


COP31’s lack of progress on climate change, why the talks feel stalled, and what could still move the agenda forward—especially in the absence of key leaders and the US.
Tom Clarke, Sky News science and technology editor, reporting from COP31; he describes the mood and negotiations on the ground.
COP is widely seen as failing because emissions are still rising and leaders are distracted by wars, inflation, and cost-of-living pressures. The US is absent because Trump withdrew it from the Paris Agreement and UNFCCC, weakening leverage and giving others cover to water down commitments. COP may still deliver “small wins,” but there’s growing talk of alternatives.
Andy Burnham attending as the only G7 leader; Trump’s non-attendance; fossil-fuel lobbyists still present; a COP proposal to push electrification; a 57-country fossil-fuel phaseout subgroup meeting outside COP.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on Andy Burnham's message and the significance of COP31.
“Search for electoral dysfunction wherever you get your podcasts.”
Analysis of the atmosphere and priorities of leaders at COP31.
“You know, you talk to any climate scientist, they will tell you the COP process has failed.”
Discussion of absent leaders and the implications for climate negotiations.
“but it turns out that he's actually the only G7 leader attending this summit.”
Examination of the U.S. withdrawal from climate agreements and effects on COP31.
“really, I think, emblematic of the year that we've had and what those leaders are thinking about.”
Discussion on the wavering commitments from various nations amidst global challenges.
“And if the Americans aren't pitching up and pitching up in numbers, that surely gives other countries the perfect excuse to say, do you know what, guys?”
Exploration of electrification as a strategy to reduce emissions effectively.
“seen this from Andy Burnham as well, you know, saying we need to be more pragmatic, we need to recognise there's only so fast we can move before we put people out of business or make it too hard for businesses to grow.”
Reflections on COP's effectiveness and the search for alternative climate actions.
“Like it or lump it, COP is viewed as a talking shop by a lot of people and a glacially paced one at that.”
Learn about the glimmers of hope and optimism in the current COP discussions.
“COP, including the UK and most of the G20, to say, look, we can do this.”
Discover how listeners can share their thoughts on climate issues.
“And that's a real, real reason for optimism in what is otherwise a very pessimistic situation.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Sky News, the full story first.
0:11Andy Burnham turned up in Turkey trying to lead the world on climate change but many others didn't turn up at all and this is why
0:24Find politics hard to make sense of? A little bit depressing? Or just bloody boring? Well it needn't be I'm Beth Rigby, Sky News' political editor and one of the hosts of Electoral Dysfunction the politics podcast that cuts through the BS and has a bit of fun on the way. And I've enlisted a crack team of political juggernauts to help me out. There's me, Harriet Harman. Me, Jess Phillips. And me, Ruth Davidson. So join us. Search for electoral dysfunction wherever you get your podcasts.
0:57Andy Burnham finished PMQs, jumped on a plane and headed to Turkey with a message for the world. I have pledged a new era of British leadership over the next decade. Climate leadership and action have become more urgent. Britain will answer the call. Climate is a national security issue. Sounds good. Just one small problem with the PM addressing the world. Quite a lot of it hasn't actually turned up. We're talking, of course, about COP31, the annual UN summit where countries negotiate what to do about climate change. These were the talks that gave us the Paris Agreement, the massive deal back in 2015 to cut emissions and limit global warming.
1:39But Donald Trump thinks climate change a con, so you won't be surprised to hear he's pulled the US out of the Paris Agreement. His administration isn't attending COP either. Other governments have sent negotiators, but Burnham is the only G7 leader there, and that says a lot. This process isn't working. You know, you talk to any climate scientist, they will tell you the COP process has failed. Tom Clarke is Sky's science and technology editor. Tom, you are at COP31. In fact, at the moment, you're actually just sitting slightly outside, but back inside the conference centre. Just explain what the mood is like.
2:16I mean, the UN chief has said that the climate crisis is outrunning us, but where you are, it kind of almost feels, to me at least, that politicians have other things on their minds. Yes, and then that was exactly the fear going into this COP. in the year in which we had the attacks on Iran, closing the Strait of Hormuz, driving up oil prices, rising inflation, feeding through to bills and cost of living. On top of that, the ongoing war in Ukraine, which is threatening all sorts of geopolitical alliances. Leaders just have their minds elsewhere. They're thinking about defence budgets. They're thinking about how to keep bills down for people on lower incomes, especially in Europe, but also in America.
2:54Yeah, they're just not, their mind is not in the climate right now. But the incredible irony, of course, though, is this is possibly the first year where pretty much everyone on the planet couldn't sort of realise through the weather they were having that we are living in a warmer world and it's impossible to deny it anymore. And we've got a super El Nino brewing out in the Pacific, which is going to make next year even hotter. And yet here we are with the potential prospect of not very much being achieved. And sadly, sure enough, just walking around the COP, it does feel there is no buzz. there is a lack of apparent optimism and hope, which is pretty much, let's face it, the only thing that's kept this whole process alive for three decades.
3:37Look, COP already has heard from Andy Burnham, but it turns out that he's actually the only G7 leader attending this summit. Who are we missing? And that's a really significant point. There are people that rarely or never come to these things, and often they're the ones producing the highest carbon emissions. Is there a connection there, possibly? You know, Russia, for example, Vladimir Putin does not engage with this process, although they do send a delegation. President Monif Rinnia rarely comes. He was at the one in Glasgow and one in Dubai. But he's a no-show as well. But that's sort of normal for this situation.
4:08But what we have always seen pretty much is the most sort of climate forward, the most proactive nations. And many of them are the G7. They're wealthy. They're already sort of decarbonising their economies. You know, notable ones, Canada, Germany, France, did not send their heads of state or heads of government to the COP this year. They sent representatives, they're still engaged, but they're not putting their national figurehead behind it. And that really matters, not just for optics and for reassuring those maybe poorer countries who are dealing with the impacts of climate change that they're listening and they care.
4:46but also materially in that this is all about negotiation about getting deals done trading things off between countries to try and agree to move it forward and if you haven't got the person who ultimately makes those decisions coming here to smooth over those obstacles the process doesn't work as well so that lack of those leaders there are actually more leaders in attendance at this COP than the last two but it's the ones that matter aren't here and that is really, I think, emblematic of the year that we've had and what those leaders are thinking about. What about the United States, though? Look, as you say, with most of those countries, the leader isn't there, but an official delegation is there to kind of sort out business.
5:25I mean, with the United States, it doesn't look like there's an official Trump delegation to COP at all for the second year running, in fact. Has he just walked away from this? Yeah, absolutely. He didn't just walk away, we're not going to send a delegation. He formally withdrew the US from the Paris Agreement, and he could do that by executive order. He also, by executive order, pulled him out of the UNFCCC, which is the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Very, very long UN speak there, but that's the whole sort of edifice that this COP process is built on. He's withdrawn America from that.
6:03That is why they don't send a delegation. They're not actually signed up to this club anymore, so they're not really allowed to come even if they wanted to. So yeah, they're not here. And that is significant. The Americans that are here on the gloomy side, their lobbyists aren't staying away. So remember the big oil firms, the big fossil fuel businesses, industry groups, they're represented here, they are having meetings with other oil producers. And that's the remarkable thing about this process meant to be about climate, you have a lot of blocking and lobbying and obfuscation going on with this process.
6:35The The Americans are definitely here in that sense, but from a governmental level, at the federal level, they are absent. And what does that absence actually mean for what happens at COP this year in terms of future kind of agreements on carbon? I mean, you take a step back from it. And if the Americans aren't pitching up and pitching up in numbers, that surely gives other countries the perfect excuse to say, do you know what, guys? We perhaps might not be as committed as we have been in the past. There you go. I mean, that's exactly it. That's exactly why everyone was so disappointed and concerned about the future of this process.
7:10When America says we're pulling out, it just says, yeah, anyone can do that. You don't have to work together. You know, we know Trump's views on the United Nations. We know his views on multilateralism. So, yeah, it's very much par off the course for him. But it's one of those things that it's hard to ignore and move on. I mean, to be honest, Tom, are we all essentially in something of a holding pattern until the United States reconnects with the climate change process. Because it's not just Trump that is kind of backing away from these sorts of policies. Take a look at Europe, to Canada, New Zealand.
7:43You know, there are countries around the world that are watering down their commitments. And I'm not sure why they are doing that beyond the fact that Trump not being there gives them opportunity to do so. I think we are effectively, yes, in a holding pattern. But I think there's a bit more jeopardy than that. I think we're at a tipping point. We're at a key sort of pivot moment. Either we hang on and the situation continues as it is. And without the US, let's not forget, you know, people are still building renewables. In fact, more renewables have been built under Donald Trump, partly because of previous policies than under any other US president.
8:17So things are still moving in the right direction in America. But how long for if people like him stay in power? China's still powering forward. progress continues but because of what's been happening geopolitically in the world you're absolutely right people are starting to think this is not a problem we have got time to worry about right now there are more urgent immediate issues concerning many leaders and if it continues to fall off the agenda like that that is i think you know existential for the climate movement. If this COP is a failure, and let's not forget, it's a decade since they signed the Paris Agreement.
8:55One of the things this COP is actually still having to do is negotiate how to implement the Paris Agreement that was signed 10 years ago. You know, it's very slow. People really are starting to lose confidence in it. If that sort of starts to unravel and collapse, there's no alternative in town. And you've got politicians back home, quite understandably, I think we've seen this from Andy Burnham as well, you know, saying we need to be more pragmatic, we need to recognise there's only so fast we can move before we put people out of business or make it too hard for businesses to grow. That might be an honest way of doing it, but it also allows what is still an extremely wealthy and powerful fossil fuel incumbent sort of lobby force to say, let's just slow the whole thing down massively.
9:37If I come across sounding like a massive greenie here, I mean, forgive me, but the emissions, the atmosphere are going up still. We've been doing this talking for 30 years. But look at what's happening to our climate. And if you think what we saw this summer with heat waves, if you think what we saw in Nepal with that glacier collapse looked horrifying, you know, just imagine that two, three, four fold, because that's what will happen increasingly over the coming decades as we get close to three degrees warmer by the end of this century. Tom, look, whenever we talk about COP, we always talk about the communique.
10:17What comes out at the end of it? What on earth is going to come out of this one? There's one thing I think to look at that is a really good idea. And it is actually down to the Turkish presidency who are hosting COP this year because they came up with it. And it's this idea, let's do more electrification. Let's just electrify the world's economies, cars, factories more. And you think, well, isn't that what we already run on? But the clever thing is here, whether you make your electricity from fossil fuels or low carbon sources, wind farms, solar panels, it will lower emissions. And it sounds a bit counterintuitive.
10:56but if you run a heat pump on electricity powered by coal it's not ideal but that heat pump is three four times more efficient than a boiler so you will have to burn less gas to make the power for those things and the reason it's clever is that means countries who don't have access to lots of money for renewable technologies can can sort of continue doing what they do for a bit we don't have to force them into compromises around coal or gas that they're just going to resist and will never get over the line. Ukraine's a brilliant example, right? They've got lots of coal. They have not got the resource of the money right now to decarbonise their economy.
11:39But this is something that they can sign up to that will make a difference. And it's doable, and it will lower emissions. And as those renewables become cheaper and more available, and we start getting electricity from them instead we're already halfway there because we've electrified the end use of that power and we're using more evs etc so it's a smart idea in a time where they're recognizing i think the head of cop a un official called simon still put it well he said the world is as it is not how we wish it to be and we have to recognize that again this sort of pragmatic language coming through let's not fight against reality there's been too much overly ambitious targets at these summits that were always undeliverable.
12:23Let's just try and keep the process ticking forward and go for the low hanging fruit, the things that we can do. So that's electrification. I think they will get that over the line here. People will be unhappy or could have gone further, could have done more. Of course it should, but it's better to get a small win than no win at all. Like it or lump it, COP is viewed as a talking shop by a lot of people and a glacially paced one at that. So Tom, whilst noting that you are generally much more positive about COP than I ever am, as this one kind of edges towards a communique and a close, seriously, is this really the way the world tackles climate change moving forward?
13:03Because it doesn't look like it right now. This process isn't working. You know, you talk to any climate scientist, they will tell you the COP process has failed. We are at one and a half degrees already, and we're still arguing about how to implement the deal to prevent one and a half degrees of warming 10 years after it was signed. There's no better evidence. By the only measure that matters, carbon emissions in the atmosphere, they're still going up. And we've been talking for 30 years. It's failed. But it's the only game in town right now. There is no alternative. It still brings people together.
13:34we still get small wins if you're of the glass half full mentality you know not letting good be the enemy of perfect we should keep going but there is a growing conversation around alternatives because this just isn't delivering after the last cop where they couldn't agree to even phase out fossil fuels a splinter group of 57 now nearly i think maybe 60 countries met outside of the COP, including the UK and most of the G20, to say, look, we can do this. We can work together as a subgroup of nations to push for that. Without America, without India, without China, we can work on getting rid of fossil fuels and support each other in doing that and make trade alliances and things to push it through.
14:21And there is another glimmer of hope I see, even within this very flawed process. The only sort of real buzz you can detect in the vast corridors of COP, And it's from America. So, you know, we were talking earlier about how they're not here. But there are quite a few Americans here as sort of dissidents in Donald Trump's America. Figures like John Kerry, a very experienced diplomat who's been in this process at the start. A coalition of largely democratic politicians who have been coming here. Some big figures like Gavin Newsom and Tim Walz, Conor Harris's former running mate, if you remember.
14:54they are going to be here reminding everyone half of America, politically speaking, is still with you. And as soon as we get the chance, we're going to come back at this with energy and enthusiasm. And obviously they've been even more energised by those midterm results. So that's a that's a positive thing. And that's a real, real reason for optimism in what is otherwise a very pessimistic situation. Well, we will see if any of that comes to fruition and what may happen at the next COP. Tom, thanks very much indeed. Thanks, Neil. And that's your lot for today, but do remember to send in your thoughts.
15:28What do you make about the state of play when it comes to the climate? Are you enjoying our inflated temperatures or are you worried about what it means for your kids? Why at Sky.UK is the email. We're back tomorrow.
15:45Find politics hard to make sense of? A little bit depressing? Or just bloody boring? Well, it needn't be. I'm Beth Rigby, Sky News' political editor and one of the hosts of Electoral Dysfunction, the politics podcast that cuts through the BS and has a bit of fun on the way. And I've enlisted a crack team of political juggernauts to help me out. There's me, Harriet Harman. Me, Jess Phillips. And me, Ruth Davidson. So join us. Search for Electoral Dysfunction wherever you get your podcasts.
When the COP climate conference was held in Scotland five years ago, it was a who’s who of global politics and celebrity – from US President Joe Biden to actor Leonardo DiCaprio.
This year's event in Turkey is very different. Donald Trump was always going to give it a miss – but it’s more of a surprise not to see the likes of France’s Emmanuel Macron, Friedrich Merz of Germany and even arch-climate campaigner, Canada’s Mark Carney.
In fact, prime minister Andy Burnham was the only G7 leader to attend. And even that was only for a few hours, as cost-of-living pragmatism overtakes climate crisis concerns.
Niall Paterson speaks to Sky’s science and technology editor Tom Clarke and asks if there are any reasons to be optimistic about what COP could still achieve.
Have you got a question for Niall? Email us: [email protected]