


Whether Trump’s “real end to the conflict” approach to Israel-Iran can work, amid a US military buildup and uncertainty over whether Washington will restrain Israel, join strikes, or push a nuclear deal.
Professor Michael Clarke, Sky News security and defence analyst; former UK defence/foreign policy expert (speaks as an analyst of US and regional military options).
Trump left the G7 early and convened his security council, signaling a defining foreign-policy moment. US forces are positioned for possible strikes (F-15/F-16 deployments, carrier battle groups, B-52s with GBU-57 bunker busters). Israel can hit Iran’s launchers but likely can’t fully destroy Iran’s nuclear program without US capabilities. Regime change would likely bring chaos/autocracy, not a liberal alternative. Iran may seek “talks about talks” without abandoning its nuclear program.
JCPOA details (300 kg uranium at 3.67%); Iran’s missile volley allegedly reduced from ~1,000 to ~150–160; ~10% penetration; risks of “internationalizing” via Red Sea/Houthi pressure.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion about Trump's diplomatic approach to Iran and Israel.
“See our seven day return policy at Carvana.com.”
Analysis of the US military buildup in response to Iranian threats.
“defence analyst, Professor Michael Clarke.”
Exploration of Iran's military capabilities and response to Israeli actions.
“Yes, I mean, all that we know about regime change in the last 30 or 40 years, is that dictatorial regimes are not replaced by liberal democratic regimes overnight.”
Speculation on whether Iran might agree to a nuclear deal amidst conflict.
“If they can't, as it were, humble the Israelis themselves, which they can't at the moment, then their only option is to internationalize the conflict with all the risks that that runs for them.”
Discussion on Trump's ability to navigate complex foreign policy issues.
“But isn't the truth that Israel is at its strongest when its interests align with the interests of the United States?”
Explore Trump's approach to international diplomacy and its potential outcomes.
“Does he have the people around him who have the kind of vision and understanding of international diplomacy, see what's possible, what's not.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Mark Austin: Today on the Sky News Daily with me, Mark Austin, could Trump's approach to the conflict between Israel and Iran work?
0:30Mark Austin: would. You never do. No, I never do. So buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply. See our seven day return policy at Carvana.com. Donald Trump left the G7 meeting early, telling reporters on Air Force One that he wanted what he called a real end to the conflict. And he's not reached out to Tehran to try and engineer peace talks as he hopes to do better than just a ceasefire. Well, five days on since Israel launched its first strike on Iran, there now seems to be a US military buildup in the region. So how will Trump's style of diplomacy play out? Joining us to discuss that is Sky's security and defence analyst, Professor Michael Clarke.
1:16Mark Austin: So Michael, let's talk first of all about where we are with all this. Trump has left Canada, the G7 meeting early. He's called a meeting of his security council what do you think is going on i think he knows he's at the biggest turning point of his career in this administration as far as foreign policy is concerned because this is the biggest issue iran it's the one he's talked about all the time going back to his first administration it's what he talked about in between the two administrations from 2020 till last year he always said he will deal with iran and sometimes by dealing with iran he meant he would denuclearize Iran.
1:53Sometimes he meant he would do a deal with Iran to keep their nuclear ambitions very low or off the table. And sometimes he seemed to imply that he would destroy Iran. So we don't quite know what he meant. There is a sort of a really delicate Iran moment now arriving. Iran is now on the floor with Israel able to range over its territory and destroy pretty well what it wants if it's got the bombs to do it. And President Trump has got to decide now, how far does he back Israel? Is he going to join in with this attack to somehow destroy the Iranian revolution? Or is he going to restrain Israel? Is he going to do a deal, a nuclear deal, which the Israelis don't want?
2:29They absolutely don't want, but is he going to do a deal and impose it on them? It's a bit like the Ukrainian issue for him, but one that he cares about. Whereas he doesn't care about Ukraine, just wanted to get it out of the way. He does care about the Iran issue because he's made such a big deal of it in the last 10 years.
2:44Mark Austin: You say the Israelis can do pretty much what they want now. What they can't do on their own is destroy the nuclear program of Iran. The big question, I guess, is do you think that Donald Trump is preparing for military action by America to finish this nuclear program? He's certainly putting himself in a position to do so if he chooses to. So we know that there's a lot of jets gone from Rammstein Air Base, F-15s and F-16s. All the tankers are with them. at least seven tankers in the air, as we speak, to refuel them on the way to the Middle East. He's got three carrier battle groups. He will have.
3:22He's got two in the area already, the Bush and the Carl Vinson. The Nimitz is on its way. It'll be there in a couple of days. And he's got B-52s at, where else, Diego Garcia. And the B-52s that he's got there can carry the bunker buster bombs, the really heavy ones, the GBU-57, as it's known, which the Israelis haven't got and can't carry. The Israelis don't have an aircraft that can carry. It's 12 tons. so the americans are building up their forces now whether this is to convince tehran that they could do it that they mean it whether it's a bluff or whether it's just to like any commander-in-chief to say look i want to have the options give me the options but those forces are certainly converging and this coming week and you know from now into next week will be really critical moments in donald trump's whole iranian policy such as it is and there's another reason why it's such a big
4:10Mark Austin: decision that if you do take out the nuclear programme, and if that leads to some sort of regime change, who knows what replaces that regime? Yes, I mean, all that we know about regime change in the last 30 or 40 years, is that dictatorial regimes are not replaced by liberal democratic regimes overnight. I mean, sometimes that may be the outcome after next, as it were, but the immediate outcome is usually chaos followed by autocracy followed by some sort of terror they're not normally better if the Iranian revolution is somehow toppled it will not be replaced I'm sure by a sort of a western orientated secular liberalish government and if you like you know the Pakhlavi family the old Shah of Iran's family I mean Reza Pakhlavi is in the United States as a famous emigre he's fated in the US as if somehow he might be a returning ruler forget it I mean, the Baklavi family are really not popular at all in Iran.
5:09And the idea of an emigre who sat out for 40 years coming back, you know, it never worked. Right. We'll see what Trump decides.
5:16Mark Austin: As for Iran, I mean, its missile stock presumably is being exhausted fairly rapidly. And we don't know what is left. Where do you think they stand now in terms of how strong they are? They tried to create a sort of 1 ,000 missile attack on Israel as an immediate response, and they're only able to make about 150, 160. So they're certainly shorter of missiles than they were. They've still got quite a lot. What they're really short of is launchers, and that's the whole point. The Israelis have been very good at being able to attack these mobile launchers. They've located them quickly. They've attacked them quickly because once the Israelis are inside Iranian airspace and their aircraft are able to range around, which they couldn't do before when there were defences there, but they've taken all the air defences down.
6:04They're inside Iran. It's 1 ,000 miles from Tel Aviv to Tehran. So these aircraft are, you know, towards the limit of their range. But once they're in Iran with air-to-air refueling, they range around in Iranian airspace. When they see these launchers, they attack them. And the lack of launchers is what's really affecting the Iranians' ability to hit back. Let's guess that they've still got 1 ,000 missiles, but they can only launch maybe 50 or 60 of them because of the lack of launchers. And every time they launch, they risk losing the launcher. And not many of those get through. Not many get through.
6:35About 10 % are getting through, which shows that the Iron Dome, I mean, any defensive system can be overwhelmed by numbers. So the Iranians are now facing the issue, okay, we can't affect Israel directly. So do we now affect the international community to put pressure on Israel to stop? You close Australia for most, which is very serious and would have all sorts of effects on China, which won't be at all pleased about it. And you begin to do something about other areas. I mean, you tell the Houthis then to, you know, increase their attacks on any shipping in the Red Sea. So you actually create problems for world trade.
7:07You internationalize the crisis. But couldn't that then guarantee to bring America into the... It might. That's the point. Or you attack American and Western forces and then they retaliate. So that's the problem for the Iranians. If they can't, as it were, humble the Israelis themselves, which they can't at the moment, then their only option is to internationalize the conflict with all the risks that that runs for them.
7:28Mark Austin: So, I mean, is the likelihood, given all that, that the Iranian leadership may now be in the mood to do a deal? And when I say a deal, I mean to relent and to agree to end their pursuit for a nuclear bomb. If I had to guess, I'd say they're in a mood to have talks about talks. In other words, they'll indicate that they want a diplomatic solution to this, but they are very, very reluctant to say we're going to cancel our nuclear program because they've put so much into it. And they were reasonably close to a deal before this Israel attack. And we all thought that there would be a deal along the lines that Trump was talking about, which would have looked very like the 2015 deal, which Trump then tore up in 2017.
8:13The deal that Obama did, which was the JCPOA, the famous Iran nuclear deal. Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action. That's right, the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action. JCPOA. JCPOA. We tripped off it. The JCPOA. You say, what does it mean? I can't remember.
8:28Mark Austin: Which restricted Iran to 300 kg of uranium, enriched to 3.67%, which would have left them a long way from, you know, the sudden production of a nuclear weapon. William Hague was saying today, sorry to interrupt you, William Hague was saying today, that was the right deal and that would have worked. And, of course, it was Trump came in in 2018. Because it was Obama's deal, he wrecked it. The thing with an enrichment, 3.67 is what you need to burn fuel for civilian purposes. You might need up to 20%, interestingly, for marine engines. Nuclear ships and submarines use 20 % enriched uranium, which is very high.
9:09But you don't need anything beyond 20%.
9:11Mark Austin: And the argument was they were approaching, well, the Israeli argument. Well, even the IEA were saying. Well, they've now got, according to the IEA, they've got 400 kilograms of 60%. And it's very easy to get from 60 % to 80%, and then 90 % is weapons grade, but 80 % will do. I mean, the Hiroshima bomb was 80%. So would they have got to that under the 2015 deal, do you think? No. If you want to develop a civil nuclear program, like everybody else, you can do it, and everything else is severely checked, and we'll look at what's happening. If you break this deal, the sanction will immediately snap back into place.
9:46That was the way it was. It was a pretty rigorous inspection as well. And it was a very rigorous inspection.
9:49Mark Austin: Why then did Israel, why then did some in the United States in the Trump administration think that this was not a tough enough deal? Because there are those certainly in Israel saying that it was too much leeway for Iran. The Israelis and Netanyahu in particular have always opposed the idea of any nuclear deal with the Iranians because they say, look, just matter what deal you do, they will cheat. And there's a long history of that. Why should we allow the Iranians any nuclear program when they don't need a civilian nuclear program because they've got all the fossil fuels they need? Now, there's an environmental argument that's arisen since 2010 to say, well, we all need to move on to non-fossil fuel sources.
10:27But the Israelis have always opposed the deal. And, you know, there's a dirty little secret about all of this, which is that people who opposed the 2015 deal said, look, we have this deal with them. Look at what they're doing with the Houthis. Look at what they're doing with Hamas. Look at all the militias they have across the Middle East. Look at how malign an actor they are. The point is, we were the ones in 2015 who insisted that we keep the whole arrangement to nuclear only. The Iranians wanted to talk about all sorts of things. We said, no, no. And the Iranians eventually agreed and said, OK.
10:55And they stuck to it.
10:57Mark Austin: So where do you think we're heading? I mean, how do you think this will play out? I guess the key decision now rests with Donald Trump. I mean, I'm guessing obviously. But I think Donald Trump is in a mess. And he doesn't really know what his policy is. He must be aware that he's facing a very critical moment in the early phase of his presidency on this, the most important foreign policy issue he has faced. And he's not in control of it. He's he's behind the curve on this whole thing. Netanyahu is driving it. So what do I think is going to happen? I think Netanyahu will continue these attacks and then he'll declare victory and stop.
11:33The nuclear program will be devastated, but not destroyed. And the Iranian military will be on its knees as a result of these attacks. President Trump may then move in and say, I've created this situation, but it won't solve the problem because the Israelis will still be committed somehow to carrying on a campaign against Iran having any nuclear power under present circumstances. So it does look as if this will be a sort of forever grumbling war in which the Americans will try to stay outside of, but will keep getting pulled into in different ways. That's what I would guess would happen.
12:06Mark Austin: But isn't the truth that Israel is at its strongest when its interests align with the interests of the United States? And on this, in a way, they don't align because Trump wants to end war, because Trump wants a deal. He's the dealmaker. He's the guy who wants to stand up and say, look what I've done. This is my deal. Netanyahu is not interested in a deal, is he? No, he's not. But if he can create a situation where Israel is the mini superpower of the region and that Saudi Arabia accommodates itself through the Abram Accords process, they're a long way from it at the moment. But if Saudi Arabia, as it were, comes alongside Israel in the sense that they learn to live together and between them, they create a sort of security arrangement for the region.
12:56The United States would find that pretty conducive. And Donald Trump might then in future get some credit for being the man who, chaotically as it was, nevertheless presided over a better situation in the Middle East and allowed America to step away from Middle East politics. I mean, US presidents from Bill Clinton onwards are desperately trying to get out of the Middle East because it's such a mess for them. And none of them have managed it. They've all got pulled back in. Trump wants to avoid that, but he may feel that being pulled back in would be for a one cataclysmic remaking of the region, will create a new basis for American power, which is going to be expressed in the Indo-Pacific.
13:35And they can stop worrying about the Middle East because the Israelis and the Saudis have got it sewn up between them. is a long-term vision. That's not so crazy from the US point of view.
13:45Mark Austin: So just to go back to where we started and you said this is the defining moment for Donald Trump. If that is the case, do you think that Donald Trump is equipped to make the decision? Does he have the people around him who have the kind of vision and understanding of international diplomacy, see what's possible, what's not. He's got a reputation for getting things done and it might work in this case. I think if it does work in this case, it'd be as much by luck as by judgment. I mean, he has an instinct for things. He makes policy on the hoof, but the group he's got around him is, most people say, it's amateur.
14:26I mean, other adjectives are available. If the luck goes with Trump, then it's possible that the sort of thing we've been talking about might work out. But I'm sure it won't work out through dint of really hard diplomatic preparation, because at the moment, America is approaching every policy issue and it's making policy on the hoof. And it's like the caravan style of management. You know, the vehicle in the front thinks it knows where it's going. And behind, there's a whole sort of tailback of cars and other vehicles trying to work out what on earth is happening at the front. That's the way Trump does things.
14:58People say he likes to do it that way because he likes to be unpredictable. He uses unpredictability as a force of power. He is. By law of averages, some of it works out quite well, worked out quite well between India and Pakistan. They were looking for somebody to tell them to stop, and the Americans told them to stop. So well done, America. Did it well on that. But hopeless on Ukraine, hopeless on Gaza, unsure over Iran, Israel, and we'll see how it works out. But if it does work, it won't be by dint of really careful diplomatic preparation.
15:29Mark Austin: Michael, thank you very much. That's it for today. We'll be back again tomorrow. you