Party

Exploration of the appetite for change in Democratic Party leadership.

“What are you thinking and hearing, Jordan?”
3:12

Freshman Class Dynamics

Analysis of the new Democratic freshman class's desire for leadership change.

“How do you read this in the broader context, Adam?”
4:19

Caucus Rules and Election Timing

Discussion on caucus rules and the implications of moving leadership elections.

“I do think it's going to be interesting to see where a lot of the energy is among this freshman class, many of whom have said that they want to see new blood.”
6:39

Fetterman's Position and Concerns

Conversation about Senator Fetterman's stance and potential party switch.

“And so it is concerning that there's an ongoing effort to try to short circuit that debate.”
9:02

Talk of the Town: The Murdochs

Discussion on James and Catherine Murdoch's political influence and strategy.

“So I think, you know, we'll have a pretty good sense coming out of they're going to have a caucus lunch on Tuesday, where if this is going to come up as a discussion, it's going to come up there.”
14:00

Media Acquisition Attempts

Discussion on efforts to acquire Pod Save America and rival media ecosystems.

“We also scoop, along with my colleague Sarah Ellison, the great media reporter, that they were sniffing around Pod Save America and tried to potentially acquire that network of podcasts.”
14:45

Air Travel Disruptions

Adam shares his frustrating experience with flight delays and cancellations.

“Okay, Adam, we should also talk about the nationwide ground stop.”
15:49

FAA Network Disruption Explained

Analysis of the FAA network issue that caused nationwide flight stops.

“I mean, she's just 18 hours, so it's really not too bad, actually.”
16:56

Political Implications of FAA Issues

Discussion on how the FAA crisis affects political narratives and responsibilities.

“So the president weighed in on this yesterday, saying that upgrading the traffic control system shouldn't be done in, quote, drips and drabs.”
Show all 12 chapters
18:22

Buttigieg's Challenges Ahead

Exploring the scrutiny faced by Pete Buttigieg regarding FAA modernization.

“How is he going to have to deal with all of this?”
20:38

Upcoming Political Events

Preview of important political events and gatherings in the coming week.

“administrations responsible for the lack of upgrades.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Playbook Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00A message from OpenAI. College freshman Ryan Honorey began developing wildfire detection technology as a fifth-grade science project. Years and many accolades later, that experiment became Sensory AI, a wildfire detection system that uses ChatGPT to turn sensor data into clear, actionable alerts. Those alerts go straight to departments like Laguna Beach Fire Department giving responders an early signal when a fire starts. Discover his story at openai.com slash stories.

0:35Today on the Playbook podcast, a battle for Senate Democratic leadership is heating up. Chris Van Hollen is challenging Chuck Schumer for majority leader and tells our Will Stakin, there shouldn't be a rush to vote. That's the story driving the day. And in Talk of the Town, we'll talk about James and Catherine Murdoch, the ones that Democratic consultants call the good Murdochs, the estranged scion of Rupert Murdoch, who are trying to undo their family's political legacy and how the Trump administration handled the FAA meltdown that brought air travel across the country to a standstill, including mine.

1:13Hello, I'm Megan Messerly. And I'm Adam Wren. It's Monday, November the 16th. and here to talk about the story driving the day we have senior congress reporter jordan carney hello jordan hopefully you didn't have any travel plans over the weekend no i was um i guess safely in dc and luckily adam's not joining this podcast from like a road trip from denver uh we're glad we're glad you made it back adam safe and sound me too Yeah. We're going to get to the FAA stuff in a minute, but we wanted to first bring in your congressional expertise, Jordan, because this morning we are talking about Senator Chris Van Holland, who announced that he plans to challenge Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader.

2:01So there's been talk for a while now about, you know, appetite for change within Democratic Party leadership. But this is quite something to have an actual challenge to Schumer here. What are you What are you thinking and hearing, Jordan? I do think there was a decent amount of skepticism within the caucus that this was going to happen, especially if they won back the majority. Obviously, I think they performed probably at the top of their expectations on election night. And so now you've got this freshman class coming in that is pretty vocal about wanting someone else besides Schumer. And, you know, Chris Van Hollen says, you know, I've heard these calls for change.

2:42and I was kind of looking at a White House run and now he says he's not. So it's going to be an interesting couple of weeks. So fascinating. And the thing that just, you know, jumps out to me, Adam, and you've been following this so closely, but, you know, just thinking about the future of the Democratic Party, to Jordan's point, I mean, on one hand, you can say, you know, wow, Democrats did so well. You know, of course, Chuck Schumer should retain control. On the other, very clearly we've seen within the party this desire for change and a shakeup in leadership and sort of this disdain for the establishment, which I think a lot of folks would see Chuck Schumer as.

3:19How do you read this in the broader context, Adam? Yeah, it's interesting, Megan. I think that Van Hollen is an interesting vehicle for people in the party who want to see change. In some ways, you know, he is kind of the establishment himself. I mean, he has links to the establishment, was on the DSCC with Schumer. So he's sort of a vessel, it feels like, for this skepticism and anger in the party about generational change. You know, he did sort of signal to the left throughout 2025 in the early stages of Trump 2.0. And you have someone like Ro Khanna, who I spoke with at What's Next in Denver, who interestingly enough is backing both Hakeem Jeffries and then Van Hollen in the Senate.

4:09And so I just find it sort of a fascinating moment. Yeah, I mean, I would even note that some of his supporters seem to have decided he was not going to run. Our colleague Lisa Kaczynski talked to Abdul El-Sayed the day after the election, and he mentioned to her, you know, like, oh, he was my, like, white whale, and now I've got to start casting around again for somebody else. Yeah, yeah. I do think it's going to be interesting to see where a lot of the energy is among this freshman class, many of whom have said that they want to see new blood. You have people like Senator-elect James Tallarico in Texas, Senator-elect Josh Turek in Iowa.

4:48And it's going to be a really revelatory moment for the new Democratic Congress. This just reminded me too, Jordan, we were talking about this this week, but like only in the Senate would going from a 75 year old to a 67 year old be seen as generational change. So speaking of Denver, Crispin Holland was out there. He did a gaggle around his speech and he got a question that was like, you know, Chuck Schumer is in his 70s and has been in like elected office his whole life. You are in your 60s and you've been in political office your whole life. Like explain the difference. Okay, Jordan, I want to bring you in here on something kind of wonky.

5:25So Playbook's Will Staken spoke with Senator Chris Van Hollen, and Van Hollen, when they spoke, emphasized that Schumer's team is trying to, quote, cut short debate and move the caucus elections earlier than December. So there's an ongoing effort to try to move this date forward. Let's listen to a part of Will's conversation with the senator. The rules were changed after the last election to move the date for the election of the majority leader to December. Right. And the whole purpose of that was people recognized that the power of incumbency to try to use those powers behind the scenes to get a coronation should be something that we don't support as Democrats, that we want a more open process.

6:15That's why it's concerning that there's an ongoing effort to try to short circuit that process because that process was put in place for the very purpose of allowing us not to rush into a decision after election. Let's not rush into a coronation. Let's take a little time to decide what direction we want to take. That change was made at the behest of the caucus. And so it is concerning that there's an ongoing effort to try to short circuit that debate. And it does suggest the concern that the longer we have this discussion, the more momentum we will have for change. But it sounds like you think you may be able to stop that from moving up, given the conversations you've had.

7:00I think the caucus, the great majority in the caucus would agree that it would send this terrible signal, not only to ourselves, but to others around the country, that we are going to try and change the rules to try to influence the outcome of an election. Okay, so this is getting a little in the weeds here, Jordan, but can you explain why moving the caucus election forward for a majority leader is noteworthy and will keeping the December date give Van Hollen the edge he needs? Yeah, so to get a little in the weeds, under the caucus rules, it says you You cannot have your leadership election before December.

7:39Right now, that is currently scheduled to be on December 1st. But pretty quickly after Van Hollen jumped in last week, we started hearing from folks who said there was a discussion ongoing within the caucus about whether or not they could move that up. That would be, you know, they're in town for one more week, so it would have to be this week if they were going to do it before December 1st. I feel like I should note that Schumer hasn't actually weighed in on this idea, but there is sort of a question, I guess, among some senators who are wondering if they really want this to be their life for the next two weeks, getting asked every day if they support Chris Van Hollen or Chuck Schumer.

8:20And so I think that's kind of what is driving that discussion to a not insignificant amount. I mean, you could argue. I mean, you could argue that keeping it in December helps Van Hollen. It gives him more time to have conversations. There's going to be a huge pressure campaign from progressive groups. They've already made that very clear to try to get senators to support Van Hollen. And so that gives more time for that to take root. I was talking to someone who thought maybe it actually gave Schumer more time to like cut deals and turn screws on people. Works both ways. Yeah, it works both ways.

8:53But it also gets him, you know, closer to the government funding deadline where he's already facing a lot of pressure from the left. I've also heard skepticism from Schumer allies that this gets moved up. So I think, you know, we'll have a pretty good sense coming out of they're going to have a caucus lunch on Tuesday, where if this is going to come up as a discussion, it's going to come up there. That does not mean that the vote would be Tuesday. It could be that someone sort of makes a motion in that Tuesday lunch and they vote later in the week. It could be that they all decide they don't want to do this.

9:19But, yeah, I think there's maybe a sense of we would prefer not to both be having this fight and also be getting asked every five minutes in the halls for the next two weeks about our decision. So fun being dogged by reporters, though, on the Senate subway. So another interesting sort of turn of the screw here. Over the weekend, we had Senator John Fetterman suggesting to Fox News that he would leave the Democratic Party if Van Hollen is majority leader. Is there a red line for you if the party does go far left that you would walk away? Yeah, absolutely. It would be troubling if my caucus elects someone like Van Hollen that has really made his name being very anti-hostile to Israel.

10:05You know, if you are going to be angry or hostile towards any countries in the region, why not make that, you know, Iran or Hezbollah or Hamas as well, too? And now, why? Why? Both in the House now and the Senate now, their first instincts are to punish Israel and to withhold these kinds of aid. Why? Why isn't your first instinct to say, let's hold Iran accountable? So there was some joking that this could actually play in Van Hollen's favor. And of course, the talk about, you know, is Fetterman going to switch parties or not is nothing new here. But Jordan, what do you make of this? I mean, ideally, to your point, there's a whole separate conversation about if he's, you know, there's the 2028, does he run for election?

10:52Does he run for election as a Democrat? I mean, I would say, though, like, there was a whole focus on John Fetterman, especially heading into the elections when Democrats thought, you know, they might win back the majority, but it might be a much smaller majority having a 55, 56 seat majority. I mean, they don't want to, no one's going to say, yes, you know, we want to lose John Fetterman. They want the largest majority they can get. But his influence is less than pretty dramatically in a larger majority. We will just have to wait to see what happens with Senator Fetterman and all the other questions that Democratic senators are going to be asked about this week.

11:26Thanks so much, Jordan, for joining us. Thanks.

11:33it's now time for talk of the town where we get to the other stories animating Washington this morning and to start us off Adam we should talk about this Politico magazine story that you co-wrote about the Murdoch specifically James and Catherine Murdoch so Adam reading the whole piece This just feels very succession-y. Yeah, that's sort of the vibes that I got from it as well, Megan. So we know that over this year and really since 2020, the Murdochs have been increasing their donations to Democratic candidates across the map. They were early supporters of former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.

12:15They attended a fundraiser for him and sought him out in 2019. And they also had lunch with him last year in Manhattan where they discussed the media and political landscape and sort of how they could work together. And what's interesting, Megan, is they're actually establishing sort of a rival network of media and political influence to their father and James's brother, Lachlan. They are giving to groups like Majority Democrats, who just gathered in Denver, and they donated almost$2 million to candidates from the bench and Majority Democrats this midterms, getting candidates like Senator-elect Josh Turek in Iowa over the finish line, spending about half a million dollars on the reelection campaign of Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro.

13:09So, Megan, what they really want to do here is become power brokers and decide where the party goes. They want to steer it to the center left as much as possible. And ultimately, they want to see a radical centrist, quote, radical centrist, as they see it, become the nominee of the Democratic Party in 2020. So they're looking at someone like a Pete Buttigieg. They're looking at someone like an Arizona Senator Ruben Gallego or, of course, Josh Shapiro. And so I guess from your perspective, like, does it feel like they're trying to like undo the Murdoch model of political polarization or are they just sort of a countervailing force against their father's work?

13:50They're trying to undo it. They're trying to be a check against it, certainly a countervailing force, Megan. They are trying to create a universe where they own influential media outlets like New York Magazine and Vox, which they acquired recently earlier this year. We also scoop, along with my colleague Sarah Ellison, the great media reporter, that they were sniffing around Pod Save America and tried to potentially acquire that network of podcasts. And so they really are trying to – and of course they have growing financial ties to the centrist bulwark publication. So they're really trying to create a rival ecosystem both politically and on the media landscape and really undo what they've seen Lachlan and Rupert do on the right.

14:43It's a fascinating piece. And you can read Adam's magazine article over at Politico's new app. Download it right now. Okay, Adam, we should also talk about the nationwide ground stop. I mean, we were just talking about this at the top of the podcast, but how bad was it for you, Adam? It was pretty bad, Megan. I was supposed to leave at 7.30. My plane was supposed to depart at 7.30 Friday evening from Denver. I went to – it was delayed until 12.59 a.m. I went to the airport and it was delayed again. And then right when we started to board, they canceled the flight. So I was able to get a hotel, one of the last hotels in downtown Denver at 2 a.m.

15:30on Saturday morning. And then I got back up and tried again at 10 a.m. on Saturday morning. And they had a plane but not a crew. And so it was delayed again. But I did rent a car and was about ready to, as a good Midwesterner, drive 18 hours back east. I mean, she's just 18 hours, so it's really not too bad, actually. Hop, skip, and a jump back home. Yeah, yeah. So folks will be well aware of this, and all the headlines probably had friends or family or themselves were also caught up in all of this. But the trouble began on Friday when a routine upgrade to the FAA's aging telecommunications infrastructure triggered a network disruption that ended up interfering with air traffic controllers' ability to communicate with and track aircraft.

16:19An FAA contractor had actually been installing new equipment, including a router, at a communications facility in Arkansas. So we saw first on Friday night, Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen and Secretary Sean Duffy came out to the White House press briefing room and gave an update on this. And then we again had a press conference from Secretary Duffy on Saturday. And then Secretary Duffy made the rounds on the Sunday shows. And he said that he expects flights to resume to full capacity today, but that he couldn't guarantee that a similar meltdown wouldn't happen again. And this just feels like where the conversation now is headed, Adam.

16:58So the president weighed in on this yesterday, saying that upgrading the traffic control system shouldn't be done in, quote, drips and drabs. And of course, we should note Congress actually approved$12.5 billion for FAA modernization last year. But Duffy said Sunday that the money won't cover all the costs of upgrading the agency's telecommunication system, which is relying on outdated routers and wiring. So, Adam, it just feels like this is the next iteration of the conversation. We've gotten through the immediate crisis, but no one can rule out that this is happening again. So then the ask becomes, OK, is Congress going to approve, you know, more money for this project?

17:36Yeah, Megan, I think this is going to be a real tell about how the Trump administration messages the first two years of their time controlling all lovers of power in Congress. I mean, Donald Trump has spent a lot of time talking about the reflecting pool. He spent a lot of time talking about the White House ballroom. But he's given some lip service on True Social to fixing and modernizing the air traffic control system. But we haven't actually seen, you know, a ton of evidence that he's invested as much political capital into that or urged his own party to do that in a concrete way, you know, as he has the reflecting pool.

18:21So, Adam, you were in Denver with Pete Buttigieg, who, of course, is the former transportation secretary. How is he going to have to deal with all of this? Yeah, Megan. And this was really interesting to watch it all unfold in real time in Denver, where former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg was at the What's Next conference. And literally, as this was happening, he took the stage and began his remarks by saying that he would be available in the hotel bar after the event to help anybody rebook their flights and make sure that they got the benefits and compensation that they deserve from the major airlines.

19:02And of course, when he did the gaggle afterwards, which was probably the largest attended gaggle of any potential 2028er and alongside, I would say, Chris Van Hollen's gaggle with the press. The first questions were shockingly not about his own political ambitions, but what had happened with the FAA. What this really shows, Megan, is that this is going to be an ongoing tightrope for the former transportation secretary to deal with as he potentially runs for president. Some of his allies are gonna potentially attack him over why he didn't do more faster to fix this patchwork of flight safety mechanisms.

19:47And what's interesting is that Ari Emanuel, the brother of Rahm Emanuel, who's running for president, potentially, tweeted at the time, no one's hands are clean here. However, Mr. Secretary Buttigieg, you had four years in the job and infrastructure money yet made zero progress modernizing the FAA. You left a failing system in place, all caps, thanks, exclamation mark. And so whenever this happens, Secretary Sean Duffy, President Donald Trump, other Republicans, and then occasionally some Democrats are going to go to Buttigieg and criticize him about this. And he's already talking on the campaign trail about the benefits of the bipartisan infrastructure law, but he's going to have to find answers that are compelling for this as well.

20:34Absolutely. This is just the inherent challenge there, right? These systems we know are decades old, which means it's been a host of Republican and Democratic administrations responsible for the lack of upgrades. So we'll have to see how this one plays out.

20:51And finally, here's what we have our eyes on for the week ahead. Mary Peltola is on track to win her Senate seat in Alaska, with results expected to come in early this week. President Donald Trump will be at two summits in Asia this week. But as Politico reports, foreign leaders see him weekend after the midterms. Plus, as part of that trip, the president is expected to meet with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese leader Xi Jinping to do their first trilateral meeting on the sides of the APEC summit. This would be a historic meeting between the three leaders of these countries. Adam, what do you have your eyes on?

21:31Well, Megan, I should have just stayed in Denver because I'm actually going with you and some of our other colleagues to Deer Valley this week to cover the NGA convening of all the freshman governors across the country, the new govs. And so I'm excited to see what the interactions between all of them is like. Excited to talk with folks like Rob Sand from Iowa and others, Amy Acton of Ohio, a lot of interesting new characters on the political scene nationally to talk to. And I find those events It's always fun. And what happens at the hotel bar is often more interesting and revealing than what happens in the main programming.

22:13So fascinated to source up there. Absolutely. I'll be packing my warm winter Coke because it's supposed to be a snowy time there. So I'll see you there, Adam. Is it really? Oh, my gosh. That's good. That is. It's supposed to snow on Tuesday. Oh, wow. Okay. All right. I better pack accordingly. And that's all for today's show. Don't forget to follow the Playbook podcast on your favorite podcast platform. You can also get episodes on YouTube and the new Politico app. Download it today. Want more news and analysis? Sign up for the Playbook newsletter at politico.com slash playbook. We'll be back tomorrow.

22:49Have a great day.

22:56Presented by OpenAI.

From the publisher

A Senate Democratic leadership showdown is brewing as Sen. Chris Van Hollen challenges Sen. Chuck Schumer for majority leader. Van Hollen tells Playbook why he thinks Democrats shouldn't rush to a vote. Then the other stories animating Washington: Two Murdochs are looking to rewrite their family's political legacy and new questions emerge about how the Trump administration handled an FAA meltdown that brought air travel across the country to a standstill. 

For more news and analysis, subscribe to the Playbook newsletter: politico.com/playbook 

More from The Playbook Podcast

All episodes