

Apple HomeView’s “app situation” and why it’s confusing; then a wide-ranging tech segment covering AI model competition, security/trade-secret and data-privacy stories, Character AI’s bankruptcy, and social media’s shifting center of gravity back toward X.
Neil Apatow (co-host/Verge Cast host). No other named guests appear in the transcript.
Neil Apatow is a Verge Cast host and tech reporter/commentator; the episode frames him as deeply engaged with Apple/consumer tech and CarPlay/HomeView discussion.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
The hosts analyze the confusing app situation with Apple's HomeView product.
“But one thing we talked a little bit about and were a little bit confused by and got some feedback about was the app situation on the HomeView.”
Discussion on how HomeView's app model compares to the Apple Watch and CarPlay experiences.
“I think most companies would be happy to sell a significant portion of a fraction of iPhone sales.”
The hosts express concerns about the software ecosystem and developer support for new Apple hardware.
“We obviously have to get it and review it.”
Explore the challenges of car app ecosystems and the dominance of CarPlay.
“And every time we do like a decoder CarPlay episode, we get all this email about it.”
Discuss the competitive landscape in AI, focusing on Google and Meta's strategies.
“The big news of this week was that Google released Gemini 4 Argon, which is its sort of re-entrance at the frontier of the model race.”
Delve into Meta's strategy of integrating AI with consumer products and its implications.
Analyze Google's difficulties in effectively deploying AI across its products.
“Like, do you build and train and refine a model to do English to French translation?”
Explore how Meta led in consumer products and a bizarre OpenAI employee incident.
“I think it is worth giving Meta some credit.”
Discuss the bankruptcy of Character AI and implications for user data privacy.
“Filed bankruptcy, it turns out in that process was under investigations stemming from a kid who committed suicide not that long after talking with its bot on Character AI.”
Contemplate whether federal privacy laws are necessary to protect user data.
“So the other thing that was on my mind is like Spirit Airlines went out of business and there was an auction for their corporate data.”
Analyze the current landscape of social media, focusing on X and user experiences.
“I actually, I realize I don't know the answer to this question.”
Explore the intriguing design ideas from Meta and its impact on social media.
“They have some real-time NBA chat stuff going on.”
Discuss the declining influence of X in the context of recent elections.
“But I do think if you are a tech journalist, you ought to go look at the primary sources.”
Analyze the ongoing cultural significance and the transformation of Twitter.
“The idea that our candidates are arguing on X or issuing policy positions on X or reacting to X is nowhere in this cycle.”
Understand how AI discussions shape social media platforms and their users.
“I don't think any normal person should be on X.”
Evaluate the role of video platforms in shaping media consumption compared to traditional social media.
“And like there's something there that it's this is Casey's argument.”
Explore the impact of social media formats and the culture on X.
“We can all go see Greg Josriak and John Ternus posting their home view videos on X because they all want to seem cool in front of Elon.”
Discuss the controversies surrounding live streaming executions and Brendan Carr's statements.
“So Pete Hegseth announced the Pentagon would live stream an execution, which apparently he didn't tell anyone he was going to announce, including President Trump, who mostly seemed surprised by this information.”
Discusses the failure of Project Gen5Sys and its implications for Dish Network and SpaceX.
“And this would create fear in the hearts of our network executives and they would once again compete for your dollars.”
Explores rumors about SpaceX potentially building a smartphone and implications for competition.
“So, okay, there have been rumors for a while now that SpaceX is going to build a phone.”
Analyzes recent smartphone market reports, highlighting declining sales and the impact of rising prices on consumers.
“So CounterPoint, which is a research firm, put out a report this week that said the global smartphone market declined 20 % year over year in Q3 of 2026, which is its lowest Q3 level in 14 years.”
Discusses the challenges and implications of AI agents in commerce and banking, including safety and responsibility.
“What I've been calling the DoorDash problem has arrived at scale.”
Exploration of Elon Musk's reputation and the implications of financial controls in banking.
“The Tesla Roadster is coming out a decade later.”
Discussion on DoorDash's role in delivery and user interaction challenges.
“Because DoorDash appears to have just wholeheartedly embraced the DoorDash problem.”
Insights on the importance of user interfaces in simplifying ordering processes.
“with no help and no visual cues, what kind of pizza I want.”
Critique of the trend to rebrand AI as 'super intelligence' and its implications.
“It's like, well, that's where the apps are.”
Discussion on the corruption within the tech industry and the impact of terminology changes.
“I'll just say, like the thing you're offended about is corruption.”
Analysis of the implications of game decompilation and its intersection with copyright law.
“Like just beginning, middle end, here's what all these people said and what they were thinking about.”
Exploration of the legal complexities surrounding decompiling software.
“Like, I can do this on a computer, so none of your old frameworks apply to me.”
Final thoughts and upcoming guests on The Vergecast.
Exploring the complexities of copyright law and its implications.
“different code important question right there it's probably a derivative work like you can get there but all of copyright law is on first impression.”
Preview of exciting guests and topics on upcoming episodes of Decoder.
“So we had Ben Jordan today talking about Flock.”
Updates on Verge's initiatives, voting acknowledgments, and listener engagement.
“Remember, you can subscribe to The Verge to get all of our podcasts, all the ones we've been talking about ad-free, including this one.”
Updates on Verge's initiatives, voting acknowledgments, and listener engagement.
“And speaking of support, thank you to everybody who voted for us in the Signal Awards.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Vergecast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Comcast Business. AI has made cyber attacks faster, cheaper, and easier to scale. Attackers can exploit security gaps long before patches are available. If you're a business owner, you need to stay ahead of threats. If you're only reacting, it might already be too late. That's where the Comcast Business 2026 Cybersecurity Threat Report comes in. Learn more about today's threat landscape and the best ways to stay prepared and ready for what's next. The 2026 Comcast Business Cybersecurity Threat Report uncovers how AI is accelerating today's attacks and how to build defenses that keep pace.
0:38Nilay Patel: Read the report at comcastbusiness.com slash cybersecurity. Cyber confidence starts with Comcast Business.
0:48Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. Your work is scattered. A thread here, a DM there, docs everywhere. And it's not only your team searching for context, your AI agents need it too. Jira taps Atlassian's teamwork graph to bring that context together across Jira, Confluence, Slack, GitHub, and more. And makes it easy to share with agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot. Assign them work directly or connect your agents through MCP. The result? Less token waste, more accuracy, and more time moving forward. Learn more at Jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com.
1:56Nilay Patel: business in one place. What it's doing, what it's done, and what it's about to do. So you stay in control. To put AI to work for people, visit servicenow.com.
2:12David Pierce: Hello and welcome to the Verge Cast, the flagship podcast of CarPlay entitlements, which are a thing I know about against my will. I'm your friend David Pierce. Neil Apatow is here. Hello, sir. I know so much about CarPlay entitlements. I am so excited to talk more. I am forcing more Home View talk into the top of this episode because CarPlay is about to become more important in your life and I think that is so funny. That's the worst.
2:36Nilay Patel: By the way, can I just shout out? Jen Toohey is amazing. It was so much fun to have her on the live stream afterwards and we saw comments that were like, you should let Jen talk more and she's British and polite and you just run over her. I just like talking to Jen a lot.
2:48David Pierce: Yeah.
2:49Nilay Patel: That's it. That's what I've got. It is fun to talk to our reporters who are deep nerds on stuff and approximately one person in this world wants to talk to me about Z-Wave and it's Jen. That's it. I can confirm that. I just want you to know I just get excited to have another nerd who cares about my nerd stuff here. Jen does not care about CarPlay. The only other person who cares about CarPlay as much as me is Joanna Stern whose Home View videos were like, CarPlay! And then she like excitedly texted me about it. So I'm working on it. We're going to bring it all together and then we'll make a show that like four people enjoy, but I will have the most.
3:24David Pierce: And all four of them are the hosts of the show. It's a show for no one except the hosts. It's going to be great. I'm excited about it. We have a lot of stuff to get to today. We have a bunch of AI news. We're going to talk about this thing where people are starting to slink back to X, which I find fascinating. We've got some SpaceX stuff going on. We've got a lot of news to get to, but I do want to start with a little bit of HomeView stuff at the top here. We did the live stream on Wednesday about Apple's new smart home entrant play here. But one thing we talked a little bit about and were a little bit confused by and got some feedback about was the app situation on the HomeView.
4:03David Pierce: And I would say both that we've had some time to learn about it and read about it and talk to people about it, but also that I feel incredibly vindicated because it is really confusing and essentially makes no sense. So, Neal, do you just want to, as best you can, sort of lay out the app situation on the HomeView as we understand it now? There is no app situation on the HomeView. Well, it's not exactly.
4:24Nilay Patel: It's mostly true. It's so true. The app situation on the HomeView is approximately the same app situation if you went onto Amazon or Alibaba and bought a$299 $49 CarPlay tablet for your car.
4:41David Pierce: Yeah, that's basically right. Yeah. They sell those. You can just get one. They're in the TikTok shop all the time.
4:45Nilay Patel: Yeah. You can just get one. You just like mount it to your car. They sell some that are so big, you just mount them over your vents. I've always been taken with these. Yeah. One day we'll do an entire episode on just people who own older model Ford F-150s ripping out the entire dash and putting in CarPlay tablets. There's a whole ecosystem there that I'm fascinated by. That's basically what Apple did here. They made the HomeView. they built some first party software to do some things. Yeah. In particular, make FaceTime calls and the home app. Yeah.
5:16David Pierce: It's not totally dissimilar from what you get kind of out of the box with the iPhone, right? It's like you get alarms, you get Apple Calendar, you get the home app, you get messages, you get podcasts. It's sort of the like bog standard set of Apple apps are on this thing.
5:30Nilay Patel: Right, but there's no app store. And then there's a bunch of Apple apps that aren't there, right? Like if you are an Apple Music classical person, which has its own app because classical music is organized and complicated different ways, that is not available to you. Apple News, a thing you might wish to scroll on your display is the chaos of your family makes French toast around you. Not available here. All of these things are going to be CarPlay apps. And if you will recall, on the day of the HomeView launch, it seemed like what Apple was going to do was take CarPlay and then like rework it for the HomeView.
6:04Nilay Patel: and instead it seems like they're just going to force everybody as a carplay app into supporting
6:09David Pierce: the home view yeah there's a thing in the developer terms that essentially says if you make a carplay app it will work on the home view the end there's like you you barely even have the ability to turn it off like if it if it is in carplay it will be on the home view does this approach make any sense to you because i confess this does not make any sense to me
6:28Nilay Patel: no it first of all apple's entire deal is apps yeah and they're already asking a lot of developers the iphone duo is going to require a lot of developers to support yet another screen size there there's some amount of rumor in the rumor mill about a touchscreen mac developers gonna have to think about that in some new way i mean this is a new hardware category for apple it is a new way of thinking about how you might interact with apple devices in your home and of all of the things you would ask developers to do, hey, think about like a true, cool, fun, multi-user app for our shared screen in the kitchen.
7:08Nilay Patel: Seems like top of the list, right? This is a new category. And instead, Apple has chained it to the iPhone in a way that means, I mean, they've sold a lot of iPhones, but they've chained it into the iPhone in a way that means you can only ever sell some fraction of the number of iPhones that exist. And so the app model is that. And the user model is that. And it's a lot of iPhones. Don't get me wrong. I think most companies would be happy to sell a significant portion of a fraction of iPhone sales.
7:35David Pierce: And I can't imagine somebody who isn't already in the iPhone world is even going to be really looking at this thing. But maybe that's kind of the point, right? Like this thing is an accessory of an iPhone. It's an Apple Watch in a very real way in that it actually, there is no reason whatsoever to buy it separately from owning an iPhone. In a way that like you can own an iPad and an Android phone and live a life that makes sense. This doesn't, this will make no sense if you are not an iPhone family.
8:03Nilay Patel: And if you recall, and I know you recall because you wrote the Wired cover story on the first Apple Watch. This is true. I'm so mad at you about it.
8:09David Pierce: I do in fact recall.
8:11Nilay Patel: Right, the Apple Watch started as like a remote control for your iPhone apps. Mm-hmm. Like that was a lot of the app model for the Apple Watch. This is just a little screen, but the app is actually running on your phone. And over time, as the processor got more efficient and more powerful, they brought the apps to the watch. This is why I was basically screaming, where is the computer on the live stream this week? The watch became a computer, and then it started running the applications. And now the watch is a vastly more independent computer, even though it's still connected to your iPhone in a lot of ways.
8:42Nilay Patel: The HomeView does not appear to be a computer, right? Right. It is the model of that first generation Apple Watch where it's a remote for your phone is right there. And then on top of that, it's very funny they picked CarPlay as the app model for those little remote control apps. The way to think about CarPlay is that it is just a second monitor for your iPhone, right? It is screen projection and you plug it in or you wirelessly connect, your iPhone detects a second monitor that's a CarPlay app and it shares a screen with custom interfaces for the apps that are running on the phone. This is fine in a car.
9:16David Pierce: It's also not. Like, it isn't fine in a car. And this is the thing, like, CarPlay, I am the pro-CarPlay person on this podcast by default. I don't think CarPlay is very good, right? Like, this experience is not good. Like, the simplest example for me is Spotify. You don't get anything remotely approaching the full Spotify experience in CarPlay, which makes some sense when you're driving and you should be tapping as little as possible. But if I'm going to have to do the stupid CarPlay search thing where it goes, what do you want to listen to? Pause, bing, and then you talk every single time I want to use the home view?
9:54David Pierce: That's awful. Like this is a thing that clearly has enough processing power. It has enough screen. It's going to be plugged in. So it's not like there's a power issue. You're also not driving. You're not distracted. Right. There is nothing preventing this thing from being a computer except that Apple doesn't allow it to be. And I guess part of it is the way that it's thinking about switching between users. And if you wanna have a bunch of apps logged in to a bunch of different things, like I can see how that model locally would get confusing, but that model's confusing anyway. And if what you're telling me is that this thing is going to learn to seamlessly switch between CarPlay devices, have you ever tried to switch CarPlay devices, Eli?
10:32David Pierce: Like, I don't know. This just makes me more concerned than ever that this thing is actually going to work in a way that works for people.
10:39Nilay Patel: We obviously have to get it and review it. We will see. But here's my big question for you is this is a lot of new hardware from Apple coming out, right? Where the Duo is soon to come out. This thing will come out. There's the new Apple TV, hot new hardware from Apple. There are rumors today that there will be a touchscreen MacBook from Gurman. Potentially very soon. Potentially very soon. There's a lot of new hardware from Apple. It's a big push, right? New CEOs, hardware CEOs. Here's all the new hardware. And it feels to me like the question we're going to ask at every single turn is, did you get the software right?
11:15Nilay Patel: Right. Did you make the right software decisions? And if I was going to be super rude, I would say none of this hardware is particularly, like, beyond the industry. The HomeV in particular, right, is like it's an LCD display on a previous generation chip. Sure. Like, yes, you could have made this at any point in the past 100 years, Apple. Sure. I will grant you the Duo has a lot of engineering in it, but foldables have been around for five years. So the wins here are all going to be software wins, ecosystem wins. Right. And it's interesting that all of my questions about all these devices are around, did we get the software right?
11:55Nilay Patel: Is the ecosystem paying off in the way we want it to, or is it actually holding us back?
11:59David Pierce: Yeah.
12:00Nilay Patel: And I truly do not know the answer to that question.
12:01David Pierce: I don't either, but it's been interesting to see the app developer community has raced to support the Duo. Yeah. Apple has gone out of its way to help people do this, but also even for a relatively new device that I suspect will not sell in giant numbers just because it's so expensive, app developers are all over this thing. And the App Store situation for the Duo on day one is gonna look great. This is what Apple is good at. This is Apple's main advantage over Android in particular. I've been using a lot of different size screen Android devices recently. I had the Alexa tablet, we have Google Books, and I am just struck over and over by the fact that Google is unwilling or unable or both to convince developers to support non-phone devices.
12:46David Pierce: You just can't do it. The keyboard stuff doesn't work very well. The large screen stuff doesn't work very well. Apple is good at this. And for Apple to come out with something like the HomeView that it ostensibly believes is going to be a big mainstream device, like Apple gave developers a better story for the Vision Pro than they're giving the HomeView. And I'm just confused by this. And I think the long run, it'll probably be like the Apple Watch, like you just described, right? It starts as an accessory and slowly over time becomes a computer. But that was a new piece of hardware with tons of new ideas and really, really intense constraints.
13:24David Pierce: Tiny thing, tiny battery, tiny processor, lots of new stuff going on. This should have none of those problems. Like if ever there was an Apple gadget to just over horsepower into existence with an app store, it should be the one that is plugged in sitting on your kitchen table. I'm just confused.
13:41Nilay Patel: Actually, the one thing Apple is best at is putting enough processing power and RAM in its computers to make its experiences work. Yeah. Like I think there's two reasons people like CarPlay. And I'm like you. I'm like, it's fine. It's there. I use it in our cars. But I don't think it's the best thing ever made. But I think there's two reasons people really like it and are very, very, very vociferous. They'll never buy a car without it. One is just the library of apps. And every time we do like a decoder CarPlay episode, we get all this email about it. And one always sticks out. In my mind, it was a reader who's like, I have a Bible app.
14:14Nilay Patel: The maker of the Bible app is never going to write an Android automotive app and put it in the Play Store for your weird Android car. There's no way to get that app, that big library of apps. This is like Instagram on the Windows phone. you can you can make all the windows when you want you know on instagram you're dead there's some long tail of apps that carplay supports and that means you have that and every other alternative does not have the one app you want so you're back to carplay the second and i think this is just tremendously important is that it is using your car's display is just a second monitor and so all of the logic all the application is running on your phone which has enough processor and enough RAM and a fast cell connection.
14:54Nilay Patel: And so the computer is good. Yep. Like that's it. And every car maker under specs the processor and RAM and everything else in their car. So you like can't compete with a new iPhone with any car. You just can't do it. Maybe Rivian and Tesla can do it. But I think everybody has the same questions about performance of those systems over time. Sure. Apple is like very, they know that this is what they win on. This is why you have a$300 Apple TV. It has more horsepower than any TV app developer can possibly know what to do with, except for the one or two game vendors who think they're going to make it happen on there, right?
15:32Nilay Patel: Yeah. What are you doing with all that power in the home view? You should just let people run their apps.
15:38David Pierce: Yeah. All the way back around to should this just be an iPad? Yes. We got so much response that essentially amounted to what if Apple had just made a really kick-ass MagSafe mount for the iPad that just worked? I'm like, yeah, that would have been the thing. Justice for the Pixel tablet. You know what I mean? Like Pixel tablet got everything right. We also missed one detail that a couple of people pointed out that I think is a very big deal, which is that the new Apple TV remote, which is easier to find, is backwards compatible. like a long way back in Apple TVs. So screw the new Apple TV, just buy the new remote.
16:17David Pierce: I think that's what I did with the last Apple TV. They just got me on the remote upgrade cycle. Remotes and polishing cloth are how Apple really gets me.
16:27Nilay Patel: I feel like I've upgraded my Apple TV remote more often than my iPad.
16:32David Pierce: Shit, that might be true. I agree with that. I've bought a lot of Apple TV remotes now that I think about it. It's like those and left AirPods are the other thing I upgrade all the time. All right, we should switch. we should talk about some AI news. The big news of this week was that Google released Gemini 4 Argon, which is its sort of re-entrance at the frontier of the model race. If you remember for the last, what would you say, three or four months, the scuttlebutt in the AI industry has been that Google fell behind with Fable and with Mythos and all of the stuff that OpenAI and Anthropic were doing, that they were way out in front and they had essentially left Google behind.
17:14David Pierce: Google then shows up with Gemini 4 Argon, which it says is just as good as those other models. It's also vastly cheaper and it has sort of announced itself back at the front of the race. Robert Hart on our team also wrote a great piece this week pointing out that Meta, which just released a model called Wonderful, which is, I don't like Meta. Well, it's Meta, it's Wonder.
17:35Nilay Patel: It's Muse Wonder. And then there's the big one, the full one, which is Muse Wonderful.
17:40David Pierce: yeah but they did wonderful and i don't i don't like that it's like it's like i just don't like it everything about meta and ai is a little too cute and oddly a little too sexy yeah it's got like a little bit of an ass on it you know but anyway um what what do you make of some of the news of this week it does feel like there is this sort of renewed sense of real competition in this space for the first time in a minute even as all these companies are reckoning with questions about safety and trying to figure out the product stuff like this who is winning at models race does kind
18:13Nilay Patel: of feel like it's back on did you watch uh zuckerberg and alexander wang on the cheeky pint podcast i mean everyone watched zuckerberg drink the guinness i was gonna say we all saw
18:22David Pierce: the meme of him enjoying it quote unquote enjoying a beer i watched bits and pieces of the interview
18:27Nilay Patel: but not a not a ton of it why uh i'm i'm fascinated where meta is right now so i watched most of that interview uh as always it's it's very fun to watch zuckerberg talk about communication styles so i think they asked him about wang's like tweets with the butts and zucker was like well you have to be authentic and i was like is that is that actually what you think um butts are who i am it's like authenticity all right whatever um anyway there's a part of that where zuck in particular was talking about the bet they made on training their own model and wang was like we need our own reasoning model and at one point inside of meta that was like frowned upon and he was like i think we're gonna fail i think we're making the wrong bet and he convinced zuck to do it and he like we're gonna write a 200 million dollar check we don't know if this is gonna pay off and zuck was like but we have to because we are a full stack technology company we need to control the thing that powers our experiences and so meta just in yeah in like zuckerberg fashion was like we're just gonna win we're just gonna do this until it's clear that we shouldn't anymore sign our metaverse right like but this we need to have this technology in order to make Muse work.
19:36Nilay Patel: And the dynamic there that I think is utterly fascinating is they launched the consumer product that people are interested in without the more powerful model. Yeah. And then now, if you pay them money, you'll get Muse Wanderer and over time, I think they'll figure it out. But Meta is a consumer products company. They're good at it. You can feel a lot of ways about Meta. But again, I will come back to the Oculus Quest 2 was a great consumer product. They are good at defining a consumer product, marketing it, making it a good consumer experience, and then ruthlessly incentivizing it with Instagram ads.
20:11Nilay Patel: Whatever it is, but they're good at it. And I think it's very interesting that their priority was launching the product that was interesting that made investment in the model seem worthwhile. Right? So they need a reasoning model because they want Muse to be more capable. But they were happy to be like, Muse is finished. we can give it to people with the capabilities it has today and then over time it will get more capabilities the same way i don't know the iphone come came out and then they were like oled screens and the iphone changed and now they're like folding oled screens and the iphone changed right but the product like made a promise and kept it i think google is releasing all these models left and right and they have no idea what their product should be right to the extent that open ai and Anthropic have products in market.
20:58Nilay Patel: They've both figured out that their products are enterprise products. They are business software companies, as you keep calling them. And they're more powerful models. I love that everyone's demo case for all these models is like, it can use Blender so well. And it's like five people in the world need this capability. I'm sure they're very enthusiastic, but they haven't made the consumer products. And Meta is the one that has truly figured out, okay, there's a flywheel here between our consumer product and our massive investment in the models and what that will enable the consumer product to do.
21:34Nilay Patel: And it's great that there's a race on the frontier, but I think that's fun and interesting. It's just, man, none of these companies apart from Meta have put it forward. Even Dots from OpenAI is enterprise software. I saw Casey talking about how much he loves dots the other day. And he's like, I run a business now and I do business stuff with my dots. And I was like, very few people are in that position.
21:58David Pierce: Sure. And that's well and good, right? The idea of these things being business software is good and fine and is going to be very successful. I've been reading Kevin Roos' book, The AGI Chronicles. It's very good. It's really, really good. And there's a point he makes very near the beginning that there were kind of two big ideas about AI that are also sort of two big ideas about AI products. And one is, do you make narrow AI to solve narrow problems, right? Like, do you build and train and refine a model to do English to French translation? You can do it very well, but it is very specific and very narrow.
22:35David Pierce: or do you do the big, huge one model to rule them all approach, which is much harder and requires vastly more compute, but that these researchers found over and over would actually over time outperform the narrow models. And he ties this to Google as a company, which looked at AI for a really long time as a way to make its existing products better. And it's like, okay, we need this new way of doing translation to improve Google Translate. And we can do really great summarization. Oh, that's going to be so useful for Gmail. and they looked at these things and they said, we have a set of products.
23:06David Pierce: How can we poke AI at them? And you can still see that inside of Google. Even now, Gemini is a product. Google is bad at understanding how to talk about Gemini as a product. And so it just exists kind of outside of itself while most of its energy is focused on how do we put Gemini into your Gmail and into your Google Docs and how do we beat you over the head with it every time you use one of our products so that we can put AI in there. And in some ways that makes a lot of sense. You get a huge distribution victory. Google has all of these business clients. Gemini 4 is much cheaper than some of the other ones, which is a big deal that doesn't get talked about a lot.
23:46David Pierce: But like these frontier models are very expensive and Google is running a promotion where they're I think 80 % cheaper than the comparative models. Like that's a big deal. But there is no sense to me. I have no belief that Google is even capable of doing what Muse did, which is one entire new thought about how people are going to use AI. It's so telling that Google tried to build this thing backwards out of Gmail rather than start with something wholly new.
24:18Nilay Patel: Oh, no, I think it's even worse than that. Google announced Gemini Spark at I.O. Yeah. They announced the product. They had the other product, the browser use product. I forget what it's called that they canceled. Mariner, yeah. and they that's what should be inside of Gmail sure what do these products what do agentic products truly need they need access to your email if you were to break it all down what is the number one thing they need to be as effective as everyone wants them to be
24:46David Pierce: they want your email this is a total diversion can I tell you my favorite new thing that's happening in Muse I play fantasy football I'm in two leagues and every uh every monday night i get a report on how the week went and then every wednesday i get uh the like waiver report on who picked up and dropped players so now five days a week maybe i get some kind of update from muse with fantasy football advice yeah i never asked it to do this pure engagement bait it's incredible it just reaches out and it's like hey here's who i think you should pick up off the waiver wire and i'm like i didn't you and i have never talked about football Have you told it to stop doing that?
25:26David Pierce: No, I haven't. I'm sort of enjoying it, to be honest.
25:28Nilay Patel: Well, so Meta is good at consumer products. They're good at engagement bait. They're good at making you come back and use the thing again. They're good at notifications. Like, they're good at this. Yeah. Really, really good at this. Talking about AI is so much like talking about a dream you had. Like, the stakes are so low for everyone else. And for you, it's like, I almost died. No, you didn't. You're fine. You're sitting right here talking about when you were asleep. anyway so uh mine is constantly digging again i gave it my spam email so it's always doing the same kind of engagement yeah and i told it to stop i was like i want you to stop proactively reading my email i just want updates on the three things that we agreed on which are mostly like did i get a class action notice right did you fill it out uh just make me the like cheapest money you can make uh and it won't stop and i was like you have to stop and i was like i want you to pay me $200 every time you proactively read my email.
26:20Nilay Patel: That's right. And it is still trying to figure it out. Like it is just in the background, somewhere at Meta, some data center is just spinning cycles, trying to figure out how to do this. It has not done more proactive email reading.
26:33David Pierce: Somebody's like, how has this one user used 11 billion tokens, but he hasn't prompted us in two weeks. It's still going.
26:39Nilay Patel: It's still, every now and again, like, do you figure out this scheme where you're going to stop proactively reading my email? It's like, I'm still figuring out how to make money. Let me know when you've done it.
26:47David Pierce: It's very good.
26:48Nilay Patel: The Roost book is good. It is fun to read. All these people truly hate each other. Kevin had a book party in New York, and I saw him speak at it, and he said the book could have been titled Fuck That Guy. That's a really good book. Because, like, they all truly hate each other. Yeah. And it is very true that Google in particular has the innovator's dilemma. All of its products are huge. They all throw off a lot of cash. They can't disrupt them too much. there isn't a business model for consumer ai yet they haven't figured it out and so they're they're trying to just increment all of those products and they really should just put gemini in gmail and be like be honest read your email and send you some notifications on what to do and i think they're they're terrified of doing that right like i i whereas the upside for meta if they get it right is sky high yeah so we'll see but i that to me is i'm just looking at yes it's great that the frontier models are pushing out there.
27:45Nilay Patel: It's great that CNBC in the morning now, the very straight-laced morning anchors on CNBC are like, RSI is coming and then we'll all be dead. Weird. It's weird that that has permeated the consciousness because of the capabilities of these models. The products are still not there. I think it is worth giving Meta some credit. They figured out a consumer product before anyone else did. And if you look at the home view, you're kind of like, well, I know what that thing should look like. Yeah.
28:12David Pierce: I have to assume that right now at Google, there is either a furious effort to buy instinct at almost any price, or a furious effort to build that exact thing. Because Google has every single bit of necessary infrastructure to have built an AI bot that works in your messaging app, and didn't do it and lost. And like, at some point, the bidding war for that company is going to be outrageous. And I suspect that is happening as we speak. Two more quick things we should talk about before we get off the AI train. One is, are you caught up on this weird story about the OpenAI employee like planting a bug in one of the conference rooms?
28:50David Pierce: I don't have anything to say about this story. I just think it's wild.
28:53Nilay Patel: I mean, it's a great story. The part that really got me was he tried to hide it with toilet paper, but tell the rest of the story.
28:59David Pierce: Okay, so as I understand it, basically, OpenAI discovered that an employee had planted a bug in one of their conference rooms ostensibly to record and take trade secrets. This is one of the like important conference rooms that not even everybody has access to. They planted it behind the TV in the USB port, which I think is just a really funny way of just totally dooming the idea of USB ports on television. Like we got to get power from somewhere. It's a really good place to hide a recording device. I'm just saying like I'm not condoning it, but if you're going to put it in a room, that's probably the place to put it.
29:36David Pierce: So anyway, this person has been arrested. said, there's been a bunch of information that has come out about, you know, they booked a one way plane ticket out of the country. Lots of this story left to tell, I think. But this is also like OpenAI is embroiled in a lawsuit with Apple over the allegation that they're stealing trade tickets from Apple that is like an official part of their interviewing process. Like the secretiveness and the value of those secrets in this industry, I think is just starting to create a huge mass of these stories.
30:08Nilay Patel: Okay, so first of all, the OpenAI guy, he used his wife's chat GPT account to find ways to hide a recording device. This is the best fact in this entire story. I didn't know that. The FBI found that it was his wife's account, which was obviously tied to him in some way. They'll never catch me. And he was like, what are the best ways to hide a tracking mark? Like incredible facts in this story. And then he had booked a flight to Saudi Arabia after he'd planted the device. So he was trying to, a one-way ticket with the family back to Saudi Arabia. Just very, very good. And then I mentioned the toilet paper.
30:45Nilay Patel: They found a thumb drive size recording device, and he had for some reason wrapped it in toilet paper and stuck it in the TV. Yeah.
30:53David Pierce: Listen, you're the TV guy. Can you explain this one to me? It feels worse. I feel like if I walk in and I see a thing in the TV, I assume it's there. If I see a thing in the TV wrapped in toilet paper, now I have questions.
31:07Nilay Patel: I do feel like there's an element of this where he used his wife's chat sheet account and it hallucinated ideas about how to hide thumb drive. And it was like, no one will ever notice if you're having a toilet paper, when what he should have done is gotten a label maker and printed out like ETH three and just like, you know what I mean? That's good. Right. Like some other thing, like I lock, like he should have printed, like, you know, the I lock dongle or just write the name of the conference room on it and then plug it in. It does.
31:33David Pierce: Everybody will just assume it's supposed to be there. Exactly.
31:35Nilay Patel: you just like whatever the conference room like ours at vox media were always named after cities which is very confusing uh-huh so you would just print like chicago on it and just like plug it in there it's like it's like well it must it must belong here but the number of times at our company when people would be like i'm in new york city and they're like yeah i know
31:54David Pierce: not new information guys but yeah that's a good story we'll track that that one as it comes um The one other one really quick is Character AI, which is a company we haven't talked about a ton on this show, but was one of the early what if the AI bot was your best friend slash sexual partner kinds of companies. Filed bankruptcy, it turns out in that process was under investigations stemming from a kid who committed suicide not that long after talking with its bot on Character AI. this investigation found or was in the middle of finding some pretty alarming stuff. But now in a really interesting way, there are lots of questions, including one of the questions we asked on the site, which is what happens to all of this data now, right?
32:41David Pierce: Like what happens in a bankruptcy proceeding is it is basically shipped for parts and sold. And presumably one of the parts is going to be vast quantities of user data, including about children. This is kind Kind of the first one of these that has gone through this at this sort of scale. We also, I think 404 Media had a really good story about the finances that go into this and just the unbelievable amounts of money that are being burned in all of these companies. But this is like, this is a tiny case study of what I suspect is going to be a lot of companies that burn through a lot of cash and have a lot of user data and are going to just go belly up out of nowhere.
33:20Yeah.
33:21David Pierce: And what happens after that? I don't know that anybody knows yet.
33:23Nilay Patel: Well, Character AI was kind of doomed in the middle of its story, right? It was started by Noam Shazir, who was one of the early LLM engineers at Google. It was, like, very frustrated that Google wouldn't do a chatbot. So then he left to do Character AI because he thought everyone was going to fall in love with LLMs. And then Google did a reverse aqua hire, right? And they brought him back. And so, like, Character AI is like dead man walking because Google just, like, hired the team out from under it. Fair, yeah. And so, like, it was always like, what are you going to do with this? I think that 404 docs, the bankruptcy docs that they reported on, they were making like a million dollars in revenue.
33:56Nilay Patel: Like it was like nothing against all of the spend that they'd taken to start the company. So at some point, they should have been actively trying to manage what happens to this user data because it was just abundantly clear when Google did the acquihire, this company was going to die. Yeah. Like when I'm talking about there's no consumer products, like your kids can illegally bang a chatbot is not a consumer product. No.
34:22David Pierce: But these companies are also in a position of they're running so fast and they're burning so much cash and like every day is an existential crisis in so many ways that this will not be the last company that didn't think hard enough about basic stewarding of that stuff.
34:38Nilay Patel: And I think a good question is how valuable is this user data? So the other thing that was on my mind is like Spirit Airlines went out of business and there was an auction for their corporate data. Right. Because if you have a bunch of data about ticket booking and flight schedules and itinerary and overbooking and feed and just like the operations of an airline, that's really valuable if you're trying to train a model that can do other enterprise tasks. You have a bunch of user data that's like, do you love me? Like they already stole all of Tumblr. Like they don't need more of it. You know? You would hope.
35:11Nilay Patel: So I think we're going to find that there's markets for different kinds of data as more and more of these companies go under. And we see what happens to more and more of them. But yeah, I mean, should there be a federal privacy law that protects user data when companies like this go out of business? They probably should.
35:26David Pierce: Yeah, agreed. All right, that's enough AI talk for one day. Let's get on to something less controversial, which is the state of social media and X. But first, let's take a quick break. We'll be right back. Are you a pet owner?
35:40Nilay Patel: Every six seconds, a pet owner in the U.S. gets hit with a vet bill over$1 ,000. Always an unwelcome surprise. That's where Fetch comes in.
35:50David Pierce: Fetch is the most complete pet insurance for dogs and cats, according to consumeradvocate.org. You get paid back up to 90 % of vet bills at any vet in the U.S. and Canada, with claims paid back in as little as two days. Go to fetchpet.com slash save right now for your free quote. That's FetchPet.com slash save.
36:17Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from AWS AI. AWS AI is powering transformation across the world's leading organizations, moving AI from possibility to production at scale. Like how AWS AI helps Formula One turn race day data into real-time insights that bring fans closer to the action. or how it helps Booking.com personalize every trip for travelers around the world. AWS AI is even transforming how things get built, helping Siemens power the production of smarter cars. Across industries, AWS AI is helping businesses innovate faster, lead with confidence, and transform what's possible today. AWS AI is how.
37:00Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Bitwarden. October is Cybersecurity Awareness Month, And here's an upgrade that actually gives you something back, time. With fewer password resets, less typing thanks to autofill, and no more trying to remember which variation of your dog's name you used this time. Bitwarden is the trusted open source solution for passkey, password, and secrets management. It makes secure password management available to everyone, with a free forever plan for individuals. That way, all users have a reliable way to create, manage, and autofill strong and unique passwords across accounts and devices.
37:36Nilay Patel: Bitwarden uses end-to-end encryption to protect vault data, while secure autofill helps reduce phishing risk by matching credentials to the right sites, giving users greater peace of mind when logging in. Bitwarden is trusted by over 15 million users and 80 ,000 businesses across 180 countries and 50-plus languages. Get started with a basic free plan for individuals or protect your business today with a free trial. This Cybersecurity Awareness Month, check out Bitwarden. Visit bitwarden.com to get started.
38:12David Pierce: All right, we're back. Neil, are you an ex? I actually, I realize I don't know the answer to this question.
38:19Nilay Patel: I check it every day now. There's a lot of AI conversation there, and I think it is important to see primary sources. Every now and again, I will snarkily reply to someone who is racist and remind them I'm from Wisconsin.
38:33David Pierce: it's actually the thing that's the thing i do i would say that's a reasonably representative use of x so that's pretty good so we're gonna have this whole conversation i just want everyone that is my experience of x yeah that's that's fair um i bring this up because over the last really couple of months now there's been this slow sort of steady drip of people with some mix of fiery resolve and their tail between their legs going back to x if you if wind like three years ago maybe four years ago kind of in the in the 12 months after elon musk bought twitter and started to ruin it and turn it into x uh a lot of people performatively left the platform announced they were leaving the platform renounced their support for this place i am one of these and left i left quietly i this was made this choice was made easily for me because i left on parental leave in december of 2022 which happened to be a really great time to stop tweeting and i just i never i never posted about it i just never went back um but i think like the the verge has explained in public how we feel about x but then recently so i think um the first one that really came across my radar was mac stories um where where john and federico two of the folks at mac stories decided that they were going to go back to x and start posting um that caused a mini revolt not even a mini revolt right they lost a bunch of their staff people got really mad at Yeah, full-scale revolt.
40:00David Pierce: People are very upset. And then just in the last week or so, our friend Casey Newton on Platformer wrote that he is now going to start posting on X again. And then our friend John Gruber wrote about basically that X is the thing again. I don't know John's particular stance on posting on X, but he pointed out basically that X is still the best social network. No, wait, hold on. That's not, that's not.
40:29Nilay Patel: sure in of its kind no i well this compare in the universe of social networks in the category of
40:36David Pierce: things that look like twitter the total the title of his post is x once again marks the spot and he basically says mastodon is a wasteland blue sky lost threads is like an empty space filled with
40:50Nilay Patel: right but what are those things those are all things that look like twitter it's like you won the academy award for best sound design and a feature film about dinosaurs like yes sure that in your category you might but best social network is a whole different thing sure sure radically
41:05David Pierce: different thing sure different between twitter and the twitter clones the there was a there was a everybody believed they were leaving for something else lots of people loudly talked about how they were leaving for something else again i'm one of those people and people are are are slinking back
41:21Nilay Patel: some people how do you feel about this uh i feel like meta really blew it with threads they have a legitimately bigger product with more people and they are so anti-news and anti-real-time feeds that they just lost they they what katie nautopals calls it the gas leak social network she's a great writer business insider um uh it you go on there and it is just the weirdest algorithm with the weirdest engagement bait people getting things wrong on purpose left and right um old tweets from like a hundred years ago being re-farmed for engagement everything that's wrong about meta is is just in your face on threads yeah they have some of the most interesting product design ideas about what a twitter like can and should do yep i haven't done this yet but if you're a podcaster you can have your podcast card appear between all of your posts on threads.
42:17Nilay Patel: They have some real-time NBA chat stuff going on. Their product ideas are good. Meta's a good consumer product company. Their algorithm ideas are so weighted to engagement that it doesn't matter. Yes. And it is by far bigger than X. By far. We'll set Blue Sky and Macedon aside for many minutes and we can come back to them. X has decided to win in one category and I think this is why everyone's confused and angry, they have decided to win an AI conversation and tangentially venture capital circle conversation. Sure. If you are a VC and you would like to talk about how smart you are in the company of other VCs, do I have a platform for you?
43:03Nilay Patel: If you are interested in AI and what it can do and being excited about the future of software development, boy, do I have the platform for you. In almost every other case, X is irrelevant. it. And I was talking to Casey about it because he and I shared a revulsion to X at the beginning. And his point, which I think is valid, and I will come to why I think it's valid, is if you want to cover the AI industry, you have to be in the rooms that they are in. And X is that room, far and away that room. If you want to cover almost anything else, you might not have to be in that room. And so all the people that you are talking about are tech journalists who want to talk about AI and converse about AI and like knock their ideas around and then go home and write about AI or make AI podcasts or whatever it is.
43:50Nilay Patel: Sure. And so all of the principles in the tech industry are on X. That's what they've chosen. And they've chosen it for good reasons or bad reasons. Maybe John Ternus just doesn't want Elon Musk to yell at him. Maybe they all just hate Zuck more than they hate Elon. Right? Like Blue Sky is not big enough. Fair enough, man. They're making whatever choices they're making. And if you're a reporter, I think it's really important to go look at primary sources. For better or worse, the primary sources of the conversation are on that platform. That's what I look at every day. I do not feel the need to participate in that conversation.
44:26Nilay Patel: I'm not into giving our work away for free, as people know, especially to people who don't value my literal existence. And there are a lot of people on x who do not value my existence my my experience with x is uh racial slurs that it's just a thing that happens to me when i post on it because people hate wisconsin they hate wisconsin i mean there's like podcasts next are called like the indian question like yeah we're like two percent of the fucking population like we're fine yeah we're just all smarter and hotter than you okay um uh i'm sorry uh but like that that is real and i i have a lot of friends who don't see it they're not experiencing that part of it sure i think that's that's happening here.
45:03Nilay Patel: But I do think if you are a tech journalist, you ought to go look at the primary sources. And if your experience on Blue Sky is kind of like mine, I started to worry that I was just looking at screenshots of X curated by other people. Yeah. By people who are mad. By people who are mad. And the reason I set those aside is I think those platforms should succeed. I think that there's some great value in federated social networks and open social networks. and maybe Blue Sky's point is never to run Blue Sky. It's to enable a bunch of other things to operate. Maybe Mastodon's point is to never really be big.
45:38Nilay Patel: It's just to be the network of things that are on ActivityPub and one day figure out how to interact with Reds, which is just like a holy war. That is all technology. It is not the consumer experience of where are the important people talking. And in this one field in tech, they are all talking on X. I understand it. I have a lot of friends besides John and Casey and all those people who are like, well, I have to go look at it. But here's my counterexample, and I'm curious what you think about this. It is, we are 20 days, 19 days away from the midterm elections. X is irrelevant to the election.
46:13Nilay Patel: It is just not a factor in this election. There was an entire right-wing conspiracy theory about James Tallarico being in a mental institution. In Ohio. In another world, X would have just horse-powered this into existence. Right. We've all experienced this in various elections where the wildfire of an ex-political conspiracy theory became the assignment editor for the entire media. Just didn't happen. Just fizzled. The idea that our candidates are arguing on X or issuing policy positions on X or reacting to X is nowhere in this cycle. And that's the counterpoint.
46:53David Pierce: okay i i fear you just picked the worst example because the talarico thing did actually kind of escape containment and it did force the times to do the piece where they went and like looked at his ring camera records to make sure that he was home and like this one hit but it's totally disagree with you i mean it's there i can show you the coverage like the the idea that random people on twitter get to assign the mainstream media what to do remains in existence it's just there it's not nearly as often but it's still there and i do i think one really but not in a
47:27Nilay Patel: way that breaks through right like uh in the in the last presidential election they're eating the dogs they're eating the cats sure just concocted out of nothing on x until it landed in a debate
47:40David Pierce: and then there's now like a rap song i agree with that and i think the thing that is most bizarre about this moment that we're in is that that kind of doesn't happen anywhere. Like in a weird way, even as so many other monocultures were breaking, Twitter stayed kind of a monoculture.
48:01Nilay Patel: So Casey's argument is that Twitter has gotten much smaller. It's much less lucrative than it used to be for sure. So we can see its financials as part of SpaceX. SpaceX is a public company now. And it's also vastly smaller. And this is why I reacted so strongly the best social network. The best social network is like Instagram reels. Well, yeah.
48:20David Pierce: Yes. Right? Or TikTok. I think there is a strong argument to be made that neither of those things even resemble social networks. But that is where people are having social media experiences. That's where they're having entertainment experiences. But this is a semantics argument we don't need to have. I take your point. And I think in a weird way, what actually happened is that we didn't replace Twitter with anything. It all just sort of died. and i'm at a point increasingly where like i i use threads more than any of the other ones um i don't really know why i just why you're so weird so blue sky blue sky is weird because everybody on blue sky is either like in violent agreement or violent disagreement in a way that i find exhausting in both directions um but everybody's mad all the time x i find just like deeply unpleasant all the people on it frankly i find deeply i just don't have a good time on x and i don't feel any obligation to post there so whatever um threads is like the sort of tamest middle ground for me and that's fine it's a place to post people can find it but there isn't like i think the idea that you have to go back to x because it is meaningful for most things is true but the thing about the ai conversation that you're missing is that the ai conversation is the most important It's the only conversation everybody is having.
49:41David Pierce: And that gives X a huge amount of power because - No, no, they did it on purpose. They made this choice. For sure. But it's, and for a long time, that was politics, right? Like they gave huge weight to political conversations. And so they elevated it onto cable news. And now it's just AI because of the people who run it. But the thing is, they called that correctly. AI is the most important conversation everyone is having right now. It's the most important conversation political journalists are having right now, right? like if you can it is like you're you're talking about the people on just offhandedly on cnbc talking about how rsi is going to kill us all like their business journal is talking about money what we do i think we are at a point now where even that one conversation is the closest thing to a universal conversation being had and it does make x powerful and i think it's a huge bummer that everybody has allowed themselves to stay on x and do that i think it has a lot to do with the fact that those the people on that platform like they're not there because x is powerful they're there because their their politics have moved in large part the same way that Elon Musk's did the same way that Mark Andreessen's did the same way that like it no one is not there with open eyes is what I'm saying uh and and you either do it feeling bad about it or you do it because these are your people and you love it but it is still powerful in that one way and that way it's very important.
51:05Nilay Patel: I'll make this distinction. I don't think any normal person should be on X. I don't.
51:11David Pierce: I don't think any normal person should be on social media, to be absolutely completely honest with you. And we'll go with text-based Twitter clone social media. There is no audience to build there. There is no community to build there because it's also dispersed and most of it is fake. I cannot sit here and make one good case for why a regular person should join Twitter, blue sky threads or mastodon well as a poster as a person who like makes things the person who views
51:36Nilay Patel: things right those are the most people are lurkers right they're just consuming there are better things to view on every other platform like or you know you can just open instagram rails yeah read a book i don't know but the i think the distinction that is getting lost in this conversation going back to x is it's a bunch of reporters the people who are describing this are reporters. And I understand why Casey's like, I didn't do the source building on threads that I was able to do on Twitter back in the day. That is a universal experience that most reporters I know are having because the sources are there.
52:12Nilay Patel: So you just got to go to the party. You just have to be in the room. I think that all of that nuance - Mike Isaac talked a lot about that, by the way.
52:21David Pierce: Mike Isaac, a reporter at the New York Times, talked a lot about basically building his profile as a reporter by being a reply guy in people's DMs.
52:28Nilay Patel: Oh yeah, absolutely. Every reporter in that period did that. We all did it. My Twitter DMs back in the day were the place to be. That's different now. The reason I'm making Instagram videos is because everyone sees them, right? Like that's just a dynamic that is true. I can talk to my phone camera for two minutes and put it on Instagram and I get a bunch of incoming because even if they're not on Blue Sky, they're definitely on Instagram. Fine. But I don't think that a bunch of reporters saying I have to go engage my sources over here is the same kind of endorsement as this platform has regained its vitality.
53:04Nilay Patel: And I think that's actually the error they're all making. If you are in tech and you want to talk about AI with other people who are building and using AI, they're all there. That's where you got it. You got to go look at it. You should reporters should look at primary sources. I believe that with all my heart. I don't think that means you have to say that like it has regained its cultural power in sports because it has not. No, it definitely hasn't. Right. And like there's something there that it's this is Casey's argument. It's powerful and it's one vertical because it has gotten smaller.
53:34David Pierce: Sure. But all that other stuff didn't go anywhere, did it? Like I do think it's possible that threads ends up going down as the biggest fumble in this whole space because it just could have done it. And there was a really funny thing this week. Connor Hayes, who is like leads product at Threads, posted, we recently made a change that could increase the posts you see from those who follow. Like Threads had to make a change to its algorithm so that when you follow somebody, you will see the things that they post. Like, what are we doing? Like everybody got so lost in the sauce of wanting to do this like content based recommendation system from TikTok.
54:16David Pierce: that they forgot how people want to talk to each other on the internet. And I think, I do think it's possible that threads may have missed its chance here, but it, boy, did it really actually have a chance to be the thing. And, and in every other vertical,
54:33Nilay Patel: except tech and AI, there's still a chance. Do you think that has a lot of money? They could just get all the sports writers to use threads. That's it. You might be, I mean,
54:41David Pierce: but I also wonder like culturally it's, it's now been three years. Maybe we've, maybe we've moved on. Maybe we don't need that thing anymore. I don't know.
54:49Nilay Patel: Look, let me zoom way out. I'm sure people will be mad at me for even suggesting that anyone can get any value from X. Fine. Like, I can't stop a network effect. And I personally do not believe that things go away if you ignore them. Right? And the network effect of the tech executives and the people building these things is on X. So if you are like, I'm not going to pay attention to you, the network effect will still be there. and they'll still have it. That's just reality. But the mainstream audience is watching video platforms. That is the thing they are doing. And they're watching the video platforms.
55:27Nilay Patel: Like every now and again, I get a video and it's just screenshots of X. And it's like, that's how I'm consuming. I'm still not at X. I'm just consuming some tweets. That is very powerful. And it's right next to the idea that instead of having a phone, you'll have a little AI Asian Tamagotchi. Sure. And I actually think the little video, the scrolly video platform is the center of gravity that will prevent X from ever fully recapturing its magic and prevent the little AI Tamagotchi from ever supplanting the phone. It's a good theory. And that to me is the real, like, sure. We can all go look at it.
56:04Nilay Patel: We can all go see Greg Josriak and John Ternus posting their home view videos on X because they all want to seem cool in front of Elon. Whatever it is. But the views for that actually happen on TikTok and Instagram.
56:18David Pierce: Yeah. There's a really interesting argument in that that suggests that scrolly vertical video is a more important format than the smartphone. But that's, I'm not ready to get into that yet. I do just want to -
56:30Nilay Patel: Whether YouTube in that conversation is a good question.
56:32David Pierce: Yeah, fair. I do just want to pick on John Gruber for just one quick second. Sure. Because he writes in this piece, and I should be clear, I think John Gruber is right about most things. I think he's so, so very wrong about this one thing. he writes the culture on x today is remarkably friendly and inclusive it is a cheerful place that cheerfulness is another differentiator is that your experience of x at all again in the
56:53Nilay Patel: context of like here's a cool new ai product that can do cool new things i think any excitement to be found is on x sure okay that's fair it is ai people cheerleading other ai people but that is something yeah right and that there's something there especially if you work in and around software you care a lot about software as john does that is exciting and fun there is there is more tech conversation that is exciting and fun on those platforms than the other twitter-like networks yeah that's fair uh he also says experience of x is nothing like an exclusive inclusive experience yeah it is like really important to say that out loud yeah yeah john
57:31David Pierce: gruber and i are both white dudes um which is a really nice thing to be on twitter um he also says without any fanfare uh x has demusked its algorithm and i would say i'm willing to bet that john gruber muted elon musk and forgot about it and now thinks that is the case because that is not my experience of x at all um do you think people should feel bad going back to x like genuinely like do you if you what is preventing you from going back and and engaging in that in a more real way it makes me feel bad you know these people i yeah i mean again i look at it
58:05Nilay Patel: several times a day because it is my job, is our job on this show to go look at primary sources and then talk about them. The fundamental job of being a reporter is not to report on someone else's reporting, but to go try to find some primary sources. And when we do report on other people's reporting, it's almost always people we trust who we know to have done that job, right? Like that's the dynamic. I think that literally the service we provide here is one, jokes. Two, we like each other and people enjoy that. And three, we curate information well. I think that's in order of what we do on this podcast.
58:43Nilay Patel: And that third thing is really important. So I want to make sure I go look at the primary sources and see the primary sources. I don't think anyone else has that responsibility. But actually contributing to that platform makes me feel bad. And other people can feel differently. Go ahead. Do what you got to do. But there's not some part where I'm like, oh, I need to look away from this. It's like, no, my job is to look at primary source information. So I'm going to go seek it out. Great. I buy that. But again, where am I putting my social media effort? Into making videos. and I'm confident that is a faster way to reach more people that I've never encountered before
59:25David Pierce: than the x algorithm it also puts your hair situation much more front and center in the conversation why do you think it's getting crazier I just imagine you like having a hairdresser on the side and you like get your camera up and you're like more and they make it higher and you're like more and they just that's that's your instagram strategy it's good stuff um all right We should take one more break and then we're going to come back. It's time for the lightning round. Be right back.
1:00:16Nilay Patel: what IDERA by Palo Alto Networks was designed to do. It's one identity platform for all, and it outshines legacy tools that were only built to manage human employees. How does it work? Well, IDERA replaces permanent permissions with dynamic access, so you can lock down every identity without slowing down your own business. With IDERA, you get unified control by replacing siloed IAM or Identity and Access Management, PAM, modern privilege access management, and governance tools, all with a single control plane. And it does that across human, machine, and AI identities. Secure every identity at your organization with IDERA by Palo Alto Networks.
1:00:57Nilay Patel: Learn more at paloaltonetworks.com slash I-D-I-R-A. Again, that's paloaltonetworks.com slash I-D-I-R-A.
1:01:13Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools, threads, and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying blind. That's the problem Jira solves. What's the goal tied to your project? What got decided last week in Slack DMs? Atlassian's teamwork graph pulls all the pieces together, from Jira, Confluence, GitHub, Slack, and more, so nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share the context with agents you already use, like Cloud, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot.
1:01:53Nilay Patel: Assign them work directly, or connect your agents through MCP. Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided and by who, and more time actually shipping with Jira. Learn more at jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com. Support for the show comes from OutShift, Cisco's incubation engine for frontier technology. You can find multi-agent AI in every enterprise roadmap right now. But here's the problem everyone's facing. Agents can pass messages but can't think together. These systems silently underperform through cognitive failures, misreadings, unverified claims, false consensus, and conventional monitoring can't detect them.
1:02:40Nilay Patel: Outshift by Cisco is building the fix with their new comprehensive resource, the Internet of Cognition. It's an open source guide that's a foundation for building multi-agent systems from design to production. The goal is to give agents shared context, shared memory, and guardrails, all to drive the results we actually expect from AI. You can lean on this resource to understand agentic AI's evolution and how it's shifted from isolated agents to orchestrated superintelligence. You can gain insights for how to future-proof your business by tackling complex challenges with multi-agent systems. You can read the paper, experience a demo, grab the code from outshift.com.
1:03:19Nilay Patel: That's O-U-T-S-H-I-F-T dot com.
1:03:30David Pierce: all right we're back it is i'm not even gonna ask i just i this one i know this one brendan broke containment in my world this week uh it's time once again for america's favorite podcast within a podcast brendan car is a dummy brendan car some dad rock
1:03:47Nilay Patel: is a dummy
1:03:52Nilay Patel: Brandon Carr
1:03:57David Pierce: is a dummy I'm so stupid
1:04:05David Pierce: little like Chicago-y vibes that time I like it it's good give me more five-part harmony singing Brandon Carr's name that's all I'm looking for that was some yacht rock that comes from Bruce Hartley who said that soft rock has been woefully unrepresented on this podcast
1:04:21Nilay Patel: Bruce Hartley little known fact played rhythm guitar for Kenny Loggins
1:04:29Nilay Patel: you know that name sounds like he did you really had me in the first half I'm not going to lie what did Brendan do this week I'm curious what broke contain for you I've got two but what did you think it's got to be the live stream execution Okay, that's one of them. We have some video of this. So let's talk about that very quickly. So Pete Hegseth announced the Pentagon would live stream an execution, which apparently he didn't tell anyone he was going to announce, including President Trump, who mostly seemed surprised by this information. Bold strategy, Pete. So we ran around and asked all the major social networks if they would carry such an execution because that is against all of their terms of service, including X, which has longstanding policy.
1:05:12Nilay Patel: And X is like very narrow and a lot of wild things happen on X. But all of them have a policy against live streaming murder. Or that kind of violent content in general. Yeah. And so most of the platforms said no. Some of them didn't respond because they didn't want to raise the eye of the president. And then the president was like, that's weird. We're going to look at it. And then they all were like, we're not going to. That's what happened. So Brendan, in the midst of all this, man loves speech controversy, goes on CNBC. And CNBC says, are you going to allow a live stream execution? What do you think about this?
1:05:50Nilay Patel: We have the clip. You can just run it.
1:05:51David Pierce: Well, I think, look, my understanding is it's not on broadcast TV. so I don't think there's a role for the FCC one way or the other there.
1:05:57Nilay Patel: But I trust Secretary Hegseth.
1:05:58David Pierce: I mean, he's implementing the laws and the regulations that are relevant to the Department of War. And I think he's doing a great job. And I trust that he's making the right call on these issues.
1:06:08Nilay Patel: Is it something that you would allow on broadcast if they wanted to?
1:06:12David Pierce: Look, I mean, ultimately, we're going to defer to Secretary Hegseth and his decisions on how to move forward with this. I'm sorry. Did he just say, I'm going to defer to Secretary Pete Hegseth on whether this is allowed on broadcast networks.
1:06:25Nilay Patel: First of all, shout out to Carl Quintanilla, buddy, for asking the most obvious question in the world. Yeah, you got to love when people ask the question. It's just like, what are you - Great job. You care a lot about content. You're always ranting and raving about the public interest. The networks don't carry the president's speeches live, and you're like, the network executives have to go to jail now. Should we lodge your execution? He's like, I don't know. I defer to the military. Weird. and then the idea that brendan is like i don't have this power because it's not broadcast television i can't weigh in on it totally belied by the fact that he wants to have the power yeah
1:07:00David Pierce: i mean my my i'm not like my i have no power here t-shirt is raising a lot of questions answered by my i have no power i'm on television saying i don't have any power here but totally everybody
1:07:12Nilay Patel: should do it yeah like my boy you wrote the project 2025 chapter on speech regulations and how you would use your broadcast power to control content moderation on platforms. I know you wrote it because your name's on it and I read it. You want to have the power, but you're like, yeah, this one's a hot potato. I don't know if it's in the public interest of broadcasting execution. I defer to Tegsa.
1:07:34David Pierce: That's also, by the way, that's the thing Brendan Carr says when President Trump has not yet declared he's in favor. Oh, he's a weasel.
1:07:43Nilay Patel: I mean, what we're describing here is cowardice. Correct. Right? Like he should be able to say, well, that seems bad, but he can't because he doesn't know what Trump is going to do. So he defers to Pete Hegseth. To Pete Hegseth. A lot there. Yeah. You know, in another world that Trump was like, we're doing this. He'd be like, I'm calling up the heads of every broadcast network and saying they have to run it.
1:08:01David Pierce: Yeah. He'd be like, Jimmy, I'm going to force Jimmy Kimmel to host the execution. Jimmy Kimmel will execute this person. Exactly.
1:08:09Nilay Patel: Cowardice, right? He doesn't even have the principles. Anyway, Trump called it off. We're not executing someone live. For like a million reasons. I think Trump was actually convinced by members of his own administration this is a horrible idea for 10 million reasons. Yeah. Including the number of people who would want to copycat it, including the number of people who would think that this is a sufficient deterrent. There's a lot of reasons we're one of the few countries in the world that still does executions. It doesn't actually deter crime. That's a different story. Okay. That's one. That's the one that broke containment.
1:08:39Nilay Patel: Can I talk about the other one? The other one that's on my list that I think is much funnier. Sure. Okay. SpaceX announced, what was it, early this week, late last week, that they're going to be going to have a major wireless carrier. Right. They've been sort of threatening to do this for a while. And this is partially Brendan. Okay. But it's partially just a winding road of Vergecast stuff. Yeah. And incompetent FCC commissioners. From every party is incompetent here. This is a bipartisan Brendan Carr is a dummy. Like, Brendan Carr, you are all Brendan Carr, people. so in trump one our we are all brendan carr t-shirt is not going to do numbers everyone at the fcc is going to be issued a i am brendan carr shirt right uh someone ai that charlie kirk song like let's go for it all right um in trump one you will recall that t-mobile wanted to buy sprint and everyone thought it was a bad idea we did endless virtual decoders about it how reducing competition in the wireless market from four carriers to three would raise prices and lower service and not be a good outcome.
1:09:46Nilay Patel: And so the Trump administration, you will recall, engineered a solution in which T-Mobile would be allowed to buy Sprint and some of Sprint's assets and spectrum would be given to Dish Network to stand up a new network called Project Gen5Sys. And this would create fear in the hearts of our network executives and they would once again compete for your dollars. I will remind you that this did not happen. In no way, shape, or form did Project JANF5s this meaningfully exist, to the point that when we covered the fact that it didn't exist, we got on-the-record emails from DISH Network Communications people that just said, our network does exist.
1:10:27Yeah.
1:10:28David Pierce: No, we did it. I have it. Look at it.
1:10:30Nilay Patel: So we sent people, it was in Vegas. Eventually it did exist in the sense that one mid-range Motorola Android phone could sometimes get it, but it mostly rolled over to AT &T's network. Yeah, they built something. It had backstop deals with AT &T and T-Mobile. Whatever. Yeah. A lot of history there if you're a VertiS fan. Project Genna 5 says, the network that was going to do it. Anyway, this failed. Dish Network declared bankruptcy, and then they did the thing that everyone thought they were going to do, which is just hoard Spectrum for several years until the value went up and then auctioned off for money.
1:11:04Nilay Patel: That is indeed what they did. there's one block of spectrum that they could not get rid of it was the 800 megahertz nextel spectrum okay because sprint once bought nextel right and it had the idon network which was the like push to talk oh yeah yeah so the idon spectrum has been sitting around for ages no one wants it again in all of this project gen5 sys noise this just ends up sitting around and dish hasn't been able to sell forever so they flipped it to a private equity company called grain management. And guess who bought it? SpaceX. Of course.
1:11:39David Pierce: For presumably nothing.
1:11:41Nilay Patel: It's like$8 billion. They bought some other spectrum over the years. Of course, Brendan is just like waiving requirements and auction rules to, right? He's just making it happen for SpaceX. And the thing that's funny about this is that SpaceX is making all this noise about standing up a major wireless carrier and the stocks of our existing carriers are dropping And they are freaking out because what does Elon Musk represent for them? Actual competition. Right? The idea that people will like Starlink more than their existing service is just reality for them. Nobody likes their wireless carrier.
1:12:16Nilay Patel: This is why you need competition in the market. Whether or not Elon can actually build a cell network using all of this spectrum that can compete nationally with T-Mobile and AT &T and Verizon without roaming agreements with those companies, which have basically said they're not going to allow them to roam because they don't want real competition. Like, they're afraid. Oh, yeah. And whether any of that will be cost-effective in the end is, like, irrelevant to the fact that Brendan got to do some waivers and finally get some Spectrum sold to his buddy Elon Musk. So we'll see. I'm very curious. I think they have some interesting plans around using small dishes connected to Starlink and using Starlink as the backhaul for this new network.
1:12:55Nilay Patel: But they've got to get phones to support their new Spectrum. Big question. They say most funds already do, but big question about battery life, performance, coverage, all this stuff. They obviously have to launch 15 ,000 new satellites, Gen 2 Starlink satellites, to support this new network. And they got to build some terrestrial network. This is a lot of network to build. Yeah. While the carriers are, like, actually afraid for the first time in their lives. That is all because in Trump 1, everyone allowed T-Mobile to buy Sprint and destroy competition for ages. This is all Project Gen5Sys' fault somehow.
1:13:31Nilay Patel: Starlink Mobile, if it comes into fruition, is the true Project Gen5Sys.
1:13:36David Pierce: Yeah. So, okay, there have been rumors for a while now that SpaceX is going to build a phone. Does this make you think it's more or less likely that SpaceX is building a phone?
1:13:46Nilay Patel: What kind of rebranded mid-range Android phone preloaded with X? They're going to take a Trump phone that no one sold. They're going to buy all of the unused inventory of Trump phone, paint it gray, and call it the SpaceX phone.
1:13:59David Pierce: It's going to be so sick.
1:14:01Nilay Patel: Well, see, again, the wireless market needs more competition. And even the presence of a real competitor has these companies shaking in their boots. Yeah, and Starlink, SpaceX. The notion of a competitor is a real thing.
1:14:13David Pierce: Especially one with the resources and brand and the history of SpaceX, right? Like this is not some upstart trying to lay fiber. This is a company with real resources to go do kind of whatever it decides to do. But then there's also rumors that SpaceX and Tesla are going to merge in some meaningful... Like, this company is going to get way more nuts before it ever figures out how to sell you a smartphone, would be my guess. Yeah.
1:14:39Nilay Patel: We did an entire decoder on this with Walter Pysik from Light's Adventures. He's deep in it. That's coming out soon. But I just want to call this out. This is, we've done a lot of monkeying in the mobile market with Spectrum over these past 10 years. And a lot of it is we're still feeling the aftershocks of allowing T-Mobile to buy Sprint, which has potentially created this opportunity. But we have never really focused on are these markets competitive? And maybe this will happen, but I suspect everyone is going to learn that building a network is much more expensive than it seems. Enough to have killed Dish Network, as it turns out.
1:15:14Nilay Patel: Yeah, although I'm not sure that took that much. But here we are. Project Genopolisis. Yeah. All right, take us out of Brendan. All right. Brendan, if you would like to explain any of your spectrum allocation decisions or your rank cowardice, you're available to join our show. We are not regulated by you here on the internet, so I've been told. So I think we would have a free-flowing and respectful debate. Don't you, Brendan? What could possibly go wrong? looking forward to that's been Brendan Carr's Dummy America's favorite podcast Brendan Carr is a dummy
1:15:54David Pierce: I feel like that cleanses me of Brendan every time it's like I'm just immersed in Brendan and then and then I am we gotta make a Spotify playlist I agree um all right my first lightning round item is about smartphone sales um one of the things we've been talking about a bunch on this show is what the rising price and lowering availability of RAM is doing to the smartphone market, in particular what it's doing to cheap phones, the answer is it's bad for everybody. So CounterPoint, which is a research firm, put out a report this week that said the global smartphone market declined 20 % year over year in Q3 of 2026, which is its lowest Q3 level in 14 years.
1:16:31David Pierce: 14 years. Wow. This is how low smartphones are. A couple of interesting things happened. So everybody is down. I should just say that. But relatively speaking, Samsung and Apple took an even larger share of the smartphone market, um, up from let's see 37 % to about 45%. So that's a, that's a big jump in two companies owning the smartphone market. Um, everybody's prices went up. Uh, one thing that counterpoint found is that there has been robust early demand for the Z fold eight, which is really interesting. This passport-sized foldable thing seems to be the thing. It's working for Samsung. It appears it's going to work for the iPhone Duo.
1:17:14David Pierce: It's just interesting that that is actually now starting to turn. Everybody's prices are up. Everybody's focusing on smaller things. But basically, the ongoing thing here is just that cheap phones are completely disappearing. Everybody is getting for... There's a line that says they're prioritizing margins by shifting supply from thinner margin segments to higher return markets and models, which means they are ditching cheap phones and pushing towards more expensive phones. And they're raising the prices on those more expensive phones because they can. Because people who pay a lot for their phone will pay a little more for their phone.
1:17:49David Pierce: And I think this market is just getting bleaker and bleaker. And there are a bunch of explanations for it, right? One is the rising costs. one is that i think you can make a good argument that there have not been a lot of interesting phones in the last several years and so people are holding onto their phones longer there are fewer compelling reasons to upgrade it'll be interesting to see if the foldable thing can flip that but like the smartphone market had so much relentless growth for so long and that relentless growth in enormous scale changed every other tech industry in its wake like my laptop the google book exists because of the smartphone supply chain like it it and in every way um and and that is just quarter by quarter being unwound kind of right in front of our eyes yeah everything is an android phone yeah and and now android phones are more expensive it's like yeah that's the it is it is going to come for everybody i look everyone wants there to be the next thing
1:18:44Nilay Patel: the next wave of growth i think this sign of maturity in the smartphone market is actually very healthy right like it is it has not been necessary to upgrade your phone every year every two years for quite some time okay and i'm sure sales are down i think the refurbished market is actually really healthy right like there's something here where like it's not necessary to get the newest thing and we're probably going to see a lot of demand for refurbished remanufactured all those devices all of that attention should go elsewhere it has all been locked up in the in app stores and app taxes, a lot of innovation has been held back because the economics of putting an app on a phone have just held back innovation.
1:19:28Nilay Patel: And we've covered every variant of this for years and years in the show. If something else happens, I think that's good.
1:19:35David Pierce: I've actually been hearing, this is mostly just anecdotal at this point, but I've heard it a few times now that there are people doing hardware startups who not very long ago couldn't even get their emails answered because these companies were just busy making giant scale smartphones for everybody. And if you weren't in the smartphone business, they would have to like redo their tooling and factory systems. And it just wasn't worth it. They were all just focused on making phones that now there is interest and energy and availability to build other stuff that there is suddenly like manufacturing capacity in this world that there was not, not very long ago.
1:20:11David Pierce: And it's made some people optimistic that like, we're the stuff is expensive it's hard to get especially if you need a lot of ram but we we can build things in a way that if you weren't building a smartphone it was very hard to build things not that long ago yeah
1:20:24Nilay Patel: the danger is that it's easier to build things that are essentially like underpowered android phones yeah and then we'll be surrounded by a lot of underpowered android phones feels like that's
1:20:34David Pierce: coming you got to put all those crappy processors somewhere so i'm saying it's like everything's an android phone really cuts both ways huh indeed uh what's your next lightning round item
1:20:45Nilay Patel: agent warfare is here. Yes. What I've been calling the DoorDash problem has arrived at scale. JPMorgan Chase, Jamie Dimon, announced that he doesn't want agents running on his platform. Bank of America announced that. We've heard it from Amazon isn't letting GrokBot on. So Elon is tweeting that he's going to build an Amazon competitor, which is just great. Is that true? I missed that. That happened today. And it got covered. And it's like, I don't think Elon's going to build an Amazon competitor. I got to be honest with you. Oh, God. I think he likes tweaking Jeff Bezos, but I don't think he's going to build a logistics network.
1:21:17David Pierce: I really hope he builds it. I hope he calls it Grokazon. And it will just make my life a little bit worse.
1:21:25Nilay Patel: If you thought the romance authors of America were mad at Amazon, just you wait until Grokazon shows up. It's here, right? The idea that agentic commerce is going to upend the world in some way is here. and I think one of the most fascinating lines of debate here is whether or not your computer is you and you know on the internet everyone's like well it's my computer it's my agent I just want to use your website I can use it any way I want and that's not true like just because it happens on the computer doesn't mean it's not happening right like people are allowed to like you can't go to the bank and be like I'm gonna come in here fully naked and just like smash a rubber chicken on the counter three times that means you have to give me money Right.
1:22:09Nilay Patel: They can be like, no, actually we, we prefer interact with our staff in a certain way. Private business. Yeah. Yeah. Right. You can't be like, here's what I'm going to do. I'm going to put together a remote controlled car and I'm going to drive it around your bank as many times as I want until everyone leaves. I'm going to rob you. Like it's just like, you know, like I'm going to stand outside the bank with a party speaker until you come out and kiss me. Like not a choice yet online, it's like, any way I want to use your website is a free for all. And I think agents are going to bring that into the sharpest focus it's ever been.
1:22:48Nilay Patel: That actually the people on the other side of the internet connection have a say, and they're going to start to find ways to enforce that say. And I know our listeners are going to say, well, it's a cat mask game, we're going to do this forever. But like, that's why you have courts and fines. And that's why all these companies are going to end up with deals. And they're going to have a lot of incentive to both block and respect the blocks of other competitors because there will be economic terms in the middle and court cases on the side. And so I see all this blocking happening. And I guarantee you, like what Bank of America said was, we want to make sure that it's safe and we are involved in how this works.
1:23:23Nilay Patel: And they're going to just write an API for how the agents are going to use the thing instead of just like clicking around on the website. Because that was always brittle to begin with. And like giving Muse your Bank of America credentials is always a stupid idea.
1:23:36David Pierce: Well, and I mean, it's actually, I think it's really good and interesting that this is starting with banking and in particular, like consumer banking, because it is such a perfect version of the problem. That's like if Muse goes and drains my bank account, either on purpose or by accident, who am I going to yell at? And ultimately, who is responsible? So Elon announced today that if Grokot buys something without your permission, he'll refund you. Yeah, Elon Musk lies a lot. That's fair enough. It's fine. I look forward to him. The Tesla Roadster is coming out a decade later. I look forward to getting my money back in 10 years.
1:24:11David Pierce: But Bank of America, it's the sort of thing that like, this makes me think of carriage disputes with cable companies, right? Where if I don't have ESPN on my TV, my instinct is not to get mad at ESPN. It's to get mad at Comcast for not showing me the stuff that I want to watch. And this is all of the leverage that those companies have over the carriers and the distributors. And if I'm Bank of America, I'm like, okay, these things are going to make mistakes. They're going to take the money. And there are people are going to come to us wanting their money back. And they just don't want that smoke, right?
1:24:44David Pierce: And so what they're going to build is a system with controls that says things like, you cannot drain their bank account without authorization. So putting this kind of guardrail on it, this is such an obviously straightforwardly good one to do that I think it's good to start with this and then work towards the one that are more complicated. Like, should Muse be able to buy things for me on Amazon that I explicitly direct it to buy on Amazon? Interesting question. Should Muse be able to proactively, without my knowledge, spend the money in my bank account? No.
1:25:15Nilay Patel: Should Muse deliver you an engagement prompt to gamble a little bit more on Kelshi? Right. No. I think no.
1:25:22David Pierce: That one is the greatest area of all. Reasonable. Right. And so I think we are going to reckon with each one of those individually. Okay. But here's my thing about the DoorDash problem. Don't we need to rename the DoorDash problem? Because DoorDash appears to have just wholeheartedly embraced the DoorDash problem. Like DoorDash has no problem.
1:25:37Nilay Patel: They announced, I think like a while ago, they announced like a CLI integration for some agents.
1:25:42David Pierce: Okay.
1:25:42Nilay Patel: You know, all these companies, any company that moves physical products around the world is like, try. Fair. You know, like it's so hard to build that thing that they're like, yeah, your agent can come and use DoorDash and we'll just charge you more money because you don't get to see. Like DoorDash has a huge advertising business. Instacart has a huge advertising business. So they're very much like, we'll just charge you the money we would have lost if you didn't look at our ads. Right? Yeah, true. That's basically where we're at. But DoorDash is doing the other thing, which is they're trying to build their own agent.
1:26:13Nilay Patel: right like all their ai stuff is like in the doordash app for consumers and it's like i don't i don't i don't think what people want is the dash buddy or whatever it's called like i think
1:26:25David Pierce: they want to use whatever agent they want to use but can i give you a really stupid example of this that i've been thinking about a lot so there's this place there's this pizza place near us called jets uh and and jets is like it's a normal pizza place it's like a mini chain there's a bunch of them. So you can you can order online, you can call you can do whatever. But they give you a 15 % discount if you text. I don't I don't know why but you get 15 % off your pizza if you text your order. So of course I go to text my order. But remembering how to text my order is impossible, because I'm not looking at a menu, I'm looking at the messages app.
1:27:01David Pierce: And I have to remember which type of pizza it is that I want, the sizes that we get, like all, it just made me realize the beauty of a UI that is a menu that you click on. It's like, I want this thing and this thing. When I have to say out loud with no help and no visual cues, what kind of pizza I want. Remembering that what I like is an eight corner pizza is impossible for me. And this is just like, this is the thing that keeps coming up to me every time I do this is like, in theory, I'd like the idea of just being able to text like, hey get me my usual at starbucks and it orders my starbucks for me like that is the flow i'm interested in in reality having the picture there that shows the thing that i usually order and having the name of it and having the confirmation of what it is ends up being the whole experience yep and and it's just like actually ui is good here in this case i mean how
1:27:52Nilay Patel: many times are you ordering with your family and everyone needs to go look at the laptop together right yeah oh my god this is just it's a thing like yeah there's a reason that i'm not so worried about phones being displaced by AI, looking at stuff remains a powerful tool in the human experience. Yep. And like, we're going to make the screen smaller has not historically been a winning move.
1:28:14David Pierce: No. What, can I interest you in a screen that's on your kitchen counter and only CarPlay is your ass?
1:28:19Nilay Patel: It's CarPlay ass.
1:28:21David Pierce: Does that, is that something you'd be interested in?
1:28:24Nilay Patel: It's like John Turnus announced that the phone would be the new intelligent hub. and I didn't realize how far he was going to take it.
1:28:32David Pierce: Do you know what I mean? It is sort of true. Apple has been saying like the phone is the thing the world revolves around. And I think they meant that much more literally than we realized.
1:28:40Nilay Patel: Yeah, yeah, truly. It's like, well, that's where the apps are. So we'll just do CarPlay, the future.
1:28:48David Pierce: Okay, I have one more for you, which is mostly just a question, which is how do we feel about super intelligence? So President Trump makes this announcement that it is no longer artificial intelligence. It is super intelligence. And I don't know how to put this like other than this, like a bunch of cowardly babies. A lot of people in Silicon Valley followed along. They're renaming SpaceX AI, which is a stupid name for a company to SpaceX SI, which is a stupider name for a company. Salesforce is out here doing SI stuff. Everybody is just throwing in line with super intelligence on the one hand i don't care about this artificial intelligence as i've we've been talking about this on the podcast for years the idea of ai artificial intelligence as this like catch-all term for all the stuff we're talking about is actually wrong and problematic and causes lots of problems and has made it very hard to talk about a lot of this stuff so like ai as a term i don't think is any good i mostly just think it's such like weak baby nonsense that my guy posts on truth social it's super intelligence now and everybody in silicon valley goes yes wait he did write an executive order with all the power and force of an executive order yeah sure which i would point out have just about as much legal standing as a post on truth social well if you ask trump he can read the constitution
1:30:12Nilay Patel: with an executive order um here's here here let me try to give you the framework for it okay what you're mad about is the naked and rampant corruption in the tech industry and this is
1:30:22David Pierce: the best example of it it's it's so in your face what is the point of being rich and powerful if you're gonna do things like this do you know what i mean like it's they don't call it fuck you money for no reason like if i had that much money i would be such a pain in everybody's ass all the time and also i would live on a giant boat and no one would ever hear from me again what is the
1:30:44Nilay Patel: point of any of this if you're just gonna like play these games purchased the government it just came at this additional cost of a little bit of their dignity yeah that's that's real right like like there will be no ai regulations but you have to call it super intelligence and they all looked at each other and said this is gonna suck a little bit oh god i hate that that's what it is that is what happened. That's what happened. Oh, that sucks so much. Okay, keep going. I'll just say, like the thing you're offended about is corruption. Yes. And this is just the naked, stupid example of corruption.
1:31:18Nilay Patel: It's right next to Kimberly Guilfoyle who got run out of her fake job as ambassador to Greece because she asked for$100 ,000. If she'd asked for like$100 million, I think it would have been like, good job. Oh, yeah. and like it's like the embarrassing corruption is like truly embarrassing by the way it's it's susie now but that was from dress to co which is eddie isard just shout out to my eddie isard fans out there uh but that is what you're mad about you're mad
1:31:48David Pierce: about how how small and shitty it is yes and it is so small and so shitty i also think it's a bad term like that's the other problem is like we didn't we didn't even improve anything which just we're just saying super now like yeah because he doesn't scare people and it's like i think it scares people more yeah ai is at least like a term we've had like people have been talking about artificial intelligence for a hundred years at least it's a thing people understand super intelligence is just literally nothing which just drives me crazy but anyway well no
1:32:21Nilay Patel: they all want it to be super everyone should go read the kevin roose book which is just dead ahead reporting. It's very good. Like just beginning, middle end, here's what all these people said and what they were thinking about. And it is just very clear that they've been trying to build AGI from the start and they've had to hide it in like enterprise sales agreements. Very funny. Yeah. Agreed. All right. You got one more. What's your last one? My last one is just like, I just want to say this out loud. There's something very big happening with decompiling software, particularly in video games, where you can take a finished binary and decompile it with AI and then like port it to whatever platform you want.
1:32:58Nilay Patel: Xbox is going to embrace this in some way. Just go for it. But Xbox needs any idea they can. So like, that's fine. By the way, again, remind everyone, Asha Sharma, the CEO of Xbox is from Racine, Wisconsin. And I continue to have an open invitation to interview her at my high school. A thing that I have not formally asked Asha or my high school about. But if you can make this happen, we'll make it happen.
1:33:17David Pierce: I'm confident everyone involved could make this happen. I just think that'd be really fun.
1:33:21Nilay Patel: Anyway, so Xbox is embracing it. There's a lot of copyright law involved in game decomposition. You know, the various VCs on X are like, all software is over now. Right.
1:33:33David Pierce: I saw something going around that was basically like, everything is going to become open source, whether you like it or not. And I was like, first of all, I don't think you have at all reckoned with the implications of that. And second of all, don't we have like big, broad legal paradigms to prevent that from happening?
1:33:48Nilay Patel: Again, maybe this is our new catchphrase. Just because it happens on a computer doesn't mean it didn't happen. Do you know what I mean? Like it occurred and you can do things about things that occur. So for example, open source as a concept in the world exists on the framework of copyright law. Yeah. Like those licenses have effect because you have some property rights in the software you've written. And then you can write a license saying, if you want to modify this, you have to use the same license. And if you don't, I'm going to sue you for copyright infringement, for contract violation. Like all that comes from the basis of copyright law.
1:34:29Nilay Patel: So if you're like, everything is open source now. Well, you boy, have you really made copyright law very powerful. This is just like the dynamic you're in. And yes, it might mean you can look at the code and you can make your own Photoshop, but Adobe will have something to say. And the copyright law is in the Constitution as a way to create value for people who make things. And I don't think you can run into the courts and be like, well, I was able to do it. I could see it, so I did it. Screw you, George Washington. It's not going to happen that way. And so, like, I'm thinking about this a lot because you can really see the tech industry, particularly in X, which is a particular kind of bubble, is just getting away from the reality of things having cause and effect, particularly if it happens on a computer.
1:35:17Like, I can do this on a computer, so none of your old frameworks apply to me.
1:35:21Nilay Patel: And it's like, oh, that's all going to catch up to you real fast. Yes. or game decompilation is like the one where i just have not had enough time to formulate all of my thoughts but boy is i'm very curious for how people want us to talk about it how they're thinking about it but it's the it's it is absolutely the one where you know we did five years of google versus oracle yeah and all of that was about whether copy or google reusing the names of APIs in Java was infringement. And that's like five years and a billion dollars.
1:35:55David Pierce: Yeah. And this is just like, I downloaded and remade Call of Duty.
1:35:59Nilay Patel: What was it? Structure, sequence, and something. Like incredibly arcane acronyms about the organization of API names. Yeah.
1:36:10David Pierce: I do think there is something really fascinating happening here. People are building all kinds of cool stuff. They're modding games. They're making games available for other platforms that they haven't been available on. It is slightly surprising to me that Xbox is in on this because I have to imagine the gaming industry is going to throw every bit of its weight against this trend.
1:36:31Nilay Patel: I mean, Microsoft owns all those studios. That's a fair point. They're fine. They're like, no, Activision Blizzard, you love this. Like, what are you going to do? Like, they need to get those games on more platforms. Yeah. Right? Like they have some amount of, and if they do it on their terms, they might be in control.
1:36:52David Pierce: Fair. And I think there is something potentially very cool there that you're going to start to see people, like if every game becomes moddable in this way, there is some very cool stuff to be had there. It gets messy in a lot of ways in the ways that you've been describing and others, but the idea of giving, like bringing the sort of vibe coding energy to video games, at this kind of scale is pretty cool. There's a lot of cool stuff that will happen as that happens.
1:37:20Nilay Patel: Yeah, and I'm not saying I'm a particular expert on the dynamics of the game industry, but I'm pretty good at copyright and software. This one is going to be a mess. Yeah. We are looking at decades of lawsuits about whether decompiling any piece of software so that you can recompile it any way you want is acceptable or allowed or copyright infringement. Like a good question. so if i ship you an app right the ones and zeros the binary of that app that i ship you that's copyright protected right you can copyright that yeah this is my app here's the thing the code i wrote to make that app protected by copyright you can file that that's it took a decade of lawsuits to get there but you can do that if you decompile my binary and you end up with slightly different code important question right there it's probably a derivative work like you can get there but all of copyright law is on first impression.
1:38:14Nilay Patel: And so I don't know the answer to that because no court has ruled on it.
1:38:18David Pierce: Right.
1:38:18Nilay Patel: I think I probably know the answer to it, but you have to have that lawsuit.
1:38:22David Pierce: Yeah. Well, personally, I'm just thrilled to finally have a reason for you to rant about copyright on The Vergecast again. So this is great news. It's been like two whole weeks.
1:38:31Nilay Patel: I'm trying to unearth the Java lawsuit for my brain. And it's like, my own body is trying to protect me. It's like, what if you just fainted instead? All right.
1:38:42David Pierce: Well, before we do, let's get out of here. Neelight, who is on Decoder coming up?
1:38:47Nilay Patel: So we had Ben Jordan today talking about Flock. And then we have Walter Pysak talking about Starlink. And then Governor J.B. Pritzker from Illinois is on Decoder very soon. I asked him if the Bears are going to stay in Chicago. That's good. You got to use your platform for the things you can. It's the opening episode. I was like, I got to do a good job here. I have so much family in Illinois. He's like, you can be, we claim you as part of Illinois. I was like, no, no, no, sir. I'm from Wisconsin. Absolutely not.
1:39:18David Pierce: It was not what he was expecting. Did you wear your cheese head to the interview?
1:39:22Nilay Patel: I should have more than revealed my Jordan Love jersey. And then there's one coming up that's a big deal. Very excited about it. I'm just going to tease it. It'll be a big one.
1:39:34David Pierce: It's exciting stuff. We have overhead projectors on Virgin History this weekend. one of the wonkier episodes we've ever done, but it's really fun. And we had an overhead projector just blaring at me in the studio the whole time. So you'll get to watch me get progressively hotter from sitting next to an overhead projector for two hours. It's good stuff. Remember, you can subscribe to The Verge to get all of our podcasts, all the ones we've been talking about ad-free, including this one. You get all of our newsletters. You get everything we're doing. Verge.com slash subscribe. It's the best way to support all of this.
1:40:05David Pierce: And speaking of support, thank you to everybody who voted for us in the Signal Awards. By the time you're hearing this, the voting is over. I don't know if we won. We'll keep you posted. I hope we won. But mostly, I just care about all of you voting for us. And thank you to everybody who did. And if you want to get in touch about all this or anything else, you can always email us, vergecastatheverge.com. Call the hotline 866-VERGE11. The Vergecast is a Verge production and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. This show is produced by Josh Cahas, Kabir Chopra, Eric Gomez, Brandon Kiefer, and Shlava Slarchuk.
1:40:32David Pierce: We will see you next week. Nealai. Back and roll.
1:40:40David Pierce: Brussels clean up nicely at Sweetgreen. Maple glazed, roasted, and edges perfectly caramelized.
1:40:46Nilay Patel: Sweetgreen's fall harvest is back on the menu. And the season's most overlooked little green vegetable is dressed to be devoured. You know what to do. Order on the Sweetgreen app.
Well, it's been a couple of days, and David and Nilay have some more information — and a bunch of new questions — about the Apple HomeView. They also talk about the latest Gemini model, and whether building the best model matters if you can't build the best products around them. They then debate the merits of returning to X, why none of the supposed Twitter replacements worked, the latest in Brendan Carr nonsense, and more.
Further reading:
HomeView doesn’t natively support any video apps yet — not even Apple’s
Apple’s new Find My-compatible remote will also work with your old Apple TV
The AI race is back on
Google finally releases Gemini 4 Argon
Google brings its AI coding platform to its Gemini app on Mac.
Google makes it easier to launch your vibe-coded apps
OpenAI employee arrested for allegedly planting a bug in a conference room
OpenAI claims an ex-employee took its product plans and presented them to Apple
Now that Character.AI is going bankrupt, what happens to all of its users’ data?
Daring Fireball: X Once Again Marks the Spot
Platformer: Does intelligence need a hard cap?
SpaceX announces plan to become a ‘major mobile carrier’
JPMorgan Chase is keeping AI agents out.
Xbox is officially embracing the chaos of AI-powered game ports
Global smartphone sales just hit a 14-year low.
Silicon Valley is falling in line with Trump’s attempt to rename AI
The US government launched a “Super Intelligence” website.
Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters, and our ad-free podcast feed.
We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to [email protected] or call us at 866-VERGE11.
0:00 CarPlay Banter01:36 HomeView App Confusion03:40 CarPlay as Home OS08:31 Apple Hardware Software Bet13:28 Should It Just Be an iPad?14:31 Gemini 4 Returns16:18 Meta Muse Strategy19:54 Google Product Dilemma26:28 OpenAI Bugging Scandal29:49 Character AI Bankruptcy32:31 Bankrupt Data Goldmine33:00 Privacy After Shutdown36:55 Why People Return to X39:35 Threads Fumbled It40:49 X Owns AI Talk49:17 Who Should Use X49:57 Reporters And Sources53:00 Video Platforms Win54:44 Gruber Gets It Wrong01:01:29 Brendan Carr is a Dummy01:02:40 Execution Livestream Fallout01:07:21 Sprint Merger Fallout01:08:48 Dish Spectrum to SpaceX01:09:44 Can Starlink Compete01:11:30 SpaceX Phone Rumors01:13:55 Smartphone Sales Slump01:18:37 Agents vs Websites01:24:21 Why UI Still Matters01:26:43 Super Intelligence Rebrand01:30:37 AI Game Decompiling01:36:35 Wrap Up and Plugs
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices