1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Why has Google refused to take down the Russell Brand video?
This Is Why

19 Nov 2026 · 19m · 8 chapters

Episode artwork

Why has Google refused to take down the Russell Brand video?

In short

The episode (Sky News) examines why Google/YouTube has refused to remove Russell Brand’s prison-message video from his YouTube channel. It says Brand, convicted and sentenced to 10.5 years for rape and sexual assault, had his wife Laura post a message reading out his claimed innocence. The government wants removal, citing potential distress to victims and possible prison-rule breaches (whether the message was intended for publication). Key claim: YouTube is not legally compelled to take it down; government can only request, not demand.

Notable examples

YouTube previously demonetized Brand in 2023; YouTube terminated R. Kelly channels and channels of a convicted Canadian rapist.

Guest

Lucy McDade, Sky News political correspondent.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:20

The Controversy Surrounding Russell Brand

Discussion on the implications of Russell Brand’s video posted from prison and the government's response.

“How likely do you think another pandemic is?”
2:26

Government's Reaction to the Video

Exploration of the government’s efforts to remove Russell Brand's video from YouTube and the legal basis for their actions.

“the limits of the government's power, and whether the law could change as a result.”
3:41

YouTube's Policy and Government Overreach

Analysis of YouTube's rules compared to other platforms and the implications of government requests.

“Look, any prisoner can express their innocence if they believe they are innocent.”
6:20

Prison Communication Rules

A look into the regulations governing what prisoners can communicate and the ongoing investigation into Brand's message.

“There's nothing really in YouTube's guidelines that say that.”
8:10

Debate on Government Influence and Ethics

Discussion about the ethical considerations of government influence on social media platforms and the implications of censorship.

“is probably too harsh because frankly, they have absolutely no right in law to do that.”
9:50

Broader Impact and Future Considerations

Exploration of the long-term effects on content moderation and freedom of expression in light of government actions.

“what is being investigated at the moment is whether or not Russell Brand had any intentions when he had this communication with his wife.”
14:01

Government Response to Russell Brand's Video

A discussion on the complexities of government action in response to Russell Brand's controversial video.

“There's the other thing as well, that this video posted this week was fronted by Russell Brand's wife.”
21:46

Pandemic Insights

Exploring the likelihood of future pandemics through personal narratives.

“You know the story, you remember the headlines, but what if you could hear from the people who were actually there?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Sky News, the full story first.

0:11The government wants Russell Brand's prison message taken off YouTube, but the tech giant is refusing, and this is why. If you've ever tried to hire someone in another country and immediately hit a wall of paperwork, compliance rules, and back-and-forth approvals, you know how fast that excitement can turn into a headache. That's exactly what Pebble is built to fix. Pebble is a global hiring platform that lets founders and HR leaders hire in over 185 countries in minutes, not months. Compliance isn't something you manage around with Pebble. It's built directly into the platform, a decade of expertise embedded into every workflow so regulatory blind spots and costly mistakes don't slow you down.

0:56Contracts, payroll, benefits, it's all in one place, integrated with the tools your team already uses. And your new hire, onboarded by Monday. Pebble starts at$3.99 per month per employee. And right now there's a limited time offer just for podcast listeners that makes it even easier to get started. Go to highpebble.ai before it's gone. That's highpebl.ai. Terms and conditions apply. How likely do you think another pandemic is? It's right at the top of the agenda. It will happen. It will happen. You know the story, you remember the headlines, but what if you could hear from the people who were actually there?

1:30I saw a man who'd been hit in the face with two bullets, put my camera to my eye and he looked at me with all the pain in the world in those eyes. He was trying to move his head to say no, and I didn't take that picture. I'm Cathy Newman and I'm going back inside the stories that changed everything with the people at the very heart of them. Search backstory and follow wherever you get your podcasts. A prison sentence takes away someone's freedom. Their online audience can be another matter. Russell Brand is serving 10 and a half years in prison for rape and sexual assault. But his wife Laura has posted a YouTube video reading out a message from him denying the crimes he's been convicted of.

2:09The government wants that video removed, saying it causes distress to his victims. Sky News understands YouTube's owner, Google, has refused. Now, we've decided not to play clips of either of the brands in this episode. We can explain the story without replaying their message. Instead, we'll look at the rules governing communication from prison, the limits of the government's power, and whether the law could change as a result. Sky's political correspondent Lucy McDade is back on the podcast. Lucy, there are an awful lot of people who are very, very upset with Russell Brand and his wife, Laura.

2:45Why? Yeah, exactly that. So, of course, Russell Brand last week convicted at Southern Crown Court, sentenced to 10 and a half years in prison for rape and sexual assault. This week, so just I think it was six days after his conviction, a video was posted on Russell Brand's YouTube. That channel has 6.6 million subscribers. Now, in the video, it was Russell Brand's wife, Laura. She was presenting it. She read out a message that she said was sent from Brand inside his prison cell. and in it there are a number of things but he claimed his innocence. Now as you would probably imagine inevitably that caused quite a lot of backlash.

3:24An investigation is actually now underway by prison services by the government into whether or not Russell Brand would have broken any prison rules by doing that. There are two tests there. Did he cause distress to his victims? Did he send that message to his wife with the intent of it being published? So there are some potential issues. Look, any prisoner can express their innocence if they believe they are innocent. I'm sure there are lots of prisoners in prisons up and down the country that are doing that. But there are rules around where and when they can do that. And we'll come to that side of the story in just a second.

3:55But in terms of what the government is doing, it's being reported by you, in fact, that government ministers approach Google and ask them to take down the video. I mean, why? On what basis? There are two things going on here, actually. And I reported that a government minister met with representatives from YouTube, their own by Google, to say, we want you to take down Russell Brand's account, his whole account. But look, the government has also separately requested that the video itself be taken down. So two requests have gone in. Why is that? What they're doing is they are relying on YouTube's moral conscience here.

4:30As I understand it, no law has been broken in that specific video being up online. There is also no law that says Russell Brand's YouTube platform now has to be taken down. But I suppose there are two things. One, this is a government that believes that some undue distress can be caused to his victims. These are people that have been through a huge amount of trauma, seeing him online to a platform of more than 6 million followers. That is incredibly distressing. The other thing is that, look, politically, this is a government that wants to talk about tackling violence against women and girls. They want to make a very strong statement that they don't want Russell Brand to have this platform.

5:04But just to be absolutely clear, YouTube has done nothing wrong in publishing this video in terms of straight up and down when it comes to the law. The government is not suggesting that there is any illegality here on Brand's part or indeed on YouTube's part. It is just that this material could be harmful, could be offensive to some, and they would rather it wasn't out there. Yeah. As I understand it, in terms of the video, there is nothing illegal about YouTube allowing that to be on their platform. Whether or not Russell Brand has broken the law by sending a message from prison that his wife has published, whether he did that with intent or not, that is something that is under investigation.

5:40But YouTube as a platform, it is completely up to them whether or not they choose to remove A, the video in question that was published this week, or if they decide to completely disable Russell Brand's YouTube channel. Now, one of the reasons this has become a bit of a story is because if you look at Meta, now they own Instagram and Facebook, straight after Russell Brand's conviction last week, they disabled his profiles on Facebook and on Instagram. That is because when you look at their community safety guidelines, convicted sex offenders are explicitly mentioned. If you're convicted of a sex offence, you could have your profile, your account disabled.

6:20There's nothing really in YouTube's guidelines that say that. There are, however, a number of different, pretty broad brush statements in their community guidelines, in their terms and conditions. They could lean on them if they do decide to either take down the video or completely remove his account. So what have YouTube been saying? All I have seen publicly are kind of what looks like holding statements our teams are investigating material in question. Yeah, it's interesting because it is being reported by lots of media outlets that Google has rejected this request. Now, the statement that we've had says that they are investigating and they are aware of the content.

6:55When you speak to government sources, they're claiming that Google has flat out rejected the request to take down the video. But look, I don't think it's out of the question that this video and indeed Russell Brown's platform does get taken down from YouTube. There is precedent. It is rare for YouTube to take steps like this. But R. Kelly, for example, found guilty of sex trafficking. Two channels that he had, they were terminated. One convicted rapist from Canada last year, he had four channels terminated. And it's worth here, if you don't mind, Neil, at the time, YouTube said in response to making that decision, they said that any creators of platform behavior, if it harms users, employees or ecosystem, the platform may take action.

7:40So really, it's down to them. And you read their guidelines, they're open to interpretation. But just to be absolutely clear, to distill it down to its purest form, ultimately what we are talking about is the government picking up the phone, getting a hold of Google, saying, please, please, please, please, please, would you take this down? Because there is no means by which it can be compelled to do so. Absolutely. That is absolutely 100 % correct. A minister met face-to-face with somebody from YouTube and said, look, can you take this down? I would even say that using the word demand is probably too harsh because frankly, they have absolutely no right in law to do that.

8:16Then you go into all these questions. Can the government legislate to give them a legal right to do this? Well, it's the UK government. You know, Google, YouTube, they are much bigger platforms. It'd be interesting to see what somebody like Donald Trump makes of this whole thing. There are people already reading this story in the United States saying that it's government overreach. It's suppressing freedom of expression. So the government knows that it can't make any demands. OK, let's go back to the prison state. And given the kind of the profusion of videos that are out there, apparently recorded inside prison cells, it's difficult to believe that there are any restrictions on what prisoners can say or do whilst they're behind bars.

8:51But there are restrictions, aren't there? So just remind us what they are. Yeah, look, so Russell Brand can have contact with certain family and friends. He can pick up the phone and speak to his wife. What he's not allowed to do is make statements with the intent of them being broadcast. So say, and this is completely hypothetical, you pick up the phone and you say, I want you to put this message out on YouTube. I want you to put this out in the local paper. That isn't allowed. You're also not allowed to really say anything that could cause distress to your victims. And again, I suppose that's open to interpretation.

9:22And that's what this investigation will look into. You've probably seen before, look, prisoners can say that they are innocent. Freedom of expression allows people to make the case for their innocence. And there are times where they could do an interview on the media. Again, we've seen that before. They have to get permission from a prison governor who will weigh up all of these risks, who will weigh up, is this allowed? Is this legitimate? Is this sincere? So there are all of those considerations that have to take place. what is being investigated at the moment is whether or not Russell Brand had any intentions when he had this communication with his wife.

10:07How likely do you think another pandemic is? It's right at the top of the agenda. It will happen. It will happen. You know the story, you remember the headlines, but what if you could hear from the people who were actually there? I saw a man who'd been hit in the face with two bullets, I spot my camera to my eye and he looked at me with all the pain in the world in those eyes. He was trying to move his head to say no, and I didn't take that picture. I'm Cathy Newman and I'm going back inside the stories that changed everything with the people at the very heart of them. Search Backstory and follow wherever you get your podcasts.

10:45I suppose if you take a slight sidestep here and look back at what we're discussing, what this shows is that perhaps the Prisoner's State, the Ministry of Justice, doesn't have as much experience as it might of dealing with high-profile prisoners that have massive social media followings. Yeah, absolutely that. And like I said, Russell Brand, 6.6 million followers on YouTube. As you say, the government isn't disputing that he shouldn't be allowed to express his innocence. This is a man that has a massive platform. He's high profile. The allegations span back years. So this is kind of unknown territory.

11:18I pointed out some examples of YouTube disabling accounts before. A lot of them are in the United States, Canada. It hasn't really happened here before, has it? The internet is a wild west. This is the government trying to tackle it. Do you get the feeling then, like I am right now, that there are perhaps ongoing discussions taking place behind the scene between government and Google. Absolutely. And this is why they don't want it being played out in public, right? They don't want it to look like the government is having a tantrum over it. They are, according to the government, in an open dialogue about it.

11:47I think they are trying to make clear that if YouTube doesn't take at least the video down, they will ask again. But ultimately, at the moment, that is all they can do. They can just ask again. It could still be the case that the prison service judges that what he did was not a breach of the rules. Yeah, of course. It depends. Did Russell Brand send a message with the intent of it being broadcast? How do you prove that? I'll be perfectly honest with you. I don't know whether or not they are able to analyse communications. I'm pretty sure phone calls in prisons are recorded, but we don't know enough about how the two communicated to know how this message got out there.

12:23If he's not found to have broken any rules, it arguably makes it even more difficult for YouTube to take down the video. Again, this is why it is relying on their moral compass, if you like. I do think it's important to point out that in 2023, so going back a few years, when the allegations against Russell Brand first surfaced, it was YouTube that actually basically turned off his ability on the platform to make money from his videos. And at the time, again, they said that their platform guidance suggests that any behavior that could cause harm to either victims making allegations at the time or, say, employees, then they can take action.

13:01So they took action then. And I think what ministers, what this one minister in particular is arguing is that you took action then. Now he's being convicted. Can you not go even further? Well, it's completely acknowledging that personally, I'd fall down more on the side of the survivors of Russell Brand. Isn't there something quite worrying about a government minister or indeed a government pressing a publicly traded company to do something that it doesn't have to do because it has broken no laws? I mean, certainly that does appear to be the opinion of Kimmy Badenow. Yeah, exactly that. And to be honest, I've been thinking this as well.

13:36Say YouTube decides to act in this case. And again, whether that's to take down the video or to take down the whole account, how many other people with convictions are still posting on YouTube? We here are talking about Russell Brand being a convicted sex offender. What about other criminals that have committed other crimes still being on YouTube? You then get into conversations about what the government can and can't legislate on, what they should and they shouldn't allow people to say or indeed post. There's the other thing as well, that this video posted this week was fronted by Russell Brand's wife.

14:07Now, we understand again from speaking to government that his wife isn't being investigated. She's not implicated in this at this stage. We've gone to her and asked for her response to all of this as well. But you're right, you then get into a debate about government overreach, what should the government be policing online. And frankly, this is actually a bit of a nightmare for the government, isn't it? And that's why it's an even bigger nightmare for it to be playing out in public. The one thing that no one is talking about, particularly not the government ministers who are doing the media rounds on this, is that his audience doesn't only exist on YouTube.

14:37He is across multiple platforms, including the YouTube clone from the right wing, Rumble. Now, there is a site that will, I guarantee you, never even countenance taking this sort of material down. So what is the government to do when it is available in plenty of other places and everyone just seems to be focused on, admittedly, one of the biggest websites in the world? I think an awful lot of this is about sending a message to people that the government wants to take this seriously. It wants to take violence against women and girls seriously. One minister, for example, yesterday said that Brand's conviction needs to be seen as this watershed moment.

15:15Last week and indeed this week as well, ministers, the prime minister will talk about, prime minister, I'm a father of daughters. This is something that I really care about. Keir Starmer said that it was his personal mission to tackle it. People get fed up of the words. I think you've got some people in government saying, this is where we can look like we are trying to take action. So let's come out in public and say that we're trying to get YouTube to take down the video or indeed take down the whole account. I spoke to one minister off the record who said, look, I actually feel for the government here because there is nothing that they can do and they know that.

15:45So I think this is just as much about signaling as it is really knowing what they can't really do very much. You say that there's nothing they can do, but I've said it a couple of times. They are the government. They have got a size of a majority. They could legislate. If they want to change the law, they could do so. So is that something? Now, obviously, that takes time. But we haven't heard from anyone in a position of power. We've heard from the former safeguarding minister, Jess Phillips, talking about it. We haven't heard from anyone actually in the job at the moment. Why not? There are a number of reasons.

16:14It is very difficult. And remember as well, the government would need to have support to be able to get something like this through the Commons. There was one thing, and I keep thinking about this when telling this story today, is that the government recently updated the Crime and Policing Bill to criminalise certain online pornography. So things like strangulation, suffocation. But there are a number of things that the government didn't really want to do because it was conscious about infringing too much on people's freedom of expression, on people's free will to do whatever they want in adult relationships.

16:45but a kind of a rebellion by Labour MPs meant that they had to back down and put these amendments in. So what I say to that is I think there will be a lot of uneasiness about the government legislating on something like this. Kemi Baden-Ock spoke earlier today, for example, the Conservative Party leader, saying what Russell Brand did was awful, but the government should not be making requests of, like you said, a private company to be removing content. So Russell Brand may or may not be censured by the prison estate. Laura Brand will face no legal consequences because there are none. YouTube doesn't have to do the thing the government would most like it to do because legally it is doing nothing wrong.

17:25So for a government that has sold itself on the protection of women and girls, this does not look good, to put it my way. No, and this is why I think at the moment behind the scenes in government, you've got a little bit of a conflict because you've got some people that wanted to come out and shout about this and say, hey, look at what we're trying to do. But you've got others who are probably saying, look, there's not a huge amount we can do here. And it also goes to show that, yes, the government can announce, you know, Bridget Phillipson, who's the Minister of Equality, she got given 15 million pounds in the budget to sort out some kind of misogyny prevention programme across the country.

17:59It shows that when it comes to the really big things, like what people see online, the government has its hands tied. Its power is very limited. We've seen the government try to legislate against what online platforms can do. And we see time and time again, it is really very difficult to enforce. Why is it difficult? Is it simply because these organisations have money coming out their ears, they have lobbyists for days, and they have a very loud and vocal presence in and around SW1P where you are right now? It's not just a minister in the Ministry of Justice that needs to maintain a positive relationship with somebody at YouTube or even their own company, Google.

18:40It's business. It's probably even health as well. It's the Treasury. It's number 10 that needs these companies on side. So they don't want to be seen to be ruffling their feathers, probably for want of a bit of a stronger phrase. They don't want to be doing that. It's also very hard to enforce. Again, the UK, yes, OK, maybe we punch above our weight, but we are a small country. And I go back to the point about if you asked Donald Trump or somebody else from the White House what they make of this situation. All it takes is for them to come out and say that it's a terrible idea for this story to take on a greater momentum.

19:14So to put it mildly, I think YouTube knows that it doesn't really need to listen to what the UK government is calling for. Yeah. What about the British public though? If I were to take a walk down any high street in the country and ask them, do you think Russell Brand should be allowed via his wife to have statements read out on his behalf professing his innocence whilst he's serving a 10 and a half street? Yeah, this is why this is a story. because for the ordinary British person listening to this at home, reading this story, they will think, well, Meta has disabled Russell Brand's Instagram and Facebook profiles because it is a clear violation of their guidance that he is a convicted sex offender.

19:51So why can't somebody like YouTube do it, especially if on YouTube he's got 6.6 million followers, he's put a video out on there, or his wife has, with a message from him? Why can't they just do the same? What's stopping them? What is their guidance? What is their thinking? because if one platform can do it, why can't another? Also, exactly as you say, this is ultimately holding the government to account on a promise that it made in its Labour manifesto to halve violence against women and girls in a decade. I've always kind of thought, what does that mean to halve violence against women and girls in a decade?

20:21But all of these things the government sees as being very important to showing that it's on that track. It's very much a priority, but it comes back down to how successful those efforts can be. And in this case, it's really very difficult for them. Lucy, thanks very much indeed. Thank you.

20:45If you've ever tried to hire someone in another country and immediately hit a wall of paperwork, compliance rules, and back-and-forth approvals, you know how fast that excitement can turn into a headache. That's exactly what Pebble is built to fix. Pebble is a global hiring platform that lets founders and HR leaders hire in over 185 countries in minutes, not months. Compliance isn't something you manage around with Pebble. It's built directly into the platform. A decade of expertise embedded into every workflow so regulatory blind spots and costly mistakes don't slow you down. Contracts, payroll, benefits, it's all in one place, integrated with the tools your team already uses.

21:28And your new hire, onboarded by Monday. Pebble starts at$3.99 per month per employee. And right now, there's a limited time offer just for podcast listeners that makes it even easier to get started. Go to highpebble.ai before it's gone. That's highpebl.ai. Terms and conditions apply. How likely do you think another pandemic is? It's right at the top of the agenda. It will happen. It will happen. You know the story, you remember the headlines, but what if you could hear from the people who were actually there? I saw a man who'd been hit in the face with two bullets, put my camera to my eye and he looked at me with all the pain in the world in those eyes.

22:03He was trying to move his head to say no, and I didn't take that picture. I'm Cathy Newman and I'm going back inside the stories that changed everything with the people at the very heart of them. Search Backstory and follow wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

The convicted rapist Russell Brand may be in prison, but he clearly still has a platform.

A video posted on their YouTube channel by his wife Laura caused widespread condemnation for containing a written message from Brand protesting his innocence and questioning his conviction.

Google, which owns YouTube, has reportedly rejected a UK government request, made via the Prison Service, for the video to be taken down.

What are the rules about how prisoners can and can’t publicly communicate? Should the government go further in its demands for content to be taken down by social media platforms? And are there competing implications for free speech and Brand’s victims?

Niall Paterson is joined by Sky’s political correspondent, Lucy McDaid.

Have you got a question for Niall? Email us: [email protected]

You can also watch This Is Why on the Sky News app, and on YouTube.

More from This Is Why

All episodes