In short
Podcast Summary: The Watch - Episode: ‘Wonder Man’ Is the Rare Marvel TV Show That Works. Plus, Does ‘The Pitt’ Need More Conflict?
Hosts
- Chris Ryan
- Andy Greenwald
Episode Overview In this episode, Chris and Andy discuss Marvel's latest television offering, *Wonder Man*, which they deem the strongest entry in the MCU in years. They also analyze Season 2, Episode 4 of *The Pitt*, debating whether the season could benefit from more interpersonal conflict among its characters.
Key Topics
- Discussion of *Wonder Man* (6:56)
- General Impressions: Both Chris and Andy express their excitement about *Wonder Man*, emphasizing that it stands out as one of the best recent Marvel projects.
- Creators: The show is created by Destin Daniel Cretton and Andrew Guest, with Cretton noted for his previous work on *Short Term 12* and *Shang-Chi*.
- Character Focus: The show centers around Simon Williams (Wonder Man), played by Yahya Abdul-Mateen II, who is an aspiring actor dealing with issues of insecurity and the Hollywood audition process.
- Tone and Style: The tone is described as light-hearted and clever, focusing on character-driven stories that don't rely heavily on typical Marvel exposition.
- Production Background: The series was filmed before the 2023 Hollywood strikes, suggesting a certain level of creative freedom that contrasts with other Marvel offerings that have felt constrained.
Positive Attributes
- Creative Freedom: The show is praised for its relaxed storytelling, allowing characters to breathe without constant references to the broader Marvel universe.
- Humor and Satire: The inclusion of humor, such as meta-commentary about Hollywood and the audition process, adds depth without sacrificing levity.
- Character Development: The relationship between Simon and Trevor (played by Ben Kingsley) provides an interesting dynamic, showcasing two actors at different stages in their careers.
Potential Concerns
- Marketing and Promotion: There is skepticism regarding the lack of promotion for the show, suggesting that it may not receive the attention it deserves despite high quality.
- Discussion of *The Pitt* (29:49)
- Current Season Analysis: Chris and Andy reflect on the characters and storylines of Season 2, Episode 4, expressing a desire for more dramatic tension.
- Character Dynamics: They comment on the softer interpersonal relationships among characters compared to the previous season, noting that some tension has diminished as characters settle into their roles.
- Critical Reflection: Chris reflects on the importance of conflict and drama in character-driven narratives, suggesting that the absence of stakes makes the show less engaging.
Observations on Character Relationships
- Character Changes: The dynamics among doctors and other characters are discussed, indicating a notable shift in their interactions which could detract from the show's tension.
- Potential for Conflict: They argue that the show needs more interpersonal conflict to maintain viewer engagement, suggesting that characters are too agreeable and lack the drama that characterized the first season.
Conclusion Chris and Andy conclude that while *Wonder Man* offers a refreshing take on superhero narratives with its focus on character and humor, *The Pitt* may benefit from rekindling the dramatic tensions that made its first season compelling. Overall, both shows provoke thoughtful discussions on character development and the complexities of storytelling within the bounds of their respective genres.
Key Takeaways
- *Wonder Man* is recognized as a standout in the MCU due to its clever writing and character focus.
- *The Pitt* is critiqued for its lack of conflict, which may lessen its dramatic impact compared to its first season.
- Both discussions reflect broader themes in television about the balance between character relationships and narrative tension.
---
For a deeper dive into these discussions, listeners are encouraged to check out the full episode of *The Watch*.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOHosts Discuss Upcoming Events
1:54 to 4:36
Hosts share their plans for an upcoming live show in Boston and discuss weather preparations.
“This is pressure breaks pipes or pressure makes diamonds, right?”
Discussion on Marvel's 'Wonder Man'
4:36 to 7:50
Exploring the premise and creators of the new Marvel show 'Wonder Man' on Disney Plus.
“In a way, you're paying some of my salary, so thank you.”
In-Depth Analysis of 'Wonder Man'
7:50 to 14:02
A detailed analysis of 'Wonder Man', its themes, and its production background.
“No, and Andrew Guest is kind of a big deal.”
The Intriguing Character of Simon Williams
14:02 to 18:06
Explore the character of Simon Williams and his struggles as an aspiring actor.
“One of the very clever reinventions here is the way that Destin Daniel Cretton and Andrew Guest have thought about what might make this character interesting and run straight towards it.”
Ben Kingsley's Role and Impact
18:06 to 21:27
Analyze Ben Kingsley's performance and its significance in the show.
“and that this was held until January for a variety of reasons.”
Unique Narrative Structure and Style
21:27 to 23:16
Discuss the show's unique narrative style and character development.
“Right, and you haven't made it to episode four yet, but episode four is a basically contained black and white episode explaining the journey of a character named DeMar Dorman Davis.”
Cultural Representation in Wonder Man
23:16 to 26:17
Examine the show's attention to cultural details and representation.
“not even the premise of the show, but the intent of the show is spelled out when a celebrated European filmmaker is hired to remake Wonder Man, which was a Star Trek-y 1960s Buck Rogers-ish sci-fi show, right?”
Exploring Themes of Power and Agency
26:17 to 28:00
Delve into the themes of power dynamics and character agency within the show.
“and I'm not sure if the larger world cares that much.”
Exploring Superpowers and Character Complexity
28:00 to 30:44
Discusses the nuances of character desires in relation to superpowers in 'Wonder Man'.
“I don't want to get too deep into like appearances and cameos and developments because maybe we can hit it next week, next Thursday or something to talk about the last couple episodes.”
Reflections on 'The Pitt' and Character Dynamics
32:30 to 39:28
Analyzes character dynamics and tensions in 'The Pitt' season two.
“Obviously, you were very enthusiastic about this episode.”
Show all 16 chapters
Comparing Seasons: Character Development and Stakes
39:28 to 42:00
Discusses differences in character development between seasons of 'The Pitt'.
“is that Patrick Ball is clearly a very good actor.”
Exploring Patient Storylines
42:00 to 43:15
Discussion on various patient arcs in the show, including dynamics of family and healthcare.
“Eyelash Lady, who is apparently also Patrick Ball's partner in real life.”
Character Development and Tension
43:16 to 44:11
Analyzing character developments, tensions, and the importance of documentation in the plot.
“The student who had an episode seems like it's got legs as a storyline because there's also the, what did the security guard do to him?”
The Balance of Stakes in Drama
44:12 to 46:58
Discussion on balancing character stakes and emotional honesty in serialized dramas.
“I think to your other point about like lower stakes conflict this season, Am I missing anybody?”
Unique Aspects of the Show's Narrative
46:59 to 49:24
Exploration of the show's distinctive narrative style and character arcs, avoiding reboots.
“And then you put him in like the worst day of his life, Redux.”
Incorporating Real-Life Elements
49:25 to 53:04
How the show integrates real-life professionals into its narrative and character authenticity.
“I'll just say just really quickly, my whole critique comes with the caveat of this is still among the best things on television.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00This episode is brought to you by TaxAct. Like analyzing plot twists, TaxAct guides you step-by-step to make sure you get your maximum refund. Get tips along the way, add expert assist to talk to tax experts, or let our experts do your taxes for you with expert full service. TaxAct helps you find the deductions and credits you deserve so you can get them over with. Visit TaxAct.com to learn more. Conditions apply. See TaxAct.com for details. This episode is brought to you by Volkswagen. It can be hard to do your own thing when everyone else is following everyone else, but that's what some of the best films are about, an outcast striving to make their own way in the world.
0:38And this is your sign to be that outcast. From us, from VW, from the other outcasts out there, take a chance. Make the most of every day, and don't be afraid to veer off course every now and then, because if you don't do it now, then when? Learn more at VW.com.
1:23Wunderman.
1:24Andy Greenwald:Is that how you pronounce it? Well, originally, yes, the Wundermans, like the Effingers, hailed from Germany during a time of transition. Okay, Franzen. Andy, great to see you. It's Chaos Menu Thursday. Actually, not very chaotic. No, we're pretty pointed in focus today. Two TV shows. I got to get on a plane and go to Boston. The forecast for Saturday is high of 14, low of zero. It sounds like you lost a bet on the AFC Championship game. I can't wait. This is good. I can't wait. This is a positive bag. This is pressure breaks pipes or pressure makes diamonds, right? What does it do to pipes? Well, I don't know what it does to podcasters.
2:02Yossi and I are going to be in Boston this weekend. We have a live show at the Sinclair on Friday. And we're showing Repo Man at the Coolidge on Saturday. I think there might be some Coolidge tickets still available. But if you're in Boston and you get out of the carcass of your tauntaun that you were living in and you want to come see me,
2:23Andy Greenwald:those are the two places I'll be are you prepared to give like are you going to be giving like cold weather advice to Yossi are you going to like talk her through you know she's only I honestly have been it's been hard because I want to say like damn it's going to be really cold I hope we can take off on Sunday if it snows again and she's like you have to talk me down should I be bringing like a personal radiator to come with me and I'm like no no no no know so oh so you're gonna have to act tough even though you're you are la soft no i'm not i'm not la soft i just spent like three weeks on the east coast it was like 20 degrees every day i was getting tired of it right but i can handle it i went to college in boston look we all went to college in boston i'm just saying i've never been colder in my life than i am during in la winter are you serious yeah because this is one of my greatest takes you're like a little chilly in your house when it's 52 degrees?
3:16Andy Greenwald:Well, my house is shaded. You know, it doesn't get a lot of direct sunlight. No, because I'm not asking for sympathy from the nation that is digging out of a historic snowstorm. I'm just saying that on the East Coast and in our other favorite place of London, the buildings are made of like pieces that they didn't use for Stonehenge. Yes. And so it is warm and all the clothing and all the life is built to behave appropriately. Warm your body without straight alcohol. Yes, yes. And everything here is made out of papier-mâché, and the heat doesn't work so good. Yes. That's all. I'm just saying it is a weirder, persistent chill.
3:56Andy Greenwald:The heat does not work as well here. It's true. That's all. And it's probably the number one thing going wrong with this country is L.A. interior heating. I was a little chilly, so think about me. Andy, today we're going to talk about The Pit, and we're going to talk about Wonder Man, a new show on Marvel, on Marvel, on Disney Plus from Marvel Studios. What does Tim Robinson say in Friendship? There's a new Marvel out. It's supposed to be sick. No, it's supposed to be nuts. He says it's supposed to be nuts. And honestly... And we're fans of both shows. So I'm excited to talk to you about them.
4:32Andy Greenwald:Rip off the band-aid. Tell people that we love things. It's good. Yeah, we loved Wonder Man. We're going to be talking about that. I can't think... There was not a lot of news. We've got Sundance. we got Peacock losing some money but gaining some subs it's funny how that works can we cut to the Harper Stern meme or just like it's an opportunity it is sharks no that's a different show no a full shorting of a streamer which one would you pick I know that you're in business with several of them so you shouldn't really say the answer well in a way as a subscriber you also are in business with them I'm a shareholder yeah Yeah, an intellectual as you're older.
5:13Andy Greenwald:In a way, you're paying some of my salary, so thank you. It's really nice of you. I appreciate that. It would be a fun thing that they would never do and should never do. But when we have Mickey and Conrad from Industry back on the show, we should just ask them to short major media brands. They have to have a career, so they shouldn't do that. Yes. You don't? Did you? But you have this to fall back on. I just have this as my... Exactly. This is my little safety blanket. It's a cold LA winter. Ooh, I'm so chilly. Well, didn't you see that Sundance, I mean, I don't want to kick it when it's down.
5:51Andy Greenwald:I mean, they're leaving Park City, but there is the Sundance channel and they are rebranding, but their rebrand was that they're algorithm-free, which... What does that mean? I don't know. The channel on cable? It's like a streaming service. Yes, yes. Oh, they're going to send an app and it's algorithm-free, so it's just an alphabetical list of what they have. Is it like you just go to a restaurant and they just bring you what's in the kitchen? Which, by the way, is charging$250 a person right now. I was going to dinner this, I went to dinner this past weekend with our buddy Zach and he was sending me like, what do you think about this and what do you think about that?
6:32And he sent me one place that had, it was like focaccia pork and apples dessert And I was like, that needs to be one of the great pork and apples that anyone's ever tasted. Because you've just really, you're fucking pot committed to that pork and apples.
6:49Andy Greenwald:I want to say, and I love Zach, and I rely on his relative level-headedness in our sports chats. And his ball knowledge. But, yes. But I do think that one of the great things that has separated him from us, like, generationally and age-wise, is that I think he still believes in the possibility of new restaurants. Yes. Like deeply. He like has a little list. He's like, I'll check it out. I will find out what's good and what's bad. And I just sit in my unheated shady home. Your igloo. Looking at people, looking at Renee from Noma being like, who should I bless with my presence here in Los Angeles?
7:29Andy Greenwald:Ah, a bagel store that already has three hour waits. did you cop a$25 Noma Courage bagel? no I've got it all on my my Klarna for my Noma LA pop up you have it all on your Klarna I'm paying it $1 a year for the next 1500 years I think it'll work out for you okay let's talk about the pit first how about that do you want to do that first or do you want to do Wonder Man first okay let's do Wonder Man first yeah what a delight first of all this is a show created by Destin Daniel Cretton and Andrew Guest Yes, and Andrew Guest. I wasn't going to negate that. No Andrew Guest erasure here. No, and Andrew Guest is kind of a big deal.
8:08He's written some of my favorite episodes of Community. He's a very, very talented writer. And Destin Daniel Cretton, who is somebody that we were both huge fans of when he kind of broke out with Short Term 12 all those years ago with one of the kind of zazziest ensembles of young actors that have since gone on to do a bunch of great things, had like a very interesting career where it was like this indie breakout to almost throwback Hollywood dramas in Glass Castle. It's a Brie Larson movie and then Just Mercy, which is the Michael B. Jordan courtroom drama. And then has kind of since moved into Marvel in-house and now among the most trusted pair of hands in Marvel.
8:56Andy Greenwald:He did the Shang-Chi movie, which was pretty good. And I think then was under some sort of creative overall with Disney and Marvel. I only like the ending of Shang-Chi. I thought that was when it really came together. I'm trying to remember. Which ending? After the credits? No, all the stuff at the end. Like the big battle in the cartoon place? Very memorable. And like, but was, as you said, like trusted enough to be brought in to be a creative consultant and creator in all of their various spaces, which included making TV shows like this one. and then briefly he was going to be making an Avengers movie before the great Kang crack up.
9:31Andy Greenwald:And then the Russo return. And then he was demoted to making Spider-Man movie, which will probably also be the biggest movie of the year. So he's doing great. The genesis of this show is interesting because it is kind of a, we've used this metaphor before, but like the way the light we see in the sky from stars is actually from quite some time ago. In a way, you ever think about that? This is a similar echo. And not echo the... No, although, that's good. This show was fully being filmed and in production not during the strike, they were not breaking the strike, but leading up to the strike in 2023.
10:12Andy Greenwald:When in the pilot of the series, they are filming on Figueroa and Highland Park, I'm like, oh, this is before Jenny's Ice Cream opened. This is a number of years ago. But I thought there was... I think the Mendocino Farms is open across the street, or is it just the building? I think it's just the building. Okay. This is now we're really getting into the LA stuff. Although there's a great Mendocino Farms joke in Wonder Man. When we had, I don't remember if it was for her book or not, but there was a time when our friend Joanna Robinson was on this podcast and we were talking to her about the state of Marvel.
10:42Andy Greenwald:And she was even suggesting, and she doesn't just throw stuff out there, that this show was so much, so not troubled in terms of its production, but so no longer the direction that the company was facing in, that it may be just discovered completely. This is clearly not the case, although you wouldn't necessarily know the quality of the show from the promotion that it's gotten. Disney has dumped all eight episodes in January with some promotion, but I would say minimal promotion. This is a shame because this is, this is, it's too, I've seen half the season. I've seen four of the eight episodes.
11:22Andy Greenwald:it is too faint praise to say that this is one of the best things Marvel television has done because the competition for that is WandaVision and Loki basically. Yeah, I think it's also worth noting that it's part of the Marvel spotlight subgenre or brand that they have. Which they've used on Echo. For Werewolf by Night. And Echo. And Echo, yeah. But it's supposed to be their like... Is this the one that they're like you don't have to have watched other Marvel stuff to understand that? I think that was the idea. Or is it this is our sort of paramount vantage? The fact that we don't know kind of highlights why this is sort of silly.
12:01Well, it was created in an era where I think they thought they were going to have a lot more volume. Yes. And so they were going to be like, this is the way to distinguish some of these shows is that some of them you're going to need to understand canonical connections. Sure. And some of them might just be artistic flourishes or fun one-offs.
12:16Andy Greenwald:This is a wonderful, low-key, universally enjoyable television show, full stop. It's great. I really love the show and not with the caveat of for a Marvel thing. I agree with you. It is made with such thoughtfulness, such care. It is incredibly clever. It is heartwarming and appealing in ways that are not unlike why I'm going to potentially overpraise this just episode of The Pit. that's just a normal episode of The Pit in the sense that I was like, I love, call me old-fashioned, but when I'm shivering at night in my little house in Los Angeles, I love turning on the space heater and watching my stories where there are characters with relationships that surprise a little bit, but comfort and entertain.
13:01Andy Greenwald:Two things people always say about you. Yeah, go, tell me. I can face my critics. A strong backbone when it comes to the natural elements. Yes. And you're always down to watch more television. I'm telling on myself here but I gotta be me yeah put it on your MySpace profile I update it frequently so the conceit here and we can put on or off or maybe I live with it my nerd hat to say that Wonder Man is a canonical Marvel superhero a member of the Avengers the West Coast Avengers for the time but honestly I'm kind of this this woke something up in me where I'm like hope this guy shows up in some other stuff wait So I want to circle back to that.
13:41Andy Greenwald:But just for the people to know, in the comics, he's an actor, a stuntman who gets superpowers. There's some overlap with the vision character and relationship with Scarlet Witch, but generally doesn't really distinguish himself much. As my younger daughter said, oh, so they're just taking Wonder Woman and putting Man on it now? I was like, that's some cutting commentary. Yeah. You should have a podcast. Yes. One of the very clever reinventions here is the way that Destin Daniel Cretton and Andrew Guest have thought about what might make this character interesting and run straight towards it. So in this, Yahya Abdul-Mateen, second from Watchmen and other things, plays Simon Williams, who is a too-in-his-head serious aspiring actor in Los Angeles, who over the course of time we will realize has some sort of powers, but that's not the focus.
14:35Andy Greenwald:What we focus on is that he basically can't get an audition or can't get out of his own way and is fired in the first episode from his guest appearance on American Horror Story. In a fantastic behind-the-scenes Hollywood moment, and also an example of vertical integration, because now that everything is Disney, you know, American Horror Story, an FX show is being used as a backdrop for a Marvel show, But it's an absolutely fabulous introductory scene of this guy going in to do a day player spot where he's just going to have one line and then he's supposed to be out. And he basically brings the production to its knees with questions, add-ons, background information about his character that's not on the page and all this stuff.
15:19Andy Greenwald:Playing against, I think that's Ashley Green who is in Twilight. From Twilight, yeah. it is in terms of like industry satire it is not as manic and frantic as the studio but it's not far off in terms of the realities of life here it's a different strata of Hollywood correct yeah the other brilliant decision that they made here is bringing back Ben Kingsley who I mean I think we are fans of Iron Man 3 I'm a huge fan of Iron Man 3 For those who haven't really caught up on the Iron Man trilogy, non-related to the larger multiverse saga, Kaya, looking at you, Ben Kingsley was cast as the infamous Iron Man villain, the Mandarin.
16:04Andy Greenwald:Yeah. But the movie reveals that the Mandarin is just an actor named Trevor hired to play this part by the real villains. And so then this character kicked around to your favorite Shang-Chi and then shows up here. Mm-hmm. Guys, Ben Kingsley is on a 30-minute Disney Plus show. Ben Kingsley is one of the best actors of his generation. He's 82 years young, and he's crushing it on this show. I would say it's closer tonally to, like, a Sterling Harjo show than it is to a Marvel show. Yeah, so when you say 30 minutes, it's not like Ben Kingsley's summing it. It's some of the best work he's done in years, or at least one of the best parts he's had in years.
16:46a party's played before but now is like basically like these are two people on either end of their careers kicking around hollywood going to auditions going to matinees of classic films doing self-tapes you know and dealing with the economic and personal struggles that come with being an artist you know in 2025 or whatever it is i uh really love this show um before we get too deep into like the mechanics of each episode or whatever which are all up on disney plus i thought i would just mention that this is just one of the strangest stories uh behind the scenes stuff that i've seen in a long time obviously disney plus slash marvel has undergone several both from the chapec to eiger to leader to come sense like a bunch of leadership changes they've also gone through a lot of philosophical changes in terms of how much stuff they're putting on Disney Plus, what they're putting on Disney Plus, what people want.
17:43You know, this is definitely a product that seems like it got caught between a couple of different administrations or strategies. But from everything I've heard from the, like, not reporting, but like just chatter, is that this was always beloved inside the building there. That's good to hear. And that everybody was like, this is so good. and that this was held until January for a variety of reasons. And I think actually the binge is probably good for it if it's going to be the way it is. I think if people, I thought the pilot was flawless, but I could also see a lot of Marvel heads being like, what's this show?
18:26Andy Greenwald:Why am I watching two men watch Midnight Cowboy? Yes. the the aperture for its success was rather small then sure if you had been like next week on wonder man these guys go to takes restaurant i mean it's possible but they do and it's just kind of you know so you you have to give people a little bit of runway and frankly this is one of the first shows in a while that i've been like beyond my professional obligation freely hit next episode yes to watch the next one so i think the binge probably works for it as broadly but i don't know if it does much for its um week-to-week marketing and build-up but let's get and i i we probably should have said this at the top but like we haven't spoiled anything particularly yet we could get into some more details momentarily but i do think it's worth noting that i'm so So given the pedigree, I'm not surprised that the show is good, but I am surprised how good it is.
19:27Andy Greenwald:And the fact that we've spent the last year correctly praising Andor and more recently praising Night of the Seven Kingdoms for kind of providing not similar blueprints, but successful blueprints for how to exist within a larger franchise and how to stand out and how to differentiate yourself and how to tell a different sort of story underneath a much larger corporate genre IP umbrella. And I think Wonder Man deserves to be talked about in the same way. I'm not saying Wonder Man is a creative achievement on par with Andor. I'm not comparing one to the other. But I'm saying that what Andrew and Destin Daniel Cretton have done here is carved out a little room to play that feels tonally consistent.
20:18Andy Greenwald:like there are references to Captain America or Steve Rogers. There's a damage control is in there's references to the larger Marvel universe. Should you care to engage with it? But what's lovely about the show is that there's just room for this to exist within itself. It's not constantly referencing other things. And one of the things that this made me feel in a surprising way was, and I think this is antithetical to what the initial Marvel TV plan was, but maybe should have been all along, which is the old version is we're going to tell stories that deserve to be upstream. And that's why Thunderbolts is a movie harvested from, you know, semi-successful plantings on the television farm.
20:58Andy Greenwald:Right, right. I don't, what's wonderful about Wonder Man is that Ben Kingsley is playing this character who he's played quite broadly and comedically in movies as a person. I mean, still, you know, there's some flourishes, but as a more complicated person with an inner life. the character of Simon Williams there's no room for that character to exist in a movie like Doomsday necessarily nor should there be now you know jokes on me when he shows up and he you know punches Professor X out of his chair or whatever but like this seems like this all backs up maybe what you were saying which is it seems like the powers that be understood that they had something good and they left it alone yeah it feels very unfucked with because at least through the three that I've watched, the tone is so remarkably consistent and well-identified where, you're right, the references to the larger superhero world, I counted two of them, three of them, and one is a Rogers the Musical billboard in the back of the Disney Fox lot that they're on, and one happens in a basically a little kernel of conversation between Simon and Trevor in a car about whether or not superheroes are allowed to audition for television shows.
22:23Right, and you haven't made it to episode four yet,
22:27Andy Greenwald:but episode four is a basically contained black and white episode explaining the journey of a character named DeMar Dorman Davis. Yeah, he's referenced in three. Played by Byron Bowers, who's a very funny comedian, with a really, I would say, paradigm-shifting guest performance by Josh Gad himself. It is the kind of, like, little filigreed flourish that I can tell you from experience is pitched in every writer's room for every show ever. Which is, we'll just do a little, we'll take a pause here, and we'll do a little fun detour and tell a different story that people are going to be like, oh, I'm in.
23:05Andy Greenwald:and it rarely makes it onto the screen. And if it does, it's rarely as successful. This episode in and of itself is delightful. Yeah. And works. The premise of the show is essentially spelled out, not even the premise of the show, but the intent of the show is spelled out when a celebrated European filmmaker is hired to remake Wonder Man, which was a Star Trek-y 1960s Buck Rogers-ish sci-fi show, right? Or movie, hard to tell what they're saying. Movie, yeah. And he's going to remake it. And it's, you know, this guy, I think it's the guy who played, who is he in Superman? He is the president of the evil nation who is infringing on people's rights.
23:53Andy Greenwald:That's right. It's Laco Burich. And he plays like a Werner Herzog, Lars von Trier-ish kind of filmmaker who's like, you know, superhero movies. these superheroes are here and these stories count. And there's even conversations about Trojan horsing things in. So you're having characters in a Trojan horse TV show talking about Trojan horsing things. But I didn't even really sweat that stuff, honestly. Because I thought that the character of Simon was three-dimensional enough and their relationship felt real enough and each has ulterior motives. We find out a little bit about Ben Kingsley's mission to why he's sort of cozying up to Simon.
24:36And a lot of that has to do with a sort of government agency represented by Ari Moyad from Succession, who is fantastic in this as well. Everything about this has been perfect so far.
24:48Andy Greenwald:It's a great scene between them at Clark Street Diner. Yes. Of all the things on my bingo card for 2026, I did not expect a reference to Russell Hoban's Turtle Diary or the film version of it in a Marvel television show, but here we are. I do want to just circle back to the Ben Kingsley of it all because it's not bizarre because, as you said, they're treating him with a lot of respect and giving him a lot of opportunities to do what he can do, which is slip into just jaw-dropping, charismatic, Shakespearean pomp and circumstance, but then also play light comedy, which he seems to be enjoying. He's so good on the show.
25:29Andy Greenwald:And it's such an unexpected buddy comedy. And yes, there are moments like in the third episode when Simon brings his new friend Trevor home to his mother's birthday party in Pacoima. And she's like, I'm so glad you brought a friend. And it's this diminutive 82-year-old Englishman. You can't make eye contact with anyone because he's actually running a surveillance operation. It is a little sus. Yeah. But at the same time, he seems to be having fun. And it's just a wonderful showcase. And then I think there's the question of the details. Now, I'm not necessarily the right person to judge this, but there's just a tension in these episodes that I've seen that I feel is not just rare in TV, but certainly rare in superhero TV.
Read the full transcript
26:12Andy Greenwald:And it's not just the little jokes about Deadline.com or Mendocino Farms, because we get those, and I'm not sure if the larger world cares that much. But when Simon goes home and brings Trevor home in the third episode to his mother's birthday party, it's made very clear this mother is of Haitian descent or from Haiti and the food that they serve and the community that they capture, someone thought about it. That takes decision making. It takes empowered creatives. Even just to get the like establishing shots of actually Pacoima and like the streets of a place that is LA but isn't really LA in the way that people imagine it to be.
26:49Andy Greenwald:That stuff matters. It adds to a more cohesive and I think fulfilling viewing experience. Yeah, and I also really liked the fact that I was watching something from Marvel and something in this genre that wasn't full of exposition. Where the exposition was more about character rather than tesseracts or an object that needed to be found. I mean, Ben Kingsley's mission through these few episodes so far is kind of vague. It's to get information on Simon to potentially... Because Arya Molyad's character is under pressure to fill this new prison for superheroes. Because now this is the part, this is the only part that kind of I bumped on a little bit.
27:29Andy Greenwald:Okay. The government has overfunded a rogue sort of police-like arm and wants to arrest tons of people to make a big show. Huh. So that was like, whoa, whoa. And they're like empowering, you know, extra legal tactics and general goonery. That was weird. That was strange. Yeah, I'm trying to think if there was anything else I wanted to mention about it. James Poncel directs the second two episodes after Cretan does the first two. It's just, I really recommend it. I don't want to get too deep into like appearances and cameos and developments because maybe we can hit it next week, next Thursday or something to talk about the last couple episodes.
28:08Is there a part of you in watching these episodes
28:12Andy Greenwald:where you were like, I kind of wish he didn't have powers? Yeah, but I mean, here's the thing is that I was thinking about this. It's funny you bring up Andor because I think that we say that word a tremendous amount on this podcast. And it's so amusing that Andor has now become not only a touchstone of like, this is everything that we ever wanted from a franchise, but also, did you know that this cost$700 million? You know, which is, I don't know the exact figure, but like the reporting about what Andor wound up costing over the course of its two-season run is whether it's true or not, I don't care.
28:54Every penny was worth it. You can see it on screen. But it is an intimidation tactic to be like, we can't make this stuff for less than$300 million. So it's got to be really popular and it's got to appeal to the most people possible and it's got to upstream the cinematic universes off of the small screen because we can't just throw this money away and let you guys make Ratso Rizzo walking around with John Voight which is essentially what this show has been so far it's shot in LA it looks more expensive than it probably is but this is such a great use of their money and their time and their server space to put up a small fun character study that I think people will go back to over and over again.
29:43Andy Greenwald:And in terms of, I completely agree with everything you just said and I think in terms of the the relationship to superpowers, this takes a page from, you know, currently unused on the big screen or small screen page from the X-Men playbook in which it presents a character who doesn't want any of that. What he wants is something else. And the more traditional, like Campbellian, like call to power of the young, like we've seen every version of that where Peter Parker accepts the mantle of his great power and responsibility. This guy just wants to be in movies. This guy just loves movies. This guy just wants to be third chair in big picture if nothing else works out.
30:16Andy Greenwald:you know like so the fact that the powers that he has are clamped down tamped down repressed unwanted and um unpredictable and really so far through four episodes have only shown up in terms of his emotional landscape um that really works for me and it's such a that's not a new conceit for characters or even for comic books but it's been a while yeah and it's really welcome uh okay we'll leave it there. Highest recommendation we could possibly get. This episode is brought to you by Tax Act. Like an expert coach, Tax Act offers step-by-step guidance and guaranteed accuracy when filing taxes. Get tips along the way, add expert assist to talk to tax experts and let our experts do your taxes for you with expert full service.
31:00Tax Act helps you find the deductions and credits you deserve so you can get them over with. Visit taxact.com to learn more. Conditions apply. See taxact.com for details. This episode is brought to you by Netflix. All right, baseball fans, get ready. For the first time in history, the Major League season kicks off with one exclusive opening night game live on Netflix. The New York Yankees, led by seven-time All-Star Aaron Judge, roll into the San Francisco Bay to battle Raphael Devers and the San Francisco Giants. The wait is over. It's time to play ball. Watch MLB opening night, the New York Yankees versus the San Francisco Giants, live on Netflix.
31:38Wednesday, March 25th at 8 p.m. Eastern time, 5 p.m. Pacific time. We all have that dream trip we've been wishing we could go on, but too often life or usually price gets in the way. That's why Priceline is here to help you turn your dream trip into reality. With up to 60 % off hotels and up to 50 % off flights, you can book everything you need for your next adventure. Don't just dream about that next trip. Book it with Priceline. Download the Priceline app or visit Priceline.com and book your next trip today. Go to your happy price, price line.
32:13Andy Greenwald:Feeding the fam isn't easy, but we got you with Denny's Slam and Meal Deals starting at$5.99. Full meals for everyone, like a Grand Slam Burrito for Grandpa and a Super Slam for Super Mom. Get to Denny's now. Ballet at participating locations for dine-in or denny's.com. Limited time offer. Additional restrictions may apply at some locations. Let's go to the pit. Okay. Obviously, you were very enthusiastic about this episode. I mean, I was doing some self-reflection. Mm-hmm. I was cold, so I was trying to keep the mind sharp. And I was like, has this show entered? I don't know what the zone is, but like, it's just in a place where I'm so happy to watch it.
32:52Andy Greenwald:Yes. I feel so eager to turn on the new episode. I'm always surprised when it's over and I want more. And so I don't know if my normal critical faculties are even functioning at this point because I'm enjoying it so much. It's so cold. Well, my extremities are not functioning. my faculties possibly. So it's so expertly done that within every episode, I just find a lot to enjoy, which is a kind of maybe a normie take, but that's where I'm at with it. But I feel like you, this might make for some good Crossfire style, old school, confrontational podcasting. I feel like you're itching for a big swing.
33:31Andy Greenwald:You're itching for something big. So I've done my own version of self-reflection. My note here under the episode is, I guess I missed Dr. Collins. And let me explain why. So Dr. Collins gets mentioned. This is Tracy Esherford's character from the first season who disappears about three quarters into the season to go home after a personal medical emergency and is not present for the mass shooting casualty event that the ER is dealing with, that the pit is dealing with, and then is explained now in the, what was this, the fourth episode? Yeah. The fourth episode that she has moved to Portland to adopt a kid and be closer to her parents, her family.
34:15Andy Greenwald:Yeah, she's from there. And it sounds like she's still in touch with some people from the hospital, but maybe not Dr. Ravi. And the mention of her made me think about whether or not she had a kind of the character and the performer had a certain quality that I did not appreciate at the time, which was an authentic tension within the ER, which I think, generally speaking, the first season had. So I went back to the first season. I kind of mapped it, the first four episodes of the first season versus the first four episodes of the second season. Did you make like a Kirk Goldsberry shot chart? No, I did not do a shot chart or anything.
34:54But I did note that I was looking through like all the people who are in the hospital right now and all the doctors. and you've got Dr. Alshimi who has been banging the drum of AI but for the most part seems like a very competent if direct manager.
35:12Andy Greenwald:And I think this is intentionally so duplicative. She's basically just parroting what Robbie says most of the time. Sure. And then you've got Ogilvy who is a student doctor who's annoying and Joy who is another student doctor who seems to not want to be a student doctor. Not with Ogilvy. Or just in general is like, oh, great. I'm glad I paid$200 ,000 to learn how to do this or something. And then all of the patients, especially in this episode, like are pretty straightforward. Like, I, yeah, fix them. Not to do whatever and be like, don't fix this person. It's not exactly Dr. House mysteries. No, it's not even the mystery aspect as much as like, I was looking back at the first season.
35:56Andy Greenwald:Because you weren't moved by Whitaker being like, what if heart attack not in front? What if heart attack in his back? I just think I have a little bit of agreement fatigue. This is a great take. The characters are walking down the hall saying things, and I'm like, I agree. The people who are like, I need help. I'm like, you need help. And we can all see what's wrong with you pretty much. And when that narratively runs into, not against, but runs concurrently with the show's, I think, quite earnest, quite, I mean, I agree with them, larger liberal political worldview. Yeah, it's - When they're like, we need healthcare and we don't have them, which is really important for a TV show to say but when that's running in concert with everyone else agreeing you're starting to feel a little it's a little soft so I think what I realized when I was watching this is that what I was wondering going into this season is how are they going to recreate the stakes of the first season without it being without it turning into an episode of 9-1-1 where it's just like you guys will never believe but aliens are here you know and that actually shouldn't have been what I was worried about what I should have been worried about was how will they recreate the interpersonal tensions among the doctors if they have theoretically been working together for another nine months or whatever it is and now it's like Santos she calls him fuckleberry at the end of the episode but it's pretty much 80 % nicer than she was in the first season.
37:20And they live together.
37:22Andy Greenwald:And the scene is pitched on his perspective watching her leave being like my friend, my colleague is having some personal trauma and is in crisis. Yes. And Langdon, who had a kind of cocky swagger, which was obviously deflated in the first season, is now like, I'm just working the program and I'm being a good guy. Let's drill down on the Langdon thing. Because first of all, you're the best at what you do. You have really identified something that I think, despite my absolute simping for the show. I'm simping too. I agree with you. And I think this is a really smart point to make. Like, when we talk about how R.
37:53Andy Greenwald:Scott Gemmel and Noah Wiley and John Wells and the team behind the show are the cream of the crop in terms of just professionalism and expertise and doing things the old school way, we are talking about something that came up in our industry conversation last week. Something that Mickey and Conrad and the people who make that show in their more new school way do not subscribe to, which is that over time, everyone becomes friends. not just interpersonally, but like the television show Friends in the sense that we just can't wait to see the people we like bounce off each other in ways that they historically do.
38:26Andy Greenwald:And conflict goes down and we are rewarded. Our pleasure centers are rewarded, but sometimes the drama can suffer as a result. We are seeing that already, not just because you could excuse the fact that they work together and they're used to it and they have their rhythm as evidenced by the scene in the ambulance bay when they're talking shit about Dr. Al-Hashimi and it's like, you shouldn't be doing this in front of an attendant. And Robbie's like, well, you can say anything with me because we know each other. I totally agree. The one point that I was eager to come in and make is a version of this in regards to Langdon.
38:58Andy Greenwald:Because Langdon is the opportunity. And there's plenty of season to go. He's been back at work for three hours now, four hours now. there is a softness and restorative nature to his off-camera arc that feels potentially like a missed opportunity. Or perhaps we're just jumping the gun and there's a lot more to come. Exactly. We still have not gotten the Landon Robbie clear the air thing. But one of the things that I've always found a little bit, not confounding, but intriguing, I guess, about the character and the casting is that Patrick Ball is clearly a very good actor. And he was just doing Hamlet here in LA.
39:36Andy Greenwald:Like he's pedigreed and talented. He is also kind of, on TV anyway, like softly handsome in a way that he looks like a TV actor in this context. Sure. Might be different in other roles, in other contexts. And I felt, and I was pleased in the first season when after a few episodes of kind of blandness from the character of being like Robbie's friend, who's also good, there was some darkness and a little bit of a, you know, there was some road for him to travel down. Maybe it's a factor of the show's unique conceit, which is that they jump to a different day that they could yada yada the harder part and we get him back.
40:15Andy Greenwald:The show works better if something is cutting against the grain. I think that's a really good point. And now, what's clearly coming to, will cut against the grain is the day is going to go haywire in some way. Yes. But interpersonally, it would be good to see that happen as well. And I think that they might, because the other thing I was going to say is the real estate that they carved out in this episode and maybe the previous episode for character stuff, they do have to be artful in it because they have to front load it. Because once the Ambo Bay starts filling up, there isn't a lot of space for Robbie to sit with his pal, the hospital psychiatrist.
40:50Andy Greenwald:Or Dr. McKay to be like, I'd love to go on a date to an art gallery with this guy, you know, and stuff like that. So we kind of have to front load that, which in the week-to-week experience might feel a little bit off, and they do a good job of hiding the ball, no Patrick. But I think it's an interesting point. Yeah. And is it a casting question? Is it a who you're adding to the ensemble question? No, I think it's just sheer numbers. So now it's less time. Joy and Ogilvy probably take 3 % or 5 % of the time we would have spent with Mel Santos and Whitaker. And there's the new nurse too. There's the new nurse.
41:29And there feels like there are more patients, but there hasn't been quite the same. By this point in last season, I think there was the Xanax fentanyl overdose. There was the Robbie and Collins debate about whether to perform an abortion. There were a couple of things happening that were like, oh and the brother sister trying to decide whether or not to that was big enforce the dnr on their
41:58Andy Greenwald:father now counterpoint so far this season we've had michael nori's exposed asshole yes and also like the the family with no insurance that the girl is i'll just go through the patients right now so like the insurance family dad with diabetes prideful mom doesn't want daughter to find out about the lack of insurance daughter overhears docs talking about lack of insurance starts GoFundMe. Eyelash Lady, who is apparently also Patrick Ball's partner in real life. That's nice. Shout out. And we learn about Dr. J, Dr. Javadi's social media alter ego persona. Would you follow her? I try not to get my medical advice from social media.
42:36Andy Greenwald:I think that's probably wise. I think that's probably wise. I say that my general practitioner is probably like, it's me, Dr. O. But wouldn't he just, from what you said about him, he would just start like a soccer podcast blog we talk a lot about world football about the beautiful game yes and then we talk a little bit about my body you know it's never been better eyelash lady parkour influencers yeah um when you say it like that it sounds silly that was my that was my shit this week when when that guy was like i'll just pull this out it's like that's a fucking big l to take dog just be like let me help me pull this giant shard of glass out of dude's back yeah the woman suffering from bulimia and louie with the tooth and the stomach.
43:19Andy Greenwald:And the yard advice. Yes. The student who had an episode seems like it's got legs as a storyline because there's also the, what did the security guard do to him? What's going on with him? They're about to do the spinal tap. And then the woman who comes back, possibly with MRSA. That's bad. Oof. They were not happy about that. Did they show her in the beginning of the season? I don't remember. I was going to ask you. I didn't remember it. So it's possible that that's... Because Langdon's patients have been... In triage. Quick, yeah. For the most part. And then we have, I'm like, I really like Joy.
43:52Yeah. Not the emotion, but the character on the show. It's to come by these days. And she's got blood exposure from puncturing her glove. The glass. And they have to give her a bunch of tests. And I'm very much hoping she doesn't get like hepatitis or something.
44:10Andy Greenwald:I think that's a good wish. Yeah. I think to your other point about like lower stakes conflict this season, Am I missing anybody? No, I mean, the simmering tension, there's one or two, but I think the simmering tension that is fueling Santos' return to, you know, the Bugs Bunny meme of like, Lord, forgive me, back to the old me, is because Dr. Halashimi is stressing the importance of documentation and paperwork. Sure. Which feels relatively, I mean, look, these guys are medical professionals behind the show, involved in the show. If they say it's important, I believe them. I believe it's important.
44:43Yeah, but it is, I was having a hard time understanding her turn was that surely because Al Hashimi had
44:53Andy Greenwald:threatened her status threatened her status and when we met when we rejoined Santos this season she's like I'm gonna dull major basically can I you know one of my favorite parts of the episode was when the glass extraction happens and the surgeon is there and then they bring out this big syringe and Ogilvy is super fucked up already once he's not fucked up but he has fucked up says what's that And the way Robbie says, and I'm going to try to get the quote right. It's a syringe full of hemostatic, fast-expanding sponges. That's the moment when I wanted the thick of it writers to join the writer's room.
45:26Andy Greenwald:Be like, a fast-expanding sponges, you absolute twat. You mentally impaired donut. Like, I just wanted some extra. Yeah. You know, I enjoyed that flex. But the jokes in general are better. Like, when he's like, motorcycle trips are Zoom therapy. Yes. Come on. You thought that was a joke? Yeah, it's all right. And I think that actually is a good segue to Robbie, which was, you know, a very obviously physician heal thyself storyline from the first season of him coming in, dealing with the PTSD of COVID, dealing with the loss of his mentor during that time period, feeling very underwater with hospital executives and Gloria and all that stuff about their patient scores and their efficiency.
46:18I think his sabbatical and his helmet thing is worth watching, worth keeping an eye on as like, oh, how could this kind of develop over the course of the season? But for the most part, he seems... It was like, I think I missed him being in a really bad place. And I don't know, I don't want that for a character. but I think it's interesting television when they're like that.
46:43Andy Greenwald:But these guys have made lots of seasons of television. Yes. And when you introduce stakes like they did in the first season to get attention, to make you feel how visceral and minute to minute this circumstance, this workplace can be, you open the show with Robbie talking his colleague down from the roof a little bit. And then you put him in like the worst day of his life, Redux. And then you have to have but then you have to have that same character anchor this show for five, six, I won't say it because I can hear my kids saying it, five, six, or eight years. Right, five, six, seven? Yeah, we're a little over it.
47:21Andy Greenwald:You got to toggle it. Like you? Everyone like me on earth. When I got back from Potter, my kids were like, do they say six, seven in England? I'm like, oh yes, you've ruined the world. We no longer are in quarantine. They sure do. You have to be careful with the character extremity dial. Because in a movie, a character like Dr. Robbie ends the movie by like, I need to fix myself and drives off on a motorcycle. Or I have recommitted to this as my course of action as a professional. But the show is now stuck in a place of credible, emotionally honest and relatable people who every day do an impossible thing.
48:05Andy Greenwald:Which exists in the world. That is 100 % realistic, but it is in terms of drama. Nowhere did I say this show is no longer realistic or believable. But they're navigating something that is not realistic, which is serialized drama. Yes. And that is an interesting thing to pay attention to. The hospital show that shall not be named that this show is not based on is it would be an interesting experiment to go back and map that show against this show because I think that this show is trying to do much different things with character and much different things with time. And can I zag and say a different opinion that I feel like hasn't been said enough, which is, thank God this isn't a reboot of the show that Jim be named Chicago Hope.
48:49Andy Greenwald:Because first of all, Mandy Patinkin is too busy. But second, the character that Noah Wiley played before when he was wearing a medical doctor's coat was a child of privilege and had a very specific background and arc that is completely different from the way he is able to play Robbie with the freedom of creating an entirely new person without the years of baggage, good and bad, from what he had been. And I think it's really important that the show is trying to do something. And I think now we can give it the credit for being something different. Last note, this may be commonly held knowledge.
49:27Andy Greenwald:I'll just say just really quickly, my whole critique comes with the caveat of this is still among the best things on television. Yeah, but I think the show gives us such a unique opportunity to question and critique in real time because proof of concept, this thing works. This show works. What's interesting, and I think why your point is well taken, is because what they're doing is so specific and so unique that we have a different way into observing their creative process because they are solving for things in real time that other shows don't have to, such as where we put character beats because we are never leaving this hospital, for example.
50:05Andy Greenwald:And so sometimes they get away with it when they hide the nutrition. Like Seinfeld's wife put spinach in brownies. Like, you know about that? This is all parent stuff. No, I didn't know about that. Jessica Seinfeld wrote a cookbook where she was like, your kids need vegetables, but they don't have to like them, so make brownies with spinach in them. And now their kid is Bari Weiss's lieutenant. Yeah, it's great. if you nepo babies stick together you know i'm sure that the group chats you guys are on are pretty rich with observations about how to nobody knows our struggle communicate with audiences you know in the digital era i have to work that much harder to have movie reviews that people take seriously you do and you've really you've done it by the way uh yeah for sure i mean i think it's telling that you haven't done rewatchables remains of the day because then it would be a little bit too close to like your father's patch.
50:56Andy Greenwald:I wouldn't hold my breath for that one. I've been waiting by the phone. This may be common knowledge, but I only recently learned this because I did feel bad that I didn't know the name of Nurse Jessie, who is stepping a little bit more into the camera, into the spotlight this season. And I was, I'll be honest, like I was thinking of that character this weekend because it felt Alex Preddy-like, like that this is just a guy who works hours in, you know, a thankless job. And so I was Googling him lately. And this is the most, shout out to Simon Williams in Wonder Man, the most like LA is a real place sort of story I can imagine.
51:36Andy Greenwald:This guy, Ned Brower, who plays Nurse Jessie, moves here to be an actor, gets a little bit work as an actor, gets work as a model, plays music with his friends, is the drummer for Rooney. Oh, yeah. The pop rock band led by Jason Schwartzman's younger brother, Robert. But was Jason Schwartzman ever in that band? He was in Phantom Planet. That's right. Okay. Drums for a while, acts for a while, sees the writing on the wall, maybe this isn't a career, goes to school and becomes a nurse. And he is actually a nurse. Yes. And then when the show is being put together, someone, because it's a relatively small community, or he sees the audition for it or whatever.
52:14Was he like a medical advisor on the show at all?
52:16Andy Greenwald:No, but I think that the spirit of the show has been to bring in, to sprinkle in real people. And, you know, I think people who are paying more attention to the show than even, we watch it, but I think super fans have probably maintained lists of like, these people are actually nurses. These people are doctors. And yeah, he's married to Sarah Jane Morris, who was on Brothers and Sisters, who made an appearance on the show as well. Okay. Past season. I just like, I like the artful way the show is doing this, where it's bringing people who are competent in multiple fields. Yes. But, I thought it was cool.
52:50Andy Greenwald:This guy's actually contributed to the world of nursing and medicine. And you can, I don't think it's an accident that like, I just, when he's in the background of scenes, I was like, that guy seems like he knows what he's doing. I didn't learn his name, which was on me. No, he definitely seems like he's been in those rooms before. Um, all right. Well, we'll be back on Monday to talk about A Night of the Seven Kingdoms and Industry. Will you give me some temperature updates of your core, your extremities? Yeah, man. I'll try to struggle throughout here. Yeah, I'm really looking forward to seeing my Boston people.
53:24Yeah. The Boston winter is something that, I mean, we went for rewatchables the last time. It was like cold, but like we were walking around. It was like 30s, 40s. And now it's aughts. Yeah. So we'll see. Thank you to Kaya and Kai. I got to catch a plane. We'll talk to you guys on Monday. Safe travels. Hopefully.
53:49Thank you.
From the publisher
Chris and Andy talk about Marvel’s latest television offering, ‘Wonder Man,’ and why it’s the strongest MCU entry in years (6:56). Later, they discuss Season 2, Episode 4 of ‘The Pitt’ and whether this season could use more tension between its characters (29:49).
Subscribe to the Ringer TV YouTube channel here for full episodes of The Watch and so much more!
Hosts: Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald
Producers: Kaya McMullen and Kai Grady
Additional Video Supervision: Jamie Yukich
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
