1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Why didn’t Christa Pike die?
This Is Why

9 Oct 2026 · 30m · 13 chapters

Episode artwork

Why didn’t Christa Pike die?

In short

The episode examines why Krista Pike didn’t die during her Tennessee lethal-injection execution attempt on Sept 30, when pentobarbital failed. It argues that Tennessee’s use of capital punishment—especially lethal injection—can be botched and may not be humane, citing that lethal injection has the highest flaw rate (per the Death Penalty Information Center).

Guest

John North, investigative journalist at WBIR Television in Knoxville, who witnessed Pike’s execution attempt and previously covered lethal-injection and electric-chair executions in the same prison.

Key claims

Pike was visibly alive after two doses; witnesses heard snoring/wheezing for about an hour; the blinds went down and the process was halted; she was hospitalized with severe injuries (can’t swallow, swollen arms/hands, pneumonia).

Notable examples

Pike’s 1995 murder of Job Corps student Colleen Slemmer; Tennessee’s earlier botched execution of another inmate; discussion of other methods (electric chair, firing squad).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:12

Setting the Scene: Krista Pike's Execution

An overview of Krista Pike's execution attempt and its implications.

“I do not have an explanation for what happened between Monday night and Tuesday morning.”
2:01

Journalist's Firsthand Experience

John North shares his experience witnessing the failed execution.

“He was actually there when Tennessee failed to execute Krista Pike.”
3:10

Inside the Witness Chamber

A detailed description of the witness chamber and events leading up to the execution.

“And precisely what you just said, nothing like this has occurred in the United States, maybe anywhere in terms of somebody facing death by lethal injection and it failing and them surviving.”
6:15

The Execution Process Begins

Krista Pike makes her last statement and the execution attempt begins.

“If you can imagine, it was a room that looked basically at Krista from her feet down to her head.”
8:07

Execution Fails: A Startling Revelation

Krista Pike's execution fails unexpectedly as she shows signs of life.

“A few minutes into it said, have they started it yet?”
9:19

Witnessing the Aftermath

John recounts the chaotic moments during the failed execution.

“The spiritual advisor comes back into the witness chamber with us.”
12:51

Understanding the Context: The Crime

Exploring the background of the crime that led Krista Pike to death row.

“The drugs did not work in the way in which they were intended.”
13:14

Colleen Slimmer: The Victim's Story

Discussion about Colleen Slimmer and her background as a victim.

“I'm happy to tell you about Colleen because she was a sweet, kind human being from everything that we know.”
14:01

Introduction to Job Corps and Colleen

Learn about the Job Corps environment and the individuals involved in this case.

“And way back in the mid-90s, computers were just really starting to have the ubiquitous presence that they do in our homes.”
17:36

The Night of the Incident

Discover the events leading up to the brutal attack on Colleen.

“So Colleen apparently is like, OK, I'll do that.”
Show all 13 chapters
21:08

Aftermath and Impact on Colleen's Family

Examine the emotional toll and ongoing struggles of Colleen's mother after the crime.

“I want to bring things back just to the kind of the current day, if we can, John, because, of course, I mean, I've covered a number of murder cases, some pretty significant ones over the years.”
24:20

Krista Pike's Current Condition and Legal Status

Get updates on Krista Pike's health and the complexities of her legal situation.

“But we've not heard from the state what their plan is for her.”
28:00

Discussion on Capital Punishment in Tennessee

This segment covers the implications of failed executions and the future of capital punishment in Tennessee.

“State of Tennessee, there is support for it.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02Sky News, the full story first.

0:09Hi everyone, Neil here. A warning straight away. In this episode of This Is Why, we will be hearing in distressing detail about the crimes and botched execution of Krista Pike, including graphic descriptions of how she killed her victim and how the state of Tennessee failed to kill her.

0:34I do not have an explanation for what happened between Monday night and Tuesday morning. But what we do know is that Krista has a long road to recovery. Hi, everyone. Today, look, we are doing something a bit different. This is very definitely not a podcast for our younger listeners. Now, usually at the weekend, we like to profile someone or something in the news. In this episode, we're going to be taking a look at the case of Krista Pike. On the 30th of September, she was taken from her cell on death row in Tennessee and moved to the execution chamber to be put to death by lethal injection. Except she didn't die.

1:12It was obvious within five, six minutes that this was not going to plan. She was starting to snore, but she was not dead, just to be blunt about it. Two doses of the usually lethal drug pentobarbital saw her rush to hospital in a critical condition and placed on life support. All this as the Pentagon announces plans to live stream the execution of US soldier turned mass murderer Nadal Hassan by firing squad, a method personally approved by Donald Trump. So what we're exploring today goes beyond Pike or Hassan. Instead, it's about what happens when a state gives itself the power to take a life, how it chooses to exercise that power, and what happens when it decides someone must die, then fails to kill them.

2:00John North is an investigative journalist at WBIR Television in Knoxville. He was actually there when Tennessee failed to execute Krista Pike. John, you have experienced something that I never have, and frankly, I hope I never will have to. You went into that prison expecting to see an execution. What did you see? What did you hear? I had covered witness to other executions in that same prison in August of 2018 by lethal injection. At the time, the state used a three drug cocktail, as we call it, had gone fine. No surprise. Inmate, to be blunt, had been dead in about 25 minutes. I also had seen an execution there February of 2020.

2:43It was an electric chair execution, Neil, because the inmate was afraid of the state's lethal injection method and elected to do the electric chair. So you're correct. I went into the building Wednesday, actually twice, because it kept being put on and put off. But I went in there fully expecting that after having covered this case for more than 30 years, there would be, if you will, a resolution with her death. Nothing like that occurred. And precisely what you just said, nothing like this has occurred in the United States, maybe anywhere in terms of somebody facing death by lethal injection and it failing and them surviving.

3:27Tell me about the room in which you sit and what you can see. And at which point did you recognize that things weren't going to plan? The witness chamber is a small concrete block room with four panels of glass that looks right into the death chamber. But when you first walk in, you don't see anything because there's reflective glass on your side. You get your image reflected back at you, and they have blinds down in the death chamber that are lowered. So you see nothing. There are three rows of chairs. I had been pre-assigned a chair on the front row to the left end, which is what I wanted. I wanted to be as close as I possibly could, having covered this case so long.

4:10To my left immediately was a door that went straight into the death chamber, didn't open or close, but I could hear sounds coming from it. When we entered the witness chamber, there were seven of us media witnesses, as well as some prison officials and also at least one of Krista's attorneys. We were told we've got pre-assigned seats for you. We're going to keep the lights on for you. But then there will be a point where the lights will suddenly be turned off. You'll be in complete darkness, but your eyes will adjust. And at that point, they said that's when the process will begin. And that's indeed what happened.

4:47We waited in the dark with the light for about 40, 45 minutes, and I could hear lots of noises of what I'd call preparation, such as papers rattling, what sounded like bandages being opened, tape being unspooled, that kind of a thing. I would hear every once in a while Krista make some kind of a noise. At one point, I thought I heard her whimper. She was on a gurney, although unseen at that point. They were inserting IV lines into her arms. At 7.27 p.m., lights went off and the blinds came up and we saw her. She was lying on a gurney. The witness chamber is not very small. I want to make that clear.

5:30And it's extremely stark. There's really nothing there. There's a silver microphone which hangs from the ceiling near the gurney. and standing in the death chamber with Krista was her spiritual advisor, a fellow who teaches Buddhist practices out of Nashville, Tennessee, somebody who Krista knew, and the warden of the prison, Kenneth Nelson, and another man. And that's it. All you can see are ivy lines leading from her arms, and she's on her back with her long auburn hair flowing from behind her head and over the gurney. She's completely strapped down. There's kind of a stark light. There are other chambers that look into the death chamber.

6:14There's a room that Mae Martinez, Colleen Slimmer's mom, the victim's mom, was watching. If you can imagine, it was a room that looked basically at Krista from her feet down to her head. We were looking at Krista from a diagonal position. At 727, as I mentioned, the blinds go up. The warden, as is common, it's not just a cliche, but it's actually the truth, says, Ms. Pike, do you have any last words that you'd like to offer? And she said, yes, I do. I would say, keep in mind, if you don't mind me saying this, that she has had great attention through the decades because of the notoriety of the case and because she's the only woman on death row in Tennessee.

6:56So that gave this some extreme notoriety. I've talked to documentary crews from the UK. I've talked to folks from a lot of different places in the world about this case leading up to this. So she's used to this kind of weird setting, if you will. She said, and I'm paraphrasing, I'm going out of this world the way I lived in it, which is with love. And I have love for the people who hate me as well as the people who have looked after me all these years. She said, in fact, maybe even more love essentially for the people who hate me. She said, I'm at peace, I'm free, and I'm ready to go. At that point then, she and her spiritual advisor began sort of a song chant.

7:45It was something like, be at ease, be at peace. And we thought, okay, here we go. Keep in mind, Neil, that you're anticipating because she's getting a massive dose of a barbiturate called pentobarbital, a drug that veterinarians use to put down animals, that this is going to go quick. That's what you're expecting. I mean quick as in a minute or two. She should be out. Didn't happen. She got a little drowsy. A few minutes into it said, have they started it yet? And she sang and she talked a little bit, engaging with the spiritual advisor. He stood right by her head. Every once in a while, stroked her forehead, talked to her, whispered to her.

8:31She would chuckle a little bit. She made a note that she felt a burning sensation. That's important. There was a spot where she felt a burning sensation. She mentioned sending love to one of her attorneys and a guy named Randy. But honestly, Neil, it was obvious within five, six minutes that this was not going to plan. I had, having watched a lethal injection execution in 2018, where the guy pretty much went out of consciousness very quickly, I thought, I don't know what's happening here, but this isn't right. So by 746, they knew that something was not right. She was starting to snore, but she was not dead, just to be blunt about it.

9:18So the blinds come down immediately. The spiritual advisor comes back into the witness chamber with us. I thought, hmm, OK, that's interesting. Maybe that means that we are really kicking into the phase to be crude about it, where she's now going to be fading away and systems will shut down. Sorry to interrupt, John. But when you are watching this process, do the blinds usually come down before the moment of the execution proper, before the death occurs? Or do they usually come down after that point? I think to answer your question, in the protocol, if they're about to do another round of the drug, that's why they come down.

9:57Sure. So I think that's what was going on. I think they were getting ready to do another round. So they put the blinds down. Spiritual advisor comes in with us. He's only there a couple minutes. And then I hear somebody whisper, send the clergy back in, meaning him. So he leaves. I hear the doors open, closed. By the way, this sounds a little grim, but it's the truth. They told us as we were waiting that the reason we kept hearing such loud clangs of doors slamming is in a prison. You want to make sure that the doors are always secure. So there you go. Doors slam. The blinds come back up. And there she is.

10:30She's snoring, as I said. And he's standing right by her again to be with her. It is 749, 750, and I won't go blow by blow, but what I want you to understand is from that time until 853, intermittently, we are hearing her snore, wheeze, snore, wheeze, sometimes go soft with her breathing, but she never stops. And there were some times, even though she's seemingly under, now receiving a second dose of the pentobarbital, that like her foot would move. There was a time where she, I guess, sort of unconscious, rose her head up a little bit with her mouth open. Her eyes were closed and gave sort of an involuntary, I don't know, I would call it maybe kind of a gargle or some kind of a noise like that.

11:22And then she settled back. That just kept going on. I'm holding up for you right now the notebook that they gave us to take notes because they'll give you a notebook if you want to take notes. And it's just line after line of me marking the time and saying, snoring, wheezing, still alive. I'm trying to be a witness for the public, for the state, and I'm a journalist, and that's what I'm doing. At 8.53, the warden comes on, and we know very clearly that this has gone badly. We know very clearly that this has failed and some of the witnesses are starting to speak up in the chamber. There was a point at 8.05 where suddenly the blinds came down again and they never came back up.

12:07They never came back up. So from 8.05 to 8.53, we are in the dark, literally. We don't know what's happening. All we can do is listen to the sounds coming from the microphone, which is filtered into the witness chamber. And I'm listening to the sound I can hear coming from the door to my left, which leads into the death chamber. And that's the way it was at this point that I am thinking to myself, I can't believe this is happening. I cannot believe this is happening. She's gotten two doses of something, which, again, to be blunt, should have killed her within, I don't know, 15, 20 minutes. And now, of course, we know very obviously the execution did not work.

12:51The drugs did not work in the way in which they were intended. And ultimately, Krista Pike has been hospitalised and will deal with the kind of the effect on her of this botched execution. But given all that we have talked about in terms of what you saw that day, I think it is probably well worth our while backtracking and going back to the 90s to that crime that put Pike on death row. Just tell me a little bit about the victim, Colleen Slammer. I'm happy to tell you about Colleen because she was a sweet, kind human being from everything that we know. Colleen was 19. She was from the state of Florida.

13:28And she was taking part in a program which coincidentally involved three other young people, one of whom was Krista Pike. It was a kind of a trades program, Neil, where you can learn a trade, a skill, and that can perhaps benefit you in life and for a career if you're not going to go to college. It's called Job Corps. And for Colleen, a family member, as I understand it, had sort of encouraged her to think about computers because she liked computers. And way back in the mid-90s, computers were just really starting to have the ubiquitous presence that they do in our homes. So Colleen thought this was a possibility for her.

14:14There's something you need to know about Job Corps, and that is this. It was for other young people. We're talking like 17 to maybe early 20s. It was maybe a last best hope legally for them to stay out of trouble because some of these kids had been in great trouble with the law. In one instance that I can think of, the court had basically said, you take this or you go to jail. Which do you prefer? So you're getting some kids that have had bad experiences, have engaged in bad behavior, probably living on the edge. There may have been some gang affiliation. I'm talking about to Daryl Shipp, who was there, who was Krista's boyfriend.

14:56So you had a mix, Neil, that wasn't so great and an idea that was truly great. And into all of that goes Colleen, a sweet girl who her mother says loved to help kids, loved to volunteer, sort of was of that personality, a good person. I'll tell you that maybe a couple of months ago, out of the blue, literally, somebody who I didn't even know called me and said, I've been reading what you've been reporting and I want you to know. I was at Job Corps in Knoxville in 1994, 1995, and I knew Colleen. I was in computer classes with her. She was the kindest, sweetest girl you would meet. And what happened to her was horrific.

15:43Take us then, John, to the 12th of January, 1995 and the events that are transparent. You bet. At Job Corps, you've got four kids, and this is important. You have Colleen, 19. You have Krista, 18. She's from North Carolina. She's here supposedly to do a nursing program at Job Corps. You've got Tadaryl Shipp, who is 17, from Memphis, Tennessee, and then a fourth person named Shadala Peterson. Shadala, Krista, and Tadaryl were more familiar with each other. Colleen was the outlier. Now, some background. Krista didn't like Colleen, and Krista had identified Colleen as somebody who was potentially a threat.

16:28She would tell police later, and I think it's a lie, that Colleen had barged into her room one night and threatened her with a box cutter. I think that's important. I believe that was a lie. Krista had told police after the fact that Colleen had torn up some of her pictures. I don't believe that's true. I don't think that makes sense at all. And you'll see why. Because on the night of January 12th, as you mentioned, Neil, Krista invites Colleen to come out with them. Initially, it was going to be to check out a job corps and go to a video store to check out a video, something that we all used to do once upon a time.

17:06And Colleen agreed. So that tells you that there wasn't necessarily a hostile thing going on there. Krista had also told a friend at Job Corps within a day or two of the murder that she thought she was going to kill Colleen. All right. So they check out of Job Corps that night. They walk down a main drag by the University of Tennessee campus. And the idea comes up. Krista says, actually, I've got some marijuana in a park nearby stashed away. Would you like to smoke some? So Colleen apparently is like, OK, I'll do that. They walked into this park, which exists today. It's called Tyson Park. And they go to a remote area.

17:46It's not a bitterly cold night. Colleen's got a coat on and gloves. It's a little chilly and it's kind of raining. It's a very remote area, as I say, even though it's quite close to what we call the agricultural campus. And Neil, pretty quickly after they get there, Colleen realizes this is not going to happen the way Krista said it was. They turned on her, particularly Krista, beating her and cussing her and accusing her of having eyes for Tadaryl. Colleen is shocked and trying to defend herself and explain that this is not the case at all. She has no interest in Tadaryl's ship whatsoever. But Krista goes into a rage.

18:24And what I'm about to tell you is from the police interviews of Krista and Tadaryl and Shadala Peterson, that fourth person. That's all three. This comes from what they said and also from court testimony. The beating accelerates, and it turns out that Krista and Tadaryl had brought a box cutter and a little mini meat cleaver, the kind of thing you might cut some Stilton with, right? Just a cheese kind of a cutter. And they both used those weapons on Colleen. They began slashing her. By Krista's estimation, this would unfold over the next 30 minutes to an hour where they would slash her, cut her, beat her.

19:10Krista demanded that she take off the coat that I mentioned, her pink sweater, and her bra. So they were trying to humiliate her. Colleen is fighting for her life. As Krista would say, she kept talking and talking and talking to me. She wouldn't shut up. It's hard to hurt somebody when they keep talking to you. That's her words. This went on because Colleen wasn't dying and that was frustrating Krista. Again, what I'm telling you comes from Krista's mouth, not mine. Krista and Tadaryl had an interest in Satanism. Tadaryl mainly was the driver of that. He had a little shrine. He'd been interested in Satanism since he was a child in Memphis.

19:50He got her interested in it. They each had matching pentagram pendants on necklaces. Krista had a little tattoo of a devil. Tadaryl's nickname was Baby Satan. So while they're in the middle of this murder, they get the idea to carve a pentagram into her chest. Tadaryl carves the star figure. Krista carves the circle around, and it's between her breasts. Finally, Krista got frustrated that she wasn't dying from all of the slashing and the cutting, including to her neck. And so they came up with the idea of grabbing a piece of asphalt, which was nearby, and Krista bashed it against Colleen's skull, the left side of her skull, repeatedly.

20:36She reached down, plucked out a piece of Colleen's skull as a souvenir. They also took Colleen's identification, and in the mud and the light rain, they walked to a nearby service station to clean up and to throw away Colleen's identification. It is a horrific crime by any standards.

21:12I want to bring things back just to the kind of the current day, if we can, John, because, of course, I mean, I've covered a number of murder cases, some pretty significant ones over the years. And something that has always struck me is that it's the friends, the families, those that are left behind who suffer over the decades that follow the crime. You've always kept in touch with Colleen's mother. In fact, you mentioned she was she was there. What is this this latest ordeal, the botched execution? What has that done to her? I think it's fair to say she's deeply disheartened. She feels like nobody cares what she thinks.

21:46When we got word, Neil, earlier this week that Krista was awake and talking, I reached out to May, as you would think I would. And I said, what are you thinking? She said, nobody cares what I think. I'm not surprised. I never thought that she would die. And I said, well, if you don't mind me asking, what would you like to see happen now? Meaning, what about it, May? And she said, nobody cares what I think. The state sure doesn't care. So she's distraught, disgusted. She lives in a different state. And if she had her druthers, she'd never come back to this state. What do we know then of Pike's condition?

22:23I mean, we are obviously aware that she is still alive. We've heard via the lawyer that she is talking, that she is even perhaps up and about now. What more can you give us in terms of the detail of how she is currently? We learned a lot from her attorneys. She can't swallow, is not eating regularly yet. She has very swollen arms and hands. One of her attorneys compared it, Neil, to if you think of a hospital glove and you were to inflate it and it has that giant, bulbous view, that's kind of what she's dealing with. They're not sure she's going to have use of her arms. She has pneumonia. So from their perspective, they say she still is in serious bad shape, but she's alive, Neil, and she is able to communicate.

23:10We'll just have to see how she progresses. She's in a really good hospital in Nashville. She is shackled to the bed. And the lawyers asked the court yesterday, please give her some grace in that regard. And the court said, I want to think about that because they don't want her wandering around. She is somebody who has committed a horrific murder and subsequently tried to kill an inmate. There are guards, according to her attorneys, at the door. I would guess someday if she's medically able, she will go back to the prison where she normally is. To be clear, the prison where she was facing execution is a men's prison, but it's the only place Tennessee stages executions.

23:55Sorry, John, are we genuinely in the ballpark of suggesting that, you know, Krista Pike, the great state of Tennessee, might try again in terms of execution? Well, definitely her attorneys have said, essentially, for the love of God, please commute this sentence. She's been through enough. But this is a very conservative state, Neil. This is a very pro-Trump state if this had happened in a – well, it wouldn't have happened in another state because there are states that don't have the death penalty and she'd just be put away for life. But we've not heard from the state what their plan is for her.

24:27Our governor has called off the only remaining execution that we had in this state. It was going to be in December. He's like, we're not doing it. He's out of office as of January. We have an election coming up in less than a month. We'll have a new governor, and it'll be up to that person to decide things. I suppose it's possible that our current governor could decide in his waning months to commute her sentence to life without. We'll have to see. But I can't sit here with certainty and tell you, Neil, it's not going to happen again. Common sense might tell you, good Lord, you tried once and it didn't work and she survived.

25:08You can't do it again. But I don't know that that's the government. Can we speak just a bit more generally then about capital punishment in Tennessee and elsewhere? I mean, lethal injection itself very much looks like a medical procedure. You've got to assume that part of the reason for that is to try and make executions look more humane. I just wonder whether your view is whether or not they have. I appreciate you raising this question because I'm going to be candid with you. I've learned something that I didn't realize. You're absolutely right. I think that lethal injection was put forward as a more palatable to the public method of killing somebody if the state's going to do it.

25:50It kind of seems that way, right? You're going to drift off to sleep and everything will be fine. But Tennessee has now botched two executions, one in May. They just couldn't get the appropriate lines going to put the drug into the inmate. So they had to call that one off. This summer, Krista's team warned the state in a hearing that I covered. You need to be careful. She's got small veins and a medical condition. You may have a blowout and this may go all over her. However, the court determined, let's go forward with it. And this is what happened. And it turns out, according to the Death Penalty Information Center, which is kind of a nonprofit that pays attention to these things, Neil, that lethal injection has the greatest flaw rate of any.

26:38So I think you can make the argument that this method was sold to the public as humane. And it turns out it has the greatest botch rate of all of them. I told you we live in a conservative state. Some of our politicians here say, you know what, maybe we should not use lethal injection. Let's go back to the electric chair. I was just about to ask you about that, because I certainly know that lethal injection is not the only method of capital punishment that is available in the United States. The electric chair that you've just mentioned there. I also had the secretary of defense the other day talking about using a firing squad.

27:13it. There's a federal inmate you're referencing where the federal government in its current state, in its current leadership, suggested that that might be a possibility. Firing squads have been used in other countries. We don't have it in Tennessee, although it's been raised. Again, this sounds macabre. I think it was legally strategic. But this summer, when Krista's lawyers were trying to save her life, they said, we don't want to do lethal injection. You say we must come up with an alternative. We suggest hanging. The court said, no, Tennessee doesn't do hangings. So no, we're not going to do that.

27:49What level of kind of popular support do you see, John, in the United States for the death penalty in those variety of ways in which it can be carried out? So let's be clear. It differs depending on where you're talking about geographically, I think. State of Tennessee, there is support for it. There was support before this. I think this is going to make people take a second look and think very hard about, do we want to do this because we've messed this up twice now? Do we want to do this? And the second time we messed it up, the person lived. There are other states in the United States that wouldn't fathom using this.

28:27That's kind of the unique aspect of the United States. We have 50 states. The state of Hawaii, no way would they contemplate having the death penalty. On the other hand, Neil, state of Texas, state of Florida, we have a lot of executions in Florida and in Texas. So I do think, to your point, that this will make people stop and reassess what do we do? Tennessee couldn't do this. What does Tennessee need to do to fix this or does it need to take a hard look at the idea of having capital punishment? There certainly are people very upset about what has happened and disgusted. But we're not to the point, I think, yet that the common populace, if you will, is like, stop this in Tennessee.

29:15And your best guess as to as to what will happen next in the Pike case? I'll give you my opinion, my hunch, if you will. My hunch would be that nobody is going to rush to plan to try and kill her again. That's my guess. We don't know what her long-term physical condition is going to be. If she is permanently debilitated, I just can't see any way that the state would want to do it. And here we are. Here we are indeed. John, really appreciate you taking the time to talk to us today. Thanks very much. Thank you, Neil. That's your lot for today. We are obviously keen to hear your thoughts, though, on the failed execution of Krista Pike.

29:53Why at Sky.UK is the email. We're back next week.

30:02Thank you.

From the publisher

A notorious killer convicted of murder more than 30 years ago has finally faced the death penalty – execution by lethal injection. Except Christa Pike didn’t die.

Investigative journalist John North was one of the few people allowed inside a maximum-security facility in Nashville, Tennessee, to witness Pike’s death. What happened next was one of the most extraordinary moments in America’s troubled history with the death penalty.

Speaking to Niall Paterson, John describes in detail how the execution went wrong, why Christa Pike’s violent murder of Colleen Slemmer still resonates three decades later, and the heartbreaking response of her victim’s family.

And as the country prepares for its first public execution in almost a century – with plans to livestream former US Army major Nidal Hasan’s death by firing squad – Niall and John discuss why state-sponsored killing remains such a divisive topic in American society.

Warning: This episode contains graphic details of Christa Pike’s original crime and attempted execution, which some listeners may find distressing.

Have you got a question for Niall? Email us: [email protected]

More from This Is Why

All episodes