1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Why are dangerous dog attacks getting worse?
This Is Why

11 Nov 2026 · 18m · 12 chapters

Episode artwork

Why are dangerous dog attacks getting worse?

In short

Dangerous dog attacks in the UK are rising, with hospitalisations up 45% (2020–end of last year) and increasing every year despite the 2023 XL bully ban; the episode argues the ban hasn’t reduced severe injuries and explores why.

Guests/backgrounds

Katie Barnfield, a Sky News reporter and dog-attack victim (Father’s Day 2023; attacked while jogging near a primary school; four-day hospital stay; plastic surgery; ~27 stitches; scarring; one finger still impaired). Also referenced: Esther Martin’s daughters Sonia and Kelly (Esther killed by two XL bullies shortly after full enforcement).

Key claims

XL bullies aren’t a true “breed” and are identified by police measurements (e.g., height thresholds), allowing similar dogs to remain legal; policing and dog wardens face more dangerous seizures and more severe bites; government won’t adopt dog licensing.

Notable examples

Katie’s body-worn police footage; Greater Manchester Police dog seizures up 900%; dog wardens modifying kennels with pulley systems; Esther Martin’s death (police stopped counting at 60 bite marks; over an hour with riot shields/tasers to enter).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:58

Katie's Attack Story

Katie recounts her horrific experience of being attacked by a dog.

“Going out for a run isn't supposed to end with a four-day stay in hospital, but that's what happened to my colleague Katie Barnfield last year.”
2:04

The Aftermath of the Attack

Discussion on the physical and mental impact of the dog attack on Katie.

“Katie, this is going to be a really strange one, because we're going to be talking about something I've seen the past few hours, a really horrendous attack on you by a dog.”
5:48

Rising Dog Attack Statistics

Katie reveals shocking statistics on the increase of dog attacks.

“Yeah, it was when I got to Withenshaw Hospital.”
7:06

Understanding Dog Attack Legislation

Overview of the Dangerous Dogs Act and recent legal changes regarding dog breeds.

“that is brought in to limit the number of attacks of these kinds clearly doesn't seem to be working.”
8:02

Police Challenges with Dog Attacks

Insight into how police are affected by the recent changes in dog legislation.

“Yeah, there have been a number of dogs that have been inverted commas banned, haven't there?”
10:00

Life on the Front Lines with Dog Wardens

Katie shares her experience working with dog wardens and their observations.

“They've got their own sort of dedicated dog court that they've set up.”
12:18

Surgeons' Perspectives on Dog Attacks

Insights from surgeons regarding the severity of injuries from dog attacks.

“And they were saying to me, the bites are getting worse.”
13:30

Tragic Outcomes of Dog Attacks

Discussion about the tragic case of Esther Martin and the implications of dog attacks.

“He said the number of severe injuries that they're getting through, that's actually increasing.”
14:00

The Tragic Case of Esther

Learn about the circumstances surrounding the tragic dog attack on Esther.

“Esther was killed just a couple of days after the XL bully ban was fully enforced.”
15:10

The Factors Behind Increasing Dog Attacks

Explore the various reasons suggested for the rise in dog attacks despite regulations.

“Well, there's several things that were suggested to me.”
Show all 12 chapters
17:00

Government Response to Dog Attacks

Examine the government's stance on dog licensing and responses to public concerns.

“licensing is you know you sort of pay an annual fee you almost have to get a license much like a driving license before you get a dog.”
17:50

Personal Accounts of Dog Attack Survivors

Hear firsthand experiences of those who have survived dog attacks and their reflections.

“I'm very, very lucky, actually, that it wasn't worse.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:03Sky News, the full story first.

0:11Four people in one hospital ward. All of them had been attacked by dogs. My colleague Katie Barnfield was one of them, and this is why.

0:25People don't show up to vote, so I'm asking them to pretend I'm on the ballot. I'm thrilled he's saying that. His approval ratings are in the toilet. America's midterms matter to all of us. Voters will decide who controls Congress, Trump's Republicans or the Democrats. The people are not being heard. They'll have the power to shape what he can and can't do. We've been travelling the country speaking to the very people who will decide what happens next. Trump 100. Wherever you get your podcasts. Going out for a run isn't supposed to end with a four-day stay in hospital, but that's what happened to my colleague Katie Barnfield last year.

1:05She was attacked by a dog. Its owner tried to pull it away, but the dog wouldn't let go. A woman dragged Katie into her house and probably saved her life. Okay, whereabouts are you injured? Just a year. Okay, okay. And a hit. Oh my God. Katie needed plastic surgery on her leg and hands. And while she was in hospital, she discovered something that really shocked her. She wasn't the only person on the ward who'd been attacked by a dog. It was interesting when I came here, actually, and the surgeon that was checking me in said there were four of us on the ward at the time that had been attacked by dogs.

1:41Four of us on the ward of 11 beds, I think? That felt wild to me. Four people on just one ward. And as Katie discovered when she started looking into it, more and more people are ending up in hospital after dog attacks, despite changes to the law as recently as 2023. Katie's on the podcast to tell us more. Katie, this is going to be a really strange one, because we're going to be talking about something I've seen the past few hours, a really horrendous attack on you by a dog. What do you remember of that day? I remember it like it was yesterday, honestly. I was out for a run. It was actually Father's Day morning last year.

2:25I was meant to be going to see my dad, which I had to pause after this happened. I was out jogging, saw this guy and his dog in front of me. The dog was on a lead, went to pass on the dog's side. It was actually outside a primary school. It was one of those barriers they used to kind of stop the kids crossing the road. Went to try and sort of squeeze past. I honestly thought the dog was jumping up to say hi to me initially. And then I realized through the adrenaline that it was attached to me. it then managed to get my thigh after biting my hip um dragged me and the owner all the way across the street it was that powerful the whole time the owner was trying to pull it off me he just could not get it to let go eventually I managed to kind of crawl away wriggle out of my running leggings as it was biting me and this incredible woman who's actually in the report I've done kind of bundled me into her house called the police called the ambulance I then from inside her house heard the owner screaming outside because the dog had turned on him as well it was at that point that armed officers turned up and tasered and then shot the dog which they told me they don't do very often but in this case they had no choice I mean one of the strangest things about this horrific story is not just that you of course went through it but you've had the opportunity to go back and look at the footage taken by the the kind of the cameras being worn by the cops that day yeah yeah so there was police body worn obviously because they were called the first time I actually saw any of the video was when I watched it being recorded for this piece uh it was pretty traumatic I have to say watching it again seeing myself kind of on the floor in in Ruth's house the woman that helped me you know seeing my injuries through their eyes that were quite significant because you were in an awful load of pain you were do you know what because Because of the adrenaline, I was just full of adrenaline.

4:15I didn't feel any pain until I got into the ambulance afterwards. Nothing. Your body just takes over in that moment when you genuinely think it's a life or death situation. I mean, your injuries were pretty extensive, weren't they? Pretty extensive, yeah. I was in hospital for four days in the end. I had to be put on an antibiotic drip, had to sleep with my arms in these kind of slings because they were worried about an infection developing in my hands. I ended up having plastic surgery to my leg and both of my hands had about 27 stitches in total couldn't drive for a couple of months I still have pretty extensive scarring and you know one of my fingers is still not working properly so it was quite significant.

4:53And just in terms of you know the immediate aftermath of this attack the physical injuries are one thing I'm wondering what this did to your head? Yeah I mean in hospital was a really difficult time I was all over the place when I was in that I think it's the adrenaline you know you're just coming down off that and then you know you're you're in a ward you know I was terrified at the time that I was going to lose a finger and actually the the wound care nurse who dealt with my injuries afterwards said that she was she was surprised that I didn't actually that was very very lucky that it had kind of missed the sort of key tendons and nerves in my thumb so it was just a really terrifying time I cannot express to you really how frightening a thing this is to go through.

5:35And now you were in hospital for a number of days, four days, I think it was. But as you were sitting there, you look around and obviously you're on a ward, there are other patients there. You realised that you weren't the only person who was there because of a dog. Yeah, it was when I got to Withenshaw Hospital. So after I'd been through A &E and they said, you know, you're going to need to stay in as an inpatient, you need surgery. And the surgeon that was checking me in, he said, you know, we are seeing this all the time. And he said, you are the fourth person to be checked into the plastics ward today with a dog attack.

6:06In one day? In one day. And there are 11 beds on the plastics ward to put it into context. And that just felt absolutely wild to me. I could not believe that. And that's when I thought, this is a massive problem and I need to look into it. Well, when you did start digging into it just that little bit deeper, what did you find in terms of the numbers? Have we genuinely seen an increase in this sort of attack? We have. So the numbers that we got for this piece were given to us by the NHS, by NHS England. They spanned from 2020, the period, all the way up to the end of last year. They showed that hospitalisations from dog attacks, so we're talking serious injuries where people need to be admitted, they need hospital treatment, have risen 45 % in that five-year period.

6:51and there has been an increase every single year, including since the government changed the law in 2023 and brought the XL bully ban in to try and address this issue. They've kept increasing and that was quite shocking to me, actually. Well, it's shocking to me as well that a piece of legislation that is brought in to limit the number of attacks of these kinds clearly doesn't seem to be working. So maybe this is a good point for you to explain. Exactly what parts of the legal system, And which laws apply to situations like the one you find yourself in? So the key piece of legislation really around dog attacks is the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991.

7:27Now that does two things effectively. The first side is the kind of reactive side of it, shall we say. So that covers once someone has been attacked by a dog, this is the law that someone would get arrested under, charged under. It makes it an offence to have any breed of dog dangerously out of control is what they say in the law. Then there's the other side of it, which should we say is the kind of preventative, proactive side of it, which aims to stop dog attacks happening in the first place. That is the controversial part of it. That is what includes what's called breed-specific legislation, which is what the XL Bully Ban is a part of.

8:01Now, the XL Bully Ban was by no means the first ban to be brought in under this Act. Yeah, there have been a number of dogs that have been inverted commas banned, haven't there? Yes, yes. So, 1991, the Act was brought in. pit bulls for instance have actually been banned in this country since 1991 other dogs like the japanese tosa fila braziliero um plenty of other breeds have been banned for years but it was when the government made this change in 2023 that they added xl bullies to it now the problem with xl bullies they're not actually a breed and i think this is something that people really don't understand i certainly don't yeah so the way that an xl bully is identified is that you know a a specific officer from the police called a dog legislation officer will assess a dog and see if it meets certain characteristics.

8:48The key one of this is height. So it's 48 centimetres for a female dog, 51 centimetres for a male dog. So you can have a bull breed, very, very similar to an XL bully to all intents and purposes. If it's one or two centimetres smaller, it doesn't qualify. It's then completely legal. It's not banned. It can be walked without a muzzle. So it's quite a difficult law in practice for the police to enact. But of course you've been back to speak to Greater Manchester Police about your attack and the detail of your incident that directly applies to just what we've been talking about is the dog that attacked you wasn't on the list.

9:24It wasn't on the list. It was just that bit too small to be classified as an XL bully. Therefore it was completely legal to walk it without a muzzle, didn't need an exemption, totally legal to own, totally legal to keep, you have it off lead in a park. What did GMP Greater Manchester Police say to you about the way in which their policing has been affected by the XL bully ban? They said it's had an enormous impact on them and not just them but police forces nationwide. They said that their dog seizures have gone up 900 % since the ban came in and they haven't been given any extra money or resource.

9:58They've actually had to come up with a system to try and filter these cases through. They've got their own sort of dedicated dog court that they've set up. So it's had an enormous impact on them and many other forces.

10:35can and can't do. We've been travelling the country, speaking to the very people who will decide what happens next. Trump 100. Wherever you get your podcasts.

10:51Tell me about the kind of, what strikes me as the front line in kind of the battle against these dangerous dogs and it's dog wardens. You went out with some of them? I did, yeah. I was invited to spend a couple of days on shift with the dog wardens, go out with them. So what they do is they respond to call outs from the public about stray dogs, abandoned dogs. There aren't dog wardens in every area, but there are in Greater Manchester where I live. So I was able to go out with them and see what they do and the kind of dogs that they're picking up. I was stunned, actually, because I was chatting to them before we went out on the job.

11:22And they said, we're still seeing XL bullies all the time. And sure enough, about an hour into the shift, we got the first call, went with them. They picked up two dogs and immediately one of the officers said, that is a red-nosed pit bull. They've been banned for 30 years. And it turns out that once both of the dogs were assessed, they both turned out to be banned breeds. What did they tell you about why people choose these particular types of dogs? Some people think that they are good companions. And actually what they said was that, look, the law banning XL bullies, just because you ban an XL bully, if people want a large breed dog, they're just going to get another breed.

11:57And that's another criticism of the law as it stands. You've got cane corsos, for instance. You know, if you can't get an XL Bulley, you'll just get a cane Corso. They were also saying there's a huge problem still with underground breeders, puppy farms, things like that. They were saying, you know, these dogs are meant to be illegal. You're meant to not be seeing them anymore. Go online, he said, for a couple of minutes and you'll see these dogs for sale. How dangerous a job is it then, being a dog worker? I asked them, have you been bitten? And they said, yeah, several times. And they were saying to me, the bites are getting worse.

12:26You know, they were showing me that they've actually had to modify their own kennels. at the Manchester Dogs Home. Because they're getting so many dangerous dogs, they've had to install a metal pulley system so the staff don't actually have to go anywhere near these dogs. So they can bring the dog into the front, put the pulley down, separate them as the staff member. And they said, we have never had to do this before. That sounds like something out of London Zoo line. It does, doesn't it? And they said, actually, you think about the XL Bully Band's been in since 2023, but she was saying to me, it's literally the last two years that we've had to do this.

12:57They've had to build five of those specialised kennels. And she said this has changed from having one highly aggressive dog, you know, every couple of weeks to seeing them every single week. So they've had to modify all their kenneling. You've also been speaking to kind of surgeons who worked with you. They presumably also have seen an increase in the severity of these attacks. Yeah, I spoke to the surgeon who leads the team of surgeons who treated me. And he was saying that from his perspective, the XL Bully Ban really hasn't made a difference. He said they're still seeing very serious attacks.

13:30He said the number of severe injuries that they're getting through, that's actually increasing. So he was saying, I just don't see how the ban is making a difference. If anything, the number of serious attacks is actually getting worse. I wonder, though, if we can just talk about Esther Martin. Now, of course, you were incredibly lucky. And frankly, you know, you could have been killed in that instant, could you? Unfortunately, Esther was by two XL bullies and you met members of her family. I did. I met her two daughters, Sonia and Kelly, obviously completely traumatised by what happened to their mum.

14:04Esther was killed just a couple of days after the XL bully ban was fully enforced. So it was brought in sort of in stages. When it became fully illegal to own them without an exemption, it was just two days later that Esther was killed. She'd gone to look after a family member. The owner had locked the dogs in the bedroom. they escaped and the way Sonia and Kelly describe it is that the dogs knocked her down and there were bite marks everywhere she said the police stopped counting at 60 it took them over an hour with kind of riot shields tasers to actually get entry to the house by that time obviously there was no hope for Esther and she sadly lost her life an incredibly traumatic thing for her daughters to to have gone through so you've spoken you've spoken to the police you've spoken to the dog wardens, you've spoken to the families of people that have died and the doctors who have treated those who are lucky enough to survive.

14:55What on earth is going on here? Because I cannot quite work it out. Why, despite the fact that we are clearly being more proactive about the dangerous dog phenomenon, are we seeing an increase in the severity of the attacks and in the hospitalisations that are taking place? Well, there's several things that were suggested to me. I mean, dog wardens were saying people want to get these breeds, these large breeds, these powerful breeds. And they said that they're just not training them and they're just not keeping them in the kind of correct conditions. And in fact, one of the things that a lot of people are calling for is to have some kind of competency testing before people get dogs.

15:31A license to have a dog. Like a license, like a kind of registration scheme where owners would prove that they are capable of controlling these large breeds. COVID has also been blamed as a factor. You know, people getting dogs and then them not being able to be socialized in the same way. Social media as well, not just dogs, including banned breeds being advertised for sale in social media, but just these kind of dogs getting more popular, getting more fashionable. And then I suppose I'd flip the question on its head as well and say, why are attacks not coming down? Just to put it in its most basic terms, the XL bully ban has not worked, has it, if hospitalizations are increased?

16:08That is what everyone is saying to me. and the data that we have from the NHS shows that serious attacks are increasing still, including every year since the ban has been put in. So as far as we can tell, no, it hasn't. It is usually at this point in a podcast that I turn to the journalist who's been doing the work on the piece and say, right, so what are the government saying? Except in this instance, they're saying nothing. They would not speak to me as part of this piece. We asked several times whether they would speak to me on camera. they said they wouldn't they wouldn't speak to a victim of a dangerous dog they sent a statement saying you know they're doing what they can to reduce dog attacks they're working with the police you know um animal welfare organizations you know and it's a commitment for them but they just referred back to the dangerous dogs act again the key thing that people are calling for is dog licensing is you know you sort of pay an annual fee you almost have to get a license much like a driving license before you get a dog.

17:07The government actually commissioned for the second time research into why dog attacks are happening. One of the key things they recommended was that the government should evaluate new legal options for dog ownership, like dog licensing. The only response we've had from DEFRA so far is for them to say, no, we are not going to bring in dog licensing. We feel it's a tax on responsible dog ownership. That's not something that we're going to consider. Although everyone I've spoken to, you know, the dog wardens were calling for it, Esther Martin's daughters were calling for it. You know, it seems to be a real kind of groundswell of people who've been affected by this, who want to see a change.

17:44So far, the government are saying that's not going to happen. I mean, physically, what a distance now from the attack itself. How are you getting on? I'm all right. Thank you. I'm very, very lucky, actually, that it wasn't worse. It could so easily have been so much worse. And that's what went through my mind, really, at the time. How easily this could have been so much worse. I was terrified at the time that the dog was going to get my face or it was going to get my neck. If it got the other side of my leg, could have been an artery. You know, I'm just very, very fortunate. You know, I obviously I have, you know, physical scars.

18:16I've got some quite extensive scarring on my leg. One of my fingers still hurts, doesn't quite work properly. Not sure it ever will, but I'm just so fortunate that it wasn't worse. Well, look, it's a great bit of reporting and you're a braver person than I am in returning to the story. Katie, well done. Thanks very much. And that's your lot for today, but do get in touch with your thoughts. Have you been attacked by a dog? Do you have concerns whenever you're out walking? Or are you a dog owner? And do you think this might just be a lot of fuss about nothing? Why at sky.uk is the email. We're back tomorrow.

19:00hosts of Electoral Dysfunction, the politics podcast that cuts through the BS and has a bit of fun on the way. And I've enlisted a crack team of political juggernauts to help me out. There's me, Harriet Harman. Me, Jess Phillips. And me, Ruth Davidson. So join us. Search for Electoral Dysfunction wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

When XL bullies were added to the list of banned dog breeds in 2023, it was meant to dramatically reduce the number of people being attacked by dangerous dogs. In fact, serious incidents are on the rise.

Hospitals are seeing more cases admitted, while Greater Manchester Police has reported a 900 percent increase in the number of dog seizures – without the resources or the kennels to cope.

Sky News correspondent Katie Barnfield was herself the victim of a serious attack last year. She’s been telling Niall Paterson about her investigation into the inexorable increase in dangerous dog attacks.

Warning: This episode contains graphic descriptions of Katie’s injuries.

Have you got a question for Niall? Email us: [email protected]

More from This Is Why

All episodes