


Alan Milburn’s planned welfare and employment reforms to tackle high youth inactivity (NEETs: 16–24 or 18–24 not in education, employment or training), especially the shift from education into disability/incapacity benefits.
UK NEET rates are ~3 percentage points above the OECD average and about three times the Netherlands; matching the Netherlands would mean 600,000 more young people in work/education/training. Half of the recent rise is linked to labour-market conditions, but mental-health problems and welfare pathways are also blamed. Notable proposals/examples: cut employer national insurance for 21–24 year olds to make hiring cheaper; “carrot and stick” approach including moving under-25s off major disability/incapacity benefits (e.g., PIP and health element of Universal Credit) toward an allowance model tied to participation, modeled on the Netherlands’ Participation Act.
Beth Rigby (Sky News political editor, host); Harriet Harman (Labour MP, former cabinet minister); Jess Phillips (Labour MP); Ruth Davidson (former Scottish Conservative leader); Rob Powell (Sky News political correspondent); John Craig (chief political correspondent); Cathy Newman (Backstory host).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the increasing number of young people not in education or employment.
“Recently, I've had to accept something quite difficult.”
Introduction to Alan Milburn's plan aimed at addressing youth unemployment.
“Now he's back with a set of proposals that could put another Labour prime minister to the test.”
Exploration of NEATS statistics and the factors contributing to high rates.
“So a sort of average of equivalent countries you'd expect us to be around the same level at.”
Discussion on the economic and policy barriers affecting youth employment.
“One of the fundamental problems with the jobs market at the moment is that it's actually quite expensive to hire people when it comes to young people.”
Debate on proposals including changes to national insurance for young workers.
“that he feels that there are far too many young people languishing on benefits.”
Analysis of incentives for businesses and potential risks of welfare reform.
“Surely the timing, the chronology of it is important.”
A look back at Alan Milburn's career and influence in British politics.
“Alan Milburn won't be a familiar name to all of you.”
Discussion on Milburn's role in NHS reforms and the implications for Labour.
“He really embraced the whole Blairite revolution.”
Explore Alan Milburn's career and his radical health reforms in the NHS.
“The reason he became Secretary of State for Health was because it was a reshuffle prompted by Peter Mandelson's resignation, or one of them.”
Discuss Milburn's return to politics and his role in social mobility initiatives.
“But I don't know, maybe there's something in the air, some strange scent carried by the Thames that brought him back into politics.”
Analyze the potential challenges and political risks following the Milburn Review.
“It's going to be a really, really deep piece of work into this issue.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:02Sky News, the full story first.
0:12Alan Milburn went from a council estate to the cabinet. Now his welfare reforms could help a generation that's currently going nowhere. And this is why.
0:27Find politics hard to make sense of. A little bit depressing? Or just bloody boring? Well, it needn't be. I'm Beth Rigby, Sky News' political editor and one of the hosts of Electoral Dysfunction, the politics podcast that cuts through the BS and has a bit of fun on the way. And I've enlisted a crack team of political juggernauts to help me out. There's me, Harriet Harman. Me, Jess Phillips. And me, Ruth Davidson. So join us. Search for Electoral Dysfunction wherever you get your podcasts.
1:02Confession time. Recently, I've had to accept something quite difficult. Apparently, I'm no longer a young person. For today's story, that means 16 to 24. So I've missed it by, let's just say, quite a bit. But honestly, my fellow middle-agers, would you really fancy starting out now? Nearly a million young people are outside work, education or training. And as the Prime Minister said at the weekend, it's a problem that's been ballooning since Covid. Sadly, we've seen a phenomenon grow post-pandemic of youth detachment, of too many young people feeling lost in their 20s and feeling there's no alternative other than benefits.
1:42Well, we can do better for them. Alan Milburn is publishing a plan to change all that. Milburn grew up on a council estate and became one of Tony Blair's most powerful ministers. Now he's back with a set of proposals that could put another Labour prime minister to the test. Let's get started with our political correspondent, Rob Powell. Rob, of course, we all know that young people are a big problem, but we're talking about the areas of their life in which they are finding things difficult. Just establish exactly what the problem is that we're going to see Labour moving on and the scale of it.
2:15The problem is around young people, which is variously defined as either 16 to 24 year olds or 18 to 24 year olds, but people in that period of their life who are not in either education, employment or training. That's that horrible acronym that we'll be talking about lots this week, NEATS. And the problem the UK has is that the rate of NEATS in the UK is very high by international standards. We're about three percentage points up on the OECD average. So a sort of average of equivalent countries you'd expect us to be around the same level at. But if you compare it to, say, a country like the Netherlands, which I'll be bringing up a few times because they have taken a lot from the Netherlands in this report.
2:55but also I was over there about a month ago trying to figure out how they do it. We have three times the NEAT rate that they do. If we match their NEAT rate, we'd have 600 ,000 more young people in either education training or a job. Historically, we've never had a very good NEAT rate. We've always been quite high up, but it was coming down basically between 2011 and 2019. It's risen again since then. And in terms of why that's happened, there's a very good report from the think tank, the Resolution Foundation, that basically says you can put half of that rise down to what's going on in the labour market and the economy more broadly.
3:35When unemployment goes up, it follows that inactivity and young people not in jobs will go up as well. Clearly, that can be put down to things like pandemic, but also policy choices like national insurance going up, increases in the minimum wage that have brought down incentives to hire younger people. That's only part of the story though and I don't think that explains why the rate has gone up quite so significantly in recent years. For that I think you're looking at health and the prevalence of mental health issues amongst young people increasing since the pandemic and then linked to that is where welfare comes in and that's where you get to what Alan Milburn has already talked a lot about this issue of young people coming out of education and rather than making that transition, as many did in the past, into employment, are making a transition onto a life on incapacity or disability benefits.
4:30One of the fundamental problems with the jobs market at the moment is that it's actually quite expensive to hire people when it comes to young people. What is Milburn saying about that? What's going to be a really interesting proposal that is going to be in this report that has been trailed ahead of time is around potentially lowering national insurance, cutting national insurance down for 21 to 24 year olds. The reason why this is interesting, especially, is that my sense on this is it's not necessarily one of the policies that is being pre-briefed and press released by the Department of Work and Pensions with number 10 stamp all over it.
5:07It feels to me, reading some of the coverage in various papers that it's been briefed to, something coming more directly from Team Milburn or Alan Milburn himself. I wonder why that might be, Rob. Perhaps to do with the fact that it was this Labour government that bumped up national insurance rates for employers. Exactly. And Alan Milburn in the past has talked about that. It's always been set in the context when he puts out the problems and how he's going to fix them about upping support, which is, you know, employment support, which we'll talk about. But it's what makes it politically a little bit tricky, this policy solution.
5:42Because if you're saying that you should be gradually decreasing national insurance for 21 to 24 year olds, because it has an impact in terms of not incentivising businesses to take on younger people, then you are also tacitly acknowledging that putting up employer NI actually made the problem of employing young people worse. But I mean, what it speaks to is the incentives for businesses, right? If it's going to cost you the same to employ someone with 10 years experience or someone with no experience, you'll employ the person with more experience. So what you do and what you need to do is incentivise businesses to make the choice to employ young people.
6:21And how do you do that? You make it cheaper for them. We know thanks to the interviews that Alan Milburn has given and indeed the interim report that he feels that there are far too many young people languishing on benefits. So should we be expecting something pretty radical there? Yeah, it was relatively late in the day after a lot of pre-briefing and trailing about the kind of carrot aspect of what we're going to get from Melbourne, that we got the stick that will come with it as well. Which is basically that the thing that underpins a lot of talk around employment support and strategies the government will put in, it begs the question, okay, but what happens if the person doesn't want to do it, but they are judged able to do it?
7:01will benefits be cut and taken off them? And the answer from Alan Melbourne seems to be to an extent, yes, because what he's been talking about in advance of this report being trailed is basically moving under 25s off the main disability and incapacity benefits, things like personal independent payment or the health element of universal credit as well, saying that you'll no longer be able to get them if you're under 25. We're going to come up with a different system, a more of a sort of allowance-based system. This is very much in the model of what the Netherlands went through 10 years ago. They passed a piece of legislation called the Participation Act, which the whole point of it was that you have a much better chance of getting access to the benefit system if you are either working part-time or you are training or you're in education.
7:52It made participation almost the guiding principle of claiming welfare. This appears to be what Alan Milburn is suggesting, what he's trying to do. You know, he's at pains to say this won't happen overnight. These aren't the crude cuts, which is that, you know, the phrase you hear is the thing that they're trying to avoid. So this isn't a case of identifying a number that they want to cut the benefits bill by and bringing through legislation immediately to do that, which brought Keir Starmer down. They're pitching this as something more nuanced. There are still big risks though. Surely the timing, the chronology of it is important.
8:25I mean, I cannot imagine a Labour government, well, I can't imagine the back benches of a Labour government, putting up with taking benefits away from people before this new system is in place. Yeah, and I think the sequencing here is the key difference between actually what the Conservatives are saying they want to do and what Labour wants to do. Alan Milburn is talking about this happening over a decade. That's why I think you had the big brouhaha with the Chancellor after the budget when he said the benefits bill will be coming down in this Parliament. they don't necessarily want to make that guarantee because they know this is a long-term thing now if you're a government though that is scrabbling around looking for where you can find money you know not being able to call on big savings from the benefits bill um is not ideal then there is i think the human risk to this um as well you know i spoke to a couple of people again over in the netherlands that talked about these welfare reforms and they said the problem is is that yes they can work in terms of incentivising young people who are able to work, but almost need the carrot and stick to get them into the job.
9:25The problem is, is that sometimes you can find kind of the edge cases or the cases where people are more severely impaired, have more severe mental health conditions, and they are basically left out in the cold because they are put together with the group that you're trying to incentivise to work. So, you know, tightening benefits is not easy, even if you are putting a lot of support in. But ultimately, there's not much money going around. And what they want to do is take money out of the benefit system and put it into employment support over the long term. And they're hoping that the big investment in employment support is what kind of calms the nerves of restive Labour MPs.
10:07How likely do you think another pandemic is? It's right at the top of the agenda. It will happen. It will happen. You know the story, you remember the headlines, but what if you could hear from the people who were actually there? I saw a man who'd been hit in the face with two bullets, put my camera to my eye and he looked at me with all the pain in the world in those eyes. He was trying to move his head to say no, and I didn't take that picture. I'm Cathy Newman and I'm going back inside the stories that changed everything with the people at the very heart of them. Search Backstory and follow wherever you get your podcasts.
10:45Alan Milburn won't be a familiar name to all of you. So I spoke to our chief political correspondent, John Craig, who remembers him from his first stint in government. You, of course, knew Alan Milburn back when he was working in and around Westminster as an MP, then, of course, as a cabinet minister. What was he like? Well, Alan Milburn became MP for Darlington in 1992. He held that seat until he quit the House of Commons in 2010. Now, Alan Milburn had an interesting path into the House of Commons. He was a council house boy who was a bright lad, obviously, went to Lancaster University and then found himself in Newcastle working in a left-wing bookshop.
11:27It was called Days of Hope, but it was known locally as Haze of Dope. Now, that always gets a laugh. You can just imagine. It was up the Westgate Road in Newcastle, and it was a left-wing bookshop, and clearly there was quite a convivial atmosphere there. But he worked in that bookshop. He worked for trade unions, but then he got elected to Parliament in 1992. Now, Tony Blair always talks about politicians making the journey, and Alan Bilburn was a classic example. There were others as well, Stephen Byers, Alistair Darling, who went on to become Chancellor of the Exchequer. These are people who started off on the left and moved with the became Blairites.
12:14Obviously, Alistair Darling was more of a Brownite, but they moved into the mainstream from the left. I mean, I wouldn't say that Alan Milburn a bit of trot, but he was certainly to the left. He really embraced the whole Blairite revolution. Remember, Tony Blair became leader of the Labour Party in 1994 when John Smith died and then prime minister in 97. and Alan Milburn was really one of his closest allies and of course he was also MP for the seat next door to Sedgefield, Darlington's next door to Sedgefield in County Durham and so they were really close allies. So just to explain that period in Labour politics, you know Tony Blair came in and he really changed the party and I'm just wondering what Alan Milburn and Tony Blair saw as necessary in that changing of Labour.
13:03Well, what they saw was a need to shake up the National Health Service, apart from anything else. If you like, the highlight of Alan Milburn's parliamentary career was when he was Secretary of State for Health. Before that, he'd been Minister of State for Health. Actually, his next job in Parliament, in the government, was Chief Secretary to Treasury, number two to Gordon Brown. Now, Alan Milburn was such a Blairite that the talk at the time was that Blair had sent Alan Milburn into the Treasury to spy on Gordon to see what he was up to. And I think there is some truth in the fact that Mr Blair did send Milburn in to keep an eye on Gordon Brown, what he was up to, because he was, as I say, he was very much a Blair ally.
13:47You could say he was Tony Blair's narc in the Treasury. But, of course, the big job came in 1999, didn't it, when he became Secretary of State for Health, took over at the Department of Health. You remember that time, John? I mean, what sort of job was he taking on? The reason he became Secretary of State for Health was because it was a reshuffle prompted by Peter Mandelson's resignation, or one of them. I had about him recently, yeah. Or one of them. I think it was the first one. So he became Secretary of State for Health. Now, already, as Minister of State for Health, he had been a real pioneer of bringing private sector cash investment into the NHS, to the fury of many trade unions and indeed some on the left of the Labour Party.
14:31Of course, when he got the top job, he went even further. Private finance initiatives, getting the private sector to carry out some operations on the NHS and so on. It was a transformation, really, that was continued by another Blair ally, John Reid, who succeeded Alan Milburn as health secretary. How well did Alan Milburn handle those routes? Because, you know, even today, talking about changes to the health service in those terms, private investment, private contractors, that's complete anathema to the Labour backbenchers. Well, of course, the NHS has been a political football for the last, what, quarter of a century, if not longer.
15:10But he was radical. I mean, he's shown that he's a radical. And I think his track record suggests that his proposals on NEAT, getting young people off benefits and into work, will be radical. But that journey that he was on, at least in terms of frontline cabinet level politics, did come to an end back in 2003 when he said that, well, he was leaving to spend more time with his family. I mean, how big a surprise was that moment? How much do you remember? It was a shock at the time because, of course, you could argue he was at the height of his powers. We know that he was under pressure from his partner, now wife, Ruth.
15:49Now, Ruth was a very senior medic at one of the big hospitals in Newcastle. And there was a lot of family pressure. He, Mr. Milburn, described it at the time to people inside the health department as a three-line whip from Ruth, his partner. So he suddenly gave it all up, went to the back benches, although he did return later, but not in such a high profile role. And you could say, you know, if we're going to be Mills and Boone about it, we could say he gave up a top job for love because they later married and they have lived happily ever after, you might say. Okay, so he leaves the Commons, leaves being an MP in 2010.
16:29But I don't know, maybe there's something in the air, some strange scent carried by the Thames that brought him back into politics. But in what capacity? He was appointed to head a Social Mobility Commission. I mean, the social mobility crusade, if you like, was much more a Nick Clegg initiative than a David Cameron initiative under the coalition. Yes, indeed. But he had a falling out, it seems, with Theresa May. She succeeded David Cameron as Prime Minister after the Brexit referendum. And he felt that he wasn't getting the necessary government support. Posts were being left unfilled and so on.
17:08And so he stepped back from that. But this job now that Keir Starmer appointed him to is his big comeback, really. And it's a chance, really, for him to make a real impact. And if, as we assume, Andy Burnham is going to accept all his recommendations, then he will have had a real impact. Thanks, John. And a final thought from you, Rob. Look, what actually happens after the Milburn Review is published? Is this a done deal? I mean, you only have to look at what happened the last time Labour tried some pretty piddling and comparison reforms. No, it's not a done deal. But I think we're not in the same place that we were last summer with Keir Starmer, in part because they have done the politics a lot better.
17:52And for all of the, you know, the really interesting work that has gone into this Milburn report. It's not just a sort of political ribbon to put on top of something the government's trying to slide through. It's going to be a really, really deep piece of work into this issue. I went to the launch of the first part of the Melbourne report and there was a lot in that. It does also function as a political vehicle for the government. It's the thing that I think attempts to bring, or they hope will bring MPs with them and will potentially bring some, even cabinet ministers that may have been a bit dubious about this sort of thing with them.
18:28I think having Alan Milburn look at this in the round like that, it has a political advantage like that. On a very, very practical note as well, you've also got some of the people that were behind the rebellion against Keir Starmer for welfare sitting in cabinet now. One Louise Haig was instrumental in orchestrating that rebellion. She's effectively the deputy prime minister now. You know, it's easier said than done, but I think they've got the politics a lot better than they had when they tried this under Keir Starmer. So things could go wrong. I think there will have to be legislation passed.
19:02Whenever there's actually having to be changes to the law made, it ups the risk of rebellion because you get that, you know, in the sort of Westminster theatre mode, you get that moment potentially in the Commons where people have to, and MPs have to vote on something. And if someone has to vote on something, there are opportunities for amendments to come in, for things to be changed and for a head of steam to coalesce around something. So there's always a risk, but I'd say it's far, far lower than it was a year or so ago. And that's your lot for today. But do keep your eyes and ears peeled for much more on this story when the review is published in full.
19:36Politics at Sam & Anne's is the place to start. My colleagues Sam Coates and Anne McElvoy will walk you through the detail. This is why it's back tomorrow.
20:08The people are not being heard. They'll have the power to shape what they can and can't do. We've been travelling the country, speaking to the very people who will decide what happens next. Trump 100. Wherever you get your podcasts.
Young, free... and on the dole. That’s the case for almost a million young Britons who find themselves not in education, employment or training – otherwise known as ‘Neets’.
But Blairite Alan Milburn is proposing a solution. The former health secretary has led a review which will set out a radical overhaul of the UK’s welfare system, in a bid to get more under-25s into work.
How hard will it be for prime minister Andy Burnham to get his MPs to back the recommendations? And are there the jobs out there for young people in the first place?
Niall Paterson is joined by Sky's chief political correspondent Jon Craig and political correspondent Rob Powell.
Have you got a question for Niall? Email us: [email protected]
You can also watch This Is Why on the Sky News app, and on YouTube.