1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Why can’t Britain build warships on time?
This Is Why

3 Nov 2026 · 18m · 8 chapters

Episode artwork

Why can’t Britain build warships on time?

In short

Why Britain can’t build Royal Navy warships on time—old ships are rotting, replacements are delayed, and procurement/industrial capacity issues are blamed.

Guests

Defence analyst Rob Clark (returns to explain). No other named guest is interviewed in the episode.

Key claims

The Royal Navy has been reduced about 75% since the late 1980s/early 1990s. Type 23 frigates (designed for an 18-year life) face seaworthiness limits by 2031; maintenance is “astronomically” complex. Only one Type 23 is “absolute maximum” available; Russian submarine activity near UK waters is rising. Astute submarines have had none deployable since summer; the UK has relied on unofficial escort support from allies. Shipbuilding is hindered by stop-start procurement, bespoke platform changes, slow decisions, and limited scale; upskilling apprentices takes years.

Notable examples

HMS Dragon sent to the eastern Mediterranean for air defence; RAF Akatiri under attack in March; Defence Select Committee report on high north shipbuilding.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:00

The State of the Royal Navy

Discussion on the current status and operational capability of the Royal Navy.

“Having to replace a warship really shouldn't come as a surprise.”
2:07

Understanding the Fleet Composition

Breakdown of the types of vessels in the Royal Navy and their roles.

“Can we start with some of the basics here?”
4:25

Impact of Aging Vessels on National Security

Analysis of how outdated warships affect the UK's national security.

“They require an extensive escort fleet because they are incredibly vulnerable and they're primarily used for that, but also for air defence as well.”
6:54

Challenges in Shipbuilding

Exploration of issues causing delays and inefficiencies in the shipbuilding process.

“I mean, didn't we used to be quite good at this?”
9:19

Comparative Analysis of Global Shipbuilding

Comparison of the UK's naval shipbuilding capacity with other nations.

“Now, their main role is to act as protection for the vanguard class, for the nuclear submarines, and also as submarine hunters themselves.”
12:10

The Future of Britain's Naval Production

Discussion on the future challenges and necessary changes in British naval production.

“Is it a case of too many cooks or is it that there are people within government, be it at the MOD, be it at Downing Street, wherever, that they just want the best of the best?”
14:01

Challenges in British Naval Shipbuilding

Explore the looming issues in British naval shipbuilding and national security.

“with replacement frigates, replacement submarines, two separate submarine builds at once, where all of these issues and all these problems are going to manifest so much more dramatically.”
16:15

Political Accountability in Defense

Discuss the need for political accountability and integrity in defense procurement.

“Some politicians, and it's usually the politicians and the policymakers who are in government, understandably.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02Sky News, the full story first.

0:11Britain's old warships are literally rotting. Their replacements are nowhere near ready. And this is why.

0:22People don't show up to vote, so I'm asking them to pretend I'm on the ballot. I'm thrilled he's saying that. His approval ratings are in the toilet. America's midterms matter to all of us. Voters will decide who controls Congress, Trump's Republicans or the Democrats. The people are not being heard. They'll have the power to shape what we can and can't do. We've been traveling the country speaking to the very people who will decide what happens next. Trump 100. Wherever you get your podcasts.

1:00Having to replace a warship really shouldn't come as a surprise. You build it, you use it, you maintain it, and at some point you need another one. Obviously, there is a bit more to it than that, but you can plan ahead, especially when the thing you're replacing helps defend the country. Unlike Russia, we do not seek confrontation. Instead, we will be prepared, but not panicked. Clear-eyed, but cool-headed. and unflinching in defending our people and our allies. True resilience depends on this military strength. Well, yes, Prime Minister. But military strength depends on having equipment you can actually use.

1:41And the Royal Navy has a problem. Old ships are becoming harder to keep going. Replacements take years to arrive. Now it's being reported that Navy chiefs are looking at whether more workers and extra shifts could get new warships built sooner. So how did we go from Britannia ruling the waves to bean counters ruling out delivery before World War III? Defence analyst Rob Clark is back to explain all. Rob, great to have you back on the podcast with us. Can we start with some of the basics here? We all know that the Royal Navy is not what it once was, but what currently is it? What do we have and what can we actually use right now?

2:19In terms of what we have, we have basically two types of fleets. We have a surface fleet and a subsurface fleet. The surface fleet is primarily consisted of warships, so frigates and destroyers, and then some smaller classes like the offshore patrol vessels. They're not really designed for warfighting. And then we have the subsurface fleet, so submarines. We have two types, a conventionally armed nuclear-powered attack submarine, the Astute class, and then we have the Continuous Axie Deterran, the Vanguard class, nuclear-powered and nuclear-armed submarines as well. We all know that the Royal Navy is a shadow of its former self.

2:53how much have we seen it diminished in recent years yeah it's been reduced by about 75 percent since the early 90s late 80s and that really coincided with what changed in the global order we obviously shifted from a cold war mentality where defense spending was you know anywhere between four to five up to eight percent of gdp three or four times the amount we spend now in percentage terms and with that we had the capability to match so obviously we were programming for the Turing War and then being able to fight it if we had to, primarily obviously against the Soviet Union in Europe. And the Navy really formed a huge part of that.

3:28And unfortunately, the decimation really of the Royal Navy, of the fleet, both in personnel and in vessels in the last 30 years, is nothing short of a national tragedy. And I don't mean that for sentimental reasons. We can see how that has undermined our national security, even this year. You've mentioned frigates, destroyers. We're going to be talking an awful lot about frigates today. Probably worth our while just distinguishing between the two. A frigate is traditionally the lighter and more lightly armed of the two vessels. We have the Type 23 frigate. The primary role is anti-submarine warfare, ASW.

4:02Now, we had a projected demand for eight of those. They've since recently had two decommissioned, and a third is in the process of being decommissioned. So we have now five. Now, of those five, we really only have one absolute maximum. Very rarely we have two available for operations. now why that's important very briefly is because the rise in russian submarine activity around british waters in the last few years has been almost exponential so these are really really highly in demand and then destroyers we have the type 45 we currently have five of those and there's again same sort of state there's one maybe two are operationally available they're a lot bigger they're a lot heavier armed and they provide the escorts for the fleet we have the two queen Elizabeth class aircraft carriers.

4:50They require an extensive escort fleet because they are incredibly vulnerable and they're primarily used for that, but also for air defence as well. They're really the UK's sovereign maritime deployable air defence capability. And we saw that this year in earnest when RAF Akatiri was under attack at the beginning of March during the current hostilities between the United States, Israel and Iran. There was a concern at the time that RF Akateri was left relatively under defended from an air defence capability. So the government urgently tried to send HMS Dragon to the eastern Mediterranean to reinforce that air defence threat.

5:27Those destroyers, those are the kind of the very sexy, angular-looking ships. But in terms of the frigates, the Type 23s I think you mentioned, I mean, you're on record as saying those things are rotting. Now, I might be wrong here, but I'm fairly certain we don't make them out of wood anymore. So what did you mean by that? so for a start these these frigates were designed uh in the late 80s into the early 90s they're all approaching if not over 30 years then they're coming up to 30 years old they were designed for an 18 year life now they've all undergone quite extensive and numerous life extension programs the most recent one is like their final one and it's only a six-year extension basically they won't be certified to be seaworthy with those extensions by 2031 so at best the last one has about four or five years left of it.

6:13In terms of what they're made of, no, it's very complicated ship steel manufacturing processes. And these warp over time. They get incredibly degraded. The maintenance for these is astronomically complicated and expensive. All of which means that anyone who has an interest in naval matters will have picked up on those very recent reports that the Navy wants to accelerate its shipbuilding program. What do you know about that? What's the truth there? So both BAE Systems and Babcock, who operate the maintenance and the structure and the life extension programs and the housing for these frigates they've submitted numerous fully costed options to the ministry of defense for basically increasing some of the current frigate build so the type 31 and the type 26 the ability to really upscale that and bring them into production a lot sooner than the original expected start dates the type 26 i think is expected to be in service well it was by next year is 2028 that's probably going to slip again for another year the type 31 not until sort of 2030 at the earliest so yeah both BAE and Babcock have tried to accelerate this program it's mainly upskilling the apprentice programs which are very expensive very time-consuming a good friend of mine from the military he's a welder and fabricator for Rolls-Royce they work on the nuclear submarines and his program was three to five years just as an apprentice so these are very very time-consuming and lengthy programs that people are trying to now rapidly sort of increase the availability of.

7:38Rob, just hold the bus for a second. I mean, didn't we used to be quite good at this? Weren't we world class when it came to, you know, chucking out warships at a rate of knots? Have we just lost that capacity? Broadly speaking, I think we have lost the capacity. Now, this goes to what I said a moment ago about the, everyone's aware of this term, the peace dividend, the so-called peace dividend after the Cold War, where we shifted focus. and we really allowed, it's not just our military competitiveness to slide, we allowed our industrial manufacturing base to slide. When you say that, when you say we allowed it to slide, what do you mean?

8:09For example, in the 80s and the 90s, the deindustrialisation, we're all broadly aware of the deindustrialisation of the UK and other Western European countries as well over the last 20 or 30 years. Now, when we talk about manufacturing warships, they are infinitely more complicated than regular commercial ships. These take decades to plan and to conceive and to cut the steel and start getting the manufacturing process. What we've had over the last 30 years is a constant stop-start, stop-start in procurement systems, very, very bespoke platforms which get constantly altered and constantly tailored by the rotating and revolving door of project managers in the MOD.

8:46And before you know it, you already have like an incredibly complicated and costly program that is consistently being altered and tailored. So we can still build the high quality, high tech equipment ships that we need. We just cannot build them at the scale that we require. So let's make this concrete, Rob. For someone who has not thought much about the Navy, about the maritime defence that we have, what does being short of warships mean for their safety? For the UK safety? I mean, just several examples. Like I said, we have five astute class vessels. The submarines, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Now, their main role is to act as protection for the vanguard class, for the nuclear submarines, and also as submarine hunters themselves.

9:29Now, of those five, none have been deployable since summer this year. Now, why that is absolutely demonstrably negative to the UK's national security, that nuclear deterrent, which our adversaries try to study, they understand, and they know explicitly what that means for them, rests on the ability for those nuclear submarines, for instance, to have escorts leading them in and leading them out of the dock up in Fas Lane in Scotland. now they're incredibly vulnerable when they come in and when they come out to detection by russian ships by any adversary ship and it has some form of protection that's the astute class submarine to not have that protection we are now completely reliant or we have been completely reliant for the last five months on the united states france and other friendly maritime nations to provide some form of escort coming in and coming out now that is completely unofficial nobody's owning up to that.

10:18Nobody is saying that's the case because it completely undermines our sovereign capability. We know this is happening.

10:48called juggernauts to help me out. There's me, Harriet Harman. Me, Jess Phillips. And me, Ruth Davidson. So join us. Search for electoral dysfunction wherever you get your podcasts.

11:05Let's try and just simplify it a step further then. So are we ordering too few ships? Are we taking too long to build them? Or a combination of the two? It's a combination of all of them, really. We're taking too long of a decision to go ahead and procure them. The procurement process is incredibly lethargic and expensive. These quite often run into, you know, hundreds of millions of pounds of project overruns. And the simple fixes that we can do going forward, we don't have to constantly fine tune these already incredibly bespoke platforms in a very, very small number. If we look at where some countries, for example, the United States, even China, and increasingly South Korea have really, really successful national shipbuilding industries they can produce at scale and so you get that economy of scale you get a much more efficient streamlined process we're building like five or six different ships for each program over a period of 20 to 25 years and every couple of years somebody comes in differently and wants to change something or alter it and the process then just becomes incredibly complicated it doesn't need to be that way that's what's so frustrating this is an incredibly sort of self-harmful process that we have been undergoing for the last 20 years Is it a case of too many cooks or is it that there are people within government, be it at the MOD, be it at Downing Street, wherever, that they just want the best of the best?

12:21We're building British, so therefore we want the list of kind of things that this piece of kit can do to be as lang as your arm because, you know, we're building it here. I cannot understand why people who have worked within the Navy would be so bad at putting together an order to build some ships. It's really this long term sort of lack of direction and strategy. Now that comes from the government of the day. they have to take ownership there's simple things that we can do where we look at our allies and other countries who managed to get this right and increasingly we need to start looking at south korea and how south korea pioneer this so for example building successive ships to a stable design using modular construction and in places distributed fabrication standardizing equipment and components across classes you know where practical for example we're building two completely different frigates the type 26 and the type 31 by two different manufacturers now Now, there's plenty of overlap that can be created there.

13:13Yes, they fulfill different roles. Yes, they fulfill different jobs. But that is a clear area where we have an interest in sort of like commonality, that sort of like more modular and standardized approach. If we want to get these out in time and in budget, one thing we absolutely have to do, ultimately we must begin to increase digitization, being able to transform things like productivity, and especially now in shipbuilding. That's absolutely key. How quickly could we move to more of a South Korean model of shipbuilding? Or are the problems that you've highlighted so embedded structurally that it almost wouldn't be worth the change?

13:47It would absolutely be worth the change. The problem we're now in is we're going to be in an increasing sort of like industrial bottleneck where we have three or four overlapping, not necessarily competing, but overlapping build programs. with replacement frigates, replacement submarines, two separate submarine builds at once, where all of these issues and all these problems are going to manifest so much more dramatically. The real problems are going to be coming down the road in about five years' time. We're going to be in this frigate gap where we're going to have maybe two or three frigates down from five for a couple of years, and an increasing gap between where Vanguard leaves and Dreadnought comes into service.

14:25And again, the SSN and Orca submarines, the replacement for the astute-class submarines. We need to absolutely be pioneering these changes now. I mean, really five years ago at the latest, but now absolutely, because the longer we leave these changes, these aren't huge cataclysmic changes for industry. By the 2030s, when we're trying to bring out these different programmes, three or four different shipbuilding programmes all at once, it's asking for absolute carnage down the road. But genuinely, in terms of our national security, with the threat from Russia as it is, and we expect it to escalate over the next few years, can we afford to wait years for these ships?

15:01Well, in one sense, we have to. Now, in another sense, there's something that's deeply unpalatable to really any government of the day, which is we do have an option to buy off the shelf. I don't advocate it lightly, but there are instances where all realistic and credible lines have already been exhausted. And it really only leaves that other option, which is we have to import. Yes, it's going to be more expensive. Yes, it's not ideal. Yes, there's a threat to British jobs by not doing that in the first place. But when we look at British security and national interest and our national security is at stake, sometimes we have to make really tough decisions.

15:36And I think it's all too easy when it comes to defence and defence procurement, whether it's shipbuilding, tank procurement, wherever it may be, where governments are so blinded for understandable reasons to buy British, to invest in Britain, to increase British jobs. I get that, but there comes a point where sometimes it is just better to cut your losses and buy off a trusted, reliable ally like South Korea, like the United States, and we can get these platforms within two to three years, not wait 10 to 15 and spend billions more than we would have done anyway. Rob, I'll be honest with you. Whenever we talk, I never end a conversation more positive than when I started.

16:13And right now I am pretty worried. Given the diminishing of the Navy over the past few years, are our politicians being economical with the truth when they are asked direct questions about our national security when it comes to maritime operations? Some politicians, and it's usually the politicians and the policymakers who are in government, understandably. I'll give an example of a politician whom I have enormous respect for for his integrity on defence. That's Tan Desi, the Labour MP who's the chair of the Defence Select Committee. he is unwavering in his position to try as best, where appropriate as well, to hold the government to account over issues relating particularly to defence procurement and overruns.

16:58And the Defence Select Committee released a report two weeks ago now on the state of the UK's ability to defend itself in the high north, and in particular with the shipbuilding questions that we've been discussing today. Now, when this report by his committee was brought to Wes Streeting, the Defence Secretary, by the opposition, by the Conservatives, and in particular James Carter, which is the shadow defence minister and his team, Wes Streeting was, I'll say it as it was, he was very undignified in his response about the Defence Select Committee, or it came across like that. It seemed inconvenient, he seemed embarrassed, which he should be, and it is inconvenient, but that takes political leadership and integrity to actually deal with these challenges head on and not to sort of oh no everything's fine we're working on it and one of the things i really despise at the moment with defense is the line that the government routinely use which is we are spending a record amount of investment or we're putting a record amount of investment into defense and it's like well well one that's actually factually incorrect but two even if that was the case like yes they have increased in real terms some some money allocated for defence but that doesn't necessarily mean it's it's right that doesn't necessarily mean you're doing the right thing there needs to be more investment it needs to be more targeted it needs to be structural there needs to be change you need to change the procurement process not just throw money at it and they're the hard political decisions so i think some politicians do find it very very easy to say oh look you know we inherited this problem and oh it's very bad it's going to take years to sort out it's like that can all be true that can all be right but don't just rest on that as a political convenience to not deal with the issues that is your direct responsibility to deal with, particularly when it's something as dangerous as national security.

18:41Rob, always good to see you. Thanks for your time. Pleasure. Thank you. And that's your lot for today. But do let us know what you think of our ailing Royal Navy. Why at sky.uk is the email. We're back tomorrow.

18:57People don't show up to vote. So I'm asking them to pretend I'm on the ballot. I'm thrilled he's saying that. His approval ratings are in the toilet. America's midterms matter to all of us. Voters will decide who controls Congress, Trump's Republicans or the Democrats. The people are not being heard. They'll have the power to shape what he can and can't do. We've been traveling the country speaking to the very people who will decide what happens next. Trump 100. Wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

The Ministry of Defence has committed billions of pounds to building a new generation of warships. But there's a problem.

Older vessels are being retired, their replacements are taking years to arrive, and concerns are growing about the Navy's ability to meet its commitments. So why aren't we building more ships, more quickly?

It's about money, a lack of skilled workers, and decades of decisions that have left Britain's shipbuilding industry struggling to keep up.

Sky's military analyst Robert Clark joins Niall Paterson to help us understand why.

Have you got a question for Niall? Email us: [email protected]. You can also watch This Is Why on the Sky News app, and on YouTube.

There is more exclusive military analysis and content on the new Sky News Defence Insider app.

Sky News Defence Insider is a subscription app designed for audiences seeking deeper insight into defence, security and global affairs.

Download and subscribe here.

Paid subscription required for full access. UK only. 18+. T&Cs apply.

More from This Is Why

All episodes