1. Podcasts
  2. The Vergecast
  3. The touchscreen MacBook Apple said it wouldn't make
The Vergecast

29 Oct 2026 · 41m · 13 chapters

Episode artwork

The touchscreen MacBook Apple said it wouldn't make

In short

Apple’s newly launched touchscreen MacBook Pro (called “MacBook Pro with ProLED XDR”)—why Apple made it, how much it changes macOS, and whether touch is actually useful. The episode also briefly covers the Pebble Index 01 smart ring as an AI-friendly voice input gadget.

Guest backgrounds

Antonio DiBenedetto, The Verge laptop reviewer; frequent hands-on user of many laptop types, including Windows touchscreen clamshells and stylus-equipped 2-in-1s (Surface Pro, Lenovo Yoga).

Key claims

Touch is “nice to have,” not the main draw; lighter weight and OLED matter more. Apple’s demos show professionals tapping occasionally, not a new computing paradigm. macOS changes are mostly gesture/tap tweaks (e.g., traffic-light targets magnify; touch gestures mirror trackpad). Apple still won’t support Apple Pencil on the MacBook; “iPad” is the answer.

Notable examples

video editing pinch/zoom and timeline scrubbing; DaVinci Resolve touch-optimized controls; iPhone mirroring via touch; hotel-room music producer beat tapping; spotlight-like touch interactions are unlikely to be used by power users.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:18

90 Seconds on The Verge

A quick roundup of the latest tech news, including major acquisitions and market trends.

“DoorDash is buying Instacart, a deal that combines two of the biggest names in food delivery.”
1:50

Teaser for Future Episode

A brief mention of a related episode about AI personal assistants and their impact.

“How much more would you get done with a personal assistant in your pocket?”
2:29

The Steve Jobs-ism on Touchscreen Laptops

Discussion on Steve Jobs' strong opinions against touchscreen laptops.

2:45

Apple's New Touchscreen MacBook

Introduction to Apple's newly launched touchscreen MacBook and its features.

“I'm paraphrasing, but that's more or less what it was.”
3:15

Antonio DiBenedetto's Insights

Antonio shares his experiences and thoughts on using the new MacBook Pro.

“I'm actually like literally on the dot two hours ago, walked into my door.”
6:00

Evaluating the Touchscreen Feature

A discussion on the practicality and importance of the touchscreen in the new MacBook.

“Yeah, I think it's very telling to me that this thing is called the MacBook Pro with ProLED XDR, not the MacBook Pro Touch.”
12:00

Apple's Future with Touch Technology

Speculation about potential future developments for touch technology in Apple's product line.

14:00

Exploring Touchscreen Features of the MacBook

Discussion on potential touchscreen features for MacBooks and their practicality.

“the Apple Pencil could attach to the side and charge.”
15:30

Touchscreen Integration in macOS

Analysis of how macOS has adapted to touchscreen functionality.

“Like, it seems like they came very close to just saying, nothing has changed, here's a touchscreen.”
18:46

Challenges of Touch Gestures on MacBooks

Discussion of the challenges and usability of touch gestures on MacBooks.

“There's definitely room to do, to do more.”
Show all 13 chapters
22:55

Implications of Touchscreens for Apple's MacBook Lineup

Exploring the potential impact and expectations of touchscreens on future MacBooks.

“a lot of things I'm curious to see about this thing, about the sort of backing and forthing from screen to trackpad.”
28:00

Touchscreen MacBook Discussion

The hosts explore the implications and challenges of a potential touchscreen MacBook.

“It solves all the problems it needs to solve and no more and causes no other problems.”
32:51

Introduction to the Pebble Index 01

A deep dive into the features and functions of the Pebble Index 01 smart ring.

“All right, before we go, I have one more thing for you.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Vergecast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02Hello and welcome to The Verge Cast, a flagship podcast of Tandem OLEDs. I'm your friend David Pierce, and today on the show, did Apple finally launch the touchscreen MacBook we've been waiting for? And should we have been waiting for a touchscreen MacBook in the first place? But first, here's everything else happening on The Verge today. This is 90 Seconds on The Verge for Thursday, October 29th, 2026. DoorDash is buying Instacart, a deal that combines two of the biggest names in food delivery. DoorDash says it's paying approximately$17 billion for the purchase. and says it doesn't plan to combine the brands.

0:32So Instacart will live on as a grocery delivery thing. Delivery is a tough, low-margin business, and there's actually a lot of tough competition. Amazon bought Whole Foods and integrated it into its systems. Walmart delivers groceries now. Uber is getting further into this. And this is just a hard nut to crack from the outside. DoorDash's idea seems to be to combine its delivery system with Instacart's ongoing integrations into grocery stores and inventory systems. but this is a really big bet on delivery grocery. We'll see. Meanwhile, Google is seeing big growth in search thanks to AI, although that might be terrible for business.

1:06CEO Sundar Pichai said as part of the company's earnings that query growth rate is at its highest point in five years and that AI investments are a big part of that. But then chief business officer Philip Schindler said Google is seeing lower monetization from its AI mode ads so far. Google also said it's working on a better AI agent for consumers to take on Muse and Dots and the rest because even Google appears to have forgotten that it already has one of those called Spark. And finally, I have some bad Ramageddon news. A Samsung executive said that they expect, quote, tight supply conditions to last into 2028 and that its 2027 supply of HBM RAM is already sold out.

1:42It turns out the ever-increasing price of everything does not seem to be slowing down anytime soon. You can read more about all this at TheVerge.com. That is 90 Seconds on The Verge for Thursday, October 29th. How much more would you get done with a personal assistant in your pocket? Life's too short to be like manually filing insurance claims and like being on hold waiting for like the lab tests that the, you know, that the doctor did. Like, I don't know. I feel like it's allowing me to show up in ways that I've always wished I could show up. I just am so strapped for time. What we gain and give up when AI agents enter the picture.

2:17That's this week on Explain It To Me. Listen to new episodes Sundays, wherever you get your podcasts.

2:28One of the most famous Steve Jobs-isms was that touchscreen laptops are a bad idea. He made the case that nobody wants to reach out and poke their vertical screen, that touch should be horizontal, and that actually a touchscreen laptop was a terrible idea, and if you want it, you're just a stupid person. I'm paraphrasing, but that's more or less what it was. And then fast forward to this week, Apple launched a touchscreen MacBook. It's not called the touchscreen MacBook. It's called the MacBook Pro with ProLED XDR, but it is very much a touchscreen MacBook. Antonio DiBenedetto on our team was there.

3:01He has seen it. He has touched it. He has used it. So I asked him to come here and explain what Apple's doing here, why it decided to make a touchscreen MacBook, and whether this is even a good idea in the first place. Let's get into it. Antonio DiBenedetto, welcome back.

3:16Antonio Di Benedetto: Hey, glad to be here. Fresh off a plane back from LA. You've had quite a 24 hours, I suspect. Yeah, it's been interesting. I'm actually like literally on the dot two hours ago, walked into my door. Nice. Yeah. Well, I appreciate you being here. I want to start just with you as a laptop reviewer. You use a lot of laptops. I think the idea of a touchscreen on a computer is not new to anyone who has used a Windows computer in the last like 10 years. So I'm curious for you just in your normal life as a person who uses a laptop and who uses lots of laptops, do you touch your computer a lot? Not really, actually, even though I use plenty of Windows laptops that have touchscreens, plenty that are clamshells, just like the macbook pro um i don't i don't use a whole lot of touch functions but i do find them useful just kind of once in a while when you do feel the need or whatever the urge to to tap at it but when it comes to like like two and ones and convertibles and like those different different form factors surface pros those kinds of things like that's when like i'll use a little more like obviously like a surface pro is really kind of geared towards touch and then when you use like a like a lenovo yoga or something like that that has a stylus and i really like that those styluses can be used on the screen or on the trackpad.

4:35Antonio Di Benedetto: And that's pretty cool. That's when I'll use it a little more. Otherwise, like your typical clamshell, it's like once in a while, a little peck or a little scroll. And that's mostly it. Yeah. So I'm of two minds about this new MacBook Pro. One is that obviously the fact that it has a touchscreen is really interesting. This is a thing people have been talking about and ostensibly asking for for a very long time. On the other hand, it seems to be maybe the least important or compelling new thing about this device. That in fact, they've made a bunch of other changes to this new MacBook Pro, all of which might matter more to someone's everyday computing experience than this.

5:14Is that fair? Like, am I right in feeling both of those things simultaneously?

5:19Antonio Di Benedetto: No, I think you're 100 % right. It's like, the fact that it's lighter will affect people more every day than the fact that it has a touchscreen. Like, you will pick it up from the corner and be like, ah, this is like much easier to pick up like it's the larger ones of like a full pound lighter right i think it was a half pound lighter for the 14 inch and like the better part of a pound for you know it's it's a big difference yeah yeah uh so like it's all that's gonna be like probably the big one of the biggest draws that and the oled right and then like and like the lid logo is just like the illuminated lid logo is just fun like there's more whimsy and magic like in the lid logo than there is really in the touch functions.

5:59Antonio Di Benedetto: The touchscreen is just there. It's just nice to have. Yeah, I think it's very telling to me that this thing is called the MacBook Pro with ProLED XDR, not the MacBook Pro Touch. Do you know what I mean? This is not a thing Apple does unintentionally. And I think Apple obviously knows that if it's going to launch a touchscreen Mac, a lot of people are going to talk about it. And that's fine. And we're about to at length. But it does seem to me like Apple is trying to communicate here that the job of this thing is not to have a touchscreen. The job of it is to do all of these other things. And also somewhere deep down the spec list is a touchscreen, which just to lay my own cards on the table, I think is the exact correct approach to adding a touchscreen to a Mac for reasons we will get into.

6:44But tell me about this thing. So obviously, you go to this event. As far as I can tell, they dragged a bunch of people out to LA to yammer at you for six minutes about a laptop and then let you touch it uh is that more or less how

6:56Antonio Di Benedetto: it went what was the actual event like uh jesus was it actually six minutes like i don't know it felt like six minutes it felt it was absolute chaos to try oh you're trying to live blog it like i was like taking i was literally like taking pictures with my phone of of turnus on stage and then like squatting down to my laptop which was sat on a seat like it's like because there was it was like mostly standing room and it was just it was weird like like i don't it's like one of those things like why are we even doing the little presentation or why aren't we making it longer like we don't need like i don't need like an hour and a half wwdc keynote but like maybe take a little more time but i don't know again maybe there was just not enough to show like what they could have done more they could have like walked us through like more of the mac os changes i know there's not not a ton but like they could have gone through a little more the dynamic island and stuff.

7:48Antonio Di Benedetto: It was, um, it was really all just a whirlwind. And then it was quickly the, you know, rush to the hands-on area. Did John, so this moment, I would think if I'm Apple, the reason to do this is a, you want to make a big deal out of a new laptop, but this laptop is the sort of thing that Apple normally would just launch with a press release, right? Like great new screen. It's even lighter. You don't need to fly to out to LA to get this. So my assumption would be that Apple sees this as the moment to get up and sort of explain why they're doing a touchscreen Mac. And at least from what I can tell, and even what I've seen in follow-up coverage, there wasn't a lot of that.

8:24There's not a lot of grand theories about touchscreen laptops coming out of Apple as part of this announcement.

8:31Antonio Di Benedetto: No, there's really not. The best I can surmise why they had us come to LA was they did have a bunch of demos and our briefings of all these different professionals that are using the the touchscreen and using the new macbook pro and you know they they obviously gear towards professionals and and you know they had someone who was in fashion design they had a photographer they had video i mean they had people from ilm there like serious like serious pros and doing this stuff for like 20 30 years and like of course it's always funny then when you see like they have them set up with like an iphone setup for for the with some crazy lens on it and i think i saw like zeiss glass adapted to it and it's just like okay like you know when they go back that's not they're using but um but the interesting thing about those some of those demos were like the touchscreen was just like it was it was as you would expect these pros to use it it's like oh they occasionally are going to tap on it like you know they were not really forcing like oh you've got to really like just show the like like oh this changes the way you use a laptop it's not all about the touch like no it's just something you're going to tap at or you know swipe at when it's convenient when it makes sense in your workflow.

9:40Antonio Di Benedetto: Do you think that's the right answer? Like, again, this gets back to kind of my grand reaction to this whole thing, which is that I feel like there was certainly a world in which Apple launches this thing as sort of the grand conclusion of the iPad and the Mac running towards each other. And this is some huge new idea about computing. It doesn't feel like they did that at all. Instead, they're like, here's a couple of things that might work really well to do with touch, swiping through timelines in video editing apps, pinching to zoom on large images. And that's it. And that's fine. And I think to some extent, I think that the reaction that I've seen is sort of disappointment that there isn't something bigger going on here.

10:23But even just back to the original question, like I, nobody looks at Windows computers and it's like, oh, it sucks that this thing has a touchscreen. They just don't mostly use it. and that you use it when it's useful and you don't when it's not, that feels fine to me. And it seems like even the people who have already been using these things, even people who are being put out in front to show you how to use these things are already embracing the idea that like I might use this a couple of times a day for occasional things. This is not some reinvention of the MacBook in favor of touch.

10:50Antonio Di Benedetto: Yeah, exactly. It's just, there's really no fault to having this. Like I saw like some commenters online that were like, just like, oh, terrible. I don't want, I don't want, it's like, I mean, okay, if you really hate it, you can go into the accessibility menu and turn it off um sure but like if you're but like you know what if you don't like the touch screen you just don't touch it like it's it's it's far enough from your hands that you're you're probably not going to accidentally touch it you're not going to pick it up from the screen and be like oh no um so it's really not that big of a deal but it's just one of those things like it'll be nice to have when you occasionally want to use it or occasionally need it i mean they had like a music producer who was talking about you know he was doing some some sequencer beat stuff that you know and made the example like well i'm in a hotel room you know like and some of these people like busy and on the go all the time like it's just kind of nice to not have to go like plugging in other things like if he is just working on something but then occasionally it's like you wouldn't really tap out a beat on a haptic trackpad you know and maybe even a keyboard key is maybe not ideal you know it's a screen kind of works for that um so yeah it's just kind of a nice to have and i guess like like we're kind of expecting like okay like but if they're finally doing this like how is that like is apple going to make it better are they going to like add their magic to it and it's just like no because there probably isn't really any magic to add and there's really i don't know maybe in the future we could see something new and better i hope that an apple pencil support will come eventually or there will be a new pencil that's supported i also would love to see like you know a different form factor or whatever but it's like i don't know apple usually takes the boring route for a while i assume if you ask somebody why it doesn't do those things every apple executive will just say ipad to you over and over did you did you get anyone to do this to you yeah uh that exactly happened um so i i ran into john turnus uh at at the event as you do as you know just yeah um there was a flock of people following him that were lining up to take selfies and the line just kind of naturally formed in my direction i'm like well i guess i'm now in line to talk to the ceo of one of the biggest companies in the world um so uh yeah i just said hi and talked to him and and when i mentioned like that it all seems very he's like what do you think and i was like seems it's a laptop you know and then and i can't tell if he would love or hate that characterization i i said i really what i really said is like it seemed it seems very normal and i meant that as like just straight that like i it was really my way of saying like i'm very whelmed you know like yeah and yeah probably wasn't thrilled i don't know but uh when i mentioned like a you know pencil support would be nice um but you know he's quickly quickly got into this the ceo talk of like we've got the ipad and it's the best for that i'm like okay all right fine fine fine i'm like like usual when you talk to ceo i was like i regret saying anything he was very nice it was fine i assume i like if i'm if i'm a betting man i would put ten dollars right now on the MacBook will eventually get Apple Pencil support.

13:51But for now, the answer is the iPad. And that is that's a fine answer as far as it goes.

13:55Antonio Di Benedetto: And it could that could be the answer for years. And like, who knows? And but I would I would love to have like imagine like you hadn't you had a MacBook that like the Apple Pencil could attach to the side and charge. And, you know, like maybe the screen could come forward. So it could be at an angle like when Microsoft did years ago with the Surface Laptop Studio. But like, I don't know, do it and make it work. and continue selling it, or a two-in-one or something. Like, there are downsides to all those. They're all kind of compromised form factors. But even if you just put an Apple Pencil supported and, like, just didn't change anything, but, like, let me do, like, the Lenovo style, where at least I can use it on the trackpad as well.

14:34Antonio Di Benedetto: So it's like you have a Wacom tablet all the time. Like, again, those are all just kind of cool things. And maybe they'll do that stuff eventually, but who knows how long it'll take. They can, you know, the same with like, they're starting with the most expensive MacBook Pros. Like, okay, how long are we going to wait? Is it just going to be the next generations of MacBook Air, MacBook Neo that get touchscreens? Are they going to make us wait even longer on that too? Who knows? Are you tired of hearing about business, tech, and finance from the bros? We are the Tiger Sisters, a top business podcast with the Vox Media Podcast Network.

15:06Tiger Sisters releases every Monday and we decode money, power, and love. And who doesn't love all those things? We are the Internet's Wall Street and Silicon Valley Big Sisters. Tune in every Monday for late night sister talk meets boardroom strategy. Check out Tiger Sisters on YouTube, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to the Tiger Fam.

15:29Is there anything in macOS changing because of touchscreens? Like, it seems like they came very close to just saying, nothing has changed, here's a touchscreen. the touch acts like a trackpad go nuts have at it um they didn't they didn't go all the way there there are there is something in mac os that changed because of touch right what is actually

15:49Antonio Di Benedetto: on the list there's some there's some little things like uh the big ones like when you go to tap like the the traffic lights in the top left corner of a of a window for like minimize or close the window like they magnify as you go to tap them and um can i just say i hate that But like, I actually think it's kind of the only thing to do for these apps. And I get why they did it. And I get why even on the iPad, it is helpful to have that kind of consistency to know where to go to change and shape the window. It does not work well or seamlessly on the iPad. And based on the stuff that I've seen on the Mac, it's going to be messy.

16:25I just don't think this is the thing anybody's going to do on a Mac. And that's fine.

16:29Antonio Di Benedetto: Yeah, I think when I'm going to minimize something, I'm just going to probably still like my if my unless for some reason my hand is not like able to reach the trackpad or it's or the screen is closer like but it's fine like the magnification is fine like it's it's nothing special okay like you kind of you did the bare minimum and that's okay um you know other menus and stuff like it's just all the same thing it's like kind of magnifies a little bit the the the touch gestures on the screen like i i loaded up the the system setting for the touch display and it's it's all the same gestures that you have in the trackpad like you can you can do like multi finger swipes to like swipe between desktops.

17:06Antonio Di Benedetto: You can, you know, do your show apps, show desktop, like all those swipes up, swipe down with, you know, three or four fingers or whatever. And it's like, that's exactly just from the trackpad, just you can do it on the screen. And I don't know who's going to do that, but it's there. You know, I guess if you're already tapping away on the screen, then it'll handle handy to have those, you know, the move to the trackpad. I'm torn on that one, actually. And I'm curious how you think about it, because there is a, there's something about that that makes sense to me in the sense that most people don't know those gestures, right?

17:33Most people don't know what to use three fingers or what to use four fingers and how to go up and how to go down. And that's just a piece of the Mac OS experience that is just lost on most people. And there's something about doing it with touch that I think is a little more knowable and understandable just because it's more direct. And I think I saw a bunch of videos of people sort of flicking apps to the sides in order to tile them, right? And like native Windows resizing on Mac is a disaster. If you just want to put two apps side by side, it is very bad and you essentially can't. And so the idea of just being able to do it with my finger actually makes quite a lot of sense to me.

18:11But it doesn't it doesn't feel like Apple took the next turn about how do we actually make some of this stuff more discoverable? Like the fact that you still have to remember to spread your fingers to do something is it's it's better on a touchscreen than it is on a trackpad because it's at least more direct input and feedback, but it's not quite the, we can make this as discoverable with touch as we could on an iPad or an iPhone. I don't know. It just seems like maybe this is something Apple still has some work to do on, but I wanted that to be a more useful new feature on the touchscreen than I think it is so far.

18:47Yeah.

18:47Antonio Di Benedetto: There's definitely room to do, to do more. Um, I, I, I do use those gestures like all the time on a trackpad. So like maybe I'm in like the slight minority of that, but it's like i'm used to them and um yeah i i but yeah the windowing still it's like install you know a third-party app like it's just so much faster like the it was i was i was i dragged a window to the side and like i did the same thing that happens when you use the native windowing in in mac os and you don't use third-party it's like you know it brought me to the next desktop no stop like i hate that what happens with a trackpad never mind touch screen and i'm still holding it on the screen like this is i hate being stuck here i have to go all the way to the left um but yeah there's there's plenty plenty more to do and um i don't know it's like maybe they'll one day get there and and really revitalize the os for it or not i don't know i could i could see it where maybe like that that stuff maybe comes when like all the macbooks have touchscreens i don't know yeah yeah that that is a challenge here and actually to that point apple talked about some of its apps being you know optimized for touch and that other apps are coming along that are also optimized for touch what does being optimized for touch even mean at this point i think it really i mean it's basically just like okay they showed like uh like i think davinci resolve like someone was doing some color some some uh you know some coloring uh and they had a film clip like shot in log a log profile and it's like okay let's let's let's do the let's do the coloring And it's like they just showed how like, you know, when you have your, you know, your your color wheels and it's like, OK, when you use a mouse, it's like this and, you know, et cetera, et cetera.

20:29Antonio Di Benedetto: And it's like and then when you just tapped it on the screen, how it like it expanded a little bit and like gave you more room to work it. And, you know, so so that way your finger is not blocking it. That's probably enough to say it's touch optimized. Like that's sure that is I can't argue with that. And that's all very iPad-y, right? the idea that if i press and hold on something it sort of expands to fill more space yeah exactly and and then um you know like another another good example where like an app developer and there's actually one of the cool things too like you know uh kind of separate but like iphone mirroring you can just use the mirror iphone like an iphone on the screen and that was kind of cool and like it's just like that's like they showed it and it's like that's so obvious like i'm almost like facepalm like duh like but it's like yeah that works that's good and that makes iphone mirroring better it actually it does like i've tried off my mirroring it's like just to go home is a pain in the ass you know like yeah uh so it's like okay cool and then like uh a developer developing for the iphone now this is something i could like i could see developers really latching onto is like you you know could be playing like you could be testing something testing your app and like then you can you have the iphone display right there like in the test and then you're just like tapping on it and doing it right there it's like ah okay also very cool example not the things that people the most people are going to do but you know useful i i do think the uh world in which apple wants to bring more of the iphone and the ipad particularly the apps to max is a world in which touchscreens become more useful and more important right like apple really wants you to be able to run ipad apps on your mac and to be able to run widgets and to be able to do the same kind of interactive stuff and i think as we've all experienced that stuff just doesn't work as well on a laptop in part because it doesn't have a touch screen there there's just some things like you said i was going to bring up the going home gesture uh because it's so annoying it's such a basic thing to do with a touch screen that is essentially impossible on a laptop with a lot with a keyboard and trackpad.

22:35And so having this thing that, again, I cannot emphasize the fact that that means you will use it three times a day for a grand total of two seconds, right? But it is useful. And I think about this in, it's such just another spec of the laptop. It is not a big new idea about how things work. Maybe it should be. I think that there are a lot of things I'm curious to see about this thing, about the sort of backing and forthing from screen to trackpad. Because I think what I find, even when I'm using an iPad with a magic keyboard and trackpad is that I tend to get in one zone or another, right? That either I'm kind of hands on the device, doing a lot of touch things in a row, or I'm mostly living in keyboard and trackpad land.

23:19And actually what's annoying is the backing and forthing. This is why people who use mice learn keyboard shortcuts, right? Like moving your hands is bad. In general, when you're using a computer, the more you can have your hands in the same place, the more productive and efficient you can be. And so I think for Apple to look at this and say, okay, this is a thing you're gonna do very occasionally in very small amounts is all fine and good. And then I look at like the demo of the person playing the piano on a MacBook. And I'm just like, well, A, no one's ever gonna do this. This is nothing. This demo is nothing.

23:52The person who needs this, and there are people who need it, 100 % guaranteed already owns an iPad. This is not a use case that exists for somebody who doesn't already own an iPad. And so that's the part where it's like, maybe this is just Apple feeling like it has to explain the sort of nth degree of what this could be. But it sounds like even the stuff that's being optimized is basically like really tiny visual changes and accept multiple inputs at a time. So you can use 10 fingers instead of one cursor. that might be as far as this ever needs to go in order to be useful and actually going further might be worse we might end up in some weird uncanny valley where it's trying to be both things to everyone all the time and i actually think that might be the worst place for this to

24:35Antonio Di Benedetto: land yeah and i mean it's possible and it would i think it would make sense then as to like why apple's so like stringent about like if you want a pencil that you buy an ipad you know it's like it's it goes back to like the whole like you know buy your mom an iphone thing right the way the way that they try to like separate everything and yeah it's to get you to buy more stuff and all that stuff too but like um i understand why like they they want to keep things separate and to prevent that like mishmashy middle where it's like everything just gets kind of you kind of muddied the waters but i don't know yeah i think like i've been thinking about like okay where where went what are my workflows like when i where will i touch the screen more frequently and like I was thinking because I like as we were you know doing all our run and gun coverage and editing photos I'm like you know I did the hands-on area and I do my usual thing where I like I just go to the side of the room and plop my laptop down on like my backpack and like kneel until someone yells at me to move and I'm like quickly editing photos and I'm thinking of my culling process and stuff and like in those situations actually maybe I would start tapping the screen and that might actually speed me up in in some ways because I know my Lightroom classic like, you know, keyboard shortcuts and stuff.

25:44Antonio Di Benedetto: And it's like where I'm making my picks and I'm double checking focus. And it's like, actually, maybe some of that where I would just, if I would just double tap the screen to zoom into a specific spot, you know, it's like, I could maybe keep one hand on the keyboard and one hand on the screen and maybe that'll work. I mean, I have to see, I have to test that myself and see. But it's like, but the thing is then, of course, like when I'm back at home and I'm on a monitor, it's like, well, now I don't have any of that. so it's like right it's like it's i think it's gonna be it's just like that that music uh producer in the hotel room example it's just again it's gonna be these part-time little things that you do maybe for convenience maybe because in some cases it's faster um but it's gonna be this very part-time thing and like yeah i mean like another example like of things where it's like where touch gets it might get weird there'll be questions so what becomes like always like this or like so you can swipe down from the top to like bring it like call of like siri ai or like that's also basically spotlight and uh i was told like that if you like it's it's still spotlight so it's like if you do the command space shortcut it also comes up at the top move it and it'll remember where you were okay so it'll stay there but then i i didn't get a chance to test this but it's like well then what happens if you swipe down from the top does it just like dart back to where it was or just come back from the top and then you have to move it again it's like it's always going to be like that thing of like people are gonna have to maybe relearn like get the quirks down and obviously we'll have to do that when we test and review it that one that's a really interesting example i would also put that on the list of doesn't matter no one's ever gonna do it like it's just the idea that somebody who is a sophisticated enough computer user to use spotlight is going to think that the best thing for them to do is take their hands off the keyboard reach up and just pull down from the top never gonna happen never gonna happen it's fun just enjoy enjoy your keyboard shortcuts and live your life.

27:35It's going to be fine. I do think I think it's going to be fascinating to see how this changes the prices of devices as it comes to the rest of the lineup, like presuming that over the next couple of years, this thing will work its way across the rest of the MacBook lineup. If it if if touchscreen is all the things we've been talking about and nothing else and changes the price of the MacBooks by zero dollars and zero cents, I think this is a smashing success. It solves all the problems it needs to solve and no more and causes no other problems. If this is now a thing that becomes a sort of base feature that makes every MacBook $100 or$200 more expensive, I think our expectations for it will go up and should.

28:17And it'll be really interesting to see if Apple can reach those. Like, my assumption is that Apple picked a wholly new device with other changes to launch this on so that people didn't just say, oh, and the touchscreen costs X number of extra dollars in order to avoid that discussion. Because the question of do I want a touchscreen for a hundred more dollars, what does it actually do for me? Looks very different for Apple than look at this remarkable new device with an amazing new display that's, you know, lighter and thinner, but also down the line has a touchscreen. So I think my, our questions about what does this thing need to do to be a success for Apple feels like they're going to get much higher stakes as this thing works its way around the rest of the mac

28:59Antonio Di Benedetto: lineup yeah absolutely there's a there's a lot of questions to be like it's it's kind of weird like if you think about how like this is like this these are existing chips right we they launched these the m5 pro and m5 max chips earlier this year so it's like what and now we have both like we have both the current laptops and and these new ones and it's like a little weird so like at At what point do these merge back? I'll be honest, Antonio. I gave up four years ago trying to figure out why Apple puts chips into laptops. There's just none of it makes you could have been like it has an M2 Pro Ultra.

29:33And I'd be like, sick. I bet it's really fast. I have so I'm so it is so impossible to figure out what chips live where and why. But the good news is that they all seem to be very fast. That's about as far. That's about as far as I've gotten.

29:46Antonio Di Benedetto: Dude, when they when they started when there was a rumor for like a hot minute that they were going to call it the macbook studio i'm like fucking don't go don't do that like no like just like not yet like i don't know i'm just not ready for that because like like look i know this is like too much like writer's brain but like when you have to write around having to write like m5 pro macbook pro like it's just it's just terrible and the names are bad like sorry and the and the don't get me started on pro led xdr god damn but you know like i don't know what the plan is like in terms of like like like they've got now like a split of these macbook pros at the high end and yeah like if like you're getting a bunch for 400 at least you're getting the oled which is like a that's a big deal and you're getting a much lighter laptop also a big deal okay so what happens with the next rev like what do these mac okay so do we just drop that and this becomes the but then is it going to stay at that price like that sucks like these things are really like they just got more expensive earlier this year because of ramageddon and now it's more about.

30:44So like, I don't know.

30:46Antonio Di Benedetto: And there's a lot to figure out, like you said, because like, if it becomes like, oh, you can, a MacBook Neo 2 is this price, but then this price with a touch screen, it's like, well, that also sucks. Like on the Windows side, you do see plenty of that. There are lots of like, you know, like the certain model at Best Buy, like that's the touch screen model. But like, if you go to like Lenovo or Dell's website, like they'll, like, you know, if you like cut this backroom deal, it feels like you buy, you can buy a crap one, you know, it's like, and it's like, it's like that doesn't have a touch screen.

31:13Antonio Di Benedetto: And sometimes it's not as bright too it's like the the 300 nit model which is like just barely passable it's like no touch and it's like bare bones that's your entry level price and it's like then you get into like the whole like oh it's 400 nits and it's got a touchscreen it's like or then you can step up more it's 500 nits and it's oled and it's touchscreen it's like it's a mess and like usually apple's pretty good about avoiding those messes but like the apple configurator is like like for macbooks is more complicated these days than it's ever been and just like there's because there's more Macs than there's ever been.

31:40Antonio Di Benedetto: So I feel like they're going to have to like maybe like kind of reset the line at some point when touchscreens are all around. But I have no idea like what that means for pricing. It's going to be just a it's a it looks it looks messy. Yeah, it does. And I think the question of it's probably useful at this point that the question of do I want a touchscreen is is sort of made for you on every model, right? You either have it on the one that you buy or you buy anything else and it doesn't have it. And we can litigate whether it is a requirement of these devices going forward and what that means and looks like some other time.

32:14I think that's probably helpful in a lot of ways because I agree there are already too many inscrutable choices to be made trying to buy a laptop these days.

32:23Antonio Di Benedetto: Yeah. And, you know, Apple's very good at this game. The whole like, you know, you click a couple of updates, upgrades, and it's like, oh, well, then I might as well just, you know, they get you in the funnel, right? And it's like, maybe I should just step up to the, you know, M5 Pro from the M6 or whatever it might be. You know, it's like, and yeah, Yeah, they can get you. Indeed. All right, we're going to have to test this thing. I'm very excited to actually figure out what it's like to live with one of these things. So we'll get one eventually. We'll talk about it. Until then, Antonio, good to see you, buddy.

32:50Antonio Di Benedetto: Yeah, always a pleasure. Thanks, David.

32:55All right, before we go, I have one more thing for you. So all the way back in December of 2025, almost a year ago now, Pebble, the rebirthed Pebble, making smartwatches and other stuff, announced this thing called the Index 01, which is basically a smart ring with a button on it. And the first time Eric Mijakovsky, the creator of Pebble, showed it to me was at CES the year before. And he showed me this thing that basically he used as a voice recorder. You hold it up to your mouth, you press a button, you talk, and it transcribes it onto your phone. And his was saving it into like a notes app.

33:30As a just dyed in the wool productivity app, nerd slash psychopath, I wanted this thing immediately. I pre-ordered one the minute that I could. I think they're$75. And then for months, months and months and months and months and months, I sat around waiting for my index to show up. It finally did. This week, while I was in Tennessee, there was a package sitting on my door for like three days. And it was the index. And it's this very simple little black ring with a button. I'm pretty on record as thinking smart rings are a really good idea. I think in an AI first world, if you believe that AI is going to be the way that we mediate everything, having an input system that is really fast and really simple becomes really important, right?

34:13You just need to be able to get ideas out of your head. You need to be able to record information as it comes. You need to be able to just dump stuff into a system as quickly as possible in order for AI to be able to work with that system. I think a lot of the devices that are coming out to do this kind of thing are intrusive and gross and bad. Like what B is doing at Amazon, where it's just this constantly recording wearable that is always on and always listening and giving you actionable insights about your daily day. Like, I hate that stuff. I am uninterested in having that as part of my life.

34:45But the idea of the index, which is very personal, it's only designed to record a really small amount of space around it, is that you hold it up to your mouth and you press the button. It's not recording ever unless you press the button and you press the button and you talk and then it sends it to your phone, it transcribes it and it does whatever you want with it, I think is the right way to think about this stuff. AI as a personal sort of introverted technology is really interesting to me. AI as an extroverted affecting other people technology fills me with bad feelings. But anyway, so I set the index up.

35:16Now it does things like integrate with Apple reminders so that I can say, remind me to take my allergy meds at 9pm tonight. And it will just send a reminder to my phone with an information to do that at 9pm tonight. and I'll get a reminder through Apple Reminders. That's awesome. It'll take notes. I also used Claude Code to rig it up to the note-taking app that I use called Capacities. So now I can say, remember I need to buy bananas at the store and it'll put it into my daily note in Capacities that I need to buy daily notes at the store. Although ironically, the system sometimes gets confused about where things are supposed to go.

35:50So there's a decent chance that thing that I just said is gonna show up in Apple Reminders. The system is not perfect, but Hebel built this as a hacky thing. It has MCP access for AI stuff. It has a web hook that you can link to almost anything. The combination of this very simple microphone, the Pebble app, and any kind of AI vibe coding tool gives you all kinds of stuff to do. If you're an Android user, it's even better. You can do things like control music. You can integrate with your calendar better. There's all kinds of cool stuff that you can do that just Pebble doesn't have system access to on iOS that it does on Android.

36:26Anyway, I've had this thing for like 24 hours. It's immediately my favorite gadget ever. I feel like a spy, just like constantly holding it up and saying inane things to myself about what's going on all day. It's delightful. And I'm more convinced than ever that smart rings are gonna be the thing. I don't know if it's this one. I don't know if it's Sandbar, another company I've covered. We've talked about smart rings before. I think smart rings have a really interesting space

36:47Antonio Di Benedetto: in the future of everything. Anyway, that's it for the show. Thank you again to Antonio for being here. And thank you as always for watching and listening. If you have thoughts, questions, feedback, If you have a use case for a touchscreen MacBook that feels like this scratches, I really want to hear about it. I think this is going to be a thing where a lot of people have one or two very specific things that they want to do that this might be useful for. And if you are one of those people, I want to hear all about it. You can email us vergecast at theverge.com. You can call the hotline 866-VERGE-11.

37:15Anything and everything, we love hearing from you. And as a reminder, the best thing you can do to support everything we're up to here at The Verge is to subscribe to The Verge. Theverge.com slash subscribe. It gets you all of our podcasts ad-free, including this one. It gets you all of our exclusive newsletters. It gets you all of our coverage of MacBooks and iPads and everything else. Theverge.com slash subscribe. Thank you in advance. The Verge Cast is a Verge production and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. The show is produced by Josh Cajas, Eric Gomez, Brandon Kiefer, and Travis Larcher.

37:41See you tomorrow. Rock it.

From the publisher

Steve Jobs once said touchscreen laptops were a terrible idea. Now Apple is shipping one. The Verge's Antonio Di Benedetto tells us all about the new MacBook Pro with PROLED XDR, how MacOS is changing for touch, why a laptop user might want a touchscreen, and whether MacBook and iPad are destined to become one.

Further reading:

Hands-on with Apple’s touchscreen MacBook Pro

Apple finally combined a toaster and a refrigerator

DoorDash is acquiring Instacart for $17 billion

Google says its investments in AI are driving more searches

Samsung’s expecting the RAM shortage to last until at least 2028.

Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters, and our ad-free podcast feed.

We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to [email protected] or call us at 866-VERGE11.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Vergecast

All episodes