1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Spending review: What does it mean for me?
This Is Why

11 Jun 2025 · 20m · 9 chapters

Episode artwork

Spending review: What does it mean for me?

In short

The episode explains Labour Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ spending review and whether people will “really notice the difference.” It says day-to-day departmental spending rises by about 2.3%, with health and defence getting larger increases, while schools rise briefly then flatten (real terms nearly decreasing by 2028-29). Social care is not funded much, and efficiency savings are required but unclear. Capital spending is higher than before, but details are hard to parse; defence gets more, transport spending rises, and nearly £40bn is earmarked for affordable housing. The guest, Ed Conway (Sky News economics and data editor), argues the changes are modest, not “a splurge” or “austerity,” and that fiscal rules leave little room if shocks hit. He notes police funding: the Home Office overall is down (real growth about -1.7%), though “police core spending power” rises. He also highlights geographic allocation (e.g., rail in Wales, nuclear in Suffolk) and warns improvements will be slow (NHS/schools).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:06

Key Highlights from the Spending Review

Discussion on the main points and predictable outcomes of the spending review.

“And with me is Ed Conway, our economics and data editor.”
2:40

Analyzing Day-to-Day and Capital Spending

Exploring the differences between day-to-day spending and capital investments.

“And, you know, it turns out defence, as predicted, gets a lot of money.”
4:28

The Importance of Capital Investment

Insight into how capital spending can impact long-term economic growth.

“in theory, the NHS is a big winner, isn't it?”
6:28

Funding Allocation and Political Implications

Discussion on how funding is allocated and its political implications, including policing and regional spending.

“I think, you know, Rachel Reeves keeps saying, if you want expensive things, you have to pay for them.”
9:52

Future Risks and Tax Implications

Examining potential risks and the likelihood of tax increases in future budgets.

“but there are some areas which are either losing out or were not really mentioned at all.”
13:21

Geographical Spending and Political Strategy

Exploration of where the funding is directed and its possible political motivations.

“No, and yesterday she was questioned by journalists and she didn't actually rule out further tax rises.”
14:00

Investment Distribution and Political Response

Explores the distribution of investment and the political reactions surrounding it.

“There was a lot of the nuclear power station will be in Suffolk.”
16:18

Impact of Spending Review on Public Services

Discusses the implications of the spending review on public services like NHS and education.

“But I think that takes us back to the question, will people feel the difference in, Rachel Reeve said, their everyday lives, jobs and high streets?”
18:38

Future Considerations and Uncertain Outcomes

Considers future challenges and the need for revisiting spending decisions amidst crises.

“And it's important to say that a lot of the decisions about exactly how much this money will, exactly where this money will be spent, departments have yet to take.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Ed Conway: We are renewing Britain. But I know that too many people in too many parts of our country are yet to feel it. That's the Chancellor outlining her spending review that the government have been talking about for months. But what will it mean for me and you?

0:20Rachel Reeves stood up in the Commons for 45 minutes and told us all how the government will spend its money over the next three years. The priorities of this spending review are the priorities of working people.

0:33Ed Conway: To invest in Britain's security, in Britain's health, and to grow Britain's economy so that working people are better off. That is my choice. That is Labour's choice. It sounds like a dry spreadsheet exercise, but it is important. The spending review outlines what Labour's priorities are for the rest of their time in office, The winners, health, defence, affordable housing and big infrastructure projects. I'm Tamara Cohn and this is the Sky News Daily and today we're asking, will you and I really notice the difference? And with me is Ed Conway, our economics and data editor. Hi Ed. Hello, you alright?

1:12Good. Well, we've been trying to digest quite a lot of information that the Chancellor has given us. I guess the first question is really, what have we learned today? Was there anything in here that we weren't expecting or anything that's come as a bit of a surprise?

1:28Ed Conway: I mean, in short, no, they weren't dramatic changes. They were kind of predictable. Health goes up, not enormously in comparison to previous years, but certainly goes up. Education goes up a bit in the short run and then not so much in the next years. But it was a few percent in most of these cases. So no, there wasn't a surprise on that front. I think that the second area where maybe people were thinking what's maybe not the jeopardy, but what are the big question marks about where the money is going to go was capital spending. So you've got your day-to-day spending, that's the biggest chunk, and then you've got this other chunk that's spending on investments.

2:02Ed Conway: And there, we knew that the total amount on capital spending was going to be big in comparison to previous years, and indeed it is. What we didn't know was where that was going to go. And that was why you had this kind of strange, I mean, almost surreal experience of watching Rachel Reads just, you know, trotting out hundreds of numbers. One thing after another that sounded massive, sounded like loads of spending. It sounded like loads of spending. You couldn't make head or tail of it. We were all sitting there. And, you know, I know other people like Paul Johnson from the IFS were kind of sitting there just scratching our heads going, this makes no sense whatsoever.

2:33Ed Conway: Even though there's like lots of good news stories in there because it just sounded like one number after another. And only now are we able to kind of look into the numbers. And, you know, it turns out defence, as predicted, gets a lot of money. We're spending more on transport. And back to your question you asked a long time ago, will we notice the difference? I mean, we are seeing a genuine increase in spending on public services. Is it massive? No. Is this anything like what we saw, for instance, the last big moment where the government kind of stepped in and said, right, we're going to spend more money was a long time ago, 25 years ago in 2000.

3:11Ed Conway: So Gordon Brown, in the first few years of being a chancellor from 1997 to around 2000, was like, I'm the prudent chancellor, put the public finances back into order, and then did this enormous splurge. And that's why you had really people noticing the NHS was better than it was for a long time. Sure start and lots of education programs meant that education was improving as well. The quantity, the scale of the numbers we're talking about in this spending review, they're nothing like that Gordon Brown period. It's quite modest, isn't it? Now, let's take this apart a bit because we've got, as you said, two things, day-to-day spending and then capital spending.

3:45So, day-to-day spending, one of the big themes of Rachel Reeves' speech, which I thought was interesting for the fact that it wasn't gloomy. She's moved away from doom and gloom and tough decisions towards there's optimism there. there. And she said day-to-day spending is going up, department spending by 2.3%, which sounds like a decent increase, but it's not all equal. So you've got more than that for health and defence. And some departments are getting a bit of an increase, but it's not huge, like schools, for example, where it is an increase, but a lot of it's going to be taken up by, for example, pay or spending on special educational needs.

4:19And some departments which are not protected are going to have cuts. So in terms of on the day-to-day stuff, whether people are going to see public services improve, in theory, the NHS is a big winner, isn't it? They're getting those waiting lists down. They are putting the money into it. But there isn't much money for social care. And the NHS says a lot of this might get kind of swallowed up anyway, given it's not huge compared to the increases they've had in the past. So I think, yeah, she's saying not austerity, but it's also not a splurge.

4:51Ed Conway: It's not a splurge. And I think the interesting thing is, take schools, for instance, okay? You can see that schools get quite a big increase in the first year or two, and then it's basically flatlining. And in fact, in real terms, schools just kind of almost decreases towards the end of 2028-29. So it's not that great by the end of the parliament. It's not a splurge, but it's not austerity. And I think that perhaps was the thing that they might have been nervous about, is that we would all be looking through and saying, well, this department, it will feel like austerity. this department would feel like austerity.

5:22Ed Conway: I mean, there are probably some examples. And part of the tricky thing in navigating today is normally on these big fiscal moments, you tend to have the officer budget responsibility kind of standing up the moment after the chancellor and saying, look, well, here's the stuff that's really going on behind the scenes. This time around, we don't have that. They are policing their own numbers. The government's numbers that they've given us. And also when we see a big number, so we've got a big, Ed and I have got this chart in front of us with the names of all the departments and a number in billions for each year of the next three years going forward.

5:55But within that, we don't know exactly how the money is going to be spent. And those departments will need to make some decisions there. And there's also this other issue about efficiency, because there's another chart that says departments will also need to save money. And that's all departments, including the NHS, need to save money by being more efficient. And they also, we don't know how they're going to do that either.

6:16Ed Conway: Every single spending review, by the way, since the invention of spending reviews has had something about efficiency in it. So, yeah, I mean, like, which is important, but not exactly. Now, we want to move on to the capital spendings. I think, you know, Rachel Reeves keeps saying, if you want expensive things, you have to pay for them. And that was why, for example, they cut the winter fuel allowance, made all these difficult decisions. Now, with capital spending, it's different, isn't it? That can be borrowed and it's for big things. It's for railways. It's for nuclear power stations. It's for things which take a very long time to build.

6:50And actually, the biggest ticket item on capital spending is nearly£40 billion for affordable homes. And that, the sector say, is going to make a really big difference. Why do governments commit to things for 10 years, Ed, when they're only going to be in power for five? I mean, can we take this really seriously?

7:10Ed Conway: Well, I mean, yeah, no, it's a good point. I think in short, because when it comes to capital spending, when it comes to doing a project, it just takes years to build it. So particularly with homes, you know, you need to get planning. as anyone who knows who's been through this process, you need to get planning permission, you need to go and get the equipment that you need, you need to get the builders and the construction people to actually build stuff. Same thing, you know, writ large with making, building a hospital, or dare I say, something like high speed too, you know, building anything big takes a long time.

7:37And so guaranteeing that money, I guess, gets the spades in the ground, gets the private sector investors thinking it's really going to happen and kind of just moves things a lot. Yeah.

7:44Ed Conway: And back to your point, you know, in the question, I mean, what the Chancellor did when she came into office, but she changed her fiscal rules and it gave her an enormous amount more that she could borrow, like you say, to invest. So the money that she was talking about today, a lot of that money for building stuff, that's borrowed money. So the government will be borrowing that money. But on the assumption that if you're borrowing to build something that might make the economy more vibrant and positive in the future, or even you could say make the case that more hospitals will ensure that people's health is better, which in turn means that they are able to work more, which is good for the economy.

8:19Ed Conway: In theory, all of that should boost economic growth. In practice, we just don't really know until it happens. And so it's easy to be kind of, you know, sniffy about it right now. But theoretically, building more roads that make it easier for someone to get to work will mean that people can work more, you know, at the margin. So that all makes lots of sense. In general, actually, it's funnily enough, the OBR, when they're looking at this stuff, they typically tend to say, it's all very well kind of saying you're going to spend X on this, but actually making it happen is far harder than just putting some numbers in a spreadsheet.

8:49Ed Conway: And I think that's particularly the one with housing. Okay, so we still, they're budgeting all this money for housing. A lot of that is all about kind of trying to improve planning, trying to kind of encourage people to build homes. The government themselves are not building any homes. So we're not back to that period back in the kind of, you know, the 50s, 60s, 70s, where the government was building lots of council housing. It's housing It's housing associations. Building or even buying them, aren't they? Exactly. And that's quite different. And we have never seen the kind of house building totals that we saw back in those days without a large amount of public sector actual construction of homes.

9:22Ed Conway: There wasn't anything in here that would radically change the shape of the state. It's gradualism. And I think for a lot of people, that's probably maybe that's kind of reassuring because they would want to see gradualism. But it is not. It's not dramatic. And I think that's a really important point about this, isn't it? that this whole exercise telling us what they're spending for the next three years tells us where Labour's priorities lie, are they going to do the things they promised when they got elected and what things are simply not going to be achieved. I think it's obvious that they've put money into some areas, health and defence, but there are some areas which are either losing out or were not really mentioned at all.

10:00One of the big rows in government in the run-up to this was about funding for the police. We had a lot of noises off from police chiefs and from individual forces in the newspaper saying we really need more money because the government promised at the election 13 ,000 more neighbourhood police. They said tackling antisocial behaviour on high streets and so on is a big priority. Now, we know there have been rows behind the scenes, but the Home Office has ended up with less money over the next few years than they've got now, haven't they?

10:30Ed Conway: And I mean, you can tell that there was sensitivity about this. OK, because when you look and I'm looking at it now, when you look at the tables that have all of the spending totals, you've got the home office. So each department has its total amount and you've got, you know, billions of this and so on and so forth. You've got the home office there and the number is not that great. In fact, it's terrible, really. The average real growth rate is minus 1.7 percent in the coming years. Then you look down, they've added this extra line going, ah, of which, of which home office? And then there's a memo below that other line saying, memo, police core spending power.

11:07Ed Conway: And when it comes to police core spending power, that's going up. And so I think the point here is they want to say, look, there is extra money for the police, but the rest of the home office is just going to have to lump it. Now, the conservative attack on this was this can't be afforded, that Rachel Reeves is going to have to raise taxes in the autumn budget in order to pay for all of this. Is that likely? So when we're talking about spending reviews, you're looking at a very specific bit of what the government actually does. So normally when it comes to the budget, you're looking at the taxes that they're bringing in or that we're paying.

11:42Ed Conway: You're looking at the amount of borrowing they have to do. You're looking at the totality of spending. And remember, when the government spends money, it's not just spending money on the NHS. It's also spending money on pensions, on public sector pensions. It's spending money on the state pension. It's spending money on benefits. It's spending money on debt interest. All of that stuff wasn't considered today. Really, we're considering one fraction of its total spending. and the upshot of that is there is a lot of other stuff that you need to think about and and that other stuff like for instance winter fuel payments that other stuff is likely to come back to haunt the government in in the coming months let alone the big economic kind of picture the macro economy right now you've got a trade war happening right now i mean it might might be that that ends but it might be that it gets worse and if it gets worse there's a very real possibility that that that pushes the UK into kind of, you know, maybe not a recession, but certainly weaker times in future.

12:34Ed Conway: And if that happens, then there's less money for everyone. I think it's a very reasonable criticism to say, you've left yourself very little room against your fiscal rules, for instance, just if anything went wrong, or if indeed any of these ambitions aren't kind of manageable. And if that does go wrong, then now that you set out your spending, the only alternative is to raise taxes or borrow more. But obviously, you can't borrow more if you've got these fiscal rules. So the point being that this kind of might pen Rachel Reeves in in the future and mean that the only lever she has left if something goes wrong in the next few years is to tax more.

13:11Ed Conway: And that, I mean, no one knows. No one knows. Even the Conservatives, even the Labour government don't know if that's going to happen right now. But they do know that they're selling close to the line. No, and yesterday she was questioned by journalists and she didn't actually rule out further tax rises. But she said so many times after that first by She said, this is the only one. I'm not coming back. I think she even explicitly said no more tax rises or at least something along those lines. And now that stuff is going to come back to haunt her because it's a hostage to fortune. You just don't know what's going to happen.

13:40One other thing I wanted to touch on just before we sum it all up is where the money is being spent geographically, I thought was interesting. So you've got quite a few of the announcements in the last few days. So rail in Wales got a big boost over 400 million for that. actually talked about the northern powerhouse. There was a lot of the nuclear power station will be in Suffolk. There was a lot of investment in areas where, and this is not entirely a cynical point, but where Labour may be vulnerable to reform to people. Gosh, who knew? People thinking perhaps we haven't seen the return on our investment voting Labour.

14:25and that's caused a bit of anger actually among London MPs. I've heard from London MPs saying, hang on a minute, why are we sort of being told that everything's great here and we have to give money to the north of England and the Midlands? I noticed Rachel Reeves also spent some time having a go at Nigel Farage over his unfunded spending commitments, which was a bit odd because he's only got five MPs and it didn't feel massively necessary. But there is a question here about where the money is being spent, isn't it?

14:49Ed Conway: The paradox there is I think that makes kind of a lot of sense and that these are areas that maybe haven't had as much investment as they could have done in the past. It's a leveling up. It's leveling up, you know, in a different guise. But I think other people would say, okay, that's fair enough. But you said, you know, a few months ago that you were all about growth. You had a growth speech. And it was like, you know, who cares about everything else? It's growth that matters. Well, if strictly speaking, it's all about growth, then probably, like it or not, you'd be putting more money into places which are growing fastest at the moment, generating the most GDP, which happens to be kind of London and the Southeast.

15:23Ed Conway: And so again, it's not altogether clear that it's very joined up. And this is the thing with Rachel Reeves, you're never quite sure, and for that matter, Keir Starmer, you're never quite sure which policymaking individual you're getting on any given week, because they've said that they're very into growth, but they've also said by the same token, they're very into kind of skewing investment into places that might not be kind of very growth positive. They said they're very into defence but they've also said that they're very into health um these these aren't kind of binary decisions clearly um but it's not altogether clear which of these you know individuals turned up today probably it wasn't the growth positive one but that being said i mean like you know theoretically spending more money on investment should be growth positive because if you're if you're putting more cash into making our infrastructure better then that should mean that we as a country are able to grow faster and we're always criticizing governments for not making these big long-term decisions.

16:14So there were quite a lot of big long-term decisions in this spending review. But I think that takes us back to the question, will people feel the difference in, Rachel Reeve said, their everyday lives, jobs and high streets? Now, in some ways, they will, but not for a long time. So if the affordable housing programme pans out in 10 years' time, we'll have a lot more affordable housing and it may be near to some of these new job opportunities created by transport and nuclear power stations. But in terms of our everyday experience of using the NHS, schools which we know are under a lot of strain at the moment, it sounds like the difference, and they admitted this when they got in, that you can't make a difference overnight, that all these years of austerity have taken a toll, the pandemic, but it will be slow to improve, won't it?

17:03Ed Conway: I think so, yeah. Yeah, there's no dramatic, dramatic game changer in any of these departments. You know, maybe defence is the biggest one. Schools, like I say, it's not that great, the settlement for schools. If you look out beyond the first year or two, it's really, it's not that great at all. I think they'll have to come back and provide more money or do something at some point. And also on defence, we may have to go further. I mean, NATO are pressuring countries to go further. And the spending review only talks about 2.6%. NATO are talking about 5%. So it may be that there's pressure within government over the next few years to also shift.

17:36Ed Conway: It may be. It may well be. And again, they've done the maximum they felt they had to do at this point. They haven't gone beyond anyone's expectations on anything, on defence, on health, certainly on education, on the Home Office. They've probably done less than expected. So it wasn't dramatic and it wasn't bold. But perhaps for some people that's like that's kind of what they were hoping for, something that didn't completely kind of change the nature of the state. and that's what we got. So there wasn't any slash and burn either. No department has had really, really difficult cuts on the scale that they did during the coalition years, for example.

18:13Ed Conway: It was not austerity. And it's worth saying as well, although this was a zero-based review, the small print to that, which in other words, examine every bit of your spending, the small print to that is if a department found that it was spending too much on paperclips, then it was allowed to take that paperclip money and spend it on another bit of their department. So it wasn't like you were kind of really had much jeopardy there, which seems like a little bit of a cop-out if you're trying to police public spending. And it's important to say that a lot of the decisions about exactly how much this money will, exactly where this money will be spent, departments have yet to take.

18:47They can decide, you know, the Home Office have said they're pleased with the money they've got, for example, for borders and border policing, but they've got£680 million for that, but clearly on sort of community police it's not been so good so I think within departments there may still be sort of some big decisions to make over the over the coming years about how exactly that that pie gets cut up but yes she's promised a real difference some of that real difference may be positive some of it may not be felt at all and some of it may actually be quite tricky.

19:21Ed Conway: I think the big question now is so at what point do they have to start revisiting some of this in the face of whatever next crisis comes up, because it would be shocking if, you know, it's great to have a multi-year spending review, which is the whole point of this is, let's not just do this stuff one year at a time. Let's allow governments to make plans for the future. But in practice, things are going to happen. I mean, COVID, dare I say, who knew that was going to happen? Who knew we're going to get a trade war this year? There's a lot of things that could surprise us in the coming years. So the story's not over yet.

19:50Yeah, the best laid plans. Well, thank you so much, Ed. That was really great. That's it for today. You can find out more about how the spending review impacts you on our website, news.sky.com. The Daily is back tomorrow.

From the publisher
The chancellor has unveiled her long-awaited spending review, which sets out detailed plans for how individual government departments are funded over the next three years. 
 
Rachel Reeves says departmental budgets will grow by an average of 2.3% a year, prioritising health, defence and infrastructure projects - but how will this be paid for? And does this make a change for working people as promised by her government?  

In today’s episode, political correspondent Tamara Cohen speaks to economics and data editor Ed Conway about the ambitious figures.    
 
Producer: Emily Hulme  
Editor: Philly Beaumont 

More from This Is Why

All episodes