1. Podcasts
  2. The Vergecast
  3. The AI is in the computer
The Vergecast

9 Oct 2026 · 1h 45m · 38 chapters

Episode artwork

The AI is in the computer

In short

The episode discusses how AI and new computing platforms are changing consumer devices and enterprise security. It focuses on Amazon’s new “Alexa tablets” (premium Android tablets with a matte “nanomat” display), Apple’s upcoming smart-home “HomePad” rumors, and Microsoft’s AI-focused Surface Laptop Ultra and RTX Spark DevBox for local AI development. It also includes a cybersecurity sponsor segment claiming AI accelerates cyberattacks.

Guests

The episode is hosted by David Pierce, Nilay Patel, and Ellison Skydance (plus references to other Verge staff such as Jen Toohey). No traditional guest interview is present in the transcript; most “guests” mentioned are internal contributors or executives discussed via calls (e.g., Panos Panay/Panos Pene at Amazon).

Key claims

  1. AI makes cyberattacks faster, cheaper, and scalable; businesses must stay ahead of patch gaps.
  2. Amazon’s tablet strategy is premium hardware plus Google Play Store, betting apps are “solved” while Alexa becomes the agent.
  3. Apple’s smart-home device may be constrained by Siri readiness and Apple’s dependence on the App Store.
  4. Microsoft’s high-end NVIDIA-based laptop targets local AI to avoid cloud/token costs and protect data.

Notable examples

  • Amazon’s matte “nanomat” display and tablet pricing ($229 for 8-inch; $549 for 12-inch).
  • Alexa’s current limits vs Meta’s Muse (smart home vs broader tasks).
  • Microsoft’s Surface Laptop Ultra ($2,600) for local AI development.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:55

Welcoming Back David Pierce

The hosts catch up and discuss parenting challenges.

“and what the implications might be for your portfolio.”
2:22

Welcoming Back David Pierce

The hosts catch up and discuss parenting challenges.

“Ellison Skydance is a real Taylor Sheridan name.”
4:26

Amazon's Gadget News

Discussion on Amazon's new gadgets and technology updates.

“We should talk about lanterns like the full hour, but there's like a lot of gadget news.”
5:28

Introducing Alexa Tablets

Debate about the new Alexa tablets and their features.

“It's a big week for what is a computer in a way that is actually very fun.”
7:20

The Future of Apps and AI

Discussion on the relevance of apps and the direction of AI.

“I didn't, but I talked to Panos many times over the years, I have a sense of Panos decisions.”
12:25

Evaluating Android Tablets

The hosts discuss the current state of Android tablets and competition.

“and you're probably better off making that bet.”
14:01

Default Tablets: The Case for Amazon Fire

Discussion on the state of Android tablets, particularly the Amazon Fire tablet as the default choice.

“back in the Engadget days talking about the default Windows laptop.”
16:46

Amazon's Product Quality Debate

Exploration of whether Amazon has ever created truly great products amidst their many releases.

“on the right side of that line, I think these things are almost by default going to be a huge hit.”
19:37

The Future of Voice Interaction and Hardware

Anticipation of a shift in how we interact with computers, emphasizing voice commands and new hardware opportunities.

“Do Ring cameras count as great products, like Amazon products?”
22:26

The Nanomat Display: Pros and Cons

Discussion on the implications and features of the new nanomat display technology used in Amazon devices.

“reading my email, it has to pay me$250 each time it proactively reads my email.”
Show all 38 chapters
24:56

Amazon's Path to Folding Devices

Speculation on Amazon's future in folding technology based on their current tablet strategy.

“That it is a productivity device and it has the keyboard case.”
27:21

Apple's Upcoming Smart Home Innovations

Anticipation and speculation about Apple's new smart home products and how they compare to Amazon's offerings.

“Real quick, before we switch gears to everybody else's ideas about computers, right next to all of this is whatever Apple is about to do in this space, right?”
28:00

Apple's Smart Home Strategy and Siri's Limitations

Explore Apple's approach to smart home devices and the current state of Siri AI.

“with a screenshot of you scrolling through the insanity of your smart home.”
42:00

Microsoft's AI-Focused Laptop Announcement

Discussion on Microsoft's recent event introducing new AI-driven laptops.

“So after all of that, two companies this week with some more traditional, I would say, ideas about laptops that are also weird ideas about laptops.”
43:16

Debate on Local AI Computing Paradigms

Exploration of the shift from cloud computing to local AI processing and its implications.

“They're giving it more control over your files, over Windows.”
44:36

Reassessing the Role of Personal Computers

Analysis of how modern computing paradigms affect user interaction and data management.

“And then I was traveling and I opened my laptop and I opened cloud and I was like, where the is it?”
46:40

High-End Laptops and Market Competition

Discussion on Microsoft's new laptop as a competitor to Apple's MacBook Pro.

“The Azure company that also spent all of Satya Nadella's tenure moving Office to the web, moving Windows to the web.”
48:27

The Future of Computing: Edge vs Cloud

Consideration of edge computing and its implications for future technology products.

“Microsoft got very excited about how many ports it has.”
50:18

Innovations in Charging Technology

Overview of the new magnetic USB-C charging feature and its potential impact.

“There is one spec of the laptop that we should talk about.”
51:29

Google's New Laptop Launch and Its Implications

Critique of Google's new laptops and their readiness for market amid software challenges.

“Okay, the other laptop we should talk about is Google Books.”
56:01

Exploring the Limitations of Browsers on New Devices

The hosts discuss the frustrations and limitations of using desktop-like browsers on mobile devices and the implications of AI integration.

“It's like, when you're using a mobile browser, like a baby browser for babies, at least you know, you know?”
1:11:07

Podcast Return and Pop Punk Music

The hosts discuss their return from a break and share a love for pop punk music.

“After seven weeks off, Eli, are we still doing this?”
1:12:09

Brendan Carr's Threats to Broadcasters

A discussion on Brendan Carr's controversial actions regarding broadcasters and free speech.

“But that does not mean you have license to do white boy reggae.”
1:14:05

Legal Challenges and Public Interest

Exploring the implications of legal challenges against Brendan Carr's decisions.

“I was like, look, I'm not voting in the Texas Senate race, guys.”
1:17:09

Brendan Carr as a Dummy

The hosts humorously reflect on Brendan Carr's political maneuverings and their absurdities.

“There's this headline today on Variety that says - Disclosure, Variety is owned by our parent company.”
1:18:39

Paramount and Warner Brothers Merger

A detailed analysis of the merger between Paramount and Warner Brothers Discovery.

“Anyhow, that has been Brendan Carr is a dummy, America's favorite podcast.”
1:22:41

Future of Streaming Services

Discussion on the future of streaming services post-merger and industry challenges.

“And then Enon Kreese, who used to be the CEO of Mattel and before that of Maker Studios, his title is co-CEO.”
1:24:00

Hollywood's Battle with Vertical Video

Discusses Hollywood's struggle with user-generated content and vertical videos.

“which by the way, the Ellison family has a stake in TikTok.”
1:25:14

The Netflix Dilemma

Explores the challenges Netflix faces with content and audience engagement.

“And then apparently they need to pay Glenn Powell's marketing department.”
1:25:46

The Go90 Streaming Service Failure

Recaps the rise and fall of the Go90 streaming platform and its impact on the industry.

“And so it's turning into, and this is true on the platform, it's turning into just chum, right?”
1:27:10

Netflix's Cultural Influence Decline

Analyzes Netflix's shifting cultural relevance and compares it to other platforms.

“Quibi famously, I believe, is the paradigmatic example.”
1:29:21

HBO Max and Paramount Plus Insights

Discusses the future of HBO Max and Paramount Plus in the streaming landscape.

“I think Netflix is an aggressively well-run company.”
1:31:24

Disney Plus's Strong Positioning

Highlights Disney Plus's unique cultural relevance and its successful IP.

“We have never had to contend with, does being merged into HBO Max constitute going 90?”
1:32:38

CEO Dynamics and Industry Insights

Examines CEO behaviors and strategies within major entertainment companies.

“Because Netflix was a rock solid zero for the last five years.”
1:34:00

Intelligent UI and ChatGPT Innovations

Explores the latest updates in intelligent UI and interactive elements in ChatGPT.

“This is officially the slowest lightning round we've ever done.”
1:38:01

Generative UI vs Traditional Interfaces

Exploring the limitations and user preferences in UI design.

“And I think actually a lot of people prefer text because text is a thing that is there that I understand that I can refer to that works in a predictable way that makes sense.”
1:40:52

Sam Altman's Controversial AI Remarks

Discussion on Sam Altman's statements about the trade-offs of AI technology.

“But it just seems like if you're a product designer at a tech company, you are required to forget it on a three-year cadence.”
1:44:47

The Challenge of Articulating AI Benefits

Examining the difficulties in expressing the positive impacts of AI amidst fears.

“But in this one, I just kept thinking about the fact that Sam Altman, in this case and in basically every case, is just completely unable to articulate the good thing that AI is going to do.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Vergecast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Comcast Business. AI has made cyber attacks faster, cheaper, and easier to scale. Attackers can exploit security gaps long before patches are available. If you're a business owner, you need to stay ahead of threats. If you're only reacting, it might already be too late. That's where the Comcast Business 2026 Cybersecurity Threat Report comes in. Learn more about today's threat landscape and the best ways to stay prepared and ready for what's next. The 2026 Comcast Business Cybersecurity Threat Report uncovers how AI is accelerating today's attacks and how to build defenses that keep pace.

0:38Nilay Patel: Read the report at comcastbusiness.com slash cybersecurity. Cyber confidence starts with Comcast Business.

0:48Nilay Patel: This episode is brought to you by On Investing, an original podcast from Charles Schwab. Each week, hosts Liz Ann Saunders, Schwab's chief investment strategist, and Colin Martin, head of fixed income research and strategy for the Schwab Center for Financial Research, bring you fresh insights on what's happening in the markets and why, and what the implications might be for your portfolio. Join Colin and Liz Ann as they explore questions like, how do you evaluate corporate bonds that look interesting? And what sectors are on the move right now? Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com slash oninvesting or wherever you get your podcasts.

1:53Nilay Patel: Slack, GitHub, and more, and makes it easy to share with agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot. Assign them work directly or connect your agents through MCP. The result? Less token waste, more accuracy, and more time moving forward. Learn more at Jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com.

2:22David Pierce: hello and welcome to the verge cast the flagship podcast of paramount skydance warner brothers plus max a new streaming service coming to you my daughter out of his 20s you leave her alone somehow this is all max's fault you've named your daughter skydance from what i understand she's very wealthy it's going very well her dad has no largesse it's a real shame i will never buy her a media company.

2:46Brendan Carr: Ellison Skydance is a real Taylor Sheridan name. Hi, I'm Ellison Skydance.

2:52David Pierce: Just putting it out there. I'm hearing like a Netflix Western. Yeah, it's good stuff. I'm into it. I'm your friend David Pierce. Neil Abusel is here. Hello, sir. It's good to have you back. I missed you. I'm glad to be here. How have things been? They've been good.

3:05Brendan Carr: Other David did a good job.

3:07David Pierce: He did do a good job. The people love David to a point that was like really alarming for my own ego. A lot of love for David Amell in my place.

3:14Brendan Carr: And he's dead now. But we missed you, man. We'll have him back. We're going to we'll find a way to make David Amell part of the Verge extended universe because he was great. But we did miss you. I missed you. I'm glad you're back. And it sounds like family's doing good.

3:29David Pierce: yeah things are good it's uh three is a lot of children uh in in a in a very like strange way there's the first thing that happens when you have three kids is people immediately start being like well you might as well have a fourth right and it's like which i just don't understand but but it is now to the point where i feel like i have infinity children uh there's just every time i turn around there's there's just another one uh so that's been interesting to get used to But everybody's good. We had like two weeks of no one sleeping. Just no one. But now we're coming out of that. And I feel alive again for the first time.

4:06Brendan Carr: Well, it's funny because last year we had children at the same time.

4:09David Pierce: Yeah. And I do not feel like we have exited the bad part of having a baby with our second one. But you are just, you're back in it. my number one parenting recommendation now is don't have two kids who can't walk and it's like there's a real there's a real thing that is like i i we were talking to a family who like had kids at about the same gap as ours and they were like oh once it's so fun because they'll have each other and they'll be so close in age that they'll they'll feel they'll grow up as peers and i'm very excited about that and they're like oh it's like in five years i'm like oh my god five years and instead i'm like i have not i have not had an arm free in two months in a way that is like very hard to describe i've like i've gotten good at doing everything with like my elbows now because that's that's what i have to accomplish goals while i carry two children it's a lot i don't recommend having two tiny children at the same time if you can avoid it yeah but you know they're real cute and it works out yeah i've also had a lot of time to catch up on tv shows and movies over the last seven weeks, which is if you'd like to talk about any major motion picture from mid to late 2025, I am ready for it.

5:20Brendan Carr: I'm nowhere there. We should talk about lanterns like the full hour, but there's like a lot of gadget news.

5:24David Pierce: There's a lot of gadget news. That is primarily what we are here to talk about. So we have Amazon gadget news. It's a big week for what is a computer in a way that is actually very fun. And I'm excited to be back for Amazon is doing tablets again. Microsoft is doing AI computers. Google Books are here. I have one. I am desperate to talk about them. You guys have been talking about them and I have so many feelings and all of you are wrong and I want to talk about all of them. Apple had just announced today as we're recording that its big home event is next week on the 13th. There's just a lot of new ideas about how we're supposed to use technology happening all at once.

5:59David Pierce: And Skydance owns Hollywood. We'll get to that. Literally, that is coming at the very end of the show is how many gadgets there are. Should we start with Amazon? Amazon feels to me like kind of the most immediately newsy. It drops today, Thursday, as we're recording. I also, this is like a perfectly Neelai-coded gadget announcement because the big thing today is the Alexa tablets, a new, vastly superior line of tablets from Amazon. They're not fire tablets. that are actually phasing out the Fire tablet brand in favor of a better higher-end set of tablets that people will actually like to use. And the question of like, what does it mean for Amazon to be a good hardware company, I think is really interesting.

6:44David Pierce: It's also entirely about the display. Like I had a call with Panos Pene, who runs all of the devices and Alexa stuff at Amazon, about all of the Alexa tablets. All we talked about the whole call was this new nanomat display that Amazon has built that they swear is like the greatest tablet screen you've ever seen in your life.

7:03Brendan Carr: It does look amazing in all of the photos and videos. It does.

7:06David Pierce: It really does. So the idea is that it takes some of the matte texture that is often just put on as a film and actually like bakes it into the glass. And Terrence O 'Brien on our team saw it, said it looks great. We'll get one to review. Very excited to see it. What do you make of just the existence of Alexa tablets?

7:23Brendan Carr: Oh, I have so many thoughts about this. You talked at Panos. I didn't, but I talked to Panos many times over the years, I have a sense of Panos decisions. Like you can identify Panos decisions. You can just see them at a distance. And there are two here that I think are really important. One, he just up-leveled the hardware. And I say this as a person who has Fire tablets, right? We've got kids, we have a Sonos system, there's just a Fire tablet sitting around to control the Sonos system, and that's what it does. And the only reason we have it is because it's one of the few tablets you can get that has pogo pin charging so it can just sit in a dock all day oh sure yeah you can open the app and it just stays charged and so like this is a an odd piece of weird technology that i interact with all the time like you would just not expect me to be a

8:08David Pierce: fire tablet i would not that that is genuinely surprising but it is literally because you can

8:12Brendan Carr: just like put it in the dock and it charges and then you can like use it as a controller um the two decisions are one none of that hardware is any good correct aside from the fact that you could put it in a dock and charge it it appears this hardware is very good he wants it to be premium hardware that is just a panaceous decision you can hear him in the meeting being like why is

8:31David Pierce: it bad you know right that's his personality that's not a like dig on the old tablets it's a strategy shift like yeah amazon never aspired to make good tablets before they wanted them to be dirt cheap and they were 29 so you would get amazon kids and then that was a subscription and

8:50Brendan Carr: That was the whole strategy because they couldn't compete with the iPad. And this is the second big Panos decision that I'm utterly curious about. They have the Play Store. They got rid of their dumb Amazon App Store, and they're just straight-up Android tablets that are part of Google's ecosystem, which comes with a bunch of Google stuff. and the fact that they're called Alexa tablets, that you are meant to talk to Amazon's assistant, which has some amount of agentic capability and presumably more to come. I can just hear Panos being like, well, apps are boring. They're the past. Just give people Google.

9:29Brendan Carr: Why are we fighting that fight? We're going to fight the next war. And I don't know if Alexa is good enough to fight the next war. Question mark. But those are the two decisions where, you know, at least a distance, I can see Amazon hired Panos Panay and he is very opinionated and very crisp in his decision-making. And those are the two changes. The hardware is nicer and we're leaving the apps in the past.

9:54David Pierce: Well, I would put it slightly differently, which is I think the mistake that a lot of people have made is deciding that apps are the past. And what it actually is, is apps are solved, right? Everybody needs apps. Like it turns out that you have to have an app store or else nothing else matters, right? Like if you decide apps don't matter, agentic AI is the only thing, you build the humane pin and your company dies and you sell to HP and you go make printers. Like that's what happens when you decide that apps are dead. But going and trying to compete in app stores is a complete waste of time. Many have tried, none have succeeded.

10:34David Pierce: and the only way to the next thing is to acknowledge that, right? So you say, okay, we're not going to try to play the app game. We're not going to try to build a bunch of new things. We're going to have a couple of new ideas around this fundamentally solved problem, which is the Google Play Store. We can't beat it. We're not even going to try, but we're going to use it to spring to the next thing. And I think that is the right bet. And it's the bet way too many companies forget to make because apps are not the past. They're not. They are the present in a super duper real way. And the only way to bet that it's the future is to actually do the app thing in the first place.

11:09David Pierce: And I think, again, that's like, we're gonna get to Google Books, but like, that's the Google Books story too, right? They're like, oh, we think agentic AI and the web can solve all of your problems. And everybody's like, I would like apps, please. And they're like, okay, here's some apps. Now we can go do the other things. And so, and I think Amazon is trying to do the same thing here.

11:24Brendan Carr: Yeah, we're two sides of the same coin here. If you believe that there is a future past apps, that apps are solved, then you give up and put the play store on these tablets 100 because you have to put all of your focus on the next thing but until that next thing took any shape you had to make your own app store yeah because otherwise you were just handing your business to google and so that's what that's what i'm getting at is they're willing to concede the past perhaps the present to google and right like The Play Store comes with a bunch of in-app purchase fees and all that stuff that Google gets sued for.

12:01Brendan Carr: I have no idea if Amazon was able to negotiate different rates with Google. But if you have the Play Store, the app developers are going to pay Google for in-app purchases. They're probably not going to pay Amazon. So you've just conceded the revenue model of the present. Right. And you're on your way to Alexa should be your all-encompassing AGI agent to do all of the economic activity of the future. and you're probably better off making that bet. And that's what I mean. Yes, it's the past in that I don't think there's going to be a lot of innovation there. There's a lot of emphasis on the AI part.

12:36Brendan Carr: Whether that's good or bad, fully remains to be seen.

12:40David Pierce: Yeah, but it is. And I think the tablet to me is super interesting because it sort of clears the deck for that question in a way that I think is really exciting. If the hardware is as good as advertised, and I think it probably is like a company like Amazon certainly has the resources to make great products if it wants to. It has gotten in its way many times, but I think this thing by all accounts so far seems to be a good piece of hardware. If you remove the, why doesn't it have this thing by giving it a decent keyboard case and a decent stylus and all of the Android apps that you want, you've gotten to the point where it's like, okay, now can our thing, and in this case, that thing is Alexa Plus, actually win, right?

13:20David Pierce: Like, do we have the next thing here? And now in a certain way, it's going to actually get to answer that question because the other stuff is just sort of solved. So if you can just make a good tablet with Android apps, great. That is, turns out easy thing to do if you just do it.

13:37Brendan Carr: Is this good enough to be like what you would call the default Android tablet? I think default Android tablet is such an insult. Do you know what I mean? This is the problem. But you know, like for years, you'd be like, what's the default Windows computer? Sure. And maybe it was... The Dell XPS 13. It's the XPS 13 some years, and it's the Surface laptop some other years. But, I mean, we made a lot of hay back in the Engadget days talking about the default Windows laptop.

14:04David Pierce: Yep.

14:04Brendan Carr: Joanna Stern built an empire on the default Windows laptop. And then it was the XPS 13 for like years and years and years. If you ask me what is the default Android tablet, I would... Some Galaxy tab?

14:18David Pierce: No, I think you would like deep sigh and then say it's a Fire tablet.

14:21Brendan Carr: No, not a Fire. No, no, no, because it doesn't have the Play Store. I'm saying right now. But it is. Okay, go ahead. Make your argument in favor of the Fire tablet.

14:30David Pierce: No, I think my argument is less in favor of the Fire tablet and more against the entire ecosystem of Android tablets. I mean, realistically, I don't think anyone was looking for an Android tablet. You were either looking for an iPad or you didn't want to spend the money on an iPad until you landed on a Fire tablet.

14:45Brendan Carr: I have Android tablet fans just furiously writing you emails right now. There are. Welcome back. I'm okay with that.

14:51David Pierce: And listen, the Pixel tablet had a chance to be that thing if Google had continued. Google can't care about Android tablets. Like Google is onto Google Books because it's no longer interested in Android tablet. This is not a small thing for anyone to try and get involved in. I think this will almost immediately become the default Android tablet. Amazon is so big and successful and the price on these is really good. The eight inch one starts at$229 and the like very fanciest 12 inch one with the fancy screen is$549. Like you're looking at like thousand dollar iPad territory for 550 bucks. And that's that's meaningful.

15:28David Pierce: And so I think Amazon, unless these things have some spectacular failure in them that we don't know about, I think they immediately become the obvious tablet to buy for most.

15:39Brendan Carr: Now I have to ask the obvious question. but every piece of Amazon hardware, does it show you ads in the home screen by default? Good question.

15:47David Pierce: There aren't any in the, well, okay. I'm trying to think about just the photos I've seen. There's a little prime widget up in the top left corner that is ostensibly there to show you like what you're reading and watching. And then there's a whole thing you can swipe right on the home screen to get to this big shelf of stuff. I assume that shelf will be a mix of things you're watching and reading and recommendations from Amazon.com I do think it's possible that Amazon is going to just slather shopping all over this thing in a way that is really upsetting one of the things they're going to do is make it so that you can just at any time be like how do I buy this and it'll look at what Alexa Plus will look at whatever's on the screen and put it in your Amazon cart that's a real flow Amazon imagines and that might be awful.

16:39David Pierce: Like it really honestly might be awful in a way that is kind of pernicious and off-putting. If it has just stayed on the right side of that line, I think these things are almost by default going to be a huge hit.

16:52Brendan Carr: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, anybody with a kid who needs a plain tablet, this is the one you buy, right? If it's a nice piece of hardware that can run Disney Plus and then get your kids to immediately convert everything they're watching on Disney Plus and to purchase this on Amazon Prime. This is going to be a huge one for everyone. But that's the danger. At$5.50 for the nice one, that price is subsidized. And the only way Amazon knows how to subsidize a price is with intrusive advertising. That is the entire experience of the Fire TV.

17:23David Pierce: I asked Panos about the price and he said something to the effect of, I don't want to talk about how we got there. Do with that what you will. That's so ominous. it really is. It's like, don't ask me questions about how we got RAM. Like, okay, man, I understood. Wow. He's like in a large conference room. He's like blown out by the window behind him. He's like, don't ask me questions about that.

17:48Brendan Carr: This Prime Air drones are launching some strikes.

17:51David Pierce: I want to know how you feel about the nanomat display, but first I have a question that has been rattling around in my brain ever since I found out about this thing. And I want you to actually think about this. Has Amazon ever, and I mean sincerely Has it ever made a great product? It has made a lot of successful products. Has it ever made an out-and-out great product?

18:16Brendan Carr: it's made so many products it's almost impossible to answer that question because prior to panos when dave limp was running devices he would have those rapid fire product launch moments where he'd be like it's a washer dryer it's a stove it's a microwave and all everything's alexa have they made a truly great product i would argue the very first kindle that was the only

18:46David Pierce: one that came to mind for me i'm not sure it was great but i think that's it had a it had an

18:50Brendan Carr: argument it it's just it's we should make a version history about it you know it's like it's such an iconic product and it was so weird with the scroll strip on the side the first alexa was not a great product, but I remember the day it came out, you and I were in the office together and we were the only two people who thought it was a good idea. And then it turns out like a decade later, it was still the same idea. Those are the two that I would call it. Okay.

19:19David Pierce: See, I think the original Echo, definitively not a great product. Kindle, maybe. But this is the thing. I think this is such a huge new path for Amazon. It is just, and again, it's not a knock on Amazon's inability to make great products. It has never tried. Like, Amazon.com is - Wait, I have a question.

19:39Brendan Carr: Do Ring cameras count as great products, like Amazon products? I mean, sure, if you want to. They are fully there. I mean, people have a lot of feelings about Ring and everything associated with Ring, but they relentlessly iterate. Like, the newest Ring doorbell is very good. That is true. Yeah. It will also get you arrested if you sign, you know.

20:00David Pierce: Yeah. But I think Amazon has just never cared all that much about building great things. Like Amazon.com is very successful. No one up to and including Andy Jassy would tell you it is like a beautifully engineered and executed and lovely user experience product. Like using Amazon.com is awful, but it makes Amazon a lot of money. And so it works for Amazon. this is maybe the most ambitious swing at like can we make great stuff on its own merits and can that work for us that I've seen Amazon do and I think that's just going to be fascinating and we have a couple more like I have the new I have a purple Kindle here that is the the aluminum one that they just came out with it's very nice there's there's almost certainly some Echo stuff coming that I think might be high end in the same way like amazon has just up leveled in a big way and whether that changes its fortunes in this space i think it's going to be really fascinating to watch

20:58Brendan Carr: again i think the the impetus here is there's a platform shift potentially afoot the way we use computers might be changing i'm saying this with as like as much skepticism as i can and muster into a microphone. This is the thesis. I'm not sure. Right. But the idea that you're going to talk to the computer, issue natural language commands, and it's going to go off and do something for you, creates an opportunity to sell new hardware. The same way that, I don't know, Apple sold a lot of iMacs in the 90s because people wanted web browsers and they didn't care so much about Wintel programs running on Windows 3.1 or whatever.

21:37Brendan Carr: Like, that was a platform shift that enabled a new hardware entrant. Same with the phone, same with whatever else. this is the opportunity for amazon is to say hey you don't care about apps anymore you care about talking to alexa yeah here's some of the best hardware you can get for talking to alexa will this work many questions remain yeah will alexa be as capable as muse it certainly isn't now i had

22:04David Pierce: jen too he was on the show yesterday talking about this and she she put up her big one year in review of testing Alexa plus piece today, Thursday. And yeah, the read is like, it's gotten very good at smart home stuff and is still nowhere near where it needs to be to do all of that other stuff. It is nowhere near as good as Muse at Muse things.

22:24Brendan Carr: Today, I told my Muse that if it doesn't stop reading my email, it has to pay me$250 each time it proactively reads my email. And it just thought about how to make money for like a long time.

22:35David Pierce: It's like, this is worth it if I can figure out how to get, This is how the hugging face hack starts. It's like your muse is just off somewhere making money now.

22:43Brendan Carr: I kind of wanted to see if I could run a crypto scam on meta servers. I was like, please, I've given you permission to read my email for two things because it's only connected to my spam Gmail. It's allowed to read for updates to class action lawsuits for which it has signed up and new class action lawsuits for which I might wish to sign up. And by the way, there's one a week. we're we're making like annualized if you do it opening eye style i'm making 10 billion dollars a year that's actually uh uh but then every now and again it's like hey some other nonsense spam email came in are you interested i'm always like please i want you to stop and so today i was like what if you had to pay me money every time you read my email and i didn't give you permission and it's like i made a ledger for you and i was like no but make the money and it just when it's wheels for a while.

23:32Brendan Carr: Here's my Venmo. Get at me. It didn't get anywhere, but I'm working on it. And if I can get Alexa to do it, we'll be in a much happier place.

23:40David Pierce: That's true. Do you have any thoughts on this nanomat display? I was talking to Panos about this and reading about this and thinking about you at the Apple launch event, standing there in front of the two studio displays, the one and the fancier one, and just like staring in awe trying to find the two differences. And I was just like, I'm, Neil is going to hear the word nanomat and have a lot of feelings.

24:00Brendan Carr: I want it. I want to see it. It's funny. I was thinking about the last album that I went to, which was the iPhone Duo launch. And the opening the Duo and seeing that it's a matte display was just a collective gasp in that room. Like everyone had that experience. And we're not expecting it to be matte. It's since come out that there's like a lot of reasons for it to be matte, including hiding the crease. It feels like we're about to have a little matte display fad in consumer devices. I really enjoyed looking at the matte display on the Duo. I haven't seen this one in person. There's something about it, especially for a very portable device that you have in like sunny spaces, bright spaces with reflections, where it's going to be great.

24:41Brendan Carr: But we'll see, especially for a cheap device that kids might use, it is much easier to clean a glossy screen. Oh, that's an interesting point. So we're going to find out. Yeah. I can definitely see my children

24:52David Pierce: doing bad things to this display. Maybe that's why it's only in the highest end device. device that like if you're buying the fancy 12 inch one you're probably not buying it to just

25:03Brendan Carr: stick in front of your kid on a plane well i'm curious i mean you talked to them what was amazon's

25:06David Pierce: argument for having a matte display essentially just that it's better right like pano started with the argument that the screen is the only thing you absolutely cannot compromise on on a tablet and i agree with that fundamentally um but i think they also are really into this being a device that does lots of things and goes lots of places, right? That it is a productivity device and it has the keyboard case. And Panos was like very proud of the fact that he uses it as his main work computer. But then also it is a thing you will, you know, hold in your hands and read books on. And so it has some of the like tone shifting that it can do automatically when you open the Kindle app.

25:45David Pierce: They really like the idea of be using it to watch movies. Like they understand, I think pretty thoroughly how many things people use tablets for. And so we need something that looks good and feels good in all of these different use cases, I think does kind of inevitably lead you to a matte display if you can pull it off. And they seem to believe they have.

26:09Brendan Carr: Yeah. I wonder how fast they will end up at a folding phone.

26:12David Pierce: I think if Amazon hadn't made the Fire Phone, they would have shipped a phone instead of a tablet. But I think this to me feels so much like one toe into that water. And then if this works, there will be an Alexa phone in 12 months.

26:28Brendan Carr: Yeah. Especially if you're talking about, I want to go all these places and do all these things. You're just going to end up with a folding phone.

26:36David Pierce: Yes. But I think that the hill for, oh God, Amazon made another phone is so high that unless they have this huge hit tablet on their hands, it might feel insurmountable. So I see why you do this first, but I also like, remember Panos Panay, longtime advocate of folding devices, made a bunch of them at Microsoft, killed a bunch of them, shipped a bunch of them. Like that, nobody loved the Surface Duo and the Microsoft Courier like Panos Panay. I am, no part of me believes he doesn't want to work on that at Amazon too. It's super clear that that's coming.

27:12Brendan Carr: Again, especially if you buy the notion that the entire paradigm of computing is shifting and this is your opportunity to try something new.

27:20David Pierce: Yep. 100%. Real quick, before we switch gears to everybody else's ideas about computers, right next to all of this is whatever Apple is about to do in this space, right? Where Apple is having some kind of something next Tuesday. That's as specific as I'm able to be. they sent an invitation to some people. It was mysterious. It had yarn that made an Apple logo. We're expecting Apple to launch a bunch of smart home things.

27:47Brendan Carr: Yeah, they invited Jen Toohey.

27:49David Pierce: Yeah, right. America's smart home reporter.

27:52Brendan Carr: Yeah, I feel like I know what's going on. Yeah.

27:55David Pierce: What are you looking for here? I still have in my head this social video you made the other day with a screenshot of you scrolling through the insanity of your smart home. This is very much Apple running towards what Amazon and Alexa have been doing successfully for some time, while Amazon is trying to do what Apple has been doing successfully for some time. Are you bullish on whatever Apple's about to do here?

28:21Brendan Carr: So the rumor is Apple's going to announce the HomePad. That's what we've all agreed to call this product.

28:28David Pierce: No, we haven't.

28:29Brendan Carr: I don't love it. We have not agreed to call it that. That's what we're calling it. you know some sort of Siri AI device that lives in your kitchen and does video conferencing and we just had Mark Gurman on Decoder and he was like this device isn't ready to go

28:43David Pierce: but they held it because Siri AI was not ready to do the thing and it's fascinating that Apple

28:50Brendan Carr: believes Siri AI is not ready to do the thing when Siri AI is now about as capable as 2023 Gemini because it is distilled from Gemini yep do you know I mean like that's where we've gotten like I've had a Nest Hub in my house for ages that can control the smart home and answer natural language query. And then it has an ad for itself on the screen all the time that says start a live chat with Gemini. And I'm always like, but isn't that what I'm doing? It makes no sense. It's awful. It's truly, if anyone at Google can explain what they think the difference in those things are, I would love to hear it.

29:26Brendan Carr: But we're at the agent part of the conversation now.

29:29David Pierce: Yeah.

29:30Brendan Carr: GrokBot and Dots and Muse. And I think launching a device like this and being like, it can do lights and locks. And we've partnered with LG, a company that just got in a huge scandal for listening to you. All of that seems very, it just seems from yesterday. And maybe Apple just got slowed up because Siri wasn't ready and they would have released this if Siri had been ready. but the yeah there's just some part of this where apple apple is the company that won apps and they might be trapped by apps interesting that's a good theory so yes i'm you know i'm as a huge smart home nerd yes i want to see what apple's riff on a smart lock with lg looks like i don't know that you can convince me to get rid of my schleg locks that run on thread where the battery lasts for 500 years and they're already installed in the doors is it possible that

30:25David Pierce: the reason Apple is partnering with LG on this stuff is because it knows that, that like, even, even Apple knows that it is probably not going to convince most people to rip out their front door lock just because Apple made a new product. Uh, there's, there is some level of humility somewhere in Apple park that prevents them from believing that. And so they're, they're happy to foist that stuff on other people and be like, well, we're going to be as the, the control layer in the middle. And that's where Siri AI becomes important.

30:55Brendan Carr: Yeah, I mean, I can already, you know, if you want to ghostwrite an Apple announcement, you're like, this will work with the huge ecosystem of Matter door locks that run on Thread. And, you know, we had some great ideas, so we partnered with LG on making some with Apple Flare them, whatever John Ternus is going to say.

31:12David Pierce: They'll have H2 chips in them or whatever.

31:14Brendan Carr: Yeah, like no buttons or whatever that is, whatever Apple thing is. But it needs to work with the big ecosystem of Matter devices. There's some reporting out there that, you know, this is a big reset for Matter too and HomeKit in general. But the point that I have just been making for ages that Jen has been making for ages is that you cannot sell a smart home in a box.

31:35David Pierce: Right.

31:36Brendan Carr: Like sort of definitionally, everyone's house is an edge case. So you cannot sell in a box something that works for everyone. Just in my house, the basement door doesn't get any Wi-Fi signal. so now you got to add a repeater or an arrow or a mesh note like it's our it's we're already done like it's already gotten more complicated than any normal human would ever deal with uh replacing light switches is easy but also complicated like it's not actually very challenging to replace a light switch but then you got to flip your breakers off and you absolutely have to flip the breakers off just take it from me just turn your breakers off don't do it hot I'm signing myself in trouble.

32:19Brendan Carr: And you got to do it. And like, not everybody wants to do that or call them a tristan and pay the money to do that. Like you just end up with, oh, this is getting complicated really fast. Yeah. And I don't, I'm very curious to see how Apple repositions HomeKit in this device and a bunch of second party accessories from LG as an actual product solution, not just some fun stuff you can nerd out with. And just to say it again, I love this stuff and I love nerding out on it and I'm a sicko and I don't think any of this is ready for primetime because there's just no way to sell it to anyone else. You just end up being the systems administrator for your house.

33:00David Pierce: Or you're Apple and you try to convince everybody that Siri AI is ready to be that thing. And unless there is some enormous advance coming next week, it isn't. Like the more I use Siri AI, the less impressed I am by Siri AI. It is, I think Gemini in 2023 is actually the exact right place to situate it because it does some of the things, right? Like some very basic things Siri used to not be able to do, like answer questions or find information for you. It can now do. And that's not nothing. That's useful.

33:31Brendan Carr: It can search your text messages and email like never before.

33:34David Pierce: It sure can. And it actually does that passably well. That is not bleeding edge AI technology, but it does work. Like, all of this other stuff, the, like, just make sense of the world around me stuff actually is bleeding edge AI technology. And I don't see any of it in Siri right now.

33:50Brendan Carr: Yeah. And, you know, you can say there's a lot of reasons Apple was behind. But to me, the number one thing is that Apple makes an awful lot of money on in-app purchases in the App Store. And disrupting the app paradigm is fully disruptive to Apple's business. and you know there's reporting out there that says John Ternus actually wants to make more money from services I mean of course he does

34:14David Pierce: sure but like John Ternus will get fired if he doesn't figure out how to make more money from services it's just a real thing

34:19Brendan Carr: well he can also make new devices people want to buy it's another choice there's a lot of ways to make money and so of course Meta was out with Muse of course Meta put an app on your phone that means you don't have to use other apps they've got nothing to lose Right. And like, I just, I think that it's going to be one of those things. I mean, this is the classic innovators dilemma. Like Apple is trapped by the scale of its own success here. And they probably should be the company that gives everybody eight gigs of RAM in the cloud to run a little web browser. So you can tell Siri to go do stuff for you and figure out how to do that in a privacy first way.

34:59Brendan Carr: And then, you know, Siri will shop for you and they can take 30 % of that. but they're not gonna it's gonna be they're gonna say siri can use the apps on your phone that's their model and they're there and even google to some extent is sticking with that model they announced gemini spark which is an agent at io yeah they are not running nfl ads for gemini

35:20David Pierce: spark no spark is so funny because every day every time anybody has a conversation about all of these devices and the sort of ai assistance everybody mentions you know muse instinct is kind of up there grok bot and then there's there's a couple others percolating around and then every time there is one commenter who from like several rooms away is like what about spark though and it's just like oh that's the google employee in the room like that's how you find him and and like google was out in front of this and just didn't didn't do the thing they like as ever google's ability to coherently make and ship and market products uh remains to be seen But okay, last thing on this, and then we need to take a break.

35:59David Pierce: I want you to call this yay or nay right now. Are you going to be able to play Candy Crush with in-app purchases on the HomePad?

36:08Brendan Carr: No.

36:09David Pierce: Okay.

36:10Brendan Carr: Look, here's the number one thing about the HomePad.

36:12David Pierce: Think of the billions left on the table by that decision.

36:16Brendan Carr: So, well, here's my number one question about the HomePad. The reporting on it all suggests that it's going to have the camera on and it will recognize you as you walk up to it and then, you know, pop up some personalized stuff. First of all, now you have a camera in your kitchen that is just like looking for people, looking for faces. Big questions for Apple there. Like, I don't like having cameras in my house. Cameras outside the house, fine. Cameras in the house, we just like don't have them. Even the baby monitor, I won't get a Wi-Fi baby monitor. Just not a thing I'm comfortable with. Apple's like, yeah, we're going to do facial recognition in real time such that when you walk up to it, we will switch to your accounts.

36:53Brendan Carr: There is not a device anywhere in Apple's ecosystem that can do fast user switching at that speed. Right. So like my number one question is, how is that going to work? And then if it works, like sure, now you're in your app store account, you can do Candy Crush. But if this is a single player experience with one app store, like it's never going to work. Right.

37:17David Pierce: Yeah, I agree. Even, yeah, I hadn't even really thought about that because what you actually want in that situation is something that can actually be used simultaneously by multiple different people. And if it's trying to essentially context switch every time, it's going to be a mess, but it also kind of has to if it's going to have the permissions that it's asking for. That is complicated.

37:39Brendan Carr: Yeah, I mean, Apple could have saw this a million years ago by doing user profiles on the iPad, which I believe all of us have begged them to do. Like every writer at The Verge, like gets their wings when they write, why doesn't the iPad have multiple user accounts? you've written it I've written it Dieter's written it like we've all written it but this device at least from what they're reporting is like that's the feature so maybe maybe it'll just be face ID and unlock but that sucks yeah

38:11David Pierce: having to do one more step every time you want to touch it feels bad alright whatever it is next week we will inevitably talk a lot about it for right now let's take a break then we're gonna go back we've got some laptops to talk about we'll be right back

38:23Nilay Patel: At T-Mobile, the new iPhone 18 Pro is here with a big leap in battery life. And you can get it for nothing up front. With so many reasons to choose T-Mobile, you'll want to talk about it. I heard at T-Mobile, you can get iPhone 18 Pro for nothing up front and get$1 ,000 off. Pass it on. Pay nothing today. No taxes, no fees, nothing down. Pass it on. Hey, Mickey, pass it on. iPhone 18 Pro has the most advanced iPhone camera ever. Pass it on. At T-Mobile, you can get iPhone 18 Pro for nothing up front. Pass it on. At T-Mobile, get$1 ,000 off the amazing iPhone 18 Pro with no trade in needed. With 36 monthly bill credits when you switch to T-Mobile on a qualifying plan.

39:07Nilay Patel: If you cancel entire account before receiving all bill credits, credit stop and balance on a required finance agreement is due. Example,$1 ,199.99 iPhone 18 Pro, 256 gigabytes. Bill credits in if you pay off device early. Qualifying credit, new line, port in, and service. $85 more per month with AutoPay Plus taxes and fees required. $35 device connection charged to its sale. Visit T-Mobile.com. Support for the show comes from Anthropic. Some people see problems as invitations. The harder the problem, the more satisfying it is to find the solution. Claude is the AI for problem solvers. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you.

39:41Nilay Patel: Whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. If you're a developer losing half your day to tasks you wish you could hand off, Claude Code lives where you already work. Your terminal, your IDE, the desktop app, the web, and GitHub. It reads your code base and takes on real engineering work. Writing tests, refactoring, debugging, even watching your pull requests and fixing CI failures while you're away. Lay out what you want in plan mode, or just hold the space bar and talk it through, and Claude executes.

40:18Nilay Patel: For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at claude.ai.verge. That's claude.ai.verge. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all the features mentioned in today's episode. Claude.ai.verge. Support for the show comes from Sonos. Think about the first time you heard your favorite song. Who were you with? What did it make you feel? Was it the music or the lyrics that grabbed you first? And what were the specific tech specs of the sound system it was playing on? Yeah, nobody remembers that last part. Sonos gets that. Their system is designed to just be there, clear, ready, out of the way, so nothing stands between you and the next song that hits you out of left field.

41:07Nilay Patel: For a bunch of years now, I've been incredibly jealous of my friends who have Sonos speakers. I was just always impressed how all that sound and punch and energy came from that speaker in the corner. But Sonos recently sent me two of its play speakers, and now I truly, truly get it. Everyone knows that the quality is immediately noticeable when you listen to a Sonos speaker. But the bigger thing that I've learned is how everything is working together and creating this little ecosystem. It's just really important to me, especially as audios become more integrated into our daily media lives, whether that's music, a movie, and yes, the Vergecast or Virgin History or Decoder, I want it to sound as good as possible.

41:48Nilay Patel: Visit Sonos.com and build your system. Sonos, love the sound, feel the system.

42:01All right, we're back.

42:02David Pierce: So after all of that, two companies this week with some more traditional, I would say, ideas about laptops that are also weird ideas about laptops. Let's start with Microsoft. So Microsoft had an event this week. They teased it by saying something to the effect of we have something new from Windows. That something new turned out to be a couple of new devices. They re-announced and announced a ship date for the Surface Laptop Ultra. They announced a thing called the Surface RTX Spark DevBox, which really just rolls off the tongue. A lot of this stuff is its sort of AI-forward laptops, built in particular on the RTX Spark platform from NVIDIA.

42:40David Pierce: Let's start with the Surface Laptop Ultra, which they've talked about before. This is, by a mile, the most powerful Surface they've ever built. It's intended to be for local AI development for people who want to build with AI. there were a bunch of new windows features about how copilot will be able to use your computer more the thing that happened by the way while i was on leave is copilot just became a joke like i don't know if everybody noticed this while you were in it every day but copilot is now the ai that everybody makes fun of and like yeah there but for the grace of god go every other ai tool on the planet uh but microsoft is still doing it they're they're plugging copilot into everything They're giving it more control over your files, over Windows.

43:22David Pierce: The Surface Laptop Ultra, Nilay, is this a real laptop to be interested in, or is this just like a supercomputer play thing for nobody?

43:32Brendan Carr: We had a number of local AA conversations while you were out. You know, Apple announced a bunch of Macs, and they made a lot of noise about how they were great for running local AA models. There's something there that is super interesting. You don't want to rent your compute in the cloud. You don't want to pay the enormous token fees. You want control of your data. Do you care about privacy? And then right next to that is, boy, a lot of people have to rethink the fundamental paradigm of computing that they have been swimming in for ages. I'll just give you a really dumb example. I'm writing this decoder book, right?

44:08Brendan Carr: And so there's like 320-odd decoder transcripts from the last five or six years. Like, obviously, this is a thing for AI to do. Yeah. Right. I should just make a decoder search tool and I'm like doing a thing. I'm like, find me a quote when someone said blah, blah, blah. Then I should go find it for me. So I built the tool and I just like built it in cloud. And I, it didn't even occur to me that that tool lived on my computer. Right. Like the artifact and the transcripts that there was all just on my computer and I was using it. Great. And then I was traveling and I opened my laptop and I opened cloud and I was like, where the is it?

44:43Brendan Carr: because you're just so used to the stuff being everywhere yeah yeah right and i was like i figured out and i made it work and it's all fine but uh there's something about this paradigm of computing that makes you really reconsider where it's gonna happen in a way that i think you know unless you had a files and folders job you were not thinking about that a lot with your computer until recently. And I'm fascinated to see if Microsoft's selling an NVIDIA platform. I mean, it's expensive. It's$2 ,600. But is there like massive demand for a high-end NVIDIA laptop that might be able to do local AI?

45:24Brendan Carr: And is that a glimmer of a signal that actually local computing is going to be back in vogue when we've all just been trained to be like, It's all in the cloud. Nothing is actually happening here. Right. Like, why do you need 16 gigs of RAM and a laptop? Because Chrome is shit. Like, there wasn't a reason before. And now there's like a lot of good reasons.

45:45David Pierce: Yeah, part of me wonders if what we're missing there is these sort of simple use case, right? Like what you're describing in a lot of ways is sort of an interface problem that I think is much more easily solved by download, you know, Gemini or Muse to your computer and it will use your computer, but also go to the cloud when it needs to. The like, how to get a local model onto your computer is still sort of opaque in a lot of ways. And then what do I do with it? And how do I interact? Like nobody has packaged that in quite the right way, I don't think. And maybe that's Microsoft's chance is we make the operating system.

46:20David Pierce: We can do this. Like Apple's trying to do this with Apple intelligence, but it's so narrow and incomplete in that way. Microsoft could be the one to be like, well, we've just baked this whole thing into your computer and now it works offline. Like, it is a very funny switch from the company that just spent the last decade. From the Azure company? The Azure company that also spent all of Satya Nadella's tenure moving Office to the web, moving Windows to the web. Everything is in the cloud now.

46:49Brendan Carr: Satya Nadella once looked me in the eyes and said, if I could rename Windows, I'd rename it Azure Edge. Really? Yeah. He's like, whatever, man.

47:00David Pierce: Satya Nadella, by the way, not great at naming products.

47:04Brendan Carr: I don't know if any of them are at this point. But I mean, again, I think it's a fascinating device. The idea of a really high end NVIDIA ARM laptop that is optimized for running models locally is new. Like I am taken by the idea of new kinds of computers. I'm curious about them. I'm interested in them. And then you're just like, well, the paradigm of this, especially in a laptop, is kind of weird. Right? Like, okay, I'm going to have a bunch of compute in my house. I don't want the models to be in a cloud. I don't want my data to go to Anthropic or whatever it is. I'm going to put a server in the basement.

47:41Brendan Carr: Right.

47:41David Pierce: You have a headless Mac studio. Like that is understandable.

47:45Brendan Carr: Yeah. And then wherever I am in the world, I can use that because it's sitting here on my connection. This is a laptop. It's like, I need to take the model with me to do what in the coffee shop locally like i'm just dying to see what use

48:01David Pierce: cases emerge for that thing yeah yeah i will say i think there there's a version of this that is just finally microsoft made an honest to god out and out macbook pro competitor that that can hang at that level that is all on its own very exciting like it's it's expensive but so is the MacBook Pro. You can spec it up to death. If the RTX Spark platform is as good as advertised, this thing looks great. It has the specs. Microsoft got very excited about how many ports it has. It got so excited that it spelled the word surface wrong on the slide about all the ports. It's really good. Really a lot going on.

48:39Brendan Carr: When you say Copilot, it has become a bit of a joke. What I know is that it was active while those slides were being made, and it said nothing. No.

48:47David Pierce: It's like, oh, SirAss. I love that. That's my favorite other computer. Thank you, Copilot. But yeah, it does seem like if you just take this as the true sort of Surface Pro, fine. But I do think Microsoft is trying to make an argument that there is a next way of using computers inside of this device that you can build and use on this laptop. and yeah i agree with you i'm not sure anyone has quite figured out what that product is supposed to look like and maybe that's fine because this is a developer computer for developers and and in this rev everyone who gets it will know how to make it work and maybe that's enough yeah or or

49:26Brendan Carr: you know there's a market for 2600 windows laptops that look nice and perform like a macbook pro and yeah people are going to buy them just for that maybe the battery life is great and performance is great and that windows on arm will have solved it because nvidia brought to bear a whole new platform like that's reasonable too i'm just fascinated by the idea of okay it is not clear if the models commoditize if you can run distilled models locally there's all this stuff right where the compute can and should live yeah and i i actually think that's totally up for grabs right

49:59David Pierce: now yeah i agree and and i think it's actually a really huge interesting product opportunity for all of these companies.

50:05Brendan Carr: Well, also, it's like if it turns out to live on a laptop in your backpack, maybe that doesn't mean it needs to live in a data center, which maybe that's how the bubble

50:14David Pierce: pops like edge computing, baby, Azure edge. Yeah, I love it. There is one spec of the laptop that we should talk about. And it's apparently the most important thing about it, which is that it is the first I have to read this to make sure that I get all of the words correct. It has built in magnetic usbc charging and if you were to say david why is that an interesting milestone i would not have a great answer for you but that's apparently a thing it's magsafe did you not watch our video it goes pink yeah but but instead of being magsafe it's just a usb cable it goes better it goes pink does it does it actually make the noise i missed the video yeah because it because it's like physically going into the think do you hear are you getting the vision one more time one more time oh all right now i'm in i get it now that's good i never used the mag

51:05Brendan Carr: safe port on my macbook pro like never not once even though i was like psyched to see it come back because i'm always just someplace with usbc right i'm not going to carry another dumb cable this is like a perfect solution yep yeah oh i i totally agree i think this is great and i think

51:18David Pierce: it's it replaces microsoft's kind of long-term janky surface connect port with something that makes a lot more sense. And if this spurs everybody to start doing magnetic USB-C, I will be a happy, happy man. That would be awesome. Okay, the other laptop we should talk about is Google Books. Google Books are here.

51:39Brendan Carr: I can just go. I know you have like a five-hour monologue now. I do.

51:43David Pierce: I have a lot of thoughts. But okay, my actual question for you, Nilay, is very simple, which is why on earth did Google ship this now? And I want you to try to hash this out with me because the story of Google Books so far, right? There's five devices out. You guys have talked about this on the show. They're an Android first take on laptops. There is nothing, not one thing about this platform that is finished. There are some weird interface edges. No apps understand what a Google Book is or how to use them or what's supposed to, like nothing. It's just, it's an Android tablet pretending to be a laptop in a way that completely drives me crazy and i just keep looking around trying to figure out why google shipped this now and what it feels like it needs to be out in front of or what wave it's trying to get like well that one's obvious i know i know i know the answer to that one do you okay hit me holidays are coming okay that's when people buy these things so you

52:44Brendan Carr: got to get them out now developers have to have them hopefully you get a wave of software updates It's people buy cheap laptops for the holidays. Off you go. Black Friday is coming. Do you know what I mean? But it's that. Sure.

52:56David Pierce: Okay.

52:57Brendan Carr: But are they ready? I haven't actually heard anyone describe them as an Android tablet all dressed up as a laptop. That's very good.

53:04David Pierce: It's what it is. Like, okay, let me give you an example. So you open Netflix. Netflix. App I was very excited about, right? This is like the reason you want a desktop app is so you can download things to your computer and watch them on planes. right? Like this is an annoyance with my Mac. Some apps exist for the Mac that will let me down. Like Prime Video has an app that will let me download stuff locally. Netflix doesn't. Very annoying. So it's great that I just have Android apps. I can download stuff locally. This thing does not understand that it's not an Android tablet. It only runs full screen or 16.9 just down the middle of the thing.

53:39David Pierce: It doesn't interact with any other windows. It can't be resized. Like it's just these are tablet apps and to some extent this is like google's ongoing problem which is that it can't make anyone care about android apps like i've sort of danced around saying this for a long time because every time i denigrate the state of android apps a lot of people send me emails and get mad but this to me is like such a blistering indictment of how much developers care about making good apps for android that even after all this time android is pretty good on a google book It's pretty good on a television. It's pretty good on it.

54:12David Pierce: It's pretty good on lots of things. Android apps suck everywhere but phones. Yep. And it is so much more obvious to me on a Google book than it has ever been on anything else. And I just look at this thing. I'm like, maybe this is just a completely unsolvable problem. And Google is hosed.

54:27Brendan Carr: It's funny because all I want back is a Chromebook Pixel from 10 years ago that just had a web browser. But there's infinity research that people want apps. They don't just want to browse the web, even though that's what they do on their computers all day long.

54:41David Pierce: They don't think that's what they want, even though it is what they want.

54:46Brendan Carr: Google has now complicated the idea of a Chromebook to the point where what is a computer is an existential crisis.

54:53David Pierce: But there are a bunch of things about this that work for me. Like the Google book has a concept of a home screen in a way that laptops really don't. Like you can come and you can see widgets and it'll show you. You can array apps like you would on your phone. And there's something about that that is immediately like, oh, this is actually a good idea. Like we should use my desktop for things instead of just being a mess of files that I've downloaded. That's smart. The control center is laid out like my phone and is actually much more understandable than how to find settings all over the Mac in a lot of ways.

55:23David Pierce: Like a lot of these things make sense to me to bring Android and Chrome OS together works. The Chrome on the Google book seems a little worse in a way that we're all still trying to figure out. It's like desktop-ish Chrome.

55:37Brendan Carr: Oh, no. It's not.

55:38David Pierce: No, no, no, no, no. If someone can actually put the pieces together on this for me, please call me and do it. But it is not just they lifted desktop Chrome and put it on here, which is essentially what Chrome OS is. Like, it is full bore Chrome with some stuff around it.

55:56Brendan Carr: I would argue there's actually nothing worse than a desktop-ish browser.

56:00David Pierce: Yes. I mean, this thing runs extensions. it has some of the extra features i haven't found any websites that are broken but there are a bunch of little pieces of the interface that aren't there there are a couple of little tweaks to the way that things work that don't feel quite right the way windows is a little bit different like it's just it just it just feels somewhat less than chrome and to me it's like the one thing this thing needs to be is full ass chrome yeah if you see a laptop you're like i'm running

56:26Brendan Carr: full fat chrome like we're doing it that's the whole thing yeah and when i say there's nothing worse than a desktop-ish browser. It's like, when you're using a mobile browser, like a baby browser for babies, at least you know, you know? You're going to get kicked out over here, and you're not going to end up in, like, some mobile web backwater because the site automatically detected a blah, blah. You know? This is the experience of using an iPad for me all the time. It's like, oh, it's so close to being a real browser, and then everyone knows it's not, and they, like, put you in a kiddie pool.

56:59Brendan Carr: Like, there's nothing worse than that because you're like, oh, I'm so close. I'm using a thing that feels like a laptop and it won't just let me be a laptop. For Google to do it with Chrome, a thing called Chrome on a thing called a Google book that looks like a laptop, it's going to confuse lots of people in lots of ways.

57:15David Pierce: Yeah, it is. It is kind of crazy making. But it occurs to me that the sort of reason for existence of basically every gadget we've talked about so far is the same. And I like, I don't think I processed that until we were sitting here talking about this, that the idea underpinning all of these is some kind of new hardware on which your AI agent is allowed to just run amok, right? Whether it's Siri AI or Alexa Plus or Copilot or Gemini, whether it's a laptop or a tablet or a weird home, like everyone's hardware idea boils down to we need to give you surface on which to let your AI agent do things on your behalf.

57:56Brendan Carr: But the right surface for that is eight gigs of RAM and eight gigs of storage in the cloud. Like Meta figured it out. It's a little tiny Linux computer? Yeah. It's like, fine. We'll just give you a little cloud VM and it's going to have a browser in it. And you know, I think Meta's approach to like, it's just your computer. You can do whatever you want and here's the file system is neat.

58:15David Pierce: I think that was so smart by the way, even just in the way that it is, it is describable in the way that you just described it is so smart that like we just gave you a little tiny Linux computer in the cloud. Immediately your brain

58:26Brendan Carr: goes oh i understand that i will say you missed some drama while you were out because i think they

58:30David Pierce: kind of retconned their way to that oh yeah i don't think that's real at all but i think it's

58:34Brendan Carr: it's a it's a good no i mean like they announced muse and then people found that it could talk about the file system and then they're like no it was always meant to do that and they like quietly changed the behavior of muse to make it actually oh i saw because you got really pissy about it on

58:46David Pierce: threads because you got in a fight with somebody and then you doubled down and then they doubled down and then everybody was mad at everybody it was great and i won and then you i think you won I'm not positive.

58:55Brendan Carr: Then I demanded a statement on the record from Meta saying what the intended behavior was, and they declined. Say I won, Mark. Say I won. I was just saying. I was like, put your money where your mouth is. Say that this was always the intended behavior on the record. And then it was dead silence. Yeah. Just letting you know. But whatever. They got to the right answer, like a cool-ass answer. Yeah. Okay. Right? The idea that you have a little computer in the cloud and your muse can use it. And this is kind of what I mean about where is the compute going to live, especially for consumers. The only answer is in the cloud managed by an IT professional who gets paid a lot of money to make sure that your agent stays in a sandbox.

59:35Brendan Carr: There's no way a regular consumer should have a Mac Mini in the basement with OpenClaw just firing away. I don't know if you saw the Ben Thompson piece this past week. like it opened with i got a virus and it's because i'm in my basement and but he's like but the only reason i found out i had a virus is because i had open claw on my mac mini and it detected the virus and it's like all of this is a swirl of problems right uh there's something there that i just find utterly fascinating like all of these devices are there to get you through a platform shift yeah right The Google book, the idea that it can sort of like silently stream apps from your Android phone onto that display, all of the walls between these app paradigms are being torn down because they don't matter anymore.

1:00:26Brendan Carr: Like Google is pretty reticent to do that. The app vendors are reticent to do that. And over the past few years, everyone's just like, screw it. Just run the apps wherever you want. Everything's everything. It's fine. Because the next thing is coming and that's actually the battle worth fighting. I just don't know that I want the AI agent to click around on Chrome on my Google book in front of me. Go do that somewhere else.

1:00:51David Pierce: Yeah. Yeah, that's where things like Instinct and Muse feel good to me. It's like I actually don't most of the time want to see you doing the work. Just let me know when you need me and it'll be fine. but that's very hard to do because then you get the thing where it's like open up this weird browser inside of a messaging app and click around like you're a desktop user with your finger it's bad but but again there's a million interesting product ideas here and then i can't help but wonder if this is where like open ai and anthropic start looking around being like do we need to build laptops like if this is the thing if it's give people a browser the android app store and our AI agent system, we can win on the merits if that's the next thing.

1:01:39David Pierce: And maybe there's a tablet coming from Anthropic in six months and it's going to actually make a kind of sense.

1:01:46Brendan Carr: Maybe. I'm just going to inject the skepticism back into this because we have bought a lot of the framing from these companies and I do think this is a strategy they're chasing. Yeah. Just to say it, none of these agents actually work perfectly yet. They're all brittle and fascinating ways. Amazon is blocking Muse. It seems very likely that some combination of Cloudflare and every other major website in the world are going to be blocking every other agent soon unless there's money exchanged. And like we're in a very interesting and fun period right now where there are no rules and it's very easy to imagine the future.

1:02:26Brendan Carr: Right. And then especially because it's e-commerce, like all of the walls are going to go up until people make the appropriate business deals. And then maybe the joy of having an agent that can just click around the browser on your behalf and do anything will fall apart. Yeah. Right. And like, I don't, I don't know how any of that's going to play out. I just see all these companies are like, well, we could never beat the phone. Right. Is this our chance to beat the phone? Yeah. Yeah. It's the only, it's the only realistic chance they've had in ages.

1:02:56David Pierce: Yeah. This is what you have to do if you are one of these companies. Like you, it's the only chance. And I think, I mean, I look at a lot of this stuff and I, even using some of these devices, like I've been using a Google book pretty extensively this week and I just can't build the bring Gemini in muscle memory. Like I just, I know how to use computers and adding this brand new layer on top of it that does things sometimes faster, but sometimes slower. And like the sort of circle to search thing that Google has been doing, I think is spectacular and useful that it's just like, what is this? And where can I buy it?

1:03:37David Pierce: It's like surprisingly a question I ask a lot.

1:03:40Brendan Carr: Do you get good answers to this? Hit and miss. I have like a 50 % hit rate on this.

1:03:46David Pierce: 50 is not bad though, right? And that's kind of my point.

1:03:48Brendan Carr: I think it's horrible.

1:03:50David Pierce: Well, okay, let me give you an example. So my three-year-old goes to preschool and every day at preschool, he rides this little blue and yellow and red plastic motorcycle on the playground. It's just one of those like little balance bikes, but it looks like a motorcycle and he rides around with all his friends and he desperately wants one to have at home. I don't know what it's called. I don't really know how to look for it. If you just like Google blue balance bike, you get nowhere. But they took a picture of him riding it at preschool and sent it to us in the app. So I cropped the thing, sent it to Muse and I was like, what is this and where do I buy it?

1:04:24David Pierce: And it found it on like a Dutch school supply website for me to buy. Never in a million years of Googling would I have found it. I went to go and try and do it on my own and didn't find it. And it went and found it for me. And like, sometimes it fails spectacularly and sometimes it doesn't, but like it is a genuinely useful thing in spots. And that is about the extent of the actual muscle behavior I've been able to build to use this stuff. And there's so many other things where it's like, oh, I could kind of do this with AI, but it would take just as long and be vastly more complicated. Like most things don't take that long is the thing that I keep discovering.

1:05:04David Pierce: Most things that we do are not that hard and don't take that long. And the idea of learning some new thing to offload to AI just because it's sort of there waiting for me is not compelling.

1:05:15Brendan Carr: This is like when you get your first internship and you just like wander around someone else's office being like, do you have anything for me to do? Exactly. And everyone's like, no, dude. Like even just telling you what to do would take too long. Yep. It's that. I will say Mustafa from Microsoft, Mustafa Silliman from Microsoft was on Dakota recently. And we were like in the thick of AI safety pacing the frontier conversation. And just as a throwaway, he's like, I mean, you have to admit the models are getting better. Like we don't even talk about hallucinations anymore. And I was like, I can't do this with you right now.

1:05:44Brendan Carr: But dude, these things hallucinate all the time. Yeah. Constantly all the time. Like one of the reasons that I'm so skeptical about all of the agentic promises that are being made is all day long. They are just making stuff up. And then, you know, they do that Claude apology where they're like, you're so right. And it's like, no, I'm madder at you now.

1:06:05David Pierce: This isn't helping. Fair. M dash. That's my bad. It immediately just gives me hives as soon as it appears in my conversations.

1:06:14Brendan Carr: Yeah. There's something about, again, I agree with you. It is the thing they have to do. Yeah. There's no choice but to say, well, that might be the platform of the future. We should build hardware and UIs around it so that if it does emerge, we might be the winner. But there's nothing to say that it will get there on the timeframe that people are talking about. Yeah.

1:06:36David Pierce: And the fact that Muse, I think right now is a phone app that looks like a messaging app and is the one that has really escaped containment is fascinating. Like Muse is not some giant mainstream thing, but it's the only one of these that people outside of this world have asked me about and tried and talked about. And it is not some big new idea about things. It's a messaging app and a tiny computer in the cloud.

1:07:03Brendan Carr: Yeah. I mean, Meta does have the world's greatest advertising ecosystem. It sure does. They have, like, I felt really bad for OpenAI when they launched Dots because then they went and had to pay Meta for Instagram ads for Dots. And I was like, oh man, we are all just way behind here. Yeah.

1:07:20David Pierce: But then, Meta comes out with glasses and everybody says, no thank you, these are perfect glasses, I'm out.

1:07:27Brendan Carr: No, no, no, phones don't have a light, David. It's fine. They have a light.

1:07:32David Pierce: There were a few things that I was really grateful to not be at work to have to reckon with. And Mark Zuckerberg saying, no, phones don't have a light was one of them.

1:07:41Brendan Carr: Oh, we're going to reckon with phones don't have a light almost every week for the rest of our lives on the show. I promise you. We're going to have a dedicated segment. We'll have theme music. We're going to collect sponsors. Phones don't have a light. Our new What is a Photo 2027.

1:07:56David Pierce: Oh, God. Well, in the meantime, let's take another break so I can go collect myself. Then we're going to come back with the lightning round. We'll be right back.

1:08:04Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Satelli. Every dog owner knows that sinking feeling, the one you get in the pit of your stomach when suddenly you realize that you don't know where your dog is. The Satelli Collar Go is a GPS dog tracker that helps keep tabs on your dog with real-time GPS tracking, escape alerts, and intelligent monitoring. Real-time GPS location tracking and virtual boundaries can help keep your pet out of danger while providing freedom. If you live on a large piece of land or in a rural location, or even just like to let your dog run off leash every once in a while, the Satellite Caller Go can give you peace of mind.

1:08:40Nilay Patel: But the Satellite Caller Go isn't just about tracking where your dog is, it's also about tracking their health. Satellite Sense AI helps you spot changes in your pet's health, particularly when you aren't there to watch. With Satellite Caller Go, you can know where your dog is, what your dog's doing, and get insights into how your dog's feeling. Go to satellite.com to get 35 % off with promo code VergeCast. That's S-A-T-T-E-L-A-I.com to get 35 % off with the promo code VergeCast. Satellite.com, promo code VergeCast.

1:09:21Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from AWS AI. AWS AI is powering transformation across the world's leading organizations, moving AI from possibility to production at scale. Like how AWS AI helps Formula One turn race day data into real-time insights that bring fans closer to the action. Or how it helps Booking.com personalize every trip for travelers around the world. AWS AI is even transforming how things get built, helping Siemens power the production of smarter cars. Across industries, AWS AI is helping businesses innovate faster, lead with confidence, and transform what's possible today. AWS AI is how.

1:10:04Nilay Patel: Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools, threads, and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying blind. That's the problem Jira solves. What's the goal tied to your project? What got decided last week in Slack DMs? Atlassian's Teamwork Graph pulls all the pieces together, from Jira, Confluence, GitHub, Slack, and more, so nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share the context with agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot.

1:10:44Nilay Patel: Assign them work directly, or connect your agents through MCP. Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided, and by who, and more time actually shipping with Jira. Learn more at Jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com.

1:11:07David Pierce: All right, we're back. After seven weeks off, Eli, are we still doing this? Is it still time? It's time.

1:11:15Brendan Carr: Today's is really good. It's time for America's Favorite Podcast. We've been a podcast. Brennan Carr is a dummy. Brennan Carr is a dummy.

1:11:37Brendan Carr: The halftime breakdown is clutch.

1:11:41David Pierce: As a special treat, we had The Offspring record Renting Cars a Dummy theme song. The people have realized that you like pop punk. The people get me, and I appreciate that. This one comes from Corey Wright, who wrote, Neil and I are around the same age, so I felt like this is a fitting tribute to our era of pop punk. You have to understand that I love pop punk. Neil, I like sad boy music.

1:12:04Brendan Carr: That's important to understand. I'm just an older generation of punk. Write me a Clash song. We're going to be very happy. Yeah. But that does not mean you have license to do white boy reggae. We excuse the Clash for doing white boy reggae. Very few other people get that excuse.

1:12:19David Pierce: Correct. Also, see also ska music.

1:12:22Brendan Carr: But we will leave that. I feel like we're really close to getting a ska Brendan Carr's dummy theme. Like every week we were inching along and now we've just tipped him over. All right. There are two this week. Okay. One classic sort of First Amendment Brendan Carr battle. And then the second one is delicious. I don't know. There's not even another word for it. But the first one, as we have been covering over and over on Brendan Carr's Dummy America's Favorite Podcast on the podcast, Brendan keeps threatening our nation's broadcasters over the content they air because he says their use of the public airways is subject to public interest.

1:13:03Brendan Carr: And that means late night comedians are bad. Something.

1:13:06David Pierce: Yeah, that seems basically right. Yeah.

1:13:08Brendan Carr: It's always been unclear what he actually means here. He's hauled in a bunch of ABC stations owned by Disney for early license renewal, which he is not supposed to do. That case is in court. And ABC's lawyers this week on Tuesday said, quote, we sit with our head on the guillotine. We are watching everything we do.

1:13:28Nilay Patel: Yikes.

1:13:28Brendan Carr: So over and over and over again, we have pointed out that the point of government siege regulations is often not the actual regulation. It is the chilling effect. It is the prevention of speech by just by saying the government will punish you for your speech. You will not speak. And so here you have ABC very clearly saying by hauling our licenses in for early review against a nebulous standard and off schedule, you are chilling our speech. We are watching what we do on our news networks in a way that is impermissibly viewpoint based, especially in the United States where we have a First Amendment.

1:14:04Brendan Carr: The government should not be doing those things. that court that case is in court it seems like that judge understands what's going on we'll see what happens as it winds to resolution which it should ahead of the thick of election season i

1:14:18David Pierce: mean it is happening right now yeah we're in it in a real way right now i'm in a swing state and

1:14:23Brendan Carr: it's a mess i watched the packers game last week on nfl sunday ticket and somehow in new york state i was getting ads for ken paxton like that's how much money is being is being just shotgunned into the ecosystem that they've broken ad targeting. I was like, look, I'm not voting in the Texas Senate race, guys. Please stop showing me this advertising. Okay. The second one, the one that I find delicious. If you've been paying attention, you know that the thesis of our segment, Brendan Carr is a Dummy, America's Favorite Podcast, is that Brendan Carr is very dumb. It's the foundational principle of the show, if you will.

1:15:04Brendan Carr: Well, one thing that happens with Brendan is that sometimes he's so corrupt, he comes all the way back around and irritates the people for whom he is generally corrupt. Are you going to agree with Brendan Carr again? This is my favorite when this accidentally happens. So Brendan waived the ownership cap on local TV stations. So in the statute written by Congress, there's a 39 % cap. You are not allowed to own more than 39 % of the local TV stations in the market. This is designed to protect competition. You don't want all the media in a market to be owned by one company. Brendan's argument is, well, Google exists.

1:15:40Brendan Carr: And so surely Sinclair must be able to buy all the local TV stations. You reason that out however you want. But he waived the cap. This might be illegal. Guess who's suing him, David?

1:15:54David Pierce: Sinclair.

1:15:55Brendan Carr: Cable TV operators. Everyone's favorite. Right. The lobbying groups for our nation's largest and dare I say most beloved cable TV operators have realized that by allowing Sinclair and Nexstar to get huge, they will not be competing for rights and prices. They will just be able to demand rates. So the lobbying groups for Cox and Comcast and all the rest have filed a lawsuit and they have said that larger broadcast TV station groups will have the leverage to demand higher retransmission fees from TV providers, resulting in higher TV bills for consumers. The FCC order, quote, arbitrarily and capriciously ignores the harms that will surely follow from allowing broadcast station groups to exceed the national cap.

1:16:42David Pierce: You come all the way back around, Brendan. Like you're so you're so close to getting it. You guys are so you're so close. Just say the word antitrust. Just say it. Say it.

1:16:50Brendan Carr: I just say it. Brendan, you did corruption for one group, but you forgot that you're supposed to be in the pocket of the big cable companies, the big ISPs. They're the ones who are paying the bills.

1:17:03David Pierce: That's great.

1:17:04Brendan Carr: But no. So now everyone's mad at Brendan.

1:17:07David Pierce: You know, this makes me think up for no reason. There's this headline today on Variety that says - Disclosure, Variety is owned by our parent company. Oh, yeah, that's right. Our friends at Variety that says, Glenn Powell is staying quiet on politics because, quote, I do not like the discourse, says running man flopped after Paramount laid off entire marketing department. And I just saw a post that just screenshotted that headline and said, God, he's so close to understanding that business decisions are political in this environment. And it's just like, yep. we're all so close to getting it we're all so close delicious

1:17:44Brendan Carr: anyhow Brendan I would love to see you come on the show and thread this particular needle cause I mean who are you gonna be more corrupt for I'm just dying come on let's hang out is it gonna be here is it gonna be Comcast or is it gonna be Sinclair buddy quite a love triangle you find yourself in

1:18:05David Pierce: okay so here's an idea I'm gonna pitch you very quickly Our new parent company also owns South by Southwest. They do. So I'm proposing that at South by Southwest, we get one of those things where like you have two people on either side and then you put the dog in the middle and see who they run to. But it's Brendan Carr in the middle and it's the Trump administration on one side and it's cable operators on the other side. And they all try to just lure him in and see who he runs to first. Main stage South by Southwest would be huge.

1:18:32Brendan Carr: Brendan, I can make this happen for you. We literally can do that. I was just in Austin with the South by people. We can figure this out. Anyhow, that has been Brendan Carr is a dummy, America's favorite podcast. We've been a podcast. Brendan Carr is a dummy. I feel cleansed. We're going to have to make a Spotify playlist very soon.

1:18:54David Pierce: I think so. It's going to be very long and very confusing to anyone who finds it by accident.

1:18:59Brendan Carr: That's our midterm election package. It's not substantive coverage of the issues. It's a Spotify playlist of pop punk songs calling the chairman of the Federal Communications Commission a dummy.

1:19:09David Pierce: The Verge. My first lightning round item is in this swirl of insanity. Paramount and Warner Brothers Discovery finally completed this long-awaited, messy, expensive, complicated merger. Yet another thing I'm glad to, frankly, have missed many of the recent machinations of. There have been many machinations. Will they? Won't they? who's going to be in charge? What's Netflix going to do?

1:19:35Brendan Carr: We're going to move to Nashville.

1:19:36David Pierce: Yeah, like fights with various governments, all of whom kind of wussed out at the end, it seems.

1:19:42Brendan Carr: I mean, look, what middle-aged man hasn't woken up one day and threatened to move to Nashville? That's real. It's just a thing you do.

1:19:49David Pierce: This deal is now done, and it puts Paramount in control of Warner Brothers Discovery, which is now a company known as Skydance in a turn that makes perfect sense to everybody. what do you get when you put Paramount and Warner Brothers Discoveries together? You get Skydance this is now just an absolutely monstrous Hollywood company. It owns huge news businesses like CBS News and CNN it owns vast swaths of the studio movies that get made every year they've made big promises about how many movies they're going to make it owns lots of channels. It importantly now owns and operates two very big and very competitive of streaming services, and there's been a lot of speculation about whether that's going to continue to be the case.

1:20:34Brendan Carr: Oh, there's no speculation. They have announced. They are merging these streaming services. Sort of.

1:20:39David Pierce: Even they have talked out both sides of their mouth on this, where there have been people who have said things like, we're going to merge them, and then there have been other people who are like, well, actually, that's going to be more like a bundle than a merger. No, step one

1:20:50Brendan Carr: is a bundle. Step two is one big streaming server. David Ellison was on CNBC this morning, and he announced that they're going to compete with Silicon Valley with tech.

1:21:03David Pierce: Well, that doesn't mean anything. I'm just letting you know what I heard. Sure. I'm thrilled for them. Congratulations. Like, they too have iPhones to make movies on, I guess. Okay, so the idea is eventually one single streamer.

1:21:20Brendan Carr: Somewhere, somehow. Yep. On what timeline, I do not know. Sure. But the idea that they have a lot of debt to service, like an enormous amount of debt to service.

1:21:30David Pierce: Which I would point out is exactly what happened when Warner Brothers Discovery combined and nearly killed it.

1:21:36Brendan Carr: Oh yeah, and it's what happened to AT &T as well.

1:21:38David Pierce: Yeah, that company made a lot of really bad decisions because it had to service debt. And now it's a richer guy with a lot of debt to service, but still a hell of a lot of debt to service.

1:21:46Brendan Carr: Oh no, we are just rolling over this overfinanced Nissan Altima into a new Nissan Altima every couple of years. Like there's a$10 ,000 payment on this Altima and we're just going to keep going. Like that's where we are. Yep. But they also have to make 30 movies a year or pay$30 million a year per movie they don't make into like a health care fund run by the biggest unions. Like they have to spend a lot of money and they got to pay off a lot of debt. And the only way they're going to do is cut costs. And there's just no way they're going to run redundant marketing budgets, redundant customer support, redundant AWS bills.

1:22:21Brendan Carr: The word you're looking for is layoffs. They're going to lay a bunch of people off and they're going to cut anything that looks duplicative. So two streaming services just simply cannot be on the menu.

1:22:29David Pierce: That's fair. I also think it's very clear that Paramount Plus is not going to win. And if this company is actually going to make smart, ruthless decisions, they'll just cut Paramount Plus.

1:22:40Brendan Carr: Yeah. They hired, this is a real decoder PhD thesis, David Ellison is the CEO of Skydance. And then Enon Kreese, who used to be the CEO of Mattel and before that of Maker Studios, his title is co-CEO. so there's a ceo not two co-ceos a ceo and a co-ceo david olson is a ceo

1:23:02David Pierce: enon's title is co-ceo this has real like dwight shrewd is assistant to the regional manager

1:23:08Brendan Carr: kind of vibes that's uh uh we just had peter kofka on decoder he just wrote a profile of enon uh he's deep in it you should listen to it if you want more for that but uh that i'm just like what are we doing it's very good i mean yeah i think i bring this one up in part

1:23:24David Pierce: because there are obviously a lot of important news questions about what's going to happen to CNN. Now there are a lot of obviously worried people who work for these companies who are worried about layoffs. But the play here, if you just take David Ellison at his word, is to build something that is so big it can compete with specifically Netflix. I would not say anything that has happened at the already combined company of Paramount and Skydance suggests that this company is equipped to do that.

1:23:58Brendan Carr: I don't think it's Netflix. I think he knows that it's YouTube and TikTok, which by the way, the Ellison family has a stake in TikTok. The way he was talking about it on CNBC this morning was very much Silicon Valley came in. I mean, this is the quote. Silicon Valley came into media with platform technology, whatever you think that means, and they took it away from us. But now I've assembled the biggest and best bundle of IP the world has ever seen, along with sports and news. And we're going to put together a tech platform that can compete with Silicon Valley and win. I think they mean Netflix when they say that.

1:24:31David Pierce: Maybe they mean TikTok and YouTube. Maybe I'm wrong. But, like, it'll be interesting to see if they try to make user-generated content work at scale, which is a thing all of these companies keep trying and keep failing at. Oh, yeah.

1:24:43Brendan Carr: I think we, Disney has already announced that creators can use their IP to make vertical videos for Disney+. I think that is a partnership with TikTok. It would not surprise me at all if the Ellison family finds a way to get TikTok content into whatever forthcoming app there is. Yeah. Oh, absolutely. We'll see, but I will just say this again. I say it so many times. The problem for Hollywood is that everyone is actually watching vertical video and none of those platforms pay a dime for it. Yep. And they have to pay actors and actresses. They got to pay Glenn Powell. And then apparently they need to pay Glenn Powell's marketing department.

1:25:23Right.

1:25:23Brendan Carr: And like, that's just a lot of money for every minute of video that they produce. And Instagram doesn't pay anyone a dime.

1:25:31David Pierce: or or you realize that actually there's a lot of really positive signs that people want to go back out into the world and watch movies and you go make good movies like i a grand theory that i am percolating is that actually the company that is in trouble here is netflix because it's going to be caught in the middle of it doesn't have the vast quantity of free content nor does it have the event content that people will actually go out of their way and pay for. And so it's turning into, and this is true on the platform, it's turning into just chum, right? Like it is reality TV. It is hours to fill.

1:26:09David Pierce: And I think everybody looks at Netflix as like this unstoppable behemoth. I look at Netflix less every month than every month before because there is just increasingly nothing on it.

1:26:19Brendan Carr: Oh boy. Okay. We're going to do it. We're going to do it. We're first episode back after your leave, David, but we're doing it. It's time to break out the Go90s tale of Doom streaming services. So if no one remembers anymore, this was 100 years ago, Verizon launched a streaming service called Go90, whose innovation was that you could turn your phone sideways. Also, I believe you could join a gang. That was their version of community. Were they crews or were they gangs? It was one of those. I think it was crews. I don't think it was gangs. It'd be amazing if it was a gang. That's going to be our app.

1:26:50David Pierce: When we do the Verge video app, It's going to be gangs.

1:26:55Brendan Carr: Anyway, Go90 quickly failed. There's no other way to describe what happened to that platform. And thus, the Go90 scale of Doom streaming services was born where you start at zero. That's alive. And 90 is dead. Many, many, many streaming services have gone 90. Quibi famously, I believe, is the paradigmatic example. We all knew. We all knew what direction that thing was going. And to 90, it arrived. Yeah. All right. Netflix has been sitting at zero on the Go90 scale of Doom and Steaming Services since Netflix existed. You are making it sound like it's not at zero anymore.

1:27:32David Pierce: I mean, it's hard because it is so big and it has so much money that it's like betting on Netflix to cease to exist is ridiculous. And yet, I think you only get to be a zero if you are also an unstoppable cultural force. And Netflix is not that. whoo and if it's not it's it it no i'll say that it is losing that rapidly like it it was a cultural force because stranger things was a cultural force and wednesday kind of was and it has it has inched along through a few things that have been huge and now it is just betting that you will go on and there will be so much reality stuff to watch that you'll find something and you won't cancel.

1:28:22David Pierce: I would put it at like a 15. Like it's still somewhere in the green zone here. But it is like, also remember, Netflix spends an unbelievable amount of money on content. It is forever hugely expensive. It is forever at the mercy of continuing to grow. And I think things could get ugly the minute anything starts to turn for Netflix. So again, I am not moving it towards it might disappear from existence, but I think this idea that Netflix is the unstoppable behemoth of the future of entertainment is wrong.

1:29:02Brendan Carr: Wow, that's bold. I think only YouTube is a zero for me on this scale. Oh, YouTube is absolutely a zero.

1:29:09David Pierce: It's not going anywhere.

1:29:09Brendan Carr: Although if they continue to slop up YouTube in the way that they appear to want to slop up YouTube, I would actually, I would move it.

1:29:17David Pierce: Am I crazy? Am I just way over my skis on Netflix?

1:29:21Brendan Carr: I think Netflix is an aggressively well-run company. Sure. And the danger for Netflix, in my opinion, is that everyone has realized that their library of good movies from the 2000s is valuable, and they don't just dump it on Netflix anymore.

1:29:39David Pierce: Yes, that's fair too.

1:29:40Brendan Carr: And there's not an engine to make a bunch of those movies anymore. This is the problem. You can go watch that Ben Affleck clip about DVD sales and like why they don't make movies like that anymore. By the way, Ben Affleck this week gave like amazing interviews about how deep he is in AI. We should spend an hour just talking about that.

1:29:57David Pierce: Everybody, like Ben Affleck, please come on The Verge Cast.

1:29:59Brendan Carr: I know you listen.

1:30:00David Pierce: Come on the show. Tell us about your Python scripts. I want to hear about all of them.

1:30:03Brendan Carr: We can make this happen.

1:30:08Brendan Carr: But Netflix is also a slave to data. And I think there's a reason every Netflix movie looks the same. and is kind of bland in every Netflix TV. Like there's a Netflix look and I think it's fine. It is, you can watch TikTok while you watch Netflix. They got to get over that. They got to make things worth watching or find a way to win the licensing battle with everybody else to buy things worth watching. And I just don't, that's their danger, but I don't think that they're confused. Maybe not. Do you know what I mean?

1:30:40David Pierce: Yeah, that might be right. I mean, yeah, that might be right. We should talk more about Netflix sometimes, But by the way, while we're looking at the scale here, my read of this is Paramount Plus immediately goes to like an 85 on the scale.

1:30:53Brendan Carr: Oh, yeah, because it's going to get merged into HBO Max?

1:30:55David Pierce: Yeah, and I think HBO Max is like a 5. Like HBO Max, I think, is the clear end state of all of this for this giant new company of Skydance. Yeah, it makes a big thing. Yeah. And they put Casey Bloys, who was running HBO, in charge of all of this stuff. Like the bet here is very clearly on HBO, both like the people and the brand. Yeah. Which I think is the right bet, to be clear. Like people don't have feelings about Paramount the way that they do about HBO.

1:31:24Brendan Carr: We have never had to contend with, does being merged into HBO Max constitute going 90? We have. Because it's going away. It's going to be gone.

1:31:35David Pierce: This is the Hulu thing, right? Like Hulu still exists, even though it's also still been merged. but it that's still kind of a bundle but eventually hulu will just be a tab in the disney plus app and when that happens hulu has gone 90

1:31:49Brendan Carr: yes i think that's correct all right last one disney plus so that's the other one of of note

1:31:55David Pierce: here yeah disney plus is like is like a two or a three it's it's i think it is as close to being the cultural force that you have to reckon with as anybody on this list this is just it's very

1:32:08Brendan Carr: obvious that you have three children.

1:32:10David Pierce: I mean, yeah, I have young children, but also like the Star Wars stuff keeps working. Marvel keeps working. They have the IP that no one else has. And it'll be interesting, like Amazon is out there spending all this money on James Bond. Can that vault it up this list a little bit? But Disney is just the one you can make theme parks out of. Like, that's not changing anytime soon. Yeah.

1:32:32Brendan Carr: We can do all the rest of them, but it's interesting to see where you put Netflix here because Because Netflix was a rock solid zero for the last five years.

1:32:42David Pierce: Yeah. It just, it feels like it has lost something. And maybe you're right. The company is as well run as any you will find in this space. So maybe it'll figure it out. But I don't know. It feels. Okay, no.

1:32:56Brendan Carr: Just to say this as clearly as I can. I think Netflix is run by essentially sane people. And all of these other companies are run by crazies. Yes. That I. Like, I don't know how else to say that. Like, we don't know much about Josh DeMauro at Disney, but, you know, this past few weeks while you were out on leave, did you see Bob Chapek reappeared? He wrote like an angry memoir, right? He wrote a tell-all book. Yeah. And, you know, his theory is that he was only made CEO, so Bob Iger didn't have to do COVID layoffs until Scarlett Johansson, Black Widow, was coming out on streaming. Incredible. And then he's like, I knew I was done for when he gave that interview to Ben Smith.

1:33:35Brendan Carr: And I was like, I know Ben Smith. What happened to this interview?

1:33:40David Pierce: I think more CEOs should write pissy books.

1:33:44Brendan Carr: He's very upset. Yeah. And then something clearly happened because he was all over the place talking to stuff and then he disappeared. Yep. He's no longer available.

1:33:56David Pierce: I did notice that. It's good stuff. All right. This is officially the slowest lightning round we've ever done. It's true. What's your next lightning round item?

1:34:04Brendan Carr: I want to talk about intelligent UI, which we sort of have been talking about through all the computer stuff. But chat GBT this week did an update, GBT 6, and now the responses can include interactive elements right in line. Buttons, I'm guessing BuzzFeed quizzes. They love to pretend we're all smart. So they're like, here's a color picker for clothes and like an interactive chart where you can do a slider to learn something. And I'm like, tell me who the five sexiest presidents were. Like whatever, whatever BuzzFeed nonsense. I am fascinated by this, right? The idea that you would get multimodal interactives has been an idea that's been floating around for a long time.

1:34:44Brendan Carr: As with everything, Google announced this at IO two years ago.

1:34:48David Pierce: Yeah. I mean, there's like a little bit of it in AI mode. The idea that it will, it will sort of, it will gin up a spreadsheet for you rather than just write you a bunch of numbers. Like there's little pieces of that coming to fruition. But this is the idea that everyone has had for a long time, right? It's like, what if it wasn't just text and then every product everybody ships is just more text?

1:35:10Brendan Carr: Yeah, but even though like it made you a spreadsheet, it's mostly been like, yes, we can do tables and bullet points. Everyone is Axios now, right? Yeah. Sometimes pictures. Yeah, sometimes pictures. This is very much like we've made an interactive bicycle for you because you asked how Bicycle works. And there's something about this, which if you put right next to agents and natural language interfaces is the dream, right? The computer will naturally adapt to you and give you exactly what you need right at the right moment. And we have been covering this industry for 500 years. So many people have tried to build this thing.

1:35:47Brendan Carr: Yes. In so many different ways. And what it always runs into is people just want the controls to be fixed. you actually want the computer to be vastly more predictable than any adaptive UI system can ever give to you. And the comparison that I will make is we just went through, I don't know, five years of car makers being like, you don't need HVAC controls. You need a button on a screen that says auto. And every single person was like, no, I want physical buttons that turn the fan up and down and move the temperature. Stop taking them away because you don't think I don't want them. or worse, intelligently assuming when I should want them and making them appear and disappear at random.

1:36:30Brendan Carr: So I can't tell if this intelligent UI update for ChatGPT is brilliant in the future or we're just going to recapitulate every adaptive UI conversation we've ever had or whether there's something else happening here.

1:36:45David Pierce: I think all of these companies are kind of dancing around the wrong idea, which is this constant reinventing the wheel of user interface. Like, not only is it, what if it was just a button that said auto? It was, what if every time you got in the car, that button was in a different place and looked different? Wouldn't you like that? And this is what it has been with all of these companies, right? You can build this AI UI on the fly. And what it actually does is build it in a slightly different way, in a slightly different place every single time. And I think I was talking to some product person a couple of years ago when we were really first starting to talk about AI code.

1:37:27David Pierce: And he was like, the reason I'm so bullish about building code with AI is that I can do it once. I can use the AI to build something that I then understand. And then I can go use that thing. And I don't have to keep using the AI. I don't have to keep burning tokens. I don't have to keep guessing how this thing is going to work or reinventing my prompts. I can build a thing that I understand. And then I can go use the thing that I understand. and this to me is trying kind of to be too clever by half and in some ways it will work and it'll be very cool like it's an information retrieval system that it's like show me company earnings which is like a thing people care about from time to time right it will show you that in a more dynamic way and that's all fine and good or like show me how to split the bill between these people like show me that in some nicer visual way fine i don't think it goes beyond that at all in a way that's going to work for people.

1:38:18David Pierce: And I think actually a lot of people prefer text because text is a thing that is there that I understand that I can refer to that works in a predictable way that makes sense. And all of this generative UI stuff, I think just feels like mess to people.

1:38:33Brendan Carr: Yeah, my hottest take lately is no one actually knows how apps work and they don't know what the buttons are and they don't pay any attention. And this is why, you know, the average number of apps downloaded by the average person is zero.

1:38:45David Pierce: Well, and when you do learn how to do them, you learn how to do the two things that you need to do, and then your brain ceases to even see everything else in the app.

1:38:54Brendan Carr: Yeah. And I think this is why chatbots generating text was like, well, at least I can just read this. Right. Yeah. But like, it's going to make you an app and it might have a crazy UI idea in it. I don't know. There's something about this. Again, I find it fascinating. It has been the industry's dream stretching back decades, right? Like the computer will adapt to you and present to you exactly the right interface at the right time based on its understanding of you just speaking to it. Boy, every single executive we've ever talked to has issued some proclamation that this will be the future. And so maybe we're on the cusp of it.

1:39:31Brendan Carr: But I'm looking at it, I'm like, huh. Like, actually, you know, all the actual users we talk to might not want this. So we'll see, I'm not saying this, I think this feature as expressed in ChattoBee today is cool. Like, yes, it will make you a chart and graph and a slider and do a thing. And like, it is funny that Google announced this 100 years ago and OpenAI shipped it.

1:39:54David Pierce: Yeah, that sounds right.

1:39:57Brendan Carr: What are we doing, everybody? But the next turn, when you have an OpenAI hardware device that has an agent in the cloud, and it's like making you custom UI and adapting the UI to you, that's the one I'm interested in because it's going to be the HVAC problem at like massive scale.

1:40:14David Pierce: Yes, yes, completely agree. And that, yeah, and figuring out how to do that in a way that is build something that is sort of permanent and that you can refer to and find and use again and share is like, it's not necessarily impossible, but no one has come anywhere near that yet. Yeah. But I do think it's a fun idea. Like, it's fun to watch people try this thing. That like, how do I, how do I deliver you information in new and better ways is great. Lots of people learn and retain information in lots of different ways. We should keep trying this. But I'm not at all convinced that let's reinvent the wheel every single time is, in fact, the answer here.

1:40:52Brendan Carr: It's funny because everyone knows that. But it just seems like if you're a product designer at a tech company, you are required to forget it on a three-year cadence.

1:41:00David Pierce: Yes. That's how you get promoted. You reinvent the wheel. You get promoted. You take a vacation. Then you come back and you start to reinvent the wheel again. It's a thing. All right. We really need to get out of here. But before we do, I just want to talk about one thing very briefly. I just want to get your temperature on this thing. So Sam Altman did an interview on a new Politico podcast, the name of which I will not say out loud for reasons that anyone who knows the name of the podcast will understand.

1:41:25Brendan Carr: You know who knows the name of the podcast is the lawyers at our fancy big company.

1:41:31David Pierce: um so sam altman on this podcast is talking about all the things sam altman likes to talk about um and he he says at one point that uh some bad things are going to happen with ai and that we have to be okay with some bad things happening because and this is a quote people will do tremendously orders of magnitude more good stuff uh this became a whole kerfuffle right everybody spent a couple of days being various degrees of mad about Sam Altman being like, I accept some bad stuff because there's also going to be all kinds of good stuff happening. I confess my immediate instinct is to be like, this is such a nothing burger of a statement.

1:42:11David Pierce: Everything that has ever happened has some bad things and some good things. And we try to lessen the bad things and increase the good things, but this is just how every advancement we've ever had in history has worked. Yeah. What do you make of this? Like, is this a real thing for people to be angry about that Sam Altman is saying?

1:42:29Brendan Carr: I don't think so. I think the way he framed it was particularly awkward. So the exact quote is, we believe the world should accept some bad things happening for the benefits of this technology and people having the agency. And I'm like...

1:42:43David Pierce: Ooh, yeah, when you put it like that. I don't care what the benefits

1:42:45Brendan Carr: of this technology. Like, the point, the technology is whatever. Like, and I get what he's trying to say. there's a big technological revolution and we're going to give people a lot more capability and some people will do bad things and the negative consequences will be far outweighed by the positive. And you can apply that, as you're saying, you can apply that to anything from electric lights to cars to whatever it is, right? You're going to give people cars, you're going to increase mobility, you're going to also have some car crashes and then the anti-car movement in cities in 2026 will be a loud and vocal potent force.

1:43:22Brendan Carr: And then we're going to do congestion pricing, whatever. Like some swirl of decisions will have to be made because cars exist. Okay. Like if that is what he's trying to say, straightforward, I think is fine. But for the benefits of this technology is the entire problem with how the AI industry communicates is as though they are not in control of what they are doing. Right. And so either we're going to have AGI or not. And if I don't get there first, then something bad will happen. And so some bad things have to happen. Like, that's how he sounds. I know that's just how he sounds to people, that he has to get there.

1:43:59Brendan Carr: We've got to do this. So you deal with it. Deal with the data centers. Deal with the teens getting AI psychosis. Like, all of that is fine because we have to do this and I can't possibly slow down or be more careful. And so if he's talking about the straight up societal tradeoff, Like the reason the decoder tagline is big ideas and other problems is like it is embedded in the very notion of the big idea that you will have to answer for some problems that you have caused. Yep. Okay. Like, of course I buy it. But the way this industry talks about the thing that they're making is though they have completely lost control of their own ambition.

1:44:35Brendan Carr: And we all just have to like, yeah, man, I think data centers and surveillance are going to tip the election in this round. And a large part of it is because the industry cannot help itself. Right.

1:44:46David Pierce: Yeah, and they also, well, at some point, at some point you and I are going to have a long, deep conversation that may or may not ever make it onto a podcast about this thing where they've all decided that AI is alive and deserves feelings and fair treatment and all of this weird, like the fact that the Claude terms now prohibit you from being mean to Claude for too long is just like buck wild in a way that I'm actually like just out of my mind about. But in this one, I just kept thinking about the fact that Sam Altman, in this case and in basically every case, is just completely unable to articulate the good thing that AI is going to do.

1:45:25David Pierce: He's like, yes, all this bad stuff is going to happen, but it's going to do so much more good stuff. And it's like, well, what, Sam? It's going to put everybody out of jobs. It might kill all of us. What's the good part? Well, it's going to

1:45:36Brendan Carr: monitor your email for class action.

1:45:38David Pierce: It's going to do sick math. And that's cool. I like math. But yeah, it's going to monitor your email for class action settlements. I don't know. Again, just as a as a watcher of this over the last couple of months i just kept looking out and it's like nobody has a better idea for ai than it can help you book trips and everybody has ideas about how it might kill us all and like boy is that a bad trade if you if you can if you can give me the trade that is good enough that i will accept a 10 chance that we're all gonna die that's actually a really fun conversation to have i would really really like someone to make that argument once and no one can do it including sam altman and it drives me nuts they're gonna cure all diseases but they also might kill you you didn't say that the gemesis office is out here being like we're gonna cure all diseases sam altman doesn't he's like i don't know war weapons maybe i don't know and i think that to me was just like this this thing that like yes there are negative consequences to technological innovation is just true but like even mark zuckerberg with Facebook was like, we're going to connect people and that's good.

1:46:45David Pierce: And that's bad in lots of ways and good in lots of ways.

1:46:49Brendan Carr: And I think there's a famous memo from Boz at Meta called the ugly. And he's like, here are all of the bad things that will happen if we connect everyone in the world and we're going to do it anyway. And there's a lot of lore around this letter. You should Google it and read it. But the sort of most important part of the lore was Boz saying, it's important for me to just say it all out loud so this whole company can react to it. I've written this as a provocation. And then the company did not react to it by trying to stop any of the things, which is maybe a strategic mistake. But there's no question that the tech industry understands that it has negative consequences when it reorders society.

1:47:28Brendan Carr: And I think here, Sam, again, if you're just saying that conceptually, fine. Like, true. Like, the steam engine. Like, whatever it is. But to say it is, like, a toss-off, which is, I think, how most people read it. Yeah.

1:47:42David Pierce: Yeah, that's fair. I agree with that. And also, for what, Sam? 10 % chance I'm going to die. I can put my own flights.

1:47:51Brendan Carr: I saw a video of Heath Ledger's Joker doing a ukulele rap with Batman the other day.

1:47:58David Pierce: All right, you've got me a 2 % chance I'm going to die. We can work from there.

1:48:02Brendan Carr: We're going to go from there. That's what I have. That's a real thing that happens.

1:48:06David Pierce: All right, we have gone way over. Send me that link, by the way. I appreciate that. we have gone way over as we are once to do it's good to be back I missed you I'm glad to be back here doing this we should get out of here thing before we do vote for our show in the Signal Awards it's a it's a podcasting awards thing we would very much like to win this show is nominated for technology podcasts version history is nominated for history podcasts decoder is nominated for business podcasts not to brag that's all of our podcasts we batted a thousand please go vote we'd really like to win all the links are in the show notes also So we have a bunch of cool Decoder stuff coming up next week.

1:48:42David Pierce: Nilay, who's on Decoder next week?

1:48:44Brendan Carr: So go listen to the Peter Kafka episode if you want more on Skydance. He really did just profile the co-CEO Skydance. He's deep in it. And then Ben Jordan is on to talk about Flock cameras and surveillance and his experience testifying before Congress. And I'm just going to say I'm a huge fanboy, and you can just sense that I was delighted the whole time that he was even talking to me.

1:49:02David Pierce: That's awesome. I'm excited about that one. This weekend on Version History, Jen Toohey is coming on to talk about the LeapPad. Jen Toohey and Andrew Marino to talk about this weird little reading device that taught millions of kids how to read in the early 2000s. Also, if you haven't watched the Chromebook episode, if you want to know the source of all of my feelings about Google Books, go watch last week's episode, you and me and Marques Brownlee on the Chromebook. It was a great time. We've gotten a lot of really good feedback on that episode. I enjoyed it very much. Remember to subscribe to The Verge to get all of our podcasts ad-free, all of our award-nominated and winning podcasts ad-free, all of our exclusive newsletters, everything else, theverge.com slash subscribe.

1:49:42David Pierce: It's the best way to support everything that we do here. Also, send us email. Vergecast at theverge.com is the email. 866-VERGE-11 is the hotline. We love hearing from you about all this and everything else. The Vergecast is a Verge production and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. This show is produced by Josh Cajas, Eric Gomez, Brandon Kiefer, and Travis Larchuk. We will see you next week. Neelai, I haven't heard it in a while. Give it to me. Rock and roll.

From the publisher

It's gadget season. More specifically, it's apparently "new computer for your new AI" season. David and Nilay talk through a slew of announcements — Amazon's Alexa Tablets, Microsoft's Surface Laptop Ultra, the new Googlebooks, and Apple's upcoming smart home launch — to figure out if anyone has the right idea about the future of computing, and where the AI is supposed to live. After that, it's time for Brendan Carr is a Dummy, our thoughts on the Paramount / Warner / Skydance merger, and much more.

Please vote for The Verge's podcasts in the Signal listener's choice awards!

Vote Vergecast: Best Technology Podcast

Vote Version History: Best History Podcast

Vote Decoder: Best Business Podcast

We’re also on video! Check us out on YouTube.

Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters and our ad-free podcast feed.

We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to [email protected] or call us at 866-VERGE11.

Read more about the topics discussed in today's 1 hour, 41 minute podcast:

⁠Amazon’s Alexa Tablets are powerful, impressive, and designed to take on iPad ⁠

⁠Hands-on with Amazon’s Alexa Tablet 12 Pro and its wild new matte display  ⁠

⁠Amazon is phasing out Fire Tablets because they weren’t ‘giving customers what they were asking for⁠’

⁠Amazon’s new Kids Tablets let parents manage access to the Google Play store

⁠Apple announces surprise ‘Welcome home’ launch event⁠

⁠Apple and LG team up on new smart home gear, starting with a lock, doorbell, and thermostat⁠

⁠New leaks provide our first look at Apple and LG’s smart home devices

⁠Everything announced at Microsoft’s Surface Laptop Ultra event ⁠

⁠The Surface Laptop Ultra finally has a release date — and a starting price of $2,599⁠

⁠Microsoft’s Surface Laptop Ultra has built-in magnetic USB-C charging ⁠

⁠How Microsoft built its MacBook Pro competitor ⁠

⁠Surface RTX Spark Dev Box is available for preorder for $5,999 ⁠

⁠The first Nvidia RTX Spark laptops cost up to $7,000 ⁠

⁠Microsoft is giving Copilot more control over Windows and your files

Our first five impressions of Googlebooks — exciting but underbaked 

Android’s physical navigation buttons are back on Googlebooks, but not the way you think

Google admits not every Android app runs great on Intel Googlebooks 

Politico: ‘Head on a guillotine’: ABC says Trump’s threats are already swaying coverage

ChatGPT’s ‘Intelligent UI’ update fills its responses with pictures, charts, and buttons

Paramount and Warner Bros. Discovery complete $110 billion media megamerger 

HBO Max and Paramount Plus will merge into a single streamer under Skydance 

CNN’s boss will remain as Paramount and WBD merge into Skydance 

Skydance is merging Paramount and Warner Bros. Discovery’s games teams.

Sam Altman says ‘some bad things’ will happen, but AI is totally worth it

0:00 Cold Open
00:37 David’s back!
01:10 Parenting Chaos Update
02:49 Gadget News Rundown
03:47 New Amazon Alexa Tablets
05:15 Panos Strategy Shift
06:31 Play Store Bet
11:17 Default Android Tablet
13:18 Ads and Pricing Fears
15:30 Amazon Great Products
21:20 Matte Display Debate
25:01 Apple Smart Home Tease
26:12 Siri AI Reality Check
29:08 Smart Home Too Complex
33:37 Candy Crush Question
34:56 iPad Multiuser Problem
39:04 Microsoft AI Surface Push
40:35 Local AI Computing Shift
47:22 Magnetic USB C Charging
48:37 Google Book Laptop Confusion
54:20 AI Agents Need A Surface
58:50 Skepticism About Agents
01:07:46 Brendan Carr is a Dummy
01:09:23 ABC License Chilling Effect
01:11:24 Brendan Carr Ownership Cap
01:12:30 Cable Companies Sue Back
01:14:44 SXSW Corruption Game
01:15:50 Skydance Mega Merger
01:18:04 Debt Layoffs Streamer Cuts
01:22:58 Go90 Scale Returns
01:24:02 Netflix Loses Its Edge
01:30:44 ChatGPT Interactive UI
01:37:47 Sam Altman Tradeoffs
01:44:49 Wrap Up And Plugs
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Vergecast

All episodes