


The episode discusses Israel’s election outcome and what comes next amid uncertainty.
Yalda Hakim (journalist reporting from Israel) and Richard (journalist/colleague).
Netanyahu and rival Gadi Eisenkot are neck-and-neck; neither bloc has a 61-seat majority, creating a stalemate. Netanyahu appears to be gaining as votes are counted, including reservist/soldier ballots. The guests argue this was an “AI election,” citing Netanyahu’s rapid, AI-generated fear-mongering ads on election day (e.g., images of a nuclear bomb over Tel Aviv; claims Arabs are swarming polling stations; “go, go, go” messaging). They also note Eisenkot used AI but with less aggressive last-minute tactics.
coalition negotiations led by President Isaac Herzog; potential coalition dynamics involving ultra-Orthodox parties, Arab parties, and far-right figures Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich; risks of renewed escalation with Iran during Netanyahu’s caretaker period.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the current state of the Israeli elections and coalition challenges.
“these elections are being talked about as the most consequential in this country's history.”
Analysis of Netanyahu's strategies during the election and their implications.
“But at this stage, and it could change, it looks like he will get the first crack at forming a government.”
Exploration of how AI influenced the election campaigns and voter behavior.
“of seats, but he's in some ways consolidated his position.”
Discussion on the impact of election tactics on future political campaigns.
“I remember the good old days, if you will.”
Insights into the challenges of forming a coalition government post-election.
“It used to be in the past that you weren't even allowed to campaign on Election Day.”
Evaluation of Gadi Eisenkot's approach and appeal as a political leader.
“as you say, get together and form a coalition government excluding some of the most radical parties, it's possible.”
Explore the challenges and prospects facing Gaddy Eisencott and the change bloc in Israeli politics.
“So just picking up on what Richard was saying there about Gaddy Eisencott, he isn't a natural politician.”
Understand the implications of far-right politics on Palestinians and potential government formation.
“They want to expel the Palestinians from the West Bank as well.”
Analyze the potential impact of Israeli coalition instability on relations with Iran.
“Yalda, we haven't yet mentioned it on the podcast.”
Delve into the identity crisis facing Israel and its implications for domestic and international policy.
“Now, what is Donald Trump's calculation?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Whether you're building a roster or a business, great talent can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies hire and support employees across 185-plus countries. Pebble believes you don't build a winning team by limiting where you look for talent. That belief is at the heart of their new partnership with Bay FC, and the way Pebble helps companies build their own teams every day. With Pebble, companies can hire in over 185 countries, bringing everything together in a single platform that integrates with the tools teams already use. The result is a global team that's actually set up to succeed with accurate pay, real benefits, and the support they need to thrive wherever they are.
0:36Bottom line, great teams can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies build them. Special offer for podcast listeners. Pebble is normally$399 a month per employee. Already a no-brainer for what you get. But right now, there's a limited-time offer on their site that makes it even easier to get started. Go to hellopebble.com slash sports before it's gone. That's hellopebl.com slash sports. Terms and conditions apply.
1:04Hi everyone, Neil here and Luke. Today we are going to be doing something just a little different. A collaboration, in fact, between This Is Why and our sister podcast, The World. I'm going to be speaking to my colleagues Yalda and Richard about the Israeli elections. Hi Neil. Hi Richard. Great to do this with you guys. That's right. these elections are being talked about as the most consequential in this country's history. Hello, Yalda. Hello, Neil. Great to be with you. A very significant time. And I think a lot of lessons can be learned from these elections. And I think we're going to see a lot of this playing out around the world.
1:41This was significant for Israel and it has global consequences.
1:48Well, Richard, let's just start with what we know. We are in a position that I suspect not many people thought we were going to be in this morning. So just in terms of the numbers, how many seats are the main blocks on? Where are we with the counting? What is the state of play? At this moment, the votes are still being counted. And neither Netanyahu or his coalition have a clear majority. So they don't have a mandate to take control of the government. But Gadi Eisenkot, the main rival, and his coalition bloc also don't have a clear majority. So we're in a bit of a stalemate. The two candidates went into the election neck and neck.
2:29They came out neck and neck. But as the numbers are coming in, Netanyahu's advantage continues to go up. So many people were counting him out. But at this stage, and it could change, it looks like he will get the first crack at forming a government. So many Israelis who were hoping for decisive change, a vote that would push Netanyahu, Israel's longest serving prime minister, out of office, they didn't get it. Yalda, both you and Richard are in Israel. So as the country wakes up to this unclear set of election results, what is the mood there and what happens now? Yeah, Neil, I mean, we went to bed with a level of uncertainty, although Benjamin Netanyahu came out at about 3.30 in the morning.
3:18Many people were saying, why is he delaying coming out? You know, most of the other candidates had more or less gone to bed. But he didn't quite, he stopped short of declaring victory, but it was Netanyahu at his most confidence. You know, he knows how to play this game. He knows how to play the numbers game. He knows how to form coalitions. So for him, he wanted to make it clear he's feeling confident. And as we got up this morning and it became clearer and clearer that actually, while there was a level of uncertainty and we have these two blocks and neither block has a majority, he is in a position that's better than what we expected.
3:55Now, he's not in a better position than he was a couple of days ago and he's lost a number of seats, but he's in some ways consolidated his position. And so he knows how to do this really well. Israel's Knesset is made up of 120 seats. The magic number was 61 that the blocks need to reach. That hasn't been reached. So I guess what happens now is we'll have to wait and see. As the votes of the reservists and the soldiers, the military comes through in the next couple of days, and then we get the final results. That will then come down to the consultations that will be had with the president, Isaac Herzog.
4:34You know, most of the candidates will be approached by him. Then he will decide who it is that will get the first sort of stab at attempting to create some kind of coalition government. But Yalda, just in terms of Binyam and Netanyahu himself, how much of a victory is it that he hasn't been defeated, if you catch my drift? Yeah, I mean, this man is a survivor. You know, they don't call him a magician for nothing. He got two endorsements from Donald Trump, and Donald Trump has been tweeting out on X saying, oh, I hear that Benjamin Netanyahu is doing better than we thought, and it was my endorsement that got him over the line.
5:14He engaged in this kind of massive fear campaign in the lead-up to the election, and even on election day. I mean, you know, we can talk a little bit more about this, and I know Richard will be keen to discuss this, but this was very much an AI election. Just the day before the election, he put out an image of a nuclear bomb exploding over Tel Aviv. And just this sense that if I, Benjamin Netanyahu, Mr. Security, don't remain in power to protect the Israeli people and the state of Israel, you know, you'll have the Iranians developing a nuclear bomb. You'll see it over Tel Aviv. So this is a man who knows how to survive.
5:54Then on the day of the election, he was putting out images of Palestinians, Arab Israelis at the polling stations going, look at them. They're coming out in droves. Come on. You know, you've got to come out. You've got to vote for me and save our nation from these Arabs. So he engages in a lot of fear mongering as well. And it seems that people have come out and listened to him yet again. I mean, Richard, your thoughts on that? I mean, I remember the election of Barack Obama to the presidency of the United States as being the social media election, the internet election. Is this the first AI election then, in your view?
6:28I think it is. And I think what we saw in Brazil was also a powerful use of social media, how Lula and he created his so-called Lula's army with millions of people interacting directly with his campaign through their phones. I remember the good old days, if you will. I don't want to be too nostalgic, but campaigns put out ads and they would hire actors and they would have a message. And then at the end of the message, they would say, I, such and such a candidate, endorse this message. And perhaps during an election campaign, they would have five or six ads like this and they would release them in different locations in order to target a specific demographic.
7:10As Yaldi was saying, just on election day itself, as Israelis were going to the polls, Netanyahu was posting AI-generated ads every few minutes telling people, go out, we're going to lose. The Arabs are swarming the polling stations. This is going to become an Arab state. Israel's Jewish identity is at risk. We are at war. Go, go, go. Take your friends. Don't stop. And he did this all day long because you can create these images quickly. They could be very catchy with music and it can be very appealing. And we were watching all day Israeli media and it seemed like Netanyahu was trailing in the early part of the day and then started to have a large number of votes coming in for him as the polls were getting closer to closing.
8:09So that last minute push driven by AI, driven by the cheap, quick ability to make decisive ads. And as Yalda was saying, a lot of these ads were fear mongering. They were talking about Arabs. They were talking about the draconian consequences that could happen if he's not reelected. And I think that maybe it pushed him over. And I think we're going to see that kind of process going forward in elections around the world. Eisenkot, the main rival, was also using AI for his campaign, but his last-minute ground game was not nearly as aggressive. It used to be in the past that you weren't even allowed to campaign on Election Day.
8:54You used to say your piece, and I remember covering elections all over the world for the last 24, 48 hours. The candidates weren't allowed to say anything. Instead, they were beating the drum, using scare tactics, particularly Netanyahu, to get people to vote right until polls closed at 10 p.m. local time. Well, let's have a think then about what may happen next, whilst acknowledging the fact that the myriad possibilities are giving me a massive headache right now. I mean, Richard, is a national unity government a potential way out of this? Is there a way that Netanyahu and Eisenhower could actually work together?
9:31So Israel is a democracy initially, and that's going to sound like a controversial statement, but I'll tell you why I don't think it is. It's a democracy in that Israeli citizens are allowed to go out and vote, and the voting is generally considered free and fair. And I was at polling stations, and there was no manipulation, and people went in and presented their IDs and cast their ballots. And there have been no questions that the ballots are being manipulated or that the ballot boxes were being stuffed. But after the vote, there is a closed door process. And that's what we're entering into right now, where the president of this country, who doesn't govern, he is the representative of the Zionist state.
10:17He's the embodiment of Israel. His job is to try and mediate between the political parties when they reach an impasse like they have reached an impasse right now. And that is a closed process. So as Yaldir was saying, the president, Herzog, will be meeting with Eisenkot, meeting with Netanyahu, meeting with about 10 different political parties as they engage in horse trading to reach that magic number. We don't have visibility on that process. We don't know what is being said behind those closed doors, what promises are being made. And each different community has its own requirements. The religious parties here, the ultra-Orthodox, for them a major issue is state benefits.
11:04Another issue is exemption from military service. So they will all be negotiating what kinds of concessions they're willing to accept and what kind of benefits are being offered to them. And that is the process we are entering into. And that's going to be playing out over the next several weeks, maybe even months. And if that process fails and no one is able to hold a stable government, then Israelis go back to new elections. One possibility is that Eisenkot and Netanyahu, as you say, get together and form a coalition government excluding some of the most radical parties, it's possible. When that has happened in the past in Israel, it created for a very strange and unstable political reality where the prime ministers were swapping every six months.
11:59And it didn't work. And guess who emerged as victorious after that process? Prime Minister Netanyahu. He's good at this kind of backroom negotiations. He's done it many times. Eisenkot, different kind of personality. He's an army general, former chief of staff. People who know him describe him as quiet, mild-mannered, humble. He's not a particularly effective public speaker, does not have fluent English, which doesn't matter so much for this process, but does matter on the world stage. Netanyahu is the ultimate backroom negotiator, and he's always managed to come out on top in this closed process that we're entering into now.
12:45Yalta, tell me a little bit more then about Eisenkot, the man who also, alongside Benjamin Netanyahu, could be the next prime minister. How much of his appeal is a different approach to governing Israel itself rather than a different approach to Israel's security? Well, I think an interesting point is, as Richard said, he's a former IDF chief. He is a military guy. He lost a son in Gaza. So he has felt the pain of the tragedy of October 7, like so many others, quite acutely with the loss of his son. I've spoken to a number of young voters who told me that was one of the reasons they were voting for him, that they saw what he went through, what his family went through.
13:29And he's talked about that in some way. He also went to vote or walked one of the voters from one of the kibbutzim that was affected really badly during October the 7th. He walked one of the members of that kibbutzim to the polling station. Now, Benjamin Netanyahu has been criticised for not really visiting the kibbutzims that were affected, not really engaging much with the families of the hostages. You know, he likes to sell himself as Mr. Security, but actually October 7 was a massive security failure. So just picking up on what Richard was saying there about Gaddy Eisencott, he isn't a natural politician.
14:09He's a novice at this. You know, unlike Benjamin Netanyahu, who's been in this game for a very long time, Gaddy Eisencott sort of emerged from this block of change. Whether it's going to fundamentally change some of the hardcore policies in this country, especially when it comes to Gaza and the West Bank, we'll have to wait and see. Because many people say, and I interviewed the former Prime Minister of Israel, Ehud Olmert, and I know that Richard did as well, that that process is going to be slow. He said the only solution is a two-state solution, but none of the other candidates from within the change bloc have presented that as an option.
14:48In fact, when it comes to the Arab bloc, which frankly has done incredibly well in these elections, defying all odds. The polls were putting them at about 14 seats. At the moment, they're looking to have taken about 18. So they could become really instrumental in all of this, kingmakers on some level. However, each of the candidates from that change bloc vowed not to form a coalition with the Arabs, which also makes you understand the mood in this country, the fact that 20 % of the population, which are Palestinians, Arab Israelis, their vote is frankly being discounted at the moment. If this change bloc were to join forces with the Arab parties, they would reach that 61 number and beyond right now.
15:35And there are those who are frankly coming out and saying, listen, we know how to count. We know the math. If you go with the Arab parties, you reach beyond the 61 number, then we can take control of our country. And I've been hearing for the past week this is a fight for the soul of Israel. This is the fight for the institutions of Israel for its democracy. And yet, when it comes to forming a coalition with the Arab parties, the Gaddy Eisenkots of the world, the change bloc, are saying, oh, well, we'll have to wait and see how this plays out. That doesn't mean that what you say in a campaign is what ends up happening.
16:11We know we've all dealt with politicians during election campaigns all over the world. They say one thing and then after the campaign is over, in order to form their power base, they'll make all sorts of concessions. Benjamin Netanyahu did that with the far right groups like Itamar Ben-Gavir. He said Itamar Ben-Gavir will never be part of the government. He ended up being his national security advisor, dismantling the police force and all of the things that we're seeing in terms of the settler violence in the West Bank and some of the rhetoric in Gaza. Itamar Ben-Gavir and Bezalel Smotrich, the finance minister, have become the poster boys of that.
16:49And these are the people that Benjamin Netanyahu vowed never to allow to be part of government. So we'll have to wait and see whether the Arab coalition plays a crucial role and whether Gaddy Eisencott does put out a sort of olive branch to the Arab parties and say, listen, let's form a coalition and see where this ends up. He has sort of put a condition to the Arab parties and said, if you denounce Hamas, then we can talk. Now, for us, this sounds quite simple. Like, yeah, they will. But that hasn't happened. They've denounced October 7, but they haven't described Mansour Abbas, the leader of one of the Arab parties, was even asked yesterday to denounce Hamas and hesitated on that point and talked about October 7, but didn't quite go after Hamas.
17:39So, you know, these are sensitive points in this country. Richard, with so much as we are talking still up in the air, it's probably a good idea if we try and pick apart the differences in the policy positions of Netanyahu and Eisenhower. I mean, where do they agree? Where do they differ on ending the fighting in Gaza and indeed who should run Gaza. So the coalition that Netanyahu has currently with his extreme far-right partners, they want to expel the people of Gaza. They want to expel the Palestinians from the West Bank as well. So it's possible, depending on how this shapes out, that Israel's policy toward Gaza and toward the West Bank gets even more hardline.
18:26So the formation of the government will have an enormous impact on what happens to the Palestinians. So far, Netanyahu has stopped short of fully annexing the West Bank, that is declaring the West Bank officially part of Israel. That would be illegal. That would be challenged. challenged but if he gets a mandate and it is very possible he gets that mandate then it will depend on who he includes if he includes Ben Gavir and Smoltric and they get what they want there could be very dark days ahead for the people of Gaza and for the West Bank and that has regional implications if the Palestinians are pushed out of the West Bank there's only one place for them to go, and that would be into Jordan.
19:15And Jordan, the royal family in Jordan, has made it clear it will go to war to stop that, not because it opposes the Palestinians, the majority of Jordan's population is Palestinian, but because it would tip the balance and it would end the Hashemite kingdom of Jordan as we know it and turn it into Palestine, which is something that Prime Minister Netanyahu has said he wants and something that the Jordanian King has said he will go to war to prevent. Eisenkot has said that he doesn't want to go into a coalition with these far-right extremists. He said just the opposite. He wants to rein in the radicals.
19:53He doesn't want the settlers who've been wantonly attacking Palestinian farmers, shooting at them, attacking journalists, trying to cover the expulsion of Palestinians from their homes. Eisenkotty said that he won't partner with them and that he will hold these extremist groups accountable. But will he be able to form a coalition? Will he have to reach out to the Arab parties who have an enormous amount of power right now, but it is a bit of a poison cup? If you drink from it, you could end up killing your political career. Yalda, we haven't yet mentioned it on the podcast. I suspect it was a topic broadly discussed during the election.
20:36Iran, I mean, while these politicians are negotiating, what does the uncertainty mean for the risk of another escalation in the conflict there? Well, Neil, I mean, spoiler alert, even if Gary Eisencott manages to be tapped on the shoulder by the president to form some kind of coalition government, Benjamin Netanyahu will remain the prime minister of a caretaker government for weeks, if not months to come until they can figure out how to form that coalition. And as Richard said, we could also go into a situation where there will be another election here in Israel early next year. And so that is something actually that Benjamin Netanyahu would want and benefits him.
21:22He wants this to drag on. Now, after the midterm elections, which is on the 3rd of November, Donald Trump has said, And that's when we're going to start looking at the Iran question yet again, whether that means resuming negotiations or resuming their bombing campaign. One thing is clear is his partner in that is Benjamin Netanyahu. And if Benjamin Netanyahu remains the caretaker prime minister, he's still in charge, which means he will decide the fate of Israel and whether to continue to pursue this conflict with Iran. And as we've seen over the course of the last few months, Benjamin Netanyahu has continued to convince his public that this is the right thing to do.
22:05And he's going to continue that war. So we are likely to see the resumption of the bombing campaign in Iran and the resumption of the war with Iran. But Richard, do Trump and Netanyahu genuinely, completely align when it comes to their objectives in this region? Probably not. There is a very serious concern that in these next several weeks, Netanyahu could resume the war in Iran. He's already said that his intention is to, quote, finish the job with Donald Trump. Now, what is Donald Trump's calculation? Gas prices are sky high in the United States, as they are in many parts of the world. It's a big issue in the midterms.
22:54People are angry about it. And Donald Trump has been less decisive, less clear about what he wants to do with Iran. He'll say, either I'm going to go in and obliterate Iran and I'm going to do a little bit more of Operation Epic Fury, which was the U.S. military's name for the bombing campaign on Iran, or we'll make a deal. Netanyahu is not saying it's an either-or situation. He's saying he's going to go ahead and finish the job with Donald Trump and remove the Iranian regime. So are they completely aligned? Maybe not. Yalda, look, I woke up this morning expecting an entirely different story on the Sky News app.
23:36How did we all get it so wrong? How did we not see this coming? How did we not see Benjamin Netanyahu potentially clinging on to the post that he's held for so long? You know, one critic, Neil, of Benjamin Netanyahu described it to me as the October 7 four pollsters, that they got it so monumentally wrong. For weeks, we were being given these polls that basically showed Benjamin Netanyahu at a loss. His Likud base looked like it was going to lose a number of seats. And the block that he had formulated was going to be stalling at around 50 of the seats. And in fact, what we've now seen, and well over 70 % of the votes have been counted, the Benjamin Netanyahu has frankly surged slightly ahead, the change block is lingering behind.
24:32What has been extraordinary to see is the high turnout of Arab voters and the Arab parties at a historic high in terms of the number of seats that they've gained. Now, the big question here is, is why then has the idea of formulating a coalition government with the Arab parties, 20 % of the population, become such a toxic subject in this country? And that is the question that needs to be asked. What is the identity of Israel today? What is it as a nation? After three years of the tragedy of October 7, the war in Gaza, the wars in Lebanon, the war in Iran, the fact that Israel has become a pariah state that is being sanctioned by the closest of its allies.
25:20And yet, when Israelis go to the polls, it seems many of them want more of the same. And that is the big question. You know, what is it that Israelis want to project to the international community and deal with domestically as well? Richard touched there on the ultra orthodox, not serving or being exempt from the military. That is a massive talking point in this country. It isn't just about Hezbollah and Hamas and Iran. It is about the fact that since October 7, there is a requirement in this country for the military to have conscripts and to serve. And yet there is a part of the population that is being exempt.
26:02And that part of the population has a bigger voice in this country. The likes of Itamar Ben-Gavir sort of saying, Let's expand the settlements and annex the West Bank. Let's continue to bomb Gaza. Let's bomb Iran. And yet the critics of Benjamin Netanyahu and these far-right groups are saying, hang on a second, why do our children have to go to war and die and yours stay at home and don't have to serve? So these are big domestic questions in this country that has international ramifications as well. And this is a big question about the soul of this nation and its institutions and the fact that this is now the direction that this country wants to take itself.
26:42It has a way out if it wants to, the change bloc, form a coalition with the Arab parties, and maybe for the sake of politics, they will. But the fact that they sort of can't see that that is perhaps the route out for all the rivals of Benjamin Netanyahu, I think is a question that we need to ask about the direction of this country. Do you know what, Yalda, Richard, I suspect you're going to have a busy few days ahead, so I'll let you get back to it. Thanks very much for your time. Great to talk to you. Thanks so much, Neil. Good to see you, Richard. Great to see you, Yalda. Thanks, guys. And that's your lot for this special collab between This Is Why and The World.
27:20Those coalition negotiations are continuing, but by the time you hear this, the votes should pretty much all be counted. So the very latest will be available over on the website of the app. No doubt Richard and Yalda will have plenty more to say over the coming days, but Do let us know who you think will emerge as Israel's next prime minister. Why at sky.uk is the email. We're back tomorrow.
27:47Whether you're building a roster or a business, great talent can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies hire and support employees across 185 plus countries. Pebble believes you don't build a winning team by limiting where you look for talent. That belief is at the heart of their new partnership with Bay FC. and the way Pebble helps companies build their own teams every day. With Pebble, companies can hire in over 185 countries, bringing everything together in a single platform that integrates with the tools teams already use. The result is a global team that's actually set up to succeed with accurate pay, real benefits, and the support they need to thrive wherever they are.
28:23Bottom line, great teams can come from anywhere. Pebble helps companies build them. Special offer for podcast listeners. Pebble is normally$399 a month per employee, Already a no-brainer for what you get. But right now, there's a limited-time offer on their site that makes it even easier to get started. Go to hellopebble.com slash sports before it's gone. That's hellopebble.com slash sports. Terms and conditions apply.
The World and This Is Why join forces for a special episode on Israel's election - a contest that could have significant consequences for the Middle East and the wider world.
Niall Paterson is joined live from Israel by Yalda Hakim and Richard Engel, asking why pollsters seem to have got it so wrong, why this might be the world's first AI election, and why Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, after 19 years, looks like he might continue to be the most powerful man in the country.
Have you got a question for Niall? Email [email protected]
You can email questions to Richard and Yalda at [email protected]
You can watch our podcasts on the Sky News app and on our YouTube channel here.